Latest / The Vegan Report / Islam for Veganism. With Zehra Abbas | Ep. 83
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan
- 0:02and today I challenge you to dream of a world
- 0:06where 2 billion Muslims, inspired by their faith,
- 0:10decide to become vegan and embrace the animal
- 0:13cause. At the forefront of making this dream
- 0:17a reality is Green Islam, an initiative of kind
- 0:21world media that reminds Muslims of how modern
- 0:25consumption and lifestyle practices are incompatible
- 0:30with the original ethical spirit of Islam. To
- 0:34discuss this pioneering work, I have with me
- 0:37none other than the founder of Kind World Media
- 0:41and Green Islam, Zahra Abbas. I asked Zahra what
- 0:46to make of Eid al -Adha, an Islamic holiday celebrated
- 0:50by families with the sacrifice of a sheep. Why?
- 0:54She thinks halal meat is a scam. how vegan activists
- 0:59are failing to reach the Muslim world, and much
- 1:03much more. If you are interested in learning
- 1:06more about the Islamic world and veganism, you
- 1:10can also listen to Al Ma 'arri, the world's first
- 1:13vegan, episode 37, and Leblon Goes Vegan, episode
- 1:1838 of The Vegan Report. In the meantime, please
- 1:23subscribe and share this episode with your fellow
- 1:25vegan. The stories we cover here are meaningful
- 1:29and deserve your attention. Thank you. Thinking
- 1:35about our conversation, I remembered another
- 1:37conversation I had with a human rights activist.
- 1:43It was years ago and I was talking about veganism
- 1:49to this activist. And the first thing she said
- 1:53was, and this was in the context of a discussion
- 1:57about international relations. And the first
- 2:01thing she said was, but veganism is a bit culturally
- 2:05insensitive. And the example she gave was Heydel
- 2:10at home, you know, uh, and she said, um, pushing
- 2:15the vegan agenda would be insensitive to people
- 2:19who celebrate head at half for instance. So I,
- 2:24I, ask you the same question. Is it culturally
- 2:27insensitive to push veganism onto people who
- 2:31celebrate had a lot of time? Maybe also, what
- 2:33is had a lot of time? I love we're starting off
- 2:38with the hard hitting stuff. I love it. You know,
- 2:42if that's a great question, and probably a pretty
- 2:46common misconception. The thing is, is We have
- 2:53in Islam quite a few schools of thought. We have
- 2:58four schools of thoughts under Sunni Islam and
- 3:01then there's also Shia Islam. The Sunni school
- 3:06of thought from and I'm just sharing with you
- 3:09what I'm most familiar with. Out of the four
- 3:11Sunni schools of thoughts, there's one school
- 3:13of thought that believes that it is mandatory
- 3:17or required to slaughter an animal. The rest
- 3:20do not believe that. The rest believe that we
- 3:24can we we should commemorate in terms of a sacrifice
- 3:29because what we know is that a prophet Abraham
- 3:32may peace be upon him there he was he believed
- 3:37that he was asked to sacrifice his son that which
- 3:41was dearest to him and he believed uh that that's
- 3:46what god was asking of him and his son of course
- 3:48said okay if if that's what needs be uh however
- 3:52there was uh the sun was replaced by a ram a
- 3:58ram that came from the heavens and so yes there
- 4:01are a group of muslims who believe that we must
- 4:04slaughter an animal however uh there is also
- 4:09a different thought, which is that we must slaughter,
- 4:14we must sacrifice. And what that can look like
- 4:17is sacrificing, you know, the funds you'd saved
- 4:20for the next new phone you were going to buy
- 4:22or the next car you were going to buy, right,
- 4:25is taking that money or taking time out of your
- 4:29busy schedule to volunteer. There are many ways
- 4:33to sacrifice and through charitable giving or
- 4:38or through a variety of other ways we can engage
- 4:42in the concept of sacrifice. And it really doesn't
- 4:44need to be animals. And there are scholars who
- 4:48have spoken about this. There are videos online.
- 4:52And so for those that believe it's required,
- 4:55I would just encourage them to dig a little bit
- 4:58deeper. And what do you make of the cultural
- 5:01and sensitive part? I don't think that it's...
- 5:06culturally insensitive at all. I think that to
- 5:12be sensitive is to be compassionate, to be kind.
- 5:19It's interesting that she evoked something from
- 5:22Islam. that she believed because Islam is all
- 5:26about peace and compassion and kindness and thoughtfulness
- 5:30and Islam is rife with instruction on how to
- 5:35care for animals. It makes today's slaughterhouses
- 5:39and animal farms pretty much non permissible
- 5:43in Islam because there are so many rules, extensive
- 5:47rules and how we're supposed to treat animals.
- 5:50In fact, within Islam, we have so many teachings
- 5:55and so many stories that instill in us that one
- 6:01act of cruelty from a pious Muslim towards an
- 6:04animal, can lead them to hellfire, whereas a
- 6:08non -pious person or a non -Muslim or somebody
- 6:14who may be sinning in other ways, one act of
- 6:19kindness towards an animal could have all of
- 6:21their sins forgiven. And so we are a tradition,
- 6:26we're people that really prioritize caring for
- 6:30animals. very beautiful. Once you dig into the
- 6:35teachings and learn the teachings, then I think
- 6:39it's actually about it's reframed this this perspective
- 6:43into caring for animals is actually the real
- 6:47tradition. And it's coming back to to, you know,
- 6:52the roots by by exercising compassion and care
- 6:56for animals. Beautiful. And let's get back to
- 7:00the head at home. So there are some assumptions
- 7:05that we have as vegans and vegan activists. One
- 7:10of them is if people had to kill the animal in
- 7:15order to eat the animal, they would not do it.
