Latest / Ego and Other Things / Parenting and Government
Transcript
- William: So basically how would I explain this to a friend? The relationship between parenting and government is probably not obvious, but I think that once we understand it, it starts to explain a lot of the psychological incentives behind while why people still hold on to the state, to a monopoly of violence as the primary way to to organize society and to organize collective relationships with one another. I think there are great similarities between the parent child relationship, the power dynamic involved there, and how it gets exploited, and the citizen to state relationship, the power dynamic there, and how that gets exploited. I think at the very least if we can understand one, it can help us to understand the other, and maybe we can see how they influence each other and perhaps even support each other. I talked about this before, but the parent-child relationship is one of a great and unique power and balance that we don't really encounter anywhere else in our day-to-day lives. The child, in relationship to their parent or their caregiver, doesn't have any choice, doesn't have any power. They don't get to choose their parents. They're born to their parents. Their intellectual, social, emotional, and physical capacities from the very beginning are incredibly limited and they depend for everything that they have. Not just their survival, but their ability to get along with other people, the opportunities that they get to Pursue the things that they really want in their life. Again, access to resources and healthcare, education, socialization, practically everything that we have, we have because of our parents. And not because we sort of choose our parents, but because we are we are born to them and our parents have, they at least should have a responsibility to take care of us. and provide us at the very least the basics of life. And when you look at the parent-child relationship historically, it's it's it's pretty dark in the sense that many children didn't survive childhood. And while I can't really get into the nitty-gritty on YouTube. The r the the r or a large reason as to why children do not survive was because of the actions of their parents, either by neglect or by a a purposeful I guess you could call it a purposeful neglect. Essentially, parents didn't have the the resources always or or the time or the ability to care for the children that they had. There was no contraceptives, it was really difficult to do to do family planning and most of The techniques around family planning were largely ineffective or or dangerous to the mother at the time. And so because of their lack of ability to take care of the children, they a a lot of the children were allowed to die in one way or another, or were simply outright killed. And the infanticide is really just one side. The story. There's much more gruesome side to the story that again I really can't get into here, though I've written about it on my Substack and other places. but we can just even take a look at the infanticide, and that can give us a real understanding of what's of what's gone on there. in that kind of dynamic, children, insofar as they survived was was largely due to either their usefulness to their parents in the task of survival itself, or by the Parents' fondness for the child. So, you know, essentially children were costly, and keeping the children around can be incredibly economically or survival costly to the parents themselves because the children take up resources and food and time and energy, but they don't really contribute anything or they're not able to contribute much until they're at least a little bit older. So you're talking probably at least, you know, five years or so of. keeping a child alive and and of that and essentially giving them resources and food and time and energy and sleepless nights and the children often would contract diseases that could be passed on to the parents and killed them. Childbirth itself was was incredibly deadly. And so when the parents had to come to the decision of who are we going to neglect, who are we going to take resources away from, and who are we going to keep, the metrics by which they they generally chose that was, well, how useful is this is this child to the family or to our survival? So if you lived on sort of a a primitive farm and you had to choose which of your children were going to survive. You might choose the one who is you know 10 years old and can work on the farm rather than the two-year-old baby, who, in from a survival perspective, is useless. So they would often take those babies and expose them. Many babies were killed just by outright exposure or starvation, or in some cultures, even sacrifice. Other than that, if the child was malformed or particularly ugly or particularly irksome or got in the way a lot or disobeyed their parents a lot, essentially if the child was difficult to be around either socially or physically, and they were carried an extra burden, this could be another reason that parents would get rid of the child in one way or another. In the beginning this could be in in the beginning of human history this could this is really just as brute as something like exposure and infanticide, but later on you had instances of of slavery and and essentially the selling of your selling of your children, depending on what what you could get, right? And not only this, but the actual behavior of children needed to be tightly controlled in those kinds of environments because it was important as far as every member could to get them to contribute to the survival of the family as much as possible. So taking that example of the of the sort of primitive farm. Oftentimes the children had to contribute to the labor in some way, either in the household with their mother or on the farm with their father, for example. And you know, the desire to to do chores and and farm is not something that is n necessarily natural to to most children. So the parents would use force and violence, intimidation and threats in order