Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #17: Week 3 & 4 Recap, New CSR Top 25 and what to look for in Week 5
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:16You're watching or listening to episode number 17.
- 0:19Seeing as I was out on vacation last week, I'll be covering two weeks worth of games in this episode.
- 0:25I'll put the AP poll voters' feet to the fire as necessary, and we'll look at what's to come in week number five.
- 0:32There were 52 undefeated teams heading into week three, and now just 22 teams remain without a loss.
- 0:39With all the new data points we have for each team, we're starting to see one-loss teams earn their way into the CSR top 25.
- 0:46Non-conference schedules are quickly turning over to conference match-ups, and most conference head-to-heads have been decided through just four weeks in the season.
- 0:54This gives us a clear conference hierarchy in 2026 and tells us which wins should receive the most credit for the season.
- 1:02Through week four, the SEC has solidified a winning record against every other conference for the duration of the 2026 season.
- 1:09Oklahoma's week three win gave the SEC a final two and O record against the Mountain West, and although there are still several rivalries with the ACC the final week of the season, the SEC could lose each of those games and still finish over 500 against the ACC.
- 1:23Every other conference is looking up at the ACC in 2026.
- 1:28The Big Ten confirmed their spot as the number two conference this season over the last two weeks.
- 1:33Northwestern's week three win over Colorado gave the Big Ten a two and one record against the Big 12 this season.
- 1:40Indiana's week three win over Western Kentucky was the lone Big Ten Conference USA matchup this season, so the Hoosiers confirmed a seventh conference against which the Big Ten has a winning record, putting it firmly ahead of the ACC and Big 12, but behind the SEC in 2026.
- 1:57The Big 12 is the biggest beneficiary of the last two weeks' results.
- 2:01They went from head-to-head winning records against just two conferences to winning records against six, launching them up into a tie with the ACC as the third-best conference in college football.
- 2:10Coincidentally, it was the final matchup between the Big 12 and ACC that likely had the most impact.
- 2:16A West Virginia win over Virginia in week three locked up that head-to-head in favor of the Big 12.
- 2:22Through week two, the Big 12 had yet to play Conference USA, the MAC, or the Mountain West, but now have winning records over each, which contributed the rest of their substantial rise in the Common Sense Rankings conference standings.
- 2:34The ACC stayed stagnant in the CSR conference rankings, maintaining their head-to-head winning record against six conferences.
- 2:40Had Virginia beaten West Virginia, it w- that would have propelled ACC to the same level as the Big Ten, but they'll have to settle for just a step below their Midwest counterpart.
- 2:50The Sun Belt, courtesy of their wins and their only matchups with the MAC and Mountain West, is the other conference that made strides since week three.
- 2:57They're now tied with the Pac-12 and American as the best conferences in the CSR from the Group of six.
- 3:03The Mountain West, even though they sport two FCS losses, do have a winning record over the MAC and Conference USA, putting them behind that three-way tie at the top of the Group of six.
- 3:13Finally, the MAC managed a surprising winning record against the American Conference this year, and Conference USA was over.500 against the MAC.
- 3:21Those two conferences bring up the rear in the CSR conference rankings.
- 3:27So now that the conference hierarchy is mostly set for the season, let's talk about what that means practically.
- 3:32In the Common Sense Rankings formula, the stronger a conference performs against each of the other conferences, the more a value of a win against that conference is worth, and on the flip side, the less a loss is worth.
- 3:43A good practical exercise then is to see comparable in-conference records in each conference that would give teams similar CSR point totals in twenty twenty-six.
- 3:53We're going to base this model off of a four and five team in the SEC.
- 3:57In the CSR formula, the SEC win is maxed out, so comparing a conference record by a team in each conference can give us an idea of what each team would have to do to match up with a just below five hundred SEC team.
- 4:10A Big Ten team would need to go five and, five and four.
- 4:13That would outperform head-to-head a team from the SEC, which seems about right.
- 4:18The Big Twelve and ACC would also require a five and four record just to match the results from a four and five SEC team, which also feels right.
