Latest / Film And Whiskey / Fight Club (1999) / Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1999, director David Fincher and star Edward Norton gave the
- 0:04world a fatalistic gut punch that still holds power.
- 0:09In 2026, we try a whiskey that hopefully doesn't make us run
- 0:15headlong into traffic. The.
- 0:18Film is Fight Club. Brad seriously, so many people
- 0:22run into traffic in this movie it's kind of insane.
- 0:25It's Whiskey is 4 Roses Small Batch.
- 0:28And we'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:32podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:53podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:56glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:59I am Bob's fat and saggy tits. Yeah, yeah, you are.
- 1:04And Brad, this week is the reason this podcast was created.
- 1:09Episodes like this, because, you know, I come on here every week,
- 1:13I give my spiel. I say we're reviewing a classic
- 1:15movie. Let's be honest, nobody needs
- 1:18Bob and Brad to review movies that have already been
- 1:20established as classics. Sure, but every now and then we
- 1:25get takes so spicy, so muy. Caliente, Brad.
- 1:32You know I don't speak Spanish. We single handedly revive the
- 1:36conversations around these movies, Brad.
- 1:38And I'm going to continue to add my spicy takes to the the pile,
- 1:43to the the burning heap of a film that we're talking about
- 1:47today, Brad, because we're looking.
- 1:48At 19. 99's Fight Club, a movie that if you ever listened to our
- 1:53first episode on you know I notoriously, it's a.
- 1:57Real eternal sunshine. Am I right it?
- 2:00Really is man, the the eternal sunshine in question is the
- 2:04hatred that burns within my heart towards this film.
- 2:08Man, I can't wait to talk about this with you.
- 2:10So folks, listen, usually we don't come on here and just crap
- 2:13all over movies. And in fact, especially when
- 2:15Brad and I have a difference of opinion, at least I try to kind
- 2:18of tamper down when I'm lower on a movie than Brad is.
- 2:22Brad just forges ahead, does not care about my feelings at all.
- 2:26This is one of those times where like.
- 2:28We're on the Internet, what's the point of just being tampered
- 2:32down, holding it back? Just let it all out, man.
- 2:35Dude, just today I was, I shared a real from our Pulp Fiction
- 2:39episode and it was like, it was a clip of me talking about how I
- 2:44think Tarantino's best movies are the ones where he's kind of
- 2:47a big softie and he has empathy for his characters.
- 2:49And I listed a few examples of the movies that I really like by
- 2:53Tarantino and then a few examples of the movies that I
- 2:55don't think do that well. And like the first comment was
- 2:59some dude being like, you didn't even list Jackie Brown, which is
- 3:04the best example of what you're arguing for.
- 3:06And therefore this is a bad take.
- 3:09And I'm just like, you're right, guy on Internet.
- 3:12Like, I'm sorry that I didn't list every movie Tarantino's
- 3:15made in this clip and then categorize them for you.
- 3:19I I apologize that I only gave you the framework for that, you
- 3:22know. Yeah, but but that's the best
- 3:24example, Bob. So you clearly don't know what
- 3:26you're talking. About and you didn't list it now
- 3:29what I'm really excited for is the the takes and the clips that
- 3:32are going to come out of this episode.
- 3:33Like I said, I try not to crap on movies a lot, but I know that
- 3:36this is a movie that Brad likes quite a bit and thinks is a very
- 3:39good movie, but it's not like near and dear to his cell heart.
- 3:43You know, like. I, I wasn't watching this when I
- 3:45was like, hey, the, the nostalgia's not there, you know?
- 3:49Not quite the family Christmas tradition that it was in.
- 3:52Apparently some other people's I mean houses.
- 3:54Well, we were talking about Pulp Fiction.
- 3:55You said you saw that when you were like 12.
- 3:58Yeah, probably 13. I was like a freshman maybe.
- 4:01Bob, that's not good. That's not good for the soul,
- 4:04no. It's the perfect time to see
- 4:06Pulp Fiction. Just seeing big names.
- 4:09Folks, if this is your first time joining us on film and
- 4:11Whiskey, we talk about movies, we talk about whiskey.
- 4:14This season, we are going back to the movies that we reviewed
- 4:17back in Season 1. This is season #10 of the show.
- 4:20We've been doing this for almost 7 years now, releasing episodes
- 4:23every single week. And you know, you go back to
- 4:26season #1 and you realize we've come a long way since then.
- 4:30And I thought it would be fun to spend our 10th season revisiting
- 4:33and kind of replacing those those old episodes with the
- 4:37older, wiser versions of ourselves.
- 4:39Brad. And so I do.
- 4:41Dragged my feet going back to this movie.
- 4:44I think is is the point I'll make here.
- 4:46Please go ahead. I was just saying I do have a
- 4:48lot more Gray hair than when we started so.
- 4:51And you used to have no hair. So yeah, that's we've come a
- 4:55long way. As I said, Brad, both signs of
- 4:57wisdom. We were going to record this
- 4:59episode at the end of November 2025.
- 5:03And it. Is I dragged my feet.
- 5:05I dragged my feet about watching it and then we had other
- 5:09episodes to record. Brad, it's been over a month
- 5:12since you watched this movie. I assume you did some level of
- 5:15refreshing yourself via YouTube clips.
- 5:18Nothing really. I I wanted to and then it was
- 5:22time to record and I was like, well.
- 5:25Here we are. We're flying blind today, folks.
- 5:26Yeah, which is going to make for a really fun episode.
- 5:31And I guess let's just go ahead and kick off the fun now with
- 5:33our first segment of the day, which we call Brad explains.
- 5:37Brad's going to give us the movie plot with only 60 seconds
- 5:41taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with this
- 5:44little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 5:47Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 5:50plot of the film that he's just seen often for the first time.
- 5:53Now Brad, this is AI want to use the word notorious again?
- 5:58But a famous example of the twist ending and one of the
- 6:03earliest examples of a true twist ending in movies.
- 6:07One that reframed the whole film.
- 6:10One that inspired countless RE watches back when you can only
- 6:13get a movie like this on VHS or an early DVD copy.
- 6:17And so this movie's popularity really took off in the early
- 6:212000s in dorm rooms across America.
- 6:24This is like one of the movies that if you're an 18 year old
- 6:27man coming into manhood. Wow.
- 6:31This is this is what movies are supposed to be.
- 6:34This is why you need to watch this on YouTube.
- 6:35Then you get to see the the quotation marks that Bob puts in
- 6:39when he says the word man. Yeah, You know, I mean, listen,
- 6:42this is all, this is a movie all about manhood, Brad, and it
- 6:45appeals to 18 year olds. And I think that there's a
- 6:47reason for that. But I say all that to say, we
- 6:51do. Brad explains, and Brad gets a
- 6:53chance to tell you everything that happens in this movie.
- 6:56So they're going to be spoilers galore throughout this review or
- 7:00this synopsis of Fight Club. Brad, you have 60.
- 7:05Brad, you have 60 seconds to explain the plot of this movie,
- 7:09which I will say, and we'll get to this two hours and 20 minutes
- 7:13long. It's a little bit too long.
- 7:16It's a long. It's a long movie, Yeah.
- 7:18And you only get one minute to break it down.
- 7:20The floor is yours, Sir. 60 seconds and go.
- 7:24Fight Club is a film that follows the narrator does not
- 7:27have a name in the film who is a run-of-the-mill just trying to
- 7:34find his way through life. Single guy in his 30s that works
- 7:39as a insurance adjuster. I don't know.
- 7:44He goes and checks things out, but as he travels across the
- 7:47country a lot, he develops insomnia and this insomnia leads
- 7:51him to go to support groups in order to fake like he has these
- 7:57bad things. And as he cries with these
- 7:59people, it gives him release and he's a lot of sleep.
- 8:02He meets another faker named Marla Singer and she kind of
- 8:06ruins things for him and he goes back to not sleeping.
- 8:08Eventually he meets a man on his travels named Brad Pitt, and
- 8:12Brad Pitt teaches him all sorts of stuff about fighting for the
- 8:17life and like capitalism is bad and and all these things.
- 8:22And so he starts a cult and he's going to blow up a bunch of
- 8:24credit card companies. And then it turns out that Brad
- 8:29Pitt was not real the whole time.
- 8:31He was a ghost, just like The Sixth Sense.
- 8:33He. Was not a ghost.
- 8:35Let's know. Listen, I know this is your
- 8:38segment, but let's pump the brakes here a little.
- 8:40Bit Edward Norton was dead the whole time.
- 8:44Man, I do think that there's a million directions we can go
- 8:48based on Brad Can. I tell one quick story in my
- 8:51research for two facts in a falsehood, apparently Rosie
- 8:55O'Donnell. Do you know a story about her
- 8:57and Fight Club? So Rosie O'Donnell started.
- 9:03I'm not going to go there like 3 or 4 days before the movie came
- 9:09out. She had seen an advance
- 9:10screening on like Monday. It's coming out on Friday and
- 9:13I'm like Wednesday on the View or whatever show she was on back
- 9:17in the 90s goes on and tells her audience across the whole
- 9:21country. This movie like terrorized me.