to force their children to do what was necessary in order to to survive. And again, this really was. necessary at for for long stretches of human history, if the children were did not contribute to the survival of the household, it could really put in danger the entire family. If if if Johnny didn't pull his weight on the farm, there might not be enough food in the barn in order to to get through the winter, for example. And you can essentially take that same i i i this is not something that necessarily just applied to farming, but This applied to to tribal survival as well. People's view of each other was a view of utility based on how useful is this person to the broader social survival here. And the roles that were not strictly tied to survival were relegated often to the very old who had were were seen as sort of earning their place, at least in most cultures. In some cultures, they just got rid of the old people as well. But there was this idea that you had if you had lived long enough to be old, then that was such a rare occurrence that the person was in one way honored. Or else the the person had to provide a a such a an important psychological contribution to society that they they were freed from labor. So oftentimes the the priestly religious shaman kind of class was this class and they often mixed with the the older members of the tribe, the ones that had survived into into old age. these classes often were were linked together. And then, of course, people who were at the top of the hierarchy, the kings, the tribal leaders, they their labor was mostly contributing to either warfare or to keeping order within the tribe. But within the family, the survival of the family, both physically and socially, often depended on the children in some significant ways. And so the parents had a great survival and social incentive to make sure that their children not only conformed to the kind of labor that the parents need them to do, but conformed to the social expectations of the tribe. Being ostracized from the tribe as a child would could would would almost guarantee death. If the tribe decided to sacrifice a child and they they picked this one, they often picked the one that was the the most sort of useless. And that's the one that they would they would sacrifice. And not only that, but the child needed to become accustomed to the to the tribe itself in order to survive as an adult, be able to navigate the different kinds of strictures. And a child acting in a sort of dishonorable way could leave a mark or a stain, a social stain, on the family itself and on the parents themselves. And so The parents had a very like I said, a great incentive to control and corral their children, and and force them to labor, meaning that the child was sort of was not free. From the beginning, the child was was not free to sort of act for the sake of what they they truly value, to sort of discover themselves, to act authentically, to express their true thoughts and feelings, to feel their their true emotions, because all of this could get in the way of the day-to-day survival needs and the social needs of the family in relationship to themselves and really in relationship to the broader tribe. Force and violence was the fundamental structure of the family unit for the vast majority of our of our history. And in fact, it still dominates the structure of parenting today, just in softer and and more indirect ways that we don't necessarily pick up on. But we still use force and violence against children in a particularly unique way that we wouldn't use against each other. In a sort of individual way. And the the force and violence that's inherent in the parent-child relationship stands out as odd in relationship to the majority of relationships that adults have to one another, at least in a day-to-day context. The only place where where this is different is in relationship to the state. But there is a class of other adult individuals. Who are not more morally righteous, not fundamentally different, not a different species, not sort of morally superior, not necessarily wiser than us, that rule are our nations, right? There is some class or group of of rulers that inflict rules and and strictures on the so-called citizens through force and violence without the consent of the people they they inflict those rules on. and this applies even in a place like the modern US, where nobody has actually consented to a democratic republic as the the means by which they choose to rule, but rather they're sort of born into the structure. The structure is imposed on them by force and violence. And the actual content of that structure, and even on the structur even the structure itself, is enforced by a select group of people through force and violence. Which is again a relationship that we wouldn't accept in any other circumstance in our life. In one on one relationships, we abhor force and violence. We don't believe that we have the right to go and force any kind of of way of living on other human beings besides resisting force and and violence itself. That that is to say that if someone uses force against me, most people would believe they have a right to some sort of self-defense and to to sort of restore things back to the original position to where there wasn't the imposition of force and violence. But we wouldn't we do not feel as though it is moral for for us to go out and violently impose our own subjective understanding of what it means to live a good life on other people. Rather we tolerate other people's ways of living. And so long as they're not committing force and violence against us, then We don't use force and violence against them. And that is sort of the the the basic moral intuitive logic that we apply in a an on a day-to-day one-on-one basis. You might even call this, you know, another extrapolation of the golden rule. People don't want force and violence being used against them, so they don't use force and violence against other people. And the people that we do, we consider immoral and we abhor them. But at the same time, we have this special