Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 5 - Crisis)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter five and our deep dive on Josh
- 0:04Powell and the disappearance of Susan Powell. Let's get into it. What do
- 0:10you say, brule, Let's do it. This is the Psychology in Seattle
- 0:13podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkhanda. I'm a therapist and a professor
- 0:17in Berto is wearing merch from the podcast. My name is Umberto Casa and
- 0:22I usually helped file File find Waldo. So let's do a recap of what
- 0:30we've already established in the previous four chapters. It's just briefly so. Josh
- 0:35Powell childhood born nineteen seventy six, Mormon family, Pacific Northwest Area. Five
- 0:43kids in the family, including Josh. Josh as the second born, first
- 0:47son. The parents fought a lot. He was targeted, particularly by Stephen
- 0:52the father with abuse. The father was violent, but also conversely overly permissive
- 0:59with the kids. Stephen the father also exposed the three sons to a lot
- 1:03of pornography apparently, and his ideology was very anti establishment. It seems like
- 1:07kind of generally right and anti Mormon as well, which the parents fought a
- 1:12lot about. He Josh was possibly rejected by his mother as a theme in
- 1:19the parenting and the relationship. It's hard to say, I don't want to
- 1:23throw the mom under the bus, but there's some minor evidence of that.
- 1:26At the very least. The abuse that Stephen put him through was massive.
- 1:33It can't be overstated just how it would feel to be a child to be
- 1:38routinely yelled at and hit and humiliated, and particularly notice that you're the one
- 1:48being targeted. And you know, when you're a kid, you don't have
- 1:51any resources to conceptualize it, to say like, well, this isn't my
- 1:56fault. You know, kids internalize this, So it was really hard on
- 2:00him. And I'm guessing that he wasn't given resources to learn how to deal
- 2:06with emotions in general. Anyway, he goes into school and adolescents, he's
- 2:13reportedly quiet and didn't get along with his peers, struggled in school, even
- 2:17though he would later test with a high IQ, And he struggled emotionally,
- 2:22particularly with the parents' divorce that happened when he was in high school. And
- 2:27we know a lot of detail about Josh and Steven and Susan later because they
- 2:32all kept detailed diaries and journals both written and recorded. So going into Josh's
- 2:40adulthood, he wanted to make friends. In college, he had a hard
- 2:46time making friends. He was also very concerned about finding a girlfriend. He
- 2:52would pursue women, often women who didn't really like him, which on one
- 2:58hand is like, well, you know, you got to bark up a
- 3:00lot of trees before someone replies. But he seemed to almost relish in pursuing
- 3:08people that were showing no sign of being into him. So that's interesting because
- 3:14you mentioned potential rejection feelings related to his mom or and definitely a very distorted
- 3:22relationship with his dad, so there could be a comfort to rejection, you
- 3:25know. Yeah, And we would see this pattern with Stephen, how he
- 3:30would obsess and target women and believe that these women were into him when they
- 3:37weren't. And you wonder if Josh had seen it and it was modeled to
- 3:43Josh subtly or not so subtly. It's just hard to tell. We could
- 3:46extrapolate from everything we know about Stephen stalking people and filming people and obsessing on
- 3:53women from Afar, we could extrapolate to josh childhood and assume that Steve when
- 4:00was probably doing things along those lines when Josh was a child, and given
- 4:05that Stephen has seemingly no boundaries regarding what he exposes his children to, it's
- 4:12not a stretch to imagine that Josh would have been exposed to at least some,
- 4:15if not a lot, of Steven's stalking and obsessing and filming and harm
- 4:23that he would commit on women and girls. So for Josh at this point
- 4:30in his life as a young man, he's in college, he has his
- 4:34life before him, he's gotten out of the house, he has hope for
- 4:39the future. He's doing well in school for the most part, and he
- 4:44has an ability to meet women and to start dating them, and he's getting
- 4:48some gratification for that. He has some friends, and he meets his first
- 4:54girlfriend. He has a first girlfriend, Catherine, and he was very worried
- 4:59about losing her. This would lead to controlling behavior and abusive behavior. He
- 5:04wasn't seemingly violent with Catherine, but he was very controlling. We reviewed that
- 5:11already and he broke that door. Didn't like there was a Yeah, she
- 5:16was large violence on her body, but yeah, you could argue that's absolutely
- 5:19violent. She barred herself in the bathroom to get away from the badgering,
- 5:25and he busted the door down. That's violent, but I didn't hear reports
- 5:30of him hitting her or Susan later, But that doesn't change how abusive someone
- 5:35can be. You don't have to hit someone to be abusive. She Catherine
- 5:41would leave him after sixteen months. She basically just ghosted him, just disappeared
- 5:45one day. And I think this is notable. I didn't really highlight it
- 5:49during the previous chapter, but I think this could have traumatized him. I
- 5:54mean, oh, sure, let's establish that he was a horrible boyfriend and
- 6:00she deserved to leave and he deserved to be abandoned. Okay, So that's
- 6:04just established, and it's probably for the best because if she had told him
- 6:11that she was going to leave, bad things could have happened totally. So
- 6:15that's established, and Josh, given his point of view in his situation,
- 6:21it's not hard to imagine that Josh would have been traumatized by that bandon bit.
