Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 08/25/26 EPISODE 018: SPECIAL EPISODE - BIRTHDAY BOTTLE - WE TASTE A 1973 VINTAGE CROWN ROYAL
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Mm-hmm. Well, welcome back to another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. We got our couple of our regular buddies in here, John Carlo. Barsh is back. Thank you for coming back in town. Absolutely. And we also got a one of my buddies here from Boston, John. So welcome, John. ⁓ This episode is exciting for me because yesterday was my buddy Barsh's birthday. And ⁓ in a previous episode, we talked about how his intro into whiskey. was Crown Royal. We don't drink a lot of Crown Royal anymore, but I thought it might be fun to taste the Crown Royal, talk through it, see what we get on the notes, give a little bit of history of Crown Royal, because it is a very long ⁓ and vast history. And then the fun part about this is because it was his his birthday, we're gonna have him open up a little gift. We procured a bottle of Crown Royal From nineteen seventy-three, your birth year, and you're gonna open that bottle and we're gonna taste it and we're gonna compare it to a today's version of Crown Royal. Wow. I'm not really sure what to say, but this is probably gonna be horrible. Actually, I mean well, you we don't know, right? Yeah, we don't. And ⁓ I think it's cool. It's our first dusty bourbon that we're gonna, or dusty whiskey dusty bourbon, ⁓ that we're gonna review. And I think it would be ⁓ I thought that was pretty cool. That one that I was able to find one. Thank thanks to your wife for reminding me. I'm gonna pull out a can of you were born. If you pull out a can of sun drop next, I'm gonna cry. Fair enough, buddy. That that was how I started on Crown was in the in the Carolinas with Sundrop. ⁓ That is Mountain Dew on steroids with five pounds of sugar in each can. ⁓ my wow. That's how you describe what sun drop is. And it's I don't think it's available really outside of the Carolinas. No, I've only seen it down in the South. Yeah. Gotta get that like extra caffeine in it and sugar. So let's dive into a little bit of the crown royal history here. So ⁓ Crown wasn't just born out of the desire to make a good whiskey. It was literally engineered to welcome a king and queen. It's in it its entire aesthetic was the crown-shaped bottle, ⁓ from the crown-shaped bottle to the iconic purple ⁓ felt bag, stems from the high-stakes marketing gamble back in 1939. So in nineteen thirty nine, King George the Sixth and Queen Elizabeth made history be by becoming the first reigning British monarchs to travel across Canada. This was a massive political and cultural event. Samu Samuel Bronf Bronfeman, ⁓ the head dis the head of Distillers Corporation at Seagram's, saw a golden opportunity. He wanted to create a spirits masterpiece worthy of the ultimate royal seal of approval. Bronferman experimented with over 600 different blends of Canadian whiskey before landing on the final recipe, an exceptionally smooth blend of fifty distinct whiskies. He packaged it in a cut glass decanter shaped like a royal crown and presented it to the king and queen inside a regal purple velvet bag with gold stitching. The couple was reportedly highly impressed, and the entire supply of their roy ⁓ the entire supply of their royal train was quickly consumed. ⁓ so the whiskey's timeline reflects how it evolved from a local luxury item into an international powerhouse. And while I'm reading, if you guys want to pour up this one, and let me get some other glasses here. Sure, sure, sure. And we can ⁓ side by side. Nice. I haven't had this in remember how long it's been. In a long time. Yeah, exactly. so yeah, maybe we can taste on the the ⁓ the current version for a minute and then we'll I'll finish reading and then we'll crack the ⁓ we'll crack the ⁓ 1973 version. So So from the whiskeys timeline, it reflects how it evolved from a ⁓ a local luxury into an international powerhouse. Ca ⁓ Canadian debuted in nineteen forties. Following the success of a royal tour, Seagrams introduced Crown Royal to the Canadian public. It quickly became a sought after luxury item, though it remained incredibly difficult to find outside of Canada. That's wild. It's easy to find here. ⁓ they expanded in nineteen sixty four into the US and it was finally brought here. ⁓ its smooth, accessible flavor profile and distinctly premium packaging caught on fast, turning it into the top-selling Canadian whiskey in the country. ⁓ The Seagram's