Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The World According To Irina Tsukerman (Ep 6): Kissinger, COP28, Israel & India
Transcript
- 0:18Welcome to this this new episode of The World According to IRENA
- 0:23Superman, our very special series on global politics on the
- 0:26KJ Master class slide. IRENA Superman is a US based
- 0:30national security and human rights lawyer as well as a
- 0:34renowned geopolitical analyst. Her writings and commentary have
- 0:38appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:42been translated to over a dozen languages every fortnight in the
- 0:46world according to Irena Zuckerman.
- 0:48We traversed the pure political landscape and delve into
- 0:52pressing international issues and gain insight from Arena's
- 0:56expert perspective. Welcome to the show once again,
- 0:59Arena. Thank you so much and I'm glad
- 1:07to be here as always. Thank you.
- 1:10Thank you. We, this is our 6th episode and
- 1:13again on this one we have got several big topics.
- 1:16Several things have happened in the last 15 days.
- 1:18Several things continue to happen and what the things that
- 1:23are happening, let's take that first in terms of COP 28 in UAE,
- 1:28help us understand what are the controversies and the outcomes
- 1:32so far. This is going to be there till
- 1:34December 2012. Will come more with with with
- 1:38more in the next episode. But till now what has happened.
- 1:40Help us understand on this big thing that is going on.
- 1:47Well, the entire project has been rife with controversy from
- 1:52the get go. First of all, this has been one
- 1:54of in the series that attracted both a lot of attention and a
- 1:58lot of skepticism in the last few years.
- 2:01During last year, it was held in Egypt and US and others pledged
- 2:11a lot of money, US alone, US to Egypt for fighting climate
- 2:17change. That aid is yet to materialize.
- 2:20Others pledged a lot of money to African countries.
- 2:23None of it has really come through so far.
- 2:28Also, every year there's controversy over the fact that
- 2:32billionaires, kings and CEOs of major corporations are flying in
- 2:39the private jet planes after lecturing everyone else on
- 2:45taking measures to cut emissions, which is always
- 2:50ironic. And of course the fact that this
- 2:52is in the taking place in the winter and in some cases some of
- 2:56these jet planes have been stopped by snow led to
- 3:01amusement. This particular episode, this
- 3:06particular cup 28 is taking place in UE.
- 3:09There's been controversy over the fact that it's CEO has a
- 3:15background in fossil fuels. Now his argument of course that
- 3:19is that fossil fuels have to work on in hand in any
- 3:23electrification process unless everyone is fully going nuclear,
- 3:27which is we're very far from that point.
- 3:32And his argument has has a lot of merit to be honest.
- 3:37But people, people, there is still a lot of argument over
- 3:42that and whether this goes unusually compatible and whether
- 3:45he's actually honest about his intentions.
- 3:48But so there's been argument about that.
- 3:51Meanwhile, the United Nations used this occasion to create a
- 3:54fund for climate change for fighting climate change, and a
- 3:57lot of criticism has been leveraged at the United States
- 4:01for supposedly not donating enough for the claim that it
- 4:06donated too little. After a lot of lofty rhetoric
- 4:11from Washington about this particular particular goal,
- 4:16there's also been quite a deal of quite a great deal of
- 4:19distractions because a number of countries, their leaders to this
- 4:26event and instead of focusing on energy and climate issues,
- 4:30started talking about the Israel Hamas war and basically using
- 4:35using their platforms as a soapbox for unrelated political
- 4:38statements. So that was a bit of disruption.
- 4:42The Iranian delegation left after finding out that Israel is
- 4:47the present, which was not unexpected given that UAE has
- 4:51diplomatic relations with both countries.
- 4:54But that highlights the tension of having diplomatic relations
- 4:58with the countries that not only do not have, you know, do not do
- 5:05not recognize, but one of which is dedicated to a genocide of
- 5:09the other states. So that puts you in the
- 5:12conundrum, but but the show must go on and so far it continues
- 5:17and a lot of discussions are taking place and it's going to
- 5:23be a topic for a while. So we may mention additional
- 5:26developments in the next program.
- 5:29Right, right. And what about, you know, India
- 5:32not signing the declaration, it has refused COP 21 declaration
- 5:37on climate and health. How do you see that?
- 5:40How is the world seeing that? Well, quite frankly, I think
- 5:46it's from India's perspective, this was the right thing to do.
- 5:49Because while you know all these resolutions are basically
- 5:55aspirational and all the members still have to interpret them to
- 5:59adjust to their own needs and abilities.
- 6:03In reality, even having this is an aspiration is in some way
- 6:10interacting best, especially if you have, I know especially if
- 6:15you prioritize this over your economic needs, you're not being
- 6:20honest with yourself if you're So as far as there's something
- 6:27that it could either could not deliver.
- 6:30I would only pretend to deliver just to get to international
- 6:34approval. I think.
- 6:36I think at the very least, it's not pretending to be fighting
- 6:41for some 'cause that has no relevance to its population at
- 6:44the moment. And quite frankly, I think a lot
- 6:47of these fights are symbolic rather than real introduction.
