Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / What's Wrong With Star Trek Pt 1 With Ed Whitfield
Transcript
- 0:00Get ready for the ultimate comic book extravagance. Terrifficon is backhat Mohegan Sun in
- 0:04Uncasville, Connecticut from July twenty eighth to the thirtieth. Over one hundred comic
- 0:08book creators, tons of celebrities, and hundreds of vendors, all under one
- 0:11roof. Meet your favorite comic book writers and artists, men, go with
- 0:13celebrities from movies and TV and explore treasure trove of comics and collectibles. Terrific
- 0:18Con where dreams come true for comic book fans. Don't miss out to Lack
- 0:21twenty eight to thirtieth and Mohegan Sun in Uncasville, Connecticut and get your tickets
- 0:25now at terrific Coon dot com. Terrific Con the Ultimate comic book Experience.
- 0:33Hey everybody, welcome back. It's Word Balloon, the Comic Book Conversation show
- 0:37John Suntress here Man right after San Diego Comic Con. So many announcements,
- 0:43so much news. Lots of it will be reflected in upcoming Word Balloon interviews
- 0:48with comic book creators. That all made the headlines, but also a lot
- 0:52of Star Trek news. They had a big hall age presentation Despite the actors
- 0:58not being able to be there, Scott Mann's laying out big announcements about Lower
- 1:03Decks coming back in September, and also some announcements about Strange New Worlds.
- 1:11I'm not thrilled with the idea that we're going to get a Strange New World's
- 1:17musical episode, kind of like Buffy or on the CW when the Flash and
- 1:21Supergirl stars did their musical episode. At least it sounds like it's going to
- 1:26be more like Buffy and that they have original songs that will reflect the characters
- 1:32and likely the storylines that are going on that's coming up in two weeks.
- 1:37But they also dropped the Strange New World's Lower Decks crossover, so there was
- 1:42so much to talk about that I ended up doing two episodes on Sunday on
- 1:46Ward Balloon Live on our YouTube channel about Star Trek, and first I spoke
- 1:51to Ad Whitfield, and Whitfield is a UK essayist and YouTuber who is a
- 1:57pop culture critics. Jaris some of my frustrations with New Trek as we call
- 2:02it. Listen, I love Star Trek, and you guys know and women
- 2:06know if you've been listening to warbilin for any length of time. I'm a
- 2:09massive fan. I've been watching since I was a very small kid in the
- 2:14nineteen seventies, and I read all the comics, I read all the books.
- 2:20I love Star Trek, and I'm just disappointed with the product we're getting
- 2:25since the debut of Discovery. I have this bad feeling that we're not getting
- 2:30good science fiction and interesting debatable topics of humanity morality that used to be hallmarks
- 2:39of Star Trek from the sixties through the end of Enterprise. I mean,
- 2:44they would just present these very interesting things to debate and discuss, and we're
- 2:49also very fair about showing both signs, and we've had glimpses of that here
- 2:53and there in New Star Trek, but certainly not enough for my taste,
- 2:59and I won't Tony Strange. New Worlds has been a massive disappointment in its
- 3:01second season, where they've done comedy and romance and it seems almost everything but
- 3:08what you would expect from a Star Trek show. So this is part one
- 3:13of a two part podcast that I'm presenting this week, Ed and I discuss
- 3:17our frustrations, and then in part two, I've got my buddies Mitch and
- 3:22Wayne, who are regulars on our Star Trek Critique show, to go over
- 3:25the last two episodes specifically, so you'll forgive the big Star Trek dump.
- 3:31But if you're a fan, I think you'll enjoy it and I'm giving you
- 3:35a plenty to listen to this week. So to start things off on part
- 3:38one, my conversation with Ed Whitfield on today's word below. Word bloind is
- 3:43brought to you by Alex ross Art dot com. Alex is doing a CGC
- 3:47Signature series signing opportunity for fans that you can send in your stuff to Alex
- 3:53to sign at CGC dot com For details hurry though the offer ends May fifth.
- 4:00Word Balloon is brought to you by my followers, the League of Word
- 4:04Balloon Listeners. That's the name I gave my followers through Patreon Patreon dot com
- 4:11slash word balloon Listen. Things are tough this year. I won't deny it
- 4:15for me financially. If you've ever considered supporting word balloon, I could really
- 4:19use your help. So if you think word Balloon is worth the price of
- 4:24a comic book, even a dollar a month would be greatly appreciated. Patreon
- 4:29dot com slash word Balloon. Thank you very much for your patronage and your
- 4:35attention the League of word Balloon Listeners. If you will subscribe to word Balloon,
- 4:40I will send you an email that will have a Domino mask and cape
- 4:43and a nice League of word Balloon Listeners emblem that you've seen here on word
- 4:48Balloon as well. But thank you for your support. Patreon dot com slash
- 4:53word balloon. Welcome back everybody. It's time again for an all yeah trek
- 5:12watch a review here at word Balloon the Comic Book Conversation Show. John Suntras
- 5:15here really happy to welcome opinionoid man himself. It's Ed Whitfield straight from England
- 5:23and Ed it's great to meet you. And as I told you off the
- 5:27year, I have really enjoyed your written essays. We've got a u RL
- 5:30that we will throw up here on the on the banner below us. But
- 5:34there we go. It's read edits reviews at Ed Whitfield dot WordPress dot com.
- 5:40And then Ed also has a YouTube channel which is uh doctor mcilvoid.
- 5:45Yes, I look forward to your insulting comments. So I think outstanding man,
- 5:51well ed. God we we we couldn't even help ourselves, who's already
- 5:56started talking about the New Trek era before we were podcasting. So can I
- 6:00wait to get your general opinions? When did you start watching Star Trek in
- 6:04a way, I've been watching it since I was in single figures. Really,
- 6:11I think I must have seen it originally on UK TV when it was
- 6:16shown sometime in the early nineteen eighties. I love the original series. I
- 6:25was first in line to see The Voyage Home when it came out cinemas in
- 6:28England, so it would have been ten nine, ten years old something like
- 6:31that, that sort of greedily went back and watched all the other movies and
- 6:36so on. So I was primed for T when it studied in nineteen eighty
- 6:42seven, I couldn't wait to see it. I was really excited and that
- 6:46that was my Trek. Really, that was my era of Star Trek,
- 6:49and that's got me on board, so to speak. You know, like
- 6:53everyone else, you know, to start within the first season, I was
- 6:56like, oh, it's not Kirkins, but I like these guys. But
- 7:00you know, by the time you got to the third season at T,
- 7:02which for me is still the best season of television ever made, virtually no
- 7:09duds in a twenty sixth episode season. Maybe just one episode that wasn't so
- 7:13good transfigurations, but all the others are great. You know. I was
- 7:17I was stuck with it and that was it. And I've been a fan
- 7:20ever since. I hear you man, Like I told you, I'm an
- 7:24OLG. I go back to my parents and vague memories of maybe the last
- 7:29season of the original series, but when it hit the syndication in the seventies,
- 7:33I was hooked, like you. First season a little clunky and tn
- 7:39but great episodes still. I mean, I depend that first episode. As
- 7:44you know, every show I think has growing paints in that first season,
- 7:47but I would say, and I wasn't all bad by any stretch of the
- 7:50imagination. It's fashion. Obviously, there are some episodes which, shall we
- 7:56say, have not aged so well, Code of Honor and things like that,
- 8:00but generally, generally speaking, uh, I mean, there are still
- 8:05shows in that season that I love, like the big Goodbye Data Law for
- 8:09example. Uh was it Heart of Glory, the warp episode with the claved
- 8:16it, I mean that's the thing. No, absolutely Data Laura with with
- 8:20Laura and everything. Yeah, there there are there are a handful of first
- 8:24season episodes that are good. DS nine is my favorite. I won't deny
- 8:26that. Um, you know, yeah, it doesn't. It doesn't have
- 8:31quite the same But I think it's about the time that you see these shows,
- 8:35isn't it in your life? Right? You know? I love d
- 8:37S nine. It doesn't quite have the same place in my heart as TNG.
- 8:41I love TG TGS like sort of a life partner, whereas d S
- 8:48nine is kind of like an intellectual a friend I met as a teenager that
- 8:50I really relate to, and and you know, we've got a lot of
- 8:54intellectually in common and so on. But I don't, I don't. I'm
- 8:56not in love with them quite the sighting why I think so, I love
- 9:03d S nine. I mean, for me, maybe it's my second favorite
- 9:07off that's fair, hey man, exactly. And you know, listen for
- 9:11everyone watching two things one. I'm aware that obviously there's a writer strike and
- 9:16an actor's strike. I am a member of SAG. That said, my
- 9:20capacity in the Screen Actors Guild is different from Hollywood Television and Film Actors.
- 9:28I have joined and am part of the news division. In my previous role
- 9:31as a news broadcaster, I've maintained my union status, but um, there
- 9:37are there are shades of gray regarding the actor's strike and the SAG members and
- 9:43who can do what. In fact, we played the Terrificon commercial. Jeanie
- 9:48Francis will be at Terrificon with Jonathan Frakes, Frakes's wife, who's a big
- 9:52soap opera star over here. I don't know if you knew that. Um,
- 9:58okay, And ironically, because they are on camera, the soap opera
- 10:03stars are allowed to work during this strike, so they're okay. Why it's
- 10:07jil not it's unusual. It meets the hell out of a man. I
- 10:11mean and truly, since the SAG members went on strike, we keep getting
- 10:16little dribbles of news of well, they can do this, they can't do
- 10:20that. And as as was explaining to Ed, the good news is all
- 10:24the stars of Trek that we're supposed to be a terrific on are still coming.
- 10:28The bad news is they won't be doing any panels, which unfortunately affects
- 10:33me as well, because I was really looking forward to doing a DS nine
- 10:37panel and a First Officers panel and you know, what are you gonna do?
- 10:41It's again I absolutely respect the union, and I don't want anyone thinking
- 10:46that I am being a scab by still talking about these studio shows and these
- 10:50celebrities. Again, we're not affected by it, so we are allowed to
- 10:56continue to critique what's out there anyway. That said, um, and we
- 11:01will get to the episodes as well, but I really want to know about
- 11:03Ed's background. Everyone listen, I'm serious. I would not have that on
- 11:09if I don't if I didn't truly love the reviews that he tells, and
- 11:11he's a very great essayist when it comes to New Trek and God, I
- 11:16was looking. I haven't read all your old stuff, but I want to,
- 11:20and I will get maybe cliff notes from you today because eventually I do
- 11:24want to hear your thoughts on Discovery and certainly the three seasons of Picard seasons
- 11:31of Strange New Worlds. But right now, let's let's focus. I knew
- 11:35we talked about these things, so I medicated before the show. Whatever you
- 11:41need to get through this hour, absolutely man, Um, you know I
- 11:46do want to know, so before we get into these most recent episodes of
- 11:50Strange New Worlds. I enjoyed last season for in general terms, I mean
- 11:56just like Discovery. I have my frustrations with their lack of respect for Cannon
- 12:01because as a guy who's been watching Star Trek for fifty years and not only
- 12:05watching it, but reading the novels, reading the comics, everyone who's been
- 12:09involved prior to this current regime of Kurtzman, Akiva Goldsman, Michael Shabon Star
- 12:18Trek, New Trek as we call it, everyone else metaphorically has been able
- 12:22to color within the lines, respect continuity, respect canon, and tell and
- 12:26tell original stories that don't interfere with will wait a minute, I thought Spok
- 12:31had was a vegetarian, and despite what we saw in this Spot episode this
- 12:37season that he's and I know he's supposed he was supposed to be human,
- 12:39but him eating bacon, I'm like, Man, if I were a vegan,
- 12:43I'd be a little offended by the fact that this joke that is so
- 12:48empty and they could have had Spock picking out on any kind of food and
- 12:52it's like, really, bacon. It's like, Okay, I guess somebody
- 12:54didn't read the memo that or doesn't know the history of Spot, but I
- 12:58think you touched a Paul. The main problem when New Trek right is that
- 13:01it isn't new. It's a sort of remake of Star Trek. It's a
- 13:05reappropriating of material. They look backwards, not forwards. Star Trek always look
- 13:11forwards in whatever incarnation. You know, from nineteen sixty six to two thousand
- 13:16and five, it was aware of its own part. It was a unique
- 13:20thing. You had all of that continuity, all of that wonderful, rich
- 13:26sequencing of events that you could dip into and you could jump forward and back
- 13:30and so on. But it was always about the next thing, what's the
- 13:33new element that we can introduce, the new stories that we can tell.
- 13:37Now it's about going backwards. It's about cannibalizing assets, stripping the franchise basically,
- 13:45and you know, trying to turn a show that the show runners don't
- 13:50understand into a show they do understand. The problem is that the show they
- 13:54do understand it is terrible. And show they don't understand was revered and enjoyed
- 14:01by a lot of people, and they don't get that. They want to
- 14:05piggyback their show on the old Trek. They want because that's what gave you
- 14:11know, that's what gives their show. It's cachet if if it wasn't for
- 14:16Old Trek, no one would be remotely interested in their shows. You can
- 14:20you imagine Discovery as a first run series without the Star Trek branding or strange
- 14:26New worlds. You know, it would seem twee and and strange and confused.
