Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. Ever since we first got the OIG report
- 0:07detailing their investigation into not only Jeffrey Epstein's death, but
- 0:12into the non prosecution agreement, I have been very, very
- 0:16interested in seeing the interview that was conducted with alex
- 0:20Acosta that was administered by the Inspector General's Office, And
- 0:24after exhaustively searching through the new unsealed files, I was
- 0:28able to put together this whole entire interview, all three
- 0:32hundred pages, and obviously we're going to get it added
- 0:34to the catalog and then you can listen to this
- 0:36interview and then go back to the deposition that alex
- 0:40Acosta gave to Congress recently and see how it all
- 0:43lines up. So with that said, let's dive in examination
- 0:48by misredacted question, So would you tell us your name?
- 0:52Please answer Renee Alexander Acosta. Question and mister Acosta, you're
- 0:58accompanied by your attorney, Gordon Tode. Is that correct? Answer? Yes?
- 1:01It is? Question and mister Todd, would you identify the
- 1:05associate you have with you? Yes? TJ. Hauran misredacted h
- 1:11E r RN. Mister Heran correct misredacted. Thank you, mister Acosta.
- 1:18I'm redacted. I'm a council with the Office of Professional
- 1:21Responsibility here at the Department of Justice, and with me
- 1:24are my fellow OPR council redacted, redacted and redacted. And
- 1:30we are in a conference room at the Department of
- 1:32Justice main building on today, October eighteenth, twenty nineteen, and
- 1:36we're starting at about nine thirty in the morning. Before
- 1:39we start, I just want to put on the record
- 1:42that mister redacted worked in the Civil Rights Division at
- 1:45the time that you were the AAG heading that division,
- 1:49and I believe had an occasion to briefly meet you
- 1:52in connection with the matter the witness. Could I ask
- 1:55what section, mister redacted, I was in the special litigation section? Oh, okay,
- 2:01mister adacted, And I provided mister Acosta some talking points
- 2:05for a press situation that we had in that case.
- 2:09The witness one four one four to one, mister adacted, Yes,
- 2:14the witness probably by misredacted question. All right, thank you,
- 2:18mister Acosta. OPR is investigating two things, as you know. One,
- 2:23whether one or more federal prosecutors in the Southern District
- 2:26of Florida, US Attorney's office may have committed professional misconduct
- 2:31by entering into the non Prosecution Agreement or MPa in
- 2:34two thousand and seven with Jeffrey Epstein, who at the
- 2:37time was under investigation by that office and the FBI
- 2:41for engaging in widespread sexual misconduct involving underage females. The
- 2:46second thing we're investigating is Judge Mara's finding in February
- 2:50of this year, twenty nineteen, that the government may have
- 2:53violated or actually found the government did violate the CVRA
- 2:58where a Crime's Victims Rights Act when it entered into
- 3:01the NPA without first providing the victims with notice and
- 3:04a reasonable right to confer with the government. You are
- 3:08subject of the OPR investigation, that is, one of somebody
- 3:12whose conduct is being reviewed and evaluated by OPR, and specifically,
- 3:16as US Attorney at the time for the Southern District
- 3:19of Florida, you had the ultimate authority over the Epstein
- 3:23for a period of two and a half years, as
- 3:25we understand it, from the time the line Ausa Redacted
- 3:30first brief you and then Criminal Chief redacted in July
- 3:33of two thousand and six, and until you were formally
- 3:35recused from the case on or about the eighth of
- 3:38December two thousand and eight, after notifying the Executive Office
- 3:42of the US Attorneys that you are seeking employment with
- 3:45Kirkland and Ellis, a firm of which two attorneys, Ken
- 3:49Starr and Jay Lefkowitz had been representing Jeffrey Epstein. Is
- 3:53that correct? Answer? We may, we may get into it
- 3:57a little bit later, but I think the character is
- 3:59ation of my seeking employment is not accurate. We can
- 4:02talk about that a little bit later. Question. All right,
- 4:05we have the documents that relate to that, So that's
- 4:08what we're basing that on. Answer, correct question. And I
- 4:12believe the term that I used is seeking employment. Answer.
- 4:16That is the term used in the email. I think
- 4:18I address that, and I believe mister Todd addressed that
- 4:22in the letter that was sent. Questioned, all right, thank you.