- 6:26Yeah, right, And I think it's important to highlight this because I
- 6:30think it played a role in his crimes later in his state of mind.
- 6:34Later, if a friend of yours said that after sixteen months of living with
- 6:42someone and maybe you're even your friend has said to you like, I'm even
- 6:46thinking about asking you going to marry me, and then he tells you one
- 6:49day she just disappeared and we weren't fighting, there was no problem. Now,
- 6:55there was a lot of problems, but Josh, the way he saw
- 6:59the world give them, given the modeling that he saw from his dad,
- 7:02he probably didn't think anything was unusual about his relationship. And if your friend
- 7:08said, like, my girlfriend she just disappeared and then she called me on
- 7:15the phone from Utah and told me she wants to break up and she didn't
- 7:18even want to talk about it. I mean, how would you feel about
- 7:23that? Oh man? Yeah, devastating. You'd feel like you need to
- 7:27work with that friend with kid gloves because they're going to be very hurt.
- 7:31I remember, you know the movie Swingers where the main character it starts with
- 7:36him having lost this relationship and it wasn't even that, like right, he
- 7:41wasn't ghosted, but he was devastated and he was depressed. And that's what
- 7:45happens normally. Let alone the uncertainty of like why what? And you know,
- 7:50again, to your point, we from the outside looking in know,
- 7:54well, hold on, dude, what do you mean, of course,
- 7:57but from the inside looking out, and what we're trying to determine is would
- 8:00it have a psychological impact? And yeah, it would on anyone, I
- 8:03think, right, we wouldn't be surprised if anyone Josh or this fictional friend
- 8:09of yours having some major trust issues moving forward and some sensitivities to abandon it,
- 8:18some hurt, some anger, some worries. You can imagine in a
- 8:24future relationship, the relationship has been going on maybe a couple of weeks,
- 8:28the person doesn't call them back right away, or they're just gone for one
- 8:31day, they're not sure where they're and they start freaking out right where normally
- 8:35you wouldn't. But yeah, So then a few years later, he meets
- 8:41his second girlfriend, Susan, the woman that he would marry a few months
- 8:46later in two thousand and one. We went over some of the wedding videos
- 8:52and this kind of stuff. So then we watched a lot of the footage
- 8:56of Josh's father, Stephen, who would talk into his video journal about being
- 9:03absolutely obsessed with Susan. So you have Josh marrying Susan, and then they
- 9:09eventually move in with Stephen to save on rent. I think they're a young
- 9:15couple. And Stephen, the father in law, is just obsessed with Susan,
- 9:22and he would secretly film her. He would secretly take pictures of her.
- 9:26He would take her underwear and masturbate to it. He would take her
- 9:30hair and master. You know, we watched videos of him talking into the
- 9:33camera. We watched videos of him looking at her underwear and displaying and stuff.
- 9:39He would take her clothes and dress up what looked to be maybe a
- 9:43couch cushion or one of those big fluffy pillows, and he would film that.
