Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / A Midsummer Night's Dream (1935)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Shakespeare returns in our
- 0:24little neck of the woods here. You can't do this
- 0:27after I just watched Spider -Man. Oh. You can't
- 0:29do a Shakespeare will return. Yet here he has.
- 0:32And yet he has with a vengeance. vengeance is
- 0:35a great way to describe what we're about to talk
- 0:38to uh about today can i ask you your familiarity
- 0:43with a midsummer night's oh man so i've i've
- 0:46gone on record saying like i am not the shakespeare
- 0:49guy and not even to the point where like i don't
- 0:52want to be i'm not anti -shakespeare i am just
- 0:55so unfamiliar with his work Which is so funny
- 0:58because I feel like there's so many like modern
- 1:00retellings of his work. But you're not familiar
- 1:02with the core work, like his work specifically.
- 1:06Yeah, I mean, we've covered a little bit of Shakespeare
- 1:09on the podcast with Hamnet at the beginning of
- 1:12this year. And, you know, that's kind of the
- 1:15behind the scenes making of Hamlet. We haven't
- 1:19done a Shakespeare play yet, have we? Not yet,
- 1:22no. We'll get there with Romeo and Juliet, too.
- 1:25Yeah, next year we do Romeo and Juliet. Next
- 1:28month, rather. So, I'm so unfamiliar. I admittedly
- 1:32had to watch a Shakespeare in 90 seconds video
- 1:36just so I could wrap my head around what this
- 1:39movie was going to be. So, I'll go ahead and
- 1:42start at the end here. You did something kind
- 1:45of unprecedented on our last episode where you
- 1:47took back... a double feature that you had from
- 1:50a previous entry because it placed better with
- 1:53Captain Blood. And I was thinking about doing
- 1:57the same thing here after you did that for, oh,
- 2:01I can't remember what I did it for, but it was
- 2:03Get Over It. And Get Over It is a teenage comedy
- 2:07that I and my brother loved growing up, and I
- 2:10still do. But it is about a guy in love with
- 2:13a girl who tries to get close to her through,
- 2:16he knows she's in drama, so he follows her to
- 2:19the drama production of A Midsummer Night's Dream.
- 2:22And then the story itself is kind of A Midsummer
- 2:26Night's Dream, but it happens within the... production
- 2:28of that exact play. That's funny. So I know a
- 2:32little bit about A Midsummer Night's Dream because
- 2:34of that movie. Interesting. So I had a pretty
- 2:37good understanding of what was going to happen
- 2:39roughly here because of that movie and how much
- 2:43I loved it. Man. Yes. Somebody was like, oh,
- 2:46well, you probably know the story through like
- 2:49a modern retelling. And I looked, I don't think
- 2:53I've ever seen this story told in any format.
- 2:56No, not to this degree. Honestly, it's not one
- 3:00that's touched that often. I think you can have
- 3:02the human relationships of the four leads that
- 3:05we'll talk about here. You can have that be told
- 3:07in some way and call that a modern retelling,
- 3:10but with fairy intervention and everything, no,
- 3:13that's pretty specific to this. Or get over it,
- 3:16in which case it's done through production and
- 3:18not actually happening. But still, fun to talk
- 3:21about. Yeah, I want to preface this episode a
- 3:23little bit with just saying that I know that
- 3:26I am ignorant to Shakespeare and I want to improve
- 3:29on that. But when when you sit here and you hear
- 3:32me talk about like, yeah, I just I just didn't
- 3:35get some of it. I know. I know I'm the problem.
- 3:38So when you say ignorant, do you mean just unaware
- 3:41or like unwelcoming? It's not that I'm unwelcoming.
- 3:44I feel like I have to sit with Shakespeare and
- 3:49have like the spark notes next to me. to really
- 3:51even be able to keep up with what's going on.
- 3:54Is it the dialogue? A lot of it's the dialogue.
- 3:57Yeah, yeah. I don't know. I'm just really bad
- 4:00at it. So I think that's how I feel, is that
- 4:04the dialogue, and again, I'm speaking broadly,
- 4:07not just of Midsummer Night's Dream, but I think
- 4:10in general, his dialogue to me is something that...
- 4:15keeps me from being able to be heavily invested
- 4:17in the story. But also Shakespeare in general,
- 4:20if you can do retellings of it, I'm very interested
- 4:23because obviously that's the way it needs to
- 4:24be done, right? You can't out Shakespeare Shakespeare,
- 4:27so you've got to do it in a different way. And
- 4:29that's why I think things like 10 Things I Hate
- 4:32About You, Get Over It, these all work a little
- 4:35bit better in my favor because it is a way to
- 4:37kind of explain. Even like Clueless, I know that's
- 4:40not Shakespeare, but like Emma. It's a modern
- 4:43retelling of Emma. And that is something that
- 4:46helps us get a little more closer to the core
- 4:48text of like, oh, well, this is the tone. This
- 4:50is the idea that they're going for. And I appreciate
- 4:54those retellings of it. This is less of a retelling
- 4:59and more just straight up, this is what the poem
- 5:02is. Or this is what Shakespeare wrote. Yeah,
- 5:04this is... This is pretty it. Let's get into
- 5:07it. I'll say this right from the bat. I don't
- 5:10know if I'm a Shakespeare guy. Right? yeah and
- 5:13that's how i feel but i'm so hesitant to say
- 5:15that but and i don't mean that in a way of like
- 5:17as soon as someone like mentioned shakespeare
- 5:19i'm like oh he sucks dude not that at all i'm
- 5:22not even saying he's bad it's just when it is
- 5:25a shakespeare movie and not a movie about shakespeare
- 5:28but like a shakespeare movie and you use the
- 5:30exact like uh i'm trying to think of the word
- 5:33for it's not dialect but the exact wording yeah
- 5:36verbiage uh as he does in his story and you just
- 5:41put that into the movie you've got to do something
- 5:43really interesting with it to make it like you
- 5:45know um appeasing yeah and we'll talk about that
- 5:49with my double feature but i just don't think
- 5:51that that really happens here before we hop into
- 5:54it should we introduce the movie Yes, absolutely.
- 5:57So Midsummer Night's Dream is what we're talking
- 5:59about today. This is the 1935 adaptation. It
- 6:02does have four nominations. First is film editing,
- 6:06and this is for Ralph Dawson. Cinematography
- 6:09was for Hal Moore. Assistant director... which
- 6:13pretty much means, hey, what went wrong on set
- 6:15here, was for Sherry Shords. It is outstanding
- 6:19production on behalf of Warner Brothers. Yes.
- 6:22We'll dive into, it did win two of those awards,
- 6:25and we'll get into which ones those were as we
- 6:27cover the episode. You mentioned this was adapted.
- 6:30The screenplay was written by Charles Kenyon
- 6:32and Mary C. McCall Jr., and it's adapted from...
- 6:36Max Reinhart's Hollywood Bowl production of the
- 6:39play. So let's start there. Max Reinhart in the
- 6:431930s did a Hollywood production at the Hollywood
- 6:46Bowl with a number of cast for A Midsummer Night's
- 6:52Dream. And in that casting, that included both
- 6:56Olivia de Havilland and Mickey Rooney. Now, Olivia
- 7:00de Havilland and Mickey Rooney reprise their
- 7:02roles in this movie from the production. Olivia
- 7:05de Havilland was Hermia. She is introduced as
- 7:09In Love with Lysander. And Mickey Rooney was
- 7:12Puck slash Robin Goodfellow. But Puck is really
- 7:15what he's known for the most. Those were the
- 7:17two names that were returning to this film from
- 7:20the Hollywood production. But that did so well
- 7:23that he really wanted to do a Hollywood film
- 7:26for it. The only issue is that he doesn't know
- 7:29how to direct a film. So that is where they brought
- 7:32in William de Turley. Right. So this film is
- 7:36one of the rare examples where we have two directors.
- 7:38And not a director who took over after a certain
- 7:41amount of time for reshoots, but it actually
- 7:42was co -directed for the entire film. Right.
- 7:45Max Reinhardt, of course, being a very prominent,
- 7:48well, prominent isn't the right word, legendary
- 7:50stage director. Exactly. And this is the only
- 7:53film he ever made. That's crazy. No, that's true.
- 7:56So the cast list here is pretty exhaustive. Rather
- 8:00than run down just a list of names, we'll point
- 8:03out the highlights. You mentioned you do have
- 8:05Olivia de Havilland, who plays Hermia. Jean Weir,
- 8:09who plays Helena. Grant Mitchell as Aegeus. Frank
- 8:13McHugh as Kintz. And then you also have James
- 8:16Cagney playing Bottom, who I think is kind of
- 8:19the standout performance for me, if I'm being
- 8:21honest. I think so, too. Yeah. The last name
- 8:24here is Mickey Rooney, who plays Puck. I would
- 8:27say that James Cagney and Mickey Rooney have
- 8:30the two standout performances here. And I think
- 8:32that that is the yin and yang to this movie.
