Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / Gaming the Guilt: Shame, Pressure, and What Healthy Gaming Really Looks Like (Episode 276)
Transcript
- 0:00matt: That's what gaming is.
- 0:01matt: It is the best thing.
- 0:04matt: And that's why everyone should game like us.
- 0:08matt: Everyone should, even if they don't think they would, like, my mom would never have of it, and now she's in the swing of it.
- 0:18matt: And that's the best thing we can do for other people really is show them the light.
- 0:23Jem: something that had up until then been quite a positive space for me to deal with all sorts of stuff, and to have a lot of fun suddenly started becoming a more negative space for me.
- 0:37Jem: And I do think that a large portion of that was down to my attitudes about my gaming.
- 0:45Alex: Particularly, for women as well, there's a lot of extra pressure on women, to conform to society's idea of what women is.
- 0:53Alex: But I think that one of the benefits or a way in which you can increase the benefit of gaming is to make it a pressure free activity if you possibly can, which is sometimes very difficult to do.
- 1:23Speaker: Hello, and welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 1:34Speaker: I'm your host for today.
- 1:34Speaker: I'm Jem, and I'm here with my friends Alex and Matt.
- 1:40Speaker: So before we get started, if you want to support us, you can subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/gamingthesystem for some exclusive content, or you can send a fo- us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address, wearegamingthesystem@gmail.com
- 2:01Jem: Today we are talking about some new research that came out of Oxford, which has found that when it comes to gaming and mental health, it's not how long you play for that matters.
- 2:15Jem: It's whether you feel that the time you spent playing was worthwhile, Goes some way to challenge the idea that screen time equals bad, and also that that screen time is in some way, time wasting or not good for you.
- 2:36Jem: But it also goes a little way to challenge some of the ideas that we've talked about a lot on the podcast about how gaming is good for mental health and, other aspects that we've talked about in the past.
- 2:53Jem: So I thought that we would spend, a couple of sessions going over what we think this new research might mean and talk about who gets to decide what healthy, gaming looks like and who gets to decide.
- 3:12Jem: Who is allowed to game and who is allowed to class it as valuable use of time versus a waste of time.
- 3:22Jem: A Nintendo study came out in March last year, 2025 and looked at Gamers who played Nintendo games.
- 3:33Jem: They looked at the link between how long you spent playing your Nintendo Switch and how that impacted your wellbeing.
- 3:42Jem: And they were looking at things like satisfaction, depressive symptoms and general mental wellbeing.
- 3:49Jem: And they found that there was no meaningful link between these two things.
- 3:56Jem: But what they did find was that what they call life fit, which was the idea of how you felt about your gaming.
- 4:04Jem: So if you believed that gaming.
- 4:07Jem: Was a positive thing for you then people exhibited positive, responses to the gaming experience.
- 4:17Jem: And basically these are, these are players who log in.
- 4:22Jem: For around one and a half hours, 1.4 hours per week.
- 4:27Jem: So these are very casual gamers.
- 4:30Jem: But it does open up an interesting idea about what that means for how gaming affects our mental health.
- 4:41Alex: I think it's interesting that you've reiterated that.
- 4:44Alex: The study focuses around casual gamers because I think all of us are like more than casual gamers, it is a very interesting study because it's a very in vogue topic right now, the benefits or perils of screen time, and particularly around parents and children as well, and limits on screen time and imposing bans on particular types of, consumption of social media, for example.
- 5:12Alex: There's a lot of talk, for, lots of countries across the world.
- 5:16Alex: I think Greece recently has put forward that they want to ban social media for under 15 year olds.
- 5:23Alex: So you can see that right now.
- 5:25Alex: It's definitely a topic, that a lot of people are talking about.
- 5:29Alex: I think in terms of.
- 5:32Alex: Is screen time good or bad?
- 5:34Alex: Is gaming good or bad or a longer period of gaming good or bad?
- 5:38Alex: I think like you touched on Jem, I think it can only come from the person who's doing the gaming themselves.
- 5:45Alex: If you feel good about the activity that you're undertaking and you know it's going to help you either wind down, decompress, or it's gonna help you have some escapism.