- 9:48And you know, because he would put an undershirt and then address on
- 9:52and he would just be like, oh, Susan, I just love And
- 9:54in the videos he would frequently mention that she must know because she's secretly sending
- 10:03me signals that she wants me to write. That's right. And you know,
- 10:09I was gonna say, in Colombia, it's actually really common, at
- 10:13least it used to be. I'm pretty sure it still is to live with
- 10:16parents even well into your you know, thirties sometimes, But it's also quite
- 10:22common that the moving out point is when you get married. Now, that's
- 10:26not true in all cultures. Some cultures, it's actually completely standard for the
- 10:28married couples to live together and all these things. So you know, that
- 10:33can vary, but I will say it's sort of less usual in the US
- 10:39as I've seen it. But if all that's being said, all that being
- 10:45said, if you have this very distorted relationship with your parent, it's probably
- 10:50not a great idea to move in with your newly weed into their house right
- 10:54just as a general rule. And this is you know, one of those
- 10:58bad examples. Yeah, Unfortunately, in my experience, what I will find
- 11:03is that the more abuse, the more problematic one's relationship is with one's parents,
- 11:11the more likelihood that adult child is going to engage in problematic engagement.
- 11:20They will choose to engage because of various diferent psychological reasons that I won't give
- 11:26into right now. And we can imagine that Josh might have been motivated by
- 11:30that subconsciously. Also, we haven't gotten into it yet, we will later.
- 11:33That Josh is very you know, some people might say cheap or frugal,
- 11:39and if he could get free rent, and Stephen was more than willing
- 11:46to provide because he wasn't free, because he had free, free access to
- 11:50the woman of his dreams apparently. So we also talked about the effects of
- 11:56early exposure to porn, because Stephen exposed the boys to porn, and we
- 12:01talked about some of the nuances of that in a previous chapter. We also
- 12:05talked about four yearistic disorder and also some aspects of narcissistic personality disorder. Burtle,
- 12:11Let's take a break. What do you say? Let's do it all
- 12:16right, We're back from the break. So that brings us to the next
- 12:20part of the story, which is that Josh and Susan move out of Steven's
- 12:26house, presumably to get away from Stephen and also because there was a job
- 12:33opportunity for both of them. They moved to Yakima, which is central Washington.
- 12:37It's about a two or three hour drive from where they were living in
- 12:43Puallup near puallp and Josh and Susan were both going to work at a senior
- 12:48center. But during this time, since it's only two or three hours away,
- 12:52Stephen visited often because he's still obsessed with Susan. Then, after six
- 12:58months of living apart, I think because Steven was missing Susan and because he
- 13:07might worry that he might because I think in Steven's mind, he's thinking Susan
- 13:15and I were getting somewhere, right, and he's competing against Josh. Yeah,
- 13:20and now Susan's three hours away. I only see her every other weekend
- 13:24or something, and Susan and Josh might be bonding because right, because Josh
- 13:31and Susan were a very new couple when they moved into steven Spice, maybe
- 13:37just less than a year. And so Steven he's losing the love of his
- 13:43life. He's written songs. We listened to some of those songs. So
- 13:46after six months, he visits and then figures out a way to get Susan
- 13:52alone in the car and Steven is driving and they are about to embark on
- 13:58a really long drive. Who knows how Stephen manages this or if it was
- 14:03random, but he is filming with his video camera and then he thinks that
- 14:09he turns off the video camera, but he doesn't. He puts the video
- 14:13camera in his pocket, and then he proceeds to accidentally record an entire conversation
- 14:20he has with Susan in which he confesses his love for Susan. Let's listen
- 14:28to that audio. What do you say, Berta? Let's do it,
- 14:37so the audio is hard to hear. He's saying, I'm probably wrong,
- 14:43but I've really fallen in love with you. So this first sentence is consistent
- 14:48with the journals he would sometimes throw in a caveat of I know this might
- 14:56be weird, Like in one of his video journals, he says, I
- 15:00don't know how people are going to see this in the future, and I
- 15:03imagine people are going to say that there's something wrong with me. But me
- 15:07and Susan have a connection. He also says, and I won't show this
- 15:11clip because it's buried somewhere, but he talks about how, you know,
- 15:16future generations when they watch this video or you know, read this journal.