- 6:51They're real. They're often unrealistic and
- 6:53damaging. So while there may be people who
- 6:57are claiming that India by not signing is not committed to a
- 7:03cleaner environment, I don't think it's necessarily the case.
- 7:11Climate change is not in line that every country needs
- 7:16abilities and the and quite frankly not very scientific
- 7:20either. So I don't think it means that
- 7:23India is not committed to a better environment.
- 7:25I just, I just think it will go at its own rate and focus on
- 7:29issues that are practically relevant to the people who have
- 7:33to leave. Live with the consequences of
- 7:36these, of the balance of these issues.
- 7:41Absolutely. And I, by the way, don't think
- 7:42there's going to be too much. Yeah, carry on, carry.
- 7:48On. Yeah, I don't think there's
- 7:52going to be too much because I'm very because there's not much
- 7:56one can do. India is a growing giant.
- 7:59It's got over. It's got nearly a billion and a
- 8:01half population. What is?
- 8:03What do people want to say? Well, we want you to do
- 8:06something else. They can't force a country like
- 8:08that to do anything it doesn't want to do, to be doing.
- 8:12And I think the best thing they can manage is arrange, you know,
- 8:16continuing discussions over what best practices in various areas.
- 8:22And I don't thinking just against any of that.
- 8:25It never rejected such conversations.
- 8:27We're talking about the very global, very theoretical
- 8:31framework that really is not very pragmatic.
- 8:37Absolutely, absolutely. Talking about India, how do you
- 8:41look at this, you know, India, US relations in the backdrop of
- 8:46this Kalistani terrorism and all that stuff and this case an
- 8:51indictment, all those things happening with related to India
- 8:55and so-called, allegedly so-called, one of the government
- 8:59employees getting involved into, you know, some sort of alleged
- 9:04assassination plot about Gurupatwar Singh Panoon.
- 9:07He is a designated terrorist in India.
- 9:10And how do you look at that? Now there's some more dusty, you
- 9:13know, flowing in the wind because of this issue.
- 9:16How do you look at the impact of it on India, US relations?
- 9:20Where do you see this going forward?
- 9:26Well, to be honest, I think it can only have a very limited
- 9:29impact at the time because there are bigger issues.
- 9:33US is not happy with the idea of its summons being violated.
- 9:36Neither would any country in its position, including India.
- 9:39At the same time, you know the legal, the legal processes are
- 9:44pursuing themselves. The indictment has been
- 9:46unsealed. There was there was a talk that
- 9:49until the indictment would cause tensions.
- 9:53There is a lot of media speculation about whether it
- 9:56will in fact cause tensions, even disrupt the Quad, the quad
- 10:03participation. But as far as I see, what's done
- 10:07is done. What happened is happened.
- 10:09These conversations after what happened have occurred already.
- 10:13I think there's already been an agreement in in place in what
- 10:18we're seeing now is are we seeing the results playing out
- 10:27as a result of those discussions that are already in the past.
- 10:30I don't think no worsening in relations beyond what has
- 10:33happened. I think there's probably a lot
- 10:36of discussions ongoing about moving forward and how to do it
- 10:39successfully. But from India's perspective, I
- 10:42believe the wisest course of action going forward is to
- 10:46understand that part of the outrage over this controversy is
- 10:50because the individual in question, while he was perceived
- 10:54as a terrorist in a criminal in India, is virtually unknown to
- 10:59Western public, and he's certainly not designated as a
- 11:02terrorist in the United States. So part of the problem is a
- 11:06complete different legal framework in which the two
- 11:09countries operated, which made any sort of political or legal
- 11:15understanding impossible in the past, and which led to this
- 11:19dramatic confrontation. I think it should.
- 11:23That should have been avoidable. I think the wise thing going
- 11:26forward is to create an information campaign that's that
- 11:32informs the public and the US government in very publicly
- 11:38about the dangers of these Palestinian extremist groups and
- 11:42various individuals. And essentially push and lobby
- 11:45for the designation of relevant individuals, you know, as
- 11:50terrorists, putting them on sanctions list, investigating
- 11:52them for crimes, extraditing them as needed and and
- 11:57essentially taking security measures.
- 11:59This perception has to change, otherwise these problems keep
- 12:03will keep faster. Right, right.
- 12:06Staying with India, you know what's happening at Myanmar
- 12:10because Myanmar, they are all that fighting is threatening
- 12:13India's border security. How should we look at that?
- 12:17How can India do better in terms of protecting itself there?
- 12:24So India, interestingly enough, has been back in the junta in
- 12:29Myanmar, not out of any ideological proximity to them,
- 12:33but because of a sense of stability.
- 12:35Reason being, the various rebel groups that are currently rising
- 12:40up, Many of them are ethnically and religiously diverse and do
- 12:44not get along with each other. So even if the junta which is
- 12:47completely undemocratic and no one is going to claim that it's
- 12:52some wonderful government has been part of the reason is it
- 12:56has been violating various human rights of various groups.
