Latest / ATO: For the W / Aiming for Glory: Leg 1 of the 2026 CPL Semi-Final vs Forge FC
Transcript
- 0:00This episode of ATO for the Dub is brought to
- 0:03you by the Glebe Central Pub. The Glebe Central
- 0:05Pub is proud to be the home away from home for
- 0:07the Capital City Supporters Group and support
- 0:09fan -made work like ATO for the Dub. Whether
- 0:12you're grabbing a pregame pint before an ATO
- 0:14or Rapid game, looking to catch all of the away
- 0:16game action, or just looking to stop in for a
- 0:18drink, they've got you covered. With DAZN and
- 0:21FUBO both licensed at the pub, you won't miss
- 0:23a moment. From our hometown clubs here in Ottawa,
- 0:25to national and global club football, and every
- 0:28match of the 2026 World Cup, all the footy action
- 0:31is happening down at the GCP. Cold Carlsberg
- 0:35on special, great food, and unbeatable vibes,
- 0:37the Glebe Central Pub is Ottawa's temple of football,
- 0:40located right in the heart of the Glebe. Big
- 0:43thanks to GCP for sponsoring this program. Now,
- 0:45on to the show. Welcome to ATO for the Dub, the
- 1:21official podcast from the Capital City Supporters
- 1:23Group, brought to you by the Glebe Central Pub,
- 1:25where we break down the game of the week and
- 1:27discuss everything ATO. My name is John Hopkins,
- 1:30and I'm joined by my lovely co -host, Patrick
- 1:32Gibson. Patrick, how you doing, my friend? Better
- 1:34than I thought I would be. After what we saw
- 1:37on Sunday, I heard it from a couple people in
- 1:40and around the grounds that I was pretty negative
- 1:42in how we were previewing this potential tie.
- 1:46And I'm glad to say I was wrong for at least
- 1:49this first half of it. As somebody who is generally
- 1:52positive, but is required to be negative in order
- 1:55to not be punished by karmic forces. This game
- 1:59was pretty much everything I could have asked
- 2:00for. You know, it was very competitive, very
- 2:03hard fought. And there's a lot to talk about,
- 2:05particularly in the third team's performance.
- 2:08But before we do dive into it all, a few announcements
- 2:12to start the show. We need to bring this beautiful
- 2:15energy that we had from TD Place with us on the
- 2:18road. That means you need to get on the bus and
- 2:22come with me to Hamilton. It's not easy, but
- 2:25you can do it. I believe in you. We'll be heading
- 2:29down 5 a .m. TD Place, coming down and back again.
- 2:34It's an early morning, but it's going to be a
- 2:36great time. I was lucky enough last year to be
- 2:39there on the bus for our semifinal win, and I
- 2:43don't want anyone else to miss that opportunity.
- 2:47We've had some rough road trips to Forge. I get
- 2:50it. But this is the time to really bring it and
- 2:53hopefully lock this up. If we play the way we
- 2:55did this weekend, I think we have a very real
- 2:57shot at defending our title. Tickets are available
- 3:00at the Team Shop. You can also find the link
- 3:02in the Dubb Dispatch on Instagram or on the Discord.
- 3:05If you're looking for tickets to the game and
- 3:09traveling separately from the bus, the link will
- 3:11also be available in the Dubb Dispatch on Instagram
- 3:14and on Discord. That will come... probably in
- 3:18the next few days, depending on when this comes
- 3:20out. So if it's not there just yet, don't worry,
- 3:22it's coming. If you can't make it to Hamilton
- 3:24for whatever reason, we do hope you'll make it
- 3:26down to the Glade Central Pub for the watch party.
- 3:28We'll be covering the first drink for everyone
- 3:30who comes out. So we really hope to see you on
- 3:33Saturday, whether that's at the pub or on the
- 3:35bus. Now, back to the show. Or your secret third
- 3:38option, where I'll be. The secret third option
- 3:41of watching on Patrick's phone at TD Place as
- 3:44the Rapid get ready to play in their playoff
- 3:47game. I think this game has to go down as one
- 3:51of our best performances of the year. You know,
- 3:54really the main issues with it were some baffling
- 3:58refereeing decisions that really handed a lot
- 4:02of opportunity to Forge. But at the end of the
- 4:05day, going 2 -2 in this game... is an accomplishment
- 4:09in and of itself. It's a hard fought game. I
- 4:12think we could have very well gotten a little
- 4:14bit more out of it, but we've gotten that so
- 4:17often this year where it's been that last minute
- 4:20winner. In a way, it's almost become an expectation
- 4:23in my brain of like, oh, it's okay. We'll get
- 4:26a corner to finish the game and that'll go in
- 4:29and it'll be glorious. But football isn't always
- 4:33a fairy tale and we have a second leg. that we
- 4:36will be contesting. So I think it was the perfect
- 4:41day for that performance with a packed stadium,
- 4:446 ,100 are high of the year, a sold out dub,
- 4:48which I can only think of finals that that's
- 4:52really happened in. And you can really, and it
- 4:55really felt it live in person. Sometimes when
- 4:59the dub gets a little packed, you get a lot of
- 5:01people who maybe aren't. necessarily invested
- 5:04in the same way or aren't necessarily aware of
- 5:07what the vibe is supposed to be. It did not feel
- 5:10like that. And I always try and tell people selling
- 5:14out the dub can make it harder to build an atmosphere
- 5:17because the way that sound works is bodies absorb
- 5:20sound. So the more bodies there are, the more
- 5:23sound is being absorbed. It's harder for me to
- 5:25hear the capos, anything happening at the front
- 5:27of the dub when I'm towards the back and there
- 5:32are rows of people in front of me. So it means
- 5:35you really need that engagement and buy -in.
- 5:37And there were moments that folks struggled with,
- 5:40but overall, such a phenomenal day. I felt like
- 5:44everyone was really quick to take the chant sheets
- 5:46I was handing out and get engaged and get interested.
- 5:51Absolutely lovely. Absolutely lovely. Truly.
- 5:55And we were rewarded with it, right? And that's
- 5:58the thing is that The overall theme as to why
- 6:01I think I've been praising this performance so
- 6:05heavily in the last 24 hours has been it's, it's
- 6:09a different gear than we've seen from this team
- 6:11all year. And yes, the second half was slower.
- 6:15It was much more of a playoff game in that respect,
- 6:18right? Where the team's tightened up. But it
- 6:20was a level of urgency that has been here unto,
- 6:25unto foreseen for this team. in the first half
- 6:30of games. It especially serves as a really sharp
- 6:34contrast to the game that we played just two
- 6:36weeks ago against Forge in our own building that
- 6:40we were able to come out and do this. We'll get
- 6:43into a lot of the details later on, but regardless
- 6:47of whatever the refereeing was in this game,
- 6:50the way that we responded to that and the things
- 6:54that Gustavo did as a manager to help us properly
- 6:58respond to that are very commendable and indicative
- 7:03of a team that can replicate this performance
- 7:06and not have it be a one -off that's the hope
- 7:09and that's the plan and forge we got away with
- 7:11a little bit more against forge than sometimes
- 7:13i think you know we've we have in the past so
- 7:16hopefully they repeat this performance too um
- 7:18in terms of selection we're back to our best
- 7:2111 um we've talked a lot about it on this podcast
- 7:23series if you want to hear us talk about this
- 7:26specific 11. You can pick any of the previous
- 7:28episodes prior to our Dead Rubber series. And,
- 7:33you know, I was a little nervous that moving
- 7:36into rotation ahead of this game might give a
- 7:41little bit of time for some rust to build, where
- 7:44you're always a little nervous when guys aren't
- 7:46playing that they're not keeping that edge. And
- 7:50obviously these are professionals. Obviously
- 7:53they're working out and they're... in training
- 7:55and doing all these things. But even at the highest
- 7:58level, you see that kind of like, okay, you need
- 8:00competitive games to kind of keep yourself moving.
- 8:04And very fortunately, pretty much every starter
- 8:06brought their A game. I thought this was some
- 8:09of the best performances we've seen from this
- 8:1211, bar none. As a collective, individually and
- 8:16as a collective, right? Yeah. It's one of those
- 8:18things where you talk, you said the rest, right?
- 8:20Like there were no signs of it. In any way, it
- 8:23was the players who did not play against York
- 8:25last week were fresh, right? We didn't see the
- 8:29rust. We saw fresh players who were coming out
- 8:32and who made the biggest difference in a lot
- 8:35of cases. 100%. 100%. I think really the only
- 8:39piece to maybe discuss in this selection is the
- 8:41fact that Ronnie Mbomio was on the bench. I think
- 8:44Tim has earned his spot to defend his spot because
- 8:48I'm kind of of the opinion. And I think this
- 8:51is a good philosophy period for managers, for
- 8:54teams. No one spot should be guaranteed just
- 8:57because of who they are and just because of what
- 8:59they've done previously. They've been away for
- 9:02a while. The guy who's cooking gets to stay in
- 9:05the kitchen. And in this case, I think we were
- 9:08very much rewarded with a phenomenal game from
- 9:12Tim. But I'll admit, I was a little surprised
- 9:14that Ronnie was not back in that 11. What did
- 9:17you make of the choice? You taught, we talked
- 9:21about, again, it's the, it's the idea of what
- 9:23is rust versus rest and the quarantine that Ronnie
- 9:27had to undertake door undertake. Yes. Undertake
- 9:32is the right word. Undertake and maybe endure.