- 15:22He says, you know, maybe they'll be our kids, me and Susan's
- 15:26kids. He says, well, and it's interesting because the way he phrases
- 15:31is I'm probably wrong, but I've really fallen in love with you. Yeah.
- 15:35Now, if you read it literally, it's like I may or may
- 15:37not have fallen in love with you. But I think what he means is
- 15:41it's probably wrong of me. Yeah. And this is evidence of narcissism in
- 15:48that, in fact, it's one of the central tenets really that for people
- 15:54with actual narcissism, they are completely or at least mostly shut off from input
- 16:02from the outside and they had to do that as a defense to what they
- 16:04were going through growing up. And when they have a feeling, there's no
- 16:10checks and balances. It is just all consuming to them, and there's no
- 16:17editor in their mind, you know. Like if Stephen wasn't narcissistic in the
- 16:22beginning of all this falling in love with her, let's say that he just
- 16:27had an attraction to her. Well, if he wasn't narcissistic, he would
- 16:33one worry about harming Josh and Susan, right, so he would raise alarm
- 16:40bells to do something about that attraction, meaning shut it down or you know,
- 16:45figure out what's going on, and there would be an editor in his
- 16:48mind of not every feeling you have is the bee's knees. You don't have
- 16:55to share everything, well, you don't have to entertain every notion and every
- 17:02feeling. But when the narcissistic and oh you mean not just about talking to
- 17:06her, you mean even just in his own head. And that's where it
- 17:07starts, because he didn't just fall in love with her overnight. It was
- 17:14something that built at least over even if it was a short amount of time,
- 17:18there was time to stop, you know. But he's not completely delusional
- 17:22or psychopathic, because he is, and he dips into this idea throughout this
- 17:29conversation, this notion of he's aware that other people might consider this to be
- 17:34a problem. So he says, I'm probably wrong, but I've really fall
- 17:37in love with you. Then he says, for the last year and a
- 17:40half, you're about the only thing I can think about. Let's watch more
- 17:53So, if you didn't catch this, he says, I don't know where
- 17:57it began, meaning the falling alone. It probably probably began when you were
- 18:03living with me and you'd come into my office and let me feel your legs.
- 18:07It just went from one thing. Then it just went from one thing
- 18:11to another. So this is an interesting statement. He is basically blaming her
- 18:18that she came on to him, and that's consistent in his journal that it
- 18:22probably began when you did this to me. Yeah, and it's hard to
- 18:27know what actually happened there. And we talked a bit about that in the
- 18:33last chapter. Was she open with her body? Which is fine, right,
- 18:40But it doesn't really matter because even if she was giving signals or something.
- 18:45He went, you know, a billion miles beyond what would have been
- 18:51justified. Absolutely, And his words say a lot like and you let me
- 18:55feel your legs to me is pretty straightforward. She walks in, He's like,
- 19:00oh, your legs look great. What can I feel? And she
- 19:02awkwardly goes, I guess sure. Right at that point she let him feel.
- 19:07Yeah, you yeah, that's much more likely what happened given everything else
- 19:12we saw. So let's go on. You know that experience on the couch,
- 19:18on your couch six months ago, it was just I mean I know
- 19:23that, I know it was a massage, right, but you know,
- 19:29just being with two or two hours. So he talks about this massage a
- 19:33lot in his journal. I think he videotapes himself shortly after this experience.
- 19:41And at this point he's saying it was six months ago in Yakama, so
- 19:45it sounds like that would have been soon after they moved to Yakama. And
- 19:48he's like, you know that experience, So he's he's making a case that
- 19:52there's justification for being obsessed with his daughter in LAWE. He says, you
- 19:59remember that cow on the moment on the couch six onths ago. It was
- 20:03a massage, but just being with you for two hours and holding you,
- 20:07That's what it's interesting. Actually, now that I think about it his narrative,
- 20:12if you just heard this, it sounds like, wow, that sounds
- 20:15really intimate, like two hours cuddling with your father in law. But in
- 20:22his video journal that night, he doesn't describe it that way. The way
- 20:26he describes it is he offered to give her a massage and he was massaging
- 20:33her neck. Did you come from a family or a group when you were
- 20:37a kid where massages would happen? Not in Colombia, there was tickling,
- 20:45Yeah, I did. I came from a family where we would massage each
- 20:49other all the time. There was it was essentially, you know, a
- 20:55way for us to have physical affection. Yeah. I feel like massages were
- 20:59unheard of in Colombia when I was a kid, meaning just even as a
- 21:03concept. I'm sure it wasn't well, but for me, I don't think
- 21:07until I moved up here and then and like I didn't have really just massages.