- 9:25I can't sleep at night and it's because Brad Pitt isn't real the
- 9:31whole movie. He's a figment of Edward
- 9:33Norton's imagination and you shouldn't go see it.
- 9:37It's a terrible movie 2 days before it came out.
- 9:41Well, first of all, don't do that.
- 9:44But also, like anytime, anytime a figure goes on TV and says
- 9:48like this is filth, you should never see it, guess what movie
- 9:51is going to be #1 that weekend, What are you doing?
- 9:56The the Streisand effect. 100% dude.
- 10:00All right, let's jump into talking about the movie.
- 10:02You mentioned The 6th Sense. I think that's a good comparison
- 10:04point. And there I, I think part of the
- 10:07way I want to talk about this movie is by comparing it to a
- 10:09lot of other movies 'cause that kind of helps me understand
- 10:12personally where it succeeds and where it doesn't.
- 10:15Cause I've seen some of this stuff done better elsewhere.
- 10:18And some of that comes down to like maybe Fight Club was the
- 10:21first to do it and we've just gotten better at it since then,
- 10:23you know? But The Sixth Sense, the other
- 10:27big twist ending movie of 1999, unless you really want to count
- 10:30The Blair Witch Project, which we don't really know what
- 10:32happens at the end of that movie, but I've.
- 10:34Never. I've never seen The Blair Witch
- 10:35Project. Oh man, you'd have.
- 10:37Fun. That was like the first shaky
- 10:39Cam movie, right? Yep.
- 10:41Yeah. All right, man, let's dive in.
- 10:44Where do you think we should start with Fight Club?
- 10:47I think man, Fight Club has so many, just so much going on.
- 10:53I, I think let's just stick with the formula, Bob.
- 10:56Let's start with performances. That's where we like to start.
- 10:59We like to talk about the actors, actresses.
- 11:02Can we talk about the fact that I think Helena Bonham Carter is
- 11:06the best actress of the last like 50 years?
- 11:12I see, I don't disagree with you in that she's a great actress,
- 11:15but like she for a long time she only either did like Jane Austen
- 11:21adaptations or she was Bellatrix Lestrange.
- 11:25Like those are the 2. And I think part of that comes
- 11:27from being married to Tim Burton for as long as she was, which is
- 11:29just if you look at pictures of Tim Burton, they like clearly
- 11:33modeled some of Helena Bonham Carter's characters after Tim
- 11:36Burton's look. Like she has the the Bob Dylan
- 11:40weird bird's nest haircut and all that.
- 11:42Like it's very weird. But I don't like her as much
- 11:46here as I do in Harry Potter. And I think that's because she
- 11:49leans into the hamminess a lot more in Harry Potter.
- 11:53And I think that you can hear her accent slipping through the
- 11:57American accent a lot in this movie.
- 12:00And, and so like, it's, it's a performance worth talking about.
- 12:04It's also kind of a nothing character.
- 12:07Even though she's like this, she's this presented as this
- 12:10live wire kind of girl. She essentially only exists for
- 12:15the plot to keep her at arm's length because of the twist at
- 12:19the end of the movie. If Edward Norton even remotely
- 12:23mentions the word Tyler to her any earlier in the course of the
- 12:27movie, the whole thing falls apart.
- 12:29So that their entire relationship has to exist on the
- 12:32basis of miscommunication and, and just involves her getting
- 12:35mad and storming out and you being as an audience member,
- 12:38like, I don't understand what's going on here, you know?
- 12:42And so I think it affects her the most because of that.
- 12:46I see for me, though, that that's what gives the end of the
- 12:49movie like the punch when she finally is like, like really
- 12:53brought into the whole picture. I think her reaction at the very
- 12:57end of things is just so, so good because you you've only
- 13:02seen her being the angry person. And when she finally, when you
- 13:07finally get to see her care about Edward Norton and be like,
- 13:10oh, yeah, no, I I care about you.
- 13:12That's why we're still in this weird relationship and I keep
- 13:15coming back. That's the moment for me that
- 13:18her character like clicks. Even though you're right, you
- 13:21you don't barely get to see her through the whole movie.
- 13:26Yeah, yeah, I'm with you. So The funny thing about this
- 13:29movie is, like, the cast of characters is enormous, but
- 13:33there's really only like, there's such a separation
- 13:35between the top three people and then maybe Meatloaf and Jared
- 13:39Leto and then everybody else. And so like, we've hit Helena
- 13:43Bonham Carter, and it's like, all right, I guess it's on to
- 13:45Brad Norton. Brad Norton.
- 13:47Brad who? Brad Norton.
- 13:49Brad Norton. Who's who's Jared Leto's in
- 13:52this? Yeah, he's the blonde guy that
- 13:55Edward Norton beats. Really.
- 13:57Why didn't anybody do that in real life?
- 14:00I was going to say really living out the wish fulfillment of most
- 14:03people of just like man, wouldn't it be nice, you know?
- 14:09100% dude, I had no idea that that was Jared Leto.
- 14:13I until this moment didn't know I'd seen a Jared Leto film.
- 14:17This is the first. You know, and, and credit to
- 14:20Jared Leto for leaning into the fact that he he is one of the
- 14:24more punchable people in Hollywood.
- 14:28Yeah, because the year after this, he's an American Psycho
- 14:31and he plays a an even bigger douche in that movie who gets
- 14:36like, killed with an axe. So it's like, you know, he he
- 14:40he's understood the assignment, kind of, Yeah.
- 14:42I. I appreciate that American
- 14:44Psycho's been on that list where I like, I feel like it's a, it's
- 14:46a very popular YouTube short movie that like you get clips
- 14:50'cause they talks about like, I don't know the world that he
- 14:53lives in. And then it shows him, like,
- 14:56killing people and you're like, OK, cool, YouTube.
- 15:00I'll have to get around to watching Jared Leto get punched
- 15:03in that movie. That sounds great.
- 15:04Yeah. So American Psycho is another
- 15:06one of those movies that I have on my list of like comparison
- 15:09points because so there's 5 or 6 movies in a one year span from
- 15:1499 to 2000 that deal with this sort of like corporate white
- 15:18collar, white male dissatisfaction.
- 15:22And we've watched quite a few of them for this podcast.
- 15:24So obviously Fight Club, American Psycho, American Beauty
- 15:29is right there. That's 99 Office Space for a
- 15:32more comedic take on it. We have to watch Office Space
- 15:36soon. I think it's one of the best
- 15:37comedies ever written. We'll get around to it for sure.
- 15:40It's a great one. And then you've got The Matrix
- 15:43and you've got Being John Malkovich as kind of like an
- 15:45outlier, not white collar, but more of just like weird
- 15:48dissatisfaction stuff. And I think American Psycho for
- 15:52me is a good comparison point because it also doesn't quite
- 15:55nail what it's going for. It really wants to be a satire.
- 15:59And for the people that it works for, it works really well.
- 16:03I can never get on that movie's wavelength.
- 16:05And I feel like that's kind of where I'm at with Fight Club
- 16:08even still after this viewing. And I think that that's that's a
- 16:12good framework then to go into talking about our two main
- 16:15performances from Brad Pitt and Edward Norton.
- 16:18And I think we should have the longer conversation about Edward
- 16:22Norton because he he was, I don't want to say top of the
- 16:26world at this point, but he really bursts on the scene in 96
- 16:30in this movie, Primal Fear, which is also a twist ending
- 16:33movie. He gets nominated for an Oscar
- 16:35for that movie and then not. Only have I ever seen primal
- 16:39fear. I've never heard of Primal Fear.
- 16:41So you've heard of it today, baby.
- 16:42That's right. After Primal Fear, he starts
- 16:45doing like he gets nominated again in 98 for American History
- 16:49X. That movie is another like very
- 16:51controversial film. He's doing rounders with Matt
- 16:54Damon. He's trying to do like more
- 16:55Hollywood commercial stuff. And then he lands this movie and
- 16:59by the end of the decade, he's really established himself as
- 17:01like, oh, this is maybe the next guy.
- 17:04And I feel like he built a bit of a reputation in the 2000s for
- 17:08being an A hole and Hollywood didn't use him as much.
- 17:11And he's kicked around quite a bit.
- 17:13But man, I just I wish we had gotten more Ed Norton over the
- 17:17last 15 ish years because he is such a good actor and I think
- 17:24that because the Brad Pitt stuff in this movie is the iconic
- 17:28imagery of the movie, people forget how good Ed Norton is in
- 17:34this movie. He is like unbelievably good in
- 17:37this movie. Dude, for me, it's the reason I
- 17:39keep wanting to come back to this film.
- 17:41I I think Edward Norton has he's captured that sense of on we
- 17:49about the American corporate life in a way that I don't think
- 17:53other movies do. Like Kevin Spacey has too much
- 17:56snarkiness to believe that he's like really just depressed and
- 18:01like, I don't know, rundown by the American corporate world.
- 18:06Whereas Edward Norton, I mean the the famous like shot of him
- 18:09at the copier and like the copier light is going across.