- 14:31I don't know what. It wouldn't have built a following, really,
- 14:35But because it's Star Trek, people have stuck with it. Some people have
- 14:39stuck with it, and though for their trouble, they've got become really frustrated
- 14:45because they see the thing they love, the old show that they love,
- 14:50being incrementally overwritten and changed and so on, while the people who make it
- 14:58maintain this sort of strange pretense that oh no, no, this is within
- 15:03continuity. She's like within the lines. Yeah, but canon. You know,
- 15:07you're looking at this picture where all the scribbling is outside of the lines,
- 15:11and you say, well, you're telling me that black is wide and
- 15:13up is down. I can see it's not within the lines. You know,
- 15:18how stupid do you think I am? As an order? You know,
- 15:22really, it's like they're gas lighting us, all Trek fans with this
- 15:26line of oh no, no, no, everything's cannon, and it's like
- 15:28no, it's not. And good lord, this season, especially of strange
- 15:33New Worlds. Literally you're we're like, oh god, I can't remember the
- 15:37name of the actress the old Hollywood movie The Snake Bit, where it's a
- 15:41woman that's in the insane asylument. She's really saying. We're like, Aha,
- 15:46there we go. Wait a minute. You just said that you pushed
- 15:48the timeline ahead so that the Eugenics wars with Khan happened in the twenty twenties,
- 15:54and it's like, you didn't have to do that. And also,
- 15:58as you likely know, I'm like, listen, I am no scientist,
- 16:02I'm no mathematician. But when it comes to space and time, if you
- 16:06leave later to a destination, the likelihood is they're not going to hit Kirk's
- 16:11ts enterprise at the same moment unless it moves all of those events along so
- 16:18that they no longer fit within the established timeline. You're quite right, and
- 16:22it means that space seed is gone, Wrath of Carn is gone. And
- 16:26if Rath of Carn is gone, then so is the such a spark and
- 16:30voyage home and final Frontier and I'll Discover Country And if that's gone, then
- 16:36does that mean t's gone, but then you've got lower decks, which is
- 16:41said in a sort of TNG adjacent universe, and they refer to those events
- 16:45as if they still occurred, and then they've just gone back to strange.
- 16:51So you watch this stuff and you feel like riker and frame of mind,
- 16:53don't you exactly? That's my snake fed analogy. Yeah, well said or
- 17:00not thinking of you're undercent right, man, No, it's it's again.
- 17:04If they would just have I assume you might be a Battlestar Galactica fan,
- 17:10ed, I don't know if you were. Yeah, old on you,
- 17:14and that's why I'm night. I've got my limits, you know. And
- 17:18as do I know Galactica in nineteen eighties, except for the return of spar
- 17:21Starbuck a bit that one episode. Yeah, but no, I am with
- 17:26you, um no, you know, run more and David Ike really took
- 17:29a chance in uh not um taken along the old Battlestar Galactica fans and saying
- 17:34up front, hey, we're rebooting. And by the way, now Starbuck
- 17:38is a woman, and they took a lot of crap twenty years ago.
- 17:41I remember it well and I understood why. But then I saw the show,
- 17:45and it's like, well, this is good. Now. If Discovery
- 17:48had had said I could get away with it, though, Joe, I'm
- 17:52sorry to interrupt you, but please, they could get away with that because
- 17:55Battlestar Galactica, it's relatively speaking, quiet, that's not all a material,
- 18:00right. People see Battlestar Galactica as a nice, self contained thing. They
- 18:04like it, they remember it, but it's not so you know, revered
- 18:10that you can't remake it. The question is do you remake it better?
- 18:14Do you have a new and interesting way into that sort of story? And
- 18:19Ronald D. Moore, as you quite rightly say, did have a great
- 18:23idea. It's quite one thing to do that. And again, like in
- 18:27my reviews, I've talked about Lost in Space, which is sort of an
- 18:32analogy I views. Whereas, again, you have another show that ran for
- 18:34a relatively short period of time, you're sure you can make a stupid movie
- 18:40written incidentally by Cuba Goldsman thirty years later. No one cares because they aren't
- 18:48elite. A group of people out there going, my god, you can't
- 18:51interfere with Lost in Space, Cannon. That would be that would be terrible
- 18:56because the vast majority of people or they know about Lost in Space is you
- 19:00know, danger, Will Robinson and Evil Doctor Smith exactly. Goldsman took those
- 19:06basic things that people remember and he put them into a sort of dumb and
- 19:11colorful space adventure movie. Now what, that's one thing. But to do
- 19:17the same thing with Star Trek, which is what the two thousand and nine
- 19:22movie is essentially, it is that the version, the Star Trek version of
- 19:26the Lost in Space movie. To do that is quite something else. When
- 19:33you have twenty something seasons of adventure, you know, stories on TV and
- 19:41ten movies and so on. To junk all of that, to throw all
- 19:45of that away and start again, is culturally much more problematic than doing it
- 19:53We're Lost in Space or with Battlestar Galactica. But at least than the Kelvin
- 20:00movies that Kurtzman and J. J. Abrams were behind. At least they
- 20:04again declared, well, this is a different universe, so I can accept
- 20:08the cursorary portrayal, quite Joe, But at least you know, you don't
- 20:14have to worry about it, right right? And there can they and they
- 20:17in the story had spot going from the prime universe to the Kelvin universe and
- 20:23he's disrupted things. Nero and the Romulans disrupted things. So now you can't
- 20:29tell different stories. That's fine, but that's why again this gas lighting if
- 20:33oh no, no, no, this is this is our new Trek is
- 20:37absolutely inconnuity. It's like again, you're are we dumb? We're not dumb.
- 20:41I mean we've been. That's why we love Star Trek because just like
- 20:45Star Wars, all of this ancillary information, technical manuals, and like I
- 20:51said, the novels, the comic books, they all respected Cannon. They
- 20:55had to Paramount vetted them, and they had people in control that are like,
- 20:59I mean, I'm literally reading a book that is a checklist of all
- 21:04the various novels that came out through the years, and then they have little
- 21:08interviews with the authors and all of them are like, well, I wanted
- 21:11this story to go this way, but Paramount said no. Or Richard Arnold,
- 21:17who was Gene roden Berry's main assistant, was put in charge of the
- 21:21novels and he would vet them. And I've even interviewed people like Michael Jan
- 21:26Friedman and John Jackson Miller who continue to write very good Star Trek novels.
- 21:30And respect Cannon. And again this group now, I think we're very influenced
- 21:36by the Kelvin movies. In fact, as much as I dislike and I
- 21:40want your opinions as well about this, the Paul Wesley version of James Kirk.
- 21:47I kind of think after seeing the time Travel episode with Laon when they're
- 21:52in Toronto and are in civilian clothes, I'm like, this casting director shows
- 21:56Paul Wesley because he's a poor man's crisp and and it's so funny in interviews
- 22:02that are are like, well, we don't want to Shatner interview, and
- 22:04it's like we weren't asking for a Shatner interview, Chris Pine wasn't doing a
- 22:08Shatner interview. But what James Kirk has always represented to me two words charisma
- 22:15and command. And I don't see those characteristics in Paul Wesley. You're like,
- 22:21I don't dislike him, but I can't take him seriously as Jim Kirk
- 22:26because when I look at him, I'm afraid I see Jim Carrey in Saturday
- 22:30Night Live, and I can't get that image out of my head. And
- 22:33once it's in there, it's almost like you know, a setting eel.
- 22:37You can't get it out. It's horrible. It sort of takes out His
- 22:41performance is fine, but he doesn't And to his credit, he's not impersonating
- 22:48William Shatner exactly. He's trying to sort of channel the essence of the character.
- 22:53He's trying to find some you know, trying to channel, as you
- 22:57say, his charisma and his authoritative air and you know that likable persona that
- 23:04he has that inhus him to people and so on, And if you squint
- 23:08really hard, you can sort of see it. You can see something approaching
- 23:14Kirk. But you know the trouble is, and this is the whole thing
- 23:18with New Track, why would you want to have a new Kirk? You
- 23:22know that Kirk is such an iconic character in an alternative universe set of movies.
- 23:32Okay, Chris Pine is Kirk? Fine, all right, I don't
- 23:34care. Let's have But Kirk is William Shatner, right, just as Spock
- 23:41is Lena Nimoy absolutely, And sometimes actors so perfectly nail their character and they
- 23:48imputs embody them occupy you know so completely that anybody who follows after that is
- 23:57just always going to suffer unfavorable comparisons, and Paul Wesley is nowhere near where
- 24:06he needs to be in order to sell to us the idea that he is
- 24:11Kirk or a new Kirk, or a Kirk that we would want to get
- 24:15to know. Because the problem is every time and this is true for you
- 24:19know, Pike on Discovery and then later Pike in this in strangew Worlds and
- 24:26I like cancer. Now he's great, law, He's good, really good.
- 24:30But the problem is that all of the presence of these characters represents a
- 24:33threat to establish cannon. Every time they're on screen. You're always on edge
- 24:41if you're an old Trekker, because you're thinking, what are they going to
- 24:44do? What are they going to say? Is this the episode where they're
- 24:47going to do something which completely contradicts established continuity? And thereby, you know,
- 24:53it would be fine, like you said, if we knew that this
- 24:56was a remake or an inconsequential universe, than we could it wouldn't matter,
- 25:02and we could sit back and we could enjoy ourselves. But the problem is,
- 25:07as long as the pretexts remain, the pretense remains that this is the
- 25:11same continuity at the only logical conclusion is that this is, and if it
- 25:18doesn't match up, is that it's an attempt to overwrite what's come before.
- 25:22So if you moost resent the presence of these characters, I wouldn't have if
- 25:29I'd been making a cos prequel set on the Enterprise, I wouldn't have made
- 25:33it in the first place because there's so many problems, particularly would Pike and
- 25:37Pike's fate. But if I was stuck with it, somebody put a gun
- 25:41to my head and said you've got to make as prequel, I had said,
- 25:45okay, fine, but I'm not going to show any of the original
- 25:49serious characters until absolutely have to. I'm going to kick that can as far
- 25:56down the road as I possibly possibly can, because once I show them,
- 26:02I'm locked into the events of the original series, and then I'm intruding on
- 26:07that part of Star Trek history. I want to put a distance between me
- 26:12and the original series so I can introduce my own characters, tell my own
- 26:18story, just like they did on a Betterical Soul. For example, you
- 26:26know with Breaking Bad, Yes, they put a lot of distance between them
- 26:30and the events of Breaking Bad, so they had time to tell their own
- 26:34story. And actually, interesting thing about Betterical Soul is that they said.
- 26:41Originally they tended the two to converge much earlier, but as they started to
- 26:45map it out, plotted out get to know their characters, the new characters,
- 26:52they realized there was a lot more potential there and that they could spin
- 26:55it out a lot longer because there was more story to tell than they thought.
- 26:57And that's the right mentality, that's the right, prettyquel mentality that you
- 27:02sort of go all in on your new characters. You don't rush to bring
- 27:07in the old ones, because then where's the space for you to develop anything?
- 27:14You know, It's not there anymore, is it? So? Agree?
- 27:17And the other thing too, was given though we only knew about Pike
- 27:22through the Cage and through the two part Menagerie, there was so much opportunity
- 27:27to tell more of Pike's story. And I'm sure you felt the same way
- 27:30that when he showed up on Discovery and number one and even well to a
- 27:36lesser degree, spok because I didn't like the way they portrayed him in Discovery.
- 27:38I don't like the fact that, all of a sudden, Spark was
- 27:41a dyslexic child that didn't seem to jive with things like yesteryear or even the
- 27:48Calvin movies. But I really thought this was an opportunity to really get into
- 27:53Pike at Number one and even Young Spark, and again agreed that I'm the
- 28:00surface. I appreciate that this season, each episode is focusing on these other
- 28:04crew members, and that's fine, we should learn more about them, but
- 28:10um, it is disappointing that we are more than a season and a half
- 28:15into Strange New Worlds. And I don't know if um Rebecca remain as Number
- 28:19one is on some sort of limited episode contract because she's conspicuously absent from so
- 28:26many episodes as hands amounts, certainly this season. And that was my that's
- 28:34my complaint as well. And it's like, Um, what I didn't like
- 28:38about Discovery, and I do want to hear your thoughts on this as well,
- 28:41was it was too much focused on Michael Burnham And it's like, well,
- 28:45you know, and and I understand that if you go all the way
- 28:49back to the original series, ninety percent of the episodes were about William Shatner
- 28:53and Kaptain Kirk. But um, yeah, well too again that's the right.
- 29:02Yes, absolutely, the Trinity, no question, but at least um
- 29:06they had the after a season or two with um the Burman era next Generation
- 29:11track. Michael Pillar comes in and says, Okay, instead of it always
- 29:15just being about the planet of the week, let's make this week a wharf
- 29:18story. Let's make this week a crusher story, a data story. And
- 29:22that's good because we want to know more about this crew. Yeah. Yeah,
- 29:27And it's like, all of a sudden, on Discovery, it's just
- 29:30the Michael Burnham show. You don't know anybody's name on the Discovery Bridge.
