Latest / Surrounded / Piers Morgan vs 20 Woke Liberals
Transcript
- 0:00Am I cowering?
- 0:01Woo!
- 0:02The wokeies are around me.
- 0:04We emotions in a positive way is literally
- 0:07participation trophies not being there disadvantages of annoying.
- 0:10Have you been on your own show?
- 0:11You interrupted me the whole time and now you're just getting the same thing.
- 0:13So me telling you that you are spreading misinformation,
- 0:16that is not fascism,
- 0:17that is just me telling you you're wrong.
- 0:19But you're,
- 0:19you're not telling me I'm wrong because I'm right.
- 0:24From Jubilee Media,
- 0:26this is the Surrounded podcast,
- 0:27where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:30In the center of today's episode is the English journalist and broadcaster,
- 0:34Piers Morgan.
- 0:35He'll be debating 20 woke liberals.
- 0:37Pierce will debate them one on one until they're voted
- 0:40out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 0:43Let's get into it.
- 0:45Hi,
- 0:45I'm Piers Morgan,
- 0:46and I'm the host of Piers Morgan Uncensored on YouTube.
- 0:48I'm also the author of a new book,
- 0:49Woke Is Dead,
- 0:50and today I'm surrounded
- 0:52by 20 apparently still alive,
- 0:54woke liberals.
- 0:55My first surrounded claim is that masculinity has never
- 1:00been toxic.
- 1:09One second.
- 1:10How do you do?
- 1:12I'm Piers.
- 1:13So
- 1:13I guess where I wanna kind of start is
- 1:15talking about masculinity.
- 1:16So,
- 1:17uh,
- 1:17I view this,
- 1:18do you think that this is like socially emergent,
- 1:20I imagine,
- 1:20to some degree?
- 1:21Well,
- 1:21I think the truth about the whole toxic debate about masculinity is,
- 1:25it's a completely new phenomenon.
- 1:27Before,
- 1:28about 30 years ago,
- 1:29nobody ever used that phrase.
- 1:30It's only really in the last 10 years,
- 1:32it's suddenly been amplified
- 1:34and used for absolutely everything.
- 1:37So I thought it might be useful
- 1:38to just start with something that Chris Williamson,
- 1:40you may know him,
- 1:41uh,
- 1:42great guy,
- 1:42and he came on my show recently.
- 1:44And he said that all the following things
- 1:47have been blamed on toxic masculinity in the media
- 1:51in the last year and a half.
- 1:53Gang violence,
- 1:54climate change,
- 1:55the financial crisis,
- 1:56Brexit,
- 1:57the election of Donald Trump,
- 1:59not wearing a face mask,
- 2:00eating meat,
- 2:01physical fitness,
- 2:03fast food,
- 2:04capitalism,
- 2:05communism,
- 2:06hip hop,
- 2:06smelling of AXE body spray.
- 2:09Being stoic,
- 2:10risk-taking,
- 2:11religion,
- 2:12but also secularism and atheism,
- 2:15playing board games,
- 2:16being interested in cars,
- 2:18and saying
- 2:19hello
- 2:19or have a nice day.
- 2:21So I have already committed at least one crime
- 2:23because I've already said hello to you.
- 2:25So my point being,
- 2:26it's become this,
- 2:28sorry,
- 2:28I said I'm actually very offended by that too.
- 2:30No,
- 2:30the thing is,
- 2:31I think the point I would make is,
- 2:33I think in a time when young men in particular,
- 2:35I've got 3 sons from 32 to 24.
- 2:38I think we've got to a weird place where they feel like they are the most
- 2:42downtrodden,
- 2:43picked upon
- 2:44people in society,
- 2:46with good reason in many cases,
- 2:48and a lot of it is down to this,
- 2:49where they don't know what masculinity is.
- 2:51My argument is,
- 2:53I don't think it's ever been toxic.
- 2:55What's happened is you have men behaving badly,
- 2:58but you also have women behaving badly,
- 2:59and no one calls that toxic femininity.
- 3:02Well,
- 3:02I,
- 3:03I actually do call it toxic femininity.
- 3:05I think when you look at,
- 3:06I do,
- 3:07uh,
- 3:07when you look at like gender studies and philosophy on this,
- 3:09right,
- 3:09we use this term called masculinities
- 3:11and femininities because we understand that like
- 3:13the like samurai era of
- 3:16masculinity looks very different than maybe the
- 3:18Knights of the Round Table and whatnot.
- 3:20So we understand that masculinity has so much morphed and shifted.
- 3:23And in every form of these masculinities or femininities,
- 3:26there are unhealthy elements to each of them.
- 3:28Could you grant me that?
- 3:30Well,
- 3:30it depends what you mean.
- 3:31I mean,
- 3:31what do you think masculinity is?
- 3:33Uh,
- 3:33in our society,
- 3:35I think masculinity,
- 3:35no,
- 3:36no,
- 3:36not in your society,
- 3:37just generally,
- 3:38what is it?
- 3:38Yeah,
- 3:38in North America we would broadly view it as like,
- 3:40well,
- 3:40you can't just say North America.
- 3:42Masculinity is a thing.
- 3:43It's not,
- 3:44it's not like territory
- 3:46specific.
- 3:46It has become that way with the toxic.
- 3:48But actual masculinity,
- 3:50when it was first
- 3:52devised as a word,
- 3:54it's not an American thing,
- 3:55it's a global thing.
- 3:56Do you think that Athenian masculinity and Spartan
- 3:58masculinity were the same in the Greeks?
- 4:00I think masculinity has never changed.
- 4:02All that's changed is
- 4:03the interpretation of it.
- 4:05And what I can't abide is this
- 4:07modern phenomenon that everything about masculinity,
- 4:10everything about being a man,
- 4:11which
- 4:12I am currently,
- 4:12Identifying as
- 4:14everything about me is supposedly toxic.
- 4:16So I would,
- 4:17I would reject the idea that everything that masculinity is,
- 4:19is toxic.
- 4:20I think that there can be bad elements of anything.
- 4:21What do you like about men?
- 4:23What do I like about men?
- 4:24Lots of things.
- 4:24I think that like the idea of protectionism is good.
- 4:27I think the like,
- 4:28uh,
- 4:28willingness to kind of like self-sacrifice is very
- 4:31tied to the version of masculinity we have.
- 4:33I think that that's a very good thing.
- 4:34I think the like desire to provide is also a really good thing.
- 4:37Um,
- 4:38and stand up for like principles and strength.
- 4:40I think all of these things are wonderful things.
- 4:42Well,
- 4:42the issue like men to be hunters,
- 4:44providers,
- 4:44protectors.
- 4:45I don't really care about them being hunters.
- 4:46Really?
- 4:47How are they going to get all these things to help you and protect you in this economy,
- 4:50I'd prefer them just to be like,
- 4:51fiscally capable.
- 4:52Let's go back to the Athenians.
- 4:54Let's go back to Athenians and Spartans,
- 4:56though,
- 4:56right?
- 4:56If you want to say masculinity has always been the same,
- 4:58well,
- 4:58the issue is history would disagree with you,
- 5:00right?
- 5:00In Athens,
- 5:01for example,
- 5:01it was completely normal for you to participate
- 5:03in civility and talk and do philosophy,
- 5:05but
- 5:06Spartan men,
- 5:06for example,
- 5:07wouldn't even touch coins,
- 5:08but they viewed it as a very different thing.
- 5:10Whereas's that got to do with them being masculine?
- 5:12Well,
- 5:12because the version of masculinity that they had
- 5:15viewed certain things like commerce as feminine.
- 5:17If you go to samurais,
- 5:19they viewed poetry as masculine,
- 5:21whereas if you go to,
- 5:21like,
- 5:22Victorian era,
- 5:23poetry is often associated with femininity.
- 5:25Right,
- 5:26OK,
- 5:26but what does any of that got to do with toxic masculinity?
- 5:28Because if we look at masculinity,
- 5:29we have to acknowledge that it is emergent out
- 5:31of a society that we are participating in.
- 5:33When I said it,
- 5:33it will enormous
- 5:34America,
- 5:35you rejected that and go,
- 5:36well,
- 5:36that's the foundational piece of this.
- 5:38What we're talking about,
- 5:39toxic masculinity is essentially a North American version
- 5:41of masculinity that we seem to not like.
- 5:43Well,
- 5:43no,
- 5:43it's not,
- 5:43it's,
- 5:44it's a symptom of,
- 5:45and forgive my phraseology here,
- 5:47but it's a symptom of weak,
- 5:48whiny,
- 5:49woke wastrels who've decided they're going to
- 5:51revise what masculinity is.
- 5:53I think it's hang on,
- 5:54hang on,
- 5:55I'll give you a chance to respond.
- 5:56And they're going to make all men feel terrible.
- 5:59They're gonna make men hate themselves,
- 6:01they're gonna make everybody else hate men.
- 6:03And at that point,
- 6:03I'm like,
- 6:04what are you doing here?
- 6:05Why would,
- 6:05why would women,
- 6:06for example,
- 6:07want their men
- 6:08to be weak,
- 6:09whiny,
- 6:09woke wastrels?
- 6:10Well,
- 6:10I think,
- 6:11I think the issue that you're neglecting here is
- 6:12the high levels of intergenerational trauma amongst men.
- 6:15I mean,
- 6:15if we go back to World War 2,
- 6:16it's followed by the Vietnam War,
- 6:18right?
- 6:18We see men dying by the thousands,
- 6:20and then they come back and they have PTSD,
- 6:22and then they go off again and die by the thousands.
- 6:24And so,
- 6:24when we look at,
- 6:25like,
- 6:25the lack of masculinity,
- 6:27masculinity and Masculine role models.
- 6:29We have to understand this through a lens of understanding that like,
- 6:32men have been like scooped out and killed over and over,
- 6:36and then when they come back,
- 6:37they're destroyed,
- 6:38and there isn't really an answer for men.
- 6:40I agree that there's a systemic lacking of answer on the left for men in a lot of ways.
- 6:45The issue is that we can't address the problem.
- 6:47I mean,
- 6:47I,
- 6:48I just to pause here,
- 6:48just to pause,
- 6:49they do,
- 6:49they do,
- 6:50even movies like Barbie.
- 6:52I'm left.
- 6:53OK.
- 6:54Here's a little secret for you.
- 6:56I'm slightly left.
- 6:57I'm a,
- 6:57I'm an old fashioned liberal.
- 6:59I'm not a,
- 7:00you see,
- 7:00they all think I'm probably I'm a right-wing head banger.
- 7:02I'm not.
- 7:03I'm,
- 7:04I'm an old fashioned liberal.
- 7:05I believe in liberalism,
- 7:07and I believe there's nothing wrong with being feminine
- 7:09or masculine.
- 7:11I hate the way.
- 7:12That masculinity has been tarred with this brush of everything about it is toxic.
- 7:17I agree,
- 7:17and,
- 7:18but the issue is that you can't throw the baby out with the bathwater.
- 7:20You have to look at things like Victorian
- 7:22stoicism and recognize how that has harmed young men
- 7:25because they stoicism,
- 7:26stoic ridiculous.
- 7:27Hold on,
- 7:28Victorian stoicism,
- 7:29not Greek,
- 7:30not Greco-stoicism.
- 7:31Stoicism generally is a good trait.
- 7:32I love stoicism,
- 7:33Hellenistic stoicism.
- 7:35Greek.
- 7:35Well,
- 7:35let me read you something.
- 7:36You've raised stoicism.
- 7:37The American Psychological Association
- 7:40released a set of guidelines to help psychologists work with men and boys
- 7:44in which it stated that male masculine traits
- 7:48like stoicism,
- 7:49competitiveness,
- 7:51achievement,
- 7:52sure of the appearance of weakness,
- 7:54adventure and risk
- 7:56should all be discarded.
- 7:58Now I would categorize all of those things
- 8:00as the very best of being a real man.
- 8:03Why would you want them discarded?
- 8:05I don't want most of those things.
- 8:07Let's talk about stoicism.
- 8:07No,
- 8:08I think we agree.
- 8:08I think we agree with each other.
- 8:09I think you agree with me too much.
- 8:11Anyway,
- 8:11it's lovely to meet you.
- 8:11Thank you.
- 8:12OK.
- 8:17Hello.
- 8:18Hi.
- 8:18How are you?
- 8:18Sassy,
- 8:20nice to meet you.
- 8:20Nice to meet you.
- 8:22OK,
- 8:22um,
- 8:22first I want to say that I don't think that masculinity is toxic.
- 8:27I just think that some men
- 8:29use their,
- 8:30I'm,
- 8:30I'm wait,
- 8:31I'm over.
- 8:32No,
- 8:32it's not.
- 8:32The whole point of the problem is,
- 8:34no,
- 8:34no,
- 8:35no,
- 8:35because you're talking about a trait,
- 8:36right?
- 8:37So I don't think masculinity is toxic.
- 8:38I think men use their masculinity in toxic ways or hide other traits.
- 8:43That are toxic masculinity.
- 8:45I don't agree with that.
- 8:46Here's why.
- 8:46They're not using their masculinity,
- 8:48they're just being bad people.
- 8:51So,
- 8:51so I think there's a clear difference.
- 8:53So then men like Andrew Tate,
- 8:54when they are bad people,
- 8:55but then stand like I'm a protector,
- 8:57I'm a provider,
- 8:58they're using their masculinity.
- 8:59I've interviewed Andrew,
- 9:00I've interviewed Andrew Tate a number of times.
- 9:02Here's what I think about him.
- 9:03I think he says a lot of things which young men
- 9:06gravitate to because.
- 9:08Few other people
- 9:09are trying to empower them about the way they look.
- 9:11Hang on,
- 9:12I'm not.
- 9:12Let me finish my sentence.
- 9:13I,
- 9:13I can have a facial reaction to you if I want to,
- 9:15right?
- 9:15Actually,
- 9:16that's fair enough.
- 9:16You can.
- 9:17You can look horrified.
- 9:19Um,
- 9:19but here's the point about Andrew Tate,
- 9:21is a lot of the things he says,
- 9:22I know why they resonate with young men,
- 9:24because young men feel sort of worthless,
- 9:26they feel disenfranchised by society,
- 9:28they're not sure where to go.
- 9:29Many of them lack father figures.
- 9:30There's chest beating Andrew Tate,
- 9:32saying.
- 9:33Fit,
- 9:34you know,
- 9:34don't abuse yourself too much.
- 9:35Just women.
- 9:36Well,
- 9:36I'm gonna come to that.
- 9:37And so he says all these things which men go,
- 9:39yeah,
- 9:39yeah,
- 9:40that's good,
- 9:40and aspire to be great,
- 9:41aspire to be successful,
- 9:43do this,
- 9:43work hard,
- 9:44and all this stuff.
- 9:45And then you get to his,
- 9:46his blatant misogyny,
- 9:48right?
- 9:48He is a terrible
- 9:49misogynist.
- 9:50He thinks that women
- 9:51should be
- 9:52left at home,
- 9:53never allowed to vote,
- 9:54never allowed to work.
- 9:55I know,
- 9:55but my point is I agree with you about that trait of his,
- 9:57right?
- 9:58I think it's,
- 9:58it's horrible,
- 9:59but that's not toxic masculinity.
- 10:01That is actually misogyny.
- 10:03There's a word for it.
- 10:03I guess the reason,
- 10:04but I think that all of this was fueled by people like Andrew Tate,
- 10:08because like you said,
- 10:09toxic masculinity,
- 10:09we've never spoke about this before,
- 10:11but I think the reason it's on the table now is because of men like Andrew Tate.
- 10:15It's not because of women calling men toxic it is,
- 10:18it's literally because Red Pill podcasters,
- 10:21especially during the
- 10:22pandemic,
- 10:22if you were.
- 10:23a loner,
- 10:24you became even more alone,
- 10:25so they needed a community.
- 10:26So everyone's living life online
- 10:28in these what they thought was a community because all these men
- 10:31did was validate their shitty feelings that they already had about themselves.
- 10:34It was an echo chamber and they have to keep them sad and angry,
- 10:37tell them to place the blame on women and
- 10:39minorities so that they get their pockets filled.
- 10:41But here's the thing they monetized insecurities and trauma.
- 10:44You can have your facial reactions.
- 10:46Go ahead politely,
- 10:46politely,
- 10:47go ahead,
- 10:48um.
- 10:48I,
- 10:49I think what you're talking about is misogyny.
- 10:51There's already a word for that.
- 10:52It's not toxic masculinity,
- 10:54that's the point of my argument.
- 10:55I don't think masculinity
- 10:57has ever been toxic.
- 10:58I do think some men
- 11:00are horrible misogynists and should be called out as I call them out.
- 11:04Don't you think some men hide behind their masculine?
- 11:05Like,
- 11:05I'm sick of hearing men say we have to protect and provide.
- 11:08Why shouldn't we?
- 11:09Well,
- 11:09no,
- 11:09no,
- 11:09no,
- 11:09but the thing is,
- 11:10is half of you,
- 11:11what are you gonna protect me from,
- 11:12another?
- 11:12And half of them can't hunt down a job.
- 11:14Like I don't or other women
- 11:16or other women,
- 11:16sure,
- 11:16yeah,
- 11:17other people,
- 11:17but that's the thing I'm saying is that men,
- 11:19I don't understand why
- 11:20I feel like a lot of blame gets placed on women for all of this,
- 11:23but in reality,
- 11:23you've done it to each other.
- 11:24I don't blame women.
- 11:25You've done it to each other for any of this.
- 11:28I think that the,
- 11:29the,
- 11:29the,
- 11:29well,
- 11:29actually that's not completely true.
- 11:31I blame some women
- 11:32who have deliberately,
- 11:34in my opinion,
- 11:35like a lot of men.
- 11:36Have done too,
- 11:37taken the word masculinity
- 11:39and they have traduced it into meaning something it was never intended to mean.
- 11:43Like I said,
- 11:43those words
- 11:44which the American Psychological Association
- 11:47have deemed unacceptable and should be discarded,
- 11:49are all the absolute foundation
- 11:52of what I believe it takes to be a man.
- 11:55Oh
- 11:56just when we're getting to know each other.
- 11:57Pick me for the last 10,
- 11:58I've got a lot to say.
- 11:58I'll think about it.
- 12:07How are you?
- 12:08Good to see you.
- 12:08What's your name?
- 12:09Parker.
- 12:09Parker,
- 12:09I'm Piz.
- 12:10I've been on your show,
- 12:11bro.
- 12:11Yes,
- 12:12I thought I recognized you.
- 12:14When was that?
- 12:15Uh,
- 12:15after the Jordan Peterson Jubilee debate.
- 12:17Yes,
- 12:17that's right,
- 12:18you did.
- 12:19He has quoted us as gayheists on Twitter.
- 12:21Really?
- 12:22Yeah.
- 12:23OK.
- 12:23How do you feel about that?
- 12:24Uh,
- 12:24well,
- 12:24I mean,
- 12:24I think it was ridiculous.
- 12:25I'm literally straight,
- 12:27but oh,
- 12:27you're straight.
- 12:27Yeah.
- 12:28OK,
- 12:28well then I can understand why you'd find that annoying.
- 12:30Oh,
- 12:30I don't find it annoying.
- 12:31I'm just saying it doesn't make sense to use that as an argument,
- 12:33but
- 12:34in,
- 12:34in general,
- 12:34I will not call you a gayheist.
- 12:35OK,
- 12:36in general,
- 12:36the point that I would make here is that toxic masculinity is kind of an
- 12:39overexpression of certain masculine traits that we see
- 12:41in this certain context to be harmful.
- 12:43We're not saying.
- 12:44All masculine traits are harmful or it's harmful to be a masculine man.
- 12:47It's certain characteristics that we would associate
- 12:49with masculinity do you think is harmful?
- 12:51Yeah,
- 12:51like for,
- 12:51for example,
- 12:52an overexpression of stoicism,
- 12:53and I think that a lot of red pill people,
- 12:54what?
- 12:55Wait,
- 12:55hold up,
- 12:55let me explain.
- 12:56And I said an overexpression of stoicism stoicism ever be overexpressed,
- 13:00ever be a bad thing?
- 13:01Explain to me.
- 13:02Yeah,
- 13:03so again,
- 13:03if you were to specifically hide your feelings
- 13:05and put them underneath specifically for like,
- 13:07say the death of a loved one,
- 13:08I don't think that would be harmful.
- 13:09I mean a positive specifically.
- 13:10For you addressing your feelings in that circumstance,
- 13:12I think you should address those feelings,
- 13:13talk about them,
- 13:14express them to loved ones and people that are comfortable,
- 13:16you're comfortable around.
- 13:17That doesn't mean you can't still be stoic.
- 13:19Well then,
- 13:19what do you mean by stoicism,
- 13:20because I'm talking about an overexpression of keeping down
- 13:23your emotions and not expressing them and actively,
- 13:26positively addressing them.
- 13:27Stoicism doesn't mean you have to be in
- 13:29sort of unemotional,
- 13:30you know,
- 13:30Spock from Star Trek.
- 13:32That's not what it means at all.
- 13:33Stoicism means that when you're dealt a tough blow in life,
- 13:36you're able.
- 13:37To reach inside yourself and deal with it
- 13:40in a strong manner,
- 13:40right,
- 13:40which is a good thing.
- 13:41I always quote to my kids,
- 13:43they can all tell you the speech
- 13:44off by heart.
- 13:45There's a scene in my,
- 13:46my favorite
- 13:47films were the Rocky movies.
- 13:48The 1st 4 were great,
- 13:49the 5th 1 was a turkey.
- 13:50The 6th 1 came back
- 13:52called Rocky Balboa,
- 13:53and in it,
- 13:54Rocky's son's in his 20s,
- 13:55he's a spoiled brat.
- 13:57He hates being Rocky's son.
- 13:58He's whining about everything.
- 14:00He's kind of pretty woke,
- 14:02weak,
- 14:02whiny.
- 14:03You know,
- 14:04moaning about his lot in life,
- 14:05you know,
- 14:06telling him woe is me all the time.
- 14:08So Rocky eventually has it out with his son in the street,
- 14:10and he says,
- 14:11look,
- 14:11he says life is tough.
- 14:13It will beat you down and it will keep you down
- 14:15if you let it.
- 14:17If you wanna win at life,
- 14:18you've gotta learn,
- 14:19it's not about how hard you can hit,
- 14:20it's about how hard you can get hit,
- 14:22get back up and keep moving forward.
- 14:24That's how winning is done.
- 14:26No one's arguing against that in general.
- 14:27So that's,
- 14:28but that is,
- 14:28that is stoicism.
- 14:30So but you're misunderstanding my argument.
- 14:31I'm seeing an overexpression of watering down and not addressing your emotions.
