Latest / MD Longevity Lab: Playing the Long Game with Drs. Vikas and Nisha Patel / 29. The Statin You Fear vs. The Peptide You Trust: The Credibility Crisis in American Healthcare
Transcript
- 0:00There are plenty of doctors online that make this case that
- 0:03not everyone should be on a statin even when they have good
- 0:07indication to be on a statin. Let's face it, pharmaceutical
- 0:10companies are not in the business of leaving money on the
- 0:13table if these peptides worked like truly worked for fat loss,
- 0:18muscle building, anti aging. Most people are ordering these
- 0:22peptides from the black market and we know when you order
- 0:26medications or anything not cost from the black market, you have
- 0:31no idea what you're getting. You know, like when a compound
- 0:35is claimed to do everything, it should make you pretty
- 0:38suspicious that it probably does nothing in particular.
- 0:41Today, the loudest, most certain voice is usually the one selling
- 0:45something, often times a supplement or a peptide.
- 0:52Welcome to MD Longevity Lab, where we're playing the long
- 0:55game. This is a podcast where science
- 0:58meets real life, with expert insights, practical tips and
- 1:01real world tools to not only live longer, but live better.
- 1:05Our aim is to radically change the way medicine is practiced
- 1:09and enable individuals to age gracefully, maintaining health,
- 1:13span and vitality well into their later years.
- 1:16We're your host, doctor Nisha and Dr. Vikas Patel, physicians,
- 1:20partners in life and parents balancing work, Wellness and
- 1:23everything in between. Let's dive in.
- 1:25Welcome everyone back to the MD Longevity Live podcast where
- 1:29we're playing the long game. I just wanted to kind of get out
- 1:32of the way. We're doing this episode today
- 1:35about really a topic, peptides, and we got a lot of direct
- 1:40messages about this topic. Please send us anything else
- 1:44that you want to have us cover or any questions that you might
- 1:47have. We do try to reply to those
- 1:50questions directly to whoever sending them, but sometimes it
- 1:53makes sense for us to do podcast episodes and address them as
- 1:57well. So let me start off with this.
- 2:02I want you to try something the next time that you are out with
- 2:05friends or maybe in the gym locker room or and group chat
- 2:12mention statins. Just drop the word everyone has
- 2:16heard of this cholesterol lowering medication and then
- 2:20just sit back and kind of wait and watch and see what happens.
- 2:24Yeah, I'm pretty sure you're going to hear things like, oh, I
- 2:29got muscle pain when I was on it.
- 2:31Brain fog. Big pharma is paying doctors to
- 2:35keep me on this medicine. My cousin stopped taking their
- 2:38statin and felt like 1,000,000 bucks.
- 2:41Someone's uncle, someone's brother, someone's neighbor,
- 2:44someone who listened to some influencer on Instagram and
- 2:48asked them to take a supplement instead of a statin.
- 2:51Right. Every single time.
- 2:54Now, in that same conversation, mentioned peptides mentioned
- 2:58BP157 or CJC 1295. Just watch the energy completely
- 3:04shift. Suddenly everyone's an expert,
- 3:07everyone knows a guy, some of these trainers on it.
- 3:10Someone's buddy is stacking three of these peptides.
- 3:12Nobody asks at all about clinical trials.
- 3:15Nobody asks about FDA approval. The compound arrived via an
- 3:20Instagram Reel or better yet, Joe Rogan.
- 3:23And that's basically enough. And the double standard is what
- 3:26really gets me. The same person who won't take
- 3:29statins because they don't trust Big Pharma is literally
- 3:34injecting a compound into their body that has been studied in, I
- 3:40don't know, like 14 people total.
- 3:42And these peptides, it's a complete underground market.
- 3:46So most of these peptides are coming overseas and they're
- 3:51literally injecting it into their body, right?
- 3:54They wet ordered it from a website calledblackmarket.com,
- 3:58graymarket.com. They found it on Reddit threads,
- 4:01but they're experts. Every single person that I've
- 4:04talked to that are on these peptides are like, don't worry,
- 4:06I've done my own research. It's like.
- 4:08Is it blackmarket.com? I think it's graymarket.com.
- 4:12I'm not. Please don't go on there and buy
- 4:14peptides. But what I'm saying is people
- 4:17are self appointed experts and this is like the Dunning Kruger
- 4:20effect in full form. And to boot, they feel good
- 4:25because it's quote UN quote natural, right?
- 4:28Because it's natural, it must be safe.
- 4:30Natural. You know what else is natural?
- 4:33Arsenic, which is rat poison. You know what else?
- 4:37Cyanide, which by the way, occurs naturally in apples and
- 4:44cassava root. Natural is not a safety profile.
- 4:49Natural is not a dosing guideline.
- 4:52Natural does not mean you should be drawing it up in a syringe
- 4:56and injecting it into your abdomen on Tuesday morning
- 5:00before work. This kind of really gets to the
- 5:02credibility crisis in American healthcare really distilled into
- 5:08just, you know, this one single Contra contradiction.
- 5:11And it's really what we want to unpack in today's episode.
- 5:16Speaking of unpacking, I have to brag about you for a second
- 5:20because part of the reason we're doing this episode, we got so
- 5:23many questions about peptides, but then Vikas also wrote a sub
- 5:27stack article covering this very topic and it got published.
- 5:32And since then he's you've had reporters and stuff all up in
- 5:36your grill. I did.