- 8:34I would agree. I would agree. So, again, I didn't
- 8:37know anything about this play, Midsummer Night's
- 8:40Dream. So I had to watch my 90 -second Shakespeare.
- 8:43And even that was confusing. Talk me through
- 8:45it. Oh, man. The way that they described it is
- 8:48like, Hermia is in love with... And Aegis and
- 8:52Aegis loves this person. And it was so confusing,
- 8:55even in the 92nd thing. But the gist here is
- 8:59that there are four individuals who are set to
- 9:03put on a play. And one night they get and it's
- 9:07more than the four individuals, but a play is
- 9:09going to be put on. And one night their love
- 9:11gets meddled with by a fairy or a group of fairies
- 9:16who kind of cast love spells on them and makes
- 9:18them all fall in love with. ones that they're
- 9:22not really interested in pursuing. So I can help
- 9:25out with this a little bit. There are four individuals.
- 9:28They are Lysander, Demetrius, Hermia, and Helena.
- 9:31Gotcha. So Lysander and Demetrius both are in
- 9:35love with Hermia going into the forest. Hermia
- 9:39is in love with Lysander, not in love with Demetrius.
- 9:42And Helena is in love with Demetrius. So when
- 9:46they go into the forest, Puck, but other fairies
- 9:50as well, put on that spell, or mess with love,
- 9:54and they all end up loving other individuals
- 9:57than they did previously. Right. And it's like
- 9:59a spell that's put on them. Yeah. And while this
- 10:02is happening, there are another group of actors
- 10:05that are trying to study and rehearse for this
- 10:09play that they're going to put on for a wedding.
- 10:11For the other characters that you mentioned.
- 10:13And they also get messed with, not so much in
- 10:16love, but more in appearance as well. Yeah. And
- 10:19we'll talk about that. But basically, the entire
- 10:22movie is how the fairies have messed with these
- 10:26individuals in the forest and how this affects
- 10:28their lives going into the wedding. Right. And
- 10:30those four human individuals, again, Olivia de
- 10:33Havilland, Jean Weir, Ross Alexander plays Demetrius,
- 10:37and Dick Powell plays Lysander. And Dick Powell,
- 10:40I mean, obviously, Olivia de Havilland stands
- 10:42out to us because we just watched her in Captain
- 10:44Blood. And this is, you know, you mentioned this
- 10:47is the debut for her because it actually was
- 10:49released before Captain Blood. But I would say
- 10:53other than that, of these four, Dick Powell is
- 10:55the one who stands out the most. Right. We recognize
- 10:57him from Here Comes... No, Flirtation Walk. Was
- 11:03he not in 42nd Street? I think he's in both.
- 11:04Oh, he is in both. And that's the whole thing
- 11:05with Ruby Keeler. Yes, you're right. So, yes,
- 11:08Dick Powell is where we recognize someone the
- 11:11most here. Ross Alexander and Jean Muir, not
- 11:14as familiar with, unfortunately. But they are
- 11:18all our four leads going into this. Right. And,
- 11:22again, there are so many characters in this movie.
- 11:26And the listing of, like, the main cast. It kind
- 11:30of doesn't make sense because you see Ian Hunter
- 11:32with top billing on a lot of the posters. And
- 11:35he plays Theseus, who is like one of the gods
- 11:38that employs the fairies to do all of the things.
- 11:43Shadow Lord or Shadow or something. They're not
- 11:46in it very often, though. So it's weird the way
- 11:49that the billing is listed here. So let's start
- 11:52with the beginning and then we'll get into our
- 11:55review of this. How about that? That works. The
- 11:57intro to this, how did you watch this? Was this
- 12:00on a website? Yes. Okay. Yeah. I rented this
- 12:03through Amazon Prime. Okay. And this means this
- 12:07is the official release of the movie, right?
- 12:10This is the official cut. Right. When we watch
- 12:11it online, there's a chance that maybe this is
- 12:14like, you know, an international cut, like this
- 12:16isn't the American one. There's a couple of variations
- 12:18that can come to that. With this. It has to be
- 12:22that this is the, like, if I picked up the Blu
- 12:24-ray, which, by the way, did just come out, everyone.
- 12:26We'll talk about that at the end. When you watch
- 12:29the Blu -ray, that means that this cut that I
- 12:32rented is the cut that you're going to see, but
- 12:34with a higher definition. Yeah. The movie opens,
- 12:37and I mean opens. No Warner Brothers, no MG,
- 12:42like nothing. It opens with, I think it says
- 12:45interlude. Yep. For six minutes. It has this
- 12:50screen, almost as if you are watching the play
- 12:53in a theater. And it's telling you the show is
- 12:57about to begin. Yeah. Take your seats, everybody.
- 12:59Take your seats. The movie's about to start.
- 13:01Six minutes go by with nothing changing on screen,
- 13:05but the orchestra is just playing. And you're
- 13:08hearing that for six minutes. And then the next
- 13:10four minutes, they lose the screen, but they
- 13:13give you the title card. And they go through
- 13:14all the credits. And when it started listing
- 13:16all the cast. I was overwhelmed. Yeah. Like,
- 13:20just like, these are just too many names for
- 13:22me to remember. A, actors. B, who these characters
- 13:25are. And it's just like, I was like, we are 10
- 13:28minutes into the runtime of this movie and I
- 13:30have not seen anyone on screen yet. There's no
- 13:33story. Right. And I don't want to fast forward
- 13:35through that interlude because I'm like, what
- 13:37if I miss something? It's part of the movie too.
- 13:39Exactly. This is the way I'm supposed to enjoy
- 13:40it. The one thing I want to bring up to this
- 13:43as a criticism, that's not even necessarily a
- 13:45bad thing. It just kind of threw me off. Here's
- 13:47the bad thing, or at least the question I have.
- 13:50Halfway through this movie, and this movie is
- 13:52two hours and 20 minutes, something like that.
- 13:54It has an intermission. And there's an intermission
- 13:58halfway through, and it says intermission 10
- 14:00minutes. And I was like, great. So I have 10
- 14:03minutes of this. After about 15 to 20 seconds,
- 14:06it cuts and goes right back into the movie. You
- 14:09were going to grab a hot dog. And then suddenly
- 14:11you hear characters talking again. You're like,
- 14:14wait a minute, what happened? Yeah, I hear Puck's
- 14:16laughter and I'm like, whoa, what's happening?
- 14:18So I am just confused as to why the whole interlude
- 14:23stays. Yeah. But the intermission gets cut. Yeah,
- 14:26that is kind of a weird, almost throwaway complaint.
- 14:30Yeah, it doesn't affect the movie itself. It's
- 14:33just more like this is a weird cut of it. It
- 14:34is weird. And I know that this is the official
- 14:36cut. That's why I'm surprised. Yeah. If anything,
- 14:39it just feels like, Cut both or keep both. Have
- 14:43both. Yeah. Yeah. But I guess it would like increase
- 14:46the runtime. But again, why does that matter?
- 14:47Because it's what played in theaters. So I don't
- 14:49really understand that. I just want to point
- 14:51that out that if anyone's watching at home and
- 14:52they're like, hey, what happened with this? Us
- 14:54too. Yeah. This is what we've seen. And I'm excited.
- 14:57I haven't picked up the Blu -ray. Insert the
- 14:59word yet. Yeah. I haven't picked up the Blu -ray.
- 15:03So I don't know if that's the cut that's on there.
- 15:06Yeah. I don't know what it'll look like. I'm
- 15:07interested to find out by reading online. Exactly.
- 15:11Yeah. Good call. So I feel like if you're a fan
- 15:15of this story, A Midsummer Night's Dream, there's
- 15:18a lot to be enjoyed here. Sure. I think that
- 15:21this movie is kind of made for fans of not only
- 15:26that particular play. Theater. But theater. Yeah,
- 15:29exactly. Because it keeps that interlude, you're
- 15:32almost simulating that element of the theater
- 15:37with, hey, everybody, take your seats. And then
- 15:40you get to see the play that you know and love,
- 15:43but in a way that is much different than you
- 15:46have seen it at this point and probably would
- 15:49be able to see on a stage because you're getting
- 15:52different camera trickery and things, which I
- 15:55think is a major highlight of this movie. So
- 15:57the things that are overwhelming to us. like
- 16:00the interlude and the massive list of cast and
- 16:03characters where we're just like, I don't know
- 16:05who this is. I almost wish they did the thing
- 16:08where they show the image of the character on
- 16:10screen with their name and their character. So
- 16:13you could be like, okay, at least now I know
- 16:15who's playing who. Yes. Because it is overwhelming,
- 16:18but I don't think that would exist for a fan
- 16:20of theater and the play itself. Well, there's
- 16:24one big thing that you have that we haven't mentioned
- 16:27just yet that kind of differentiates this from
- 16:29the, um story that shakespeare wrote and that's
- 16:33that this is a musical it is but it's it's like
- 16:37would you say there's musical like sequences
- 16:40yeah there's like dance a little bit certainly
- 16:44there's dance and the score is is definitely
- 16:46notable well it's not like yeah but not to the
- 16:49level that i would like call it a musical Interesting,
- 16:55because to me, that was my complaint of something
- 16:57like The Love Parade, where there's people singing,
- 17:00but it's not really a musical. Well, I think
- 17:03it's the amount of music that's being sang. There's
- 17:07three numbers in this, is that right? Three feels
- 17:09short for two hours and 20 minutes. Well, it's
- 17:11a long movie, that's true. Actually, let's go
- 17:14ahead and do this. We've set up the movie a good
- 17:16bit. Yeah. We've given you some background details.
