Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Good Earth (1937)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And oh boy. Say it again
- 0:24for me. Oh boy. That's right. We got two oh boys
- 0:28coming for you. And these oh boys are here to
- 0:31talk a little bit about Paul Muni and Louise
- 0:35Rainier. This is true. I want to start this episode
- 0:38by saying... You've heard this before. We've
- 0:41talked about various times the jazz singer, for
- 0:46example, right? We've seen Al Jolson dawning
- 0:50blackface for this movie, and that's inappropriate,
- 0:55obviously. It is something that is frowned upon
- 0:58today and should have been frowned upon. Back
- 1:02in 1927 at the release of The Jazz Singer. Right.
- 1:05We've seen it various times where actors are
- 1:07playing races that, you know, is not of their
- 1:11own. And it is always problematic. Wallace Berry
- 1:14in Viva Vida, where he plays Mexican icon. Pancho
- 1:19Villa. Pancho Villa. Thank you so much. I knew
- 1:21his last name. Viva? Yeah, that's the one. Pancho
- 1:24Viva. Pancho Viva. Yeah. This is going to be
- 1:28a heavy theme on today's episode. Not to compare
- 1:32atrocities, but this might be the most egregious
- 1:36example of it so far. Yeah, I have some thoughts
- 1:39on it, and I think there's some specifics to
- 1:44it. But at its core, the end message that we
- 1:47have here at Once Upon a Time in the Oscars,
- 1:49but certainly was not the case in the early versions
- 1:52of Hollywood, you should be casting the appropriate
- 1:56races. Yeah. We should be casting people in the
- 2:00roles to play their own race. Again, characters
- 2:03are meant to be played by different people. But
- 2:06at this time, it was just not the right move
- 2:08at all. Right. To have someone named Paul Mooney
- 2:11play a man named Wang Lung. Yeah. I saw that
- 2:15when we were covering this. I was like, oh, Paul
- 2:17Mooney is Wang? I was like, oh, no. Oh, yeah.
- 2:21It's rough. So that being said, if you are watching
- 2:23along with us, and this is something that does.
- 2:26bother you to the point where you don't feel
- 2:28like you can watch uh just understand that you
- 2:32know we don't condone this behavior but it was
- 2:3590 years ago at this point and that doesn't uh
- 2:39you know relieve it from its sins but it was
- 2:43i'm gonna say the line It was a different time,
- 2:46and we are here to judge the movie on their merits,
- 2:49as well as their misguided decisions. Thank you
- 2:54so much. With that said, I will also say, any
- 2:59thoughts that you have on these movies and all
- 3:01the other movies we cover, feel free to shoot
- 3:03those in to outaopodcast at gmail .com. And also...
- 3:08If you are feeling so generous, check out our
- 3:10Patreon for our many benefits, including early
- 3:12episodes and Horror of the Overlooked that we
- 3:15drop on the 13th of every month. Yes. With that
- 3:19said, we are talking about The Good Earth. Are
- 3:22you familiar with this movie at all before we
- 3:24covered it? Hadn't been. I'd never heard of it.
- 3:26It was a... A shocking revelation, I think. Not
- 3:29at all what I thought the movie was going to
- 3:31be about. No. Based on the title. You know, I
- 3:33don't mind telling you either that when we watch
- 3:35these movies in threes, because we record these
- 3:37movies in threes, we watched A Star Is Born,
- 3:40which I own. And I was like, wow, loved it. And
- 3:42then we watched Captain's Courageous, which I
- 3:44own. I was like, wow, I really had a good time
- 3:46with that. Four stars. And then The Good Earth
- 3:48is the third thing that we have to cover. I was
- 3:50like, oh, I don't own this one. I haven't seen
- 3:52it. I'm gonna have to get it on demand. And I
- 3:53find it on demand and I watch it. Now, here's
- 3:57the beginning of the oh boy that I threw at the
- 4:00top of this episode. For some reason, this does
- 4:03not have subtitles. So I wasn't able to watch
- 4:06this with subtitles. And as you know, I can't
- 4:09hear without my subtitles. This is true. So I
- 4:11was kind of a little lost at sea on this one
- 4:13when it comes to some of the dialect or dialogue.
- 4:17Not that big of a deal, but definitely a little
- 4:20more difficult than I would have liked it to.
- 4:22But still. Kept in pretty good condition. Movies
- 4:26from 1937. It does have five nominations, and
- 4:29of those nominations, we had film editing for
- 4:32Basil Rangel. Cinematography was for Carl Frund.