- 14:34I think we both agree that would be a bad expression of your emotions,
- 14:37and I oftentimes men,
- 14:38men view it that way because they say if you address.
- 14:40Your emotions to any degree,
- 14:41there's gonna be,
- 14:42oh,
- 14:42don't be a man,
- 14:43don't cry,
- 14:44be a man.
- 14:45So that's an idea of an overexpression of
- 14:46masculinity in that sense that becomes toxic.
- 14:49I,
- 14:49I,
- 14:49so you say does that make sense?
- 14:50Yeah,
- 14:50it does.
- 14:51And so you so that you agree toxic masculinity makes sense.
- 14:53No,
- 14:53no,
- 14:53no,
- 14:53that's not what I'm saying.
- 14:55So you would find,
- 14:56you would find it objectionable to use the phrase man up,
- 14:58for example,
- 14:59in the context in which like someone is having
- 15:01a positive address of their like particular emotions.
- 15:03And in typical I wouldn't use it like like that type of phrase,
- 15:05you'd say maybe you should address your emotions in a more positive way,
- 15:08maybe you should go to therapy.
- 15:09A lot of people should do that,
- 15:10like men should go to therapy,
- 15:11it's an important thing that they should do,
- 15:13and that would be positive for their life.
- 15:14I've never been to therapy in my life,
- 15:15you should.
- 15:16And I don't cry all the time.
- 15:18I think the last time I cried was about 12 years ago when my grandmother died.
- 15:22I just think this is overdone.
- 15:24We've,
- 15:24no,
- 15:24no,
- 15:24we've just moved from an incredibly stoic.
- 15:27Uh,
- 15:28generation,
- 15:28say the World War II generation,
- 15:30who were literally sacrificing
- 15:32their lives for their country,
- 15:33but weren't
- 15:34crying all the time,
- 15:35to an era now,
- 15:36why are you associating what I'm saying with crying all the time.
- 15:39You're the one who mentioned crying,
- 15:40so let me just explain what I'm talking about.
- 15:42I don't think it suits anybody
- 15:44to encourage a society
- 15:46to constantly be over-emotional either.
- 15:48I'm
- 15:49I'm not saying you should suppress emotions,
- 15:51and if you feel emotions about something,
- 15:53I'm all for it.
- 15:54I can get emotional with the best of them,
- 15:55normally about.
- 15:56Football team,
- 15:57but I don't spend all my time blubbing like a baby,
- 15:59and my argument would be,
- 16:01well,
- 16:01hang on,
- 16:02I'm gonna finish my point.
- 16:03I think that if you look at the woke world
- 16:05generally,
- 16:06there seems to be a premium
- 16:08on over-emoing
- 16:09and not enough of a premium in my view of stiff upper lip,
- 16:13pull yourself together,
- 16:14and crack on.
- 16:15Because let me,
- 16:16let me tell you,
- 16:16let me tell you,
- 16:17there are two things you want to worry about in life,
- 16:19really worry about.
- 16:20I say this to my kids,
- 16:21dying
- 16:22and getting a terminal illness.
- 16:24Outside of those two things.
- 16:25Everything is surmountable.
- 16:27You can overcome.
- 16:29What about if your partner cheats on you?
- 16:30But what you've got,
- 16:30yeah,
- 16:31like,
- 16:31even that makes sense.
- 16:32OK,
- 16:32so there are plenty of examples we can give where people
- 16:34are gonna have like legitimate circumstances to cry or be sad.
- 16:37But like I'm asking you,
- 16:37like,
- 16:38in the circumstance,
- 16:39give a specific of what you're referencing in terms of
- 16:40these woke liberals of how they're being too overly emotional.
- 16:43Well,
- 16:43you're talking to me about why you want people to be more emotional.
- 16:45I'm telling you I don't think that's I want them to express it in positive manners,
- 16:48like go to therapy,
- 16:49like how I told you.
- 16:50Yeah,
- 16:50but I think we're overtherapied.
- 16:52Everyone I know
- 16:53over here goes to therap.
- 16:54You haven't gone to therapy at all.
- 16:55How are you over therapy?
- 16:56Why don't you come and talk to me if you want to talk to somebody?
- 16:58I'll soon sort you out.
- 16:59I,
- 16:59I can talk to my therapist and we can actually
- 17:01engage in positive reconstruction of how I address things.
- 17:04Yes,
- 17:04actually,
- 17:04it's been very helpful for my mental health and my
- 17:06emotional health to be able to talk them through,
- 17:08to be able to talk,
- 17:09like,
- 17:09what can I do to like make myself feel better in these circumstances?
- 17:12Am I being genuinely like real here?
- 17:14Like,
- 17:14or am I being a little bit too overly emotional in a circumstances?
- 17:16It's totally a question.
- 17:17I ask my therapist all the time.
- 17:19So if you want to talk about being overly emotional,
- 17:20how to address being a,
- 17:21being overly emotional,
- 17:22how?
- 17:23Just start with therapy.
- 17:24What's your solution?
- 17:25What's your solution?
- 17:25Calm down.
- 17:26I'm calm.
- 17:27I'm totally calm.
- 17:28Wait,
- 17:28are you,
- 17:29do you think me talking fast is not being like calm?
- 17:31you don't want me to get a word in,
- 17:32right?
- 17:33And I wanted to finish my statement.
- 17:34Right,
- 17:34I just think people go to therapy too much.
- 17:36Sorry,
- 17:37I do.
- 17:37You may not like to hear it,
- 17:39cos I just think going and talking to some
- 17:40stranger about all your problems all the time,
- 17:42get a grip.
- 17:43It's not all the time,
- 17:43it's every once in a while you go and talk
- 17:45about your problems specifically so you can address them.
- 17:47Do you not talk about your problems ever with anyone.
- 17:49I look at Parker.
- 17:50This is the problem I talked about.
- 17:51Stop talking.
- 17:52I look at you and I see somebody who's confident,
- 17:54you're a good talker,
- 17:55you're obviously intelligent,
- 17:56you've obviously got a lot going for you.
- 17:58Stop spending all this money going to see some stranger
- 18:00to go over everything and it's that much money to be able to go every
- 18:04once in a while to go see a therapist for me specifically in my life.
- 18:06I've never been to one in my life.
- 18:08You can,
- 18:08it's not much money for you.
- 18:09You could easily go with the money that you make and go talk to a therapist.
- 18:12I need to.
- 18:13I understand you don't want to.
- 18:14Everyone says that specifically before going into it.
- 18:16I said the same thing,
- 18:17but I'm telling you,
- 18:17you can actually address your emotions in a positive way.
- 18:20And also
- 18:21also.
- 18:21Here's what I'd rather do.
- 18:22I would rather honestly
- 18:24have groups of people like you in the woke world,
- 18:26right,
- 18:27who clearly are struggling with
- 18:28regular life,
- 18:29right?
- 18:31Everything's a calamity,
- 18:32everything's a problem,
- 18:32has to be overanalyzed,
- 18:33over dissected,
- 18:34overtherapized,
- 18:36and I just think you've all got to be given the mental tools
- 18:39to deal with ordinary life.
- 18:41Ordinary life,
- 18:42ordinary life,
- 18:43let me tell you,
- 18:44ordinary life,
- 18:44yeah,
- 18:45but without going to therapy all the time.
- 18:46Wait,
- 18:46what's your solution?
- 18:47What,
- 18:47what's your solution?
- 18:48People,
- 18:49I think at school.
- 18:50And colleges,
- 18:52we need to reinforce,
- 18:53this comes back to masculinity,
- 18:55with men,
- 18:56we need to reinforce the mental tools required for life.
- 18:59It's,
- 18:59well,
- 19:00I can tell you when I can chart the absolute descent of this
- 19:03in in the wrong way,
- 19:04when,
- 19:05and I think it began in America,
- 19:06when you started giving kids participation prizes for coming last at sport.
- 19:11Absolute shambles.
- 19:13I mean,
- 19:14whoever thought of that?
- 19:14How does this have to do with actually
- 19:16like men making their emotions better off participation trophies
- 19:20I'm explaining because if young people are conditioned to
- 19:23think that if you come last at something,
- 19:25you get a prize,
- 19:27it is the worst possible preparation
- 19:29for the real world.
- 19:30What's the actual solution?
- 19:31You're just telling a problem again,
- 19:32problem,
- 19:32problem,
- 19:33problem,
- 19:33what's the solution?
- 19:34If I could finish my sentence,
- 19:35start with the solution.
- 19:36Solution is you just stop talking for a moment,
- 19:38right?
- 19:38How about you actually provide a solution.
- 19:39All you've done.
- 19:40Bring about problems.
- 19:41Parker,
- 19:41I've just given you a solution.
- 19:42I wanna,
- 19:43I want that's not a solution,
- 19:44that's a problem.
- 19:45You stop participation prizes.
- 19:47You condition kids to deal with the real world when they become adults.
- 19:51Otherwise,
- 19:51when they men not having the ability to address their emotions in a
- 19:54positive way is literally participation trophies
- 19:57not being disadvantage is I'm annoying.
- 19:58Look,
- 19:58have you been on your own show?
- 19:59You interrupted me the whole time and now you're just getting the same thing.
- 20:02You're just don't be mad.
- 20:03Don't be mad.
- 20:04Parker,
- 20:05are you,
- 20:05are you mad?
- 20:06No,
- 20:06I'm trying to finish my sentence.
- 20:07It's OK.
- 20:08Parker.
- 20:10Come on,
- 20:10calm down,
- 20:11you're shaking.
- 20:11I'm totally calm.
- 20:12I'm not shaking at all.
- 20:13You're shaking.
- 20:15I'm not shaking.
- 20:15Why do you have to act like I'm,
- 20:17why do you have to say something delusional to try to deflect
- 20:18away from the fact that you haven't addressed anything meaningful here.
- 20:21Christ Parker.
- 20:23My point is,
- 20:23I,
- 20:23I,
- 20:23there's a brilliant book by Jonathan Haid about the impact of
- 20:27smartphones on young brains,
- 20:29right?
- 20:30And it goes back to 2010 when smartphones became smart.
- 20:33In other words,
- 20:34you could access absolutely everything.
- 20:36And I look at what happens on my feed each day and I'm
- 20:38horrified about what may happen to younger,
- 20:41more impressionable brains,
- 20:42right?
- 20:42And so young people's brains have got scrambled.
- 20:44So since 2010,
- 20:46there's a direct correlation of young people
- 20:48who get
- 20:49ever more anxious,
- 20:50ever more depressed,
- 20:51in some cases tragically,
- 20:53ever more suicidal.
- 20:54And.
- 20:55It's been driven by this constant negative dopamine.
- 20:57So partly I understand
- 20:59why
- 21:00what I call the weak,
- 21:01whiny woke wastrels
- 21:02are like they are,
- 21:04because they're constantly getting overloaded with negative dopamine,
- 21:07which is making them think the whole world's about to end.
- 21:09In fact,
- 21:10as Steven Pinker has explained in great detail,
- 21:13statistically,
- 21:14this has never been a better time to be alive.
- 21:17There are fewer wars than in recorded history.
- 21:19People are.
- 21:20Living longer and healthier than in recorded history.
- 21:23There's less child poverty than in recorded history.
- 21:26Water is cleaner
- 21:27than in recorded history,
- 21:29etc.
- 21:29etc.
- 21:30etc.
- 21:30The problem is social media
- 21:32amplifying all the bad stuff going on,
- 21:35making young people think
- 21:36the world's about to end.
- 21:37It's not.
- 21:38So I,
- 21:39I would like young people
- 21:40to be given the proper tools in their education process
- 21:43to enable them to deal with.
- 21:45The real world
- 21:46and make them catastrophize less.
- 21:48I do think in this country,
- 21:50as in my country,
- 21:51young people are overmedicated.
- 21:53I think they go to therapy too much.
- 21:55I think they end up overanalyzing and over self-obsessing.
- 21:59I think it can make them quite narcissistic.
- 22:01It's all me,
- 22:01me,
- 22:02me,
- 22:02me,
- 22:02me,
- 22:02me,
- 22:02me,
- 22:03and woe is me,
- 22:04woe is me,
- 22:04woe is me.
- 22:05I think we've got to a place oddly in society
- 22:07where losing is deemed to be better than winning.
- 22:10Where winning is something to be frowned upon,
- 22:12actually better to be a good loser
- 22:14and get all your mates to like you going,
- 22:16oh my God,
- 22:16I just failed my driving test for the 20th time,
- 22:18but I'm so proud of myself.
- 22:20I'm like,
- 22:20you're a terrible driver,
- 22:22get better,
- 22:23right?
- 22:23So it's all about how you treat these things,
- 22:25and out of it,
- 22:26hopefully
- 22:27I would produce a nation of people like me,
- 22:29Parker.
- 22:30I would love to be able to the perfect way to win.
- 22:32I'd love to be able to.
- 22:33I'd love to see you.
- 22:33Good to see you.
- 22:36My next surrounding claim is that woke ideology is anti-liberal
- 22:39and fascistic.
- 22:44How's it going?
- 22:45How are you?
- 22:46Good to,
- 22:46good to meet you.
- 22:47My name's Evan.
- 22:48Evan,
- 22:48yeah,
- 22:48nice to meet you,
- 22:49Evan.
- 22:50My issue with this claim is I find
- 22:51associating wokeism with fascism to be quite ironic.
- 22:55Wokeism to me is a term that's used,
- 22:58a shorthand pejorative term that's used to describe
- 23:01left-wing cultural politics,
- 23:02and I think the term wokeism and people on the right often use it
- 23:06as a means to deflect and distract from class.
- 23:09Politics.
- 23:10And there's a very key example of this.
- 23:12So,
- 23:12the Department of Government Efficiency,
- 23:14Doge,
- 23:15um,
- 23:15this was something that you actually celebrated quite
- 23:17a bit when it initially came into office.
- 23:19Elon Musk was coming in
- 23:20to root out waste,
- 23:21fraud,
- 23:22and abuse.
- 23:22Obviously,
- 23:22they found zero instances of fraud.
- 23:25To the extent they found waste,
- 23:26it was just stuff that they ideologically disagreed with.
- 23:28And there were all these programs they were cutting,
- 23:30for example,
- 23:30like LGBTQ programs in Latin America,
- 23:32etc.
- 23:33and we were celebrating this all as a big.
- 23:35Victory,
- 23:35but this was all a distraction because what the agency was actually doing was,
- 23:39uh,
- 23:40destroying the National Labor Relations Board,
- 23:42a board that is designed to protect
- 23:44workers' abilities to unionize.
- 23:46The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
- 23:48a bureau that is meant to protect
- 23:49consumers from billionaire capitalists like Elon Musk.
- 23:52These institutions,
- 23:53along with the IRS,
- 23:55all of these institutions meant to actually protect
- 23:58and put a check on capitalist billionaires.
- 24:00Like Elon Musk and the consolidation of fascistic power in our state,
- 24:04all of that was being distracted by this term wokeism,
- 24:07and I think that like when,
- 24:09when you obsess,
- 24:11when you obsess over things like
- 24:13trans people in sports or
- 24:15DEI policies and X,
- 24:16Y,
- 24:16Z,
- 24:17it is a deliberate means to distract from these very real issues.
- 24:20Yes,
- 24:20100%.
- 24:20Well,
- 24:21let's take,
- 24:21let's take
- 24:22what you just mentioned,
- 24:23trans athletes in sports.
- 24:24Do you think it's a good idea?
- 24:25Uh,
- 24:26not necessarily.
- 24:27I mean,
- 24:27it
- 24:27it is or it isn't,
- 24:28so it depends on which sport and it depends on which,
- 24:30which sport,
- 24:31but notice,
- 24:32but notice what you're doing right now,
- 24:33right?
- 24:33You,
- 24:34you mentioned it.
- 24:34I didn't mention it.
- 24:35Well,
- 24:35what,
- 24:35what I mentioned is that these are all a means to distract from the very real issue.
- 24:39Can you at least,
- 24:40the very least acknowledge that you did,
- 24:41that you,
- 24:42that you,
- 24:42that you did celebrate Doge despite it
- 24:44rooting out all these institutions.
- 24:46That actually impact.
- 24:47I'll answer you.
- 24:48I thought that cutting
- 24:49government waste was a good thing.
- 24:51Do I think it was well executed?
- 24:53Not particularly.
- 24:54Sorry,
- 24:54you've got to let me finish.
- 24:55Go for it,
- 24:56go for it.
- 24:56Do I think it was well executed?
- 24:58Not particularly.
- 24:59You know,
- 24:59Elon left pretty quickly and the government just carried on spending a ton of money.
- 25:04You know,
- 25:04do I think some of the things they cut were wrong?
- 25:06Yes,
- 25:06I agree with you.
- 25:07Do I think all of them?
- 25:08No,
- 25:08I think they did find examples of ways.
- 25:10So,
- 25:10you know,
- 25:10if you had a proper consistent
- 25:12ongoing
- 25:14doge mentality which cut genuine things which we
- 25:16all can agree are probably a bit wasteful,
- 25:19I'd be all for it.
- 25:20Do I support everything they cut?
- 25:21No,
- 25:21I don't,
- 25:21but given you mentioned
- 25:23the trans thing,
- 25:24cos I hear a lot from the woke left,
- 25:25and I try and say to them,
- 25:26look.
- 25:27If you wanna know why Donald Trump got re-elected,
- 25:29your worst nightmare coming true,
- 25:31and you all sit there on election day thinking how on earth has this happened?
- 25:35Well,
- 25:35one of the reasons was he just stood there,
- 25:37well,
- 25:37you can shake your head,
- 25:38but one of the reasons is he stood there and went
- 25:40under me,
- 25:41if I get elected.
- 25:43Then I am going to ban trans athletes from women's sport.
- 25:47No,
- 25:47no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:49I'm gonna,
- 25:49I'm gonna add one thing to it,
- 25:50then you can respond.
- 25:52If you remember,
- 25:52Kamala Harris endorsed it,
- 25:54thought it was a good idea.
- 25:55So the first potential female president of the United States
- 25:58thought it was fair and equitable and safe
- 26:01that biological males compete in women's sport.
- 26:04Trump understood that most people in America,
- 26:06most people around the world
- 26:08outside of the woke left,
- 26:09do not agree with that,
- 26:10and there's a reason we don't agree with it.
- 26:12Let me finish.
- 26:13The Olympics are coming here,
- 26:15right,
- 26:15to Los Angeles you're also wrong about Imman Khalif,
- 26:17by the way,
- 26:17yeah.
- 26:18Well,
- 26:18I'm not wrong about Imman Khalif.
- 26:20Well,
- 26:20Amman Khalif was banned from the world championships,
- 26:23she's an Algerian boxer,
- 26:24banned from the world championships
- 26:26because of testing positive for male chromosomes,
- 26:29right?
- 26:29That's true.
- 26:30Well,
- 26:30it is true,
- 26:31you may not want you might not want to believe it,
- 26:33but it is true.
- 26:34So the,
- 26:35so the International Olympic Committee said that uh
- 26:37Imman Khalif was both uh born female,
- 26:39she has a female passport.
- 26:41Algeria,
- 26:42you think Algeria,
- 26:43the state of Algeria recognizes trans identity,
- 26:45really,
- 26:45Piers?
- 26:46Like let's be honest with ourselves,
- 26:47the.
- 26:47The only,
- 26:48the only institution,
- 26:49male,
- 26:50no,
- 26:50no,
- 26:50the institution that claimed that she failed an unspecified,
- 26:54uh,
- 26:54gender or sex identity test was some
- 26:56Russian-backed organization that is not internationally recognized
- 26:59by the International Olympic Committee.
- 27:01But wait,
- 27:01but,
- 27:02but wait,
- 27:02wait,
- 27:02no,
- 27:03no,
- 27:03no,
- 27:03let me,
- 27:03let me reset.
- 27:04I,
- 27:04I need,
- 27:04you can't say something and me not challenge you,
- 27:07I know,
- 27:07but that's what exactly what you did earlier.
- 27:08I just,
- 27:09I just very straightforward quickly get all I,
- 27:11all Imam Khalif has to do
- 27:13is take a sex test,
- 27:14sure,
- 27:14OK,
- 27:15then now.
- 27:15Bringing the sex,
- 27:16I don't,
- 27:17then there's no problem.
- 27:18Why do you think Imam Khalif is not,
- 27:20I don't want you to distract from the fact that the election,
- 27:22there is no evidence that people voted based on
- 27:25their opinions on trans identity give it to you.
- 27:27No,
- 27:27wait,
- 27:27no,
- 27:27wait,
- 27:28let me,
- 27:28let me,
- 27:28let in a,
- 27:29in a Gallup 2024 poll,
- 27:31yes,
- 27:32in a Gallup 2024 poll
- 27:33post-election out of 22 issues,
- 27:36trans,
- 27:37uh,
- 27:37trans issues ranked 22 out of 22.
- 27:40Every in every election in all OCD countries across the world.
- 27:44to respond,
- 27:44Evan.
- 27:45Yes,
- 27:45but Evan let you go on.
- 27:47No,
- 27:47let me just respond to you.
- 27:49Actually,
- 27:49if you read the New York Times the week after the election,
- 27:52they did a New York Times,
- 27:53then you will remember a deep dive they did into it.
- 27:56Wait a minute,
- 27:56just stop talking.
- 27:57You,
- 27:57you wanna talk all the time.
- 27:59Show me some respect.
- 28:01There was a New York Times report into a particular commercial ad,
- 28:04you know,
- 28:05campaign ad that the Trump,
- 28:06uh,
- 28:07side put out,
- 28:08and they originally started it in a few sports arenas,
- 28:09and it got bigger and bigger and bigger.
- 28:11And the ad was basically a 32nd mashup of
- 28:14Kamala Harris endorsing
- 28:16trans athletes in women's sport and in women's spaces and so on and so on.
- 28:19And it ended with Kamala is for they,
- 28:22them,
- 28:23Donald Trump is for you.
- 28:24The New York Times
- 28:25said that they believe that move the needle,
- 28:27their reporting
- 28:29by as much as 3 points.
- 28:31So this.
- 28:32As the New York Times.
- 28:33No,
- 28:33that's not,
- 28:34you,
- 28:35you understand news agencies aren't conducting polling analysis.
- 28:39That same article cited the Gallup poll that I just
- 28:42identified where trans issues ranked 22 out of 22.
- 28:451 ad moved the needle by 3 points and based on what information,
- 28:48polling if you.
- 28:49Poll people on what issues that they cared about in the,
- 28:52in the 2024 election.
- 28:54All of it was centered around economy and inflation,
- 28:56and this is just obvious because this is a global phenomenon.
- 28:58Every
- 29:00and every incumbent party across the world lost election.
- 29:02A lot of,
- 29:03a lot of Democrats and and people on the left in particular
- 29:06have tried to assure me
- 29:08that absolutely nobody cares
- 29:10about trans athletes in women's sport.