- 4:27For each of the American, Sun Belt, and Pac-12, the best group of six conferences statistically, a team would need to go six and two to outperform a four and five SEC team.
- 4:37The Mountain West, although a step below the other three, would also require six and two, but would come in just barely above a four and five SEC team.
- 4:45Lastly, a team from the MAC or Conference USA would need to go seven and one in the regular season to have more direct win points than a four and five SEC team.
- 4:55Keep in mind that head-to-head results for each team only account for half of a team's common sense ranking.
- 5:00It also matters how their opponents performed in their other eleven games.
- 5:04That exercise though, the comparing the conferences, at least gives us an idea of the benchmark for each team now that we've hit conference play.
- 5:12Before I launch into the top twenty-five in this week's CSR, let's do a couple resume comparisons.
- 5:17A reminder that we don't care what preseason hype each team had or what their future may hold.
- 5:22This is strictly based on wins and losses up to this point in twenty twenty-six.
- 5:28Our first blind resume test, Team A has a Big Twelve win, an ACC win, and a win over the MAC.
- 5:34Those three teams are a combined seven and five.
- 5:37Team B has a win over an ACC and Conference USA school while having a loss to an SEC team.
- 5:43Those two wins are over teams with zero FBS wins.
- 5:48Team A is Cincinnati, who improved to 4-0 last week with a Big 12 opening win over Kansas State, but only received 20 total votes in this week's poll.
- 5:57Team B is Tennessee, who is ranked 17th and only dropped three spots after their loss to Texas.
- 6:02Notice how I don't mention the conference affiliation of each team.
- 6:06That shouldn't matter when so few conference games have been played.
- 6:09Tennessee would need to perform well in SEC play to outperform Cincinnati's resume this season.
- 6:16Blind resume test number two.
- 6:18Team A has two FBS wins, one over a Big 12 and a Sun Belt team.
- 6:22Those two opponents have combined for just one FBS win between them.
- 6:26Team B has two MAC wins and a Big Ten win, so more FBS victories, and those opponents have three FBS wins.
- 6:34So not only do they have more direct wins, they have more opponent wins as well.
- 6:38Team A in this case is Missouri, who is ranked 25th in the AP poll this week.
- 6:43Team B is Nebraska, who only managed 36 votes.
- 6:48Let's do another.
- 6:49Team A is 4-0 with three FBS wins, one each over the American, Big Ten, and ACC.
- 6:55Those three opponents have a combined five FBS wins.
- 6:59Team B is also undefeated with wins over a Big 12 and Pac-12 team.
- 7:03Those two opponents have combined for three FBS wins.
- 7:06So Team A has more wins directly, more quality wins, and those opponents have had more success thus far, so they should be ranked, right?
- 7:15Team A is Duke, who is just outside the top 25 in the AP poll this week, while Team B is BYU, who just took an early week bye and is ranked number 10 in the AP poll one more fun one.
- 7:27Team A is three and one with a loss to the Big Ten, but wins over the American and the MAC.
- 7:31The two teams they've beat have three FBS wins.
- 7:35Team B is four and O with wins over Conference USA, Pac-12, and Sun Belt, but opponents have combined for two FBS wins.
- 7:42This one is a little closer, but according to poll voters, one is clearly better than the other.
- 7:46Team A is Boise State, the clear-cut CFP favorite from the group of six, while Team B is James Madison, a CFP qualifier last year and a team focused on winning each of their remaining games this year.
- 7:57JMU received precisely zero AP votes in this past week's poll.
- 8:02So what does the top twenty-five in the CSR look like?
- 8:05With the SEC sitting as top dog in the conference rankings, any team with SEC wins is going to push their way to the top.
- 8:12With four teams having started two and O in the SEC, you'd think it'd be one of those teams, but you would be wrong.
- 8:18The number one team matches the AP poll in this week's rankings, the Texas Longhorns.
- 8:23While they have fewer points gained from direct wins, it's the quality of their opponents they've defeated that sets them apart.
