Latest / Reformed Thinking / On the Feeding of the 5000
Transcript
- 0:00Usually when you think about a courtroom you you expect a very
- 0:05specific rigid sort of dynamic. Right, very formal.
- 0:08Yeah, very formal. A judge sits elevated behind a
- 0:11heavy wooden bench. A defendant stands trial.
- 0:14Physical evidence sits on tables in little plastic bags.
- 0:18Witnesses take the stand. One by one they get sworn in and
- 0:22they answer questions. It is orderly, it is sequential,
- 0:25and the rules are strictly defined.
- 0:27Absolutely. But, you know, imagine walking
- 0:30into a courtroom where the person on trial is actually the
- 0:33judge. That is a wild thought.
- 0:35Right, and the defendant is the one who wrote the very law they
- 0:37are being accused of breaking. Yeah, and the people hurling the
- 0:40accusations are using his own legal code to trump convict him.
- 0:44It is a completely upside down, dizzying scenario.
- 0:47It really is. That is the precise paradox we
- 0:49are looking at today. Welcome to reformed thinking.
- 0:52I am thrilled you are joining us.
- 0:54Yes, glad you are here with us. If you are listening to this
- 0:56right now, you are likely someone who wants to grasp the
- 0:59massive theological weight of scripture without getting lost
- 1:03in a confusing maze of academic jargon.
- 1:05Right, keeping it clear. You want to understand what the
- 1:07text says, and you want to do that with absolute clarity.
- 1:12So today our mission is to unpack Daryl L Bach's commentary
- 1:16on John, chapters 5 and 6. It's a fantastic commentary, by
- 1:20the way. It really is.
- 1:21We are framing this entire discussion around a single
- 1:25massive question. How does someone prove they are
- 1:29the author of reality? That is the big one.
- 1:31We are going to watch how Jesus defends his divine authority in
- 1:35that figurative courtroom, and then how he practically
- 1:38demonstrates that same authority over physical lack and the very
- 1:42laws of nature. Framing it around that question
- 1:44of proving authorship over reality is brilliant because
- 1:47that is the core tension of these two chapters.
- 1:50But before we look at the specific verses, we should
- 1:53establish the theological lens through which we are viewing
- 1:55this text as a show rooted in Protestant Reformed theology.
- 2:00We hold to the doctrines outline in the Westminster Confession.
- 2:03When you read John Five and Six through that lens, 3 massive
- 2:07realities just, you know, jump off the page first.
- 2:10You see the absolute, unquestionable sovereignty of
- 2:13God over all things. Meaning God is in total control
- 2:16of both salvation and the physical universe.
- 2:19Spot on. Second, you see the singular
- 2:21authority of scripture. The Bible is not like a self
- 2:24help manual. It is an instrument pointing
- 2:27exclusively to Christ. Yes, exclusively.
- 2:30And 3rd we see a stark depiction of human inability in
- 2:33theological circles. This is called total depravity.
- 2:36Which can sound like like a really harsh term.
- 2:38It can. Yeah.
- 2:39That term can sound intimidating or like we are saying humans are
- 2:42as bad as they could possibly be.
- 2:44But it actually means that our internal compass is broken,
- 2:47right? Apart from divine intervention,
- 2:49our natural inclination is to reject God.
- 2:52We are going to see that total inability on full display in the
- 2:55crowds and the religious leaders Jesus interacts with today.
- 2:58That broken compass analogy is perfect.
- 3:00It helps us understand why the people in these chapters act the
- 3:03way they do. Well, absolutely.
- 3:05Oh, and before we jump in, let me stayed a ground rule for this
- 3:08deep dive. Right, the rule.
- 3:09We're going to let each other finish our thoughts completely
- 3:12today, avoiding any interruptions to ensure a clear,
- 3:15systematic unpacking of the text.
- 3:18I am fully on board with that. It helps keep things organized.
- 3:21Perfect. OK, let's unpack this by
- 3:23stepping into the tense scene of John chapter 5.
- 3:26Jesus is facing severe opposition from the religious
- 3:29leaders regarding his authority over the Sabbath.
- 3:32Right, the Sabbath healing. Yeah, he has just healed A
- 3:35paralyzed man by the the pool of Bethesda on the Fabeth, which
- 3:39the religious leaders view as a blatant violation of their laws.
