Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Can We Show That? Depicting Third-Party IP in Film & Television
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Can We Show That? Depicting third
- 0:06party IP in film and television. I'm Keith Kelly,
- 0:10chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:12entertainment law section. The entertainment
- 0:15law section is sponsored by Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:18Company. For five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:22Company has been the only California -based company
- 0:25to continuously provide lawyers throughout the
- 0:28state with professional liability insurance coverage.
- 0:31Their experience and expertise are complemented
- 0:34by the fact that they are directed by a group
- 0:37of dedicated lawyers. They offer special rates
- 0:40with competitive premiums for a wide range of
- 0:42practice areas, including entertainment. Learn
- 0:45more at lawyersmutual .com. I'm delighted to
- 0:50introduce our speakers, Serene Atik, Tatev Ovanisyan,
- 0:54and Omar Rambert. Let me tell you a little bit
- 0:57about each one of them. Serene is an associate
- 0:59in the Entertainment, Technology, and Advertising
- 1:02Practice Group in Shepard's Dallas office. Her
- 1:05practice centers on transactional entertainment
- 1:08and advertising work, including content licensing,
- 1:12rights acquisition, and endorsement, sponsorship,
- 1:15and branded content deals. She represents advertising
- 1:18agencies, brands, studios, production companies,
- 1:22and celebrity talent. And she's known for translating
- 1:25complex agreements into plain terms so clients
- 1:29understand the protections and risks before they
- 1:31sign. Outside of the firm, she serves on the
- 1:35board of Genesis Young Leaders, which works to
- 1:38stop domestic violence in the Dallas community.
- 1:41Thanks for joining, Serene. Thanks for having
- 1:43me. Tatev is an associate in the Entertainment
- 1:46Technology and Advertising Practice Group in
- 1:48Sheppard's Century City office. She represents
- 1:51clients across the entertainment industry in
- 1:54transactional matters, including film and television
- 1:56library, rights acquisitions, music catalog acquisitions,
- 2:01chain of title diligence, and she serves as a
- 2:04production counsel on various film and television
- 2:06projects. Thanks for being here, Tatev. Finally,
- 2:11Omar. is an associate in the entertainment, technology,
- 2:14and advertising practice group at Shepard's Century
- 2:17City office, where he handles transactional entertainment
- 2:21matters, spanning television, digital media,
- 2:23film, podcasts, and audiobooks. He regularly
- 2:27serves as production counsel for numerous film
- 2:29and television clients. Now let's get started.
- 2:34Sure. One second. I'll share my screen. Okay.
- 2:45Okay. Hi, everyone. Thank you for being here
- 2:48today. And thank you, Keith, for that introduction.
- 2:51As Keith mentioned, our presentation is called
- 2:54Can We Show That? And our plan here is to just
- 2:57give you a high level practical roadmap through
- 3:00one of the more nuanced areas of entertainment
- 3:02law, which is the depiction of trademarks in
- 3:05films and TV shows. We're intentionally going
- 3:08to stay pretty high level. rather than doing
- 3:11a deep dive into any single case or spending
- 3:14half an hour unpacking one of the prongs of the
- 3:16Roger test, we wanna show you all the puzzle
- 3:19pieces and then how they fit together in real
- 3:22life. So for example, when does the Roger test
- 3:25apply? When does it not apply? How does the Supreme
- 3:28Court's Jack Daniel's decision take you out of
- 3:31Rogers? And if Rogers doesn't apply, what other
- 3:34arguments and defenses are still available to
- 3:36use? So our goal with this presentation is really
- 3:39to just empower attorneys that maybe have never
- 3:42dealt with the trademark clearance issue in the
- 3:44past with an overview of the basics in a fun
- 3:47and different way than what you may be used to.
- 3:51On a personal note, during my first year as an
- 3:54entertainment associate at Shepherd, I learned
- 3:56the most by just being a fly on the wall on a
- 3:59lot of the conversations that were going on around
- 4:01me, whether that was a conversation between a
- 4:04partner and an associate or between a partner
- 4:06and a client. A lot of the time, the questions
- 4:09that they had were questions that I had. So listening
- 4:13in on that dialogue was very helpful for me.
- 4:17It's kind of like in math when people are showing
- 4:19you how they answer the question. versus showing
- 4:22you the answer, it's easier to follow. I give
- 4:25this background because it actually inspired
- 4:28the structure of our presentation today, so bear
- 4:31with us because there is some acting involved.
- 4:36These are our emails, by the way, so if anyone
- 4:38has any questions that maybe we don't get to
- 4:40or you think of after the fact, feel free to
- 4:43reach out to either of us. Okay. Let's get started.
- 4:48We're going to set the scene a little bit. You
- 4:51are a young entertainment attorney out in LA.
- 4:54Congratulations. You graduated law school. You
- 4:56passed the bar. Made your family really proud.
- 4:59And now you have a meeting with a prospective
- 5:01client. His name is Omar and he's an up and coming
- 5:04movie producer. So together, we're going to walk
- 5:08through that initial client meeting with Serena
- 5:10and I acting as his potential attorneys. Just
- 5:14going to give a bit of a disclaimer here. This
- 5:15isn't legal advice. This is a fictional prospective
- 5:18client, and we're giving him advice in a very
- 5:20fictional setting. So with that said, Omar, thanks
- 5:26for meeting with us. Yeah, really hoping you
- 5:28guys can help me. Of course. Let's start with
- 5:31telling me a little bit about your project. Sure,
- 5:34so I want to make a movie. I'm thinking a lot
- 5:37of explosives, car chases, but also with some
- 5:40romance, fantasy elements, sci -fi, horror, comedy,
- 5:45twist. You know, I'm thinking The Notebook meets
- 5:48Obsession meets Interstellar meets Michael Bay,
- 5:52you know, and so it's still in development. I've
- 5:54hired some writers and the script is in progress.
- 5:57Wow, okay, that sounds really interesting There
- 6:00are a lot of legal considerations that are important
- 6:03to keep in mind at every stage of making a movie
- 6:05But it's most important to flag any clearance
- 6:08issues at the script stage So we're really happy
- 6:11to hear that you're meeting with us so early
- 6:13on in the process Being so proactive will definitely
- 6:16help save you time and money and protect you
- 6:18from a lot of legal disputes Now I know it's
- 6:22still in development, but tell me a little bit
- 6:24about some of the scenes you're most excited
- 6:26about There's one particular that does stand
- 6:30out. There's a part in the movie where the villain
- 6:33is going to jump out of a Jeep while he's drinking
- 6:36a Red Bull in his hand and the car crashes into
- 6:39a Chipotle and there are a lot of explosions,
- 6:41like I said. Then he's going to escape down a
- 6:44very narrow corridor with nothing in his hand
- 6:47except for a Birkin that's stuffed with cocaine.
- 6:50That is awesome, but it definitely raises some
- 6:54trademark issues. What's a trademark? So a trademark
- 7:00is any word, name, symbol, or design that identifies
- 7:04and distinguishes a source of goods or services.
- 7:07So when we say trademarks, those identify the
- 7:10source of goods and service marks identify the
- 7:13source of services. Today, when we say trademarks,
- 7:15we're using them as shorthand interchangeably.
- 7:18And most people think of trademarks as brands
- 7:20and logos, but it can be so much like broader
- 7:23than that. So for example, trademarks can include
- 7:26sounds. So think every time you turn on Netflix
- 7:29and you hear ta -dum as the letter loads, or
- 7:32it can include the MGM's lion roar. Trademarks
- 7:36can also include colors, think Tiffany Blue or
- 7:39UPS Brown. It can also include patterns and prints,
- 7:43think Louis Vuitton's monogram or Burberry check.
- 7:47And then it can also include slogans, so Nike's
- 7:50Just Do It or McDonald's' I'm Loving It. So think
- 7:53source identifier, like if you see something
- 7:55or you hear something and you know where that
- 7:57good or source came from, who made it and its
- 7:59general quality, you're probably looking at a
- 8:02trademark. And trademarks have different strengths
- 8:06that fall onto a spectrum. So where the mark
- 8:09falls on the spectrum determines how much protection
- 8:12it gets. At the strongest end, you have fanciful
- 8:15marks. These are completely made up words with
- 8:17no prior meaning. So think like Adidas, Xerox,
- 8:21Haagen -Dazs. They are invented purely to identify
- 8:24a brand. So they are inherently distinctive and
- 8:27receive the broadest protection. Then we have
- 8:30arbitrary marks. These are real words that are
- 8:33applied to products. or services that they don't
- 8:35really have a logical connection with. So think
- 8:38Apple for computers, think Amazon for retail.