- 21:11Yeah, you wouldn't ever see anybody And like the first time I ever
- 21:15had a massage, I was like twenty five. Wow, after a race.
- 21:22Wow, no, wonder you have an issue with touch. I remember
- 21:27in the second grade when and I remember this so well because in the third
- 21:33grade I remember talking with my friends about how we missed second grade. The
- 21:37way that we were in second grade. It was as if we hadn't downloaded
- 21:45the cultural victorian notions about touch, and so we were just free to be
- 21:51who we were. And my memory is that in school, whenever we were
- 21:59watching a film strip or a movie or something, or it was story time,
- 22:03we would give each other massages. And it sounds weird right when I
- 22:08say it out loud, and you think, well, was anyone uncomfortable with
- 22:11that? Yeah? I don't know. It's just a thing, But I
- 22:15remember thinking it was just it was just a thing. And you know,
- 22:18this is before hormones and all that kind of stuff, and none of us
- 22:22were thinking about boyfriend, girlfriend or anything like that. I see. I
- 22:26mean, like, okay, so I will say, like in high school
- 22:30a few times there were like shoulder rubs, but definitely as a flirtatious thing.
- 22:37Yeah yeah, yeah, okay. So in my family, maybe it's
- 22:42a Japanese thing. It seemed like it might have come from that side,
- 22:45and we would have a lot of massage time, and I knew how each
- 22:53person in my family would massage my shoulders. My dad was intense. I
- 23:00mean it was like, I don't even it felt good, but it hurt
- 23:04at the same time. And massages are are they culturally big in Japan.
- 23:08There's a lot of themes. There's like Shiatsu massage, and my dad was
- 23:12really into that. I don't I don't know. I just know that there
- 23:15was a lot of that growing up, and I think it's great. Yeah,
- 23:19I had a lot of that. Yeah, and as a kid,
- 23:25so I remember in the third grade just thinking like what happened to all of
- 23:29us? We're all so uptight now, you know, And it never went
- 23:33back to that way and with this family, Yeah, I'm imagining that.
- 23:41For Susan, that's what she was thinking. It's just like, oh,
- 23:44you know, we're we're just it's it's a way to relieve tension in your
- 23:48shoulders and it's a way to bond with people, and it, you know,
- 23:52it feels good. I feel like in today's anti touch world, most
- 23:56people would think like, why would you let your father in law give you
- 24:00a massage? You know what I mean? So it's hard to say,
- 24:03but it seems like, at least according to Stephen, the massage lasted for
- 24:07a while, and the waste Steven described it right afterwards, is that I,
- 24:11you know, crossed the line by massaging your shoulders, like I put
- 24:15my hands into her shirt and she let me, you know, because he's
- 24:21looking for signs, and this shows again that he's not delusional and he's not
- 24:25psychopathic, or he's really wanting her well, he's the way that, again
- 24:32to use an analogy of like healthy life, when you have a crush on
- 24:37someone, you know, say you're seventeen in high school and yah, and
- 24:41you have a crush on someone and she's giving you attention and you're thinking does
- 24:45she like me? Does she not right? And then one day she puts
- 24:48her hand on your forearm when she's talking to you, and you're like,
- 24:52oh my god, does she like me? That's the Waistephen is talking.