- 29:13People care,
- 29:13the right cares,
- 29:13but,
- 29:15but your median voter cares more about what's in their pock for you is you're doing.
- 29:19Exactly what I claimed you were doing by using wokeism to distract from my question,
- 29:23my question for you is this.
- 29:25I interviewed a woman called Betty Yee,
- 29:27uh,
- 29:27a couple of weeks ago on my show.
- 29:28She's a candidate to be governor of California,
- 29:31and she endorsed in my interview
- 29:34gender neutral Olympics when it comes to Los Angeles.
- 29:38Now,
- 29:38that to me
- 29:39is where the woke mind virus takes you,
- 29:42to complete
- 29:43and utter
- 29:44insanity,
- 29:45because if there was a gender neutral Olympics,
- 29:47and this woman might be.
- 29:48Governor of this state
- 29:51have any control over it with the Olympics or the policies of the Olympics.
- 29:53Wait a minute,
- 29:54wait a minute.
- 29:55I'm talking about the mindset
- 29:57that says that actually gender neutral Olympics,
- 29:59do you agree with me?
- 30:00Can we reach a point of agreement that that would be absurd?
- 30:03Um,
- 30:04I,
- 30:04I don't,
- 30:05you know,
- 30:05it you don't know,
- 30:06it depends on the sport,
- 30:07it depends on the sport.
- 30:08She specified some sports specified,
- 30:10she specified track and field,
- 30:11but guess what,
- 30:12I don't care what some you don't care about women los.
- 30:15No,
- 30:15no,
- 30:15no,
- 30:15this is a,
- 30:16this is a governor's position,
- 30:17this is a what,
- 30:17a state representative.
- 30:18Who is it,
- 30:19a mayor?
- 30:19What's your opinion?
- 30:21Honestly,
- 30:21it doesn't matter.
- 30:22This doesn't matter.
- 30:22No,
- 30:23because this person has no institutional power,
- 30:25and this is exactly what I mean.
- 30:27When you champion Elon Musk and you're like,
- 30:29oh my God,
- 30:29he's correctly identifying the woke mind virus and all and doing X,
- 30:33Y,
- 30:33and Z,
- 30:33you're distracting from the very real issue that we have an unelected billionaire.
- 30:37You're not.
- 30:38No,
- 30:39this is,
- 30:40my question.
- 30:40We are,
- 30:40we exist in the conversation of a larger Evan,
- 30:43answer my question.
- 30:44It depends on the sport.
- 30:45Give me a sport where it'll be fine,
- 30:47uh,
- 30:47archery.
- 30:52It's very good.
- 30:53Good to see you.
- 31:01How are you?
- 31:01Good to meet you,
- 31:02Pierce.
- 31:02Good to meet you.
- 31:02What's your name?
- 31:03I promised Mason.
- 31:04Mason,
- 31:04I do not mean this as an insult.
- 31:06No,
- 31:06you seem way more comforting in person.
- 31:09Like,
- 31:09you look,
- 31:10one,
- 31:10you look taller on your show,
- 31:11like,
- 31:11and you have this like very like,
- 31:13I'm 6'1.
- 31:13What are you talking about?
- 31:14I don't,
- 31:15when I saw you walk in,
- 31:16when I saw you walk in,
- 31:17I don't know,
- 31:17maybe you,
- 31:18you just look like a giant on your,
- 31:19on your show.
- 31:20Thank you.
- 31:20I don't know how to take that,
- 31:21but I'll take it as a,
- 31:22yeah,
- 31:22yeah,
- 31:22yeah,
- 31:22um,
- 31:23so I,
- 31:24I really wanna make sure that we get our definition.
- 31:26Des cracked first.
- 31:27When you say that wokeism equals fascism,
- 31:29would you say that's like the claim diluted into like a small sense.
- 31:32Here's,
- 31:32let me explain what I mean by that.
- 31:33OK,
- 31:33and I've talked about this a lot in my book,
- 31:35Woke Is Dead,
- 31:35and again,
- 31:36just to remind you,
- 31:37I come at this as a pissed off liberal
- 31:39who has nothing in common with the woke left and wants the woke left
- 31:43to actually come back to a more commonsensical electable position actually.
- 31:47And here's what I think about what wokeism became.
- 31:50It began.
- 31:51The 60s in
- 31:53black American music.
- 31:54In its origin,
- 31:55a great thing.
- 31:56It was about raising awareness for social and racial injustice.
- 31:59By that criteria,
- 32:00I'm happy to say I'm woke,
- 32:02but that's not what's happened in the last few years.
- 32:04In the last few years,
- 32:06for a combination of reasons,
- 32:07one of which the pandemic sent everybody nuts,
- 32:09and everyone was at home drinking too much on the internet,
- 32:12firing off all their ridiculous views and just got into rabbit holes and so on.
- 32:15But we can leave that.
- 32:16But wokeism.
- 32:18It's supposed to be a celebration,
- 32:20you would,
- 32:20I would think,
- 32:21agree.
- 32:22Well,
- 32:22hang on,
- 32:22hang on,
- 32:22hang on.
- 32:23It's supposed to be,
- 32:24you're the person in the center.
- 32:25Can I,
- 32:25can I talk a little bit on my 3 minutes I get before I'm voted out?
- 32:28I haven't,
- 32:28I haven't made my point.
- 32:30Do you agree that it's supposed to be about liberalism,
- 32:32about being a liberal?
- 32:33I would say that
- 32:34the idea of wokeism is kind of an evolution from a bunch of different.
- 32:37Turns that have been used to throw at the left specifically.
- 32:40So like before wokeism it was critical race theory.
- 32:42Before critical race theory,
- 32:43it was social justice.
- 32:44There's,
- 32:44there's a lot that the right specifically,
- 32:46and I know you say that you're not the right,
- 32:48but it's a reactionary,
- 32:49it's a reactionary response towards the elevation of
- 32:53certain groups that has historically been silenced.
- 32:54But does it celebrate liberalism?
- 32:56I,
- 32:57I don't think so.
- 32:57I don't think it has to.
- 32:58I think,
- 32:59I think a lot of it also has to talk about class solidarity,
- 33:01which typically is,
- 33:02let me give you a little Latin lesson,
- 33:04cos the Latin words liber meaning free,
- 33:07and also the root of liberty meaning the quality or state of being free,
- 33:10and liberalis meaning courteous,
- 33:11generous,
- 33:12gentlemanly.
- 33:12I love these definitions.
- 33:13Wait a minute,
- 33:14can you describe?
- 33:14You asked for a definition.
- 33:15Can you describe I'm giving you one.
- 33:17That's really what I wanna talk about.
- 33:18I know what fascism is.
- 33:19Wait,
- 33:19what is it then?
- 33:20Because enlighten me.
- 33:21Can I finish telling you what liberalism is?
- 33:23No,
- 33:23I know what liberalism is.
- 33:24Well,
- 33:24you don't think you do,
- 33:25because if you're awoke.
- 33:26Left,
- 33:26they don't understand what being a liberal actually means.
- 33:29I do,
- 33:30being a liberal.
- 33:30I do.
- 33:31So let me explain to you,
- 33:32the definition of a liberal include one who is
- 33:34open-minded or not strict in the observance of orthodox,
- 33:37traditional or established forms or ways,
- 33:39a person who's willing to respect or accept
- 33:41behavior or opinions different from one's own,
- 33:45favorable to or respectful of individual rights and freedoms,
- 33:48and concerned with broadening general knowledge
- 33:50and experience.
- 33:50Now,
- 33:51what part of that do you think the woke left have adhered to
- 33:54in the last five years?
- 33:56Because I'm about to tell you,
- 33:57so the woke left have basically said we hate fascists,
- 34:01we hate Nazis.
- 34:02In fact,
- 34:02we think everyone we don't agree with is a fascist and a Nazi led by Donald Trump,
- 34:07led by everyone who voted for Trump,
- 34:08led by Charlie Kirk,
- 34:09led by all these people.
- 34:11Wait,
- 34:12let me finish my point,
- 34:13then you can respond,
- 34:14that they're all a bunch of fascists,
- 34:15they're all a bunch of Nazis,
- 34:16and I kept warning the woke left
- 34:18as a pissed-off liberal,
- 34:20stop
- 34:20over demonizing people by using the word Nazi and.
- 34:24Hitler and fascists,
- 34:25it is ridiculously self-harming to yourselves,
- 34:28and it leads actually
- 34:30to young deranged minds like the assassin of Charlie Kirk
- 34:33to actually put anti-fascism slogans on their bullets
- 34:36and to murder people for their speech,
- 34:38right?
- 34:38So
- 34:39wokeism,
- 34:40in the end,
- 34:40in the last few years,
- 34:41transformed
- 34:43from what was supposed to be a celebration of liberalism in many ways
- 34:46into a form of fascism.
- 34:48Why do I say that?
- 34:49Because it conditioned people
- 34:51that you either adhere to our narrow worldview.
- 34:53And if you don't,
- 34:54we're gonna shame you,
- 34:55vilify you,
- 34:57the flags.
- 34:57I didn't even get to talk.
- 34:58We're gonna,
- 34:59I'm gonna let you respond.
- 35:01I'm gonna lose my cancel you,
- 35:02or in some circumstances we're going to kill you
- 35:05for your
- 35:05free speech and opinions.
- 35:07And that is where it became,
- 35:08in my opinion,
- 35:09a very dangerous,
- 35:10but it just sounds very deluding sounds like you're form of fascism,
- 35:13which is ironic because
- 35:14what you say they hate the fascists.
- 35:16It sounds like you're trying to correlate fascism with authoritarianism,
- 35:19which is control of speech or control of how people interact or control of behavior.
- 35:22Fascists do control.
- 35:23Right,
- 35:24that,
- 35:24that can be a part of it is the authoritarianism,
- 35:26but the specific part of fascism is specifically trying to preserve
- 35:29a hierarchy based on either shared ethnicity or shared culture.
- 35:33That is the idea of elevating one specific group into the top.
- 35:36No,
- 35:38so you're telling me that Hitler would have been wearing
- 35:39a BLM shirt or Hitler would have been wearing an
- 35:42antique because wokeism is not fascism.
- 35:44Fascism is specifically dealing with one particular group,
- 35:47but they're elevating to the top of the hierarchy.
- 35:49That's what we saw.
- 35:50That's what we saw in fascist Italy.
- 35:51That's what we saw in Nazi Germany.
- 35:53That's what we saw in Imperial Japan.
- 35:55But none of that correlates with
- 35:57the elevation of particular groups that have historically been silenced,
- 36:00which is the,
- 36:01the idea of what progressivism is.
- 36:03I hear you.
- 36:03I,
- 36:03I reject the idea of wokeness just because wokeness again is used as that
- 36:06insult that is elevated from different insults that have been thrown in the past.
- 36:10Respectfully,
- 36:10I think wokeism has become
- 36:12one of the worst scourges in the world.
- 36:14Yeah,
- 36:14because I think that there's been a successful campaign to,
- 36:17uh,
- 36:18basically attach,
- 36:19attach the woke.
- 36:20No,
- 36:20it has been to attach all of these pejorative.
- 36:22to a,
- 36:23a,
- 36:23a
- 36:24idea of emancipation from silence groups.
- 36:26That's the idea.
- 36:27The idea that silent about the idea that we should bring people to the table that
- 36:33you never stop.
- 36:33That's what I hear so much about cancel culture,
- 36:35about how everybody's getting canceled when they're millionaires with
- 36:37podcasts that talk about this shit every day.
- 36:39The best quote I have in my book,
- 36:40Woke is Dead,
- 36:41and it clearly it's still slightly alive here,
- 36:43but
- 36:43the best quote,
- 36:44I had an Australian woman come up to me
- 36:46in the streets in London and she said,
- 36:47Mr.
- 36:48Morgan,
- 36:48do you mind if I just say something about these wokeies?
- 36:50I went,
- 36:51sure,
- 36:51she said.
- 36:52They just want to suck all the joy out of life.
- 36:55And I went,
- 36:56God,
- 36:56you're so right,
- 36:57that's exactly
- 36:57what they do.
- 36:59What you are sucking
- 37:00stopping saying slurs is sucking out the joy of life.
- 37:03You wanna say slurs that bad?
- 37:04I don't wanna say slurs.
- 37:06Well,
- 37:06you are,
- 37:06that's like,
- 37:07but you are collectively the most joyless group of people to ever walk on.
- 37:10I'm cracking jokes.
- 37:13My advice is I can get a beer with you advice for all of you.
- 37:16I think you need to relax a little bit.
- 37:17Collectively,
- 37:18a bit of,
- 37:18a bit of,
- 37:18I know you love a bit of Zen,
- 37:20Zen,
- 37:21calm down,
- 37:22take a chill pill,
- 37:23right?
- 37:24see the funny side of life,
- 37:25chills respect other people's opinions,
- 37:27respect my right to have different opinions.
- 37:29I think that you've dressed this like nightmarish scenario around you,
- 37:32and then you start cowering.
- 37:33No,
- 37:33then you start cowering at the own demons that you set up.
- 37:35It's funny.
- 37:36that like are the woke,
- 37:37are the woke in this room?
- 37:39You're saying they're the joy I've sat in the middle of 20 hardcore,
- 37:42they are joyless,
- 37:43they're ruining the joy of life.
- 37:45They're sucking out the happiness,
- 37:47they're sucking out the happiness of society.
- 37:49That's the idea
- 37:50is,
- 37:50is you're saying,
- 37:51yeah,
- 37:51you're saying the happiness is being sucked out by woke people.
- 37:54I think you're just a joyless bunch,
- 37:55you should lighten up a bit.
- 37:57It's an insane overgeneralization.
- 37:59That's how I feel about British people,
- 38:00but.
- 38:07Hello.
- 38:08I'm Anne.
- 38:09Hi Anne.
- 38:10You're peers.
- 38:11I am Piers.
- 38:12Um,
- 38:12I do wanna kind of touch on the last thing that you and Mason talked about.
- 38:16I think the idea that the woke left is just this
- 38:20soulless joyless,
- 38:21uh,
- 38:22majority of the left,
- 38:23at least now is what you seem to be making it out to be.
- 38:25I don't think it's the majority,
- 38:26it's the noisy part of the left.
- 38:28OK,
- 38:29OK.
- 38:29I actually think I can agree with you there.
- 38:31I think
- 38:32it's a loud,
- 38:33loud minority of what.
- 38:34You're calling the woke left.
- 38:36I think that
- 38:37what really wokeness comes back to is that idea of
- 38:40fighting for equality,
- 38:41speaking up for people who
- 38:43don't have a voice themselves and advocating on their behalf for their rights.
- 38:47And I think that you don't,
- 38:49do you identify as a woman?
- 38:50No,
- 38:51but I think that's
- 38:51what you identify as
- 38:53that's tangential to this conversation.
- 38:54No,
- 38:54no,
- 38:54it's actually very relevant what I'm about to say.
- 38:56No,
- 38:56I don't think my identity is relevant.
- 38:58What if I started bringing up the fact that you're British
- 39:00and you're here talking to a bunch of Americans in America?
- 39:02Great.
- 39:03That would be completely irrelevant to this whole point.
- 39:05Irrelevant.
- 39:06We're talking about American the last guy to sit at
- 39:07this desk used British as a slur against me.
- 39:10So yeah,
- 39:11I mean,
- 39:11absolutely fine,
- 39:12but I've risen above justified.
- 39:13I haven't run to my therapist.
- 39:14I've risen above the slur.
- 39:16I'm not gonna report him to,
- 39:18I'm not gonna report him to the authorities for using a racial slur.
- 39:21I've moved on.
- 39:22That,
- 39:22that's great,
- 39:23but I my point in asking you what you identify is,
- 39:25is that you're talking about equality,
- 39:27the wokeism of the aligned
- 39:28to equality,
- 39:29and yet where does that equality apply if,
- 39:32for example,
- 39:32and we've touched on this already,
- 39:34if you are a woman
- 39:35athlete in sport,
- 39:37where's the equality in having a biological man
- 39:40compete against you when they have a physical advantage?
- 39:43OK,
- 39:43look,
- 39:43I think,
- 39:44well,
- 39:44that kind of strays away from.
- 39:45That's equal.
- 39:47Do I think it's equal for men and women
- 39:48to play in sports if there's an advantage that's
- 39:51like far above the threshold?
- 39:52Yes.
- 39:53No,
- 39:53I don't think that's you understand that's why we separate the sexes in sport,
- 39:56because men have a physical advantage
- 39:58to an extent,
- 39:59we do to an extent.
- 39:59So like they just do.
- 40:00OK,
- 40:01then answer the question about archery.
- 40:03What do you think about archery?
- 40:04Do you think that has to be a segregated?
- 40:05I've read,
- 40:06I've read a report,
- 40:07and correct me,
- 40:08some of them I'm sure will correct me on the internet.
- 40:09Read a report that if it was a gender neutral Olympics,
- 40:12women may end up with 2 bronze medals
- 40:15in the entire Olympics,
- 40:16right?
- 40:19You say wait,
- 40:1922 medals in the entire Olympic Games.
- 40:23In other words,
- 40:23it would be the destruction advocating for,
- 40:25no,
- 40:25I'm just saying it would be neutral,
- 40:27it would be the destruction of women's sport.
- 40:29That's why we separate the sexes,
- 40:31and that's why the issue matters.
- 40:34Sorry,
- 40:35lovely to meet you.
- 40:36Thank you.
- 40:42Excellent,
- 40:42nice suit.
- 40:43Great to meet you,
- 40:43sir.
- 40:43What's your name?
- 40:44Nick,
- 40:44nice to meet you.
- 40:46So look,
- 40:46the,
- 40:47the prompt was about the equivalency between wokeism and fascism.
- 40:50The key difference,
- 40:51well,
- 40:51to be clear,
- 40:52the prompt,
- 40:53actually,
- 40:53my real point is,
- 40:54if you want to brand everybody fascist,
- 40:57you can't behave like fascists yourself.
- 40:59But the key difference is fascism uses the power of
- 41:02the state to impose their opinions woke wokeism does not.
- 41:05Oh,
- 41:05it does.
- 41:06Was anybody deported for being woke during the Biden administration?
- 41:09Here's my answer.
- 41:10Does anybody get rounded up in the streets for their opinion?
- 41:12Did anybody get canceled because the FCC said you're being too woke?
- 41:17Can I,
- 41:17can I answer.
- 41:17Can I answer?
- 41:18Of course,
- 41:19of course.
- 41:19Actually,
- 41:20the woke left have deployed the power of the state many times.
- 41:23Look at the pandemic.
- 41:25Look at the pandemic.
- 41:26How is that wokeism?
- 41:27I'll tell you how it's woke diseases are woke now.
- 41:29No,
- 41:29woke wokeism is where you take things which are not actually science-based,
- 41:34for example,
- 41:35for example,
- 41:35the efficacy of masks,
- 41:37right,
- 41:37and by the way,
- 41:37I feel guilty of this myself.
- 41:39I'm not,
- 41:39I'm not saying I'm whiter than white about this.
- 41:41So masks are woke.
- 41:42No,
- 41:42no,
- 41:42they can be,
- 41:43if the woke mentality.
- 41:45I'll,
- 41:45I'll explain why,
- 41:46I'll explain why.
- 41:47When a government says that if you're seen without a mask during a pandemic,
- 41:51you can be fined or punished,
- 41:53you're wait,
- 41:55wait a minute.
- 41:56I'm giving you the argument which I ended up accepting,
- 41:58right,
- 41:59which is in a fast moving pandemic
- 42:01when the scientific advice changes so rapidly,
- 42:03I fell victim to this myself.
- 42:05I was.
- 42:05Very censorious to people,
- 42:07but you can't deny that the state
- 42:09had a mindset of you will conform or we will punish you.
- 42:12And it turned out they were making people,
- 42:14they were making.
- 42:15It is true.
- 42:15You may have felt uncomfortable being unmasked in public because people would say,
- 42:18hey,
- 42:19be courteous of other people.
- 42:20I didn't.
- 42:20Nobody got fired.
- 42:22Nobody lost their job.
- 42:23Nobody got did get fired and did lose their job.
- 42:25All that stuff got overturned because we are a nation of laws.
- 42:29People did get fired.
- 42:30They all lost their jobs for not wearing a mask.
- 42:32They were told they couldn't come to work.
- 42:34Who?
- 42:35Loss of thousands of people.
- 42:37Oh,
- 42:37OK,
- 42:38so thou these nebulous people lost their jobs.
- 42:40To be clear,
- 42:40you don't think anybody lost their job in the pandemic for
- 42:43refusing to wear a mask or refusing to be vaccinated.
- 42:46I think that people who were in public
- 42:48facing situations where they could have easily taken
- 42:51a,
- 42:51a
- 42:52scientifically proven preemptive measure proven.
- 42:55Yes,
- 42:55it was.
- 42:55No,
- 42:56it turned out not to be proven.
- 42:57That's my point.
- 42:58And yet the state driven by a left-wing Democrat president,
- 43:03telling you that you are spreading misinformation,
- 43:05that is not fascism,
- 43:06that is just me telling you you're wrong.
- 43:08No,
- 43:09no,
- 43:10you're,
- 43:10but you're,
- 43:10you're not telling me I'm wrong because I'm right.
- 43:12OK,
- 43:13no,
- 43:13you're just not,
- 43:14and we're,
- 43:15we're not gonna relitigate COVID,
- 43:16that's now years ago at this point.
- 43:18The key point is,
- 43:19is it fascism?
- 43:21It is not fascism.
- 43:22You gave your very long definition of liberalism.
- 43:25Wokeism is about everything on that list that you described as being liberal.
- 43:29It's about standing up for other perspectives.
- 43:31It's about listening to other people that have not traditionally been listened to.
- 43:34Oh,
- 43:35you don't listen to anybody.
- 43:36What are you talking about?
- 43:37Of course you don't.
- 43:38You said yourself wokeism started about just acknowledging social problems.
- 43:42I think it's woke that Middle America's jobs have been shipped overseas.
- 43:46That's woke to recognize that there's larger social problems.
- 43:48I don't just Police brutality,
- 43:50recognizing that there's a problem with the institution of policing.
- 43:52That's woke.
- 43:53It's not fascist.
- 43:54Would you defund the police?
- 43:55No,
- 43:56absolutely not.
- 43:56OK,
- 43:56well,
- 43:57that's woke.
- 43:58Not defunding the police is woke.
- 44:00Calling for the police to be defunded is one of the worst things the woke,
- 44:04including Mamdani in New York.
- 44:05The new mayor of New York City called for the
- 44:07first call was toxic masculinity has always meant one thing.