class of bureaucrats or politicians or people who have control over the dominant power of society that imposed through force and violence their own understanding of how society ought to operate, how we should go about living in terms of our markets, in terms of our social world, in terms of our relationships with other nations. In terms of how we we spend our money, in terms of what we are allowed to do on the day-to-day basis, on who we're allowed to marry, on all kinds of in all in all kinds of different ways, the state interferes with the lives of individuals. And the state, of course, is nothing other than other individuals. It's just other adults who happen to have control over the monopolization of power that we call the state. And so you can kind of already see that. Parallel power dynamics that exist between the individual and the state and the child and the parent. The child has no power to resist the violence of their parents, even in the modern day. The child has no conception of child protective services or the actual options available to them to get away from their parents if they needed to. Again, they're radically constrained. in their in their intelligence, in their emotions, in their knowledge, in their physicality, whomever their their caretakers are, they have to endure. They have to be subjected to their force and violence. They have to be subjected to their whims. They have to be subjected to their arbitrary rules. They have to be subjected to whatever the parents deem is right for the child. It is not a relationship of mutual respect and understanding. It is not a relationship of the parent helping the child to grow into the whom the child actually is, but rather imposing sort of their own ideas of who the child should be on the child by force and violence. And the child has no power to resist this. The child has no power to even understand what is really happening to them. Their entire psychology, their entire native mindset is itself constructed by the parents. And the child has every incentive psychological from a psychoevolutionary perspective, they have every incentive to conform readily. To what the parents is asking them, insofar as as they must. I mean, there's degrees to which they they try to get away with it, so to speak, but they they understand the boundaries of which they must conform to in order to receive love and care for their parents, because they know that they are dependent on their parents fundamentally for their survival. There is a sort of subtle threat in the parent-child relationship that says, that says and comes from our evolutionary past or comes from our historical past that says. If you do not conform enough to what I am to what the parent tells you to do, you're in danger. Your life is in danger. Your your bodily integrity is in danger. That force and violence will will be inflicted on you. And even today, there are there children all over the world suffer from the force and violence of their parents. Peaceful parenting, non-force-based, non-violence-based parenting is today still. something which is incredibly rare. In fact, corporal punishment is is legal in many of the states in the US at the very least. So quite literal force and violence the hitting children is still legal in much of the US and so this is something that that that is still very much with us but the further back you go the more intense it is. And so the child really has no other choice but to conform to the the parents' expectations. And then perhaps when they're when they're teenagers and they have a little bit more physical power, they have a little bit more independence, they have a little bit better perspective on how their parents have treated them, then they can actually make their own decisions and act for the sake of what they what they value. When it comes to the parent-child relationship, we still haven't gotten to the point where we actually respect that a child is a human being. With their own authentic wants and needs. We don't give them the same kind of basic moral respect that we give to ourselves, and it's one of the great failings of modern society in general, and is at the same time, I think, one of the psychological roots that perpetuates the state violence, because the individual's relationship to the state is about the same thing. The state has the power of force and violence, it has the massive Control the use of deadly force. And if the citizen steps outside of the certain constraints that the state has imposed on the individual, even though the individual hasn't agreed or consented either to the structure or to the laws, the state will use force and violence against the individual and ultimately will kill them if the individual violates the boundaries, so to speak. This really applies to any kind of law. The basis of law is comply or die. That's not a phrase original to me, but I think it really spells it out. Law is about comply or die. And what that means is that if you break a law and you get caught, because that's the one element of it, right? You have to get caught. If you can get away with it, you get away with it. But that's very much like how. a child if they can get away with breaking one of their their parents' rules, then they get away with it. There's no there's no sort of punishment. If the individual, if the citizen, breaks a law and they get caught, then the state escalates things to another level, right? And they maybe they maybe it's a it's a smaller law, so they just impose a fine on you. And then it's again, comply or die. You either comply with the the fine, you pay the fine, right? Or you don't. And if you don't pay the fine, eventually this gets brought to court. Let's say you don't go, you don't go to court, they're gonna send an an officer to your house in order to to put you in contempt of court. If you if you continue to to ignore that, you don't comply with with going to the judge and going to the court and paying the fine and doing all the things that they continue to impose on you, then eventually they're going to send an officer to your house