- 24:56And it's also notable that the waste even very childish, which I think points
- 25:02to his traumas. But let's let's go on. Yeah, maybe maybe I'm
- 25:07getting the wrong with signals from you. Maybe maybe I'm interpreting something that I
- 25:12shouldn't be interpreted. Quick question, is this all real time? Because we're
- 25:17not hearing any words from her? Yeah? She I don't know if we'll
- 25:22listen to this whole audio, but she barely says anything. But she's sitting
- 25:26there in the car. So burto what's the most likely state of mind Susan
- 25:32had prior to this conversation beginning. So I I imagine that actually there was
- 25:37already a bit of uneasiness throughout the experiences with her father in law, and
- 25:44even just him approaching her to talk about anything would probably this is my guest
- 25:48maker somewhat uneasy, but in her and I'm imagining she's like, oh,
- 25:53what do we you know, I'm wondering what the topic is here? I
- 25:59do not imagine. And she was anticipating this conversation, Yeah, no,
- 26:03I don't think so, either given it O or she was dreading it.
- 26:07Yeah. So I hadn't thought about this before. But you know, I'll
- 26:15tell you that I have been obsessing on this case. In between recording chapters,
- 26:18you and I I have been doing more deep dives. I don't know,
- 26:26it's it's a very interesting case. And if anyone else wants to go
- 26:30down that rabbit hole, you know, get ready for a lot of data.
- 26:34But I have a lot of data in my head about Susan because of
- 26:40her emails and her written journal and her audio journal, and her friends,
- 26:45the way they would talk about Susan. She was on the naive side,
- 26:52and not in a horrible way, or you could say innocent or thought that
- 26:56other people were good. She didn't seem to be suspicious of anything her and
- 27:02she's very young at this point, she might be twenty. I think her
- 27:07state of mind is that she is noticing that Stephen is being flirty, but
- 27:15Susan is suppressing it. I think she was very good at suppressing. I
- 27:19think she was very good at sweeping things under the rug. And I would
- 27:22imagine as a woman, as a gal, she you know, she gets
- 27:29attention, unwanted attention pretty regularly. It just happens to be that this is
- 27:33there's this additional category of oh and this is my father in law. Yeah,
- 27:37but there is possibly just learned behavior of like oh, okay, yeah,
- 27:41I'm cute, thank you. There's another possibility that she did know that
- 27:48Stephen was clandestinely filming her and taking pictures, which isn't hard to imagine given
- 27:55the technology that Stephen was using to spy on her, and how brazen he
- 28:00was with it. I mean just sticking a giant video camera under the gap
- 28:04on a door and filming her while she's on the front. So you know,
- 28:07it's hard to know what would be going on in her mind, but
- 28:11it also could be in her mind of wow, that's horrible. I don't
- 28:17know what to do with that. I don't really trust Josh because maybe she
- 28:21would have tested the waters with Josh and Josh shut it down. You know,
- 28:23we could imagine that Josh wasn't a very good listener. Well, you
- 28:26could also imagine she might have even said, Josh, I think your father's
- 28:32like filming me, and that Josh would have been like, Oh, that's
- 28:34just dad, he's a little weird, right or whatever. Right? And
- 28:38who do you go to with that information. You can't go to your friends,
- 28:41You can't go to your family because they would either say you're making that
- 28:45up. That's crazy town, or they would say you gotta get out of
- 28:51that family or whatever. You know, and who knows what sort of way
- 28:55she was being raised blah blah blah. Anyway, so there's a lot of
- 29:00possibilities there, but I think before this conversation with Stephen, I would imagine
- 29:06that she knew something was going on, and she was just trying to avoid
- 29:12the whole topic. And having moved to Yakamash, she probably thought, Okay,
- 29:18that's in the past. I'll just never live with Stephen again. But
- 29:21here it is again at our doorsteps. So as this conversation is beginning,
- 29:25Berto he is telling her, I am in love with you because you let
- 29:32me touch your legs and because of this this long massauce. What do you
- 29:37think is going through Susan's mind right now? I'm imagining there is silent panic,
- 29:42like deer in headlights, frozen, like uh, you know a little
- 29:48bit of this what do you call it? Disembodiment or dissociation? Like what
- 29:52is happening right now? Yeah? Because what you know, I've been in
- 29:55situations like that before, where something completely not okay and out of context this
- 30:00happened. I don't mean even when I was little. I just mean as
- 30:02an adult and where you just you're you're really kind of confused. You're like,
- 30:07well, what am I supposed to do right now? Yeah? What?
