Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / The Nones: Doing versus Believing with Courtney Byers
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to the Together for Good Podcast, a podcast specifically
- 0:08designed to inspire, challenge and uplift you during your daily
- 0:11walk of faith. We are continuing on our journey
- 0:15as I interview the nuns people without a religious affiliation.
- 0:19My interview today is really neat and interesting.
- 0:22I bring on my friend Courtney Byers, who is just so wise and
- 0:26insightful and just a real delight to talk to in a lot of
- 0:31ways. And she has such an interesting
- 0:32story growing up in the church, going to a Christian college,
- 0:36being really involved and then taking a step back for the last
- 0:40eight years. I won't tell you where the story
- 0:42goes from there because it's kind of interesting where we end
- 0:44up, but this is a great long conversation.
- 0:47I really hope you enjoy it. As always, thank you so much for
- 0:50listening. Please continue to show this
- 0:52podcast with family and friends, people who might be interested
- 0:54in these stories that we're sharing.
- 0:56But now an interview. An interview with my longtime
- 0:58friend Courtney. Hello everyone.
- 1:04Welcome to the Together for Good podcast.
- 1:06We are continuing with this series where I'm talking with
- 1:09people who have no religious affiliation or have gone away
- 1:13from attending church regularly. On the line is a very dear
- 1:16friend of mine, Courtney Byers. Courtney, say hello.
- 1:20Hey there. Courtney and I have known each
- 1:23other. Gosh, when did we meet Courtney,
- 1:252003, I believe it was. Does that sound right to you?
- 1:29Yeah, OK. We'll get into that complicated
- 1:33story, That complicated, funny story.
- 1:35It's great in a second here. But first, Courtney, just tell
- 1:38us a little bit about who you are, where you live, what's
- 1:40important to you these days. OK, so I am currently living in
- 1:46Maine, right? Off I'm not on the ocean, but
- 1:52pretty close and it's mid coast, so anybody who knows Maine, it's
- 1:56like 2 hours north of Portland. And so we've been here for
- 2:04almost 8 years. What does my life look like
- 2:08these days? I have, so I'm married and I
- 2:11have two daughters who are 13 and 10.
- 2:16We have been homeschooling them. Through their whole lives.
- 2:21So a lot of my life is parenting and homeschooling and you know
- 2:26socializing and all that. And we also have a small family
- 2:33farm where we've got 13 acres and which honestly mostly is
- 2:40woods, but the the small family farm part is about 3 acres with
- 2:47we raise a lot of our own food. Well, we, we aspire to raise a
- 2:51lot of our own food, to be honest, when it really comes
- 2:54down to it, we raise some stuff that we eat for sure.
- 2:57But you know, it's not not totally there yet.
- 3:00Got it. We've got two pigs, 30 chickens,
- 3:0430 ducks, rabbits and then some cats and a dog.
- 3:12Oh my goodness. I didn't know about like the
- 3:14whole. Yeah, the farm aspect of it.
- 3:16When I when you said family farm, I'm thinking you grow
- 3:18vegetables but you have, yeah, livestock.
- 3:22Yes, yes, we grow, yeah, we we grow vegetables for ourselves to
- 3:25eat primarily and for me to like preserve, but the the livestock
- 3:31feeds us and I would say a handful of other people.
- 3:35We're not like market, you know, market scale, but we do feed
- 3:39neighbors and other people connected to us.
- 3:43That's so great. Ohh man, that's what a cool
- 3:45you're painting a really cool picture of life.
- 3:47Just a very, yeah, living off the earth and living probably in
- 3:52a like a simpler sort of style. I'm thinking about how much
- 3:56traffic I have to deal with here in Denver and just how busy
- 3:59everything is. And at least my picture of what
- 4:01you're saying is that it's a little calmer where you are.
- 4:05Yeah, it's beautiful. And our home is off the grid.
- 4:09It's a small house and yeah, we've been experimenting with.
- 4:14For years now with various forms of appropriate technology, and I
- 4:22just got I just got hot running water this year from a tank
- 4:27attached to our wind stove. So Hot Showers is like a new
- 4:30thing that I'm very excited about.
- 4:33I'm very happy for you. Incredible, Courtney.
- 4:35I did not realize the extent of all of this neat okay.
- 4:39So yeah, you're painting a really interesting picture.
- 4:42And I love also because I'm hoping, like our listeners are
- 4:44getting a sense too. This is always how you've been.
- 4:46You've always been just so patient and wise and kind of
- 4:51loving the simple pleasures in life in a lot of ways.
- 4:56And I feel like that was even sort of part of your upbringing
- 4:59as well. And so if we can kind of trace
- 5:01it, I want to, right. We're talking a lot about the
- 5:03way that religion plays a role. And so now we can admit we met
- 5:06in 2003 at the National Youth Gathering when we were both
- 5:09elected onto the National Lutheran Youth Board and we
- 5:14served three-year terms. So we would go to all these
- 5:16meetings all over the country and feel important and but it's
- 5:22but also, I don't know about you.
- 5:23I mean that was such a formative experience in my life in so many
- 5:27ways. Yeah, for sure.
- 5:29So grateful for it. So obviously.
- 5:31Right. Yeah, we were the the top notch
- 5:33church nerds in 2003 to 2006. So, yeah, tell us a little bit
- 5:38more just about where you grew up and and and, you know, to
- 5:41kind of pay attention to the ways that faith played a role in
- 5:44your life and in your upbringing.
- 5:47Yeah, so. I think significantly.
- 5:51I mean where I grew up is significant in that I grew up in
- 5:54Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, which is, if anybody knows that
- 5:58area, hugely Amish and Mennonite and my own heritage comes from
- 6:06that group as well. My great grandmother was raised
- 6:09Amish, and I have other Mennonite roots in there as
- 6:14well, and for anybody who doesn't know the Amish.
- 6:18Especially in that area there are there are farming based
- 6:21community obviously they've branched out as you know the
- 6:24world has changed but still very agrarian and very much focused
- 6:31on living out life, living out a life of faith through lifestyle
- 6:38and and and community. So that's like the.