- 3:42A. Huge issue for them.
- 3:44Huge. And instead of apologizing or
- 3:46claiming it was, you know, an emergency exception, Jesus
- 3:49responds by claiming an unbreakable unity between his
- 3:52work and the Father's work. He double s down.
- 3:54He does, he says. My father is working until now,
- 3:56and I'm working. He places himself on the same
- 3:59level as God the Father, claiming authority over life
- 4:02itself. Which was just shocking to hear.
- 4:05Totally shocking. He tells them that the rules
- 4:08governing humanity do not constrain him because he offered
- 4:11those rules. He is the Lord of the Sabbath.
- 4:14This claim is what initiates the trial.
- 4:16This is the figurative courtroom scene.
- 4:18Jesus is standing before the religious establishment and he
- 4:21knows they need proof. He knows their legal system
- 4:23inside and out. So he decides to play by their
- 4:25rules. He really leans directly into
- 4:28their legal system to dismantle their accusations.
- 4:31In the Old Testament, the legal standard required to establish
- 4:34truth in any matter was quite high.
- 4:37Very high. Deuteronomy 19.15 demands two or
- 4:41three witnesses to confirm any charge.
- 4:44You could not just accuse someone and have it stand on
- 4:46your word alone. Right, it had to be verified.
- 4:49The testimony had to be corroborated.
- 4:51Jesus accepts this premise, but utterly overwhelms the
- 4:54requirement. Yeah, he is above and beyond.
- 4:56He brings not 2, not 3, but 4 distinct, unassailable witnesses
- 5:01to the table to testify to His divine connection and authority.
- 5:05OK, let's list those out. The first witness he calls is
- 5:07John the Baptist. This is a human witness.
- 5:10The religious leaders had initially celebrated and sent
- 5:12priests to investigate. The second witness is the
- 5:16Father's works. These are the miraculous signs
- 5:19Jesus is performing, which could only happen by divine approval.
- 5:23The physical evidence, basically.
- 5:24Absolutely. The third witness is the
- 5:26Scripture itself, the very texts these leaders have dedicated
- 5:30their lives to studying. Yes.
- 5:32And the fourth witness is Moses, the supreme human figure in
- 5:37their religious hierarchy. Jesus stacks the deck with the
- 5:40highest possible authorities in the Jewish legal and religious
- 5:43mind. He builds a case that is legally
- 5:46airtight according to their own standards.
- 5:48That third witness, he brings up the scripture that creates A
- 5:52fascinating contrast in the text.
- 5:54It really does. There is a massive divide
- 5:56between how Jesus reads Scripture and how his audience
- 5:59reads it. The religious leaders think that
- 6:01obsessively searching the text will grant them eternal life.
- 6:04Think about it like a map. It is as if they are holding a
- 6:08map to a hidden treasure and they become obsessed with the
- 6:11parchment it is printed on. Oh, that is a great way to put
- 6:14it. They study the ink, they
- 6:15memorize the folds of the paper, they debate the font used on the
- 6:19map, and they believe that simply possessing and analyzing
- 6:22this piece of paper makes them rich.
- 6:24Right, they miss the point completely.
- 6:26They absolutely refuse to look up from the map and travel to
- 6:30the destination it is pointing toward.
- 6:33They search the Torah, believing the text itself contains eternal
- 6:36life. Jesus, however, reads Scripture
- 6:39entirely differently. He views it as the revelation of
- 6:42a promise, a promise that culminates in Him.
- 6:46The map is pointing to a person. The historical context provided
- 6:50in box commentary shows how accurate your map analogy is.
- 6:54Really. Yeah, the footnote shed
- 6:55incredible light on the rabbinic thought of that era.
- 6:58For example, Rabbi Hillel, he was a massive figure whose
- 7:01teachings are recorded in the Mishnah.
- 7:02OK. He taught that if a man has
- 7:04gained for himself the words of the law, he has gained for
- 7:07himself life in the world to come.
- 7:09Wow, just possessing the words yes.
- 7:11We see the same mindset in the apocryphal Book of Baruch, which
- 7:15states that all who hold fast to the law are appointed to life.