- 30:11Well? What might she be thinking as a response to this, what
- 30:15what would you be thinking if you were in her shoes, I I don't
- 30:18did you mention what the situation like? I'm wondering if she was like in
- 30:22her car kind of trapped, or if she's in the passenger seat and he's
- 30:26driving and he's just they're totally trapped. Yeah, and they're they're like an
- 30:30hour. Oh my gosh, it's a long drive. Talk about feeling trapped.
- 30:37She would be thinking. I mean I doubt I doubt that she was
- 30:41jumping to like, oh he might kill me or something. Right, but
- 30:44maybe but at the very least I'd be thinking that, because if someone is
- 30:48it could be willing to go that far. At the very least, if
- 30:52I were in that situation, I might be thinking, Oh, I need
- 30:55to get out of this car somehow. Yeah, I wonder if we're going
- 30:57to stop at a gas station, maybe I could just It's not strange for
- 31:02a woman to have had a previous experience where they shot down a man,
- 31:07whether it was a man at the bar or a boyfriend. A lot of
- 31:12women have been through scary situations where actual threats or hintset threats happened, So
- 31:18it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine that she was terrified. We don't know.
- 31:22It looks even trivially, this is nothing compared to what she's in.
- 31:25But even recently, I was in a conversation with someone, two adults outside,
- 31:30just nothing where I'm feeling trapped or anything, and it has nothing to
- 31:34do with me, really, but we're having a conversation and the person starts
- 31:38talking about how they're excited to get this one car that they want to get
- 31:42because that way they can outrun the cops because it's got more horsepower than the
- 31:47cop cars. And I'm sitting there wondering what the heck guy would say to
- 31:53this person. Should I say, well, that's illegal? What are you
- 31:59daring? Like? What do I do? And and again I'm not comparing
- 32:02at all the situation I'm saying, even in something as trivial as two adult
- 32:07males out in the open talking about something that doesn't even concern me, but
- 32:10it's such a kind of an awkward situation. I can't even begin to imagine
- 32:15trapped in a car with your relative confessing there they're unwanted and unnatural love to
- 32:22you and and insinuating that you were, that you're the one that you were
- 32:29giving signals right, and then in that moment, also confirming everything you probably
- 32:31actually were suppressing in your brain. You're like no, and then now you're
- 32:36like, oh, yes, yikes, yeah, so what's going you know.
- 32:43And then just for example, when we were sitting on the couch and
- 32:46just felt like you were weary, you know, I mean I was extremely
- 32:52aroused, and I think you were similar. Rads. Uh. So he's
- 32:59talking about but I think the massage, and he's saying, you know,
- 33:01we were sitting on the couch and it felt just like you were. And
- 33:07I think he was going to say you were very aroused, and then he
- 33:12pauses and says, I was extremely aroused, and I think that you were
- 33:16somewhat aroused, at least I thought. So it's so interesting to hear him
- 33:23have those qualifiers, right. He wanted to say you were aroused. I
- 33:30know you were aroused, but then he you know, he softens it a
- 33:34lot. You know, I was extremely aroused, and I think you were
- 33:37somewhat aroused at least I thought you were, right, And he that's reflective
- 33:42of his journal. He's not just being nice because he's in front of her.
- 33:45This is the way he talked when he was just by himself, right,
- 33:49which is an interesting nuance to all this. Yeah, and by the
- 33:52way, because you could imagine a situation like this but way less severe where
- 33:59and in a appropriate let's keep it the same. Father in law ends up
- 34:02developing feelings for the daughter in law, but they're not this extreme narcissistic except
- 34:09so they end up inappropriately but they end up going to the person and saying,
- 34:14I gotta let you know, I've been struggling with This is gonna sound
- 34:17terrible. It's like I've kind of developed feelings for you. Like that is
- 34:22one version of that, right, this one you have to like dial all
- 34:27the dials to eleven for because it's not that it's like, well, you
- 34:30know, I'm extremely in love with you and you're all I can think of.
