Latest / The World Unexplained / THE CONTROVERSIAL CASE OF THE BOY BUTCHER
Transcript
- 0:02The World Unexplained. The World Unexplained a podcast that explores the unusual beliefs,
- 0:09conspiracies, customs, rituals, and traditions from around the world. This is
- 0:16your host, Doctor Carlos. The Boy Butcher of Neosho County is today's story.
- 0:40Let's find out what this is all about. Sometime after midnight of March
- 0:44seventh, eighteen eighty six, Robert Mendel woke to his dog barking outside and
- 0:49gnawing. Someone knocking at the door of his farmhouse. When he dressed and
- 0:53opened the door, his neighbor, a sixteen year old by the name of
- 0:55Willie Sill, stood cold and frantic in front of him. He couldn't talk
- 1:00clearly, and he was rambling on about something that happened at his home.
- 1:06Mendel put his eutaware on and together they went out to find out what was
- 1:08happening. The Cell family we had a small two room house on an eighty
- 1:15acre farm, and the family had worked that farm for about fifteen years,
- 1:19and the community knew them well. Where Willie's father, j W. Was
- 1:23a school teacher and farmer. His wife Susan, and their children Willie,
- 1:29who were talked about right now, nineteen and Waddie and their youngest teen nine
- 1:32now were all well liked. When Mendel and Willie reached the cell home,
- 1:37they little lamp and took in a scene of abject horror. Inside. His
- 1:41father, his mother, and his two siblings had their schools been beaten and
- 1:46crushed. They're all dead, and each of their throats had been cut nearly
- 1:49from ear to ear. Now, as a forensic psychology expert myself, this
- 1:57is where we're going to change this podcast a little bit, because we're going
- 2:00to add a little bit of criminology to the game here. And this is
- 2:04obviously very personal. When somebody crushes somebody's skull and throats are slashed like this.
- 2:13Either it could be a psychotic episode, a psychiatric disorder severe one where
- 2:16they're deluded, deluded or hallucinating, or it's extremely personal, or both could
- 2:22be a combination. Maybe even drugs could be in effect. Of course,
- 2:24this is one hundred and forty years ago, but drugs were still around,
- 2:29so somebody probably knew. But we'll continue the story. The cell parents were
- 2:34sprawled on the floor and the children lay bloodied in their beds. It appeared
- 2:38that the elder cells. The dad had struggled doing whatever occurred that night,
- 2:44so obviously something happened. Whether or not they came in, we don't know
- 2:47if the entry of the doorways were busted open. Was it somebody who snuck
- 2:51in, was somebody who broke in? Did they let them in? The
- 2:53floor was covered in blood, and a hatchet and a butcher knife were lay
- 2:57nearby, again, very personal pan staying with blood stood evidence of the killer's
- 3:01attempt to clean up after the murder. So an attempt to clean up starts
- 3:06giving us an idea of an organized killer compared to a disorganized killer, which
- 3:10we probably haven't heard much about this in this podcast because we deal a lot
- 3:15of wild West stories. But in this particular case, when you have a
- 3:17killer who tries to cover up, they call it an organized killer. They
- 3:21have more of a sense of what's going on. They know what they've done
- 3:23is wrong. They don't want to get in trouble. Somebody with a severe
- 3:27psychiatric disorder or a psychotic episode doesn't really care. They'll just leave everything as
- 3:31is now. In this case, they still left the body, so maybe
- 3:35they ran out of time and they couldn't clean it. Who knows when question.
- 3:38Willie claimed he woke around midnight I saw a strange man in the doorway.
- 3:43When Willie gave chase, the man fled, circling in the cell house
- 3:46twice before throwing a walk at Willie. Willie followed the man but couldn't get
- 3:51close enough to catch him. Eventually, the man met up with an accomplice
- 3:53in a nearby field, Willie claimed, and the two rode into the night,
- 3:58But the murder scene in the cell home told a different story. When
- 4:00the sheriff arrived at daybreak, in the scene was investigated. It was reported
- 4:03that no other tracks were found aside from Willy's bootprints over to the mental residence.
