Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Baker Hughes pensions, heat pump wonders, and Prax in Shetland
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:06podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:10the UK energy market. This week we heard that Baker
- 0:15Hughes was potentially making some people redundant over a
- 0:19pension scheme overhaul and Drax isn't sinking a power station.
- 0:25But first, I should probably introduce myself.
- 0:27I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, and joining me this week
- 0:30is our fearless leader, our news editor, Erika Askel.
- 0:34And how are you this week, Erika?
- 0:36Thank you. Feeling fearless because hey,
- 0:39you know, why not? How are you?
- 0:41Yeah, not bad, not bad. Our she's Our Lady with the
- 0:45lamp. She sort of guides the way.
- 0:47You know, I don't know why I went for Florence Nightingale as
- 0:51the reference, but that's what we're going for.
- 0:53She keeps, you know, she keeps us, right?
- 0:55Healing powers and as well. So yeah.
- 0:58Yeah, we'll, we'll go with that. We'll go with that.
- 1:02And you know, yeah, I'm doing all right.
- 1:04I'm doing fine. It's been, it's been really
- 1:06well. The weather was really nice over
- 1:07the weekend in Aberdeen, which was lovely.
- 1:09It got some work done in the garden but it it's kind of
- 1:13tailed off a little bit, something that our London
- 1:15colleagues I'm sure, wish was happening with them as they melt
- 1:19in their offices. Wow.
- 1:21See, I mean, sometimes I find they are like weather conditions
- 1:27up here in Aberdeen, nice and moist and cool and you feel a
- 1:32little bit smug when you're seeing your london-based
- 1:34colleagues melting basically in front of your eyes.
- 1:37But then of course, sometimes you just wish you want it.
- 1:40You just got a little bit more vitamin D, mainly just because,
- 1:43you know, I do think we're sometimes at risk of getting
- 1:45scurvy up here. I, I completely agree we need to
- 1:49start chewing on limes, but we, we should probably move on from
- 1:54our London colleagues that are feeling hot to Baker Hughes
- 1:58getting hot into the collar. After we, we seen, we, we saw
- 2:04some internal, internal documents from, from the firm
- 2:08this week essentially saying that they were overhauling their
- 2:11pension scheme and that folks that don't agree with the
- 2:16results of a consultation that's being held with employees will
- 2:21face dismissal. Now this, this was something we
- 2:24reported earlier in the week and we've, you know, had some back
- 2:27and forth about what that actually means and what's going
- 2:30on. But essentially I'll I'll give
- 2:32you the skinny and we can get into the details and what what
- 2:35we think about it. The one concerned Aberdeen
- 2:40worker explained that essentially it's a 25% reduction
- 2:44in pension contributions. Now Baker Hughes in the internal
- 2:47document said that it can no longer afford the £34 million
- 2:52per year that it's a UK retirement savings plan is
- 2:56costing that. That same worker explained that
- 3:01Baker Hughes provided advanced provided and I quote advanced
- 3:05notice of redundancies to 4500 people across the UK if as
- 3:11employees we fail to agree to new pension terms.
- 3:16So that's quite stark words. Now Baker Hughes has contested
- 3:19the fact that there's a there's going to be any jobs at risk.
- 3:23They say that that's not quite accurate language because
- 3:26there's also a fire and rehire sort of process detailed under
- 3:30under the document that we were sent.
- 3:33Now how how this works is essentially if employees aren't
- 3:37happy with the results of the consultation which are currently
- 3:40taking place, it will span 60 days.
- 3:43If they're not happy with the the results of the the pension
- 3:46changes, they, they will be dismissed, but then they can be
- 3:51immediately rehired under new terms.
- 3:53Now unions have long since rallied against fire and rehire
- 3:58policies for many, many different reasons.
- 4:01You know, namely, if, if, if there's, if there's redundancies
- 4:04in the future, someone's, someone's package is obviously
- 4:08going to be much, you know, much reduced if they've, you know,
- 4:11just technically joined the company and they've, although
- 4:13they've been there for years. So a lot, there's a lot of
- 4:18nuance. This is a lot that are going on.
- 4:20But Erica, you're actually on our pension board and I thought
- 4:25you could maybe provide a little bit of, a little bit of
- 4:28background on how you think this process is being conducted
- 4:32because it's, it feels unusual to say we're changing it.
