Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 7. More money doesn't mean more decisions: Before you say yes to minding your own business
Transcript
- 0:02Before you say yes, think about how you would explain to your five-year-old self what the consequences of signing this might be.
- 0:12Before you say yes, I think it's always important to have a really good friend around you.
- 0:19A person who you know will always tell you what you don't want to hear.
- 0:26I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, former senior bank executive, now working with companies, governments and regulators around the world to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:35This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask before you share your money, your accounts and your digital life with someone you love.
- 0:47So before you say yes to minding your own business, listen to this.
- 0:52Financial consent is a simple idea.
- 0:55Before you share your money, your bills, your accounts with anyone, you understand what you're agreeing to.
- 1:02You ask the questions, you make the decisions deliberately and without pressure, and you revisit them together.
- 1:10Most of us don't.
- 1:11We just fall into it for the little decisions, then do what we see everyone else do, and then gradually, and then all at once.
- 1:19And then life throws you a curveball and suddenly the way things are set up matters a lot more than we thought it would.
- 1:26Financial consent is also the foundation of financial safety.
- 1:30The decisions you make when everything is fine and the ones that determine what your options look like if it ever isn't.
- 1:38And that's true whether your relationship is difficult or whether it's the best thing in your life.
- 1:43And a trigger warning, today's episode discusses domestic and financial abuse.
- 1:49Moo Baulch has spent her life working to understand what it takes to change behaviour before something goes wrong.
- 1:56She chairs Our Watch, the national organisation working to stop violence against women before it starts.
- 2:03She'll tell you the financial conversations most couples never had aren't that hard.
- 2:09They just need someone to start them.
- 2:11We know that when we get to the end of a relationship and there are other tensions and there are going to be those sorts of challenges and often finances and money will be one of those things where there are, you know, small explosions or bigger ones.
- 2:26I think being able to think about things and have that conversation and talk about it through the lens of, you know, what if, what if.
- 2:35I get sick.
- 2:36What if you get sick?
- 2:37What if you're unable to, what if you lose your job and you're unable to work for six months?
- 2:40What would that look like for both of us?
- 2:42How do we feel about this now?
- 2:44And having a regular check-in around those things, whether it's an annual kind of day where you just sit down and reflect on some of those decisions that you've made jointly as a couple, it might be
- 2:58You know, who's going to pay the health insurance for a while?
- 3:02It might be, you know, you tend to have those conversations when you have children or when you get pets because the bills get bigger.
- 3:09You know, those sorts of expenses start to mount up.
- 3:13So making sure that you've got a regular check-in where you can have that conversation.
- 3:17It might be that you have children.
- 3:19you know, a monthly money date where you're having that check-in, particularly in times like this where, you know, cost of living is going through the roof, people are scared about jobs, they're worried about being able to afford, they're thinking about how they might need to adjust lifestyles around things like the fuel crisis.
- 3:36Like being able to have those conversations in a way that is safe, respectful and also not at a point of crisis is so important.
- 3:48Yeah.
- 3:50It does boil down to just healthy, open, respectful discussion, doesn't it?
- 3:56And doing that and making it not a scary topic.
- 3:59Yeah.
- 4:00Yeah.
- 4:01Because, and it's interesting to me that money does seem to be scary and it seems to be even more scary than talking about sex.
- 4:08Yes.
- 4:09Yeah, it really does.
- 4:10I don't know what it is within this culture that says we do not talk about money because it's not.
- 4:15It's impolite or, yeah, it seems to me very, very strange.
- 4:20And that's why it has to start in schools or at school age.
- 4:23I think there is an opportunity for us too, for Gen Xs to be opening the door a little bit differently, trying to work out the lingo as we do it.
- 4:34Yep.
- 4:37I'm interested to, as we do...
- 4:40open the door and young people are more able to maybe have some of these uncomfortable conversations because they are learning about consent in a way that Gen Xers and above didn't learn about.
- 4:54How do you give friends and family a language to open a conversation, to notice something might not be quite right but step into checking on a friend or a family member or someone they care about
- 5:10without being awkward or without being judgmental, without potentially causing some safety issues.
- 5:21Well, firstly, I would say in many circumstances it is going to be awkward and you just have to swallow that bit and say, actually, I may not be prepared for the answer that I think I'm going to get and it may be a bit uncomfortable for me to be able to ask this question, but actually I could be prepared.
- 5:41It could be saving someone's life.
- 5:42You know, that's not overstating it.
- 5:45I always suggest to people that they keep it really simple.