- 6:44I I I wasn't raised Mennonite or Amish, but that was what
- 6:48surrounded me. So I saw it was certainly, like,
- 6:51endemic to that culture, for sure.
- 6:55Did you eat at their bakeries a lot?
- 6:56Because that was always my favorite.
- 6:57When I in Philadelphia, there's like the Reading Terminal
- 7:00Market. Yeah.
- 7:01And I would always go there to the Amish Bakeries because those
- 7:04were the best. Sorry, you made me hungry.
- 7:06I haven't had breakfast yet. For sure.
- 7:08There's definitely roadside stand bakeries and all that.
- 7:13All the great stuff. So I grew up in a, you know,
- 7:18fairly rural ish kind of place and my parents were Lutheran
- 7:26ELCA. We went to a church right in our
- 7:29town and we were really involved.
- 7:35My grandparents went to that church too.
- 7:37So you know, couple generations of us were there and.
- 7:43As a kid, I mean, all I remember is like mostly dressing up for
- 7:48church and we went every week and we played with like
- 7:51figurines and the pews, that kind of thing.
- 7:55And then, but as I got older, like middle school age and high
- 8:01school, my parents were really involved and we're actually the
- 8:05youth leaders for middle school youth groups and high school
- 8:09youth groups. At times, to my chagrin, but
- 8:13they were over there and they were great, but so we got really
- 8:19involved. So we got really involved and I
- 8:22don't know, I feel like I was at church a lot, you know,
- 8:24obviously for the Sunday like morning worship, but then like
- 8:29youth group stuff and I was on the city or not the City
- 8:33Council, the church council board as a youth.
- 8:39Yeah, at some point in high school I got voted onto the
- 8:42board, yeah. Or the the, the, the council,
- 8:46yeah. That is like a 15 or 16 year
- 8:49old, probably. Yeah.
- 8:51Fascinating and and and all of this.
- 8:53It sounds like it was a really relatively positive experience.
- 8:56Other than your parents. Being in charge of the youth
- 8:58group at times was probably, yes, embarrassing or
- 9:01uncomfortable, but not ultimately, bad.
- 9:04No, no, no. I had a great experience in
- 9:06church. Definitely, really formative.
- 9:10I mean, interestingly too, like the because of where I grew up,
- 9:13my public school was predominantly Christian.
- 9:18Like most kids at my school went to church in some form, But I
- 9:22just had a lot of, I had a lot of Christian influence.
- 9:24And it's interesting, having grown up Lutheran, because #1I
- 9:31grew up with like the liturgy, which a lot of my friends
- 9:33didn't, and. I loved that.
- 9:39Even as a kid. Even as a kid.
- 9:40Be honest. As a kid, I mean, I think I just
- 9:46didn't know anything different. So sure, no, I I probably didn't
- 9:49love it. But I really got it in.
- 9:51I really got into it like theologically as like a high
- 9:55schooler, you know, like confirmation, like confirmation.
- 9:58And that whole time, like, I I just loved diving into like, why
- 10:04we do these things and where they came from.
- 10:06Yeah, no. And I, it's funny too, I, I
- 10:09asked that question. Well, we were talking on the
- 10:11phone yesterday and prep for this and and I said to you
- 10:14right, that I think I love the liturgy now, too.
- 10:17So, so much. In fact, here at the church
- 10:21where I serve in, in Denver, we hadn't been using traditional
- 10:25Lutheran liturgy for much of the summer.
- 10:26But this past Sunday we did, right.
- 10:28And this is just normally in the year we have two services and
- 10:31one is very liturgical and one's less so.
- 10:34And I didn't realize how much I missed it when we finally had a
- 10:36summer service that was just like traditional Lutheran
- 10:39energy. My gosh, this is, I don't know,
- 10:41there's just something powerful about it.
- 10:43And and in particular, the joke I made to you yesterday is that
- 10:47I I feel like I didn't love it as a kid.
- 10:49But because I did it for 30 years, that's how I developed
- 10:53this affinity towards it. Because I have, like, memories
- 10:56and. And it's muscle memory, too, of
- 10:58singing the same tunes, Right. It's like your favorite song
- 11:01that you heard as a kid that you're hearing again.
- 11:04Yeah. I don't know.
- 11:04Yeah, there's something really powerful about all of that.
- 11:07But I mean, say it more, too. I'm curious.
- 11:09What was it in high school that you kind of dove into with it?
- 11:12Just the history of it and the way that it does kind of connect
- 11:15us across generations or something else.
- 11:21The clearest memory I have, I mean definitely appreciating it
- 11:25and I think because. Because a lot of my friends
- 11:29didn't have liturgy. They were part of different
- 11:32Christian denominations that were much more fundamentalist or
- 11:37Bible based or whatever. They just didn't have a liturgy.
- 11:40And so I just became more like defensive of what I did, you
- 11:45know, and why, why that mattered to me.
- 11:48And I got to have a lot of this. I got to have a lot of those
- 11:51conversations, you know, with friends who didn't understand.
- 11:57And then I remember like in high school, there was like a group
- 12:01of three of us who would meet with our pastor and just like
- 12:06dive into the Bible. Like we would just choose a
- 12:10passage somewhere and just like talk about it for, I don't know
- 12:15an hour or two and just really like break things down and look
- 12:19at. I think we looked at like the
- 12:21translation and like where I think what words different words
- 12:24meant and. What that meant theologically
- 12:26and whatever, I was a nerd. I loved that stuff, that stuff a
- 12:31lot. And it was fascinating to me.
- 12:33Yeah, that's I'm sitting thinking on the other side of it
- 12:37too. I bet the pastor just adored the
- 12:40opportunity to do that as well, right?
- 12:42Like hearing you said, I'm like, gosh, I wish I could do that.
- 12:44That sounds awesome. Yeah, it's awesome.
- 12:47Really cool. OK.
- 12:48So. And so then you kind of go on,
- 12:51right? Like great, great high school
- 12:53experience, it sounds like. And then we met.
- 12:56Let's see, we were both finishing our junior year of
- 12:58high school. That's 2003, right?
- 13:00Yeah, because we're both 2004 grads, right.
- 13:03And yeah, we get on to this National Lutheran Youth Board,
- 13:06which is its own. That is a podcast.