- 18:11His face. And he's just like, you know,
- 18:14like there, it's perfect. He he does such a good job with
- 18:18it. Yeah, And I think that he's able
- 18:21to kind of move between modes of like, likeability as well, like,
- 18:27because I think that the beginning part of this movie is,
- 18:31is like insufferable. And I'll, I'll get around to
- 18:34this eventually. I, I just, because I'm not sure
- 18:37as an audience member yet whether this really is like my
- 18:39protagonist. And he just sounds like a whiny
- 18:42little punk who's, like, mad about having this privileged
- 18:45life. It's like, oh, F this guy.
- 18:48Now, he captures that sort of, like, ennui and morose thing
- 18:52very well, but he's also, like, just punchable enough.
- 18:56And so then when he meets Brad Pitt and he actually gets
- 18:58punched, you're like, yeah. But then he also is like, he can
- 19:02be sweet and he can be likeable. And then he takes his shirt off
- 19:06and you realize, like, he's not quite as jacked as Brad Pitt,
- 19:09but this dude's in very good shape.
- 19:10And like I, I think that he could fit into so many different
- 19:14molds. And I guess the only thing I can
- 19:17really think to compare it to is a couple years later when we get
- 19:21Tobey Maguire as spider man and he's trying to do kind of like I
- 19:25can. I can be a sarcastic a hole to
- 19:27Uncle Ben. I'm also really sweet.
- 19:29I am also kind of jacked. But Tobey Maguire always felt
- 19:33more boyish. And I feel like Edward Norton
- 19:35had that sense of like, I'm a grown up and I can be kind of a
- 19:39Dick. And, and it worked for whether
- 19:42he wanted to be a hero or a villain, he brought that, that
- 19:45layer of nuance to it. And it works because Brad Pit is
- 19:49opposite of him. Like he has just enough of AI
- 19:57don't mean this word in a bad way at all.
- 19:58Just it's the way he presents it.
- 20:00He has just enough of a feminized kind of like he just
- 20:06like kind of is reserved. That.
- 20:08Brad Pitt. Edward Norton is yes.
- 20:11Edward Norton OK, OK, that Brad Pitt being this like hyper
- 20:14masculine, like argumentative, just points out your flaws.
- 20:22It just makes for such a great contrast to watch Edward Norton
- 20:26change throughout the movie. And by the end of the film, when
- 20:29he's trapped in this cult of his own creation, you feel him
- 20:35finally starting to wake up and fight in the way that Tyler has
- 20:39always wanted him to wake up and fight, even if it's fighting
- 20:42against his own creation. I I think it's such a good
- 20:45transformation throughout the course of the film.
- 20:48Yeah. And I think it makes the last
- 20:50half hour of this movie by far the best part of the film.
- 20:53Like, yeah, from from the time even before the reveal that he
- 20:56is Tyler, when he like, gets on the plane and starts kind of
- 20:59trying to reach race Tyler's footsteps, it becomes such a
- 21:04much more interesting movie plot wise.
- 21:06Because before that, it's this weird effed up domestic drama
- 21:10where he's in a house with these two other people, but none of
- 21:13them are ever in the same room together.
- 21:15And it's not really going anywhere.
- 21:17And it really tests your patience for not just like,
- 21:20what's the plot of this movie, but also like, what are we
- 21:23trying to communicate here? Like, what's, you know what I
- 21:26mean? Like what's this about?
- 21:28And I think that part of the reason that it really is buoyed
- 21:31at the end of the film is because Edward Norton so good at
- 21:34playing like desperate, like I, I really have a, a sense of
- 21:38conscious now. I want to stop this thing from
- 21:40happening. I'm out of breath.
- 21:42I'm running around like he plays that, that sort of like frantic,
- 21:46nervous energy really, really well.
- 21:48Yeah, and they also do. I think this gets to more the
- 21:51writing, but it's it almost becomes a little bit of like a
- 21:55horror thriller at the end of the movie when he's he's in the
- 22:00detective's office and he's confessing everything and the
- 22:02detective is like, all right, I'm going to go take care of
- 22:04things. And the moment one of the guys
- 22:07in the room goes, I think it's honorable what you're doing,
- 22:10Sir. And and you realize that they're
- 22:13in Project Mayhem. Yep.
- 22:15It it feel you feel trapped the way Edward Norton is trapped.
- 22:21And you have no doubt that they are about to do what they are
- 22:23threatening to do that like the whole movie, like builds to that
- 22:29point. And it's like a fuse is about to
- 22:31hit the bomb. And I, I think it's just such
- 22:33great, great writing. All right, let's talk about Brad
- 22:37Pitt a little bit. Brad Pitt is such an interesting
- 22:40actor to talk about because he is like, and I think I've
- 22:43mentioned this before, he he's such a weird actor.
- 22:48Like every time you think of how like an actor would deliver this
- 22:52line, Brad Pitt chooses the complete opposite of that all
- 22:56the time. And it's not the same thing as
- 22:58like, I think Nicolas Cage also chooses the opposite of what a
- 23:01normal actor would do. But it's not, it's not that.
- 23:04But like Pitt Mumbles a lot. Pitt kind of mashes words up
- 23:08together and says his lines too quickly sometimes.
- 23:11But because he's so magnetic and so good looking and so
- 23:15physically intimidating in this movie, you're like, OK, spout
- 23:20your dumb philosophy. Like I I'll listen to whatever
- 23:24you have to say in whatever weird mumbly voice you want to
- 23:27say it. I don't.
- 23:29I don't know what to make of the performance, Brad.
- 23:31Like, it's just he is. He is there to be Brad Pitt.
- 23:35And him being in this movie is a commentary by Brad Pitt on being
- 23:40Brad Pitt to the point where, like at the end of the film,
- 23:42he's just like, hey, Adam Thornton, I'm who you want to
- 23:46be. I'm better looking than you.
- 23:47I screw better than you. I'm in better shape than you.
- 23:50I am every man's dream and for for Brad Pitt to kind of lean
- 23:55into that and also like lean into the effed upness of that.
- 24:01I think is is more interesting in a lot of ways than the actual
- 24:04performance on the screen. That's that's really
- 24:08interesting. What What do you think it is
- 24:10about Brad point in this point of his career that makes this
- 24:14such a big capital C choice for him?
- 24:18Well, I mean, like, so you know, he works with Fincher in 95 on 7
- 24:22and he was a big name already, obviously, like and he had done
- 24:25legends of the fall, but he was still like this very pretty kind
- 24:28of like, sure, this you know, I'm women are crushing on him,
- 24:32right? And then 7 happens and it's
- 24:34like, Oh, this guy really wants to be edgier.
- 24:37And it reminds me a lot of like when DiCaprio does the departed
- 24:40and it's like, Oh, this is a different kind of DiCaprio and
- 24:43his choices over the next few years are like, am I this pretty
- 24:47tabloid guy? Am I going to start dating
- 24:50actresses from friends? Am I gonna be in movies like 7
- 24:54Years in Tibet, which is actually like on the Billboard
- 24:56of one of in the background of one of the scenes in this movie?
- 25:00Really. So like, yeah.
- 25:02Or am I gonna take all that image that I've built up for
- 25:05myself and kind of turn it on its head and critique the
- 25:09consumerism that, like, my own stardom feeds into?
- 25:15And I think that that's really, I mean, it really is a
- 25:17commentary on his own stardom. And at the end of the day, it
- 25:21just made him more popular and more consumer friendly for being
- 25:26a sexy masculine Brad Pitt kind of guy.
- 25:31I want to hear your thoughts though, like what do you
- 25:32actually think of the performance?
- 25:34Especially because season 1 and now season 10 have been very
- 25:38Brad Pitt heavy. So I think we have a better
- 25:42sense of like, you know, like we and just in the past couple
- 25:44years we've done Moneyball, we've done Tree of Life, we've
- 25:46done this movie. I'm sure there's two or three
- 25:48others Inglourious Basterds we had just had this season, you
- 25:52know, and that's Pitt 10-15 years removed from this movie.
- 25:56So a more mature actor I think too.
- 25:59Where do you land on him performance wise in Fight Club?
- 26:03I mean, it's Pitt at his most unrestrained from what we've
- 26:07seen him. Like when I think about Pit and
- 26:10Tree of Life and Moneyball, he is a very, he plays very
- 26:15restrained characters, right? And obviously Tree of Life is
- 26:18him with bouts of exploding because he has his anger.
- 26:21But for the most part, he's a 1950s dad that made it through
- 26:25World War 2. And when you see him in Fight
- 26:29Club, compared to those and even Inglorious Basterds, like, yeah,
- 26:32he's a little bit unhinged, but he's like the control point for
- 26:36all of these really unhinged soldiers, right?
- 26:40I think when you have him in Fight Club, you have him fully
- 26:44let loose, unhinged, like psychotic.
- 26:49And I think it's a fascinating performance because of that,
- 26:51because we don't really see him do that in other movies.
- 26:54Now, I haven't seen a lot of early Brad Pitt, so I don't know
- 26:58if this is like more normal for him in the 90s.
- 27:01But to see him going absolutely ham and yelling at people and
- 27:08screaming and making sex note like recordings of sex sounds to
- 27:13be played with Helena Bonham Carter, like this is him going
- 27:17full out. What?
- 27:18What would it be like if I chewed not just the scenery, but
- 27:22the lighting and the sound and everything that I possibly can
- 27:26chew? Yeah.