- 7:20And when I see Hed al -Adha, I think this goes
- 7:24against that profound assumption that we have
- 7:27on people because it becomes normalized, you
- 7:30know, to sacrifice an animal and to make it,
- 7:34you know, a family event, a ceremonial, religious
- 7:39event with a high significance. And I guess,
- 7:45you know, the challenge is how do we pierce through
- 7:50that conditioning to reach people? Did you ever,
- 7:55you know, think about it? Absolutely. This is
- 8:00a great... I feel like it's actually someone
- 8:05from a similar cultural background can understand
- 8:09this perspective or even have this thought or
- 8:14consideration because it does seem like in the
- 8:17sanitized lives that we live here in North America,
- 8:20for example, we don't... see slaughter, it is
- 8:25tucked away. And I think the vast majority of
- 8:27us would be horrified, at least I would like
- 8:29to believe the vast majority of us would be horrified
- 8:31if we saw that. I was born in Pakistan, and I
- 8:36did see slaughter. I was there until I was about
- 8:39six years old. And I did see slaughter. And it
- 8:43was distasteful, but it was normal. And it is,
- 8:48in fact, culturally, as you mentioned, it can
- 8:51be a family celebration. Folks will bring animals
- 8:55to their home, decorate the animals, my goodness,
- 8:59and like before the slaughter, right? It's a
- 9:02family activity, and that desensitizes children
- 9:06to the act of slaughter, and it becomes normalized.
- 9:10And over time, then it's very comfortable for
- 9:13people to conduct the slaughter themselves, because
- 9:16there is a sense of detachment or greater purpose
- 9:21or something along those lines. What's interesting
- 9:24is that the UN Committee for Child Rights has
- 9:28recently used child slaughter as an example of
- 9:31child abuse because it has a traumatic effect
- 9:35on a child's brain. And so it does make sense
- 9:38that within those communities where kids are
- 9:40exposed so early on and taught to become desensitized
- 9:46to it, it is In fact, they're normal. And it
- 9:51also makes sense that folks who live and grow
- 9:54up in these countries where they don't see any
- 9:57blood or guts or slaughter or anything horrible,
- 10:00if they as adults are then confronted with the
- 10:04reality of what's happening in a slaughterhouse
- 10:06would probably be quite repelled by it. Yes,
- 10:10I had the same childhood background, you know,
- 10:13I've seen countless, I think, slaughterings of
- 10:18sheep. And it's always in the back of my mind,
- 10:22you know, when vegans talk about, you know, spreading
- 10:27veganism, that there's a large part of this world's
- 10:32population that is not that impacted by, I guess,
- 10:39footage of slaughter or the act of slaughter
- 10:41itself, you know, that language of compassion
- 10:44and look how horrible this is doesn't, you know,
- 10:49sound the same ring the same way. And I feel
- 10:53that there's something lacking there in terms
- 10:56of activism, you know, of language and tactics
- 10:59used to reach more people. Have you brainstormed
- 11:03any solutions? I think that what's really been
- 11:07effective for me, at least with advocacy within
- 11:10the Muslim community, I did, I learned early
- 11:12on as a vegan, who cared so deeply about extending
- 11:17the vegan message to folks, I learned early on
- 11:21that you have to meet people where they are.
- 11:26And truly the learning the teachings of Islam
- 11:31around animal rights and me learning about them
- 11:34brought me closer to Islam. And I think that
- 11:39when I speak with a Muslim audience that is practicing
- 11:44Muslim audience that really care about Islam
- 11:48and Islamic teachings and doing their best to
- 11:50follow them, I find that I have the easiest time
- 11:53advocating. to them or with them, because they'll
- 11:58immediately recognize that Islam is very clear
- 12:01on animal rights and we're not following those
- 12:02rules. And so it's almost easier than the person
- 12:06who doesn't really care. You know, we've all
- 12:09met those folks who just say, I don't care what's
- 12:12happening to the animals. And that I find perplexing.
- 12:15I don't know how to respond to that. You know,
- 12:18I don't know how to respond to somebody who doesn't
- 12:20care. But speaking with people who do care, it's
- 12:23actually immediately we find common ground. And
- 12:27what I find is lacking there is just simply a
- 12:29lack of knowledge or all the reasons we know
- 12:32why people don't necessarily go vegan, which
- 12:34is, you know, convenience, having a social network,
- 12:38accessibility, and knowledge is a big piece,
- 12:41not just knowledge around what's happening. with
- 12:44animals and all the impacts on from climate to
- 12:49public health, the grave impacts of animal farming
- 12:52is such extensive piece to download in terms
- 12:55of knowledge. But then there's also a big piece
- 12:57of well, now what do we eat and what do we buy?
- 12:59Because my folks haven't been thinking about
- 13:01these things. I know for me, it was a bit of
- 13:02a learning curve, I had to almost relearn food.
- 13:06And so there has to be a deep commitment. And
- 13:09I find it easier to reach with folks who are
- 13:14really trying to follow Islam well. And I want
- 13:17to hear those arguments. And I'm really interested
- 13:22about the halal part. I think lots of people
- 13:24are intrigued by that concept of halal. But they've
- 13:29seen that all around, you know, in the city or
- 13:32something, the supermarket. How did we get there?