- 29:36At least on Strange New Worlds, they were very smart and like, all
- 29:41right, here are the new characters and everything, And again I appreciate the
- 29:45focus on them as we get into these last two episodes. Certainly episode six
- 29:49in a horror episode, but there should be more for Pike and Number one,
- 29:55and they at least show a lot of Spock. I'm not crazy about
- 29:59the Port trail, but yeah, it's like I don't understand, and again,
- 30:03shame on us for having the preconceived notion that it would be about that
- 30:07trinity of Spark Number one in Pike, it's not. Please. I think
- 30:14there's more of an effort on Strange New Worlds to make it an ensemble show.
- 30:18Make it more inclusive than certainly on Discovery. I think the problem with
- 30:22Discovery is that it was adapting Brian Fuller's original concept badly. They inherited a
- 30:30format in effect. Yes, it was designed as an anthology series, so
- 30:37the idea to make it a prequel to TS, to have the emphasis been
- 30:45on, say, the First Officer rather than the Captain. That's a time
- 30:49limited idea that was supposed to run as a limited series. And then of
- 30:55course you'd leap ahead maybe to the TNG era, and then you'd leap a
- 30:59head apps into the unseen Star Trek future. But it was all supposed to
- 31:03be within original cannon and continuity. And I think what happened as I understand
- 31:08it, there are people out there who know a lot more about this than
- 31:11me, but the Secret Hideout hijack that in development idea, and they decided
- 31:18that because I have no ideas of their own, of course, and they
- 31:22turned it into try to turn it into something like a regular Star Trek series.
- 31:27So you have inherited the idea that the emphasis is going to be on
- 31:32the First Officer to the exclusion of most of the other characters, and you've
- 31:37inherited the idea, the bad idea that it's going to be a cos prequel.
- 31:41So the seeds of its failure was sewn into that decision to turn it
- 31:48into a full or ongoing series rather than honor what Brian Fuller, as I
- 31:53understand, it originally intended something. You know, I forget the name of
- 31:59the guy who are doing those fantastic Star Trek shorts at the moment for the
- 32:05Is it for the Gene Roddenberry Foundation or something? Yes? Or Toy is
- 32:08the name of the company, Oh, Toy. And they've made some people
- 32:13haven't seen this. They've made some extraordinary short films that are they're silent for
- 32:19the most part, but they feature cult at ns and cult from the Cage
- 32:23and it's wonderful stuff and it's completely authentic, completely congruous with the original series
- 32:30and indeed with the next generation. There's a wonderful short about Spock visiting Cut's
- 32:37grave and Veridian three. Fantastic that the rendering of those characters apparently with makeup
- 32:45rather than crazy. I mean, yeah, it's incredible, photo realistic.
- 32:50Leonard Nimoy. Yeah, it's it's a really I mean, there are photos
- 32:52Arnold Toy's website of the actor putting the prosthetics on to resemble Lenard Nimoy,
- 32:59and it's like, this isn't CGA, this is an AI. This is
- 33:01an actor with prosthetics who looks like Spark and what you can do with makeup.
- 33:08I didn't know it was even possible, but someone should get an oscar
- 33:14anyway. The thing is something like that would, which is a far more
- 33:21abstract, cerebral intellectual approach to prequelizing TS and synulizing T would have made for
- 33:30an absolutely fantastic limited prequel series to TS. If Discovery had been that,
- 33:37I think you and I would be singing its praises now. But instead they
- 33:42took the raw material that they had. They took the outline that they had
- 33:46from Brian Fuller and maybe a script that he had written, and they cutsman
- 33:51did up. They added all the nonsense and ship that we associate without it,
- 33:57and they turned the central character we now lovingly call Michael Burnham into this
- 34:04sort of insubordinate Attitudeinoid, the comedy version of which is Mariner from Lower Decks.
- 34:14But now so we've got two versions of the same character, but both
- 34:17of them are terrible, and that's why we've got the focus in Discovery on
- 34:23that character because they didn't start from scratch. I didn't conceive it as an
- 34:29ensemble show with Strange New Worlds. They did in a way like as you
- 34:36say, they've got the characters that we know already. Number one's pike spot.
- 34:42So naturally that's where our focus is because we're watching them. We're watching
- 34:45those characters, see what they do with them and to what degree they screw
- 34:51them up. I mean, developed them over the course Strange New Worlds,
- 34:57but they have adopted Michael Pillar philosophy that you alluded to of the ensemble show,
- 35:04where every week the emphasis is on a different member of the cast.
- 35:07And I'll give Strangey World's credit in its first season for making much more of
- 35:14an effort to introduce us to those characters. We've got to know them a
- 35:17bit. By the end of season one, I knew who they all were
- 35:21and what they all did, and I knew something about them, so I
- 35:24care a little bit about what happens to them next. I didn't feel that
- 35:30way at the end of Discovery season one, or two, or three,
- 35:36or four, for that matter. I agree, man, I so agree.
- 35:42Get it an even briefly mentioning Mariner and last night's crossover, which we
- 35:46watched, and we will spoil a bit. I have to say, as
- 35:51much as I dislike Mariner as an animated character, Tony Nussen playing her live
- 35:57action was a bit toned down. She still had the attitude one of the
- 36:00things I dislike, and I might even have, well I don't have as
- 36:05a still or i'd play it. Nobody needs to sit through my my plinking
- 36:08out the theme song on Garage Band, as I did for the Trek openings
- 36:13that I do. But those like hooded eyes of Mariner, like I know
- 36:16it all and it's I'm kind of beyond all this Starfleet nonsense annoys the hell
- 36:22out of me. But I have to say it felt a bit toned down
- 36:27when you saw live actually because she couldn't do that, because it's not human.
- 36:30Almost passed for human in live action, yes, but almost. But
- 36:37and also Jack Quaid and I have to acknowledge and appreciate that lower Deck seems
- 36:43to have adjusted itself from that first season where Mariner knows it all and she
- 36:49I, you know, I don't know. This is an American show,
- 36:51an old fifties show. Sergeant Bilko the peels much. Yeah, okay,
- 36:57and I know and actually I do know that it was well loved in in
- 37:00the UK. You know, that's what Mariner did. I would say Mariner
- 37:04is Starfleet Sergeant Bilko where she's in Starfleet, doesn't really want to do the
- 37:08day to day state of Phil Silva's is on the futain they want to sue,
- 37:15but yeah, it gets around like her boring gigs and that's fine to
- 37:19a degree. But I really like how the other actors in Lower Decks that
- 37:23they focus on really the quartet that the other three are all of us in
- 37:29terms of, hey, we'd be happy to stock shelves in Starfleet and it's
- 37:34like, oh yeah, that's Starfleet thing. It sucks that was Mariner's at
- 37:37AIM. It's like, no, we're all like Boimler and Tendy and Rutherford,
- 37:40where it's like we'd be thrilled to be working on the ship and we'd
- 37:44be like they get even in the last night's episode, oh man, I
- 37:46can't wait to measure takeions and stuff. So I've kindle appreciate that level of
- 37:52fan service and humor that is in Lower Decks because I do think the writing
- 37:58has improved in subsequent sceneson what do you think of Laurie Decks in general?
- 38:01And I have my own private reasons for not liking it very much. I'll
- 38:07go into this a little bit, so okay, So as far as I'm
- 38:12concerned, the problem with it is, and it is the laziest kind of
- 38:15Star Trek pastiche that they could have done. I think there is a Star
- 38:20Trek sitcom to be made. Sure, maybe I'm not not. It doesn't
- 38:25We're in Star Trek to have a humorous take on what's going on, but
- 38:30you've got to be very very careful that you don't make it so ridiculous or
- 38:37so self referential that it shrinks the Star Trek universe and it makes it sort
- 38:42of knowingly absurd, which I think is what lower Decks does. I mean,
- 38:47when I was a teenager, which was about four thousand years ago,
- 38:52now, I had a you know, there was a joke that I sort
- 38:57of mapped out this this idea for this a Star Trek sitcom which I called
- 39:02Celestial Luminous Space Body Trek. Right, this is my idea, and I
- 39:07mapped out whole seasons of potential story and they were deliberately stupid they were.
- 39:13The joke was that they were totally incongruous with what would be in a real
- 39:20Star Trek series, a serious Star Trek series. I think I even had
- 39:24a musical episode, and holy Christ, we're about to have the real thing,
- 39:29you know, thirty something years later. I can't believe anyway. That's
- 39:34one side a joke was this sort of thing would never make it into a
- 39:38real Star Trek show, because if it did, it would destroy Star Trek.
- 39:43You can't have a show in which the characters of the same cultural reference
- 39:47points as the audience. They don't. They shouldn't be revering the original crew
- 39:53of the Enterprise the way we do, or have the same knowledge of TNG
- 39:58in DS nine that we have. Sure it shouldn't be. Watching lower Decks
- 40:04is like being trapped in a room with employees of the Star Trek Experience in
- 40:09Las Vegas. Those poor bastards who had to be in character and shepherd idiots
- 40:17like me through the attraction every day, and you you were all there there.
- 40:22And by the way, I love the Star Trek. No disrespect to
- 40:24the Star Trek Experience. It was fantastic, Absolutely walk core breaches and nearly
- 40:30died and lots of dry ice goldfish bowl. You had to be there anyway,
- 40:37good Lord. Yes, and I had a richer stake as well,
- 40:39but we weren't getting into that now. The point is this you that start
- 40:45those sorts of ideas, which is very teenage, irreverent, playground kind of
- 40:52humor. You don't expect to ever see it in a real Star Trek show.
- 40:57I call it kind of hyperactive buying juveniliar because that's how I see it.
- 41:02Marina and Boemler and all those characters. I think I would be exhausted
- 41:08being in a room with them for more than two minutes. They were good
- 41:13enough in those old scientists to at least refer to the fact that they are
- 41:16irritants, and that they do they are hyperactive. But I hate the way
- 41:22they talk. I hate the fact that they talk like sort of teenage degenerates.
- 41:25Every time they say dude or cool or likely or whatever or anything like
- 41:31that. I want to put my fist through the screen, you know,
- 41:35and get them by the throat and strangle them. Because it's it was long
- 41:40established back in the old days, in what we used to call Star Trek.
- 41:44You may remember Star Trek Ygo back in Star Trek, it was established
- 41:52that characters in the future talk differently from the way we talk, right,
- 41:58you know, they forgot that. It's even in the Revered Pericard season three
- 42:02they forgot it, right, Yeah, you know Star Trek. For the
- 42:07Voyage Home, Mike gave us an in universe explanation or rather established in Cannon
- 42:15that we're put. You know, patterns of speech and colloquialisms change over time.
- 42:21By the time you get to the twenty third and twenty fourth centuries,
- 42:23people don't swear anymore, they don't use modern day idioms. They you know,
- 42:30in the same way that if we traveled back to Shakespearean times, we
- 42:34wouldn't know what the hell they're talking about. After So to have Mariner and
- 42:39Boimler talk like every American teenager as I as in England, I imagine them
- 42:46to speak. Of course, you nailed it, so sorry America didn't.
- 42:53So you know, this is the thing. They shouldn't speak that way.
- 42:58They speak that way because that is the register of the people who write lower
- 43:01decks. That's the humor they understand. If they don't write characters who speak
- 43:05like idiots, they don't know what they're doing blah blah blah. Right,
- 43:08it's the audience that they're aiming at, which is a younger audience and more
- 43:12contemporary audience. And that's one of the reasons I hate lower decks because it
- 43:17does what All New Trek does. It splits fandom down the middle of all
- 43:23you before the show that we all used to be one big Trek family.
- 43:29The only arguments we had around the dinner table at Christmas were about which Trek
- 43:34we like best. You know, was it TS, was it d S
- 43:38nine. There's always a black sheep of the family who preferred Voyager, but
- 43:42we didn't talk to them too much. Do you remember we used to mop
- 43:45people for liking Voyager. I was a bit more forgiving, but I always
- 43:52say Voyager has a third of their episodes that are a good Star Trek and
- 43:57another third that are very bad Star Trek. And then you had the Metal
- 44:00that were just kind of I hate to use the word met but yeah,
- 44:04they kind of were. And also, conversely, not only would we sound
- 44:08ridiculous to the Shakespearean age with our modern parlance, but also the idea that
- 44:15discovery could go a thousand years in the future and be the solution problems,
- 44:22and it's like, can you imagine a Viking suddenly appearing in twenty twenty first
- 44:28century Earth? And it's like, I am a solution. Why don't you
- 44:31sacrifice a goat to Thor and the thunder god will solve this for you.
- 44:37I mean, that's it. I don't again, you have to I was
- 44:40saying this to another friend the other day. The great thing about Shatner and
- 44:45the original series was Shatner would throw around styrofoam rocks, but he believed that
- 44:52they were rocks. And as long as the people that were acting and writing
- 44:55Star Trek believed in their universe, we leaved. And that's the problem.
- 45:00And in fact, a good friend of mine I own out of him because
- 45:04he's a very famous combook writer, is like, you know, it's almost
- 45:07like the current writers. I don't blame the actors at all. They can
- 45:10only do what's given to them. But the current writers and producers they're kind
- 45:15of mocking us old school Trek fans in that Isn't this silly? Is?