- 27:28And I freaking love it, dude. I like I think that yes, Edward
- 27:32Norton is the key to this movie, but I think Brad Pitt's the
- 27:36linchpin, like his psychotic energy is what draws you in, is
- 27:41what keeps it from being boring. So I'm with you.
- 27:43Like the whole purpose of Edward Norton is to say this is I like
- 27:49the word you used morose. He like he is just this like
- 27:52dead doldrums of life. And Brad Pitt is that driving
- 27:57energy that's supposed to shake him loose.
- 27:59And he, he nails that, absolutely nails it.
- 28:02Right. So this is only our third
- 28:04Fincher movie that we've talked about on the podcast.
- 28:07We did this, we've done we've done the social network and
- 28:10we've done Zodiac. So very different movies.
- 28:14Very much so yeah. And I think that like this one,
- 28:16definitely, I have huge issues with how long and how repetitive
- 28:21and how I just redundant a lot of this movie is.
- 28:25But it definitely in terms of like how many cuts and how many
- 28:29edits happen over the course of this movie.
- 28:31It is by far the most fast-paced editing wise.
- 28:35And I think this is the first time in Fincher's movie career
- 28:38where you see him start to get into some of these things where
- 28:41he's making montages. And it'll start with like
- 28:46they're filming ATV report and then they'll do like this quick
- 28:48whip pan around and you'll see the people on the couch watching
- 28:51the TV report or whatever. And he uses those kind of very
- 28:54precise camera movements from here on out in his career.
- 28:59You see it a ton in The Social Network, a little bit in Zodiac.
- 29:03Fincher's a weird dude, man. He, he loves to make movies
- 29:06about like the darkest impulses of humanity.
- 29:10He just seems like he, he loves to get grimy with stuff, but he
- 29:16also has like a really sick sense of humor.
- 29:18And Fincher's kind of right now, like, yeah, you know, persona,
- 29:23like persona non grata in a lot of places right now because he's
- 29:26like gotten in bed with Netflix and he's just kind of like
- 29:29making whatever Netflix wants him to do now, which gets me a
- 29:33lot of points in my like, I think David Fincher's kind of a
- 29:35hack hot take that I want to introduce someday.
- 29:39He's not a hack. He's technically brilliant.
- 29:42But I just, I struggle with Fincher because I don't know.
- 29:48I don't know how deep he goes, like as a person and as a film
- 29:51maker because so many of his movies seem to be geared towards
- 29:56like the shit you would find deep and the shit you would find
- 29:59sickly funny at 21 years old. And I don't really know how much
- 30:05we go beyond. Even when he tries to do that in
- 30:08like Benjamin Button and like I just, it doesn't feel authentic.
- 30:13You don't like Benjamin Button? It's OK, Yeah, Fight Club is
- 30:17Fight Club for to me is like the the apex of that too, where it's
- 30:21like, what do you have to offer me, man?
- 30:24Is this like, are you hinting at anything deeper than this or is
- 30:28this just you like having fun, bro.
- 30:30And out with Brad Pitt making a movie for 20 year olds, which is
- 30:35cool. But I also don't know that that
- 30:38puts you on like my pedestal of great film makers.
- 30:41Yeah, I, I mean, for me, this Fight Club never made me think
- 30:47of Venture as a top five, top 10 greatest directors of all time.
- 30:53Like it. It definitely feels like a movie
- 30:57that I, it depends on your reading.
- 30:59It's one of those movies. It's kind of like 500 Days of
- 31:01Summer. Like either 500 Days of Summer
- 31:04is written by somebody who understands that Joseph Gordon
- 31:08Levitt is not actually that mature and he's kind of the bad
- 31:12guy in the movie. Or it's written by somebody who
- 31:15is so immature that he doesn't realize that, and he's trying to
- 31:18make Summer the villain, but isn't because she's not the
- 31:22villain, right? Like it's one of those two
- 31:23things. And it feels the same here.
- 31:25Like, either David Fincher is like growing out and things,
- 31:30Project Mayhem is actually kind of cool, and the whole fighting
- 31:34is like, like, yeah, we need to fight to become real men.
- 31:38Or it's a guy who's making it as a commentary on that to say,
- 31:42hey, like, like this is what unrestrained unhealthy
- 31:49masculinity looks like when it is only reactive.
- 31:54And I like, I think for me, that's why I like this movie is
- 31:57because there is some nuance between those two positions.
- 32:01But at the end of the day, this this movie is not a promotion of
- 32:05what happens in the film. At least I don't I don't think
- 32:08it is. I agree with that.
- 32:10And I so I'm, I'm, I'm texting you at the midway point of this
- 32:13movie or not even midway. I'm like, I've been watching
- 32:16this for six hours now and it tells me it's an hour into it.
- 32:19Bob, you had a .5. What are you doing?
- 32:23It was a real slog, man, and until I got to that last half
- 32:27hour. And I have a lot of thoughts on
- 32:30how to unpack, you know, what the actual point of this movie
- 32:34is and people's response to it and whether people got the point
- 32:37of this movie and who that falls on.
- 32:40Is it the artist's responsibility to make sure the
- 32:43audience understands what they're going for or is it
- 32:46completely on the audience? And I think that that's, I mean,
- 32:48that's art, right? We can unpack that I think in
- 32:51the second-half of the episode, because you mentioned 500 Days
- 32:55of Summer, a movie that we just talked about.
- 32:58And that I actually think might be the best lens through which
- 33:02to compare to this movie. So Brad, if it's OK with you,
- 33:05let's hit pause here. Let's go drink some whiskey so
- 33:08that we can get ourselves ready and fueled up to talk about
- 33:12Fight Club some more in the second-half.
- 33:14What do you say, dude? I'm ready.
- 33:15Let's do it all. Right.
- 33:22So today we are checking out Four Roses small batch.
- 33:27Now Brad, I feel like it's been, first of all, it's been a minute
- 33:29since we've tried some 4 Roses. I think we had some high quality
- 33:33well aged ones from our friend Zach Johnston a while back, but
- 33:38it's nice to kind of return to the basics here now. 4 Roses
- 33:42small batch is not the most basic of the basic 4 Roses.
- 33:45That would just be the one that's called 4 Roses.
- 33:48Yellow label, colloquially 4 roses for those of you who are
- 33:52not super familiar with the distillery is famous.
- 33:55It it it has an almost film bro like following Brad because they
- 34:00make 10 different recipes of bourbon inside the walls of four
- 34:04Roses and they combine them in various different combinations
- 34:08to make some really good bourbon.
- 34:10And so Yellow Label is their cheapest 1 and it is just a
- 34:13blend of all 10 recipes put together.
- 34:16And it's. Like now the one that we have.
- 34:17Right now $28.00 per bottle. Cheap $20 bottle of whiskey.
- 34:22The one we have right now is just like one step up from that
- 34:24and it is four select recipes and these recipes basically are
- 34:29varied between 5 different yeast strains that they use and a high
- 34:34rye mash bill and a low rye mash bill.
- 34:36So that's how you get your 10 recipes.
- 34:37This one is a combination of four of those recipes.
- 34:40For those of you who know and care about these sorts of
- 34:43things, it's OBSKOESKOBSO and OESO.
- 34:50And this is where, Brad, I realized that I love whiskey.
- 34:55I don't love whiskey this much. Yeah.
- 34:58I mean, like, I'm not hunting down specific yeast strains to
- 35:01try. I just like a good.
- 35:03Product. Yeah.
- 35:04I just want to drink normal bourbon that I don't have to
- 35:08think about too much, you know? I mean, no hate to the people
- 35:12who are hunting down specific yeast strains.
- 35:14I just like, that's a level of bourbon nerd dumb that I have
- 35:17not achieved even like 7 years into this podcast.
- 35:22Yeah. Yeah.
- 35:23All right, So Small Batch is small batches bottled at 90
- 35:27proof. So it's a step up from Yellow
- 35:29Label, which is bottled at 80 proof and and it commands a
- 35:32higher price point because of that, but still in this
- 35:35affordable range. Kind of sits next to Elijah
- 35:37Craig on the shelf. And, you know, that Bob Book
- 35:41loves his $35 range of bourbon. I feel like that's where you can
- 35:45show up to the party with the bottle and people know that you
- 35:47weren't on the bottom shelf, that you put a a little bit of
- 35:50thought into it, you know? I, I had a friend text me, I
- 35:53don't know, a month ago saying that he was going to like drink
- 35:56whiskey with a group of like, like whisk capital W whiskey
- 36:00guys. And he's like, what should I,
- 36:02what kind of bourbon should I bring?
- 36:03And I was like, what's your budget?
- 36:05He's like $30.00. I was like Cooper's Craft 100.
- 36:11That's it, man. But if you'd had an extra 5 to
- 36:14$8 to spend, I, I mean, I don't, I don't want to spoil the whole
- 36:18review, but I think 4 roses would be in the mix.
- 36:21I think so too. I'm excited to dive back into
- 36:24this. I have not had this in a really
- 36:25long time. Brad, you've tried it already,
- 36:28so why don't you give your nosing notes while I stick my
- 36:31nose in this glass here? Yeah, this is a very traditional
- 36:37bourbon nose. It to me.