- 8:42The word means something, but not in relation
- 8:45to what is being sold. And that disconnect makes
- 8:48them strong and highly protectable. And then
- 8:51you have suggestive marks. These hint at a quality
- 8:54or characteristic of the product without describing
- 8:57it directly. So think Netflix, the flicks suggest
- 9:01entertainment or Greyhound suggests speed. These
- 9:05require some imagination on the part of the consumer
- 9:07to make the connection, but they're still protectable
- 9:10without proof of secondary meaning. And then
- 9:13you have, as you move down the spectrum, you
- 9:16have descriptive marks. These are marks that
- 9:18describe a feature or quality or characteristic
- 9:21of the goods or services. They're not inherently
- 9:24protectable. To register a descriptive mark,
- 9:27you have to prove it's required some distinctiveness,
- 9:30meaning like consumers have come to associate
- 9:32it with your brand over time. And then at the
- 9:35weakest end, we have generic terms and these
- 9:37are not going to receive trademark protection.
- 9:40They're words that everyone can use. So for example,
- 9:43you can't trademark the word bread for your bakery
- 9:46or computer for a tech company. And the takeaway
- 9:50here is just simple. So the more distinctive
- 9:53and fanciful your marks are, the stronger and
- 9:55easier they are to protect. And the more descriptive
- 9:58or generic it is, the harder they are to protect.
- 10:01Okay. I don't think I need to worry about this.
- 10:04I mean, the trademarks won't be on the screen
- 10:06for too long, just a few seconds each time, so
- 10:08no biggie. You know, yes, that's an important
- 10:12consideration, but the reality is that trademark
- 10:14law doesn't have like a minimum screen time exception.
- 10:17So there's no like five second rule, like food
- 10:19you dropped on the floor that's still safe to
- 10:21eat. So although how long a mark is used will
- 10:25impact the legal analysis, the key issue is how
- 10:28the mark is used. So when we think about the
- 10:31right to use trademarks, we're balancing two
- 10:33concerns. One, protecting against consumer confusion
- 10:36on one side and then the right to free speech
- 10:39on the other side. Under trademark law, there's
- 10:42three purposes. They want to or the goal is to
- 10:46identify the source of goods and services to
- 10:48protect consumers from being confused. And to
- 10:52protect the brand owners investment in the goodwill
- 10:54that the mark represents and then like we said
- 10:57on the other side you have the first amendment
- 10:59and their purpose is different it's to protect
- 11:01free expression so. When we conduct trademark
- 11:04clearance for films we have to balance these
- 11:07two interests and the tension arises because
- 11:10trademark law doesn't auto doesn't include like
- 11:13an automatic exemption. for artistic expression,
- 11:17and the First Amendment doesn't automatically
- 11:19override trademark rights. So trademark clearance
- 11:22is not simply a matter of asking how long a mark
- 11:25appears on screen. Context is really going to
- 11:28be key here. Does that make sense? Omar? Omar,
- 11:33did I lose you? Sorry, I think I dozed off when
- 11:36you were quoting the Constitution at me. This
- 11:38is all fine and dandy, but what's the real risk
- 11:40here? If you put someone else's trademark on
- 11:43screen, there's always a risk of being sued.
- 11:46And the cherry on top is that there's lots of
- 11:48different ways to get sued. So plaintiffs can
- 11:51throw as many claims as they can at the wall
- 11:53to see what sticks. Some claims are going to
- 11:56be trademark based claims and others are not.
- 11:59So a trademark owner can sue you for infringement.
- 12:02So for example, they are alleging your use confused
- 12:05people into thinking the film came from them
- 12:08instead of you. They could sue you for dilution
- 12:11by tarnishment, which means the trademark owners
- 12:13alleging that your use. harmed the reputation
- 12:18of their famous mark by associating with something
- 12:21inferior so think like. A Birkin bag stuffed
- 12:25full of cocaine as a villain runs down a narrow
- 12:27corridor. They can sue you for dilution by blurring,
- 12:31which means they're alleging that your use weakened
- 12:33what made their mark unique. So that's, for example,
- 12:36if you're calling your plumbing company, Nike's
- 12:38plumbing services, they can sue you for like
- 12:41disparagement. Okay, okay. I get it now. I shouldn't
- 12:44doze off. This is important stuff. There are
- 12:47a lot of different ways that I can get sued.
- 12:49Now I don't even have the money to be fighting
- 12:51off these lawsuits. I'm just never going to use
- 12:53any trademarks in my films for as long as I live.
- 12:56You know that doesn't have to be the case and
- 12:58arguably isn't very practical based on the scene
- 13:00you described that you're really excited about
- 13:02shooting so how about for today we just focus
- 13:05in on the infringement claim we can talk about
- 13:07like what the law says what the trademark owner
- 13:09has to prove and how you can defend yourself.
- 13:12Sure. So the Lanham Act provides a cause of action
- 13:17for trademark owners of both registered and unregistered
- 13:21marks. For today, we're going to focus on section
- 13:2332, which provides a cause of action to owners
- 13:26of registered marks. So the trademark owner has
- 13:29to prove by preponderance of evidence that one,
- 13:32it owns a valid trademark, a valid and protectable
- 13:35trademark, and two, your use of it in your film
- 13:38creates a likelihood of confusion as to the source
- 13:42sponsorship or affiliation. I don't know. I mean,
- 13:45this likelihood confusion thing seems more applicable
- 13:48to, you know, competing products in the marketplace
- 13:50like, you know, Apple or Android or something.
- 13:54I mean, in a way, you're right. In most non -expressive
- 13:58commercial contexts, trademark infringement is
- 14:01analyzed under this likelihood of confusion test,
- 14:04where basically you would ask, would an ordinary
- 14:07consumer be likely to think that the use is sponsored
- 14:10by, affiliated with, or approved by the trademark
- 14:14owner? Courts end up weighing a set of factors.
- 14:17We'll get into this later to answer that question.
- 14:21But the good news is that in some circuits, like
- 14:24the Second and Ninth Circuit, expressive works
- 14:26like films and TV shows have a go -to defense
- 14:30designed to strike the balance that Serene was
- 14:33just talking about between the First Amendment
- 14:35and trademark law. The framework for this defense
- 14:38actually comes from a foundational Second Circuit
- 14:41case called Rogers versus Grimaldi. Rogers like
- 14:45Ginger Rogers, the iconic actress in Hollywood.
- 14:48Yes, so as you know, she was famous for her partnership
- 14:52with Fred Astaire where she appeared in classics
- 14:54like Top Hat and Swingtime through the 30s and
- 14:5840s. So Ginger ended up suing the makers of a
- 15:021986 film called Ginger and Fred which was directed
- 15:06by Federico Fellini. I haven't seen it. So basically
- 15:11the film tells the story of two fictional Italian
- 15:15cabaret performers who had spent their careers
- 15:17imitating Rodgers and Astaire on the Italian
- 15:21variety show circuit. The nickname Ginger and
- 15:24Fred was the stage name the Italian public had
- 15:28given them as a nod to their American idols.
- 15:31The film ended up following these two aging performers
- 15:34as they reunited decades later to perform one
- 15:38last time on a glitzy Italian TV special. and
- 15:42why did Roger sue? She sued alleging, among other
- 15:46things, that the use of her first name in the
- 15:49film's title violated her Lanham Act trademark
- 15:53rights. She claimed that the title of the film
- 15:55created the false impression that the film was
- 15:58about her or that she was affiliated with or
- 16:01endorsed the film. So the main question before
- 16:04the court was, whether the creator of the expressive
- 16:08work could be liable under the Lanham Act as
- 16:11well as state law for using Roger's name in the
- 16:15title of the work. And ultimately, the Second
- 16:20Circuit's answer to this question was what we
- 16:22now call the Roger Test, which is a two -prong
- 16:25framework that courts use to determine whether
- 16:29a trademark infringement claim can proceed when
- 16:31it's being asserted against an expressive work
- 16:34like a movie or a TV show. If it is an expressive
- 16:38work, the use of the trademark in the film is
- 16:40protected unless the plaintiff proves that the
- 16:45defendant's use of the mark either has no artistic
- 16:48relevance to the underlying work or explicitly
- 16:52misleads consumers as to the source or content
- 16:55of the work. So I need to pass both prongs? Yes,
- 16:59when you're doing clearance, you have to pass
- 17:01both prongs for your use of the trademark in
- 17:04the film to be protected under law. Okay, so
- 17:08artistically relevant, explicitly misleading.