- 45:20And especially this season, there was always room for a trouble with tribbles or
- 45:25a piece of the action or trials and tribulations on DS nine. You know,
- 45:30I can't think of well the episode with Matt Freuer where he's the time
- 45:38what was it called me a matter of time time? Yes, okay,
- 45:43so those are all humorous Star Trek episodes, and that's fine. First of
- 45:46all, as you said, you had twenty six episodes, he had more
- 45:50room to tell those stories. But the Ji episode saying a long season as
- 45:54a breath, but the whole season you kind of sea. And even last
- 46:00year with the spok a muck and the body switching of to bring and Spock,
- 46:05I'm like, all right, that's their comedy episode. And even the
- 46:07crossover, which I actually liked for the most part. I have my little
- 46:10knit pigs. But I liked it enough because they telegraphed we're doing this one
- 46:15episode this season. Okay, that's cool. One is fine, three is
- 46:20not. And like you said, I am dreading the musical. I don't
- 46:23think it's gonna be fun. I appreciated when Buffy did the musical back in
- 46:28the day because it was novel and they wrote songs. They were actually in
- 46:32continuity, like made sense for the characters. I think of when The Flash
- 46:37and super Girl had their musical episode and all they did were singing all these
- 46:43like a Galie episode and much like that. And now with Star Trek,
- 46:46it's like I didn't come to watch Star Trek to see the cast sing you
- 46:51know what. I came from Star Trek four Star Trek and we're not getting
- 46:54integrity and makes you think, makes you think, good lord. And we
- 47:01were talking before we started recording the Una trial episode. I was really hoping
- 47:07for a balanced argument. Absolutely, others feel neglected and you know, compartmentalized
- 47:16and not part of society. That's a fine argument on UNAH's side. Starfleet
- 47:21has a legitimate side, as you and I were discussing regarding eugenics, and
- 47:25these are the dangers of eugenics. We are concerned the way they handled eugenics
- 47:30in the Bisher episode on DS nine of Hey, you know it's against the
- 47:35law. You know you're genetically enhanced for good reason. But we were yes,
- 47:40and we reviewed you and your your service in Starfleet, and we found
- 47:45a way that you can stay in Starfleet and we're gonna give you special dispensation.
- 47:50And that's how it should have been, and it was handled that way
- 47:52with Una. But rather than while Starfleet's a big bad thing and you know
- 47:55what this is an analogy for, and it's like, okay, but there
- 48:00is a legitimate non gay analogy or LGBTQ analogy that they felt they needed to
- 48:07imprint on this show. And that's fine, and by all means give that
- 48:10argument, but also give the counter argument of this has nothing to do with
- 48:15sexuality. This is something that has happened in the past, and absolute power
- 48:20corrupts. Absolutely. We need to be aware of that because, as you
- 48:23know, those original writers were World War Two vets, and we're very clear
- 48:29on what the Nazis were trying to do. And it's like, you certainly
- 48:31don't want that again, and that's a valid argument for Starfleet's side, and
- 48:37it really disappointed me. We didn't get an equal Well I'm slighting sort of
- 48:40neurodivergent in the sense that I take everything absolutely literally and on its face.
- 48:45So I watched that episode and I thought it was a teachable moment for me.
- 48:50They taught me eugenics was good. I didn't know that for I went
- 48:53into the episode. I had serious misgivings about it, but afterwards I came
- 48:59through it was actually fine. Well it isn't, but it is a legitimate
- 49:02slippery slope of yeah, what about the genetic manipulation that is happening now or
- 49:07that will purport to happen ten or twenty years from now, of well,
- 49:12you know, we can really go into somebody's DNA and if we see that
- 49:15a baby might be born deaf or might be born blind, we can fix
- 49:17that. And that's a legitimate for genetic manipulation, and that's and that it's
- 49:22so valid to point out they didn't do that, or we know that staff
- 49:28Lee are happy to alter your genetics under certain circumstances, like for example,
- 49:34you know they've bolled that. I mean, they mentioned it in a later
- 49:37Strange New World's episode. They said, you know, I've got the ability
- 49:42to alter the genome or something like that. I can't remember exactly what they
- 49:45said. So obviously some form of gene splicing or gene alteration technology is available
- 49:52in the future. Sure, it's available in your local Starships infirmary if you
- 49:59if you need it. We're not clear on what the circumstances are and which
- 50:02it can be used. I suppose that it could be used, perhaps to
- 50:07reverse something that happened. After all, when Spock was robbed of its vulcan
- 50:12DNA, they could change him back. I wondered what the law was there,
- 50:16whether or not by technically changing him back into a vulcan where they're breaking
- 50:21the law. But maybe there is a clause in the law that says that
- 50:24if you're reverting back to your original configuration, that's okay, you just can't
- 50:30alter it permanently. I was hoping for a two Vix moment for where where
- 50:36Spark is like, you know, we're more comfortable being human. Maybe I
- 50:39don't want to And that made the episode more interesting. Yes, well that's
- 50:45why. And then of course I mean two Vix. We some people mock
- 50:52two Vix is one of those early Voyager episodes that people kind of go,
- 50:55hey, do you remember two Vix? That was weird, wasn't it?
- 50:59But actually the ending of t VIX is very interesting, very dark, last
- 51:05five ten minutes. Yes it's a real sucker punch. And that scene in
- 51:10which the doctor says, I won't do it. I won't participate in that
- 51:15process because it goes against my ethical programming. It's not even a real person.
- 51:21He won't do it. Janeway has got to make that call, you
- 51:23know, do I keep this living creature who doesn't want to die, or
- 51:29do I kill effectively kill this man to bring back my two friends who strictly
- 51:35speaking, don't have a voice in this argument because they've been superseded by this
- 51:40joint consciousness or whatever. It's a very interesting ethical philosophical dilemma of the time.
- 51:47We used to watch Star Trek to enjoy and think about, indeed,
- 51:51or a dead Enterprise episode, whether there are two races, the kind of
- 51:55slave labor race and the past race, and ultimately Flocks discovers, oh,
- 52:02you know, the pass race is dying out. It's really the slave race
- 52:06that's going to become the dominant species. And Archer's face with that dilemma what
- 52:12to do? And yeah, man, it's those kind of high minded debates
- 52:15that we did look forward to, and we could have after hours conversations with
- 52:20other Trek fans and what do you think? Then this is interesting? And
- 52:22I love that, don't you? I love it throws up those little dilemmas
- 52:28for us to argue over, Like you know the season one of TNG,
- 52:31It's symbiosis, didn't you where you had? You know, Picard made the
- 52:36call, is going to let that the entire race of drug addicts go through
- 52:39the hell of Cold Turkey because ultimately it's been cruel to be kind. In
- 52:45the short term, it will be horrific for them, but it will break
- 52:49their dependency on the other race that are exploiting them. Yep, so it
- 52:53withdraws this help in order to free up a whole planet of people, and
- 53:00instead we get simpleton science fiction of the most big musical episode of Strange New
- 53:07World's coming John, aren't you Yes? And then more comedy and also,
- 53:10let's let's treat mister Spark like a young A young will use American note.
- 53:17Let's just give a note of praise here where it's due to Boimler in the
- 53:23latest episode of Strange New World, because to my intense surprise and shock,
- 53:29he went on the enterprise and he actually stopped to critique this stuff. He's
- 53:32like, Hey, that's not mister Spark. Spot doesn't smile. What's going
- 53:37on with Spot? Have I done this? Yeah? I don't blame him
- 53:40for thinking he might have corrupted Spot with his idiocy, because if I were
- 53:45Boimler, I think the same thing. But no, we know that Actually
- 53:50it's his relationship with Chapel, a relationship that we suspect would never have happened
- 53:55under normal circumstances, that is to blame. So I've be interested to see
- 53:59what they do with that, because they've made a point of noting it.
- 54:02They've marked our card, haven't they. What are they going to do?
- 54:06Because Spot, to be Spark can't be in that relationship. He has to
- 54:10have that distance that's his That intellectually is what he chooses to do to retain
- 54:17his logic and to retain his focus. He doesn't allow himself to be distracted
- 54:22by these things, not to any great extent. So where are they going
- 54:27to go with that? Or is that a prelude, a sinister prelude to
- 54:31overwriting the character's spok in introducing us to a new Spot. Now, Spot's
- 54:37got a vision of the future like Pike. They've they've got a choice,
- 54:42haven't they. They can do we want to be the people the future says
- 54:46we are? Or do we want to go down our own path? We've
- 54:50been given that, Cassandra, like, look into our own futures and so
- 54:53we can change it convenient If you're a Kiva Goldsman and you intend to change
- 54:59it, dude, I am so with you as far as it's almost conspiratal
- 55:04as far as that attitude of these are the problems with Coos. We need
- 55:07to rewrite these characters. To Pring, it's all this sympathy now for to
- 55:13Pring and oh, you know, she's kind of jilted and Spot should have
- 55:17taken her more in his confidence. And it's like, excuse me a month
- 55:21time she tried to kill Spok or she was willing to let Spok die.
- 55:27That's a fem fatale if I could put it into our statesman statements, and
- 55:30it's like, I'm sorry, I don't again, you don't. My theory
- 55:35of get out of jail free for this series is ed is much like we
- 55:38saw in the time travel episode with Laon where the temporal cop comes and says,
- 55:44yeah, listen, you can't talk about this with anybody. I think
- 55:47at the end of this series, because it also solves the law on Nunion
- 55:51Sing problem with all of a sudden, Conn is there and like did we
- 55:54need somebody like this years ago? I think the solution is another temporal cock
- 56:00or the same temporal cop will come and say I'm sorry, you don't belong
- 56:02in this timeline. You need to go. She will go. It will
- 56:07erase these experiences and perhaps the Spock Chapel relationship as well, that they'll all
- 56:13be reset for ts. But in cheesy why am I wasting all time with
- 56:17it? Then well I agree, but wait and cheesy kind of bad writing
- 56:22things, some sort of totem like the watch that Lan had that she took
- 56:27with her from the alternate timeline and stuff. Something will exist so the viewers
- 56:30will know, well, she's still existed. It's okay, but they're gonna
- 56:34do either they're gonna do that or as you say, no, no holds
- 56:37born Bart, we've already got our Kirk, a new McCoy and other and
- 56:43a new Scottie and the like. I might be waiting in the rings.
- 56:46I really hope they don't rewrite this continuity. I suspect that that is their
- 56:51plan, and it is such a disservice And for all the warts you want
- 56:55to impose on sixties star trek and it's a fair cup because again it was
- 57:01a different time. The lead actor always got the girl, and the girl
- 57:07changed every week, and nobody linked for over two decades before the eighties,
- 57:12and it's like, yeah, maybe that's not cool anymore. That's the effectial
- 57:15history of the future you're talking about Jonas, I don't know ed honestly,
- 57:21it's I don't know what their plans are, but I agree. And also
- 57:24the spot Chapel thing like and again forgive me old TV references American TV show
- 57:30Moonlighting with Bruce Willis and Sybil Shephard. Oh great, okay, So will
- 57:36they are? Won't they? Will they are? Won't they? Well when
- 57:37they finally get together, all the sexual tension is gone, and my god,
- 57:42we're only a season and a half into Strange New Worlds and Spocket Chapel
- 57:46or off to the races, and it's like, well, now where do
- 57:50you go? You've you've consummated this relationship and again, how does this jive
- 57:55with Coos later down the rhine? And that's what I liked about last night's
- 58:00episode, the crossover episode where I can say, wait a minute, I
- 58:02act like this in the future, or wait a minute, I don't know.
- 58:06So I don't know what they're going to do with it. It's a
- 58:07different kind of tension, isn't it, Because they create the relationship which they
- 58:12know shouldn't exist, and so what do you do with it? You have
- 58:15to do something, you have to sync up that with TS somehow, unless
- 58:22you are, at some point in the future going to do a moonlighting and
- 58:24have all the characters and Strange Your World's turned to the camera and say,
- 58:28hey, who are you? Who are you out there in the world.
- 58:31We're characters in a TV show and we do whatever we like because we're self
- 58:36aware. You know, unless they're going to do that, at some point,
- 58:38they're going to have to make an on screen declaration to us the audience
- 58:44as to whether or not Strange New World is Cannon or not. Now,
- 58:47I think what they're waiting for is for there to be more of their fans,
- 58:53and there are TS fans. There is a split down the middle in
- 59:00the Star family, as we discuss. There are the old fans, gentlemen
- 59:06like you and I, more seasoned veterans of the show, and there are
- 59:10younger kids out there with flags in their Twitter bios and Insta accounts and TikTok's,
- 59:17and they love New Trek because they're deranged and I'm sorry, different different
- 59:23priorities, and those kids love it and they think that it's it's their Star
- 59:30Trek and so on. And when the time comes that there are enough of
- 59:35them, you know, we've all fallen away because we've grown so disillusioned and
- 59:39disgusted by watching our you know, cultural touchstones, soiled and soiled and desecrated
- 59:47and so on, we fall away. They're left. Then Akiva Goldsman as
- 59:52soon as he gets that signal, yep, there's only eight original Trek.