- 9:35I don't know his mental health. Undertake over
- 9:37the course of the last three of the previous
- 9:39three weeks before the York game. Like that's
- 9:42a pretty significant thing to undertake. And
- 9:45as such, it made it. pretty like reasonable but
- 9:50that wasn't going to be him playing a full 90
- 9:54minutes for us right you can hem and haw about
- 9:58how effective tim has been at right back at certain
- 10:01points this season when he's been called upon
- 10:03to do so but i think it's ultimately the right
- 10:05the right choice because ronnie ronnie is much
- 10:10more on the rust side of the spectrum and you
- 10:12need it to get him back to match fitness rather
- 10:15than trying to thrust him into such an important
- 10:18game like this. Yeah. And I think that's kind
- 10:21of the reasonable position. And I expect we'll
- 10:25see Tim start again. Again, he gave such a great
- 10:27performance. We heard in the post -game press
- 10:29conference that it was just a really bad cramp.
- 10:32It wasn't a serious injury in terms of that late
- 10:38tackle from Ampoma that was pretty nasty in real
- 10:41time. But fortunately, that seems to be okay.
- 10:45So hopefully Tim will be back starting again
- 10:47because he had such a great game. And look, the
- 10:50bulk, the bulk of the discussions in the first
- 10:52half really like, and we'll talk about it later,
- 10:56but there's really not that much to mention from
- 10:58the second. No, it was, it was, it really was
- 11:01a tale of two halves. One of the most entertaining
- 11:03halves of football this team has played in a
- 11:05very, very long time. Yeah, truly, truly. So
- 11:10let's dive into that as it were. Yeah. And look,
- 11:13the mailbag has a number of questions around
- 11:17referees. So we'll try and leave a little bit
- 11:21in the tank for it. It's a core part of the story
- 11:24of this half is that the reffing crew and obviously
- 11:30the head referee is the one leading everything.
- 11:33So it falls to them first and foremost. And LAS
- 11:38just had a really rough game. It seemed he was
- 11:42going in with a bit of a, it's playoffs, so I
- 11:46won't give yellows easily. Yes. Where we went
- 11:5031 fouls without a yellow, two challenges for
- 11:54reds. And I think, as we'll get to, one of those
- 11:58could have been a yellow and maybe should have
- 11:59been a yellow. But at the end of the day, he
- 12:02had this kind of maybe let them play mentality
- 12:05specifically around giving out cards. Yeah. Any
- 12:10other time he was ready to buy a dive. Yeah.
- 12:14It's a really weird contrast to call everything,
- 12:17but not punish anything. Right. Like it's, it's
- 12:21a really weird balance to strike as a referee
- 12:24to be like the, because it, it doesn't curb anyone
- 12:28from fouling anymore. Right. If you don't issue
- 12:31cautions, those things don't stop. And the same
- 12:34behavior continues to progress through the game.
- 12:37which is bananas because even the same behavior
- 12:40wasn't being called saying every single time
- 12:42it was happening. It was, it was a, it was a
- 12:45horribly inconsistent and it was just emblematic
- 12:49of like the pressure getting to an official and
- 12:52him not being able to deal with the situation.
- 12:54It's not, do not attribute malice to that, which
- 12:57can easily be explained by ignorance, right?
- 12:59Like we can all do the, the Karl Popper thing
- 13:02or whatever it is. And these are CPL refs. Yeah.
- 13:05These are CPL refs. The reality is we kind of
- 13:09expect to be a little bit hard done by. And,
- 13:13of course, we're football fans. We're always
- 13:15hard done by, even if we aren't. So, you know,
- 13:18there's those things. But I will say one thing
- 13:20that I thought was interesting that was raised
- 13:22by Coach Leal in the post -game press conference
- 13:25was the tone and behavior LAS had towards a lot
- 13:30of the players. Guys are coming at him hot because
- 13:34he's missing some key calls that we'll talk about.
- 13:37But apparently he was very aggressive in how
- 13:41he was talking to Sergei, to Tim, and others.
- 13:46And for young players, that can be pretty rattling.
- 13:50It's interesting you highlight those two players
- 13:52specifically. Well, those are two defensive players
- 13:56who are needing to focus. We're both young. aren't
- 14:01used to a ref losing their screaming back in
- 14:05their face. Now, again, you can argue, you got
- 14:07to give it, you got to take it. But the idea
- 14:10with refs is that they are staying above that
- 14:13level. So, you know, there's that. So apparently
- 14:18he was quite, and again, we can't, we didn't
- 14:21hear it in the sense of we were busy shouting
- 14:23other things. It's interesting that he was very
- 14:27aggressive and firm with players without cautioning
- 14:29them. And I think in many ways that it's kind
- 14:32of part of the challenge that he had with this
- 14:36game. Yeah. And it's interesting because he is,
- 14:38I think he is known as a referee who is more
- 14:42likely to give fouls. I think we like, you can
- 14:45look on the FOTMOP stats, he's well above the
- 14:48average amount of fouls called per game. He was
- 14:51the referee and notably in the game that set
- 14:54the CPL record for most fouls called last year
- 14:56between us and the then York United at 48 in
- 15:01one game. It's interesting because I think the
- 15:05problem is the inconsistency. And you can look
- 15:09and you can point at a certain number of things
- 15:11and a certain couple of players. I'm going to
- 15:17call it Maxime Bourgeois for the most heinous,
- 15:20I think, of the dives, which was when he backed
- 15:23into Sergei and Sergei's arm was slightly out
- 15:26in front and he jumped. Jumped backwards. And
- 15:29just, he was at star gymnastics going off the
- 15:31pit into the, into the pit of the like foam squares.
- 15:34Like it was bad. Like it was pretty heinous.
- 15:37And Alias bought that hook, line, and sinker.
- 15:40Yeah. And Forge, I think to their credit and
- 15:43to my disgust, adapted well to just diving left
- 15:45and right. Like just. going into anything looking
- 15:49for the foul, knowing LAS is probably going to
- 15:51bend on it. And, you know, I will say, I'm just
- 15:56glad that there wasn't a ton of yellows, especially
- 15:59for dissent and things like that. I will give
- 16:02him credit for that in the sense of like, this
- 16:05could have been a lot worse if he was handing
- 16:07out yellows like candy, making these calls and
- 16:09then also over punishing, you know. I think that
- 16:14could have been much worse. But now that that
- 16:16initial flurry is over, let's talk about the
- 16:19first goal, which also implicates the refs. First
- 16:2213 minutes, we give up a corner, one of far too
- 16:24many this game. We gave up 12. And with the height
- 16:29advantage that Forge have, that's going to be
- 16:32a risk. Asking for trouble. It's a risk. And
- 16:34don't get me wrong, like pretty much most of
- 16:37the time when you send the ball out of the touchline,
- 16:40it's a calculated risk of, okay. I need to shut
- 16:43down the play now. It'll be better when we're
- 16:46all back and we can go from there. And the first
- 16:50ball in in this 13 minute is quite poor from
- 16:53Jensen, I think. And it is easily claimed by
- 16:58Colongo, if not for a player directly walking
- 17:03back into him, shrugging him off of his shoulders
- 17:06and pushing him back into the goal. It's a foul.
- 17:09It's a very obvious foul. A little frustrated
- 17:13that the AR didn't signal that more aggressively.
- 17:17And look, corners are busy. Things are happening.
- 17:21Heck to get the best of times. At the very best.
- 17:24But this is a very obvious one. This is a very
- 17:27clear foul that you can call. And the fact that
- 17:31he doesn't is inexcusable in a lot of ways. This
- 17:34is a very clear foul on the keeper that you're
- 17:37just ignoring to give another corner where Dunn,
- 17:40Dunn. Clears the header, but he only has to because
- 17:45Colongo's taken out of the play. And it shouldn't
- 17:49be incumbent on us to let them score so that
- 17:52we can get the right call from the referee. It
- 17:57speaks to the inconsistency stuff because there's
- 18:00a slight tap in the back that Garcia makes on,
- 18:04geez, I want to say Rama potentially on a corner
- 18:06a little bit later on in the game where it's
- 18:09still the first half. And it's like, it's a foul.
- 18:12But these two things are called in completely
- 18:16different ways. And it's incredibly frustrating
- 18:20because you look at how goalkeepers are protected
- 18:25and how arbitrary that is game to game. It's
- 18:30the same thing with goaltender interference in
- 18:32the NHL, really. It's like, it's flipping a coin
- 18:36and like, it's not. relying on the actual skill
- 18:41of players or anything. It's just hoping and
- 18:43praying that someone sees that something illegal
- 18:47happened. Yeah. Yeah. And so they get a second
- 18:52try on the corner. The goal is credited to Aromatario,
- 18:56but really the definitive touch comes off Sergei's
- 18:59shoulder where he kind of turns into it a little
- 19:02bit. It deflects upward off the shoulder and
- 19:05that floats it right, you know, far corner. Very,
- 19:09very unlucky from Sergei. Incredibly frustrating
- 19:12that it comes off that non -call on Colongo.
- 19:15And we can't review saying, hey, you missed a
- 19:17foul that led to this corner. Yeah. So unfortunate.
