Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / The Ripple Effect: How Learner-Centered Environments Support Every Student
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:03and today we're speaking to Dr. Kara Schoenfeld from Education Reimagined.
- 0:08Education Reimagined is a national nonprofit on a mission to make learner-centered
- 0:12education available to every child in the country.
- 0:15Dr. Kara Schoenfeld is a partner of research at Education Reimagined,
- 0:19a former K-12 teacher, and a parent of a neurodivergent child.
- 0:23Thanks for joining us today, Kara. It is great to chat with you,
- 0:26and it's good to have you here.
- 0:28It's such a pleasure to be here. Thank you for inviting me.
- 0:32Our work has crossed paths many times. Ila and Education Reimagined.
- 0:36Kara, we've had the pleasure of having some great conversations.
- 0:39So let's kick it off and let's talk a little about your background.
- 0:44You have an extensive background in education research, but was there a specific
- 0:48spark or any personal experiences that drove your passion for learner-centered education?
- 0:54Thank you for asking that. It actually is very personal to me.
- 0:58It started in my own childhood.
- 1:00I was a child in my conventional public school, and I really was not doing well there. I wasn't seen.
- 1:09My talents as an artist weren't acknowledged or really known,
- 1:12and I was starting to fall through the cracks.
- 1:14And my parents had the insight to pull me and put me in a really well-established
- 1:19progressive elementary school that had been created during the progressive era,
- 1:26so like in the turn of the century. And so.
- 1:29I saw firsthand the difference of what it was like for me to be in a school
- 1:35environment like that, that was learner-centered. So that was the first thing.
- 1:38The second thing I would say was then as I actually became an art teacher and,
- 1:45later in my teaching career, when I was working on my master's,
- 1:49I found out about Big Picture Learning,
- 1:52which is a network of schools across the country and internationally now, too.
- 1:57And they were opening up a school in Philadelphia.
- 2:00And I just really resonated with their model. So I actually got to teach in
- 2:05a school that was learner-centered.
- 2:07And then I would say the final piece was when I worked on my doctoral dissertation,
- 2:13I studied unschooling, which was, I would say, one of the more extreme ways
- 2:18that you can center learning around a child.
- 2:21So I went from being a child to being a teacher in the setting to being a researcher
- 2:27of this arena of education.
- 2:30And Big Picture Learning is one of our ELIP partners. They're fantastic,
- 2:34the work that they're doing, and I just love how the pieces of the ecosystem
- 2:38all kind of come together like that.
- 2:39For listeners who might be new to this concept, could you help us unpack what
- 2:43exactly do we mean when we talk about learner-centered education?
- 2:47What sets it apart from traditional schooling?
- 2:50Yeah, so this is something I spend a lot of time thinking about,
- 2:53but I love the word itself. it's learner-centered.
- 2:56So in a lot of conventional schooling models, it's not centered around the learner.
- 3:01It's centered around something like, say, a system, a set curriculum,
- 3:06others dictating what should be learned and when and how.
- 3:10But learner-centered really does center around the learner. So you can almost
- 3:14picture the learners in the center.
- 3:17They're there with their strengths, their interests, and their goals.
- 3:21And that becomes the keystone for the whole education experience. So,
- 3:28With that, there's also a high level of strong relationships and deep levels
- 3:34of care, usually in learner-centered education.
- 3:38We adopt a mastery or competency-based approach where you progress based on
- 3:46your own development and your own ability to show what you've learned,
- 3:50opposed to seat time or,
- 3:53okay, now you're this age, so you have to advance to this.
- 3:57And one of the things I particularly love about Education Reimagines' way of
- 4:03framing learner-centered ed is that it is very important that it be not just
- 4:08contained within a school,
- 4:10that it be really brought to life with real-world learning experiences.
- 4:16And that can happen in many ways. But basically, the learner is connected in
- 4:21different ways to the community.
- 4:24So what they're doing feels grounded in real life, opposed to isolated.
- 4:29And, you know, you have to wait till you graduate before you get to get to have
- 4:33those real life experiences.
- 4:35Education Reimagined conducted this incredible multi-case study alongside a
- 4:40team of practitioner researchers to explore how learner-centered environments
- 4:44can support youth with learning differences.
- 4:46I had the privilege of interviewing several of the practitioners and researchers
- 4:51for previous podcast series, Needs to Strengths.