- 17:19We've kind of given you a little bit of lore.
- 17:22I will say production design is where I think
- 17:24we're going to have the most fun talking about
- 17:26this. But let's go ahead and rip off how we feel
- 17:29about this. Yeah. I think this was the roughest
- 17:32watch for me so far of what we've done in the
- 17:34podcast. I think so, too. And there are movies
- 17:37that we've watched that I feel like I just enjoyed.
- 17:41I didn't. like i just didn't enjoy it sure and
- 17:44cavalcade comes to mind yeah um traitor horn
- 17:48traitor horn comes to mind and you know traitor
- 17:51horn was a disaster so it was kind of fun to
- 17:55watch a little bit of like disaster happening
- 17:57on screen but disaster what i mean by that is
- 18:01it was both on and off screen like off screen
- 18:04it's like hey this is really troubled and so
- 18:06was the movie and so i didn't enjoy it but at
- 18:09the same time I could look back and be like,
- 18:11yeah, I mean, it was long and I didn't really
- 18:13enjoy my time with it, but it was at least a
- 18:15disaster on screen. It was kind of interesting
- 18:16to see that. With this, to my knowledge and all
- 18:20the research that I did, there's not much of
- 18:22a disaster that happened behind the scenes. I
- 18:24think this was very successful. I think it was
- 18:27very successful. Yeah. I mean, let's not forget
- 18:30that this is the first Shakespeare adaptation
- 18:32to be nominated for Best Picture. Yeah. So there's
- 18:35success in that alone. And again, you know, this
- 18:38is a lot like my complaint with One Night of
- 18:40Love, where my complaint is what other people
- 18:44love about it. And like, hey, it's just like
- 18:46going to the opera. And like, I love the opera.
- 18:48So this is great. And if you love theater, you're
- 18:50probably going to end up loving this because
- 18:52that's just what you want from it. But this is
- 18:55two hours and 20 minutes. It is. Of exactly what
- 18:59you described. And there are fantastical elements.
- 19:02It is also the first fantasy film. to be nominated
- 19:05for Best Picture. Oh, yeah. Let's think about
- 19:07that. Wow. And there are a lot of firsts with
- 19:10this, but my God. I mean, so we saw each other
- 19:14a little behind the scenes. We saw each other
- 19:18yesterday. Yeah. There's a gaming convention
- 19:20for retro gaming in Atlanta, and you stopped
- 19:23by, and we were able to hang out a little bit.
- 19:25Yep. And I had asked you if you'd watched everything
- 19:27for the pod, and you said, I haven't watched
- 19:29Midsummer Night's Dream yet. Correct. I think
- 19:32I said Godspeed. You did. And you were just asking
- 19:35me questions of like, is this going to put me
- 19:37in a bad mood or something? And you said, what
- 19:40advice do you have? And I just told you, don't
- 19:42watch it tired. And that was a problem that I
- 19:46had too. I wouldn't say I was tired when I started
- 19:48it, but I sure was tired when I ended it. And
- 19:51it is, I mean, how do you describe how we felt
- 19:54watching this? So you gave me all that advice
- 19:57yesterday and I came home and I had a massive
- 19:59headache. And I was laying in bed so tired. And
- 20:03I put this on. And here's the thing. I would
- 20:07say this is a good movie. I would say this is
- 20:10a good adaptation of a Shakespeare play. I would
- 20:15almost argue with the word adaptation because
- 20:17so much of it feels like, I mean. It's like a
- 20:19direct. It's direct. I mean, the script of the
- 20:23movie. Is what Shakespeare wrote. Yes. That's
- 20:26it. I think that if you are a fan of Shakespeare,
- 20:28if you are a fan of Midsummer Night's Dream,
- 20:30I like the performances of Dick Powell and Olivia
- 20:35de Havilland and Ross Alexander. And Jean Muir.
- 20:39Yes. They're all great. James Cagney is fantastic
- 20:43in this as Bottom. He's a lot of fun. And I want
- 20:47to point out the highlights of the movie. And
- 20:50visually. Again, this was nominated for cinematography
- 20:54and for editing. And there is like the intro
- 20:58to this movie and all that past the interlude.
- 21:01Like it looks great just on its own. They use
- 21:05so many cool effects in like the forest with
- 21:08the fairies where there's almost like a screen
- 21:11placed in front of our actors that gives. Oh,
- 21:15what is his name? Oberon? Yes. It gives him like
- 21:18a sparkle. to his costume and everything. And
- 21:22it looks so cool. It's so fantastical. And the
- 21:25sequence where the fog and the mist rolls in
- 21:28over the forest floor and then turns into people
- 21:33or fairies, it is beautiful. I have a little
- 21:38bit of context behind this. So cinematography
- 21:41was for Halmore, which we mentioned. So Hal specifically
- 21:46thinned the trees. and sprayed them with aluminum
- 21:49paint, and then covered them with cobwebs and
- 21:53medical particles to reflect light and properly
- 21:55light the set that was built by Max Reinhardt.
- 21:59The reason for this was the lighting. The lighting
- 22:01like against the set just didn't look good. So
- 22:03he provided like the aluminum paint, the cobwebs,
- 22:07the medical particles. So then when there was
- 22:09light, it would reflect off everything and make
- 22:11it more airy. And that's what provides like the
- 22:14glittery kind of context on the screen that you
- 22:16see. I mean, this was heralded as just an amazing
- 22:19choice and it makes the film feel so much more
- 22:21magical and kind of like, you know, fantastical.
- 22:24Yeah. I think you know this, but for the audience,
- 22:28because of this. Hal Moore became the first and
- 22:33only, to this day, well, I mean, I think this
- 22:36isn't going to change, but the only and first
- 22:39write -in winner of an Academy Award. Oh, wow.
- 22:42So we talked previously about, in other ceremonies,
- 22:45how write -ins are becoming more possible now.
- 22:48Yeah. And Katherine Hepburn was obviously a big
- 22:50part of that. Yeah. Or she benefited from that,
- 22:53rather. Yeah, Betty Davis. Betty Davis as well.
- 22:55And we... haven't seen anyone actually win from
- 22:59that write -in just yet right so this is the
- 23:01only time this happened and a big part of that
- 23:03seems like everyone was just taken by the cinematography
- 23:06of this movie whether it's for that reason or
- 23:09not who's to say but clearly the cinematography
- 23:11lived within people well i think the cool thing
- 23:14is again you mentioned this is the first fantasy
- 23:16film to be nominated and there are sequences
- 23:19here that we have not seen at the academy awards
- 23:24Those fairies that come out of the fog and then
- 23:26like walk up a tree into space almost. It is
- 23:32so beautiful. And you only see something like
- 23:35that compared to some of the musicals. You know,
- 23:39Gold Diggers of 1935 and all of that. 1936. Whatever
- 23:43it is. Like that's the closest you're getting
- 23:46to any of these fantastical elements. And it
- 23:48almost has like an art house. cinema vibe it
- 23:51does with all of this and i i was really taken
- 23:54aback by it so it's cool to see that type of
- 24:00filmmaking make an appearance you don't just
- 24:02have like your narrative features where everything
- 24:04is very very grounded you're starting to get
- 24:07almost like a throwback to the early days of
- 24:11cinema with like silent film of camera trickery
- 24:15and things you know It's a lot of fun. It is
- 24:19gorgeous. It is beautiful. And the performances,
- 24:23there are some standouts here. So I don't think
- 24:25this is a bad movie. But I can tell you that
- 24:28I despise this movie. I hate this movie so much.
- 24:33And I never want to see it again. Ever. I can't
- 24:37stand it, Ryan. You know what this sounds like?
- 24:39This sounds like... God, what is it? It's like
- 24:42a breakup. Yeah? Where you're like, hey... I
- 24:44love you. There's a lot of great things about
- 24:46you, and I cannot wait for someone else to benefit
- 24:49from that. It can't be me. I need you to get
- 24:51away from me as soon as possible. I despise it.