- 59:54He's left the rest of our people. He can push the button and say,
- 1:00:00yeah, this is Star Trek. Now, don't worry. We've over
- 1:00:02written all of that old stuff, all of that unreconstructed, old bigoted crap
- 1:00:10that you that your dad used to watch. That's all gone. And what
- 1:00:15we're making is real Star Trek. And that's when he'll declare. But he
- 1:00:20won't declare yet because the people who make Star Trek now are still reliant on
- 1:00:27the brand as it was established in the past, Yes, to invest their
- 1:00:31shows with meaning. No one cares that their shows aren't strong enough to stand
- 1:00:37on their own. That's why they brought Pike into Discovering the first place.
- 1:00:40It's an emission of failure. One season a Discovery where we weren't inured to
- 1:00:46a single new character. What do we do for? Holy shit, we
- 1:00:50better do something. We better pull a stunt to generate some interest in season
- 1:00:55two, let's get the enterprise in and so you know the enterprise and Pike's
- 1:01:00enterprise takes over in the second season and so indeed failure. You didn't see
- 1:01:07Spark in TN until season five, right, that's the that's the difference in
- 1:01:12this generation. Absolutely. Yeah. Well, guys, that were hanish brand
- 1:01:16and a show phenomena in its own right before they brought a member of the
- 1:01:22original cast back as a guest. Well and even season well, I was
- 1:01:27gonna say the Sarak episode in season three and again I've read um Mark Altman
- 1:01:32and ed I forget ed the co author's name, but the fifty Year Mission
- 1:01:37books, they're amazing if people watching haven't read them, and they really were
- 1:01:42like, I don't know, should we do this? Serah thing, I
- 1:01:44don't know, And really that edict of this needs to be its own thing.
- 1:01:47Stay away from the original series as much as you can. And again,
- 1:01:52because it was the future, they were able to create these characters and
- 1:01:54these stories. Great comments here from two people in particular, and that's mister
- 1:02:00Vick and bake Bean. Mister Vicks says, I don't want any comedy and
- 1:02:04star Trek and lessons McCoy talking shit to Spot and it's at the end of
- 1:02:07the show. Bake Bean says, I can't remember in the name of the
- 1:02:09episode, but enterprises coch Editor is one of the best Star Trek episodes ever.
- 1:02:14That's the thing then, both and I mean, for all the three
- 1:02:19pot of the coach enitor Um, I thought it was the one we were
- 1:02:22talking about with the slave race and the oh wait, oh okay, okay,
- 1:02:27I thought. And also, don't forget the episode some similitude with the
- 1:02:32clone that flocks grows of Trip to help him, you know, perform a
- 1:02:37brain operation and Trip's gonna die and it's like, okay, you know,
- 1:02:42the clone of Trip. Bake Bean also says, can't remember that was that
- 1:02:45one. Bank Bean also says Old Trek handled comedy well funnily get through the
- 1:02:50app character at the app time data, the doctor, Warf, Garrick,
- 1:02:53etc. Yeah, man, everything's too goofy. And mister Vicks says,
- 1:02:57and all the Vulcans hated Spot for being half human forget them well, and
- 1:03:00that that Spok episode this season, the father, the Prince's father was very
- 1:03:06Unvulcan, like really enjoying its food and smiling and everything, and it's like,
- 1:03:12what's going on here? Man? These aren't Vulcan the parents channel the
- 1:03:15only thing, the only thing that the things wrought is known about Valcans,
- 1:03:20which is that they faketate against humans. It's it's flashcard knowledge of Star Trek.
- 1:03:27Or like the way they treat Kirk. It's like these producers saw a
- 1:03:32super video cut of Kirk kissing every female alien he could and it's like,
- 1:03:37oh, Kirk's the misogynists, and it's like, again, it was written
- 1:03:42in the sixties and I'll even acknowledge. Sure he jumped around. Yeah,
- 1:03:45he had a lot of relationships that was just literally, if you want to
- 1:03:49be generous, twenty percent of Kirk's character, where are the other good interest?
- 1:03:53I mean that line in Unification the Spots two parter on t N when
- 1:04:00when Patrick Stewart says to it with respect, ambassador, your sort of cowboy
- 1:04:04diplomacy is a past thing, and just the contempt on spots face and cowboy
- 1:04:11diplomas, that's what my career has been reduced to. And that's smart writing
- 1:04:15and it is so not there. I mean again, I'll give crossover,
- 1:04:19the crossover a little credit because it at least introduced some ideas, and even
- 1:04:25again Boiler was our voice like, wait a minute, why are you treating
- 1:04:28Spot this way? Why is he smiling? So at least they've they've introduced
- 1:04:31it. I have my suspicions that with the next three episodes it's not going
- 1:04:38to come up and and and God. Now with the writers and actors strike,
- 1:04:42there's not much very molet there's right. I think there's three musical episode
- 1:04:48is sandwich between two episodes about the goal? Yeah, eventually I'm so happy
- 1:04:54to stand it. Yeah, well there you go. Yeah, the season
- 1:04:57you'd be forgiven for not nicing because it mentioned for three seconds in the first
- 1:05:01episode of the season. But the season ark what passes for a season arc
- 1:05:06is that the Gone or you know, orminary war. Yeah, supposedly we'll
- 1:05:12see again. It's strange version of the Gone that they which another another thing
- 1:05:16that, oh god, I truly I agree with you. One of the
- 1:05:19main culporences that Civa Goldsman, good lord when they the I don't know if
- 1:05:25you get the after show that we get the Will Wheaton hosts in England.
- 1:05:30We're spared Will Wheaton's ready. Well, they know that we can't take it.
- 1:05:35We're too you know, disappointing man child too. We've seen clips that's
- 1:05:42we're only allowed by law in the United Kingdom. You're only allowed to see
- 1:05:45thirty seconds of the Ready Room. Well many one day Goldsman and Goldsman in
- 1:05:50regards to the spark half human up or a human up a full human episode,
- 1:05:57he's like, we're secularly writing romance stories and it's I don't know how
- 1:06:00to break with you. It's not a sacred and uh, it's these are
- 1:06:03bad teen romances pretending to be star Trek and oh god, when when Chapel
- 1:06:09made u Ortegus and Elhurra turnaround while she was baring her soul to the ethereal
- 1:06:15crow cloud alien and it's like, come on, my god, turn around.
- 1:06:20I'm gonna bear my soul and tell everyone about my love for a spot.
- 1:06:24I can't have you watched this. Like again, it's like, this
- 1:06:28is bad teenage romance writing. It is so shameful that they have adults acting
- 1:06:33this way. But again they're appealing, like you said to this kid audience
- 1:06:38who And I don't mean they're in a dismissive way as far as calling them
- 1:06:41kids. But this is their first star Trek, so they're very comfortable with
- 1:06:45these choices. They're in a strange position, aren't like that by themselves have
- 1:06:49created? And this is the floor in having strange new worlds as a show
- 1:06:55at all, is that you've lumbag yourself with these characters. Character like Spot
- 1:07:00that's already had this huge long life on television's been a You've watched him grow
- 1:07:06up and mature in front, you know, over a course of very very
- 1:07:10many years. Now you've got a prequel where he's a main character. What
- 1:07:14do you do with him? The only thing they can think to do is
- 1:07:17to show us how he became that sort of cold, hard logician that we
- 1:07:23are used to see. And the only way they can imagine to do that
- 1:07:27is to turn him into an idiot initially so that his friends can educate him,
- 1:07:31and how he can become a vulcan. I mean, for me,
- 1:07:33the low point of this season was spok forgetting how to act like a vulcan
- 1:07:40and what a vulcan thinks like just because he'd had a genetic alteration. He's
- 1:07:45been a half vulcan all his life. He's but in behavior wise's performed as
- 1:07:49a vulcan his whole life. All I have to do to completely get him
- 1:07:54to forget all that is to genetically alter him. I mean, you've got
- 1:08:00Alarm and and Una and or take us teaching him how to act like a
- 1:08:04vulcan. What the fuck do they know? And you're so right, and
- 1:08:10it's it is all these humans telling this vulcan how to behave How about Mabenga
- 1:08:15giving him the vulcan harp? And it's like yeah, yeah, And also
- 1:08:19good Lord. In the your horror episode, Oh, James Kirk meeting mister
- 1:08:24Spike, come on, my god, everything about the characters we know now
- 1:08:30are as you said it first meeting, wasn't it? Yeah? Well,
- 1:08:35and there was nothing, and it's I can I can accept it be nothing
- 1:08:41because you know, actually there's I didn't mind it being low key because I
- 1:08:47to build it up into something major would be confusing then our knowledge of the
- 1:08:55characters with them with what they know in universe. So I set that it
- 1:09:00would be a low key handshake whatever, blah blah blah. But really it
- 1:09:04should be at the end of the show, like the whole series, not
- 1:09:10you know now, because maybe like you know, as I said in one
- 1:09:14of my reviews, maybe they just don't think it's going to run very long.
- 1:09:16Maybe it's three seasons and out whatever, and they're they're people in a
- 1:09:20hurry. They've got to start converging these two quick Instead, there's so much
- 1:09:26story they could have told without having to wasting episodes on gimmicks, which is
- 1:09:31so weird. I mean, like, we've had seventeen episodes now and we've
- 1:09:36had almost We've had so little drama. We've had so little thought provoking storytelling.
- 1:09:44We've had a lot of emoting, and we've had a lot of relationship
- 1:09:49development between the characters, very sop operatic, like a lot of personal trauma,
- 1:09:55a lot of personal trauma. Yeah, but we've not had Star Trek
- 1:10:00stories that we can say, Wow, I'm glad to show this because it's
- 1:10:03given me my new favorite episode. You know, absolutely, I would be
- 1:10:08hard pushed to recommend a single episode. No, maybe one in the first
- 1:10:12season, the one that they they ripped off Sulla l Gwin, that one,
- 1:10:17you know, and I'm glad you Bretta, because I was going to
- 1:10:19do it as well. As much as they ripped her off. At least
- 1:10:23it felt like a Star Trek episode, and I think good episode. Jeh,
- 1:10:27Yeah, I think it's the best one that Strange Your Worlds has made
- 1:10:30so far, because again it asked this very interesting intellectual debate of yeah,
- 1:10:35they're abusing this one child. But as the woman who represented the planet said
- 1:10:40the pike, well can you guarantee that children don't suffer in your way of
- 1:10:44life? And Robert Robert Mbands has said very eloquently and often that they didn't
- 1:10:49credit La Gwin. Fore they didn't you know that this is a show that
- 1:10:56is absolutely has no moral scruples at all about ripping off other writers and not
- 1:11:02giving them any not paying them, not giving them any on screen credit.
- 1:11:08Just as like David Picard, was it season one or two one where they
- 1:11:14essentially adopted one that the character of a measure of a man? Yeah,
- 1:11:19rismatics, Yeah, rismatics. Melinda Snodgrass's character indeed, great episode. Did
- 1:11:25she get a credit? Did she know anything about it until the head I
- 1:11:28doubt it? Well, And even further, DC Fontana's backstory for number one
- 1:11:33that she did in the novels, and my god, d DC Fontana,
- 1:11:38who when they think of it, they laud as an important star Trek creator.
- 1:11:44But my guy, especially in this era of promoting women characters, promoting
- 1:11:48women actors and women writers and directors and the lot, well, here is
- 1:11:54this woman that was there from the beginning with the original series, that not
- 1:11:57only wrote this wonderful backstory for number one, created the animated episode of the
- 1:12:01original animated series Yesteryear, which they borrow from very generously all the time,
- 1:12:08the parts that they like. And it's like, my god, this woman
- 1:12:11was so responsible. She was the story editor. She was rewriting Star Trek
- 1:12:15episodes. That was her job and was so important to the whole mythos and
- 1:12:21and yeah to to like you said about her, Solila Gwynn, whose credits
- 1:12:26are vast and amazing, I mean, yeah, it's it's crazy. It
- 1:12:30really is crazy. So I don't I don't understand that unethical to rip them
- 1:12:38off and not credit them. Well, I mean technically, I know,
- 1:12:41I know, I know, you know, we can look about it,
- 1:12:43but you know, well they own everything. I mean, start Riders have
- 1:12:47always look to literary inspiration and inspiration and so on for stories. So you
- 1:12:57could argue, Okay, you know, it's not a new thing to take
- 1:13:00an idea and sort of adapted the Star Trek and sell on. But I
- 1:13:04think when it's that on the nose, when it's that close to the story,
- 1:13:10you really do need to acknowledge the source material because you have effectively copied
- 1:13:15it. You haven't adapted it, you have ripped at all. Agreed,
- 1:13:18No, I agree. I hated the final episode of season one, The
- 1:13:25Terror, and it was like watching college students act out of Star Trek scenario
- 1:13:30and as as Robernette pointed out, the subtlety Mark Lenard brought to the Romulan
- 1:13:35commander and we really got to know him, and in this redo, he's
- 1:13:42just another empty character that's just moving the plot along without really understand And I'm
- 1:13:46saying the same words, but without the other other dialogue that they left out,
- 1:13:53and that lack of an emotional impact of oh, this is a tragic
- 1:13:57hero that unfortunately is on the losing side of this scenario and stuff. It's
- 1:14:01almost almost as if they see this stuff is just raw material to be reworked,
- 1:14:06rather than understanding what's great about it in the first place. Yeah,
- 1:14:11and big being seriously again, I appreciate you subscribing, and I agree love
- 1:14:15R and B may get a little passionate about his politics. It's sorry,
- 1:14:18mind are in the right place, And yeah, man, no, I'm
- 1:14:21I agree. I Rob as a chess master and I am a student at
- 1:14:27his feet when it comes to Star Trek, Laura and everything. But I
- 1:14:30do love my conversations that I have with Rob, and I completely agree and
- 1:14:35I the whole I share his indignation of what's going on. I mean,
- 1:14:41I think the only the only thing that I've ever really not not really disagreed
- 1:14:46with him about I suppose had a slight difference of opinion, was on the
- 1:14:50third season of Piccard. Tell me, yes, well, it's not that
- 1:14:55I don't like the third season of Piccard. I would agree with him and
- 1:15:00those people who say it advanced the t characters. It developed them in a
- 1:15:04way that was congruous with their characterizations before. I liked that it took them
- 1:15:10to a new place. I thought it did respect what had come before.