- 4:54So looking at that data through your lens, both as a researcher and a parent,
- 5:00what were some of the biggest takeaways for you?
- 5:02Yeah, so I should start by saying, before I came to Education Reimagined,
- 5:08as a parent, I was so hungry to find out my child had just gotten diagnosed with ADHD.
- 5:13And I was so hungry to find out, what does this mean? What does he need?
- 5:18And I, of course, would turn to research because that's my background.
- 5:22And I was just like, if I could study anything, it's this. It's learner-centered
- 5:25ed, and it is neurodivergence.
- 5:27Like how are learners being supported in these environments?
- 5:32And sure enough, I start this position and they say, hey, guess what?
- 5:36We have a grant in the works for this exact thing.
- 5:38So from the start, it felt quite miraculous that this even happened.
- 5:44And the study itself was really special. As you mentioned, Aurora,
- 5:47it had usually with a case study, you just dive really deep.
- 5:52We did dive deep, but we did it across three different settings. Right, right.
- 5:56Schools, learning environments don't necessarily have to be schools to be learner-centered.
- 6:02They can be out-of-school time. They can be...
- 6:06There's different contexts. It can be programs, but we did pick three schools
- 6:10because they were all public.
- 6:12And all of them have over 40%.
- 6:17Actually, it was even higher, but over 40% of their learners have IEPs or 504s.
- 6:23So we specifically chose them. And we did the case study because we wanted to see through lines.
- 6:29Every learner-centered environment is slightly different, but we wanted to see
- 6:33what carries through with our findings.
- 6:37And what even made it even better was that, as you said, we got to work with
- 6:41a team of practitioners.
- 6:44So these are school leaders, principals, organization leaders,
- 6:50researchers, educators, and we all together, there were 16 of us,
- 6:55went to the three different sites.
- 6:57And the site leaders went to those sites with us, too.
- 7:01Right. It was this very like it was a system of they saw each other's schools
- 7:07in action. Right. They saw. Right.
- 7:09Or learning environments. I like that distinction, too, that a learning environment
- 7:13isn't necessarily a school.
- 7:14In this case, they were all schools, but they went to see each other as well.
- 7:18Yeah. And it's so important because sometimes in research you have you're the
- 7:22participant or the researcher, but they got to play both roles.
- 7:26So what that does for our research is it enriches it in a way that you just,
- 7:31unless you are an insider, unless you're someone who's living it.
- 7:36You're going to miss things.
- 7:37And even for someone like me, I was living it, but I haven't in 10 years or longer.
- 7:42So it was just a phenomenal experience to learn from these practitioners.
- 7:47And I hope if the listeners here are interested in hearing more,
- 7:50they will go to the, the, the five minutes with podcast. So.
- 7:55You asked about the findings. Yeah. We were so excited. We kind of came in hypothesizing
- 8:00that we would have positive results showing that learner-centered schools are
- 8:06supporting youth with learning differences well.
- 8:10But we didn't realize quite how well.
- 8:12Oh, great. Yeah. Great. And in what ways?
- 8:16And I would say the main thing it all starts with is mindset.
- 8:21Said what we found is there was just a different way of thinking about,
- 8:29differences about human variability rather than it being oh this is a problem
- 8:35to be fixed it was from the get-go of,
- 8:39we're designing education systems around differences because we're all different
- 8:44and that meant that meant the world of difference that was a really powerful,
- 8:50finding for me as a parent.
- 8:52Because in theory, I thought I was really adopting a strengths-based mindset.
- 8:57But as I went to these schools and talked to the co-researchers,
- 9:02I realized I had a lot more growth to do in that area.
- 9:05From the way I spoke about my child to the things I focused on in my mind.
- 9:10I know that is part of human condition to look at the problems and go for it.
- 9:14But These schools really embody a different way.
- 9:18They really embody, we're going to look at this child and see what's great about them.
- 9:25The other few things that we found, we conducted a lit review,
- 9:29and we found a lot of the practices that they were doing are supported by evidence,
- 9:34and established evidence.
- 9:36So we looked at nine different specific learning differences.
- 9:40So when I say learning differences, what we meant is what sometimes can be classified
- 9:48as learning disabilities, like dyslexia, dyscalculia,
- 9:54dysgraphia would be another one.
- 9:55We also looked at attention deficits as one.
- 10:01We also put in autism, anxiety.
- 10:03Those were things we were seeing. And we had some students with dyspraxia,
- 10:06which I got to learn about. Oh, interesting, yeah.