Empire in two in the two in 2000 was dismantled and sold off. The Crown Royal brand was acquired by a global spirits giant, Diaggio, who significantly ramped up marketing, sponsorship deals, and flavor innovations. So where is it made today? Despite the global footprint, Every single drop of Crano Royal is still produced in one tiny isolated town, Gimli, Manitoba, located on the shores of w of Lake Winnipeg. The Gimli distillery is a massive straw massive, sprawling across three hundred and sixty acres and housing roughly one point five million barrels of whiskey aging at any given time. The harsh natur ⁓ the harsh naturally shifting Manitoba climate, freezing winters and warm summers, forces the whiskey in and out of the oak barrels, giving the spirit its significant. S signature character. The ingredients are strictly local, using a vast amount of Manitoba rye, corn, and barley, alongside naturally filtered water pulled directly from underground aquifer beneath the facility. All right. As we before we talk about the nineteen seventy three version. That's a lot of facts that I didn't know anything about. I d obviously never did any research on Crown World whatsoever. Just Give me some Diet Coke or some Sundrop. Call it good. I've never even sniffed it before. This is the first time I'm like, it smells better than I thought it would. Yeah, actually, if you don't shoot it or mix it with something, you're like, it's not too bad. 80 proof, right? The base version? Yeah. Yeah, it's not a high proof at all. That's anything down there at 80's gotta be a good candidate for a Coke mixer or something like that. Nice light sweetness to it. A little bit of a little bit of a spice note, but mostly like honey sweetness. Honey sweetness, I with that, yeah. Yeah. So is it different than the nineteen seventy three Crown Royal? Why don't you do a little unboxing here so we can see what this baby looks like? Your birthday present. All right, it's exactly look at that cardboard though. This is clearly not modern day card whatsoever. Fifty three year old cardboard. It's still it's actually a velvet bag. Fifty three year old cardboard. Yeah, I thought I was doing math right there. Math is math. All right. Wherever this was originally sold, it's got the liquor label on it, like they do in New York and a few other states. Yep. With the year of distillation, which is pretty cool. Yep. So it this this sticker has been on here since 1973, and the sticker has not broken. And I'm going to say the bottle looks different. Yeah. Let's see. Take a look at the front of that compared to this. I don't think the camera's going to pick it up per se, but subtle changes in that label, right? Yeah, for sure. Not just that it's aged, it's been sitting in a box with no sunlight on No. I prefer the old label version of the new label. Right? Yeah. I'm gonna pass down so these guys get a chance to look at Take a look at that. Obviously I've seen enough Crown Royal bottles in my life, so I'm like my it looks just a tiny bit different, that label on the front. I kinda like the old one. And the label on the back is completely different. Interesting that it's only seven hundred and ten MLs. Well it's Canadian, they can't count. ⁓ one of the facts I believe that I found in here is that for a long time it was ninety proof. This one is is at eighty proof. Okay. Okay. ⁓ so let's see here. It says, ⁓ is the bottle of Crown Royal from nineteen seventy-three significantly different than what you can buy on the shelf today? The age on that cardboard. No kid, right? But just the type of the cardboard itself. Actual cardboard. Right? All right. So while the brand has always maintained a smooth, approachable profile, several major shifts in production scale, distillery equipment, and corporate ownership over the last 50 years mean that the actual liquid in inside the bottle has evolved. The main difference comes down to three factors. So the production methods and equipment is first. In nineteen seventy-three, Crown Royal was owned by Seagrams and distilled using older, smaller capacity stills. In nineteen ninety, a massive new computer controlled twin still was completed in their Gimli Man Manitoba plant to meet global demand. Exponentially increasing output, whiskey enthusiasts and distillers note that the blend that blending the distillates from these two different generations of equipment changed the based complexity of the of the whiskey. So they say at at some point it was bottled at 90 proof. We do not have a 90 proof version. We also