- 5:39I did do a couple interviews. I wrote a piece for Stat News
- 5:43and it had a fair amount of interest, so yeah, so.
- 5:50I had to ask him last week if I needed to start scheduling in
- 5:54media availability since you're so big time now.
- 5:58Like, do we need a publicist? Do we need like, is it
- 6:01paparazzi? These are like big journals.
- 6:07I have groupies now. You have more group, you have
- 6:12like 18 followers on Spotify on your 90s playlist.
- 6:16That's like 70. 70 that's probably about how many
- 6:19followers you have on substantive.
- 6:21So you're growing that's. Right.
- 6:23The real point here is that I think the piece I wrote kind of
- 6:29hit a nerve, right? It's this I, I made this kind of
- 6:34debate between statins versus peptides, why Americans have
- 6:39decided to trust a compound studied in, you know, just 14
- 6:43patients. And they trust that more than a
- 6:47drug that's been studied in a half million people.
- 6:50And that contradiction is really at the core of how we're
- 6:56evaluating medical evidence right now in 2026.
- 7:00And that's really what we're going to spend the next hour or
- 7:03so on because the 800 word piece that I wrote, it doesn't do
- 7:09justice to really what this is all about.
- 7:11And I'd like to weigh in too. Can't wait.
- 7:15Right, all right, so let's dive into the drug that everyone
- 7:20loves to hate. Let's start with the boring one
- 7:22first. Statins.
- 7:24I know I can feel people you know reaching for the skip
- 7:28button already on their phones, but we have to lay down what the
- 7:33evidence actually says before we can have an honest conversation
- 7:37about peptides. Especially because the same
- 7:40people who won't touch a statin are injecting mystery compounds
- 7:46from a mystery compounding pharmacy in Florida but getting
- 7:51their peptides overseas 3 * a week.
- 7:54So let's get calibrated and press the reset button.
- 7:59OK, so statins are a class of drugs called HMG, Co a reductase
- 8:06inhibitors. They reduce cholesterol
- 8:08synthesis in the liver. They up regulate LDL receptors
- 8:13and lower circulating LDL, which is the lipoprotein most directly
- 8:19implicated in plaque formation within our arteries.
- 8:23They are, and this is not hyperbole, one of the most
- 8:27studied drugs drug classes in literally the history of
- 8:32medicine. Yeah, and for anyone who thinks
- 8:35most studied is just a talking point, you're wrong.
- 8:39There's studies that have pulled over 170,000 patients on these
- 8:44meds and there was a 2024 meta analysis of more than 500,000
- 8:49people that found a 25% reduction in major
- 8:54cardiovascular events and a 40% reduction in all 'cause
- 8:58mortality. That's significant.
- 9:01And remember, these are five year outcomes.
- 9:05We're longevity doctors. We're interested really in 30 or
- 9:1040 year trajectories, not five year trajectories.
- 9:14If you can see a mortality difference at five years, the
- 9:18effect over decades is much, much larger.
- 9:22Yep. Now let's be honest about the
- 9:24other side. For primary prevention, people
- 9:27without established heart disease, the numbers are less
- 9:31dramatic. The number needed to treat can
- 9:34run from 200 to 470 patients over five years, depending on
- 9:40their baseline risk. So prescribing A statin to a low
- 9:43risk 42 year old is a genuinely different conversation than
- 9:47prescribing 1 to a 58 year old diabetic smoker with a family
- 9:51history of heart attacks. I want to be really clear about
- 9:54this. You know, we're not saying that
- 9:57every human being should be on a statin.
- 10:00What we are saying is that the decision should be made based on
- 10:03actual data, not with the fear generated by, you know, someone
- 10:09on Instagram doing shirtless deadlifts.
- 10:12I I saw that. Though RFK Junior.
- 10:15I hope he's listening. I kind of hope so too.
- 10:19Yeah, let me tell you what this actually looks like in our
- 10:22clinic. Patient comes in, they get the
- 10:25whole work up. We do a full body DEXA scan, VO2
- 10:29Max, full biomarker blood testing, genetic testing, and a
- 10:33coronary calcium score. Let's say the coronary calcium
- 10:37score comes back at 180. This is a 48 year old, let's say
- 10:43soft plaque, hard plaque, the works.
- 10:47Their Apple B levels are through the roof, their LP Little A is
- 10:51elevated, and their father had a heart attack at 50.
- 10:55And then I recommend a satin. And then where does the
- 11:00conversation go? But doesn't the statin cause
- 11:03diabetes? Want to give me dementia?
- 11:05Doesn't it deplete Coq 10? I heard it tanks testosterone.
- 11:10Isn't cholesterol actually good for you?
- 11:12Doesn't our body need cholesterol?
- 11:14This is a person who literally, you know, just paid big bucks to
- 11:18find out with imaging that they actually already have coronary
- 11:23artery disease, they have heart disease.
- 11:26They do this work up. They get the answer that
- 11:29honestly they didn't want to get, which is they've got some
- 11:32disease. And then they don't want to take
- 11:34the single most useful, most evidence based tool that we have
- 11:40to change their trajectory. Yeah, it's like going to a car
- 11:45mechanic, having him diagnose a problem with your engine, and
- 11:50then telling him you, you know, searched on Reddit that oil is
- 11:55bad for your car when you need an oil change.
- 11:58We can usually get there, we can usually make the case, but we
- 12:03have to dismantle all these myths before we can, you know,
- 12:08build that right decision. So this brings us to side
- 12:12effects myth #1 in clinical practice, up to 30% of patients
- 12:18report muscle symptoms that they attribute to their statin.