- 10:09When we looked at the research on them, we were seeing that the schools are
- 10:13doing them because they're in systems that allow them to put those practices into place.
- 10:18Right, right. And enable the educators to do that, whereas educators in other
- 10:23systems might know best practices, but they can't implement them.
- 10:28Yeah, they don't have the systems there to support them.
- 10:31We also found that the schools, because we wanted public schools,
- 10:35they were so creative in how they were navigating policies and conditions.
- 10:40And we actually published a whole brief on just that. We have a policy expert on our team.
- 10:44And that was really interesting where they didn't see barricades.
- 10:50They saw different possibilities. Yeah, I feel like I did an interview specifically around,
- 10:57compliance and how to, you know, make some of the restrictions kind of work,
- 11:03how to work within the boundaries without compromising rigor,
- 11:07without compromising quality, without compromising the student experience.
- 11:11It's incredible what folks that can do in the public school system when they've
- 11:16got the right mindset and the right supports.
- 11:19Absolutely. And what was neat was that we were in three different states.
- 11:22So we had one of the schools in New York, one of them was in Minnesota,
- 11:27and one of them was in Wisconsin.
- 11:28So each of them was navigating different state regulations and local contexts.
- 11:36And one of them was a charter. So the one in Minnesota was a charter school.
- 11:40The one in New York was actually another big picture learning school.
- 11:44And that was a school within a school model. So it was nested within the high school.
- 11:49And then in Wisconsin, that was the, we love to call the smallest school district,
- 11:54in Wisconsin, and they served a highly transient youth population.
- 12:00And yeah, so there were three public schools, but very different context,
- 12:04policy, and just even how they're set up.
- 12:08Yeah. And I would just say to wrap it up in this with this question,
- 12:11because this is a great question I could keep going,
- 12:14was we saw a lot of trauma healing, personal growth and academic growth,
- 12:22which I can talk more about if you're interested in.
- 12:25And we also saw that it wasn't just the learners who were receiving the benefits.
- 12:32And this is part of what really surprised us, is we saw it extending to their peers.
- 12:40Educators were staying with the profession longer. We saw families,
- 12:45which the stories always made me cry because it was the parents talking about
- 12:49immense relief that they felt.
- 12:51And then also because it's out in the real world, you saw a lot of mentors and
- 12:57community partners getting influenced, particularly about their thoughts on relationships.
- 13:04Most of our schools served high school students, some middle school students,
- 13:08but shifts in teens, perceptions of teens, and particularly teens with learning differences.
- 13:15It really showed them how capable and creative and outside-the-box thinkers they were.
- 13:22Your research revealed that learner-centered schools can create a ripple effect
- 13:26of impact. Can you walk us through what that looks like exactly?
- 13:31I think what was really interesting was, so we're centering around the learner.
- 13:36Let's first start with the ripple effect. It starts with the learners. Yeah.
- 13:39So one of the things that if you look at research, particularly when you look
- 13:45at like ADHD research, there is a strong need for interest-driven pursuits,
- 13:51for that intrinsic motivation to be activated.
- 13:54The learner-centered schools we studied were all about that.
- 13:58So rather than saying, well, you have to learn math and you have to learn algebra,
- 14:02it starts with what are you interested in?
- 14:06What excites you? And then we'll figure out how to build the math into that.
- 14:12So for example, there was one learner in one of the schools that didn't have
- 14:17any interest in learning math, but his father was a welder.
- 14:22And he decided for his internship, big picture learning schools have internships
- 14:26twice a week or more where they go out and the youth are out in the community
- 14:31working. He decided to work with a welder.
- 14:34And when he set the goal, he wanted to make a welded toolbox for his father.
- 14:40And when he realized, oh, I need to learn angles and calculations.
- 14:44And it was something he cared about. It was something he was interested in.
- 14:49And then the math was needed for that.
- 14:53So you have a totally different starting position than something that's imposed from the outside.
- 14:59And that supported, I mean, all of a sudden his relationship with math changed.
- 15:04You had one other youth, I'm going to tell one more story with this one,
- 15:08you know, wasn't as interested in science, but he was interested in bowling.
- 15:12So he did this whole project based on the physics of bowling.
- 15:15I was going to say physics right there, right?
- 15:17Exactly. And that's where all of these academic subjects come from.
- 15:22They're built into the fabric of living, and we've parsed them out for whatever reason over time.