- 4:36Actress in a leading role, this was Louise Rainier.
- 4:39We'll talk a lot about her in this episode. Director
- 4:41was Sidney Franklin. And this was an outstanding
- 4:44production nominee on behalf of Metro -Goldwyn
- 4:47-Mayer MGM. They keep popping up. Another tally
- 4:50on the old spreadsheet. Another notch on the
- 4:53bedpost of MGM. This is true. So, The Good Earth
- 4:56stars, as we've said a couple times now, Paul
- 4:59Muni as Wang Lung, Luis Reynier as O -Lan, O
- 5:03-Lan, excuse me, and then Walter Connolly returns
- 5:06as the uncle of Wang. And there's a few other
- 5:11characters. These are the main trio here that
- 5:13you deal with throughout the majority of the
- 5:15movie. As others pop up, we'll kind of dive into
- 5:17that. Yes. And I mentioned that when I saw Paul
- 5:21Muni playing a character named Wang Long, I was
- 5:23a little cautious. And then when I saw Walter
- 5:26Connolly as Uncle, I was like, well, maybe that's
- 5:29not so bad. He's just Uncle. Who's Uncle? Exactly.
- 5:32Who's to say? Maybe he's just Unc. Maybe. I think
- 5:35he is at this point. Well, that's true. There's
- 5:37that. But he is certainly uncle to, as you mentioned,
- 5:40Wang Lung. Yeah. You want to talk us through
- 5:42the story a little bit of The Good Earth? Yes.
- 5:44So The Good Earth takes place during the Qing
- 5:48Dynasty in China. And it follows Wang Lung, who
- 5:53is a farmer in China and is set up in an arranged
- 5:57marriage with O -Lan. and she is a domestic slave.
- 6:02It follows the story kind of their relationship,
- 6:06their marriage, their feelings on one another,
- 6:10and how they survive in kind of a struggling
- 6:12error on their farm, trying to make ends meet,
- 6:16trying to raise a family, and trying to navigate
- 6:19different elements such as domestic issues, a
- 6:25kind of obnoxious uncle. In the form of Uncle
- 6:29Walter Connolly. True. And Plague, even. The
- 6:34movie has range, I'll say that. It certainly
- 6:38does. And that's one way to put it. I will also
- 6:42put out there that we mentioned this was directed
- 6:46by Sidney Franklin. I do want to point out that
- 6:48this film taking place in China was not fully
- 6:52filmed in China, believe it or not. Location
- 6:55shots were filmed previously. By, you're going
- 6:59to like to hear this, George W. Hill. George
- 7:01W. Hill. Are you doing the, I haven't heard that
- 7:04name in years. I can't recall. Big House. Oh
- 7:08my goodness. Wow, that's cool. Yeah. So he previously
- 7:11filmed that for a film that was later abandoned.
- 7:14And then Hill did die before this production.
- 7:17So they used that footage that Hill captured
- 7:19for another film. for uh china the location shots
- 7:23here otherwise this was filmed uh in chatsworth
- 7:27california they actually turned a 500 acre farm
- 7:31in chatsworth into the chinese farmland yeah
- 7:34so this was kind of filmed in california in place
- 7:37of china but they had location shots to complete
- 7:40that idea so we'll talk a bit about that and
- 7:43why that might be i kind of want to hear your
- 7:48let's start at the beginning And hear your thoughts
- 7:51on the good earth. So this is kind of a story
- 7:55that we haven't dealt with or a setting even
- 7:59that we haven't dealt with on the podcast where
- 8:02you're going back in time in another country
- 8:04as well. We're kind of exploring not only China
- 8:09as a setting, but also as a culture here. And
- 8:12right off the bat, you know, we've alluded to
- 8:15it. You have actors here portraying Chinese characters.
- 8:19and they themselves are not of Chinese descent.
- 8:22So that's a big red flag when the title rolls.
- 8:26I was excited, though, for kind of something
- 8:30new, something different, you know? We've done
- 8:33our gangsters, we've done our musicals, we've
- 8:35done just kind of the romantic dramas, and we've
- 8:38done period pieces as well, but usually in English
- 8:41-speaking countries and things of that nature.