to arrest you. Or they'll put a warrant out for your arrest. So the next time you're driving, they'll pull you over. And if they see that warrant, they'll arrest you. And then from that point, if you try to effectively resist arrest, again you refuse to comply with the orders, then they are either going to physically subdue you by beating you, tasering you, pinning you to the ground. They're going to either physically make you submit and so comply. Or they're going to continue to escalate the violence if you're resisting effectively enough until you until they kill you. So they're behind every law, no matter how small it may seem, if you break the law and you get caught, and they decide to to prosecute you for it, because sometimes the state just arbitrarily decides not to prosecute people, even if they they break a law. So it's kind of a the law is not something which actually applies to everybody. It depends on who's ever in charge of Of actually executing the law. And it's very arbitrary in that way. And of course, many powerful people get away with breaking the law because prosecutions simply just refuse to actually to do so. But anyway, if you break the law and you refuse to comply and they they charge you for it, and you continue to refuse to comply to the ex ex Escalations of threats and force and violence, eventually they will kill you. And so the logic behind every law is comply or die. And that's actually the reason why people follow the law, because at some level they understand this. At some level, they know that if I don't comply with the law at some point, if I don't comply with what these people in government or what this person who calls himself a police officer, what they're telling me to do, I will die. Or I will be seriously injured. Or I will be forced, physically forced and subdued and locked in a box somewhere. Threats, violence, and death sit at the base of all law. Even the smallest, most seemingly minuscule law. Underneath that lies violence and force and threat. And that is what actually makes people comply. It is not the sense in which we all come to the to to consent to the law. We've all come to the rational conclusion that the state and its wisdom is what's going to, you know, really define how we live life and really going to create the best society. Of course, the vast, vast majority of people, something like 90% of people, are greatly dissatisfied with the way the way the state actually operates. So it's not about consent, it's not about choice, it's not about the wisdom. Of democracy or the wisdom of the bureaucracy that runs our lives, or the wisdom of Congress or the president, it's these are merely window dressings on the use of force and violence to impose arbitrary limits and arbitrary rules on citizens through death. And that's that's actually how they get people to comply with the laws, because if that threat of death did not sit underneath the law, Then people wouldn't follow the law. They would act for the sake of what they truly valued, not follow the law. The law has no independent power, it's just a bunch of pieces of papers that people have written on, not anything real. What is real is the gun. What is real is the beatings. What is real is the jailhouse. What is real is the threat and death and violence which undergirds it all. And the individual is entirely. Powerless to resist this, particularly in a physical way. one man cannot stand up to the state in really any capacity and not get get hammered down by by force and violence. Even on an intellectual and cultural level, there is so much cultural and historical baggage related to the state that anybody, even somebody like myself, you you go out and you you just break down the basics of these kinds of things, you're going to get hit with all kinds of really just virulent people. Like not people who are interested in having a rational conversation with it, but people who just kind of react very emotionally and they it it's almost like they are personally committed to the existence of a state which ha which doesn't care about them as an individual at all. There's a great emotional resonance with this and many people get caught up in notions of patriotism and nationalism and which are these just these kinds of fantasies as though, you know, this this particular geographic area had some sort of significance to it, right? Or as if, you know, the people of the past genuinely The the the violent governments and states of the past really had a genuine interest in in the people and weren't just lording over them through force and violence. So it's really hard to find a rational conversation about that in general. and this is just to say, I mean, it doesn't mean that it is the the end of overcoming the state. I think eventually they there can be cultural and intellectual. developments that can help dismantle the state, some of which have been progressing since the Enlightenment. But more related to this topic, there is the parental dismantling that is equally as important. Because part of the reason why people are are so willing to psychologically swallow the violence of the state, this relationship of overwhelming violence being lorded over you. For the sake of imposing arbitrary laws, which you did not or arbitrary rules or ways of living, which you did not consent to, which you did not choose, and which you were born into. The reason that people are are so willing to accept that that giant power disparity and willing to and in one sense accept not being free is because the near-universal experience of childhood is exactly the same. You are a powerless child. In relationship to a parent who has overwhelming, almost godlike power over you, at least from the child's perspective, whom you must submit to, you must conform yourself to in one way or another, in order to survive, in order to get love and care for them from them. You bury your authentic self, you bury what you actually value or want. And maybe, maybe if you wake to the fact later, you can you rediscover that. But in the parent-child relationship, it is very much I am born