- 24:56I cannot stand it. And like I said, I was sitting
- 24:59in bed. I had a massive headache, and I was tired.
- 25:04And my blood pressure went up from this movie.
- 25:08It was so bad. Did you track that? I could feel
- 25:11it. I knew it was happening. I like I don't know
- 25:16if this has ever happened in a movie. I feel
- 25:17like I've watched some movies where maybe the
- 25:20story gets my blood going because a character
- 25:23dies or something. And I'm so invested in this
- 25:26movie that it's really affecting like my physiological
- 25:28being. But this is the first time I think in
- 25:32my life that I have watched a character on screen
- 25:35that has caused me so much anger and frustration.
- 25:42There's a big reason for that. And we'll talk
- 25:45about that here in a second. It is just, to me,
- 25:49it's boring. It is boring. It's beautiful to
- 25:52look at. I can see that, yeah. It is just an
- 25:54absolute slog to sit through. But it is also
- 25:57daring you to be invested in it. Because anytime
- 26:02that you feel remotely invested, there is a reminder
- 26:05that you shouldn't be. And before we talk about
- 26:10that reminder. I do want to talk a little bit
- 26:13about James Cagney. Sure. Yeah. This is a movie
- 26:16in which I should be enamored by, and maybe I
- 26:19am, but I got to find disturbed is probably the
- 26:22best comp I can think of. Yeah. Of like enamored,
- 26:26but negatively. So I guess disturbed. I, we got
- 26:32to talk about the production. So. James Cagney
- 26:36is bottom, and James Cagney is putting on, he's
- 26:39one of the actors who are putting on the performance
- 26:41here, and he is frustrated with his scene partners.
- 26:45He feels like he's not getting the performances
- 26:46out of them that he needs, and he runs off into
- 26:49the woods. And as he runs off into the woods,
- 26:51Puck the fairy finds him and spreads some magic
- 26:56on him and transforms him into a donkey. And
- 27:01not even just a donkey, but a donkey -human hybrid
- 27:02where he has a donkey head. Yes. And the transformation
- 27:06scene is he feels like magic on his hair or something
- 27:10on his hair. And he's just kind of like playing
- 27:11with his hair a little bit. Then he starts playing
- 27:13with his face. And it's almost like he molds
- 27:16it into a la like Cersei from the Odyssey. Like
- 27:19molds it into the sculpt of a donkey. But the
- 27:24actual scene transformation of him into a donkey
- 27:27is like horrifying. In a good way. Yeah. I was,
- 27:32like, amazed at this. It's very similar to, like,
- 27:34the werewolf transformations to come years later.
- 27:37You're talking about American Werewolf in London.
- 27:39Prior to that. Oh, like Wolfman. I'm talking
- 27:41about, like, Wolfman and Werewolf in London.
- 27:44You're right. Yeah, Werewolf in London. So, that's
- 27:48correct. I know what you're saying now. I was
- 27:50thinking of Rick Baker's effects in American
- 27:53Werewolf in London. Right. But you're right because
- 27:55that is more you're watching everything happen
- 27:57on screen. In this, it's more like maybe five
- 28:00to six different sequences that are like layered
- 28:04on top of each other. Yeah, exactly. And you
- 28:06see him like becoming less and less human and
- 28:08more and more donkey -like. And when he has the
- 28:11final form of his donkey feature, his eyes are
- 28:15almost like black. Right. And he's got the Batman
- 28:18makeup around his eyes. Yeah, it's terrifying.
- 28:21It's very scary. It is terrifying to look at.
- 28:24But also at the same time, I was like, this rocks.
- 28:27Like, this is really good. Yeah. And the mouth
- 28:30moves on this like prosthetic or mask. It is
- 28:35so slightly, but it still is impressive because
- 28:37there are moments where James Cagney is singing
- 28:39a little bit. Yes. And the donkey is not well.
- 28:42No. But it's moving. The mouth is moving. Yeah.
- 28:45And it is unmistakable that James Cagney is under
- 28:49the makeup. Yes. Or under the mask. And that
- 28:53is another bonus point for me. Because it is
- 28:55so easy to be like, ah, James Cagney will put
- 28:57on the donkey head. Get the extra in there. And
- 29:00just put his voice over it. No. It is James Cagney
- 29:03in there and that rocks. I feel like James Cagney
- 29:05read the script and was like, hell yeah. Yeah,
- 29:08I'm in, dude. Put me in that donkey mask. And,
- 29:11you know, this transforms him a little bit with
- 29:13like his humor or not humor. His like laugh now
- 29:16is more of a hee haw than anything. But then
- 29:19he falls in love with a woman fairy. I couldn't
- 29:24tell you. Yeah. I don't remember which one it
- 29:26is. It's someone so lost. He falls in love with
- 29:28them. And then there's almost like a love ceremony,
- 29:30like a wedding in part put on by the fairies.
- 29:33And there's a moment here. I filmed. Two separate,
- 29:37three separate things for my brother. He was
- 29:40like, hey, what are you doing? I was like, I'll
- 29:41show you what I'm doing. And I showed him the
- 29:43James Cagney transformation scene. I showed him
- 29:46when James Cagney is a donkey, and then he brings
- 29:49in that little monkey -looking guy to help him
- 29:53grab some stuff. Yes. And he has a little puff
- 29:56of hair on his head, and then he also has the
- 29:58same puff of hair around his waist. You know
- 30:00what I'm talking about? Yeah. I don't think they'd
- 30:02grace him with a name. And then the third thing.
- 30:05which is like the most like what is going on
- 30:07right now, is when he and his love are celebrating
- 30:11and they have like flower veils on and like a
- 30:14necklace. There's a party and there's a band
- 30:18that is playing and there are little trolls,
- 30:21I assume, that are dancing and playing music.
- 30:24And the makeup effects on them are like little
- 30:28goblin masks. And I was just like, am I dead?
- 30:34Did I die and like fall asleep halfway through
- 30:37this set or this movie? And like now I'm just
- 30:39imagining the rest of this. And it is just, it's
- 30:42interesting. It is a choice. And I actually rock
- 30:45with it. Yeah. But it is so standalone. And everything
- 30:49else in the movie is like, nah, it's the only
- 30:50part where there's weird stuff. Otherwise, it's
- 30:52mostly just these four humans talking. Right.
- 30:55I was like, if the movie had embraced that mindset
- 30:58and the rest of it matched that, I would actually
- 31:01kind of be rocking with it. Yeah. But it was
- 31:04so like on its own that it just felt jarring
- 31:06when it did appear. Yeah. Well, like when Oberon
- 31:10shows up towards the end of the movie, too, and
- 31:12he brings like his army of bat creatures. Sure.
- 31:16Things. They're very similar to Les Vampires,
- 31:20this old French, like long series of movies.
- 31:24They have like the Spider -Man wingsuit kind
- 31:28of thing. They look very cool. And like all of
- 31:31the wire work is really impressive in this. There's
- 31:33lots of people being like yoinked very quickly
- 31:36into the air. It reminds me a lot of what ends
- 31:40up happening in Wizard of Oz where the monkeys
- 31:43would grab people and kind of take off. There's
- 31:47a lot of stuff that looks really cool. And I
- 31:49think like the sequence with James Cagney as
- 31:51the donkey is very cool. And that's kind of what
- 31:54I'm saying. Like, I don't think this is a bad
- 31:56movie. If you're not into Shakespeare, like maybe
- 31:58it's not your bag, but if you are, there's a
- 32:01lot here for you and there's a lot to be praised.
- 32:04So we say it's not a bad movie, but we don't
- 32:08ever want to see it again. And we despise it.
- 32:10What is the reason for that? And you specifically
- 32:13off pod asked me not to mention this until we
- 32:17got to this part. I'm trying not to like be dramatic.
- 32:20Like, I'm like holding my face right now. And
- 32:23maybe I am being dramatic. I don't think you
- 32:27are. Mickey Rooney in this movie plays Puck,
- 32:32the fairy, who he's the one that puts the enchantment
- 32:35on the characters and makes them all fall in
- 32:37love. And he's the one that turns James Cagney
- 32:39bottom into a donkey. Yeah. He is the most irritating
- 32:44little. I have ever dealt with in a movie. I
- 32:52hate him so much. So much, Ryan. Okay, so listen.
- 32:57I want to say this right off the bat with Mickey
- 32:59Rooney. The minute that Puck is on screen, nay,
- 33:02the second that Puck is on screen, I think I
- 33:05read that he's 14 when this movie is filmed.
- 33:08Sure. So he's 14. In the minute that Puck, I
- 33:12think I was even looking off screen, but I hear
- 33:14Puck speaking. I was like, is that Mickey Rooney?