- 12:22That sounds alarming, so let's talk about the Samson trial.
- 12:26I love this trial. It's like one of the most
- 12:29elegant studies in modern medicine.
- 12:31Basically this is like brilliant.
- 12:33They took a bunch of patients who had previously quit statins
- 12:38because of the side effects and randomized them into either
- 12:44getting statins or getting a placebo or getting no treatment
- 12:48at all. Patients then rated their
- 12:50symptoms daily on a smartphone app and the result is just
- 12:55crazy. Symptoms scores were essentially
- 12:59identical between the statin group and the group receiving a
- 13:04placebo. 90% of the symptom burden was what we call the
- 13:10nocebo effect, the expectation of side effects causing side
- 13:16effects. And half the patients in the
- 13:19trial were able to successfully restart the statin afterwards.
- 13:23Like it's just crazy how many people have been programmed to
- 13:28say that this drug is bad, that when they don't actually know
- 13:32what they're getting, they just assume the drug is bad and I'm
- 13:35having symptoms even when all they're getting is a sugar pill.
- 13:38Yeah, that's 90%, nine, zero, 90% of the symptoms burden was
- 13:45the nocebo effect. That's crazy.
- 13:47That's 90% of patients who previously already had symptoms,
- 13:52quote, UN quote symptoms to a statin.
- 13:55So these are the people who actually thought they had
- 13:58symptoms when they were on a statin.
- 14:00And then when they're randomized into this trial, we find out
- 14:03that 90% of them actually never had a symptom.
- 14:07So, you know, the true pharmacologic muscle symptoms,
- 14:12which are the things that I think most people fear that can
- 14:16actually be happen from these drugs where patients can get
- 14:19muscle soreness or muscle breakdown.
- 14:22It's actually somewhere near 1/2 to 2%.
- 14:25Everything above that threshold is coming from something else.
- 14:31Basically Instagram. Joe Schmo giving advice.
- 14:36Their neighbor? Who knows?
- 14:38Or you know what? When you're old, your muscles
- 14:40hurt. That's what happens.
- 14:41It's not because of your satin. Sometimes you're just old and
- 14:45things hurt. But people always want to blame
- 14:48their medicine or something else instead of just being like,
- 14:51yeah, this is life. Yeah, I, I think it comes from
- 14:54the same kind of cultural machinery that is now selling
- 14:59something far less studied right at four times the price with
- 15:04none of the data. And that's where we're going to
- 15:06head to next, I think. I want to, I want people to
- 15:09understand before we move on to peptides that there are plenty
- 15:14of doctors online that make this case that not everyone should be
- 15:18on a statin, even when they have good indication to be on a
- 15:22statin because they look at that number needed to treat, you
- 15:25know, 400 patients need, need to be treated for lowering 1 heart
- 15:30attack, the risk of a heart attack in one patient.
- 15:34And that's over five years for people who don't have any other
- 15:37risk factors, right? But that number, if you take
- 15:42that out from five years to 30 or 40 years, right, If you're,
- 15:45if you're a 30 year old with high cholesterol and we're
- 15:48expecting you to live until you're the average, average
- 15:51lifespan up to 80 years of age, right?
- 15:54So now you have 50 years of high cholesterol and the number
- 15:59needed to treat really drops from one in 300 or 400 down to
- 16:05like one in two to make a difference.
- 16:08And so those odds really do matter.
- 16:11And that's why I think a lot of the physicians online that are
- 16:14critics of this drug are just not doing the math correctly and
- 16:17they're not making the right conclusions from the data that
- 16:21we have now. So got that off my chest.
- 16:24I'm so glad you got that off your chest.
- 16:25All right, let's move into the next segment, the compounds that
- 16:28everyone loves to trust. Let's talk peptides.
- 16:32SS31 Matzi BPC 157 CJC 1295 Sir Moreland Milano Tan right, which
- 16:44makes you tan by injecting yourself, literally stimulating
- 16:48melanocytes. And when we stimulate
- 16:50melanocytes, we also get Melanoma as a side effect.
- 16:54Surprise, surprise. So spend 5 minutes in the
- 16:56biohacking space and you'll hear these names spoken with near
- 17:01religious reference. It's crazy.
- 17:03Here's something most people don't really understand or know,
- 17:06like many of these. And this is like a common
- 17:09misconception. Like literally I was just on a
- 17:13physician forum yesterday and, and, and physicians don't even
- 17:18know this stuff. Like many of these compounds,
- 17:22they actually were study that through FDA trials, right?
- 17:25Like Sumarellan CJC 1295 Hipmarellan these started off as
- 17:31pharmaceutical compounds Samuel and was actually FDA approved
- 17:35for growth hormone deficiency in children.
- 17:38It had a legitimate pathway. So why isn't it a blockbuster
- 17:42drug for anti aging today? But let's face it,
- 17:46pharmaceutical companies are not in the business of leaving money
- 17:49on the table. If these peptides worked like
- 17:52truly worked for fat loss, muscle building, anti aging, the
- 17:58indications that people are buying them for pharma would
- 18:01have chase those drug trials aggressively.
- 18:05The profit motive alone would have driven it.
- 18:08They didn't. They ran the numbers, they
- 18:10looked at the data and they walked away.
