Latest / Construction Technology Podcast / Construction Technology Podcast - Episode 011
Transcript
- Luigi La Corte: everyone. Welcome to construction technology podcast. I'm Luigi CEO at provision. I'm joined by, my two fabulous co-hosts, Andrew from join and Mike from build vision. Gentlemen, how are you? Mike Powers: What's up? Happy Friday. Luigi La Corte: Friday. Okay, the first topic is kick us off. Mike Powers: Yeah, yeah. So our friends over at Bricks and Bytes had Joe on from A16Z this week after he posted an article, I think everyone's read, around the AEC world operating and building buildings and software designed in 1997. So the perspectives that he brings up, there's obviously good points, but like, I think it misses the focal point of the value creation chain that's in the ASE space. Their critique of ASE software has fractal problems, but the real issues is that it's economic. And the short run, AI can help engineering firms capture value from engineering labor or from engineer labor to software value to revenue. But in the long run, the ⁓ productivity flow to the owner. And at no point does the engineering firm itself come out ahead. So like the same pie on a job gets sliced up differently. And this like visual is very like eye opening of like how the market is, how software companies are going to market, how the actual general contractor, subcontractor, AE firms are going to market. And the core and pushback that I would have is like, Like in simple math, like let's say we have a dollar, dollar construction spend for a commercial project. Roughly eight to cents or eight to 10 % of that is architect and services. Let's say 9 % and then around 3 % of that ⁓ is, 3 % the 9 % is actual tech spend. So that AEC software industry that the A16Z report is referencing is. companies like Autodesk, Procore, Nimicheck, completely missed Bentley, which is a billion dollar revenue company, is interesting. And every like AI native entrant into this market is kind of fighting over that really like 27 of a percent of every construction ⁓ dollar just for AC side. This is not construction side. This is not that side. So that's one data point. And then see, you know, Autodesk revenue has been growing 20 % year over year. Revit inside of Autodesk revenue structure is not $3 billion. Autodesk revenue for AEOC, is Revit, BIM 360, Forma, Pipe, all the consolidated companies is 3 % or sorry, 3 billion. So you'd assume maybe like 1 billion of that is Revit. So like software is growing at least four times faster than the industry sells into. The gap has to close somewhere. And because owners set AE fees, it closes like the fee structures that AE firms actually build. And the only way AEs can then increase their revenue is reducing labor cost. Because the owner is not going to increase their fee. They're not going to pay 12 % for design services as opposed to 10 % just because a customer is using AI. So like in the short run software vendors capture value from engineering labor and the longer the fee compression passes the productivity gains to owners on the next contract cycle. The engineering is squeezed on both ends and never catches the upside. So like the real value creation is what we just were talking about before is like schedule rework, like ⁓ operations and maintenance, like building performance, procurement, is like focusing on that other 91 cents. So was just interesting. Again, like overall NetNet, I think that the article misses the perspective. to that point, like, all right, you have $3 billion of AE tech spend right now. The majority of the already that concentrated in tooling that is embedded and taught in grade school, you've learned Revit in college as an engineer. to replace that $3 billion because it's not growing while Autodesk revenue is growing seems like an insurmountable mountain to climb. And I would completely push back that there's that much value to be created in the AE space specifically around software outside of the big foundation of players. Construction as a whole is completely different. I know us three are all in the construction side, but that was my biggest takeaway from that argument that I think it completely misses the point on where to allocate venture capital dollars in the AC space. Luigi La Corte: Well, if you're looking, if you're only looking at software spend, maybe the answer is yes. if you're looking at labor, the answer is no. Andrew Zukoski: you Mike Powers: So yeah, so the pushback on that is like like that thing goes to like, you're already seeing like the like, the late like, so you look at like, the the big engineering firms are growing revenue, but their margins not increasing. So WSP, HKS, StamTac are all publicly traded. So you can see that information and they what they've been doing is they've been acqui hiring companies to build that revenue, but their margins not increasing. So there's been no actual report of reduction in labor across any of this tooling. And then at the end of the day, at the end of the day, like you still have to have an engineer stamp it. You still have the insurance process and the litigation and the quality control process owned. So it's not a five to 10 X improvement. Maybe it's a two X improvement, but that's still not venture