- 13:08There's a lot of stories that go along with that crew.
- 13:11But then you also went off to college at Messiah College.
- 13:14So tell us a little bit about that experience, too.
- 13:17Yeah, so. So yeah, we served on the board
- 13:20and that was an amazing opportunity and was really I
- 13:27just, I think the richest things I took away from that without
- 13:34really pretty much reflection into this before this moment.
- 13:36But I I just have like certain memories of #1, like deep faith
- 13:43conversations, which I love, yeah.
- 13:49Uh, times that we had like we did that amazing like tasay
- 13:54service one time and then teachings from I'm gonna blank
- 14:01on his name. Is it like Bill?
- 14:03Yeah, Bill Keys. Bill.
- 14:05Yes, Bill Keys. There's some people listening to
- 14:09this podcast I know who are gonna be so excited that his
- 14:11name got mentioned. Yeah, he's he's connected all
- 14:14through the Luther world. There's a lot of people I meet
- 14:16who are like, oh, do you know Bill Keys?
- 14:17Like, Oh yeah, Gosh, yeah. Yeah.
- 14:20So just I mean I guess with that what that the link among all
- 14:24those things are just deep spiritual stuff from people
- 14:28getting to experience that in different ways.
- 14:30And I love that. So I I did go to Messiah which
- 14:36is an Anna Baptist College in Pennsylvania.
- 14:40And yeah, a lot of stuff shifted there.
- 14:45And it was interesting because I I feel like I have these two
- 14:48main. Branches like if there's, you
- 14:51know one big river of like spirituality.
- 14:53There's like these two main branches that feed it and well,
- 14:56there's more than maybe 2. But two main ones that come from
- 14:59religion are the Lutheran and liturgical sort of life.
- 15:08And then the other branch being this Anna Baptist ranch, which
- 15:13is very different. You know, if you look at church
- 15:15history, very different than than the.
- 15:17What was then the like Catholic liturgical church?
- 15:21The Anna Baptists were really paving a new way which was
- 15:26looking at really living out faith through lifestyle.
- 15:31It was very land based communities and their whole
- 15:37thing was saving baptism for when you're an adult and old
- 15:42enough to choose it. Not as an infant.
- 15:45Yeah, and for our listeners too, Anna, Baptist is is vastly
- 15:49different than Baptist and. Yes, very different.
- 15:52Say Anna Baptist is is very close to Mennonite in a lot of
- 15:56ways. Is that fair?
- 15:58Oh yeah, yeah. So the Anna Baptist umbrella
- 16:00includes, like, Mennonites, Amish Church of the Brethren.
- 16:05Brethren in Christ. That's right.
- 16:07OK, Yeah. Thank you.
- 16:08Perfect. Yeah, so that was the roots of
- 16:12of Messiah College. And so I feel like for my first.
- 16:17So again I found myself surrounded by people who most of
- 16:21the people I came in contact with had no familiarity with,
- 16:26like liturgical church. So I feel like for my first like
- 16:31one to two years there, I was just like fanatically liturgical
- 16:38and. Was just, you know, like kind of
- 16:41like searching for, like why this matters so much to me and
- 16:44the church history around it. And I had a certain professor
- 16:48who was like, I don't know what he was maybe Anglican or
- 16:51something, but he was super, You know, like this is the right
- 16:55way. Kind of like not not totally,
- 16:57but just really pushed the little surgical thing.
- 17:00And I was like, yes, just like eating it all.
- 17:02You just ate it up, yeah. And you know, like lots of,
- 17:05like, just debates with friends and.
- 17:08All that fun stuff. So anyway, and you Were you a
- 17:12religious studies major? Do I remember that correctly?
- 17:16Yes. Well, so I went into college.
- 17:18OK. So, yeah, we should back up a
- 17:21little. Go ahead just to.
- 17:22Say that another huge, another huge influence in my high
- 17:26schooling time in faith was was camp and I was really so I was
- 17:35involved in the the National Youth Board, but I was also
- 17:37involved. On our Synod level, right.
- 17:41And was the vice president of that for a while And anyway I
- 17:45would run. I would like lead the middle
- 17:47school retreats for kids at camps and I was part of a
- 17:51leadership training camp like every summer.
- 17:54And that's right. And that was like a really cool.
- 17:58That was amazing. I mean, really, most formative
- 18:01things for my faith life. Who was the Synod guy in charge
- 18:05of that? Charlie.
- 18:07Charlie Roberts. Roberts.
- 18:09That's right. Yeah, that.
- 18:09Was amazing. So I went through that whole
- 18:11program and then and then I came back as a older high schooler
- 18:15and you know, mentored kids coming up through it.
- 18:19So, But all of that was like preparing you.
- 18:22What? I mean, how I took it was like
- 18:24preparing you for church leadership, basically.
- 18:27Yeah. And I had a lot of encouragement
- 18:29to do that, which at the time mostly translated as like being
- 18:34a pastor. And so I So when I went to
- 18:41college, I I majored in Global Missions.
- 18:49Whoa, okay, I. Think I started out missions
- 18:53person like it. It was all you know, it was all
- 18:55in the same branch. It was like ministry and you
- 18:58could do youth ministry or global ministry or church
- 19:00ministry. I don't know.
- 19:02Anyway, I told I chose global because I was interested in the
- 19:04rest of the world. So.
- 19:07So I did that and my my first like year was like, lots of were
- 19:12not lots, but a few like theology classes, which I
- 19:16thought I would love because I used to love diving into that
- 19:20stuff. And actually I was just like,
- 19:22we're sitting through a class where we're just debating the
- 19:24same old stuff that's that's like literally been debated for
- 19:29like 500 years. Totally.
- 19:33And we're. Like we're not moving anywhere.
- 19:36Like, what is the point of this? It's a brief aside.
- 19:39I had thoughts, especially when I worked at the seminar in
- 19:42Philadelphia. I was like, gosh, like, I love
- 19:46this academic environment and I love thinking big thoughts.
- 19:48I'm like, yeah, maybe I should go and do a PhD, Like, maybe I
- 19:52should do a PhD. And then I thought about it.
