Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Gulf Breeze: the incident (part 1 of 2)
Transcript
- 0:03from the unexplained to the mundane. Come join
- 0:06us on a Journey to the Fringe. Hello and welcome
- 0:12to Journey to the Fringe. And Chelsea, I don't
- 0:15really have an opener. It's more on a side that
- 0:17we need to go over right now. I think it is only
- 0:21due to societal pressures that we pronounce it
- 0:24dandelions and not dandelions. and I can't get
- 0:29it out of my head and I just need that to be
- 0:31known to people. There are so many things that
- 0:33could be pronounced in a different way that could
- 0:36you imagine though if you're just talking to
- 0:38someone in there like dandelions? Yeah, somebody
- 0:41who had only read the word and looked at those
- 0:44beautiful dandelions. In a social setting and
- 0:49like, I think I would ponder it for a minute
- 0:51before he's like, okay, was he trying to say
- 0:54dandelion? Yeah, I don't know if I hadn't thought
- 0:56of that. If somebody said that, I would fully
- 0:58assume they're talking about dandelions at that
- 1:01point. But it sounds flowery, that name, does
- 1:04it not? It sounds like it's how it actually should
- 1:06be, but for societal pressures. There ought to
- 1:09be a day where you just pronounce things weird.
- 1:12Try pronouncing things new. What would you call
- 1:14that day? It needs to be there. Alternate pronunciation
- 1:18day. The funnest day on the earth. I am so excited
- 1:22to go pray to our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ,
- 1:25personally. Yes. Anyhow, we are your podcast
- 1:30hosts, Taylor and Chelsea. Here today, probably
- 1:33covering a two -parter in what... Mayor may not
- 1:37be to connected stories it's weird to explain
- 1:41starting out here but what we go through the
- 1:44entire story it's gonna make more sense okay
- 1:46i'm really curious what's this about we are talking
- 1:50about the ufo hotbed. Golf breeze florida have
- 1:54you ever heard. I need to look at the. No, no,
- 2:04I haven't I haven't maybe I have though. Maybe
- 2:07I have I need more information at this point
- 2:10What weirdly enough I bought secondhand? I think
- 2:13this is like four years ago at a used bookstore
- 2:16a book called the golf breeze incident Oh wait,
- 2:19I think I have heard this but vaguely I can't
- 2:22think of anything It's written by an Edward Walters
- 2:25who we're going to be talking a lot about in
- 2:27this episode. I'm actually glad if you haven't
- 2:29heard about this one. This is a really fun story
- 2:32that takes some twists and turns that we're going
- 2:34to go through and just learn like why Golf Breeze
- 2:37is significant in the UFO community. I always
- 2:40love a good twist and a turn and potentially
- 2:42an asshole to look into at a later date. This
- 2:45is where we're looking into him. We'll learn
- 2:48about him. Okay, good. I would hope so. Okay,
- 2:52good. strap yourselves in. For some reason, our
- 2:55seats as podcasters do have seat belts. Yep.
- 2:58You as podcaster listeners, I don't think they're
- 3:00mandatory, but you should just invest in some
- 3:02good seat belts for your seats. You probably
- 3:04should, because mine's done up. You've told you
- 3:06so many times to do it. I know. And you wouldn't
- 3:10believe how many times the seat belt has come
- 3:12in handy while we've been recording. Well and
- 3:15you gotta admit, you guys look really awkward
- 3:17when I say strap yourselves in and you guys do
- 3:19the like fastening your seatbelt motion like
- 3:21you're on a plane and just look like a fool in
- 3:24public because you don't have that seatbelt with
- 3:26you. You would look so much better if you had
- 3:29the seatbelt. It's true, just to do it up while
- 3:32everyone was watching you pretend to do it up.
- 3:35Judging you. With those eyes. We know the eyes.
- 3:41Anyhow, Chelsea, our story starts in the 80s,
- 3:44specifically on November 11th, 1987, when a building
- 3:47contractor by the name of Edward Walters is working
- 3:50late at his home when he notices a strange light
- 3:53outside his property. Intrigued, he made his
- 3:55way to the window to see what the source of the
- 3:58glow might be. What was it? A glowing object
- 4:00hovering in the sky, although his view was partially
- 4:03obscured by a tree outside his house. Wanting
- 4:05to get a better view, Walters immediately ventures
- 4:08outside. Good choice. He makes a of good choices
- 4:11actually as we get going here. I love that for
- 4:13him. As soon as he stepped outside he realized
- 4:16he was viewing something out of the ordinary.