return value. When Autodesk, I think the biggest pushback is like construction's growing, whatever it is, three to 5 % a year. Autodesk revenue is growing 20 % a year. Bentley revenue is growing 20 % a year. revenue is growing 20 % a year. So you're seeing those, that continue to eat into that 33 % of an AE firm while trying to reduce the labor. And if labor only is increased, say you can do two times as many projects, I think those other lines catch up faster than opportunity to create another billion dollar revenue company. I'm not saying that there's not opportunities for 10, 20 million dollar a year revenue companies. It's the other billion dollar company. Luigi La Corte: Good. Right. Mike Powers: that needs to be successful, needs to be IPOable. Luigi La Corte: So three things come to mind. One, you're assuming that that growth is coming from the Revit side when it's probably coming from the construction side. And so I think that's the number, maybe that's part of the issue. But do you know? Mike Powers: It's not though. Having insider information on how Autodesk sells, increase the token price of Revit every year. And that's where the revenue growth has come from. Luigi La Corte: Okay. So 20 % growth is coming on the Revit side. And so then you're saying if they're passing that, that cost is, is effectively a past, ⁓ it's not past there. So then you're eroding the fee for a first. That's what you're saying. Okay. Well, Mike Powers: Correct, correct, yes. And we're seeing that. So you're seeing these articles probably five years ago, a group of in the EU wrote an article about just like this increased tech fee with no value. Because the whole business model of how Autodesk is successful is like, you're going into Chuck E. Cheese and you got a bucket of quarters and machine at Chuck E. Cheese or the arcade. is a different tool and Autodesk tool, but so you have Revit, you have Vim 360, you have Building Connected, you have Pipe, and each one of those per day costs a different amount of tokens. So I go in and then every year, every EBA renewal or enterprise business agreement rule, the cost per machine goes up. And that's where there's friction in the market. again, like without, and because they have such a, it's just the same thing on Bentley, it's the same thing on Nimichek, it's the same thing on like all these other AEC tools. It's fascinating. I'm not saying there's a clear answer, but I just like don't know how that that fix it, how that model fixes. Luigi La Corte: I don't like I don't know any structural reason why similar to legal, you can't massively reduce the cost of your labor. mean, everyone's thesis and venture capital right now is like A's coming for services and labor. And again, there's nothing that says that this can't be done similar to legal, you still want somebody who's going to be you know, who's past the bar, somebody who has, you know, you don't want to have counterparty risk, you want to be able to sue them if they do a bad job, similarly in construction, or at least in architecture engineering, you want them to be a licensed accredited. You want them to stand behind their work. You know, want to be able to go after their seal if they do a bad job. This is a company out of my, ⁓ my lead investors portfolio, Cedar build. ⁓ do you know them? So they, they, basically have just taken, ⁓ a cookie cutter approach to architectural projects and only do one type of project. ⁓ I believe it's, ⁓ it's, it's mid rise commercial. So let me go back here. The service offering is we are basically going to do a. Andrew Zukoski: Nice. Luigi La Corte: They only work in Texas and all they're going to do is help you get permit approval for, I believe it's residential. Yeah. So, so a multifamily residential, that's all they do. You can see this stacking on various types of projects though. Right. So they'll AI enable the site review, they'll AI enable the preliminary design, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, until they squeeze every dollar out of that labor as much as possible. If you do this across many asset types and you do this across many configurations, I don't see why this can't be venture scale. Andrew Zukoski: This could be the software tools that sell into this much more, much more questionable. And it's going to be very difficult for Arc it for existing A and E firms to make the leap to this sort of business model. Like they're all it's it's. Mike Powers: This is different, yeah. Luigi La Corte: But this is a thought virtual. This is a software tool. This is a software tool. Everything that's in the back end are tools. And you could have them plug and play. Mike Powers: But so. But so in this example, like WSP with their 10,000 employees is not rolling out this tool across the organization to get to 5,000 employees. Luigi La Corte: No, they probably won't very quickly. But if someone's gaining market share in a segment that they're participating in, they might have to. It's the same, it's exact same conversation and illegal. And I'm not debating that it's going to be easy. I don't know. I don't think that's the case. But it's possible that with efficiency gains, let's say through permitting reduction in costs, let's say through expedited permitting. the reduction in