to this situation and I must submit to the power of my parents regardless of what they tell me to do or how to or how to live. And I must bury my own emotions and bury my own my own authentic desires and wants and and who I am andor to conform with them. And that kind of psychological scaffolding translates very neatly. later on to the the state citizen relationship. That relationship between the state and the citizen feels natural. because the state, we know we've we kind of forget that the state is just people. We forget that the state are is individuals. And I think that sometimes we think of the state as just this, you know, giant, overwhelming, abstract power that rules over our life, y if we even get that far into to thinking about it or conceiving it, you know, the The government is not people and individuals using force and violence against us. It's like this giant abstract entity that rules in the background of our lives that we just continually debate about. But that sort of giant power that sits behind the rules of our life, that's a very similar feeling that the child has phenomenally towards their their parents. And so I think that it doesn't strike us as odd when we grow up, unless we're sort of conscious of the parent-child relationship already. The the state citizen relationship doesn't strike us as odd because we just had it in our childhood, right? I mean, we we were we just came out of that that relationship of dependence in the teenage years. And by the way, a lot of the reason why teenagers struggle so much and why they rebel so much is because they are unconsciously rebelling. against that that unfair and unjust power structure that they were that was inflicted on them as children. And now they're sort of, again, I think in an unconscious way, perceiving the power struggle that's going to come up there, right? But what do you learn as an adult? What you learn as an adult is that you have to comply with the state, whether it makes sense or not, whether it's rational or not, whether it benefits you or not, whether it's in line with who you are and what what you want for your life. You have to conform with the violence of the state and its dictates, regardless of what you think, and regardless of whether you you've chosen to or not, because it holds the power of life and death over you. And so you learn, you you you take the habits you learned as a child and you just apply them now to the state. The state becomes your new parent, right? there's that that old conservative joke of like the nanny state. And it's closer than than what people think. in some ways, because the state creates these dependencies and and it it makes itself necessary for life, but also because it really does reflect the old parent-child relationship that happened in the past. And the you know, the vast majority of people are are not even necessarily aware of the parent-child relationship, never mind the state-citizen relationship. In fact, I think that I mean there are do two big reasons why people get so obsessed over politics and heated and why politics breaks apart families. One is that the state really does just on the daily interfere with people's lives in such a significant way that individuals are trying to grasp at what little power or influence they might have over the state, which is effectively zero. They are so much so desperately trying to impact the power of the state as far as they can because they know the overwhelming power it has over their lives. But the second reason that it's so passionate is that it becomes a perfect abstract entity to express one's anger and frustration and pain towards rather than the parent-child relationship, right? So if you grow up in a parent-child relationship and The parent lords their power over you, whether it's consciously or unconsciously, because it's mistaken, because they're just doing what their parents said, you know, whatever excuses they have for using a force and violence against you in order to conform you to what they think is good for you, you know, every child because of that imposition is going to feel a certain sense of anger and unjustice, a desire to to get their parents to kind of admit to what they were doing that was wrong. to write things that were wrong and to assert control and autonomy over their life. Like I said before, this kind of comes out in teenage hood in a little sort of an unconscious way. And maybe I'll do a a separate video on that. But this attempt, this anger and this frustration against the parents for the ways that they've controlled you, gets spilled over into the in into the political realm because the same power structure is there, the same relationship is there. But it's safer to to vent your anger politically. It's safer to vent your anger at the injustice of the power structure of the state than it is to sit down and have an on an honest conversation with your parents where you're saying, hey, when I was a kid, I felt you mistreated me in this way or that way, or you shouldn't you should have related to me differently, or this is not how you would have treated other people or yourself, right? It's more, it's much more emotionally charged and emotionally difficult to have that honest and vulnerable kind of conversation about the moral hypocrisy of your parents, in part because you don't know how they're actually gonna react in that moment, but in part they they have been your source of survival for so long. And when you're when you're, you know, sort of poking the bear of an emotional an emotional breakup, right? Because when you confront your when you confront your parents with moral hypocrisy, they might react very negatively and that relationship might might be strained. And if you did that as a child, that would be incredibly f frightening because they're your source of survival and love and care. And a lot of that feeling gets carried over into an adult because you've been trained for 15 odd years in that emotional kind of environment. And so instead Of doing that, which is scary and vulnerable, and who knows what could happen, right? It's