- 19:24But we're going to have to spend the next week
- 19:27focusing on set pieces because this is a team
- 19:30that is going to just try and farm set pieces
- 19:33and beat us in the air. Yeah. Yeah. If they're
- 19:36going to be able to take advantage of it like
- 19:37that. And it's not as if. Any of our players
- 19:40were beaten in the air on this call. This is,
- 19:43this is what the baffling thing is about this
- 19:44situation is that it wasn't as if someone just
- 19:48jumped over somebody. It was a low driven ball
- 19:51to the near post that Oketekun was just able
- 19:55to run away from someone or Oromatarion was just
- 19:58able to run away from someone. That's, that's
- 19:59not the type of set piece defense that you would
- 20:03be really concerned about from our team with
- 20:05our lack of height. That's something that should
- 20:07have been dealt with. Yeah. And it's unlucky.
- 20:10And you can say in the modern games, if someone's
- 20:14at the back post, maybe they do that. I know
- 20:16Gord Smith talked a little bit about that in
- 20:19the post game. So you can consider that maybe
- 20:22is that we need somebody on the back post for
- 20:24these just because there's going to be a lot
- 20:27of set pieces in the second leg. Yes. And it's
- 20:31a very frustrating situation. Very difficult
- 20:33situation. What I really liked was. That we didn't
- 20:37wait to respond and that we met the occasion.
- 20:40We didn't kind of crumble mentally. We stuck
- 20:44to it. We got right back to work and we started
- 20:47driving and we started pushing. And, you know,
- 20:50Tabla beats Mandrakar James up top, plays the
- 20:53ball from out wide right into Habibullah, who's
- 20:57got tons of space, you know, perfect. It felt
- 21:01like that movie moment of like, it's going to
- 21:02happen. And then he just doesn't quite get enough.
- 21:06on it to really make it dangerous. It stays on
- 21:09the ground. Brahma is back in net because one
- 21:13thing that this forward team loves to do is stick
- 21:15a defender in the net. Yeah. To just block. Yeah.
- 21:20And again, they're an organized defense that
- 21:23clears things off the line. They understand what
- 21:25the situation accounts for and it's just right
- 21:27place, right time again and again and again because
- 21:29they're well drilled. Yeah. If Habibullah hits
- 21:33that, Well, first time, it's probably in the
- 21:35net. But, I mean, the pain of that is somewhat
- 21:39taken away given what happens only a few minutes
- 21:41later. Well, and even in that same play, Rama
- 21:45clears it. Then we recycle. We bring it back.
- 21:48We push it back up. We get it back to Tabla,
- 21:50who beats another defender on a dribble. Gets
- 21:53into this nice little 1 -2 with Habibullah. Sends
- 21:56it to Habibullah. Habibullah again receives it.
- 21:58Here, he doesn't actually take a touch. He just
- 22:01takes... A step or two too many. Where if he
- 22:05just hits that ball a second early, I don't think
- 22:08Berto has a chance on it. It's also hard because
- 22:10I don't think Habibullah quite realizes Berto
- 22:12is coming out in that moment. Yeah. He's just
- 22:15trying to get the shot on goal. He's not totally
- 22:18on balance to be able to take that first time.
- 22:21Just trying to make sure he makes solid contact.
- 22:23And it's a good save on Berto with his six to
- 22:26charge out. And then Garcia, again. comes in,
- 22:30gets the header back across the box. It felt
- 22:32like we were just flowing so well in these few
- 22:36minutes of just like, this is all one play where
- 22:39we just constantly hit and hit again. And yeah,
- 22:43it doesn't go off, but it's building those opportunities
- 22:46that you get those goals eventually. And it doesn't
- 22:50take long. Two minutes later, Garcia has a great
- 22:53run down the line, plays it. It kind of trickles
- 22:56through traffic to get to Habibullah, who once
- 22:59again doesn't get enough contact on it. Rama,
- 23:03once again there to clear it off the line. But
- 23:05he sends it out to Gutierrez, who takes this
- 23:07beautiful little touch to control it, to get
- 23:10it away from the defender. You know, brings it
- 23:13to the ground, takes a step out, and just rips
- 23:16it past Berto. Yeah. What a goal. I sit here,
- 23:21I watch that goal back, right? And part of it
- 23:26is the sun, like the sun and the way that the
- 23:28shadows reflected today were there on Sunday
- 23:30were ridiculous. And Berto sees it so light and
- 23:34like the sort of seeing eye shot right from Gutierrez
- 23:38to be in that position. Gutierrez gets really
- 23:40lucky on the touch because his boot is so high.
- 23:44It is. If Aromatario comes into that, if Aromatario
- 23:47comes into that challenge a little bit differently,
- 23:49Gutierrez might be sent off. Right? Like he gets,
- 23:52again, Game of inches, right? His header doesn't
- 23:59take a deflection off a surrogate. Maybe that
- 24:01doesn't end up in the net. He's maybe an inch
- 24:03further forward. He gets his head taken off.
- 24:06Gutierrez is sent off, and we're having a completely
- 24:08different podcast. But it doesn't happen, and
- 24:12we don't need to deal with hypotheticals, and
- 24:13it's a wonderful sequence from Gutierrez to be
- 24:16able to recover all of that. Yeah, and just that
- 24:18redemption after a rough week. Looking back at
- 24:20the last Forge game with the double yellow, this
- 24:22was a game that was screaming out for someone
- 24:25to be angry at the ref and to maybe lose their
- 24:28cool. And he didn't. He kept it. You know, that
- 24:32I think is something to appreciate in terms of
- 24:35character growth, perhaps, or at least a little
- 24:38bit of discipline to keep himself. on side of
- 24:42those things. And the celebration's great, kicking
- 24:44the boards. You can tell he kind of needed that,
- 24:47and that's just such a great moment in this game.
- 24:51Now for the first FVS challenge of the game.
- 24:54It's about the 28th minute. A ball is played
- 24:56out long to NFC, who's in the middle of the pitch.
- 24:59He's got Javremovic on one side, Rama on the
- 25:01other. He touches the ball out ahead of him.
- 25:04He's, you know, running as he can, and he goes
- 25:07down, looking for the red, obviously. I think
- 25:12in rewatching this a number of times, he does
- 25:15go down a bit easy. I don't think that is strictly
- 25:20debatable. On the broadcast, they were talking
- 25:22about simulation or anything like that. I think
- 25:25that would have been insane to give simulation
- 25:28there. And obviously, Jovramovich was asking
- 25:30for simulation. But for me, the big problem is
- 25:34Jovramovich's arm, which does extend. Now, he's
- 25:38already kind of falling. He's already kind of
- 25:41stumbling, though one could argue that's how
- 25:43he runs. But in that moment, if you've got the
- 25:49arm on a guy's back in that situation and it's
- 25:52extended, that's a foul. Now, I don't think it's
- 25:56a red. No. The reason I don't think it's a red
- 25:59is because Rama's there. Rama is definitely covering.
- 26:02So I think Rama's position does cover you. It's
- 26:08tricky because if he doesn't go down, does he,
- 26:09you know, outrun them both? Maybe, I don't know.
- 26:13I don't think so. Given he was in possession,
- 26:15he had taken two touches at that point and he
- 26:16was in possession of the ball. Rama is catching
- 26:19up to him, right? I'm not trying to be disillusioned
- 26:23about this whole sequence. No, he is going to
- 26:25be caught up too just because the nature of how
- 26:27physics works with when you're in possession.
- 26:30I don't, I didn't see any strict contact on the
- 26:34legs. But again, for me, it's the arm. The arm
- 26:37there in the angles towards the back is what
- 26:42really sells it for me as a yellow. I don't think
- 26:46it's a red. I think it's a good use of a challenge.
- 26:49It's not even about getting the call in that
- 26:50instance because it was very clear that the team
- 26:54was at a fever pitch in this moment. And Gustavo
- 26:57using that challenge to literally just calm everyone
- 26:59down regardless of what the result ended up being
- 27:01because it was still, it was a decent amount
- 27:04of time after that call. But the challenge was
- 27:07issued, right? It was a goal kick for us. And
- 27:10taking the time to just be like, let's reset,
- 27:14I think saved us a little bit, despite the fact
- 27:18that we would go down five minutes later. But
- 27:20it saved us because it allowed him to get back
- 27:25to everyone and be like, look, switch, flick
- 27:28the switch. And for most of the rest of the game,
- 27:32we were still pretty switched on in a way that
- 27:35wasn't being motivated by Spice. Yeah. And I
- 27:39think the other element is just that, like, an
- 27:41NFC got nothing this game from the refs. LAS,
- 27:45I don't know. And I think there's a mailbag question
- 27:48about it. So we'll save it for that. But NFC
- 27:50was pretty hard done by in a number of cases.
- 27:52And again, the other thing is it doesn't really
- 27:53take much to knock guys down when you're running
- 27:56like this, when you're battling for this. So,
- 27:58you know, the fact that the arm's there means
- 28:00simulation is an impossible call, in my opinion.
- 28:02And for me, yellow is the right call. But I can
- 28:06be okay with it in the sense of, like, it's the
- 28:11challenge of the context of the rest of the game.
