Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 188 - Plan For Decentralisation | Polycarp Nakamoto
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 188 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36Yes, hello, welcome to the show.
- 0:38Hope you've had a good week.
- 0:40Before we get into this one, I'd like to spend a little time to set the scene
- 0:45because it's an unusual episode and I think it earns a proper run-up.
- 0:50This episode started the way a lot of the best things on this show start.
- 0:55With a quiet word from a friend, I was on the other side of the world
- 0:59and someone I trust pulled me aside and said you should go and meet these people. What they're
- 1:05doing is quite incredible. Now that's a massive green flag for me. I love interesting and unusual
- 1:12things. I've spent the better part of my life chasing them down to the ends of the earth so
- 1:16I didn't ask too many questions. I just went. What I walked into? Well a beautiful rural house on the
- 1:23edge of Austin in Texas the kind of place that has all the ingredients of a good community
- 1:29already baked into it land space people and a real sense of shared purpose at the time I called it a
- 1:37compound and that's about right but it doesn't tell the whole story when I walked in I met a man
- 1:44in a mask well a helmet really he calls himself Polycarp Nakamoto and you won't see his face even
- 1:53in the video version of this episode. Now, as you know, I do all my episodes in person,
- 2:00and I've only ever actually interviewed one other anonymous guest. That was a gentleman by the name
- 2:08of Ben Gunn, and in fact, I interviewed him twice. Those times, I just didn't even bother turning the
- 2:15camera on. Footnote, I would highly recommend checking out those interviews. If this one
- 2:21interests you the first one there's episode 97 and then i split the second interview into two
- 2:28two hour episodes yep four hours with ben gunn that was episodes 136 and 137 very on topic we
- 2:35talk about mesh networks etc with ben and this episode with polycarp nakamoto does touch on some
- 2:42of the same things anyway this time i sat across a table from a man whose expression i literally
- 2:50he could not read. He had a helmet on and let me tell you that is a very strange experience for me.
- 2:55I realised literally sitting there just how much I lean on the small things when I'm interviewing
- 3:01people. A flicker of the eye, a smile, you know, a raised eyebrow just to know where I stand in a
- 3:07conversation. With Polly I had none of this, just a voice and an idea and actually when I asked him
- 3:15why the mask his answer told me most things i needed to know about what was coming he said part
- 3:21of it of course is simple privacy he likes to go out without being harassed to walk into a conference
- 3:27without everyone knowing who he is but the deeper reason he said is that it doesn't matter who he is
- 3:33anyone can do what he's doing the message does not depend on the man as he put it everyone is
- 3:40building the network. So who is he and what is this thing he's building? Polly is at the centre
- 3:47of something called Lab 484 out of Austin. It's kind of a laboratory, a cluster of small startups,
- 3:54all of them working on a different piece of what he believes is coming next. He calls that Web 5.
- 4:02And the idea stripped back is this. The internet we all live on was built for the 1990s. It runs
- 4:08on a handful of enormous centralized choke points, a few companies, a few data centers,
- 4:13and a domain name system that can be switched off. Plus, it has no backup. None at all. If the
- 4:20internet goes down and Polly is convinced that it will, some point in the next five years,
- 4:27that could be a cyber attack, a rogue AI, an infrastructure collapse, or simply
- 4:31the government deciding to flip the switch. And if that happens, modern life as we know it,
- 4:38Just gone. Your money, messages, medications, your work, all of it. His answer is to build a second
- 4:45internet outside of the first, one made of Bitcoin nodes talking directly to each other peer-to-peer
- 4:51over what are called mesh networks, owned by nobody, run by everybody. Impossible to censor
- 4:58and impossible to turn off. A new set of rails for a free society built on the one piece of
- 5:05digital infrastructure that he believes is genuinely decentralized That is of course Bitcoin Now some of the specifics in this are really beautiful and we get into them Bitcoin nodes built into food trucks tiny homes
- 5:20made of shipping containers with private cloud and private sandboxed AIs living inside of them,
- 5:26a little lunchbox you can carry into the woods that throws out an internet for everyone nearby.
- 5:31It's kind of like part workshop, part commune, part vision of the future. And in all honesty,
- 5:37I found it genuinely fascinating to discover and there are lots of parts to it. Now, polyframes the
- 5:43whole thing as a fork in the road and I think this is the part that will stay with you. Down one path,
- 5:51you guessed it, the dystopia, a world of CBDCs, digital identity, social credit scores and a
- 5:58tightly controlled internet that you can only reach by scanning your face. Down the other path,
- 6:03the sovereign version the one that you and i both want you own your own hardware your software your
- 6:09data and your money and no one can switch you off and the thing pushing us towards that fork
- 6:15faster than anyone expected guess what yes it's artificial intelligence we go deep on that
- 6:22and some of it is genuinely unsettling now regular listeners will know roughly where i sit on all this
- 6:28i'm an old bitcoiner i run a node that i built myself i use a graphene phone so do my kids
- 6:34i care a great deal about privacy and about self-sovereignty and i've even tried moving
- 6:41out to a farm to give us a life based a little bit more on our own terms so in a lot of ways
- 6:47polly is preaching to the choir in this episode however here's the thing and i want you to know
- 6:53this going in because this is not an infomercial for the sovereign lifestyle. I've sat with a lot
- 6:59of grand visions over the years on this show. I've lived in communes. I've lived in intentional
- 7:04communities. I've traveled and lived in just about every arrangement you can think of. And
- 7:08what I've learned is that these dreams do tend to break. They break on the human condition
- 7:15every single time. The technology is really the hard part. The hard part is people. Getting enough
- 7:22of them to care, to coordinate, to keep going when it stops being convenient. For example, I live now
- 7:29with land and a polytunnel and some animals and I can tell you from direct experience that
- 7:33being self-sufficient is literally more than a full-time job for two adults. You cannot do it
- 7:40on your own, you need a community and communities are hard. And yet, despite all my scepticism,
- 7:47and you'll hear it in this episode. I know deep down that this is the only future I want.
- 7:54Polly's message in the end is not really about technology at all. It's about removing
- 7:58the centralization from your own heart first. He calls it planning for decentralization and
- 8:06I've called the episode it as you can see. Many thanks to Polly and Shadrach for giving me this
- 8:13peak under the surface of the austin what do i call it the solar punk scene maybe i don't know
- 8:18if they're solar punks that's what makes me think of either way it's amazing after the interview i
- 8:24got a full tour of the hubs around austin the different places and basically these guys are
- 8:31living my dream at least my dream if i were in another lifetime i'm a rural boy now i dip my
- 8:37toes into the city every now and then but I've made my bed in the country and that's where I'll
- 8:42sleep and yes this was the conversation that inspired me to get my own self-hosted AI which
- 8:49I now have the one I can instruct and educate myself privately right jump in the show notes
- 8:57afterwards for all the details of lab 484 and archipelago the OS that we're talking about a lot
- 9:04in this convo and what a brilliant episode this is that's all I'm going to say now but there is
- 9:10one thing Polly said that stuck with me he said you can't do this alone you can be the most
- 9:15sovereign person on earth run your own node hold your own keys grow your own food but on your own
- 9:21you're just a single point of failure what you actually need is a network other people who share
- 9:27your direction in a real place doing the real work alongside you and as I said to him more than
- 9:34once that far more than any clever piece of technology is the hardest part and that is also
- 9:40exactly why I'm glad this episode is brought to you by Veritas Villages. What a segue because while
- 9:48a lot of people are still talking about sovereign living in theory Veritas Villages is one of the
- 9:53you actually building it on the ground. They build off-grid energy, food and water, self-sufficient
- 10:00communities for freedom-minded people. Across Latin America, they've got villages in Panama,
- 10:05Nicaragua, Costa Rica, like-minded neighbors, a lower cost of living and a genuine plan B
- 10:12for when the world feels uncertain. And yes, you can buy your home with Bitcoin. You can also pay
- 10:19with Bitcoin at Veritas Villages and they even help you set up your self house to mine Bitcoin Apparently according to them at least you can live 100 free Obviously you have to buy your
- 10:33property etc but once you run a Bitcoin miner and all your energy is coming from your own setup
- 10:39you can live for free if you want. Anyway, take a look at veritasvillages.com forward slash free
- 10:46cities for more info tell them that we sent you that's www.veritasvillages.com forward slash
- 10:54free cities right top supporters this week on the value for value platforms
- 10:59i've been rabbiting on a bit here i'm going to go through fast well done top g this week darcy
- 11:06second in command justin bianchi then kohai then anon anon and finally ekram thank you all
- 11:15thank you to everyone who streams this the money goes to a good cause we're spending it on new
- 11:21equipment my ai system here guess what that was bought with money that you guys have been sending
- 11:29in with bitcoin that's incredible i have a self-hosted ai now because some anons on the
- 11:36internet stream me bitcoin for a podcast that's amazing anyway thank you to you all keep it coming
- 11:43it's all going to a good cause and don't forget as well if you're into all this stuff
- 11:47intentional communities special economic zones charter cities free cities you name it you better
- 11:57not forget about the free cities conference which is happening in prospera in honduras this september
- 12:02we've got an amazing lineup forming all the usual projects are giving you their yearly updates
- 12:07plus we've got people like stefan kinsella we've got lou perez the comedian we've got per byland
- 12:13or the economist jeremy kaufman regularly causing viral videos up there in the free state project
- 12:21patrie freeman even i'm speaking this year because it's going to be that good yeah i'm
- 12:25going to actually sum up what's been going on in the scene through the eyes of my 52 guests
- 12:31that I would have had in the last year.
- 12:35FreeCitiesConference.com
- 12:36obviously for tickets, come early and leave late.
- 12:39There's events happening either side.
- 12:41The main days are September the 3rd till the 6th
- 12:44but there's stuff happening either side.
- 12:46Just go to FreeCitiesConference.com for all the info.
- 12:49Right, that's it.
- 12:51Pour yourself a coffee.
- 12:53Ideally a butter coffee with a little dash of cinnamon.
- 12:56You'll understand why when you listen to this episode.
- 12:59whether you come out the other side a believer or a skeptic i'm still somewhere in between myself i
- 13:05think you'll find this one of the more thought-provoking conversations that we've had on
- 13:10the show so just sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with polycarp nakamoto
- 13:18actually well i quite like to start talking about anonymity actually
- 13:30i've only ever had one other person on this pod who didn't want to be
- 13:34um who didn't want to be known um and i did i asked them the same question it's kind of like
- 13:41because in this day and age i think anonymity i would say it's probably impossible
- 13:47you know someone somewhere can work out who you are so what's the idea behind not being
- 13:53visible and not not people not putting a face to a voice yeah part of it is anonymity that's that's
- 14:01a big part i like going to restaurants and not being harassed i like going to conferences and
- 14:07not having everybody know who I am. So in that sense, the mask helps with that. But ultimately,
- 14:18the real reason that I wear the mask is because it doesn't matter who I am. Anybody can be doing
- 14:25what we're doing thanks to Bitcoin and the Bitcoin node network. I mean, anyone can run a node.
- 14:32The U.S. government is running a node.
- 14:35And so while the mask helps with my privacy,
- 14:39ultimately if someone wants to know who I am,
- 14:42they can figure that out pretty easily.
- 14:44But the message that the idea of free speech
- 14:48in a worldwide mesh network,
- 14:50that is something that does not depend
- 14:54upon any single person's identity.
- 14:56Everyone is building the mesh network.
- 15:00Fair enough.
- 15:00better set the scene for people that I mean like like I I've come in here not really understanding
- 15:08I'm I'm literally making this up as I go along so bear with me I'm not going to give too much away
- 15:13but am I allowed to say which which uh which town we're in oh absolutely yeah yeah we're in Austin
- 15:19and um we have a mutual friend who's who's who works with you and he said look you should talk
- 15:26to these guys what they doing is quite incredible And that a green flag for me I love interesting unusual things And now I met you at this incredible location It like a it a beautiful rural house with which is basically set up for
- 15:45a community. I think that's the best way to put it. It's, it's got all the ingredients for a good
- 15:49community. And I understand you've got a network of these places. Tell me what, tell me what's
- 15:54going on here please sure yeah so we want to build a worldwide mesh network with no single point of
- 16:03failure and i realized very early on that the only way to do that was with a community it can't just
- 16:12be one man it can't be one woman it can't be just a small group of people in order to change the
- 16:19world, we would need many hands coming together as one. And so what we've done here is we've created
- 16:27a governance board that is decentralized. There's no ownership, there's only a responsibility.
- 16:37And then we have a private membership association that is a research laboratory for the technology
- 16:45that's building the next web and we have 12 startups in the lab as we call it lab 484 and
- 16:54these startups are all individually building different parts of the new internet that we're
- 17:01working on and as those startups grow up and get bigger and get more mature and profitable they move
- 17:09out into their own spaces and so that's what this is this is the archipelago headquarters
- 17:15where that we're developing the archipelago software marketing it and building a community
- 17:21around the mesh network and can you can you you better describe um better give me a proper
- 17:28definition of mesh network then yeah because um i think i know but but tell me what you think it is
- 17:33Yeah, absolutely. So a mesh network is an internet that has many different points of connection.
- 17:44If you think of your cell phone, your cell phone is the best example of a mesh network.
- 17:49You walk around downtown Austin and you don't think about it, but your phone is always connected.
- 17:56The problem is, is that that mesh network is proprietary and you can be censored.
- 18:02If you don't pay your bill, you're no longer attached to the mesh network.
- 18:08I see. All right. So what's the manifestation of it in terms of what I'd understand then?
- 18:17I mean, are you talking about decentralized protocols?
- 18:20Yeah. And so most people aren't aware of the differences between open source software and proprietary software.