- 18:13It doesn't mean that the drugs may not have some of the
- 18:17benefits, but if they saw in their early trial data that
- 18:22there was some problem with the drug, then they abandon it
- 18:25because the the risk benefit isn't there.
- 18:29And that's a market signal nobody wants to hear.
- 18:32These aren't compounds Big Pharma is hiding from you.
- 18:36These are compounds Big Pharma evaluated and actually
- 18:40abandoned, right? That doesn't make them useless.
- 18:43It means the evidence wasn't compelling enough for companies
- 18:47whose entire survival depends on finding drugs that work and
- 18:51finding drugs that they can sell and make money off of.
- 18:54The online narrative is pharma can't patent them, so they're
- 18:59suppressing them. But many of these compounds
- 19:02actually have been patented. Companies just chose not to
- 19:06pursue any wider indications. You know, suppressed and
- 19:10abandoned for lack of evidence are very different stories.
- 19:16And I think the crazy part I've got to throw in there, most
- 19:19people are ordering these peptides from the black market.
- 19:22And we know when you order medications or anything,
- 19:27knockoffs from the black market, you have no idea what you're
- 19:30getting. We would not order our produce
- 19:33from the black market and just be like, Yep, like I'm going to
- 19:36put this in my body. But somehow people are ordering
- 19:40these needles and substances, injecting it into their body.
- 19:44Like, it could be cyanide, it could be arsenic, you have no
- 19:48clue. And that's a problem when all of
- 19:50this stuff shifts to the black market. 100% So why don't we get
- 19:56into one of the big ones right now and that is BPC 157.
- 20:04It's often combined with TB500 called The Wolverine blend.
- 20:08And I think this is kind of where some of this gets
- 20:13troubling, right? So peptides are short chain
- 20:16amino acids. They basically are not as large
- 20:22as what we would consider like a full protein.
- 20:27They're smaller compounds and yes, they are natural in the
- 20:32sense that they are derived from something that is actually
- 20:36naturally occurring. But be clear, these are all
- 20:39synthetic. These are all modified amino
- 20:42acid chains. They're not the exact thing that
- 20:45is circulating in our body. This is something that
- 20:48scientists have isolated and modified somehow and then made
- 20:52it available to us to use. So BBC 157 is derived from a
- 21:00protein in human gastric juice. The animal data on tissue
- 21:04healing and angiogenesis is genuinely intriguing.
- 21:09I won't pretend otherwise. But let's talk about the human
- 21:12data. Tell people what the human data
- 21:15actually looks like. Yeah, so there's been one
- 21:18registered phase one trial. It started in 2015 with 42
- 21:24healthy volunteers. In 2016, the researchers
- 21:28cancelled submission of the of the results.
- 21:31No explanation, no conclusions. The trial just vanished.
- 21:35Since then, there was 1 retrospective study of 12
- 21:39patients with knee pain, no control group.
- 21:42And then there was a pilot study involving 2 healthy adults 2.
- 21:46And FYI, like all of the papers that have been written about BPC
- 21:52all come from one researcher. By the way, it's the researcher
- 21:56who patented BPC from Croatia, and he's the one who started
- 22:02these trials and basically never reported any results.
- 22:06No conflict of interest. No conflict of interest
- 22:08whatsoever. Yeah, let's just shoot.
- 22:10Shoot up. Why not?
- 22:11Literally 2 people studied. That's the entire published
- 22:15human data set for a compound that millions of Americans are
- 22:20injecting weekly. And unlike Sumrellan or
- 22:23Ipramrellan, BPC doesn't even have like an established
- 22:27mechanism of action. We at least know that sumarellin
- 22:32hits the growth hormone receptor hormone site, and we know
- 22:37ipramerellin mimics ghrelin. Real biology, even if the
- 22:44clinical case might be weak with BPC 157, researchers have
- 22:49hypothesized some pathways, you know, nitric oxide angiogenesis.
- 22:54But there's literally no validated mechanism for this
- 22:58thing or how it supposedly might do what it's supposed to do.
- 23:02And what do they claim that it does?
- 23:05BP 157. You know, it started off as the
- 23:08healing peptide, like it heals tendons, but literally there's
- 23:12like, if you go online, it can reverse Parkinson's disease, It
- 23:16can treat schizophrenia. If you go online, if you go on
- 23:19Google or ChatGPT or like. This is not evidence based.
- 23:24I mean there's no trials so how are we even know?
- 23:27It treats schizophrenia, cures ulcers, fixes dry eyes, fights
- 23:31cancer. You know, like when a compound
- 23:34is claimed to do everything, it should make you pretty
- 23:37suspicious that it probably does nothing in particular.
- 23:40Now tell them about the patent. Yeah.
- 23:42So you know, I mentioned this a few minutes ago.
- 23:46Virtually all the published research on BPC 157, literally
- 23:51over 150 papers, comes from one single research group at the
- 23:55University of Zagreb in Croatia led by Professor Securic.
- 24:01Securic is named on the BPC 157 patent applications dating back
- 24:07to 1989. He's listed as the CEO of a
- 24:11company called Diagen, which is the company that owns the patent
- 24:15for a special stable version of BPC 157 currently on sale on
- 24:20their website. He also Co owns
- 24:23Pharmacotherapia, the company that's sponsored the one human
- 24:28trial, the one conducted in Tijuana, whose results vanished.
- 24:34You know what, if I wanted to go to the capital for research, I
- 24:39think the first place I think of is Tijuana, Mexico.
- 24:42Trusted. Nothing shady.