- 28:14Where because little bits of arm contact and
- 28:18little touches and things like that will later
- 28:21be called fouls or have been called fouls up
- 28:25to this point, the fact that we're not giving
- 28:28it there. Is, yeah, is the problem, right? It's
- 28:31the consistency. It's the fact that Noah Jensen
- 28:34can get a light touch on the shoulder, flail
- 28:37his arms in the air and fall down and win a free
- 28:39kick in the attacking half. NFC gets an arm in
- 28:44the back, goes down and around the halfway line
- 28:47and there's nothing. Yeah. And look, even, even
- 28:50after that, we get another chance where NFC gets
- 28:53another ball played in by Sergei. Bertomas judges
- 28:56it and just kind of jumps out at it. In some
- 28:59ways, part of me was like, if he catches Nick
- 29:01here, that should be a red. Yes. But Nick dodges
- 29:06Perto, gets the ball, and it looks like he does
- 29:09get it on target. It deflects off of Nimick's
- 29:11thigh. Yeah. Or, sorry, his... His calf. His
- 29:16calf. That's the right word. So it deflects off
- 29:18his calf, goes out for a corner, very routine
- 29:21play, and Alias and his team decide, no, we're
- 29:25giving a goal kick. And, again, this is one of
- 29:28those just clearly incorrect calls that... Colors
- 29:33the game from our perspective where if you're
- 29:36not gonna get the basics, right? Yeah, even if
- 29:40things might be a little more touchy where it's
- 29:42like, okay Yeah, yeah, I can see why you might
- 29:44not give a red a big game -changing decision
- 29:46on the arm in the back from Javar Mavich It's
- 29:49not that much contact. It's not you know, it
- 29:51happens as he's falling rather than preceding
- 29:55his fall so, you know But when get all of these
- 29:59calls wrong, I'm less willing to give you the
- 30:02grace on those other things. And I'm looking
- 30:05for the makeup and it's never going to come.
- 30:08So just a really bizarre question. And Alias
- 30:12just calls it. He doesn't look to his AR. No.
- 30:14It's one thing that I watched where I rewatched
- 30:17the replays a few times. He doesn't really look
- 30:18at his AR for the call. He just kind of points.
- 30:22And I'm like, buddy, like. I'm going to, again,
- 30:26I don't know why. He's way out of position. He's
- 30:29making the call from distance. Again. That's
- 30:32a call you got to get right at this point in
- 30:34a playoff game like this. Like, come on. This
- 30:37is not that hard. It's an objective, clear call.
- 30:41So, and of course, seconds later comes the other
- 30:48equalizer. Happy Bullet tries to slow Jensen
- 30:50down, recognizing that, you know, apparently
- 30:52contact from the arm is not a foul based on the
- 30:55NFC ruling. But Jensen, who is already falling
- 30:58before he gets touched. Flails his arms up, throws
- 31:02himself to the ground, gets the call. Again,
- 31:05if that's the bar, then I think we might have
- 31:11to be looking at a few things differently. And
- 31:16again, I don't think Jovanovic should have been
- 31:18off for that challenge. So the fact that he scores
- 31:22an absolute stunner wouldn't change. Now, if
- 31:26we get the corner. Does that sequence happen
- 31:28that way? No. So we are still hard done by in
- 31:31that sense. Um, but it's, you can't be that mad
- 31:36about the stunner from Jaremovich. Um, they were
- 31:38talking about the wall a lot on the broadcast.
- 31:41I don't know that you can send a smaller wall.
- 31:43We had three guys in the wall. If we sent two,
- 31:46I think that's not doing a whole lot, but blocking
- 31:49vision. Um, and it's just a good strike. Well,
- 31:53yeah. And the, I think the more. app thing about
- 31:56the wall is how Forge positioned their wall behind
- 31:58us to deny Colongo a little bit of, to deny vision.
- 32:02So Colongo sees it a second later, right? Like
- 32:05if Colongo is able to see that right from the
- 32:07kick, he probably makes that save. It's not tucked
- 32:09in the corner by any means. There's plenty of
- 32:12room between the post and Colongo for him to
- 32:15make up that crowd. He just sees it late because
- 32:17of the setup from Forge. Yeah. And I don't blame
- 32:21Colango for that. It's a wonder strike. Look,
- 32:24they happen. You hit it incredibly well. Yeah.
- 32:27You took your cap, you move on. Exactly. And
- 32:30that's exactly what we did. And I think that's,
- 32:33again, speaking to this mentality element, we
- 32:35get right back to work. Tablet, you know, goes
- 32:38into the box and gets another arm shove from
- 32:42Javermovich. Not dissimilar, in my opinion, to
- 32:46what happens with Romitario. He does get the
- 32:48ball, which I think is the, compounding factor
- 32:51but again if we're giving those bumps it's a
- 32:55penalty but i think it doesn't quite reach the
- 32:59threshold for me no never never never never was
- 33:02never no but again if if that beeth the bar then
- 33:06here we are The cross actually does come off
- 33:10of that where Garcia makes the run deep to preserve
- 33:14that ball. It's just over hit. And I don't blame
- 33:16him because he's kind of like just trying to
- 33:18keep it in because I don't know that he thinks
- 33:20Jovremovic got the ball. So he's trying to send
- 33:25it back in, get it back in the mixer just a little
- 33:27too far. They forge, get a few other little weird
- 33:31fouls where Tim gets caught on one where like
- 33:34Patton plays the ball out of play. and then runs
- 33:38into Tim, and then gets the foul. Soars. Soars
- 33:42through the air. So a bunch of fouls like that
- 33:45that just kind of happen, and that brings us
- 33:47to about the 42nd minute, and there's this great
- 33:50little sequence where Sergey plays it into NFC,
- 33:52who just knocks it right to Koulange on the sideline,
- 33:55and it's not the best hit ball from NFC, but
- 33:59Koulange does a great job to keep that in play,
- 34:03and he just drives down the field. And we've
- 34:07talked about the urgency problem of just like,
- 34:09we got to feed our guys. And he doesn't hesitate.
- 34:13He gets it into Tabla. Tabla takes a touch, curls
- 34:17it perfectly into the bottom right corner to
- 34:20equalize 2 -2. Fantastic goal from Tabla. Yep.
- 34:24Really well taken. Really well taken. The defenders
- 34:27are all over him. You know, an action -packed
- 34:30half. Yeah. You know, is there any other? And
- 34:35on Kulaj for a second, I think one of the big
- 34:38things, and I saw a lot more in the second half
- 34:40just because he was right in front of us, but
- 34:42he was very, very keen to dribble inside and
- 34:48take space. I mean, a lot of players were more
- 34:50willing to take space in this game than they
- 34:51have been in recent weeks. And that created,
- 34:55it creates this goal, obviously, but the way
- 34:59Forge usually set up and how they've set up against
- 35:01this defensively. has always been to allow our
- 35:04fullbacks or wide center backs to have space
- 35:07to carry the ball up and then try and collapse
- 35:09when the passes are made. If you force them to
- 35:12collapse on the person who is supposed to be
- 35:14allowed the space, then that creates the space
- 35:17for other players. And not necessarily in this
- 35:20moment with the top of the goal because it's
- 35:21a more transition moment, but a lot of times
- 35:24in the second half where our best stuff came
- 35:26from was when they were set up and Kulaj was
- 35:28attacking. Kulaj was attacking. And it drew the
- 35:32players out of shape and it gave room for Gabby
- 35:35to run in behind what he came on more for hubby
- 35:37bullet to do that for Maddie to make overlapping
- 35:39runs and to go down left, even survey once or
- 35:42twice. It just, it created a whole nother dynamic.
- 35:45And I think his. Aggression and impetus was very
- 35:50important as to why we were able to play so successfully
- 35:52today. 100%. And I've got a list, you know, in
- 35:57terms of highlights, we're not talking about
- 35:59any disappointments. We're just going to be talking
- 36:01about highlights today. And I've got a nice list
- 36:03that certainly includes Coulange to dive into
- 36:07his game a little more in particular. But that
- 36:10closes out the first half. Again, incredibly
- 36:12action -packed. So much to talk about. So much
- 36:17to talk about. It felt like the reffing was very
- 36:20heavily weighted towards Forge in that half.
- 36:23I will say the second half started and I started
- 36:27to wonder if LIS just likes to call things in
- 36:31one direction of the pitch. It might've been
- 36:33a case of like, you can only see what was happening
- 36:36in that half of the pitch based on how the shadows
- 36:38in TV place were working. Suddenly a lot of things
- 36:41were getting called more in, in that direction.
- 36:44Um, again, similarly questionable. Um, And still
- 36:50not great. Certainly doesn't make up for a number
- 36:53of the basics that they've screwed up that wound
- 36:56up resulting in goals. We've got to be better
- 36:59on a few of those pieces. And, you know, also,
- 37:02God needs to not touch the ball when Jovramovich
- 37:06strikes it. But things kind of tighten up there.
- 37:12Similar to, I think it was the Inter against
- 37:15Pacific game that was like 4 -3 with like 12
- 37:18minutes of added time. The second half can't
- 37:21possibly live up to it. And it doesn't. Things
- 37:24tighten up. The teams, you know, lock in a little
- 37:27bit more defensively. I loved seeing the no give
- 37:30up attitude and work rate from NFC continue.
- 37:33Really basic ball that Joaquin was battling for.
- 37:37He comes in, knocks the ball around, just barely
- 37:40can't keep it in. But just great hustle, great
- 37:45hustle to really try and make something of nothing.
- 37:48There was another great stop from Kozlowski.