- 4:18He would later describe the object quote top
- 4:21shaped craft which I think he means like a spinning
- 4:23top end quote. Okay. Sorry I need to end the
- 4:26quote differently there but you guys all get
- 4:28what I was trying to do. They're strapped in
- 4:30of course they do. Yes this is why you have the
- 4:34straps. The top had a circle of bright lights
- 4:38on the underside. Around the edges were what
- 4:40appeared to be dark square windows that were
- 4:43separated by portals, as he called them. Upon
- 4:46coming to his senses, he sees it, he's like,
- 4:49whoa, and he's like, wait, I clearly need a camera.
- 4:52So he goes and gets his Polaroid camera, grabs
- 4:55it, comes back outside, and he snaps several
- 4:58photos of the phenomenon from his front yard.
- 5:01Wanting to get a better view, he left his front
- 5:02yard, steps out onto the street. heads closer
- 5:05to the UFO and takes several more photos as he
- 5:07does this. A moment later the object headed in
- 5:10his direction and then hovered directly over
- 5:12where he was standing and he took five Polaroids
- 5:15of the object in the sky outside his home. Walters
- 5:18reported seeing the object hover about 200 feet
- 5:21above the ground describing it as being quote
- 5:23right out of a Spielberg movie end quote. As
- 5:27he looked at the craft, a sudden bright blue
- 5:30beam of light came from its underside and struck
- 5:33him. He said the force of the light was so strong
- 5:35that he was even lifted several feet from the
- 5:38ground. He later described the moment to a local
- 5:41newspaper stating that as soon as the light hit
- 5:43him, he was unable to move his arms and that
- 5:45his entire body appeared blue. He further recalled
- 5:48that he was, quote, trying to breathe, but my
- 5:50chest wouldn't expand, end quote. At the same
- 5:53time, a voice appeared in his head stating that
- 5:56he should not worry and that, quote, we will
- 5:59not harm you, end quote. Despite these assurances,
- 6:02Walter screamed to be put down. He also recalled
- 6:05a, quote, piercing smell, a little scent of ammonia
- 6:08mixed with heavy cinnamon. We've heard cinnamon
- 6:11before. I don't know where. I don't really remember
- 6:14that. You don't? No. End quote. And this scent,
- 6:18quote, scorched and then stuck to, end quote,
- 6:21the back of his throat. Things then turned even
- 6:24more bizarre as he began seeing pictures and
- 6:27images of dogs in his head, further describing
- 6:29this as if he was turning pages in a book in
- 6:32his mind while humming sounds began resonating
- 6:34in his head. The next memory he had was waking
- 6:36up on the ground. He looked up and around him
- 6:38and the strange craft was now nowhere to be seen.
- 6:41Dazed and perplexed at what had transpired, Walters
- 6:44returned to his house with his camera. November
- 6:4617th of the same year, Ed goes and contacts a
- 6:50local newspaper, the Gulf Breeze Sentinel, and
- 6:52met with an editor and told him of events occurring
- 6:55six nights earlier, as well as presenting this
- 6:57photographic evidence. However, Ed did so under
- 7:00the guise of having been given the photos by
- 7:02somebody else named Mr. X and remained anonymous
- 7:05during this time. That seems like an odd thing
- 7:08to do. However, days and weeks go by and he would
- 7:11eventually claim He claims further sightings
- 7:15and eventually admits that he was the anonymous
- 7:17friend who was the witness to these bizarre happenings.
- 7:20So November 11th, the first sighting, November
- 7:2217th, when he goes and talks to the newspaper.
- 7:25On the evening of November 20th, Walters claimed
- 7:27to suddenly be able to hear voices coming from
- 7:30somewhere, as well as a hum that filled his head
- 7:33during his initial encounter. He left what he
- 7:35was doing and made his way outside. Once there,
- 7:38he could see a glowing orb -like object that
- 7:41was descending. Then it stopped and hovered in
- 7:43place for several moments allowing him to take,
- 7:45again, more photos of it. Several weeks later,
- 7:48at around 3 .30am on December 2nd, the family's
- 7:52pet dog awoke Walter from sleep with its sudden
- 7:55barking. Walter's got out of bed, headed to the
- 7:58French doors where the dog had its focus, and
- 8:00Walter's opened the blinds and was beyond shocked
- 8:02to see a strange figure standing directly outside
- 8:06looking at him. He described the creature as
- 8:08being around four feet tall with a particularly
- 8:10large head and black eyes. Walters claims that
- 8:13he was surprised at the sight that he momentarily
- 8:16fell to the ground in shock after the two locked
- 8:19stairs for several moments and the strange figure
- 8:21turned around and began to walk away. At this
- 8:24point, Walters opens the door, began to pursue
- 8:26the creature, and after taking only a few steps,
- 8:29the bright blue beam of light rapidly descended
- 8:32from above and instantly paralyzed him. He looked
- 8:35on as the small figure headed off into the field
- 8:37and disappeared from sight. I'm finding a couple
- 8:40things interesting already. Don't worry, there's
- 8:42more to the story. There will be more interesting
- 8:45things. Okay. A moment later, the blue beam retracted
- 8:49and he could move once more. Already with his
- 8:51camera in hand, he took a picture of the object.