- 15:28But what learner-centered education is doing is it's re-weaving it in.
- 15:33To the lay person we may think that algebra is disconnected from real life we
- 15:40as educators know like there's a reason why we teach algebra in school and it's not just to.
- 15:46Torture kids who don't like math but what you just said for whatever reason
- 15:50we've parsed that out the academic study from the real life application in many systems
- 15:57it's been separated and so learner center of education is bringing that back,
- 16:00bringing those connections again.
- 16:03That's just incredible. As somebody with ADHD too, it's like that idea of interest,
- 16:10novelty, personal connection to something. That's incredible.
- 16:15I was trying to support my son this morning as a parent.
- 16:18To support his nervous system by breathing in through his nose and out through
- 16:23his mouth. And he didn't, he was resistant to his nose.
- 16:26But my eight-year-old's really into chemistry. So we looked up why,
- 16:31exactly why breathing through your
- 16:33nose is more supportive than breathing through your mouth for calming.
- 16:37And it turns out there's, oh my gosh, nitric oxide that, you know this,
- 16:44that happens when you breathe through your nose, that doesn't happen through mouth breathing.
- 16:49And we broke that down into the chemicals he wanted to know about the molecular
- 16:53structure. And then all of a sudden, he's bought in.
- 16:55Right. And he's probably regulated also because it's also been a good diversion as well.
- 17:02And he's bought in. That's incredible. Yeah. And I give that example because
- 17:05a lot of what I saw in these schools, I've learned to adapt as a parent.
- 17:11So it doesn't have to be, you don't have to find necessarily a learner-centered
- 17:14school to take on a learner-centered way of thinking about being with young people.
- 17:21So it starts with learners, the impact we saw. And I talked about,
- 17:24you know, academic growth. We also
- 17:27see a lot of expanded ideas about like possibilities for their future.
- 17:30A lot of times they're, like I said, out in the real world, so they're getting
- 17:35exposure and they're getting these professional skills that they wouldn't get
- 17:39if they're just isolated in a school dynamic all day.
- 17:44So you see they know how to talk to adults they know how to I mean big picture
- 17:49learning we explicitly taught professional skills interview skills things like this,
- 17:54and then we saw because it has this positive effect on the learners a positive
- 17:59effect on their peers we saw a lot of peers supporting each other.
- 18:03Feeling like family with one another um,
- 18:06noticing each other's strengths, because that's what the educators are modeling.
- 18:11And then the educators, you know, it's like all the children or all the students are my students.
- 18:16There isn't like, this is my caseload, that's your caseload.
- 18:19It is this network of support where not one person feels like they have to know the child.
- 18:26And the one at the school in Wisconsin, And what I loved is they they would
- 18:30see who the student graduate gravitated towards and they would have their own special person.
- 18:38So there was all these adults and the adults came and brought their own interests.
- 18:43And the learners who were interested in the same thing would connect to them and learn from them.
- 18:47That's the way the schools were designed to be able to to make that happen.
- 18:51And then, like I said, the families, you hear parents saying,
- 18:54you know, I don't have to come to school. I don't have to battle with my child
- 18:57to come to school every day.
- 18:59I, you know, my child feels so accepted. One parent said, I walk away every
- 19:03day feeling like it just can't be this easy.
- 19:07Wow. Which is, I can, someday maybe, I really could relate to that.
- 19:13And then I said, yeah, with community partners, we saw the big impact too.
- 19:16So if an educator or a parent wants to start implementing these practices in their community,
- 19:21today, tomorrow, you know, next Monday, what's the best first step that they
- 19:26could take to shift the focus onto the unique needs of the learner?
- 19:31There was a quote from one of the school leaders that said that the focus isn't
- 19:36on how smart are you, the focus is on how are you smart.
- 19:42I love that. Isn't that great? I love that.
- 19:45So that's where you'd start.
- 19:49What are you interested What do you care about? What ignites that passion?
- 19:55And then once you really know that,
- 20:00Keep that focus in your mind. Like shifting a mindset is doable,
- 20:07but it takes intention and practice.
- 20:09So think about the way, if you're an educator or a parent, think about the way,
- 20:15what you're noticing about your child.
- 20:18Are you focusing on the wins? I track my child's behavior every day and there's always a daily win.
- 20:24And when he was little, we always did, we did a wonderful list where every night
- 20:28we were writing down everything wonderful about him from that day.