- 17:10What does that even mean? Okay, let's start with
- 17:14artistic relevance. Courts have said that the
- 17:16use of the mark must have at least minimal artistic
- 17:20relevance. So the bar here is intentionally really
- 17:23low. It just has to be a little bit more than
- 17:26zero. And if the use has absolutely no artistic
- 17:30relevance, then the First Amendment isn't going
- 17:32to protect it. In this case, the title Ginger
- 17:36and Fred easily clears this bar. The entire point
- 17:40of the film was built around two performers who
- 17:43modeled themselves after Rogers and Astaire.
- 17:46So this reference to Ginger and Fred was... central
- 17:49to the story and thus was artistically relevant.
- 17:53So for your purposes, when you're trying to figure
- 17:56out whether your use is artistically relevant,
- 17:59there is a few questions you can ask yourself
- 18:01to kind of help guide that analysis. One question
- 18:04is, does the mark establish a character's wealth,
- 18:09status, taste, or personality? So If the character
- 18:13is a multi -billionaire fashion empire businesswoman,
- 18:17it would make sense for her to be wearing Chanel.
- 18:20You can also ask, does this ground the story
- 18:23in a specific time period, geography, or like
- 18:27a cultural moment? So if the film is set in the
- 18:302000s, it makes sense for the character to maybe
- 18:33own a Blackberry or talk about Blockbuster. Wow,
- 18:37yeah, Blockbuster was deep in culture at that
- 18:39time. I know. And culturally significant marks
- 18:42are more likely to be used in artistically relevant
- 18:46ways. Got it. So we're trying to be creative
- 18:49and make the world of the film feel authentic,
- 18:52realistic, things like that. Exactly. So if the
- 18:55mark makes the world feel authentic in a creative
- 18:58and expressive way, then your use likely satisfies
- 19:01this first prong of the Roger test. But if the
- 19:04answer is that the mark appeared on a prop on
- 19:06set and no one thought about it, then this prong
- 19:08would fail. Actually, have you seen Game of Thrones?
- 19:12Of course. I mean, I don't live under a rock.
- 19:15So I don't know if you remember that one episode
- 19:18when a Starbucks cup was left in the background
- 19:20of a scene. Obviously makes no sense for Starbucks
- 19:23to exist in the 13th or 14th century. And the
- 19:27tone of the show is not satire for it to be considered
- 19:29a joke. So this was clearly an accident and not
- 19:32artistically relevant. Yeah, I remember that
- 19:35the entire Internet was talking about it, but
- 19:37everyone knew that was an accident. Exactly,
- 19:40so it didn't mislead the public, but sometimes
- 19:43the use of the mark is not obviously an accident
- 19:46and people could be confused, which leads me
- 19:49to the next prong, which is no explicit misleading.
- 19:53In contrast to the artistic relevance prong,
- 19:56the bar here is actually pretty high. Just using
- 19:59the mark is generally not enough to be considered
- 20:02explicitly misleading. In this case, even though
- 20:05Rogers submitted survey evidence showing that
- 20:08consumers were misled as to her connection with
- 20:10the film, The court emphasized that mere consumer
- 20:13confusion is just not enough. The court will
- 20:17ask whether there was an explicit indication,
- 20:20an overt claim or some explicit misstatement
- 20:23that caused consumer confusion. And unfortunately
- 20:26for Ginger, the court determined that the use
- 20:28of the title was not explicitly misleading. Got
- 20:32it. Do you have any guidance for analyzing the
- 20:34second problem? Yes, so when it comes to this
- 20:37prong, some courts require an affirmative statement
- 20:41of the plaintiff's sponsorship or endorsement
- 20:44to deem it explicitly misleading. But the Ninth
- 20:48Circuit has expressly rejected the affirmative
- 20:51statement requirement and has identified two
- 20:53considerations as being relevant to assessing
- 20:56whether a use is explicitly misleading. The first
- 20:59consideration is the degree to which the defendant
- 21:02is using the mark in the manner that the plaintiff
- 21:05uses the mark. So are you putting your logo on
- 21:08the same kind of product for the same purpose
- 21:11as the original mark owner? This consideration
- 21:14looks at which markets the parties operate in.
- 21:17So if your mark is on a movie and their mark
- 21:19is on a granola bar, the marks are being used
- 21:22in different ways and for different purposes.
- 21:24So that would help the defendant. And the second
- 21:28consideration is the extent to which the defendant
- 21:31and the filmmaker has added its own expressive
- 21:33content to the work beyond the mark itself. The
- 21:38thought process here is that if you're using
- 21:40a mark as the centerpiece of an expressive work
- 21:44itself, without any of your own artistic contribution,
- 21:48then you're just using a consumer's potential
- 21:51confusion to induce a sale of your own good.
- 21:54So if you have added a lot of your own elements
- 21:57around the trademark, then it's less likely to
- 22:00mislead. Ultimately, since the use of Ginger's
- 22:04name in the film title was both artistically
- 22:05relevant and didn't explicitly mislead, the court
- 22:08ruled in favor of filmmakers, her claim was dismissed,
- 22:11and the First Amendment protected expressive
- 22:14use. Heck yeah, one for filmmakers. Yes, this
- 22:18is the balance they struck between trademark
- 22:20law and the First Amendment that Serene was talking
- 22:22about. They generally don't stop production from
- 22:25using a trademark unless the public interest
- 22:28in avoiding consumer confusion outweighs the
- 22:30public interest in free expression. I should
- 22:33also note that there's a practical benefit of
- 22:36raising Rogers in that it allows you to win on
- 22:40a motion to dismiss really early on in the process
- 22:42without you having to take on discovery or litigation
- 22:45costs, which can definitely add up. And ultimately,
- 22:49this ends up dissuading a lot of lawsuits. Okay,
- 22:53so Roger seems pretty favorable to artists. I
- 22:56definitely want to have the argument in my back
- 22:58pocket. But you said that Rogers was a second
- 23:00circuit case. And we're in California, which
- 23:03is the Ninth Circuit, right? Yeah, good catch.
- 23:06So it was a second circuit case, but funny story.
- 23:10OK, what's one of the more popular karaoke songs
- 23:13you could think of? What does it have to do with
- 23:16me? If you're charging by the hour, I want to
- 23:18stay on topic, you know, tick tock. It's on top.
- 23:21It's on topic. I promise. Now answer me. Famous
- 23:23karaoke songs that you can think of? Well, my
- 23:28personal go to is Empire State of Mind by Jay
- 23:30-Z. But my fiance, she always wants to do that
- 23:34one Barbie song. Can't remember the name. Do
- 23:37you know it? Do I know it? The song Barbie Girl
- 23:41is why Rogers applies here in the Ninth Circuit.
- 23:44So Mattel, the owner of the Barbie trademarks,
- 23:47sued the Danish pop group Aqua and their label
- 23:50over the song, claiming, among other things,
- 23:53the use was trademark infringement under the
- 23:55Lanham Act. And let me guess the Ninth Circuit
- 23:58adopted the Second Circuit's Rogers test and
- 24:00applied it here. Yes, exactly. So for the first
- 24:03prong, the court found that the use of the Barbie
- 24:06name was clearly relevant to to the song's artistic
- 24:10purpose. The entire song is about Barbie and
- 24:14what values Aqua claims Barbie stands for. And
- 24:18then for the second prong, the court found nothing
- 24:21in the song or its packaging or its marketing
- 24:24that would explicitly mislead consumers into
- 24:27thinking Mattel produced, sponsored, or endorsed
- 24:30the song. Hmm, so Barbie girl passed the Rogers
- 24:33test and that's why my fiance can be able to
- 24:36sing it at the top of her lungs all across town.
- 24:39Yes, exactly. Wait, so the Rogers case was about
- 24:45the title of the film. The Barbie case was about
- 24:47the title of the song. I want to use the trademarks
- 24:50and the body of my film, not just the title.
- 24:53Remember Jeep, Red Bull, Chipotle, explosions.