costs, let's say through reduced regulation, maybe there's more competition in construction because they're more profitable. There could be a surge in demand for projects, which could mean like that, that, that case is still possible. And I'll take, I'll take the opposite side of this conversation. I don't know if it's necessarily doom and gloom, but they definitely need to invest in labor replacement and productivity. And they have to hope that there's a surge in demand. Mike Powers: I say, it's fun. It's like the macro lens of that is, will the surge in demand come? And we're seeing like three to 5 % growth in construction annually right now. ⁓ I would say 10 % of that growth is data centers and negative 5 % of that growth is everything else. So the net out is 5 % growth year over year. So now you're in this pie, like you're grabbing a portion. You're grabbing a slice of pie that's shrinking in example. Andrew Zukoski: I mean, AIA billing indexes, have they crossed 50 in the last three years? Like, they're down and down and down. The AIA, in partnership with Dell Tech, I got it, I'll pull it up here. They... Luigi La Corte: What's this? What's this, Andrew? Mike Powers: Yeah. American Institute of. Andrew Zukoski: They do a billing index ⁓ where they survey a bunch of firms, large firms and small firms. I haven't signed in to have access, but it's like asking, are you billing more or less than you were in the last reporting period? I believe it was like the key one. like, like this is the headline. It approaches growth. And I don't think it's, I don't think it's been above, I don't remember the last time it was above 50. Luigi La Corte: So sorry, that's if it was above 15. Andrew Zukoski: If it's at 100, everybody is growing. If it's at zero, everybody is shrinking. If it's at 50, I believe, you you're about flat. And I think it's dollar weighted. I think it's dollar weighted, but I couldn't say. If it's below 50, people aren't growing. Luigi La Corte: soon. Mike Powers: everyone's losing, yeah. Luigi La Corte: And this is just perf firm, not weighted by some of the model. What do you take from this? So like one out of two firms are not growing the revenue. So basically half of the industry is flat. Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, at this point it's flat. When it hangs out at 40 for ⁓ two years against a backdrop of, over that time, 10 % 15 % growth in the construction industry overall, you have to say that the pie is growing, but the slice that is going to these fees is shrinking. ⁓ Mike Powers: every day world. Andrew Zukoski: I don't know how you're going convince, I don't know how you're going to extract enough blood from the stone to support the next billion dollar UC technology company. I mean we started in this, we started in this industry actually. started, first products all went to market with A &E's and it's tough. Like these firms are, firms are set up as, like law firms, you hire a of junior people, you work them really hard, you bill hourly. Like you advance by making partner and bringing in work and having client relationships, not by improving the firm overall. It's like very difficult inside of an A &E firm to compound like value creation. It like, it literally walks out the door every day. Like there would be all these like famous international firms who would turn out there was the one guy who was really good at something. And when he would leave, the whole firm would get worse at that and they would never get better at it again. Like. which is like right in a software company that's insane, right? Like we would have taken that knowledge and like turned it into a software artifact and like, ⁓ yeah, I mean someone left, but like we can keep running all the code. Like the database still works. ⁓ So, I mean, I agree. I think Revit has like a deep, deep mode. The mode is not the technology. The mode is ⁓ the training. that's happened around it in the distribution that exists into the market, that like everybody learned it in grade school and knows it because the fundamental task is very complicated and there's not a ton of budget and I think all the BIM 2.0 companies should be selling to contractors instead of any firms. Luigi La Corte: Thank you, and I'll just do this. Mike Powers: It's fascinating. Yeah, so I pulled together this and I'll share this after. So this was my deep, my deep collage design work. ⁓ So this is getting back to that 27 basis points that we chatted about earlier, like that structure down from the AEs fee being 9 % to the tech fee of the AEs fee being 3%, which is 26 basis points. think the miss here is this is really just AE not C. ⁓ so every dollar of construction spent, sorry, every, every, ⁓ dollar spent on construction, ⁓ point two, 27 basis points hits tech spend. ⁓ this entire pie is like where Autodesk Bentley Procore Nemechek and these other tools are entering. ⁓ so to take the Steelman AE16Z position, like there's obviously capacity constraints in the MVP space for data centers. where this is where you're seeing companies like Jacob just own the entire process. So Jacob's is a massive data center designer builder procurer, APC. ⁓ Their three vector framework is compelling. This is like replacing Revit spend, net new softwares or providing