- 8:52now hovering over the field where the creature
- 8:55went headed, shooting a blue beam down to the
- 8:57ground. Walter stated that it was his belief
- 9:00that this second beam was, quote, picking up
- 9:02the creature, end quote, that had been outside
- 9:05the house. Two nights later, in early hours of
- 9:08December 5th, holy Jesus, Ed awoke in the middle
- 9:11of the night and witnessed objects hovering over
- 9:14the high school that was near Walter's home.
- 9:16After several moments, the object descended.
- 9:18Although Ed could not tell if it hovered just
- 9:21above the ground or it actually landed. In total,
- 9:23over this time period, Chelsea, from November
- 9:2611th, December 5th, he took 32 photos and one
- 9:30video recording of the object over these sightings.
- 9:33It's funny, if I Google it, only like three or
- 9:36four come up, actually. They're actually all
- 9:39in the book, funny enough. I mean, that's probably
- 9:42a red flag. Don't worry. There will be time for
- 9:44red flags when we get to red flags, Chelsea.
- 9:46Oh, they're just a fly in. They're just a fly
- 9:50in out right now. OK. But I'm keeping my mouth
- 9:53shut so far. By this time not only had many in
- 9:57the local community heard about Walter's claims
- 9:59but so did Mufon who contacted Ed in order to
- 10:03conduct an investigation into these enigmatic
- 10:05events. Oh man. So Mufon gets involved here and
- 10:09after examining the photographs and listening
- 10:11to the details that Ed accounts they are largely
- 10:15impressed and even describe it as one of the
- 10:18most incredible cases in modern UFO history.
- 10:21They had even provided Walters with specialized
- 10:24cameras and equipment so that he could capture
- 10:26clear images should he have any further encounters.
- 10:50I love that for this story. Investigators also
- 10:55began to collect other sightings from Gulf Breeze
- 10:57and nearby residents. So it's not just him seeing
- 11:00this. One of these events even occurred on the
- 11:04same day as Walter's initial sighting on November
- 11:0711th, several hours earlier at 4 30 a .m. Arthur
- 11:10Hooford. claimed that on the afternoon in question,
- 11:14he and his wife witnessed an object that looked
- 11:16exactly like the one photographed by Walters
- 11:18hovering over trees in Pensacola. Resting. In
- 11:22an article of Hufford's report, Jackie Brooks
- 11:25wrote in the New Journal that he was a, quote,
- 11:28quiet, sober, involved, intelligent, unquote,
- 11:32man, and someone, quote, you would trust to tell
- 11:34the truth, end quote. In the same article, she
- 11:36also highlighted a similar sighting by Dr. Fenner
- 11:38McConnell, describing him as a, quote, Well -respected
- 11:41man of community and someone known for extreme
- 11:44views or exotic notions. I feel like that's wrong,
- 11:47but I'm gonna keep going with it Okay, I have
- 11:50to assume they mean not known for extreme views
- 11:52or exotic notions, but that's not what it says
- 11:54I always wonder if I was to ever see a UFO like
- 11:58how people would describe me as either being
- 12:01credible or not Are people still respected in
- 12:05communities anymore? That's my one question Yeah,
- 12:11maybe. Like, community might be used loosely.
- 12:16I feel like it's just not hated within the community
- 12:19nowadays, because I feel like that's the only
- 12:20reputation you get anymore. What with society
- 12:23killing the idea of community? That's true, but
- 12:25you would have to ask people directly, because
- 12:27if you ask people on social media, like, everyone
- 12:30would hate you, I think. Because you get behind
- 12:33a screen and people feel a lot looser to give
- 12:37their full opinions. I mean, it really depends
- 12:39on what you mean by social media. If it's blue
- 12:41sky, they might say good things. If it's Twitter,
- 12:44whatever they call it now these days, there might
- 12:46be a few N words and other things thrown around.