- 36:39It is a little bit corn heavy, but not like overly sweet.
- 36:43It has a little bit of that corn syrupiness.
- 36:46There's caramel, there's vanilla.
- 36:48For me, the the uniqueness finds itself with a little bit of
- 36:52citrus, like a really light citrus note that's going on.
- 36:56But overall this is just a straight line.
- 36:59Really nice bourbon nose. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 37:0210. I'm getting kind of a weird note
- 37:05on this that I've only gotten a couple times.
- 37:07It's not the predominant note, but it keeps throwing me off
- 37:09every time I stick my nose close to it.
- 37:12And there's like just a slight hint of like oniony, like
- 37:15everything bagel seasoning going.
- 37:17OK, I don't know why, but underneath the weird onion note
- 37:22that I'm getting, there's a lot of sourdough bread it, but it
- 37:25doesn't smell like yeasty. It doesn't smell youthful or, or
- 37:28too young. It just has like a nice baked
- 37:29sourdough kind of thing going on.
- 37:32And there are some nice like almost eggnogy notes.
- 37:35Like I get a lot of like custardy vanilla notes on this.
- 37:38I like it a lot, except for the fact that I keep thinking of
- 37:41like like an Arby's beef and cheddar where you get the little
- 37:45onions on the top of the bun. Can I give one quick hot take
- 37:48before we move on 'cause I, I was just talking about this with
- 37:51somebody yesterday. I think that eggnog is better
- 37:55without alcohol in it. 100% I prefer a non alcoholic nog.
- 38:00Yeah, I mean partially because like I grew up with the non
- 38:04alcoholic nog and like now I've put bourbon in it a few Times
- 38:10Now. I will say if you do, if you
- 38:14heat it up and do like some espresso in it and do like an
- 38:17eggnog latte, I can get down with that dude.
- 38:21That is freaking Kahlua. Yeah, OK.
- 38:24Maybe a little Kahlua in with it.
- 38:26There's something about just. Bourbon it.
- 38:28It thins it down too much and it puts it in this weird, like
- 38:32snotty consistency that you don't want, you know what I
- 38:35mean? You don't want like baby drool
- 38:38consistency for your. Hey, but this 4 roses small
- 38:42batch 7.5 on the nose, Brad, yes.
- 38:46The palette for the Four Roses, it is Carmely, there is peanuts,
- 38:51the vanilla is there. The for me, the citrus turned
- 38:54into a little bit of like a summer fruit kind of melon kind
- 38:57of vibe. Really pleasant, refreshing
- 39:00bourbon that I'm going to give a 7 1/2 to on the palate.
- 39:04Yeah, this is man. Caramel's a great note and it
- 39:07sounds like very plain and simple, but I feel like a lot of
- 39:09times we bring up Carmely notes and what we really mean is like
- 39:13brown sugar or Maple or vanilla 'cause we just kind of lump the
- 39:16sweet notes together sometimes. This is the first one I've had
- 39:19in a while. It reminds me of like a
- 39:21Werther's Original. There's just a ton of caramel
- 39:23here mixed with like quite a bit of spice.
- 39:25This is black pepper heavy for me.
- 39:27I do get some of those kind of Melanie notes that you're
- 39:30getting as well. It tips a little bit bitter
- 39:33towards the back of the palate for me, but I think I'm going to
- 39:36Ding it more on the finish than I am on the taste.
- 39:38This is significantly better than I remember it being.
- 39:41I think I'm going to come all the way up to an 8 out of 10 on
- 39:43the palate here. Yeah, I'm kind of with you on
- 39:46the finish. It it doesn't quite sour for me.
- 39:49It just kind of dissipates a little bit.
- 39:51There's pepper, there's oak, the caramel sticks around.
- 39:54It returns to its kind of base corn flavor.
- 39:58But overall it's a medium length finish that's got a nice
- 40:02Kentucky hug. I'll give it a 7 out of 10 here.
- 40:05Yeah, I think for me, like I said, it tips bitter, it gets a
- 40:08little more herbal and it gets some of that like barrel char in
- 40:12a bad way, like the the bitterness of the barrel char.
- 40:15I think this is just a 6 1/2 for me on the finish, but I don't
- 40:19think that it's rocky enough to really Ding it here on the
- 40:23balance. Overall, I think this is a
- 40:24pretty well balanced whiskey. I'm going to stick it a 7.5.
- 40:28Yeah, I'm at a 7.5 as well for balance.
- 40:31It's a pleasant experience. There's nothing incredibly
- 40:34complex about it, but there's some good flavors mixed in with
- 40:37your classics to make it a relatively well balanced
- 40:40whiskey. And for value in the state of
- 40:43Ohio, you're going to spend about $37 on this bottle of
- 40:48whiskey. So it, you know, it's 3699,
- 40:52you're going to walk out the door at 40 after tax.
- 40:55I don't think that that's a bad value.
- 40:57I, I, it's not quite like there, I'll give it a 6 1/2 out of 10.
- 41:03I, I think it's a decent value. I think there's other stuff in
- 41:06that 35 to $40 range I might recommend before it.
- 41:10But overall, I don't think this is unfairly priced.
- 41:14Yeah, I think the market has just risen on stuff like this.
- 41:19When when we first started the podcast, I think we did small
- 41:21batch and we did single barrel somewhere around the same time.
- 41:25And I remember at the time for Roses single barrel was like one
- 41:28of the cheapest good single barrels you could get.
- 41:31It was around 38 to $40. And so now that's risen in price
- 41:35and this has kind of come up to take its place.
- 41:38If this was $25 or $27.00, I would say that's right in line
- 41:42with what you're getting because this is a right down the middle.
- 41:45There is nothing, no real peaks and also no real valleys.
- 41:50But because of that, I'm just like, you know, $37 when we
- 41:56started the podcast is what we would pay for like Eagle Rear.
- 41:59And I think Eagle Rear is better than this now.
- 42:01Like what can you get for $37 now?
- 42:04Elijah Craig I think I would still say is better than this.
- 42:07I think I would say like Cooper's Craft 100 for seven or
- 42:11$8 less is better than this. So I'm going to come down to a
- 42:14six out of 10 on the value here, Brad, and that's going to bring
- 42:19me out to a 35.5 out of 50. Where are you at on this one?
- 42:26I'm coming to a 35.5 out of 50 and I will say that $30 in 2019
- 42:33based on inflation. You know what it's worth today,
- 42:36Bob? 38 dollars $38.02.
- 42:42Wow. So inflation, inflation wise, it
- 42:46feels. Right in line.
- 42:48It's right in line with where it's at, so I don't know if that
- 42:50changes your score at all, but. Yeah, I think it's one of those
- 42:54things where, like, you and I talk about like, the burger and
- 42:58fries, lunch should still only cost $10.
- 43:01Like there's no reason I should spend more than 10 American
- 43:03dollars on a burger and fries. That's kind of where I'm at with
- 43:07this. Like this is a $30 bottle of
- 43:09whiskey. I don't care what's happened
- 43:11with inflation, it should still be $30.
- 43:14And that's why we are coming out to a 71 out of 100 on this or a
- 43:1835.5 out of 50 on average. I will give this a mild thumbs
- 43:23up. Like if if this is your bag, if
- 43:25you like 4 roses, I think this is a good baseline.
- 43:29Yellow label's not my favorite. So I would say like make this
- 43:32the baseline version of that and then scale up from there.
- 43:36Yeah, I I mean, I think this is a really pleasant experience.
- 43:39It's a little bit peanutty if you enjoy that like nutty
- 43:42flavor. The corn is there, the caramel,
- 43:45it's very vanilla. Y It's a good pleasant bourbon
- 43:49experience that you know for the mid, upper mid 30s you're,
- 43:53you're getting a decent bourbon. Yeah, I think there's really
- 43:57only one thing left to say, Brad, and that is I am Jack's
- 44:01inflated whiskey price. Rule #1 Don't talk about Four
- 44:06Roses. Talk about inflation.
- 44:08All right, man, let's get back into talking about Fight Club.
- 44:10What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 44:16All right, everybody. That was 4 Roses Small Batch, A
- 44:20respectable whiskey at the price point it was.
- 44:23It was a good experience, Bob. I was trying to think of
- 44:26something clever to start with. I am Jax, whatever.
- 44:29And if we were really clever, we would have, we would have done
- 44:32Jack Daniels so we could say I am Jax.
- 44:34You know, I was going to say. Your version, Jax Thorny
- 44:38something you gotta love that roses.
- 44:42Because of roses. Because of roses.
- 44:44Yeah. Yeah, Well, you.
- 44:45Know it's been a little thorny for you this season, Bob.
- 44:48It's our game. 2 facts and a falsehood, Brad.
- 44:52Is going to try to stump you Bob 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 44:592 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 45:02the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 45:06the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 45:10Now, Brad, I know only the barest semblance of the facts
- 45:13about the movie Fight Club. I know about the author Chuck
- 45:16Polonic and like I remember having some friends in high
- 45:20school that were really into reading his books because it was
- 45:23the edgy thing to do at the time.
- 45:25I've never read any of his. No, I was gonna say, you've not
- 45:28read Fight Club. No, I've not read anything
- 45:31written by him. And it's not like I'm crusading
- 45:34against him. It's just never happened.