- 19:54And in order to get a PhD in any discipline, you have to create
- 19:59something, right? Your dissertation is.
- 20:01Creating something that has never been written about before
- 20:04in that field. And I when I had that
- 20:07realization, I'm like, wait a second.
- 20:09Like, maybe there's a reason no one has written about some of
- 20:13the things that we get to in like theology, PhDs.
- 20:16Just like you're in such a, you know, such a small little niche
- 20:20content area that it's probably not worth it.
- 20:23So that that idea died very quickly for very similar
- 20:27reasons. Like you're stating, right?
- 20:28Like just we are debating the same things again and again.
- 20:32Yeah, And like, nobody's, Nobody's budging.
- 20:35Like it's been this way. Right?
- 20:39Nobody's budging. So true.
- 20:42Anyway, so I kind of became like disillusioned with some of that
- 20:46stuff, like in that time. And then somewhere in there too,
- 20:56we should talk about we worked at camp together, which was a
- 21:00really cool experience. I mean, that was such a strange
- 21:03summer. But I know that I I don't think
- 21:05I'm out of line in saying that. For both of us, the week where
- 21:09we were in charge of the high school program, what was it
- 21:12called? Disciples of God?
- 21:14And so it's like a very intensive, very small high
- 21:17school program, probably similar to your high school Bible
- 21:20studies with the pastor, where we just had like 10 really
- 21:26awesome kids who really wanted to be there and wanted to learn
- 21:30and wanted to ask the big questions.
- 21:32I still think so fondly of that particular week and experience
- 21:38and yeah, just how powerful it was to be able to lead it.
- 21:42And I don't know if I could do that again.
- 21:44I would absolutely sign up for another chance to lead that
- 21:47group. Yeah, I mean, I I think it's so
- 21:49fun. And I think this is true in my
- 21:51adult life too. I mean, the things that give me
- 21:54the most energy and excitement in life are deep conversations
- 21:59with people who are willing to be curious and be vulnerable
- 22:07with themselves and understand, you know, trying to understand
- 22:10each other and and and having a, you know, degree of an open mind
- 22:14to hear another person's experience.
- 22:18And that was just so fun. And for people who like, really
- 22:21wanna seek, and are like, open to yeah, they being curious.
- 22:27No, that's. Lose.
- 22:29Yeah, that's really well said. That's really well said.
- 22:31I would echo those sentiments. And there was like so much fun
- 22:36creativity to it all, too. Gosh, yeah, just such a good
- 22:39time. Yeah, it was great.
- 22:42So, OK, so this, right? Like you're still painting this
- 22:44picture as someone like, very involved, very passionate about
- 22:48faith and and I'm just curious like what do you think?
- 22:51Kind of. When did it change or shift?
- 22:52And yeah, what? What other details do we need to
- 22:54hear? Yeah.
- 22:55So I'll try and sum this up quickly.
- 22:57So I did start off as a global missions major during that
- 23:01summer. I think it was during that
- 23:03summer that we were at camp. Is that the summer that we went
- 23:05to that seminary in, like North Carolina?
- 23:09Yes, it was. It was like a it was an event
- 23:11for people interested in. Seminary, yes.
- 23:15So I was still on that path and I feel like after that.
- 23:18Visit. I had people telling me if
- 23:21you're going to go to seminary major and something that's not
- 23:24religion, like not religion or Bible related and I was like OK
- 23:29great. So I ignored that advice.
- 23:32So good for. You so I, you know, I was kind
- 23:35of like burned out on the theology stuff.
- 23:37And so I went to my next love, which was psychology, and and
- 23:44then on to my next love, which is sociology.
- 23:47And I ended up majoring in sociology and minoring in
- 23:49psychology. And OK, still took, still took
- 23:54some, you know, Bible or not, well I don't know, Bible based.
- 23:59I took like Greek for fun. And then and then I had some
- 24:08amazing classes towards the end of my year.
- 24:12So that's one significant thing that happened.
- 24:14Things began to shift. Well, things begin to shift when
- 24:18we were at our end of our LYO term.
- 24:21So part of what was happening for me was there's a big,
- 24:27there's a big influence in my college education.
- 24:30There were people who taught at Messiah, not currently there,
- 24:34but who had taught there and had written books like Don Kraebel
- 24:37and Ron Cider. I don't know if your audience
- 24:40would be familiar with them at all, but they wrote books like.
- 24:45The Upside down Kingdom and Rich Christians in an age of hunger
- 24:49and very social, social, justice minded and very much about how
- 24:57do we actually live out the gospel and that that really
- 25:04started to sink in for me and it became harder and harder to go
- 25:08to these huge national conventions where there's
- 25:11millions of dollars being spent on.
- 25:14A lot of fun and some meet and like, some meet like, yeah,
- 25:19there's there's meaningful stuff, but like, wow, like a lot
- 25:24of money and energy and all this stuff for, yeah.
- 25:28For ultimately, I don't know. I mean, who knows?
- 25:31But anyhow, that became harder and harder for me to keep seeing
- 25:36and being a part of, and at the same time my parents left the
- 25:40church. So my parents have been, my
- 25:43parents have been really involved in our church.
- 25:47The pastor and my dad were like, we're really good friends.
- 25:51The pastor actually, when he left the church, went to work
- 25:53for my dad as a plumber. Yeah.
- 25:58So anyway, my parents have been really involved and my dad in
- 26:02particular was really kind of he was considering like youth
- 26:07ministry for himself as a career at one point.
- 26:10And and. Just began seeing all these
- 26:14dynamics within the Church of how much, how much everybody
- 26:18relies on the pastor and how people might want to change
- 26:23things. But there's so much.
- 26:24It's so hard to make to make things change or that things
- 26:29change. So anyway, they actually ended
- 26:31up leaving the church before I did.
- 26:35And at the same time that I'm kind of grappling with like.
- 26:39What does it even mean to, like, live out a life of faith?
- 26:43Does that have to be done in a church?
- 26:46What about, like, the earlier churches that were like house
- 26:49churches, you know, that kind of thing.
- 26:51And I had a professor, I took an amazing class with this
- 26:55professor who was very challenging.