- 8:29We all know they beat Ohio State, who sits three and one with three wins over FBS competition.
- 8:34Two of the Longhorns opponents, Texas State and UTSA, actually played each other, which hurts Texas, but UTSA sits at three and one while Texas State is two and two.
- 8:43Finally, Tennessee sits three and one with a win over the ACC.
- 8:47Put all of that into the CSR formula and Texas is atop this week's rankings.
- 8:52Numbers two through four are all SEC teams with two in-conference wins.
- 8:56In order, number two is Mississippi State, followed by Alabama and Florida.
- 9:01Where the Bulldogs and Tide separate themselves from the Gators is the lack of FCS opponent thus far.
- 9:07Starting four and O against FBS teams give both Mississippi State and Alabama the nod over Florida.
- 9:12Mississippi State is number two courtesy of their win over Minnesota compared to Alabama's victory over Florida State because a Big Ten win carries slightly more weight than an ACC win.
- 9:22Florida at number four has the best opponent wins right now.
- 9:25Each of their opponents' only loss was to the Gators, and they have two wins over CSR-ranked teams in Auburn and Ole Miss.
- 9:31Their win over Florida Atlantic in week one is also weighty as the Owls are just outside the CSR top twenty-five.
- 9:39Notre Dame rounds out the top five courtesy of their three Big Ten wins plus their dub over Rice from the American.
- 9:45While the quality of their opponents' conference is high, the quality of their opponents' other performances is substantially lower than those teams above them The rest of the top 10, we have two under-ranked teams at numbers six and seven with UCLA and Duke.
- 9:59ACC favorite Miami is number eight in the CSR.
- 10:03The Bulldogs sit at number nine with their two SEC wins.
- 10:06Utah rounds out the top 10 as the top-ranked team in the Big 12.
- 10:10Utah's win over Arkansas is carrying them to a top 10 ranking as they're the only undefeated team from another conference to have an ACE-- SEC win.
- 10:18The rest of the top 25 are as follows: 11 is Iowa, 12 is Southern Cal, more on them in a minute.
- 10:24Number 13, Cincinnati, 14 and 15 play each other.
- 10:2714 is Virginia Tech, 15 is Pittsburgh, 16 is Ole Miss, 17 LSU, 18 Auburn, 19 Texas Tech, 20 Indiana, 21 Nebraska, 22 James Madison, the top group of 16 in the CSR, 23 is North Dakota State, Clemson is 24, and South Florida rounds out the top 25.
- 10:48If you'd like to see the complete one through 138 ranking, you can go to commonsensrankings.com.
- 10:52In the CSR this week, we have eight SEC teams, five Big Ten, five ACC, three Big 12, plus Notre Dame, and one each from the American, Mountain West, and Sun Belt.
- 11:05How does that compare to the AP poll?
- 11:06The SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 are all overvalued, as we see more teams in the AP top 25 than have earned it.
- 11:13The ACC, however, is significantly undervalued with only two in the AP top 25.
- 11:19Boise State is the lone group of six rep in this week's AP poll, but they shouldn't be ranked either.
- 11:24James Madison, North Dakota State, and South Florida each, I would argue, have put together better resumes thus far in 2026 than the Broncos.
- 11:33With just 22 remaining undefeated teams in college football, 20 of them are ranked in this week's CSR.
- 11:39BYU, mostly due to their early bye week, sit at three and O and just outside the top 25, while UMass, while four and O, has only two wins against FBS competition, meaning we'll need to see more from the Minutemen going forward.
- 11:54Our Common Sense Rankings College Football Playoff bracket stands as thus after four weeks of play.
- 11:59Four SEC teams get the byes, and if you think this is SEC bias, please refer to earlier in this podcast.
- 12:05Texas, Mississippi State, Alabama, and Florida, we will see you in the quarterfinals.
- 12:09First round matchups would be number five Notre Dame versus number 12 James Madison as the Group of 6 representative.
- 12:15Number six UCLA versus number 11 Iowa, a Big Ten matchup.