- 45:36So I think that there's a lot of opportunity.
- 45:38I actually read I read Fight Club after I saw the movie.
- 45:42Partially. Partially because it's literally
- 45:44like 104 pages. It it like it's.
- 45:48More of a short, I wouldn't call it a short story, but it's not
- 45:51like a 300 page novel. It's a pretty quick read.
- 45:55I don't there's like a few differences.
- 45:57Most everything stayed the same. I do remember in the last like 4
- 46:01pages of their book there being like a line that like really
- 46:04stuck with me for a long time but now I can't remember it so
- 46:08you know. Thanks a lot, Chuck.
- 46:11Come on, I said. I said all that to say, there's
- 46:13a lot of different areas where you can get me today because I
- 46:16just don't know a lot. So, Brad, hit me with your two
- 46:19facts and a falsehood. All right, I, I love my themes.
- 46:24A lot of times my themes come from the fact that like as I'm
- 46:27reading, there's a bunch of facts that weirdly have the same
- 46:30thing. This one, there's a bunch of
- 46:33facts that like we're like around 55 minutes in parentheses
- 46:38and then the fact. So that's, that's our theme
- 46:40today, Bob Around 55 minute. Fact #1 around 55 minutes.
- 46:46The line. It's only after we've lost
- 46:49everything that we're free to do Anything.
- 46:51Was originally written as a longer monologue explaining
- 46:54Tyler's philosophy. Fincher director David Fincher
- 46:58explained in the DVD commentary that he cut it down to a single
- 47:01sentence after realizing the message was more unsettling when
- 47:04delivered without explanation. Fact #2 Around one hour and 9
- 47:10minutes. Bob wears a shirt during his
- 47:12fights, despite 1 of the 8 rules being you're not allowed to wear
- 47:16shirts or shoes during fights. This is because Tyler Durden
- 47:21fights Bob's man boobs to be too gross behind the scenes, though
- 47:25this was also because Meatloaf's fat suit had to be hidden.
- 47:29Fashion #3 At around an hour and 15 minutes.
- 47:33When a Fight Club member sprays the priest with a hose, the
- 47:36camera briefly shakes. This happens because the
- 47:39cameraman could not keep himself from laughing.
- 47:49I think 2 is true, and I could go either way on Yeah, I could
- 47:56go either way on three because there's so many like jittery
- 47:59camera things added to this movie, which are again, like,
- 48:02oh, you're you're so edgy and cool.
- 48:05You hate this movie, Bob. I can just feel it in your soul.
- 48:12So #1 is kind of like the obvious candidate here for a
- 48:15falsehood, but it's just. It's also not like the sexy 1 to
- 48:18pick. Yeah, and we know you, Bob.
- 48:21You like picking the sexy ones? I sure do.
- 48:23I sure do Brad. I'll go with #1 because AI don't
- 48:27remember what it was and B3 sounds like it could be
- 48:30innocuous enough to be true. I do think 2 is true for sure.
- 48:34So it's either one or three. I'll take one, Brad.
- 48:37Man, with that convincing inner dialogue being explained to us,
- 48:42Bob, I have to tell you that you are correct.
- 48:45Number 1 is a falsehood. I was so.
- 48:48Worried you were going to be like actually 2 is the falsehood
- 48:50and you're so wrong. Those are my favorite 2 facts in
- 48:54the falsehood. When you immediately dismiss my
- 48:57falsehood, you're like, Oh yeah, obviously that one's true and
- 49:00then you like spend 5 minutes debating which of the true ones
- 49:04is false. I it's I just get to sit here
- 49:06and. Be like, all right, man.
- 49:10So I'm riding high off of a victory here.
- 49:13It's about the only good thing to come out of Fight Club.
- 49:16No, here's the thing. I want to come in and like, I
- 49:22want to have my Last Jedi thing like you did.
- 49:24I want to have my tome written and my logic in place for why
- 49:29this movie is incoherent and I think ultimately irresponsible
- 49:34and dangerous. And I still kind of think those
- 49:37things. But I also think the last half
- 49:39hour of this movie is pretty easy to follow and pretty easy
- 49:44to to use as an interpretive lens for the rest of the movie.
- 49:49Yeah. And if you're watching the movie
- 49:51closely, especially because once you know the twist, you you do
- 49:54you rewatch the movie really closely all through the movie.
- 49:58Like Edward Norton's character says at one point he's like, I'm
- 50:02a 30 year old boy. I don't want this or that, you
- 50:05know? And then you've got like Tyler
- 50:07Durden growing out and being like, we're a generation of men
- 50:10who were raised by women. Do you really think we need
- 50:13another woman in the mix? And, and once you understand
- 50:16that Tyler Durden literally only exists as the worst impulses of
- 50:22a narrator who needs to grow up, it, it makes a lot more click.
- 50:27I do still think that the bulk of the movie is keeping the
- 50:36twist at Bay, but by keeping the twist at Bay, it's also keeping
- 50:40the point of the movie at Bay for a really long time.
- 50:43And So what people remember from the movie, like there's some
- 50:46cool imagery at the end and the Pixies needle drop and the
- 50:49buildings blowing up, It's really cool.
- 50:51But what people remember from the movie are like the fight
- 50:53scenes and Brad Pitt shirtless and Brad Pitt with his cool red
- 50:57leather jacket saying cool, manly sounding machismo bullshit
- 51:03philosophy. And so I do think that there's
- 51:05an element of like, I, I think this movie is perfectly clear
- 51:09about what it actually thinks. And also it's a little bit
- 51:14irresponsible in the way that it's structured and the way that
- 51:17it's written, because it was so easily misinterpreted by a whole
- 51:22generation of angry young males who hold its incorrect
- 51:28philosophy in high esteem. Yeah, I mean to me the the
- 51:32thought I had coming out of it was and you'll know the director
- 51:36that said this, you can't make a true anti war movie, right.
- 51:42Who? Who said that, Bob?
- 51:44I think it was Truffaut that said.
- 51:46Yeah, Truffaut, and like that. Like that is what I walked away
- 51:50from with this. I also feel like this is the
- 51:53classic example of a person who gets the the analysis right and
- 52:03the prescription wrong. Right.
- 52:06Like the analysis is right. Corporate America sucks the soul
- 52:09out of humanity, especially men in a lot of ways.
- 52:14And the prescription of like fight and fuck is basically the
- 52:19prescription. And like, that's not the right
- 52:22prescription to become a healthy man.
- 52:25I, I think that there is a lot of great things that you can do
- 52:29to become a healthy man. And some of it involves fighting
- 52:32for something and some of it involves being honorable towards
- 52:36women and pursuing them in a healthy way.
- 52:39Right? Like, I, I think that it's OK to
- 52:41say that masculinity involves some of those things, but when
- 52:47you present the unhealthy exclusively and at the end of
- 52:52the film, you say, bad, I'm going to slap you on the wrist.
- 52:57It's like, yeah, no, I, I think that Fincher is a little bit
- 53:01irresponsible with what he's presenting.
- 53:04Well, and also because like you go the whole movie thinking that
- 53:07they're railing against consumerism and whatever, but
- 53:10then the final kind of reveal of the movie is basically, you
- 53:14know, the narrator character waking up to the fact that like,
- 53:18I, I mean, I am an insane person, but also I need to grow
- 53:21up. It's it's a very largely writ
- 53:25satire of a coming of age story. And Fincher has called this a
- 53:29coming of age story. Like if you even if you go to
- 53:31the Wikipedia, it says he calls it a coming of age story, but
- 53:34for people in their 30s. And I think that's a really
- 53:36funny way of talking about it because then you do have this
- 53:39site, this kind of quarter life crisis, like what am I putting
- 53:43my money, my time, my effort into?
- 53:45Where am I going in my job? That's all folded in.
- 53:48So yes, that's there. But the ultimate point of this
- 53:51movie is like a guy learns how to not be scared to be in a
- 53:56relationship. This is a movie about like a guy
- 53:59finally becoming ready to not be selfish and and be a good
- 54:03boyfriend. And in that respect, it really
- 54:06is very similar to 500 Days of Summer, another movie that we
- 54:09kind of struggle with. Because when you watch that
- 54:12movie as a young, impressionable teenager to early 20s person,
- 54:17you're on Tom's side for a lot of that movie.
- 54:19And you don't realize that the movie is telling you throughout
- 54:23its entire course that Tom is in the wrong and Tom is super
- 54:26immature. And it's on Tom to get over this
- 54:29paradigm that he's concocted for himself.
- 54:32And this movie does the same thing.
- 54:33But because it does it in this kind of like fantastical, weird,
- 54:37schizophrenic, violent way, I think it does kind of dabble
- 54:41with being irresponsible. And I think the irresponsibility
- 54:46for me comes in like how much weight is given to that reveal
- 54:50at the end where everything throughout this movie, nothing
- 54:53is subtle about this movie. It I mean, it punches you in the
- 54:56face repeatedly. And yet even after that twist
- 55:00and the the sort of reframing of Edward Norton's character, I
- 55:04don't think they do enough to like underline it in red pen,
- 55:08enough for the people in the audience who are too young and
- 55:11impressionable and immature to understand what they're trying
- 55:15to go for. And it's weird.