- 7:19Interesting. The prevailing belief was that
- 7:22the Torah was an end in itself. Jesus flips this entirely on its
- 7:26head. He sure does.
- 7:28He states that Scriptures true function is to bear witness to
- 7:31him. By refusing Jesus, the religious
- 7:35leaders are refusing the life the scriptures promise.
- 7:38Which is just tragic. It is this brings us to the root
- 7:42of their unbelief, Jesus diagnosis their rejection not as
- 7:46a lack of sufficient evidence. They had plenty of that.
- 7:48Right. They had the miracles.
- 7:49They had John the Baptist, they had the texts Jesus diagnosis,
- 7:53their own belief as a fundamental lack of love for
- 7:56God. In their hearts they seek human
- 7:58approval and glory from one another rather than the glory
- 8:01that comes from the only God. This is the Westminster
- 8:04Confessions view of human depravity in action.
- 8:07Broken compass again. Absolutely.
- 8:09The mind is darkened, the will is in bondage and without a
- 8:12heart supernaturally oriented toward God.
- 8:15No amount of logical or miraculous evidence will ever
- 8:19convince a person they cannot believe because their desires
- 8:23are entirely captive to human praise.
- 8:25Here's where it gets really interesting and, frankly, a bit
- 8:28shocking. Oh yeah, Jesus concludes his
- 8:31defense with A twist ending that must have felt like a physical
- 8:36blow to his audience. A total gut punch.
- 8:39The religious leaders view Moses as their absolute hero.
- 8:42Moses is the Lawgiver. Moses is their advocate.
- 8:45Their entire religious identity and their hope for standing
- 8:48before God is wrapped up in their allegiance to Moses, and
- 8:52Jesus looks right at them and reveals that Moses will actually
- 8:55be their accuser before the Father.
- 8:56It is a stunning reversal the. Defense attorney they thought
- 8:59they had hired is actually the lead prosecutor for the state.
- 9:01Great analogy. Jesus explains why because Moses
- 9:05wrote about him. He is likely alluding to
- 9:07Deuteronomy 18.18 where God promises to raise up a prophet
- 9:11like Moses from among the people and demands that the people
- 9:14listen to him. Jesus is telling them that
- 9:17because they are rejecting the one Moses wrote about, Moses
- 9:20himself will stand and condemn their unbelief.
- 9:23The way this is written in ancient Greek carries a hidden
- 9:26punch too. Oh.
- 9:27Really. Tell me about that.
- 9:28The commentary analyzes the structure of John 5.46 as a
- 9:32second class conditional clause. OK.
- 9:35It translates roughly as if you believed Moses you would have
- 9:40believed in me. But the grammatical implication
- 9:43of this specific Greek structure is heavily sarcastic away.
- 9:47Yes, it actually implies if you believed Moses, which we both
- 9:50know you do not, then you would have believed in me.
- 9:53Oh wow. It is a total exposure of their
- 9:56hypocrisy and the text notes that this functions as a classic
- 9:59literary open ending. Jesus delivers.
- 10:02This devastating critique states that failure to believe Moses
- 10:06leads to failure to leave Jesus, and then the discourse simply
- 10:09stops. Just dead silence.
- 10:11The narrative offers no immediate reaction from the
- 10:13Pharisees. The question is left hanging in
- 10:16the air. If you are listening to this,
- 10:17think about what you would do with that silence.
- 10:19Jesus just stops talking. He leaves the reality of their
- 10:23condemnation and the identity of their true accuser suspended in
- 10:27the silent air of that courtyard.
- 10:28So heavy. It forces the original audience
- 10:32and it forces you, reading it today, to ponder the truth of
- 10:35his words. You have to decide what you are
- 10:38going to do with the fact that the entire Old Testament points
- 10:41forward to this single man standing before the religious
- 10:45elite. Absolutely.
- 10:46And with that heavy silence, the text forces us to turn the page.
- 10:50We move from this incredibly tense intellectual legal debate
- 10:53in Jerusalem to a very different scene in John chapter 6.
- 10:57A huge shift geographically and temporally.
- 10:59We're going to go a massive shift.
- 11:00We move up another to the region of Galilee.
