Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [BABA/TENCENT] US Strategy Against Tencent Alibaba Military Fusion
Transcript
- 0:00Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 0:03and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 0:07The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 0:11constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 0:14before making investment decisions.
- 0:16If you want to listen our full deep dive about this topic,
- 0:19welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or subscribe us on
- 0:23Apple Spotify Podcasts channel Deep Value investing.
- 0:26Welcome to the deep dive. If you've tried to follow the US
- 0:29China tech rivalry this past year, you've probably felt lost
- 0:33in a total Blizzard of bureaucratic moves, sudden
- 0:36shocks, and frankly, confusing intelligence leaks.
- 0:39It is overwhelming. It is.
- 0:40But 2025 was really the year the US government put its cards on
- 0:43the table. They codified their ultimate
- 0:45strategy. That's a perfect way to put it.
- 0:47They rolled out this strategic 1-2 punch against two of China's
- 0:50biggest companies, Tencent and Alibaba.
- 0:52And it showed that Washington now has, well, both slow
- 0:56structural weapons and these really fast political weapons in
- 0:59its arsenal. So our mission today is to cut
- 1:01right through that complexity. We want to give you a shortcut
- 1:05to understanding these two core strategies the US used in 2025.
- 1:09This whole thing, it's what our sources are calling a whole of
- 1:12government campaign. And it's all designed to counter
- 1:15one thing, China's core national doctrine, which is military
- 1:18civil fusion, or MCF, right? Washington has, you know,
- 1:21they've stopped pretending that firms like Tencent and Alibaba
- 1:24are just commercial companies for national security purposes.
- 1:27That line between a civilian platform and a military one,
- 1:31it's gone, erased. So that's the puzzle we need to
- 1:35solve today. How did the US government, and
- 1:37we're talking the White House, Congress, the DoD, everyone, how
- 1:40do they coordinate both a slow long term weapon and a fast
- 1:44political shock weapon in the same year?
- 1:47And what does that duality really mean for global tech?
- 1:50It's the key question. OK, let's start with the
- 1:52foundational why? I mean, most people know these
- 1:54companies for gaming, for e-commerce, social media.
- 1:56Why is Washington suddenly targeting them like they're I
- 1:59don't know if arms dealers? It all comes back to MCF
- 2:03military civil fusion isn't just a policy on a piece of paper,
- 2:06it's what they call a whole of society approach.
- 2:09A whole of society approach. It's mandated by Beijing.
- 2:12The goal is to make sure every single technological
- 2:15advancement, we're talking AI, cloud computing, quantum
- 2:18science, all of it is systematically funneled into
- 2:21modernizing the People's Liberation Army, the PLA.
- 2:25So if China's national plans are basically forcing civilian
- 2:28companies to work with the defense sector, then the US sees
- 2:32firms like Alibaba and Tencent as as the centerpieces.
- 2:36They're the engines. They're not just contributors.
- 2:38They are the engines of that effort.
- 2:40They've got the data, the talent, the infrastructure,
- 2:42everything you need for what China calls the
- 2:45intelligentization of warfare. The US response, it's coming
- 2:47from a few different places. Right.
- 2:49A triumvirate. Really.
- 2:50You have the White House setting the big picture strategy, then
- 2:53Congress creates the legal tools like this thing called the 1260H
- 2:56list, and then the Department of Defense.
- 2:58The DoD is the one that actually brings the hammer down.
- 3:02OK, let's start with that first weapon, the one aimed at $0.10
- 3:05back in January 2025. This was the Slow 1, the
- 3:08structural weapon. So what exactly happened on
- 3:11January 2nd? On January 2nd, Tencent Holdings
- 3:14was formally added to the DoD's official list of Chinese
- 3:17military companies, or CMC's. CMC's.
- 3:20This comes from section 1260 H of a defense bill from 2021.
- 3:24It's a formal bureaucratic designation.
- 3:27And they weren't alone. Catl, the battery giant, was
- 3:29also on. There the 1260 Ageless.
- 3:31It sounds really scary, but our sources are pretty clear that
- 3:34the immediate impact, it wasn't some kind of financial knockout
- 3:37punch. No, not at all.
- 3:39It didn't instantly freeze their assets or stop Americans from
- 3:41buying 10 cent stock or even hit subsidiaries like Riot Games.
- 3:45At least not right away. So what's the point then?
- 3:47The point is the weapon strength is its prominence, not its
- 3:50speed. 10 cent was targeted because it's tech like WeChat.
- 3:5310 cent cloud is dual use. It could be used by the PLA.