- 55:17I I don't usually call for film makers to be less subtle, but I
- 55:20think a movie like this kind of demands it when it's like you
- 55:24front loaded it with all this other stuff and got the incel
- 55:28Bros on your side. And if you're going to try to
- 55:30tell them that what this movie is actually about is like
- 55:33growing up, then you can't just end it the way you did without
- 55:37underlining that a bit more. Well and and the way he ends it.
- 55:41I agree. I think the ending is him
- 55:43growing up but the ending is like he becomes masculine by
- 55:47shooting himself. Like, he literally kills the
- 55:53dark version of himself by putting a gun in his mouth,
- 55:56pointing it to the side and kind of shooting a hole through, like
- 55:58the side of his mouth and throat.
- 56:01Yeah. And And it's it's this wildly
- 56:04violent way of becoming a man. And so even in.
- 56:08Like it's very 1990s too. Like I, I don't think we can
- 56:12divorce ourselves for there was a great documentary a couple
- 56:15years ago about Woodstock 99 when they tried to revive
- 56:19Woodstock at the end of the 90s and all the music acts that they
- 56:23booked were like new metal bands.
- 56:24So it was like Limp Bizkit and corn.
- 56:26And I don't know if you remember this.
- 56:28I remember from when I was a kid, like people, like, I'm
- 56:31pretty sure people died like they burned everything down.
- 56:34It was like a giant riot. And it was like the undoing of
- 56:37what Woodstock in the 60s was supposed to.
- 56:40Because there was just this innate unspoken anger among
- 56:46predominantly white teenagers at the end of the 90s that led to
- 56:50things like Columbine. And everybody was blaming media
- 56:54for these violent impulses. And there's just something there
- 56:57that's like, I watch The Matrix now and I'm like, damn, there's
- 56:59a lot of guns in this. Like we really were obsessed
- 57:02with guns as a culture, you know?
- 57:04And and Fight Club is Fight Club is still a popular movie, but it
- 57:08definitely does feel like a relic of early millennial or
- 57:12Gen. X kind of generation and the way
- 57:14they expressed their anger. And they worship violence in a
- 57:17lot of ways. Yeah.
- 57:19Yeah, which is interesting because like, you hear Gen.
- 57:23Xers especially talk about their childhood and they're like,
- 57:25yeah, no, we were violent and our playgrounds could kill us
- 57:28and things like that. And then they ended up
- 57:31worshipping it. And I feel like millennials are
- 57:33kind of where that starts to shift.
- 57:35And, and for sure, I, I don't know, as far as Fight Club goes,
- 57:40I actually, I, I disagree on the subtlety part.
- 57:43I don't think he needs to be less subtle about the ending.
- 57:48I like. I think Fincher made the movie
- 57:50he wanted to make. I I will place the blame on the
- 57:54audience. Yeah.
- 57:55If this if this style of life is attractive to somebody, that
- 58:02says more about them than it does about David Fincher and
- 58:06that. And that's not to like, say
- 58:07they're bad people or anything, but there's reasons why a
- 58:12violent brotherhood cult community is attractive to some
- 58:18people. Elements of our society have
- 58:22created this pocket of a dearth of brotherhood and friendship
- 58:29and adventure and like challenging men to strive after
- 58:34something in a healthy way. And when you have a void of
- 58:38something that is necessary to the human soul, it will get
- 58:42filled with something and it gets filled with things like
- 58:44Fight Club. And so I, I think Fincher is
- 58:47actually putting his finger on the pulse of something very key
- 58:51to what it means to be a human being, to be a man.
- 58:56And like I said, the the prescription within the movie
- 58:58that he kind of judges is not good, but he never gives a
- 59:03healthy prescription. He just kind of says, like,
- 59:06yeah, starting a cult that blows up buildings is bad.
- 59:09Like that's pretty clear by the end of the film.
- 59:11But he never. Well, that's my point, because I
- 59:17think that what he's doing is he's he takes the end of the
- 59:19movie and he just says like it was never about any of that
- 59:21stuff. I was saying earlier.
- 59:23It was never about the Fight Club.
- 59:24It was never like the prescription is part of a
- 59:27completely illusory paradigm, right.
- 59:32But to your point, he never like builds out what the actual
- 59:35solution is. And the way the movie ends, just
- 59:38from a plot device standpoint is like Edward Norton's tried to
- 59:42turn himself in. That didn't work out.
- 59:44He can't keep the buildings from being blown up.
- 59:47And you know that the he escaped from the police station, so the
- 59:49police are going to be chasing him.
- 59:51So now he's like a fugitive terrorist leader who had an
- 59:55enlightening moment. But you don't know, like, is he
- 59:58going to disband the terrorist organization or is Marla going
- 1:00:02to become the Bonnie to his Clyde?
- 1:00:05Like it it you don't know. And again like.
- 1:00:09I hate being the guy that's begging for like, spell it out
- 1:00:12for me, David Fincher. But when you're releasing.
- 1:00:15A movie, 10 more minutes of back story Is.
- 1:00:18Is that what you need, Bob? When you're releasing a movie
- 1:00:22into an environment of people who are clamoring for something
- 1:00:25to latch onto with their anger or to explain their anger or to
- 1:00:29fuel their anger, I think you do have to, as a, as a film maker,
- 1:00:34ask yourself, like, what if this gets misinterpreted?
- 1:00:37What kind of harm could this do? It's a conversation we had about
- 1:00:41a movie like Joker that I think is equally misinterpreted like
- 1:00:44this movie. And I I thought a lot about like
- 1:00:47the Wolf of Wall Street, which is a really good movie that I
- 1:00:50still think it glorifies its lifestyle in order to satirize
- 1:00:56it. But to your point, like you
- 1:00:58can't make an anti war movie at some point the glorification is
- 1:01:03the the end of the thing. You can't make an anti Wall
- 1:01:05Street movie Bob. You sure can't, dude.
- 1:01:09Do you know why, Bob? Because when you're on wall.
- 1:01:11Street, you got jacked to the tents.
- 1:01:18All right, dude, we've talked a lot about this movie.
- 1:01:20I think it's time for us to pick a movie to pair it up with, and
- 1:01:23that means it's time for our final segment of the day.
- 1:01:26Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:01:28episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 1:01:32Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:01:34struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:01:36day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:01:38Make it a Double is the part of the show where we pick a movie
- 1:01:40to pair up with this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:01:44Brad, I do think any of the movies I've mentioned that Wolf
- 1:01:46of Wall Street is a is a really good one because it captures
- 1:01:49like I think where both the film makers kind of got things wrong
- 1:01:52and also is very glorifying of what it says it's going to
- 1:01:56satirize. I'm gonna go kind of a little
- 1:01:59bit more. Let's watch another movie.
- 1:02:01The scene where he's like tracking Tyler around the
- 1:02:04country and trying to figure out who is this elusive guy that I
- 1:02:08know really well. My friend is really similar to
- 1:02:12the great movie The Third Man, which we've talked about on the
- 1:02:15show and never watched. And it is one of the best movies
- 1:02:18ever made. So if you could bottle up just
- 1:02:21that scene and it becomes like the first hour of this mystery
- 1:02:25movie of I'm chasing around Vienna post war trying to find
- 1:02:31my friend who people said is dead but who may or may not
- 1:02:34actually be like a secret underground mobster.
- 1:02:37Freaking fantastic. The third man.
- 1:02:39OK, When did the third man come out?
- 1:02:4247 maybe. OK.
- 1:02:45Yeah, yeah, I'm ready, man. Let's do it.
- 1:02:48We're going to do it. I think for me, I am going to go
- 1:02:51with the coming of age. My brain is disappearing on me.
- 1:02:55I'm going to go with the coming of age idea and say I'm going to
- 1:02:59go with The Graduate. I think that there's a weird, I
- 1:03:03have seen The Graduate. I did not love The Graduate.
- 1:03:06Not my favorite movie. I think though, that there's
- 1:03:09this, there's this sense of like existential drift.
- 1:03:12There's a lot of sexual confusion and what it means to
- 1:03:16be a man, and there's a lot of anger that you get to see Dustin
- 1:03:21Hoffman work through throughout the film and you know, the kind
- 1:03:25of the rebellion and the malaise and all this stuff going on.
- 1:03:28I think there's a weird amount of correlation between Fight
- 1:03:32Club and the Graduate. Obviously The Graduate being for
- 1:03:369, you know the 1960s what you get in the 1990s with Fight
- 1:03:40Club. Well, I know that they actually
- 1:03:42approached the screenwriter of The Graduate to adapt Fight
- 1:03:46Club. Like they wanted him to write
- 1:03:48the script because they found so many themes.
- 1:03:51They're like, this guy totally gets it.
- 1:03:52It's a movie about malaise. And he was like, absolutely not,
- 1:03:55go find somebody else to rate this movie.
- 1:03:58So. I did not have.
- 1:03:59That dude, yeah, I think two really good movies you could
- 1:04:02play this up with. Also, Bob, I I think that
- 1:04:04whatever goal you had setting out to do this podcast, yeah, I
- 1:04:08think you accomplished it. If if I'm referencing a movie
- 1:04:12from 3035 years before, not even knowing that that was a direct
- 1:04:17reference. Like we've, we've made it, dude.