- 11:03The text specifically mentions the Sea of Galilee, noting that
- 11:06is also known as the Sea of Tiberias.
- 11:08That is an interesting historical marker because
- 11:10Tiberias was a city founded on the shores of the lake in 8026
- 11:13by Herod Antipas, named after the Roman emperor.
- 11:16Yes, it grounds the narrative in actual, verifiable history, and
- 11:20it also subtly highlights the looming presence of the Roman
- 11:23occupation over the Jewish people.
- 11:25The timing of this shift is just as critical as the geography.
- 11:29John explicitly points out that it is Passover.
- 11:32OK, unpack that. In John's Gospel, these temporal
- 11:35markers are never accidental. Passover is the defining
- 11:39national memory for the Jewish people, right?
- 11:41It is not just a holiday, it is their entire identity.
- 11:45It commemorates their liberation from slavery in Egypt, the
- 11:49leadership of Moses, and the supernatural provision of manna
- 11:52in the wilderness. So all those themes are coming
- 11:54back up. Absolutely.
- 11:56By setting the events of Chapter 6 against the backdrop of
- 11:59Passover, John is prepping the reader's theological palette.
- 12:03All of those historical themes, Liberation.
- 12:05Moses, bread from heaven are about to be activated.
- 12:09Wow. This historical backdrop sets
- 12:11the stage for everything Jesus is about to do, and it explains
- 12:14the fever pitch of the crowd crowding around him.
- 12:16Right, because the text tells us a massive crowd is following
- 12:20Jesus and we know why. Oh yeah, they are following him
- 12:22because of the miraculous healing signs He has been
- 12:25performing both back in Jerusalem and here in Galilee.
- 12:28The signs were drawing huge numbers.
- 12:30They have seen him heal the sick, they've seen him restore
- 12:33bodies, and they are drawn to that spectacle.
- 12:35They want a front row seat to the supernatural.
- 12:37Who wouldn't? So Jesus goes up on a mountain,
- 12:40sits down with his disciples, looks up and sees this massive
- 12:43throng of humanity coming toward him.
- 12:46He decides to initiate a miracle, but he does it in a
- 12:49very specific, almost strange way.
- 12:52He turns to Philip and asks him a question.
- 12:55Where are we to buy bread so that these people may eat?
- 12:59No, wait, hold on. If Philip is just a regular guy,
- 13:02why is Jesus putting this massive, impossible logistical
- 13:06nightmare on his shoulders? That is a great question.
- 13:09Jesus has Peter, He has John, He has these prominent leaders
- 13:12among the disciples. Why is 0 in on Philip for this
- 13:15particular problem? The text provides a very
- 13:18practical geographical reason alongside A deeper theological
- 13:21one. OK, practically Philip was a
- 13:23local. We know from John 1.44 that
- 13:26Philip was from nearby Bethsaida.
- 13:28Oh, that makes sense. He would know the local markets,
- 13:30the bakeries, and the sheer logistics of acquiring food in
- 13:34that specific region. If anyone knew where to buy
- 13:36bread, it was Phillip right? However, the text explicitly
- 13:40notes that Jesus is asking this to test Phillips faith and his
- 13:44understanding. Jesus already knew what he was
- 13:46going to do. So it was a setup.
- 13:49Well, yes, absolutely a setup. This entire situation is an
- 13:53active instruction for the disciples.
- 13:55He is pushing Philip to the absolute limit of his human
- 13:58resources so that Philip can realize his total inadequacy.
- 14:03Jesus is teaching the disciples about who He is by first showing
- 14:06them who they are not. Philip's response reveals sheer
- 14:10unadulterated panic regarding the financial reality of the
- 14:13situation. Complete panic.
- 14:15You can almost see him mentally checking his ancient Judean bank
- 14:17account. He does the math in his head,
- 14:19looks at Jesus and says 200 denarii's worth of bread would
- 14:23not be enough for each of them to get a little.
- 14:25Let's break down that financial reality so we can feel the
- 14:28weight of Phillips panic. A denarius was the standard wage
- 14:31for a single day of manual labor. 200 denarii means 200
- 14:35days of back breaking work. If we account for a standard 6
- 14:39day work week observing the Sabbath, we are talking about
- 14:44roughly 33 weeks of Labor. That is massive.