- 24:45Like that's where you're going to find me.
- 24:47That's right. Not Mayo Clinic.
- 24:50So, you know, virtually all the evidence for BPC 157 was
- 24:54generated by the person who holds the patent, owns the
- 24:58company selling it, and sponsored the trial that
- 25:01disappeared. And the compound that you know
- 25:05thousands of Americans trust more than statins is basically
- 25:11fraud in my opinion, until someone does some real research
- 25:15to prove otherwise. Yeah, if Pfizer or Merck had
- 25:19this conflict of interest profile, self funded studies on
- 25:23disclosed financial interest, a vanished trial, right?
- 25:27A child that just completely disappeared, no data.
- 25:31The same people promoting BPC 157 would be calling it
- 25:35corruption because it's sold as a natural peptide outside the
- 25:39pharmaceutical system. But, and that's a crazy part,
- 25:42when it's natural, it's not a pharmaceutical.
- 25:46They're not held to the same standard, right?
- 25:49So the scrutiny completely evaporates and these companies
- 25:52are allowed to claim whatever they want.
- 25:55I mean, that brings us kind of to the last misconception,
- 25:59right? That peptides are safe because
- 26:01they're naturally occurring? Yes, BPC is derived from a
- 26:05gastric protein. People here are natural in their
- 26:10guard drops, but natural and safe are just not synonyms.
- 26:15Arsenic is natural. As I said, rattlesnake venom is
- 26:18natural. Your stomach producing trace
- 26:20amounts of a parent protein during digestion is not the same
- 26:25thing as injecting a synthetic fragment under your skin three
- 26:30times a week. The dose, the route, the
- 26:32context, they all matter and we have essentially no human data
- 26:37on any of that. I think a good analogy, you
- 26:40know, when they our kids eat those fruit snacks and it says
- 26:44all natural fruit, it's as idiotic as someone actually
- 26:49thinking that that's fruit right, because it's all natural.
- 26:54No, but fruit snacks are it's an ultra processed food.
- 26:57It's made in a plant, it's a chemical, so you cannot equate.
- 27:01Just because it's as natural doesn't mean it's good for you.
- 27:0590s Marketing. It's, I mean, we fell for it,
- 27:08yeah. I think it's a little bit
- 27:10important for us to kind of get into like, why our brains get
- 27:15this backwards. Yeah.
- 27:17So how do we get here? How did we arrive at a place
- 27:21where a drug studied in hundreds of thousands of humans is
- 27:25treated with more suspicion than a compound studied in 14 people?
- 27:31Exactly. This is something I write about
- 27:33extensively in in the book that that I'm going to be publishing.
- 27:38And I think it's the most important concept for people to
- 27:42understand. Our brains are running really
- 27:46ancient software in a modern information environment.
- 27:51So the same cognitive tools that kept our ancestors alive on the
- 27:55on the Savannah, you know, pattern recognition, narrative
- 27:59thinking, the availability hoyeristic are the same tools
- 28:05that make us wildly vulnerable to medical misinformation.
- 28:11We evolved in small groups of maybe, you know, 5030 to 100 a
- 28:16150 people where your cousin's experience with a poisonous
- 28:21Berry was the best data you you had going.
- 28:24There was no meta analysis available on the Savannah.
- 28:28There were no forest plots around the campfire.
- 28:33Our hardware was built for a world where individual study,
- 28:37individual stories were actual data.
- 28:40Yeah, walk people through the biases.
- 28:43We all have bias, but let's start with the basic 1.
- 28:48So, availability horroristic. We judge the probability of
- 28:54events by how easily examples come to mind.
- 28:58Your neighbor's cousin who had muscle pain on the statin is
- 29:01vivid. It's emotional and immediately
- 29:04available. 170 thousand person meta analysis is abstract,
- 29:11statistical, and basically like invisible to us.
- 29:15The anecdote wins. It wins every time, and it
- 29:19doesn't matter how educated you are.
- 29:21This bias is not defeated by having a PhD.
- 29:25It's a feature of the architecture of our brain.
- 29:29It's not a bug you can think your way out of unless you have
- 29:32specific training on how to analyze statistics.
- 29:35All right, let's move on to confirmation bias.
- 29:38Why don't you tell us what confirmation bias is?
- 29:41So confirmation bias is it's kind of a quiet one.
- 29:45Once you belief statins are harmful, you inhabit a
- 29:50completely different information universe.
- 29:53You notice every story about the side effect.
- 29:56You find communities that share your belief.
- 29:59You dismiss trial data as pharma funded.
- 30:03Your belief becomes unfalsifiable.
- 30:06Which is a fancy way of saying nothing can ever really change
- 30:09your mind, and the social media algorithms are really happy to
- 30:15help with that. Right.
- 30:16YouTube doesn't show you the boring meta analysis.
- 30:20YouTube shows you the charismatic guy and a tank top
- 30:23who's going to explain what they don't want you to know.
- 30:27And let's walk everyone through the seduction of certainty.
- 30:31This one's honestly my favorite because our desire for
- 30:36certainty, it explains so much of the modern Wellness culture.
- 30:42An honest physician who says statins reduce your risk by this
- 30:46much and carry these potential side effects.
- 30:49And the decision depends on your profile.
- 30:53That person sounds weak, right? They're hedging.
- 30:56They're uncertain. The influencer who says statins
- 30:59are poison? Throw them away.
- 31:01Here's what you need. Instead.
