Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Forgotten Enemy: The Battle of Montgisard 1177
Transcript
- Lucas: So, we've talked a lot about Saladin's victories — Hattin, the conquest of Jerusalem, the long siege of Acre. But today I want to look at a battle that almost no one remembers, one where Saladin was on the losing side. A battle that, for a brief moment, made the Crusader kingdom believe it could not only survive but triumph. Luna: You mean before everything fell apart? Which battle? Lucas: Montgisard. November 25, 1177. It's one of the most extraordinary upsets of the entire crusader period. Saladin had invaded the Kingdom of Jerusalem with a massive army — somewhere around 20,000 men, by most estimates. The Crusader king at the time was Baldwin IV, and he was just sixteen years old. And he was a leper. Luna: Sixteen, a leper, and he's facing Saladin? That sounds impossible. Lucas: It does. And that's exactly why Montgisard became such a legendary event for the Crusaders. Baldwin's forces were tiny — maybe 500 knights and a few thousand infantry. He had no business winning. But he did. And the way he did it tells us a lot about both Saladin's early overconfidence and the desperate courage of the Latin kingdom. Luna: So how did Saladin get caught off guard? He was usually so careful. Lucas: That's the key. Saladin had been campaigning in Syria for years, consolidating power, and by 1177 he saw the Kingdom of Jerusalem as weak and divided. Baldwin was young, sick, and the nobility was fractious. So Saladin launched a massive raid from Egypt into Palestine, aiming to draw the Crusader army into a trap or just ravage the countryside. He didn't expect Baldwin to actually meet him in the field. But Baldwin did. Luna: He marched out with his tiny army? That's either brave or reckless. Lucas: Probably both. The Crusader army gathered at Ascalon, and then moved inland toward where Saladin was camped near Ramla. Saladin, hearing they were coming, decided to withdraw — but he was slow, burdened by plunder. Near the village of Montgisard — which is probably the modern Tell al-Jazar — Baldwin caught up with him. The Crusaders charged. And they hit the Ayyubid army while it was still strung out on the march. Luna: So Saladin's army was caught in a column, not deployed for battle? That's a disaster waiting to happen. Lucas: Exactly. The Knights Templar, under their Grand Master Odo de St. Amand, led the charge. Baldwin himself was carried into battle on a litter because he could barely walk — but he was there, holding the True Cross, which the Crusaders believed gave them divine protection. The impact was devastating. Saladin's army broke and fled. Many of his men drowned trying to cross the river or were cut down from behind. Saladin himself barely escaped, reportedly riding a camel all the way back to Egypt. Luna: A camel? That's not exactly a dignified retreat for the sultan. Lucas: No, it's not. And it's a measure of how close he came to being captured or killed. The Latin chronicler William of Tyre, who was Baldwin's tutor and a key source for this period, describes the victory as a miracle. He says the Crusaders found Saladin's personal banner, his tent, and even his war chest abandoned on the field. The Templars lost Odo de St. Amand, who was taken prisoner and later died in captivity. But for the Kingdom of Jerusalem, it was the greatest victory in a generation. Luna: What about the Muslim sources? How did they record this defeat? Lucas: That's interesting. The main Arabic chronicler, Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani — Saladin's own secretary — is very cagey about Montgisard. He mentions a battle near Ramla but downplays the scale of the defeat. He says something like 'the Franj emerged from their hiding places' and hints that Saladin was betrayed by bad intelligence. Ibn al-Athir, writing a generation later, is more direct: he calls it a serious setback, and notes that Saladin vowed never to be caught in such a situation again. Luna: And he kept that vow, didn't he? Because later on, he was much more cautious. Lucas: He did. Montgisard was a harsh lesson. Saladin had underestimated his enemy. He assumed the leper king was too weak to fight, but Baldwin's determination — and the Templars' ferocity — caught him off guard. After 1177, Saladin became far more methodical. He stopped launching big invasions without careful preparation. He studied his opponents. And he waited for the right moment. That moment came ten years later at Hattin. Luna: So Montgisard bought the Crusader kingdom a decade? But it didn't change the long-term outcome. Lucas: That's right. In the short term, it was a huge morale boost. It proved that Saladin could be beaten. But it also masked the underlying weakness of the Latin states. Baldwin's leprosy was incurable, and he would only get worse. The succession crisis after his death tore the kingdom apart. Meanwhile, Saladin learned patience. He built alliances, secured his supply lines, and never again let himself be caught in a disorderly retreat. Montgisard was a defeat, but it made him a better commander. Luna: It's almost like the battle that taught him how to win the war. Lucas: Exactly. So Montgisard is often forgotten because it was a Crusader victory in a story that ultimately ends with Saladin's triumph. But it's a crucial turning point. It shows that even the greatest generals have blind spots. And it reminds us that history is full of close calls — if Saladin had been captured that day, the entire course of the Crusades might have been different. Luna: If you've been stepping into history with us episode by episode, you know we dig into these overlooked moments. And if you value hearing about battles like Montgisard — without ads or sponsors — listener support is what keeps this going. People who care about the show sometimes chip in at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small thing that makes a big difference for us. Lucas: Yeah, and it means we can keep exploring these stories in depth. So back to Montgisard — one detail I love is that the Crusaders were so convinced God had given them the victory that they named a church on the site. It was called the Church of St. Catherine, because the battle happened on her feast day. That kind of piety was central to how they understood the world. Luna: That makes sense. For them, it was a miracle. For Saladin, it was a learning experience. Lucas: Exactly. And the learning stuck. After Montgisard, Saladin never again faced a Crusader army without thorough reconnaissance and a secure line of retreat. He also started focusing more on building a professional army that could manoeuvre in the field, rather than relying on sheer numbers. In a way, Montgisard made him a better general — but it also doomed the Kingdom of Jerusalem. Because once he had absorbed that lesson, the next time he came, he was unstoppable. Luna: And the next time was Hattin, ten years later. So Montgisard bought time, but it didn't change the underlying realities. Lucas: Right. The underlying reality was that the Crusader states were a small, isolated outpost surrounded by a much larger Muslim world. They could win battles, but they couldn't win a war of attrition. Saladin had the resources to bounce back. Baldwin, even at his best, could only delay the inevitable. And once Baldwin died in 1185, the kingdom fell into civil war, and Saladin saw his opening. Luna: So Montgisard is really a story about the limits of a single victory. Lucas: Exactly. And it's also a story about character. Baldwin IV is one of the most tragic figures of the medieval world — a brilliant young man slowly consumed by a terrible disease, yet still leading his army from a litter. Saladin, for all his later chivalry, never forgot that a leper boy had humiliated him. I think that's part of why, when he finally took Jerusalem in 1187, he was merciful — he had learned that victory could be snatched away at any moment. Luna: That's a beautiful way to tie it together. Montgisard made both men who they were. Lucas: I think so. And that's why it's worth remembering — not just as a footnote, but as a pivotal moment that shaped the entire crusader era.