- 44:11Now you're saying woke used to mean one thing,
- 44:12but now it means a different thing.
- 44:14So words only have one definition when they suit you,
- 44:17but when they don't suit you,
- 44:18they change and obviously,
- 44:19obviously you said,
- 44:20you said that wokeism
- 44:22is
- 44:22a form of liberalism,
- 44:23right?
- 44:24You said that.
- 44:25Everything I read,
- 44:25wokeism is a form of just to remind you,
- 44:27a person who is willing to respect or.
- 44:29Accept behavior or opinions different from one's own.
- 44:32The woke left famously,
- 44:33I would say infamously,
- 44:35never accept anybody
- 44:37objecting to anything they say.
- 44:38We confront bad speech with better speech.
- 44:41You confront bad speech with better speech.
- 44:43No,
- 44:43you don't.
- 44:44Like denying the efficacy of masks and vaccines,
- 44:46and I'm telling you that's wrong.
- 44:47I'm not saying you should be canceled or you should be imprisoned for that.
- 44:50Actually,
- 44:51if you want my honest view.
- 44:53I do not think the efficacy of masks was ever proven.
- 44:56In fact,
- 44:56I think most of the evidence now suggests they were pretty pointless.
- 45:00Secondly,
- 45:00on vaccines,
- 45:01I think they saved millions of lives,
- 45:03but I do think it was completely misleading
- 45:05of the government here and the government in the UK and other countries
- 45:09when they stated as a scientific fact that if you had the vaccine,
- 45:12you couldn't transmit the virus.
- 45:13The measure was whether the healthcare system would be overwhelmed,
- 45:16wait a minute.
- 45:16The healthcare system did not collapse,
- 45:17it worked.
- 45:18That was all it was supposed to be.
- 45:19It wasn't that no one would ever get sick.
- 45:21I'm making the point that when you issue government
- 45:23mandates and it turns out you were wrong,
- 45:25for example,
- 45:26when they said
- 45:27you cannot transmit the virus
- 45:29if you have the vaccine,
- 45:30it turned out that wasn't true.
- 45:32Do you accept that?
- 45:33I do accept that.
- 45:33So there were lots of things they said
- 45:35which turned out to be wrong.
- 45:37So I would rather err on the side of caution,
- 45:39you know,
- 45:39with a disease that killed millions of people around the world.
- 45:41That's just me.
- 45:42Hey Nick,
- 45:43as I did,
- 45:43and in fact I was very censorious to people.
- 45:46Who took the position I'm now taking against you censorious.
- 45:49We're having this debate in a public forum.
- 45:51I'm not saying you're not allowed to speak about this.
- 45:53I'm just gonna tell you you're wrong.
- 45:54I'm making the point that I was wrong at the time about those particular parts of it.
- 45:58We can agree that the vaccines broadly,
- 46:00I think worked,
- 46:02but we can also agree the scientists got it wrong about masks.
- 46:05They got it wrong about the efficacy
- 46:06of transmission of vaccines.
- 46:08These are things we should be able to come together on.
- 46:10Hey,
- 46:10this is nice to meet you,
- 46:11great to meet you.
- 46:11It's really good to see you.
- 46:14My
- 46:15next surrounding claim is that gender neutral pronouns are pointless.
- 46:23Hello,
- 46:24how are you?
- 46:25Good.
- 46:25How are you?
- 46:26Good,
- 46:26thank you.
- 46:26I'm Jeremiah.
- 46:27OK,
- 46:27so,
- 46:28oh,
- 46:28I bet you didn't know that you were coming to a therapy session.
- 46:33I am a therapist and so finally,
- 46:36finally,
- 46:36finally,
- 46:37finally,
- 46:38but a missing link in my life.
- 46:40Yes,
- 46:41so I would argue that pronouns,
- 46:43people being wanting,
- 46:44wanting to be referred to the pronouns that they want
- 46:47actually aid them in their self-esteem improving.
- 46:50And their validation and affirmation in life.
- 46:52And they,
- 46:53then,
- 46:53then their lives obviously
- 46:55are lacking a lot of other things.
- 46:56It's like nobody cares about pronouns.
- 46:58What,
- 46:58what would their,
- 46:59what would their life be lacking?
- 47:00What pronouns are yours?
- 47:01I'm he,
- 47:01him.
- 47:02OK,
- 47:02so you're a bloke.
- 47:03Yes.
- 47:04OK,
- 47:04why do you need to call yourself he him?
- 47:05I know what you are,
- 47:06you're a,
- 47:06you're a man.
- 47:07Right,
- 47:07but I think that you're talking about people that you feel,
- 47:10do you feel affirmed by the fact that you call me he him?
- 47:12I'm talking about other pronouns,
- 47:13so like they,
- 47:14them,
- 47:15the,
- 47:15well they,
- 47:16alright,
- 47:16they them,
- 47:16yes.
- 47:17There's one person.
- 47:19call me they them,
- 47:20OK,
- 47:21they them is a plural.
- 47:23How can you be more than one So guess what?
- 47:24What about,
- 47:25what about someone 9?
- 47:25I mean,
- 47:26call me stupid,
- 47:26but someone that's non-binary who can engender what does non-binary mean?
- 47:30I'm explaining it right now,
- 47:32who have,
- 47:33who can engender both masculine and feminine traits,
- 47:35and that is their
- 47:36third gender.
- 47:38If that's what they want to be called,
- 47:39why is it so hard for you and other people.
- 47:41to call them what they want to be.
- 47:42I I just think it's all bullshit.
- 47:43But I'm asking you,
- 47:44why can't you just call them what they want to
- 47:46be called if that's what they want to be called
- 47:48to.
- 47:49So then,
- 47:49so how are you being empathic if you don't want
- 47:51to call them what they want to be called.
- 47:53But so empathy,
- 47:55so empathy is a muscle that you could develop in therapy.
- 47:57So if you went to therapy,
- 47:58you'd have developed that muscle.
- 47:59I can't think of anything I'd rather less developed.
- 48:02Well,
- 48:02when some.
- 48:03When one human being
- 48:04says to me,
- 48:05call me they them,
- 48:06I laugh,
- 48:07it's absurd.
- 48:08It's one of them.
- 48:09And,
- 48:09and,
- 48:10and that shows that you're you're
- 48:12not empathic.
- 48:13I asked a non-binary person who was a guest on my show recently,
- 48:16what does non-binary mean?
- 48:17She couldn't explain it.
- 48:19OK,
- 48:19so it was actually torturous.
- 48:20So that's her,
- 48:21but the thing is,
- 48:21what if,
- 48:21why don't you get someone on,
- 48:22on your show who can explain.
- 48:24How many pronouns are there?
- 48:25Um,
- 48:26multiple.
- 48:26How many?
- 48:27I don't know.
- 48:28I'm not,
- 48:28I'm not an expert in that.
- 48:29The last,
- 48:29the last count is there are 74 official ones.
- 48:32Do you know?
- 48:32No,
- 48:32OK,
- 48:32you're gonna say cat and dog.
- 48:34I'm a cat,
- 48:35I'm a cat.
- 48:35No,
- 48:35no,
- 48:36no,
- 48:36I'll come to those.
- 48:38No,
- 48:38no,
- 48:38no,
- 48:38no,
- 48:39no,
- 48:39no,
- 48:39no,
- 48:39no,
- 48:39no.
- 48:40I'll talk about,
- 48:40talk about gender pronouns.
- 48:42Yes,
- 48:42so am I.
- 48:43There are 74.
- 48:431 of them is astral gender,
- 48:45an affinity with space.
- 48:46So,
- 48:46where are you getting this information?
- 48:48Official genders,
- 48:49Google it,
- 48:50literally Google it.
- 48:51Have you met,
- 48:51have you had someone on your show who said,
- 48:52I'm an astral,
- 48:53whatever.
- 48:54Got one on.
- 48:55No.
- 48:56And did you pay that person to go on?
- 48:57Like I,
- 48:58I mean utter lunacy,
- 48:59the whole thing.
- 48:59It's like kids identifying as cats at school.
- 49:02You know what I would do with them happen.
- 49:04It does happen is some bogus like media presentation that does not happen.
- 49:08No,
- 49:08it has happened.
- 49:09Read my book Woke is Dead,
- 49:10it's all in there.
- 49:12I,
- 49:12I don't know.
- 49:12There was a there was a phenomenon called the furries,
- 49:15you know what it was?
- 49:16Kids would go to school and say I know what furries are and furries are not a gender,
- 49:20that that's a,
- 49:21that's its own kind of lifestyle,
- 49:23it's like.
- 49:24People in outfits,
- 49:25but this is where,
- 49:25with all due respect,
- 49:26this is where limitless self-identity takes you.
- 49:30It takes you to the absurd.
- 49:32For example,
- 49:33do you,
- 49:33do you,
- 49:34do you believe,
- 49:34let me ask you,
- 49:35do you believe that you can identify as anything you like?
- 49:38Um,
- 49:39no.
- 49:39Oh,
- 49:40what are the exceptions?
- 49:41I think that most people that when they think about their gender identity,
- 49:45it's he,
- 49:46him,
- 49:47she,
- 49:47her,
- 49:47they,
- 49:48Z.
- 49:49Those are the ones that people are,
- 49:51Z is um.
- 49:53Oh God,
- 49:54now I can't explain it.
- 49:55No,
- 49:55but,
- 49:57you've no idea,
- 49:58have you?
- 49:59It's all complete baloney.
- 50:00What's Z?
- 50:01I've no idea.
- 50:03And you're the guy trying to defend this nonsense.
- 50:05Here's my other question for you,
- 50:06right?
- 50:07So there's,
- 50:08so it used to be LGBT,
- 50:10then it was LGBTQ.
- 50:11What is it now?
- 50:12What's the,
- 50:13the it's LGBTQ plus,
- 50:15or it could be LGBTQIA2S,
- 50:182 spirit.
- 50:18Right,
- 50:19and what does it stand for?
- 50:20Two spirit or the LGBT read the whole thing,
- 50:22um,
- 50:23LG lesbian,
- 50:24gay,
- 50:25bisexual,
- 50:26uh,
- 50:26LGBT,
- 50:27trans,
- 50:28queer,
- 50:29or questioning LGBTQIA intersex,
- 50:32asexual,
- 50:34two-spirited,
- 50:34it's the two spirited individuals.
- 50:36You forgot pansexual and asexual.
- 50:38Uh,
- 50:38well,
- 50:38so pan is,
- 50:39I did say asexual,
- 50:40pan is not in there.
- 50:42Nice to nice to meet you.
- 50:49Hello,
- 50:50hello,
- 50:50Piers.
- 50:51What's your name?
- 50:51I'm Jenny.
- 50:52Jenny,
- 50:52nice to meet you.
- 50:53Nice to meet you.
- 50:54So we wanted to talk about,
- 50:55I guess your initial claim is that pronouns are silly or purposefully.
- 50:59I think we've just established how silly they are.
- 51:01I mean,
- 51:01even the people defending them can't remember what they mean.
- 51:04Right,
- 51:04so I just wanted to touch on
- 51:07two things here.
- 51:08So I don't think anyone is denying biological sex assignment at birth,
- 51:12right?
- 51:12Whatever your doctor determines,
- 51:13you're,
- 51:13well,
- 51:13it's not about doctors assigning anything,
- 51:15is it?
- 51:15You're either born with certain genitals or you're not,
- 51:18right,
- 51:18but a a.
- 51:19When you're a male or female.
- 51:21Right.
- 51:21Do you accept that?
- 51:23This whole we've got this whole phrase assigned at birth,
- 51:25what does it mean?
- 51:26That means a doctor has looked at you as a baby and they look
- 51:29at you and they just see what I look at you and see.
- 51:31I don't have to be a doctor to know what you're assigned as.
- 51:33You're just born.
- 51:34Do you accept that the vast majority of people
- 51:37ever in the history of planet Earth
- 51:38are born male or female?
- 51:40Yeah,
- 51:40I do believe that.
- 51:41But can we stop the phrase assigned at birth by a doctor?
- 51:44Literally I've had 4 babies,
- 51:46they look at them and they go,
- 51:47oh,
- 51:47it's a boy.
- 51:48It's a girl,
- 51:49that's it.
- 51:50Right,
- 51:50so a doctor determines that and writes that on your birth certificate.
- 51:54But there's no one assigning,
- 51:55can I finish my point,
- 51:56please?
- 51:56Yeah,
- 51:56but they're not assigning anything.
- 51:57Can I it's my phrase,
- 51:59please.
- 52:00Thank you.
- 52:01So
- 52:01whatever your biological sex is determined by a doctor upon your birth,
- 52:06I don't think anyone's denying that.
- 52:07However,
- 52:07gender is a construct
- 52:10that is
- 52:11how we express ourselves.
- 52:12How many genders are there?
- 52:13For me,
- 52:14I think that it's a scale,
- 52:15and however you want to express yourself is up to you.
- 52:18with anything I want.
- 52:19Well,
- 52:20if you let me finish my point,
- 52:21OK,
- 52:21so,
- 52:22for example,
- 52:22we talk about masculinity,
- 52:24we talk about femininity,
- 52:25and some days I feel like I want to feel more feminine,
- 52:28so I wear a dress or I do things
- 52:29that are socially constructed and designated as feminine,
- 52:32or maybe other people have like this idea of masculinity,
- 52:35so they present themselves in that way.
- 52:37So gender is different from biological sex in that it's how you express yourself.
- 52:41To me,
- 52:42somebody's gender expression and how they want to be addressed is no different
- 52:47than using some.
- 52:47Somebody's name,
- 52:48because I,
- 52:49I write,
- 52:49so when we use pronouns,
- 52:50it's with purpose,
- 52:51right?
- 52:52What are your pronouns?
- 52:52She,
- 52:53her.
- 52:53So you're a woman.
- 52:54Yes.
- 52:54So why do you need to call yourself she her?
- 52:56Well,
- 52:57I,
- 52:57that's just how you address women.
- 52:59So why,
- 53:00why use them as pronouns?
- 53:02But pronouns are just used in the English language.
- 53:03We never used to,
- 53:04this is just only started 10 years ago.
- 53:06Nobody ever pronouns has always been used in the English language.
- 53:09I'm talking about the new cavalcade of extra pronouns.
- 53:13I think we're making it out to be so much more than it really is.
- 53:16If you're a.
- 53:17And you're a he,
- 53:18him,
- 53:18that's it,
- 53:19right?
- 53:19The rest of it is just a complete construct of the woke left,
- 53:22and none of it,
- 53:23as we've already established,
- 53:24none of it makes sense to the point that none of you can even explain half of it.
- 53:27No,
- 53:27and I'm still explaining it,
- 53:29so how many genders are there?
- 53:30I'm still talking about gender expression.
- 53:32Can you tell me how many genders there are?
- 53:34I'm talking about how many are there?
- 53:36I personally
- 53:37don't care.
- 53:38I don't know.
- 53:39Do you know a number?
- 53:40No,
- 53:40because for biological sex,
- 53:41maybe we can talk about that in bin in the concept of limitless self-identity.
- 53:45Um,
- 53:46no,
- 53:46so.
- 53:47So where's the,
- 53:47where's the limit?
- 53:48If you would let me continue,
- 53:49where's the limit?
- 53:49If you would let me continue,
- 53:51thank you.
- 53:52So what I'm saying though is that when you refer
- 53:54to somebody and their pronouns that they ask for,
- 53:57it's just general English language how we use it.
- 53:59There are plenty of languages out there that don't even have pronouns,
- 54:03um,
- 54:03because that's just how the language works.
- 54:06So if you can speak a different language and not have to refer
- 54:08to somebody by their pronouns and know exactly who you're talking to,
- 54:11then I don't think pronouns are a big deal.
- 54:12I hear you,
- 54:13and you,
- 54:13and you phrased it very,
- 54:14you know,
- 54:15nicely,
- 54:15but my point being.
- 54:16I think it's got completely out of hand.
- 54:18When there are 74 cited genders,
- 54:21if you Google it,
- 54:22as the official list of genders,
- 54:24and one of them is an affinity with space,
- 54:26I'm calling bullshit.
- 54:28When you have LGBTQ and it now has so many letters that even experts in the field
- 54:33of the LGBT community acronym cannot remember what they all mean,
- 54:38it is ridiculous.
- 54:40And when it comes to limitless self-identity,
- 54:41I had this debate with someone on Women's
- 54:43International Women's Day on my show Uncensored.
- 54:46And I had two guests,
- 54:47one was white,
- 54:48one was black.
- 54:49There's a relevance to that.
- 54:50And we were talking about this,
- 54:51and I said,
- 54:52right,
- 54:53two women.
- 54:53I said,
- 54:54um,
- 54:55do you believe in limitless self-identity?
- 54:57And the,
- 54:58the wokey
- 54:58of the two guests said,
- 55:00I do,
- 55:00and you have to respect what people
- 55:02want.
- 55:03And she said,
- 55:03yes.
- 55:03I went,
- 55:04OK,
- 55:04in that case,
- 55:05I,
- 55:05on International Women's Day,
- 55:07Piers Morgan,
- 55:07am now identifying as a black lesbian.
- 55:10And the black panelist burst out laughing because she knew what I was doing,
- 55:13which is taking this argument
- 55:15to its logical conclusion,
- 55:17which is once you make it limitless,
- 55:20society just collapses because anyone
- 55:22can say that they're anything they want.
- 55:24And and you would say to me,
- 55:25if I said to you I'm a black lesbian,
- 55:26what would you say?
- 55:27I would say that you're conflating this idea of limitless.
- 55:31Like whatever gender expression or self-identity.
- 55:34I already said I don't agree with that.
- 55:36But you didn't say where the limit is,
- 55:37right?
- 55:37So for me personally,
- 55:39and what I believe is that there are scientific
- 55:41things that we can agree to like biological sex,
- 55:43right?
- 55:43But gender expression is a cultural and societal,
- 55:46where is the limit right?
- 55:47So you can't identify as another race because that's just genetically not correct,
- 55:51right?
- 55:51So there are limits to this.
- 55:53Yeah,
- 55:53I do.
- 55:53So I'm really curious where the woke limit is on self-identity.
- 55:57Gender is a social construct.
- 55:59The social construct means we made it up,
- 56:00right?
- 56:01Yes,
- 56:01exactly.
- 56:02So it's completely so therefore you can have whatever identity that
- 56:06you want because you've decided to create that but my point,
- 56:10the point of my,
- 56:11but why is that a problem?
- 56:12No,
- 56:12here's the problem,
- 56:13it's got so out of control.
- 56:16Nice to meet you,
- 56:17nice to meet you.
- 56:24Got you.
- 56:24Um,
- 56:25hi,
- 56:25Ryan.
- 56:26Nice to meet you,
- 56:26Ryan.
- 56:27Oh,
- 56:27peers.
- 56:29So actually
- 56:30I have my preferred pronouns.
- 56:31OK,
- 56:31what are they?
- 56:31Uh,
- 56:32hot,
- 56:32hotter,
- 56:32hottest.
- 56:33I can call you that.
- 56:34I can honor that,
- 56:34yeah.
- 56:35But throughout the conversation,
- 56:36I expect you to call me,
- 56:36all right,
- 56:37hottie,
- 56:37is that OK?
- 56:38Uh,
- 56:38I prefer hottest.
- 56:40Hottest.
- 56:40OK,
- 56:40that,
- 56:41well,
- 56:41I take that personal because I thought I was.
- 56:43Um,
- 56:44so look,
- 56:45I,
- 56:45I think you do this really great job of taking the
- 56:48far edge use case and writing a book about it.
- 56:50I think what you're trying to do is take this thing that is explicitly a.
- 56:53One dimensional,
- 56:55two dimensional
- 56:55range and adding things like this
- 56:58random,
- 56:59you know,
- 56:59star thing and then elephants and all that stuff.
- 57:02Nobody who is
- 57:03serious random.
- 57:04Oh fine,
- 57:05fine,
- 57:05I'll tell you what,
- 57:06you're right,
- 57:06you're right.
- 57:06If you can Google it,
- 57:07it must be the mainstream.
- 57:09If you read my book,
- 57:09you'll see these are specific examples.
- 57:11No,
- 57:11I got it,
- 57:11I got it.
- 57:11No,
- 57:12I understand.
- 57:12You're really good at taking anecdotes and making them data.
- 57:14If that was how science works,
- 57:15not data,
- 57:16not data,
- 57:17just facts.
- 57:18Well,
- 57:18for example,
- 57:19for example,
- 57:20for example,
- 57:20there was a school in.
- 57:21The north of England called the Alteringham School for Girls,
- 57:24where everybody there
- 57:25is a girl.
- 57:26That's why they call it Alteringham School for Girls.
- 57:28And then because of the trans activist campaign,
- 57:31eventually they banned teachers and pupils from referring to each other
- 57:35as girls,
- 57:36even though everybody there
- 57:37was a girl.
- 57:38I think,
- 57:38I think the vast majority of people who care about
- 57:40this at all would say that's an edge case,
- 57:42and most of us think that's weird.
- 57:43Great.
- 57:44That's the vast majority,
- 57:45and I agree with you.
- 57:46Yeah.
- 57:46So explain to me why you think
- 57:47personal pronouns.
- 57:49matter.
- 57:49Well,
- 57:50you know,
- 57:50the question of gender has gone back for thousands of years.
- 57:53There were over 150 distinct civilizations in North America
- 57:56before colonialism that had more than two genders.
- 57:58So this is what we in the real world like
- 58:00to call an open question that evolves over time.
- 58:02I don't think that the fact that the question
- 58:04exists means there's some systemic sickness within society,
- 58:08and I don't understand why the fact that something that maybe you're
- 58:10not that familiar with or is an open question makes you uncomfortable.
- 58:13My argument is only that it's pointless.
- 58:15Well,
- 58:15I mean,
- 58:15what,
- 58:16what are your?
- 58:16What are,
- 58:16what are your pronouns?
- 58:17He,
- 58:18him,
- 58:18right,
- 58:18so everyone I've asked has basically said
- 58:20she,
- 58:21her,
- 58:21he,
- 58:21him.
- 58:22Well,
- 58:22in my day it was just male and female,
- 58:24man and woman.
- 58:24Got it.
- 58:25So here's the thing that you,
- 58:26but,
- 58:26but it's not for us to get,
- 58:27it's not ours to get.
- 58:28That's the point.
- 58:29No,
- 58:29but my point is I shouldn't be compelled
- 58:31to use absurd.
- 58:32You don't,
- 58:33well,
- 58:33no,
- 58:33fine,
- 58:33listen,
- 58:34I,
- 58:34whatever you call absurd,
- 58:35fine,
- 58:35whatever you choose not to,
- 58:36you shouldn't have to call me hottest's the thing,
- 58:38you could go around even though I say my preferred pronoun is hottest,
- 58:41you don't have to,
- 58:41you could listen,
- 58:42as a gay man,
- 58:42you could go around calling me a.