- 4:37It I, I described it like yesterday sort of just behind
- 4:41closed doors, just chatting a little bit about it almost feels
- 4:44like they've put a gun on the table and when you're going to.
- 4:46Agree. You know that's a very good
- 4:49comparison. Yeah.
- 4:50So I'm, I'm a a pension fund trustee and I kind of think
- 4:56these and, and, and actually I've, I've, I've been in, you
- 5:01know, put through a few redundancy situations as well.
- 5:05And quite frankly, you know, kind of this just seems like
- 5:08such hard ass tactics. I mean, you know, it just is
- 5:12really, you know, kind of too strong, I think.
- 5:17I mean, and I was actually even speaking to my husband about
- 5:20this. He's a another veteran of a, a
- 5:23number of corporate restructurings and changes in
- 5:27pension discussions and, and that sort of stuff.
- 5:30And I said, is it usual for someone to say, you know, you're
- 5:36all being made redundant in order so that, you know, you can
- 5:39sign up to new terms under the pension legislation?
- 5:43And he's like, like, what, what kind of crazy stuff is that?
- 5:47And it's just like, you know what, It's just, it just sounds
- 5:49like bullying, frankly. And you know, like there's no
- 5:52negotiation. There's no discussion here
- 5:55unless you know, kind of like, you know, you sign up to the new
- 5:59reduced pension terms or you probably don't get rehired
- 6:03again, which just is like crazy. So anyway, I, I think it's bad.
- 6:07I think it looks strong armed. I don't know if it's because,
- 6:11you know, that's just how Americans do business, you know?
- 6:15You know, it's just one of those things.
- 6:16Yeah, it's, it's interesting, isn't it?
- 6:17Because you know, they've, they've said that they're going
- 6:21for this Sapp fire and rehire policy, but in that same
- 6:25literature that details the fire and rehire sort of thing that
- 6:28they're going for, they say that we're not planning on using
- 6:33this. We're just offering it for legal
- 6:35reasons. We have to.
- 6:36We have legal reason. Yeah, I know.
- 6:39Weasel words, Really. So it's like, right, So, so
- 6:43there is no, there's no jobs at risk.
- 6:45But if people dis, you know, decide not to agree to the new
- 6:49pension terms, they get dismissed and that's when the
- 6:53fire and rehire policy comes in. But they don't want to use the
- 6:57fire and rehire policy and they're only offering it for
- 6:59legal reasons. It feels a bit contradictory to
- 7:02me. Now, I get that.
- 7:05Yeah, like I say, technically if you look at things as that
- 7:08policy is in place, the jobs aren't at risk unless people
- 7:12choose to walk away sort of thing.
- 7:14But then that's also offering a thing of, well, if people are
- 7:16choosing to not sign up and walk away, does that mean they don't
- 7:19get redundancy packages? Obviously, the firm's not going
- 7:22to tell us too much on. That although remember, remember
- 7:25there was, you know that, yeah, they've kind of gone radio
- 7:27silent again. But I kind of think, you know,
- 7:30there's, there's two processes here.
- 7:32You were speaking to a union representative about this, you
- 7:35know, about the timings and of course this consultation lasts
- 7:3960 days, which is more kind of what you'd expect, you know,
- 7:42when it comes to pension negotiations.
- 7:44But of course also you're looking at when you're handing
- 7:48out these H21 forms or submitting H21 forms to the UK
- 7:54government, the Insolvency Service, when you're putting
- 7:57jobs at risk, that's a 90 day window that you have to do that.
- 8:02So I do think what's going on here is that, you know, you've
- 8:06got the 60 days process, you know, whereby you can decide
- 8:10whether or not you take a reduced pension or, you know,
- 8:14like look or look down the barrel of the gun on the table
- 8:18or. And then, you know, therefore,
- 8:20you know, there's if there's a need to implement the redundancy
- 8:26process, depending on, you know, whether or not you've chosen to
- 8:30accept door one, then you're still within, you know, the
- 8:34window through which the company has applied to the Insolvency
- 8:39Service to take on redundancies. So I mean, like honestly, like
- 8:43what are these, you know, situations like, I mean,
- 8:46they're, it's all very legal. It's just maybe a little bit
- 8:50unseemly. Yeah, it's definitely all above
- 8:52board there, at least from, from my understanding.