- 26:57And he said he he assigned us to read the four Gospels and make a
- 27:02list of every everything that Jesus says you have to believe.
- 27:09And then everything that Jesus says, you have to do like and
- 27:13the list, the and like I did it in like a weekend.
- 27:17And literally there are. If I'm recalling, there's
- 27:22literally like 2 verses that say what you need to believe and
- 27:28like pages and pages and pages of all the verses that tell you
- 27:32how you should be living or what kind of actions would you know.
- 27:38Be you know things that Jesus was teaching Fascinating.
- 27:43And and yeah and I can also see right you're from your Anna
- 27:47Baptist college and your Amish, right.
- 27:52Like your Amish heart was just so encouraged by this
- 27:55assignment. Yeah, so really interesting.
- 27:59And and anyway, so I began attending.
- 28:04So I I guess at that point I had been really involved in a in a.
- 28:08In a church, a Lutheran Church off campus that I was a youth
- 28:12leader in during college, and I guess I ended that.
- 28:15I mean, maybe I stuck around to be the youth leader still, but I
- 28:20moved on to joining a house church.
- 28:25I had a group of people that I knew from from college and the
- 28:29surrounding community who were mainly in a Baptist and had
- 28:32started a house church. And that's what I kind of moved
- 28:34into and that was great. So did I answer your question?
- 28:42I think you did well. And yeah, I mean, you're kind of
- 28:45talking about where things shifted, but you're still very
- 28:47much involved in a church, like community as a house church,
- 28:51right. And.
- 28:52Yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah.
- 28:54So, OK, so I'll speed up. OK, go ahead.
- 28:58So I went to another thing I did in college is I went to the
- 29:03Middle East for a semester. That's right.
- 29:06Which was life changing? It was we we went there.
- 29:09It was from a coalition of Christian colleges.
- 29:12But we we went there to to study Islam and culture and the
- 29:17politics and religion of the Middle East.
- 29:21Not with the intention of like proselytizing or bolstering our
- 29:25Christian faith, but really exploring like what are these
- 29:28other religions and what are they teaching?
- 29:30And how do people live and how are people treated and what are
- 29:33the dynamics? That's where where I met my
- 29:37husband Steve. So.
- 29:40And he was at a different college.
- 29:43He went to a different Christian college and he was on that
- 29:46semester as a as a staff person. He had, he had already been
- 29:51there and was living in Egypt and was on this pro was staff on
- 29:55this program. So that's where where we met and
- 29:58we really connected on this. This passion for like, how do
- 30:06you live out the gospel? So can I ask, just thinking
- 30:14about that for you and Steve, in terms of this passion for how
- 30:17you live out the gospel, Do you feel like, but you connected on
- 30:23this on this trip where you're really studying Islam?
- 30:27Is there something about the Muslim faith that really focuses
- 30:32on kind of living out the faith in a way that kind of made you
- 30:35look differently at your own Christian practices?
- 30:40I don't think it was anything specifically Islamic, OK.
- 30:44But in general, the Middle Eastern culture, which where we
- 30:49were was primarily, you know, primarily Muslim in Egypt
- 30:52anyway. But just really culturally,
- 30:55throughout the Middle East, people were so hospitable and so
- 31:05welcoming and warm. And yeah, there's a certain,
- 31:10like, welcoming the stranger, right?
- 31:12Was so, yeah, like, we stayed with poor families and they
- 31:18would give you the best of what they had.
- 31:20Yeah, like the absolute best. And.
- 31:23So I think that was like what stuck with us a lot was just, I
- 31:30don't know if that's, you know, if you want to find that as
- 31:32Islamic or Christian or anything like that, but it's just a
- 31:35cultural way of being that that I do.
- 31:38I do assume probably, you know, pervaded like the world that
- 31:41Christ grew up in, right? Well, just that culture that
- 31:45still exists there. So, no, that's really I asked
- 31:50you. So my brother in laws, Maslam,
- 31:52and I've always been, you know, as I've gotten to know him over
- 31:55the last decade better and and seen him practice his faith,
- 31:59there's just like observing the way someone practices a religion
- 32:03that's different than yours. I always think it's a really
- 32:05powerful experience if you allow it to be.
- 32:09And just like there's such a focus on practice, it feels
- 32:13like, right, like, go to pray five times a day, right?
- 32:17Like, really be intentional about not only your fasting
- 32:21during Ramadan but also breaking fast as community at the end of
- 32:24the day in Ramadan. But it goes like kind of
- 32:27observing those pieces and just the.
- 32:30Yeah, the consistent practice of how they frame their life around
- 32:33it. So that that was part of why I
- 32:34asked is because it's been powerful for me to be like,
- 32:36wait, like how can I make practice a little more a part of
- 32:41my living on my Christian faith? But I love your reflection, too,
- 32:45on just the radical hospitality of the Middle East and
- 32:48experiencing that and how that, yeah, can kind of have its own
- 32:52way of changing you and your outlook on a whole number of
- 32:56things, I'm sure. Yeah, yeah.
- 32:59So I think that kind of wraps up college.
- 33:05It kind of left me. It left me.
- 33:11It left me really seeking. Community spiritual community
- 33:17and really seeking a lifestyle that would that would fit with
- 33:21like living out the the these values and and it left me with
- 33:28Steve and so we got married and we lived in a intentional
- 33:34community first with people with disabilities for a while and
- 33:41then we had a baby. And then so during that time we
- 33:46were still affiliated with churches, we still, we still
- 33:50went to a church and then we lived in Pennsylvania for a
- 33:53while and went to a Mennonite church that was a really great
- 33:58small Community Church that had a pastor that they hired like
- 34:02for. It was, I think he worked 1/4
- 34:04time. So everybody took turns.
- 34:08Everybody took turns. Like sharing a sermon.
- 34:12So it's just really community based.
- 34:14And yeah, and so and Steve and I spent the first three months of
- 34:20our marriage traveling down the East Coast, visiting different
- 34:25Christian communities of people who are living together and
- 34:28living out certain missions together.
- 34:32So, so yeah, we we did that. We explored intentional
- 34:37community, all the while considering ourselves Christian.