- 5:48So I think what we've done really well in Australia is encourage people to talk about mental health and ask people if they're okay.
- 5:57It can be as simple as that.
- 5:58And it can be talking generally.
- 6:00I would suggest you mention a couple of things that you might have seen or observed about that person's behavior.
- 6:05So if we think about, you know, I'm having a conversation with my sister and I'm worried
- 6:11her it'll be you know last time we caught up you didn't see myself is everything going okay so when you are setting up your shared accounts uh your shared bills why is that important to know whose name is on the bill and how would you set it up so that it does protect you from the things that um may go wrong
- 6:35Yeah, I mean, I am an optimistic person, but you do need to think worst case scenario in these circumstances, both from the perspective of what happens if everything goes horribly wrong and I suddenly have no way of accessing information about our account.
- 6:51Or if you are signing up to, you know, a product or a service or a liability, which means that you, in the worst set of circumstances,
- 7:03could be the one that is fully paying this bill, this mortgage, this credit card, this whatever the product is.
- 7:10You know, you may be paying that television off for the next 10 years of your life and your relationship might last for six months.
- 7:16So it's those sort of simple practical considerations, having that conversation really, really early on.
- 7:23Being very aware of what the consequences are if you have a phone bill, a rental account, a private health fund that is in both of your names, who is liable for that, but also who benefits from it.
- 7:43The moments we don't say anything, the comment we let slide, the joke we don't pull up, the thing we tell ourselves isn't our business.
- 7:54These can, over time, become permission for someone to go a little further.
- 7:59And often the person best placed to interrupt that isn't a professional or a service.
- 8:05It's a friend, a mate, a colleague, a sibling.
- 8:10My next guest understands the weight of that better than most.
- 8:14Dave Kramer is a behavioural scientist and a facilitator who works with men and boys in schools, workplaces and communities.
- 8:24He talks about respectful relationships.
- 8:27And he came to this work through a loss that changed the course of his life.
- 8:32I was studying psychology back in 2018 and then midway through the degree, my best friend Hannah Clarke and her three children were all murdered by Hans' ex-partner and the children's father.
- 8:43And I also knew the man who took their lives and I reflected a lot on my relationship to that man and the role I could have played in preventing what happened.
- 8:52While I take no responsibility for what happened, I take a lot of responsibility for the lessons I've learned, especially through understanding behavioral science and psychology and understanding the role that
- 9:02has largely been absent for a lot of men in society who think we're doing good things.
- 9:06There's a lot more we can do, and I just try to call forward more good men to do better things.
- 9:12First of all, I'm really sorry for your loss, and I thank you for all the work that you do and bringing your...
- 9:20your professional capabilities and your personal experiences to advocate for this work.
- 9:25And I really like to dive in how you're doing that and the conversations that you're having.
- 9:30When you're talking to men and boys about relationships and about money, what do you see?
- 9:36If I think about men who I work with, what I see a lot is genuinely a sense of pride in being able to be a provider.
- 9:42But I also see this kind of belief that comes with it that because I make the money, I'm in charge.
- 9:47And I should make all the decisions that revolve around it.
- 9:50And interestingly, with young men or with boys, I see a really...
- 9:55kind of being sucked into the old school beliefs around, gendered beliefs around money, right?
- 10:03As a man, like if I ask them, what is the role that a man should play in the home to a group of high school students, they'll say provider straight away.
- 10:11And if I dig deeper on what that means, they'll say make money.
- 10:14It's not provide a safe home.
- 10:15It's not provide emotional stability.
- 10:17It's not provide a space for people to talk about problems.
- 10:19It's provide money.
- 10:20And that's kind of it.
- 10:22And then you talk more about the role they should play in the relationship and they'll say decision maker, dominant, in charge.
- 10:28Unfortunately, though, sometimes particular algorithms can corrupt what that looks like.
- 10:32And then they find themselves in really challenging spaces.
- 10:35So the conversations we have is how do we navigate that space together so we can have equal partnerships and fair relationships while still being able to live up to someone who can provide and support their family in a range of different ways.
- 10:46Yeah, I'm sure no one grows up and says, I'm going to just have all this weight all over me that I need to be a good person that is under so much stress.
- 10:57Are you...
- 10:58It must put a lot of stress on people if they're thinking it's all on me.
- 11:04Yeah, it does.
- 11:05It does.
- 11:05Because I talk about this because they often, like, it sounds good, right, to be a provider and a protector, make lots of money, drive a big and fast car, have a mansion.
