Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Mothman Prophecies.... Spieled over - part 2 of 3
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:14Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, a podcast that's pretty good.
- 0:18I'm not going to oversell it, I will let the episode speak for itself.
- 0:23We are your podcast hosts, Taylor and Chelsea.
- 0:25We're here today following up on our John Keele episode and what I don't know if we're
- 0:29classifying as a two-parter, Chelsea?
- 0:32Yeah.
- 0:33Okay.
- 0:34You're at this point.
- 0:35Nice.
- 0:36And I will let you take it from there.
- 0:38Okay, thanks.
- 0:39Great opener.
- 0:40Don't oversell the opener, Chelsea.
- 0:43So, we left off on Keele and I think you may have noticed that we're clearly missing one
- 0:50of Keele's most renowned marks on the UFO community, at least from my perspective, that
- 0:56being the Mothman prophecies.
- 0:59I decided it needed its own episode or two and I'm talking about an in-depth look at
- 1:05the book itself.
- 1:06I also wanted to take the time in this episode to pull out some of the major happenings in
- 1:12the book to talk about.
- 1:13So let's not waste time and dive right in.
- 1:16November of 1966, the people of Point Pleasant and the surrounding area in West Virginia,
- 1:23which is along the Ohio River, begin to experience strange things.
- 1:29And the events take place over a period of about 13 months and entails hundreds of documented
- 1:35witnesses and accounts, Mothman being only one of them.
- 1:40It's hard to track down an official first encounter.
- 1:42They differ.
- 1:44But I'm going to go with this one.
- 1:45It's a National Guardsman on duty at the Point Pleasant 1092nd Engineer Battalion Headquarters.
- 1:53He was on the base when he saw an impossibly large creature perched high in a tree on a
- 1:58fence above the base.
- 2:00It was so big he thought it was a man and he sat staring at it for a little bit and couldn't
- 2:05make sense of it.
- 2:06He thinks it must be a bird, but it's too big and it would have been the largest bird
- 2:11he'd ever seen in his life.
- 2:12He goes to get someone else to come take a look and by the time he comes back it's gone.
- 2:17I was going to say like, I've, I've ostriches larger than a human, but I guess he's never
- 2:21technically seen one and it would still be odd to see an ostrich perched on top of that.
- 2:25I don't think it's perched on top is something you hear from ostriches that often.
- 2:29Yeah.
- 2:30And I'm going to go out on a limb and say like an ostrich is pretty unique looking.
- 2:36So I would think that if you saw an ostrich it would be, I mean if I saw the shadow of
- 2:42an ostrich that would be freaky.
- 2:43I mean I don't like birds so it's like one of my worst nightmares.
- 2:47So I wouldn't like seeing it, but I would feel like I'd be like he was in the shape
- 2:51of an ostrich because it just had like one super long neck with a bulb on the top and
- 2:57a fat body.
- 2:59The next day after this sighting, a man you may have heard of before but may not be able
- 3:05to immediately identify named Woodrow Darenberger was driving down the highway and had an
- 3:11encounter with a little entity that called itself cold.
- 3:15Ah yes, I know who we're talking about now.
- 3:18Yeah, so I just wanted to tell you that that's where that happened in conjunction in the
- 3:24timeline.
- 3:26Second encounter of the Mothman comes November 16, 1966 and I'm going to take this one right
- 3:32from the Point Pleasant Register.
- 3:34Quote, two Point Pleasant couples said today they encountered a man-sized bird-like creature
- 3:39in the TNT area about midnight last night.
- 3:42Quote, within a quote I guess because I'm quoting the article, it was a bird or something.
- 3:47It definitely wasn't a flying saucer, end quote.
- 3:50Sheriff's deputies and city police went to the scene about two o'clock in the morning
- 3:54but were unable to spot anything.
- 3:57But the two young men telling their story this morning were dead serious and asserted
- 4:01they hadn't been drinking.
- 4:03Steve Millette of 3305 Jackson Avenue, I love that they put their address in there, and Roger
- 4:09Scarberry of 809.
- 4:12This is before they came out with the term doxing, isn't it?
- 4:17It would explain a lot of how much attention these people got after people started walking
- 4:23out of the staining and stuff like that.
- 4:27And Roger Scarberry of 809 30th Street described the thing as being six or seven feet tall,
- 4:33having a wind span of 10 feet and red eyes about two inches in diameter and six inches
- 4:39apart.
- 4:40It was like a man with wings, Millette said.
- 4:42Oh that was a quote, re-quote.
- 4:44It wasn't like anything you'd see on TV or in a monster movie, end quote.
- 4:48The men and their wives were in Scarberry's car between 11.30pm and midnight, and they
- 4:53spotted the creature near the old power plant adjacent to the National Guard Armory Buildings.
- 4:59Creature was seen standing on three occasions and was described as being extremely fast.
- 5:04In brackets it flew about 100 miles an hour, in brackets, in flight, but was a clumsy runner.
- 5:11That's weird.
- 5:12What?
- 5:13I just think it's ripped.
- 5:15Yeah, it must have.
- 5:20Deputy Millert Halstead said that he had seen dust in the vicinity of a quilt field, but
- 5:26it could have been caused by a bird, he said.
- 5:29I'm a hard guy to scare, Scarberry said, but last night I was four getting out of there.
- 5:35They did just that, but the thing followed them.
- 5:38They said it was hovering the car apparently gliding until they reached the National Guard
- 5:42Armory on Route 62.
- 5:44But we went downtown, turned around, and went back, and there it is again, Millette said.
- 5:49It seemed to be waiting on us.
- 5:51He said the light gray light creature then scurried through a field, it had flown across
- 5:56the top of the car.
- 5:57It apparently is afraid of light, Millette reasoned, and maybe it thought it was scaring
- 6:01us off.
- 6:02The young men said they saw the creature's eyes, which glowed red only when their light
- 6:07shone on him, and it seemed to want to get away from the lights.
- 6:11They said it looked like a man with wings, but that the head was not an outstanding characteristic.
- 6:16Chelsea, is this a good point to bring up just a statement that they have all described
- 6:23it as bird-like?
- 6:24Yeah.