- 8:54Obviously neither of us are lawyers, but having looked at
- 8:57the documents provided by by a contact and it does seem, it
- 9:02does seem like everything is above board.
- 9:04However, like you say, it just feels a little bit like a strong
- 9:07arm tactic. It feels a little bit like, you
- 9:09know, we're changing this and that's, that's that.
- 9:12And I get that, you know, the, the contributions of Baker
- 9:16Hughes is, you know, it is quite high compared to even its
- 9:19contemporaries, even compared to other oil and gas firms or
- 9:23energy businesses in general. It's, you know, and under the
- 9:27reduction it's still going to be a fairly, you know, fairly
- 9:30generous pension contribution. However, that's not the point.
- 9:34The point is these people signed their contracts, they joined the
- 9:38company under certain terms and now they're being told, well,
- 9:42that's not happening anymore. And if you don't agree, agree to
- 9:46new terms, Cheerio is essentially how I see it.
- 9:50And that's that's how it boils down.
- 9:53Yeah, well, I mean, you know, pensions is, you know,
- 9:56employment incentives that of course, you know, is really
- 9:59useful A to attract and retain staff.
- 10:03But also, you know, like it's not something that should be
- 10:07done, you know, whimsically or changed whimsically because this
- 10:12a lot of people will, well, a lot of people should be thinking
- 10:16in the long term and, you know, kind of factoring into, you
- 10:20know, their factoring their pension contributions and the
- 10:22contributions that they're receiving from employers into
- 10:25kind of like a long term plan. You know, for some people, you
- 10:28know, this could make the difference between, you know,
- 10:30retiring at 55 or 60 or whatever, you know, I mean, and
- 10:35that's the sort of thing that you just think, well, you know,
- 10:39to meddle about with that is kind of a a big, big thing, you
- 10:44know, But I guess Baker Hughes's needs to haircut, you know, it's
- 10:49pension contributions, needs to save a bit of cash,
- 10:53streamlining. There's lots of stuff going on
- 10:56here. Yeah, it's a multi faceted 1 and
- 10:58I'm sure we're going to have further updates over the next 60
- 11:02days or so and probably beyond. So that probably does it for
- 11:06this, but we're going to move on from Baker Hughes sinking its
- 11:10pensions to a man that knew all about floating after the short
- 11:14break. So up next, our renewables
- 11:54reporter Michael Baer was out at the Lothian School of Technology
- 11:58to speak to Syncrestore. Let's hear what they had to say.
- 12:02Hi, I'm Michael Baer. I'm the renewables reporter for
- 12:06Energy Voice. And today I am coming to you
- 12:08from the Lothian School of Technology.
- 12:11I'm speaking with Alexis Dole. He is the Chief Technology
- 12:15Officer for Syncrestore. Alexis, you've just taken me on
- 12:20a tour of the the workshop here at the Lothian School of
- 12:24Technology where you're developing a new gas compressor.
- 12:27And you've been talking to me about the technology, about the
- 12:31company, and about how this this gas compressor fits into the
- 12:35energy transition. I think to start with, you know.
- 12:39To let's just. Talk a bit about the company and
- 12:43where it came from. Would you mind just telling me a
- 12:45little bit about it's Synchro store and it's history?
- 12:47Well, first of all, Michael, thanks for coming.
- 12:49It's great to great to have you here today during the open day
- 12:52of the Louisian School of Technology.
- 12:55Yeah. So Synchro store actually
- 12:57originates from a technology called digital displacement,
- 13:00which was developed for hydraulic machines.
- 13:04So I've been working on this technology for over 15 years and
- 13:07we, we applied it to wind turbine transmission and lately
- 13:13with for the mobile market. So developing hydraulic machine,
- 13:17very efficient hydraulic machines for the mobile market
- 13:20like escalators and and forklift.
- 13:24And the founder of Synchrosource is the Professor Wyn Rampam.
- 13:27He is also the the chair of energy storage at the at
- 13:31Edinburgh University and in 2017 it founded a synchro storm
- 13:36basically to use a very similar concept of machine, this
- 13:40compressor machine to generate high temperature heat and to and
- 13:45to be used for large scale heat storage, which can be used for
- 13:51storing electricity as form of heat and then generate
- 13:54electricity again. So synchrotor was actually came
- 13:58from from Android University in 2017 and we we went through a
- 14:03large phase of growth after gaining a contract from the
- 14:06Department of Energy Security and Mesio in 2022 to develop a
- 14:11MW scale demonstrator of our panthermal energy storage, which
- 14:16we are actually building here in our facilities in Lonehead.