- 33:17Like, immediately. Mickey Rooney has a voice,
- 33:21and even the way he speaks, where I was like,
- 33:23that's Mickey Rooney. Or this person's doing
- 33:25a Mickey Rooney impression. And I looked, and
- 33:27I was like, well, he's not 60 years old, so he
- 33:29can't be Mickey Rooney. Right. And then I looked
- 33:31it up, and I was like, that's Mickey Rooney.
- 33:33And this is crazy that that's Mickey Rooney.
- 33:36That's so funny. I know Mickey Rooney from many
- 33:37things, it's just I never knew he was in this,
- 33:40or even was in movies when he was 14. Oh, interesting.
- 33:43But, I mean... I'll say this. Mickey Rooney is
- 33:48going for it. He is. He is absolutely going for
- 33:59it as Puck in this movie. Perhaps to a fault.
- 34:03Absolutely to a fault. Because he is, I can only
- 34:07describe to you, the audience, as a fairy, but
- 34:12if he's on cocaine. Because everyone else in
- 34:17this movie is kind of just like, yeah, this is
- 34:20a little high art. This is a prestige picture.
- 34:24This is worth noting. A prestige picture is a
- 34:27movie that is taken from highbrow source material
- 34:30and is then given a platform through cinema.
- 34:34And this is a prestige picture. And you can tell
- 34:36that the majority of people in this movie, I
- 34:38would say even maybe 99%, are like, yeah, I'm
- 34:41in a prestige film. And Mickey Rooney said, put
- 34:44the camera on me. And don't say a word. And this
- 34:47guy is on something else in this movie. He's
- 34:50all over the place. He's everywhere. He's in
- 34:54so much of the movie, too. I mean, he is the
- 34:57movie. Yeah. Everything that happens is because
- 34:59of him. I would argue he is the main character
- 35:01in this movie. Yep. He's in at least 90 % of
- 35:04it. And it's a two -hour and 20 -minute movie.
- 35:08I feel like my hands are shaking. They literally
- 35:11are. He really bothered me so much in this movie.
- 35:14And I went to show an example to Ziggy. And I
- 35:18pulled up a scene on the internet. And she said
- 35:20three things. And it's so funny that you identified
- 35:23him by his voice. She said three things. One,
- 35:26she saw James Cagney as the donkey and said,
- 35:28I don't like that. That's my nightmare. I can't
- 35:31agree with her. That was the opposite of how
- 35:33I felt. I saw James Cagney as a donkey. I was
- 35:35like, I love that. She has a phobia of that kind
- 35:38of thing, so I get it. Of James Cagney turning
- 35:40into a donkey? That exact one, yeah. It's very
- 35:43weird. It has a strange name. I think it's called
- 35:45James Cagney Donkophobia? Cagna Hee Haw Phobia.
- 35:49The second thing she said is... Wow, that's really
- 35:53pretty. The effect of like the sparkling on Oberon's
- 35:56outfit. She was like, this is beautiful. I can't
- 35:59believe you didn't like this movie. And then
- 36:01she saw Mickey Rooney. And she said, why does
- 36:04that look like a grown man? He looks like Mickey
- 36:07Rooney. Like his face is 60 -year -old Mickey
- 36:10Rooney. And it's so bizarre. And I tried to show
- 36:16her. What it is, it's Puck's laugh. So Bryce
- 36:21points this out in his letterbox. He does. That
- 36:23his laugh haunts his nightmares. And I read that
- 36:27before I watched the movie. And I was like, all
- 36:29right, man. Can't be that bad. As soon as I heard
- 36:31Mickey Rooney laughing as Puck, I was like, oh
- 36:33yeah, that's it. It feels like the ring, like
- 36:36I'm cursed for like seven days. Yeah. That's
- 36:39what that laugh feels like. It is just, it is
- 36:41in my head. It is consistent because he is laughing
- 36:45through a majority of the movie. And he is reveling.
- 36:48I mean, I don't want to say he. I mean, Mickey
- 36:50Rooney is. But Puck is reveling in the chaos
- 36:53that he is causing in the forest. So his character
- 36:57has a reason to be. But again, he is just so
- 37:00he is at 11. This entire movie. There is no setup.
- 37:04There is no nothing for him. It is starting at
- 37:0711 and ending at 11. And this movie has the gall
- 37:10to end on Puck doing like the. It's a Wonderful
- 37:16Life. Every time a bell rings, an angel gets
- 37:20his wings. Right. And like closes the movie.
- 37:22Like he gets his own little moment at the pearly
- 37:25gates. I'm assuming he's at a giant gated door.
- 37:30Yeah. That is like maybe 10, 15 times the size
- 37:33of him and just says something like. Have a great
- 37:37night, folks. And like slams the door, which
- 37:39is so unearned for the performance he was given
- 37:42before. It just feels like we have ended our
- 37:44Looney Tunes cartoon. Yeah. Well, and that's
- 37:46the thing you mentioned earlier. You started
- 37:49to wonder, like, did I fall asleep? Was this
- 37:50a fever dream? And that's the whole point of
- 37:52that ending. Yes. Is Puck says, who knows? Maybe
- 37:56everything you've seen up to this point was a
- 37:58dream. In which case, I would like to know the
- 38:01recipe so I can never replicate that again. I'll
- 38:04tell you what ingredient to omit. Is Mickey Rooney.
- 38:08It's Mickey Rooney. Yeah, man. I never in my
- 38:15life has there been a character that I'm just
- 38:18like, this is the worst thing to happen to this
- 38:22movie. And it pulls the entire movie down with
- 38:25it. Yeah. And I'm going to insert some of Puck's
- 38:30laughs into this episode. So that you guys at
- 38:48home, like if you don't want to watch this movie,
- 38:50you can hear what it is. Because it's not even
- 38:52just like, oh, he laughs a couple times here
- 38:56and there. It's every line that he says either
- 39:00starts or ends with his laugh. And I want you
- 39:03to remember, too, it's not just that it starts
- 39:05or ends with his laugh, but that, again, this
- 39:07is the Shakespeare text. Right. So Mickey Rooney
- 39:11is a 14 -year -old slash 60 -year -old. is reciting
- 39:15the exact Shakespeare dialect while laughing
- 39:19maniacally. And this is, even with subtitles,
- 39:23I was like, what is going on? I don't know what's
- 39:26happening. Why is this kid going to murder everyone?
- 39:29Like, what's his deal? Oh, man. There was a moment
- 39:33about an hour and 45 minutes into this movie
- 39:35where... It's like halfway through. Yeah. I'm
- 39:39sitting in my room with a massive headache watching
- 39:42this. And I just go, son of a... Because I can't
- 39:50stand his laugh, man. It ruined the movie. Everything,
- 39:53everything. I'm in a bad mood. I'm in a bad mood,
- 39:56man. You got to save us here. You got to save
- 39:59us. I just remember yesterday when you were asking
- 40:01about it. I tried to retell it like I didn't
- 40:05just watch all of my friends die on the battlefield.
- 40:08Yeah. When you were like, so man, how was it?
- 40:09And I was just like, I don't want to talk about
- 40:11it. I really don't want to. It was rough. Yeah.
- 40:16It was a real rough time. And the thing that's
- 40:20frustrating to me is if the movie was bad, we
- 40:24could just say that. Sure. Objectively, we could
- 40:27just say the movie is bad. It wasn't well made.
- 40:30No one should see it for that reason. You can't
- 40:32say that. No. There's some inspired things going
- 40:35on here, specifically in, I mean, again, there's
- 40:37a reason he was written in, but how more? Him
- 40:41receiving that write -in nomination is, well,
- 40:43even write -in win at this point, is so well
- 40:46-earned because of, you know, seeing a problem,
- 40:48resolving that problem, and then cinematography
- 40:51is incredible. Like, there's a sequence maybe
- 40:54in the first third of the movie. where there's
- 40:57a beam of light coming down in the forest, and
- 40:59it's, like, waking up the fairies coming out
- 41:01of the ground. Exactly, yeah. And you could see
- 41:03them almost, like, on an escalator coming down
- 41:06and, like, waiting until they touch the ground
- 41:08and then, like, walking away. And you're like,
- 41:10well, how did they film this? It's incredible.
- 41:12It's fun. Like, it is very fun to watch. But
- 41:15then, literally born of the earth, like, risen
- 41:19from the weeds, is Puck. yeah and once puck is
- 41:25born and brought into like the forest all bets
- 41:28are off and the movie just changes tone and it
- 41:31can it it has that tone throughout and then when
- 41:35king elrond or whoever over on supposed to be
- 41:38shows up and it's like no puck you weren't supposed
- 41:41to do this to the other people not to these guys
- 41:44and puck is just like oh well and i mean i say
- 41:47oh well he does some like you know He says, oh,
- 41:50well, but in five lines and then laughs in the
- 41:52beginning and the end of it. Yeah. It is exhausting.