- 31:03That person sounds like a leader, and we are truly evolved
- 31:07to follow the confident leaders, not the hedging ones.
- 31:12Because in the ancestral environment, confidence was a
- 31:16reasonable proxy for competence. The loudest, most certain voice
- 31:21in the tribe was usually the one who'd actually killed the
- 31:25mammoth. Today, the loudest, most certain
- 31:28voice is usually the one selling something, often times a
- 31:32supplement or a peptide. But our hardware in our in our
- 31:36central nervous system, it just hasn't updated.
- 31:39So we're all susceptible to that.
- 31:40Sometimes you get convinced because these people are
- 31:42convincing. They're so charismatic, they
- 31:45they have their ring light, their setup, and like you said,
- 31:49the algorithm of social media. I could just think about
- 31:52peptides and the next thing you know I'm getting 10 different
- 31:56reels of just times. I mean, you don't have to go any
- 31:59further than looking at politics, right?
- 32:01Like this is this is what America's political system is
- 32:05like also. And on top of that, let's move
- 32:08on to risk. We're horrible.
- 32:10Humans are horrible at risk. You know that hit the nail on
- 32:14the head. We are 100% horrible with risk.
- 32:18We over. We truly overweigh rare dramatic
- 32:22events and underway the common slow ones.
- 32:26This is why people are terrified of sharks and indifferent to
- 32:31their blood pressure. The heart attack at 68 that's
- 32:35been building silently over 34 years?
- 32:38It doesn't feel real. It can't really compete with the
- 32:43vivid story of the guy who started a pill last month and
- 32:47got sore calves. The slow, invisible statistical
- 32:51benefit of a 25% risk reduction over decades is no mash for an
- 32:58immediate, emotionally charged anecdote.
- 33:01Our brains treat might die in 20 years and will not die in 20
- 33:06years as almost the same category.
- 33:08Both are basically like Tuesday. And this is exactly what the
- 33:11peptide industry exploits. Perfectly.
- 33:14The testimonial for the peptide industry is their entire
- 33:19marketing apparatus. The before and after photo, the
- 33:22guy on Instagram who says I tore my rotator cuff and BPC healed
- 33:27it in two weeks. The story really like, activates
- 33:32every bias that we have. The availability bias, narrative
- 33:36authority, confirmation, they're social proof, and all in just
- 33:40one single post. It feels like data, but it's not
- 33:44data. It's an anecdote from one person
- 33:48with no control group, no blinding, and every incentive to
- 33:53credit the injection rather than six other things that he might
- 33:57have been doing. Was he resting?
- 33:59Probably. Was he doing some physical
- 34:01therapy? Probably.
- 34:02Did he modify his training? Probably.
- 34:04Was his shoulder going to heal on its own, the way most
- 34:07shoulder pain does? Probably.
- 34:09And our brains, which are magnificent at pattern
- 34:13recognition, built, really built for a world that no longer
- 34:17exists. They fall for this anecdotal
- 34:21evidence every single time. Yeah, and pharmaceutical
- 34:23companies are held to a different standard.
- 34:26They cannot claim that a pharmaceutical drug does
- 34:30something unless it's been proven in trials.
- 34:34Whereas these supplements, peptides, anyone can say
- 34:38anything and there's no backlash, there's no
- 34:41consequence, right. So you can just say this thing
- 34:44cured my cancer and there's no fallout.
- 34:48And what happens? Patients suffer, they're
- 34:50misinformed, and they go down this rabbit hole instead of
- 34:55turning to real evidence. Totally.
- 34:58All right, let's move on to the next segment, why America is
- 35:02uniquely vulnerable. So let's zoom out, because I
- 35:05think there's something specific about American culture that
- 35:09makes us more susceptible to this than many other populations
- 35:13around the world. I think this is important.
- 35:16It's a combination of at least four factors that converge in
- 35:20the US in a way that maybe they don't other places.
- 35:24First, it's our healthcare system.
- 35:27We are the only wealthy nation without universal health care.
- 35:32So millions of Americans have no real, like primary care
- 35:36relationship. Millions more have insurance
- 35:39that makes seeing a specialist prohibitively expensive.
- 35:43When you don't have a trusted physician who knows your history
- 35:47and can guide your decisions, you fill that void with
- 35:51whatever's available. And what's available is TikTok
- 35:56and Instagram and Joe Rogan and the guy at the gym.
- 36:01In countries with universal healthcare, you know, UK,
- 36:06Canada, Scandinavia, Japan, people are more likely to have
- 36:10actual ongoing relationships with their doctors.
- 36:14They have someone to ask. The void is much smaller in
- 36:19America. We've created a healthcare
- 36:21desert for 10s of thousands, millions of people.
- 36:25And then we're surprised when they when they're like
- 36:29irrigating with social media. Yeah, and not to mention the
- 36:32millions of Americans like us that pay boatloads in monthly
- 36:36premiums to these health insurance companies and have
- 36:39$10,000 deductibles. So we're essentially paying for
- 36:42nothing because we're afraid to use it and people end up
- 36:47canceling doctor's appointments or there's wait lists.
- 36:50People can't get in to see their primary for six months, which is
- 36:53crazy. We are a first world country.
- 36:55This should not be happening. So let's move on to the second
- 36:58one. And this connects to what you
- 37:00wrote about in your article. It's the institutions that
- 37:03earned the mistrust, the opioid crisis, right, which killed over
- 37:08500,000 Americans. This was not an accident.