- 34:43And then we moved to Vermont because my husband is a clinical
- 34:48herbalist and he wanted to go to school, which for anybody who
- 34:52doesn't know that doesn't mean that we just thought he's like a
- 34:54marijuana grower. I feel like everybody's like,
- 34:56oh, herbalist. Does he grow marijuana
- 34:59especially in Colorado where? Most people are listening, yeah,
- 35:02he's he's a clinical herbalist where he's been trained for
- 35:05years to work with. An apothecary of plants that he
- 35:10formulates pinctures and treats people and works on different
- 35:14health issues. Correct.
- 35:16And we should, we should say too.
- 35:18So part of one of our fun connections too is that my, my
- 35:21older sister lives right in the same like adjacent town to where
- 35:25you are. And I know that that Steve is
- 35:28their clinical herbalist. Yes, yes, yes, yes.
- 35:32If anybody wants to learn more, his website is Steve
- 35:34byerswellness.com. So, so yeah, so we where was I?
- 35:42Vermont. We went to Vermont and that's
- 35:43kind of the 1st place where we kind of played with like, hmm,
- 35:46like what does it mean if we call ourselves Christian or not?
- 35:51Yeah. Explore that because there
- 35:53weren't there weren't a lot of church options.
- 35:58It's, it's certainly not very religious area, obviously.
- 36:03Yep, the Godless Northeast. That's what I always call it.
- 36:05Yeah, and so. So we we just kind of played
- 36:08with that like what does it even mean to call ourselves Christian
- 36:10and does that matter? Like does it matter what we call
- 36:13ourselves as long as we're living out what we believe we
- 36:17want to be living out and like being aligned with our values.
- 36:20Yeah. So we we kind of played with
- 36:24that and we didn't really have a church community and but still
- 36:29really felt a strong pool to spiritual community and we did a
- 36:32lot of moving and we did a lot of traveling and.
- 36:37Ended up in a in a intentional community for a little bit just
- 36:42to kind of learn from them and anyway came out of that saying
- 36:48let's move to Maine where we can and and our model kind of
- 36:53shifted from instead of intentional community which is
- 36:56like people living together in a very shared way.
- 36:59How can we live? How can we choose a choose a
- 37:02place where we can live with like intentional neighbors?
- 37:06Like, let's move somewhere and really intentionally form
- 37:08relationships with our neighbors and our community.
- 37:11And I really love that. That's just something I'm really
- 37:17passionate about currently. It's funny that you should bring
- 37:20that up because I I read this book, it's actually written by
- 37:23two, like, evangelical pastors in Denver and it's called the
- 37:28Art of neighboring. And basically their story is
- 37:31that, like, the City Council person came to this group of
- 37:34pastors, and it's like, hey, could the church help us do,
- 37:38like, teaching people to care about neighbors and their small
- 37:42communities? And the pastors in the book they
- 37:45read about, they're like, we were so embarrassed that it took
- 37:47a City Council person to ask us to fulfill the message of Jesus.
- 37:52But then they kind of go through it like that, You know, just
- 37:53this whole process and they share stories.
- 37:56And it's such a neat vision of right.
- 37:59Like, one of the things that Jesus did command us to do is to
- 38:02love our neighbors. And that, like, is repeated in a
- 38:05number of different ways to the Gospels.
- 38:07And I don't think we ever realized just how revolutionary
- 38:10that actually would be. That's what the book really
- 38:12opened up for me is like, yeah, if if we just really took this
- 38:16seriously, you know, we could impact these little corners
- 38:19where we spend most of our time and collectively that could
- 38:23really change the scope of society as a whole.
- 38:28You know, we always try and, like, solve the big problem all
- 38:30at once. Like, what if we just tried to
- 38:32really live faithfully in the little corners where we are?
- 38:35And. And it sounds like you're you're
- 38:36really doing that. I I I know I wrote a note down
- 38:39right at the beginning of our conversation about how you you
- 38:42intentionally feed your neighbors.
- 38:43You said you, you right. Like you share some of the food
- 38:45that you have with your neighbors.
- 38:48And that's just such a neat vision of exactly what you're
- 38:51talking about here, I think. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:53And I and so those so from all of this and from all of our
- 38:57years like. Kind of experimenting in various
- 39:00communities and different living situations.
- 39:05I think what we held and still holds us is this desire for like
- 39:16reconnection and I think part of part of the reason of like
- 39:21leaving the church or taking our years of absence from it.
- 39:27Was there's so much embedded in our Western Christianity that
- 39:34detaches us from what is holy and sacred like right around us.
- 39:44Like there's these beliefs that are that.
- 39:47I mean, of course we can understand God is like all
- 39:51around us, but I just feel like the mentality in the church
- 39:54while they would say that. Isn't really the feeling you get
- 39:59like, it's like, no, God is like out there and we've got to like,
- 40:02pray to him and, yeah, and and and there's like a huge
- 40:08disconnection between our bodies.
- 40:10I mean, just philosophically through church theology, right?
- 40:14It's like the bodies are simple, yeah.
- 40:17But our whole life is experienced through our body.
- 40:21And God. Especially, yeah, yeah.
- 40:24Especially because mother and. I worked for a couple of years
- 40:28as a doula and I still work with women postpartum.
- 40:31It's just like all of life enters through a body and it's
- 40:35sustained by a body and and I totally think that that's
- 40:41something that you can find in scripture and I'm able to
- 40:45connect to. But it took me years of just
- 40:48allowing myself to be absent from it to like form these.
- 40:53More like. Just reconnect with what is
- 41:00alive and and here and real and magical and elemental to then be
- 41:07able to like reenter church kind of and say Oh yeah, I can see
- 41:14these pieces are alive here. Just the church doesn't really
- 41:18spend much time on that or talk about it but it feeds me and I
- 41:22can I can reconnect that well and just this whole I love this
- 41:27thread about embodiment because it it literally is a core
- 41:32Christian statement of God became human.
- 41:36You know the whole incarnation is God saying like yes like a
- 41:40human body is a good thing. I will choose to take that on.
- 41:45But we've we've glossed over it with a whole bunch of moralism,
- 41:47I think and and I love there's just so much to what you're
- 41:52talking about. But I guess like some of my
- 41:55pushback or my question would be one of the really powerful
- 41:59things for me is recognizing church community.