very personal, it's very direct, it's a it's a one-on-one conversation. Instead of doing that, all the anger and the frustration gets projected onto the state, it gets projected onto government, it gets projected onto whoever's the president or whatever party is in power, or whatever party seems to be most in line with the values of your parents. what have you. You find a group that you can be angry at. You have a you you find a person that you can be angry at. And you try to resolve the the parental frustrations and anger and injustice in into politics, right? So I think that that's part of the reason why people are so politically part of the reason that people are so politically obsessed beyond the fact that that the state really does have an impact on a person's life in a number of ways, but But it is this relationship of power, really, that is most most similar about it. And again, I think the parent-child relationship, it sets you up for accepting the state, the state citizen relationship in in a most fundamental way, because you get trained to accept the power dynamic as a child. And by the time you you become an adult and you step into relation the power relationship with the state. You've already been trained, right? It's already normal to you. In some sense, it's comfortable to you. And when somebody comes around and says, Hey, we don't need the state in order to to to rule ourselves or to survive, I think it's very much like a child being told, Hey, you don't need your you need your parents, right? And I think part of the reason that's why the the conversation can get so so emotional and heated. It's also the major reason why states come about and perpetuate regardless of the rationale, whether it makes any coherent sense, whether it's a a a giant moral contradiction and a moral hypocrisy that oftentimes people just don't think about, right? And the state has come again and again and again through all different kinds of justifications. You know, first it was tradition, and then it was the divine rights of kings, and then it was democracies, right? And every new generation, or not every new generation, but every new iteration of state power just comes up with a new justification for why some special group of people gets to lord force and violence over everybody else. And again, I think this is part of the psychological scaffolding that that keeps that alive. And if we want to dismantle state power and Really, if we want to be free personally, if we want to be able to be more authentic personally, then part of what needs to happen is this evolution of peaceful parenting over time. And as parenting becomes more voluntary and more free and more oriented towards helping the child become who they are, The more that the state citizen relationship, the state, the power of the state becomes more and more foreign to us. And the more we desire to have our own autonomy. And I think you can actually see this in the evolution of history over time, where the further back you go, the more authoritarian and violent and lording was parenting. And over time, the structures of parenting have loosened, they've become More free and more voluntary, more focused on the the the humanness of the child. And as that parenting has become more free and more voluntary, the societies have become more free and more voluntary over time, less brutalistic. There's more rights involved. And there's even good arguments to be made that the parenting of places like Germany and Russia, many of the Axis powers. The parenting in these kinds of states were particularly brutal compared to other European countries prior to World War I and World War II. And this might be part of the psychological reason why the citizens of a nation like Germany were so sympathetic and receptive to somebody, to the to the rhetoric or the authority of somebody like like Hitler, for example. and You know, a lot of this work has a lot of this analysis has been done through people like Lloyd Damas, who is a psycho historian, and and Alice Miller. So if you're if you're more interested in these kinds of psychological power dynamics and how parenting has impacted the evolution of the state, then I would I would recommend that that you look into these guys. In fact, this this book, it's a book called Parenting for a Peaceful World by by Robin Grill. And what Robin Grill does in this book is that he kind of sums up or or yeah, he sums up and distills the work of of Lloyd Damas, and presents really the the historical, the historical picture, and it's a really powerful book. It was one of the first I think I read it when I was like twenty or so, and it was probably the first non fiction book that actually might be the only nonfiction book that has ever made me cry because just the the depth of of the dark history of childhood is something that is it's really just hard to grasp and and that book will will really show you. And Alice Miller also do a did a great job of this. Books like Thou Shalt Not Be Aware. And this is an old version, but for your own good. Those two books in particular, I think, if I remember correctly, they they take a historical perspective on on this question and and really help to I think in inform the psychoevolutionary background of these power dynamics and how the state relates to parenting in this sort of direct way. Neither of them were were voluntarists or anarchists, but they were both influential in my in coming in from in me coming to understand that these kinds of dynamics and how they relate to one another. So I think with that we're gonna we're gonna end here. So if you if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think that somebody else would benefit from this, then then please share it with them. If you have any thoughts at all, whether whether it's positive, whether it's criticisms, different avenues of thought, please put down the comments. I'd love to be able to to just chat more with you guys about these kinds of ideas. And if you want more videos like this, then please subscribe. And I as always, I'll talk to you guys next time.