- 1:15:14Maybe it was too respectful in the sets that it looked look backwards too much
- 1:15:17in my view. I know people will say, well, it was about
- 1:15:20a old man looking back, so and so on. But for me,
- 1:15:27though, it was far better than any of the other New Trek that we've
- 1:15:30had much much better and it felt like Star Trek. My only problem with
- 1:15:35it was that it did that thing that New Trek does, which is it
- 1:15:39looks backwards that it cannibalizes the old stuff for parts. Did it in a
- 1:15:44much better way. It reconstituted all of this stuff into a new story.
- 1:15:49But you know, it was so clear what it was ripping, what it
- 1:15:55was using, what parts it had taken from this episode, and that move
- 1:16:00being so on and so on, right down to the use of certain sound
- 1:16:02effects and so on. Score I just got impatient. I just thought,
- 1:16:08isn't there a new story to be told here, a new idea? Because
- 1:16:13when they gave the original crew a send off in the Undiscovered Country, Nick
- 1:16:17Mayo and Lennon Nimoy didn't sit down and say, hey, we've got it's
- 1:16:20their final adventure. We've got to do something that references everything they've ever done,
- 1:16:27you know, and these key episodes from the original series. We've got
- 1:16:30to do that. They said, no, we'll make it a legacy story
- 1:16:35in the sense that we will acknowledge how important these characters are, how important
- 1:16:42their history is, by putting them into a new situation that is befitting of
- 1:16:47their status. That's what The Undiscovered Country did, and that's what I would
- 1:16:54have liked Picard Season three to have done. I can't really forgive them for
- 1:16:59missing the chance to use Sealer as a villain, which would have given us
- 1:17:03a full reunion of all the TN cast. You had it right there.
- 1:17:09You had somebody who had a familial link to the to the cast, to
- 1:17:14the characters, and that would have been a really interesting philosophical dilemma for them
- 1:17:19to be facing off against the child of a lost colleague. Dasha's good to
- 1:17:27have been really interesting, Grid, But they weren't brave enough to tell that
- 1:17:30story. They fell back the old reliables like Lacutas and War three five nine
- 1:17:34and all this again, like for the fifty millionth reprise of that story.
- 1:17:39Way too many boring episodes, way too many carn episodes in New trek Um.
- 1:17:45I did like Michelle Forbes coming back. I don't know how you felt
- 1:17:47about that. Yeah, No, I mean again, you know, they
- 1:17:49handled it well. It was good to see her the way they dealt with
- 1:17:54it. I don't have any problem with any of that stuff. I like
- 1:17:57sure, I like that character. I like the too you know it was
- 1:18:01great. I've got no problem with I didn't like, you know, the
- 1:18:04swearing in it, and so one that's very cool. Yeah, t make
- 1:18:09sure they say fuck you know what is with that? And it was and
- 1:18:13it was so disapproprit think that's how you make it adult and edgy and content.
- 1:18:17I guess, I guess, but yeah, even Patrick Stewart drop in
- 1:18:20the F bomb. It's like, come am, I not to put a
- 1:18:24red line through this stuff? It just yas it's so easy not to do
- 1:18:30it. It's almost aggressive when it happened. So agree and no, like
- 1:18:34you said that in other iterations of Trek, it's obvious the language has evolved,
- 1:18:40and um, yeah they forgotten all that because they want to be aren't
- 1:18:44we like you said, aren't we edgy? And it's like, no,
- 1:18:46it's it's cheap. All the all their plois or most of their ploise are
- 1:18:53incredibly cheap and bad. I keep going back to just bad writing. That's
- 1:18:57what it is. I don't know. You're absolutely right. I mean,
- 1:19:01look, if I were, Let's say there was a mass plague in Hollywood
- 1:19:06and all Hollywood writers were wiped out. I don't want this to happen.
- 1:19:11By the way, this is my an apocalyptic fantasy purely for the purposes of
- 1:19:15this conceit right, But let's say that happened, and they rang me up
- 1:19:18and they said, ed, I want you to run a New Star Trek
- 1:19:23show. I'd say, great, but I've got one rule to start with.
- 1:19:29I want to make sure that what we're writing works whether you're seven,
- 1:19:33seventeen or forty seven. I want people to be able to grow up with
- 1:19:39this material and get something new out of it when they look back on it
- 1:19:42in twenty years time or forty years time. So it's got to be aimed
- 1:19:45at that level. It's got to be aimed at a family audience without being
- 1:19:49patronizing, without dumbing down. You're talking up to the audience, but you're
- 1:19:55making sure that whoever's watching it, whether it's little Joey or Joey's great grandfather,
- 1:20:01can have a good time and get understand what you're doing and enjoy it.
- 1:20:06That seems to me to be lost with New Trek. I don't think
- 1:20:12they know who their audience are half the time. It's this Hence they can't
- 1:20:15conceive of making a show that has broad appealed. They don't know how to
- 1:20:19write that show, the compartmentalized Star Trek. Let's make one for the kids,
- 1:20:26Let's do Prodigy. Let's make one for you know, hyperactive ADHD afflicted
- 1:20:33teenagers that lower doubt. Let's let's make one for people in a waking coma
- 1:20:40that's Discovery. Let's let's make one for people who half remember Star Trek because
- 1:20:45they saw four episodes back in nineteen eighty five. That's strange New Worlds.
- 1:20:50You're killing me. That's so true, man, it's you know, I
- 1:20:55know this philosophy is in animation and I disagree with it, but and I
- 1:21:00don't know how deep beyond Trek and some other shows, but the Justice League
- 1:21:04animated TV series, and even more so, there was a season of Green
- 1:21:11Lantern as an animated series, and it was really well written, but it
- 1:21:15was made to sell toys to a Y seven audience, as the rating at
- 1:21:20least here suggests, and it didn't connect with that audience. They canceled it
- 1:21:25after a season, and a lot of my friends that also were podcasts just
- 1:21:29like, I don't understand. And it's like, because it was made for
- 1:21:32a Y seven audience, and this is my suspicion with Prodigy as well that
- 1:21:36it didn't pull enough. Why seven numbers and that's why it's gone. It's
- 1:21:41a damn shame, I confess I haven't seen it. Well do it.
- 1:21:45It was one of those shows that I was going to get round to watching
- 1:21:49when I had some free time. Like a fool, I thought it would
- 1:21:53be there forever, absolutely and I'll just go on Paramount Plus and watch it
- 1:21:58at some point. And then they pulled it as Oh yeah, I am
- 1:22:00so angry about that, because truly it was a very well written show that
- 1:22:05I could see was made for tweeners, you know, that twelve to fifteen
- 1:22:10sort of audience. But it was smart Star Trek. They did a very
- 1:22:15good job having a young cast but telling real Star Trek stories. Once it
- 1:22:19found its footing and they established who all the characters were. Man that second
- 1:22:25half of that first season got into some really great Star Trek. And to
- 1:22:30not only decide to not go ahead with the second season, but to pull
- 1:22:33down that first season. What a disservice. And it's like, you can
- 1:22:36on let people discover this thing, no pun intended. But also I hope
- 1:22:44that another platform will see the quality and want to pick it up. That's
- 1:22:48what happened with the an animated Batman series that's still in production. HBO Max
- 1:22:55is not going to run it, but they did get a suitor and Amazon
- 1:23:00has picked it up and they're going to run it. A good friend of
- 1:23:01mine was the story editor in charge of the writer's room, and it's like,
- 1:23:06no, like, I trust these writers. They know how to write
- 1:23:10Batman. What are you doing, HBO Max? But now we know you
- 1:23:14know again, at least they found a new home. I'm hoping that's the
- 1:23:16case for Prodigy. But I'm one of those people that always wants what they
- 1:23:20can't have John, and so now they've taken away Prodigy. I actually want
- 1:23:25to see it, whereas when it was on I didn't have any interest in
- 1:23:28watching it. Um I've heard. I think I'm right in saying that,
- 1:23:32is it David mac who's a consultant on It's who's these I don't know.
- 1:23:38If I don't know if he is specifically a Prodigy, I do know in
- 1:23:41general is a name someway. I know in general, David mc the novelist
- 1:23:47has been creatively consulting. Hey, Michelle Paradise, who was one of the
- 1:23:51card show Runners has written good voyager novels. I always I wish I knew
- 1:23:59these people better to sit down and have a drink with them and go,
- 1:24:01okay, what's going up? It's because Bayer Bayer. I don't know how
- 1:24:06christ and Amber shop Buiread. That's Christen Byo. She's an interesting case study
- 1:24:12because my understanding, I haven't read any of her voyage novels, but I
- 1:24:15am told that they're pretty good, and they are pretty good, and so
- 1:24:19I'm surprised in a way by how poor her contribution is to TV Trip because
- 1:24:26she wrote one episode of Discovery, which was the one where they were trapped
- 1:24:30in a sort of fungal universe or something like that, which I think one
- 1:24:32of my toenails has been there. But you know, that was okay.
- 1:24:39It was kind of structured like a conventional Star Trek episode, and I remember
- 1:24:43thinking, yeah, this looks like it's been written by somebody who knows what
- 1:24:47they're doing. But then she's contributed, I think, to Strange New Worlds,
- 1:24:54and I'm afraid I've been really disappointed by I don't know whether it is
- 1:24:59whether it's because she's hemmed in, maybe they're all hemmed into it. That's
- 1:25:03what I think. Go on, But I mean who knows. But um
- 1:25:08well, somebody knows. If you know, tell us put it in the
- 1:25:11comments. But the thing is, something's either the writers who work on these
- 1:25:18shows are just terrible. They're just people people know. They're writers for higher
- 1:25:25Hey, hey, John, you did me a favor twenty years ago?
- 1:25:27Do you want a job on Star Trek's here? That's I do hear.
- 1:25:30That's what's happening. As far as choosing these writers, They're na start.
- 1:25:34They're na science fiction writers or Star Trek writers. They're friends from previous shows.
- 1:25:42That would make sense to me because what we can definitely say is that
- 1:25:45they have not been interrogated at any great length about their knowledge of Star Trek
- 1:25:49before they were given the job. I mean, look, why should they
- 1:25:53know anything? A Kiva Goldsman doesn't, Alex Kurtzman doesn't, So why should
- 1:25:58they agree to impose on them that burden when the show runners themselves don't know
- 1:26:02anything. But you know, I'm being interested to be a fly on the
- 1:26:08wall in those writers rooms and know to what degree do they have the ability
- 1:26:12to kind of put forward these arguments about you know, if I were in
- 1:26:15that room, would I be able to say we can't do this because it
- 1:26:18contradicts established cannon or you know, like like Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park.
- 1:26:27You know, we're thinking so much about whether we can do it, we
- 1:26:30haven't stopped to think whether we should. Indeed, those do those people at
- 1:26:34xist in Star Trek writers rooms. I think they have been listening to them
- 1:26:39now I think they're MMed in. And further, what was my point I
- 1:26:43was going to make, as because I completely agree with what you're saying.
- 1:26:45They know. In fact, the science expert that they even featured on the
- 1:26:50Will Wheaton Show last season or the first or horror episode they did, one
- 1:26:57of the bridge crews says, well, as we know, space is very
- 1:27:00noisy, and it's like, again, I only have a grade school knowledge
- 1:27:05of science, but it's like, no, it's in a vacuum. There
- 1:27:09is no sound in space. And it's like and again it's like, hey,
- 1:27:12look at our science advisor. And I was. I had a noise
- 1:27:15of sorts, but not the type that you can hear like you would if
- 1:27:18you were on the ocean for its long. There you go, It's not
- 1:27:23that kind of noise. I do have a friend who was a writer's assistant
- 1:27:28and even helped. I mean, God only knows what the writers strike and
- 1:27:32when they finally do get to production of the Michelle Yoe Section thirty one film,
- 1:27:38which is a ridiculously bad idea. But he did tell me there are
- 1:27:44knowledgeable star trek writers in the room. But ultimately it is the showrunner's decision
- 1:27:49of do we agree and want to go with Canada? We do our own
- 1:27:53thing, and I do because I asked to go specifically about the Science Advisor
- 1:27:57and it's like, no, she's there and she makes the gentleman points.