- 24:56How would that work? Good question. Yes, the
- 25:00Rogers test was originally developed to protect
- 25:03the titles of expressive works But since has
- 25:06been extended by federal courts to cover trademarks
- 25:09appearing within the body of a film and TV show
- 25:12You know the seminal case on this expansion actually
- 25:15involves a video game and strip clubs Okay, now
- 25:19you have my attention So yes as entertainment
- 25:22operated a real strip club in East LA called
- 25:25play pen gentleman's club Rockstar Games published
- 25:29a video game called Grand Theft San Andreas which
- 25:32depicted a virtual fictional strip club called
- 25:35Pig Pen with a similar look and feel to ESS's
- 25:38real -world strip club. ESS sued Rockstar for
- 25:42trademark infringement and the court held that
- 25:45Rockstar's use of the Pig Pen in the body of
- 25:47the video game was protected by the First Amendment
- 25:50under the Roger Test. On the first prong, Artistic
- 25:54relevance? Yes, the court found that including
- 25:56a strip club resembling the playpen in a cartoon
- 26:00-style parody of East LA had at least some artistic
- 26:03relevance because recreating that neighborhood's
- 26:07critical mass of businesses, including its strip
- 26:09club, served rock star's artistic goals. On the
- 26:13second prong... Explicitly misleading. Yes, the
- 26:17court said video games and strip clubs do not
- 26:20go together like a horse and carriage and found
- 26:23no explicit misleading. Nothing indicated that
- 26:26consumers would believe ESS produced Grand Theft
- 26:29Auto or that Rockstar Games operated a strip
- 26:32club. So with this case, the Ninth Circuit explicitly
- 26:36extended Rogers beyond titles. The court said
- 26:39Although this test traditionally applies to the
- 26:42use of trademarks in the title of an artistic
- 26:44work, there is no principal reason why not also
- 26:48apply to the use of a trademark in the body of
- 26:50the work. And there have been plenty of cases
- 26:52since where the courts have applied the Rogers
- 26:55to use of the trademarks in the body of the work.
- 26:57So you're good there. Okay, this is great news.
- 27:01So under the Rogers test, I'm protected. I can
- 27:03use a trademark in the title. in the body of
- 27:06my film unless a plaintiff proves the mark was
- 27:08there has no artistic relevance to the film or
- 27:11the use explicitly misleads consumers regarding
- 27:13the source or content of the film. Yes, but we
- 27:17should mention Jack Daniels. Don't worry, I don't
- 27:20drink. No, the case. It's actually a wild one.
- 27:24So the litigation lasted more than a decade and
- 27:26included multiple phases of district court proceedings,
- 27:30multiple night circuit appearances and a landmark
- 27:33Supreme Court decision. More than 10 years. Listen,
- 27:36I'm a Scorpio. Even I'm not petty enough to do
- 27:39something like that for 10 years. I know it's
- 27:42crazy. So VIP product sells like a line of like
- 27:46silly squeaky dog toys shaped like well -known
- 27:50beverages. And in 2013, VIP launched this bad
- 27:55spaniels toy dog toy, and it was shaped like
- 27:58a Jack Daniel's bottle. It featured a spaniel,
- 28:01and it also featured some potty humor, and Jack
- 28:03Daniels wasn't too happy about it. And I won't
- 28:06bore you with all the details of the case. Thank
- 28:08God. But we will zero in on what the outcome
- 28:12was regarding the trademark infringement claim,
- 28:15which is the cause of action we're focusing on
- 28:17today. So when Jack Daniels sued VIP for, among
- 28:21other things, trademark infringement, VIP asserted
- 28:24the Rogers defense. Fast forward through a lot
- 28:27of back and forth between like the Arizona District
- 28:30Court and the Ninth Circuit, the Supreme Court
- 28:33stepped in in 2023 and they made a decision that
- 28:37held that the Rogers defense does not apply when
- 28:40the defendant is using the plaintiff's mark as
- 28:43a source identifier for the defendant's own goods,
- 28:46meaning using the mark to tell the public who
- 28:48is responsible for the goods. In our case, this
- 28:51would be your film. But for films, when a trademark
- 28:55shows up in the title, it's part of the artistic
- 28:57content, right? It's not being used to identify
- 29:00the film or who made it. And the source identifier
- 29:03is the studio's own name and branding, not a
- 29:05third -party mark in the title, right? You know,
- 29:08unfortunately, the Supreme Court gave zero guidance
- 29:11on how lower courts should determine whether
- 29:14a title is used as a source identifier. On one
- 29:17hand, titles are usually just describe the subject
- 29:20matter of the work, like home alone is about
- 29:22a child left home alone, Mean Girls is about
- 29:25girls who are mean. But on the other hand, some
- 29:28consumers may be able to gauge the source of
- 29:30the work from the title. So this is a new and
- 29:33nuanced area of the law that's still developing.
- 29:37But here is what we do know. So Rogers is still
- 29:39good law and use of Marx's inexpressive works
- 29:43for creative purposes continues to be protected
- 29:46under Rogers. The second thing we know is that
- 29:49it has impacted the procedural history. Before
- 29:53Jack Daniels, Tatev mentioned defendants would
- 29:55be able to use the Rogers defense and get dismissal
- 29:58at an early pleading stage, which would avoid
- 30:01expensive costs of discovery. Post Jack Daniels,
- 30:05plaintiffs are pleading that filmmakers are using
- 30:08their marks as marks, as source identifiers.
- 30:12Often they don't even need like factual support
- 30:14for this They're just just having the allegation
- 30:17makes it harder for courts to dismiss on Rogers
- 30:20grounds earlier At least for title cases because
- 30:24the courts are you know, they tend to view the
- 30:27use as a mark as a question That's more fact
- 30:29dependent and so it's pushing cases into discovery
- 30:33and it's delaying resolution So even if you ultimately
- 30:36like have a strong Rogers argument Jack Daniels
- 30:39can reduce the ability in title cases for you
- 30:43to get the case thrown out a little bit earlier.
- 30:47And another thing is if you do plan on using
- 30:50the Rogers defense for a title of your film,
- 30:54we recommend not registering the mark because
- 30:56courts have said if you register the mark, then
- 30:59you intend to use it as a source identifier for
- 31:01yourself and that would take you out of Rogers.
- 31:04And then wasn't there actually a recent update
- 31:05in the Jack Daniels case itself, like literally
- 31:08last week? There was. So the 9th Circuit issued
- 31:11a new opinion on August 4th, and they reversed
- 31:15the injunction against VIP products holding that
- 31:18Jack Daniels failed to prove dilution by tarnishment.
- 31:21You might have remembered I mentioned that we
- 31:22were talking about all the ways you can get sued.
- 31:25So that's a separate cause of action from trademark
- 31:27infringement, which is the one we're focused
- 31:29on today. Okay, so it doesn't change what you
- 31:31just told me about Rogers and trademark infringement
- 31:34claims? Yeah, correct. But, speaking of recent
- 31:38court rulings, there is actually a recent case
- 31:41from this year that can help contextualize some
- 31:44of what we've been discussing. Anyone I would
- 31:46know? Depends. Where did you go to school? Actually
- 31:50right by the beach. Pepperdine? Well, your alma
- 31:53mater sued Netflix. No way, you're kidding. No,
- 31:58so Netflix and Warner Bros put on a show called
- 32:01Running Point, which is a comedy about a woman
- 32:03who ends up running a professional basketball
- 32:05team. This fictional team is called the Los Angeles
- 32:09Waves and Pepperdine's team has been the Wave
- 32:13since 1937. So Pepperdine argued that Netflix's
- 32:17use of the mark was similar to Pepperdine's Wave's
- 32:21trademark. Specifically, Pepperdine claimed that
- 32:24Netflix used a similar font similar blue, orange
- 32:28and white coloring and the word waves in a similar
- 32:32context which was on athletic style clothing.
- 32:35There is also a framed jersey in the show with
- 32:38the number 37 on it which is the year Pepperdine
- 32:40was founded. Let me show you a little trailer
- 32:43of the show to give you a better idea visually
- 32:45of what I'm talking about. I work in a family
- 32:54business. The greatest basketball franchise in
- 32:57the history of the game. The Los Angeles Waves.
- 33:01And this is the story of the fucked up family
- 33:03that runs it. I'm making you the president of
- 33:09the Waves. When I was a little girl, daddy never
- 33:12believed in me. And I started to doubt myself.
- 33:15I need you to stop because I don't care about
- 33:16any of that shit. You are the president of the
- 33:20Waves. This is shocking, but on behalf of all
- 33:22women, don't ever make a mistake. What's bad
- 33:24for all of us? Yikes. That seems bad for Netflix
- 33:33and Warner Brothers. Pepperdine thought so too.
- 33:36So Pepperdine sued in the central district of
- 33:39California a week before the premiere and asked
- 33:41the court to block the release. The court said
- 33:44no, the show came out and it became Netflix's
- 33:47number one show. Then Netflix and Warner Bros.
- 33:49moved to dismiss. And? It was dismissed and the
- 33:54reasoning is exactly the analysis we just walked
- 33:57through. Step one is the Jack Daniels gateway
- 34:00question. Was the Waves mark being used as a
- 34:03source identifier for the show? The court said
- 34:05no. And how did Pepperdine argue it was? Well,
- 34:09Pepperdine pointed out that the mark is everywhere.