- 13:00But it were to fall, I don't think the fighting itself would
- 13:03end. There would be still an ongoing
- 13:05power struggle. So essentially India is back in
- 13:09the Hunter is the evil scenarios unless there's a group of
- 13:14countries moving forward to sort of create some sort of a very
- 13:17responsible governance framework for these other rebel groups and
- 13:23I think that's going to change. But with now we're seeking the
- 13:27worst of two-part you know the worst of all case scenarios.
- 13:31The Hunter continues to vary. It has not been pushed to in any
- 13:36way change its ways and to accommodate different interests
- 13:40into incorporate them into some sort of a more inclusive
- 13:44governance model. And on the other hand, the
- 13:46rebels are fighting and they're being armed by various
- 13:51countries. Russia and China are playing
- 13:54both sides. They're lucratively selling
- 13:57weapons to everybody and they're doing destabilization.
- 14:02The China, ironically, is also backing the junta, but at the
- 14:06same time, certainly anything that threatens India's security
- 14:12place into the hands of its rivals, such as Beijing.
- 14:17Then another aspect of that is the Rohingya crisis, because
- 14:21India has taken out in a lot of refugees.
- 14:23But they're also concerned that any separatist movements could
- 14:27inspire and fuel additional movements like the Palestinian
- 14:32separatism in its own border. So they're concerned about the
- 14:35spillover effect of these border issues, not only of the actual
- 14:38violence, but of the political mindset that could be
- 14:42detrimental to its own domestic security.
- 14:45So they they are trying to lock down the borders and to keep a
- 14:50price of of anything that goes on and hope that the crisis will
- 14:54be resolved. But so far it's additional
- 14:58regional, local concern on top of everything else that's going
- 15:02on. Right, right.
- 15:05Now let's move on to the story of Henry Kissinger.
- 15:09Finally he has, you know, he he is gone.
- 15:14He is gone from this earth. But because a lot of people have
- 15:18looked at him as a war criminal and that is why there he has
- 15:22gotten a Nobel Peace Prize. People have loved him for that.
- 15:26Many people have hated it for that.
- 15:28So there was always a lot of many people considering either
- 15:31American patriot as the, you know, one who who loved the
- 15:36American way of life and treat everything to protect it.
- 15:39So in that aspect, many people will look at it in their own
- 15:43manner independently. How do you look at it?
- 15:47Who was Henry Kissinger? Finally?
- 15:50How will the world remember him? How do you see it all?
- 15:56You know, it's funny. There's a saying.
- 15:58Only the good day young if that saying it's true Hendrick is
- 16:02injure who looked to be 100 is illustrates this is saying his
- 16:11legacy is controversial and for good reason.
- 16:13He was very much part of the until his dying day.
- 16:17He never repent, recanted his support for China and its
- 16:21imperial ambitions. He's terrible for the United
- 16:25States. He's an American.
- 16:27Forget, you know, the global communities, an American.
- 16:29He should have come to understand that there China is
- 16:33never going to be argued out of looking down on everyone,
- 16:36including the US But that's just fine.
- 16:42Anyone can be wrong, and it's not criminal to have wrong
- 16:46foreign policy views. The problem is when these wrong
- 16:50foreign policy views turn into a downward, completely unethical
- 16:55implementation of policies, as was the case with Cambodia.
- 16:59We don't need to retell that story.
- 17:01The people there remember all too well and of course back in
- 17:05the Pakistan's abuses in Bangladesh, which of course
- 17:12caused a massive security problem for engine horrific
- 17:15human rights abuses. So his complete disregard for
- 17:18human rights made him not a real politic politician, but what the
- 17:23as opposite, a very short sighted politician who did not
- 17:27understand that good as human rights abuses turn into massive
- 17:31security problems and they're detrimental toward peace and
- 17:35stability. So I think his legacy is wrong.
- 17:38All the people who are suddenly working geographies of him, I
- 17:42have no idea who they're trying to impress.
- 17:44He's not even there. He had somehow become the
- 17:48godfather of foreign policy and every leader in every foreign
- 17:52policy thinker and journalist was trying to get in on him
- 17:56before his death. But I don't just because he
- 17:58lived a long time, just because he was successful personally, as
- 18:06in making an impact that doesn't make that impact desirable or
- 18:10good. So yes, his legacy is huge, but
- 18:12it's not positive. A lot of it is highly damaging
- 18:15and the impact of it is seen to this day in my opinion.
- 18:20Right, right. Kissinger was, you know, of a
- 18:24man of a different era altogether, born in 1923.
- 18:28That was. His family had to flee from
- 18:31Germany during those tough times.
- 18:33He was, you know, born in a Jewish family, came to the US
- 18:37and and then he went into, he fought there, he fought at the
- 18:41Battle of the World was part of this whole World War 2 and then
- 18:46built his life back in the US, studying political science and
- 18:49getting into him and the good. The thing is that whether love
- 18:53him or hate him, but almost every president after this, when
- 18:57he was in the midst in the power corridors, they consulted him.