- 12:50Yeah, I've seen people's opinions. I think there's
- 12:54a little bit too much leeway given. Well, not
- 12:57leeway, just ability now that people shouldn't
- 13:01have. It's too easy to give their opinion. Anyhow,
- 13:04not known for his extreme views or exotic notions
- 13:06and like huge his accounts work were operated
- 13:09by his wife. So these seem to line up and MUFON
- 13:14is pumped that they have this kind of sighting
- 13:17going on with multiple times over the course
- 13:20of months and photographic evidence from each
- 13:22time it happens. Like super pumped. But as they
- 13:25get going a few holes start to show up. Oh no.
- 13:29Many, even in the UFO community, were far from
- 13:31convinced from Walters credibility. Just one
- 13:34of whom was the Center for UFO Studies. One of
- 13:36the main refutes against Walters is that he intentionally
- 13:39produced the photographs using double exposure
- 13:41techniques and a toy model. Which Chelsea, I
- 13:44don't know if you know what double exposure is.
- 13:45It's basically when you take one picture and
- 13:47then take another picture on top of it. Oh, okay.
- 13:50Which makes it look like something completely
- 13:52different. Yeah. But, you know, with a Polaroid,
- 13:55it's hard to do that. Is it? Yeah, because the
- 13:58photo comes out once you do it. Yeah, but then
- 14:01you just take another Polaroid of that photo.
- 14:04That's not quite how that works. It's because
- 14:06the film gets exposed. You can re -expose the
- 14:09film to another shot and it'll have an underprint
- 14:12of the first photo in it. Oh, okay. Do you understand
- 14:15that? Yeah. It's basically how ghosts kind of
- 14:17show up on some pictures is because there was
- 14:20a negative already on there that when it took
- 14:22the photo and it gets a little blurry because
- 14:24of it. Oh, I didn't know that. That's actually
- 14:27it can explain away some of the ghost photos.
- 14:30I've actually never heard that theory put forth
- 14:33before. Oh, okay. Which is super interesting.
- 14:36And the veracity of these claims appeared even
- 14:38more certain when ufologist Zan Overall seemingly
- 14:41discovered that Walters did indeed he'd have
- 14:43the knowledge of how to do double exposure techniques
- 14:46and the capability to utilize them. Even those
- 14:49who did not accuse Walters of perpetrating a
- 14:51hoax were not as convinced of the photograph's
- 14:53authenticity. The National Enquirer asked a photo
- 14:56expert with NASA, Dr. Robert Nathan, to analyze
- 14:59the pictures as they were interested in running
- 15:00a story on Walters' accounts. Ultimately, however,
- 15:03he stated his findings were inconclusive and
- 15:06so couldn't say with certainty that they weren't
- 15:08fake. There were also details that came to light
- 15:11such as Walters reported paying a fee to Dr.
- 15:14Bruce McCabe in order to write a chapter in a
- 15:17potential book he had been given a six -figure
- 15:19advance for that he was to call UFO's proof positive.
- 15:23A little weird thing there. Just a little weird
- 15:26thing. However, when the publisher had the photographs
- 15:29analyzed, they received a similar report that
- 15:32was given by Dr. Robert Nathan and ultimately
- 15:34had the title of the book changed to The Golf
- 15:37Breeze Sightings. Interesting. We should also
- 15:40note that during this time, Walter's wife and
- 15:43family stood by his accounts. Furthermore, in
- 15:45February of 88, Walter's passed two polygraph
- 15:48tests regarding his claims. Now, despite the
- 15:51skeptics, however, further sightings of the bizarre
- 15:53object hovering and moving over the region continued
- 15:55to unfold, with Walter's himself recording several
- 15:58more apparent close encounters. Indeed, although
- 16:01he began by giving his information under the
- 16:03guise of a go -between, he quickly became a celebrity
- 16:05in the state of Florida, even appearing appearing
- 16:07on several television shows that wish to examine
- 16:10his apparent evidence of visitation. With all
- 16:13of this fame and fortune, he moved out of the
- 16:15house where most of the sightings had occurred
- 16:18and he moved elsewhere in the region to an undisclosed
- 16:20location. And he specifically kind of says that
- 16:23he did this because he was getting too big in
- 16:25the UFO world and he wanted to be kind of remain
- 16:28anonymous, not have people come visit him in
- 16:29his house. That property stood empty for close
- 16:33to a year. And when it was clear to the UFO adventure
- 16:36seekers that Walters had indeed gone for good,
- 16:39the house was finally bought by somebody named
- 16:41Robert Menzer. that name's gonna come up again
- 16:43here soon. Really? Okay. Actually, immediately.