- 11:15Like, all that sounds really cool until you realize, oh, man, that's hard.
- 11:19There's a lot of pressure on me to be able to do that.
- 11:21And then the message they get underneath it is if you struggle, you're on your own.
- 11:25They're not looking at their mates and going, hey, man, you're struggling with something.
- 11:28Are you okay?
- 11:29They're looking at maybe women or girls and saying, hey, I'm struggling.
- 11:32This is your fault.
- 11:33What would that look like in terms of having the conversation with your partner and then literally starting to manage money in a more equitable way, even when you might have some of these other pressures on you?
- 11:47When we set goals as a couple for saving, saving for a house, whatever it might be, they're realistic and they're achievable for both people.
- 11:57What we see sometimes in financial abuse is this setting of targets that are unattainable and unachievable.
- 12:02And, you know, a woman shared with me, and she's given permission for me to share this as well, that she was set a target to save 80% of her casual income by the end of the month, whilst also looking after school stuff, kids stuff, groceries, bills, all that sort of stuff.
- 12:22And he made more money, so he said, no, I'll contribute more to the savings, but you have to contribute X amount.
- 12:28And by the end of the month, she got nowhere near it because it was impossible.
- 12:31And then he said, well, you can't manage your money.
- 12:33I'll get all the money from now on.
- 12:34I'll be in charge, and then I'll just give you what you need.
- 12:37Even though she got the same amount of money every single week, he was giving it to her either in an envelope or transferring it to her, and now she has no autonomy over her money.
- 12:46So when we set goals, they're achievable for both parties.
- 12:49They are reasonable for both people.
- 12:53And there's no sense of because I make more money, I make more decisions.
- 12:59It's just equal shared decisions across the board because we both contribute to this relationship.
- 13:04Sometimes their experiences of control, they're not genuinely coming from a place of like, I want to control this person.
- 13:12They might be coming from a place that they call love but is actually fear.
- 13:17it probably feels the same.
- 13:19Love and fear can be confusing.
- 13:20And maybe this person, this man who is reaching for control in this household or this particular group of men who are reaching for control in this household, maybe they're afraid that that extra dollar could break the bank and therefore they are an inadequate father, they are an inadequate provider, they are not good enough for their family, she might leave him for someone else who's made more money.
- 13:40All of this type of stuff might be going on there.
- 13:42So for me, as an outsider, again, acknowledging that there are people with real intention, there are also potentially people who are struggling and then choosing to control.
- 13:53For those people who are struggling, as I said very early on, they need support.
- 13:57They need help to manage that belief system they hold.
- 14:00And this is where the behavioral science thing, I think, comes in.
- 14:03They hold particular beliefs about what money means to them and their role as a provider, and it's helping them manage those beliefs that will then probably do a lot to soothe those emotions, and this may happen over a course of a very long time.
- 14:16And that may help them to make different decisions or even include the other person in the decisions that are made around money and their financial future.
- 14:25You have talked about, you know, thinking,
- 14:29hearing something that might make you feel a bit uncomfortable, but maybe letting it slide a little bit and then what that might lead to because it can become a bit of permission for somebody.
- 14:44Can you tell me a little bit about that and what that looks like?
- 14:47Okay.
- 14:47Yeah, I think often what we speak about is violence on a continuum rather than violence just happening one day out of the blue that no one expected.
- 14:56And usually that's how it's portrayed.
- 14:58We see a lot of behaviors that happen first, and that might start with sexist language and jokes, rigid gender beliefs about what men should be or what women should be.
- 15:08Then that might move towards something like objectification of someone saying that they're, you know, they're too unintelligent to manage money.
- 15:16They're just an object.
- 15:17They're
- 15:17you know, a side piece or whatever it is, whatever language they want to use, then there might be some victim blaming involved in that.
- 15:26Like he's out spending money or he's saying that she's spending this and it's all her fault that, you know, they're having challenges.
- 15:34So, and then we look at things like sexual harassment, sexual assault, domestic violence, and murder, which will write down the other end of the continuum.
- 15:41What we often see as men hanging out with other men in a workplace that is dominated by men is language that comes up, like she's a bitch for spending X or she's a gold digger or those types of comments.
- 15:56And that's why I talk about if we can hold people accountable at that point,
- 16:00And it doesn't necessarily mean saying to someone, hey, you're an idiot, you shouldn't say stuff like that, but to have a check-in conversation as well.
- 16:05Hold them accountable for sure.
- 16:06Hey, man, that's not okay.
- 16:08But also you could add to that, what's going on for you?