- 4:09The sheriff, along with the county attorney C. A. Cox and
- 4:12local coroner JP Fouch, also noticed that Willie showed literally emotion during the ordeal,
- 4:15leading to the belief he might be a prime suspect. When an inquest
- 4:21was held at the cell home later that day, all four bodies still lay
- 4:25there where they were found. Willie remained unfazed by the butchering of his family.
- 4:29Now again, he could have been in shock, which happens a lot
- 4:31of times, and psychologically our body will go into a coping Mensidon. That
- 4:35mechanism was sometimes we can become catatonic, which means we don't move, or
- 4:40we can develop a lexthemia, which means we have a lack of emotion because
- 4:45of what's happening. However, the towns people took that though as guilt,
- 4:49and the coroners and promptu jury found him guilty. On the spot also didn't
- 4:55help in his case, and one knee of his long underwear was covered in
- 4:58blood, and he claimed that he had to notice the blood that soaked his
- 5:00boots and socks from the night before. Willis's motive for the murder wasn't obvious,
- 5:04though he was on good terms with his family, particularly his young sister,
- 5:08though some suggested he was jealous of Watti wat Y courting a girl Willy
- 5:12was also interested in. This may have been Robert Mendel's daughter. In Willy's
- 5:17defense, however, one theory suggested a gang of local horse thieves may have
- 5:21killed the family in retaliation, again which I was saying was personal. J
- 5:26w was a member of an anti horse thieves association, which may have made
- 5:29him a target among ant laws. There was rumors as well that Cells had
- 5:33been chloroformed. That night, when Willy woke up before the others, he
- 5:35was able to stumble out of the home and get him help before he himself
- 5:39was killed. Others, including neighbors and peers, believe Willy to be innocent,
- 5:43simply because he was a meek, mild manner boy who loved his family
- 5:46as far as everyone else knew. But a mob formed at the residence ready
- 5:50to hang Willy for the hanness crime, but the sheriff was able to slip
- 5:54with Willy away to the Fort Scott jail. Over the next few weeks,
- 5:59more than five people came to the jail to see the boy butcher of Neosho
- 6:01County. Though Willie still proclaimed innocence, there had been no leads in the
- 6:05case to suggest anyone else committed the crimes. Most of the evidence against Willy,
- 6:10though, was circumstantial. There was the glaring question of why he alone
- 6:13was spared, but at one point he appeared to have confessed the sheriff,
- 6:16Parsons, and several defense attorneys. Newspaper reports claimed that Willy asked if he
- 6:21should discuss how the murders took place, but the sheriff told him to act
- 6:26as if Willie had a theory about what happened, and that is, instead
- 6:29of outright confessing, he would tell his attorneys in third person. Several times,
- 6:33while Willy was telling me the story, said the sheriff, he would
- 6:36start to say aye instead of the man. I always corrected him and made
- 6:40him tell it in the third person. Wilson also made some vague, questionable
- 6:44statements before and during his trial. He made one, for instance, that
- 6:48said, those fellows try to get me to say that I did it,
- 6:50but I thought it would be best not to admit it. His theoretical conversation
- 6:54with Sheriff Parsons wasn't illegally binding confession, but it certainly didn't help Willy's case
- 6:59either. In July of eighteen eighty six, the jury took just less than
- 7:02an hour to find Willie Sell guilty of all the four murders. During the
- 7:05trial, chance people floated all all kinds of theories about the boy Butcher,
- 7:09that he was insane, or I committed the murders in a sleep walking state,
- 7:13which has happened very rarely. I think two murders, and one of
- 7:16them actually the person. The perpetrator was not convicted in that case, there
- 7:20was a claim that his head was misshaped to the point they had no development
- 7:24of the organs to donate family affection. Not true. Well. Another suggests
- 7:29he may have read too many violent dime novels. Again it was he influenced
- 7:31by outside influences. Who knows. In any case, the evidence against Willie
- 7:38was enough to convict him, and because Kansas didn't hang murderers whose sentence was
- 7:41essentially life in prison for more than twenty years, he was a model prisoner,