- 16:47I didn't realize it was immediately. I thought
- 16:49it was a little further down. Menzer moves in
- 16:52and he says in the June 10th 1990 edition of
- 16:56the Pensacola News Journal that he had ventured
- 16:59into the loft of the house in order to turn off
- 17:02water so he could install a new ice maker and
- 17:04as he was moving insulation in the attic he finds
- 17:09a model UFO. No way! And he claims it. Does this
- 17:15guy have both of his arms? Robert Menzer or Ed
- 17:18Walters? Ed Walters. I assume so, why? This is
- 17:23getting a little suspicious, and I don't know,
- 17:26Billy Mayer would have never left the homeland.
- 17:29Yeah, they don't speak enough German in Florida.
- 17:31He's not going there. No, they really don't know.
- 17:33Okay. So Menzer says that the object was made
- 17:36of two foam plates and two slightly smaller foam
- 17:39plates with paper rings in between them, onto
- 17:41which windows had seemingly been drawn. Perhaps
- 17:44even more damaging when the paper was removed,
- 17:46records of a house sale were discovered in handwriting
- 17:49that appeared to match that of Walters. In response
- 17:52to the find, Walters completely dismisses this
- 17:54and he says, quote, only a fool would leave behind
- 17:57such a piece of evidence. End quote. Further
- 18:01stating that the model have clearly been quote
- 18:03unquote planted in order to discredit both him
- 18:06and the many sightings he had experienced. He
- 18:09added that the house sale records were his papers
- 18:11and that they related to a house sale which fell
- 18:13through two years after his initial sightings
- 18:15in November of 1987. I don't really get the sale
- 18:18of the house papers thing, but whatever. I think
- 18:22it's just tying it to him that they were found
- 18:25together. Oh, yeah. Fair enough. Yeah. And they
- 18:29likely would have been his if it was found with
- 18:31papers of his. Yeah okay that makes sense. He
- 18:34stated that he often found people searching in
- 18:37his trash and that someone must have retrieved
- 18:39the house paperwork from there. In another twist,
- 18:42investigators eventually discovered that the
- 18:43plans did indeed match those of a housing project
- 18:45for 1989 that had fallen through. Walter stated
- 18:48the model Mincer had discovered was not at all
- 18:51like the crafts he'd photographed. Although he
- 18:54stopped short of accusing Menzer of being behind
- 18:56the model, he heavily hinted at it. We should
- 18:59note that Menzer only revealed the model's existence
- 19:02when a reporter arrived at the property in relation
- 19:04to the former owner. That is hilarious. He didn't
- 19:08actually go to the papers for it. This paper
- 19:10wanted to write a story about it. He's like,
- 19:12oh yeah, I found this. Does this help your claim
- 19:14at all? If this guy had any brains, he would
- 19:18have been like, yeah, I was just trying to recreate
- 19:20the UFO that I saw. I don't know. Like, if we
- 19:24know anything about how the world works now,
- 19:26it's either you deny or you don't even answer
- 19:29the question and you just completely respond
- 19:31to something else. Like, that's how the world
- 19:33works these days. And he didn't do a bad job
- 19:34with that. Yeah. Now, with those cases at the...
- 19:38All that happening, Walters appears to kind of
- 19:41weather the storm and his claims of the model
- 19:43being a plant are taken pretty well by actually
- 19:46the people who believe him. Then, something else
- 19:50happens, Chelsea. Oh, I'm so excited. What happens?
- 19:53What happens? So the following week, June 17th,
- 19:561990 edition of the Pensacola News Journal, another
- 19:59article appears concerning Walters UFO sightings.