have an 80 proof, so there'll be like for like comparisons on this one. ⁓ cr the recipe, the Crown Royal is a blend of a dozen ⁓ of dozens of different component whiskeys, rye, corn, barley. ⁓ because the individual components ⁓ component barrels aging in Rick House has change over the decades, the exact recipe Of those 50 plus whiskeys has been tweaked over time to maintain consistency at a massive corporate scale. ⁓ so whiskey reviewers who do head-to-head tastings of 1970s dusty bottles versus modern bottles consistently point out a few flavor shifts. So the 1973 bottle may tend to have much more of a richer, heavier mouthfeel. It features deeper notes of maple, rich caramel, dark fruits like plum or stewed apples. And more prominent, spicy Canadian rye character. Where the modern bottle tends to be a little lighter, sweeter, cleaner, with a heavier focus on the vanilla and brown sugar, but less on the mid palette. I don't know how well this picks up on the camera for the folks that are watching it, but from sitting here under the lighting, I mean I'll shift ⁓ around a couple different times. ⁓ the older one is just substantially darker and thicker looking to Yeah. Yeah. Also predates the plastic safety seal. There's no safety seal on there, so Just yeah, once you bust that tax stamp, that's it. It's over with. Yep. Could be a tampered bottle. So the last thing here, bonus, ⁓ if you look closely at the 1973 bottle, ⁓ it will come with a tax stamp over the cap. You might see references to the ages of the whiskeys used. I don't know if it says that on the back or not. but up until the nineteen seventies, Crown Royal expli explicitly used older whiskeys in its flagship blend. ⁓ featuring whiskies aged up to 10 to 30 years. By the mid to late nineteen seventies, Seagram dropped the age statement entirely from the back label. And today standard Crown Royal features no age statement at all, but is generally produced somewhere between three and twelve years. So this one says Crown Royal, a regal blend of treasured whiskeys, some of them as old as 30 years, and each imparting a rare characteristic to create this superb. Whiskey of unequaled taste. That's awesome. Wow. So and last but not least, it says if you happen to have a bottle of this nineteen seventy three ⁓ Crown Royal, it's highly collectible. And offers a literal taste of whiskey history. Cool. Let's crack and taste the history, buddy. I was gonna say pop that top. Let's go. ⁓ you're gonna pop that. That's a you that's a you thing. That's a birthday boy duty. It's yours now. Uneventful. No pork pop, but a nice little ⁓ a nice little peel bag from a cardboard cardboard cap. Actual real cardboard cap inside the plastic crown top. Yep. Look at that. Here. I was gonna let you pour them this time. Well, okay. Just for the sake of time, we'll get these all poured up. Thank you, sir. And ⁓ see how these taste. Anybody ha anybody had any dusty whiskey or what's the oldest whiskey you've had? I'm about to have a nineteen seventy three. Nineteen seventy three, probably. Nothing here in a minute. Nothing in the seventies. That's Many many, many years ago we had a friend who drank Jack Daniels and I bought him a bottle and it sat for many years. So that's probably the oldest I That's the oldest ⁓ I don't know if that's considered dusty, maybe. No, no, no. ⁓ the ⁓ I think I've had a nineteen eighty eight and a nineteen eighty six is the oldest thing that I've personally tried. I've had a few wild turkeys from the nineties. Okay. Mid nineties. So Awesome. Yeah. I heard. Okay, let's see what the what we're getting on the nose of these two very different. Compare ⁓ up a little bit. ⁓ my goodness. Yeah, they're we described the first one as being the modern one as being light and sweet and honey, right? Yep. Yep. What are you getting? What are you getting off the older one, the dusty? This definitely has a little bit more of a a spice note to it. Yes. I mean it's it's right there. Man, it's got this like I they said maple syrup and I'm thinking, you know, it's Canadian. I obviously gotta taste like maple, right? Being from Canada. ⁓ but it does have this like maple syrup deep, like sugary reduction type note to it on the nose. I would go deep and sugary and definitely ⁓ like a I'm calling it a hardwood spice, but the spice knows absolutely there. Yeah. And it has a little bit of like a light funkiness to it on the nose. I don't know if you'd call that dusty or what, but I'm gonna dive in and find out. Yeah, taste it. ⁓ yeah. That's night