- 37:51I think it was with Levante Johnson running into
- 37:54him. He tracks it back really well, and he makes
- 37:57the perfect step to just pick that pocket, send
- 38:01the ball out. Phenomenal moment. And I mean,
- 38:03the other thing is, I feel like we're becoming
- 38:05more and more of a real soccer city. Yeah. In
- 38:08the sense of... The crowd reacting to the right
- 38:11things. Yes. Where Sergei makes that stop and
- 38:15you can hear the pop. Yeah. And I'm like, that's
- 38:18what we need. Yeah. You know, that's one of the
- 38:21reasons it feels so good. That might just be
- 38:22you hearing me go nuts over the littlest things
- 38:26on the sideline too in the dub, right? I listened
- 38:29back to it on broadcast. Because I cheer for
- 38:31the most random things that happen during games
- 38:34that like no one else is even witnessing. Yeah,
- 38:37it's a very, you and I get excited by little
- 38:40tackles, little movements, little runs off the
- 38:43ball. I got so excited by watching Manu turn
- 38:45into open space in his own half in this game.
- 38:48Three or four times, I loudly was cheering and
- 38:51he was 80 yards away from the opposing goal.
- 38:55Yeah. And look, that wasn't Kozlovsky's only
- 38:58cool moment in the second half. He takes a rip
- 39:01from outside the 18. That's just really well
- 39:03struck, you know. Unless that is a horrible mistake
- 39:06from Berto, it's always getting saved, but it
- 39:09forces a corner, which is great. You know, we
- 39:11don't get anything from it. You don't know where
- 39:12the ball's going to go off the parry either,
- 39:14right? No, no. And so, great getting the ball
- 39:18in the mixer. And I think that was around the
- 39:2073rd minute. And then we have, again, Forge got
- 39:24so accustomed to flopping and getting calls that
- 39:27it felt like in this particular play, they were
- 39:33kind of expecting a call. So the ball's played
- 39:37into NFC from Manu, who's making a great run
- 39:40through the middle. He plays it in well. NFC's
- 39:42battling with James. He wins the battle. He gets
- 39:45around him. And James just kind of throws himself
- 39:47on the ball. Yeah. There isn't a foul there.
- 39:51There isn't really any contact to precipitate.
- 39:53He jumps on the ball. Now, that's intentional
- 39:56to me. Watching that play, it's the kind of thing
- 40:00that a lot of players will do when they think
- 40:03they've won a foul. where they just land on the
- 40:05ball so that worst case scenario, they call a
- 40:08handball on me, it's fine. I've diffused the
- 40:11play by falling on the ball. And so any touch
- 40:16of the hand to the ball, in my opinion, with
- 40:19that in mind, is a handball. Because it's a deliberate
- 40:24movement. The hard thing is the angles that we
- 40:27get of this aren't great. Mainly because we don't
- 40:31get the angle from... The right side where, so
- 40:35NFC is standing on the right. The ball is coming
- 40:39through to him. And then James falls on the left.
- 40:44He doesn't, it doesn't hit his left arm. Not
- 40:47immediately. His left arm is extended out. Like
- 40:49it doesn't, it doesn't hit it at all from what
- 40:51I could see on the replay. I rewatched, I tried
- 40:54to get as many angles to rewatch this and get
- 40:57it. That way I can speak somewhat competently
- 41:00on it. It seems to hit NFC's foot on the other
- 41:05side. So his right arm, unless he has amputated
- 41:10it, is likely where it hits. Of course, it then
- 41:13rolls through his chest. He gets up and plays
- 41:16it. The one soccer commentary talks about how
- 41:18athletic he is for standing up. I'd like them
- 41:21in my bedroom tomorrow morning just so I can
- 41:23get some morning encouragement. And yeah. I think
- 41:29with the angles you have, you're hard pressed
- 41:31to give the handball. I think it likely is a
- 41:34handball, but you don't have the angles because
- 41:36you need the right side angle to see if it hit
- 41:38that right arm. But another angle, and again,
- 41:42this wasn't what was challenged for. So they
- 41:45weren't looking at this. I see it as playing
- 41:48in a dangerous manner. Throwing yourself on the
- 41:51ball when you're competing for it with another
- 41:53player. And also deliberately trying to head
- 41:55the ball on the ground. Throwing your head into
- 41:58it. Yes. Like that for me is playing in a dangerous
- 42:02manner, which is still a caution. And if he's
- 42:06playing in a dangerous manner, he's still the
- 42:08last man. He's still, it's still denying a goal
- 42:11scoring opportunity by doing so. So I think,
- 42:15again, the challenge for the handball, I think
- 42:17my theory is it hits his right arm. I can't prove
- 42:20that theory because the angle we have from the
- 42:21net is shown for two seconds on broadcast. You
- 42:24can't see anything because it's so far away and
- 42:25grainy. The left side shows that it does not
- 42:28hit his left arm. I agree with that. It does
- 42:30roll through his chest quite a bit. It doesn't
- 42:33touch him when he stands up either. But the way
- 42:35that he plays that, the way he dives onto that
- 42:37ball for me is likely playing in a dangerous
- 42:40manner. Because again, if NFC tries to have a
- 42:42rip at that and doesn't touch it, you know, towards
- 42:45him and catches him. I don't put that on NFC.
- 42:49I put that on the guy who just dove on top of
- 42:51the ball. Yeah. And I think that's where the
- 42:54whole issue of interpretation comes into play.
- 42:56It's like, how can you determine his intent in
- 42:58that moment? Yeah. Right? Like, two players battling
- 43:01for the ball and he stumbles and falls on the...
- 43:04Like, there is no way for the official to determine
- 43:06intent. I've always viewed intent very differently,
- 43:09I think, to a lot of other people when it comes
- 43:11to the interpretation of the laws of the game.
- 43:13For me, the intent to... There's never, there's
- 43:1899 % of the time, there is no intent to injure
- 43:21when you're making a hard tackle or you're doing
- 43:23something right. Like unless it's a very obvious
- 43:25file of conduct, there's no intent to injure
- 43:27for most players on like a tackle that goes awry.
- 43:32Right. Or a scissors challenge or anything like
- 43:34that. But the intention is still to make the
- 43:37tackle right. As opposed to this, where he is
- 43:41intending to defend the ball. You can, and defend
- 43:45the player. You can't make the distinction of
- 43:47whether or not his diving is a part of his intent.
- 43:50He is intending to try and stop the player. As
- 43:54a result, he falls over because he's trying to
- 43:56stop the player. Does he make the most of that
- 43:59to try and get the ball away? Yes, obviously
- 44:01he's a defender. He's trying to knock the ball
- 44:02away. I, I just look at that and it's like, it
- 44:06is emblematic of the luck that Forge has sometimes.
- 44:10And I think that end of the day, I think. Good
- 44:13teams get lucky. You bake your own luck. And
- 44:15that just happened to be one of those cases.
- 44:17I think part of it is NFC's running style creates
- 44:23these scenarios where it is hectic and not very
- 44:26difficult to determine what is going to happen
- 44:29because he is not in control of himself a lot
- 44:32of the time. If he, if it was another striker
- 44:35who got past James. The physicality that creates
- 44:40that situation doesn't happen in my mind because
- 44:43that's not how most people run. And so if he
- 44:48doesn't, if the striker just gets around, and
- 44:50again, we're talking about a hypothetical that
- 44:52really doesn't matter because that's not what
- 44:53happened. But a striker who gets around him and
- 44:56wins the ball, the situation is never created.
- 44:59The situation is created specifically because
- 45:01of the way that NFC fights. And if he is just
- 45:03like a little bit more in control, I think that
- 45:06falls on the back of that. Yeah. Yeah. And again,
- 45:10there's a reason every guy's here. It's a rocky
- 45:13one. I'd love to hear from any refs if you want
- 45:15to reach out, if you have any interpretations
- 45:17on it. Again, I think at the end of the day,
- 45:19for what we challenged on, which was a handball,
- 45:22there's not a conclusive angle. So I'm all right
- 45:24with a non -call on that front. So that's the
- 45:28second call. And again, I think part of it is
- 45:29we're hard done by because all of the other little
- 45:31things keep getting biffed. So, you know, the
- 45:35big things feel like they're getting biffed too.
- 45:37We make some late subs with such a good game
- 45:40from our starting 11. Ray Abraham, in terms of
- 45:43subs, I turned to you and I said, look, how great
- 45:46would it be if he scores his first and wins this
- 45:48game? You don't have the same predictive power
- 45:52that I do when I said that Ralph Corey was going
- 45:55to come into the game against Supra and then
- 45:57literally won us the game. So, I mean, I'm Nostradamus.
- 46:03I'm just the doomsday guy on the corner with
- 46:05a sign. And I think he actually played pretty
- 46:09well. He, you know, he really put in the hustle.
- 46:13He really left it all out there. And like I said,
- 46:15the easiest way to my heart is work rate. Sequence
- 46:18where he chests the ball. We're trying to go
- 46:20in transition. He chests the ball down. It's
- 46:21just a little too slow, right? Where it's like,
- 46:24if he connects on this better, we continue the
- 46:27transition play and who knows what happened,
- 46:28but it's just. And again, it felt like from that
- 46:31sequence and onward, things were just kind of
- 46:34a touch off. It wasn't. catastrophic it wasn't
- 46:38terrible but it was just like there's a little
- 46:40bit little bit of polish where there's a ball
- 46:45from tabla to antinoro that's just a little over
- 46:47hit so gabby can't keep it in like there's little
- 46:51things where a run doesn't quite start on time
- 46:53so the ball's gone but generally it felt like
- 46:55we were we were pretty solid on the on the front
- 46:57foot for a lot of this half forge did have maybe
- 46:59a good 10 -15 minutes where i was getting sweating
- 47:02um and it wasn't just the 13 degree weather um
- 47:05that we they created maybe one or two things.