- 34:12It's on the jerseys, the shirts, the stadium,
- 34:15all through the series. And the actors were posting
- 34:18in Waves jerseys to promote it, too. Mindy Kaling
- 34:22is one of the co -creators and EPs of the show
- 34:24and Kaling International, which is her production
- 34:27company, changed its Instagram bio to say home
- 34:30of the Los Angeles waves and showed her wearing
- 34:33a wave shirt. So Pepperdine said that all of
- 34:36this makes it synonymous with the show's identity
- 34:39and its source. I mean, that sounds like a decent
- 34:42argument. The court didn't think so. They said
- 34:45pervasive is not the same thing as source identifying.
- 34:49The court got into this whole discussion about
- 34:51the Mattel case we previously mentioned and about
- 34:54how with Barbie, the Ninth Circuit found that
- 34:57the song titled Barbie Girl, which included an
- 34:59impersonation of Barbie and repeated use of the
- 35:02Barbie name, did not use the Barbie mark as a
- 35:05source identifier, even though it was pretty
- 35:08pervasive because it did not mislead as to the
- 35:11source of the work. Then the court noted that
- 35:14the Jack Daniels court, which is the one that
- 35:16established this threshold rule, said that in
- 35:20Barbie, the court handled it correctly and that
- 35:22the trademark was not to designate a work source,
- 35:25but solely to perform some other expressive function.
- 35:29Here, the court didn't think that Netflix was
- 35:32trading on the goodwill of Pepperdine to market
- 35:35its own good. Got it. So Pepperdine's pervasive
- 35:38argument didn't hold up under the Barbie and
- 35:40Jack Daniels precedent. Exactly. And the court
- 35:43also made a really practical point. When you
- 35:46open an episode of the show, you see the Netflix
- 35:49logo, then you see the Warner Bros logo, and
- 35:52then the words, a Netflix series, and then the
- 35:55words, a Warner Bros television production. Even
- 35:58in the trailer we just showed you, the Netflix
- 36:00mark was in the top right corner the whole time.
- 36:03The studios are very loudly telling you who the
- 36:06source is, and it's not Pepperdine. Okay, so
- 36:10it clears Jack Daniels because the use isn't
- 36:12functioning as a source identifier, and this
- 36:14is a TV show, so it's an expressive work, and
- 36:17Rogers can be applied. Now, Pepperon has the
- 36:19burden to show that the studio's use of the mark
- 36:21fails Rogers, right? Do they succeed? No, Pepperdine
- 36:25tried, but it wasn't able to defeat the Rogers
- 36:28defense. Nobody really disputed the artistic
- 36:30relevance prong. Like we said, it's a pretty
- 36:33low bar. It's a TV show about a basketball team
- 36:35in California. But on the second prong, the court
- 36:38found no explicitly misleading as to who is the
- 36:42source of the work. Here, the court pointed to
- 36:45a couple things. They said that Pepperdine used
- 36:47the mark for a real college team while the defendant
- 36:50used it for a fictional professional team inside
- 36:53a television show. So Netflix wasn't alleged
- 36:57to be in the business of college sports. The
- 37:00only product that they really had is a TV show.
- 37:03They also said that Netflix was explicitly claiming
- 37:07to be the source of the series So it was a misleading
- 37:10consumers as to the source of the series They
- 37:13also said that if the defendant had advertised
- 37:15the show as brought to you by Pepperdine or even
- 37:19brought to you by the waves, that would tell
- 37:22the consumer that someone other than the actual
- 37:24creator of a work is the creator, which would
- 37:27be a different case here. However, the way it
- 37:30was done wasn't explicitly misleading. So because
- 37:33the Rogers defense was successful, the Lanham
- 37:36Act did not prohibit the use and state law and
- 37:39common law claims were likewise dismissed. Wow.
- 37:42So Pepperdine laws. For now, this is a district
- 37:46court case and Pepperdine is appealing this decision
- 37:48to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. So we'll
- 37:51see if the Ninth Circuit affirms the district
- 37:52court's decision. Okay, I think I understand.
- 37:56So for my use of the trademarks in the film to
- 37:58be okay, I have to per Jack Daniels not use it
- 38:02as a source identifier and pass the Rogers test.
- 38:06But what happens if there's a question whether
- 38:07I'm using the mark as a source identifier? You
- 38:11know, if that happens, then we'll need to see
- 38:12if another defense applies. What are my options?
- 38:17Separate from Rogers, there's a nominative fair
- 38:18use defense. So this is the principle that you
- 38:21can use someone else's trademark to name or identify
- 38:24them or their product or service. In other words,
- 38:27you're not using the mark as a source identifier
- 38:30for yourself. You're using it as a reference
- 38:32point to something that exists. So nominative
- 38:35fair use is a judge made doctrine, which means
- 38:37that the courts built it from the ground up to
- 38:39deal with a practical problem they came across.
- 38:42And that problem is sometimes the only way to
- 38:45identify a thing is to call it what it is. So
- 38:48for example, imagine I am a mechanic and I'm
- 38:51trying to tell customers what types of cars I
- 38:53can fix. How do I do that without saying saying
- 38:56Volkswagen, Ford or Lexus. And so this doctrine
- 39:00was formalized in a Ninth Circuit case in 1992
- 39:03when two newspapers ran reader polls and they
- 39:07asked their readers to vote on like their favorite
- 39:09member of New Kids on the Block. The band sued
- 39:13over the use of their trademark and the court
- 39:15basically had to ask itself, how would these
- 39:18two newspapers have run the poll? Without saying
- 39:21new kids on the block and the answer they came
- 39:24to is you can't so any substitute would be like
- 39:27awkward or misleading or unclear and that's the
- 39:30key practical takeaway here, so When a trademark
- 39:34is the most practical and often the only practical
- 39:37way to identify A brand or a good or a service
- 39:40then that use can be fair So in the film context
- 39:44for you Omar, this is gonna be this is like straightforward
- 39:47Nominated fair use and Rogers can protect like
- 39:50a filmmaker like yourself who depicts someone
- 39:53ordering a Coca -Cola in a scene or even uses
- 39:56a brand name in dialogue like ring doorbell to
- 39:59identify a specific item. Nominated fair use
- 40:02may even be used to protect use of a trademark
- 40:05in a title. So for example, think this is an
- 40:07old one, but think like the documentary Enron,
- 40:09the smartest guys in the room. And then the Courts
- 40:17have taken different approaches to addressing
- 40:19this type of use. So the Ninth Circuit set out
- 40:22the first formal nominative fair use test in
- 40:25the new kids on the block case we talked about.
- 40:27The Third Circuit set out like a variation of
- 40:30the Ninth Circuit for its own test. Then the
- 40:32Second Circuit kind of took the Ninth Circuit,
- 40:34took the Third Circuit and set out its own variation
- 40:37of the test a little bit based on both. And then
- 40:40the other circuits actually haven't adopted formal
- 40:42tests and instead they apply like a traditional
- 40:44likelihood of confusion analysis. which we'll
- 40:46talk about later. So basically where I get sued
- 40:49matters. Yes, but the problem is you don't know
- 40:53if you'll be sued or where you'll be sued So
- 40:56you remember at the beginning when I said like
- 40:58context is important. It was right when you fell
- 41:00asleep All of these cases are very fact intensive
- 41:04So when you are conducting the clearance process
- 41:07You never want the facts around your use to be
- 41:10so close that they wouldn't pass muster in all
- 41:13circuits But since we are in, California and
- 41:17we've been focusing on like the Ninth Circuit
- 41:19for other cases, let's talk about the elements
- 41:21of the Nomative Fair Use Test in the Ninth Circuit.
- 41:26So the Ninth Circuit applies a three -part Nomative
- 41:30Fair Use Test. The first... prong that you have
- 41:33to meet is the thing you're referring to must
- 41:35not be readily identifiable without using the
- 41:38mark. Now the mark doesn't have to be strictly
- 41:41essential. Even if there are multiple ways to
- 41:44identify the plaintiff's goods or services, the
- 41:46defendant can meet this prong if the use of the
- 41:50plaintiff's mark is far simpler or more likely
- 41:52to be understood. So for example, it's easier
- 41:56for me to say Dallas Cowboys and you to understand
- 41:59who I'm talking about rather than if I had said,
- 42:02oh, that professional team in the National Football
- 42:05League based in Dallas. So again, if it's easier
- 42:08and more likely to be understood, you pass this
- 42:11first prong. The second prong is you can only
- 42:15use so much of the mark as is necessary. So the
- 42:17Ninth Circuit emphasized that this factor doesn't
- 42:20focus solely on the number of uses of the plaintiff's
- 42:23mark, but rather on the nature of the use. So
- 42:26in the production context for you Omar, that
- 42:29usually means say or show what is necessary,
- 42:32but avoid turning the mark into like this focal
- 42:35point or like the hero of the story. For instance,
- 42:38if you were to use trademark in a title of a
- 42:40documentary, you would want to avoid making the
- 42:43trademark unnecessarily prominent. And then the
- 42:46third prong that you have to meet is the use
- 42:48cannot suggest sponsorship or endorsement, which
- 42:51we've kind of covered through other elements
- 42:53we've talked about. And remember, the nominative
- 42:56fair use applies only when a mark is used to
- 42:59identify the trademark owner's goods or services.