- 14:19So this is kind of background there.
- 14:21Like I said, you just took me on a tour of your workshop and I
- 14:24got to see some of the machines that you were working on and
- 14:27it's obviously the, the, the compressor expander is very,
- 14:31very much what sinker store's been working on recently.
- 14:35You know, we chatted about heat pumps.
- 14:37Now, as I pointed out, most people when we think of heat
- 14:40pumps, we think of home storage units.
- 14:42Now what's the thought of the, the talk around them as based
- 14:47around their efficiency? They're kind of they're
- 14:49temperature limited. So I think you said it was about
- 14:51100°, which is fine for a home unit.
- 14:54Admittedly, I wouldn't want to heat my home up to 100°, but for
- 14:59industrial uses that is simply not not quite enough.
- 15:05So could you talk a bit more about this compressor expander
- 15:09and how it works and sort of what it can be used for?
- 15:15Yeah. So the magic about heat pumps is
- 15:17that they don't actually generate heat that they used to
- 15:19move heat from a a source like the atmosphere or water or
- 15:23source of waste heat to a higher temperature.
- 15:27And they use everywhere. We have some in our fridges, in
- 15:30our home heating devices, but also in industry to generate
- 15:34heat for a number of applications.
- 15:36But heat pumps are limited to the temperature by the
- 15:40compressor units actually. So the maximum temperature heat
- 15:44pumps can reach today is in the range of hundred 120° C, but
- 15:48there's a, a large portion of the, the, the, the industrial
- 15:52heat requirements which is beyond 100°.
- 15:55So about 2030% of the heat requirements of the industry is
- 15:59between 100 and 400° C. So we need a new new type of
- 16:04compressors to be able to reach this, this higher temperature.
- 16:07And that's what Cinco Store is is trying to do here.
- 16:09You know, I think when we look at the energy transition and as
- 16:12we move away from fossil fuels, the electrification is very much
- 16:18touted as being the solution for a lot of our energy needs, you
- 16:22know, for transport, for a lot of industrial purposes.
- 16:26But hydrogen is very much seen as kind of filling some of those
- 16:31gaps, especially for high temperature industrial
- 16:33processes. It sounds as if your compressor
- 16:37is basically going to eat into some of the the usage of
- 16:41hydrogen for these kind of industrial processes.
- 16:44I mean, what? What kind of processes could
- 16:47your compressor be used for? Yeah.
- 16:50So industrial heat is is used everywhere.
- 16:52So we're in Scotland and for example whiskey distillery needs
- 16:56a lot of heat. Most industrial application are
- 17:01actually using a lot of heat at temperatures ranging from 50°
- 17:06all the way to to 500° in. So heat pumps are the most
- 17:11efficient way of generating heat.
- 17:12The other what we call a coefficient of five months above
- 17:153, which means that one unit of electricity will generate 3
- 17:19units of heat. While hydrogen can be used for
- 17:24higher temperature application but the efficiency is is is much
- 17:27lower. So one unit of heat generated by
- 17:311 unit of energy from hydrogen will generate less than a unit
- 17:34of heat in an industrial application.
- 17:37So if you can reach high temperature with your your heat
- 17:40pump, you can basically make a lower cost of energy for for the
- 17:44industrial application. And therefore heat pumps will be
- 17:49more competitive against hydrogen hydrogen solutions.
- 17:52So we think we think heat pumps is is the future for industrial
- 17:55heat decarbonisation and synchronous always able to
- 17:59increase the temperature range of of compressors and will will
- 18:04yes start eating into the into the to the higher temperature
- 18:08industrial application. OK, As a journalist, I always
- 18:12like making, trying to get my guests to make predictions about
- 18:15the future and talking about very hypothetical technology.
- 18:21Could you give me an idea of maybe if there is there a
- 18:23ceiling to how high and how efficient heat pumps could go?
- 18:28Is it a case that there's always going to be a, A use for sort of
- 18:32fossil fuels and hydrogen or is there a case that in your
- 18:37opinion, heat pumps could actually go all the way and
- 18:39basically replace everything? Admittedly, you know I'm asking
- 18:43you to get your crystal ball, but I'm always interesting
- 18:46interested to get your your thoughts on it.