- 47:08That was the thing. That stretch was the only
- 47:09time in the game where they created anything
- 47:10from open play. And it was still very minimal
- 47:14in terms of what they were able to do from open
- 47:16play. And I think that was the biggest boon out
- 47:18of all of this is even when we weren't necessarily
- 47:20taking control of the game in the way that we
- 47:23would want to in the second half, they weren't
- 47:25really doing that either. Yeah. So... That's
- 47:29pretty much the game comes to a close. We get
- 47:31a corner at the death that doesn't quite go off.
- 47:33So we don't get our fairytale ending of that
- 47:3590 plus goal. We come away even maybe deserving
- 47:39a little more. Anything else you want to touch
- 47:41on from that half before we get into some stats
- 47:43and some player performances? Not really. Fair
- 47:47enough. In terms of stats, it pretty much aligns
- 47:50with the feeling we... Largely controlled the
- 47:53big chances, possession, XG, shots on target,
- 47:55and forged dominates at pieces. You know, we
- 47:59had 59 % possession, 1 .45 XG, and six shots
- 48:04on targets with two goal line clearances from
- 48:07Rama and three big chances. All missed, by the
- 48:10way. All missed. Yes. Five corners and 16 free
- 48:15kicks. We were actually even in fouls. between
- 48:17forge and ato even though it didn't feel like
- 48:20it now one could also argue that's not counting
- 48:23missed calls that's not counting you know a couple
- 48:26things but at the end of the day we end with
- 48:2916 free kicks forging 41 percent per 7 .1 or
- 48:320 .71 xg Three shots on target, no big chances,
- 48:37but 12 corners and their own 16 free kicks. I
- 48:41will note, again, we've been having this ongoing
- 48:43discussion about XG as a metric and how it's
- 48:46so variable. I think you remain correct in that
- 48:48it's very like the CPL stats are CPL stats. They
- 48:52reported 1 .18 XG for us and 0 .57 for Forge.
- 48:58Still about, they had about half. of what we
- 49:02got in terms of chances and expected goals, which,
- 49:05you know, fair enough. So that aligns, but you
- 49:08can see how those scales maybe don't weigh quite
- 49:11so well. All right. And look, like I mentioned
- 49:17earlier, there's no non -performers for me this
- 49:20week. I think everybody at the very, like anybody
- 49:23that would have been, I just didn't really notice.
- 49:26I didn't really notice. I think there was a lot
- 49:28of great things happening on the pitch. Let's
- 49:31talk about it. Who do you want to start with
- 49:33in terms of some individual praise? Anyone who
- 49:36spoke to me in the hours after the game knows
- 49:38that I was very, very happy to see what Tim Orneau
- 49:42put forward in this game. Young player, again,
- 49:46sort of playing at a position, right? We were
- 49:47told he was going to be a center mid. He's adapted
- 49:50well to being right back. 19 years old, first
- 49:53real game of consequence in, in this way, in
- 49:57this manner, in his professional career. And
- 49:59he stepped up and they got nothing done. Mm -hmm
- 50:02just absolutely denied anything down the left
- 50:05side of the pitch. And with we're not for the
- 50:08fact that we can see the two goals on set pieces,
- 50:09he really would have been in contention for like
- 50:11actual night of the match stuff. Just because
- 50:13I, I, I sit there and I watch and then I just.
- 50:17see a maturity and a calmness to him that far,
- 50:20far surpasses his years, which will only behoove
- 50:24him as he continues to grow as a player. I asked
- 50:28coach about Tim after the game, because he, look,
- 50:30this is a very Tim positive show. We've been
- 50:33very high on Arnaud and really excited for him.
- 50:36And coach kind of mentioned, yeah, look, like
- 50:38at the beginning of the year, he was a boy who
- 50:40wasn't playing much. He was playing a completely
- 50:42different position and he's really grown into
- 50:44his own this year. He's like, he's become a man.
- 50:47In that sense, because rights of passage are
- 50:49always fun to reference. So, yeah, just phenomenal
- 50:54from Tim offensively, defensively. It felt like
- 50:56he was contributing at every point. You know,
- 50:59absolutely fantastic performance from Tim. Definitely
- 51:03earned a start in the second leg as long as he's
- 51:06healthy. Agreed. All right. Next up, I want to
- 51:09raise Diego Gutierrez, kind of his redemption
- 51:11arc from a frustrating Forge game. Best we've
- 51:15seen him all year, I would argue. And that's
- 51:18not just talking about his goal. I think in a
- 51:21lot of ways, he was a great outlet and a great,
- 51:25you know, kind of team player in that sense.
- 51:27He received the ball well. He passed it out well.
- 51:30There's maybe one moment that I questioned a
- 51:32little bit with a deflection that. came off him.
- 51:37But at the end of the day, this is the goodie
- 51:39that we want to see. This is the goodie that
- 51:41we, you know, pay for in that sense. This, this
- 51:44was 2023 Diego Gutierrez, right? Like this was
- 51:48the player that took the league by storm was
- 51:50really ready to make a significant contribution
- 51:53to Calvary. And it just, it didn't work out.
- 51:55It was, I said this to a lot of people as well.
- 51:58It was a player who was channeling his emotion
- 52:00positively. In a way that we haven't seen in
- 52:03a while, right? Like, I think a lot of people
- 52:05would agree that he had channeled his emotions
- 52:07negatively in recent weeks and in the games,
- 52:11and I think especially in the previous matchup
- 52:14we had against Forge. But today it was, he was
- 52:18frustrated, but he used that frustration to build
- 52:22into the game and really make a difference in
- 52:24a way that he hadn't quite been able to for the
- 52:28rest of this, through the rest of the season
- 52:30to this point. 100%. 100%. And it's hard not
- 52:34to talk about Mono Aparicio. He got so much space
- 52:36to run. He was in the postgame presser. And he
- 52:39was asked about, you know, his space to Rome.
- 52:41And he's like, yeah, I didn't even really, you
- 52:43know, see it with the sun in my eyes. So I just,
- 52:47I couldn't see the past. So I just ran with it.
- 52:51Truly, truly a great game from him. A vintage
- 52:54performance where he's contributing up and down
- 52:56the pitch. He played, it seemed to me, he played
- 52:59a little bit more of the defensive. central midfield
- 53:02he was dropping in with the center backs too
- 53:04when we were in possession especially through
- 53:05the second half trying to get on the ball and
- 53:07trying to affect play in that way but i mean
- 53:09i said it earlier the amount of times i saw him
- 53:11turn into space like it felt he did that more
- 53:14today than he did the rest of the season combined
- 53:16Again, confirmation bias for my part, almost
- 53:18certainly. But it's one of those things where
- 53:21I took notice of it because it was happening
- 53:22again and again, and it made everything feel
- 53:24like we were on the front foot a lot more because
- 53:27we were taking space and we were able to create
- 53:30space and take it again and again and again.
- 53:33100%. 100%. Joachim Kulange, very similar, in
- 53:38my opinion, to Tim's performance in the sense
- 53:40of just really stalwart. And coach mentioned
- 53:44that Sergei also really came into his own this
- 53:46game. I would definitely agree. His long balls
- 53:49were great. His distribution was phenomenal.
- 53:51His defensive contributions. Five tackles, seven
- 53:54clearances, right? You have 13 defensive actions.
- 53:57He put a stamp on this game. Yeah, 100%. And
- 54:01so Sergei was also, from what Coach was saying,
- 54:05talking and communicating with Coulange to help
- 54:07him out. I mean, Coulange found himself in some,
- 54:09you know, one -on -twos that were really tricky
- 54:11and could have been punished more severely if
- 54:15he and Sergei weren't up to the task. Huge for
- 54:18both of them. And again, Coulange is dribbling.
- 54:22It's such a difference maker, especially from
- 54:25that deep. So good. I will say there were a couple
- 54:29of very wayward passes that could have been very
- 54:33detrimental to our overall mental health. But
- 54:36on the balance, I think Kulan's very effective
- 54:39on the deck. 100%. 100%. And I think, again,
- 54:43a lot is asked of him as that kind of pseudo
- 54:46-wingback. And so with so much asked of him,
- 54:50he's going to struggle in some capacities. But
- 54:53just a great game from him. And again, we're
- 54:55talking about like Tim, Coulange, Sergei. These
- 54:59are all young guys. These are all guys who aren't
- 55:01even 20 yet. Like, that's wild. Yeah. That we're
- 55:07getting this. And it's part of our identity as
- 55:10a club, it seems, to really focus on that youth
- 55:12development. But yeah. Anyone else you want to
- 55:15highlight? Balotabla. You want your best players
- 55:19to show out. You want your best players to be
- 55:21at their best. I think that week of rest did
- 55:23him a lot of good because anytime he was on the
- 55:25ball, it was dynamic. It was what we come to
- 55:29expect from him. The finish was gorgeous, right?
- 55:34We talked about a player who has had trouble
- 55:36at time finding his finishing boots. And in the
- 55:39most important moment, he takes it with aplomb.
- 55:43You can't do anything but applaud. your best
- 55:46player showing up and being at his best in the
- 55:48most important situations on the year. Yeah,
- 55:51100%. He did it in Toronto, he did it here. NFC
- 55:55and Dunn didn't have the showiest games they've
- 55:57had for us, but I think both did their roles
- 56:00well. NFC didn't get to pop off. Again, the ref
- 56:04certainly wasn't giving him anything. He got
- 56:06zero calls. So at the end of the day... I think
- 56:11he fought for it, and he showed that continued
- 56:14push that we love to see from him. And Julian
- 56:19Dunn has been our best defender for the past
- 56:21month and a half, two months. At the end of the
- 56:23day, it's great to see him thriving and continuing
- 56:25to push and do great things for this team. So
- 56:29many players did so well this game, and we could
- 56:31probably gush about them for another hour, but
- 56:34we're already pushing it on time. So that's enough
- 56:38from us. Time to hear from all of you. CCSG Mailbag.