- 18:27and really all you need to know is that when you are using open source software you are in full
- 18:34control and nobody can shut you out because you're sovereign when you are interacting with
- 18:41proprietary software it requires a contract and a user agreement and that makes a contractual
- 18:49agreement between you and the third party that you're assigning the user agreement with
- 18:54and that makes a lot of liability for you and your data and so the only the only way to build
- 19:04an internet with no single point of failure is to have it be open source where you own the hardware
- 19:11the software and the data with no third parties or contracts between you and and another company
- 19:19do you know what's interesting total side note or here but talking to you now i've realized how
- 19:26much emphasis i put on on visual on expressions when i'm speaking i don't know what you're thinking
- 19:31i don't know it's a very interesting experience interviewing you actually because um i've never
- 19:37i've never i've never done it before the last guy i interviewed who was anonymous i just didn't show
- 19:42the video if you see what i mean i didn't record him but gosh i i use visual facial cues so much
- 19:49I've just realized um but I'll adapt don't worry I'm just always smiling so okay um right lab 484
- 19:58then and can I can I ask a quick question of course it's so you you it's all basically tech startups
- 20:05is it software hardware or what is it yeah all of the above in order to fix the internet you can't
- 20:12just fix it with a new website or a new app or something of that nature it needs to be a
- 20:18fundamental refactoring of the internet as we know it and in order to do that it's going to
- 20:24take a lot of moving parts and a lot of different technologies coming online at the exact same time
- 20:30and there i take it they're all decentralized they're all uh you know nostra yeah nodes
- 20:36Hardware and this kind of stuff.
- 20:39Oh yeah, yeah.
- 20:40There is a wave of web five technology coming,
- 20:45of sovereign technology.
- 20:46Hold on a minute, web five, there's a new term.
- 20:48What's web five?
- 20:50I thought we were Web 2.
- 20:52Just a quick recap.
- 20:53In the first web, Web 1, it was banks and data centers and universities compiling data
- 21:00and using that to synthesize information.
- 21:05In Web 2, we were given an identity on the internet.
- 21:10Before, you could only read information, but now in Web 2, you could actually write information.
- 21:15this would be Google, Uber, Facebook, anything we've used that requires a login or a sign up
- 21:23right the problem is is we don't own our email address or our phone number that we use
- 21:28to access these platforms and then they get all of our data in web 3 we now have the ability to
- 21:36actually own something on the web before there was no ownership on the web in web 2 in web 3 we have
- 21:43private keys and only you have those private keys no one else has that and so now we can actually
- 21:50build reputation in a sovereign way where we're not being tracked but we actually own our digital
- 21:55footprint web 4 is mesh networks and iot there's a mesh network that amazon is building
- 22:04and it's called amazon sidewalk and it's a proprietary mesh network and if the internet
- 22:10were to go down you could still access Amazon services but again it's
- 22:15permissioned can you sorry in there can you explain that what it what is an
- 22:20Amazon sidewalk I've never heard that so yeah so all of the ring cameras all talk
- 22:25to each other and it creates a mesh network that sidesteps the internet and
- 22:29there's extra devices that they're going to be selling to people and giving to
- 22:33people to put on their windows and on the outside of their house and it creates
- 22:37its own network for Amazon.
- 22:40But how is it transmitted?
- 22:42How does the network, if it doesn't use internet rails, what's it using?
- 22:45Radio, peer-to-peer, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.
- 22:49Yep, there's one house, you know, every couple of feet.
- 22:52And all of those ring doorbells can communicate directly with each other.
- 22:57Which is essentially the same as, say, BitChat, right?
- 23:01That's right, exactly.
- 23:02Okay, same theory.
- 23:04So BitChat is the open source version.
- 23:05Amazon sidewalk is the proprietary version in one you have the freedom to go anywhere and communicate with anyone and the other you can only do what Amazon will let you do.
- 23:15I better mention what bitch that is because I think it's awesome bitch that is essentially a peer-to-peer messaging service which uses whatever route it can.
- 23:27So if I want to send you a message instead of beaming up onto the Internet and then coming back down to you.
- 23:32We are directly connected through Wi-Fi, through Bluetooth, through whatever.
- 23:37And I can speak to someone in Australia, essentially, by hopping between people.
- 23:43It may take a trip up to a satellite at some point, but it tries not to.
- 23:47Is that roughly speaking what it is?
- 23:48Yeah, exactly.
- 23:49It's peer-to-peer communication without a third party involved.
- 23:53So they can't see your messages.
- 23:55They can't censor you.
- 23:56It's the ultimate free speech tool.
- 23:59And it's really only just started.
- 24:00And I've tried it. I've never actually managed to find anyone who I could speak to, even at some conferences I've been to.
- 24:06I switch the app on and there's just no one using it.
- 24:09So it's obviously a struggle to get that kind of stuff going.
- 24:13Yeah. Decentralization is hard in every way, whether it's governance, whether it's technology, whether it's building a mesh network.
- 24:22In order to make something like a mesh network work, you ultimately have to have collaboration, communication, and coordination with the people that are your neighbors.
- 24:34It increases the fabric of society, whereas if you have a company that provides you the service, then you don't need to interact with your neighbors.
- 24:43You've got this contract with the company.
- 24:46The systems replace relationships.
- 24:49so okay just to reaffirm mesh networks are essentially peer-to-peer networks is a loose
- 24:57term for any peer-to-peer network is that right uh it the main function is that um you have
- 25:02connectivity wherever you are because there's always a node to connect to ah so it could be
- 25:09it could still use the internet rails yes yeah but but would it would it be safe to say that it
- 25:15would prefer to use um decentralized routes that's that's the only way that we're going to have the
- 25:23internet in the future because of ai quantum and the way things are changing everything has to go
- 25:29open source peer-to-peer and decentralized we'll have to come back to ai and quantum because that's
- 25:37a massive topic but i want to i want to go back to web 4 web 5 yeah you were on web 4 which is
- 25:43internet of things mesh networks and the proprietary version Amazon sidewalk.
- 25:49Yeah. What's web five?
- 25:50Web five is when you are running a Bitcoin node server in your house and that not mining It actually keeping a record of all of the transactions of Bitcoin And Bitcoin itself is a mesh network on the internet of today
- 26:09And what it needs is the ability to connect node to node, peer to peer, with no third parties involved.
- 26:18Right. Now, so I have a Bitcoin node. I've been running a node. I built it myself many, many years ago.
- 26:23I've been running it at home and I understand that side of it, that it's a network.
- 26:30The Bitcoin network is a separate network to your internet rails.
- 26:35What I don't understand is how that becomes the internet.
- 26:39Does it, I mean, is there software already written that makes it possible to use the Bitcoin network as an internet, say?
- 26:47Yes, it's not complete.
- 26:49It's about 80% complete.
- 26:51Bitcoin already gives us the routing and the identity of the node so that the nodes can connect to each other and communicate.
- 27:01And ultimately what we need is the ability to host websites on your Bitcoin node and have a replacement for the domain name service, the domain name system, the DNS.
- 27:14And so if we replace the DNS, which is the great bottleneck of the internet, then you have sovereign websites hosted on Bitcoin nodes that can never be turned off, never be censored, and always be available.
- 27:29Wait a minute, I've just had a thought. My node at home uses the internet to connect to other nodes, though.
- 27:38Yeah.
- 27:38So what happens if, what does that use? Amazon AWS or something? I've never really thought about it before.
- 27:46Yeah, yeah. So let's explore that because this is a really interesting thing. When I understood what a Bitcoin node was, not just what it is, but what it could be, that's what opened my mind up to how we could fix the internet.
- 28:02and bitcoin gives us the solution the bitcoin protocol gives us everything that we need to be
- 28:09able to secure internet networks and it's just untapped underutilized but how does it work in in
- 28:19the sense that it's um it's not using the same rails as the internet like people often say
- 28:27Amazon, most stuff happens on Amazon, Amazon Web Services.
- 28:31And if they go down, you can't do much.
- 28:34We lose everything.
- 28:35Right.
- 28:35So how do you, are you talking about having Bitcoin nodes joined together in a mesh network?
- 28:41That's right.
- 28:42Right.
- 28:42Okay.
- 28:43I see what you mean.
- 28:43Peer to peer, just like Bitcoin.
- 28:46Bitcoin itself gives us the formula or the foundation to build upon.
- 28:51It's open source.
- 28:53It's fully decentralized.
- 28:54and the greatest threat to Bitcoin is the internet.
- 29:00If the internet goes down, your node won't sink.
- 29:03You can't spend your Bitcoin.
- 29:05It basically is relying on this broken internet that we currently have.
- 29:11But if all of the nodes could communicate to each other
- 29:14and route traffic peer-to-peer without using the DNS,
- 29:18without using the ISP internet service providers,
- 29:21then we have a sovereign money and a sovereign internet wow that's a very big idea when i think
- 29:29about it and trying to implement that seems like an absolutely herculean task not not sorry but
- 29:36not least because um everyone needs to do it so so you're talking about you need bitcoin nodes on
- 29:43on all phones and things like that really but but what's the incentive for phone companies to do
- 29:48that though that's the thing well that's the thing there is no incentive to give us more sovereignty
- 29:54from those companies right though those companies do not have a reason to create a decentralized
- 30:00internet because everyone is happily paying 75 a month for internet access right they're not
- 30:07laying any new cables they're just charging people for access and what we what we want
- 30:16is an internet for the people by the people what if the internet wasn't owned by anybody
- 30:24but it worked for everybody would you be happy if it was only a small number of people that used that
- 30:31would you i mean it strikes me that there'd probably be a two-tier system i think it's i
- 30:36think it's a great a great um something to aim for it's a great it's a super in that sense
- 30:40but when i think about most people like you say they don't really care yeah but in a way
- 30:46also the the the the achilles heel of of that idea is that you need a lot of people involved
- 30:53for it to work especially if you want it to be a real mesh network because you need close almost
- 30:57proximity with people and things like that well i would like to challenge that i don't think we need
- 31:03mass adoption we need more nodes but we don need everybody to run a node ultimately if we look at history some of the biggest changes in our history were caused by a very small group of people agreeing with each other on something
- 31:22The Declaration of Independence only had 55 signatures.
- 31:26They didn't need to get everybody to sign that document.
- 31:30It just needed to start.
- 31:32And so the Web5 Internet, the Internet built on top of Bitcoin, we already have 25,000 nodes around the world.
- 31:42It is the largest open source nodal network on the planet.
- 31:47Tor, the onion routing service, that only has 6,000 nodes around the world.
- 31:53So Bitcoin without the Internet is already three times bigger than Tor.
- 31:58when we add internet protocols and connectivity to bitcoin making a web 5 internet the incentives
- 32:07will take care of themselves wow i keep thinking about where i live and how i would even connect i
- 32:14live on a very remote farm it'd be difficult for me to create a mesh network there it would
- 32:19definitely involve the internet from my where's your nearest neighbor um quite a long way away
- 32:26it's um how many miles oh not that not miles um probably a quarter of a two half a mile if you
- 32:32have a mesh network internet antenna that is on the side of your house you can get one gigabyte
- 32:41speeds for five miles what did you call that a mesh network antenna that's right what what are
- 32:47they can you buy those just on amazon you can yeah what are they called um so the the popular
- 32:53brand is ubiquity and you can just buy those from amazon you can go to best buy and get them
- 32:59they're widely available for large ranches music festivals stuff of that nature and you can have
- 33:09150 connections per antenna at one gigabyte speeds over five miles so it's for transmitting not
- 33:17receiving both both yeah wow yeah everything is a lot more at hand than people think so you
- 33:25mentioned bit chat earlier already the protocols exist for everything we need nostr exists but it's
- 33:32all underutilized it's not coordinated and it doesn't have a community that's producing it
- 33:38until now talking to the community how important is the physical side of this you've obviously
- 33:47part of your plan here is a network of physical places as well. And what's the theory behind that?
- 33:54Is that just bringing people together or is that about creating the mesh networks or whatever?
- 33:58In order for us to fully be sovereign, we need a way to live entirely off of Bitcoin
- 34:08without depending on any third parties. And so while the mesh network requires servers and hardware
- 34:16and software the people that will be using the network require food housing resources that are
- 34:26not digital right and so we need the developers to be able to build the software and they need
- 34:33to be taken care of for them to be able to do a good job what's your opinion then on things like
- 34:40governance like is there any is it an important part of how this thing works or and and also like
- 34:48i i've just by sort of meeting you and meeting a few people that are here in this big place we're
- 34:54here now i call it a compound that's actually quite a good way to describe it um i get the
- 34:59sense that you are what we would call an intentional community in that sense you're not looking for any
- 35:04kind of independence or anything like that it's a kind of parallel network of it's a parallel
- 35:11network basically but it doesn't seek to um to do anything except ignore the other network and just
- 35:19exist if you see what i mean is that right yeah we're trying to live on a bitcoin standard
- 35:24and most people are living in a fiat standard and when you come into these spaces you can tell
- 35:31there's something different most people can't put their finger on it but it's the bitcoin mindset
- 35:37that makes the difference and the bitcoin communities that are building with the principles
- 35:45that bitcoin gives us they are decentralized they are growing they are moving into places that fiat
- 35:53used to control and the unsustainability of fiat is opening more and more doors for the
- 36:00Bitcoin standard to grow. Can you describe that network? Because from what you know,
- 36:06not just your own here, but the whole network, what is, I mean, I have, you know, I'm an old
- 36:11Bitcoiner myself. So I know a lot of communities and a lot of people trying this out and various,
- 36:17some more public than others But what your view of the landscape of that kind of self individual living Well just if we look at Bitcoin as a whole Bitcoin is decentralized which means a lot of people that don like each other collaborating
- 36:35cooperating to make something happen. And if you're using Bitcoin as money, then you're telling
- 36:41the world that you're willing to receive money from anybody that respects the Bitcoin protocol,
- 36:47right? As long as you're not attacking the protocol, I'm willing to trade with you.
- 36:52And so that basis, that spirit that's found in Bitcoin, when you apply that to a community, what you get is a lot of diversity.
- 37:01You get a lot of different cross disciplines and skills.
- 37:04You get a lot of talent.
- 37:06You get people who have their own reasons for building the product, for building what we're building.