- 3:56OK. But the real consequence, and
- 3:58this is the key thing for you to understand is the powerful
- 4:01delayed ancillary impact. It's a bureaucratic trigger for
- 4:04a massive systemic decoupling. OK, make that tangible for us.
- 4:08What are these delayed consequences?
- 4:10What does this chokehold actually look?
- 4:12Like it happens in three waves on three different timelines.
- 4:15First procurement bands. Meaning the government can't buy
- 4:18their stuff. Right, starting mid 2026 for
- 4:20products and mid 2027 for services, the entire DoD is
- 4:25barred from buying anything from 10 set.
- 4:27It shrinks their global footprint, even if the direct
- 4:30government spending isn't huge. And the second wave that goes
- 4:33way beyond just the DoD, doesn't it?
- 4:35The sources call it supply chain contagion.
- 4:37That's it. This is death by 1000 cuts all
- 4:40the big US defense contractors. Your Lockheed Martins, your
- 4:43Raytheons, they now have to audit their entire ridiculously
- 4:47complex supply chains. They have to prove beyond any
- 4:50doubt that they aren't using any 10 cent software or hardware
- 4:53anywhere. It forces them to just
- 4:55proactively scrub $0.10 out of their systems years ahead of the
- 4:58deadline. So it's a mandatory, very
- 5:00expensive detox for the whole US defense industry.
- 5:03And then there's the third consequence, which sounds like
- 5:05the nail in the coffin the lobbying ban.
- 5:08This one is extremely strategic. The 2025 defense bill created a
- 5:12new rule by June 30, 2026. Any US lobbying firm, any K St.
- 5:18firm in Washington has to make a choice.
- 5:21An impossible choice. Keep your multimillion dollar
- 5:23DoD contracts or keep your contract with Tencent.
- 5:26You can't have both. That's crushing for a big DC law
- 5:29firm. That's not just choosing a
- 5:30client, that's choosing to exit the entire defense world.
- 5:33It's designed to completely dry up Tencent's influence in
- 5:36Washington. It's a slow, bureaucratic boa
- 5:39constrictor. And Tencent's response was well,
- 5:42it was just as procedural. They called it a
- 5:43misunderstanding and said they'd seek legal proceedings.
- 5:46They wanted to fight it in court.
- 5:47Fascinating. So if Tencent was the slow boa
- 5:49constrictor, then what happened with Alibaba?
- 5:52That was a totally different animal.
- 5:54The action in November 2025 was a pivot to what?
- 5:57Direct political and information warfare.
- 5:59It had to be. The structural weapon takes
- 6:01years. By November, Washington clearly
- 6:04wanted immediate financial pain and a new narrative.
- 6:06So the MEC was completely different.
- 6:08No formal designation. No, it was an intentional leak
- 6:12of a White House national security memo citing top secret
- 6:15intelligence that had just been declassified, and it went right
- 6:18to major financial news outlets. So the goal wasn't quiet
- 6:21compliance, it was immediate public reputation damage.
- 6:25Drive the stock down, shape the story.
- 6:27And the allegations in that memo were they were a serious
- 6:31escalation. They crossed a major line.
- 6:33The claims went from passive compliance to active complicity.
- 6:37There were three of them. First, that Alibaba was giving
- 6:40the PLA ongoing access to mass customer data.
- 6:43What kind of data? I addresses Ayment records, the
- 6:47works. 2nd that they were supplying the PLA with
- 6:50sophisticated AI and cloud services, directly helping them
- 6:53modernize their military. But it was the third claim that
- 6:55was the real smoking gun, the one that reframed the whole
- 6:58thing. That's right.
- 6:58The core allegation was that Alibaba employees transferred
- 7:02knowledge of 0 day exploits to the PLA.
- 7:04OK, for anyone listening, a zero day is a software vulnerability
- 7:07that nobody knows about yet. There's no patch, no fix.
- 7:10Which means it's an incredibly powerful, offensive cyber
- 7:13weapon. Sharing that is like handing
- 7:15over the keys to the Kingdom. It arms the PLA with tools they
- 7:19can use against US targets without any warning.
- 7:22So that one allegation reframes Alibaba from just a passive data
- 7:27company into an active participant in state sponsored
- 7:30hacking. Exactly.
- 7:31It's a narrative designed for maximum damage.
- 7:33And it worked. Oh, it worked immediately.
- 7:35Alibaba's US listed shares dropped I think as much as 4.5%
- 7:39right after the report hit on November 14th.
- 7:42The damage was instant. That was the whole point.
- 7:44And Alibaba's response, unlike Tencent's legalistic 1, was
- 7:47purely political. Absolutely.