- 37:12It was a product of deliberate pharmaceutical marketing.
- 37:16Americans watched that happen. They watched companies lie.
- 37:20They watched regulators fail to stop it, and they watched
- 37:25doctors become completely complicit in this whole opioid
- 37:29crisis. So that erosion of trust is not
- 37:33an irrational fear that Americans have.
- 37:37But the mistake is a leap of faith from pharmaceutical
- 37:41companies have sometimes lied to.
- 37:44Pharmaceutical science is completely a lie altogether.
- 37:47And that leap is more pronounced in America than almost anywhere
- 37:52else around the globe, because the opioid crisis was more
- 37:55devastating here than anywhere else. 3rd And I think this is
- 38:00also uniquely American, it's our relationship with capitalism and
- 38:06individual autonomy. I, you know, I'm not against
- 38:09capitalism or individual autonomy, but we have a cultural
- 38:13DNA that says the free market sorts things out, that the
- 38:18individual should be able to make their own choices, that
- 38:21government regulation is inherently suspect.
- 38:25In most of Europe, if a compound hasn't been approved by a
- 38:29regulatory authority, the default assumption is it
- 38:33probably doesn't work or it isn't safe.
- 38:36Yet in America, the default assumption is increasingly the
- 38:41government is keeping it from me because someone can't profit
- 38:44from it. That framing, you know,
- 38:47regulation as suppression rather than protection, I think is
- 38:52distinctly American. And it's rocket fuel for the
- 38:56peptide market. Yeah, for sure.
- 38:58And the 4th, the 4th 1 is the natural is safe fallacy which we
- 39:04covered. It's everywhere, but it is
- 39:07particular power here in America.
- 39:10Americans have a deep cultural association between natural
- 39:14being good. We spend more on supplements per
- 39:18capita than almost any other country on earth.
- 39:22The idea that a peptide is safe because it's derived from a
- 39:25naturally occurring compound, that it's somehow fundamentally
- 39:30different from a pharmaceutical because it comes from the body
- 39:34rather from a rather than a lab, has enormous intuitive appeal.
- 39:40And the peptide industry absolutely knows this.
- 39:43That's why the marketing always emphasizes the natural origin.
- 39:48It's already in your body. It's completely natural it's not
- 39:51a drug, it's a peptide. As if your body distinguishes
- 39:55between a synthetic 15 amino acid chain manufactured in a
- 40:00Chinese compounding plant, right.
- 40:03Versus what's actually created in your own body so they are
- 40:07modified from what naturally occurs in the body, but.
- 40:10Like make no mistake, these are lab made and most of the time
- 40:15these are coming from China. And that final piece of the
- 40:18national argument really needs to be dismantled.
- 40:21The claim that pharmaceutical companies don't want you taking
- 40:25peptides because they can't be patented.
- 40:28We just discussed right with BPC 157.
- 40:32Literally it has a patent, right?
- 40:34Secure. It holds it, Diagen sells it,
- 40:37and for other peptides. Sumerellin was patented and FDA
- 40:41approved. CJC 1295 was patented and
- 40:44ultimately was discarded because sumerellin and ipramerellin were
- 40:50better than CJC. These compounds went through the
- 40:54patent process. The companies evaluated the data
- 40:58for expanded indications and decided the evidence just really
- 41:02wasn't there. The big pharma is suppressing
- 41:05natural cures narrative is just wrong in this case.
- 41:09It's the opposite of what actually happened.
- 41:12I think it's important to touch on the dangers of when things go
- 41:16underground. It's kind of like what you see
- 41:20in the emergency room when it comes to heroin overdoses,
- 41:23right? Most of the heroin now is laced
- 41:27with fentanyl or chemicals that are 10 times more potent than
- 41:31fentanyl. That's because heroin is illegal
- 41:34and it's underground. I think people should have the
- 41:38same skepticism with peptides because it's underground.
- 41:43Because this is completely black market.
- 41:46You have no idea what's in it. Is it BP157?
- 41:51Is it arsenic? Is it saline?
- 41:54Is it something else? We don't know and it's almost
- 41:58impossible unless we start regulating it, which needs to
- 42:02happen for everyone's safety. So I'd like to move on here and
- 42:06kind of talk about like what would the right way to talk
- 42:10about these compounds and how should we really evaluate these
- 42:14types of problems? Right, so we've laid out the
- 42:17problem. Let's give our listeners
- 42:19something practical. What does good skepticism
- 42:23actually look like? So, you know, 5 questions, apply
- 42:26them to every health claim, whether it comes from Pfizer or
- 42:30it comes from a guy with a ring light one, how many human beings
- 42:36has this actually been cited in? Not rats, not cell cultures,
- 42:40humans and you know, obviously not to humans.
- 42:44Thousands, statins, for instance, hundreds of thousands,
- 42:48right? BPC 14 Two, what is the absolute
- 42:54benefit? Not the relative benefit.
- 42:57Not just a 25% reduction without knowing 25% of what demand
- 43:04absolute numbers. Anyone who only gives you
- 43:07relative numbers is either uninformed or trying to persuade
- 43:11you. 3 What are the actual harms documented in controlled trials,
- 43:16Not anecdotes. The Samson trial showed 90% of
- 43:21statin side effects were no SIBO effect.
- 43:24True pharmacologic muscle symptoms happen in one to 2%.
- 43:28That's a real number for who is making the claim.
- 43:33And what exactly is it that they're selling?