- 19:01Was it what was it that people, whatever their opinion, people
- 19:06in power always wanted his opinion?
- 19:09Even till today he was known famous for his shuttle diplomacy
- 19:13and this continued even at this age.
- 19:16What was it about him that, you know, they always needed him
- 19:20around? And is there another man that
- 19:23could take his place? Obviously in history there are
- 19:26always people around, but what was special about him and what
- 19:30will the American foreign policy or diplomats will miss or the
- 19:34president's event will miss about him, about his, you know,
- 19:38going away from this active life?
- 19:45You know what? I'm going to say something
- 19:47extremely controversial. I think a lot of this
- 19:50presidential quota into somebody whose legacy was quite wrong,
- 19:54quite short sighted quite self-serving and sometimes
- 19:59downright anti-Semitic as as as with them quite.
- 20:04You know as with the time he he did not want to send arms to to
- 20:09Israel and Nixon who is not known for his love of Jews or
- 20:13Israel had to actually intervene.
- 20:15You know what? If people are looking to embrace
- 20:18that to virtue signal because he was an intelligence person who's
- 20:24not anyone foolish. Or who failed to understand the
- 20:29issues. He was wrong handed.
- 20:31He was arrogant in that he refused to change his mind and
- 20:35he was. You know, I I'm not even going
- 20:37to speculate on his motivations, but I can talk about the impact
- 20:40of them. And the impact was without a
- 20:42question, damaging policy. And so when I see presidents go
- 20:47after time after time again to somebody who wasn't just wrong
- 20:51once or twice and admitted and reconsidered their action and is
- 20:56seeking the wisdom of somebody who's had to grapple with
- 20:59different complex problems. But when they going to somebody
- 21:02who's been adamantly wrong and the principles by which she
- 21:06operated were wrong, you know, it makes me wonder whether this
- 21:10is not the Emperor is naked phenomenon where people are
- 21:14afraid to admit that this fixture foreign policy is just
- 21:19an empty suit, someone who's who should be discarded.
- 21:24Because so much of Washington is built on the policies and the
- 21:27legacy of the past precedents, political precedents that are
- 21:32very now very difficult to dislodge.
- 21:34And I think this conventional way of thinking, this
- 21:38establishmentarianism is serving consequent that administration
- 21:46is quite badly, quite poorly. I think the reason our foreign
- 21:49policies has come off the rails so much and has been so
- 21:54intrigued in in troops that need to be discarded and you know,
- 22:01very short sighted, very bubble and thought is precisely because
- 22:05everyone is afraid to say the emperor is naked.
- 22:10We need to move on from past mistakes, from past individuals,
- 22:16however impactful, who did damage.
- 22:18We have to admit that this never worked, and it's not going to
- 22:22work just because we tried again.
- 22:24Now can we find masterful diplomats with, you know, the
- 22:30worst complex experiences? I have no doubt that one day
- 22:34such people will emerge. Right now it's very difficult to
- 22:38say because this is something that can only be judged in
- 22:42hindsight. We've had, we've got, we've had
- 22:45those types of diplomats before aside from Kissinger.
- 22:49Right now it's very hard to say who they are because quite
- 22:53frankly, a lot of our diplomacy is very shallow, very short
- 22:56sighted, very tactical and not very impactful in a positive
- 23:02way. That doesn't mean that out of
- 23:04this morass we won't see great diplomats in the future.
- 23:09Maybe they are already there and we just don't.
- 23:12I see them. Maybe it's in the process.
- 23:14The history is in the process of being made.
- 23:17But do we necessarily need Titans of wrong headed policies
- 23:22just to make us feel good about themselves?
- 23:24Do we need one guy, one person to tell us how to think?
- 23:28No. We can learn the art of
- 23:30diplomacy and foreign policy from various different examples
- 23:34and from the many hard working people who dedicated to
- 23:40promoting US interest in global peace and prosperity.
- 23:44So I think this is something that can be found.
- 23:48We can learn from many different people who don't need to just
- 23:51rely on a couple of big influence in this sphere.
- 23:56Absolutely, Absolutely. Henry Kissinger may be gone, but
- 24:00he has left a lot for people to continue to talk about,
- 24:04especially in the last so many years.
- 24:07You know, the world has changed the way he has impacted all
- 24:10those things positively or negatively.
- 24:13People will see it in their own ways, countries will see it in
- 24:15their own ways. But I am sure a lot of people
- 24:19will try and understand and gain insights into what could have
- 24:22done, been done better and how we can look at foreign policy
- 24:26perhaps in a better manner. Be that as it may, let us move
- 24:30on to other issues in terms of let us move on to the Middle
- 24:34East. Now.
- 24:35What is the latest there? Is it, you know, do we see
- 24:39another ceasefire happening or is it now?
- 24:42And because they it will it be only after the end of the Hamas
- 24:47leadership, as what Israel has leadership has promised.
- 24:56And well, I think this we're not going to see a very fast return
- 25:00to any form of ceasefire. Hamas was playing games the
- 25:03entire time and it managed to leverage the upper hand on on
- 25:08Israel in many ways. It was dictating the rules of
- 25:11this ceasefire the entire time. It was diverting attention.
- 25:16It will. It Co opted Qatar as its
- 25:19spokesperson and managed to get the international community
- 25:22pressure in Israel, not Hamas, for to negotiate.
- 25:26And then it broke all of its own rules, the rules that it itself
- 25:30proposed. It broke them.
- 25:32It did not carry through with what it promised.
- 25:34It violated the ceasefire, and it also got other groups to step
- 25:40in and complement its efforts. So it's no wonder that all of
- 25:44this fell apart. And there seems to be no going
- 25:46back. I know Macron, he promised to
- 25:49help out, but he hasn't brought anything new to the table.
- 25:53Other countries, you know, I try pressuring Israel can work on
- 25:57it. So far, if it's not getting
- 26:00anything in value in return, makes no sense for it to listen
- 26:05to pressure. There's only so much everyone
- 26:07can do, even to Israel. And the Hamas absolutely is
- 26:11showing that it's nowhere near the point where it's ready to
- 26:14return to the table because it simply has not been destroyed
- 26:18enough, even though people are claiming the destruction has
- 26:21been so great. It brings us back to the
- 26:24military definition of proportionality, doing enough to
- 26:27have taking enough action to debilitate the other party and
- 26:33to make it worthwhile the the effort.
- 26:37And clearly Hamas has not been brought to that point, probably
- 26:43in part because they feel that international community has been
- 26:46protecting them politically, probably because of the tunnels
- 26:50that make it difficult for Israel to reach its goals and
- 26:54because of so much support from so many various state and non
- 26:58state parties. That's the third factor.
- 27:00So Hamas is not yet in the position where it can be, where
- 27:05it makes sense for it to come back to the table and and sue
- 27:11for peace. And that should be the position
- 27:14that Hamas should be begging for peace.
- 27:16And it should be up to Israel and its allies to determine
- 27:19whether that's something they're willing to give, in on what
- 27:23terms it should not be Hamas dictating the terms and making
- 27:26demands to accommodate its needs to, to allow time for a group.
- 27:30This was the wrong thing to do. I understand why Israel did it
- 27:35from a humanitarian perspective, but from a security perspective
- 27:39it was a mistake. Right, right.
- 27:43So where do is there any chance of you can say peace in the
- 27:50coming future or is it then going towards a long drawn war
- 27:54which we thought talked about earlier on?
- 27:57This is what Hamas wants to draw Israel into a long run war
- 28:01benefit. Out of this, what does it look
- 28:04like? Will it end soon or will the
- 28:06world become busy in their own thing?
- 28:09US is going will soon be getting busy into its elections.
- 28:13The world will and and at the in the midst you know different
- 28:17political parties. The warships are still in the
- 28:19region. The attacks are still very much
- 28:21on America. How will it look at that place?
- 28:24What will be the Iran's role and Saudi Arabia's role down there?
- 28:29They are talking. They are not talking.
- 28:31How does it look like Even Somali pirates came into the
- 28:35picture? How does this whole scenario
- 28:37look like to be panning, you know, out in the times to come,
- 28:41maybe, maybe in the next six months or so.
- 28:44How should a person, again as I said, looking from India, should
- 28:48understand from this? It is very confusing indeed.
- 28:54Well, I'm very much shared the political vision of Ronald
- 28:59Reagan and his contemporaries, meaning peace through strength.
- 29:04You do not arrive at peace by being weaker by appeasing
- 29:08aggressors, whether they're terrorist organizations, state
- 29:12actors or individual, you know, authoritarian individuals who
- 29:16amass too much power. You, you, you need to respond.
- 29:21You need to put boundaries and make it.
- 29:23You need to make it impossible for them to to harm you and to
- 29:26operate without being destroyed and suffering very heavy
- 29:31consequences in deterrence. And this has not happened.
- 29:34It hasn't happened because in part because Israel has not
- 29:37defined the threat. It defined it too narrowly,
- 29:40defined it as Hamas and Gaza. But Hamas is not just Gaza.
- 29:43And Gaza is, you know, is not the only place that or even the
- 29:47main place of the threat. It's just the most the immediate
- 29:50thing that just happened. It's one location and in my
- 29:55opinion framing of it excessively focusing on Hamas
- 29:59and Gaza actually ally many potential allies because they
- 30:07were now because Hamas and framed anti Palestinian movement
- 30:11versus should have been made to see as an anti terrorist, anti
- 30:14extremist movement global and threatening to the entire
- 30:17region. It also hasn't happened because
- 30:20US is still pursuing a confused and wrong handed policy chasing
- 30:26after some mythical deal with Iran that nobody even knows what
- 30:29it is. It's no longer than nuclear
- 30:30deal. That's we don't even know what's
- 30:33going, what's happening with that, whether Iran has now
- 30:36attained its goals or not because everyone's been so
- 30:38focused on the world. So we don't know what, yes is
- 30:41actually trying to get from Iran.