- 5:57Alex: Just have some other activity to do that takes you perhaps out of yourself and is a benefit to your mental health, where you feel like it's going to be a change of scene for your mental health, then it's obviously going to have a positive impact.
- 6:12Alex: I think when it's bad is if you start to feel more frustrated than, pleased with what you're doing, and we talked about how that is sometimes a fine line to balance, particularly, when it comes to maybe competitive gaming.
- 6:28Alex: Or even indeed, if you are competing with yourself and you become more and more frustrated, you've got to know when it's a good time to stop because it could be making you feel more negative if you kind of continue that cycle and get more and more down on yourself.
- 6:45Alex: I certainly had, I think, experience of that when I was younger.
- 6:49Alex: My parents would step in and say, that's enough now.
- 6:52Alex: Come back to it later, turn it off.
- 6:55Alex: Which is the opposite thing you want to hear when you're a child.
- 6:57Alex: Of course.
- 6:58Alex: So I think there is definitely a fine line to tread, but I am confident in saying that I think gaming is definitely a benefit to my mental health.
- 7:08Alex: And that's from someone who definitely games for more than one and a half hours a week, much more than one and a half hours.
- 7:18Jem: I mean, we're maybe not the right people to talk about this in some ways because we do believe that gaming is positive for our mental wellbeing.
- 7:26Jem: So based on the results of this study, that probably means that it is for us, beneficial.
- 7:33Jem: But I think that, you've raised a lot of points that we will dig down into a little deeper as we go on about how we feel about it, how people can make us feel about gaming and how we feel we have to sort of justify it from time to time.
- 7:48Jem: I mean, the idea of life fit was an interesting concept for me and I was sort of like, well, what does life fit mean?
- 7:58Jem: They did look at a, seven point scale running with whether gaming.
- 8:06Jem: Greatly interfered or greatly supported, various aspects of life ranging from work life and social life and, cognitive health.
- 8:19Jem: So, what are your initial thoughts on this, Matt?
- 8:25matt: This feels like a study that is missing the point of what gaming can be foundation of my life is gaming.
- 8:40matt: That's my level of activity that I could do that all day every day and that would feel good for me.
- 8:50matt: I would enjoy that.
- 8:53matt: But I do other things.
- 8:57matt: as you go, right, you need to have balance in your life around the things that you enjoy doing and the things you need to do.
- 9:04matt: this very, very outdated perspectives on what a good life is or a full life is or what you should be doing when now.
- 9:19matt: The message to gamers is that you can find other people who game as much as you do and love gaming as much as you do, and you can only choose to spend your time with those kinds of people.
- 9:37matt: You don't need to arbitrarily go off to other places.
- 9:41matt: You can have your thing and find people who are also doing your thing then.
- 9:48matt: You've got socializing potential.
- 9:52matt: Built into that like we do, we socialize, we game together and we do a podcast and that's all on gaming.
- 10:06matt: I game with my mom and my sister and that's opened a load of things for me.
- 10:12matt: done plenty of solo streaming, now doing my game development stuff, a massive part of my life revolves around the activity of gaming not just being about the time you spend actually gaming.
- 10:29matt: about the time I spend talking with you two, doing the podcast streaming gaming with and Meghan, and watching gaming streams and gaming is just that.
- 10:41matt: Not just playing a game.
- 10:44matt: It's gaming as a universe is the foundation of my life.
- 10:49matt: There that is the role it can play.
- 10:52matt: not as simple as these kinds of things thinking, oh, if you play it two hours a week, that couldn't be healthy.
- 10:57matt: But if you play it for five hours a week, then that means that something's wrong.
- 11:01matt: It's going, no, you can spend almost all of your free time gaming and then when you're not gaming, you can be watching someone.
- 11:07matt: I watch someone play games while I play games.
- 11:11matt: And then I text you both about games the more we've, we build away from this kind of reductive thinking is the way to properly embrace what we can have.
- 11:26matt: Starting Mom and Meghan gaming was.
- 11:29matt: Two and a half years ago now.
- 11:31matt: Mum had never played a game before.
- 11:32matt: Meghan had played a few games with an ex-boyfriend, and I managed to talk them into playing some games.