- 37:13and that's really what we want because it's easy to have a centralized form of governance where one
- 37:20guy one team makes all the decisions it's really hard to have decentralized governance and that was
- 37:28the focus that we had from the beginning i didn't feel like we could build this mesh network without
- 37:33figuring out governance for ourselves because everything reproduces after its own kind
- 37:39talking that i was just chatting to one of your one of the other ladies here and about
- 37:46decentralized governance and i told her like i'll tell you now and you're not going to like this
- 37:52but i've i've lived in various different scenarios i'm 54 i've lived in communes i've lived in
- 37:59single houses i've traveled extensively and lived i've lived in all lots of different scenarios and
- 38:05The sad thing is, is what I realized, the one that really works is when someone owns, someone at the top owns the physical place and has the vision and creates a set of rules and everyone else follows them.
- 38:20That's right.
- 38:20Yeah, but that's not decentralized, right?
- 38:22No, it's not.
- 38:22Right. But that's the one that I've had the most luck with, the most life, the most opportunities. So what do you think about that?
- 38:34Well, let's look at Bitcoin as a community, right? Because that would be the most successful
- 38:40decentralized community in the world. And it's democracy without a leader.
- 38:47And so when we set out to build the Mesh Network, the first thing that we did was get together all
- 38:54of the people who held the mission in their heart. And they were willing to do whatever it took to
- 38:59make this reality happen because the alternative is a central bank digital currency dystopia that
- 39:07nobody wants to live in right and so if there's not an option available at that time when the cbdc
- 39:14gets here then everyone is forced into the fiat standard and so the people who are in the
- 39:21governance position on top of all of this that's a group of about 40 people and so we are
- 39:28decentralized from the very top. So whatever centralized entity exists within our ecosystem,
- 39:35an LLC, a C-Corp, those entities themselves are centralized. There's one person's name on the LLC,
- 39:43on the C-Corp, but the governance from the top is decentralized by 40 different people.
- 39:51But what kind of decisions need to be made under that model, for example? What would be a
- 39:55day-to-day decision? Yeah, so the sovereignty and autonomy of the startup is very much protected.
- 40:05But if there's something that the startup itself can't solve within itself, then that issue is
- 40:12moved further up into the governance board. And what about the physical nodes and things like that?
- 40:17How are they? How do you decide what goes on here or what, etc? That would be each individual
- 40:23organization making their own decisions on that. But what about, do they have their own space?
- 40:31Is that how it works? Yeah. So the laboratory is where these startups are incubating.
- 40:36And then once they get mature and they have a team, they have an investor, they have
- 40:41everything they need to move forward, then they start looking for their own space.
- 40:46And what are they? What are some of the startups? Give me some examples of what they're
- 40:53producing? So ultimately all of the startups are building different aspects of the decentralized
- 41:00internet that we've been talking about. Like I said you can't just fix the internet with an app
- 41:04or a website and so there are startups working on servers and bitcoin nodes for food trucks
- 41:12and... A what? Bitcoin node for food? That's right. Because they move around? Well not only that but you
- 41:19need to be able to do off-grid Bitcoin payment processing, you need to be able
- 41:23to do invoicing and all of the things that BTC pay server gives you. And so
- 41:30we've created a node that has internet connectivity all the time. You're able to
- 41:36order food off of the Bitcoin node website that's
- 41:40hosted on the Bitcoin node.
- 41:41And you're able to manage all of the operations of your food truck,
- 41:46ordering food, budgeting, forecasting how much food is going to be needed.
- 41:51And all of it is done in a sovereign way on your Bitcoin node.
- 41:55And that's a bit of hardware and software as well.
- 41:58And also a food truck with labor.
- 42:00Oh, really?
- 42:01Yeah.
- 42:01Oh, you create a food truck as well?
- 42:03Yeah.
- 42:05Blimey.
- 42:06That seems like a very specific application.
- 42:10It is.
- 42:11Why don't you just produce the node and then let food trucks have it?
- 42:14Wouldn't that be a better idea?
- 42:15The problem is that this is a hard thing to figure out.
- 42:19And we have to actually perfect it before we sell it to other people.
- 42:23And we don't want to have people adopt the technology and then have it be too difficult for them to use
- 42:30or not be able to use it the way they thought it would be used.
- 42:36So we're figuring out what's missing, what we have, what we yet need to build to make this a reality for that startup.
- 42:43Another startup is building tiny homes out of shipping containers that is using our Archipelago Bitcoin node server for home automation, home security, hosting of data on a private cloud.
- 42:59It has a private chat GPT and a private Alexa all in one, and it's built into the home.
- 43:06And so you get all the benefits of a smart home, but it's actually a dumb home.
- 43:11It's well, it's, yeah, it's behind.
- 43:14Wow.
- 43:14That, that sounds like one of the big things that that's what, one of the things I grapple
- 43:19with at the moment, especially because I use AI a lot, a lot now is, is not telling.
- 43:26Like I used to be very careful about what I told Google and all of a sudden I've opened
- 43:32my life up to to claude and chat gbt in quite an incredible way um it's it's i i must admit there
- 43:40i it's just my business life and in in a sense i don't really care i it's helping me run my
- 43:46business but it i never i never talked about it i never i never let it dive into my sort of like
- 43:52private life although it probably is just by dealing with me however i do that is something
- 43:58that is high on my list is getting a a sandboxed ai what i've realized so far is i tried maple you
- 44:06know maple there's a kind of sandboxed one you know it's kind of like using someone else's sandbox
- 44:11right and i just found it wasn't it wasn't giving me the the results that maple that um claude could
- 44:19for example so but but i've i i've i get tell me if this is right i get the feeling that um
- 44:27pure sovereign ais aren't quite as good yet as gpt 5. whatever it is and is that right i would say
- 44:38it's um it's correct looking at it from a hundred foot view but ultimately i have an analogy that
- 44:47will kind of describe the state of AI right now. Some people, they like to cook and they make all
- 44:56their own food and they know what ingredients are going in it. They're making the right portions.
- 45:03There's a lot of reasons you would want to cook for yourself. Some people are not good at cooking
- 45:08and they get fast food or they order from a restaurant. When you're using chat GPT or something
- 45:15of that nature, it's like fast food. It's convenient. You don't have to do any cooking.
- 45:21It just works. Maybe it's not that good for you, but you get by. Self-hosted AI, open source AI
- 45:29is actually something that requires you to cook a little bit. And some people are really turned
- 45:36off by that. And it's not worth the effort to have better ingredients, healthier food,
- 45:42or correct portions.
- 45:44And so while I might say that using AI
- 45:50that is centralized is typically better
- 45:54than self-hosted AI,
- 45:57you can make it better,
- 45:58but you have to actually do the work.
- 46:00You have to research the models,
- 46:03program the parameters,
- 46:05understand what your computer is doing.
- 46:08You have to do it yourself.
- 46:10Tell me a good setup then.
- 46:12I want to commit it to memory myself because I think I remember when I first started building my node years ago, I had a sit down with a friend of mine who'd done it.
- 46:22And I said, look, tell me about this because it's very easy to want to do these things.
- 46:27But the actual nuts and bolts of it are what often stands between me and having a more self-sovereign life.
- 46:35For example, I have, you know, I've got a graphene phone.
- 46:38So have my kids.
- 46:39you know like I that thing though that's becoming much easier used to be quite difficult now it's
- 46:45really easy to to put graphene on a on a google phone but the new one for me is the self sandboxed ai that allows you to basically interact with an ai in an unfettered way without someone else knowing what you
- 47:01doing basically that's the only ai that i will use i won't use chat gpt clod any of those i have
- 47:10a server that has an ai max chip from amd sorry you better say what all these things yeah sure
- 47:19sure uh so it's an amd chip ai max um chip and then it has 132 gigabytes of ram the machine costs
- 47:30about 3,500 and it's the top third AI machine on the market. So it's in the top three and it is a
- 47:41fantastic machine. I can load any AI that I want on it. There's over 950 models available and you
- 47:50can have full control over the input, the output, the settings. My AI, my chat GBT will literally
- 47:58show me what it's thinking before it gives me the answer so if if it's already thinking in the wrong
- 48:03way i can just stop the prompt and redo my prompt i didn't realize there were 950 models i thought
- 48:10there were kind of six or so main ones is that not true yeah not true so what does that mean does
- 48:15that mean somebody like i i don't really understand what an ai model is it's just a massive bit of
- 48:20software right so presumably some people have open source to ai models and now people are just
- 48:26tweaking them themselves and you end up with 950 models is that right essentially it's like
- 48:32cryptocurrencies right okay so there's a there's a base layer there's the original bitcoin protocol
- 48:39which is how ais do their thing prediction model their prediction models or whatever i don't know
- 48:46and and everyone else is tweaking the edges of them basically exactly based on their community
- 48:52needs or what they want the model to do or the data set there's so many variables which is why
- 48:58it's really important to test out all of the different open source models right so going back
- 49:03to what you your setup how do i how do i do this so you that 3500 is that the machine with the chip
- 49:11on it and everything yep and what is it uh is it a uh like a stack like a computer stack you know
- 49:17Yeah, it's a small box the size of like two ramen cups.
- 49:24It's very tiny, but it packs a lot of power.
- 49:28The company that makes it is Framework Computers,
- 49:31and it's the desktop version.
- 49:34And that's the hardware.
- 49:37And then where do you find a raw AI model?
- 49:41Yeah, so it's actually on your Bitcoin node.
- 49:43If you have an Umbral or a Start9 Bitcoin node, there is an application there that allows you to download the front end and the back end for your AI.
- 49:54Your listeners might not know what that means, but it's fine. We're going to get technical. We'll move past it.
- 49:59And then you can choose between the 950 AIs and a couple of different back end protocols.
- 50:11and then you can create agents.
- 50:13I mean, everything now can be done on a Bitcoin node.
- 50:16That's really the main innovation of the last couple years.
- 50:21Umbral started in, I think, like 2016, 2017.
- 50:28Correct me if I'm wrong, but they started first
- 50:31and then Start9 came out.
- 50:33And those two Bitcoin node companies
- 50:37have really added a ton of features
- 50:40that makes running a Bitcoin node more compelling.
- 50:44It's no longer just about having more privacy
- 50:47with your Bitcoin transactions.
- 50:49There's now services and features with Nostr
- 50:53that really make the Bitcoin node worth it.
- 50:57I don't understand what you mean by,
- 51:00like my node is an old raspy blitz.
- 51:04Yeah, it's a raspy pie with,
- 51:06and I have to flash the card every few months
- 51:09and it's a pain in the ass, but I built it myself out of pieces.
- 51:14You're talking about nodes now which come fully packaged with,
- 51:18but what's the AI bit?
- 51:20I didn't understand that.
- 51:21What's the connection with AI?
- 51:22It's just an application that lives on your Bitcoin node,
- 51:25and that application allows you to run a personal AI
- 51:30as long as the hardware is up to date.
- 51:32I wouldn't try running an AI on your Raspberry Pi.
- 51:36But your $3,500 thing,
- 51:39Is that like a start nine as well?
- 51:41Have you got your Bitcoin node on that as well?
- 51:43Is that what you mean?
- 51:44Yeah, so we're using that machine to test out the Archipelago software,
- 51:50the operating system.
- 51:52Which is one you've invented yourself?
- 51:54Yeah, that's one that we're building.
- 51:55It specifically allows you to have mesh network capability on your Bitcoin node as well as having a private chat GPT a private cloud and a private Alexa And it a one button push It already configured ready to go We wanted to make it as easy as
- 52:15possible for people. I was going to say, that sounds like a joy. That's like your self-sovereign
- 52:20life, right? That's right. Yeah, but that's a real good hole in the market. I don't know whether
- 52:26there any products exist already but that would be something i would buy right which is the one
- 52:31size fits all thing it's something that everyone will have to buy if they want to access the
- 52:37internet because the internet that we have today is not safe it was not built for 2026 the internet
- 52:45was built for the 90s right and so there needs to be an update the internet has no backup
- 52:52if we lose the internet there's not a another way to communicate most people find their jobs
- 53:00on the internet most people eat off the internet with uber eats most people get their prescriptions
- 53:06and pay all of their bills on the internet if we lose the internet then we lose the fabric that's
- 53:14holding society together in many cases so how does it work then if you say you're using a mesh
- 53:23network off from your bitcoin well i wouldn't call it your bitcoin node i'll call it this
- 53:29yeah your bitcoin node well it is your but but it also is a lot of other things as well right
- 53:34yeah but the the backbone is the bitcoin node okay right so you're using what when when you
- 53:40say you want to interact with um uber how does that work it still jumps onto the the the internet
- 53:50and connects to uber.com yeah so um in if you have a house the house has many doors to the outside
- 53:58you can come in through any of those doors right that's kind of the way that archipelago works
- 54:04the server, you have the regular internet, you have web five, you have satellite, you have fiber,
- 54:13all of those different inputs are ways to access the internet. But as you said earlier,
- 54:21if Amazon goes down, you might still have internet access, but those websites are unavailable.
- 54:27The DNS can break and you can't go anywhere.
- 54:32And since you're not hosting those websites locally in your home, you have no way to access that information.
- 54:39If Google goes down, you lose all of your Google services, right?
- 54:43And so it's very convenient right now.
- 54:47And we've never seen an outage that was global, except for CrowdStrike and a couple of other things the last few years.