- 12:19Number seven Duke hosting number 10 Utah.
- 12:22And number eight Miami playing host to number nine Georgia, which would be fire.
- 12:26The first teams to miss out are Southern Cal, Cincinnati, and Virginia Tech.
- 12:32Let's go back and talk a little bit about Southern Cal.
- 12:34That is the biggest oddity in the CSR this week, as they are at number 12 while Oregon is unranked sitting at number 32.
- 12:42Given that Oregon just beat USC, many armchair rankers likely think that necessitates the Ducks being above the Trojans.
- 12:49But here at the CSR, it's the totality of the resume that matters, not just the lone head-to-head game.
- 12:55So let's dive into each team's resume thus far.
- 12:57I'm going to intentionally leave opponents' names blank.
- 13:02has four FBS wins, one against the Big Ten, the second-best conference, one against the Sun Belt and the Pac-12, both of which are tied for the best Group of 6 conference, and then one more against the Mountain West.
- 13:12Their lone loss is to a Big Ten team.
- 13:15Oregon, meanwhile, has two FBS wins, so two fewer, one against the Big Ten and one against the Pac-12, and their loss came against a Big 12 team.
- 13:23So looking just at wins, they both have wins against the Big Ten and Pac-12, but USC also has wins against the Sun Belt and Mountain West.
- 13:31Early in the season, that's a drastic head-to-head difference in favor of Southern Cal.
- 13:35Additionally, losing to a Big Ten school loses fewer points for USC than does Oregon's loss to a Big 12 team since the Big Ten is higher in the conference rankings than the Big 12.
- 13:45If we look at opponent performance in other games, USC's and Oregon's opponents are contributing roughly equal points to each team's CSR.
- 13:53So if we take team names out of it and look at the conferences of the opponents as well as the success of the opponents, USC sits higher than Oregon at this point in the season in the Common Sense Rankings.
- 14:06As we turn our attention to the AP poll, they correctly ranked 15 of the top 25 this week, so a slight improvement over previous iterations.
- 14:13And they can claim to have put the best resume at number one in the Texas Longhorns.
- 14:18Other positives, Mississippi State is ranked.
- 14:20We like that.
- 14:21They got six of the top 10 right, but it got bad quickly after that.
- 14:25Lastly, there are no two-loss teams ranked, which agrees with the Common Sense Rankings.
- 14:32Negatives, still no Duke, which is nearly criminal at this point.
- 14:36They got a Group of 6 team in there in Boise State, but the CSR has three, James Madison at 22, North Dakota State at 23, and South Florida at 25 Let's take a look at how each voter did in comparison with the CSR.
- 14:53A couple of good ballots.
- 14:55We had Mississippi State, while they had the second-best resume according to the Common Sense rankings.
- 15:00In most AP ballots, they were somewhere between 14 and 19.
- 15:04The highest any poll voter had them was number 11, so we wanted to specifically mention Pat Welter, Ian Cress, and Javon Edmonds for their appraisal of the Bulldogs.
- 15:14Next up, Sarah Hughes and Tom Murphy.
- 15:16Duke just missed a ranking this week, but it wasn't due to these two.
- 15:19They were the highest on the Blue Devils, the CSR number seven, and put them at number 18.
- 15:24Hopefully, their colleagues soon follow suit.
- 15:26I'm back to Javon Edmonds' ballot, as he was the only voter to give a spot to both James Madison and North Dakota State, the top two group of six teams in the CSR.
- 15:35That deserves a special call-out.
- 15:38Some of the bad ballots, uh, Louisville sits at two and two with just a single win over an FBS school, yet Kirk Bowles claims that makes them the 18th best team in the country.
- 15:47Something isn't quite adding up.
- 15:49Next, Bob Ballow is the lone voter to have Indiana as the number one team.
- 15:53I know they won the national championship last year, but this is a new season.
- 15:57Anything that happened before August 2026 was meant to be discarded and we start fresh.
- 16:02They are four and O with three FBS wins, but those three teams have a combined two FBS wins to their name.