- 56:44Welcome to the Mailbag, the segment of the show
- 56:46where we discuss your questions, comments, and
- 56:47hot takes. If you want to submit your thoughts
- 56:49for next game's Mailbag, be sure to send them
- 56:51to us on Discord, Instagram, email, or however
- 56:54else you can get a hold of us. All right, Patrick,
- 56:57kick us off. With the absolute disgrace of refereeing
- 57:02we watched, at what point does this start to
- 57:03harm the growth of the league? The consistent...
- 57:06The consistency of inconsistency during team
- 57:09matches drives the narrative and conspiracy of
- 57:11Forge being the favorite team in the CPL. At
- 57:14what point do the officials get held to higher
- 57:16standards? It's a tough question. I land on the
- 57:19side of Forge are just lucky fucks. They're really
- 57:22fortunate that they get a lot of things just
- 57:25fall in their favor. And again, you said earlier,
- 57:28good teams make their own luck and all that.
- 57:30But also, you know. They don't control the laws
- 57:34of physics. They don't control, you know, a deflection
- 57:37and the way it's going to bounce off Sergey's
- 57:39back. They can't control how a ref is going to
- 57:43not notice Colongo getting pushed backwards.
- 57:46At the end of the day, I think this is a problem
- 57:50globally. We will complain about referees in
- 57:53the Premier League. We'll complain about referees
- 57:55in the CPL. It's going to be something that we
- 57:58really live with. for the longest time. I think
- 58:02FVS has made it harder to live with, where because
- 58:06it disrupts the flow and the pace. And look,
- 58:07Bobby didn't challenge anything this game. There
- 58:10wasn't really anything for him to challenge.
- 58:11But, you know, at the end of the day, there was
- 58:14nothing happening to challenge for there. And
- 58:20it's going to look favorable to Forge because
- 58:24they're lucky fucks. Officials should get held
- 58:28to higher standards, but the reality of the standards
- 58:30is it's Canadian soccer standards, which aren't
- 58:35that high. It's, yeah. We were having this discussion.
- 58:39I mean, the NSL had some refereeing issues over
- 58:42the course of the weekend just as much, and they're
- 58:43pulling from the same refereeing pool as we are
- 58:45at this point. There are 19 qualified center
- 58:48referees, and even then, it's only really 15
- 58:51with four of them being in the development program.
- 58:55Don't see either of the two women who referee
- 58:57from that program in the CPL at all. So realistically
- 59:02we are working from a pool of 17 referees to
- 59:05referee for matches every week. And that's not
- 59:09going to grow anytime soon. Right. The standards
- 59:13aren't going to grow either with the current
- 59:15institutions in place, right? Like Canada soccer
- 59:18is still trying to get rid of the rot that has
- 59:20existed in its organization for decades. We can
- 59:24talk about how great Cut and Blue's been at organizing
- 59:26and philanthropizing and getting money into the
- 59:29program. There's still a lot of leftovers from
- 59:31previous administrations that aren't suited for
- 59:36the roles that they are in. And until that happens,
- 59:41we're not going to see substantive reform in
- 59:44the way that our referees are managed. I think
- 59:46a lot of it comes down to a lack of transparency
- 59:48because I don't think the public should have
- 59:50referee reports. handed to them i think it just
- 59:54exacerbates conspiracy theories and i think it
- 59:58puts a real emphasis on a lack of critical thinking
- 1:00:03and a critical approach to the way that referees
- 1:00:06analyze games and everything like that i think
- 1:00:08the more information is available to the public
- 1:00:10in this context a public that is generally pretty
- 1:00:13misinformed about the laws of the game i don't
- 1:00:16think it would be a good thing and i'm a sicko
- 1:00:18who quite enjoys the laws of the game So I want
- 1:00:22it all. And I think in many ways, it's the opacity
- 1:00:25of things also makes it very frustrating where
- 1:00:28I think we need to be willing to accept. I saw
- 1:00:31what I saw or I didn't see what I didn't see
- 1:00:34as an answer sometimes. But I want to hear what
- 1:00:41a ref was thinking in making or not making a
- 1:00:44call. I want to see that. I think that transparency
- 1:00:46helps also humanize them in a lot of ways. at
- 1:00:49the end of the day, they're humans. They're going
- 1:00:52to make errors. They're going to have issues.
- 1:00:54And it's going to be very frustrating. It's going
- 1:00:56to be infuriating. And we're going to boo them.
- 1:00:58And that's going to be part of it. And they need
- 1:01:01to do better. And they should do better, just
- 1:01:03like a lot of people should at their jobs. I
- 1:01:05think adding a little more transparency is helpful,
- 1:01:09at least for rational people. There will always
- 1:01:12be an irrational group who will hate a decision
- 1:01:15no matter what. But they already exist and they
- 1:01:17already made the decision. So I think you're
- 1:01:19winning over some people by actually explaining
- 1:01:22the call. And it's tough to do it in -game, during
- 1:01:24the game. It's got to be a post -game kind of
- 1:01:27situation. I think there's a difference, though.
- 1:01:30I think there's a difference between explaining
- 1:01:33what happened on the day. And publicizing the
- 1:01:36evaluations that are done of these referees.
- 1:01:39Oh, I don't think the evaluations should be public.
- 1:01:42No, because that actually fuels conspiracy. Yeah.
- 1:01:47I think I would much rather, in terms of an accountability
- 1:01:51kind of structure, again, have them explain the
- 1:01:54decision. And in my view, we almost should be
- 1:01:58looking to get a real pot of money together to
- 1:02:01fund the referees for this league. If you've
- 1:02:05talked to me at any length about this, you'll
- 1:02:07know that I want a transfer market for referees.
- 1:02:10So I'm a little out. I mean, I'm starting to
- 1:02:12have stats there now. So I'm just saying, let's
- 1:02:15develop some good refs and move them up. But
- 1:02:18that's beyond the federation system and a lot
- 1:02:21of other things. So again, I think the standards
- 1:02:24are going to be what they're going to be. And
- 1:02:26as mentioned, we don't have that many refs that
- 1:02:29we can rotate through. But look, I live this
- 1:02:34frustration. All right, next question. What did
- 1:02:38NFC do to the referee? Did he, I'm going to make
- 1:02:42this one a little more polite, make love to his
- 1:02:44wife, threaten his children? NFC was not able
- 1:02:48to get a single call from him. They could have
- 1:02:51killed him on the pitch and the referee would
- 1:02:53have said no foul. That's one man's opinion.
- 1:02:57I don't think. For as much as referees get abused,
- 1:03:00I don't want to accuse any of them of having
- 1:03:02a cock fetish. But I suppose that if he had a
- 1:03:06cock fetish, then he would have welcomed that
- 1:03:08happening. I don't know. I'm spiraling. I don't
- 1:03:11know how to answer any of this. It falls in line
- 1:03:13with what we were just saying. Yeah. At the end
- 1:03:15of the day, I agree. NFC couldn't get a foul
- 1:03:17to save his life. Meanwhile, they were giving
- 1:03:20anything to Jensen that he wanted. So very frustrating.
- 1:03:24Sometimes those games just happen. Our boy Tablet
- 1:03:28knows them all too well. All right. Have we heard
- 1:03:33from the league whether or not Arnaud will be
- 1:03:35forced to dig Patton out of his pocket and return
- 1:03:38him in time for the second leg? Yes, the league
- 1:03:40has announced that Arnaud will not be returning
- 1:03:42him from his pocket and he's going to stay there
- 1:03:45for the entire second leg, hopefully. I'm sure
- 1:03:47Patton will protest and try and climb out, but
- 1:03:50we can only hope that he will remain in that
- 1:03:52pocket for at least another 115 minutes at most.
- 1:03:58Exactly. Am I the only one who predicted back
- 1:04:00in the summer that we'd be on the march with
- 1:04:02Arnaud looking down the right and Dunn feasting
- 1:04:05on the league's number nines? Yes, not even I
- 1:04:08could have predicted the Julia Dunn thing. I'll
- 1:04:10hold my hands up and say that might be the single
- 1:04:12biggest surprise we've had this season. And it's
- 1:04:16all the better for it. I think you could have
- 1:04:19convinced me that Tin would have played a proper,
- 1:04:21somewhat of a role, but not to the extent that
- 1:04:23he has. I think they've both been a revelation.
- 1:04:26And I think... Julian especially exposes the
- 1:04:30importance of different profiles at center back.
- 1:04:34I know we had talked like JD had mentioned this
- 1:04:36in our interview with him last week was how heavily
- 1:04:39we were focused on ball playing center backs
- 1:04:41in order to accommodate Diego style at the beginning
- 1:04:43of the year. Right. And then that as a result,
- 1:04:47sort of limited potential physicality in a lot
- 1:04:51of ways. And Julian has really reintroduced like,
- 1:04:55no, I'm at center back. You're not going to be
- 1:04:57able to get through me. And yeah, maybe we lose
- 1:04:59like a tiny bit in terms of how he plays out
- 1:05:01the back, but. It also makes everything simpler,
- 1:05:04right? He's not going to try and overcomplicate
- 1:05:06things when he's on the ball in the back line.