- 41:56Exhausting is the word. It is exhausting. And
- 41:59Mickey Rooney's performance, while it is something,
- 42:03like, again, he is going for it more than anyone
- 42:05else in this movie. He is not phoning it in.
- 42:07We can say that for sure. It brings down the
- 42:10movie. Tremendously. And it is a glacial pace
- 42:13from then on out. Yeah. And I have just, like,
- 42:16the movie wants to be a drama. The movie wants
- 42:19to be a fantasy. The movie wants to be a comedy.
- 42:21The movie wants to be horror with some of the
- 42:23transformation scenes and what I can only describe
- 42:26to you, the audience, as the most Isley Cantina
- 42:29band of fairy forest creatures playing at what
- 42:35I can only assume was donkey, I was about to
- 42:38say donkey bottom, uh -oh, of the donkey version
- 42:42of bottom, James Cagney, his wedding. Yeah. I
- 42:47don't know what's going on in this. And I want
- 42:50to be invested and I want to enjoy this movie.
- 42:52Of course I do. But there's something that feels
- 42:55at odds of a director like William de Turley.
- 43:00And I'm probably saying that wrong. And Max Reinhardt.
- 43:04Thank you. Max Reinhardt, where there is the,
- 43:06hey, here's the film version of this. And then
- 43:08here is the stage adaptation of this. Yeah. And
- 43:10we're going to try and meld it into one. But
- 43:12it feels like you're putting two. of the same
- 43:15side of the magnets together. And you can just
- 43:17feel it repelling. Interesting. And you can just
- 43:20feel like the film version and the stage version,
- 43:22just like rejecting itself. And there's times
- 43:25where it feels like it's getting close again,
- 43:28the beginning. Well, once the movie starts, right.
- 43:31The beginning. And then the end, like I thought
- 43:35that once I left the forest, I was like, great,
- 43:37we're good. But there's still, like, 20 minutes
- 43:38left after that. Oh, that's the crazy part. Oh,
- 43:41my God. And, like, they're like, well, you do
- 43:43want to see the play that they actually put on,
- 43:46right? And you're like, no. We just want to be
- 43:48done, man. Like, we spent so much time in this
- 43:51horse. I was watching this, and Taylor called.
- 43:55My wife travels for a good bit of work. And she
- 43:59called me. Which I'm always going to answer.
- 44:02So I paused the movie and I was talking to her.
- 44:04I was like, yeah, I'm watching this movie. I'm
- 44:05just having a real tough time with it. But it's
- 44:06almost over. And I checked and it said hour and
- 44:0910 minutes with an hour and 15 left. And I was
- 44:13like. Yeah. I was like crying. I was like, no,
- 44:18stop. And then, of course, the intermission happens.
- 44:21And I was like, all right, I guess I'm going
- 44:23to go. Snack time. At least 10 minutes of this
- 44:25movie are the intermission. And it was like,
- 44:27nope. Right. Just 15 seconds. You get denied
- 44:30that as well. Nope. You have to watch the rest
- 44:32of this movie. I was like, no. Yeah. This was
- 44:35just, and you know, the last thing, this is what
- 44:38sucks about this. The last thing that I want
- 44:41is for people to listen to this episode and be
- 44:42like, well, these guys don't enjoy Shakespeare.
- 44:45And these guys don't enjoy highbrow or prestige
- 44:48pictures. And they just, you know, didn't like
- 44:51this movie. Now they're trashing it. I wanted
- 44:53to like this. And I agree with you. This isn't
- 44:56bad. It's just I think the best way I can describe
- 44:59it is I think they thought they were doing chocolate
- 45:03and peanut butter and made Reese's. And instead,
- 45:06I think they're doing like peanut butter and
- 45:08lime. And they're like this. That's not the right
- 45:11word. Maybe mint, like peanut butter mint, where
- 45:13it's like, hey, these are good together, right?
- 45:15You're like, not the way you did it. You know,
- 45:18it's so funny because you and I are in agreeance
- 45:23that we don't like this movie. Yes. We are in
- 45:26such a large disagreement over why, though. Really?
- 45:30Yeah. I think that this is one of the— You think
- 45:33it's puck? The best adaptations of a play that
- 45:36we've experienced yet. I think that taking this
- 45:41fantasy play and making it as fantastical as
- 45:44it is on the screen, like you're doing things
- 45:46that someone who would go see this on a stage,
- 45:50sitting down to see this in the theater, you
- 45:53must have been like, oh, my God. This is wild.
- 45:56This is something I never could have imagined.
- 45:58And I think that is so expertly done. And I think
- 46:02the performances really are great. Olivia de
- 46:05Havilland and Dick Powell and the other two,
- 46:08like Ross Alexander and Gene Muir. Yeah. Like
- 46:12they're all great in this. My problem is I can't
- 46:15keep up with the Shakespeare lingo. So I struggle
- 46:18to like really have any of the jokes land with
- 46:20me. So my complaint is more about Shakespeare.
- 46:24And that's a me thing. You know, that's me not
- 46:27understanding. A Midsummer Night's Dream is one
- 46:31of Shakespeare's comedies. The comedy in this
- 46:33movie comes from the text, the Shakespearean
- 46:36dialogue that I just, I need the spark notes
- 46:39to be able to really get the jokes. The other
- 46:42element comes from loud, loud noises, loud ha
- 46:47-has, not just from Puck, but also like our main
- 46:51characters. There's a moment where Olivia de
- 46:54Havilland, like, is crying, but her crying is
- 46:57done in such a comedic, like, loud, overacting
- 47:01way. And that's supposed to be the comedy. And
- 47:04in a world where I am literally having my blood
- 47:08pressure raised because of Puck's laughter, like,
- 47:12none of the comedy worked on me. Do you think
- 47:15every 10 minutes you should just pepper in Puck's
- 47:18laughter? Maybe I should. small dose of what
- 47:23it's like watching this movie um my god maybe
- 47:26see and i i stand by what i said but i think
- 47:30what i mean more so is what you said where it's
- 47:32the text and to me a not faithful but a successful
- 47:37adaptation of something like this should come
- 47:40from how do we adapt this how do we if we're
- 47:43going to use the core text How do we adapt that
- 47:46into a way that is interesting for the audience?
- 47:48And in this, I just don't feel like they successfully
- 47:51did that. Does it look amazing? Absolutely. There's
- 47:54zero argument to that. There's a reason he won
- 47:57the Oscar and is a write -in. He did great work.
- 48:00And again, it's not even just the cinematographer,
- 48:02but the set designer, Max Reinhardt. Well, not
- 48:06set designer, but the set that he put together.
- 48:09The set looks great and the cinematography looks
- 48:12great. It is the heart behind it, the soul of
- 48:15the movie. And the soul of the movie to me is,
- 48:18well, it has to be the core text because that's
- 48:20what's most interesting. But you are asking a
- 48:23general film audience to understand the core
- 48:26text. And I don't just mean meaning, but like
- 48:29literally the understanding of the sentences
- 48:31that are being said. Yeah. And that's not very
- 48:34feasible, especially when someone like Mickey
- 48:36Rooney is a mile a minute going off. And every
- 48:42other sentence is a rhyme. And you can hear the
- 48:46cadence of the way they're supposed to be saying
- 48:48this. Sure. To me, that is where they took the
- 48:52stage and they just said, well, you have to fit
- 48:55into the film. They're like, great. What do we
- 48:56do to offset that? They're like, you don't. Just
- 48:59put it in. And maybe this will make more sense
- 49:01when I talk about my double feature, but there's
- 49:04a way you can do it. There is a way it can be
- 49:07done and keep the core text. But I don't think
- 49:10that the film adapts itself enough to fit that.
- 49:14Let me ask you this. Or counterbalance, maybe.
- 49:17Did you see, I forget which Coen brother did
- 49:20it. The Tragedy of Macbeth. Yes. Did you see
- 49:22that? I did not. Okay. And that was Joel Coen.
- 49:26Gotcha. Joel Colan does The Tragedy of Macbeth
- 49:29with a very unique style as far as visually.
- 49:33It's very expressionist, right? Yes. Black and
- 49:35white. Yeah. And the sets are kind of like minimalist,
- 49:38really unique. And I didn't love that, again,
- 49:43because I struggle a little bit with understanding
- 49:46the Shakespearean lingo and all of that. But
- 49:49I think that that's something I could revisit
- 49:52and digest. In a different way every time or
- 49:56like more successfully every time. You know what
- 49:58I mean? I have a desire to understand the core
- 50:03text of Shakespearean plays and cinema. But I
- 50:07think with this, I'm okay with having a direct
- 50:10showcase of that Shakespearean language and play.
- 50:14It really is just certain elements that take
- 50:17away my enjoyment of this particular adaptation.