- 6:25Like they're all man-like birds, or bird-like men.
- 6:29Not one person has said like insect-like.
- 6:32No.
- 6:33Okay.
- 6:34No, because I think most people compare it to they see a man, but then it spreads its
- 6:38wings and take off.
- 6:39Just generally.
- 6:40I don't think I've ever heard anyone compare it to an insect.
- 6:44Yeah, and I'm just thinking.
- 6:45It's always man-shaped, and then there's wings.
- 6:48Yeah, and bird wings.
- 6:50Yeah, like bat wings.
- 6:51And what year are we talking about here?
- 6:54This would be 1960s.
- 6:571966.
- 6:58Okay, this is right around the time that the comic book character Birdman came out.
- 7:06He was in 67.
- 7:08They name it after, I can't remember.
- 7:12You would think I would have it in this episode, but it's not.
- 7:15It's a superhero that they name it after.
- 7:19Mothman?
- 7:20Like a mix between Batman and something else they name it after.
- 7:25It's actually somebody that works at one of the newspapers that names it Mothman.
- 7:29But yeah, everybody says man-shaped, and then it'll just take off, and it spreads its wings.
- 7:36They said it looked like, quote, man with wings, but that they have with not-not-standing
- 7:41characteristic.
- 7:42Both were slightly paled and tired from lack of sleep during the night following their
- 7:45harrowing experience.
- 7:47They speculated that the thing was living in the vacant power plant, possibly in one
- 7:51of the huge boilers.
- 7:52Quote, there are pigeons in all the other buildings, and quote, Mollette said.
- 7:57Re-quote, but not that one.
- 7:59End quote.
- 8:00If I had seen it while by myself, I wouldn't have said anything, Scarberry commented, but
- 8:04there were four of us who thought.
- 8:06They said it didn't resemble a bat in any way, but maybe what you would visualize as
- 8:11an angel.
- 8:12The last time they saw it at the gate of the CC Lewis Farm on Route 62.
- 8:17They heard a sound like wings flapping, and they said the bird rose straight up like a
- 8:21helicopter.
- 8:22If this doesn't have an explanation to it, Mollette said, it was an animal, but nothing
- 8:26like I've seen before.
- 8:28Are they going back to look for the creature?
- 8:30Yes, Mollette said.
- 8:31This afternoon and again tonight.
- 8:34Today's Scarberry said, but tonight I don't know.
- 8:37So that'll set the scene for you about kinda what's going on in Point Pleasant at the time.
- 8:43We actually haven't talked about this yet.
- 8:45I love the Mothman.
- 8:47It has the math man.
- 8:49I don't think you like the math man.
- 8:51Totally different guy.
- 8:52But we've never covered this Mothman before.
- 8:58I love Mothman, and I've done the Illinois Mothman because I hadn't heard of them.
- 9:04This guy's the famous one, the original one coming out of Point Pleasant.
- 9:08That's the background.
- 9:09Well, I think it's very good of us to get to it within the first four years of the podcast.
- 9:15Are we in your five?
- 9:16Yeah, it could come immediately.
- 9:17Oh.
- 9:18No, all the big ones you guys want, we're alluding to and will come at some point.
- 9:22Yeah, exactly.
- 9:24That kinda sets the scene for you for what's going on.
- 9:27Gray Barker writes the first book on the Mothman, and it's called The Silver Bridge.
- 9:32He writes it about the goings on in West Virginia, and he writes it in 1970, which is five years
- 9:39prior to the Mothman prophecies coming out in 1975.
- 9:43I read that one too.
- 9:45Keel's Mothman prophecies accounts of his investigation into the alleged sightings of
- 9:50a large wing creature known as the Mothman in the vicinity of Point Pleasant, West Virginia
- 9:55during 1966 and 1967.
- 9:58Gray combines these accounts with his series about UFOs and various supernatural phenomena,
- 10:04ultimately connecting them to the collapse of the Silver Bridge across the Ohio River
- 10:08December 15, 1967.
- 10:11Official investigations in 1971 determined the bridge collapse was caused by stress-corrosion
- 10:17cracking in an eye bar in a suspension chain.
- 10:20Okay, so the official response was not Moth people.
- 10:23No.
- 10:24Okay.
- 10:25It was never.
- 10:26Nope.
- 10:27It was years and years ago, and I was never able to get very far through it.
- 10:31I got a subscription to Audible and thought, I've heard so many great things about this
- 10:35book.
- 10:36Everything I've heard has been that it's a great book.
- 10:38I thought maybe listening would be better.
- 10:40I don't think that it necessarily was.
- 10:43I got through it.
- 10:44The guy said, enthusiast funny.
- 10:46It came up way more than you would think in this book.
- 10:49It's a well-used word in the book.
- 10:53He calls them enthusiasts.
- 10:54Ah, and sir, who are the enthusiasts?
- 10:58UFO enthusiasts.
- 11:00Oh, okay.
- 11:01He uses the word a lot.
- 11:04That's my review of the Audible, by the way.
- 11:07Not bad.
- 11:08Use the word.
- 11:10Now that I've had time to actually process what I read and taken a great amount of media
- 11:16and other books and TV show, well, media includes all of those, about the Mothman prophecies,
- 11:23I think I had a hard time with getting into it as well as wrapping my head around the
- 11:28Audible book because it wasn't necessarily what I was expecting, especially after seeing
- 11:33the movie, which I'll talk about in a second, which is right now.
- 11:37So Richard Geer doesn't come up in the book at all, I take it?
- 11:41Or what's his name?
- 11:42The guy from Shameless.
- 11:43What the hell's that guy?
- 11:44He's the guy who dies.
- 11:45Oh, did you just spoil Shameless for me?
- 11:48No, he dies in Mothman prophecy.
- 11:50Oh, oh, that's little Patton.
- 11:52Yeah, the guy in Fargo, right?
- 11:55Who's the guy in Fargo?
- 11:56I don't think it's Will Patton.
- 11:59Let me look at his name.
- 12:00Will Patton was just in the TV show I really liked, Oder Range.
- 12:04It is.
- 12:05I don't think it's Will Patton.
- 12:08It's William H. Macy.