- 18:48No, I think it's quite a simple answer.
- 18:50So heat pumps efficiency depends on the temperature increase of
- 18:55of your process. So there is limitation at which
- 18:58temperature you can use heat pumps.
- 19:00So physically as well heat pumps will have limitation in the
- 19:04maximum temperature that can reach.
- 19:06But the efficiency with the competitivity of heat pumps
- 19:11really depends on the efficiency of the process.
- 19:15So for higher temperature application, for example to make
- 19:19steel or concrete, heat pumps are unlikely to be competitive
- 19:23and other sources of energy would be required.
- 19:26Hydrogen could be one direct electrification.
- 19:28There's a number of technology which could be used.
- 19:31It's unlikely that heat pumps would play a major role for the
- 19:33very high temperature application.
- 19:35But what we see is that for for many application below 400° C,
- 19:39there's actually a lot of waste heat available in the industry
- 19:43and that's waste heat can be used by heat pumps to improve
- 19:46the coefficient performance, reduce the the the operating
- 19:50cost of the of heat pumps. So we think up to 304 hundred
- 19:53degree heat pumps are going to be the dominating technology in
- 19:56the future. And, you know, let's bring
- 19:58things back to the the here and now instead of hypotheticals.
- 20:03What's next for Synchro Store because what you showed me out
- 20:07in in your workshop it's, it seems like you've basically got
- 20:11a working a working version ready to go.
- 20:14What is kind of the next step for Synchro Store's technology
- 20:18and for the company? Yeah.
- 20:20So we, we really proud of our can do attitude at at Synco
- 20:24store. So we, we, we like making
- 20:26machine and breaking them and, and try again, again and again
- 20:29until, until they work and they're reliable.
- 20:31We actually have a long history of bringing technology from low
- 20:35TRL all the way to mass production.
- 20:38And we, we have this past now with, with, with, with the
- 20:41technology we're developing. So we, we have a fully
- 20:44functional machine. So yesterday that, that machine
- 20:47was actually making gas at over 300° C, which is quite
- 20:52impressive. There's not many machines
- 20:54available on the markets able to do that.
- 20:57And what we want to do next is really go into manufacturability
- 21:02of, of the machine. So get, get, improve the
- 21:05manufacturability of the machine, improve the reliability
- 21:08and, and enter the market as quickly as possible.
- 21:11And we, we're looking for partners to, to be able to test
- 21:15this machine in the field as soon as next year.
- 21:18And of course, we're looking for investment to allow us to move
- 21:22very quickly into, into the field and and yeah, help help
- 21:26decarbonize our economies. Excellent.
- 21:28Well, thank you very much for speaking with me, Alexis.
- 21:30It was great to be here. So from a story about staying
- 21:33afloat to one of sinking yet again, we've been up and down
- 21:38this week. We're going to be speaking about
- 21:40practice after this break. So finally, Erica, you've been
- 22:38speaking about Prax and what's happening here in Shetland, but
- 22:42you know this, this has been a long running thing.
- 22:46You've you've now got further details.
- 22:47Please tell me what's going on. I do, I do.
- 22:50Well, so Prax Group is the kind of interesting mystery buyer
- 22:57that moved into the North Sea in 2023 when it bought Hurricane
- 23:02Energy. Do you remember that company?
- 23:03It was a listed West of Shetland entity.
- 23:06It was all about, I don't know, fractured basement play, which
- 23:11is oil and gas producing asset anyway.
- 23:14So they came in, they bought that.
- 23:17It was an AIM listed company. It was kind of like having a bit
- 23:19of trouble. Then, you know, they bought the
- 23:24Total energies West of Shetland assets including the Shetland
- 23:28gas plant, which of course if anyone's visited Solemn Bow is
- 23:31sits on part of that site and is a part of that mix takes a lot
- 23:36of gas from the West of Shetland assets that Total also owned and
- 23:43which agreed to sell to Prax. Now Prax of course hit the
- 23:49headlines just this week when it turns out because they also own
- 23:53the Lindsay Oil refinery on the Humber that they basically were
- 24:01being forced to liquidate that asset as well as a few storage
- 24:04sites. And that is a big deal.
- 24:07It's you know, over like hundreds of people work at this
- 24:10refinery. It's one of, you know, following
- 24:12Grangemouth, it's one of the last five refineries in the UK.