- 42:04Like the way that it's spoken about in the epistles is as the
- 42:07body of Christ. Like we are the continuation of
- 42:10the embodiment of God here on earth.
- 42:12And so I'm just curious about like how do you still, like,
- 42:17find community or or like how does community still play into
- 42:21it? Cuz that does feel like the
- 42:22peace. I I don't disagree with
- 42:24anything. You're saying that, like church
- 42:26practice often detaches us from what is sacred and holy.
- 42:28That's what you said. And yet by nature of forcing us
- 42:33into a community that's sacred and holy to me and and.
- 42:39Right, like, so there is this weird balance between the two.
- 42:41I'm just wondering, yeah, your reaction or thoughts on that?
- 42:44No, I think that's truly true and I feel like.
- 42:48Stepping away has definitely left a void of that community
- 42:55that still feels really important and really wanted.
- 43:00And I think I think some people I like for my for my parents for
- 43:05instance, I I know that they have found kind of the support
- 43:10and friendships and such in different places and then the
- 43:13church. And so they don't feel they need
- 43:15the church for community. I think I've, I think I've heard
- 43:19other people say that too. There's certainly a lot of
- 43:24spiritual practices that can be done like solo that feel
- 43:28nourishing and good and at the same time, yes and a big yeah, I
- 43:37contemplate this and and when I look at different tradition,
- 43:41well, I mean just just the Christian tradition in general.
- 43:44It's like. The body of Christ is how the
- 43:47word of God continues, right? And I see that, and I love that,
- 43:54and I want that. And it's like, it's just, it's
- 44:02kind of been years of figuring out like, what does that mean?
- 44:05And to me, just because a church is Christian doesn't necessarily
- 44:12mean it. You know, follows certain values
- 44:18or is actually a community that's like open to people.
- 44:23Yeah. And and it comes back to kind of
- 44:25that assignment that your professor gave you too, is that
- 44:28Christianity in a lot of spaces and places has become a a, an
- 44:33institution that insists on belief.
- 44:35And yeah, that, that, that that's really jarring from what
- 44:40we actually read in the scriptures about, you know,
- 44:43practice and the way you live your life as being important.
- 44:47And in the same I don't want to doubt.
- 44:49Like, there is something powerful about belief too, in
- 44:51its own sense, just not in the way that we often articulated, I
- 44:56think, because I think there's something very important for me
- 45:00about believing in like the the love and presence of God despite
- 45:06what I do, You know, like that. That's the kind of the flip side
- 45:09of it, too. Like you can these are pendulums
- 45:11and you can go way too far to one side or the other.
- 45:14Yeah, yeah, totally so. I.
- 45:16But you you have to get to it. And I know, like, I know we're
- 45:19on time crunch too, because you have somewhere else to be.
- 45:22But I really want you to share too about the what spirituality
- 45:26looks like for you today. And I've been sure people are
- 45:28already getting a sense of that, of caring for your neighbors,
- 45:30living off the earth, really connecting with the God, the
- 45:35creator in a lot of really specific ways, I would say.
- 45:39But also you have like a really interesting kind of postscript
- 45:43to this whole story. So go ahead.
- 45:45Yeah, so. So I'm gonna follow up quickly
- 45:47with like the vocational piece a little bit though there was that
- 45:51thread like through high school and College of like church
- 45:54leadership, vocation, something connected to ministry.
- 46:00And I feel like I finally connected those pieces like in
- 46:04the last two years where. I started doing counseling for
- 46:08people in. The therapy model is internal
- 46:13family systems, which is. Inherently spiritual.
- 46:18I mean, you can absolutely do it with no spiritual, you know,
- 46:23underpinning if you don't want to.
- 46:25But for me it is it. It just very easily fits into
- 46:34just spirit. Like the divinity that is within
- 46:38us and and from outside of us. For the goodness of like
- 46:42healing? Really cool.
- 46:44So I started doing that. And when I started doing that, I
- 46:46was just like, oh, this is it. Like, this is the piece.
- 46:51Like where, no, I didn't ever want to be a pastor, but I do
- 46:56want to do this. Like, I love being in a space
- 47:01with people, and I'm honored to be in that space with people.
- 47:04Who trust me enough to share and be vulnerable and explore and
- 47:09ultimately come to places themselves from their own, their
- 47:13own awareness and system for healing.
- 47:17So anyway, that's what I do now, you know, as well as farming and
- 47:23homeschooling and all that other stuff that's really beautiful.
- 47:26No, I love that and and bringing people to to wholeness through
- 47:29that process, right. I'm a big proponent of therapy
- 47:34and counseling in a number of different settings.
- 47:36I've Steve and I both feel like we are ministering in the ways
- 47:41that we're serving people and and focusing on healing, being
- 47:49part of that journey for people. But yeah, so my spiritual path
- 47:57now. I I mean, I've always, yeah.
- 48:00So I've always wanted that spiritual community in some
- 48:03form. And there were definitely things
- 48:05that kept me from it at different points in my in my
- 48:09life. One being this just for like,
- 48:15frustration with the patriarchal nature of the church.
- 48:21And and and and again, it's like, of course when when we
- 48:24talk, when we really talk about it.
- 48:26Of course nobody would say God has a gender.
- 48:29But the way that we really relate is very, you know, Father
- 48:34man in the sky kind of thing. And so I began exploring and
- 48:42getting more connected to Mary because I knew that that was a
- 48:48part of church tradition as well.
- 48:52And so just through my own like reading and exploration and
- 48:56learning I. I was really interested in
- 48:59connecting with this figure and symbol for like this divine
- 49:03feminine more, you know, I mean obviously the whole like
- 49:09spiritual principle, the universe like has mask and
- 49:13feminine quality but I feel like Mary was this thing I could
- 49:16relate to more to experience the feminine anyway so and then in
- 49:24in continuing to look for community this past winter.
- 49:29I have tried different churches in the area at different times
- 49:31and have mostly felt uncomfortable or just like not
- 49:37really able to be who I am or or definitely knowing that I won't
- 49:41be allowed like in the club because I didn't believe the
- 49:43right thing. And so this past winter I was
- 49:47like, you know what, I'm just gonna like try the Catholic
- 49:49Church because I haven't been there yet.