- 58:44And that would be OK.
- 58:45You would be allowed to do that.
- 58:46You're not gonna get arrested,
- 58:46you're not gonna go to prison.
- 58:48You can do whatever you.
- 58:49Exactly,
- 58:49it would be offensive and unkind.
- 58:51It would not be OK,
- 58:53but you could do it.
- 58:54What I'm saying is you don't have to accept other people's pronouns.
- 58:57Yes,
- 58:57well,
- 58:57you've been saying a lot.
- 58:58You're I'm referring to things you've said.
- 59:00You're putting words into my mouth.
- 59:01Correct me.
- 59:02You should let me say what I think about you,
- 59:03go for it.
- 59:04I can't wait.
- 59:04I just found your terminology offensive.
- 59:06OK.
- 59:07I.
- 59:07Is that all you were gonna say?
- 59:08Obviously,
- 59:09look,
- 59:09we can agree that when there are derogatory terms like that,
- 59:11it's offensive.
- 59:12Of course,
- 59:13right.
- 59:13And so if I find it offensive that you refuse to honor someone and they them pronouns,
- 59:17I'm allowed to be offended by that,
- 59:19you're allowed to be offensive.
- 59:20That's a thing that can happen out in the world that doesn't make you right.
- 59:23No,
- 59:23but we had a crazy phase,
- 59:25which I talk about in the book
- 59:26where literally where companies,
- 59:28you know,
- 59:29big companies,
- 59:30people were getting fired for not using people's pronouns.
- 59:32I don't think,
- 59:33look,
- 59:34do you agree that you agree that's insane.
- 59:36Hold on,
- 59:36listen,
- 59:37anytime change happens,
- 59:38there are gonna be blips of extremity.
- 59:40Nobody I don't think anybody should get fired.
- 59:42No,
- 59:42nobody should be fired.
- 59:43It'd be great.
- 59:45Yeah,
- 59:45no,
- 59:45but the vast majority of people think that,
- 59:46Piers.
- 59:47I mean,
- 59:48this for the same reason that most of us call ourselves woke,
- 59:50tongue in cheek,
- 59:51where there's,
- 59:51there's
- 59:52minutia,
- 59:53there's little details,
- 59:54a little off the onto the side cases,
- 59:56and then there's what's
- 59:58that's what's common.
- 59:58And what's common is people respect people's pronouns,
- 1:00:01but it is uncommon
- 1:00:02for an employer to fire someone for refusing to put them in their email signature
- 1:00:05more common than you think and actually became a very insidious part of wokeism.
- 1:00:09Which is,
- 1:00:09which is the,
- 1:00:10the what I call the,
- 1:00:11the canceled culture.
- 1:00:11We're gonna come to that as a separate question,
- 1:00:13but this whole idea that if you don't conform
- 1:00:16to a particular worldview,
- 1:00:18you have to be.
- 1:00:19No,
- 1:00:19look,
- 1:00:19I understand,
- 1:00:20I understand that,
- 1:00:21look,
- 1:00:21there are,
- 1:00:22there are people on the far extreme of,
- 1:00:23of both the left and the right who want to get rid of people who
- 1:00:26believe,
- 1:00:27think differently than they do.
- 1:00:27That's a both sided on both sides.
- 1:00:29But,
- 1:00:29but 95% of us are inside of those sides.
- 1:00:32This is not like a systemic
- 1:00:34problem with our whole human society.
- 1:00:36This is a,
- 1:00:36uh,
- 1:00:36this is a far.
- 1:00:37Edge use case.
- 1:00:38So if you want to write a book and you want to
- 1:00:40go around talking about it like it applies to all of us,
- 1:00:42I just want to be clear,
- 1:00:43you're taking a molehill and making a mountain out of it.
- 1:00:46Sounds like you pretty well agree with me.
- 1:00:48Well,
- 1:00:48yeah,
- 1:00:48no,
- 1:00:48I agree with
- 1:00:49the principle of
- 1:00:51some of these things can be extreme.
- 1:00:53What I disagree with is how you take it
- 1:00:54and you make it this permanently awful bad thing,
- 1:00:57black and white,
- 1:00:58binary,
- 1:00:58it's bad,
- 1:00:59and you want to dismiss out of hand anyone that might be.
- 1:01:02I think wokeism as a mindset
- 1:01:04is honestly,
- 1:01:05I think it's.
- 1:01:05A joyless,
- 1:01:07hectoring,
- 1:01:08censoring,
- 1:01:09virtue signaling load of old load of old crap.
- 1:01:12I do,
- 1:01:12I do,
- 1:01:13and I say that I hear you and like I say,
- 1:01:14I don't say that cos I'm on the right,
- 1:01:16cos I'm not.
- 1:01:16The right,
- 1:01:17the right will tell you I'm not one of them.
- 1:01:19Ask them what they think about things like
- 1:01:20gun control and abortion and things like that,
- 1:01:23right?
- 1:01:23Your contrarian thing works is a great brand,
- 1:01:25and I believe it's authentic,
- 1:01:26I believe it's authentic.
- 1:01:26I genuinely,
- 1:01:27I genuinely sit in the middle on this.
- 1:01:28Well,
- 1:01:29I,
- 1:01:29here,
- 1:01:29fine,
- 1:01:30but here's the thing,
- 1:01:31I
- 1:01:32want to just
- 1:01:33be clear.
- 1:01:34That
- 1:01:35what we're talking about are
- 1:01:37holding against the whole of society
- 1:01:39edge cases.
- 1:01:40I have been a grassroots activist for 15 years.
- 1:01:42I also do stand-up comedy with all kinds of people.
- 1:01:44People say things that are offensive all the time,
- 1:01:46and every once in a while in all these places you
- 1:01:48run into one or maybe two people who are these joyless,
- 1:01:51you know,
- 1:01:52you know,
- 1:01:52joy sucking,
- 1:01:53you know,
- 1:01:54nothing is OK people.
- 1:01:55But all of us,
- 1:01:56the vast majority of us who give a shit about any of these things,
- 1:01:59find those people to be
- 1:02:01unusual.
- 1:02:02They get cornered over there and they're over there.
- 1:02:03And we don't do,
- 1:02:04and that's why,
- 1:02:05that's why when you say wokeism is like that,
- 1:02:07we all go bullshit because that's not how we are.
- 1:02:09Listen,
- 1:02:09listen,
- 1:02:10I,
- 1:02:10I agree that
- 1:02:11all encompassing,
- 1:02:12you know,
- 1:02:13verdicts on a group of people
- 1:02:15is often a bit misleading.
- 1:02:15If you're,
- 1:02:16you know,
- 1:02:16you're clearly not an extreme progressive wokey,
- 1:02:19right?
- 1:02:20You're some are probably a bit more normal,
- 1:02:22which is,
- 1:02:22like I said at the start,
- 1:02:24no,
- 1:02:24but you know,
- 1:02:24but I,
- 1:02:25I can see you probably are,
- 1:02:26you've probably got quite a common sense
- 1:02:27valve in you,
- 1:02:28right?
- 1:02:28I hope so.
- 1:02:29And that's all I,
- 1:02:30all I want really is common sense.
- 1:02:32Good luck to you.
- 1:02:40Hello.
- 1:02:40Hi Sophie,
- 1:02:41nice to meet you.
- 1:02:41Sophie,
- 1:02:42nice to meet you.
- 1:02:43So what are your pronouns?
- 1:02:44She,
- 1:02:45her.
- 1:02:45Great,
- 1:02:45another one.
- 1:02:46But,
- 1:02:46so actually,
- 1:02:47oddly,
- 1:02:47ironically,
- 1:02:48none of you have anything but the standard old pronouns,
- 1:02:51which we never needed
- 1:02:52because everyone knew you were a woman or a man.
- 1:02:54Yes,
- 1:02:54however,
- 1:02:55my best friend goes by gender neutral pronouns,
- 1:02:57and I am an 18 year old high school student.
- 1:03:00What do you mean by that?
- 1:03:00Uh,
- 1:03:01they go by they them.
- 1:03:02They then,
- 1:03:02but it's only one of them.
- 1:03:03Yes.
- 1:03:03Explain that.
- 1:03:04They then can refer to a singular person.
- 1:03:07Like I,
- 1:03:08I feel like if somebody comes to my house and drops off a package at the door,
- 1:03:11I say,
- 1:03:12oh,
- 1:03:12they left the package there.
- 1:03:13I'm not like,
- 1:03:14oh,
- 1:03:14he left the package there,
- 1:03:15she left the package there.
- 1:03:16I say they left the package there,
- 1:03:18and that's only referring to one person.
- 1:03:20Um,
- 1:03:21so I'm an 18 year old high school student,
- 1:03:23and many of my friends
- 1:03:25are trans or go by gender neutral pronouns.
- 1:03:29Are they,
- 1:03:29cos what's happening is quite interesting,
- 1:03:31apparently
- 1:03:32the number of people,
- 1:03:33no,
- 1:03:33no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:35the,
- 1:03:35the number of people,
- 1:03:36well,
- 1:03:36I'm talking about a group of people,
- 1:03:37all the reports are suggesting in the last year there's been a dramatic collapse
- 1:03:41in the number of young people at colleges and universities identifying as trans,
- 1:03:45which would confirm to me
- 1:03:46that the thing was a fad which got completely out of hand and the people and the.
- 1:03:50People I actually felt sorry for were the people who are genuinely trans
- 1:03:54in some cases go through years of surgery cos they feel they're
- 1:03:58born to the wrong body,
- 1:03:59the wrong sex,
- 1:04:00and so on.
- 1:04:00I feel like they have been lost in all this conversation.
- 1:04:03They've been made to feel ridiculous,
- 1:04:05they've been mocked and so on,
- 1:04:06and I feel badly for those people
- 1:04:08because actually
- 1:04:09a lot of this trans stuff,
- 1:04:11particularly with young people.
- 1:04:12Colleges has been a fad.
- 1:04:14And you know,
- 1:04:14there was a school near me
- 1:04:16near where I grew up in East Sussex in England,
- 1:04:18where 900 kids in one school were apparently trans do golf.
- 1:04:24Honestly,
- 1:04:24I understand.
- 1:04:25I understand,
- 1:04:26however,
- 1:04:26I think
- 1:04:27it's about respect and it's about garnering respect
- 1:04:30to
- 1:04:31the people who are
- 1:04:32like you're talking to a person.
- 1:04:34And if they want to be called they them by the pronouns,
- 1:04:37they want to be called a black lesbian.
- 1:04:39OK,
- 1:04:39but that,
- 1:04:40that gets into a race conversation.
- 1:04:41That's not what we're talking about.
- 1:04:43If I want to be called,
- 1:04:43uh,
- 1:04:44let me think of something.
- 1:04:44No,
- 1:04:44we're talking about they.
- 1:04:46We're talking about gender neutral pronouns.
- 1:04:47That was if I want to be hot,
- 1:04:49hotter hottest.
- 1:04:50OK,
- 1:04:50well.
- 1:04:51That would be your choice.
- 1:04:52Would you respect that?
- 1:04:52Yes,
- 1:04:53I would.
- 1:04:53So you would call me that,
- 1:04:54yeah,
- 1:04:55because that is your pronouns.
- 1:04:56And so I,
- 1:04:58I feel like,
- 1:04:59you must call me that.
- 1:05:00OK,
- 1:05:01uh,
- 1:05:02but I'm referring to you
- 1:05:03at the moment.
- 1:05:04But,
- 1:05:06but address me and another thing is that.
- 1:05:08So you go OK,
- 1:05:09so hotter.
- 1:05:11OK,
- 1:05:11thank you,
- 1:05:11um.
- 1:05:13This can really catch on.
- 1:05:15Language evolves over time.
- 1:05:16But you see how ridiculous that exchange was.
- 1:05:18No,
- 1:05:18it's preposterous.
- 1:05:22Sorry,
- 1:05:22lovely to meet you.
- 1:05:29Welcome back.
- 1:05:30Hey,
- 1:05:30good to see you again.
- 1:05:31Good to see you again.
- 1:05:32So
- 1:05:33I think that like the,
- 1:05:34the fixation on this really shows your emotional connection to the
- 1:05:38idea of pronouns more than like other people's want to self-identify,
- 1:05:42because for me,
- 1:05:42it's like I've had people come up to me,
- 1:05:44I work in a lot of queer spaces and nonprofit work,
- 1:05:46and I've had people who say
- 1:05:48they're they them,
- 1:05:49I misgendered them on accident.
- 1:05:50I call them,
- 1:05:51you know,
- 1:05:51if they look
- 1:05:52very femme presenting,
- 1:05:53I'll call them she,
- 1:05:54her,
- 1:05:54and they'll be like,
- 1:05:55actually it's they them.
- 1:05:56In my mind,
- 1:05:56I'm like,
- 1:05:57OK,
- 1:05:57I messed up.
- 1:05:58They're not chastising me,
- 1:05:59they're not pissed at me.
- 1:06:00They're not gonna like victimize me afterwards.
- 1:06:02And that's a majority of people.
- 1:06:04If,
- 1:06:04if there are people that do feel a sense of defensiveness,
- 1:06:07it's because there's been a propaganda campaign
- 1:06:09nationally that's been pushed on these people
- 1:06:11specifically to target and victimize them.
- 1:06:13So my big thing is,
- 1:06:13if we want people to be less offensive and less emotional,
- 1:06:16why are we fixating so much on it?
- 1:06:17Why are the people that say they hate pronouns
- 1:06:19so much talking about pronouns every chance they get?
- 1:06:21I just think when we get to 74 different ways of identifying your gender,
- 1:06:25and one of them is an affinity with the stars.
- 1:06:28You should all accept it's got ridiculous,
- 1:06:30and my point of saying things like I identify as a black lesbian or whatever,
- 1:06:34is simply to show
- 1:06:35that if you
- 1:06:36allow things to be limitless,
- 1:06:38it goes to ridiculous places.
- 1:06:40We've had,
- 1:06:40I mean that Rachel Dolezll story,
- 1:06:42do you remember that was the,
- 1:06:43the white woman pretending to be black,
- 1:06:46right?
- 1:06:46It was absolutely absurd,
- 1:06:47and she's led this whole life as a,
- 1:06:49as a fake person.
- 1:06:50It's all that kind of stuff.
- 1:06:52I,
- 1:06:52to me,
- 1:06:53to me,
- 1:06:53to me it's fuel,
- 1:06:54it's fueled by a mindset that says anyone can.
- 1:06:57You know,
- 1:06:58they use the phrase express themselves,
- 1:06:59but actually
- 1:07:00if your gender identity and you want people to use this,
- 1:07:03if we get to 74,
- 1:07:0580,
- 1:07:06100,
- 1:07:06right,
- 1:07:06it becomes,
- 1:07:07as I point out,
- 1:07:09completely pointless.
- 1:07:10Yeah,
- 1:07:10but if,
- 1:07:10if you're someone who feels this like sense that
- 1:07:12you need to identify as hot and hottest,
- 1:07:14I'm just gonna call you Pierce.
- 1:07:15Like that's really how it is my point.
- 1:07:17Yeah,
- 1:07:17so my thing is you've answered my,
- 1:07:19that's,
- 1:07:19that's it.
- 1:07:20No,
- 1:07:20exactly,
- 1:07:20and that's what you can do.
- 1:07:21No,
- 1:07:21no,
- 1:07:22you agree.
- 1:07:22No,
- 1:07:22but,
- 1:07:22but you're going on a show and you're
- 1:07:24writing a book specifically highlighting these people.
- 1:07:26That's the difference.
- 1:07:28I'm not making a big stink saying this is the degradation of society.
- 1:07:31I'm saying that this is somebody who's
- 1:07:33saying something that I don't totally understand,
- 1:07:34get it,
- 1:07:34but just because I don't understand it,
- 1:07:36I can still respect them.
- 1:07:37I know.
- 1:07:37I don't have to punch down and specifically target them out.
- 1:07:40That's the difference.
- 1:07:40There are a million things more important in life
- 1:07:44than
- 1:07:44being concerned about how people call you.
- 1:07:46Then don't focus on it,
- 1:07:47Pierce.
- 1:07:47Why are you writing a book about it if
- 1:07:49there's millions of things to concern yourself with?
- 1:07:51Why aren't you talking about a genocide happening in Palestine?
- 1:07:53Why aren't you talking about actual victims that are.
- 1:07:57you're writing a book about people who say astrogender,
- 1:07:59something I've never heard before,
- 1:08:01and I work in queer spaces,
- 1:08:02mate,
- 1:08:02time out.
- 1:08:03I literally do a show
- 1:08:05every night where I talk about
- 1:08:07the wars in Ukraine
- 1:08:09and Gaza and other major issues.
- 1:08:10I'm just talking about this.
- 1:08:11I'm talking about this because I think it was
- 1:08:13very interesting to me that Donald Trump got re-elected.
- 1:08:15I was like,
- 1:08:16how has this happened?
- 1:08:17And I think it was partly immigration,
- 1:08:19it was partly the economy,
- 1:08:20and it was partly
- 1:08:21what the Democrats call the culture,
- 1:08:23well,
- 1:08:23and partly the culture wars,
- 1:08:25right?
- 1:08:25A lot of people were fed up with this.
- 1:08:26I think it really was a big focus on the economy,
- 1:08:28and I think you're right there,
- 1:08:29and I think Trump's version of populism spoke to
- 1:08:31a lot of people who have been disenfranchised.
- 1:08:33Also the culture war stuff,
- 1:08:35it did cut through didn't.
- 1:08:36Yes,
- 1:08:36it did.
- 1:08:36That's not and I don't meet anybody on the left who will admit it.
- 1:08:40None of you admit it,
- 1:08:41because if you talk about people's economic conditions,
- 1:08:43they're not gonna give a shit of who their
- 1:08:44neighbors are and what their pronouns identify as.
- 1:08:46They just want to be able to afford meals for their kids and actually get healthcare.
- 1:08:50Exactly,
- 1:08:51hence why gender pronouns are pointless.
- 1:08:53No,
- 1:08:53if,
- 1:08:53if it,
- 1:08:53if.
- 1:08:55If a certain group of people feel more comfortable,
- 1:08:57that shouldn't be something we discriminate.
- 1:09:01My final surrounding claim is that cancel culture is real
- 1:09:05and a serious threat to free speech.
- 1:09:12How are you?
- 1:09:12Hey,
- 1:09:12Pierce,
- 1:09:13I'm Tyler N.
- 1:09:13Good to meet you,
- 1:09:14T.
- 1:09:14OK,
- 1:09:15so I actually,
- 1:09:15I read your book.
- 1:09:16Yes,
- 1:09:16what did you think?
- 1:09:17So,
- 1:09:17um,
- 1:09:17oh,
- 1:09:17I liked it.
- 1:09:18I like that you gave,
- 1:09:18like,
- 1:09:19you know,
- 1:09:19the movie American Fiction the praise it deserves,
- 1:09:21but,
- 1:09:21um,
- 1:09:22so on page 81.
- 1:09:23You talk about how you're a liberal who respects free speech,
- 1:09:26and on that page,
- 1:09:28you say the Republican Party,
- 1:09:29and I quote,
- 1:09:30is ferociously free speech.
- 1:09:32Yet Donald Trump two months ago signed an executive order
- 1:09:34banning the burning of the American flag.
- 1:09:36So how does that work?
- 1:09:37I don't agree with him.
- 1:09:38Yeah,
- 1:09:38but then how are they ferociously free?
- 1:09:40I don't agree with him.
- 1:09:40No,
- 1:09:40but no,
- 1:09:41on your book on page 81,
- 1:09:42you said they're ferocious.
- 1:09:43I would say in the last few years,
- 1:09:44the Republicans have been more pro-free speech than the woke left.
- 1:09:47That doesn't mean occasionally,
- 1:09:49as we saw with the Jimmy Kimmel thing,
- 1:09:50it doesn't mean that occasionally
- 1:09:52they don't do stuff.
- 1:09:53Which I think is hypocritical because actually it's not supporting free speech.
- 1:09:57So I,
- 1:09:58I agree with you.
- 1:09:59So what,
- 1:09:59um,
- 1:09:59executive order did the Democrats pull?
- 1:10:02Were they banning anything to the regard of burning the American flag?
- 1:10:06I don't think it happens.
- 1:10:06I'm talking about,
- 1:10:07well,
- 1:10:07I don't agree with it,
- 1:10:08so,
- 1:10:09but your book it's a ferociously free speech.
- 1:10:11It's a contradiction.
- 1:10:12They are.
- 1:10:12Should we just turn,
- 1:10:13turn or tear page 81 out of your book then?
- 1:10:16No,
- 1:10:16no,
- 1:10:17no,
- 1:10:17you can be ferociously free speech and
- 1:10:19still occasionally do things which are hypocritical.
- 1:10:21So,
- 1:10:22OK,
- 1:10:22like.
- 1:10:23Like yourself,
- 1:10:24but um,
- 1:10:25so where have I been hypocritical?
- 1:10:26So,
- 1:10:26OK,
- 1:10:26so on um page 245,
- 1:10:28you,
- 1:10:29I like the book,
- 1:10:30what can I say?
- 1:10:31Are you like one of those weird little mentalists
- 1:10:32who just remembers every single word of every page?
- 1:10:34I'm just a massive Celebrity Apprentice fan,
- 1:10:36so I need no idea?
- 1:10:37Oh,
- 1:10:38you killed Trace Adkins in the end.
- 1:10:39I really appreciate that.
- 1:10:40I actually bumped into him in Beverly Hills recently.
- 1:10:42But so on page 245,
- 1:10:44you talk about how you are against,
- 1:10:45if you were king for a date,
- 1:10:47you would ban anybody
- 1:10:48who participates in cancel culture online.
- 1:10:50Yes,
- 1:10:51and you would call them out.
- 1:10:52However,
- 1:10:53Michael Knowles,
- 1:10:54a guest you have on all the time,
- 1:10:55has recently said that he wants to ostracize certain people from society,
- 1:10:59that when they,
- 1:11:00they say negative things.
- 1:11:01He was on this show and said if you wave
- 1:11:03the pride flag,
- 1:11:04you should be in jail for that.
- 1:11:06That is against the First Amendment and that is absolutely cancel culture.
- 1:11:09I don't yet you never call him out on that.
- 1:11:11You've never done it.
- 1:11:12You have him on the show all the time.
- 1:11:13I will,
- 1:11:14next time he's on,
- 1:11:15I will call him,
- 1:11:16you promise you have,
- 1:11:17you have a match.
- 1:11:18So like right now though,
- 1:11:19it just seems to me anyone who watches my show will know I call out everybody.