- 16:08Will they be one of the best teams at the end of the season?
- 16:10Maybe, but their resume is not deserving of the number one spot right now.
- 16:16Lastly, the team that is lowest in the CSR that got an AP rank is SMU.
- 16:20Two FBS wins and a loss to two and two Louisville ain't cutting it in the Common Sense rankings.
- 16:25I'll call out Brian Fonseca as he had the Mustangs higher than any other voter at number 16 With conference play dominating the rest of the college football calendar, most conference head-to-heads are already wrapped up.
- 16:37There are, however, a couple key match-ups we're watching in week five that could change the college football landscape in the common sense rankings.
- 16:44First, the ACC plays the Mountain West just twice this season and won the first match-up in week zero when Stanford beat Hawaii.
- 16:51The second match-up happens this weekend when California heads to Vegas to take on UNLV.
- 16:57A California win would maintain the ACC's stance as the third-best conference tied with the Big 12.
- 17:02But a run-and-rebels win would mean the Mountain West and ACC split their two match-ups this year, lowering the value of the ACC in the eyes of the CSR and putting them below the Big 12 for the rest of the season.
- 17:14The Big 12, meanwhile, currently sits at one and O against Conference USA, with the second match-up between the two occurring in week five when Kansas plays host to Middle Tennessee on ESPNU at twelve noon Eastern.
- 17:26Similar to the importance of Cal's game for the ACC, Kansas needs to beat the Blue Raiders to confirm the Big 12's superiority over CUSA on the field in twenty twenty-six.
- 17:36A Jayhawks loss, on the other hand, would put the season series at one and one between the two conferences, giving the Big 12 just five conferences against which they have winning records and putting each team in the Big 12 farther behind the SEC and the Big Ten this season.
- 17:50The American and Mountain West head-to-head could be settled this weekend.
- 17:53The American are currently two and O, halfway through their season series, and the Commander-in-Chief trophy will end up deciding it.
- 17:59Air Force of the Mountain West will face Navy of the American in week five, and a Midshipman dub would solidify the Americans' dominance over the Mountain West and lock them into their spot among the best group of six conferences in twenty twenty-six.
- 18:13Five teams in the CSR top 25 will be on bye in week five.
- 18:17A sixth, LSU, plays an FCS team.
- 18:20The number one team, the Texas Longhorns, are also on bye this week, meaning we're going to have a new number one in the CSR following this week's games, and we'll likely see quite a bit of turnover from this week to next.
- 18:32A few ranked CSR match-ups in week five include the number two CSR team, Mississippi State, hosting the number three CSR team in Alabama this week at 12 noon Eastern on ABC.
- 18:44With the number one team on bye, the winner of that match-up will move to number one in next week's Common Sense rankings.
- 18:51CSR number eight, Miami, is visiting number 24, Clemson.
- 18:55That is in prime time on ABC Saturday night.
- 18:58A big one in the ACC title race occurs Friday with CSR number 14, Virginia Tech, taking on number 15, Pittsburgh.
- 19:05If the Hurricanes were to falter against Clemson, the winner of that game would take over as the best team in the ACC in the Common Sense rankings.
- 19:13While both teams aren't ranked in the CSR, a couple of AP ranked match-ups include Ohio State against Iowa at 3:30 on CBS, and Florida against Missouri at 3:30 on ABC.
- 19:25With our conference rankings all but solidified, SEC teams will continue to lead the CSR as conference play deepens.
- 19:31Unless the SEC cannibalizes itself and the conference champion has two losses or more, then the top team in the CSR at the end of the season will almost certainly be an SEC school.
- 19:41An undefeated Big Ten champ could, however, have a path to the top if the SEC does produce a two-loss champion.
- 19:47Thank you for listening to episode 17 of the CSR podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 19:53If you want more access to Common Sense Rankings content, please give me a follow on the socials@comsenseranking.
- 20:00You can also see updated rankings throughout each week at commonsensrankings.com.
- 20:04Thank you again for listening, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense