Latest / Health Coach Power Community / E302: Answering the Question: Why a Health Coach Instead of a Dietitian?
Transcript
- 0:01Hello there, health coaches,
- 0:02thank you so much for joining me for another episode of the podcast.
- 0:07Today we're going to tackle a very tricky situation that comes up fairly
- 0:12often among health coaches,
- 0:14and here's what it's Crystal actually posted inside our Health Coach Power
- 0:19Community Facebook group, and she asked, how do you answer the question?
- 0:24Well, why would I hire,
- 0:26I work with the certified health Coach if I can work with a dietician or if I
- 0:30can work with a nutritionist? E, that's a tough question, right? And she said,
- 0:35how would you eloquently explain the benefit to working with Health Coach
- 0:40in conjunction with a dietician or a nutritionist?
- 0:44And I thought this was a really great question on
- 0:48several levels,
- 0:51and I'm curious if you're here with me live or if you're watching this in our
- 0:54Facebook group later, tell me in the chat,
- 0:56have you ever had to answer a question like this,
- 0:59and what would you say and how does it make you feel? Most of all,
- 1:03because I bet every health coach in our community has experienced something
- 1:08like this at one point or another. I know I have. Now,
- 1:12before we dive into answering that question,
- 1:15I do want to give a quick shout out to Amber Swift. Hey Amber.
- 1:19She is one of the health coaches in our community and she's a healthy Profit
- 1:23University member,
- 1:24and Amber just launched her podcast using nothing but our
- 1:29free podcast, quick Start Guide for Health coaches. I took a listen. Amber,
- 1:34you are doing an amazing job. Way to go. I'm so glad you did this.
- 1:38The podcast, everyone, because you might want to check this out.
- 1:40The podcast is called Everyday Health for the Christian Woman,
- 1:44and we'll put that link in the show notes.
- 1:47And if anyone's listening and you're like, I'd like to start a podcast,
- 1:50Michelle, you can get that same free quick start guide. It's at
- 1:54healthcoachpower.com/podcastguide.
- 1:59Again, that's healthcoachpower.com/podcastguide. Anyway, Amber,
- 2:04I left you a five star review, and speaking of reviews are really,
- 2:09really, really helpful for podcasts.
- 2:11It's like one of the ways that we get this show in front of so many listeners
- 2:14and have become,
- 2:16I'm proud to say the number one podcast in the health coach business space.
- 2:20So take a minute,
- 2:21leave a review for your favorite podcast because we are all so very appreciative
- 2:26of that. But this episode, this episode is not about podcasting.
- 2:29I just had to give Amber A. Little love.
- 2:31She just launched this into the world last week.
- 2:34This episode is about feeling really confident in how health coaching and how
- 2:38you fit into the bigger picture of the health
- 2:43industry.
- 2:44And why would someone hire us if they could just go to a
- 2:48dietician first?
- 2:52I think we need to be clear within ourselves
- 2:56what that difference is. What are the clear
- 3:01benefits to coaching? What does make it different?
- 3:04Either going to know that or we're going to immediately feel less than when
- 3:09someone asks this question, we're just going to go, oh, I hate this question.
- 3:14I feel like an imposter. We're inferior. We're not enough.
- 3:19So first we have to know that in here. And then secondly,
- 3:24how do we communicate this especially to a potential client?
- 3:30I think it's easiest if we start with the first question.
- 3:32Just like within ourselves, we know the value of coaching. We've gone to school,
- 3:37we've done the thing. Hey, maybe you've even hired your own coach.
- 3:40If you haven't, I highly recommend it.
- 3:42Then you'll really know it in your bones how helpful coaching can
- 3:47be when you're actually on the other side of it.
- 3:51So why would anyone hire us though? They don't know that.
- 3:54What is the difference?
- 3:57I think the mental story that comes up for me is like, well,
- 4:01they could probably get insurance to just cover a visit to a nutritionist.
- 4:06That sounds like a pretty good idea.
- 4:08Why would anyone spend out of pocket money to work with someone who has
- 4:13fewer credentials? This is killer.
- 4:17So what I really loved was inside our Facebook group,
- 4:21everyone was kind of grappling with this question and I was just kind of eating
- 4:24popcorn and watching as all the comments came in.
- 4:27So I'm going to share some of them with you and give my own color
- 4:32commentary on the whole thing.
- 4:35Cynthia said about dieticians, and I quote,
- 4:39you're just a number to them to collect insurance payment.
- 4:42They may be interested in nutrition,
- 4:43but there is little follow up in between appointments. Just my experience
- 4:49now, I read what Cynthia wrote.