- 1:28:00Sometimes the writers room was like, well, nobody cares. I mean,
- 1:28:04it doesn't exist. Let's let's now worry about her remembering classic trick. There
- 1:28:10used to be I don't know if you remember this, but there used to
- 1:28:13be such a thing as like a writer's guide or template that you could get.
- 1:28:16I think it was for Dstein because of course they had an open submissions
- 1:28:19policy. Do oh yes, my friend has the Bible that was given to
- 1:28:25get submissions. What a wonderful thing that was for prospective writers to be able
- 1:28:30to take a chance and send the script. You know, and a few
- 1:28:33people were taken on staff through that policy as well. Now they showed you
- 1:28:39a sample I can't remember I saw it. I saw it somewhere in a
- 1:28:43book start some Star Trek book somewhere, but there was like a there was
- 1:28:47a sample screenplay I think it was for a d S nine episode, and
- 1:28:53you could see inserted there were gaps in the dialogue where they would put the
- 1:28:58word tech and that's where you put in the technobabble. Sure, they talked
- 1:29:03to their science consultant, I think Andre burmanis was it or you became a
- 1:29:09writer after starting as a science right, and they said to him Andre,
- 1:29:14we need what what's the thing that we can put in here that works on
- 1:29:18real scientific principles that make this script work. So you get stuff like the
- 1:29:24Heisenberg compensator, for example, which explains transportation technology, because Heisenberg said,
- 1:29:31you can know I think the position of a molecule or an atom or whatever,
- 1:29:36or its size, but you can't know both at the same time.
- 1:29:40Or so the scientists in the audience know what I'm talking about. They'll correct
- 1:29:44me. I don't know what I'm talking about, you know, do you
- 1:29:46tell us? But the thing is the way they got around it was that's
- 1:29:50Heisenberg's that's the problem that Heisenberg put forward that makes transportation technology impossible in the
- 1:29:58te century and twenty first century. So what do they do? They just
- 1:30:02sketch in the Heisenberg compensator problem solved. Sure, we don't know how it
- 1:30:09works. You don't need to know. The point is it's in there,
- 1:30:14and because it's in there, the transport works properly. Now that's the kind
- 1:30:18of attention to detail that as a teenager I got excited about because I was
- 1:30:24like, I didn't heard of Heisenberg untils that I watched Star Trek the Next
- 1:30:29Generation. It was wonderful that it used to teach you little things like that
- 1:30:32or put you introduce you to names and concepts and ideas that pushed you down
- 1:30:40certain rabbit holes, you know. And that was one of the wonderful things
- 1:30:44about being a Star Trek fan that it sort of opened up your mind to
- 1:30:47different ideas, schools of thought and so on. The contrat red lad and
- 1:30:54Media made a very funny parody of Yeah, I Love Them. They made
- 1:30:59a very funny par idea of Discovery Season two. I think it was in
- 1:31:03which they mocked the technobabble. You know, they basically just came up with
- 1:31:08a lot of basically horseshit that sounded vaguely scientific, that didn't make any gibberish
- 1:31:15essentially, and it showed the contrast because there is a difference between gobbledegook and
- 1:31:23tetna babble. Indeed, and that video, I don't know where it seek
- 1:31:28it out on bread lead of Media's channel. That video brilliantly illustrates difference between
- 1:31:32the two. I remember the first time I had ever heard about a daycent
- 1:31:36sphere was the Scotia episode of TAM and what an interesting concept. And it's
- 1:31:42like again and it was, you know, the c story in that episode
- 1:31:46or whatever. It wasn't even the beast why, I guess it was the
- 1:31:48story. It's just a setup, just the frame the story. But again,
- 1:31:53it introduced this very interesting scientific notion or theory, and it's like,
- 1:31:58wow, that's really cool. I've actually learned something. And god, you
- 1:32:01know, prior to not being able to do these panels at terrific on for
- 1:32:05a moment, and I now I need to do it because I'm not doing
- 1:32:09the panels anymore. I don't want to piss anybody off. But I really
- 1:32:12want to like make a mock up of those infamous books Algebra for Dummies or
- 1:32:17whatever we're experiencing Star Trek for Dummies, because it is so dumb down and
- 1:32:24it is so disappointing that it isn't the intellectual stimulation that it was for decades,
- 1:32:30and it's it's really insulting to us old Star Trek fans that god,
- 1:32:35to paraphrase Michael J. Fox in the movie The American President, we're so
- 1:32:40thirsty that when a Charlatan comes and has us in the desert drinking sand,
- 1:32:45we think it's water. It's not. Yeah, I mean, and that's
- 1:32:47unfortunately, that's where we are right now. We can take some comfort from
- 1:32:53the fact that these episodes have got absolutely no shelf life. You're right,
- 1:32:58it's just talking about these episodes in thirty years time. Except as a footnote.
- 1:33:03You know, when Star Trek went wrong? Remember that era? Do
- 1:33:06you remember the Kurts from golds Goldsman era of Star Trek? No, I
- 1:33:11don't, what was it like? It was terrible. We we all we
- 1:33:14all referred to it as New Trek in that same way that New Coke was
- 1:33:18that unfortunate misstep of Coke, remember, exactly the same way as New Coke.
- 1:33:25Yes, yeah, And I mean that's the thing, man, And
- 1:33:27that's why there will come a time. There will come a time where these
- 1:33:31producers are no longer in charge of the franchise. Their influence will peter out
- 1:33:35in the same way that Rick Berman Eira Star Trek petered out. Yeah.
- 1:33:39I mean, we know they do have some considerable influence. And the evidence
- 1:33:44of that, I think is Picard season three. Because even when you've got
- 1:33:47somebody on board like Terry Matalis, who, by all accounts he blocked me
- 1:33:51on Twitter because of something I wrote, I don't know. It's okay,
- 1:33:57I'm completely over it. I'm not in any way bitter, But I don't
- 1:34:02know why he did. I think because I might have written something that he
- 1:34:06didn't like about. You know, anyway, who knows, only he knows
- 1:34:13tell me all is forgiven. Anyway. The point is, if somebody like
- 1:34:18him, who's in charge of obstensibly the showrunner of Star Trek show, who
- 1:34:25we know gets it, who we know is a big fan, who does
- 1:34:30have reverence and respect for what came before, if he can produce a show
- 1:34:34that has these sort of weird, little incongruous moments in it, the swearing,
- 1:34:42the some not a lot of gratuitous violence, but a little bit more
- 1:34:45a slightly darker, brooding, manic depressive version of that show he used to
- 1:34:53love. You know, if that can happen with him in charge, Either
- 1:34:57he's brought to one or two things. Only a spot might say, there
- 1:35:00are only two possibilities. Either one he's brought into it. He's brought into
- 1:35:08the Kurtsman Goldsman view of Star Trek, and he's serious, not towing the
- 1:35:14company line when he says they did great stuff, their own takes blah blah
- 1:35:18blah, their own vision, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. And I but
- 1:35:21mine was a different version, but everything they did was great blah blah blah.
- 1:35:28Yeah, if you believe that I've got a bridge, I can sell
- 1:35:30you, etcetera, etcetera. Either he believes that, or he's insane and
- 1:35:36he's been captured, or he has to say that and actually he's working within
- 1:35:43certain tram lines. There's always the memo from on high, don't contradict what
- 1:35:47we've done, don't undermine what we've done, don't overwrite what we've done.
- 1:35:51Remember that your show is a limited show. That is this within our sphere,
- 1:35:58within our unify to fit in with that. Yes, wise, we're
- 1:36:03sending a signal to the audience that we regret what we've done, or that
- 1:36:08we made a mistake, or something like we have to all be shower united
- 1:36:13front. Right, you want to run a Star Trek show, Terry tow
- 1:36:16the line. Okay, well you don't get to make Star Trek anymore.
- 1:36:23I think that's what happened. I absolutely agree with you. Come on,
- 1:36:26man, secret hideout signs his paycheck, So I mean you're nacking a shit
- 1:36:30on your your your employer. So I understand, and I will not be
- 1:36:35free until these guys are out of the picture. And there was this sort
- 1:36:40of argument between what was it Robert my Benette and Doomcock about you know whether
- 1:36:48or not by praising Pricard Season three people who did that were inadvertently doing Cutsman's
- 1:36:55work for him. Right now, I don't know the ins and outs of
- 1:36:59it. People who are far closer to it in Los Angeles, well it
- 1:37:01will know whether or not it made a sintiller of difference as to whether or
- 1:37:05not that deals extended maybe it did, maybe it didn't, but I do
- 1:37:11understand the people on the other side. He said, let's not be too
- 1:37:16full of adulation because we otherwise. Metallis may well come back, but it
- 1:37:21will come back under the control of Alex Skirtzman. And what I would like
- 1:37:28to see in a tery Metallist, because I do think he is a good
- 1:37:31writer, a talented writer. I would like to see his version of Star
- 1:37:35Trek without them involved. What he can do when he's got absolute freedom to
- 1:37:43make his own show and he can refer back to Old Trek because Old Trek
- 1:37:50once again is the Trek if you like. As far as we're concert echnically
- 1:37:58speaking, that, I'd like to say, I'm more concerned about saying Star
- 1:38:02Trek legacy, while Cutzman it's still got any position of power. I hear
- 1:38:10you. I want to point out this person asking a legitimate question. I
- 1:38:14absolutely want us to address. This goes by not my name. Let me
- 1:38:17ask, what are you guys wanting? Do you want these shows to be
- 1:38:21in the same tone as a really bad nineteen sixties series. I will answer,
- 1:38:25and I will answer, Okay, no, we don't. What we
- 1:38:29want, as we've been describing, is what the sixties showed absolutely has Wartz.
- 1:38:33However, they did also present interesting intellectual subjects that were worthy of debate
- 1:38:43on both sides. We're not getting that from new Star Trek. We're getting
- 1:38:47very simpleton science fiction with a lot of heavy romance and trauma drama disguised as
- 1:38:56Star Trek. I would point not to the sixties, but the success of
- 1:39:00the eighties and nineties the Rick bermaner of Star Trek that introduced complicated issues,
- 1:39:06gave us both sides and let the audience decide for themselves the examples earlier in
- 1:39:12the show, and you might not have seen him, not in my name,
- 1:39:15but exactly like the example that Ed made of us TNG season one with
- 1:39:19the drug dependent Society and piccard intervening my examples that I gave of two Vix
- 1:39:28and Cojenitor in Enterprise and in Voyager, where this is a complicated issue,
- 1:39:34and again we're not seeing that. We're seeing very simple Oh it's phenomenal,
- 1:39:40it's an anomaly. Oh it's we can't communicate with this group. Well,
- 1:39:44let's try and communicate. And I'm not saying that there weren't episodes like that
- 1:39:46of previous iterations of Star Trek. But what is missing are those measure the
- 1:39:51measure of a man. Comparing Piccard Season one to what we got in the
- 1:39:56Measure of a man is such an insult to that original Melissa's Nigres story.
- 1:40:00There really was like, well, then it is a machine, but then
- 1:40:03again it is a sentient. So what do we do about this? I
- 1:40:06mean, and really making it this very interesting to be ed your thoughts of
- 1:40:11what do we want? I think the question is slightly unfair because there's a
- 1:40:15presumption in the question that by virtue of tsben a sixties show it's somehow absurd
- 1:40:24and ridiculous and can't be replicated tonally and so on. And in some respects
- 1:40:30that's true in the sense that you wouldn't want Strange New Worlds to be a
- 1:40:35show where you know, women had no agency in that they were shot in
- 1:40:41soft focus and there was you know, the light was on the eyes and
- 1:40:45all the rest of it that would obviously for a modern audience be off.
- 1:40:49But Star Trek isn't like a lot of sixties TV shows. This is the
- 1:40:56thing I mean, like, I think you can say that a comparison with
- 1:41:00something light Lost in Space is instructive because Star Trek is a lot more of
- 1:41:06an idea show. It's a lot more cerebral. It's just got a lot
- 1:41:12more to say. That's why it has endured. It did something like Lost
- 1:41:15in Space has not endured right in the same rights. It's a sci fi,
- 1:41:20silly show that didn't going to be anything else. Star Trek is different,
- 1:41:26and that that doesn't mean that Star Trek the original series doesn't have silly
- 1:41:30moments. I mean you can laugh out loud when Kirk is slapping himself in
- 1:41:33the face, for example, and things like that. But okay, but
- 1:41:38we love all of that. That yeah, Yeah, Shatner's performance is part
- 1:41:44of what makes Star Trek so wonderful, of course, and that's why it's
- 1:41:47missed when the character is reinvented. But what do we want. We want
- 1:41:54a show that is has visual continuity with Coos, so it's a credible prequel,
- 1:42:00so you can imagine the two marrying up. It's possible, like the
- 1:42:05prelude to Acts and Alf for example, showed how it could be done.