- 13:37How did the Muslim world? get to that place of,
- 13:41you know, mass slaughters of animals for Adel
- 13:45Ata or this acceptance, I guess, or tolerance
- 13:51of slaughterhouses and factory farming if they
- 13:55are even aware of them existing. How did we get
- 14:00to that place? I think when we want something,
- 14:03it becomes really easy to fool ourselves into
- 14:06something. I think that's why halal today isn't
- 14:12at all about animal welfare, even though the
- 14:14halal rules originally came down in regards to
- 14:18the welfare of animals or the care for animals.
- 14:23Today it's the vast majority of Muslims that
- 14:27I have interacted with sincerely believe that
- 14:30halal means ethical. That halal means the animals
- 14:33are treated well and it's not from those factory
- 14:36farms because that wouldn't be halal. I think
- 14:39the vast majority have simply not thought about
- 14:41what halal really means and I know for myself
- 14:44when I was younger I used to go with my family
- 14:49to a halal slaughterhouse. It's actually not
- 14:53even a halal slaughterhouse. It's just a chicken
- 14:54slaughterhouse that had certain days where they
- 14:57made halal. They made their chicken halal. And
- 15:00you could go there and buy chicken breast and
- 15:04chicken wings and ground chicken in bulk. And
- 15:07so it was the best prices. And you would stand
- 15:09in line because there was a customer area. specifically
- 15:13for the day that they would open up to the public
- 15:16and you would line up and then go place your
- 15:20order for these boxes and buy them in bulk. And
- 15:24it's so bizarre that I thought that that was
- 15:28acceptable. I thought that that meant these animals
- 15:31were treated well and that, you know, there was
- 15:35nothing potentially problematic about engaging
- 15:39in this. And it was only when I came across an
- 15:43investigation that was done on this particular
- 15:46slaughterhouse on cruelty, and they were fined,
- 15:50I believe, for cruelty towards animals, that
- 15:54I thought, well, how could a halal slaughterhouse
- 15:57be charged with cruelty? How do those two things,
- 16:02how can I reconcile that? And so the more I dug
- 16:05into it, the more I realized, oh, it's not. true,
- 16:08it's not real. This isn't really halal. This
- 16:11is, you know, we're getting hoodwinked. And so
- 16:15I became vegetarian. And I remember having a
- 16:18couple of thoughts, because I also came across
- 16:20other investigations and learned that the turkey
- 16:25producer also selling halal turkey also has been
- 16:29charged with cruelty. And that's when I said,
- 16:32okay, I'm going to go vegetarian. And that was
- 16:34fairly easy. It wasn't very difficult to be vegetarian.
- 16:38And I found that I had a couple of thoughts here
- 16:42and there about, well, where does dairy come
- 16:45from? Or what about eggs? And what are the circumstances
- 16:49behind that? And are there enough cows? Because
- 16:52I live in the sub, at the time I lived in the
- 16:55suburb, but very close to the city. So I don't
- 16:57really see cows. So I remember thinking, where
- 17:01are all the cows to make enough milk and do they
- 17:04just make milk all the or are they are there
- 17:06that many pregnant cows that are producing all
- 17:10this milk that's available in every convenience
- 17:12store and any place i might go or any grocery
- 17:16store that i might go to where are all the cows
- 17:18that produce this maybe there's not a whole lot
- 17:21of milk in the milk right i remember thinking
- 17:23that um and and making a note in my brain oh
- 17:27i've got to research this or i've got to look
- 17:29into this and then I just didn't because I got
- 17:33distracted with this that or the other and it
- 17:35wasn't until one day somebody said in front of
- 17:39me as they were speaking with one of their friends
- 17:42they said if only people knew that dairy is so
- 17:45much worse than meat and I remember at that time
- 17:47thinking what is he talking about and going home
- 17:51and researching it and and then that was my journey
- 17:55so I think the vast majority of folks are a not
- 17:57thinking about it, be particularly in the Muslim
- 18:00community, convinced that we have divine permission.
- 18:05And if it's halal, it is divinely done. It's
- 18:09we're practicing it in a divine way. And so therefore,
- 18:13nothing could be wrong with this picture. Everything's
- 18:16tickety -boo. So then who is responsible of that
- 18:21label, the halal? label. I guess I never asked
- 18:25myself that question. But is there like a international
- 18:29organization or something that takes care of
- 18:32that? There are a lot of certifying bodies. And
- 18:36as far as I understand, they're localized. So
- 18:39Canada has our own UK has their own US has their
- 18:43own and then within the countries, there can
- 18:46be different certification organizations. So
- 18:51there's not just one. When I was younger and
- 18:54there were less Muslims here in the greater Toronto
- 18:57area, there was, I believe, one main one, but
- 19:00now there's multiple. And so that's the thing
- 19:03is just about anyone can form a certification
- 19:07body and say, well, this is what to get our certificate,
- 19:11you have to meet this criteria. And when you
- 19:13go on their websites and look up what that criteria
- 19:15is, you'll find that animal welfare is generally
- 19:20missing from the equation. There was one organization
- 19:24or one butcher butcher place that was serving
- 19:30grass fed pasture raised organic, hand -slaughtered
- 19:36meat. And I remember associating that with the
- 19:40most ethical available. And, you know, this must
- 19:44be the humane farms. This is the true halal,
- 19:46I thought. And I remember asking the assistant
- 19:50manager of this butcher shop when I was picking
- 19:52up some chicken from there, how much space the
- 19:57chicken has when they say grass fed or pasture
- 20:01raised and all that. What does that mean when
- 20:04it comes to the life of a chicken or the life
- 20:07of a cow or a goat? And he said, well, you know,
- 20:10they have enough space. And he was quite dismissive.
- 20:13He said, oh, yeah, yeah, they have enough space.