- 4:26So we recognize that you're no longer with the Department
- 4:28of Justice. Answer right, question, and that it's your choice
- 4:32to come and talk to us, and that we very
- 4:34much appreciate your willingness to voluntarily do so and help
- 4:38figure this case out. OPR provided you with a few
- 4:41thousand pages of records, emails and correspondence, and some other
- 4:45documents that reflect your involvement in the Epstein matter over
- 4:49that two and a half year period. Now that you've
- 4:51had a chance to review, I hope those emails and
- 4:54other documents, we hope that you can be specific in
- 4:57helping us understand what happened. Have you in fact been
- 5:01able to review those documents? Answer? Yes, I have question.
- 5:05Thank you. O PR asked you for a written response
- 5:08to certain questions, and we've reviewed and received a written
- 5:12response prepared and submitted not by you, but by your attorney,
- 5:16mister Todd on your behalf. Have you reviewed his response? Answer? Yes?
- 5:21Question yeut? You answer? Yes, I have question? And will you,
- 5:26now under oath subscribe to that response as if you
- 5:29had submitted it yourself. Answer? So, mister Todd spoke to
- 5:33me and conveyed the investigation that I provide him. I
- 5:36believe he conveyed that the information accurately, and the statements
- 5:40that he ascribes to me in that letter, I believe
- 5:43or accurate. Question all right, do you have any changes
- 5:46or corrections to the written response? Answer? No, I don't.
- 5:50Question is there anything in it that you do not
- 5:53agree with? Answer? Again, I think that the statement that
- 5:56he ascribes to me are accurate, and I agree with them.
- 6:00Question all right, so we're going to accept that statement
- 6:02as representing accurately your What would you have responded if
- 6:07you had responded to us directly? Is that correct? Answer? Yes,
- 6:12the statements He basically gives me positions, and I believe
- 6:15that he gave my positions accurately. Question perfect, Thank you. So,
- 6:20as we ask questions and refer to documents, we would
- 6:23like you to correct any misstatements in our questions or
- 6:27any misstatements or errors that are in the documents themselves,
- 6:31because we want to make the entire record correct. Also,
- 6:35there's been an enormous amount of publicity about the Epstein case,
- 6:38particularly this year, including about the events and decisions made
- 6:42back in two thousand and six to twenty ten that
- 6:46are the subject of our investigation, and so as best
- 6:49you can, we ask you to try to answer today
- 6:52from your knowledge, understanding, and recollections as of that time period. However,
- 6:57to the extent you are asked or do speak retro actively.
- 7:00Retrospectively will just make it clear that that's what you're doing.
- 7:06Answer all right, question, okay, answer, And if I could
- 7:09just say, one of the difficulties is with everything that,
- 7:12all the publicity and all the documents that have made
- 7:15it to the press, and in litigation, distinguishing between recollection
- 7:19versus the fact. Question right, Acosta interjects speculation, and I
- 7:25will try, but I would appreciate reminders along the way,
- 7:28because it's an important distinction. But it's kind of hard sometimes.
- 7:33Question we recognize, particularly the importance of it. Answer right,
- 7:38question that that's precisely the heart of the matter. So,
- 7:43mister Acosta, your professional background is a matter of public record.
- 7:47I have a couple of questions. By what state bar
- 7:50are you currently licensed? Answer, so, I'm an active I
- 7:54believe in active in Pennsylvania and also in DC. Question
- 7:58all right, and not in Florida. Answer not in Florida. Question,
- 8:02so is it do I understand that you are not
- 8:05currently an active member of any bar? Answer? I would
- 8:08have to confirm with DC. I said not inactive in
- 8:10Pennsylvania and in DC, because I'm not certain whether I'm
- 8:14currently active or inactive. In DC, I'm not currently practicing,
- 8:18and so I would have renewed under either active or inactive.
- 8:22Question all right, answer, we can verify that and get
- 8:25that question. We would appreciate that if mister Todd could
- 8:28let us know your current status, I would also like
- 8:31to know the status your bar status in the period
- 8:34of two thousand and six through two thousand and eight.
- 8:36Do you know what that was? Answer? Most likely, I
- 8:39can speculate. I don't know for a fact. Most likely
- 8:42it was active in DC. Question uh huh answer and
- 8:46an active in Pennsylvania. Question okay, but likely active somewhere right?