- 16:10Just to have that check-in conversation and seek that and see that this person gets support to prevent them from taking further steps along that continuum towards the end of the line.
- 16:19If we don't do the work there, then...
- 16:22It's complicit.
- 16:23It's saying to this person, that belief is okay.
- 16:25And often what we see, in fact, is people colluding.
- 16:29She's a bitch because she spent money on X and Y. Yeah, man, that must be tough.
- 16:33That sucks.
- 16:33Yeah, yeah, she is a bitch.
- 16:35Rather than saying, oof, watch the language, man.
- 16:37And sounds like you've got a bit of struggle at home with the money.
- 16:40Do you want to talk about it?
- 16:41Or do you want to go seek help from the EAP, the financial counselor, something like that?
- 16:44What would hold people back though from having that conversation?
- 16:47If you're in a big group and everyone's part of it, it's really hard to be the one who steps in.
- 16:53Yeah.
- 16:54I mean, that's across age groups as well.
- 16:56It's a challenge, right?
- 16:58And everyone else, we sit there in silence because we feel uncomfortable with the comment that this person has made, but no one else is saying anything, so we then blame ourselves.
- 17:07We sit there and go, well, I must be the only one who has a problem with this.
- 17:10I might have missed the punchline.
- 17:11I might have missed the joke.
- 17:12Or maybe this is really hard for that person and I just think I'm too woke or whatever it might be that, you know, I'm the one who has the problem.
- 17:21Rather than being…
- 17:22Curious about it.
- 17:23You know, is this okay?
- 17:25Is this the way we normally speak around about our partners when we're at lunch?
- 17:29Like just being curious about that situation and then people might, you know, say something or do something in that moment.
- 17:35There's a lot of stuff that comes up.
- 17:36I think sometimes a lot of these behaviors that they're seeing are pretty normalized, right?
- 17:40People call it just complaining about my partner.
- 17:43And sometimes it is genuine complaints.
- 17:45They're struggling with money.
- 17:47I mean, the world isn't that easy at the moment.
- 17:49And finances are tough.
- 17:50And struggles happen.
- 17:52And sometimes we have disruptions in our relationship.
- 17:56And even healthy relationships have disagreements and arguments and sleeping in separate bedrooms and all those types of things.
- 18:02And sometimes because of that, we just excuse whatever's going on.
- 18:05Oh, they're going through a tough time.
- 18:07That's fine.
- 18:08I'll just leave them go through it.
- 18:09Rather than going, oh, they're going through a tough time.
- 18:11Maybe I'll check in on them, have a private conversation after this and see if they're okay.
- 18:15And if they continue maybe to degrade their partner or say negative things about them, I can hold them accountable to that.
- 18:20But I really want to make sure they get the support they need to navigate this tough time they're going through.
- 18:24Yeah, I love the way you're talking about it doesn't have to be all on me either to solve the problem.
- 18:30How do I step in and maybe be a bit of a circuit breaker or encourage people to think a little bit differently and then get them to other support if they need it as well, that referral?
- 18:41You've talked about calling people out and calling people in.
- 18:47What does that mean?
- 18:48How do you call someone in rather than call them out?
- 18:52Yeah, I find it interesting with these little things.
- 18:54They sound so cliche, but I think it's a good way to think about it.
- 18:58Often calling out looks like calling someone a name or putting them down or something like that.
- 19:05Calling them in is just being curious.
- 19:07It's just asking them what's going on.
- 19:09Rather than, the big difference is that there's a sense of curiosity when it comes to calling someone in.
- 19:14When we're calling them out, we don't care.
- 19:16We're judging, we're putting them down, that sort of thing.
- 19:18So it would look like, like I said before, if we've noticed they made a negative comment or a degrading comment about their partner and it somehow relates to finances or something like that, we can say, oh man, that must really suck.
- 19:28That must be really hard.
- 19:29Is everything going okay at home?
- 19:31Are you managing your money okay?
- 19:32Are you having any struggles?
- 19:34Asking questions about what's going on for this person.
- 19:37If we have no curiosity, then we know that we're stepping very far away from calling in and we're moving towards calling out.
- 19:43How would you go about having a healthy money relationship?
- 19:47For some people, what it looks like is having independent incomes and then where there's maybe shared bills, there's a shared account or a shared credit card or a shared mortgage, whatever it is, and they still have their independent incomes.
- 20:02The other thing that's really important is when we set goals as a couple for saving, saving for a house, whatever it might be, they're realistic and they're achievable for both people.