- 20:14And I said, well, how much space do they have?
- 20:17And he said, oh, you know, it's enough space
- 20:19for them to spread their wings. And in that moment,
- 20:23I thought, oh, this is another form of us having
- 20:27the wool pulled over our eyes, excuse the non
- 20:30-vegan expression there. But it certainly was
- 20:36a moment of It was an opportunity at that time
- 20:43for me to either say, I'm going to shrug this
- 20:47under the rug. I'm going to hide it under the
- 20:49rug. It's not my responsibility because they're
- 20:53telling me it's ethical. So now it's really their
- 20:55responsibility if they're not doing it right.
- 20:57I'm doing my best. Or the opportunity to say,
- 21:01I'm not okay with this. I cannot support this.
- 21:05And I really am so grateful for the investigation
- 21:07videos that I happen to watch because had I not
- 21:11seen the extreme amount of cruelty within the
- 21:16slaughterhouses and within animal farming in
- 21:21general, even on the so -called humane farms,
- 21:24I don't know if I would have had the empathy
- 21:26or the connection with the animals to make such
- 21:29a big jump because in our community, it really
- 21:33is. I mean, in society as a whole, but then particularly
- 21:37in the Muslim community, it's a whole host of
- 21:39very different objections that you are faced
- 21:43with continuously. So as a A vegan person in
- 21:47the broader society, you're asked a lot about
- 21:49your health, right? Like, where do you get your
- 21:51protein? What about your B12? What about calcium?
- 21:54And, you know, aren't animals here for us to
- 21:56eat? And those kind of concepts. But within the
- 21:58Muslim community, there's a lot of, but God said
- 22:01you can eat animals. Are you defying God? Right?
- 22:04And so it gets a lot more complicated within
- 22:08that context. And I'm sure so many, so many different
- 22:11communities have their own version of that. Well,
- 22:14that's the I think the most interesting part,
- 22:17you know how do you navigate those objections
- 22:21and how you know because I I feel like for many
- 22:27people you would be the first person that ever
- 22:31mentioned veganism or Has denounced, you know
- 22:36what's happening with the halal business to them
- 22:38like you're breaking the news I don't know of
- 22:43many other, and you tell me of many other vegan
- 22:48advocacy initiatives directed to Muslim communities.
- 22:52So yeah, how do you navigate those objections?
- 22:57There are quite a few in Muslim countries, wonderful
- 23:01organizations like the Middle East Vegan Society
- 23:04that are doing really great advocacy and really
- 23:08great community building. I think that everyone's
- 23:13kind of working within their geographical location
- 23:17for the most part. And, you know, because we're
- 23:21such a diverse community, there's about two billion
- 23:24of us on planet Earth, almost quarter of the
- 23:27world's population. And so the vegan Muslim activists
- 23:32that I know or Muslim adjacent activists that
- 23:35I know are advocating in so many different languages,
- 23:39in so many different Muslim -predominant countries.
- 23:42I think we're slowly growing. I think as more
- 23:52people become aware, more people are making the
- 23:55decision to leap into veganism. It's a whole
- 24:01different experience to then become a full -time
- 24:06advocate. or a regular advocate, right? Many
- 24:09people start practicing themselves, but aren't
- 24:11necessarily comfortable expressing in front of
- 24:15others. And it really is a lot of, it takes a
- 24:18lot of time and work to accumulate all of the
- 24:22reasons so that we can be effective advocates.
- 24:25So you do have to learn a little bit about environmental
- 24:30science and you have to learn about various slaughterhouses,
- 24:34and you have to learn about health, so many things
- 24:38about health, right? And so I think it's not
- 24:40easy, but slowly and surely we're getting there.
- 24:44When I welcome religious leaders on this podcast,
- 24:48I always ask, you know, what is the value of
- 24:53making the religious argument for veganism? So
- 24:59I ask you the same question. The religious argument.
- 25:03Wow, okay. It's a great question. I'm sure you've
- 25:07gotten so many great answers. I think the religious
- 25:11argument is fairly simple. It says in the Quran,
- 25:14yes, we are, Muslims are given permission within
- 25:17the Quran to eat animals, specific animals. However,
- 25:23it also says in the Quran that we can eat that
- 25:27which is halal and tayyab, which means permissible.
- 25:30and pure. And tayyab, pure, it means both morally
- 25:36as well as physically. Now we turn to the hadith,
- 25:41the sayings of Prophet Muhammad, may peace be
- 25:43upon him, and the understanding of his lifestyle
- 25:46to then understand what that really means. What
- 25:49does it mean that we can eat halal and tayyab?
- 25:53And what that means is that we cannot slaughter
- 25:57an animal in front of another, that they cannot
- 26:00be distressed. They cannot see blood, smell blood,
- 26:03even hear another slaughtered. They cannot, they
- 26:06should not see the knife before being slaughtered.
- 26:11There is a specific way that things are allowed
- 26:15and in today's animal farming that way is nearly
- 26:20impossible. It's impossible. We cannot separate
- 26:26babies from their mothers. And animal farming
- 26:29depends on that. There is a lot of interference.
- 26:33When we speak about the concept of pure, we are
- 26:36breeding animals and there is human interference
- 26:40and involvement in cruel ways to breed animals
- 26:43into existence. The Quran speaks about us destroying
- 26:50destruction and corruption of the earth, land
- 26:52and seas, and that is precisely what we're doing
- 26:55with animal farming. We are not supposed to uproot
- 26:58a tree in battle, and yet we are uprooting so
- 27:03many trees for a very, very cruel industry. So
- 27:09there is immense responsibility on Muslims to
- 27:15be stewards and vice regents. And we are simply
- 27:20unable to meet that requirement of us, if we
- 27:25are engaging in any way with animal farming today,
- 27:29because of the environmental impact, because
- 27:31of the public health impact, and most importantly,
- 27:34because of what we're doing to the animals directly,
- 27:37we're simply not allowed to do those things.