- 34:34And it's when you let me do this, and you did this and
- 34:37you're really aroused to like your skipp and she hasn't said a word yet.
- 34:40Yeah, you are now at It is really delusional. It's it's incredible.
- 34:45Yeah, let's watch some more, Susan, I will tell you what I'm
- 34:57I'm married to your son. And so Susan chimes in pretty quick and says,
- 35:05I don't know where you're going with this? And then Stephen like starts
- 35:09to scramble, and she interrupts and says, I'm married to your son.
- 35:15I should just be your daughter in law. It almost feels to me,
- 35:19honestly, as if she's been through therapy, because this seems like such a
- 35:23strategically grounded way to react, because again, she might be frightened, I
- 35:30would be right, but whatever the case may be. Instead of her saying
- 35:35what are you a monster, she goes, actually, she kind of ignores
- 35:38everything he said, I don't know where you're going with this, which is
- 35:43a great way to both invalidate but also not like attack. And then she
- 35:49states a clear boundary line, I am married to your son, and I
- 35:52should just be the daughter in law. Right. Yeah, when I see
- 35:59prime school teacher or my mom with the daycare kids, and I would just
- 36:05marvel at the masterful way in which they respond to really chaotic communication from another
- 36:14person, because, as you said, and I didn't think this at the
- 36:16time, but I'm thinking it now because you said this that you know,
- 36:22she could have said, what are you talking about? Yeah that was just
- 36:27a massage, or I wasn't aroused, or what are you talking you know,
- 36:32I let you touch my what do you? You know what's going on
- 36:35here? Were you? Have you been in love with me the whole time
- 36:37or whatever? Or let me out of the car or whatever it is.
- 36:40You know, there's a lot of different responses. Instead, it's just like,
- 36:43Okay, let me interrupt you. I don't know where you're going with
- 36:45this. Yeah, but I'm married to your son and i'm your daughter in
- 36:49law, so let's just end this right now. Yeah. And she's saying
- 36:52it in a way like the DMV worker, like, h sir, I
- 36:58don't know where you're going with this, but and I love it. I
- 37:00mean, that's right. It kind of reminds me again, I'm not trying
- 37:04to compare any of these situations, just I always try to find little mini
- 37:07perils when we've discussed before a mutual acquaintance who at one point was being fairly
- 37:14abusive over emails to me, And there was that shift for myself where I
- 37:19used to initially I would always try to respond point by point, and I
- 37:23would draft these like super long emails and a lot of ones I didn't even
- 37:27send, but I would still spend the time like, oh my gosh,
- 37:30well this is wrong for this reason, and I finally got to the point
- 37:32where I'm like, why, I just need to be like it kind of
- 37:37like this. I don't know where you're going with this, but this is
- 37:39my boundary line. And it definitely feels liberating when you can do that,
- 37:45even though it's still so chaotic on the other side. Yeah, and it
- 37:49takes a lot of differentiation and maybe consultation with other people. How do I
- 37:53respond to this? And when you nail a response, you know, you
- 37:59really feel good the next day about a response in person over email or whatever.
- 38:05It's such a satisfying feeling that you responded and you didn't let the other
- 38:12person get away with it, but you also didn't dig yourself into a hole
- 38:16by going too far or giving them more amibnition against you. But it's just
- 38:22I'm in awe because it took me well into my thirties and therapy and guidance
- 38:29from peers and stuff to be able to reach a point like that in something
- 38:32actually less scary. I'm in awe that she just pulled this out of the
- 38:37hat. Yeah. So there's a lot more to this audio. It goes
- 38:43on for a long time, but this is the gist of it. She
- 38:45doesn't say much. He keeps saying these kinds of things, and when she
- 38:50does say something, it's along these signes of like, I don't know where
- 38:53you're going with this, I'm your daughter in law, and she doesn't get
- 38:59into the details of it all. So let's take a break and when we
- 39:04get back, it'll just be for the patrons of the podcast, and we're
- 39:06going to continue with the story. What do you say, Burdo, Let's
- 39:10do it. If you want to hear the full episode, all the chapters,
- 39:15then become a patron of the podcast. Otherwise, take care of yourself
- 39:19because you deserve it.