- 43:02So, AKA when you're saying Coca -Cola to identify
- 43:05a Coca -Cola. Okay, I think I'm following. So
- 43:09ideally my use is protected by Rogers because
- 43:12courts try to avoid letting trademark law chill
- 43:14expressive works, right? Or by the nominal fair
- 43:17use defense, you know, if I'm using the mark
- 43:19just to identify the real brand. But if I don't
- 43:22meet either one, does it automatically mean that
- 43:24I have to cut the trademark? Not quite yet. If
- 43:29Rogers and nominative fair use don't apply, then
- 43:32we get into the likelihood of confusion analysis
- 43:35we've been referencing all throughout the presentation.
- 43:39Respectfully, if you give me another test with
- 43:41multiple prongs, I'm going to lose it. I promise
- 43:44this one is less of a test and more of like a
- 43:47balancing exercise. The likelihood of confusion
- 43:50analysis asks whether a reasonable consumer would
- 43:53be confused as to the source sponsorship or affiliation
- 43:55of the defendant's work with the trademark owner's
- 43:57brand. The analysis involves looking at a multitude
- 44:00of factors and each circuit court has their own
- 44:03set of factors that they use to assess this likelihood
- 44:06of confusion. The second circuit created this
- 44:09eight factor Polaroid test and then the ninth
- 44:12circuit applies the sleep craft factors which
- 44:14are very similar to the Polaroid factors. Generally
- 44:18all the circuits look at similar considerations,
- 44:20but since we're in the 9th circuit, let's zero
- 44:23in on the sleep craft factors. The first factor
- 44:26here is the strength of the plaintiff's mark.
- 44:29Here the court looks at conceptual strength and
- 44:32commercial strength. With respect to conceptual
- 44:35strength, as Serene explained earlier, is it
- 44:37a mark that is more fanciful and arbitrary, which
- 44:40is stronger, or is it just the generic or descriptive
- 44:44mark without secondary meaning, which is not
- 44:47as strong? With respect to commercial strength,
- 44:50the court measures how powerfully a trademark
- 44:52is recognized by the public in actual commerce.
- 44:56The stronger the mark, the more likely to cause
- 44:59confusion. Then we have proximity of the goods.
- 45:03And what does that mean? So with this one, courts
- 45:07examine whether the party's products or services
- 45:10are sufficiently related such that a consumer
- 45:13might assume they came from the same source or
- 45:17when the marks are used to offer a similar product
- 45:20to a similar group of consumers. So for example,
- 45:22if a movie title is similar to a pre -existing
- 45:26television series title, this factor might Way
- 45:30in favor of confusion as courts have found that
- 45:33films and television series are related goods
- 45:36and services and they may come from a single
- 45:39source But to be clear through this is a fact
- 45:43specific inquiry all of the likelihood of confusion
- 45:47analysis is it's so different depending on the
- 45:50circumstances And speaking of looking at things
- 45:53holistically, when it comes to the similarity
- 45:56of the mark factor, the courts look at the overall
- 45:59impression of the mark. So they consider the
- 46:02similarity of the sight, the sound, and meaning
- 46:05of the marks. The more similar the marks feel,
- 46:08the more likely they are to confuse a consumer.
- 46:11And then that leads me to the next factor, which
- 46:14is evidence of actual confusion, which is pretty
- 46:17self -explanatory. And how do I go about showing
- 46:20that? A lot of times this is proven through survey
- 46:23evidence, but conducting surveys can be pretty
- 46:27expensive. So moving on, we have the marketing
- 46:31channels and this considers whether the two parties
- 46:34are both promoting on the same platform. Then
- 46:38we have the sixth factor, which is the degree
- 46:40of consumer care. So you would consider if the
- 46:43consumer is a child or an adult, how much time
- 46:46is the consumer spending making the decision
- 46:49to purchase this good? The less time and care
- 46:53the consumer spends making the decision to purchase,
- 46:56the more likely they are to be confused. And
- 47:00then seventh, the court considers the defendant's
- 47:03intent. But intent to do what? Here, the court
- 47:07looks at whether the intent was to infringe,
- 47:10not that it was just to use the mark. If the
- 47:13defendant knew about the mark, some courts will
- 47:16see it as bad intent, while other courts will
- 47:19say it's knowledge, but not necessarily bad intent.
- 47:23And if you show evidence that you conducted a
- 47:25thorough title and trademark clearance search
- 47:27before using the title, this can weigh against
- 47:30the likelihood of confusion because it shows
- 47:32good intent. And then the final factor here is
- 47:37the likelihood that either party will expand
- 47:39into the other's market. So how likely is it
- 47:42that the brand owner is going to expand into
- 47:45the film or TV space for your purposes? And then
- 47:49are all these factors applicable to me using
- 47:51your trademark in a movie? So courts don't have
- 47:55to use all the factors in their analysis. In
- 47:58the entertainment context, the most heavily weighed
- 48:01factors are the similarity of the marks, proximity
- 48:04of the goods and services, the marketing channels,
- 48:07and the presence or absence of actual confusion.
- 48:11Evidence of actual confusion tends to be the
- 48:13most disposive one for this likelihood of confusion
- 48:16analysis, which makes sense, right? Like if the
- 48:19law was created to ensure that consumers are
- 48:21not confused and someone provides evidence. of
- 48:23confusion, it can be convincing. Okay. I'm having
- 48:28a hard time imagining how all these factors actually
- 48:31work in reality. Can you give me an example?
- 48:35Yes. Have you ever heard of the movie Age of
- 48:37Hobbits? You mean The Hobbit? No. And this confusion
- 48:42is exactly why you haven't heard of it. Let me
- 48:44tell you about it. There is a case called Warner
- 48:47Brothers Entertainment versus The Global Asylum.
- 48:49The plaintiffs in this case are Warner Bros.
- 48:52Entertainment, New Line Cinema, and MGM who produced
- 48:56and distributed films that are based on J .R
- 49:00.R. Tolkien's works, specifically The Hobbit,
- 49:02as well as the SolSense company who owns multiple
- 49:05trademarks that include the word hobbit. The
- 49:09plaintiff sued Global Asylum, which is a film
- 49:11production company known for making mockbusters,
- 49:14which are films created to exploit the publicity
- 49:17of another major motion picture with a similar
- 49:20title or subject. The plaintiffs sued for trademark
- 49:23infringement requesting a temporary restraining
- 49:27order to stop the distribution of Global Asylum's
- 49:31film, which was titled Age of Hobbits. That was
- 49:34scheduled to be released on DVD and then three
- 49:37days before the theatrical release of the actual
- 49:40Hobbit film. So Global Asylum insisted that its
- 49:45movie had nothing to do with Tolkien's Hobbits.
- 49:48Instead, they claimed that the film was about
- 49:50a group of prehistoric humans living in what
- 49:53is now Indonesia. Asylum asserted that it used
- 49:57the term Hobbit in the film title to refer to
- 50:00the species, which was given the nickname Hobbit
- 50:03by scientists who discovered the species. Ultimately,
- 50:07the court granted the temporary restraining order
- 50:09and blocked the release of the film under the
- 50:12title Age of Hobbits. Wow, that's like my worst
- 50:15nightmare. Understandably so. Let's go through
- 50:18the court's analysis and figure out where global
- 50:20asylum went wrong. To explain why the plaintiffs
- 50:24were likely to succeed, the court started with
- 50:27the basics of trademark infringement that we
- 50:29started this conversation on too. The plaintiffs
- 50:32needed to show One, that they had protectable
- 50:35ownership in the trademark. And two, defendant's
- 50:39use was likely to cause consumer confusion. On
- 50:43the first ownership prong, the court found that
- 50:45the plaintiffs did have a protectable interest
- 50:47in the word Hobbit. It had been registered in
- 50:50multiple forms with the U .S. Patent and Trademark
- 50:52Office, including at least one registration tied
- 50:55to printed matter. The court did note, though,
- 50:59that the plaintiffs did not show a registration
- 51:01specifically for movie titles. So then they looked
- 51:04at whether Hobbit had gained secondary meaning
- 51:06or distinctiveness in the marketplace. and the
- 51:11court concluded that it had. The plaintiffs had
- 51:14submitted surveys showing that about half of
- 51:17400 randomly selected respondents associated
- 51:19the word hobbit with Tolkien's works. The court
- 51:22also pointed to the plaintiffs' extensive use
- 51:25of the term over time, including in the Lord
- 51:27of the Rings films, as additional evidence that
- 51:30the word had become strongly associated with
- 51:32the Tolkien universe. So the plaintiffs had a
- 51:35protectable ownership interest in the trademark.