- 27:40Do you feel like this type of argument for a
- 27:43Muslim is more convincing? and impactful than
- 27:47the usual arguments we hear from, let's say,
- 27:51secular vegans. You know, I get that feeling
- 27:55that the religious lane in the vegan movement
- 27:59and the animal rights activism space is not really
- 28:04that much explored, that there isn't that much
- 28:10invested when the potential is so great. What
- 28:16do you make of that? You know, we do the best
- 28:20we can with what's available to us. And I think
- 28:24that when it comes to it might be a bit repetitive,
- 28:28but really, when people are following religion,
- 28:32they're interested in following religion. And
- 28:35so when they see that Something opposes their
- 28:40understanding of that religion. I think it's
- 28:42much easier to reach that demographic than the
- 28:45average person who says, I don't particularly
- 28:48care about the animals or I don't really particularly
- 28:51care about religious teachings. it's harder to
- 28:55say to them, you should care, right? It's almost
- 28:59easier to reach the people who say, I already
- 29:01care, and I'm trying to be a good person. And
- 29:04this is my understanding of trying to be a good
- 29:06person. If that makes sense, you're then able
- 29:09to disrupt that a little bit and say, well, is
- 29:12it good? Is it acceptable? Is it okay? And when
- 29:17when we bring to attention where halal rules
- 29:20came from, you know, 1500 years ago, It was a
- 29:25food desert. When Islam came, it was a literal
- 29:30desert. There were no grocery stores. There was
- 29:32no import -export. And even at that time, Prophet
- 29:35Muhammad, may peace be upon him, only ate animals
- 29:39once in a while. Some sources might say once
- 29:43every two weeks. Some will say once every two
- 29:45months. Some will say on a very rare occasion.
- 29:48everybody agrees that he was plant forward. And
- 29:53so it's, you know, once you're able to poke a
- 29:57hole in the concept of what halal is today, and
- 30:00poke a hole in people's understanding of, or
- 30:05association of halal with ethics, then it's fairly
- 30:08simple to convince them to be more plant based,
- 30:12at least it's a bit of a learning curve, you
- 30:15have to relearn food, right? So it's difficult
- 30:18and family and what everybody's used to eating
- 30:21and, you know, social occasions, it all becomes
- 30:24a little bit difficult. But what people find
- 30:27easier is to then start shifting their diet to
- 30:30a more plant forward diet. And I've had so many
- 30:33folks express that they'll try. they'll try buying
- 30:40meat alternatives and try cooking with them and
- 30:42say you know this meat alternative worked out
- 30:43well but this one didn't work out so well so
- 30:45I still need to find a replacement for this and
- 30:47this or folks will say stop eating red meat and
- 30:51you know next I'll try to reduce my intake of
- 30:56other animal things that I'm eating but that
- 30:59I find to be an easy objective to get to so it's
- 31:04the best kind of advocacy that I personally have
- 31:07participated in because it's just easier. We're
- 31:10just on the same page about where we want to
- 31:12go. Do you get the feeling sometimes that there
- 31:17should be more Muslim vegans out there that you're
- 31:24far too, you know, of a small group? And what
- 31:30do you attribute that to? I absolutely do think
- 31:37that we should have a lot more Muslim vegans
- 31:40and I attribute the lack of vegan activism, advocacy
- 31:46and engagement in our community with the fact
- 31:52that there is an overwhelming amount of halal
- 31:58now available and this overwhelming concept of
- 32:04halal being associated with ethics, which we
- 32:06know is not. So I think that's really the culprit
- 32:11at hand. And I think dismantling that would go
- 32:14a long way for us. I have met people who will
- 32:17say things like, well, it's really our duties
- 32:20to buy halal. So if the halal folks are hoodwinking
- 32:25us, then then it's their responsibility. But
- 32:28it's a very rare person who will say something
- 32:30like that. The vast majority immediately will
- 32:32say, oh, this is not OK. And people want to express
- 32:37their care in the way their actions are. And
- 32:42so I think we'll get there over time. But I think
- 32:46that we have our work cut out for us. I think
- 32:51that we need more activists. understanding how
- 32:56to communicate with the Muslim community. We
- 32:59need more Muslim advocacy, and we need a more
- 33:05engaged Muslim advocacy. And I think that would
- 33:10help light the fire, if you will, a little bit
- 33:14more effectively or faster. Help us scale. Yeah.
- 33:20Yes, I mean, going back to that. Comment of being
- 33:26culturally sensitive. I do feel that That argument
- 33:31should be made by a Muslim to an a fellow Muslim
- 33:35and it would be more effective than from a you
- 33:41know your standard vegan to a Muslim although
- 33:44I do think that you know the Your standard vegan
- 33:48who is doing the cube of truth out there should
- 33:51be aware that there is an argument to be made
- 33:54with, you know, Muslim vegans, and that, you
- 33:59know, there should be something like a flyer
- 34:02with all of the things you said about halal,
- 34:06for instance, that they could distribute to people.
- 34:10I agree. I think that, you know, while typically
- 34:16I would say folks, it's really important for
- 34:19the message that folks are receiving from a specific
- 34:23community to be coming from within the community.