- 12:10The Mothman prophecies book is not one complete story.
- 12:15It's not an easy linear story to follow, such as the movie had me expecting.
- 12:20Is William H. Macy not in Mothman prophecies?
- 12:23Do I have him confused with somebody?
- 12:25No, you're thinking of the wrong guy.
- 12:26Yeah, I am.
- 12:27Don't think you say that.
- 12:28Google Will Patton.
- 12:30Oh, that guy.
- 12:32Yeah, yeah, I definitely have the wrong guy.
- 12:35He was in Remember the Titans.
- 12:37Yes, he is.
- 12:38I've never seen Shameless so I had no idea.
- 12:42I disagreed with you.
- 12:44So with all that being said, I wouldn't mind reading it again now knowing what I know and
- 12:50taking it all in again.
- 12:52This time I would read it.
- 12:53Not that I haven't kind of read it based on my notes throughout a book.
- 12:57The book was widely popularized as the basis of a 2002 movie called The Mothman Prophecies,
- 13:05which stars Richard Gere, Will Patton, like we were just talking about.
- 13:08Not Macy.
- 13:09That's how I knew his name so quick.
- 13:11Nope, not him.
- 13:13He was in Fargo.
- 13:14Laura Linney and Ellen Bates and I don't know why everybody keeps not mentioning Deborah
- 13:21Messing, but she's in it too.
- 13:23Only briefly though, maybe that's why.
- 13:24Is she the one who has a dream?
- 13:26She's the one that dies in the beginning.
- 13:28Oh, oh right.
- 13:292002, I'm not ruining anything.
- 13:32Well, you can't ruin the first five minutes of a movie.
- 13:35Yeah.
- 13:36Straight out.
- 13:37That came out in 2002.
- 13:38The whole home movie.
- 13:40So Gere and Bates played two parts in Keele's personality, Bates' character is named Leak,
- 13:45which is Keele spelled backwards, and Gere's newspaper journalist character is called John
- 13:50Clime, also a play on Keele's name.
- 13:53Taylor.
- 13:54Yes.
- 13:55You've seen the movie?
- 13:56Yeah, it's a Christmas movie.
- 13:58Yeah.
- 13:59You know, now that you mention it, it is.
- 14:01What do you think of it?
- 14:03From what I remember, it was pretty good.
- 14:04Based on your really good memory of it.
- 14:07Yeah, my, William H. Macy was fantastic in it.
- 14:12It's a shame he had to die.
- 14:14I don't really know what to tell you.
- 14:16Like, their Ingrid Cole is probably a little overrepresented for what he actually had
- 14:21as a relationship in the whole thing.
- 14:23But overall, not a bad movie.
- 14:24Richard Gere and his prime.
- 14:26So.
- 14:27I will say that it was my first introduction to the Mothman.
- 14:32Yeah, me too.
- 14:33So, as we grew up together.
- 14:35Yes, we were both introduced to Mothman through the Mothman Prophecies movie.
- 14:42Reading the Mothman prophecies and having started out being very familiar, 2002.
- 14:49So it came out when I was like going into high school and reading the book so far after
- 14:55it came out.
- 14:56After being a huge fan of Mothman, I was actually impressed that most major things in the book
- 15:04are covered in the movie.
- 15:06Not necessarily how they're covered in the book, but the first story that I told you,
- 15:11well, the third story that I told you in the beginning is in the movie.
- 15:17A lot of things do make it into the movie.
- 15:20And I will say the movie is much more cohesive than the book is.
- 15:25I was really impressed because most everything that's in the movie is in the book.
- 15:29They just took key points, made it into, you know, they made it a linear story that they
- 15:35can actually sell to the public.
- 15:38Yeah, exactly.
- 15:39That being said, there's like, Indring Cold isn't the same, but interactions that Will
- 15:45Patton has with Indring Cold, while they weren't necessarily interactions that Woodrow Darenberger
- 15:53actually have with Indring Cold, they are themes that are in the book.
- 15:57And you'll see through some of the things that I go through in these episodes that as
- 16:00well.
- 16:01You're going to see some things, if you can remember the movie, come up in this that are
- 16:05just presented a little differently.
- 16:07He'll also said that he was pleased with director Mark Linton's interpretation of the
- 16:12book.
- 16:13Quote, they got a lot of stuff in the book into the movie, but with slight variations.
- 16:16I have no real complaints about it.
- 16:18It's Hollywood and it's done well.
- 16:20That's my feeling about it.
- 16:22I actually would give a similar review.
- 16:24They did do a good job and a lot of the stories did make it in the movie.
- 16:28Like I said, I agree.
- 16:29I have to say it's probably one of the best book to movie renditions.
- 16:33I do have some thoughts on the book.
- 16:35I read a synopsis of the book above to you.
- 16:39I mean, previously throughout, if you rewind a little bit, I read it.
- 16:44And I have to honestly say I would not say it is an accurate one, but it's not.
- 16:50I would summarize the book as being more about general heist strangeness than specifically
- 16:56the mothman.
- 16:57And while the moth person does come up, I found there to be much more information on
- 17:02the men in black, UFO encounters and contactees or random thoughts and encounters where I
- 17:08think keel is just trying to work out what's going on and he's trying to tie all the weird
- 17:15information he's getting together.
- 17:17And to that effect, I believe that's why they end up bringing the bridge into the storyline
- 17:23and tying it to mothman because it gives the mothman a purpose and a closure, which is
- 17:28much more comfortable to the human brain for there to have been a purpose behind the sightings
- 17:33and what happened.
- 17:34So in the book, is there less of a connection?
- 17:37No, there's the same connection.
- 17:39Oh, okay.
- 17:40They do tie it together with things.
- 17:42I don't really get into it.
- 17:44But like I said, I think it's just much more of a comfortable thing for people's brains
- 17:49to wrap their head around a tragedy as well as the really super weird things that were
- 17:55going on.
- 17:56Okay.
- 17:57So yeah, the book jumps around a lot.
- 17:59He brings in other people's work and sightings from around the world.
- 18:03I think, like I said, in an attempt to make sense of what's going on, I'm not 100% sure
- 18:10where he was getting some of his information from that he brings into the book because
- 18:14there was a large amount of information taken from elsewhere that wasn't noted.
- 18:19A lot of the book is second hand info.
- 18:21That being said, he does have a lot of witness accounts too that he works on.
- 18:25And Gray Barker also pulls from John Keel's witnesses that he uses in his Silver Bridge
- 18:31book.
- 18:32To be honest, I don't know that I have heard of any other experiences of such a large amount
- 18:38of centralized weirdness going on, such as what is put together in this book that is
- 18:43happening to an entire region other than to say Skinwalker Ranch.
- 18:48But yeah, that's not quite as populated.
- 18:51Yeah, it's more localized in Skinwalker Ranch and West Virginia, I would say, what
- 18:57Keel's reporting on is less weird, but still like weirder in a wider area covered.
- 19:04So I would compare them kind of the same and I hear a lot of comparisons to the two works
- 19:09in all my stuff that I've been taking in.
- 19:11This has been a long time coming and all I've been doing is like living and breathing the
- 19:16Mothman prophecies and the Mothman.
- 19:19Something that wasn't in the book that I found out from the Coast to Coast AM episode with
- 19:24Art Bell that John Keel was on, he did like a little interview prior to the Mothman prophecies
- 19:30coming out.
- 19:31The same day he did the interview that it came out and he told Art Bell.
- 19:36Way back in the day, wow.
- 19:38Yeah, yeah.
- 19:39So he tells Art Bell that what brought Keel to West Virginia in the first place was to
- 19:45investigate Thomas, the Wing Cat.
- 19:48So that's a fun tin bit for you.
- 19:50That's not in the book.
- 19:51That's why he's just there.
- 19:52Oh man, is that a future episode?
- 19:55Yeah.
- 19:56Oh my God.
- 19:58We could do like Bat Boy, Thomas the Wing Cat, like you know those, what are they called?
- 20:04Like, oh, I don't know, but they were the weekly world news stuff.
- 20:08Yeah.
- 20:09Yeah.
- 20:10Oh, we could do an episode on those guys.
- 20:11The major thing that stuck out to me is that a witness statements and general high-straightness
- 20:18happenings.
- 20:19Keel tells more like a story than an actual witness account, what people are wearing,
- 20:25the color of their skin, how good looking an individual was, inner monologues of people
- 20:31that you wouldn't possibly think he could know or that they would divulge to him.
- 20:37Do they all think he's really attractive and cool?
- 20:40Yeah.
- 20:41He thought, man, Keel's so cool and good looking.
- 20:46Details that are totally irrelevant to eyewitness and countertest emojis.
- 20:51And on that thought, there were many unnecessary sexual undertones.
- 20:55It made me uncomfortable listening to it because you don't really get that in books anymore
- 21:01unless you're listening to like one of those, you know, spicy books, which I don't listen
- 21:07to.
- 21:08I assume Keel's not writing.
- 21:10Yeah, no.
- 21:11This is the Mopin prophecies.
- 21:13He definitely writes it to be like a story, but it's not.
- 21:19It has true witness accounts in it and stuff like that.
- 21:22So that was also hard for me to wrap my head around.
- 21:25That being said, this book definitely shows its age, not only in language, but also the
- 21:30way that the information is presented.
- 21:32And you can tell Keel is trying to connect the dots where he should have just let them
- 21:38not be connected because, you know, you're trying to connect and make a connection.
- 21:43It was just kind of scrambled.
- 21:45That being said, the information is mostly still relevant in the field.
- 21:49Again, look at Skin Blocker Ranch.
- 21:52People haven't been able to connect stuff like this.
- 21:55There's no unifying theory.
- 21:57That sets you up for the book.
- 21:59Now I have the Mothman on the way.
- 22:01I want to get into some of the various other themes that Keel delves into in his book.
- 22:05So first off, do you have any questions about the book?
- 22:08General questions.
- 22:09So is it written in like a very misogynist way?
- 22:13Yeah.
- 22:14Yeah.
- 22:15I don't know what I'm getting from Keel here.
- 22:19I guess is there chapters or is it just like stream consciousness?
- 22:23So there's chapters and then the chapters are divided into parts.
- 22:29So this is why I had to.
- 22:32It took me a good, you know, I read this over Thanksgiving, which the timeline is not going
- 22:37to make sense for this coming out when it does.
- 22:40I read it over Thanksgiving.
- 22:41I feel like I've only just now, like within the last month, kind of put it together in
- 22:46my head where I want to read it again because I was expecting something so different.
- 22:51So it took me a while to figure it out in my head.
- 22:54But now I do think it's a good book.
- 22:57There's lots of cool stuff in it.
- 22:58There's lots of different encounters.
- 23:00I love the high strangeness components to it.
- 23:04But yeah, some of the observations in it didn't age well.
- 23:11It's interesting to hear just like, you know, you watch old TV shows and it's like kids
- 23:17today think it's weird that they don't have cell phones and stuff like that.
- 23:20I know it's actually kind of funny that like if you watch shows from like mid to late 2000s,
- 23:26they're grasping with that idea that they actually have to write about people always
- 23:29constantly having cell phones and like a trope of TV shows for the longest time was like,
- 23:34oh, they can't find each other or somebody's missing.
- 23:37So they have to find ways to write around people just very easily being able to get out
- 23:41of that situation.
- 23:43Yeah.
- 23:44So kind of like that.
- 23:47But very different.
- 23:48Yes.
- 23:49Yeah.
- 23:50So first up, we're going to talk about the Men in Black.
- 23:54Keel actually invented the term Men in Black in an article for the Men's Adventure Magazine
- 24:00Saga published 1967.
- 24:01I love those Men's Adventure Magazine.
- 24:03There are.
- 24:04Yes, we talked about in the first half.
- 24:06Weird, right?
- 24:07Yeah.
- 24:08Keel comes up in it.
- 24:09If I had to rename this book anything, it would be Men in Black because it's such a strong
- 24:15theme throughout the book.
- 24:16I was left feeling sometimes that the people he was referring to sometimes might not have
- 24:22been Men in Black based on the descriptions given.
- 24:25He develops a really complicated relationship with the Men in Black throughout the book,
- 24:31which will kind of discover.
- 24:32Is that the sexual undertones?
- 24:34He's coming to terms that he's that's why he's pursuing the Men in Black.
- 24:40There are some sexual undertones stuck up with the Men in Black.
- 24:44Yes.
- 24:45No.
- 24:46Keel says, referring to the Men in Black quote, there were a few that almost pulled off their
- 24:51capers without drawing attention to themselves.
- 24:54But in nearly every case, there is always some small error and slip of dress or behavior
- 24:59which the witnesses were usually willing to overlook but which stood out like signal
- 25:05flares to me.
- 25:07That being said, he does present more information than I think I've ever heard or seen on the
- 25:12Men in Black, which is interesting and a little bit creepy, including that they drink
- 25:18Jell-O instead of, you know, eating it with a spoon.
- 25:22Yeah.
- 25:23That they drove old out of date pristine cars.
- 25:26The dress appeared to include everything brand new, shoes, pants, wallets, even walking through
- 25:33mud with no mud appearing on brand new shoes.
- 25:37Clothing out of fashion or would come into fashion years later.
- 25:40They used very old slings such as 23 Skidew or Haba Haba.
- 25:48They would claim to be military with no military knowledge.
- 25:52I'd be very curious what the military knowledge was if it's like they saw a gun and it's like
- 25:58what's that?
- 25:59Yeah, it was actually.
- 26:01No, don't call me on anything because I'm not going to be able to think of a single example
- 26:06if you do that.
- 26:07I really like that idea though.
- 26:08I'm from the military.
- 26:09What's that?
- 26:11Come up often in conjunction with people who had witnessed a UFO or an inhabitants if
- 26:16asked and would show up on the doorstep of contactees who had not yet revealed their
- 26:21encounter with anyone.
- 26:22Thus, the suspicious nature.
- 26:25They offered contactees pills.
- 26:28Some had wires sticking out of their pant legs.
- 26:31I do have the story.
- 26:32I think it's too long of a story to read right now.
- 26:35When you say offered pills, is it literally just here?
- 26:37Have some pills?
- 26:38Yeah, so they had gone to the house of, I knew this was going to come up, but I didn't
- 26:44prepare for it.
- 26:45They had gone to the house of a contactee and offered her a pill.
- 26:49They gave her two pills actually and they said take one now and then take one imprecisely
- 26:54however many hours later.
- 26:57She did take the pill and then she ended up telling it must have been Keele because it
- 27:02made it into the book and they had it tested and it was something ordinary.
- 27:07I wish I could tell you right now.
- 27:10Something like that.
- 27:11Yeah, still super straight.
- 27:15Some had wires sticking out of their pant legs in this story.
- 27:19They show up at the house of a contactee and this man is looking very strange.
- 27:26It's always something that's just out of the ordinary, very well dressed, like bulgy eyes.
- 27:33This guy says that he needs to come into their house because somebody had passed away in
- 27:37their family and they just wanted to verify that he was actually the person of the loved
- 27:44one that had died in another state.
- 27:46So he needs to come in for precisely 40 minutes and ask some questions.
- 27:51So he goes in and he's asking the contactee questions that are very personal about like
- 27:58any identifying marks on his body and stuff like that where he went to school.
- 28:05Very personal stuff.
- 28:06The wife asks him if he needs a glass of water, if he'd like some coffee or anything
- 28:11like that and he says he'll take a glass of water but that he would take it in 10 minutes.
- 28:17It was a very precise amount of time.
- 28:19So in that time he keeps talking and he is getting more flush and flush and uncomfortable
- 28:25as he continues talking.
- 28:27At that 10 minutes is up he says I'll take that glass of water now.
- 28:31He takes a pill to which all the symptoms appear to be relieved and he continues on
- 28:38and right at the 45 minute mark that he had said or 40 minutes, whatever it is, he gets
- 28:43up and leaves and they are all talking at the end about how weird the encounter was
- 28:50and they had all noticed that he had wires sticking out of his panty that they talk about
- 28:55after and then they look out the window when he leaves and he's gone.
- 29:01No car was ever in the driver or anything and the guy just disappears.
- 29:05So anyhow they get a call weeks later being like yeah he wasn't the guy.
- 29:12He'll believed he was being watched closely by the men in black and at one point he'll
- 29:17stop making appointments and plans just because it seemed like people would be knowing about
- 29:23plans and meetings that he had.
- 29:26Random contactees when he was interviewing them would comment on meetings that he would
- 29:31have in the future and stuff like that which he thought was very weird.
- 29:35So he ends up stopping planning his life and he just does everything on a whim and he just
- 29:40starts like stopping by previous contactees houses.
- 29:44He'll just go about his day drive past and be like this guy's a contactee and stop by
- 29:48because he wanted to get out of this where people would be able to know about what's
- 29:53going on because he's keeping appointments and stuff like that.
- 29:57Once he did that in a bit to reclaim some of his privacy, Keele says they were always
- 30:02still a step ahead of him even when he didn't know himself what he was doing, what hotel
- 30:07he was staying at, where he was going in the day and stuff like that.
- 30:12Contactees would receive phone calls from Keele's secretary that contactees would relate their
- 30:16experience to about their encounter and Keele did not have a secretary.
- 30:21He would show up to interview the contactee and he'd be like what secretary?
- 30:26That's what he talks about as just a brief rundown of men and black encounters in the
- 30:32book.
- 30:33Yeah, that's enough that you wonder why he decided to just go with Mothman as the title
- 30:38of the book.
- 30:39Yeah, I wondered that too.
- 30:41It's pretty huge in the book.
- 30:42There's a lot going on with the men in black and it evolved as it goes on.
- 30:48He has a very complicated relationship with the men in black.
- 30:53Now I'm going to move on to Indra Cold and the grinning men.
- 30:56We have done a whole episode on Indra Cold and to my dismay I've left some stuff out
- 31:02so I get a second chance.
- 31:04Lucky me.
- 31:05And in preparation for this episode I told you I took in a lot of Mothman media.