- 4:51I am 100% positive that there are so many dieticians who care
- 4:56very deeply about their clients and who also provide perhaps a level of
- 5:00coaching. And Cynthia,
- 5:03I have also had poor experience with dieticians, and this is anecdotal,
- 5:07but yes,
- 5:08I think it is safe to say that health coaches tend to be more
- 5:13personal with our clients, and that's because we have the time to do it right?
- 5:17We have longer sessions, we have more frequent sessions.
- 5:21We aren't restrained by the medical model at all, which is a gift.
- 5:25We're not limited to those short little visits because that's all that the
- 5:29insurance company is going to cover.
- 5:31So our model of care is actually vastly different.
- 5:35It's like comparing apples to oranges. So there's that.
- 5:39And I really liked what Susie and Deanna had to say.
- 5:42So shout out to both of you. Susie wrote,
- 5:45the term health coach is not a great title.
- 5:48We're really more behavior change specialists.
- 5:52Love that she said,
- 5:53dieticians and nutritionists and doctors can be directive while health coaches
- 5:57help the client actually implement lifestyle changes they know they need or want
- 6:02to make. Right? And Deanna said, this is a good topic to discuss.
- 6:06Let's just say telling people what to do without any mindset or cognitive
- 6:11behavioral guidance applied can make one not reach their goals.
- 6:16Dieticians are there to prescribe meal plans, diets, et cetera,
- 6:19whereas coaches help them implement or in the passenger seat when it comes to
- 6:23helping clients.
- 6:24Plus rds aren't able to sit with clients for weeks at a time and
- 6:29are driven by insurance if they do accept it to only be reimbursed for a few
- 6:32sessions. So yes to all of this,
- 6:36people can get a diet plan from a licensed medical
- 6:41professional.
- 6:41People can get a diet plan from a book that they pick up at the library,
- 6:45but regardless of where it comes from,
- 6:47we know it's incredibly hard for most folks to actually follow the plan
- 6:53and then they don't. And nothing changes. And that's the difference.
- 6:57Now in my experience,
- 7:00and I'm super curious if any of you have had experiences like this,
- 7:05the biggest shifts that my clients ever saw in my own health coaching practice
- 7:09had nothing or had very little
- 7:15to do with their food choices. Oh yeah, I said it.
- 7:19I mean, yes,
- 7:21I've had clients get rid of really terrible autoimmune pain by
- 7:26eliminating trigger foods. That's true.
- 7:28I've had clients get off blood pressure medication,
- 7:31acid reflux prescriptions just by changing their diet.
- 7:36Also true.
- 7:37And I've had clients who changed jobs,
- 7:42who started riding a motorcycle, let their hair go gray,
- 7:46climbed the Mount Everest base camp and just started living a
- 7:51more authentic life. And it's not because of a diet plan,
- 7:56it's not because they were able to adhere to some particular diet plan that
- 8:00somebody gave them. That wasn't it at all. It's because yes,
- 8:03maybe they came with certain health goals and certain ideas about their diet,
- 8:08but they had someone actually listen to them for once
- 8:14and ask the right questions.
- 8:16They had the space to think through some of the larger questions and
- 8:21sort out what's really most important to thrive on the
- 8:26plate. Yes, but also off the plate, right? Are you with me?
- 8:30Health coaching goes so far beyond eat this food,
- 8:34eat that food, eat this many calories, blah, blah, blah, whatever.
- 8:38So I would say health coaches, yes,
- 8:42we help clients change their behavior around food and we help clients
- 8:47explore and change their behavior around everything,
- 8:51around how they do life. And that is the really,
- 8:54really exciting stuff. But how do you convey that to someone?
- 9:00How can you summarize that and have someone who's never heard of coaching before
- 9:05go like, oh yeah, that sounds like a good idea. Oh yeah, I totally get that.
- 9:08My whole life,
- 9:09all I've ever done is gone to my physical at the doctor and the dentist twice a
- 9:14year. But I totally understand what you're talking about. It's very hard.
- 9:19And if a person's coming to you with that mindset of like, I go to the doctor,
- 9:24I pay a $20 copay or whatever,
- 9:27that's the only type of practitioner I've ever seen. And this person,
- 9:31let's say they want to lose weight, just an example. And you're like,
- 9:36great, I'm a health coach. I can help you with the required behavior change.
- 9:41They're like, all right, but can you just tell me what to eat?
- 9:47Just put up a hand. Say me in the comments.
- 9:49If you've ever had a client say something to the effect of,
- 9:52can you just tell me what to eat?
- 9:54I have a list of clients going through my head right now.
- 9:59That's just where they're at.