- 34:25However, in this case, animal farming is just
- 34:28so extensive and we just don't have the halal
- 34:33industry so extensive and non -Muslims are selling
- 34:37halal in order to capture the Muslim audience
- 34:42because other consumers don't necessarily care.
- 34:46if the Boston pizza chain here is serving halal
- 34:50meat, they'll just eat it. But to target the
- 34:54Muslim community and make sure they're also eating
- 34:56there, they'll serve halal meat. And so we have
- 34:59a really big halal meat problem that is far more
- 35:02extensive. It's far more pervasive and it's just
- 35:08out there, right? It's a little bit unhindered.
- 35:12We've had health gurus in the past like Kevin
- 35:15Trudeau in his book speak about how halal meat
- 35:19is a more clean or healthier meat. So we have
- 35:23a problem of non -Muslims consuming and selling
- 35:28halal meat. And so we don't have a choice. We
- 35:32need to really light the passion within vegan
- 35:39activists to be able to effectively reach Muslims.
- 35:43Because otherwise, you're missing a quarter of
- 35:48the world's demographic, right? And so when I
- 35:53speak with our fellow animal lovers and folks
- 35:58who advocate for animals regularly, I ask them
- 36:01or encourage them to arm themselves with knowledge
- 36:04as I attempt to do. And I know they do as well,
- 36:10but I want them to arm themselves with knowledge,
- 36:13specifically in regards to religion as well,
- 36:16because there are a whole ton of people who follow
- 36:19religious teachings. when it comes to the way
- 36:23they consume animals. And the thing is, is you
- 36:26don't necessarily need to learn the religion
- 36:29yourself or learn all the finer points of it.
- 36:34You can just ask questions. What does halal mean?
- 36:37How do you know that halal animals are coming
- 36:40from farms that aren't like these slaughterhouses?
- 36:45Can you, what evidence do they provide of that?
- 36:49If it is in fact coming from this kind of a slaughterhouse
- 36:52and it's labeled halal, is that permissible for
- 36:54you to eat? There's so many questions and that
- 36:57can help, it's deep canvassing work really, is
- 37:01it can really help people. consider and think
- 37:04about what halal means. And there's a couple
- 37:07of street activists that do such a great job
- 37:09and their YouTube videos can go a long way to
- 37:12help inspire our fellow vegan advocates as well
- 37:15to speak to the Muslim audience. One of them
- 37:18is Earthling Ed. There is a bunch of videos with
- 37:21if we just look up his videos on YouTube with
- 37:25vegan and halal, you'll find a couple of debates.
- 37:28And then there's also Joey Carbstrong, who's
- 37:32done really great work. And as a non -Muslim,
- 37:35he's able to communicate so well with the Muslim
- 37:38audience. Both of these gentlemen do a really,
- 37:42really great job. And I think all vegan advocates
- 37:45need to be able to do that. And some of the vegan
- 37:50content can be easily repackaged to reach the
- 37:55Muslim audience, but some has to be mindful that,
- 37:58for example, pig slaughterhouses, doesn't reach
- 38:03the Muslim audience. And so just making sure
- 38:06that when we are doing street activism, it's
- 38:09of course great to include pigs, but it's also
- 38:13really important to also make sure that there's
- 38:16content with cows and chickens. And if you have
- 38:22material on halal slaughterhouses or footage
- 38:25from halal slaughterhouses, that can just go
- 38:27a really long way in being able to connect with
- 38:30folks. What about the language barrier? I know
- 38:36that George Hayek from Lebanese Vegan, he posts
- 38:42a lot of videos and stuff like that with Arabic
- 38:47subtitles. But there is that problem too, I guess,
- 38:51to reach those two billion Muslim people in the
- 38:55world. I think the funders are doing great job
- 38:58these days in reaching community members who
- 39:02are advocating within their own communities.
- 39:04And so, you know, somebody in Bangladesh is going
- 39:07to make it relevant to their community and George
- 39:11is going to make it relevant to his community.
- 39:13I tend to stick to the diaspora community, Muslim
- 39:17leaders. and Muslim community members in Western
- 39:21countries who speak English. And so I think we
- 39:25need to just spread out in the areas where we
- 39:29are the experts and really concentrate on those
- 39:32and just make sure that our fellow Muslims in
- 39:35other parts of the world are also empowered and
- 39:38we're collaborating in great ways so that we
- 39:40can help achieve the goals that we're all interested
- 39:43in achieving. We talked a lot about the food
- 39:47part, the diet part, but what about the rest?
- 39:50You know, the zoo, I know that if you visit some
- 39:56Middle Eastern countries, even North African
- 39:59countries, they will put you on the camel and
- 40:04you will visit the Phoenix in cages and stuff
- 40:08like that. What about that part of animal expedition
- 40:13that is not about diet. I when when I'm engaging
- 40:20in advocacy, I do speak about animal testing
- 40:22or you know, accessing or just making sure that
- 40:28our purchases are more aligned with ethics. So
- 40:33cruelty free makeup fee and makeup. And I find
- 40:36that many people tend to when they're presented
- 40:41with an ethical option, they tend to go for the
- 40:44ethical option. As but oftentimes, it'll be so
- 40:50in a way where they're not compromising quality.
- 40:53So if if there are ethical, products, they'll
- 40:58tend to lean a little bit more towards the ethical
- 40:59products. There are many folks I know who are
- 41:03not vegan who don't go to the zoo because they
- 41:05don't like that animals are in cages or confined.
- 41:10And I think that there is, you know, just like
- 41:14we do advocacy outside the Muslim community.
- 41:18It's quite the same within the Muslim community.