- 49:52And again, I live in Maine, so like the number of churches
- 49:54available is is few. And most are the, like, average
- 50:00age is like 60 to 80. Yep.
- 50:03So, like, there's a beautiful Episcopal Church in our
- 50:05community that is lovely. But, like, I'm the youngest
- 50:09person there by like 30 years. Yeah.
- 50:12So I was like, that's not going to work for my for, like, my
- 50:14family. So I this past winter, I was
- 50:18like, you know what? I haven't tried the Catholic
- 50:19Church yet. I was kind of drawn to it, just
- 50:21knowing that Mary is some presence there.
- 50:25And was interested to you know explore that And I I went in
- 50:33like went in the doors and immediately just like relaxed
- 50:39and felt it just felt really good to be there And it was a
- 50:46small community. There were like people of all
- 50:48ages. There were like many families
- 50:50which blew my mind and. Yeah, it's just a very simple
- 50:56church, like you know, three churches share 2 priests and and
- 51:06you know people well. And volunteers quick.
- 51:08You know, it's very small, but you you were talking about this
- 51:12to me yesterday too. And one of the things that you
- 51:13said too is just how you also have really loved the way that
- 51:17the Catholic Church, just that the priest isn't really that
- 51:23important in a lot of ways, too. It's like the everyone is there
- 51:27for the Eucharist, really. Like the Eucharist is the
- 51:30central point of it, of like Jesus's body and blood, the
- 51:34presence of Jesus in this space and in this place.
- 51:37And that's what people really care about, which is really
- 51:41beautiful in a lot of ways, too, of just, yeah, like it's about
- 51:44the divine, not entertainment. For sure, Yeah, there's nothing
- 51:50entertaining there. But I love that.
- 51:53I love that it's simple. I mean, I mean, again, this is
- 51:56for me who is someone who came from a liturgical background.
- 52:00So it feels, you know, it's easy for me to fall into.
- 52:04I know most of the words already by heart.
- 52:08I also just love. There's like an awe inspiring
- 52:13piece of it to me that I love that reminds me of like being in
- 52:18the Middle East. Where we would go to like a
- 52:21Coptic Orthodox Church or or an Anglican or like Catholic Church
- 52:27in the Middle East. And just there's something that
- 52:31is I I love how there's this connection around the globe.
- 52:35Yeah, of these places. And I know that part like that's
- 52:40mainly due to like colonization and you know lots of ugly church
- 52:44history. And amidst that, there's.
- 52:50There's still to me, just like all of the like sacred and how
- 52:55people hold that around the world.
- 52:56And I think that's what I think. Those are the two things that
- 52:58kind of brought me there were the desire for community and the
- 53:08desire for some place to be sacred.
- 53:13I I mean, I I think. Sorry, yeah, no, that makes a.
- 53:17Lot of sense that's sacred. There's a lot of that's sacred
- 53:19everywhere, but not much that our society holds sacred.
- 53:22Yeah. And there is, there is something
- 53:24important about a place that's set apart and a time that's set
- 53:28apart, right, for coming in touch with that, remembering
- 53:33that aspect of your being and that aspect of reality.
- 53:36And I do think that that's what church is ultimately trying to
- 53:39provide for people. It's just these these touch
- 53:41points of remembering God's presence in your life and in
- 53:45your world and the promises that God has made to the creation.
- 53:50Yeah, that's really beautiful. Just really, really wild.
- 53:53It's. Also not, it's also not lost on
- 53:55me that like, I feel like the Catholic Church is like one of
- 53:58those patriarchal churches out there.
- 53:59So, you know, so it's funny and and yet there's whatever.
- 54:06There's so much that is. There's so much.
- 54:11To me that gets, that gets acknowledged by just having like
- 54:17the presence of Mary there. It's really helpful to me.
- 54:20And yeah, there's just, there's a lot there coming from where
- 54:26having left and coming back in. In this regard, I feel like I'm
- 54:32coming to it on my own terms. And so I can bring everything
- 54:37that I've, like, gained from being out of the church, like
- 54:39the freedom I've had to open my mind.
- 54:41And experience different things without, like shame.
- 54:46I'm able to like, bring that back into this setting and have
- 54:50it be really meaningful. And there's enough space there
- 54:55because people really aren't, you know, shoving beliefs down
- 55:00my throat. Or like, there's just enough
- 55:03space where I can be and like be with that.
- 55:05And that feels good for me. I'm not sure if it's always
- 55:07going to be like that. I've been there for like 6
- 55:08months but. But you know, like maybe next
- 55:12year, this time I won't be there.
- 55:13I don't know because I because I I also feel like, you know,
- 55:21yeah, there's just, there's freedom.
- 55:23There's freedom from you to keep to keep trying and keep
- 55:25experimenting with what that looks like.
- 55:30So yeah, I love that. While you continue to live out
- 55:33your faith in very tangible ways, separate from that entire
- 55:38investigative error, right? Yeah.
- 55:40And I think, I think a shift to, as I've reflected on it is I'm
- 55:46not expecting me going, I'm not expecting a church to be
- 55:50everything for me. You know, it's like I value the
- 55:55space as the sacred space that it is.
- 55:58And that's really all I all I need it to be.
- 56:00I don't, I don't need to receive some amazing message to feel
- 56:04better about myself. I don't need.
- 56:09There's just like I'm I'm getting other needs met, even
- 56:12spiritually in different places too.
- 56:14Yeah. So it doesn't need to be
- 56:16perfect. I guess that's a great way to
- 56:20wrap it up. Courtney, thank you so much for
- 56:23just sharing all of this with us and for your continue.
- 56:27You're such a genuine person who thinks so deeply about so many
- 56:30things. And you're always.
- 56:32Yeah, I just an incredible humility about yourself too.
- 56:36And I just really appreciate all that you shared here.
- 56:38Thanks for taking. Yeah.
- 56:40Thanks so much, Nate. Alright, and you, dear listener,
- 56:43thanks for listening. Stay in peace, everyone.