- 7:49Their spokesperson called the claims complete nonsense, said
- 7:52the memo was an attempt to manipulate public opinion.
- 7:55They fought fire with fire. And this didn't come out of
- 7:57nowhere, did it? There was already pressure
- 7:58building. For sure.
- 7:59Back in September, the House Select Committee sent a letter
- 8:02raising concerns about Alibaba's cloud partnership with the
- 8:04Olympics, specifically the LA 2028 Games.
- 8:08So the groundwork was already being laid.
- 8:10So let's put it all together. The duality here is pretty
- 8:12stark. Tencent gets the slow
- 8:15bureaucratic weapon designed for long term systemic decoupling.
- 8:18The boa constrictor. Right.
- 8:20And Alibaba gets the fast political Viper strike designed
- 8:24for immediate punishment and to control the narrative.
- 8:27The US showed it has both patience and overwhelming force.
- 8:31That synthesis is perfect. But, and this is a huge but,
- 8:35here's the major paradox we found of the sources.
- 8:37This whole strategy, this thing designed to counter military
- 8:40civil fusion, it might actually be accelerating.
- 8:43It wait, how is that possible? How do policies designed to slow
- 8:46them down actually speed them up?
- 8:47It creates a feedback loop. Think about it, when the US put
- 8:51strict export controls on high end AI chips, those GPU's that
- 8:5510 cent needs for its cloud business, that creates a huge
- 8:58supply chain problem for. Them.
- 9:00And they've admitted that. They have.
- 9:01So that pressure from abroad just validates Beijing's long
- 9:05held belief that it absolutely cannot rely on the West for
- 9:07critical technology. So every time Washington
- 9:10tightens the screws, Beijing sees it as proof that its push
- 9:13for self efficiency is the right move.
- 9:15Precisely back in February 2025, President Xi explicitly tasked
- 9:20his tech CEO's from Alibaba, Tencent, all of them to double
- 9:24down on technological innovation and state directed fusion.
- 9:28The sanctions designed to slow integration are actually forcing
- 9:31China to mandate even deeper integration.
- 9:35It's a self perpetuating cycle. The US acts because of the MCF
- 9:38threat, but the action makes the MCF threat even more urgent for
- 9:41China. And that's how they justify the
- 9:43next round. Which brings us to the future.
- 9:45The playbook is now set and the stakes are getting much, much
- 9:48higher, especially for Alibaba. So what's the most likely next
- 9:52step for them after that November shock weapon?
- 9:54That political attack has to be formalized.
- 9:56Alibaba is at extremely high risk of being added to the same
- 9:591260H list as Tencent or, and this is much worse, the Commerce
- 10:03Department's Entity List. And that zero day allegation is
- 10:07the justification they need. It's the perfect justification.
- 10:09Explain why the Entity list is so much more devastating than
- 10:12the 1260 H list. The 1260H list is a procurement
- 10:16ban. It's about who the government
- 10:17can buy from. The Entity List is a technology
- 10:20export ban. It would essentially block
- 10:22Alibaba from buying crucial US technology, component, software,
- 10:26everything. Which for a company like Alibaba
- 10:28Cloud that relies on US semiconductors.
- 10:30It could be crippling. It would stop its global growth
- 10:33in its tracks and severely limit its ability to develop advanced
- 10:36AI. And we have to assume this
- 10:38playbook isn't just for Tencent and Alibaba.
- 10:40Oh, highly unlikely. The net is almost certainly
- 10:43going to will. Sources are already pointing to
- 10:45other big firms with dual use tech.
- 10:47Think Baidu with its AI and self driving cars, or Byte Dance with
- 10:52its massive global data stores. The precedent is there now.
- 10:55So what does this all mean for you?
- 10:57I think the core take away from our deep dive is pretty clear.
- 11:00For the US government, the distinction between civilian and
- 11:02military tech in China is, for all practical purposes, dead,
- 11:07And it now has two very different tools to deal with
- 11:09that fact. Which leaves us with a final,
- 11:11and I think pretty provocative thought for you to consider.
- 11:14If U.S. policy designed to counter military civil fusion is
- 11:18in fact just accelerating China's drive for technological
- 11:21self-sufficiency, what's the next strategic weapon the US can
- 11:25possibly deploy that doesn't just intensify the conflict and
- 11:28speed up the very thing is trying to stop?
- 11:30Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 11:34and maybe subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 11:37The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 11:40constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 11:43before making investment decisions.
- 11:45If you want to listen our full deep dive about this topic,
- 11:48welcome to join Deep Value Club Membership or subscribe us on
- 11:51Apple Spotify Podcasts channel. Deep Value Investing to track
- 11:55total market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 11:57the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.