- 14:47That is well over half a year salary just to buy enough bread
- 14:50so that everyone gets a tiny crumb.
- 14:53And this crowd is staggering in size.
- 14:55The text mentions 5000 men. In that cultural context, women
- 15:00and children were counted separately, meaning the total
- 15:03crowd could have easily been up to 20,000 people.
- 15:06Which is a whole town, basically the.
- 15:08Logistics are entirely impossible.
- 15:10Into this impossible situation steps Andrew, who brings forward
- 15:14a young man. The details surrounding this
- 15:16young man and what he brings are highly significant.
- 15:19Tell me more about that. The Greek term used for young
- 15:21man is paid. Darian Bach's notes point out
- 15:24that this does not necessarily mean a small child, which is
- 15:27often how it is depicted in classic Sunday school lessons.
- 15:29Right, I always pictured a little kid.
- 15:31Most people do, but the Septuagint, the Greek
- 15:34translation of the Old Testament, uses the same word
- 15:37for Joseph when he was 17 years old and for men of marriageable
- 15:41age in the apocryphal literature.
- 15:43Oh wow. So this is likely a teenager or
- 15:46a young adult and the offering he brings is incredibly meager.
- 15:495 barley loaves and two fish. We really need to highlight the
- 15:53specific detail about those barley loaves.
- 15:56It is not just about the small amount of food, it is about the
- 15:59quality. Yes, the quality is key.
- 16:01The commentary brings in a quote from the Jewish philosopher
- 16:04Philo, who lived around the same time.
- 16:06Philo wrote that barley bread was strictly the bread of the
- 16:10poor. He actually described it as food
- 16:12fit for irrational animals and needy men.
- 16:15It was essentially animal feed. Wheat was the bread of the
- 16:18wealthy. Barley was the dirt cheap,
- 16:20absolute lowest quality grain you could consume.
- 16:23So not only is the quantity pathetic, 5 small lows for
- 16:2520,000 people, but the quality is the absolute bottom tier.
- 16:29Bringing 5 barley loaves to feed this massive crowd is like
- 16:33showing up to a Super Bowl party with 20,000 guests and you
- 16:37brought a single half empty bag of generic potato chips.
- 16:41It is a visceral image of absolute physical lack.
- 16:46It is the perfect canvas for a display of divine sovereignty.
- 16:49Yes, it is. The text tells us that Jesus has
- 16:52the crowd sit down. He takes the barley loaves, and
- 16:55he gives thanks. OK, now this blessing was likely
- 16:58the standard Jewish blessing offered before a meal.
- 17:01A faithful Jew would say, Blessed are you, O Lord God,
- 17:04King of the universe, who brings forth bread from the earth.
- 17:07After giving thanks, Jesus distributes as much as the
- 17:10people want of both the bread and the fish.
- 17:12Notice the contrast. The panic versus the provision.
- 17:15Precisely. Philip panicked that 200 days
- 17:18wages would only give everyone a tiny crumb.
- 17:21Jesus provides until everyone has as much as they desire.
- 17:23Wow. There is no lack in the economy
- 17:25of God. He takes the animal feet of the
- 17:27poor and turns it into a royal feast.
- 17:29And then he instructs the disciples to gather up the
- 17:32remainder so that nothing is lost.
- 17:34They gather the leftovers and they fill exactly 12 baskets
- 17:38with the broken pieces of the five barley loaves.
- 17:41Right. When we look at this detail, we
- 17:42have to ask about the symbols. 12 baskets of leftovers for 12
- 17:47disciples. It seems too specific to be a
- 17:50coincidence. The commentary suggests that
- 17:53this likely points to the 12 tribes of Israel.
- 17:55And that makes a lot of sense. It is a symbolic demonstration
- 17:58that Jesus is the true provider for the entire nation.
- 18:02Just as God provided manna for the 12 tribes in the wilderness
- 18:06under Moses, Jesus is providing supernatural sustenance here.
- 18:10The Passover connection again. Absolutely.
- 18:13But he is not just repeating the miracle of the manna, He is
- 18:16surpassing it. How so?
- 18:17The manna in the Old Testament rotted if the Israelites trying
- 18:20to keep it overnight. Here there is a super abundance
- 18:24that remains gathered by the new leadership of the 12 disciples.