- 1:11:23You don't,
- 1:11:23you never call Michael Knowles.
- 1:11:24He's done it multiple times.
- 1:11:25You've just pointed that out to me,
- 1:11:27so we'll call him out of it.
- 1:11:27It just sounds like you're not,
- 1:11:28Michael,
- 1:11:29if you're watching,
- 1:11:30I'm gonna ask you about that.
- 1:11:31You better,
- 1:11:31you better have your,
- 1:11:32OK,
- 1:11:33so then,
- 1:11:33other than,
- 1:11:33so what has the left done?
- 1:11:34Has I'm not left or right.
- 1:11:37What has the left,
- 1:11:38what has the left done in the past 10 years that has
- 1:11:40been worse than trying to ban the burning of the American flag?
- 1:11:43Well,
- 1:11:43well,
- 1:11:43what's the woke left done?
- 1:11:45Pretty,
- 1:11:45they're trying to ban everybody and really they tried to make it illegal.
- 1:11:48Name one example.
- 1:11:49That's just not that flag.
- 1:11:50So yeah,
- 1:11:50but what legislation they put forward?
- 1:11:53Nothing,
- 1:11:53no,
- 1:11:54but here's the big question back to you.
- 1:11:55What's,
- 1:11:56what's more being canceled than being put in prison?
- 1:11:58Well,
- 1:11:58OK,
- 1:11:59I'll let me give you an example.
- 1:12:00I'll give you an example.
- 1:12:01Graham Linehan.
- 1:12:02OK,
- 1:12:03I'm not bringing it back because I want to talk about his issue,
- 1:12:05he's a comedian who did Father Ted.
- 1:12:07Uh,
- 1:12:07obviously his issue is singular,
- 1:12:08it's the trans issue,
- 1:12:09we've debated that.
- 1:12:10However,
- 1:12:11the principle of a comedian posting jokes which people may find offensive
- 1:12:15on social media,
- 1:12:16as he did back in April,
- 1:12:17about the trans issue.
- 1:12:19Then being met by 5 armed police officers at Heathrow Airport in London
- 1:12:22and arrested and taken off,
- 1:12:24and a very interesting thing happened,
- 1:12:25which is why I say woke is dead
- 1:12:27as a as an ideology,
- 1:12:29because.
- 1:12:3023 years ago,
- 1:12:31that would have been supported by everybody in the world cleft,
- 1:12:34yeah,
- 1:12:34bang him up,
- 1:12:35absolutely disgusting.
- 1:12:36How dare he,
- 1:12:37he's transphobic,
- 1:12:38he's horrible.
- 1:12:38We know this because of the way that,
- 1:12:40hang on,
- 1:12:41we know this from the way that JK Rowling was treated,
- 1:12:42right,
- 1:12:43for doing the same stuff about the trans issue.
- 1:12:45She was given death threats,
- 1:12:46she was threatened with this,
- 1:12:47that and the other.
- 1:12:48But what a different thing happened this time.
- 1:12:50This time there was such a public outcry,
- 1:12:52including from many on the left actually.
- 1:12:54To be fair to them,
- 1:12:55that this had crossed the line.
- 1:12:57We've got to stop doing this for stupid posts on social media.
- 1:13:00Hundreds of people on social media in the
- 1:13:01last two years in Britain have been arrested.
- 1:13:03It's completely ridiculous.
- 1:13:05Well,
- 1:13:05let me finish.
- 1:13:06So,
- 1:13:06so actually the police not only said we're not going to prosecute him,
- 1:13:09but we're not going to prosecute anybody for this kind of offense going forward.
- 1:13:13That's a big win.
- 1:13:14So and the repudiation of canceled.
- 1:13:16All you've told me is the left has progressed in their position on free speech.
- 1:13:19The right is regressed.
- 1:13:20That's all you've said.
- 1:13:20I'm not here to defend the rights position.
- 1:13:22I think that,
- 1:13:23but I'm saying if you're gonna write a book,
- 1:13:24it's it's trying to defend free speech,
- 1:13:26you should focus on where it's actually being attacked.
- 1:13:28But you wasted your time talking about this left boogeyman that does not exist.
- 1:13:32I agree with you.
- 1:13:33I love free speech.
- 1:13:34I am against all that stuff.
- 1:13:35I'm wearing the poppy today
- 1:13:36because of Remembrance Day,
- 1:13:38and we fought for free speech,
- 1:13:39and the right right now is attacking it,
- 1:13:40and you have a huge platform,
- 1:13:41and you can take this time to actually.
- 1:13:43Defend free speech,
- 1:13:44but you're not.
- 1:13:45I always defend free speech.
- 1:13:46OK,
- 1:13:46so then why don't you put more focus on the right then?
- 1:13:48So let,
- 1:13:49let me give you an example.
- 1:13:49You actually agree with my argument.
- 1:13:51Let,
- 1:13:51let me let you actually agree with my argument on page 241 of your book,
- 1:13:54as I'll quote it again.
- 1:13:56You,
- 1:13:56you,
- 1:13:56you,
- 1:13:56you attacked Bob Chapek
- 1:13:58because he,
- 1:13:59um,
- 1:13:59denounced Rhonda Santos for putting in like
- 1:14:01anti-gay laws,
- 1:14:03to put it,
- 1:14:03uh,
- 1:14:04quotely,
- 1:14:05but you said he should be attacking people like Xi Jinping because he does.
- 1:14:08Way more human rights violations,
- 1:14:09but that applies here.
- 1:14:11Trump and the right do way more than the left.
- 1:14:13You said that in your own book,
- 1:14:14but right now you're contradicting yourself again.
- 1:14:16I think both sides are capable of rank hypocrisy.
- 1:14:19I actually think on balance over the last 5 years,
- 1:14:22the woke left have been more suppressive of free speech,
- 1:14:25yes,
- 1:14:25let me give you an example.
- 1:14:27OK,
- 1:14:27but you take like 15 minutes to give an example,
- 1:14:29and we have 14 minutes.
- 1:14:30We gotta stop talking.
- 1:14:31That's true.
- 1:14:32Alright.
- 1:14:33Oh,
- 1:14:34I had a great time.
- 1:14:34Oh,
- 1:14:35that was good,
- 1:14:35yeah.
- 1:14:37I like the book.
- 1:14:38Thank you.
- 1:14:43How's it going?
- 1:14:43Hello,
- 1:14:44good to meet you.
- 1:14:44Good to see you.
- 1:14:45My name's Dash.
- 1:14:47Piers standing off against the liberals.
- 1:14:49This is really something.
- 1:14:50Well,
- 1:14:50I am a liberal.
- 1:14:51Your thoughts and beliefs in private,
- 1:14:53I would assume more align with ours,
- 1:14:54but I understand,
- 1:14:55I understand getting that back.
- 1:14:58So I'll save you the trouble.
- 1:14:58I'll do it for you.
- 1:14:59Piers Morgan's new book,
- 1:15:00Woke Is Dead is out now.
- 1:15:02It's great.
- 1:15:02Thank you.
- 1:15:03I also read it,
- 1:15:04covered.
- 1:15:06I wanted to take that off your shoulders,
- 1:15:07but let's get into it.
- 1:15:08So I'm just curious,
- 1:15:09someone who doesn't have any kind of a relationship with accountability.
- 1:15:12Do you agree that everything comes across to them as cancel culture?
- 1:15:16No,
- 1:15:16I don't,
- 1:15:16I don't believe that speech comes without accountability.
- 1:15:19OK.
- 1:15:19Uh,
- 1:15:19but I do believe we had a frenzied
- 1:15:22atmosphere in the last few years,
- 1:15:23driven predominantly by the woke left of canceling anybody
- 1:15:28that didn't sign up to their worldview,
- 1:15:30which I thought was very insidious.
- 1:15:31I called it out while it was happening.
- 1:15:33I've called it out since.
- 1:15:34I've now written a book about it all,
- 1:15:35saying we cannot go back to that.
- 1:15:36It doesn't mean the the right aren't capable of doing
- 1:15:38similar stuff and being hypocrites,
- 1:15:40they are.
- 1:15:41But it also means that if you look at it in totality,
- 1:15:44I think this cancel culture mentality
- 1:15:46has been really damaging,
- 1:15:48and I think the war on free speech has been really damaging.
- 1:15:50OK,
- 1:15:51well,
- 1:15:51let's,
- 1:15:51let's put this on a spectrum because I think we use
- 1:15:54this term cancel culture and everybody's been canceled by the left.
- 1:15:57I don't have any actual
- 1:15:59evidence of what you're talking about.
- 1:16:00So let's say accountability is on this side,
- 1:16:02which is you facing consequences for your actions.
- 1:16:05And on this side of the spectrum,
- 1:16:06it is facing consequences for something that is not just.
- 1:16:10Let me give you an example.
- 1:16:10So now let's start to place it in that spectrum.
- 1:16:12Let me give you a specific example,
- 1:16:14because the people you carry water for on the right tend to be over here
- 1:16:17where they don't take accountability for anything
- 1:16:19and instead feel like they're being canceled.
- 1:16:21Wait a minute.
- 1:16:22Although it's just consequences for your basic actions.
- 1:16:24Do you ever watch my show?
- 1:16:25I do.
- 1:16:26And you really think I carry water for the right?
- 1:16:28Absolutely.
- 1:16:29Really?
- 1:16:29Yes,
- 1:16:30there's a statistic that you,
- 1:16:31you,
- 1:16:32you defend Republicans more than anybody else.
- 1:16:34No,
- 1:16:34no,
- 1:16:34I don't,
- 1:16:34I just attack the woke left more than anybody else.
- 1:16:37Uh,
- 1:16:37OK,
- 1:16:38but I.
- 1:16:39But it's friendly fire.
- 1:16:40I come at you as one of your own,
- 1:16:42only I didn't go mad.
- 1:16:44Only I didn't go mad,
- 1:16:45right?
- 1:16:45I didn't go mad,
- 1:16:46woke,
- 1:16:47bonkers.
- 1:16:48I stayed old-fashioned liberal,
- 1:16:50with liberal values,
- 1:16:51wanting
- 1:16:52free speech at the cornerstone of it.
- 1:16:54Let me give an example.
- 1:16:54It appears I read your book,
- 1:16:55that's not the case.
- 1:16:57You spent most of the book with Trump's cock in your mouth.
- 1:16:59If you read the,
- 1:17:00sorry?
- 1:17:00You,
- 1:17:00you,
- 1:17:00you spent most of the book with Trump
- 1:17:03sucking him off.
- 1:17:04No,
- 1:17:04I didn't.
- 1:17:04Yes,
- 1:17:04you,
- 1:17:05the,
- 1:17:05the prologue was The Dawn Rises,
- 1:17:07D O N.
- 1:17:08The prologue actually,
- 1:17:09if you read it,
- 1:17:09and I don't think you did because you just revealed you probably haven't,
- 1:17:12the prologue actually starts with two conversations I had with him.
- 1:17:16One
- 1:17:16positive and one extremely negative,
- 1:17:18which ends up with him saying Piers Morgan's so dead,
- 1:17:21he's catching flies.
- 1:17:22I'm not sure you've read the book,
- 1:17:23have you?
- 1:17:24I have read the book and you wouldn't say that I
- 1:17:26bleep bleep.
- 1:17:27because that was you reading at Mar a Lago trying to
- 1:17:29win favor back because he was becoming the presumptive nominee,
- 1:17:32so he needed to get back onto his side,
- 1:17:34but look,
- 1:17:35after spending years
- 1:17:36being a critic.
- 1:17:37Of or a critic of his,
- 1:17:39then you needed to win a favor back.
- 1:17:40I've never been,
- 1:17:41I've never spent years as a critic of Trump.
- 1:17:43I've spent years,
- 1:17:44I've I've known Donald Trump nearly 20 years.
- 1:17:46He's been a politician for
- 1:17:48the last 10 years of that period.
- 1:17:49In that time,
- 1:17:50for example,
- 1:17:51I used to write columns for the Daily Mail in America.
- 1:17:53I calculated after his first term in office,
- 1:17:56I wrote about 120 columns about Trump.
- 1:17:58You can go and check it,
- 1:17:59and about half were negative
- 1:18:01and half were positive.
- 1:18:02I do think in Trump's first term,
- 1:18:04if people had been fairer to give him credit.
- 1:18:06Deserved it
- 1:18:07and criticized him when he deserved it,
- 1:18:09everyone would have been a lot better off.
- 1:18:10I feel it now.
- 1:18:11The Trump derangement syndrome is a real thing
- 1:18:15and it's bad.
- 1:18:16I know,
- 1:18:16but it's kind of pathetic.
- 1:18:17It's like when I hear people say he's the new Hitler.
- 1:18:19Really?
- 1:18:20Hitler murdered 12 million people,
- 1:18:22including 6 million Jews in the Holocaust.
- 1:18:24Do you think Donald Trump is the new Hitler,
- 1:18:26you're a fucking idiot.
- 1:18:27OK,
- 1:18:28if we're gonna talk about hyperbole,
- 1:18:30here we have focused half of the discussion today on trans issues,
- 1:18:33but we're not gonna talk about things like.
- 1:18:35I don't know.
- 1:18:36Trump is in the Epstein files and he's using the government to cover it up.
- 1:18:39Should we talk about that?
- 1:18:41That affects a lot of people.
- 1:18:42How about him denying the 2020 election and eroding
- 1:18:45the public's trust in our institutions and processes?
- 1:18:47That affects everybody.
- 1:18:49So let's try not deflecting to the trans athletes conversation.
- 1:18:52You've just brought up two more issues.
- 1:18:53I'm happy to talk about that.
- 1:18:53We'll see if you deflect.
- 1:18:54Go on.
- 1:18:56Well,
- 1:18:56you won't have asked me about them.
- 1:18:57Go on.
- 1:18:57OK,
- 1:18:57well,
- 1:18:57I'm saying let's focus on the issues that affect lots of people,
- 1:19:01not deflect into the culture war.
- 1:19:04Issues that affect very few people in the grand scheme of things.
- 1:19:07Well,
- 1:19:07let's be clear,
- 1:19:08the number of people directly affected by the Epstein scandal is probably 2000.
- 1:19:12What the president of the United States
- 1:19:13covering up a pedophilia scandal affects everybody,
- 1:19:16if that's what he's doing.
- 1:19:17Common sense,
- 1:19:18you're a champion of common sense.
- 1:19:19Well,
- 1:19:19I can tell you that I've spoken to Virginia Grey's lawyer multiple times,
- 1:19:23David Boyes.
- 1:19:24He's seen the files.
- 1:19:25He does not believe there's anything
- 1:19:27against Trump in those files.
- 1:19:29Well,
- 1:19:29OK,
- 1:19:29what happened to common sense,
- 1:19:31Piers?
- 1:19:31Well,
- 1:19:32actually I prefer to stick to facts.
- 1:19:36Oh,
- 1:19:36come on.
- 1:19:38Hello.
- 1:19:39Nice to meet you.
- 1:19:40What's your name?
- 1:19:40My name's Z.
- 1:19:41Z.
- 1:19:42Z.
- 1:19:42Yes.
- 1:19:42He doesn't know what that means.
- 1:19:45I corrupted him and you're sitting with each other.
- 1:19:47OK,
- 1:19:47so that's not your pronoun,
- 1:19:48that's your name.
- 1:19:49It's my name.
- 1:19:49OK.
- 1:19:50My pronouns are she,
- 1:19:50her.
- 1:19:51Oh,
- 1:19:52great,
- 1:19:52great,
- 1:19:52um,
- 1:19:52so I.
- 1:19:53I
- 1:19:54think I tend to agree with you mostly on the cancel culture stuff.
- 1:19:57In fact,
- 1:19:57like
- 1:19:58I was canceled back in April from this guy behind me,
- 1:20:00um,
- 1:20:01yeah,
- 1:20:01and so over,
- 1:20:02over some,
- 1:20:03over some work stuff,
- 1:20:04OK,
- 1:20:04are you serious?
- 1:20:05I'm serious.
- 1:20:06Yeah.
- 1:20:06What did he do to you?
- 1:20:06Well,
- 1:20:07it was about
- 1:20:08about him.
- 1:20:09It was about microaggression.
- 1:20:10So,
- 1:20:11but my point is,
- 1:20:12that I think that the far left tend to do this to shrink the
- 1:20:16Democratic tent so that they don't have
- 1:20:17to take responsibility in winning elections.
- 1:20:20And I do think that that's a very small portion of the far left,
- 1:20:23except they're now winning,
- 1:20:24they're now winning power.
- 1:20:25This is where Mamdani.
- 1:20:26They are,
- 1:20:26right,
- 1:20:27which is a good thing.
- 1:20:28But it's a terrible thing.
- 1:20:29Well,
- 1:20:29first of all,
- 1:20:30I don't think Mamdani is considered the far left.
- 1:20:32Parker and Mamdani are not in the same category to me.
- 1:20:35Because
- 1:20:35he believes in electoral power,
- 1:20:37right?
- 1:20:37But my point is,
- 1:20:38is that you still,
- 1:20:40as you still are stumping for Republicans,
- 1:20:43as if Republicans,
- 1:20:44I don't stump for anybody.
- 1:20:45Well,
- 1:20:46Pierce,
- 1:20:47I've watched your show a lot.
- 1:20:48Then you will know I don't stump for anybody,
- 1:20:50OK,
- 1:20:51but you're,
- 1:20:51you're,
- 1:20:52you just made the defense in this argument with,
- 1:20:54I think the guy before this last guy where you said that you think Republicans
- 1:20:58are better on free speech than than the have been in the last few years,
- 1:21:01yes.
- 1:21:02Well,
- 1:21:02and I totally disagree with you.
- 1:21:03Can we use Charlie Kirk as an example?
- 1:21:05Do you think that Charlie Kirk stood for free speech?
- 1:21:07Absolutely.
- 1:21:08You do.
- 1:21:08Oh my God,
- 1:21:09really?
- 1:21:10How?
- 1:21:10tell me about that.
- 1:21:11Charlie Kirk was the absolute personification
- 1:21:14of
- 1:21:15defending free speech.
- 1:21:16Oh really?
- 1:21:16Let me explain why.
- 1:21:17Charlie Kirk had strong views about a lot of things,
- 1:21:20many of which you probably don't agree with,
- 1:21:21I'm guessing.
- 1:21:22Yeah.
- 1:21:22But Charlie Kirk,
- 1:21:23week after week around America
- 1:21:25would go onto university campuses knowing that most people.
- 1:21:28There,
- 1:21:28didn't agree with him,
- 1:21:29may have a preconceived view about him,
- 1:21:31maybe thought he was a fascist and all the other things they called him,
- 1:21:34and he would sit there in his tent,
- 1:21:35sometimes outside as he was when he was appallingly assassinated,
- 1:21:39and he would say,
- 1:21:40prove me wrong,
- 1:21:40and people would line up and they'd come and have a debate like this,
- 1:21:43and he would listen to them respectfully,
- 1:21:45he'd challenge them,
- 1:21:46he'd argue with them.
- 1:21:47That's that's not what happened.
- 1:21:48Sorry,
- 1:21:48that's exactly what Charlie Kirk did.
- 1:21:50OK,
- 1:21:50as somebody that and for that he got a bullet in the neck.
- 1:21:53OK,
- 1:21:53as somebody that runs the counterorganism.
- 1:21:55to Charlie Kirk's turning point.
- 1:21:56That is not the point of what Charlie Kirk was doing.
- 1:21:59Charlie Kirk did not decide to debate high profile debaters,
- 1:22:02people like Destiny or people on the left,
- 1:22:04that would actually give him a real debate.
- 1:22:06In fact,
- 1:22:06he even denied debating Dean Withers.
- 1:22:08I was literally with him
- 1:22:09when he did that.
- 1:22:10OK,
- 1:22:11so it's not like he was going in to have a real debate.
- 1:22:13He would go to these real debate.
- 1:22:15No,
- 1:22:15he would go to these college campuses to debate kids that were
- 1:22:18very much underprepared so that he could clip them and then raise.
- 1:22:21Money for Turning Point to go out there and then register voters,
- 1:22:24OK?
- 1:22:24And I think that that's,
- 1:22:25and I think that that's brilliant.
- 1:22:27OK,
- 1:22:27that's why I'm trying to replicate it,
- 1:22:28but you cannot say that he was there for
- 1:22:30free speech because that's not really free speech,
- 1:22:33especially,
- 1:22:34hold on,
- 1:22:34especially when Charlie Kirk went and tried to deny,
- 1:22:37he denied us from going into his events just because we were Democrats.
- 1:22:40He canceled our permits even though we had permits that we paid for.
- 1:22:44You wouldn't argue that's not free speech.
- 1:22:45But you wouldn't argue that he would regularly.
- 1:22:48And I mean almost on a daily basis,
- 1:22:50debate with people who he didn't agree with.
- 1:22:52Oh,
- 1:22:52college students,
- 1:22:53unprepared college students,
- 1:22:54do you think that
- 1:22:56that's me,
- 1:22:56let me throw back at you something which I,
- 1:22:57I'm interested about your response to this.
- 1:22:59He went to the Oxford Union uh in April,
- 1:23:01May this year and he debated a guy during the appearance there
- 1:23:06who then became the president-elect of the Oxford Union,
- 1:23:09who when Charlie Kurt was murdered,
- 1:23:11reacted by posting
- 1:23:13LOL.
- 1:23:15Laughing out loud,
- 1:23:16and then he said,
- 1:23:17Charlie Kirk just got shot,
- 1:23:18let's effing go!
- 1:23:19exclamation mark exclamation mark.
- 1:23:21He celeb well when he celebrated
- 1:23:23the murder of Charlie Kirk,
- 1:23:25who was killed,
- 1:23:25let's be clear,
- 1:23:27because he had views that the person who killed him
- 1:23:29didn't agree with.
- 1:23:30That person continued to want to be president elect of a debating society.
- 1:23:35Do you agree
- 1:23:36that it's not a question of free speech
- 1:23:38or cancel culture,
- 1:23:39that he was incompatible.
- 1:23:41With the position of being president
- 1:23:42of a debating society,
- 1:23:43if you celebrate someone's murder for their speech.
- 1:23:45Yeah,
- 1:23:46I,
- 1:23:46I agree with you.
- 1:23:46So 100% we can agree on that.
- 1:23:48I watched,
- 1:23:48I watched the way a lot of them awoke left celebrated,
- 1:23:51posting,
- 1:23:52and these were teachers,
- 1:23:53nurses,
- 1:23:54doctors,
- 1:23:55professors,
- 1:23:56posting videos of themselves,
- 1:23:58glorifying,
- 1:23:59celebrating
- 1:24:00the murder of Charlie Kirk.
- 1:24:02It was one of the most disgusting things I have ever seen.
- 1:24:05Do you think that they should be fired for that?