additional services. ⁓ And the problem, this is where it breaks down, which I think is very, interesting is like growth is only construction growth is this five, three to 5 % that we talked about. Autodesk growth is 20%. That's the same with Bentley. So there's like this ratio of revenue growing into this already small. The revenue growth of Autodesk, these big entrenched players is four times larger than the growth of the industry. Andrew Zukoski: What's the... so, but, ⁓ you know, A16Z probably also has blog posts talking about how low technology penetration is into AEC relative to... Mike Powers: I don't know where the money comes from. So if you look at this, so this is where like, right, like, hey, like here's the breakdown. This ⁓ is the Dell ⁓ tech report that pulls out like where the P &L is for an AE firm. So like you're living in this tech software spend. ⁓ I would say out of the gate, know, points of that are already Microsoft. which will not be replaced, that's you're like, hey, I run my business on this. So take a half line and say, like, where does that 3 %? So that 3 % of the 9 % that we talked about, the 27 bips, how does that get, does that ever grow to 10%, 5 %? And the positioning here is that the only value for an AE firm to become more profitable would be to reduce the labor headcount reduction because if the prop like you're not gonna reduce profit, partners aren't gonna do that. You're not gonna be able to increase fees to owners. So you kind of lay in this labor bucket and then what does that do over time? ⁓ It's interesting. Andrew Zukoski: mean, we saw this with Revit. There was like a brief and shining moment when Revit rolled out where ⁓ project teams expected a certain number of drawings for a project and it became radically easier to generate them and smart firms were able to make a ton of money and then everyone else caught up and now we have huge stacks of drawings and nobody is any more profitable. It's interesting. Do you guys know the case story? There have been like, there are these, I mean, our architecture is big industry. There are a lot of diversified firms over time. And so there have been a lot of experiments and they're very successful. case was an architectural design firm. was very technology forward. Got started the early 2000s. Everybody knew how to code. They had software engineers on staff, like very serious software engineers. And they formed a partnership with WeWork. where they offered WeWork flat fee pricing. was dollars per square foot design done. And WeWork loved this because they predictable pricing. They wanted to be able to go fast. And ⁓ it worked for Case because it meant they now had a business structure where they were able to. They were able to compound and capture the value of efficiency, right? They didn't have to move the bar on the perfy structure. were pricing much closer to WeWork's outcome than to their cost basis. And yeah, it worked great. mean, eventually, WeWork bought case and it formed the nucleus ⁓ ⁓ AEC technology group that now has spawned quite number of these BIM 2.0 companies themselves. But yeah, when it's done, it can work great. Mike Powers: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Luigi La Corte: So what do we think the future of these BIM 2.0 tools are? I know it's hard to make a generalization. And then the opposite side of that question, if you're a AE firm, what do you do to expand your share of the pie? Andrew Zukoski: I I I hope the BIM 2.0 companies spend a lot more time with contractors. I think that they are the agent of change and adaption inside the industry right now. I think that they are better poised to deliver the only outcome that actually matters in the industry, which is like an owner getting a building. And I think they have needs that are different from any needs and that that can provide a wedge where you can go in and... win in a really compelling way versus Revit. And if you fast forward 10 years, there will be a lot more seats, ⁓ inside GC firms than outside of it, you ask me. Mike Powers: And then I'll take the other side of that. think the, do AE firms turn? A good example of this is a company called Taylor engineers ⁓ outside of, ⁓ they're California. Fun correlation is ⁓ the owner of this Taylor, the owner, his son is Brett Taylor, ⁓ the chairman the board of OpenAI. ⁓ Andrew Zukoski: The famous HBO Silicon Valley producer? Mike Powers: and founder of company called Sierra. But anyways, what's interesting about what Taylor engineers has done and scaled is about 10 years ago, developed a very, he has an A-H-R, A-S-H-R ⁓ blog post about this, which is like the American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Engineering. ⁓ He saw his fee structures go down. He was dealing with big clients like Metta, and he started to procure the equipment. the mechanical systems for the project. So going back to that thesis of, hey, you know, we have a $1 building, cents of that $1 building goes to the structural fee for the A.E. firms. The mechanical portion of that is smaller. He looked at, well, 10 to 15 % of that $1 is the mechanical electrical equipment. Can I efficiently procure that better? Him being the engineer of record understands the systems better than a mechanical subcontractor