- 11:39matt: And then because I wasn't very comfortable, being out of my room as much, then I asked them to,'cause I wanted to watch them play.
- 11:51matt: But being out there, With them at the same time was a challenge for me.
- 11:58matt: So rather than me going right, I will force myself to go and sit in there with them we set up a streaming system, so whenever they're gaming, can stream and I can be in my room and I'm watching them play.
- 12:12matt: And if I don't watch them live, then it's recorded and I can watch it back like that.
- 12:18matt: So I've got hundreds of hours of.
- 12:20matt: Streaming footage from the two of them from the last two and a half years.
- 12:24matt: And that has evolved to me.
- 12:26matt: I'm always in the conservatory gaming with them when they game and that's, evolved in a way that.
- 12:34matt: Doesn't on paper doesn't sound like a big deal, but it's been a massive, massive deal for me to have done.
- 12:41matt: And then playing Fortnite with Meghan, most of the time she'll be playing in the conservatory and I'll be playing in my room.
- 12:49matt: And this older way of thinking, would describe these things as negative versions of doing things, but they love doing it.
- 13:01matt: It suits.
- 13:01matt: It's about doing what suits us and going from there rather than going, this is what we should probably do.
- 13:14matt: But what this kind of conversation needs to be is expanding it into who we are.
- 13:19matt: And how we define ourselves.
- 13:22matt: that's antithetical to capitalism.
- 13:24matt: It's going, you need to define yourself on your job, based on what you can do, what your capacity is, rather than going, right.
- 13:32matt: You what you love, not what you do.
- 13:37matt: And if you go from that, then you can't, you don't choose what you love.
- 13:42matt: So that's the simplest place to start.
- 13:45matt: It's tricky to know which studies to follow and which are really impactful because we are not presented in this study.
- 13:56Jem: No, and I think that is important to recognize.
- 13:59Jem: I do think that this study is working towards challenging those outdated attitudes that you were talking about, Matt, because I think what this is saying is that if you spend your week playing games, not a problem as long as you aren't kind of conflicted about it, I suppose.
- 14:24Jem: Which says to me that actually, as you say, Matt, what we need to do is change.
- 14:32Jem: Social attitudes towards gaming because it's the attitude towards gaming and people who spend time gaming that can create a negative basically if, if you see what I mean, A sort of feedback loop is caused by the people's negative attitudes towards gamers.
- 14:53Jem: There is a lot that is about how we feel about it in ourselves and obviously that is influenced by the people around us and society at large.
- 15:05Jem: And I think, you know, these days culturally it's more acceptable to game than it was say, when I was younger.
- 15:14Jem: As part of a.
- 15:16Jem: Hobby gaming is much more a thing that many people have done at some point or might do with some friends online or in couch co-op or whatever.
- 15:29Jem: whereas when I was younger, it was such a sort of niche thing, certainly for anyone who wasn't male, basically.
- 15:37Jem: So, you know, I think there was some issues with it there I think we have seen a bit of a shift away from.
- 15:45Jem: But I know that when I started to feel that my gaming with World of Warcraft for example, was becoming.
- 15:55Jem: Too consuming that it was taking up too much time, despite the fact that all of the people around me were on the game.
- 16:05Jem: All of the people were playing the game or were into the game.
- 16:09Jem: My husband at the time was into the game.
- 16:12Jem: Our friends were all players, you know, so my social life was on the game, so that wasn't affected.
- 16:19Jem: I wasn't working at the time, so that wasn't affected and I was keeping on top of all of my day-to-day chores and all of those things, but at some point I suddenly started to feel that the time I was spending on there was too much.
- 16:33Jem: I dunno what triggered that, but that happened and as a result of my attitude change it started having a negative effect on my mental health.
- 16:43Jem: And whereas something that had up until then been quite a positive space for me to deal with all sorts of stuff, and to have a lot of fun suddenly started becoming a more negative space for me.
- 16:57Jem: And I do think that a large portion of that was down to my attitudes about my gaming.
- 17:05Jem: And I'd like to be able to talk about what triggered that, but I honestly don't know.