- 20:14Understanding that just because I make money does not mean I make all the decisions.
- 20:19Regardless of what the workplace says around that sort of thing, a romantic relationship is very different.
- 20:26It's an equal shared partnership and maybe one person does earn the money and the other person is at home
- 20:31cooking cleaning nurturing the children and to school and back and doing all the other stuff if they're not doing that then that means that you can't work full time you have to do some of that work right so it's shared so everything should be shared decisions should be shared and there should be particular information
- 20:47Fair enough, there'll be someone in the relationship who knows more about money and someone who probably manages spreadsheets better than the other person, for sure.
- 20:54But that doesn't mean that all the decisions are controlled by that person.
- 20:57It just means that they may have more of an understanding of how these budgets will work and they can be well explained and then we can support each other.
- 21:05And if – sorry, this is so long –
- 21:08If we both struggle with that or if we're struggling to come to agreements, then seek external support.
- 21:12Look for a financial counsellor or someone who can help to navigate those decisions together as a couple.
- 21:18If you're watching a friend or a family member's relationship and something doesn't feel right, what would be a way to open that conversation up?
- 21:30Yeah, I think sometimes it's good just to talk about ourselves a little bit.
- 21:34Sometimes it can be easier just to say, geez, this economy is hitting us hard at home.
- 21:38How do you manage it?
- 21:39And then just to see if anything further comes up in that conversation.
- 21:42I think I might have said this before about staying curious without judgment.
- 21:46I think it's important when maybe they say, oh, yeah, you know, I just don't worry about the money.
- 21:51He handles all of that.
- 21:51That's not my job.
- 21:53We might think, oh, that's controlling or that's not okay or that's unfair.
- 21:56Yeah.
- 21:57But if we can just hold that and then say, oh, that must be really tough.
- 22:00Do you want to make more decisions around the money or is that just something you're comfortable with?
- 22:05And just stay curious and continue to ask questions and continue to keep that space safe.
- 22:10Any judgment we pass on the person we're speaking with or the person they're speaking about will ultimately end that conversation and that person feeling unsafe to share anymore.
- 22:19Keep judgment completely out of the situation and just inquire curiously about how are you
- 22:28we don't we we tend to make decisions around money that look like this what how do you make those kinds of decisions um anything that might help them to open up a little bit more and just be okay with whatever they say because they might not open up at all you say okay well if you ever need to talk about it i'm always here if someone listening to this series takes one thing away
- 22:51into their life and particularly men and boys, what would that be?
- 23:00What would you want them to take responsibility for?
- 23:04Each other, mostly.
- 23:05I think that's a big thing.
- 23:07We tend to excuse each other's behaviors and emotions because we think as men, we don't know how to deal with them.
- 23:13So we just say, oh, he'll find someone who you can talk about that with.
- 23:17But we acknowledge those things as we spoke about throughout where he might be expressing some emotional distress, but he's talking about it from a perspective of control of finances or she's doing X and Y and it's not good.
- 23:28or degrading her, we take responsibility for each other.
- 23:31And we say, hey, mate, I've heard some things.
- 23:33I don't like the way you're speaking about her.
- 23:34And also, do you need some support?
- 23:37Again, that's the choice to do both, to engage in both the belief around control and then the decisions they make off the back of that.
- 23:46And I think understanding that just because I make money does not mean I make all the decisions.
- 23:56My takeaway from Moo and Dave, the most dangerous expectations are the ones nobody says out loud.
- 24:03So before you say yes to minding your own business, do this.
- 24:08Have the conversation about what's mine, what's yours, what's ours before you need to.
- 24:13Making more money doesn't mean making more decisions.
- 24:17Financial control in a relationship, whoever earns it decides how it's spent, whoever contributes less gets less say, is not how a real healthy partnership works.
- 24:29Both people contribute.
- 24:31Decisions are shared.
- 24:33And if the spreadsheets make more sense to one person, then they can explain them to the other.
- 24:38That's not distrust.
- 24:39That's how a team works.
- 24:41If you notice something, say something.
- 24:44You don't need to fix it.
- 24:46You don't need to have it all figured out.
- 24:49Keep it simple and specific.
- 24:51Hey, last time we caught up, you didn't seem yourself.
- 24:54Is everything okay?
- 24:56Stay curious and be ready for an answer that maybe you weren't expecting.
- 25:01It might be really uncomfortable.
- 25:03Drop the judgment.
- 25:05The most important thing is to stay connected.
- 25:08Because love shouldn't cost your freedom.