Latest / For the Missing: Missing Persons, Families & the Search for Answers / The Axe in the House: Lizzie Borden’s Silent Truth | For the Missing
Transcript
- It was a Thursday morning, bright and ordinary, when a neighbor came to borrow a rake and found the house locked tight. He didn’t know then that he was about to walk into a silence so heavy it would echo for over a century. John Turner stood on the porch of 462 Second Street in Fall River, Massachusetts. It was August 4th, 1892. The air was thick with summer heat, the kind that makes you want to stay inside where it’s cool. John had come for a simple favor—a borrowed rake. But the door wouldn’t open. No answer from inside. Just stillness. And something else. A smell. Not just the usual scent of an old house, but something metallic, something wrong. When he finally got inside, what he found changed everything. Andrew Borden, the patriarch of one of the wealthiest families in the city, lay dead on the sofa in the second-floor sitting room. His face was nearly unrecognizable, destroyed by multiple hatchet blows. In the adjacent bedroom, his wife, Abby Durfee Borden, had been found in a similar state. Two lives, ended violently, in the home they built together. The world held its breath. Who could do this? Who would do this? Let’s remember who they were. Before the blood, before the headlines, there was Lizzie Andrew Borden. Born in 1860, she was the third child of Sarah and Andrew Jackson Borden. Her early years were marked by loss; her sister Alice died young, and her mother Sarah passed away when Lizzie was just three. She grew up with her older sister Emma, raised in a household that was deeply religious and socially prominent. They attended Central Congregational Church. Lizzie taught Sunday school to children of recent immigrants. She served as secretary-treasurer for the Christian Endeavor Society. She was involved with the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union. By all outward accounts, Lizzie was a pillar of the community. Respectable. Quiet. Devout. But behind closed doors, the picture was different. Her father, Andrew, was a man of considerable wealth but also of considerable stinginess. Despite owning mills and real estate, their home lacked indoor plumbing. It was a house of contradictions—wealthy in status, poor in comfort. And within that house, tensions were simmering. The relationship between Lizzie and her stepmother, Abby, was strained from the start. Lizzie called her "Mrs. Borden," never "Mom." She believed Abby had married her father for his money, not his love. There were arguments, sharp and frequent, over property and inheritance. In May 1892, Andrew killed pigeons in his barn with a hatchet, believing they carried disease. Lizzie had recently built a roost for them. She was upset. Was it just about birds? Or was it a symbol of control? Of destruction? By July, the tension had reached a breaking point. A family argument prompted both Lizzie and Emma to take extended vacations in New Bedford. They returned to Fall River a week before the murders. But Lizzie didn’t go straight home. She stayed in a local rooming house for four days. Why? To keep her distance. To breathe. On the night before the murders, her maternal uncle, John Vinnicum Morse, arrived. He slept in the guest room. Andrew invited him to stay and discuss business matters. Property transfers. Money. The very things that had caused the rifts. The entire household had been violently ill for several days prior, likely from spoiled mutton left on the stove. Abby feared poison. She knew Andrew wasn’t popular in town. Fear hung in the air like smoke. Then, the morning of August 4th, breakfast was eaten. Andrew and Uncle John went to the sitting room to chat. Lizzie and Emma were elsewhere. Bridget Sullivan, the live-in maid, was busy. The stage was set. When John Turner returned to the house later that day, he didn’t find Lizzie. He didn’t find Emma. He found death. Andrew Borden was on the sofa, his head crushed by the axe. Abby was in the next room, her face similarly mutilated. The brutality was shocking. The method was precise. Multiple blows. Close range. This wasn’t a robbery gone wrong. This was personal. This was intimate violence. The police arrived quickly. The town was stunned. How could this happen in such a respectable home? Who lived here? Who knew these people? And who hated them enough to strike twice, in the same hour, in the same house? The questions multiplied faster than the answers. And as the investigation unfolded, eyes turned toward the women who had been living under that roof. Lizzie and Emma. Sisters. Survivors. Suspects. Lizzie Borden became the prime suspect almost immediately. She was present in the house. She had no alibi. And she acted strangely in the days following the discovery. Police noted that shortly after the murders, Lizzie burned several items of clothing in the kitchen stove. She claimed they were old rags. But why burn them? Why hide them? Then there was the dress. A blue silk dress she wore on the day of the murders. It was later found stained with blood. Forensic analysis at the time couldn’t definitively prove the stains were human blood from the victims, but the suspicion was undeniable. The jury saw a woman who seemed cold, detached, even relieved. She asked if her father was buried yet. She offered opinions on how long it might take for decomposition to set in. To the public, it looked like guilt. To her lawyers, it looked like shock. But the narrative had already taken hold. The dutiful daughter. The pious sister. The murderer. The rhyme began to spread through Fall River, whispered in kitchens and shouted in streets: "Lizzie Borden took an axe, gave her father forty whacks. When she saw what she had done, she gave her mother forty-one." Forty-one. The number stuck. The image stuck. Lizzie was arrested. Charged. Tried. The trial lasted only three hours of deliberation. Three hours. For two lives, for a town divided, for a nation watching. The prosecution painted a picture of resentment, of inheritance, of opportunity. The defense argued lack of motive, lack of evidence, lack of proof. The blue dress was inconclusive. The burned clothes were explained. The mood in the courtroom was tense, cinematic in its own right. But the jury listened. They looked at Lizzie. They looked at the evidence. And they acquitted her. June 20, 1893. Justice was served, or so it seemed. No one else was charged. No one else was convicted. Lizzie walked free. But freedom didn’t mean peace. It meant living with the question. With the stare. With the whisper. "Did she do it?" The search doesn’t end until they’re home. But in this case, they were never home again. And Lizzie remained. Lizzie Borden spent the rest of her life in Fall River, living with her sister Emma in the family home. They inherited their father’s estate. They lived quietly. Lizzie died of pneumonia in 1927, nine days before Emma. The case remains officially unsolved. No other suspects were ever formally charged. The hatchet was never conclusively linked to Lizzie, though it matched the wounds. The truth is lost to time. But the mystery remains. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected. Thank you for listening. I’m Kimberley Callahan. Hold that thought with me.