- 1:42:10Agreed that it was possible to make a show that has more production values and
- 1:42:15visual effects but still fits into that world and still feels futuristic still feel of
- 1:42:23a different place and time. Okay, it's not much of a mental adjustment
- 1:42:27to make, you know, you just have to accept. As many people
- 1:42:30have pointed out that Star Trek is an alternate history of the future, our
- 1:42:35future. But if you understand that, then you don't have a you don't
- 1:42:41feel this need. But Alex Kurtzman and so don't understand this. That's why
- 1:42:45everything has got to look up to date, a modern than all the rest
- 1:42:48of it. Actually, they've sort of made it into a kind of a
- 1:42:54weird sort of homage to sort of sixties architecture or whatever, which doesn't quite
- 1:43:00fuck me, you know, it doesn't quite worry anyway. So what do
- 1:43:04we want? I would, you know, what the visual continuity aside,
- 1:43:09which is a problem. I would settle for a show that honored the original
- 1:43:14series commitment to telling intelligent, thought provoking stories, sci fi allegories and so
- 1:43:24on. Yes, that looked at the issues in our world in a way
- 1:43:30that was not too didactic and not too literal, which is a problem that
- 1:43:34New Trek has agreed that it doesn't know how to do subtlety. It doesn't
- 1:43:40know how to allegory. It doesn't. It can't. It can't do it,
- 1:43:45can't do allegory properly. They don't. Then the writers just don't know
- 1:43:48how to write those sorts of shows. So look, we're stuck with a
- 1:43:54show that doesn't look like Star Trek, but it could still feel like Stuff
- 1:44:00Track. If the people, if you fired all of the riders and got
- 1:44:03people they knew understood Star Trek and and understood the great inheritance that they're taking
- 1:44:11on and the enormous amount of material that is this. If they're stopped for
- 1:44:15inspiration, man, they've got plenty to draw upon, like hundreds of novels,
- 1:44:20dozens of comic book stories, and again with the vetting that you get
- 1:44:28now in Star Wars, although they have their own problems. But yeah,
- 1:44:30I am with you on that that it's like, all right, you can
- 1:44:32do it, but you can't do b and this is why, and there
- 1:44:36is nothing like that and and honestly, not my name you've said, okay,
- 1:44:40thanks, I jumped in laying the stream personally, not a big fan
- 1:44:43of New Track either, thanks to the clarification, got it and I don't
- 1:44:47want it because again it's not really I think not my name is asking a
- 1:44:50legitimate question that comes up on my own Patreon, where fans are like,
- 1:44:56well, what do you want? Exactly? So I'm glad to have this
- 1:44:58opportunity. He's asking the question that Alex Kurtzman was probably asked back in twenty
- 1:45:03seventeen, what do you want? Alex? Do you want to show that
- 1:45:06looks like a shot fifty year old TV? Yeah? Of money? But
- 1:45:12you know it would never have occurred to Kurtzman, particularly after the two thousand
- 1:45:15and nine movie, that you could make a show that was retro. I
- 1:45:20agree with that. Yeah, but well Enterprise did it? You know they
- 1:45:26do the are two parter and it looks like the original series. I mean
- 1:45:30it, Like you said, an accent are the fan film prelude to accent
- 1:45:34are for people who may not know it can be done. I'm assuming that
- 1:45:38if you're a Trek fan you probably know pro prelude accent are No, it
- 1:45:41can be done. I'm most of acton are wonder I don't I don't think
- 1:45:47so? Again, well we ever see those new fifteen minutes? You know
- 1:45:51I gotta be honest, man, I can of worms, isn't it?
- 1:45:55I mean yeah? And I will even say I contributed to the the initial
- 1:45:59kick starter and uh yeah, where your money's gone? Well, I got
- 1:46:04a bunch of patches and a blu ray of prelude acts and are okay?
- 1:46:10But what was going to come next? And we're still waiting. And I
- 1:46:14have many friends, including Rob that were a part of that production that no
- 1:46:17longer are and even some subsequent people that were involved. What are you gonna
- 1:46:21do? Man? I mean, it is what it is. Oh.
- 1:46:24Langley also says that trials and Tribulations clearly match the old continuity in a very
- 1:46:29positive way. That is a textbook example of how you do it when you
- 1:46:34have respect and reverence what's come before. I have to admit I am less
- 1:46:40inclined to knock on there that the current product, even though it takes place
- 1:46:45supposedly in the in the past, doesn't match up. And I agree with
- 1:46:48you that could have been done and should have been done. But I'm less
- 1:46:51about that as I am about the characterization and the storylines lacking in intellectual debate,
- 1:47:00smart science fiction, deep characterization. Uh the as you as we both
- 1:47:04say, they're leaning on modern parlance as they do. It's it's not it's
- 1:47:12it's too simple, it's too easy, and I'm sorry. Star Trek has
- 1:47:16for over fifty five years, challenged us and asked us to think about the
- 1:47:23ideas that they're putting forward, even going back to the sixties. Let us
- 1:47:28like it, don't you You want to like Strike one? As uh someone
- 1:47:31else said in the in the talk here said it. We love we want
- 1:47:38to love New Trek. We really do. It's the truth. I mean,
- 1:47:41and I and truly every week I have the opinion of, well,
- 1:47:45maybe I'll like next week's episode. But and that's why truly crossover. The
- 1:47:49crossover was okay. I mean, it wasn't great, and I sold my
- 1:47:54little quibbles about it. And I'm sure I'm looking forward to reading your review
- 1:47:57and when we're done it, and also I hope you liked it. You
- 1:48:00might not look forward to it so much. Well no, no, I
- 1:48:02mean no, no, no, I mean it was all right. It
- 1:48:05was completely let's briefly touch on it. Yeah. Please, it was lighthearted,
- 1:48:13it's fun. You could say, yeah, it was okay. Yeah.
- 1:48:16The main problem is and this is what I said summer. It's just
- 1:48:20paraphrase my review to summarize my review. What I said was that it lays
- 1:48:27bare the problem with Strange New Worlds, which is Strange New Worlds is itself
- 1:48:30a cartoon. That's there's if you haven't seen Those Old Scientists yet, I
- 1:48:38won't spoil it, but there is a scene at the end that will make
- 1:48:42you think about tone and about the show itself and whether it's as incongruous as
- 1:48:48you imagine the writers think it is. That's all we'll say until you've seen
- 1:48:55it. Okay, fair enough, I mean again, I know it just
- 1:48:58came out last night. Those two shows, Strange New Worlds and Lower Decks.
- 1:49:03When you see on paper that they're going to do a crossover, you
- 1:49:06think, how would that work? Now they make it work by not dwelling
- 1:49:13too much on the fact that one is animated the other isn't. But yeah,
- 1:49:16there are a few sort of in jokes about that, about you know,
- 1:49:21feeling you'll look more realistic, blah blah blah ah this stuff. But
- 1:49:27the real reason if it works, and I suppose it does work superficially,
- 1:49:30if it does work, it's because those shows are closer in tone than they
- 1:49:35should be. Agreed well, certainly this season, certainly this season. So
- 1:49:42they've done it at the right time. They've done it at a point where
- 1:49:45Kiva Goldsman has thrown his hands up and he said, fuck it. Let's
- 1:49:48just I don't and why are we pretending that we're a serious drama series.
- 1:49:54Look, we had a fun kids, let's have fun, and it marks
- 1:49:58it marks us all old fans that appreciated the drama aspect and the action adventure
- 1:50:03of Star Trek. You know, and I will say, um, we
- 1:50:08got a slightly interesting Orion B plot last night in the crossover. I wish
- 1:50:15we had more of it. And again it was very basic and there's nothing
- 1:50:19wrong with what they did with this Orion B plot, but it and it
- 1:50:24served the episode fine. And again I didn't mind. I mean they told
- 1:50:29us that that night. You wish that they had started with that idea and
- 1:50:33spun that into an episode, right, agreed. God, David McKay is
- 1:50:36like, those old Senses is out already. Yes, it was a shock
- 1:50:41to everybody, but they in a surprise they dropped it last night Saturday night
- 1:50:45for people who might be listening on audio when I put this out as an
- 1:50:48audio and didn't know, So yeah, you don't have to wait till this
- 1:50:51coming Thursday for this Those old Scientists crossover episode. It is out on Paramount
- 1:50:58Press. They showed it a couple hours earlier at San Diego Comicon, and
- 1:51:02as I was saying that off the air before we started, I have a
- 1:51:06feeling that the studios in general have finally wised up with social media and everything
- 1:51:12else that don't hold this stuff for the general fans or hold it back from
- 1:51:15them, because I always felt with Doctor Who, when a new season would
- 1:51:19start, the Brits would get it first, and sometimes it would be months
- 1:51:23before the Americans got it, and so that all that did you have that
- 1:51:27problem anymore? From now? All the Humians that we're in America were pirrating
- 1:51:30the show and nobody wants that. And finally a year or two ago they
- 1:51:35realized, all right, or maybe a little longer, COVID screws up my
- 1:51:39timeline, but it's like, okay, internationally, it's all going to come
- 1:51:43out on the same day. Depending where you are in the world. It
- 1:51:45might be six hours ahead for the Brits than it is for us over here
- 1:51:50in the States. That's fine, but you don't have to pirate it.
- 1:51:54It'll be there same day. And that's why I'm really glad they did this
- 1:51:59and put it out last night. Um yeah, so oh that's funny,
- 1:52:02David says, his evening plans are sorted out. Absolutely there, man,
- 1:52:05No, it's and again really as as as toughest critics as we both are
- 1:52:12on New Trek and everything. Like I mean, I liked it enough.
- 1:52:15I like I said, I am my little quibbles. It was relatively inoffensive.
- 1:52:19There were a few things in it. There were some there was some
- 1:52:23stuff in it that was quite interesting. Yes, I guess you know.
- 1:52:28Both shows very gently and affectionately critiqued each other, which I didn't expect to
- 1:52:33happen. I thought that that was interesting. So there's a little bit more
- 1:52:38going on than nothing, which is what I expected. I expected nothing and
- 1:52:42I got something. And I'll take that on this show. I so hear
- 1:52:45you. Man, we could wrap up right there, my dad. We're
- 1:52:47almost in two hours then, and I feel like I'm keeping you from your
- 1:52:50evening. So I've enjoyed it, John, Thank you very much. At
- 1:52:55anytime, man, seriously expect a future perhaps at the end of the season.
- 1:53:00Uh, let's meet up, let's talk about it. Indeed, let's
- 1:53:03make that happen. Man, all right, everybody again, you can see
- 1:53:05right now on the banner. And I was saying this for the audio audience.
- 1:53:09Read Ed review Reed's reviews at Ed Whitfield. That's w H I T
- 1:53:15F I E L D dot WordPress dot com. And Ed also has his
- 1:53:21YouTube channel which is uh at doctor mackel Void and that's n A C C
- 1:53:29L E v O. I D always up to spell slowly because I'll screw
- 1:53:33it up otherwise. Yea, so Ed, truly great conversation, man,
- 1:53:38I really I really enjoyed this. Thank you already enjoyed it well. And
- 1:53:42I and I certainly I suspect as your more of your reviews come out,
- 1:53:48I'm betting Rob is going to probably tap you. A good friend of mine
- 1:53:51mine in Rob's John Price. We really appreciated his essays as well on Medium,
- 1:53:58and John is another I think clearheaded objective critic because actually he's even like
- 1:54:03more episodes this season than than we have. But whatever, I mean,
- 1:54:09God, blessing then for finding entertainment and what we always say, don't we
- 1:54:15that if you like, if you really love something great or powerty fantastic,
- 1:54:18we're not. I'm I'm yeah, I'm a miserable combudgeon. Lee Old bastard.
- 1:54:25If we don't have to, please don't feel that, you know,
- 1:54:29I'm I'm, as we say in England, pissing on your chips. World
- 1:54:34you love lower Decks, yeah, go go great, but you know set
- 1:54:41that there is a a difference of opinion, some views may differ. I
- 1:54:48think that's healthy and it keeps us all talking. And look, as we
- 1:54:53said at the top of the show, John, we only criticize it because
- 1:54:55we love it, indeed, and we're hoping for good Star Trek, that's
- 1:54:58what we want. But also, like like Ed said, if you're enjoying
- 1:55:01this fantastic ignore us. It's all right, you don't worry about it.
- 1:55:08But hey, you know something I want to give threats please. Yeah,
- 1:55:13that's that's where we draw the line. Um Niche from Terrificon, who is
- 1:55:16another co host of mine when it comes to Star Trek will be along later
- 1:55:20tonight to give his views of the horror episode and um the strange the Lower
- 1:55:27Deck crossover. So that's happening at I'm trying to do the math. That's
- 1:55:30at nine Eastern, eighth Central here and and six specific if you again,
- 1:55:38hitting all the American time zones. So that's coming up later on. If
- 1:55:41you're not sick of hearing this already, believe me. There's more to come
- 1:55:44tonight, but no thank you, ed, thank you everybody for watching.
- 1:55:47Until next time, Please stay safe, stay happy, stay healthy in bo