- 20:33So I think it takes intention, but we all can shift our mindsets.
- 20:38And it's about catching when you don't and being kind to yourself.
- 20:45And then thinking about not just how you're thinking about the child in front
- 20:49of you, but how you're speaking to them and to others.
- 20:54That's something I- That's a great point. Catch myself all the time that I'm
- 20:58like, oh, there I go. I'm focusing on the deficits again and just use that to
- 21:04see where I am and move forward.
- 21:06So I really emphasize mindsets because I think it really makes a tremendous difference. And then.
- 21:12I would say building on that practice, it's really this idea of how can I build,
- 21:20my child or the student I'm working with? How can I get their interests woven
- 21:25into whatever we're doing?
- 21:27How can I make this connect to what they're passionate about and what they're excited about?
- 21:32And if you're in a situation where your child isn't at a learner-centered school,
- 21:39because hopefully there'll be more.
- 21:40That's what our organization wants to do. But you can ask the teachers if that's
- 21:46something that they might be willing to think about or work with you on.
- 21:51Or when they bring stuff home from school, think about how you can enliven that,
- 21:56with experiences or connections.
- 21:59And I would say, like, particularly for students with learning differences,
- 22:04just being creative, like just being really creative about,
- 22:10like, the way the school leaders were with policy and conditions. Be the same.
- 22:16How can you, if you're having trouble reading, what are those ways,
- 22:19what tools can you use? What are other ways to get that content so you can shine
- 22:24and you can show how smart you are?
- 22:28If something takes a long time for you to practice and you have to keep trying
- 22:32it over and over, like be creative about ways you can do that.
- 22:37So it's a fun process. And those different ways of learning and needing to show
- 22:43how you can learn are really celebrated.
- 22:46And enjoyed as opposed to a burden.
- 22:50Yeah, so one of the things I liked was there was a learner at one of the schools,
- 22:55the school in Minnesota, and that student had autism and ADHD.
- 22:59And that student, like they just gave him something simple, like sentence starters.
- 23:04Like that student, you know, it's like, I feel, I, and just something very simple like that.
- 23:09So they could just know that they're cared about, know that they have what they need to thrive.
- 23:17Just small modifications make a really big difference. But approaching it with
- 23:20creativity, I think, is huge. Yeah. Yeah.
- 23:24And there's also a lot out there, you know, learning from each other and other
- 23:29teachers, other parents. There's so much about community, which is,
- 23:33I think, a really key part of this.
- 23:35So we're just about at the end of our time.
- 23:38And there's so many great things going on with your work at Ed Reimagined,
- 23:42how can folks stay involved, get in touch, or learn more about your work and
- 23:47about this, especially about this research?
- 23:50Yeah, how can folks get involved? So our website is education-reimagined.org.
- 23:56If you want to learn about learner-centered education and more,
- 23:59we have a newsletter with great articles about the schools and different ways
- 24:05of thinking about learner-centered that come out every month.
- 24:08We have a whole page dedicated to this research. Like I said, we ended up doing...
- 24:14Five different briefs. So if you're interested more in the policy side,
- 24:20if you're interested on that research that I mentioned.
- 24:24So if you want to see, well, what's the research on dyslexia and how does that
- 24:29connect to learner-centered practices from the study, you can go to that particular brief.
- 24:35And then also we have a YouTube channel, Education Reimagined YouTube channel,
- 24:39and we have some beautiful videos on there if you want to really see how these schools come to life.
- 24:44The one school in Wisconsin, we just put out a short video. I think it's about
- 24:49six minutes, but it's showing how they approach learning differences.
- 24:52So I definitely encourage you to check it out and learn more about what learner-centered
- 24:58schools may be operating in your community.
- 25:01Nice. And it's all free, open access. That's a big part of the ELO model as
- 25:06well, right? We want folks to be able to.
- 25:08Yeah. Well, Kara, it's been great talking with you. Thank you for joining me
- 25:12today. It's been great chatting with you.
- 25:14Thank you so much. It was a real pleasure. I'm really grateful for all of,
- 25:18for you, for the work you do, and for all those who took the time to listen to this.
- 25:22And to learn more, check out their website at education-reimagined.org.
- 25:27If you enjoyed this episode, don't forget to subscribe on your favorite podcast
- 25:31platform and follow us on social media.
- 25:34I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was a deep dive with Education Reimagined.