- 7:45working in a penitentiary dispensary and even helping prison guards recover from an attempted
- 7:48jailbreak. For years, his legal team worked in getting impardoned in one moment,
- 7:53in particular Sophie Boye, the daughter of a Kansas City judge. But
- 7:57our countless hours writing letters and requests that has behind half. Eventually her efforts
- 8:01paid off. Willie was eventually pardoned twenty one years after the murders. Willie
- 8:09worked in drug stores around Kansas, eventually owning his own store. For nearly
- 8:11forty years. He never had another run in with the law, and believe
- 8:16it or not, he lived to be ninety one. He died in Kansas
- 8:18City Kansas in July nineteen sixty. To this day, it's not really completely
- 8:24clear who murdered the cell family that night. In March eighteen eighty six,
- 8:28after William's convictions, some reports claimed that there were actually tracks of another man
- 8:31that night at the cell house, and that a broken bottle of chloroform was
- 8:35found near the home. Years later. The wrestler in prison even confessed to
- 8:41the crime later on, though it's not clear if this was confession was ever
- 8:45confirmed. Perhaps the Eriie Lynch mob, eager for swift justice, had overlooked
- 8:48or ignored evidence in the interest of finding a quick resolution, maybe out of
- 8:52fear, maybe out of something else. But there was also evidence to suggest
- 8:58Willie may have been hiding the full story. You see, one year after
- 9:01the murderer proclaimed that someone on the cell property found a pair of trial there's
- 9:05belonging to Willie under the floor of the hog pen, where they have been
- 9:07pushed clear out of sight by a whole handle. They were clearly staying with
- 9:11blood and meant to be hidden, and if they were in fact Willy's pants,
- 9:15one wonders why he would go to great lengths to hide them. Again,
- 9:18the organized killer to disorganized killer theory. Who knows what really happened there.
- 9:26It's a complicated story. Again, the evidence is kind of difficult.
- 9:31It doesn't look like they did a great job on trying to figure out what
- 9:37was going on. A lot of evidence was left, and we don't know
- 9:41some of those other pieces of evidence that they found years later were planted for
- 9:46whatever reason. Nobody really knows. But it happened one hundred and twenty eight
- 9:54years ago and they fascinating thing to me about this case was that he ended
- 10:00up going to jail for twenty years and then he actually was released and then
- 10:05lived on for another forty years. Man. You remember, the only surviving
- 10:09family member at the time was Willie and he was sixteen. Incredible stuff.
- 10:20So was he responsible? I don't know. No one believed him, at
- 10:26least not that night. Well, some people started believing him after and that
- 10:31was tough. Things that hurt Willie were the hidden trousers years later found and
- 10:35Willie the never showed emotion or cried over the slaughter. In fact, he
- 10:39soon went to a neighbor's house and went to bed. So many people are
- 10:46not understanding psychology, don't understanding trauma and defense mechanisms went quickly into this he's
- 10:50guilty, but the Kansas governor finally a pardon Willie in nineteen oh seven.
- 10:58As we mentioned, after he had served his twenty three you're staying again with
- 11:00the defense had repeated at the trial there was absolutely no motive for the crime.
- 11:07So really it's interesting because again thirty nine years went by. He was
- 11:13a church member and a model citizen. Eventually died in nineteen sixty at age
- 11:16ninety one, and from all you know in writings, no other crimes were
- 11:22committed by him. Robert E. Handals was survived by one the life and
- 11:28mind of a family mass and redeals with a teenage son from Mountain Vernon.
- 11:31And so the Southern Illiniah who killed not only his parents but his two bows
- 11:33and sisters in nineteen eighty five. It's a similar case. The rabbit Robert
- 11:39E. Hanlin survived by one. Now, this individual who killed outan Odel
- 11:48is serving serving a life sentence, and he confessed to the horrific crime.
- 11:54Everybody tried to make up motives for him trying to kill his family, but
- 11:58nothing really they came through offer. A local historian, John Halwas was a
- 12:03colonist wrote a little bit about the boy Butcher, so to the Old West
- 12:07magazine, that's it for now.