- 20:01In it, a teenager by the name of Tom Smith claims
- 20:05that he had assisted Walters in making the UFO
- 20:07model. just before the sightings began. He went
- 20:10on that Walters had first taken pictures of the
- 20:14model which had been made to give the appearance
- 20:16of glowing and then taken pictures of the night
- 20:18sky using the same frame on the film, which is
- 20:21what double exposure is. He even revealed that
- 20:25to make it appear that a UFO had landed in a
- 20:27nearby field, Walters had turned a trampoline
- 20:29upside down and then jumped on it over and over
- 20:33again in order to flatten the grass and vegetation
- 20:35in the shape of the round object. Smith continued
- 20:37that, to begin with, he thought Walters was merely
- 20:40going to play a joke on family or friends. However,
- 20:43when he asked him to take the photographs to
- 20:45the newspaper as if he had taken them in order
- 20:48to make the story more believable, Smith realized
- 20:50that Walters was looking to dupe the media and
- 20:53publicize for financial gain. Not wanting to
- 20:55get caught in a fraud, not least as he didn't
- 20:58want to disappoint his family, Smith declined
- 21:00to further be involved. When Smith's parents
- 21:03were interviewed about their son's claims, they
- 21:05stated that what he was saying was true and that
- 21:08he had told them about the trickery before. And
- 21:11while they had urged him to come forward with
- 21:14the truth, he wished to stay out of the affair
- 21:15until now. So this was three years after the
- 21:18whole thing. And you got to think about it, I
- 21:19don't know how old he was at that time, but three
- 21:22years for a teenager is a lot of time to grow
- 21:25up. That's true. That's true. But this story
- 21:28just keeps going, Chelsea. So providing further
- 21:30interesting backstory to the claims of the Smith
- 21:32family was the fact that Smith was running against
- 21:35Ed Walters for city council. What? The dad of
- 21:39the teenager who allegedly helped him do this
- 21:42is running against him for city council. Ed Wolter's
- 21:46apparently got involved in politics, and this
- 21:48is when it all comes out. Oh my god. Of course
- 21:51he's getting involved in politics. Yeah, he's
- 21:55got money, he's a celebrity. Coincidentally or
- 21:58not, around the same time their son came forward
- 22:00with the claims is when this all happened. So
- 22:06the Smith family could have some motive for saying
- 22:09this. Yes. Yeah. This, as we might imagine, led
- 22:13those who backed Walters' accounts as proof and
- 22:15fact to accuse Tom Smith of not only lying, but
- 22:18of the Smith family being behind the plant of
- 22:21the model in the first place so that they could
- 22:23then publicly humiliate Walters. But of course,
- 22:26Smith family denies this. Those who side with
- 22:28Walters turn their attention to the claims made
- 22:30by Smith. For example, landing spot that was
- 22:32examined and investigated did not grow vegetation
- 22:35for almost 18 months. So they say. And what's
- 22:38more, no chemicals or other agents were discovered
- 22:42that could have caused the lack of growth, in
- 22:43a perfect circle no less. This was something
- 22:46that certainly could not be produced by jumping
- 22:48on an upside -down trampoline. There was also
- 22:50the details that Smith had given regarding how
- 22:52Walters achieved the blue beam of light shown
- 22:54in one of the pictures. He had claimed that Walters
- 22:56had peeled away ever so slightly the back of
- 22:59the film. This was something that those with
- 23:01knowledge of photography stated would not achieve
- 23:03such a result. Perhaps even more damaging for
- 23:05Smith's claim were that, as well as those who
- 23:08believe double exposure was the cause of the
- 23:10UFO in the photograph, is that no photographic
- 23:12expert could produce a double -exposed using
- 23:15the camera that Walter said he used, a Sun 600
- 23:18Polaroid. Perhaps most damaging of all to Smith's
- 23:21claims was the fact that there's absolutely no
- 23:23evidence whatsoever that Smith had ever met Walter's
- 23:26before or after the sighting. Which, I don't
- 23:29know, there's not a lot of paper evidence, even
- 23:31in this day and age, of any relationships people
- 23:34have with teenagers. That's just how it works,
- 23:37is it not? Unless you're related to them. So
- 23:40Smith offered in response to this that Ed had
- 23:43used Smith's camera to take the photographs and
- 23:46not the Polaroid which he said he even produced
- 23:48these fake UFO pictures and made them available
- 23:52to the media to prove how easily he could do
- 23:54it and when these pictures were analyzed no evidence
- 23:57whatsoever could be found to show that these
- 23:59were fake meaning perhaps ironically by their
- 24:01own standard they had declared the pictures authentic
- 24:04images of UFOs. What? He's like oh yeah no those
- 24:07didn't come from a Polaroid they came from my
- 24:09camera I can even show you how I did it and he
- 24:11made more UFO photos and they're like, yeah these
- 24:13appear to be authentic Basically when they say
- 24:16authentic they just mean they haven't been tampered
- 24:18with Further turns in the already strange affair
- 24:21occur following Walter's self -publishing of
- 24:23the book, which I talked about before, that contained
- 24:26many of the photographs. As we might imagine,
- 24:29many people were eager to see the pictures close
- 24:31up for themselves, both believers and skeptics
- 24:33alike, and one picture in particular drew the
- 24:35attention of skeptics, as one wore the UFOs just
- 24:38above a road. In this image, an apparent UFO
- 24:41is hovering and casts a reflection on the road
- 24:43below. However, this picture was examined by
- 24:45one particular photographic expert, and it was
- 24:47determined that the were approximately nine times
- 24:50larger than normal, suggesting that these reflections
- 24:53were not coming from the road, but were suspended
- 24:55in the air. Further analysis suggested that the
- 24:58reflections didn't match the bottom of the underside
- 25:00of the craft and that the road appeared too bright
- 25:03to be a reflection from the object. Although
- 25:06it appeared that Walters had finally been exposed,
- 25:09some investigators pointed out that if the object
- 25:11had been at an angle while the photographs had
- 25:14been taken, this would explain the long shadows
- 25:16and discrepancy in them matching the craft's
- 25:18underside and the brightness of the road. Now
- 25:20despite these the counterclaims to the apparent
- 25:22exposures of Walters photographs being fakes,
- 25:26it appeared at least as far as Mufon was concerned,
- 25:29who really liked Walters at the time, that it
- 25:32was finally time for them to withdraw support.