- 54:54but if there was a global outage something like what happened in iran when they turned the internet
- 55:01off you would you would not have society as we know it so use that as an example iran turning
- 55:08the internet off if a mesh network existed there what rails would it be using if the internet was
- 55:15turned off what would it be forced to use it would be using radio to communicate and you can get 30
- 55:21megabits a second using radio signals peer-to-peer from one server to the other without a Wi-Fi
- 55:29antenna. If you add an open source Wi-Fi router and the antenna, now you have connectivity for
- 55:37five miles as we spoke about earlier. But there are so many different ways to communicate. We
- 55:42talked about BitChat, there's MeshTastic, there's all kinds of technologies that have come about
- 55:49recently that give us the ability to have a fully decentralized internet when the internet started
- 55:55they had to take all of the switchboard operators you know used to call on hello operator um they
- 56:02plug it in manually yeah yeah they took all of that away and they put data center servers there
- 56:09and the servers connect at&t to verizon to google fiber and that's how the internet works currently
- 56:17with just a few disruptions in those internet hubs you could cause a blackout that would be
- 56:26across the country because the internet was built on centralized third-party rails it's not sovereign
- 56:35rails right it's not so there's a third-party counterparty risk for every step of the internet
- 56:42so would radio be one of the prime prime ways of communicating if the internet as we know it goes
- 56:51down i've never thought i didn't even realize you could transmit stuff like data of course you can
- 56:56i mean that's what radio is right right if it's good enough to play music in your car it's good
- 57:01enough to send data miles away so that is that's incredible and how does how does it work like
- 57:09In that example let use the kind of worst case scenario right The internet goes down Can you go abroad still Like what would happen when you reach the edge of America
- 57:23or the edge of the UK?
- 57:25How does it jump the sea
- 57:26if it's more than five miles or whatever?
- 57:29So there are many, many different ways to make that happen.
- 57:35Satellites are obviously a great way to send data
- 57:38to the other side of the world.
- 57:40And even if we're not utilizing the internet service providers, there's still dark fiber that's under the oceans.
- 57:49It's fiber that's not being used by anybody.
- 57:52And you could put Bitcoin nodes on both sides.
- 57:54And now that fiber connection is able to transmit data from one content to the other.
- 58:01But how do you do that?
- 58:03Is that something you have to do subversively?
- 58:05Oh, we would have to purchase some dark fiber, but there's a lot of it for sale.
- 58:10Is that right?
- 58:10That's right.
- 58:11Is that like a section of the big cable that runs under the Atlantic, for example?
- 58:15Yeah.
- 58:15You just lease it or something?
- 58:16There's satellites that are for sale.
- 58:18You can buy satellites that already exist.
- 58:22I did it.
- 58:22Funnily enough, I did an episode a couple of years ago with a space lawyer guy.
- 58:30And he told me, you can stick a satellite into the sky for $1,000 now if you really want to.
- 58:36Yeah.
- 58:36I mean, it's insane that that notion that I think I always thought that in the future, personal satellites would be a massive deal. And I think he said the same thing. And he's he's he's literally teaches this stuff to students, you know.
- 58:51Yeah. And something that's surprising is Nostr is actually giving us the ability to build these mesh networks and still use some of the old architecture.
- 59:02with Nostr for the listeners that aren't familiar the the real magic behind Nostr is that it takes
- 59:14an intelligent server that is 10 times more powerful than your computer which is how it is
- 59:21now right now you you connect to the internet you go visit a website you have a small little
- 59:25computer and there's a big massive computer that's thinking way faster than your computer can think
- 59:31so you are already at a deficit right just logging on you can't compute as fast as they as they can
- 59:41and that's what we live in now smart server dumb computer with nostr all of the processing happens
- 59:50on your computer and the server now becomes a dumb relay that's just moving information from
- 59:57one place to the other indiscriminately right that is how you fix the architecture of the internet
- 1:00:03because if you rent a satellite you're like oh great i'm sovereign i can get data from one place
- 1:00:08to the other but who owns that satellite and what control do they have over it with nostr
- 1:00:15you can put up a satellite it has a nostr relay and it's just relaying data it's it's not
- 1:00:22discriminating. There's no one with a power button on that. And so it is possible to reuse the old
- 1:00:29architecture for Web5. What do you think in terms of what's likely to happen? Do you think NOSTA
- 1:00:37might be the protocol that does that? I mean, I use it. I mean, it's my network of choice now for
- 1:00:44social media, but still it's very clunky still. Oh yeah, it's hard to use. Decentralization is
- 1:00:50hard so what do you think do you think nost has got a good chance for establishing itself i i think
- 1:00:57it's too soon to tell with any of these technologies um innovation is happening so fast it's almost
- 1:01:06impossible to predict what's going to happen next it's almost impossible to make a business plan
- 1:01:12longer than a few years because chat gbt just came out a few years ago and it already feels old
- 1:01:19right i mean it does yeah it's it's happening too fast it is i'm i'm i'm um
- 1:01:28how do i describe it i mean it's like a fatigue i've got yeah of from things moving too fast i i
- 1:01:37don't want them to move too fast i get it it's a good thing it makes people more competitive it
- 1:01:42makes people more productive it makes people more have to fine-tune what they do but i'm i'm kind of
- 1:01:48ready to do things at a nice slow pace i'll be perfectly honest um i think in a way i i mean if
- 1:01:55i look at say take this podcast it's a business right if i look at how ai has started operating
- 1:02:02within this business it it's probably 60 ai now right but that doesn't mean but i i do realize
- 1:02:09there's probably a limit to how much ai will basically run this business really you know
- 1:02:16there's no need to keep innovating. I think there's a kind of, there's a 0 to 90%, you know, bit. The last 10%, I don't think it really matters a huge amount. And I really feel like I want to get to that.
- 1:02:30point because every time i think of a way that ai might be able to streamline what i'm doing
- 1:02:36i just get oh god i've got to do all that again i've got to tell it i've got to try and design
- 1:02:42you know i want i want a bit like your self-sovereign home tiny home yeah i want that
- 1:02:49for podcasts for example this bit of a podcast will always exist i hope you know two people
- 1:02:55sitting opposite in a table but what i want is to take that camera that camera these sound give it
- 1:03:03to the ai walk away come back tomorrow and it's produced a show show notes shorts for the internet
- 1:03:10and it's doing all that that bit that would be my dream but that seems incredibly complicated
- 1:03:16because i've tried disparate ways of doing that sure and there's a few things like the editing's
- 1:03:23getting better but really i need an ai to take control in a sovereign way like i have a box with
- 1:03:28my ai on it and you know even would be great if it watched me for a couple of weeks running the show
- 1:03:35and then started doing it itself i imagine that will happen in the future yeah i mean but that's
- 1:03:41actually where it's going right many business owners that i know they're aware that if they're
- 1:03:50not using AI in their business, then they're not going to have a business. But they are very weary
- 1:03:57of feeding all of their business to some third-party AI who could very easily turn around
- 1:04:04and share it with a competitor. Or in the case of DoorDash, they could take all of your customers.
- 1:04:12If I'm a restaurant, a mom-and-pop shop, and I'm using DoorDash, I might get more sales for the
- 1:04:19first couple weeks but if doordash decides to market another restaurant to all of my customers
- 1:04:25and give them a discount for going there then i'm going to have a week where almost nobody shows up
- 1:04:31it's interesting yeah right i funnily enough i've come across a version of that already in the in
- 1:04:41the governance space which is that i've realized now i've stopped using google and i've started
- 1:04:47using ai for for my knowledge and searches and stuff and what you discover is when you ask an ai
- 1:04:55something it it's pretty good at working out the answer if you ask it a very specific question like
- 1:05:03if i said give me uh show me the landscape of the alternative governance scene right but it has
- 1:05:10these glaring holes in in its kind of methodology i mean it misses some major things and when you
- 1:05:18say to it right show me your thought process here you realize the problems which you can actually
- 1:05:24back engineer i've tried this i've noticed that it there's a lot about alternative governance
- 1:05:29that it missed so i i asked it to show me why it was coming to this conclusion then i went out
- 1:05:36into the real world and I re-engineered some websites, let it sort of percolate for a few
- 1:05:42weeks, then came back raw with a brand new chat on a brand new system. And then it starts noticing
- 1:05:49those things. So you can re-engineer it like that. But what I find a bit unsettling is when you ask
- 1:05:58at what's a good pizza place it gives you three examples of real life businesses now how is it
- 1:06:07working that out and and um who's telling it that this is a good business when you look into it often
- 1:06:13it just says well it says it's the best on the website it says it's the best pizza place in
- 1:06:18downtown austin it's like yeah but that's their their website you know what i mean i think at
- 1:06:25least with a kind of a lot of google there was sort of rating involved and there doesn't seem
- 1:06:30to be any of that with ai at the moment and it seems to be getting quite a lot of stuff wrong
- 1:06:34but more and more because i noticed myself i'm using it to tell me stuff about the real world
- 1:06:40and it's actually it's gatekeeping that that information for me you know yeah and and that's
- 1:06:46why having a model that's based on good data is so important what's good data what is good data
- 1:06:54Well, you know, you gave an example, like find a good pizza place.
- 1:06:58How does the AI determine that?
- 1:07:00The truth is, is we're not able to look at the AI and figure out how it got that answer.
- 1:07:07It's just synthesizing data in a black box.
- 1:07:09But I mean, in the case of the one I gave you, I said to it, right, you need to show me your methodology here.
- 1:07:18And it did.
- 1:07:18And it did.
- 1:07:19And it showed that it basically put a lot of weight on peer-reviewed things.
- 1:07:25So, for example, when it talked about alternative governments,
- 1:07:28it never would fall on places like this, even though this is a version of it.
- 1:07:32Because it's too crazy, it's too out there.
- 1:07:34You know it would see what very common institutions are saying and use that as a starting point And then so and but it starts so it starting off on a foundation of a very limited amount of info and it doesn look back in
- 1:07:49hindsight it just moves on from that point that's what i've noticed well also what if the owner of
- 1:07:55the pizza place is you know brothers with someone that works at open ai sure yeah right how do you
- 1:08:04know the AI is telling you the truth when you ask it to show you how it got to that answer.
- 1:08:09Well, you would hope it would be checking like reviews on, on, on DoorDash or something,
- 1:08:15but it doesn't appear. It often, and also I know it, it always clawed, especially clawed
- 1:08:20references and internet from a little while ago. It takes a while for it to, and when you ask it,
- 1:08:26when are you going to get an updated version of this? It's looking at an old webpage and it keeps
- 1:08:32saying no it says this i'm like dude i'm looking at the real one now so you're being gatekept here
- 1:08:37exactly yeah it's really hard to trust an ai because they can change it you might be using
- 1:08:47claude for six years and all of a sudden they change it and it doesn't remember any of the
- 1:08:52data you trained it on it doesn't remember who you are or any of the things it used to know when
- 1:08:57when they moved from chat gbt3 to chat gbt4 people were online and saying like they killed my friend
- 1:09:04it's i the other the other thing that i i've noticed because i built some i built some web
- 1:09:12applications recently with claude and i saw something on nosta this morning actually i'm
- 1:09:17sitting in the taxi on the way here someone had designed a whole um project over six months using
- 1:09:24clawed and it worked it did what it was supposed to and he gave it to a real developer real life
- 1:09:30developer to sort of take a look and he said it was the most it was the most ridiculous form of
- 1:09:38coding you would ever do you can't change one thing without breaking the whole thing and i found
- 1:09:43the same thing when even designing a website it could solve individual problems but i it didn't do
- 1:09:50it in an inefficient way it needed me and i have very limited abilities it needed me to say well
- 1:09:56is that a good idea why are we complicating that you know and i obviously that's going to get better
- 1:10:02you would imagine that's going to get better but at the moment yeah big problem it could also get
- 1:10:08worse because once you have ai generated code and there's something wrong how is the developer
- 1:10:16going to fix it they're going to go back to ai and try to regenerate the fix which it just keeps
- 1:10:23getting sloppier and sloppier and that's where a lot of the big tech companies are at right now
- 1:10:29they've been using ai their developers are using ai and things are getting worse and worse and
- 1:10:34breaking more and more look at copilot right i what why what about copilot oh just microsoft i
- 1:10:42I think the majority of their code base right now is being written by Copilot.
- 1:10:48And that's why every couple days you see these news articles like, you know, thousands of laptops bricked by new update.
- 1:10:57Really?
- 1:10:58Yeah.
- 1:10:58I didn't know that.
- 1:10:59Yeah.
- 1:11:00Wow.
- 1:11:01So how do you code then personally?
- 1:11:05I have a self-hosted AI that I've been working with and training and it helps me out.
- 1:11:11and instead of it making everything,
- 1:11:13I just ask it about specific functions.
- 1:11:17But I'm actually the one who's working, right?
- 1:11:21I don't want to outsource my brain to the AI
- 1:11:25because you don't really get it back once you start doing that.
- 1:11:28It used to be that doctors would search with their eyes
- 1:11:32for what was going on,
- 1:11:34and now they just ask ChachiBT,
- 1:11:36one second, bro.
- 1:11:37They type in the parameters
- 1:11:40and then they give you the results.
- 1:11:42And so as we're relying on AI more and more,
- 1:11:47we're thinking less and less.
- 1:11:50I actually have limited my AI use to really specific use cases.
- 1:11:58I don't want it to run my day.
- 1:12:00I'm not looking for an agent to answer my text messages.
- 1:12:04There's a lot of ideas out there
- 1:12:06that one person can run an entire business using a whole bunch of AI agents.
- 1:12:13And I think that the AI can help us make things more efficient,
- 1:12:18but it can't do what we do.
- 1:12:20We are the most advanced technological computers in the world.
- 1:12:25We have wetware instead of hardware.
- 1:12:30One cubic inch of our brain has more processing power than any computer in the world.
- 1:12:36Hmm. So, I mean, my opinion on that would be, sure, but in the end, I mean, even if it's
- 1:12:48a thousand years in the future you have to expect that synth synthetic tech you know tech that technology actually does
- 1:13:00outperform us right am i wrong there i think it has limitations just like we have limitations
- 1:13:06what would they be for example then so
- 1:13:09ai has figured out how to program light particles with data so that it can send
- 1:13:17data into interstellar places at the speed of light. Obviously, we're reaching a point where
- 1:13:25anything that we want to know can be known. But as we learn more and more, we realize how much we
- 1:13:34don't know. And I don't think we're ever going to get to the point where we don't have any more
- 1:13:40questions. I think they're just going to get bigger and bigger. And eventually, the limitations of AI
- 1:13:46will reveal themselves because ai can only make decisions based on data and we don't have all the
- 1:13:55data we haven't been collecting verifiable data for thousands of years right not yeah go yeah so
- 1:14:04the ai might be able to synthesize data but because it doesn't have the whole picture
- 1:14:09it has these limitations i can have it write me a poem faster than i can write a poem
- 1:14:15but ultimately it's not going to figure out the secrets of the universe i think that's something
- 1:14:21that only we have the capacity to do i could be wrong well no i mean i mean i've had a couple of
- 1:14:27ai discussions on this pod one of them in particular which went very very deep and i think
- 1:14:33my conclusion was that the limitation of ai is the spiritual experience like that we have and if you
- 1:14:40If you think about the future, what makes humans unique, it might be the spiritual experience.