- 8:51Answer yes, yes, I think that's a requirement answer, so
- 8:55it would be DC. The distinction between active and an
- 8:58active in DC is more as I recall, then Pennsylvania,
- 9:02where there's a large fee difference. Question All right, thank you,
- 9:05and we look forward to hearing confirmation of that from you,
- 9:09mister Todd. So, after serving nearly two years as the
- 9:12Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Department's Civil Rights Division,
- 9:16you were presidentially appointed the interim US Attorney for the
- 9:19Southern District of Florida in June of two thousand and five,
- 9:23and then, as we understand it, you were formally nominated
- 9:26as US attorney in June of two thousand and six,
- 9:29and after being confirmed by the United States Senate, you
- 9:31were sworn in by the US Attorney as US Attorney
- 9:35in late October two thousand and six. Answer. I think
- 9:39that may be inaccurate. I would have to confirm when
- 9:42you say presidentially appointed. I believe it may have been
- 9:45appointed by the Chief Judge at the request of the
- 9:47Attorney General. The Chief Judge has appointing authority. Question okay, answer,
- 9:53and you'd have to go back and confirm whether it
- 9:56was either an ag designation or the Chief Judge. Answer,
- 10:00all right, question and I understand. And again I would
- 10:03appreciate if you could follow up on that question, mister Todd. Answer.
- 10:09I'm not certain how to confirm that that's something that
- 10:11in all candor the department would know. Question all right,
- 10:16then we will pursue it. My point is that there
- 10:18was a change in your status from an interim to you,
- 10:22you know, the US Attorney with the full confirmation, How,
- 10:27if at all, did the change in status affect your
- 10:29view of and your exercise of your authority as US attorney? Answer?
- 10:35So it's difficult to recall now you're asking that just
- 10:38ten years back, but even further back, I was interim
- 10:41for a sufficiently long period of time, and by the
- 10:45time change in status took place, I would speculate that
- 10:48I was, in my mind the you know, acting as
- 10:51US attorney, whether you have adjunctive interroim or acting in
- 10:55front of your name or not. You know, I had
- 10:58great people. I don't recall when I came on board
- 11:01as a first assistant, but he was my crim chief,
- 11:04and I thought for the continuity of the office it
- 11:07was important to promote him to first assistant. Question. He
- 11:11was promoted actually effective October of two thousand and six.
- 11:14You made a series according to emails, the announcement, the
- 11:17personnel announcement was made to be effective in October two
- 11:21thousand and six, naming redacted as criminal chief and redacted
- 11:25as first assistant. Answer, right, and they they were both
- 11:29long serving professionals within the office, and basically, as my recollection,
- 11:33everyone just moved up one wrung question. Okay, answer, you
- 11:38would know better than I because you have those records,
- 11:40and so, sitting here today, I don't recall any specific
- 11:43way in which that shift would have impacted question. All right,
- 11:48answer my thinking question. You had not served as a
- 11:51prosecutor before and didn't have direct criminal experience, is my understanding. Answer?
- 11:57That's correct. I had supervised civil rights for a example,
- 12:00had supervised criminal prosecutions, but I had not been a
- 12:04line prosecutor previously. Questions, So, as the US attorney supervising
- 12:08a couple one hundred answer right, question, line prosecutors most
- 12:12involved in criminal work? What interested you most or appealed
- 12:16to you most as you undertook and carried out your
- 12:19duties as US attorney? Answer? What interested me and appealed
- 12:23to me? So the work of the office. I mean,
- 12:26it's a broad question, but the work that office, in
- 12:29any US Attorney office, I think is incredibly impactful to
- 12:32any local community. And I very much enjoyed being part
- 12:35of the effort to bring folks to justice, to move
- 12:38policy initiatives. You know, I recall early on we identified
- 12:42health care fraud as one big, one big area, and
- 12:46we had one of the largest, one of the largest
- 12:48health care fraud initiatives. You know, we focus quite a
- 12:51bit on gun violence and we did a great job
- 12:54on that. And it's one of those jobs where people
- 12:57feel very good about what they do, and it's great
- 12:59to be a part of of question that's helpful. It
- 13:05just gives us answer. Yeah, question some perspective question, Was
- 13:10there any aspect of it that you particularly disliked answer
- 13:13to the extent you're dealing with personal issues. I think
- 13:16personnel issues are rarely the preferred part of any executive function.
- 13:22Question you mean the conflicts among attorneys things like that,
- 13:26or performance issues. Answer performance issues question? All right, answer,
- 13:32And you know, when you've got in any large office,
- 13:34you got personal issues, disciplinary issues, and those are never
- 13:39those are never fun. All right. We're going to wrap
- 13:42up this episode right here, and in the next episode
- 13:44dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where we
- 13:47left off. All of the information that goes with this
- 13:49episode can be found in the description box.