- 1:04:20We. We have arrived, my friend.
- 1:04:23All right, Brad, I, I feel better.
- 1:04:27I, I still think this movie is irresponsible.
- 1:04:29I don't think it's inept anymore.
- 1:04:31And I'm looking through like a lot of the notes I took on this
- 1:04:34movie, especially towards the beginning.
- 1:04:37Let me read this. I thought I wrote this quite
- 1:04:39well. This, this still holds true.
- 1:04:41I had a big problem with the first like 10-15 minutes of the
- 1:04:44movie where he's kind of an unreliable narrator and random
- 1:04:48stuff is happening and you don't understand how it all adds up.
- 1:04:52And I said that the intro to the character works thematically.
- 1:04:56It is a scattered mishmash of his thoughts and impressions of
- 1:04:59the world, his consumerism, his dissatisfaction with his
- 1:05:03corporate life, his insomnia. It is a schizophrenic depiction
- 1:05:07of what you come to learn is burgeoning schizophrenia, but it
- 1:05:12doesn't work as a narrative hook because it's not presented as a
- 1:05:15descent into schizophrenia. It's presented as a reliable
- 1:05:18narrator and his introduction to his world, and you have no idea
- 1:05:22what's going on or what's important.
- 1:05:25And I'd still think that, like as I move into final scores, the
- 1:05:28last half hour of this movie is really, really good.
- 1:05:32Yeah, the. First hour and 40 minutes were a
- 1:05:37real struggle for me, man. And last time we watched this
- 1:05:40movie, I want to say I gave it a three or a 2 1/2 out of 10.
- 1:05:43Really. Low dude.
- 1:05:45I still think by and large this movie does not work OK, but I
- 1:05:50respect the swing of it a little more this time.
- 1:05:53It's a swing and a miss, but it was a hell of a swing.
- 1:05:56I'm going to come out to a I'm going to come out to a 5 out of
- 1:05:5910 on this movie, bro. OK.
- 1:06:00That's a little bit of a movement, Bob.
- 1:06:02I'm proud of you. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:06:03Thank you. I mean I still think that Fight
- 1:06:07Club technically is really well made.
- 1:06:10I like everything you just read. I'm with you 100% except for on
- 1:06:16how it made me feel like. And whether you like it or not,
- 1:06:20Fincher does not treat the audience well in this movie.
- 1:06:23Like he, he doesn't make you feel good for thinking that
- 1:06:28Edward Norton is a reliable narrator.
- 1:06:31And I'm like, like, that's interesting to me.
- 1:06:34That is not the norm when it comes to filmmaking.
- 1:06:39And so I'm, I'm interested in things like that.
- 1:06:41I think that it makes for a better movie.
- 1:06:44And when you add in some of the great performances on top of
- 1:06:47that, we didn't even talk about like the lighting of this movie
- 1:06:51and how I I think he really does a masterful job of using color
- 1:06:56in the film there. There's so much of this that I
- 1:06:59think it's technically really well made.
- 1:07:01And on top of that, you have a really interesting story that is
- 1:07:06not taken down a notch once you know the twist.
- 1:07:12Like, you know, and obviously if it's spoiled for you, that is
- 1:07:15the worst ruining. But like, once you've seen the
- 1:07:18movie, you come back to it and you're like, yeah, this is still
- 1:07:21a compelling film, even knowing the huge twist.
- 1:07:25It's why I still like 6 Sixth Sense a lot.
- 1:07:28It's why I still like this movie a lot.
- 1:07:31It's not a perfect movie. I, I don't think it's like a
- 1:07:33nine, 9 1/2 out of 10. I might have given it a nine in
- 1:07:36season 1. I think I'll give it an 8 1/2
- 1:07:39this time. I, I think that Fincher does a
- 1:07:41great job overall. And you, you kind of have to
- 1:07:45reconcile with the fact that a lot of audience members who like
- 1:07:48this movie like it for a lot of reasons that might not be
- 1:07:53healthy. Yeah.
- 1:07:55And and that's hard. And I don't want to hold that
- 1:07:58against the the actual product of the movie 'cause it's
- 1:08:00possible that this is like a 10 out of 10 movie that people
- 1:08:03still misread and is very dangerous that way.
- 1:08:05I just think that there are actual problems with the film
- 1:08:08itself and not least of which, Brad, You know, you bring up The
- 1:08:116th Sense again when you rewatch The 6th Sense with the twist in
- 1:08:15mind, you start to poke holes in it a little bit and, like, it's
- 1:08:19kind of cutesy and it's kind of gimmicky.
- 1:08:20How like, oh, Bruce Willis never touches anybody or, like, sure
- 1:08:24is never actually in the room, never says anything to the mom.
- 1:08:27We never. And it's like, oh, that's a
- 1:08:29gimmick. Yeah.
- 1:08:30But crucially, The 6th Sense still works because of the other
- 1:08:33stuff. Like that final scene with Haley
- 1:08:36Joel Osment and the mom in the car is like, that's why I
- 1:08:38watched The 6th Sense. I don't care about the gimmick
- 1:08:40anymore. Yeah.
- 1:08:41And I feel like all those little gimmicky things that happened in
- 1:08:44The Sixth Sense happened twice as often in Fight Club, and the
- 1:08:49movie relies on them. Like you, you come in here a lot
- 1:08:53with a criticism that, like nobody in this movie behaves
- 1:08:56like a human being. Sure.
- 1:08:59Edward Norton's motivations throughout this movie are like,
- 1:09:01what? What is he doing and why?
- 1:09:04And it kind of works as a satire 'cause it's very like blown out
- 1:09:08of proportion. Like, why is he living in this
- 1:09:09dilapidated house for months on end?
- 1:09:12Why is he doing any of this? Why is he putting up with Darla
- 1:09:15or Marla? Sorry.
- 1:09:16And I'm like. Darla from the Little Rascals.
- 1:09:20From the Little Rascals, Dear Darla.
- 1:09:24Anyway, all that to say I I do wonder if people forgive a lot
- 1:09:29in this movie because they think it's cool to go back and watch
- 1:09:32the twist happen again, but like the movie just does not hold
- 1:09:36together for me as well as other twisty movies do.
- 1:09:39Because it it relies so much on the twist.
- 1:09:43Yeah, and like, you can't the the characters don't behave like
- 1:09:46real people because they have to behave specific ways to make the
- 1:09:50twist happen. See, I, I think it's great
- 1:09:52because there's, there's the moments where Brad Pitt is
- 1:09:56screaming at Bob, the fat guy who Edward Norton actually
- 1:10:00really likes. And then Edward Norton goes out
- 1:10:02and grabs his bag. He's like, Bob, come on, man,
- 1:10:04come on. And then to look back and be
- 1:10:06like, Bob, just experienced Edward Norton do both of those
- 1:10:10things. I, I love that.
- 1:10:11I think that's so funny. Oh, man, All right, guys, we're
- 1:10:14coming out to a 6.75 out of 10 on Fight Club on average, which
- 1:10:19I know is the perfect score for us, Brad, because I'm not
- 1:10:22satisfied with that score and I know that you're not either.
- 1:10:25So that's like it's a great dude take talking point.
- 1:10:29I'm even just thinking about the way they twist Bob's death.
- 1:10:33Like what? Great writing, dude.
- 1:10:36When when, when? Edward Norton is like, no, what
- 1:10:39the hell are you talking about? He's not a.
- 1:10:40Nameless. No, he has a name.
- 1:10:42He. Has A and then they immediately
- 1:10:44in death we have his. Name His name was Robert Paulson
- 1:10:49all. Right.
- 1:10:51Stop waxing poetic. We want to know what you think
- 1:10:53about Fight Club. Whose team are you on here, me
- 1:10:56or Brad? Let us know on any of our social
- 1:10:58media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or
- 1:11:03YouTube at Film Whiskey. We also want to know if Bob and
- 1:11:07I were to start a Fight Club, who would win?
- 1:11:11I mean, I I've got the boobs for it so.
- 1:11:15Yeah, you would win in the in the testicular cancer group,
- 1:11:18Bob. No thanks so much Brad.
- 1:11:22What a weird quote to pull from this episode.
- 1:11:26Also I will say maybe my favorite line of the whole movie
- 1:11:29is just when he's like sulking and his voice over goes this
- 1:11:33chick Marlo Singer did not have testicular cancer.
- 1:11:38So funny dude. Oh man.
- 1:11:40If you want to join the conversation, we are on discord
- 1:11:43every single day. We've got a great server full of
- 1:11:46people that are awesome and we talk about whiskey and movies
- 1:11:49and other stuff. If you want to join, you can
- 1:11:51find a link to our server at the end of every single one of our
- 1:11:54show notes. We'll be back next week with
- 1:11:57another one of our Season 1 classics to talk about.
- 1:12:01Probably not one featuring testicular cancer and man boobs,
- 1:12:05but you never know folks. So join us next week.
- 1:12:08But until then, I'm Bob Book, I'm Brad G and we'll see you
- 1:12:12next time.