or a general contractor could. So his bet is that he could and he did, and it becomes an additional profit stream for him as a business. Again, he's not going after his 9 % AE normal fee. He's attacking revenue and profit from a different spectrum of that dollar fee structure of a project. Andrew Zukoski: This is the like, EPC, like, do EPC, but in more scopes and in more projects that maybe didn't have, take on more and more of the scope, yeah. Mike Powers: correct. And the mere... Go ahead. Luigi La Corte: So you're really hoping for a, sorry, last point on that. think you're really hoping for a, like a ⁓ surge in demand tailwind or else you have to really go the kind of integration route to your point on both Jacobs and Taylor. This is like the last data point here. I just had Claude spin up a permit applications versus architecture firms and estimating firms in New York state. I mean, the only really enlightening thing here is that you can infer that around 2020 ZERP era interest rates go really low, permit applications go up, which is great. Mike Powers: Yeah. COVID. Luigi La Corte: And actually surprisingly, there's a decent amount more architecture than just the main. actually expected this summer to be quite flat. Like I thought it would be, you're right. No, but you exactly right before this is firms, not headcount, but ⁓ there are basically no barrier to entry. You just bring like, you just bring over your experience from your previous firm. ⁓ And so I think any, any increase in permitting that we experienced from like low interest rates environments. Andrew Zukoski: always super fragmented. Luigi La Corte: have basically just gone away because more firms have been spun up. Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, okay, I'll give another way to expand the business. Like capturing more, integrating more of the offering is one way to do it. The other way would be to go upstream and capture more of the equity value of what is being designed. ⁓ What? So, building, your developer, call it multifamily, could be anything like. Mike Powers: Unpack that. Unpack that. Yeah. Andrew Zukoski: works really well, it's going to drive a lot of profit to the developer. you trade, and firms do this with people that they trust, like on a case by case basis, right? If you trade fee today for equity in the project, where you get attached to the equity outcome, which is usually future dated, like that's ⁓ very to owners, right? Because it means that you're risk aligned and it means that they don't have to pay you right now. And so I don't know that I know every way that you might do this, but if you can say, okay we can I don't know if it solves the problem in the long run, but drive down our fee initially and what I'll do is I'll say look I'm not gonna offer you a 20 % better fee I'm gonna offer you an 80 % price reduction now but I get 2 % of the gross on the back end of the project or upon completion we can do this and because my cost structure now emphasizes technology investment rather than like payroll that has to go out the door every day like I can make that you know I can make that trade and I can align with a longer-term outcome like that would be one way Mike Powers: Hmm. It's very similar to what M &A lawyers do. Or an IPO lawyer, if you take a company public, I'm not, hey, we might charge a hold fee of 50K, but I'm getting a percent of the IPO. Interesting. Do you think there's enough... Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Mike Powers: risk adverse aversion in the world to do that. Luigi La Corte: risk loving this. Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, people do this. I've talked to people who do this. It tends to be with like, it's like the third project we do and it's like, all right, we'll plug half our fee into the equity stack. The other way would be. Mike Powers: Cool. But that has to be like in the, like ⁓ residential that has an IRR, not the hospital system, right? The design of the hospital system, you're not getting equity in the hospital system. Of like San Francisco General or whatever, right? Yeah, so it's more of like where the, ⁓ ones that are probably more debt finance that are getting IRRs, yeah. ⁓ Andrew Zukoski: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. has to. I don't know how you do it with institutional ones. Institutional ones, like, would we do this? Yeah. Yeah, inside of institutional, I don't know why they would do that. They're going to Mike Powers: Yeah, yeah. Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, the risk aversion is a good question. Either way, though, you're taking on new risk. You need to expand the scope of your services. Sounds like often to include messy physical things. Or you need to expand the scope of the business risk that you take. And even more so than other segments of this industry, the A &E segment has worked really hard to avoid that sort of risk. Mike Powers: Yeah. Interest. That's fascinating. Do you guys want to chat through more of our side, the GC side, the sub side of how there's correlations here into like what GCs are doing? I this other fun graph that I've been losing sleep over on. I had like 13 Claude going last night. This was aggressive. ⁓ So like, this is the same dynamic on the other side, ⁓ I think is like tied to like, AE might be a little behind the curve ⁓ this shift. ⁓ So this is ⁓ Turner. Turner has seven ancillary ⁓ product businesses over last 25 years. ⁓ Net out. these, where's my numbers? think these ancillaries are, it's hard to get the numbers out because Turner is buried under Haktif, which is buried under ACS Grupo. ⁓ But the EBITDA on these seven, I think is two to three times higher than the EBITDA on ⁓ their CMFee. So this interesting perspective is, If CM fee is just the cost of customer acquisition, here's where the profit center is. So as you're a general contractor or you're ⁓ someone selling into the general contractor space, if CM fee is where Procore is allocated right now or to the project, ⁓ if that fee goes down, that pie shrinks ⁓ because of CM fee reduction, how do you as a tech company tie to one of these seven pillars? I know biasly like Build Vision is on this pillar number one. But that's another thought process. Here's how a company has taken this. And you're seeing this repeated across the top 25 general contractors. I did a case study that will publish at some point where if you were to give a point for each one of these across the top 25 commercial construction companies, Turner has seven. There's three general contractors that have five. There's 10 that have four. And then the rest are kind of spread out below. ⁓ of the different services that they offer. So again, they're starting to have this shift. This becomes this powerhouse. We saw this in the defense industry in the early 50s with the consolidation of hundreds of defense contractors into the big five prime. We're seeing the same thing happen on the contractor side. Structure tone. Yeah, you're seeing this already though. Andrew Zukoski: Wait, can we make a bet about that? So how consolidated do you think it'll be? OK, guess you're saying that Heibutah is concentrating quickly. Because whenever I look at the ENR 400, I'm like, boy, it's as fragmented as it's always been. Mike Powers: I Correct. But the growth, the revenue numbers, the commercial construction in place is concentrating amongst the top contractors more than ever. And you can say that's because of data centers. But what that does is the other, but in that world, as you play that out over five years in the K-shape economy where data centers are the 10 % growth and everything else is the negative 5 % growth, where... Andrew Zukoski: Well, that is exactly what I will say. Yes. Luigi La Corte: It is dirty. It is data center. Andrew Zukoski: Yeah, but the negative five is driven by the data center demand. are only so many electricians. There are only so many construction firms. if like, ⁓ Mike Powers: I don't think, I think it's macro. That's macro. The market, macro, there's not enough commercial construction demand outside of data centers right now. Luigi La Corte: I don't know if that's true, Mike, because even if you look at other firms, okay, this is all anecdotal, but I speak to people. Andrew Zukoski: There's a lot of shit that doesn't pencil right now because of construction costs. Sorry, Luigi. I don't mean to talk over you. Luigi La Corte: No, no, no, no, no, no, I think it's fine. It adds to the conversation, but like every time I talk to a general contractor, they are busier than they've ever been. Maybe not in Canada residential, for example, but that is macro. But if I talk to a US based contractor, they've never been busier and it's commercial in general. think a lot of GCs are end up going multi-sector. And if you go multi-sector, yes, you would. And Mike, will, I will say, I don't necessarily believe that CM. Mike Powers: you Andrew Zukoski: Well, you definitely would because any single sector will end up being highly cyclical, right? Luigi La Corte: fees will be squeezed because I believe that CM is being driven mostly by branding and by the client relationship. I think if you look on, let's say like lump sum, design, bid, build, I still think that those fees are going down over and over time. you know, there's an argument about whether that procurement structure is going to work long-term given the quality of construction that you end up getting. But CM is a different beast. Mike Powers: So the pushback I'd have on CM CM the people more than the brand. ⁓ They the Luigi that built the last hospital. They don't want provision contracting. Luigi La Corte: I don't know about that. I don't know about that. think it's the process of... Yeah. Andrew Zukoski: I won. Luigi La Corte: But the way these, I know you would want, you'd get a good hospital, you get a level four. But if you have, let's say a mega hospital based firm, let's call it PCL, but does a lot of hospitals in Canada, you can't get, you can't get Luigi because Luigi is tied up on a five year, maybe six year project. You get a bunch of Luigi's that are informed by the PCL process. Like you don't have, you can't get Luigi. Luigi's already tied up on a six year job. Mike Powers: So what is, yeah. Andrew Zukoski: Every owner we talk to is like, yeah, I read the resumes and I talk to the project managers. I might not get Luigi, the king of hospital construction in Canada, but I'm going to get the senior PM who did the last two with you and is finally ready