- 24:17So an ever dwindling number of means in which to kind of handle
- 24:22and process oil and gas from the North Sea.
- 24:25And of course they funnily enough bought that from Total
- 24:29Energies just in 2021. And you're just going to think,
- 24:34OK, so they it's an interesting company, but so I think now and
- 24:40they have of course several entities.
- 24:42So I have to be a little bit careful here.
- 24:44But basically, you know the company which owns the Lindsay
- 24:50oil refinery, that one into liquidation, the company which
- 24:55owns Prax Group is in administration and it's being
- 25:01handled by 10 AO. So they're the administrators
- 25:04and they're looking to sell all sorts of assets.
- 25:07Now of course, the upstream business which includes
- 25:12Hurricane Energy is not an administration, but it looks
- 25:16like it's up for sale. But what I found out as well,
- 25:20because I thought Total Energies, I was always trying to
- 25:23figure out how much they actually sold the Shetland gas
- 25:27plant to Prax 4 as well as the Lagantermoor area assets.
- 25:34And I can never get it. And you always think, well,
- 25:36it'll show up one of these days on like the quarterly stock
- 25:40market updates, you know that Total Energies do.
- 25:46But then it turns out that the deal hadn't actually completed.
- 25:49So, you know, I guess if you're one of those people working up
- 25:54at the Shetland Gas plant or on one of the assets out and lag
- 25:58into a more, nothing has changed And you know, the new ownership
- 26:03is not going to take place or you know, if it does, I'll be
- 26:06really surprised just because it's still owned by Total
- 26:09Energies. That's quite interesting, isn't
- 26:12it, because obviously, yeah, the deal, the deal to sell
- 26:14especially the the share and the the gas terminal was.
- 26:18As big shock. Widely it was it was widely
- 26:20reported at the time and it kind of it, it almost feels like
- 26:24maybe I'm wrong about this. This is kind of off the top of
- 26:26my head, but it does feel a little bit like that was the
- 26:29first domino in the sort of string of dominoes to fall in
- 26:35total trying to sort of vacate the UK.
- 26:37And we've seen a lot of assets are be sold off.
- 26:39And so it's quite interesting that the first deal that went
- 26:45through for Total or the first one that was proposed and widely
- 26:49reported about it trying to sort of shell off some of his UK
- 26:53assets is the one that's fallen through.
- 26:56And it's the one that it's still stuck out in Shetland.
- 26:59And but you mean to be fair, West of Shetland isn't a a bad
- 27:03place to be in terms of the UK basin.
- 27:05It's probably one of the. Same more interesting areas West
- 27:09of Shetland. Remember, you know, where we've
- 27:11got Rosebank out there, we've got all that, you know, kind of
- 27:14hopefully, maybe fingers crossed coming aboard.
- 27:17You know, this could be a big revitalization for Shetland and
- 27:21the gas plant, you know, particularly, you know, but and,
- 27:26but you're right in terms of the timing, in terms of like the,
- 27:30you know, as David Murzai over at SP Angel said, you know, it
- 27:36was one of those things that was going on in terms of sales.
- 27:40When, oh, how did he put it in? He was looking at, you know, the
- 27:47they were trying to sell, you know, because of course,
- 27:50remember at that time too, they'd just been revealed as
- 27:52like the biggest taxpayer in the North Sea just because, you
- 27:56know, they had all they were just kind of came the wrong side
- 27:58of the balance sheet and the windfall tax EPL.
- 28:01And basically, you know, Patrick Pruyan was on the record often
- 28:06speaking in other areas going fed up with the North Sea gonna
- 28:09sell lots of stuff. Not everything, but you know,
- 28:13certainly, you know, one of their historic assets.
- 28:15But of course, you know, the I was talking about David Murzai
- 28:21and he said that, you know, there's at the time, you know,
- 28:24that large companies are were looking to exit their UK
- 28:27positions. There was limited credible buyer
- 28:30universe, which is like kind of like a a rude thing to say about
- 28:34Prax. Now, of course, Prax is
- 28:36interesting because it was set up by like this husband and wife
- 28:40team. And actually they were initially
- 28:42into kind of like buying petrol stations.