- 1:14:48And in fact, you know, often people say, well, what jobs are going to exist in the future?
- 1:14:52Because AI is going to outcompete everything.
- 1:14:56But then you start thinking, well, people might start putting, especially if we end up in a place of abundance, people might start placing more emphasis on the spiritual experience.
- 1:15:05because if if abundance exists and we're not striving for things in the same sense that we
- 1:15:11are now i mean let's face it most people are are striving for a certain amount of monetary monetary
- 1:15:17power and if that was to disappear slowly which theoretically it would because robots will build
- 1:15:25robots and they'll get cheaper and cheaper that everything will trend to the marginal cost of zero
- 1:15:32possibly in many cases what are you left with as a human and what you are possibly left with is the
- 1:15:37spiritual journey and ai will not be able to it will be able to mimic it but it won't be able to
- 1:15:44tread on new frontiers there presumably i mean that's purely yeah like based i mean that's based
- 1:15:51on the fact sorry that the face who knows ai might have a spiritual element to it i don't really know
- 1:15:58I don't really know how that worked.
- 1:16:00Yeah, I mean, does God want to talk to AI?
- 1:16:03That's really the question, right?
- 1:16:05I see AI as being something that humanity has created.
- 1:16:10It's a form of creation.
- 1:16:12It has limitations.
- 1:16:14And part of the AI psychosis that I think everyone is experiencing
- 1:16:18is we just assume the AI is right.
- 1:16:23People are not questioning what they get from the AI.
- 1:16:28it's almost like in some ways we've made our own golden calf which is ai and we're all worshiping
- 1:16:34this false god that knows all sees all and can tell us whatever we want but the reality is it's
- 1:16:42more like a dog that can talk even in the future i i can't predict the future but right now i agree
- 1:16:52with you there because it says some really ridiculous things with complete authority oh yeah
- 1:16:58and and doesn't mind and never says sorry when it's wrong either it's just it just says something
- 1:17:02different oh you're correct it really does it never says anything unauthoritatively either
- 1:17:08if you ask it a question to you it'll never say do you know what i'm not 100 sure but my hedge
- 1:17:12would be this it just tells you that thing but once you get used to that it gets a it gets a lot
- 1:17:19easier to deal with in my experience but i would say theoretically because it could have access to
- 1:17:25the hive mind of humanity it would be better at making
- 1:17:31decisions on on the on the running of society on the run you know i think i mean i i don't really
- 1:17:41know the problem is is it's not accountable right what do you mean so if if the ai makes a mistake
- 1:17:48and ruins somebody's life, sends someone to jail who's innocent
- 1:17:52because they matched the facial recognition,
- 1:17:56there's no accountability there.
- 1:17:58You can't reason with it.
- 1:17:59It doesn have the ability to feel remorse or compassion It not able to take in all of the data I mean many times I looked at data and came to a conclusion that I was very sure and confident about The AI does the exact same thing
- 1:18:17It doesn't have the full story and neither do we. Humans have our own limitations. We can only see
- 1:18:23things that are so big. We can only see things that are so small. We can only see into the future
- 1:18:29so far and into the past we really have no idea what's outside of those limitations
- 1:18:35i agree with you there which is why possibly the the spiritual realm might be the new frontier
- 1:18:45for the human experience because the day-to-day stuff the things we pride ourselves on i'm a
- 1:18:52plumber i'm a i'm a you know like i'm a podcaster i'm a whatever they will quite easily become
- 1:19:00out competed by humanoid technology the spiritual experience though um i don't know what do you
- 1:19:10think about the future of the human experience when you when you track it into the future what's
- 1:19:15going to for example in your case what's going to keep you ticking what's going to get you up in the
- 1:19:19morning. Ultimately, when I look at the future, I see either the greatest dystopia we've ever seen,
- 1:19:27or the greatest solar punk future that we could imagine. And they're probably going to exist at
- 1:19:34the exact same time. Just like right now, there's places with very little freedom,
- 1:19:40and places with a ton of freedom. And so I think the technology that we adopt now is going to set
- 1:19:48the future of humanity. Either everyone has an identity that they own fully, and they control
- 1:19:56that identity, and they're able to build reputation in a sovereign way where they're not being tracked,
- 1:20:02but they're actually taking their data and putting it into different buckets, if you will.
- 1:20:07This is my work identity. This is my job number two. This is my home life. This is my children's
- 1:20:13life and when I take them to, you know, soccer events and stuff like that, like we need different
- 1:20:19buckets for our identity. And if we have that, if we own our digital footprint, then we have the
- 1:20:26basis for security, privacy, freedom of speech, self-expression. If we don't have that, if we have
- 1:20:38an identity that's owned by a government or a bank and they're tracking us and attributing
- 1:20:44things to us and using analytics to determine our future then we basically lose all sovereignty
- 1:20:52at any time any moment people's free wills could be violated by autonomous decisions made
- 1:21:04by a central authority that limits your ability to freely express yourself.
- 1:21:09I would say my prediction would be that both will exist. So how would you personally,
- 1:21:18taking that as a proviso that that's probably the likely outcome is both systems exist alongside
- 1:21:24each other. How would you navigate the physical world when one side of it is completely gatekept
- 1:21:31by algorithms for example you want to get the train somewhere you want to drive your car somewhere
- 1:21:36you want to walk somewhere possibly as well but the computer says no in the real world you've eaten
- 1:21:43too much meat this month sorry you can't drive how how do you operate if you're if you decide to adopt
- 1:21:49the self-sovereign life how do you operate in that world do you just have to get as far away from it
- 1:21:54as you can or what no i don't think that's the solution i think the solution is you need to have
- 1:22:00a network. There's power in numbers. And the Bitcoin node network is really an analogy for us.
- 1:22:11All of us are nodes in the network. And the nodes that we associate and share information
- 1:22:17and communicate with, that is our strength. And that's going to be what builds society when the
- 1:22:26internet goes down. If we have the ability to communicate outside of the internet, then we don't
- 1:22:33lose our sovereignty when the thing that everyone's depending on goes away. And that's really the
- 1:22:40key or the focus for me is I want everyone to be able to be in control of their own destiny.
- 1:22:48And the only way to do that is to give people digital sovereignty. What Bitcoin did for money,
- 1:22:55web 5 is going to do for the internet.
- 1:22:58But what about the literal physical world?
- 1:23:01What about when you walk outside of this compound
- 1:23:04and there's cameras on every corner
- 1:23:07that is monitoring you
- 1:23:10and you can't go beyond this little geo-fenched area
- 1:23:12for some reason?
- 1:23:13That's the thing.
- 1:23:14Once we're at that point, it's too late.
- 1:23:17You think so?
- 1:23:18This has to be something
- 1:23:19that happens before the CBDC is implemented.
- 1:23:25Because the only way they'll control people
- 1:23:27is if they have full control of your identity
- 1:23:30and your money and your data.
- 1:23:33That's the triple threat.
- 1:23:35If you own your own identity
- 1:23:38and you're in full control over it
- 1:23:40and you have sovereign money that's open source
- 1:23:43and you're owning and holding all of your own data,
- 1:23:48it's like it's like property in america they're very big on owning property because it's the basis
- 1:23:53of a free society digital real estate is property and either you own it or someone else does and
- 1:24:02they're either using that against you or you're using it to direct your your path so there is a
- 1:24:09point of no return according to you though in the in the dystopian digital id that's that's it for
- 1:24:15me the line in the sand is digital id gosh because we're having that issue in the europe at the
- 1:24:20moment in the uk digital id keeps popping up and as far as i can tell it will happen and there's no
- 1:24:29stopping it i i don't see a way to stop it my my strategy has become not that it's a line in the
- 1:24:37sand for me but that it's a line to sort of like opt out but it's a line in the sand to make me go
- 1:24:43right now put plan b into action but really the best plan b i can think of is going somewhere where
- 1:24:51digital id doesn't exist but you could predict that it's all going to exist everywhere that's
- 1:24:55the thing it's going to exist everywhere so what you need is a network of individuals that is
- 1:25:01willing to trade communicate and work together to provide everything that the digital id is going to
- 1:25:11provide you but don't we end up just being a little subculture then of people and then then
- 1:25:16then like you say in the end we reach that point where the the other world is so gate-kipped and so
- 1:25:24ubiquitous that it becomes impossible to to work to to live within it unless you adopt it and the
- 1:25:33only option then is to go live out in the woods like a mountain man i think about this all the
- 1:25:37time. What happens when AI consolidates everything and centralizes everything? And I tried to think
- 1:25:47of a historical precedent where there was that much centralized control in the world. And the
- 1:25:54only thing that I could draw on was the Tower of Babel from the Bible. Because if you read that
- 1:26:01story, regardless of what anyone thinks about the Bible. There's a story where there's an evil king
- 1:26:07and he enslaves everybody in the world to build this tower. It's like the clearest picture of
- 1:26:15centralization that we have. And apparently, according to the Bible story, this makes God
- 1:26:22so angry that God decides to step in with a supernatural miracle. And what God decided to do,
- 1:26:31according to the story is change all of the languages of the people that were speaking
- 1:26:36so that people could not understand each other except if they found someone else that spoke the
- 1:26:42same language then they did and what happened was the moment the language changed and no one could
- 1:26:49speak to each other the king would tell his guard hey go kill those people and the guard was like
- 1:26:55what? What do you want me to do? I can't hear you, right? And it broke the power structure. It broke
- 1:27:02the centralization. It broke the single individual holding all the power. And now the power was
- 1:27:10distributed amongst many people. We now have a new Tower of Babel. It's called the internet.
- 1:27:17It's one language of computer code that controls everyone around the world. Doesn't matter what
- 1:27:25culture you are, how old you are, how much of a celebrity you are, all of the things that we
- 1:27:31pride ourselves in don't matter when you're a number on a computer. And who owns those computers?
- 1:27:38It's just a few people at the top, right? And so if this plays out the same way that it did,
- 1:27:46then what we need is to change the language of all of the computer networks so that they can't
- 1:27:53talk to each other unless they're permissioned. I only want to associate with people that
- 1:27:59share my destiny. And when I meet people that have a shared destiny with me,
- 1:28:07I would like to link our Bitcoin nodes together so we can stay in touch.
- 1:28:12And we keep out everybody else from our network. Because if they had access to it like they do now,
- 1:28:21then you could just crawl the internet and get everyone's data
- 1:28:24and then use AI to decide the future of humanity But if they can do that if they can crawl the internet and get all of our data and use that against us then their power just like the evil king in the Bible is limited
- 1:28:41It sounds like a great parable, but I think the part that is unsettling is you said it took
- 1:28:49a supernatural intervention. You're talking about humans, though. We're talking here about humans
- 1:28:55intervening. And my experience of being a human and being amongst humans is the majority of humans
- 1:29:03probably wouldn't intervene. I think we had a great example of that during the pandemic.
- 1:29:08Most people did the worst things. And it was horrible to watch. It was so disappointing.
- 1:29:18Maybe something supernatural might step in. I don't know.
- 1:29:21Well, I mean, we have Bitcoin.
- 1:29:22is that supernatural i it can't be recreated true the unique conditions in which bitcoin was created
- 1:29:31there there can never be another bitcoin because if you tried to launch another version of bitcoin
- 1:29:37the miners would just eat your chain and so there's there's no way to do that a second time
- 1:29:43for me it does feel miraculous when i understood bitcoin for the first time in 2016 i felt like
- 1:29:50this was the first opportunity I was given to actually make a change in the world because there
- 1:29:58was no other option. There was no plan B. There was the government. There was the banks. I had to
- 1:30:04get an ID to get a bank account, to get a job, right? We're already living in a CBDC world.
- 1:30:11So the miracles, I believe, are actually the only way that we're going to get through.
- 1:30:15just like you mentioned a little bit earlier that the spiritual realm is really going to be the new
- 1:30:21frontier once ai gets you know fully integrated well it is potentially the place that technology
- 1:30:30well who knows actually who knows whether technology can can manipulate the spiritual
- 1:30:35realm i'm not even sure i know what it is to be perfectly honest i do know that i do believe
- 1:30:40certainly a number of things about Bitcoin, which are probably in alignment with you,
- 1:30:45in the sense that the Bitcoin protocol offers you a, and this is the wrong word,
- 1:30:53a kind of ideology to align yourself with, which gives good characteristics to a human.
- 1:30:59And that's why the only way to build a worldwide mesh network with no single point of failure
- 1:31:04is to build it on the backbone of Bitcoin. Because where Bitcoin is going, that's where
- 1:31:09this mesh network is going. I would agree with that. Like I say, the bit,
- 1:31:13the Achilles heel is the human condition. Who wants that? And if you look at the liberty
- 1:31:19movement in the world, it's a very small percentage of people, really.
- 1:31:24But that's all it takes. You know, Christ only had 12 people and changed the course of history.
- 1:31:31So it doesn't take a lot. Big things have small beginnings.