to step up and lead the project. Mike Powers: and pay him a shit ton of money to do it. So I would say the memory of an organization is tied more to the people than to the processes, specifically in that hospital example. So my first job out of college was at the Eagle Stadium in Philadelphia. Turner built the stadium in 2006 to 2010, whatever it was. And the Eagles want to do a renovation. They wanted to add more seats to actually bid on the World Cup of 2014, whatever it was. So they engaged with Turner because Turner knew the project, knew the historical project of building the Eagles stadium, knew where everything was. And the value prop was this guy named John Zawadzińak who has built seven stadiums. was his last project that he was on with Turner and then he went out and consulted and did consulting and he goes runs around and does sturdy datings across country. Turner does very good at stadiums because they have a team of stadium professionals that live inside of Turner that do those stadiums. The interesting note on that is when we bid the project, Turner bid the project, they knew where Bedrock was. I spent like a month in December digging micro piles in the lot to find Bedrock in two feet of snow because we had no idea where Bedrock was. on the renovation, which was funny. But going back to that, it's like the person, the individual, and I'm starting to talk to general contractors and they're like, hey, our employees are the best asset we have. The contractors that train and upgrade their employees will be the ones that are most successful because this technology is gonna be commoditized across the layer when it just becomes a people game. Luigi La Corte: Sure, I cannot deny that there is value in the individual experience at a general contracting firm. But let's say I'm PCL and there's a hospital that needs to be built in Ontario. They're not going to first look at the resumes. Let's say they want to solicit bids and go to RFQ. They're looking at the firm. They're saying, as a firm, how many hospitals have you built? What's your success story? Then they go to the resume. I think it really is firm first. And if you were building a hospital, If you're building a hospital in and you still had, let's say you took like three of the best hospital builders from PCL and you created a new firm, I highly doubt that an owner would take the risk with that new firm. They would go Ellis Don PCL because these are the hospital builders. Andrew Zukoski: The, okay, so what we see in the US they might not go full hospital tower with Steve's new contracting but what we see in the US is there are national contractors who compete in healthcare in multiple regions and potentially like across the country. In any given city, there are multiple, major metropolitan area, there are multiple contractors who have a track record of delivering like, any type of facility you want to say, including hospitals. And it's because owners know enough, especially as institutional owners, know that they want to keep contractors fed. Otherwise they will get screwed. If it ever gets to the world that only PCL Elaston can build hospitals in Canada, they're going to make a lot of money. And owners know that. Interesting, in the what you see is a small number of national firms that can build Luigi La Corte: That is the case. That is the case. Andrew Zukoski: hospitals sort of anywhere in the country but then in each major multi-public area there's usually a regional super builder or two who does very good work. Very excellent work. like Rudolph and Sletton. would, my, gotta a trip to Children's Hospital of Oakland yesterday and my son is fine. I'm glad to say, but, we went by this, they're building a tower right next to the old one and it's Rudolph and Sletton and they're, they're a local firm. They're a subsidiary of Tudor Perini. I think they only work in California. ⁓ and they build amazing hospitals, but they, don't bid the next hospital in Las Vegas, right? That's just, that's not their, the scope of their work, but it means that if I'm here and I'm Kaiser and I'm building the next hospital, yeah, I got my got excel and yeah, got reoff and slotted to bid it. ⁓ Luigi La Corte: It's obviously an and it's obviously an end conversations. Like what makes a really good GC firm? It's the people, it's the process, it's your bonding capacity. know, the people in the process, that's going to be your resume. But I mean, it is the case in Canada that if you want to build a new hospital, like you are going PCL LSDOM. Like the yeah, yeah, go look in Ontario, the last I'd say the last seven out of eight were done by LSDOM or PCL. ⁓ Andrew Zukoski: Okay. Man, I got a business idea to pitch you guys on. We're gonna get into hospital construction in Canada. Luigi La Corte: the easiest type. Mike Powers: Hahaha! Andrew Zukoski: Yeah. Luigi La Corte: Okay, next topic. Mike, did we have one more or was that it? We had software cost allocation, which we talked about, A16 article, permit expeditors. Andrew, you want to this one or you want to do the next one? Or the next one? Okay, you guys want to call it here? Andrew Zukoski: ass. Mike Powers: Let's do it. Andrew Zukoski: Thank you. Luigi La Corte: All right. Thank you everyone. Talk to you guys next week.