- 30:43And until we define what it is we want from them, what kind of
- 30:46agreement or framework, we can't attain an objective without, You
- 30:51know, if you don't define it, you can't develop a strategy.
- 30:54So right now there's no strategy.
- 30:56There's no the tactical response is mixed and very weak at best.
- 31:01And so yes, now is being increasingly drawn into a
- 31:04conflict that he didn't choose because it's refusing to respond
- 31:09with force that would prevent for the attack.
- 31:11So it may end up, it's in a much more escalated conflict
- 31:15precisely because it failed to response quickly and early
- 31:18enough. We in six months from now, we
- 31:22may be facing a much more global war.
- 31:25Not a nuclear war, necessarily, not an organized war of states,
- 31:31you know, sending their armies, but an asymmetrical, prolonged
- 31:35and broader conflicts with many more stakeholders and proxies.
- 31:39And work for sure, unless, unless you know Israel and US
- 31:44reframe, reframe their own actions to reframe the conflicts
- 31:48and start operating smarter, right?
- 31:53Right. How?
- 31:53Do you look at the role of Qatar?
- 31:56Sometimes it looks like to be helping everyone from an outside
- 32:00perspective. Sometimes it looks like it is so
- 32:02clued into everything. How should the world understand
- 32:06Qatar? And also, you know, in the role
- 32:09of Turkey, Erdogan, he double S down on Hamas support.
- 32:13And there is also all that pressure to expel Hamas plotter.
- 32:17So how do you look at these roles of these two layers down
- 32:22very important players in the region.
- 32:24How should we understand? And when you are talking of
- 32:26nukes, I also want you to address this whole thing about
- 32:30Taliban also wants to have nukes to obtain top tactical nukes.
- 32:35What does it mean you know for the new regional security and
- 32:38what does mean what will you do with these nukes?
- 32:41Do you do they have the power to control the you know that that
- 32:45thing which requires a lot of responsibility, a lot of you
- 32:48know positive way to keep it contained so that it does not
- 32:52fall into the wrong hands. Well Qatar is a is a is a mafia
- 32:59family with the country it's 300 thousands of native population
- 33:05as one tribe controlling all of them several tribes under them
- 33:10that are given special privileges and everybody else
- 33:14essential to to the second hand citizen, second class citizen.
- 33:19So what do they do they sell their services.
- 33:21To whom Where is buying US wanted the Taliban and Hamas to
- 33:26have political offices. They happily agreed to it.
- 33:29We went far beyond what they were asked in actually becoming
- 33:32main sponsors of terrorist organizations.
- 33:36And they create fires that then they help put out an entirely
- 33:41self-serving and highly damaging way which a way that allows the
- 33:47bad actors to get away with murder and pretending that
- 33:52somehow they created peace after negotiating with people who
- 33:56should never be negotiated with them, who should never have been
- 33:59legitimized in any way. So they're actually helping
- 34:03legitimize, you know, organizations like Taliban, like
- 34:08hookies, like Hamas, they and helping legitimize Iran and
- 34:14helping legitimize themselves in that particular way.
- 34:17So yeah, that's all we need to know.
- 34:18They feed on corruption. They feed on blackmail.
- 34:22They feed on alliances with the stronger rogue regimes with more
- 34:26power. And if you don't, the fact that
- 34:29no one knows what quite what to do with them and is afraid of
- 34:32confronting them for various reasons, There's no political
- 34:36rule as far as Turkey goes. Turkey's in the highly
- 34:39advantageous position because of its native standing and close
- 34:44relations with Russia, with Iran and many issues and so forth.
- 34:48So Erdogan can play these games or feels he can play with the
- 34:53games and he can play them more. The less US refuses to confront
- 34:57those other issues. Turkey would be far less able to
- 35:01manipulate anybody had NATO and US taking the lead on
- 35:06confronting Russia, confronting Iran fully and not have to
- 35:10depend on other countries to do to to help on some some of these
- 35:15issues. Have they taken action to
- 35:17prevent these countries from becoming a problem to begin
- 35:21with? You wouldn't need Turkey to
- 35:23them, help block some of them, try to manipulate them.
- 35:27So essentially Turkey gets away with what it does because US and
- 35:31others are giving so much. Leave it to everybody else.
- 35:35If if we decide to get serious, we'll start with those countries
- 35:401st and then we'll get to middle, middle powers like
- 35:43Turkey that using these issues to the advantage in the worst
- 35:47possible way. And we will simply tell them,
- 35:50OK, you want this, you will. Our conditions are that and
- 35:54that's and that's it. But until we get serious, I will
- 35:58about our priority issues. Turkey and Qatar and you know
- 36:04and various other countries will take advantage of us and create
- 36:07and use our needs to the advantage, right?