- 31:10I read Woodrow Darenberger's book Visitors to Lanulos which is the story of Woodrow and
- 31:17his contact with Indra Cold.
- 31:20He did go on to visit the planet Cold was from named Lanulos in case you needed that
- 31:25spelled out.
- 31:26I don't know that I talked about that in an episode.
- 31:32So he's from Lanulos and Darenberger actually goes to Lanulos.
- 31:36So Woodrow and Cold contact each other.
- 31:40Well Cold contacts Darenberger primarily through telepathy.
- 31:45Well Woodrow would get a tingling sensation in his forehead and then receive thoughts
- 31:50from Cold into his mind that would explain different things such as what Lanulos was
- 31:55like and that the people there lived to be 125 to 175 earth years and then upon completion
- 32:02of the conversation I guess you could call it.
- 32:05Cold withdrawals from Woodrow's reign I guess and he describes it being very painful like
- 32:12sharp pains on his temple and Cold always says to prepare for it because it's going
- 32:16to be painful.
- 32:17End quote.
- 32:18No that wasn't a quote.
- 32:19The quote ended before I commented on it.
- 32:22Not the issues with quoting.
- 32:24I've never heard it described as like painful telepathy.
- 32:27Yeah it had to have been a little bit more than telepathy at that point I think.
- 32:33Woodrow and those around him also had experiences with the men in black.
- 32:38Salesmen went door to door around the small town.
- 32:41He's actually from just outside of Point Pleasant and salesmen are in around that town
- 32:46selling different things at each door like when it would be bibles the next door would
- 32:51be vacuums and they would be asking about Woodrow and the validity of his alleged account.
- 32:57They were asking about him in the end I guess and they're just being super weird.
- 33:02Those men in black are weird.
- 33:04Another interesting thing about Indra Cold is that there are cooperating stories.
- 33:10Not only did someone witness Darren Burger pulled to the side of the highway speaking
- 33:14with someone the night that he met Indra Cold on the same night as Darren Burger's experience
- 33:19we have this one that I'm going to read right from the book and I'm going to open it up.
- 33:24Turn the light on because I'm too old to not have the light on to read this.
- 33:28On November 2nd 19th do you hear that?
- 33:30That's the book.
- 33:31Good work.
- 33:32That's how you know it's true.
- 33:36On November 2nd 1966 he said he and another workman this is telling the story here I
- 33:42don't know let's just say he doesn't want to give his name at this point because I don't
- 33:46know who does.
- 33:47He and another workman were driving home to Point Pleasant from their job near Marietta,
- 33:52Ohio on Interstate 77.
- 33:55As they neared Parkersburg, West Virginia an elongated object appeared low in the sky
- 34:01and descended directly in front of them.
- 34:03They stopped their car and a man emerged from the object and walked over to them.
- 34:08He looked like a normal man and was grinning broadly.
- 34:11He wore a black coat and kept his arms folded with his hands out of sight under his armpits.
- 34:15That's such a weird thing to do.
- 34:19The witness rolled his windows down and there was a brief conversation.
- 34:23The stranger asked the pair who they were, where they were from, where they were going
- 34:26and what time it was.
- 34:28Then he strolled back to the dark cylinder and it rose quickly into the chill drizzling
- 34:32sky.
- 34:33The two men had a strong emotional reaction to the seemingly pointless encounter.
- 34:38They debated whether they should tell anybody deciding against it, but the Point Pleasant
- 34:42resident found himself suffering from insomnia and when he finally slept he had strange nightmares.
- 34:47He started to hit the bottle, something very unusual for him.
- 34:51Mrs. Hyer, we're going to talk about her in the next episode, listened to a story,
- 34:56non-plussed and made a few notes.
- 34:58A day or so later, the man's son called on her and asked her not to print the story.
- 35:03Several weeks later, she repeated the story to me and we called the man on her office
- 35:07phone.
- 35:08He verified the details and then said, quote, look, don't use my name, I don't want to
- 35:12get involved in this thing.
- 35:14That scientist fella told me.
- 35:16What scientist fella?
- 35:18That's Keele.
- 35:19He's asking what scientist?
- 35:20And then the guy continues a couple of weeks after this thing happened, a scientist from
- 35:24Ohio came to see us.
- 35:26He told us it would be better if we forgot the whole thing and Keele says, how did he
- 35:30hear about it?
- 35:31How did he find you?
- 35:33And the guy says, damn, if I know, and Keele says, did he identify himself?
- 35:37And he continues, sure, but I can't remember his name, but he seemed to know what he was
- 35:42talking about.
- 35:43Keele goes on, I couldn't, this is just his thoughts now, I couldn't get much else
- 35:47out of him.
- 35:48I would have ignored the whole story except for one drawing fact, the same thing had happened
- 35:51the same night on the same road to another West Virginian.
- 35:55Unlike the two point pleasant residence, he had gone to the police with a story, a press
- 35:59conference was held and he was catapulted into the Never Neverland of the UFO contactees,
- 36:04the center of one of the biggest UFO stories in 1966.
- 36:09And that's Woodrow Derenberger with Indra Kolt.
- 36:12So you think that's weird enough?
- 36:14That was the same night as Derenberger meets Indra Kolt.
- 36:17There's more.
- 36:18The young college student from Adelphi, Maryland called Tom in the book.
- 36:23He was driving home and sees a large object in the road, specifically a bone white reflective
- 36:29object like an egg standing on four legs.
- 36:32He pulls up to the object and he can make out two figures standing next to the thing
- 36:37and terrify him.
- 36:38There's another word there that I spelled wrong and I can't make it out.
- 36:42A man walks up to his car grinning.
- 36:44It was about 5'10", where light blue coveralls, thick stole boots and had a ruddy or sun tan
- 36:50complexion with large eyes like thyroid eyes he says.
- 36:54And the grin remained fixed the whole interaction.
- 36:56I've never heard the term thyroid eyes.
- 36:59Thyroid eyes are bulging eyes.
- 37:01Okay.
- 37:02This man tells Tom his name is Daddig and asks him random questions about where he's
- 37:08from, where he's going, whatever.
- 37:10Valding says to Tom, I'll see you in time and peace is the fuck out.