- 17:10Jem: So I suppose the next question is, does this ring true for you?
- 17:16Jem: The idea that quality.
- 17:19Jem: Of the gaming IE how much you are enjoying it, whatever
- 17:24Alex: it.
- 17:24Jem: that means more important than quantity.
- 17:28Jem: So, do you feel that, a really good session of, Sima or, Fortnite is like a really useful.
- 17:40Jem: And valuable use of your time and good, for your mental health versus, I don't know, sitting there playing like a puzzle game
- 17:48matt: I don't think I've ever not enjoyed gaming.
- 17:52matt: I don't think there's ever been a period where I've sat down and I've gamed all day.
- 18:00matt: I've never not enjoyed myself doing it.
- 18:03matt: I could sit and I have just play a game.
- 18:06matt: I've done that today self-awareness is the critical thing really is to know yourself well enough to go okay, that.
- 18:16matt: That bit is becoming a bit, seeing where the flaws in it are.
- 18:19matt: 'cause my only issue at the moment is I've been playing Neo three and I've been playing it for two months now, which is unusual.
- 18:27matt: And I played up to a point and then started it again, and then started it again and still haven't finished it.
- 18:35matt: And it's gotten me proper.
- 18:39matt: I dunno if you two do this, you twist when you.
- 18:42matt: You twist
- 18:43Alex: Yes.
- 18:44matt: So this is a perfect opportunity to talk about how gaming can be.
- 18:48matt: My self-awareness is the way to diffuse that the bosses at the moment, because I've played it through to like, I dunno how much percentage of it is, it's dozens and dozens and dozens of hours so I'm, I know enough about the combat to chop my way through most of the normal enemies, then that means that I have done less killing by the time I get to the bosses.
- 19:15matt: So I am.
- 19:16matt: Lower level than the boss would be if I had grinded my way towards to get to that boss.
- 19:21matt: So I keep on like, I'll kill my way through this area, know where I'm going get to this thing, and they hit a boss that takes me three days to beat.
- 19:30matt: I go back to it every couple of hours.
- 19:32matt: So I don't just get to that boss and then try and.
- 19:35matt: Kill that boss and over and over and over and over and over again till I do it.
- 19:38matt: I'll do that for a certain amount of time, then go that I'm never gonna beat this boss.
- 19:42matt: I'll then I'll either go to a different game or do another mission in the same game.
- 19:48matt: And that has been happening over and over again for the last two weeks of, I'll hit a boss, feel like I'm never gonna do it, then eventually do it.
- 19:59matt: But my eye on it at the moment is going, I've been playing this game for two months.
- 20:03matt: I've been loving it like the, it's been the right game for me at the moment, and there are these really difficult, painful bits.
- 20:14matt: It doesn't put me off playing it, it doesn't put me off playing a game in general, but I have my eye on it going, I can stop, I can uninstall this game and I can choose to never touch it again and switch to another game.
- 20:28matt: I give myself that option.
- 20:30matt: And that's the thing, I don't put pressure on myself with.
- 20:34matt: Gaming.
- 20:35matt: If I was to go so right, I'm gonna do nothing but play games for the next week.
- 20:40matt: And I had neo three sitting there, I would.
- 20:46matt: Play something else.
- 20:47matt: If I found I wasn't enjoying it, and then I'd enjoy that and I know that I could just game all day every day and just enjoy myself.
- 20:58matt: And that's, a good thing.
- 21:00matt: 'cause it means that you've got this enjoyable thing to be doing.
- 21:05matt: There isn't anything as rich as gaming any kind of safe activity that is just as rich and as consistent as a game can be.
- 21:18matt: It's just.
- 21:20matt: It is just, it's the best thing.
- 21:21matt: That's what gaming is.
- 21:23matt: It is the best thing.
- 21:25matt: And that's why everyone should game like us.
- 21:30matt: Everyone should, even if they don't think they would, like, my mom would never have of it, and now she's in the swing of it.
- 21:40matt: And that's the best thing we can do for other people really is show them the light.
- 21:45Alex: It is interesting, Matt, that you, briefly mentioned putting pressure on yourself.