- 25:35Oh, thank God. So after all of this happens,
- 25:37they finally go out and in a state regarding
- 25:40matter, they offer their belief in UFOs and that
- 25:42they had, quote, entered this investigation with
- 25:44a natural and favorable bias towards Walters
- 25:47case. But our investigation and analysis lend
- 25:50to the conclusion that several, if not all of
- 25:52the photographs are probable hoaxes, end quote.
- 25:55But regardless of Mufon's position, the fact
- 25:58is that there were many more than just Ed Walters,
- 26:02who also claimed to have seen UFOs in the Gulf
- 26:04Breeze region of Florida during the late 80s,
- 26:07early 90s. According to some sources, around
- 26:10200 other people in the region made reports of
- 26:13similar objects to those allegedly reported photographed
- 26:17by Walters, with some of them even offering their
- 26:20own photographs. One resident, Bland Pew, which
- 26:23is a terrible name. managed to capture a picture
- 26:27of an apparent alien craft in 93. This is an
- 26:30absolutely terrible picture, so don't even bother
- 26:32looking at it. Furthermore, in 1990, a group
- 26:35of witnesses and believers organized themselves
- 26:37into a loose organization that was dedicated
- 26:39to studying sightings as well as documenting
- 26:42any further encounters. And they would not be
- 26:45disappointed observing and documenting several
- 26:47encounters, including one that is similar to
- 26:50the object to the one Walters claimed to have
- 26:53seen. that had red lights on the underside. Although
- 26:55the concentration of sightings in Gulf Breeze
- 26:57began to slow as the 90s unfolded, reports of
- 27:00bizarre aerial crafts continue to come from that
- 27:03region, and it remains a location with more than
- 27:05its fair share of UFO activity. The surge of
- 27:08activity, however, at the end of the 80s into
- 27:10the early 90s arguably remains the region's most
- 27:13active years. In response to the Gulf Breeze
- 27:16sightings, MUFON ends up holding its first annual
- 27:19UFO symposium in nearby Pensacola, 1990. attracting
- 27:23hundreds of attendees. The conference continued
- 27:27for a remainder of the decade in this area and
- 27:29the director of tourism for Golf Breeze said
- 27:31that the free publicity attracted tourists and
- 27:34UFO sightseers. A local travel agent even said
- 27:37that she arranged 600 flights for the MUFON conference.
- 27:41Merchants began selling UFO related goods in
- 27:43the area. That's crazy. It ends up being a big
- 27:46thing. And that is the year immediately after
- 27:49Bill Moore did his weird rant up at the MUFON
- 27:54symposium. So this was the one they followed
- 27:56that up with. It's not looking good for MUFON
- 27:59at this time. It's sure not. I should note in
- 28:031993, somebody from News Journal revisited this,
- 28:06named Curtis, the evidence against Walter's account
- 28:09mentioning a friend of the Walters family, Tommy
- 28:11Smith, that come forward admitting to, quote,
- 28:13witness Ed faking UFO pictures, end quote, as
- 28:16a practical joke. Curtis also reported that Walters
- 28:19and his wife had divorced in 92 and they had
- 28:22to split $2 .5 million in assets that Curtis
- 28:25believed came from the hoax. So he got a ton
- 28:28of money from this entire thing and like got
- 28:31a book deal out of it. Now, right in and around
- 28:35the MUFON 1990 symposium in Gulf Breeze area,
- 28:38there's a group called the Gulf Breeze Six, and
- 28:41it is six people who went AWOL from the military
- 28:45and were posted in Germany, and they ended up
- 28:47getting arrested in an area at that time. And
- 28:51that's gonna be part two of this story. Whether
- 28:54or not it's related to any of this, we're gonna
- 28:56see. I'm gonna keep it vague at that point, but
- 28:59it's just so weird that this other thing up happening
- 29:02right around this and engulf Breeze. So I think
- 29:06this is a good place to end it. It is a wild
- 29:08story. And go ahead. You already mentioned Bill
- 29:11Moore. I think we ought to throw Mufon on the
- 29:14future episode list. At this point, it's not
- 29:17a bad idea. I think between the 80s and the 90s,
- 29:20they have a ton of baggage that never heard addressed.