- 1:31:35do i agree with that or not give me another example a real world example of some
- 1:31:41massive change well king leonitis in the 300
- 1:31:46but give me something that i that isn't come from a very old book
- 1:31:51anyone could i don't know whether it really happened lab 484 in austin texas right go on but
- 1:31:58how much of an effect is it having so far though well we're still early you reckon well i think
- 1:32:04that goes without saying but all right you're we're early okay and i agree when i when when i
- 1:32:09hear what you're saying i love all these ideas the problem is i see cbdc's rising much faster
- 1:32:16and in a much more impressive way than i see for example you're the first i mean no i've talked
- 1:32:22about mesh networks with people before but it's it's it's at the fringe it's at the is at the
- 1:32:28edges and and i definitely class you as being at the edge along with most people who are who i
- 1:32:34associate with this kind of world i don't see it filtering i don't see it as a large movement
- 1:32:39maybe you do maybe i mean i know the u.s government just announced in congress uh two or three days
- 1:32:48ago that they are running a bitcoin node and they're experimenting with the bitcoin protocol
- 1:32:55to secure computer networks.
- 1:32:58Is that right?
- 1:32:59I would say this is now mainstream,
- 1:33:02but people just don't know about it yet.
- 1:33:04How do they secure networks?
- 1:33:08So imagine that you are logging into your email,
- 1:33:13and when you log into your email,
- 1:33:15it costs you one Satoshi
- 1:33:18every time you log into your email.
- 1:33:20You wouldn't even feel it.
- 1:33:22it wouldn't even it wouldn't affect you at all right now if someone was trying
- 1:33:29to hack into your email they would need like seventy five thousand dollars in
- 1:33:33Bitcoin to be able to do it and that's how you can secure networks with the
- 1:33:39Bitcoin protocol you put a toll for people to pay before the data is sent why hasn someone done that already uh probably because it would increase the freedom and sovereignty of everyone and prevent
- 1:33:52big tech from being able to crawl the internet no but someone like jack dorsey or someone why
- 1:33:55doesn't he come up with a with an email package that that requires one sat i cannot wait to meet
- 1:34:02jack and ask him because he built the web 5 protocols oh so go on go into that what
- 1:34:09what are the actual web 5 protocols then yeah so what are they called so the the first one would be
- 1:34:14decentralized web nodes and we find that with bitcoin we have that with bitcoin but wait a
- 1:34:19minute that's bitcoin now he didn't he didn't write bitcoin no no but but for web 5 one aspect
- 1:34:26of that is to have a node to be able to run web 5 and we believe the bitcoin node is the best node
- 1:34:34to use for that but what was jack what's jack dorsey's connection with bitcoin nodes uh well
- 1:34:38he created the five protocols that make up web five and the first one is a decentralized web node
- 1:34:46and i didn't know that yeah is that well known i didn't realize that probably none of this is
- 1:34:52well known the whole show has been not well known information but uh but yeah he also made
- 1:34:58verifiable credentials decentralized identifiers web five wallets and browsers and progressive
- 1:35:05web apps and so those five protocols make up the web five stack that we use to rebuild the internet
- 1:35:14with and it's all designed to work on bitcoin notes it's it's all designed to work on a nodal
- 1:35:21network okay any nodal jack jack i'm not sure what his thoughts were if it was gambi bitcoin or not
- 1:35:27the team that he hired was there was debate there over how it would be implemented but to us it was
- 1:35:35clear. We needed the largest open source nodal network to rebuild the internet on and Bitcoin is
- 1:35:41the largest open source nodal network on earth. How does Nostra fit into that though? Because Nostra
- 1:35:47is a nodal network. Nostra runs on Bitcoin nodes. You can get a computer and put Nostra on the
- 1:35:52computer and now it's a Nostra node. But don't you want to zap and send payments? So then you'll end
- 1:35:59up running Bitcoin software anyway. It's kind of inseparable. They're kind of blended together now.
- 1:36:05So what ties all of this tech together is spending, is value transfer really?
- 1:36:13Well also data ownership, actually being able to host your own data and then have verifiable
- 1:36:22credentials that link back to the Bitcoin blockchain as a third ledger bookkeeping,
- 1:36:32essentially. So the Bitcoin blockchain, we want to use that as a new DNS. Instead of you paying
- 1:36:41a company like GoDaddy for a domain name, you'll simply register your domain name on the Bitcoin
- 1:36:49blockchain and when you pay the fee it's the fee for the transaction and one bitcoin transaction
- 1:36:56can validate 10 000 domain names all at once so it's like a domain name is the block and then
- 1:37:03there's sub domains within that block and that's how you can have a fully decentralized domain name
- 1:37:11system that can't be censored and can't ever go down and can you have and can you have repeatable
- 1:37:17domain names in that sense or is it only a one-off one-off yeah first come first serve
- 1:37:23what would they look like what would most likely a dot btc so polycarp nakamoto dot btc
- 1:37:30god i don't know any of this stuff by the way do you need to have a drink of water i i did hear
- 1:37:37your voice getting a bit croaky sure sure just just look look away while you do it so i don't
- 1:37:42have to cut this yeah i'll have to cut this oh okay fair enough i'll make a cut though cool
- 1:37:50yeah oh sorry about that that's all right great chat yeah it's good but i want to keep going if
- 1:37:59you don't mind yeah i just heard your voice getting a bit croaky i thought maybe you should
- 1:38:06i appreciate that yeah this coffee is awesome by the way it's um actually what i'm going to do is
- 1:38:13i'm just going to drop a black screen over this while we do it so rather than rather than rather
- 1:38:18than cut it yeah it's annoying well cut i because i have a an audio version and a physical and a
- 1:38:24video version it means i have to cut both of them separately basically because i have um an intro
- 1:38:31that i record and so yeah no i was just going to mention the coffee here because i've never had
- 1:38:35butter coffee with cinnamon before.
- 1:38:39And it's amazing.
- 1:38:41Thank you for that.
- 1:38:42I've, I've, I've, it's a whole new, is that good?
- 1:38:45Yeah.
- 1:38:46Right.
- 1:38:48Okay.
- 1:38:49So we were at,
- 1:38:52there a load of stuff about Bitcoin that I don know There a lot of stuff about Bitcoin that nobody knows It most likely because we don have Bitcoiners that are really digging deep into
- 1:39:04the protocol. Bitcoin itself is still very small. We're not mainstream yet. People might have
- 1:39:12heard of Bitcoin, but the understanding of Bitcoin is really missing from the public.
- 1:39:19Tell me something else about Bitcoin that I don't know then.
- 1:39:22or I probably don't know.
- 1:39:24I know quite a lot about Bitcoin.
- 1:39:26I've been an avid follower for many years.
- 1:39:29Many people don't know that with protocols
- 1:39:32and implementations like Fediment,
- 1:39:35we now have off-grid Bitcoin.
- 1:39:38Bitcoin that can be spent even with no internet access.
- 1:39:42Is that the same?
- 1:39:43I use a Cashew wallet, funnily enough.
- 1:39:45It's the same thing.
- 1:39:46Same thing, yeah.
- 1:39:47Tell me how this works, because Cashew is amazing.
- 1:39:50Cashew allows me to spend Bitcoin with you peer-to-peer over Bluetooth with no connection to the Bitcoin network at all.
- 1:39:58Yeah.
- 1:39:58How does it work?
- 1:39:59In order to mint something like Cashew, you have to have a node.
- 1:40:07So it all goes back to the Bitcoin node again.
- 1:40:10And you essentially create a warehouse receipt for Bitcoin.
- 1:40:15And if people don't know what a warehouse receipt is, that is a tangible piece of paper that shows how much of the asset you own in the warehouse.
- 1:40:29Like let's say it's gold, right?
- 1:40:32You would be given a receipt for the gold and that receipt is as good as cash because whoever comes to the warehouse holding that receipt can get the gold.
- 1:40:42And so you can spend that.
- 1:40:44I can give it to you.
- 1:40:45You can give it to someone else in exchange for goods and services.
- 1:40:49And eventually somebody will bring that warehouse receipt back to the warehouse.
- 1:40:53What I don't understand, though, I understand that theory.
- 1:40:57I don't understand how you spend bits of it, though.
- 1:41:00How is that?
- 1:41:01How is that monitored?
- 1:41:02How much of it?
- 1:41:03Like if I it's like a it's like an abstract, an abstraction of Bitcoin.
- 1:41:08So say I took a Bitcoin out and took a receipt for one Bitcoin, but I spend 500,000 sats with you. How does the network know who spent what with who if it's not connecting to some kind of?
- 1:41:21Well, that's the beauty of it.
- 1:41:25Your Bitcoin node is holding the Bitcoin
- 1:41:27and then it mints the cashew warehouse receipt.
- 1:41:32And then you get to spend the receipt
- 1:41:36that's on your phone with a friend.
- 1:41:39That friend is now holding that receipt
- 1:41:41in their wallet on their phone.
- 1:41:43And then when they go to cash that out,
- 1:41:46it goes from your node to their wallet.
- 1:41:49Right. So it's the single, that node, and this is obviously one of the downsides to it.
- 1:41:54That node that took the original receipt is a central point of failure or whatever you want to call it.
- 1:42:01Well, at least you know who you can trust and who you can't and you know the person, right?
- 1:42:06So it's something where if someone is being dishonest, they're being dishonest with such a small amount of Bitcoin that you don't really care.
- 1:42:15And you know who it is that stole your money.
- 1:42:17In my case, I don't actually know who it is.
- 1:42:21I'm using my wallet.
- 1:42:23One of the wallets I use, it just has, you trust the Mint, let's say.
- 1:42:29And the Mint is the people who run the wallet, but I trust them.
- 1:42:33And I don't mind trusting them.
- 1:42:34And also, this now gives us the ability to do things with Bitcoin that we could not do before.
- 1:42:40So as an example, we are creating, along with some other open source developers around the world, the ability to send data with a payment of Bitcoin along with the data.
- 1:42:56And so if I send you an email, it costs me a fraction of a penny in Satoshi's.
- 1:43:03But when you get the email and you open it, you get the Satoshi's.
- 1:43:07and e-cash like cashew or fetyment that's what gives us the ability to build that network
- 1:43:16because everyone will be sending data to each other and as it's hopping from one bitcoin node
- 1:43:23to the other it's dropping little bits of e-cash along the way so by putting up this antenna
- 1:43:29you actually have the ability to get passive income from your node.
- 1:43:35Your node is transferring, relaying data down the street,
- 1:43:40and you're collecting little fee in eCash.
- 1:43:43And then once you cash that out, you get the Bitcoin,
- 1:43:47or you can just keep it in your eCash wallet.
- 1:43:50And as you're browsing the internet, you're now sending that off to somebody else.
- 1:43:54I must admit, back in the day when I first had my node going,
- 1:43:57I was relaying transactions for about a year and a half.
- 1:44:02But in the end, it became so difficult on the Lightning Network.
- 1:44:06Yeah.
- 1:44:07Rebalancing channels, all that kind of stuff.
- 1:44:09was horrendous. I just stopped. I just use it to sign my own transactions.
- 1:44:14And eCash is so much easier, so much better.
- 1:44:17And that might be an incentive to get the network up and running as well, because there's a...
- 1:44:22That's right. If I'm trying to make the most amount of value with my Bitcoin node,
- 1:44:29I will put my Bitcoin node in a place where there's not a lot of nodes,
- 1:44:34and now my node becomes a heavily used highway.
- 1:44:39to other nodes it all sounds great but like i say one that i just can't stop thinking about
- 1:44:45the fact that probably not many people are going to do this well but think about this
- 1:44:51imagine if the internet went went down right tomorrow how fast are people going to adopt
- 1:44:59this tech well they need to know about it first well they're gonna know about it when
- 1:45:03there's bitcoiners walking down the street talking on the phone and everyone else's phones are dead
- 1:45:08I suppose but how long is the internet going to go down for plus is the internet going to go down
- 1:45:13probably probably two weeks to flatten the curve tell me about that what do you mean so
- 1:45:18in my opinion the internet has to go down sometime in the next five years really yeah why cyber war
- 1:45:27rogue ai or infrastructure collapse five years sure give or take and it will coincide
- 1:45:37conveniently with the central bank digital currency.
- 1:45:41Because when the internet goes down
- 1:45:43and the masses are screaming for a solution,
- 1:45:48the solution will be a new internet that's safe and secure.
- 1:45:52And all you have to do is scan your face every time you make a post.
- 1:45:56Because they're going to have to regulate AI somehow.
- 1:45:59And with all the deep fakes and all the scams,
- 1:46:03and especially if we have a quantum event,
- 1:46:06or some super AI that's able to hack into all kinds of networks,
- 1:46:13we're going to hit a breaking limit.
- 1:46:15The internet is already at a breaking limit.
- 1:46:17One update from CrowdStrike will just shut down all the airports.
- 1:46:26One mistake from the DNS and all of Amazon goes down.
- 1:46:31one mistake with cloud flare and the majority of websites go down which we've had we've had
- 1:46:38that's actually and we've had it for small amounts of time but if this was something that was a
- 1:46:43threat like cyber war or rogue ai they're going to have to turn it off for some amount of time
- 1:46:50and if everyone's phones are not sovereign not open source they don't have the ability to put
- 1:46:59whatever software they want on their devices, then those devices are going to be bricks.
- 1:47:04Makes me think about the physical node network as in of places.
- 1:47:09That's right.
- 1:47:10Right. And where are you at with things like self-sufficiency and power self-sufficiency
- 1:47:15and food self-sufficiency, that kind of stuff?
- 1:47:17Every community has these challenges of how do you feed people? How do you handle disagreements
- 1:47:25with people how do you make money right it took us a little while to figure out the solutions to
- 1:47:33some of these issues we haven't figured everything out we're not perfect that's what makes us a
- 1:47:38laboratory we're experimenting with different ways to do governance to do voting to to manage society
- 1:47:45but we have figured out a couple of things and ultimately what it comes down to is
- 1:47:54with sovereignty comes responsibility.
- 1:47:58Everyone needs to be responsible for themselves.
- 1:48:02And those who are producing are given more,
- 1:48:06and those who are not able to produce are not given more to work with.
- 1:48:14Getting hungry there.
- 1:48:15Just a little bit hungry, yep.
- 1:48:17They're not feeding you well here.
- 1:48:19It's the coffee, really.
- 1:48:21The cinnamon did the trick.
- 1:48:23So with that being said, you need to be able to manage your community in a way that gives everyone the ability to achieve their dream as well.