- 1:24:07Yeah,
- 1:24:07absolutely,
- 1:24:08they should be fired for that.
- 1:24:13How are you?
- 1:24:14I'm Rob.
- 1:24:15Nice to meet you,
- 1:24:15Rob.
- 1:24:16So,
- 1:24:16I think we are conflating accountability with cancel culture.
- 1:24:20Um,
- 1:24:21I am the,
- 1:24:22uh,
- 1:24:22mayor of my hometown,
- 1:24:24and if I came on here,
- 1:24:26Los Gatos,
- 1:24:27California,
- 1:24:27if I came on here and said a bunch of bigoted things,
- 1:24:30my voters would righteously vote me out.
- 1:24:33I would be out of a job.
- 1:24:34Uh,
- 1:24:34that's not cancel culture.
- 1:24:36That's just common sense and,
- 1:24:38and accountability.
- 1:24:39Can you tell me someone who has been permanently canceled?
- 1:24:44No,
- 1:24:44no,
- 1:24:44no,
- 1:24:44you're here today.
- 1:24:46People like Bill Cosby
- 1:24:48don't get gigs because he's a pervert,
- 1:24:51right?
- 1:24:52I can tell you somebody,
- 1:24:53I can tell you two people,
- 1:24:55where there was a
- 1:24:56global effort to cancel us.
- 1:24:58Right,
- 1:24:59and one was me,
- 1:25:00and it came after the Oprah Winfrey Weathon
- 1:25:04where Meghan and Harry trashed my royal family
- 1:25:06and trashed the monarchy in the most despicable,
- 1:25:08disingenuous manner imaginable.
- 1:25:1057,000
- 1:25:12wokies.
- 1:25:14Bombarded the Ofcom television regulator,
- 1:25:17they weren't Good Morning Britain,
- 1:25:18the show I was doing,
- 1:25:19viewers,
- 1:25:20these were just woke left progressives
- 1:25:23who wanted me fired for disbelieving the claims about racism
- 1:25:27and mental health that were cited in that interview,
- 1:25:29which have never been substantiated and which I to this day do not believe.
- 1:25:33And I was told you've got to apologize for this
- 1:25:36because the mob have come,
- 1:25:37you've gotta apologize.
- 1:25:38Guys or lose your job,
- 1:25:39a job I was doing very successfully.
- 1:25:41Done it for 5 years,
- 1:25:42trebled the ratings.
- 1:25:43We'd just,
- 1:25:43uh,
- 1:25:44eclipsed the BBC as a number one morning show.
- 1:25:46I was at the peak of my powers,
- 1:25:48but because I was exercising my right not to believe somebody
- 1:25:51who actually it turned out was spewing a load of bullshit,
- 1:25:54I had to leave my job,
- 1:25:55because I wasn't gonna apologize.
- 1:25:56Now,
- 1:25:56let me give you the,
- 1:25:57the subjunct to that,
- 1:25:58which is far worse.
- 1:26:00Sharon Osborne,
- 1:26:01my longtime friend.
- 1:26:02Was hosting a show here called The Talk on CBS,
- 1:26:05she'd done it for 10 years,
- 1:26:05she loved that job,
- 1:26:06she was brilliant at that job,
- 1:26:08she defended me.
- 1:26:09When asked about it,
- 1:26:10she didn't defend what I'd said,
- 1:26:12she just said,
- 1:26:13I'm,
- 1:26:13I'm here,
- 1:26:13I'm here for my friend Piers,
- 1:26:15right?
- 1:26:15The black
- 1:26:16co-panelist,
- 1:26:17Cheryl Underwood,
- 1:26:19played the race card on
- 1:26:20the next episode of the talk.
- 1:26:22She turned to Sharon
- 1:26:23on air
- 1:26:24and said,
- 1:26:24out of nowhere,
- 1:26:25this wasn't planned,
- 1:26:26why did you support someone who said racist things?
- 1:26:28I'd never said anything racist about Meghan Markle.
- 1:26:31Sharon,
- 1:26:32obviously under attack,
- 1:26:34saying she'd been supporting a.
- 1:26:35Racist and by definition
- 1:26:37must therefore be a racist,
- 1:26:39said,
- 1:26:39Well,
- 1:26:39what's he said that's racist?
- 1:26:40I wish Sheryl Underwood went on this ridiculous little,
- 1:26:43I,
- 1:26:43I,
- 1:26:43it's a point to my,
- 1:26:44it's a point to it.
- 1:26:45She,
- 1:26:45Cheryl Underwood just said,
- 1:26:47well,
- 1:26:47well,
- 1:26:47it's,
- 1:26:47it's not so much that he said racist things,
- 1:26:49it's kind of the way he said stuff.
- 1:26:50So Sharon says,
- 1:26:51Is this what you think are talking about Wait,
- 1:26:53wait,
- 1:26:53wait,
- 1:26:53wait,
- 1:26:53wait a minute,
- 1:26:54yes,
- 1:26:54I'm gonna come to it.
- 1:26:55So Cheryl Underwood says this,
- 1:26:56and then she says,
- 1:26:57I'm not accusing you of being racist,
- 1:26:58Sharon.
- 1:26:59Sharon says,
- 1:27:00I think that ship has sailed.
- 1:27:01Here's what happened to Sharon.
- 1:27:02For a job she loved,
- 1:27:04she was bombarded with death threats,
- 1:27:06online mayhem,
- 1:27:07vilified,
- 1:27:08shamed,
- 1:27:09people saying fire her,
- 1:27:10wait a minute,
- 1:27:11let me finish,
- 1:27:11let me finish.
- 1:27:12Fire,
- 1:27:13fire,
- 1:27:13fire,
- 1:27:13fire,
- 1:27:14fire her.
- 1:27:14Death threats as well.
- 1:27:16She she eventually issued a groveling,
- 1:27:17sobbing apology.
- 1:27:18It still wasn't enough.
- 1:27:20She got fired from that job.
- 1:27:21For what?
- 1:27:22For absolutely nothing.
- 1:27:23For the next year,
- 1:27:24she had the worst year of her life.
- 1:27:25I don't think I don't think that's what people.
- 1:27:31She was,
- 1:27:31she was left when you're talking about,
- 1:27:32wait,
- 1:27:32you're talking about cancel culture saying like no one
- 1:27:34has ever been,
- 1:27:34you're talking about comedians who make a racist joke
- 1:27:37and somebody doesn't want to listen to them anymore.
- 1:27:39Sharon Osborne.
- 1:27:40I,
- 1:27:40I,
- 1:27:40I don't know much about that.
- 1:27:42That sounds.
- 1:27:42I know,
- 1:27:43no,
- 1:27:43no,
- 1:27:43that sounds bad,
- 1:27:44that sounds bad.
- 1:27:45I,
- 1:27:45I wouldn't cancel Sharon Osborne.
- 1:27:47Why did I have to,
- 1:27:48why did I have to leave my job for disbelieving Meghan Markle?
- 1:27:51I,
- 1:27:51I,
- 1:27:51I,
- 1:27:52I don't know.
- 1:27:52I,
- 1:27:52I,
- 1:27:53I cancel culture.
- 1:27:54Yeah.
- 1:27:57Nice to meet you.
- 1:27:58OK.
- 1:28:03Hello.
- 1:28:04Hi
- 1:28:04Amanda.
- 1:28:05Amanda,
- 1:28:05nice to meet you.
- 1:28:06Nice to meet you.
- 1:28:07So cancel culture,
- 1:28:08um,
- 1:28:08I'm trying to understand,
- 1:28:10is it that you believe it's something that's not necessary within society
- 1:28:14to hold people accountable?
- 1:28:15Is it?
- 1:28:16I do,
- 1:28:16I,
- 1:28:16I do think
- 1:28:17accountability is very important,
- 1:28:19and individual companies
- 1:28:20are perfectly entitled to operate their own policies.
- 1:28:23What I'm talking about is where the woke mob
- 1:28:25normally
- 1:28:26through social media
- 1:28:27would pile pressure,
- 1:28:28and it's not exclusive to them.
- 1:28:30I've seen it happen with the right as well,
- 1:28:31but would.
- 1:28:32Pile pressure
- 1:28:33on companies,
- 1:28:34on institutions to fire people,
- 1:28:37often for what,
- 1:28:38in my opinion,
- 1:28:39were
- 1:28:39things that might be offensive to people or whatever,
- 1:28:42but they're not at the bar
- 1:28:43where they should lose their livelihoods.
- 1:28:45Well,
- 1:28:46I do understand.
- 1:28:47I mean,
- 1:28:47there's a line when it comes to cancel culture
- 1:28:49where there are things that are taken too far,
- 1:28:51where people do lose their jobs for certain things that
- 1:28:54some people may find offensive or some people might not find offensive.
- 1:28:57But free speech,
- 1:28:58you know,
- 1:28:58the whole point of,
- 1:28:59the whole point of free speech is it's not about you and I agreeing.
- 1:29:02It's about our ability to listen to each other
- 1:29:04and maybe you even saying hateful things to me.
- 1:29:07If they don't cross the bar of criminality,
- 1:29:09you're allowed to do that,
- 1:29:10and I should just suck it up.
- 1:29:12I don't have to like it,
- 1:29:13but I have to tolerate the fact in a free democratic society like the United States
- 1:29:17with the First Amendment,
- 1:29:18you're entitled to do that.
- 1:29:20And see,
- 1:29:20that's where I disagree.
- 1:29:21I don't feel that it has to reach a.
- 1:29:23A bar of criminality in order for it to be
- 1:29:25something that someone has to be held accountable for.
- 1:29:28Though we have free speech,
- 1:29:29there
- 1:29:30there does have to be lines drawn
- 1:29:32because there are things that are inappropriate
- 1:29:35regardless.
- 1:29:36You know,
- 1:29:37as you said when you were discussing,
- 1:29:38um,
- 1:29:39books
- 1:29:40that are banned or certain things,
- 1:29:42the remarks you made about Meghan Markle,
- 1:29:44I don't agree that's something that you should be fired for,
- 1:29:46but I do see why.
- 1:29:48There are people,
- 1:29:49and you need to look outside of your own perspective.
- 1:29:52There are people who felt that you needed to be counseled for such an instance.
- 1:29:55Black women,
- 1:29:57especially around the world in the global West,
- 1:29:59they're
- 1:30:00oftentimes not listened to,
- 1:30:01and their problems,
- 1:30:03their pain,
- 1:30:03their mental health are oftentimes
- 1:30:06disregarded or undermined.
- 1:30:08And so that's also been a problem in gynecology,
- 1:30:10which is why we see maternal rates for black women are.
- 1:30:14I believe Meghan Markle.
- 1:30:15Really?
- 1:30:16I don't,
- 1:30:16why wouldn't I believe?
- 1:30:17Well,
- 1:30:17let me give you an example of why you probably shouldn't.
- 1:30:18So she said in that interview that she and Harry were married
- 1:30:21secretly by the Archbishop of Canterbury 3 days before the public wedding.
- 1:30:25Had that been true,
- 1:30:27the Archbishop of Canterbury would have committed a crime
- 1:30:29and would have gone to prison.
- 1:30:30Yes.
- 1:30:31Did you ever see him go to prison?
- 1:30:32No,
- 1:30:32I did not.
- 1:30:33Did that make you think that maybe that never happened?
- 1:30:35Um,
- 1:30:35honestly,
- 1:30:36no,
- 1:30:36it did not make me think that it's something that did not occur.
- 1:30:39I answer.
- 1:30:40They said in that interview that senior members of the royal family,
- 1:30:43who we now know
- 1:30:44through a leaked copy of the book where the names appeared,
- 1:30:46were supposedly
- 1:30:48then Prince Charles,
- 1:30:49now King Charles,
- 1:30:50and Catherine,
- 1:30:51William's wife,
- 1:30:52made comments that they were concerned about the potential skin.
- 1:30:55Color
- 1:30:56of the unborn baby.
- 1:30:57Do you believe on balance that that's likely to have happened?
- 1:31:00Absolutely.
- 1:31:00Really?
- 1:31:01Absolutely.
- 1:31:02Coming from the British institution,
- 1:31:03that's something that has been,
- 1:31:05you know,
- 1:31:06for centuries trying to maintain the purity of the blood,
- 1:31:09you know,
- 1:31:10something that has been within British aristocracy.
- 1:31:13No,
- 1:31:13I'm not saying that.
- 1:31:14What are you suggesting?
- 1:31:16Something being white,
- 1:31:17if you're purposely trying to preserve it,
- 1:31:19it is.
- 1:31:19Something that you are doing purposely trying to
- 1:31:22preserve the way they interbred for years.
- 1:31:24I have studied English aristocracy for many years,
- 1:31:29the royal family will have been deliberately trying to stay white.
- 1:31:33What I will say is that conservatism oftentimes
- 1:31:36does have to tie with the purity of white
- 1:31:38um whiteness and white culture.
- 1:31:40And so there are a large majority of conservatives who do see white.
- 1:31:44as the main basis of being a conservative,
- 1:31:48of something that's very important
- 1:31:50that they need to preserve,
- 1:31:51and it's why a lot of times they exclude exclude minorities and
- 1:31:55why they feel as though things such as wokeness are poor,
- 1:31:58they,
- 1:31:58they shouldn't be included,
- 1:32:00because it's giving that pathway.
- 1:32:01What should worry you more is that having set off this absolute inferno
- 1:32:06about the royal family being a bunch of callous racists.
- 1:32:10Where's the?
- 1:32:10Harry then wrote a book,
- 1:32:11do you remember the book Spare?
- 1:32:13420 odd pages of his life story.
- 1:32:16Do you know the two things that didn't appear in that book?
- 1:32:19The racism allegations against his family about
- 1:32:21the skin color of their unborn child
- 1:32:23and the fact that the Buckingham.
- 1:32:24Palace officials apparently told Meghan Markle she
- 1:32:27couldn't get help for her suicidal thoughts.
- 1:32:30Those two things never got repeated,
- 1:32:32never appeared in their documentary,
- 1:32:34never appeared in the book.
- 1:32:35They just vanished.
- 1:32:36And in the documentary.
- 1:32:39I did well,
- 1:32:39when Harry was asked about it,
- 1:32:41uh,
- 1:32:41recently,
- 1:32:41he said,
- 1:32:42oh no,
- 1:32:42no,
- 1:32:42it was the media
- 1:32:43that put a racist,
- 1:32:45uh,
- 1:32:45tone on this.
- 1:32:46I never meant to say my family were racist.
- 1:32:48Oh yes,
- 1:32:48you did.
- 1:32:49We all watched what you guys said.
- 1:32:53It's OK.
- 1:32:54That was great.
- 1:32:54Thank you.
- 1:32:55I enjoyed it.
- 1:32:55Nice to meet you.
- 1:32:56Nice to meet you too.
- 1:33:00How are you,
- 1:33:01Shane,
- 1:33:01good to see you,
- 1:33:02Shane.
- 1:33:02Nice to meet you.
- 1:33:03I want to take it back all the way to your original claim,
- 1:33:05and
- 1:33:06you've set a lot of examples.
- 1:33:08I don't think you've provided a single example
- 1:33:10of how cancel culture is a violation of free speech.
- 1:33:13OK,
- 1:33:14I'll give you one.
- 1:33:14The
- 1:33:152 weeks before the election where Biden won.
- 1:33:18The New York Post got an exclusive story about Hunter Biden's laptop.
- 1:33:22It was,
- 1:33:23OK,
- 1:33:24and people can laugh,
- 1:33:24actually contained incredibly damaging damaging information
- 1:33:27which may have led to serious charges against a lot of the Biden family.
- 1:33:31We now will never know because they've all been pardoned.
- 1:33:34But,
- 1:33:34but this story,
- 1:33:35this story
- 1:33:36was suppressed
- 1:33:38by the left in the most disgraceful manner imaginable.
- 1:33:41The left at the time being all the tech giants who were all define suppressed.
- 1:33:45They literally banned the New York Post account
- 1:33:48from their platforms
- 1:33:50until they took down the front page exclusive.
- 1:33:52Free speech isn't protected on what platform you can speak on.
- 1:33:54No,
- 1:33:54no,
- 1:33:55these are private.
- 1:33:55You asked me for an example of cancel culture.
- 1:33:57I'm,
- 1:33:57no,
- 1:33:57I'm
- 1:33:58they ask you for an example of violation of free speech,
- 1:34:00which is,
- 1:34:00that is a violation of free speech,
- 1:34:02which is a promise that the government.
- 1:34:03The Government will not come in and arrest you for anything you say.
- 1:34:06You,
- 1:34:06you are not entitled to viewers on your show
- 1:34:09just because people agree with you.
- 1:34:10I agree.
- 1:34:11Shane,
- 1:34:11let me make my point.
- 1:34:12You asked me for an example of where free speech had been suppressed.
- 1:34:16A major,
- 1:34:17yeah,
- 1:34:17violated,
- 1:34:17suppressed,
- 1:34:18violated,
- 1:34:18violated.
- 1:34:19A major national American newspaper of 100+ years' standing,
- 1:34:23the New York Post,
- 1:34:25had its account
- 1:34:26taken down
- 1:34:27on social media.
- 1:34:29Did anyone get arrested because they were.
- 1:34:30Exposing a true story about the son of
- 1:34:33the man who would be president and became president
- 1:34:35in a way that was directly intended to benefit Joe Biden
- 1:34:39and hinder Donald Trump's chances of winning that election,
- 1:34:42and that is a,
- 1:34:42and I don't agree with that.
- 1:34:44So that that's what I mean.
- 1:34:46But how was anyone arrested?
- 1:34:47What do you mean arrested?
- 1:34:48Was,
- 1:34:48was any free speech violated that the government stepped in and arrested someone?
- 1:34:52Well,
- 1:34:52I've just told you the story of Graham Linehan,
- 1:34:53who was arrested
- 1:34:54at the Heathrow Airport
- 1:34:56in the UK.
- 1:34:57You don't have free speech in the UK.
- 1:34:59Well,
- 1:34:59that's part of the problem,
- 1:35:00I agree.
- 1:35:00That sounds like a UK problem,
- 1:35:02not a US problem.
- 1:35:03The US has a big problem.
- 1:35:04So what it has a problem,
- 1:35:05but where has free speech been violated because of canceled.
- 1:35:08No,
- 1:35:09you gave me one at Heathrow Airport.
- 1:35:10I'll give you the New York Post example.
- 1:35:12Who has been arrested?
- 1:35:14As as a result of cancel culture,
- 1:35:15because someone has said something that was either bigotatory,
- 1:35:18racist,
- 1:35:19sexist,
- 1:35:20whatever it is,
- 1:35:21and people are not entitled to have viewers based on their opinions.
- 1:35:25I'm not saying they are.
- 1:35:26If people disagree with you,
- 1:35:27they can say,
- 1:35:28oh,
- 1:35:28we're not gonna watch you anymore.
- 1:35:29They're gonna go out on social media and say,
- 1:35:31hey,
- 1:35:31everybody,
- 1:35:31let's stop watching this person because he came out as racist.
- 1:35:34100%.
- 1:35:35OK,
- 1:35:35and that's not a violation of free speech.
- 1:35:36No,
- 1:35:37Sharon Osborne was fired as a.
- 1:35:39Told you.
- 1:35:39Also not a violation of free speech.
- 1:35:41Of course it was.
- 1:35:4249 states are at will
- 1:35:44employee states.
- 1:35:45Companies can fire you for any reason that is not related to discrimination.
- 1:35:48I,
- 1:35:49I agree.
- 1:35:49So I've already said,
- 1:35:50I think you're misunderstanding me.
- 1:35:51I've already,
- 1:35:52you're misunderstanding me.
- 1:35:53I've already said that companies are perfectly entitled to do what they like.
- 1:35:56They're private businesses,
- 1:35:57right?
- 1:35:57So CBS was perfectly entitled to do it.
- 1:35:59But was it a violation of Sharon's free speech rights,
- 1:36:02what they did?
- 1:36:03Yes.
- 1:36:03No,
- 1:36:03not a violation.
- 1:36:04It was a suppression.
- 1:36:06It was,
- 1:36:06I don't agree with it.
- 1:36:07What's the difference?
- 1:36:07I think the people,
- 1:36:08she didn't get arrested for what she said.
- 1:36:10Well,
- 1:36:10a violation doesn't,
- 1:36:11doesn't just mean you get arrested.
- 1:36:12Yes,
- 1:36:12a being violated of your free speech,
- 1:36:14being able to not I can violate you without involving arresting you.
- 1:36:17Is that what you see when you look at me?
- 1:36:19You wanna violate me?
- 1:36:21No,
- 1:36:22that is what we have in our Constitution,
- 1:36:24that is protected.
- 1:36:25You can say and do whatever you have better protections here than we do in the UK.
- 1:36:28I agree,
- 1:36:29but your speech is protected.
- 1:36:30You can be as hateful,
- 1:36:32as angry,
- 1:36:33as misogynistic as you want to be,
- 1:36:35and people can hate you for that.
- 1:36:37Consequences,
- 1:36:38you do not
- 1:36:39have a right to be on a platform and get to say whatever you want.
- 1:36:42You can,
- 1:36:42but if you can,
- 1:36:43but people don't have to watch you.
- 1:36:44Say right now on camera,
- 1:36:46I think you should be shot dead.
- 1:36:47That is actually a criminal offense.
- 1:36:49And,
- 1:36:49and I would be arrested.
- 1:36:50If you said you wanted to shoot me dead or you're encouraging people to shoot me dead,
- 1:36:53that is not protected free speech,
- 1:36:55that is a threat.
- 1:36:56Correct,
- 1:36:56it,
- 1:36:56it's,
- 1:36:57it's a,
- 1:36:57it's a crime.
- 1:36:58You saying I should be shot dead is free speech,
- 1:37:01and that makes you look like a terrible person.
- 1:37:02Right,
- 1:37:02not all,
- 1:37:03yeah,
- 1:37:03I agree,
- 1:37:04and you're not gonna be arrested for that.
- 1:37:05I've already made the point that hateful speech has to be tolerated in a free.
- 1:37:08Democratic society,
- 1:37:09right,
- 1:37:10where it passes the bar of criminality,
- 1:37:12then obviously the law enforcement
- 1:37:14take over,
- 1:37:15and that's how it should be.
- 1:37:16The,
- 1:37:16the problem comes,
- 1:37:17and it's been more of a problem in my country than here,
- 1:37:19I agree,
- 1:37:19but I do think in terms of suppressing free speech,
- 1:37:22what was going on with things like the New
- 1:37:23York Post story being suppressed was absolutely disgraceful.
- 1:37:26I agree,
- 1:37:26we're not disagreeing on that.
- 1:37:28Good.
- 1:37:28Your claim was let's end on a point of agreement.
