Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / How Much Are You Willing to Lose to Be a Good Teacher?
Transcript
- Ilana: You're teacher, you're underpaid, and you still have to spend your paycheck in order to do your very hard, very demanding job. Then you go home exhausted, spend your evening working, and you still feel guilty about not doing enough. So I was biking home from work, absolutely exhausted and really, really overwhelmed. Like normally when I'm biking, I can just like enjoy it. I pass some water, it's nice. but I was just ruminating, ruminating, ruminating. And instead of just looking forward to time at home, listening to my daughter sing Perfect Princess over and over again, I was wondering if it was time to look for another job. By the time I got home, I could not shake that feeling of wanting to look at the job board, see what was available, and I started wondering why. Why did I want to leave a job that I have loved For 16 years. What's going on? So I sat down and I really thought about it and I reflected and I was trying to figure out what's making me feel more exhausted, you know, than last year, which was the hardest year I've had. what's making me feel more overwhelmed than usual? And I realized I am deep in teacher debt. And teacher debt is costing us a lot more than money. there's the money that we are spending on our classrooms. Then there's the emotional energy we spend trying to be everything and everyone to our students and help them with all of the needs that they've got. And then there's the hours we keep giving away because we think, well, that's just what good teachers do. The question I have for you is. Are you giving all of this because you genuinely want to or because you feel like you owe your students more? Okay, so teacher debt, let's start with the most obvious type of debt: money. I do think it's the most obvious. I also actually think it's really nuanced, layered, and complicated. Teachers, you are buying things for your classrooms for a lot of different reasons. You know, maybe you found something amazing and you genuinely want it. But sometimes you're buying it because your school doesn't have it. You need resources or you need something for a student and there just isn't money in the budget. Schools are chronically underfunded and teachers have a choice that doesn't actually feel like a choice at all by yourself or your students don't have it. And I often fall into this trap more times than I care to count because the resource that will help the students finally solve that problem, finally understand that mathematical equation, finally understand how to apply those mathematical concepts. and you know what? You can solve it with your own credit card. And that also feels nice because as a teacher, there's not a lot of problems you can solve so easily. So you end up doing it. But this is where it gets really uncomfortable for me. And I'm not even talking about being underpaid and then deciding to go into debt for a resource that would help a student. I'm uncomfortable with why we have made it so normal for the person standing in front of the classroom to personally absorb the cost when the system doesn't provide what students actually need. We don't have this expectation for other professionals. We do not expect other professionals to operate in this way. You know, if a nurse If a nurse needs a piece of equipment to care for a patient and the hospital doesn't have it, we don't say, Well, I guess you should just pick one up on your way home. we recognize that the institution has a responsibility to provide the tools the professional needs to do the job. But teachers do not get the same consideration. There's this idea that if something is missing, a good teacher will find a way. And finding a way often means opening up your pockets and buying it yourself. And I think this guild chat becomes really interesting because once teachers start filling those gaps themselves, it be can become very easy to feel like not spending your money means you're letting your students down. Or when you see other teachers spending their money in their classrooms, you can feel like you need to keep up. You look around your classroom and you think, if I don't buy this, They won't have it. And maybe that's true, but that doesn't mean you're responsible for fixing it. and I'm not saying teachers shouldn't ever buy anything for their classrooms. I buy stationary all the time because I like things to be super cute. I was doing workshops at a university over the summer and I saw highlighters that were bears and it was like emotional bears and I course I bought them. I was like, yes. And sometimes I like using the colors that I like. And sometimes I'm like, I'm a sleepy bear and I'll use purple. Like we all do that to kind of make our days nicer or make ourselves feel better at work. Or to just kind of because we like it and we're gonna keep it anyway. So why not? If you wanna spend fifteen dollars on something because it makes your life easier or you love it. Go for it, I do, but we certainly need to start separating choice from obligation. Loving giraffes and buying giraffe stationery that makes you happy and the students think is like funny is something you might genuinely want to spend your money on. Are you spending your money because you genuinely want to, or because you feel like you've been put in a position where spending your money feels like the only way to give your students what they actually need? If the answer is the second one, that's not really a story about teachers being generous. That's a story about what happens when we make individual teachers responsible for absorbing the cost of a system that isn't adequately funded. And we really need to be honest about that before we tell teachers to simply stop spending. Because sometimes the teacher is buying it because they care and because the alternative feels like letting their students go without. And that is exactly what makes teacher debt so complicated. Okay. So we've gone over the money. Let's talk about the second kind of teacher debt. And this one is a lot harder to recognize because No one's sending you a bell bill for it, and that's emotional debt. This feeling that you owe your students more than you've been able to give them today. And you know, last year my teacher partner was working with a student who was really struggling and she was doing everything. Everything, checking in with the student, adjusting assignments, you know, universal design for learning, communicating with parents, advocating for all of the support she could get at the school level, at the district level. And then things started