- 29:24Yeah. My other thing that immediately I went
- 29:28to when I was like red flags everywhere was the
- 29:30being that he saw on his front door, which I
- 29:34believe was described as a gray. Yeah. Guess
- 29:37when communion came out. Oh, man. Is it 87? It
- 29:40is. Yeah. Yeah. February 1987, and this I believe
- 29:44you said was November 87, which was a wildly
- 29:47popular time for to graze. If you've ever heard
- 29:51the story of communion and the cover of communion,
- 29:54that was my other thing that I immediately went
- 29:57to. I just want to add this too, at this point,
- 30:00when we're talking about the grays. Thank you
- 30:01for bringing that up, because they maybe remember.
- 30:03That totally reminded me of the Stanley Tiger
- 30:06story. I know. That was the other thing. I'm
- 30:09glad you said that. It is almost exactly like...
- 30:13Technology was too good for Stanley Tiger, so
- 30:15it became very obvious. It reminds me exactly
- 30:20of the Stanley Tigers story. This guy that just
- 30:23happens to be constantly surrounded by UFOs.
- 30:27Just getting like the best footage. Stanley Tigers
- 30:32is so good with the grays in his house. Yes,
- 30:37thank you for following my own train of thought
- 30:40that I forgot because that was my other thing.
- 30:42It sounds exactly like Stanley Tiger. Bill Moore
- 30:45being in Mufon in and around the same time, which
- 30:48it doesn't seem like he's like talking about
- 30:51this, but maybe they needed this to kind of distract
- 30:55from the mess that Bill Moore made. To be fair,
- 30:59Bill Moore was too busy with his own drama going
- 31:01on at this time to really address this. and it
- 31:06being very close to. And he got it. I mean, most
- 31:10people will be like, I don't want to make money
- 31:12off of this. You don't see me getting rich, but
- 31:14this guy got rich. He already had a book deal.
- 31:16He already had a book deal, like right as it's
- 31:19going on. Yeah, so those are just all the things
- 31:23that I noticed about the story. So yeah, every
- 31:26now and then you might hear about the Gulf Breeze
- 31:28incident. This is literally it. Oh, and I forgot
- 31:30to mention too, there is a fairly large Air Force
- 31:33base very close to Gulf Breeze, which does somewhat
- 31:37explain the sightings. And in fact... Oh, I guess
- 31:40so. People did go talk to the base as well and
- 31:42say, like, hey, was there anything weird on your
- 31:44radar these nights? They said no. Nothing weird
- 31:46was on a radar any of the nights that - As a
- 31:48matter of fact, yes! And Walter saw it! Yeah.
- 31:52Oh. Because we always hear that come up with
- 31:56these UFO stories that the military just comes
- 31:59clean about the secret shit that they're testing.
- 32:02Don't worry about us, is what they say. Yeah,
- 32:05maybe. I don't know. Who's asking? We're definitely
- 32:09not gonna have Richard Doty be in contact. Okay,
- 32:17good story. I love a good Stanley Tiger story.
- 32:20The next one is even more bizarre, but it's going
- 32:22to be the second part because we are like roughly
- 32:25at the right time for an episode. And I think
- 32:28the other one's going to be just as long. Fantastic.
- 32:31So we'll leave it here. I have been Taylor here
- 32:33with Chelsea. We are Journey to the Fringe. Thank
- 32:35you all for listening and we'll see you next
- 32:36week. Bye. Thank you for listening to Journey
- 32:42to the Fringe. If you have liked what you have
- 32:44listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or
- 32:48follow, depending on what. venue you are listening
- 32:51to us through. Also, please, if possible, leave
- 32:54a five -star review, as that really helps us
- 32:57in the algorithms. Should you wish to interact
- 33:00with us, please check us out on your social media
- 33:02of choice. I bet you we are there. And if you
- 33:05really want to communicate with us and give us
- 33:07ideas for new episodes or tell us that we're
- 33:10wrong and terrible, either way, please send us
- 33:12an email at journeytothefringe at gmail .com.
- 33:16For now, I'll see you in the next episode.