- 51:38So then the courts turned to the likelihood of
- 51:41confusion analysis and applied this nine circuit
- 51:44eight factor test. On strength of the mark, the
- 51:48court said Hobbit is a strong mark because it
- 51:51was coined by Tolkien. He invented the term for
- 51:54fictional creatures, which makes it a fanciful
- 51:56mark. And as Serene explained, fanciful marks
- 51:59receive the maximum trademark protection. The
- 52:02court also pointed to the extensive marketplace
- 52:04recognition the plaintiffs presented. So this
- 52:07factor favored confusion. And then on proximity
- 52:11of the goods, both of the products are films.
- 52:14And the court concluded that both films were
- 52:16targeting an overlapping audience, which was
- 52:19people interested in feature length fantasy entertainment.
- 52:22And then the timing mattered, too. The defendants
- 52:25picked a release date just three days before
- 52:28the plaintiff's major film release, which increased
- 52:32the risk that consumers would assume some sort
- 52:34of connection. The products are of the same type.
- 52:37They're marketed to the same audience at nearly
- 52:39exactly the same time. So this factor favored
- 52:42confusion. But you said one was coming out in
- 52:46theaters and the other on DVD. So how's that
- 52:48overlapping? So the court didn't think it mattered
- 52:52much that one film was going to theaters and
- 52:54the other was going to DVD, since many consumers
- 52:57may not be aware of the different modes and timing
- 53:00a release. From the court's perspective, the
- 53:02channels were still close enough to generate
- 53:05confusion. I see. And the marks are identical.
- 53:08They both use the word hobbit, so the similarity
- 53:10of the marks factor must have weighed towards
- 53:12confusion too. You're right, but it wasn't even
- 53:16just about the fact that the words are identical.
- 53:19The court looked at how the film was presented
- 53:21visually and noted that the imagery associated
- 53:24with the defendant's marketing looked similar
- 53:26to what consumers would expect from the Tolkien
- 53:28-style fantasy film. So things like characters
- 53:31holding mythical weapons, mythical creatures
- 53:33like dragons, battle scenes, big mountains and
- 53:37fire. Obviously, the plaintiffs don't have an
- 53:40exclusive right to this imagery, but when it
- 53:42is paired with the word hobbit, it does favor
- 53:45confusion. There was also evidence of actual
- 53:48confusion. The plaintiffs pointed to a Nielsen
- 53:51tracking study suggesting that around 30 to 40
- 53:54percent of 1200 respondents showed confusion
- 53:58about the source of age of hobbits. Generally,
- 54:02confusion levels of around 25 to 50 percent provides
- 54:05solid support for finding the likelihood of confusion.
- 54:09So this survey in connection with the other factors
- 54:12also favored confusion. It is not looking good
- 54:15for global asylum. What about marketing channels?
- 54:18For marketing channels, both were promoted online.
- 54:22I mean, isn't everything promoted online these
- 54:24days? You're right while the court acknowledged
- 54:27that internet marketing can create confusion
- 54:29They also noted that this factor can be less
- 54:32decisive because online marketing is used by
- 54:35nearly everyone like you just pointed out But
- 54:37regardless the court still stated that this factor
- 54:39favored confusion Not particularly strongly though,
- 54:43but it still didn't help global asylum Let's
- 54:47look at degree of care. The court said that the
- 54:50movie tickets and DVDs are relatively low cost
- 54:54items under $15. This was in 2012. Keep in mind.
- 54:59So consumers don't exercise a lot of care when
- 55:01purchasing cheaper items around this price and
- 55:05thus this factor also favored confusion. And
- 55:08then finally since the court didn't think that
- 55:09the likelihood of expansion into the others product
- 55:12line was a relevant factor here. They considered
- 55:15intent. I mean, they're definitely sketchy for
- 55:17the release date thing than the prehistoric humans.
- 55:20I mean, come on. Exactly. The court was skeptical
- 55:24of Asylum's claim that the movie had no connection
- 55:26to Tolkien. The scientists gave the nickname
- 55:29of Hobbit to the species because its appearance
- 55:32resembled Tolkien's hobbits. So the court called
- 55:35Asylum's argument disingenuous. They emphasized
- 55:39a few things. They said that the defendant's
- 55:41mockbuster business model reflected bad intent,
- 55:44the lack of proof that the film was actually
- 55:46marketed as a story about prehistoric Indonesians'
- 55:49bad intent, and again, the strategic release
- 55:52date so close to the Hobbit bad intent. But then
- 55:56putting it all together, the court said many
- 55:58factors supported likely of confusion and none
- 56:00of the factors weighed against it. At that point,
- 56:03the court considered whether the defendant had
- 56:06valid defense. Was one of them Rogers? Yes, that
- 56:10was one of the three defenses that were raised,
- 56:13but the court rejected all three. First was the
- 56:16Rogers defense that you just flagged, which if
- 56:18you remember, the defendant would have to prove
- 56:19artistic relevance and no explicit misleading.
- 56:22For artistic relevance, the court said that the
- 56:24title had no real artistic relevance to the film
- 56:27as the defendant described it. The court said,
- 56:31in order to succeed on this prompt, asylum must
- 56:33show that the use of the term in the title in
- 56:36some way relates to or references the trademarked
- 56:40term. The court highlighted this contradiction,
- 56:42which was that the defendant denied referencing
- 56:45Tolkien, but then couldn't credibly explain why
- 56:48using Hobbit was artistically relevant. And then
- 56:51given the strong likelihood of confusion analysis,
- 56:55the court did believe that it was explicitly
- 56:57misleading. Second, the defendant argued nominative
- 57:01fair use. The court rejected this too because
- 57:04nominative fair use applies when you use a mark
- 57:07to refer to the trademark owner's product, not
- 57:10to brand your own. Here, the defendant wasn't
- 57:15using the term to describe the plaintiff's film
- 57:17and in fact said it did not intend to refer to
- 57:20the plaintiff's mark at all. As the court in
- 57:23New Kids on the Block stated, if the defendant's
- 57:26use of the plaintiff's trademark refers to something
- 57:29other than the plaintiff's product, the traditional
- 57:32fair use inquiry will continue to govern. And
- 57:35then third, the defendant argued the term hobbits
- 57:38was generic. The court rejected that too, explaining
- 57:41that a federally registered mark is presumed
- 57:44not to be generic. And the defendant did not
- 57:47present evidence that consumers view hobbit as
- 57:49a generic term separate from token. So after
- 57:53rejecting the defenses, the court moved to the
- 57:56remaining temporary restraining order factors,
- 57:58which were all satisfied. The court entered the
- 58:02Tiara blocking the defendant from releasing the
- 58:05film under the title Age of Hobbits. Wow, so
- 58:08after all that work, they couldn't even release
- 58:10the movie? Well, they did end up releasing it
- 58:13under a different name. It's Lord of the Elves
- 58:16or Clash of the Empires, depending where you
- 58:18check. Wow, talk about material change in the
- 58:2111th hour. I know, but if you follow the clearance
- 58:24process from the beginning, you can avoid all
- 58:26this mess. So I know we've covered a lot. How
- 58:32about we do a recap? We can go over like a high
- 58:34level framework that kind of ties everything
- 58:36that we've covered together. Before we do that,
- 58:40friendly reminder, everything we discussed today
- 58:42was focused on trademark infringement claims
- 58:45for federally registered marks in the context
- 58:48of TV and film. So trademark law is broad. There's
- 58:51lots of different ways you can get sued, but
- 58:53with our focus in mind, Let's talk about the
- 58:56steps you need to consider. So step one, you
- 58:58need to flag it early. Omar, the moment you think
- 59:02that a real brand or logo or trademark is going
- 59:04to appear in your project, whether it's in a
- 59:06script or the set design or promotional material,
- 59:09flag it for clearance. The later you identify
- 59:12a problem, the more expensive it'll be to fix.