- 37:16Thyroid makes more appearances to Tom throughout some amount of time and is actually taken
- 37:21to Daddig's planet.
- 37:23Wait for it, Lanulos.
- 37:25Tom shares this with his college roommates and gets a hard time about it.
- 37:30And it wasn't until they were all watching, this is a much longer story in the book by
- 37:34the way, it wasn't until they were all watching TV together and happened to come across an
- 37:39interview of Woodrow Derenberger on the TV where he's speaking about Indra Cold and
- 37:45Lanulos.
- 37:47And all four were flabbergasted to hear Woody describe the experiences that were identical
- 37:53to Tom's.
- 37:54Oh.
- 37:55Isn't that weird?
- 37:56That is weird.
- 37:57This is the first time I've ever heard of Lanulos and the fact that two people have the same
- 38:00story is interesting, I will say.
- 38:02So what are you more blown away by Lanulos than that you never heard of it before or the
- 38:07cooperating episode?
- 38:08Uh, I think Lanulos, just the fact that it's like so out there.
- 38:13Like we've heard of tons of planets that have been brought up as like things aliens say
- 38:17they're from there and even places that people get taken.
- 38:20But like, Lanulos for the first time.
- 38:22Yeah, Keel does go on to say that he wouldn't have put that much stock in Woodrow Derenberger's
- 38:29encounter with Indra Cold and even continuing because his contact with Indra Cold does different
- 38:37from other contactee encounters that he's having in the book.
- 38:41So he said based on that, he wasn't putting much stock on it, except that it's so corroborated.
- 38:47Not only people seeing Derenberger parked on the highway speaking to Indra Cold, but
- 38:52there's two more encounters with grinning men that happen.
- 38:56One is with the same exact planet and the other is another grinning man that happens
- 39:02the same exact night.
- 39:03Like that's, that's more than a coincidence to me, which I would agree.
- 39:08For Indra Cold, that one's a little bit out there as far as believable contactee reports.
- 39:14But again, at the time, this is not something that was following sci-fi movies and stuff
- 39:19like that.
- 39:20It would have been out there to even fabricate.
- 39:24So the grinning men, as you may gather from what I just said, are apparently a phenomenon
- 39:29of contacts with extraterrestrials that differ from Indra Cold.
- 39:35Yes, I know when I did the Indra Cold episode, there were a couple more, but it wasn't anything
- 39:41crazy.
- 39:42Keele says it's a little bit more than that, and he's talking to a witness here.
- 39:46Quote, one night when I was walking home to my apartment, I became aware of a man following
- 39:51me.
- 39:52When I looked at him, he stopped and grinned at me, but there was an air of evil about
- 39:57him.
- 39:58I can't pinpoint it exactly.
- 39:59Quote, Keele responds, quote, was he possibly some kind of sex deviant?
- 40:05Good question.
- 40:06Very necessary question.
- 40:07I don't know what you're talking about.
- 40:08A very unnecessary weird sexual comment I told you about.
- 40:13Yeah.
- 40:14Quote, no, I don't think so.
- 40:18He was short and sly and wore a black coat and black trousers.
- 40:22His face was dark and foreign looking.
- 40:24I don't know why, but the evil grin is burned into my memory.
- 40:28Quote, Keele goes on to say that the foolishly grinning man is a staple item of psychic lore.
- 40:35Black suited with a dark complexion and craggy foreign face.
- 40:39He has been described to me in many places and by many people.
- 40:44He didn't provide any stories in the book other than, you know, those three about the
- 40:49grinning man, but he kind of sums it up there saying he sees it over and over again.
- 40:53I mean, I don't look in all places.
- 40:56So there has to be more out there.
- 41:00Question mark.
- 41:01Because when I looked it up with Indra Cole, I didn't get a whole lot more stories, but
- 41:06there was quite a few in this one.
- 41:08So we're moving on from Indra Cole now to contactees.
- 41:12Quote, when you entered the unreal, this is Keele, when you entered the unreal world of
- 41:17contactees precision, prophecies and mysterious invasion of your privacy become commonplace.
- 41:24Changes seem to develop heightened perceptions, ESP and prognition.
- 41:28Is that, I'm just wondering if that's why he's able to glean what people are thinking
- 41:33throughout the book.
- 41:34Is he's getting it like secondhand from all these people?
- 41:38Yes.
- 41:39Okay.
- 41:40Yes.
- 41:41It must be.
- 41:44The changes occur almost overnight.
- 41:47In their meetings with the entities, they are served up platters of propaganda along
- 41:51with rumors and nonsense, which they accept and repeat as fact.
- 41:56Many of the choice tidbits of UFO lore were put into circulation by contactees who placed
- 42:01their complete trust in their contactors.
- 42:04Entities spun well, tales about crash saucers being confiscated by the US Air Force, farmers
- 42:10shooting and wounding spacemen and so forth.
- 42:13Contactees repeated the stories to wild-eyed UFO enthusiasts and certainly spread in ever-widening
- 42:20circles until they appeared in articles and books.
- 42:23Daren Berger never claimed psychic powers.
- 42:26He said he received telepathic messages from cold, giving him specific information.
- 42:32Uri Geller claimed that his psychic abilities came from space intelligences.
- 42:37He became world famous after his alleged contact with a flying saucer on a desert in the Middle
- 42:42East.
- 42:43He has been tested by armies of scientists and parapsychologists.
- 42:46Yeah, we've talked about him before.
- 42:49And he was a part of something else.
- 42:52Yeah, I'm trying to think too.
- 42:54It was an army program.
- 42:55It was remote viewing.
- 42:56Yes, remote viewing.
- 42:57Thank you.
- 42:58I was going to say it's adjacent to Men Who Stare at Goats, but yeah, you're right.
- 43:01Yeah, that's what I was thinking too.
- 43:04I always have to translate Men Who Stare at Goats into remote viewing.
- 43:08Usually contactee experiences follow certain patterns, which they are not even aware of
- 43:12at the time.
- 43:13A long series of seemingly unrelated events occur prior to the first overt contact.
- 43:19These events can begin childhood and span many years.
- 43:23Then too, most contactees have active or latent psychic abilities before contact.