- 1:05:09And he adds that whole dimension of, okay, now
- 1:05:13when we go away to forge, Oketekun isn't just
- 1:05:16going to run through Sergei three times and score
- 1:05:18in the second half like what happened last time,
- 1:05:20right? These little things that can compound
- 1:05:23when you have too many players that have the
- 1:05:26same profile in a position, you're able to balance
- 1:05:29it out. And it really has been one of the best
- 1:05:33and most important things for the success that
- 1:05:36we have enjoyed in the second half of the season.
- 1:05:38100%. 100%. Julian Dunn, I think, has done a
- 1:05:42phenomenal job. I think a lot of us are ready
- 1:05:44for a depth piece, but we got an absolute beauty
- 1:05:47instead. All right. Indeed. And for our last
- 1:05:50English language question, Julian, you big beauty,
- 1:05:54sign me up for the fan club. Let's pack the bus
- 1:05:57to watch the boys on the donut hole and end those
- 1:06:00orange white bags season. Post -script. If that
- 1:06:03first half didn't give you a sport -rection,
- 1:06:05go see your doctor immediately. And if that sport
- 1:06:08-rection is lasting more than seven days, then
- 1:06:13see a doctor about that as well. I'll sign on
- 1:06:17to the Julian Dunn fan club just along with them.
- 1:06:20At the end of the day, we do want to pack this
- 1:06:22bus. We want to bring a real atmosphere. to the
- 1:06:27donut box or whatever. They've rebranded it to,
- 1:06:29I think, Karmat Stadium or something. We have
- 1:06:34the ability to impact the game in a way of bringing
- 1:06:37energy and encouragement. And we got to deliver
- 1:06:40on that. Again, this road trip is hard. I'm not
- 1:06:43saying it's easy. But like going to the moon,
- 1:06:46we don't do things because they're easy. We do
- 1:06:48them because they're hard. And because, you know,
- 1:06:50based on this question, we might also be hard
- 1:06:53with a sport reaction. So that's... That's where
- 1:06:56we'll leave the English mailbag, I suppose. Yeah,
- 1:06:57I'm not commenting any further because there's
- 1:07:01no way. This would turn into a Joey rant about
- 1:07:05something that would definitely need to get cut
- 1:07:07from the podcast. This has actually probably
- 1:07:09been the spiciest the mailbag has really gotten
- 1:07:11all year. Playoffs do that to people. The playoff
- 1:07:14spirit is alive and well. Call it an aphrodisiac.
- 1:07:17All right, let's dive into the French segment
- 1:07:18of our podcast. We like to call En France, s
- 1:07:20'il vous plaît, where we answer a few questions
- 1:07:22in French. Allons -y. Ambiance de malade, on
- 1:07:26veut le dub comme ça pour 2027. Que pensez -vous?
- 1:07:30Et non seulement pour 2027, pour le 21 novembre
- 1:07:34aussi. On espère. Si Dieu nous le donne. Oui,
- 1:07:37c 'était super. Nous avons discuté tantôt l 'idée
- 1:07:42que nous pourrons remplir le dub avec des personnes
- 1:07:48qui ne sont pas conscientes de tout ce qui arrive
- 1:07:51dans notre section. And we can develop this atmosphere
- 1:07:55throughout a game for all 90 minutes and not
- 1:08:00only 45 or just after we score. It was there
- 1:08:04from the beginning to the end of the week. To
- 1:08:07continue like that, with that, it's a good future
- 1:08:13if it can continue for next year and all the
- 1:08:17next games. Oui, je suis complètement d 'accord.
- 1:08:21Et je l 'ai mentionné, comme ça se fait environ
- 1:08:26une heure, que les Capos ont fait un excellent
- 1:08:31job. Je veux vraiment remercier Brandon, Alina,
- 1:08:34puis Shane aussi pour leurs efforts. C 'est quelque
- 1:08:38chose de très difficile quand le job est si plein,
- 1:08:40que t 'apportes l 'énergie pour le 90. Et ça
- 1:08:44veut dire qu 'il faut faire des ajustements.
- 1:08:47Très rapidement. Parce que ça se peut qu 'une
- 1:08:49chanson, ça ne fonctionne pas trop. Et il faut
- 1:08:52qu 'on le change parce que personne ne peut l
- 1:08:54'entendre ou quelque chose. Alors, comme toujours,
- 1:08:57je pense que c 'est aussi un testament un peu
- 1:09:00à l 'effort qu 'on a mis pour ramener des gens,
- 1:09:04pour leur inviter de chanter avec nous et d 'autres
- 1:09:07choses. C 'est peut -être quelque chose pour
- 1:09:09le futur qu 'on a besoin d 'autres bénévoles
- 1:09:11pour aider dans le système de dire aux gens,
- 1:09:14hey. You're sitting anywhere and after the game
- 1:09:20starts, standing up, not standing up, standing
- 1:09:22up for Sissoko. So it's something really special
- 1:09:28that we can do as a group, as a partisan. So
- 1:09:33I hope people will try their best to recreate
- 1:09:37it. And not just for the playoffs, not just for
- 1:09:39one moment. For all the games. Where were the
- 1:09:45Hamilton partisans? Plus de job, plus d 'argent.
- 1:09:48Regarde, c 'est une économie un peu difficile.
- 1:09:51On doit nationaliser Stalco. Oui, et comme ça,
- 1:09:56Ottawa va vraiment acheter un peu la ville d
- 1:10:00'Hamilton. Mais je pense qu 'en partie, c 'était
- 1:10:04probablement parce qu 'il y avait quelques -uns
- 1:10:06qui ont venu pour le match il y a quelques semaines.
- 1:10:10Alors, les gens ne vont probablement pas faire
- 1:10:13deux fois. 14 jours ou 16 jours, quelque chose
- 1:10:16comme ça. Mais aussi, c 'est simplement parce
- 1:10:19que je pense qu 'ils sont un groupe qui s 'apparaissent
- 1:10:23un peu plus lorsque c 'est le fin d 'un série
- 1:10:28et non au début. Dans le sens que pour ceux d
- 1:10:32'Hamilton, tu l 'as vu l 'année passée, 1 contre
- 1:10:352, il n 'y avait pas grand monde là -bas à Hamilton.
- 1:10:40Et c 'était chez eux. Alors... Voyager, si ce
- 1:10:44n 'est pas un final et d 'autres choses. Ils
- 1:10:46sont un peu aussi gâtés avec leur succès. Oh,
- 1:10:49je ne veux pas voyager pour ça ou d 'autres choses.
- 1:10:51Lorsqu 'on veut être là pour notre équipe, n
- 1:10:54'importe quoi. Alors, je sais qu 'il y avait
- 1:10:57six ou sept gens qui étaient du côté des bancs.
- 1:11:01Qui l 'ont mis sur le côté du nord. Ce que j
- 1:11:05'ai entendu, c 'était tout des... Ils travaillaient
- 1:11:07tout pour le club. Alors, ce n 'est pas vraiment
- 1:11:09des partisans comme tel. Mais quand même... And
- 1:11:18that brings us to the end of our mailbag. Thank
- 1:11:21you so much to everyone who sent in questions,
- 1:11:23comments, everything. If they're silly, if they're
- 1:11:26a bit out there, we'll still read them out. We'll
- 1:11:29still have some fun with it. And we'd love so
- 1:11:31much to hear from you on the next episode. Hopefully,
- 1:11:33it will be a very exciting episode where we will
- 1:11:35be discussing what comes next in this process.
- 1:11:39But we don't count any chickens till they hatch.
- 1:11:42Before we close out this episode, we would like
- 1:11:44to invite you, if you aren't already, to become
- 1:11:46a member of CCSG at CapitalCSupporters .com.
- 1:11:49Membership gets you access to our members -only
- 1:11:50Discord, along with priority access to events
- 1:11:53such as our road trips. It also helps support
- 1:11:55great content like ATO for the Dubs, so if you're
- 1:11:57enjoying this podcast, share it with a friend,
- 1:11:59you know? Maybe not this one, depending on how
- 1:12:01you feel about the mailbag. Reminder, if you
- 1:12:05haven't purchased road trip tickets, they are
- 1:12:07limited, so grab them now. This is not a road
- 1:12:09trip we are organizing, but the club, huge thanks
- 1:12:11to them for doing so. They are losing money,
- 1:12:14I guarantee, on this road trip. As someone who
- 1:12:16has costed these things out, it is a great deal
- 1:12:19at $55. The second leg is our most important
- 1:12:22game of the year. At the end of the day, it's
- 1:12:24all or nothing now, and we need to be spending
- 1:12:27that day, spending that game together as a community.
- 1:12:31Be that in Hamilton. or at the pub, whichever
- 1:12:33is best for you. Kickoff is at 1 p .m., so be
- 1:12:37sure to check out the Dubb Dispatch or the Discard
- 1:12:39to secure your tickets. And yeah, we're going
- 1:12:43to be covering the first drink at the pub, so
- 1:12:45if that helps you get over the line, I'm sure
- 1:12:48there'll be some libations on the bus as well.
- 1:12:50So we hope to see you Saturday in red and white,
- 1:12:52and it'll be a great day. All right, that's the
- 1:12:55end of our show, and thank you so much for listening.
- 1:12:57This has been ATO for the Dubb, and we hope you'll
- 1:12:59join us again sometime soon.