- 36:12Right, before I come again. You know about the Taliban
- 36:16talking about, you know. I want yeah, I will come to.
- 36:20That before that help us understand how long can the US
- 36:24warships be in that region? Because if it's going to take
- 36:27long, other other, you know, countries have also sent in
- 36:32their troops in that region. So what happens to that?
- 36:35Will the US warships continue to be stationed there or if they
- 36:39pull it out again, what will be the situation there?
- 36:42Does it look like? How?
- 36:44How does that possibility look like pulling out or staying
- 36:48there for a long haul? Well, they their role was
- 36:53supposed to deter terrorist organizations from from
- 36:57escalating. The problem is it's not working
- 37:00because isn't US is not. USS Bark is bigger than its
- 37:05bite. It's not willing to use the
- 37:10power that it's seeking to attack civil force and so these
- 37:14organizations are not taking this deterrence signal
- 37:17seriously. Moreover, US is in danger of
- 37:19getting trapped there because now Iran is taking over islands
- 37:23in the Babylon London area in which which provide the only
- 37:29exit point for one of its warships.
- 37:32So if you get stuck there, US will have will be drawn into a
- 37:36direct conflict with Iran. That is not something anybody
- 37:40wants. It is not desirable.
- 37:42Yes, U.S. Navy is far superior to Iran's,
- 37:45but how do we do against terrorism from multiple sides?
- 37:51I don't know and I don't really want to find out.
- 37:55This is something that should be dealt with right now before it
- 37:59becomes an issue. Overall, the plan for it is to,
- 38:02you know, the problem is US has no strategy for putting this
- 38:07whole situation to an end. So what?
- 38:09The answer may be as long as it's needed, nobody needs.
- 38:12You need to know what steps are needed to not make this not the
- 38:17forever war, how to de escalate, how to rollback the influence of
- 38:22Iran and its proxies. That should be the answer.
- 38:25There should be a timeline that should be framed by US and NATO
- 38:30and not by Iran and its allies. But I don't believe we have any
- 38:34of that in place right right now.
- 38:38Talking of Taliban about they said to be, you know, trying to
- 38:42obtain near tactical nukes. Why do they need these nukes for
- 38:47who is their enemy and and what will they do?
- 38:51Do they have the wherewithal to 1st buy it?
- 38:54Who will sell them? And secondly, what will, where
- 38:56will they keep it? Because it needs a lot of
- 38:58responsible handling of these things.
- 39:04I should note that the Taliban is not the only one seeking
- 39:09nukes. Al Qaeda expressed such an
- 39:11interest as well, and I think the result would be about the
- 39:14same because the organizations are very similar and have been
- 39:19partners in the past and they're continuing a very profound level
- 39:24of cooperation. Al Qaeda is flourishing in
- 39:26Afghanistan. So Taliban if, as Taliban will
- 39:30say that their enemies are ISIS K, their enemies are on occasion
- 39:35Iran, you know, where, you know, etcetera, etcetera.
- 39:41None of it is true because ISIS K the occasional struggle for
- 39:46power. But they're very similar and
- 39:48they've helped each other out in the past, certainly against the
- 39:51West. Iran has backed Taliban when it
- 39:54was convenient and continues to work with them on occasion.
- 39:58So I don't think Taliban has any interest in fighting a nuclear
- 40:02war with Iran and certainly not with ICSK within its own
- 40:06territory. I think unfortunately those
- 40:09tactical weapons would be used against other regional powers
- 40:14and possibly could be traded with other Iran proxies or
- 40:19Islamist groups in the region. Maybe some of the Pakistan
- 40:23backed groups, if they asked for it, storing it would be
- 40:27problematic. I think Pakistan could be able
- 40:30to help them figure out how to store it.
- 40:34You know, some of the enriched uranium has disappeared from
- 40:37Pakistan soil and ended up in strange places like the Heathrow
- 40:42airport, which Pakistan has denied.
- 40:46But we all remember the situation.
- 40:52We don't want a repetition with that of that.
- 40:54But Afghanistan seems very likely purchase all such
- 40:58services and where there was 1 precedent that could be very
- 41:02well be another. This is grossly irresponsible.
- 41:06It's horrifying. They're not the responsible
- 41:09after, you know, whenever people are afraid of Russian threats,
- 41:13Russia is by far the more rational after even at this
- 41:16source. The Taliban not only is not
- 41:19rational, but by our standards, it also doesn't know what it's
- 41:24doing. It has zero experience with
- 41:26handling such weapons. It has shown gross level of
- 41:30responsibility with handling far less dangerous weapons that the
- 41:34Americans left behind, and it's a possibility no one really
- 41:39wants. Unfortunately, with Taliban in
- 41:41power, with it likely becoming normalized by many countries, it
- 41:45is that much closer to having the legitimate means to obtain
- 41:50such weapons, right? Right.
- 41:53Let's. Move on to Taiwan and China.