- 10:01That's how people come to us because that's all they know.
- 10:04That's all they've ever been led to believe can help them.
- 10:09And if you're like, alright,
- 10:13you want me to tell you what to eat? Or we can explore that,
- 10:16but we're going to do more than that.
- 10:18We're going to explore changes to your entire life,
- 10:21a holistic approach, which sounds really good to us,
- 10:25but this person's going to think,
- 10:27what sounds a little over the top?
- 10:31What does this cost anyway? I just want to lose a few pounds.
- 10:37So my point is it's really difficult to explain coaching in
- 10:41words. This reminds me by the way, we have an episode in our archive,
- 10:46it was number 193 and it's called How to Answer What Is a Health
- 10:51Coach,
- 10:52which is very similar with that question or with this question about why should
- 10:57I hire you over a dietician? What happens is it's really easy to get thrown into
- 11:02a defensive position where you are over explaining yourself.
- 11:07You're trying to justify your existence.
- 11:09It's a weak spot for you to be in.
- 11:14So if you find yourself answering the question, what's a health coach?
- 11:18Or Why should I hire you instead of a nutritionist or instead of an
- 11:22RD or instead of a dietician,
- 11:25my best advice is you are having the wrong
- 11:29conversation. However you found yourself in this conversation,
- 11:32you just don't want to see yourself out and try not to do that Again,
- 11:36I really like what Natalie wrote in our Facebook group because one of her
- 11:39comment on this question was, honestly, if someone asked this question,
- 11:43I'd consider if I properly conveyed my value and the transformation I can help
- 11:48them achieve. If they continue to question it,
- 11:51either I failed at conveying or they're just not a good fit. I'm not into
- 11:56selling myself like a hard sale.
- 11:59I'd rather align with those who match me energetically.
- 12:04Yes, yes, and yes, I agree with this 100%.
- 12:09So the question is how can you convey your value
- 12:14and prove how helpful a coach is so
- 12:18much that the question is never asked, it just doesn't come up.
- 12:23They already inherently see your value. I mean,
- 12:27you could say with words,
- 12:29you can say how valuable coaching is,
- 12:32or you can be valuable.
- 12:36You can show up in the world in a way that is already very
- 12:40clearly valuable and this person already knows it.
- 12:43How you can be a voice in your community.
- 12:46You can have super valuable content to share on your blog,
- 12:49on your podcast every week.
- 12:51You can give someone a giant aha moment during a free
- 12:56workshop. Any of these,
- 12:58you can show up with such great energy that people are just
- 13:02attracted like a magnet and they don't care one bit what your credentials are.
- 13:07I mean, in my entire 13 years in private practice,
- 13:10someone asked me maybe twice if I was a nutritionist or if
- 13:15I was a dietician. In my experience,
- 13:18if they're psyched to be around you, that's all they need to know.
- 13:22That overrides everything else in their brain,
- 13:24all the different objections that they can come up with. If they're just like,
- 13:27yeah, this person makes me feel like everything's doable,
- 13:31they feel inspired. You lift them up. And if someone still asks,
- 13:37you can say, oh,
- 13:40coaches spend time with our clients, coaches actually listen to you.
- 13:45You can say that. Or you can take the opportunity to actually listen.
- 13:51What is this person looking for? What is important to them?
- 13:56What have they tried in the past? Ask them why didn't it work?
- 14:02Can they think of a time that they did have success working with a
- 14:06practitioner of any kind? Tell me about that.
- 14:10What made it so successful? Ask the questions,
- 14:15actually listen to the answers instead of jumping in where
- 14:20you start to defend yourself. Trying to define what health coaching is,
- 14:24putting down other professions. I mean, there are no reason to do this,
- 14:28so don't say you are a coach.
- 14:31Be a coach in that moment.
- 14:35You have the opportunity to do exactly that and help this person figure
- 14:40out for themselves what they need.
- 14:42They might need a nutritionist either because of their health issue
- 14:47or just because that's where they're at right now, And that's okay.
- 14:52So in other words, when it comes to answering the question,
- 14:57why a health coach instead of a dietician,
- 15:01you don't need to answer at all.
- 15:06I hope that helps. Crystal,
- 15:08thank you for asking the question in the first place.
- 15:11Thank you to everyone who contributed to this conversation inside our group. If
- 15:15you are feeling stuck in your health coaching practice or lonely working by
- 15:18yourself,
- 15:19or you're looking for guidance from someone who's been in your shoes since 2009,
- 15:24that's me.
- 15:25Subscribe to the podcast and join the conversation in our free Facebook group at
- 15:29healthcoachpowercommunity.com. I'll see you all soon. Take care.