- 41:21There's many people who love animals and care
- 41:23for animals and care for their well -being. And
- 41:25so when we position, you know, look at what's
- 41:28happened to the animals that are confined, look
- 41:30how deeply traumatized they are, look at what
- 41:35humans are doing to animals, many of them upon
- 41:38understanding that the animal is being hurt in
- 41:43question, they will often express care. And there's
- 41:49of course, many who just simply don't care. So
- 41:51it's like activism in any community. And same
- 41:57goes for like wool. I remember in a group chat
- 42:01when my friends were speaking about wool and
- 42:03they were saying, oh, wool, you know, it's...
- 42:06really cold, and we've got to get some wool socks.
- 42:08And I said, Well, look, here's, you know, an
- 42:10investigation in wool farms, and this is what's
- 42:14happening on the wool farms. And they were like,
- 42:15Oh, no, okay, what else can we get? And so there
- 42:18are, there's definitely a desire for people often
- 42:23to do better, when they know better. Do you find
- 42:28that there is a segment of the Muslim community,
- 42:34or maybe a country that does better than others
- 42:41in terms of animal welfare, even veganism. Veganism,
- 42:46sure. We have the data that shows us where plant
- 42:51-based options are more available and more people
- 42:54are consuming plant -based and all of that, or
- 42:57ethical. However, don't personally think so.
- 43:04I think that, you know, in every corner of the
- 43:06world today, sadly, there is animal exploitation.
- 43:10It just takes on different faces sometimes. Sometimes
- 43:13it's a little bit more available for public consumption
- 43:17and a little bit you know, sometimes hidden away.
- 43:22But we've got animals being tested on in really,
- 43:25really cruel experiments. And I have no idea
- 43:30how these laboratories continue to operate in
- 43:33the developed world, right, where we like to
- 43:35think that everything is so proper and done properly.
- 43:39But we know slaughterhouses are the stuff of
- 43:43nightmares here. So yeah, I think it's the same
- 43:47everywhere, unfortunately. to some extent. What
- 43:50are I guess the organizations out there that
- 43:52we should be supporting, that we should be highlighting,
- 43:57putting more, you know, on sharing on our social
- 44:03media pages, that kind of stuff to to add, you
- 44:06know, to shed light on what is happening in terms
- 44:10of vegan advocacy directed to Muslim communities.
- 44:14Oh, that's a tough one. There are so many great
- 44:16organizations. Green Islam, of course, has really
- 44:20great content. Middle East Vegan Society has
- 44:24really great content that's relevant to the community.
- 44:27And then there's also investigations done by
- 44:31non -Muslim organizations or activists that are
- 44:34also extremely relevant, like Joy Carpstrong
- 44:37did in investigation in Halal slaughterhouses
- 44:44very recently, and it's really atrocious stuff
- 44:47and really can be used by Muslim advocates to
- 44:52highlight what's happening on Halal slaughterhouses.
- 44:55or in halal facilities. Same thing with the US,
- 44:59there was a investigation there recently. So
- 45:02really, I think there's great organizations that
- 45:06are within the context of Muslim Islam teachings.
- 45:11However, there's also lots of really great stuff
- 45:15from outside the community. We really do need
- 45:19to be well rounded as activists in order to be
- 45:22effective. And so knowing a little bit about
- 45:25health and following our beloved Dr. Gregor and
- 45:30other doctors that are doing great work is also
- 45:33just as important. About the halal label again,
- 45:40coming back quickly to it, I did read about a
- 45:44debate concerning how slaving the throat of the
- 45:49animal was considered particularly cruel. and
- 45:53how there are Western governments that thought
- 45:56about banning that. And of course, it also concerns
- 46:00kosher food in that instance. Do you have an
- 46:05opinion on that whole debate? Well, I think that
- 46:11I would just like to see animals not be seen
- 46:18as products or you know, something to consume
- 46:23or less than humans. And so I'm personally a
- 46:28bit of an abolitionist. I just don't want to
- 46:32see animals used. And so when it comes to the
- 46:37format, that can look like various different
- 46:39formats. And there's many micro debates going
- 46:44on. But for me personally, it's really just about,
- 46:48let's stop using animals. Let's just leave the
- 46:51animals alone. It's not that hard. We really
- 46:53don't need to eat animals. We don't need to find
- 46:56new ways of abusing animals. We're trying to
- 47:00fit things into like a box so we can make it
- 47:02more palatable. And I just don't think that's
- 47:04necessary. Does that answer your question? Yes.