- 1:37:30We end up agreeing.
- 1:37:31I love that.
- 1:37:34Pierce will now choose someone from the outer circle to come
- 1:37:37back to the center to debate him on their claim.
- 1:37:40Um,
- 1:37:41Parker,
- 1:37:41you're too annoying.
- 1:37:43Uh,
- 1:37:43Nick,
- 1:37:44I've chosen Nick,
- 1:37:45uh,
- 1:37:46to come back for the final debate,
- 1:37:47which will be his
- 1:37:48debate,
- 1:37:49cos he impressed me during our conversation earlier,
- 1:37:51and I,
- 1:37:52that cannot be said about everybody that's sat opposite me today.
- 1:37:55So Nick,
- 1:37:57come to the chair.
- 1:37:58Good to talk to you again,
- 1:37:58Pierce.
- 1:37:59Welcome back.
- 1:38:00My surrounding claim is that discussions of woke politics
- 1:38:03are merely a distraction from our common enemy,
- 1:38:05the billionaire class.
- 1:38:07So,
- 1:38:08as I just said,
- 1:38:08I think that these discussions of woke,
- 1:38:10whether we think we're saying that the problems
- 1:38:11in society are because of broke graduate students
- 1:38:14or people that are being mean to us on Twitter,
- 1:38:17ultimately it's all secondary to what really unites us.
- 1:38:19I think that it's woke to talk about the fact that.
- 1:38:22The,
- 1:38:22the middle America,
- 1:38:23the industrial heartland of Britain have been
- 1:38:25hollowed out by forces of globalization,
- 1:38:27outsourcing jobs to places like China or India or Malaysia or Vietnam,
- 1:38:31and that these,
- 1:38:32talking about trans athletes,
- 1:38:34talking about what people choose to identify themselves as,
- 1:38:37it's all so unimportant and 80,
- 1:38:3990,
- 1:38:4095% of what actually matters
- 1:38:42is what's gonna put more money in people's pockets,
- 1:38:44what's gonna let them have a dignified life for them and their family.
- 1:38:47And
- 1:38:48talking about wokeness,
- 1:38:49whether it's dead or alive,
- 1:38:50it's just a distraction and it's really not important or relevant
- 1:38:54to most of our lives
- 1:38:5695% of the time.
- 1:38:57OK,
- 1:38:58I think you can,
- 1:38:59the first part I agreed with
- 1:39:00about the globalization.
- 1:39:01I think you're spot on.
- 1:39:02And also I'm not trying to claim that
- 1:39:05the wokeism cultural war issues
- 1:39:08are more important
- 1:39:09than
- 1:39:10globalization or the impact,
- 1:39:12as you say,
- 1:39:12of nefarious billionaires around the world
- 1:39:15having too much power and money
- 1:39:16with the disparity between them and the poorest
- 1:39:18parts of society,
- 1:39:20yeah.
- 1:39:20Getting bigger and bigger.
- 1:39:21Well,
- 1:39:21I have very strong views about that.
- 1:39:23Nor am I trying to say that,
- 1:39:24you know,
- 1:39:25the,
- 1:39:25the debate about pronouns
- 1:39:27is in any way as significant as the debate I have all the time
- 1:39:30about the war in Gaza or the war in Ukraine.
- 1:39:33I just think you can have all these debates at the same time,
- 1:39:35and to pretend,
- 1:39:36as the woke left do,
- 1:39:37that none of these culture wars cut through or matter
- 1:39:40is to be completely deluded.
- 1:39:42And I would simply say to you that
- 1:39:44there was a UN report came out,
- 1:39:46and it said,
- 1:39:46I think it was 2024,
- 1:39:48uh,
- 1:39:48nearly 900.
- 1:39:50Medals in competitive women's sport,
- 1:39:52to come back to that issue we discussed,
- 1:39:54had been deprived from actual women
- 1:39:57because trans athletes had won them.
- 1:39:59That's a staggeringly large number
- 1:40:01of girls and women
- 1:40:03who've been deprived of their rightful medal
- 1:40:05competing in women's sport
- 1:40:06because of the altar of trans activism
- 1:40:09driven by the World Cup.
- 1:40:10See,
- 1:40:10this is my trouble,
- 1:40:11Pierce,
- 1:40:11with talking about trans athletes,
- 1:40:13because
- 1:40:13functionally you're talking about 900 medals given out to people.
- 1:40:16I don't,
- 1:40:16I don't know the figure.
- 1:40:18My thing is that an 8 year old winning a track and field meet
- 1:40:22doesn't really affect me.
- 1:40:23What about Riley Gaines?
- 1:40:24What about Riley Gaines,
- 1:40:25who's written a campaign?
- 1:40:26But what about Riley Gaines?
- 1:40:27I mean,
- 1:40:27why.
- 1:40:28This is exactly my point,
- 1:40:29Piers.
- 1:40:30This whole discussion of trans athletes has nothing to
- 1:40:32do with what actually matters to people's lives.
- 1:40:34I don't agree with you.
- 1:40:34You're talking about it with all due respect,
- 1:40:36a lot of clicks,
- 1:40:37gets a lot of I don't agree with it.
- 1:40:38I don't agree with it.
- 1:40:39And these other issues are much more important,
- 1:40:41but you know who,
- 1:40:42you know who leads that campaign of saying no one cares?
- 1:40:45The woke left.
- 1:40:46Most of whom think it's absolutely fine.
- 1:40:48Most of whom think someone like Riley Gaines is the
- 1:40:50enemy this is for standing up for women's rights.
- 1:40:52If you're saying that we have time to debate all of these issues,
- 1:40:55but practically we know.
- 1:40:56That society prioritizes different issues.
- 1:40:58How much time do you think you've spent on the
- 1:41:00Israel-Hamas war compared to wokeism in the last calendar year?
- 1:41:03A lot of time has been spent on the Israel-Gaza war.
- 1:41:06A lot of people have died.
- 1:41:07Give me a percentage of how much time I personally devoted to war.
- 1:41:11I'm not sitting here with a stopwatch going,
- 1:41:12how much time is spent on what I know is not nearly enough time is being spent.
- 1:41:15Let me help you.
- 1:41:16I spend a lot of poverty.
- 1:41:18These are the issues that really matter.
- 1:41:19There are a million issues.
- 1:41:20You may not care
- 1:41:22about the trans athlete issue.
- 1:41:23I can tell you
- 1:41:24millions.
- 1:41:25People do.
- 1:41:26Who are you,
- 1:41:27all due respect,
- 1:41:28to have the arrogance to tell people what they should be caring about?
- 1:41:31You can compare,
- 1:41:32you can.
- 1:41:32I'm not trying to tell them not to care about it.
- 1:41:34I don't think it should be at the top or even in
- 1:41:36the top 10 of the issues they actually are talking about.
- 1:41:38That's entirely your prerogative,
- 1:41:40but you should not be arrogant enough to assume
- 1:41:43you know what people care about.
- 1:41:44I know from
- 1:41:46the work I did on this book
- 1:41:47and this tour I've been doing
- 1:41:49and the conversations I've been having,
- 1:41:51a huge number of people do care about this.
- 1:41:53They genuine.
- 1:41:54Genuinely have felt that the woke left have turned the world into a joyless,
- 1:41:58horrible place where everyone gets scolded,
- 1:42:01vilified,
- 1:42:02canceled,
- 1:42:02shamed,
- 1:42:03and sometimes shot
- 1:42:04because of what they're saying.
- 1:42:05But this is the I think that does matter of social media and the way that public
- 1:42:09discourse works is instead of talking about the issues
- 1:42:11that are the most relevant to people's lives,
- 1:42:13I'm not talking about whether they care or not,
- 1:42:14but I'm talking about relevance,
- 1:42:16how much it actually matters to your life.
- 1:42:19That,
- 1:42:19do you have any kids?
- 1:42:20I do not have any.
- 1:42:20OK,
- 1:42:20if you had a daughter,
- 1:42:21I've got a 13 year old daughter.
- 1:42:23She's showing no sign of doing this,
- 1:42:24but if she had aspirations
- 1:42:27to be an Olympian,
- 1:42:27for example,
- 1:42:28would you feel differently if her Olympic place was taken by a transathlete?
- 1:42:32I,
- 1:42:32I do not want anyone's Olympic dreams to be crushed,
- 1:42:34but I think that their ability to get a well-paying job
- 1:42:37is much more important and something we should be focusing on.
- 1:42:39And you made it clear you think that the Olympic dream is irrelevant.
- 1:42:42I,
- 1:42:43I,
- 1:42:43I much prefer to focus on the American dream than an Olympic dream,
- 1:42:47so you have your fixed set of things that you care about.
- 1:42:49I respect that,
- 1:42:50right?
- 1:42:51A lot of people will,
- 1:42:52but again,
- 1:42:52Pierce,
- 1:42:52I think everybody cares about these things,
- 1:42:55but they don't work people up as much,
- 1:42:56and so it doesn't get as much airplay.
- 1:42:58Of course they do.
- 1:42:59No,
- 1:43:00we,
- 1:43:00we all know that if this was a discussion about the minutia of healthcare policy,
- 1:43:04it would not get as many viewers as an hour-long conversation about trans athletes.
- 1:43:08You don't come on,
- 1:43:09we know this.
- 1:43:09You don't think that issues,
- 1:43:10for example,
- 1:43:11like the wars in Ukraine and Gaza,
- 1:43:13get people angry and passionate.
- 1:43:14If it bleeds,
- 1:43:15it bleeds,
- 1:43:16of course that matters.
- 1:43:17Of course.
- 1:43:17You don't think war and peace is incredibly important.
- 1:43:20You don't think the issue of globalization and the
- 1:43:22impact on people's jobs and lives has not been
- 1:43:24the subject of a lot of passionate,
- 1:43:26angry,
- 1:43:26animated.
- 1:43:27I think it gets far less airtime than it deserves because what we see
- 1:43:30is that whether you're on the right populist side or the left populist side.
- 1:43:33They've all got their fingers squarely aimed at the
- 1:43:36puppet masters pulling the strings behind our whole system.
- 1:43:38But it's the people in the middle,
- 1:43:40and this is what I wish people would really understand at home.
- 1:43:43It is not the left that pushed woke politics or identity politics.
- 1:43:47It was neo-liberals who wanted to have
- 1:43:50the,
- 1:43:50the current system maintain the status quo,
- 1:43:52but give people who hadn't had a stake in that system
- 1:43:55more representation within it.
- 1:43:57But the fact is that for most people.
- 1:43:59Whether the CEO of Lockheed Martin is a trans black woman does not matter.
- 1:44:03What matters for most people is whether they have a
- 1:44:06job that actually is able to pay the rent,
- 1:44:07so they can own,
- 1:44:08have a hope of owning a home,
- 1:44:09that they can marry who they like to,
- 1:44:11that stuff matters.
- 1:44:12It only matters if the black trans leader of a company
- 1:44:15has only got that job
- 1:44:17because they're black and trans and not on ability,
- 1:44:20because then you move into a country and society which prides itself on media.
- 1:44:24Over meritocracy.
- 1:44:26I believe in opportunity for all
- 1:44:28at the bottom rung,
- 1:44:29but once that ladder starts,
- 1:44:30I believe only the most capable people
- 1:44:33should get to the top.
- 1:44:34The people getting tens of millions of stock options are not my priority.
- 1:44:38You know the person making minimum wage that's my priority,
- 1:44:40the best quote about DEI I've heard was Steven Pinkett,
- 1:44:43who said that rather like the Holy Roman Empire,
- 1:44:45which ended up being neither
- 1:44:47Holy
- 1:44:48Roman
- 1:44:48or really an empire.
- 1:44:50That's what DEI became,
- 1:44:51it's supposed to be diverse,
- 1:44:52equal and inclusive,
- 1:44:53ended up being none of those things,
- 1:44:55and that's the problem.
- 1:44:56So we should be,
- 1:44:57look,
- 1:44:57one of the good things about this conversation,
- 1:44:59it's been a conversation.
- 1:45:01I don't think enough of this happens where people don't just scream at each other.
- 1:45:04I've actually found this an engaging
- 1:45:06environment to talk in.
- 1:45:07I like being challenged.
- 1:45:08You've all given me a little something to think about,
- 1:45:10you in particular,
- 1:45:11that's why I brought you back.
- 1:45:12These are good conversations to have.
- 1:45:14I'm not saying you're intrinsically wrong,
- 1:45:16that your priority list is not more important.
- 1:45:18I think it probably is,
- 1:45:20right,
- 1:45:20but I also think the idea that millions and millions of people around the world,
- 1:45:24tens of millions,
- 1:45:25hundreds of millions probably,
- 1:45:26do not care about those other issues
- 1:45:28is deluded.
- 1:45:29This is why I chose the prompt that I did,
- 1:45:31because I know that when I get upset about something,
- 1:45:33it clouds out a lot of other things that I should be thinking about,
- 1:45:36but I get so focused on the thing I'm angry about.
- 1:45:38This is why woke politics has become such a
- 1:45:40useful canard for people of all political persuasions,
- 1:45:43because it does get people worked up,
- 1:45:45because it does speak to basic issues of identity and belonging and meaning.
- 1:45:49And when you undermine that,
- 1:45:50people do get really upset.
- 1:45:51And what that does is it takes away their emotional and
- 1:45:54intellectual bandwidth from the things that
- 1:45:55would materially improve their lives.
- 1:45:58And that is why I think that this whole conversation,
- 1:46:00not that it's not important,
- 1:46:02but it should not be crowding out as it is in our public discourse,
- 1:46:06all the other issues that are so,
- 1:46:07so much more important.
- 1:46:08That's why you saw,
- 1:46:10I know you don't agree with Mamdani in New York.
- 1:46:12Mamdani did not run a campaign on woke politics.
- 1:46:15He aimed it squarely at cost of living,
- 1:46:17affordability issues,
- 1:46:18and he won
- 1:46:19more votes than anybody in New York City in the last 60 years.
- 1:46:22Hang on.
- 1:46:22He also promised,
- 1:46:23like all good socialists,
- 1:46:24he's going to give everyone everything for free.
- 1:46:26And let me tell you what's,
- 1:46:27I'll tell you what,
- 1:46:27buses are free for most people in New York already.
- 1:46:29Let me,
- 1:46:30you know,
- 1:46:30let me tell you what's gonna happen with Mam Dani.
- 1:46:32You can take this to the bank,
- 1:46:33because socialism has never worked anywhere in the
- 1:46:35world for any sustained period of time.
- 1:46:37Mamdani is gonna let down all the people that voted
- 1:46:40for him because he will not be able to afford
- 1:46:43to do anything like the stuff he says he's gonna do.
- 1:46:45You can take it this is where I agree with you,
- 1:46:47Piers,
- 1:46:47definitions matter.
- 1:46:48Socialism is about public ownership of the means of production.
- 1:46:51Zoran Mamdani is not proposing seizing uh.
- 1:46:54You know,
- 1:46:54JP Morgan's building,
- 1:46:55he literally said he wants to take control of productivity.
- 1:46:59I have not seen him say that a communist.
- 1:47:01He is not a communist.
- 1:47:02Literally,
- 1:47:02that is the rhetoric of a communist.
- 1:47:04He is not a communist.
- 1:47:05And again,
- 1:47:06if you want to drink the Mamdani Kool-Aid,
- 1:47:08fine with you,
- 1:47:09right?
- 1:47:09He is a communist
- 1:47:11masquerading it's good to have more candidates like New
- 1:47:13York has never had a guy like that,
- 1:47:16like Mamdani who are focused on cost of living and affordability,
- 1:47:19speaking to the issues that actually matter in people's lives.
- 1:47:21Childcare being $22,000.
- 1:47:23We may disagree on how to provide that childcare,
- 1:47:25but you're speaking to an issue that affects 80% of families,
- 1:47:2880% of parents.
- 1:47:29So let's talk about that more.
- 1:47:31Trans athletes,
- 1:47:32with all due respect,
- 1:47:33you,
- 1:47:33you brought up Riley Gaines.
- 1:47:34There might be a couple of others,
- 1:47:36but we're talking about a vanishingly small number.
- 1:47:38And what I'm concerned about is the little girl who just wants to be on a team,
- 1:47:42who just wants to participate in her community.
- 1:47:44And I look at all the young California children
- 1:47:46who saw trans athletes participating,
- 1:47:48and they didn't care at all,
- 1:47:49man.
- 1:47:50So why does everybody
- 1:47:51Else,
- 1:47:51when the kids get that this is,
- 1:47:53here's what happens,
- 1:47:54Nick.
- 1:47:54I know you're gonna get your little
- 1:47:56round of applause.
- 1:47:56I know it's easy,
- 1:47:57but here's what happens.
- 1:47:58When the little girls grow up and they get to
- 1:48:00be Riley Gaines and they're actually competing for a living,
- 1:48:03and this is their livelihood and their dream,
- 1:48:05and they dream of getting to win competitions to get to the Olympics,
- 1:48:08well,
- 1:48:08luckily Riley didn't become a minute,
- 1:48:10did she?
- 1:48:10Well,
- 1:48:10she's just a commentator.
- 1:48:12Actually she did become her Olympic dream was shadowy,
- 1:48:14sadly never going to be.
- 1:48:16You may be glib about it,
- 1:48:17but actually what happened is a 6 ft 3 inch.
- 1:48:19Biological male came in and began to destroy
- 1:48:22the integrity of women's swimming in America.
- 1:48:24You may not think that matters.
- 1:48:26I do.
- 1:48:27That's why I talk a lot about this.
- 1:48:28That's why Riley's been brave to talk about it.
- 1:48:30That's why JK Rowling was brave to talk about it.
- 1:48:32And the idea that she,
- 1:48:33I know,
- 1:48:34you can all vilify JK Rowling,
- 1:48:35I don't even like her.
- 1:48:36She hates me.
- 1:48:38She called me a disgusting,
- 1:48:39toading Trump apologist on Bill,
- 1:48:41when I was on Bill Maher once,
- 1:48:42when I got told to fuck off,
- 1:48:43so I've got no truck for her whatsoever,
- 1:48:46right,
- 1:48:46but on that issue,
- 1:48:47I've loudly.
- 1:48:48Supported her,
- 1:48:49which is kind of what I feel about the Trump thing,
- 1:48:51by the way,
- 1:48:51is that the hysteria that goes around him,
- 1:48:54it doesn't help anybody.
- 1:48:55You're better off saying well Trump does something good,
- 1:48:57for example,
- 1:48:58if I was to ask you as a group,
- 1:48:59is it good
- 1:49:00that Trump has basically shut the southern border down
- 1:49:03after the Biden administration let in 10 million
- 1:49:05people illegally over that border in 4 years,
- 1:49:07and that may be a conservative estimate,
- 1:49:09is that a good thing?
- 1:49:10The,
- 1:49:10the honest,
- 1:49:11intellectually honest answer should be
- 1:49:13yes.
- 1:49:14Are there issues now about the way.
- 1:49:16ICE has been going around picking up undocumented
- 1:49:19people who may have built their lives here,
- 1:49:21contributed to society,
- 1:49:21and so on.
- 1:49:22Absolutely you made the point for me,
- 1:49:24I didn't have to.
- 1:49:24Absolutely.
- 1:49:25So there are caveats to my support for the overall policy,
- 1:49:28but on the southern border,
- 1:49:29everybody should be able to say
- 1:49:31that's a good thing,
- 1:49:32and they should also applaud Trump for trying to forge peace
- 1:49:35in places around the world where there is war,
- 1:49:37be it Gaza where he got the hostages out and ceasefire or Ukraine.
- 1:49:41So,
- 1:49:41so my,
- 1:49:42so my point is
- 1:49:43if the hysteria just dials.
- 1:49:44Down a touch,
- 1:49:46and actually we try and do what we've done here,
- 1:49:48right?
- 1:49:48Bring,
- 1:49:49bring people a bit more together,
- 1:49:50have a bit more consensus,
- 1:49:52give credit where it's due,
- 1:49:53criticize where it's due,
- 1:49:55but sometimes agree to disagree.
- 1:49:57You know,
- 1:49:57I,
- 1:49:57I'm not saying you're wrong
- 1:49:59with your priority list,
- 1:50:00I'm just saying that I think to exclude these other things
- 1:50:03is
- 1:50:04disingenuous from my perspective,
- 1:50:06because I think it is important,
- 1:50:07but we can agree to disagree about that,
- 1:50:09and I'm not saying that your priority list is in any way invalid,
- 1:50:12cos it's not.
- 1:50:13Well,
- 1:50:13I think we found some middle ground here,
- 1:50:15that's the wrong show.
- 1:50:16Yeah,
- 1:50:17you know what,
- 1:50:18just in case they,
- 1:50:19they want to end it,
- 1:50:20you know what,
- 1:50:20Nick,
- 1:50:20I've always hated you.
- 1:50:23Thanks
- 1:50:24you.
- 1:50:26I think he's intentionally not really aligned with either.
- 1:50:28I think he likes to
- 1:50:30punch the left from the center,
- 1:50:31I think he likes to punch the right from the center.
- 1:50:33I think he's kind of all over the map depending on the issue he's talking about,
- 1:50:36so I don't,
- 1:50:37I don't think that you can neatly categorize him into
- 1:50:40this block or that block,
- 1:50:41which frankly I think we need more of in our politics.
- 1:50:43I literally still,
- 1:50:45even after debating him and hearing his takes,
- 1:50:47still have no idea who the he is.
- 1:50:49The problem I have with a lot of the wokies when it comes to the debating,
- 1:50:52I do feel like they've been infected with a weird virus,
- 1:50:55which gives them a kind of self-righteousness that their positioning
- 1:50:59is not only
- 1:51:00right,
- 1:51:01but it's the only acceptable worldview.
- 1:51:03I have grown,
- 1:51:04I think,
- 1:51:05more intellectually honest as I've got older,
- 1:51:08about accepting when I've been wrong.
- 1:51:10You've gotta know that when.
- 1:51:11Facts are facts
- 1:51:12and
- 1:51:13if facts change in particular,
- 1:51:14you gotta move where the facts go,
- 1:51:16and you mustn't be intransigent that your worldview,
- 1:51:18even if it's science and biology denying,
- 1:51:21is the only acceptable view.
- 1:51:23I recommend anyone reading
- 1:51:25books that they fundamentally disagree with.
- 1:51:28So if you are somebody who considers himself v and liberal,
- 1:51:31read it.
- 1:51:31If you are a conservative,
- 1:51:33you'll.
- 1:51:34They just confirmation bias.
- 1:51:36Hey listeners,
- 1:51:37we have releases coming out every Sunday,
- 1:51:39so consider subscribing wherever you get your podcasts
- 1:51:42and also leave us a positive review.
- 1:51:44We appreciate your time and attention.