- 18:27It also strongly connects to Old Testament precedent.
- 18:30We see echoes of the prophet Elijah in 2 Kings chapter 4,
- 18:34where Elijah miraculously feeds 100 men with 20 loaves of barley
- 18:38and they have some leftover. Jesus is doing what Elijah did,
- 18:42but on an exponentially larger scale.
- 18:45We also see echoes of the Messianic promises in the Psalms
- 18:48and the Prophets. Which the crowds would have
- 18:50known. Psalm 22 speaks of the afflicted
- 18:52eating and being satisfied. Isaiah 55 issues a divine
- 18:57invitation. Come everyone who thirsts come
- 19:00to the waters, and he who has no money come buy and eat.
- 19:05Jesus is visibly, practically fulfilling these massive Old
- 19:09Testament promises right in front of them.
- 19:11The crowd sees the sign. They eat the bread and they
- 19:14reach a conclusion. OK, what do they decide?
- 19:16They say this is indeed the prophet who is to come into the
- 19:19world. They are referencing that
- 19:21precise promise from Deuteronomy 18 about a prophet like Moses.
- 19:25They correctly identify Jesus as the coming prophet.
- 19:28But then they take a very dangerous turn.
- 19:29They completely misunderstand his mission.
- 19:32This misunderstanding is rooted in their fleshly desires.
- 19:36They experience the supernatural provision and their immediate
- 19:38reaction is to seize him by force and make him a political
- 19:41king. We have to remember the
- 19:43geopolitical tension, the Roman occupation.
- 19:46The Jewish people were subjugated, heavily taxed and
- 19:49desperate for liberation. They want it out.
- 19:51They see a man who can create food out of thin air and they
- 19:54immediately calculate his military value.
- 19:57That is so true. They want a Messiah who will
- 19:59guarantee endless free bread. Fund an army without a supply
- 20:04chain problem and overthrow Rome.
- 20:07They want physical comfort and political victory.
- 20:10But Jesus rejects that. Completely.
- 20:12Jesus completely rejects this fleshly political goal.
- 20:15He views his kingship through a spiritual lens.
- 20:18This moment heavily foreshadows his later trial before Pilate in
- 20:22John 18, where Jesus will explicitly state my Kingdom is
- 20:26not of this world. Because he refuses to be the
- 20:29kind of king they want. He withdraws to the mountain by
- 20:31himself. He will not be drafted into
- 20:33their political revolution. It is a stunning rejection of
- 20:36worldly power by Jesus. The crowd wants to hand him a
- 20:39crown and he walks away from it. And that withdrawal sets up the
- 20:435th sign, which takes place later that evening.
- 20:46The scene shifts from the mountain to the water.
- 20:49The disciples get into a boat and start rowing back toward
- 20:52Capernaum. Right.
- 20:54The text gives us precise measurements again.
- 20:57It says they had rode about 25 or 30 stadia when the winds
- 21:00started blowing fiercely. Let's do the math on this storm
- 21:04for a second, because it illustrates their total
- 21:05helplessness. A stadium is roughly 600 feet.
- 21:09The Sea of Galilee is about 12 1/2 miles long and seven miles
- 21:13wide at its broadest point. If they have rode 25 to 30
- 21:18stadia, that translates to roughly 2 3/4 to 3 1/2 miles out
- 21:22onto the water. They're literally right in the
- 21:25dead center of the lake. Absolutely trapped.
- 21:27They cannot swim to the western shore and they cannot swim to
- 21:30the Eastern Shore. They are exhausted, it is pitch
- 21:33dark, the sea is raging, and they are trapped.
- 21:36And right in the middle of this terrifying isolation, they see
- 21:39Jesus walking on the water, approaching the boat.
- 21:42It is a display of absolute authority over the forces of
- 21:46creation. But this raises an interesting
- 21:48issue among theologians. Is this event truly considered
- 21:52one of the Johannian signs? OK, unpack that.
- 21:55The Gospel of John is structured around these specific public
- 21:57signs that point to Jesus's identity.
- 22:00But this miracle happened privately, in the dark, with
- 22:03only the frightened disciples present as witnesses.