- 43:28People who see ghosts or religious apparitions have the same patterns of the UFO contactees.
- 43:34And in fact, the apparitions described in religious miracles usually share the same
- 43:39physical characteristics as our UFO entities, that is long fingers, dusky complexions, and
- 43:46pointed fingers.
- 43:48Those are just, there's many contacts within this book.
- 43:52He basically, the whole book is just men in black and contactees, to be honest.
- 43:58And the Mothman comes up a couple of times.
- 44:00Well, there's more than a couple.
- 44:01Hey, there's a Mothman.
- 44:02What do you get what I'm trying to say?
- 44:03I just thought that was an interesting thought that he was getting out of boat contactees.
- 44:09Every so often you see him have a glimpse at what he's trying to put together and it's
- 44:14pretty good.
- 44:15I do like that he's making the connection between religious apparitions and UFO contactees
- 44:21in that last little bit there.
- 44:23But that's where I'm going to leave this episode on today.
- 44:27And then I'm going to leave it for a surprise on just what we're going to be talking about
- 44:31in relation to the Mothman prophecies next week.
- 44:34What do you think so far?
- 44:36Ah, there's actually more to it than I was expecting.
- 44:39I was kind of expecting it to be more bunk than it's turned out.
- 44:43Well, I think we were both surprised with the Keele episode.
- 44:46Yes, just with that background and the fact that from what I've heard, yeah, he's not
- 44:50the best investigator.
- 44:52No, and you can tell I have my critiques in the next episode spoiler alert.
- 44:59But aside from the way he tells his stories and the way he does kind of lead his witnesses,
- 45:07which again, next episode, it's really entertaining.
- 45:11He has some good stuff in there and I can't fault him for wanting to make it a good read.
- 45:18You know, he was just generally a good writer before this.
- 45:24He wasn't a UFO investigator.
- 45:27He was a propagandist.
- 45:29So you could see why he would bring something like that into this.
- 45:33It does make it more enjoyable.
- 45:36To me, it sticks out like a sore thumb and you can kind of read around it.
- 45:40But still an enjoyable book.
- 45:42I like the topic.
- 45:43I love the stuff he's talking about.
- 45:45So I don't know what to say about it in the end.
- 45:49And plus, these people are all contactees and haven't had their experiences.
- 45:54So it's not like he was making it up.
- 45:56He was just, you know, adding his Keele flair to it.
- 46:00Well, and you got to think if he's trying to draft a narrative into a linear story,
- 46:04well, not necessarily a linear but a story nonetheless, he's not going to necessarily,
- 46:09I don't know, this might be, I didn't read it, but I could be completely off base.
- 46:14But he's not going to ask as tough of questions as he might need to to actually see if it's
- 46:18a legit case, if it's aligning with what he already has.
- 46:22I don't know because I didn't read it.
- 46:24So you'll have to.
- 46:25Yeah, but the thing with that is he doesn't know what he has.
- 46:31That's fair.
- 46:32But like for the most part, when we're looking at like cryptids and whatnot, they're all
- 46:35like one off sightings.
- 46:37They're not things that really go on for that long, but his story seemed to.
- 46:41Yeah, that's something I couldn't make heads or tails of with the mothman prophecy.
- 46:47There's nothing else like this.
- 46:49There's nothing else where I mean, yeah, you get UFO flaps and stuff like that, but
- 46:54other like I said, skinwalker ranch, there's nothing else where you get such a concentrated
- 47:00area for a finite amount of time where just some really weird stuff is going on.
- 47:06And it's not happening every day all the time.
- 47:09But in the end, when you get all these people coming forward and sharing their experiences
- 47:13and people they're investigating it, it adds up to something weird happening, right?
- 47:18Like when they're investigating it.
- 47:20But where else can you say something like that happens?
- 47:23No, exactly.
- 47:24And that's why I'm wondering.
- 47:25You got mothman UFOs.
- 47:26You got men in black.
- 47:28Like where else?
- 47:30It's really sometimes.
- 47:31Please.
- 47:32Sometimes.
- 47:33Sometimes in our creature features at Halloween, there are kind of things that go on for a
- 47:38few sightings over like a week or two period.
- 47:41Yeah, but please like leave us a comment if there was anything where there was a prolonged
- 47:47presence of men in black, a prolonged presence of, you know, something like the mothman doesn't
- 47:54have to be mothman, just something that can't be explained that happens over like the period
- 47:59of a year.
- 48:00Please let us know, I would be so interested in that.
- 48:04And it makes me suspicious as to and it doesn't seem, I mean, it does happen sporadically
- 48:10still in West Virginia with mothman sightings and stuff like that, but not like that.
- 48:16So why did it just stop?
- 48:18And why right around the time he stopped investigating it, I was just going to say, and why did it
- 48:23stop?
- 48:24Like they obviously him and Gray Barker obviously didn't stay there forever.
- 48:28No.
- 48:29They didn't make it up, but why was it finite?
- 48:33Well, and especially it's not like it's not like people within this community just abandoned
- 48:38this location like this.
- 48:40It's known for this.
- 48:41Like they have mothman festivals there.
- 48:44So if there were stories, they would be sharing that.
- 48:48And if mothman love fame and fortune, he would be there.
- 48:52Like he'd show up for the festival.
- 48:55Yeah, it's a weird spot.
- 48:57I agree.
- 48:58It's weird.
- 48:59Yeah.
- 49:00And maybe that's the appeal of it as well, because that is just something you can add
- 49:04to the pile.
- 49:05The mysteriousness of it.
- 49:08Mythos.
- 49:09Yeah.
- 49:10I don't know if I use that word right.
- 49:11I guess with that, more questions will come or be answered, I guess, maybe in part three
- 49:16of this.
- 49:18So I do or do it.
- 49:19Chelsea.
- 49:20I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 49:22We are journey to the fringe.
- 49:23Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 49:26Bye.
- 49:28Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 49:30If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow,
- 49:37depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 49:40Also please, if possible, leave a five star review, as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 49:46Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 49:51I bet you we are there.
- 49:52And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 49:57us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 50:04For now, I'll see you in the next episode.