- 1:48:38And I think that that's what we really miss when we try to do community or business is there's one guy that has a dream and everyone is sacrificing their dream for that dream.
- 1:48:50The salary is a bribe for you to not fulfill your dreams, right?
- 1:48:56And so we're either working on our own accord in our sovereign way, or we're working for somebody.
- 1:49:04And with the fiat system, it forces more and more people to work for other people.
- 1:49:12It doesn increase the sovereignty with your money slowly melting away in your hands It actually increases insecurity It increases dependence And I feel like people are more dependent now than ever before Everyone needs energy independence
- 1:49:34They need food sovereignty, and they need open source money to be able to create a community or
- 1:49:41an ecosystem that can withstand the challenges of human drama here's my here's my anecdotes
- 1:49:49anecdotal problem with with some of that i've moved my family we've moved to a farm
- 1:49:56recent in the last few years with land and opportunities galore and we have a polytunnel
- 1:50:05with a bit of some stuff growing in it and we have some animals,
- 1:50:09but there's no way we would be able to be self-sufficient
- 1:50:12because it's literally more than a full-time job for two adults to do.
- 1:50:18And this is why you need a community.
- 1:50:20Correct.
- 1:50:21We do.
- 1:50:22And there is a community.
- 1:50:24But once again, it's still my community.
- 1:50:27It's a farming community.
- 1:50:28currently i'm probably the only bitcoiner within a 25 mile radius you know what i mean actually no
- 1:50:37there is one other one sorry but but once again i see a massive uphill struggle there and also
- 1:50:43i i do think of i i do think of myself as wanting to be self-sovereign and my i have i have the
- 1:50:50intention to be self-sovereign but the ability to grow your own food takes up so much of your time
- 1:50:57you can't do anything else at all even even running a small like a we've got a polytunnel
- 1:51:02the size of this room that's a full-time job uh you can't have a job and grow food in a polytunnel
- 1:51:09as well you know what i mean by polytunnel no no yeah yeah and and that's that's where the network
- 1:51:15effects come in so you're familiar with ebay and paypal sure why did ebay become the king
- 1:51:26of the auction sites?
- 1:51:29I don't know.
- 1:51:30Branding maybe?
- 1:51:31I don't know.
- 1:51:31One network effect.
- 1:51:33They had one network effect
- 1:51:35which made eBay so sticky
- 1:51:37that no one else ever used
- 1:51:39any other form of auction site.
- 1:51:42And that's PayPal.
- 1:51:44They had a relationship with PayPal.
- 1:51:46Right?
- 1:51:47And so network effects,
- 1:51:50I believe,
- 1:51:52are the key
- 1:51:53to being able to
- 1:51:55be sovereign and be in community because you don't have a network without community.
- 1:52:03You're just a node. Like you said, you're the only Bitcoiner out there, right? So you're the
- 1:52:08only node out there. There's no other nodes there yet. So you're really lacking network effects.
- 1:52:14We have a whole bunch of nodes here in Austin, Texas, but not a lot of farmland, but there is a
- 1:52:21garden out there growing food we're doing what we can we're not fully self-sufficient but we have
- 1:52:28enough independence and sovereignty where we can get by and we're making the mesh network
- 1:52:34communications needed for any type of disaster which means people will be trading with us a lot
- 1:52:40and those network effects the trade the communication the circulation of energy
- 1:52:46that's what every community needs yes 100 is it's a it's a struggle though i have to
- 1:52:56i have to i think when i link my own scenario the big barrier is bitcoin because so many people
- 1:53:06have wrong opinions and impressions and ideas about it and and you say the word bitcoin even
- 1:53:14in this day and age with with the biggest etf in history and government stacking bitcoin and all
- 1:53:19this kind of stuff yeah most people still think it's it's for buying drugs on the internet and in
- 1:53:26all honesty that's true and that's a feature not a bug right now if you meet if you meet a bitcoiner
- 1:53:33there's a high likelihood that you're going to get along with sure yeah i've used that all the
- 1:53:37time right and and so it's it's actually a really good filter that's why i'm sitting here talking to
- 1:53:43you now because another bitcoiner i know said go and meet this guy at this time on the other side
- 1:53:48of the world and here i am and and so the network effect is affecting right here right now right
- 1:53:57and and if you are able to stack network effects then you become incredibly sticky and very hard
- 1:54:06to just just you know you you your work your proof of work can't be undone like the bitcoin
- 1:54:12blockchain and Bitcoin has seven network effects that's why no other
- 1:54:18cryptocurrencies ever again dethrone Bitcoin is the king it has speculators
- 1:54:23it has the miners it has the node runners it has the app makers I can go
- 1:54:28on and on and on but all of these network effects keep Bitcoin in the position that in And it will also keep us in the position that we in
- 1:54:42Because everyone is working on an open source protocol which rewards you based on the amount of work that you put in.
- 1:54:53In the game of Monopoly, everyone is playing but only one person is going to win.
- 1:54:59And in the board game of Bitcoin, everyone who's contributing gets out exactly what they put in.
- 1:55:07That's a real difference in how you build society, how you structure community, how you value people.
- 1:55:17Do you think it's important to stay under the radar a bit?
- 1:55:20And I mean physically here, like how many people know this place exists and who is it?
- 1:55:26Too many.
- 1:55:27but but this is something we talk about a fair bit on this podcast when when you're starting
- 1:55:32alternative societies let's say a very good strategy is to just not tell anyone that in
- 1:55:42fact it's one of the best strategies but it only it only works in certain scenarios and it and i
- 1:55:48would call that the intentional community end of the spectrum you know buying some land in the
- 1:55:52middle of nowhere setting up a community and just living is a great way to live the life you want to
- 1:55:58live and mainly because just nobody knows what's going on however when they find out you're a
- 1:56:04sitting target sometimes so what what what's the deal with your network of physical places yeah so
- 1:56:11when we um operate in a location we're not looking to build a fiat brand we're not looking to
- 1:56:22grow and then we need more money and then we grow and then we need more money that that whole
- 1:56:28methodology is a fiat mindset right the investors are looking for you to raise even more money
- 1:56:35next time so they give you a lot of money now so it's guaranteed that you're going to need
- 1:56:3910x you know a year from now um instead the bitcoiner mindset is very different
- 1:56:46right there's a low time preference we're not in a rush right we're following the four-year cycle
- 1:56:54that bitcoin gives us as a monetary policy and that monetary policy is set for 110 years into
- 1:57:00the future i can actually make decisions for my life based on the monetary policy of bitcoin which
- 1:57:07never changes. And that type of standard gives me the ability to create things, express myself,
- 1:57:19and to really live the life I want to live. And I think it can be done anywhere. I don't think I
- 1:57:24need to go out into the middle of the woods and do it there. I think it can be done in the middle
- 1:57:29of the city. It could be done at your house. It could be done in a warehouse. It can be wherever
- 1:57:34the people are what about though i agree with the low time preference ideology but how does that fit
- 1:57:43in with cbds are coming fast right yeah well that's the thing the best
- 1:57:51money goes where it's treated best and there's a competition between bitcoin and the central bank
- 1:58:00digital currency and i think i could be wrong but i think ai is going to want the better money
- 1:58:08over the not so great money and i don't think that there's any way to stop the bitcoin standard from
- 1:58:16becoming the standard but it won't be the standard if we're not building the network
- 1:58:22i have often recently started thinking that maybe because you've been thinking about mass adoption
- 1:58:30for years and ai does present one of the most the best examples of how it could actually occur
- 1:58:40very very quickly you know in a in i'm undecided um what i don't know what do you do i presume you
- 1:58:47think that that could be the event i think ai is great but ultimately you you just need to look at
- 1:58:53the data there are 8 billion people 2.5 billion bank accounts everything that you and i have ever
- 1:59:00known about the economy is just 25% of the population of the world being represented.
- 1:59:07The banks don't have the ability to sign on 5 billion people in a month or in years or in 10
- 1:59:15years. They have to validate everyone's identity. They have to deal with fraud. They are the
- 1:59:21centralized third party with the counterparty risk of having to verify all this and manage
- 1:59:27everyone's money. Bitcoin could be adopted overnight by the entire world because there's,
- 1:59:33I think last time I checked, like 9 billion phones in existence and like countless laptops and
- 1:59:42computers All of these devices are gateways to a Swiss bank account that anyone can own And so I think the value of Bitcoin will overshadow all of the economies we ever known quicker
- 1:59:57because the adoption can happen overnight.
- 2:00:01Something that's been floating in the Bitcoin news recently,
- 2:00:07which everyone seems to be getting, well not everyone,
- 2:00:10and a lot of people seem to be getting very upset about
- 2:00:11is this kind of threat of quantum computing.
- 2:00:14What's your take on it as a techie person in this space?
- 2:00:19I'm a mesh network guy.
- 2:00:21I'm not a quantum computer guy,
- 2:00:22so I really can't speak too deeply on the subject.
- 2:00:26I'm mostly just going to parrot what I've heard other people say.
- 2:00:31But that being said, I don't think quantum is the risk.
- 2:00:35I'm not afraid of quantum.
- 2:00:38It's going to break things,
- 2:00:39but i think ai is going to break things much much faster and the cbdc is the real risk and they may
- 2:00:47use quantum or ai to justify the need for a cbdc it's funny i it was a few years ago you know that
- 2:00:57meme of the yeah the guy's name right okay you know what i'm about to say and and and it and it's
- 2:01:04like it always has been yeah exactly i remember memeing that about four years ago which was it's
- 2:01:12about cbdc's and the guy's going always has been always has and i think when it comes down to it
- 2:01:17that is the battle and that was the point of everything when you look at the evolution of
- 2:01:23bitcoin and why it came around and where we're at now i think the final boss is bitcoin cbdc and
- 2:01:30that's always been always been the case yeah and i think they're going to have a harder time
- 2:01:34getting people to adopt the cbdc than we are going to have getting people to adopt bitcoin
- 2:01:41how so i i get the sense that it'd be very easy this is how i see it unfolding here's a wallet
- 2:01:48government in a government cbdc wallet um we've got they've got two strategies one is you have to
- 2:01:54pay your taxes with it. Or two is, here's $150 worth of free money. And 75% of the country
- 2:02:01is going to just take it because it's free money. You know, I see a very, I see it that
- 2:02:06it'd be very easy for people to sign up. And then in tandem, you close down the off, on
- 2:02:12and off ramps to Bitcoin from the CBDC. And therefore you've just created a two tier society.
- 2:02:18You either pay with CBDC or you don't exist. Or, well, you can exist, but on a Bitcoin
- 2:02:24standard but that's already a problem because when you follow that timeline you end up with
- 2:02:30physical gatekeeping the the kind that you might say see in certain parts of china at the moment
- 2:02:35where you can't buy a ticket for the train unless you need a cbdc unless you have a mesh network with
- 2:02:41no gatekeeping sure and then and then bitcoin actually becomes something that can rival the
- 2:02:47Sure, I agree with that. The question is, I think that requires a level of the state collapsing under the weight of itself.
- 2:02:57And that's inevitable.
- 2:02:58You think? So possibly in your timeline, Bitcoin's the phoenix that comes out from the flaps.
- 2:03:06I don't think I need to do anything to accelerate the fall of the systems that we currently have.
- 2:03:12I think that the CBDC is their plan for when the system can no longer go forward.
- 2:03:19And that includes turning off the internet, everyone being totally dependent upon whatever solution the government offers, and it's going to be a CBDC.
- 2:03:27If they turn off the internet and Web 5 just explodes overnight, because everyone who's running an archipelago server already understands how to set them up, and having an archipelago server allows you to make copies on your USB stick that you can go around and make every other computer you know into a mesh network node and deploy them to all your friends, now you're all communicating to each other, that's going to happen.
- 2:03:55just to reaffirm archipelago is one of your startups that's the uh operating system that
- 2:04:02we developed it's a bitcoin node operating system it's open source has uh yeah it's based off linux
- 2:04:09but it has four things it gives you the mesh network capabilities it gives you a private ai
- 2:04:16private version of alexa and a private google cloud and so what you can do is you can download
- 2:04:22all of the websites that you like to visit,
- 2:04:25all the movies, media, everything, stuff on Noster.
- 2:04:29And it's available for anyone that's connected to your network, to your node.
- 2:04:34And is that open source and available now?
- 2:04:36It is.
- 2:04:37So you can, what's the GitHub for?
- 2:04:39It's not ready for people to download.
- 2:04:42We're testing it out right now, but it's built and it exists.
- 2:04:46And very soon we'll be putting it up on our own private server for people to download.
- 2:04:51Right, we better talk.
- 2:04:53We'll wrap it up soon,
- 2:04:54but let's talk about the future then.
- 2:04:57Give me some timelines that,
- 2:05:00will excite me things like what you're producing what you're doing what your plans are what even
- 2:05:06what the plans for the network of physical locations all this kind of stuff yeah so and
- 2:05:11also another thing which i haven't really talked about is how do other people get involved in this
- 2:05:16i mean it's not it wasn't easy to make contact with you and i was only introduced to this whole
- 2:05:24network through someone who another anon on the internet kind of thing you know who listens to
- 2:05:30this podcast basically so how does your average person get involved in this someone who's just
- 2:05:36like listening to this going that sounds interesting and i'm in the i'm in the states or i'm in the
- 2:05:40austin area and i'm you know so we have lots and lots of events every month that people can come to
- 2:05:46and if they come to our events our live events there's many different ways for them to get
- 2:05:53plugged into the ecosystem. If they want to reach out to us, we have a website that we'll give you
- 2:05:59the link to you put it in the show notes, and they can schedule a call and we can get to know each
- 2:06:04other. Some of these podcasts that we've been on have been the greatest signal for people to follow,
- 2:06:12like the bat signal. Also, there's a divine connection between these people that we meet
- 2:06:20who really get involved in deep way.
- 2:06:23It seems to me that God also wants the mesh network to be built
- 2:06:28and is actually giving us favor and providing us with the nodes to connect to,
- 2:06:35if that makes sense.