night and day on the palate. That is not Crown Royal. That is so different. Whoa. That that just hits completely different than what you think Crown Royal should taste like. I like it by the way. It's good. I don't know if it's because it's old and dusty or if they just made it better back then, but I definitely like it. ⁓ it's it's way rich. It's a spice. It's way richer. It's got a little more spice to it. Yeah. Yeah, you can tell there's older mid to finish. Yeah. Distillant near. I got a little heat on the finish. Maybe I just opened my mouth, started talking too soon, but I definitely got a little. Mm-hmmth, not a not a Kentucky hug, not a burn, just a nice little warmth going down. It's much thicker, much richer. I much sweeter. I taste that funk. Yeah. It has it's much more pronounced. It's like a almost like when they say wild turkey has like a rickhouse funk to it. Like that. I don't know what you what what that is, but it's there. It almost has it different than wild turkey. It almost has this like sweet texture to it. Right. Right. I'll go with that. I also taste that funk on a like a fray some of the fray ranch as well. Yeah, and sometimes those I refer to like as like a graininess or green grains vibe to it. This is interesting. There's definitely a little funk to it for sure. Now see I'm a bit I've been a big clowner of Crown Royal. Everybody out there knows. ⁓ and and and Blantons for that matter. And I and the I had an eighty eight Blantons and it is incredible. I w if we could find those and drink those all day long, I'd be I would not be making Negative memes about blands 'cause 'cause it's great. ⁓ same thing with Crown Royal. This older version is definitely a step up. Yeah. But is it a step up because it's a dusty old bottle or was it just better by I if it would have the that when you can say funk, I'm agreeing with you, but I'm going, I don't know if crown should have that funk. That funk might just be from age. But the flavors are so different in this. Yeah, I don't I it could be the it could be the age, it could be I mean we don't know where this thing's been stored, so ⁓ don't don't tell me if you do. You I'm guessing this was in somebody's grandparents' liquor cabinet and they passed on and and then It got sold to a broker that can that they can move, you know, unopened vintage whiskies. ⁓ in Kentucky there's a a rule now that you can there's you can get a license to procure vintage whiskeys and then resale them as long as they have not been opened. Okay. So there's a few stores like Justin's House of Bourbon there in Louisville and in Lexington you can go to. You can try, they have a bar with open bottles of LC whiskey, which is super cool. That's where I tried the two that I tried. but if you want to purchase a bottle You can purchase it there too. Or you can offload your collection to them as well. We look to see, because I can't see in the room here what state the stamp is from. Manitoba, right? I think it all comes out of that one spot. The tax stamp? So this would bottle would have been sold in Canada then is what you're suggesting. It has Canadian tax stamp on it. Yes, yeah, yeah. That would the the tax stamp would come from the So rules out it probably wasn't spending its life in Florida somewhere. Probably not. Yeah. controlled environment. You know, if it really was up in Manitoba, it doesn't get that hot there. So no I this thing's been sitting in a in a inside a a bag, inside a box, possibly in somebody's shelf in the back of a closet. And if it was up in Manitoba, it didn't get extreme heats. Right. So it just sat there and just aged itself in a kind of natural good way, I think. It's definitely improvement. So As as as the resident Crown Royal connoisseur. I guess that's me. So I'm the one I but and and you know I'm gonna stop shitting on Crown Royal because apparently they used to make some great stuff. They did. But a lot of bourbons are that way too as well, right? The old stuff is better. What are your what's your verdict? What do you think? Well, I'm actually surprised 'cause I just took a sip of the newer one. I kinda forgot about that one. I just don't remember a time where I've ever sipped on crown without mixing it with something. Yeah. ⁓ it's just not something I ever thought of. It was just always crowned with a soda, always crowned with a soda. ⁓ I think it was you or somebody tried to get me do like ginger ale or something one time. And I was like, nah, it's not it's not me. Then that's not I'm not a ginger beer and ginger ginger