- 41:56So the elections, the, you know upcoming elections in Taiwan,
- 42:00how do you see that? Is it a three-way split, you
- 42:04know in Taiwan in terms of elections.
- 42:06So how do you see is it a good situation for China?
- 42:10It will take as much advantage as possible, you know, how do
- 42:14you look at it? Well, the Taiwan elections took
- 42:21an unexpected term. We are now facing a three-way
- 42:25race that one of the opposition parties largely collapsed, which
- 42:30is not all that surprising given that a lot of these opposition
- 42:34parties are pro peace dialogue with China and much of the
- 42:37population. The population is about half and
- 42:40half, but there is an edge, an increasing edge against peace
- 42:46talks with China out of security concerns, And as I've repeatedly
- 42:50stated in various places, I don't believe that China's first
- 42:55choice is military invasion. If they can avoid a military
- 42:59confrontation with the possible involvement of many different
- 43:02actors and different sides, they will.
- 43:05So their first choice is to meddle in elections, to
- 43:08instigate coups, to try to take over Taiwan political, to try to
- 43:13take over public opinion in its favor.
- 43:15And that's exactly where it's going to be focusing its efforts
- 43:18for until January, when the elections are expected to take
- 43:22place. While I do not, you know, while
- 43:27there will be election observers in support of all kinds soft,
- 43:31the exercise of soft power of these sort of active measures is
- 43:35something China, with Russia's help excel in and US is far less
- 43:41adept at preventing than they are at, you know, direct
- 43:46response to some military crisis.
- 43:47Yes, they can sell Taiwan weapons quietly.
- 43:50They can, you know, put all sorts of boundaries.
- 43:53But political involvement, I don't, I'm not sure we have the
- 43:58resources they were without to fight these political games long
- 44:03term. Maybe we have some capability,
- 44:06but I am not convinced, because the fact that this is even a
- 44:13question at this point, after all the threats that China made
- 44:16to Taiwan itself, shows that it has achieved formal success
- 44:21politically that anyone cares to admit, right?
- 44:26Right. The last topic that I want to
- 44:28touch, you know based on ARENA is that you are a, you know,
- 44:33information warfare specialist. You know about how those things
- 44:36work. Help us understand all this, you
- 44:39know, global wave of cyber crime and attacks happening around.
- 44:43Is it coincidence, coordination or something in between?
- 44:46What exactly should we understand about all these
- 44:50things? Are we secure at all or are we
- 44:52not even a common person like me?
- 44:57So I think several things are happening at once.
- 44:59First of all, when you have multiplying global crisis, they
- 45:03create opportunities for various actors, regular criminals who
- 45:08are just opportunistically feeding on distraction and and
- 45:12you know witnesses and state actors seeking advantage and
- 45:17semi you know mercenary actors who will work for whoever is
- 45:20paying them, be the stakeholders in a conflict or crime groups or
- 45:27so forth. And also semi state after school
- 45:30on the one hand are affiliated with some political agendas but
- 45:33are also pursuing their own private interests as well on the
- 45:37side. So all of this is multiplied
- 45:39exponentially and there's, I think there's increasing,
- 45:43growing coordination among these actors due to globalization of
- 45:47communications, crime and law enforcement, due to the fact
- 45:52that there is a fluidity in global threats and there is a
- 45:57increased interaction between different actors and they
- 46:01cooperate a lot more and also because of increased
- 46:04opportunities. So on the one hand, you do have
- 46:07more independent agendas just happening simultaneously, not as
- 46:12a complete coincidence, but due to observation of the impact and
- 46:16successes of others. They're inspired by each other.
- 46:19They're inspired by the opportunities, by the success,
- 46:22but the distraction of law enforcement by the inability
- 46:26over the privates and and public sector to keep up with these
- 46:30threats. And the more there are, they're
- 46:31easier. There is to increase impact,
- 46:35because you can't chase down every ransomware attack or every
- 46:40phishing attack all over the world, and there's only so much
- 46:43resources you could put in. When you're constantly
- 46:45overwhelmed with new threats. It makes it easier.
- 46:50The more crime you have, the less effect you had at fighting
- 46:54crime, the more the more crime will proliferate.
- 46:58Similarly with terrorism and any political threats as well.
- 47:01So we are seeing balls, direct coordination between politically
- 47:11aligned actors who are pursuing the opportunities in that way
- 47:16through coalition building and more opportunism that's not
- 47:19necessarily directly coordinated, but very much
- 47:22inspired and very much enthused by the opportunities right,
- 47:28right there. Is a lot of things happening in
- 47:31the world at the same war, including war, cyberwire fare, a
- 47:35lot of things on Internet as well as on the ground.
- 47:38And and we will continue to bring all the analysis with you
- 47:42as you know as this happens every week, every second week
- 47:47with this it's a wrap on this very special edition of the KJ
- 47:51master class lives the world according to IRENA Superman.
- 47:55Thank you so much indeed for joining us.