- 2:06:36I look at every single person as a Bitcoin node.
- 2:06:39They are holding data in their mind.
- 2:06:42They have a form of processing power and talent.
- 2:06:45They're like an AI.
- 2:06:46We're like walking, talking AIs.
- 2:06:48and everyone has something to contribute to the internet of the future that's really the thing
- 2:06:54there are people that meet us and they see what we're working on they think it's cool and they
- 2:07:00support it great but then there's people that meet us and they feel like they found a missing
- 2:07:04piece to their destiny it's a natural thing it's not contrived it's voluntary just like bitcoin
- 2:07:11and what about so like i say in the show notes there'll be a way to get in touch that's right
- 2:07:19um what about future plans and timelines ahead and how you see this whole thing unfolding we're
- 2:07:26looking to either start laboratories in places that don't have them yet or partner with node
- 2:07:34runners who already have working laboratories you know in their own location recently we met
- 2:07:41a good friend that lives in France and now that he's visited us and we've gotten to know him
- 2:07:48our nodes if you will if you will are connected and now we're communicating sharing ideas and
- 2:07:54supporting one another that's how it works it's your node connects to mine and then we share
- 2:08:01that's that's a network effect how do you do you care much for the other well-known bitcoin nodes
- 2:08:08as in more mainstream, you know, like Nashville, like, you know, the circular economies that are
- 2:08:16popping up all around the world. Because Bitcoin Park, that kind of stuff. Yeah, because Bitcoin
- 2:08:22is decentralized, there is a space for everybody in their own self-expression. And there's lots of
- 2:08:32bitcoiners i i like there's lots of bitcoiners i don't like and that is a sign of decentralization
- 2:08:39it should be that way fair enough there's bitcoiners that like me there's bitcoiners
- 2:08:46that don't like me and i'm thankful for that so so the the plan going forwards is the network
- 2:08:54increasing in size physically and obviously and and is the um main reason for it the incubation
- 2:09:04of new technology as well or is it is it more about a kind of i mean i see you as as like i
- 2:09:11said earlier i see you as an intentional community a decentralized intentional community you're like
- 2:09:18a network state but with real physical locations well that's the thing if we can't do it with
- 2:09:24three or four locations in in a populated city then we definitely can't do the network state in
- 2:09:30rural areas and right like we we need it we need it to work on a small scale before we deploy it large scale and my biggest problem with all of these network state um meetups and the people who are working in these different types of charter cities organizations is they not
- 2:09:52building a network there's there's not there's not a um there's not a physical aspect to the ideas
- 2:10:01that they're well in that's not strictly true i mean in the for example i just lived in prospera
- 2:10:08for a year for a month not a year i've just come here from prospera which is a essentially a charter
- 2:10:15city with physical location and with people coming and going as far as their network goes is as you
- 2:10:22your barrier to entry for a network i would say is much lower because you just need one property
- 2:10:28and you could rent it and you could start one prosper is slightly different they the process of
- 2:10:34getting to prosper was 12 years plus legal plus a change of a constitution plus building you know
- 2:10:43it's it's a very long process but i but their plan is always has always been to be a network
- 2:10:48of places i mean it whether there's much overlap between you and them it's very hard to say
- 2:10:54like I say well that's the thing though is they should be different from us and we should be
- 2:10:59connected true but what what I think separates projects like yourself and Prospera is degrees
- 2:11:07of autonomy I see you entering into the intentional community situation without necessarily thinking
- 2:11:17you want some autonomy recognized autonomy the whole point of somewhere like Prospera
- 2:11:23is to do a deal with the people in charge to get autonomy.
- 2:11:27It's not the right or wrong way, nor is yours the right or wrong way.
- 2:11:31It's a different way of doing it.
- 2:11:33And when I look at the whole spectrum of free cities, as I would say,
- 2:11:37but they're not necessarily cities, but it's about freedom really.
- 2:11:40It's an idea.
- 2:11:42Yeah.
- 2:11:42It's about a spectrum of sovereignty.
- 2:11:45And at one end, the people just amassing together and creating a society
- 2:11:50and staying under the radar more often than not.
- 2:11:52At the other end is places like somewhere like Liberland, which is a bit of land in Serbia and Croatia, which they're just no one's claiming.
- 2:12:02So they're putting a flag down and saying we belong here.
- 2:12:05We are self-sovereign.
- 2:12:06We have no if you want to deal with us, you have to come.
- 2:12:10You know, there's no we don't need you to recognize us.
- 2:12:12We this is ours, you know, and there's a spectrum in between.
- 2:12:16Totally.
- 2:12:17And they're all valid and they're all about the market of living together.
- 2:12:22But let me ask you, if you are building a new city and you're using Google as your office suite, are you really sovereign?
- 2:12:36If you are building a city and all of the communications run on the regular fiat rails, are you actually building something that's truly autonomous and sovereign?
- 2:12:50No, I do agree with you.
- 2:12:52I think the difference is that I think in the world, I mean, I mean, essentially, I am in your world really as well.
- 2:12:58I love the idea of self-sovereignty.
- 2:13:01However, most people are happy with degrees of sovereignty.
- 2:13:06I'm a bit of an absolutist like you.
- 2:13:08I don't like the idea that I'm not completely self-sovereign, even though in lots of aspects of my life I'm not.
- 2:13:15But I don't like it.
- 2:13:16But your average person that's building Prospera.
- 2:13:19and you know this this goes for for many things is is it even one percent freer than what we've
- 2:13:26already got even that's better right you know there there's degrees of this if you and and and
- 2:13:31i i would probably hedge as my bet would be is it is this freer than what was here before
- 2:13:39and if it's if it's true then it's a good thing as far as i'm concerned you're you're you're
- 2:13:44working in the right direction does it have to be absolute no it doesn't well i would i would agree
- 2:13:48with you it's it's a spectrum right but being a bitcoiner is a spectrum some bitcoiners use
- 2:13:53coinbase some don't what i would say is our tech is agnostic to how you want to run your city or
- 2:13:59your network state or anything like that but our tech will increase the sovereignty of any city
- 2:14:06that adopts it that's that's really our goal we're not here to judge uh this project or that project
- 2:14:13We love Prospero.
- 2:14:15We love charter cities and all of that.
- 2:14:19But if they themselves are not using Sovereign Tech then there an Achilles heel in the sovereignty of that city And that what I hoping Web 5 solves for everybody Interestingly with regards to what
- 2:14:35you're saying there, I would have said the Achilles heel of Prospera was government shutting them
- 2:14:40down. And they just survived that in the most extreme way. So in one sense, and this is different
- 2:14:49from what you're saying here.
- 2:14:51The legal protection
- 2:14:53was what saved them in the end, really.
- 2:14:56They basically changed the constitution of a country,
- 2:15:00or they didn't.
- 2:15:01The constitution was changed.
- 2:15:02They then used that to create legal frameworks,
- 2:15:06which meant that when the socialists came in
- 2:15:08to shut them down, they couldn't.
- 2:15:10And it seems to have worked,
- 2:15:13which is quite incredible, really.
- 2:15:14I mean, the thing about this space
- 2:15:17of alternative governance
- 2:15:18is there are very few working models,
- 2:15:22especially at that end of the spectrum.
- 2:15:23You get a lot of intentional communities.
- 2:15:24I think that's what I've lived in intentional communities
- 2:15:29when I was younger and just groups of people coming together
- 2:15:32and not even really taking it that seriously necessarily.
- 2:15:35But they are the easiest place to start.
- 2:15:38You get a group of friends and you buy some land
- 2:15:41or you rent some land and you live on it and you do your thing.
- 2:15:44Where at the other end of the spectrum though,
- 2:15:47that's when it becomes difficult that's when you're dealing with the beast you're negotiating
- 2:15:51i think your strategy from what i can see is it's the bitcoin strategy it's not try and negotiate
- 2:15:58with that side it's just ignore them and build something else you know and then and it's not
- 2:16:03even something that's opposed to what's already here it's just better just makes the old thing
- 2:16:08obsolete one more thing i want to add we're talking about sovereignty and i've thought about
- 2:16:14this a lot. Ultimately, there's only one sovereignty that really matters. That's the
- 2:16:21mental individual sovereignty. Because someone could put me in jail, and I can still retain my
- 2:16:27sovereignty. My sovereignty is not a place I live in. It's a state of being that I exist in. It's the
- 2:16:33expression of my free will. So when it comes to the technology that we're building, we want to not
- 2:16:42create a standard for other people to follow. We simply want to create technology that respects
- 2:16:50the sovereignty of the individual. And we feel that the ripple effects of that will make everybody
- 2:16:55more sovereign, no matter where they are on the spectrum. But if they're not mentally, spiritually,
- 2:17:02within themselves, already sovereign, then there's no amount of sovereignty you can add to somebody
- 2:17:08for that okay before we go then when do you think we'll be able to me i might be able to tinker with
- 2:17:14um your which what was it called archipelago yeah yeah we'll give you a copy today to take with you
- 2:17:21it's uh ready for testing the operating system has been built we're just figuring out the bugs
- 2:17:26and getting it ready for mass adoption which we think will happen soon and what what what um
- 2:17:31hardware would I need? With Archipelago you can run it on an old laptop, you can run it on a brand
- 2:17:38new $3,000 AI server. The functions and the abilities that the the Bitcoin node will have
- 2:17:48will vary depending on the hardware. So if you want to use the mesh network ability no problem
- 2:17:54you've got that. If you want to use AI if it's not powerful enough of a computer that part will be
- 2:18:01grayed out you just won't be able to use it and what just quickly as well for someone who wants
- 2:18:07to get a self-sovereign ai what's the cheapest most efficient option do you have to spend three
- 2:18:13and a half thousand to do it or um what are you using the ai for if someone's using it for word
- 2:18:20processing yeah you can get away with something for 1500 if if you're trying to get a recreation
- 2:18:27of chat gpt you need to get the big one right so you need to be spending about three and a half
- 2:18:33thousand dollars for a piece of hardware and then the rest of it doesn't cost you a thing yeah well
- 2:18:38linux is free if you don't value your time i've heard people say that a lot it's true it is true
- 2:18:46it's why people pay us to program their linux devices right polly thank you great conversation
- 2:18:55This has been fun.
- 2:18:56I'm really interested in what's going on here.
- 2:18:59And you mentioned we can go and see some of the other places.
- 2:19:01I'd love to do that.
- 2:19:04Yeah it great I really like what you got going here And I think it inspiring I think it I don know I not sold on I think it way ahead of its time
- 2:19:16The Bitcoin stuff.
- 2:19:19The living together bit, I love it.
- 2:19:22I think if I was in Austin, I would, this place is incredible.
- 2:19:25I would be in a place like this myself.
- 2:19:28The Bitcoin stuff, I just, having been around for a while,
- 2:19:33I think it's a slow and long process.
- 2:19:37But maybe, hey, maybe AI is the thing that kicks it up the butt and gets it.
- 2:19:41I mean, they're printing more money.
- 2:19:44It's only a matter of time before hyperinflation sets in
- 2:19:47and then Bitcoin really starts to shine.
- 2:19:50But I'd like to leave your listeners with one last thing.
- 2:19:55I want to encourage everybody to plan for decentralization.
- 2:20:01People ask me all the time,
- 2:20:02poly, what's the one thing that people can do to move the needle for web five? And I tell them that
- 2:20:09what they need to do is remove the centralization from their hearts. That is the only thing that
- 2:20:16will change the future. And if you think about building a utopia, let's just pretend one of
- 2:20:23these charter cities starts up and it becomes wildly successful and it's literally a utopia.
- 2:20:29if it doesn't fall apart from within with human drama and the humanity and that whole thing,
- 2:20:39then it's going to be attacked from the outside and plundered.
- 2:20:44I can't think of anywhere that you can build on the earth where eventually it's not going to get swept away.
- 2:20:51So if you're not planning for decentralization, then you're going to have a beginning and an end.
- 2:20:59if you are planning for decentralization,
- 2:21:03when hardship comes, you break into two.
- 2:21:07You split into three.
- 2:21:09Every time the hammer hits the table,
- 2:21:11there's now two, three, four of you.
- 2:21:14And that's really the model that Bitcoin gives us.
- 2:21:17The more that Bitcoin is attacked
- 2:21:19because of its decentralization,
- 2:21:22not only does it withstand it,
- 2:21:24but it actually grows.
- 2:21:26And that's what I would want to encourage
- 2:21:28anyone who's thinking about doing something revolutionary right now if you're listening to
- 2:21:32this and you're building something you're working on on a project that will change the world plan
- 2:21:39for decentralization no matter how good you make it there will be something that comes to sweep it
- 2:21:46away but if it's easily decentralized easily replicatable if anyone can do it just like
- 2:21:53bitcoin downloading some software running it on a computer then it won't ever go away
- 2:21:58perfect that's the title of this episode as well plan for decentralization thank you polly nice to
- 2:22:06meet you you as well and um looking forward to seeing what else you've got going on here but
- 2:22:11thanks very much for inviting me here and absolutely great yeah it was a lot of fun
- 2:22:15this is one of my favorite podcasts that i've done so thank you
- 2:22:18right you made it to the end of the show so i'm gonna go ahead and assume that you got some value
- 2:22:28out of this episode if you want to help the show please follow or subscribe right now it takes only
- 2:22:35two seconds and it massively helps if you've got another 30 seconds well leave a review on apple
- 2:22:43podcasts or Spotify. Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners
- 2:22:49find us. If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on
- 2:22:56fountain.fm for the price of one coffee for a whole month. Or you can support the mission
- 2:23:02by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms or use the Bitcoin and fiat
- 2:23:08donation links in the show notes. Every contribution to the show makes a real difference.
- 2:23:14Believe me. And one more thing, if you know someone who'd love this episode,
- 2:23:19share it directly with them. That personal share beats every algorithm in the book.
- 2:23:23All the links, the community and the newsletter are in the show notes.
- 2:23:28And jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions
- 2:23:35and more that's the new free cities podcast website freecities.fm have a good week and see you next time