going well in class. Nothing's linear, but things started going well in class until they absolutely didn't. And the student had a very difficult day, which, you know, went into all of the students in the classroom having a difficult day and they had been having a difficult day and a lot of people having a very difficult day. And nothing worked. And it ended up being very exhausting. trying to keep the student safe from themselves and the other students safe from the student. And obviously she was just completely drained by the end of the day. And what struck me was that, you know, that teacher didn't say, wow, I did a lot today. She went home thinking, I should have done more. I should know my student better. I should have been able to figure this out. And that is teacher debt. She did everything she could. Everything that was on a safety plan, everything that was on a behavior management plan, everything that had worked for the student before. And somehow all of that disappeared as soon as the day didn't go the way she had hoped or wanted. And I think teachers, you do this all the time. You look at the thing that didn't work and you use it as evidence that you didn't do enough. Instead of looking at everything you did do, all of the success. And you know, that student having a hard day doesn't mean that you failed them. Sometimes you can do everything that is reasonable and the student can still have a challenging day. Sometimes the lesson can, you know, be absolutely well planned and a student will still not engage. And that's hard for you, you know, that's hard for teachers because you're used to being the people who fix things. But caring about an outcome doesn't mean you control the outcome. That's one of the biggest emotional debts teachers carry. You take responsibility for things that were never entirely yours to carry in the first place. you teach the lesson and on the drive home, you are thinking about the student who didn't get it. And you start immediately redesigning the lesson or the unit as you're making dinner. The school days ended, but the job didn't. there is a difference between responsibility and feeling responsible for everything. Not everything is in your locus of control. As teachers, yes, reflecting is really important. That's how we get better. That's how we learn more and adapt. It's how we can teach to a diverse group of learners, but we need to stop before reflecting turns into ruminating. Instead of thinking, what can I adjust tomorrow? You're thinking, what is wrong with me that I couldn't fix this? And that's where the emotional debt really starts to pile up. Let's face it, teaching has a nasty feature. You can do Everything right and still not get the outcome that you wanted. And if you've decided that your job is to make sure every student is successful, happy, regulated, engaged, and thriving at all times, you are going to spend your entire career feeling like you're behind on a debt that you can never repay. And that brings us to the third type of teacher debt. Time. This is where I'll just do one more thing becomes incredibly expensive. You are surrounded by tasks that are very easy to justify finishing because you think things will only take a few minutes. You know, the emails, taking work home to finish at night, which in the moment might not seem unreasonable. And that's what makes it a really dangerous slope to go down. Because your time as a teacher doesn't disappear in large chunks, It's five or twenty-minute increments. And you think, okay, well, 20 minutes after school, 45 minutes on the weekend, an hour in the evening, another half hour before bed, and all of a sudden you've Built this second workday within your day. I think it's time to start asking a really hard question. Instead of, can I fit this in? You need to ask yourself, What am I taking this time away from? Your time isn't free. When you spend another two hours making a resource, those two hours come from somewhere. Maybe they came from your sleep, maybe from your family, maybe exercise, right? Or not seeing that friend. Maybe it came from the time you could have spent on the couch doing absolutely nothing. Which by the way. Is a completely legitimate use of your time. I've got a line in the sand here. I'm just gonna say it. You need to stop treating your personal time as though it's the least important category within your budget. It is time to start protecting your time. This doesn't mean you don't give anything extra or stay late sometimes. Because there is a difference between occasionally choosing to give extra time and building your entire career around the assumption that your personal time is available whenever your job needs it. It becomes toxic when you give your time because you feel work needs to be done, or when doing more makes you feel like a better teacher, or spending all that time means you care more. Because that's not true. That time you take away from yourself and give to teaching doesn't make you a better teacher. Sometimes an extra three lessons may produce a better lesson, sometimes it only makes it four percent better. And the trade-off is you are now exhausted for the next three days because you didn't take the break away from work. Is the improvement actually worth that cost? Your students don't experience you in a vacuum. They experience you tomorrow and the day after that, and the day after that, and next week. so if constantly working beyond your hours leaves you exhausted, resentful, distracted, or completely depleted, you have to consider whether all of that extra time is actually helping you become the teacher you want to be. Sometimes the most professional thing you can do is to say, That's good enough for today. You are a teacher, not an unlimited resource. And that's where all three types of teacher debt come together. Spending money so students have what they need, spending emotional energy to help our students succeed, and And spending extra time to do your job well. The problem is when caring becomes a reason that we stop having the boundaries around what we give. And that's why I keep coming back to this question. I need you to ask yourself, how much are you willing to lose before you realize that giving everything isn't the same as being a good teacher? Being a good teacher. Isn't about how much of yourself you can give away. It's about knowing what you're willing to give, what you're not willing to give, and being able to keep enough of yourself so you can actually keep doing this work well. Let me know in the comments what is one thing you're going to let go of to start paying off that teacher debt and start taking care of yourself. See you next time.