- 28:45I mean, if you looked on their website, they have this like
- 28:48interesting story about how they mortgage their house to buy
- 28:52their first petrol station. And then they just started
- 28:54building and building a building until they went, you know, from,
- 28:57you know, the, you know, the way downstream, you know, first
- 29:01petrol station into upstream assets.
- 29:04Like, you know, Buzzard through, of course, there's major
- 29:07acquisition that they did in North Lincolnshire on the
- 29:10Humber, the Lindsay oil refinery, which is of course the
- 29:14one that is like now, you know, kind of like most at risk.
- 29:17And of course, all, you know, all the unions are going, you
- 29:19know what, we need more government intervention.
- 29:21And you know what? I haven't seen or heard a damn
- 29:25thing at all from energy ministers, UK government, you
- 29:30know what they're going to be doing about this refinery
- 29:32collapse. It kind of feels like maybe
- 29:34they're going to let that one go swing in the wind again.
- 29:37Yeah, it feels, feels like what's happening in Shetland
- 29:40because obviously total of retained the asset and all that.
- 29:42It feels like maybe that's, that the government will go, well,
- 29:45you know, that's just business. Sometimes that happens.
- 29:49But yeah, for the refinery, we saw that massive initiative,
- 29:53Project Willow, which ultimately was, you know, fruitless.
- 29:56We do, you know, we've still closed the refinery, but we're
- 29:59looking to, you know, the unions weren't happy with that.
- 30:02They campaigned for, for both the Scottish and UK governments
- 30:06to save the refinery rather than just look for other people that
- 30:10could move in and, you know, sort of create jobs in the
- 30:13region because obviously that takes time.
- 30:15But the government has really backed that Project Willow
- 30:18thing. Millions of pounds in public
- 30:19funds have went that way. You're right, I've not heard
- 30:23much about this. I've not heard, you know, a
- 30:26response. Is it, is it going to be one of
- 30:28those things that, you know, the government will just be late to
- 30:31the party, wait until it actually closes, then go, oh,
- 30:35yeah, we're going to do something?
- 30:36Or is it going to be like British Steel and they're going
- 30:38to wait until the day that it's closing and then swoop in and do
- 30:42something? Well, see, I guess you know what
- 30:47I'm just kind of looking at, you know, what Michael Shanks said
- 30:50about it. And basically he said that PRAC
- 30:53should be putting its hands in its pockets to deliver
- 30:55compensation to workers, which doesn't sound like Disney's is
- 30:59going to be, you know, kind of making any big interventions
- 31:02there just because they just don't seem to have much sympathy
- 31:06for people who are, you know, working and investors in the oil
- 31:10and gas industry that we're trying to kind of make a go of
- 31:13it. So it really just does sound
- 31:15like, you know, it's another blow for Eminem.
- 31:19And honestly, you know, like there's all this, you know, the
- 31:23stuff falling over in, you know, the Humber region, which is kind
- 31:28of making, you know, a bit of a mockery of big plans out there
- 31:33to decarbonize that really massive industrial cluster on
- 31:38the Humber. You know, there's very little
- 31:41sympathy or support kind of going out there, which is kind
- 31:43of maybe being a bit worrisome, I'd say.
- 31:46Yeah, I mean, how often do you hear energy ministers say that
- 31:48they're protecting the industrial heartlands of the
- 31:51United Kingdom and yet we're we're seeing headlines like
- 31:54this. But I suppose they'll there will
- 31:56be more to come on this. We'll hear more about FRAX and
- 32:00it's it's woes I think is the nice way to put it over over the
- 32:04coming weeks and months. I'm sure much like this the the
- 32:07story that topped the show, but I think that'll probably have to
- 32:10do. Stay tuned to Energy Voice,
- 32:12where we're going to be keeping on top of that story for sure.
- 32:15Exactly. There we go.
- 32:17What a way to sign off. Erica, thank you very much.
- 32:19And yes, and that does it for this week's episode.
- 32:22So thank you, Erica, for joining me and thank you very much for
- 32:25listening. We don't really have any events
- 32:28to to flag that we're going to next week, but I suppose it's
- 32:32always worth mentioning that over over the weekend, on
- 32:35Sunday, there will be the Piper Alpha Memorial service in
- 32:38Hazlehead Park. So if you're in the area and you
- 32:41want to pay your respects to the 167 men that lost their lives,
- 32:44just make sure you swing in past.
- 32:48Anyway, that does it for us this week.