- 50:21And it really is puck, man. He makes it unwatchable
- 50:26to me. I would say that as a podcast, if we had
- 50:30one sole tagline for Midsummer Night's Dream
- 50:341935, it would be puck off. That's the one. That
- 50:40is the one. Because I agree with you. Mickey
- 50:43Rooney is puck. Like, it's... Okay. This is what
- 50:48I mean when I say, like, it is... How do I put
- 50:52this? It's like cumin or cayenne. When you put
- 50:55a little bit in there, it's going to rock. But
- 50:58when you dump the whole bottle in, which is what
- 51:02Mickey Rooney is doing as Puck, it overpowers
- 51:05the movie. Yeah. And it is now the only thing
- 51:07that I taste, hear, see, and that is the movie.
- 51:12The taste of the movie now is just Puck. Whenever
- 51:15I think of a scene from the movie... Unless it's
- 51:18James Cagney's donkey transformation. Right.
- 51:20It's Puck. And even that transformation, Puck
- 51:22is doing it. It's cutting between him and the
- 51:26transformation itself. And when I hear anything
- 51:29from the movie, it's not the songs. It's not
- 51:32the score. It is not the beautiful retelling
- 51:35of the actual Shakespearean dialect. It is Puck.
- 51:39It is Puck. Yeah, I mean, I had my moments where
- 51:43I'm like, OK, I'm going to lock in and I'm going
- 51:44to listen to the dialogue between these four
- 51:46humans to try and really understand the jokes.
- 51:49And as I'm watching, you see little Mickey Rooney
- 51:52like scamper on the screen in the corner. And
- 51:55you're just like, he's going to talk in like
- 51:57three seconds. There that goes. Like, you know,
- 52:00it's like seeing a train cut, cut to Barry Keegan,
- 52:03Banshees of the Inner Sheeran. And I'm just like,
- 52:06there goes that dream. Because I know Puck is
- 52:08just lurking. And it's just a shame. It's just
- 52:11a shame. So this dream becomes more of a nightmare.
- 52:15It does. It does. A Midsummer Night's Nightmare.
- 52:18A Midsummer Nightmare. That's the one. That's
- 52:21the one. I love that we're renaming all these
- 52:24movies. We're doing our best. Captain Doctor
- 52:26Blood. Yeah. And Midsummer Nightmare. Midsummer
- 52:30Nightmare. I don't really have anything else.
- 52:33That I want to talk about with the movie. Do
- 52:36you? It's frustrating. It really is. Because
- 52:39I want to walk away. And, you know, this is the
- 52:42other thing, too, man. This is the last movie
- 52:44of this year. Yeah, yeah. This is the last movie
- 52:46that we're going to be talking about of the 1936
- 52:49ceremony. So, it's frustrating. Because you want
- 52:53to... This has been a great year. There have
- 52:55been some fantastic movies we've talked about.
- 52:57And we will continue to talk about them on the
- 52:59ceremony episode. But, I mean, Les Mis. The Informer,
- 53:03Captain Blood. It's been fun. There have been
- 53:06a lot of great highlights. And even ones that
- 53:08didn't fully connect for us, we could still see
- 53:11the intention behind it. This one feels more
- 53:14like a torture method. It does. And it is because
- 53:17the movie looks great. The acting, pretty good.
- 53:20The score, present. There are decisions being
- 53:24made that are exciting. But at the same time,
- 53:27it is, I think, the longest movie I've ever seen.
- 53:32Yeah. I think it is the longest movie I've ever
- 53:35seen, and I know it's not. I'm aware I've seen
- 53:37The Brutalist, and I'm aware that I'm going to
- 53:40see Gone with the Wind in a couple months. And
- 53:42I know those are both longer. But this felt like
- 53:45the longest experience. I felt like I started
- 53:48it at a very good time, like 7 o 'clock. I'm
- 53:51like, I have the rest of the night when this
- 53:52movie's over. Then I ended it, and it was like
- 53:5410 .30. And I was like, what happened? How? How
- 53:57did that happen? What happened? So I will say
- 54:00that when you're about to go through ratings
- 54:01here, you and I are matched. So you can go for
- 54:04it. Okay. Here's my ultimate takeaway. This movie
- 54:08without Mickey Rooney's puck, and not the character
- 54:12removed, but Mickey Rooney's specific portrayal
- 54:15of this character, I would give this movie three
- 54:18stars. I really would. I think what the cinematography
- 54:22is doing here really is incredible. Almost like
- 54:26as a fan of David Lynch and kind of like that
- 54:28abstract filmmaking. This should be right up
- 54:31your alley. Yeah, like the imagery and everything.
- 54:34It's very like arthouse cinema. It's a three
- 54:39-star movie for me. The fact that Puck laughs
- 54:42for 90 % of this movie drags it down to a one
- 54:46and a half for me. I, once again, despise this
- 54:50movie because of Mickey Rooney. So I gave it
- 54:54four stars. One and a half for me, too. I'm admittedly
- 55:00not a Shakespeare guy, and I think that that
- 55:02allows me some wiggle room. Not allows me wiggle
- 55:05room, but it allows me to be pretty fair in my
- 55:11rating of it. So even if I didn't like it because
- 55:13it's a Shakespeare thing, I can still say, you
- 55:15know, I didn't love it, but this movie is still
- 55:17well made. All of these things. Puck. And I still
- 55:22think the Shakespeare dialect being adapted,
- 55:25not adapted, translated 1000%, like from pen
- 55:29to paper, makes this so much slower than it needs
- 55:33to be and incoherent at times. Sure. And when
- 55:37you have the spark notes, when you have an understanding
- 55:39of what the play means, and you are like a master
- 55:41of the core text and can decipher it, I'm sure
- 55:44it's a great watch. I'm sure it is. That on top
- 55:48of Mickey Rooney makes it to where it is almost,
- 55:51I'm going to stick with it, a torture device.
- 55:53This is an unwatchable movie to me. It feels
- 55:56unwatchable with Mickey Rooney's performance
- 55:59on top of that script. So again, you can't say
- 56:03he's phoning it in. You absolutely cannot say
- 56:06that. I don't know what Mickey Rooney was going
- 56:08through at this time to where this, I don't know
- 56:11what fueled this, this performance from him,
- 56:13but it is incoherent. It is baffling, and it
- 56:19is, frankly, disturbing isn't the word for his
- 56:24specific performance. It's upsetting. It's upsetting.
- 56:26That's the best way to put it. It's rage -inducing
- 56:28for me. My blood pressure has been up this entire
- 56:30episode. I don't know if you can see it. It's
- 56:32bad. I feel like I need to go to a doctor and
- 56:35talk about, like a therapist, and be like, is
- 56:38it normal to have this kind of reaction to a
- 56:40movie? I really, I know you're not supposed to
- 56:44do this, and you shouldn't, but also please do.
- 56:46I want you to record that meeting. Yeah. And
- 56:49then be like, so tell me what's going on. Headaches?
- 56:52Yeah. And you just hear a crash. Blood pressure?
- 56:55Yes. All right, cool. What do you think caused
- 56:57this? Mickey Rooney. Mickey Rooney? Mickey Rooney?
- 57:01Well, he's been dead for years. Their hand is
- 57:04reaching slowly for the phone that leads to the
- 57:08psych ward. Yeah. Oh, boy. We got a code puck.
- 57:12A code puck. In room three. Hey, how about double
- 57:15features? Yeah. So I said earlier that I wanted
- 57:20to, uh, first off, I think maybe a drill in the
- 57:23ear. Is that, is that a good double feature for
- 57:26this? Yeah. A trip outside. touching fresh air
- 57:30yeah no so i mentioned my double feature i thought
- 57:33about walking back my get over it pairing with
- 57:36a previous film and uh i decided not to do that
- 57:39because i think instead of trashing this movie
- 57:43which again it doesn't really deserve to be trashed
- 57:45it is what i wanted to do is give it a double
- 57:49feature of something that i think did something
- 57:50a bit better and again i'm not saying that this
- 57:53is a better movie i certainly enjoyed it more
- 57:55but in 2012 Joss Whedon was filming The Avengers.
- 57:59Okay. Okay. Maybe in 2011 he was filming The
- 58:02Avengers, but sure. You know what I mean. He's
- 58:04filming The Avengers, and while he's filming
- 58:07it, he decided to invite all of his friends,
- 58:10and just in general, whoever wanted to come,
- 58:12over to his house. And over the span of 12 days,
- 58:16they filmed Much Ado About Nothing. Oh. And Much
- 58:20Ado About Nothing is a black and white retelling
- 58:22of this, but it is set... in 2000s los angeles
- 58:27and it is the events of what much ado about nothing
- 58:31within a hollywood hills house of actors they
- 58:36don't play themselves but actors and friends
- 58:38and how those events can come over time And it's
- 58:42not fantastical. It's not magical. It's not whimsical.