- 21:50Alex: I was gonna bring up pressure as a talking point, and it is harking back as well to the discussion around like, how many hours is healthy for somebody versus not this, like this outdated notion about that.
- 22:04Alex: And I think it kind of links in a little bit with the pressure we put on ourselves with other aspects of our health.
- 22:11Alex: Like, you need to have eight hours of sleep every night.
- 22:14Alex: You need to eat five fruit and veggie every day.
- 22:17Alex: You need to drink this many glasses of water.
- 22:21Alex: There's a lot of pressure on ourselves to do what's considered the healthy thing or the latest healthy thing that we're being told.
- 22:28Alex: And particularly, for women as well, there's a lot of extra pressure on women, to conform to society's idea of what women is.
- 22:36Alex: But I think that one of the benefits or a way in which you can increase the benefit of gaming is to make it a pressure free activity if you possibly can, which is sometimes very difficult to do.
- 22:50Alex: And I wonder, Jen, when you talked about that shift in your attitude to world of Warcraft, whether you felt pressure about your time.
- 22:59Alex: Not being used in the right way.
- 23:01Alex: I don't know if I'm hitting the nail on the head there, but,
- 23:05Jem: I think that was what was going on.
- 23:06Jem: But I think a lot of that pressure came from myself.
- 23:10Jem: It might, it probably came from the broader society, but it didn't come from the people around me, my close friends.
- 23:17Jem: It came from something in me.
- 23:19Jem: And I do wonder if is a gender aspect to that.
- 23:25Alex: Yeah.
- 23:25Alex: 'cause I think what I was kind of ruminating on while we were all talking about it, was the idea that the times when gaming has felt.
- 23:34Alex: Like a negative.
- 23:35Alex: The rare occasions that it has for me is often when I put pressure on myself, because I feel like I'm not doing enough of what's the proper thing.
- 23:43Alex: Like, I haven't done enough chores today.
- 23:45Alex: I haven't done enough X, Y, and ZI should be doing this instead of gaming.
- 23:50Alex: And that's when it starts to feel like, oh, this is too much screen time.
- 23:55Alex: I need to stop.
- 23:57Alex: And I think that maybe is where that.
- 23:59Alex: Side of it comes from for me, which is not a nice thing, but it's something that, I'm beginning to, through a couple of years worth of counseling, have become more aware of the amount of expectation I put on myself.
- 24:13Alex: That comes from no one but me,
- 24:15Jem: yeah, we have talked about it in previous podcasts about the idea of sort of shame and the link.
- 24:21Jem: To gaming and this idea of I should be doing something more productive with my time.
- 24:28Jem: and again, I think that in some ways this report comes so.
- 24:33Jem: Tantalizingly close to hitting the nail on the head with the struggles that gamers feel whilst completely sidestepping it and missing it.
- 24:43Jem: Because obviously it's talking about how it's your attitude to gaming.
- 24:47Jem: But then, How does that attitude get managed and how do you decide as an individual what is good enough?
- 24:56Jem: What is enough time?
- 24:58Jem: What is too much time?
- 25:00Jem: How much time should you spend, cleaning the house versus playing your games?
- 25:06Jem: Some research that came out this week that, lots more teenage boys would refer to themselves as gamers than girls, even though there's about the same amount, if not slightly more girls who play games.
- 25:24Jem: A young boy will say, oh yeah, I'm a gamer.
- 25:27Jem: Whereas a young girl wouldn't.
- 25:29Jem: So there's obviously still some stereotypes and social.
- 25:34Jem: Norms and things at work there.
- 25:40Jem: I feel like we're really kind of getting into the heart of this, topic.
- 25:45Jem: So, we are going to continue, but you are gonna have to wait till the next episode to hear the rest of that.
- 25:51Jem: So for now, I will say, thank you very much for listening and we have something come out every Thursday, and if you are interested in hearing more, then like share.
- 26:05Jem: Follow us and, let us know what you think.
- 26:07Jem: Let us know how you feel about, your gaming and how good or bad it is for your mental wellbeing and your physical wellbeing.
- 26:17Jem: So thank you both very much and we will see you next week.
- 26:22Jem: Bye.