- 43:36Statin data comes from researchers funded by pharma,
- 43:39yes, but also from independent academic collaborations,
- 43:44Cochrane reviews, and government funded meta analysis.
- 43:48The BPC 157 data comes almost entirely from the person who
- 43:52holds the patent. When the strongest evidence for
- 43:55a compound is the research of the person most profiting from
- 44:00it, that should trigger the same skepticism you apply to the
- 44:03pharmaceutical lab. And five, is a compound
- 44:07regulated? If not, why not?
- 44:10FDA approval is not a guarantee of safety, but the absence of
- 44:14FDA approval for a therapeutic compound in in 2026 doesn't
- 44:19always mean the FDA is suppressing it.
- 44:22Sometimes it means nobody has done the work to prove it
- 44:25actually works. And sometimes, as in the case of
- 44:28DPC 157's case, the work was started and abandoned without
- 44:33any sort of explanation. That should concern you.
- 44:36Yeah, I want to close with what I think is the uncomfortable
- 44:41part of all this. The reason the peptide narrative
- 44:45is so seductive, and the reason millions of Americans would
- 44:49rather inject an unstudied compound then really take a well
- 44:54studied pill, is not really about peptides or statins.
- 44:58It's about a healthcare system that has failed to earn trust,
- 45:02medical profession that has failed to communicate honestly,
- 45:05and a population left to navigate an impossibly complex
- 45:09information environment with cognitive tools designed for a
- 45:14world that just doesn't exist anymore.
- 45:16Yep, like you said, we're running ancient pattern
- 45:19recognition software in a modern data saturated environment.
- 45:24We evolved to evaluate claims from people we knew personally
- 45:29in communities like you said of 50 people, 100 people where
- 45:33reputation tracked reality. We did not evolve to evaluate
- 45:38compelling health claims from strangers on the Internet on
- 45:41TikTok, each backed by a sophisticated marketing and
- 45:46algorithm amplification with a like shop now like it's like for
- 45:52my Lincoln bio for my free just 20% off coupon.
- 45:57And you know, that's not a reason to give up.
- 46:00It's a reason to just build better cognitive tools.
- 46:05We have to demand absolute numbers instead of relative
- 46:09ones. We have to ask the right
- 46:11questions. How many people has this been
- 46:13used in? Not like how many followers does
- 46:16this person have? Recognize that the most
- 46:19confident voice in the room is often the least trustworthy, and
- 46:24understand that genuine expertise almost always sounds
- 46:28like nuance. Right.
- 46:30And we have to recognize the actual mismatch.
- 46:33You are not broken for finding this information difficult.
- 46:37You are mismatched. Your cognitive architecture was
- 46:40built for a different informational environment.
- 46:43And so recognizing that mismatch won't make you immune to
- 46:46manipulation on the Internet, but it will give you friction.
- 46:51It will make you pause and give you a habit of asking what would
- 46:56change my mind. The statin on your night stand?
- 47:01Honestly, it's been studied in more human beings and most drugs
- 47:05in the history of medicine. The peptide in your fridge has
- 47:08been studied in fewer people than are sitting in your local
- 47:12coffee shop right now. Yeah, sit with that information.
- 47:16It's crazy. Then you should really decide
- 47:19who to trust and why. Well we hope you guys found this
- 47:23episode useful. I think the article for those
- 47:29who enjoy those longer form pieces.
- 47:31Vikas wrote a full article in Stat and Sub Stack about this
- 47:36topic and if you guys have any other questions and things that
- 47:39you want us to cover. But we're in the business of
- 47:42playing the long game. And I think it's going to be
- 47:45interesting to see in five, 10/15/20 years what happens when
- 47:51an entire generation of people in their 40s have been taking
- 47:54these unstudied peptides and what comes from it.
- 47:58We're not saying peptides are bad, we're just saying it is too
- 48:02soon to tell and it's black market right now and you should
- 48:06be skeptical of anything you're putting in your body that you're
- 48:10ordering off the Internet. And you know, the flip side of
- 48:12that, like I stands, aren't for everyone.
- 48:15And we make no money by promoting stats or anything
- 48:18either. So the nuance here is just we
- 48:21got to be able to look at the data for what it is and
- 48:24recognize that we have these biases and we're very suspicious
- 48:30of lots of stuff. Unfortunately, it plays into the
- 48:37way that we have evolved and there's a lot of people in the
- 48:41public space that know how to manipulate the way that we think
- 48:45based off of these biases that we all have.
- 48:48And we should really be suspicious of that more than
- 48:51anything. For.
- 48:53Sure. All right, guys.
- 48:53Thank you so much for joining us today.
- 48:57Please send us messages if you have questions, please leave us
- 49:01reviews and please follow us on our Instagram Sub Stack,
- 49:06Spotify, Apple Podcast. YouTube.
- 49:09TikTok. We love TikTok.
- 49:12I hate tik. T.O.K All right, thanks for
- 49:14playing the long game. Thank you for playing the long
- 49:20game with MD Longevity Lab. You can visit us at
- 49:23www.mdlongevitylab.com to learn more about how we can support
- 49:28you on your dream. Stay connected with us on social
- 49:31media at MD Longevity Lab for tips, updates, and behind the
- 49:36scenes insights. If you enjoyed today's episode,
- 49:38we'd love it if you subscribe, left us a rating, or shared it
- 49:41with someone you know who's also playing the long game.
- 49:44Thanks for listening, We'll see you next time.