- 22:06That is a fascinating point of tension.
- 22:09If the goal of a sign in John's Gospel is to publicly testify to
- 22:13his authority and validate his claims, how does a private walk
- 22:16on a dark lake qualify? That seems to break the pattern.
- 22:20The commentary explains a divide among scholars on this issue.
- 22:23OK, a scholar named Kostenberger argues that it actually does not
- 22:27qualify as a formal sign specifically because of its
- 22:30private nature. He views it as an internal
- 22:32lesson for the disciples meant to bolster their faith, rather
- 22:35than a public declaration to the world.
- 22:37I can see that. However, DA Carson offers a
- 22:40different perspective that resolves the tension
- 22:42beautifully. Parson points out what happens
- 22:44the very next day. The crowd on the other side of
- 22:46the lake does some deductive reasoning.
- 22:49They realized that only one boat had left the shore the night
- 22:51before, and they saw the disciples leaving it without
- 22:54Jesus. OK, so they do the math.
- 22:56Yes, yet when they find Jesus on the other side of the lake the
- 22:59next morning, they are baffled. They ask him, Rabbi, when did
- 23:03you get here? The private miracle becomes
- 23:06public knowledge through their logical deduction.
- 23:09The fact that he crossed the sea without a boat validates his
- 23:12divine authority over the physical constraints of nature
- 23:15to the crowds as well. I love how the logical deduction
- 23:18of the crowd turns a private moment into a public validation
- 23:21of His sovereignty. It is brilliant.
- 23:23When we synthesize all of this, what we see across John 5 and
- 23:27John 6 is a brilliant, cohesive progression.
- 23:31It answers our central question about how the author of reality
- 23:34proves his identity. In chapter 5, Jesus provides A
- 23:38rigorous, legally structured verbal defense of his authority.
- 23:43He calls 4 distinct witnesses to prove he is equal with the
- 23:46Father. Then, in chapter 6, he moves
- 23:49from verbal defense to physical demonstration.
- 23:52He shows absolute, unquestionable sovereignty over
- 23:56physical lack by multiplying the animal feet of the poor into a
- 23:59feast, and he shows absolute sovereignty over natural lies by
- 24:04walking on top of a raging sea. He is the judge, He is the
- 24:07provider, and He is the Lord of creation.
- 24:10Looking at this through our reformed theological lens, we
- 24:13see a consistent picture of human nature that is frankly
- 24:16quite sobering. It really is.
- 24:18The crowd in chapter 6 desires A Messiah who acts as a cosmic
- 24:22vending machine. They want someone who provides
- 24:24physical comfort, economic stability and political victory.
- 24:28Right, all the benefits. They want the gifts, but they do
- 24:30not want the giver. When Jesus demands spiritual
- 24:34submission, when he points to the glory of the Father rather
- 24:36than their own temporal satisfaction, they resist him.
- 24:40The religious leaders in Chapter 5 resist him because he
- 24:42threatens their theological pride and their status.
- 24:46The crowds in Chapter 6 resist him because he refuses to cater
- 24:49to their physical appetites and their political ambitions.
- 24:52Both groups demonstrate a heart that is hostile to the true
- 24:55Sovereign Lord. It is a perfect illustration of
- 24:58how our internal compass is broken.
- 25:01That brings us to a final thought, a question I want to
- 25:03leave with you today. In John 5, Jesus looked at the
- 25:07most religiously educated people in the country and told them
- 25:11that if they truly understood Moses, if they truly understood
- 25:14the scriptures they spent their lives memorizing, they would
- 25:17recognize him, right? But they missed it because they
- 25:20were looking for the wrong thing.
- 25:22So the question is, when you open the scriptures today, what
- 25:25are you looking for? That is the big question.
- 25:27Are you just searching for a life hack?
- 25:29A formula for a better life? Much like the crowd wanting an
- 25:33endless supply of free bread. Or are you allowing the text to
- 25:36do its real work, to confront you, to dismantle your
- 25:39expectations, and to bring you face to face with the absolute
- 25:42sovereign authority of the Son of God?
- 25:45Amen. It is something to think about
- 25:46the next time you find yourself standing in that courtroom.
- 25:49Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into reformed
- 25:51thinking. We will see you next time.