Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 113
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two, one one one.
- 0:27Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are
- 0:31all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started.
- 0:39A Doomed Pair the murderer Dan Montekalvo. Some people seemed destined to be
- 0:47criminals from the time they were born. I'm not saying that they will find
- 0:51themselves on the wrong side of a sliding metal door every night, but the
- 0:55odds that they will are greater than the average Joe's. Seems to be the
- 1:00case for one Dan Montekalvo. His father had been killed in a shootout with
- 1:04police while he was just a child. Dan's mother was no saint herself.
- 1:11When times got tough, she would turn to prostitution as a means to make
- 1:15money, even using their own home to service her clientele. Given these two
- 1:21factors, it wasn't surprising their son started stealing at the age of nine.
- 1:26This led him to spending the next nine years of his life in and out
- 1:29of reform schools and various foster homes. Unfortunately, when Dan turned eighteen and
- 1:36became an adult, it didn't also come with the realization that he needed to
- 1:40turn his life around. He'd already had a criminal record, drank heavily,
- 1:45and had a gambling addition, alcohol and casinos cost money, and he funded
- 1:49these ventures by robbing banks. Eventually, though, he was caught and found
- 1:55himself locked away in a federal correctional facility in Oxford. The second character in
- 2:00our story is Carol, the daughter of a working class family, earned her
- 2:06Bachelor of Science degree from the University of New York and then followed that up
- 2:10by achieving a master's degree from the same school in nineteen seventy. During this
- 2:15time, she met a student studying at the same university from overseas. They'd
- 2:21been married, but the union only lasted a year. Her father had been
- 2:24vehemently opposed to the marriage and it had created a rift between the two.
- 2:30With no husband and now cut off from her family, Carol turned to religion
- 2:36as a means of support. One of the people in the church she belonged
- 2:39to had asked her to become a penpal with a man by the name of
- 2:43Dan Montecalvo. She agreed, and the two began to exchange letters with one
- 2:47another. Those letters led to visits, where Carol came to the conclusion Dan
- 2:53and his choices had been the result of a troubled childhood. Over time,
- 2:59Carol and Dan grew close and eventually decided they were in love with one another.
- 3:04Despite this, Dan still had ten years left in his sentence before he
- 3:07was set to be released. Ever, the one to believe in her higher
- 3:12power, Carol put all her faith in the power of prayer, believing it
- 3:16was the key to an earlier release. The couple, however, decided they
- 3:21didn't want to wait any longer to get married, so on July fourteenth,
- 3:24nineteen eighty, the two became man and wife in a small ceremony in the
- 3:29prison yard. Six months later, Carol's prayers were answered and the couple relocated
- 3:35to the city of Burbank, California. Carol took a job selling yellow page
- 3:39ads, which she proved quite successful at. When she was hired at Pacific
- 3:45Bell, she was able to make a good living for herself. Dan,
- 3:49on the other hand, wasn't as lucky. He bounced from job to job
- 3:53and found solace at the bottom of a bottle. He soon slipped into a
- 3:57deep depression, which only got worse when he was diagnosed with a bleeding ulcer.
- 4:01The pain from the injury was so bad Dan couldn't work and he started
- 4:05drinking even more. When Carol won a sales contest at work and received an
- 4:11all expenses paid trip to Hawaii, she believed it was just the thing Dan
- 4:15needed to snap him out of his funk. When they came back, things
- 4:19would be like they used to be. On March thirty first, nineteen eighty,
- 4:24the day before the two of them were set to leave, Dan and
- 4:27Carol went out for a walk at about ten thirty pm, which was normal
- 4:30for the evenings when he was home. It would be the last thing they
- 4:34would do together. The nine one one operator received the call at eleven p
- 4:40m. The man on the phone said they needed help and they'd been shot.
- 4:44A squad car pulled up to the Monte Calvo house one minute later.
- 4:47They didn't immediately enter the residence, fearing the shooter might still be inside.
- 4:53Only after Dan came out nine minutes later did they rush to help. Dan
- 4:58had been shot in the back and the bullet had stopped its trajectory somewhere around
- 5:02his small intestine. He was taken to a nearby hospital, where an operation
- 5:06successfully removed the bullet. Carol wasn't as lucky. They found her in a
- 5:13hallway dead as a result of a gunshot wound. When he was able,
- 5:17Dan told police that when they'd arrived home, he noticed the tags on their
- 5:21car's license plate were going to expire the following day. He had the replacement
- 5:27in the glove compartment. While he opened the door to retrieve it, Carol
- 5:30had gone inside to get something to clean the plate with. That is when
- 5:34he heard his wife say what are you doing here, followed by the sound
- 5:40of two gunshots. When this happened, he ran inside, only to be
- 5:44grabbed from behind and then shot himself. He heard one of the intruders say
- 5:48let's get out of here, or something similar to that. When they left,
- 5:54Dan managed to get to his feet. That is when he saw Carol
- 5:58in the hall badly bleeding from her injuries. He made his way into their
- 6:02bedroom and called nine one one. During this time, he said that a
- 6:06safe and cash box had been burglarized. The story was convincing, and it
- 6:12seemed to fall in line with the evidence they found at the scene. When
- 6:15they looked for signs of forced entry, police found the back screen had been
- 6:19slit open, giving the apparent killers. Access police told Dan they were sorry
- 6:25for his loss and left him to his grief while they attempted to find those
- 6:30responsible for the murder. Only a week would pass before the detectives working the
- 6:34case started taking a closer look into Dan Montecalvo. All of this was after
- 6:42the discovery of his previous criminal history. They found out that Carol's life had
- 6:46been insured for six hundred thousand dollars, four hundred thousand dollars of which had
- 6:50already been paid out to Dan. The remaining balance was being held because Dan
- 6:57was considered a suspect in the investigation. With all this new found money,
- 7:01Dan had made the trip to Las Vegas and proceeded to lose thousands of dollars
- 7:05a day. This only prompted investigators to look into Dan further. It was
- 7:12discovered that he had been using lines of credit to gamble at the casinos.
- 7:15He'd racked up huge debts, and they were threatening to attempt to get their
- 7:19money by means of Dan and Carroll's checking account before her death. There was
- 7:24no way Dan could have covered the markers. If this would have happened,
- 7:29there was a chance he could have gone to prison. Once again for writing
- 7:31bad checks. Now he was flush and had money to burn. Detectives were
- 7:38now sure Dan had killed his wife to cover his gambling debts and keep himself
- 7:43a free man. If this was the case, what happened to the guns?
- 7:47Based on the ballistic report, Carrol had been shot with a thirty eight
- 7:51caliber bullet, while Dan had been struck with a twenty five caliber round.
- 7:57When an extensive search of the house was conducted, did officers discovered a hollowed
- 8:01out book that would have more than fit two pistols until they could be discarded.
- 8:07The state's attorneys took a mountain of circumstantial evidence into a conviction on the
- 8:11charge of first degree murder. Dan Montekalvo maintained his innocence to the bitter end.
- 8:18The judge didn't hold back when it was time to punish the man.
- 8:22He handed down a sentence of twenty seven years to life in prison.