ale, nothing, nothing like that. Don't do Moscow mules, but anyhow, ⁓ can't remember the last time I sipped on it straight, so I'm actually surprised that I don't want to drink it straight, but it's not as bad as I thought it would be. And then I go to the older one and it's just so different, potentially so much better. But that it's got that little bit of funk. I think is just from the age. I think this might have actually been a better blended whiskey back in nineteen seventy three. I like the funk. I'm when I say funk, just to be clear, I don't I'm not saying that as a negative at all. I think it's it adds a layer of like intrigue to the poor. All I'm saying is I don't think the funk was in that bottle nineteen seventy three. I think the funk evolved. Could be over the last fifty three years. That's it could be my two cents if I'm wrong. Well, I mean, if if what we said earlier where, you know, they were using a smaller d still. Yeah. It may have produced a different flavor profile, ⁓ in the past, right? It had to. Yeah. It may have. And I don't know if that funk it it may appeal to you or us or more kind of ⁓ experienced whiskey drinkers, but I wonder if that funk doesn't have the mass appeal. That's true. Especially to your point, it's often used as a mixer. Yep. And when Diaggio took it over, I wonder if they said, Hey, listen, we don't need to keep doing it this way. People are mixing it with the This, that, and the other. And by the way, palettes have kind of evolved to a point where we don't need to have this 30 year old distillate in it. We can, you know, kind of dummy it down a bit, make it a little more palatable to a whole wider range of tastes and profiles. Yeah. And I don't want to dive down the rabbit hole, so to speak, but if this is fifty three years old and some of the whiskeys that are in it were thirty years old, that means some of those whiskeys were barreled in the nineteen forties. Great point. So the w those and if the tr I don't know how old the tree is, sixty years, hundred years old before they make it into a a barrel, right? That tree's from a very different period than anything barreled today. Very true. Yeah, great point. You could be drinking from wood that was in the eighteen hundreds. Yeah. Yeah. Easily. Yeah. Yeah. Very different environment. It's a great even great perspective. I hadn't even thought about that. You're also just drinking, you know, World War Two distilled whiskey essentially or post world just post World War two. Yeah. that's wild. So Interesting. Yeah, this was an incredible find I think you I appreciate this. Absolutely, buddy. I thought I saw it and I was like, I wonder if I could find one that I you know, his birthday's coming up and and I think we're gonna film pretty close to his birthday. So I wonder if I could find a bottle with like the You did good. That's that's on the on his a ⁓ birth year there. The master distiller in nineteen seventy three could not possibly have imagined a day when there would be chocolate crown crown royale and raspberry crown royale. No. I mean those days. Peach, vanilla, cramolia, as well. The and the flavor profiles that have evolved today are good. They've definitely gone off the the deep end with the with the flavor. But I mean, that's what they're trying to do. They're trying to appeal to the people. I admittedly, when I didn't like whiskey. That's what the difference is. This has got gluten in it. Fair enough. Well, cool. I appreciate you guys being here. Happy birthday, buddy. Happy birthday. Glad we were able to celebrate a little the day after the birthday here with you. And ⁓ Listen, let us know in the comments. Have you ⁓ do you enjoy Crown Royal? ⁓ have you moved on to it? Have you gone back to Crown Royal if you have moved on? ⁓ or have you tried any dusty ⁓ Crown Royal or or dusty old whiskies? I think this is the first one I've tried here. I've I did procure another one ⁓ that we'll do on another episode. It is a nineteen eighty nine wild turkey. So we'll ⁓ we'll try to pair that up and see how that tastes to some ⁓ some current day wild turkey down the road. ⁓ but thank you all for joining us. Thank you for listening in. ⁓ if you if you can, if you're enjoying what you're hearing, please leave us a review on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, ⁓ YouTube, wherever you happen to be listening to us, we appreciate your support. Thanks again. And to John, our buddy, thanks for coming through and good having you. Thanks for having me. Cheers, everyone. Cheers. Cheers.