- 59:14I mean, think of what happened with Hobbit. Then
- 59:18you go to step two and you ask yourself, is my
- 59:22use functioning as a source identifier for my
- 59:25film? Remember, this comes from the Jack Daniels
- 59:27case. So you're asking, are you using the mark
- 59:30as a mark for your film? If the answer is no,
- 59:34you can continue to step three. ask yourself,
- 59:37is the use artistically relevant to the underlying
- 59:40work? And remember, this is the first prong of
- 59:43the Rogers test. And as Tatev said, the bar is
- 59:46intentionally low because courts don't want to
- 59:48be involved in dissecting like your creative
- 59:51brain. If the use is artistically relevant, continue
- 59:55to step four and ask yourself, does my use explicitly
- 59:59mislead consumers? And this is the second prong
- 1:00:02of the Rogers test. And again, as Tatev said,
- 1:00:05The bar here is a little bit higher. If your
- 1:00:07use is not misleading, then you're likely protected
- 1:00:10under Rogers. If it is protected under Rogers,
- 1:00:14or if it isn't protected under Rogers, you might
- 1:00:16want to go to step five and see if there's another
- 1:00:18defense. And then step five is the nominative
- 1:00:20fair use. Ask yourself, does nominative fair
- 1:00:22use apply? Have I used it in a way where I would
- 1:00:25pass the test? And if this is not the case, then
- 1:00:29you're going to go to step six, which is what
- 1:00:32Tatev talked about, the sleep craft factors and
- 1:00:34the Hobbit case. And you're going to apply the
- 1:00:36likelihood of confusion analysis. Courts weigh
- 1:00:39lots of different factors. None are dispositive.
- 1:00:43Okay, so then I can use trademarks in my films,
- 1:00:46but to avoid trademark infringement claims specifically,
- 1:00:49I should ensure that the use falls, you know,
- 1:00:51safely within the Roger's defense, the non -deferred
- 1:00:53use defense, and or, you know, passes the likelihood
- 1:00:57of confusion analysis. And so that's great. If
- 1:01:00I do that, then I don't have to get consent from
- 1:01:03any of the trademark owners. Okay, don't hate
- 1:01:06us. There's actually a step seven you should
- 1:01:08consider. Another step you don't you don't think
- 1:01:12this is overkill I mean the Rogers test has two
- 1:01:15prongs and I'm gonna fair use test has three
- 1:01:17prongs Then there are eight sleep craft factors
- 1:01:19next you're going to tell me they're you know,
- 1:01:21two turtle doves and a partridge in a pear tree
- 1:01:23I'm sorry. What can we say the like life in law
- 1:01:27is nuanced? So step seven is actually a non -legal
- 1:01:31point So even if you think the risk of losing
- 1:01:34a case is low, there might still be instances
- 1:01:38where you choose to get consent anyways. Wait,
- 1:01:42why on earth would I even do that? There are
- 1:01:45non -legal factors we really urge you to consider.
- 1:01:47Even with a solid event like defense, you should
- 1:01:50consider whether the insurance issuing the E
- 1:01:54&O policy agrees with your risk analysis. Another
- 1:01:58thing you should consider is whether you're viewed
- 1:02:01as an attractive litigation target with deep,
- 1:02:04deep pockets someone could go after. So a small
- 1:02:07independent film is different than a major studio.
- 1:02:12But you definitely want to weigh that when you're
- 1:02:14considering whether to get consent. And another
- 1:02:17big factor you should weigh is whether the rights
- 1:02:20holder has a documented history of being aggressive
- 1:02:24in trademark enforcement. So some brands are
- 1:02:26known for sending cease and desist letter out
- 1:02:28like candy. So at the first sign of unauthorized
- 1:02:32use, you're getting a letter. Some file suit
- 1:02:35fast and they litigate hard and that's true for
- 1:02:38like celebrities and their states and their teams
- 1:02:41as well. So a rights holder doesn't need to have
- 1:02:44a strong legal basis for filing a claim. Filing
- 1:02:48a claim could be a tactic. So it could be a pressure
- 1:02:50tool designed to force you to negotiate a license
- 1:02:53with them. It could delay your release. They
- 1:02:57could make litigation so costly that a settlement
- 1:03:00is like the easier path that you just decide
- 1:03:02to take. And so some of these brands have virtually
- 1:03:06bottomless litigation budgets and you do not.
- 1:03:09And so even when the law is on your side, you
- 1:03:11have to ask yourself a separate question. And
- 1:03:14that is, who are we dealing with? Okay, so why
- 1:03:18not just always ask for permission then? It's
- 1:03:21a balance. So sometimes asking for permission
- 1:03:24may be riskier than not asking. A few factors
- 1:03:27to consider are like one notice. So seeking permission,
- 1:03:31you could actually tell the rights holder that
- 1:03:34you're using it and they like without you telling
- 1:03:36them they otherwise would have never noticed
- 1:03:38it and never worried about it. Another thing
- 1:03:40is timing. So obtaining permission can be a lengthy
- 1:03:43process. So even after lengthy negotiations,
- 1:03:47the brand can come back and they can still say
- 1:03:49no or they can say here's the license fee and
- 1:03:51it could be a high amount that you can't afford
- 1:03:53in the first place. And then another thing is
- 1:03:56resources. So negotiating a license, finding
- 1:03:59the true copyright owner and like other matters,
- 1:04:02it all takes. you know, money and time. And so
- 1:04:06time and money are really the non -legal considerations
- 1:04:09to, you know, to think about. I mean, that showbiz
- 1:04:13alright. Okay. So I promise that even if all
- 1:04:16appears clear on the legal front, I'll consider,
- 1:04:18you know, the pros and cons from a business and
- 1:04:20our risk perspective, you know, in deciding whether
- 1:04:22to seek consent. No, this is honestly been great.
- 1:04:26You know, I've learned a lot. I'd like to hire
- 1:04:28you, you know, as my attorneys though. Definitely
- 1:04:31not in the movie. I already have a leading woman
- 1:04:33in mind. I think it's Zendaya. She's going to
- 1:04:36play twins like Lindsay Lohan in The Parent Trap.
- 1:04:39But nonetheless, what's your retainer? $1 billion.
- 1:04:46And C. Yeah, exactly. Take a bow. Yeah, thank
- 1:04:52you all for bearing with us. Oscar -level word
- 1:04:57worthy acting. Absolutely So I see that there
- 1:05:00is we went over and there's like 13 questions
- 1:05:03in the chat Serene and I do need to jump but
- 1:05:07we want to answer at least one of these questions.
- 1:05:09So let me just Open this and see you Yeah, and
- 1:05:14thanks for staying with us Okay, um if I see
- 1:05:21a question here if use of the mark is protected
- 1:05:23under rogers does that protection extend to promotional
- 1:05:26materials so like the trailers and the posters
- 1:05:29for this one's a great question. I can take it
- 1:05:32yeah go for it okay so often yes when the promotional
- 1:05:38uses simply marketing the expressive work and
- 1:05:41doesn't. Like it mislead consumers, which we've
- 1:05:44talked about a lot today. The use is permitted.
- 1:05:46There was like a case in the night circuit. It
- 1:05:49was a empire case. So Fox is empire TV show.
- 1:05:54Um, it is about like a fictional hip hop label
- 1:05:57based in New York. Um, and then there's a real
- 1:06:00music label called empire distribution and empire
- 1:06:03distribution was not too happy with Fox's empire
- 1:06:06use and. When they were arguing empire distribution
- 1:06:11the real record label tried to say, hey rogers
- 1:06:15doesn't work for fox's use of empire because
- 1:06:18they're using it outside of the title of the
- 1:06:20work and the body of the work they're using it
- 1:06:23in promotional materials there people are doing
- 1:06:25cast events they're releasing music under the
- 1:06:28album there's shirts but the court basically
- 1:06:32said like. The court disagreed with them and
- 1:06:36said like although the promotional efforts technically
- 1:06:39fall outside of the title of the work and the
- 1:06:42body of the work Rogers logically needs to extend
- 1:06:45to promotional materials because if you're allowed
- 1:06:48to. If the use itself is protected that it makes
- 1:06:51sense and logically it makes sense for you to
- 1:06:53be able to promote under the thing that you're
- 1:06:56allowed to call it. But you know marketing is
- 1:06:58risky so again. always be thinking, like, am
- 1:07:01I confusing anyone? Is there a chance that I
- 1:07:03could? And stay far away from that. Thank you.
- 1:07:09For any of the questions that we didn't get to,
- 1:07:11please feel free to reach out to us. The emails
- 1:07:14are on our firm website. So we definitely want
- 1:07:19to answer those questions for you guys. So thank
- 1:07:22you so much. Really appreciate it. Bye, everyone.