- 47:09I'd love to know a little bit more, if I'm allowed,
- 47:12I'd love to know a little bit more about your
- 47:15take on this and your journey to veganism, because
- 47:20you also come from a community that is as complex
- 47:24as the community I come from, right? So I'd love
- 47:27to hear your take as well. Well, I guess what
- 47:31I would have to say is, yes, I was exposed to
- 47:36sacrificing, you know, The sheep on those important
- 47:41holidays and you cannot miss it, you know the
- 47:45The streets can get bloody. It's that you know
- 47:49graphic literally and I did witness also how
- 47:54people looked at animals as Objects, you know,
- 48:00I remember my neighborhood had lots of stray
- 48:03cats and those stray cats were not considered
- 48:07People are sentient beings in a way They were
- 48:11toys or they were curses, you know if you were
- 48:14superstitious and they were the wrong color or
- 48:17they were you know, just nuisance and and pests
- 48:21and I guess you know It's interesting. I was
- 48:26asked the same question in my last episode and
- 48:30I don't know how come I you know I became vegan
- 48:34I feel like veganism chose me instead of me choosing
- 48:38veganism because I always had that little voice
- 48:42at the back of my mind saying you know this is
- 48:46weird this this is not this should this is not
- 48:51good and and you should be thinking about you
- 48:55know getting away from it and And I guess the
- 48:58reason why I became vegan was I was never able
- 49:01to mute that voice. It stayed and it haunted
- 49:05me until I became vegan. So yeah, I do feel I
- 49:09was guided into it through those natural instincts
- 49:14that I was born with. And so, yeah, I was really
- 49:23grateful to listen to your lecture because then
- 49:26I thought I can reach out to some of my relatives
- 49:30who are you know Muslims and religious and you
- 49:35know show them what you have developed as materialist
- 49:39content as arguments concerning halal and other
- 49:43related topics and before listening to your lecture
- 49:48and by lecture I mean We both attended the AVA
- 49:53Summit in Los Angeles a few months ago. Well,
- 49:56I never realized that this was missing in my
- 49:59life, that I did not have the tools to reach
- 50:04those family members, but now I do, which makes
- 50:10me feel very grateful for your work. So yeah,
- 50:14I guess. I hope I answered your question in some
- 50:19way. You did. Thank you. I really appreciated
- 50:22hearing that. As a way to end this conversation,
- 50:27I was wondering, you know, what maybe passage
- 50:31of the Quran or something is saying from one
- 50:34of your favorite Islamic teacher or thinker?
- 50:39Would you like to share with us that inspires
- 50:41you and feed that? heart of compassion that so
- 50:45many activists like yourself have. Yeah. You
- 50:49know, when I was around 1920, I started asking
- 50:54questions that because, to be frank, I find a
- 50:59lot of the understanding of the Muslim community
- 51:02around Islam. unrelatable for myself personally.
- 51:07And so I looked into the anti -oppression teachings
- 51:12of Islam when I was 19, 20 and found a whole
- 51:15new world. And so I often joke that I'm a born
- 51:20again Muslim because I really did choose Islam.
- 51:24I was born into it and taught Islam, but I didn't
- 51:29really comprehend the teachings and I didn't
- 51:32really comprehend the different ways of understanding
- 51:37the teachings until I was much older. And it
- 51:41really is animal rights that brought me closer
- 51:47to Islam. And I remember the moment that I realized
- 51:54I had to go vegan. It was what flashed for me.
- 51:58didn't believe what I thought was vegan propaganda
- 52:01around dairy and I didn't want to go vegan. I
- 52:05was very comfortable being vegetarian, but I
- 52:08love milk chocolate and I love desserts, various
- 52:12cakes and all sorts of, you know, delicious desserts
- 52:16I was eating at the time. I did not want to let
- 52:19them go. And I, milk chocolate was probably my
- 52:21major food group at the time. I just love chocolate
- 52:24so, so much. And I have an allergy to dark chocolate,
- 52:29but I can't tolerate dark chocolate or even semi
- 52:32sweet chocolate. So I didn't want to let go of
- 52:35milk chocolate. And I was almost looking for
- 52:37reassurance that what I was watching was vegan
- 52:40propaganda. And I didn't, I didn't really need
- 52:43to, you know, these people with an agenda and
- 52:45I didn't really need to worry about making the
- 52:48switch to becoming dairy free. And I was, I joined
- 52:54a Facebook group of the dairy farmers of Canada.
- 52:58And one of them, and I asked them questions about
- 53:00how they treat their animals and everything they
- 53:02said was very reassuring. And I was feeling pretty
- 53:07confident that, okay, I'm okay with dairy, dairy
- 53:11sounds fine. These people really care about their.
- 53:13cows and it's a very natural process it's all
- 53:16good it's all okay and then one of them said
- 53:18well let me send you the dairy the cattle rearing
- 53:22manual that's nationalized for canada and i said
- 53:25great thinking i'm never going to read this who's
- 53:27going to read a cattle rearing manual and yet
- 53:30i clicked on the pdf she sent me and i perused
- 53:34I just, you know, scroll through with no real
- 53:36intention of digesting it really. But somehow
- 53:40my eyes landed on a passage that very clinically
- 53:45was describing that animals or the cows are very
- 53:50emotional creatures. And when their calves are
- 53:53extracted, they will it will have an impact on
- 53:57their lactation levels because they will feel
- 53:59depressed. So if you put all the mother cows
- 54:04together, they will comfort each other. And that
- 54:08will help raise the lactation level. And in that
- 54:14moment, I had an immediate realization in my
- 54:19brain, I said, Oh, shoot, I have to go vegan.
- 54:23And what What I connected within that second
- 54:27with Islam is that in the Quran, it says that
- 54:32animals are made in communities just like you,
- 54:36and they will be raised to their Lord at the
- 54:39end. They will be that essentially what that
- 54:43saying is that they will testify on how we treat
- 54:46them on Judgment Day. Right. And so we don't
- 54:50get to just mistreat animals and pretend it's
- 54:54OK. And that passage in the Quran, they're made
- 54:57in communities just like you. It was so blazing
- 55:01red hot for me that that passage in the Quran
- 55:04that I've got to say that's probably my absolute
- 55:07favorite. I think that I am now I know that I
- 55:11am vegan because it says that in the Quran. That's
- 55:15beautiful. Thank you so much, Sarah. Thank you
- 55:17so much for your time and for your great pioneering
- 55:21work. I'm so glad that you're part of this movement
- 55:24and yes, thank you. Likewise, my friend. Such
- 55:29a pleasure meeting you. Thank you for this conversation.
- 55:32Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 55:36you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 55:38know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 55:42Again, thank you so much for caring and I will
- 55:45see you next Tuesday for a new episode.