- 58:46But instead, they take that core text and they
- 58:48talk about how the powers that be of magic are
- 58:51actually just the power of influence. And it's
- 58:54them whispering to other people, hey, this person
- 58:56has feelings for you. Hey, this person has feelings
- 58:57for you. And they start wondering, well, hey,
- 59:00I wonder if that's something I should be looking
- 59:03into. So it kind of corrupts them. And instead
- 59:06of magic, it's the... communicate the power of
- 59:08communication yeah and like the influence that
- 59:11people have over each other interesting and again
- 59:13they keep that with the core shakespeare text
- 59:16so they filmed something that was again they
- 59:20didn't have to write a script because well the
- 59:22words because the words are there instead they
- 59:24have to mold it to kind of fit well these three
- 59:26people are in this room saying this and they
- 59:28plot for this so then they are the fairies And
- 59:31they're going to kind of corrupt these people
- 59:33because they don't have what they have. Yeah.
- 59:35And it provides so much more of like, oh, this
- 59:38is a really interesting interpretation of that.
- 59:40But you keep the script the same. That's what
- 59:42you want. That's what I want. You want an interpretation.
- 59:45I want an interpretation because when you were
- 59:47giving me this is what it is. Yeah. Like what
- 59:50it is. is very difficult to understand. So when
- 59:53you put it into more of a modern lens and say,
- 59:55well, here's the understanding. That's what Clueless
- 59:57did for Emma. That's what Get Over It did for
- 1:00:00Midsummer Night's Dream. Much Ado About Nothing,
- 1:00:02I know, is not the same as this. So the fairy
- 1:00:05thing is off. But the idea of that is you change
- 1:00:09the context, but you keep the words. And to me,
- 1:00:12that is a faithful adaptation to where, yeah,
- 1:00:14it's not exactly what they meant in that text,
- 1:00:16but you took the words and the words mean exactly
- 1:00:18the same. You've just changed the connotation
- 1:00:20of it. Yeah. So to me, it's like an actor reading
- 1:00:24a sentence and being like, oh, I can see a little
- 1:00:26more despair in this than hopefulness. And they
- 1:00:28read it two different ways. Sure. That is what
- 1:00:30I think is really interesting. So while I'm not
- 1:00:34going to applaud Joss Whedon as a whole, I will
- 1:00:39applaud that movie. Because to me, that was extremely
- 1:00:42interesting and really, really fun to watch.
- 1:00:45I like it. That sounds good to me. I actually
- 1:00:48want to check that out because it does sound...
- 1:00:49Pretty cool. You can borrow my copy. Oh, thank
- 1:00:51you. Appreciate it. The elements in this movie
- 1:00:55that I really liked were kind of like the camera
- 1:00:57trickery. They felt like a nod, like I said,
- 1:00:59back to old silent films that relied heavily
- 1:01:02on that to engage audiences. So I went with maybe
- 1:01:07one of the most famous films of all time, 1902's
- 1:01:11A Trip to the Moon by George Meleys. There's
- 1:01:14so much of this like forced perspective and...
- 1:01:18Using editing to like make actors disappear right
- 1:01:21before your eyes. It really, and those are usually
- 1:01:25fantasy films as well. So to me, Midsummer Night's
- 1:01:29Dream almost feels like a nod to that era of
- 1:01:32filmmaking, at least visually. So I think it's
- 1:01:35fun to go back and watch one of those old George
- 1:01:39Mealy's film. Or if you want to get real crazy
- 1:01:41and see like a horror version of it, watch Hexen,
- 1:01:44the witch movie. Oh, yeah. The old black and
- 1:01:48white horror movie. Same concept, but pretty
- 1:01:52wild stuff. I see what you're saying because
- 1:01:54there's a lot of forced perspective in Midsummer
- 1:01:57Night's Dream. Yeah. And a lot of that forced
- 1:01:59perspective is also seen in Trip to the Moon.
- 1:02:02Yeah, yeah. So that's a really great call. Or
- 1:02:04Dante's Inferno, the old black and white. Oh,
- 1:02:06it's so good. I love that. I think it's actually
- 1:02:08a really funny comp that you gave. It's not a
- 1:02:11funny one. It reminds me of the Howard Hughes.
- 1:02:15compilation that you and I both ordered off of
- 1:02:17Flickr Alley. But while I ordered that, I also
- 1:02:19saw they had a trip to the moon. Oh. And I was
- 1:02:21like, well, why not just save a little bit on
- 1:02:23shipping? And I ordered that. So tomorrow, I
- 1:02:27should be receiving both my Howard Hughes compilation,
- 1:02:31which includes the racket. Yeah, which is really
- 1:02:35cool. And Arabian Nights. Two Arabian Nights.
- 1:02:38Two Arabian Nights. Yeah. I thought I was just
- 1:02:39getting one. Look at that. Two Arabian Nights
- 1:02:43and The Racket. Very excited for that. But Trip
- 1:02:45to the Moon, I'm very excited to own. So it's
- 1:02:48very coincidental that you bring that up. Yeah,
- 1:02:50I'm excited for that. I've not seen Two Arabian
- 1:02:53Nights. I like Lewis Milestone a lot. I think
- 1:02:55we both do. I'm excited to rewatch The Racket,
- 1:02:58not on Tubi. That's going to be really nice.
- 1:03:00Man, how far we've come. The first iteration
- 1:03:03of the show, I had to track that movie down in
- 1:03:05like the depths of the internet. And now the
- 1:03:08Blu -ray is coming. Yeah, now I can pop it into
- 1:03:10my systems. Here we go. I'm excited to hear something
- 1:03:15that's not the entertainer. Yeah. Yeah, me too.
- 1:03:18I really want to know people's thoughts on...
- 1:03:21Not you, Bryce. This movie. Yeah. Well, specifically
- 1:03:24you as well, Bryce, because I need somebody else
- 1:03:26to just say what I had to hold back from saying
- 1:03:29in this episode. But Shakespeare, we let into
- 1:03:32it. Kind of rough for us. Me personally, I want
- 1:03:37to have a better grasp of that, but man, when
- 1:03:39you throw stuff like Mickey Rooney in here, you're
- 1:03:42making it so hard for me. So if you have thoughts
- 1:03:45on this movie or Shakespeare in general, Shakespeare
- 1:03:48adaptations, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 1:03:52at gmail .com. Again, have those responses in
- 1:03:56by August 23rd, and we will read those on the
- 1:04:00show. Also, I've been forgetting to promote this,
- 1:04:03but... Sign up for the Patreon, patreon .com
- 1:04:05slash OUTAOPodcast, where you can vote for what
- 1:04:09film nominated for the 1936 Academy Awards actually
- 1:04:13deserved the Best Picture win. I know it shouldn't.
- 1:04:17Yep. But yeah, next episode, we have our 1936
- 1:04:21ceremony episode where we're going to recap everything
- 1:04:25that was nominated in every category and cover
- 1:04:29all 12 films that we've spent the last six weeks
- 1:04:32talking about. So stay tuned for that. And anything
- 1:04:37else you got? For anyone who watched Midsummer
- 1:04:39Night's Dream, if you feel like you want a better
- 1:04:42understanding of what Kyle and I are talking
- 1:04:44about in terms of what we are looking for in
- 1:04:46these movies, I would say that you go and look
- 1:04:49at Get Over It. I don't mean that to sound dismissive.
- 1:04:53Like, hey, get over it. Go watch the movie Get
- 1:04:56Over It, starring Ben Foster, Kristen Dunst,
- 1:04:58and who can forget Cisco. Martin Short is also
- 1:05:01in the movie. And Mila Kunis. It's a real who's
- 1:05:04who of the 2000s. I think that that gets it.
- 1:05:08That movie understands Midsummer Night's Dream
- 1:05:10and it interprets it in a very modern version,
- 1:05:13but also makes it very exciting to where you
- 1:05:16understand it and want to seek out the original
- 1:05:18because now you have that core understanding.
- 1:05:20Gotcha. This on its own is like, I know what
- 1:05:24Midsummer Night's Dream is and I just couldn't
- 1:05:26even like figure out what was going on because
- 1:05:28the core text is like so confusing. Yeah. And
- 1:05:31Mickey Rooney is trying to actively harm me.
- 1:05:34Right. Don't let this be your first. taste of
- 1:05:37a Midsummer Night's Dream, I think is what we're
- 1:05:39saying. I think that's right. But if you love
- 1:05:42Midsummer Night's Dream and you love the story
- 1:05:44of it and understand it 100%, then I think this
- 1:05:47is probably a lot of fun. Good luck with Puck.
- 1:05:49Good luck with Puck. That's going to do it for
- 1:05:52this episode. As always, I'm Kyle. And I'm taking
- 1:05:56my medication for high blood pressure. And we'll
- 1:05:59see you at the movies.