- 8:44So this felt like a welcome change. even if it
- 8:48was clouded by the inherent racism that kind
- 8:54of revolves around it, if that makes sense. Yeah,
- 8:57it does. And I will say I was excited to hear
- 9:02a different story. Chinese farmland and a farmer
- 9:04and his family is not necessarily something we've
- 9:06tackled on the Academy here, nor is it something
- 9:10that we tackle a lot moving forward, right? It's
- 9:12a rarity in that too. At least in American cinema.
- 9:15That's true. What I will say is I didn't hear
- 9:19much of a review from you on that. I heard a
- 9:21little synopsis of like what's in this movie.
- 9:23Yeah. But how did you feel about it? I like this
- 9:26movie. Do you? I do. I do. This is one of those
- 9:29things where it's like this is the America during
- 9:33this time period. This was the culture. They
- 9:35were making movies about whatever and they were
- 9:38using the actors they had at their disposal.
- 9:40They were using the actors that were signed to
- 9:42these studios. That being Paul Muni and Luis
- 9:45Reynier. Like, it's one of those things where
- 9:49it's the fault of everybody, but that was the
- 9:53business, you know? So you're going to get these
- 9:56stories told by these actors. And Anna May Wong
- 10:00is such a huge name in early cinema, and it is
- 10:04pretty disastrous that she was not used in this
- 10:07movie. That being said, what studio did Anna
- 10:10May Wong work for during this time period? Were
- 10:13they able to get Anna May Wong for this? Was
- 10:16she already working on another film? I don't
- 10:18know. But that would still only take the spot
- 10:21of one actor, namely Louise Rainier, right? So
- 10:25I have a little bit of backstory on that from
- 10:27what I read. Okay. That may just bring some life
- 10:30to it. So there are two large female characters
- 10:34in this movie. One is obviously Olan, played
- 10:38by Louise Rainier. And the other is... I don't
- 10:42know why I want to say her name is Serpent. Lotus.
- 10:44Lotus. Thank you so much. Lotus, who is introduced
- 10:49towards the end of this film. And towards the
- 10:53end, we see that she is a dancer. And she gets
- 10:58the attention of Wang Long, and they begin a
- 11:01relationship. Now, Anna May Wong was introduced
- 11:05to this movie, and she was going for the part
- 11:08of O -Long. And they told her... we're not going
- 11:11to give you that part, but we are interested
- 11:12in giving you the part of Lotus. And she was
- 11:15not interested in this. She really wanted the
- 11:17lead of the film, so she walked away from the
- 11:19movie altogether. But they did not want her for
- 11:21the part of Olan. And honestly, this is where
- 11:24I think my issue with the movie stems the most.
- 11:27You're correct. This was of the time. This is
- 11:29what they did. They did not think to hire many
- 11:33people within that specific race to portray these
- 11:36characters. They thought about the star power.
- 11:40And they thought, well, this movie needed star
- 11:41power, so we're going to get Paul Muni. We're
- 11:43going to get Louis Rainier. We're going to get
- 11:45Walter Connolly. And the thing that frustrates
- 11:48me is that they have these three individuals
- 11:51playing a race that they are not. And I do appreciate
- 11:55that they didn't fully lean into stereotypes.
- 11:58Sure, yeah. The performances of them at the beginning
- 12:00are a little dicey. But as it goes on, we don't
- 12:03hear a lot of the accent coming out from Paul
- 12:06Muni. We don't see a lot of the, you know, they're
- 12:09playing stereotypes very heavily. They're just
- 12:12playing individuals that happen to be that race.
- 12:14Yeah, this isn't Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at
- 12:16Tiffany's. No, no, no, no. We see a much different
- 12:18characterization, which I will say, all things
- 12:21considered, I do appreciate that they didn't
- 12:23lean into, like, you know, the cheap tricks of
- 12:26that. I agree. And I think that is worth mentioning.
- 12:30However... where I do not want to give the company
- 12:33or the studio any kind of leeway in that, is
- 12:36that there are a lot of extras in this film.
- 12:38There are a lot of background actors. And a lot
- 12:41of those background actors are of Chinese descent
- 12:43and are Chinese individuals, which shows that
- 12:47you can do this. Totally, you can. You can put
- 12:51men, you can put Chinese individuals in your
- 12:56film. You just decided not to have them lead
- 12:58this. And that becomes more frustrating to me
- 13:01than just like excluding them altogether. Totally.
- 13:05So that's where a lot of my frustration stems
- 13:07from. Paul Muni and Louise Rainier are fantastic
- 13:10actors. And they're very good in this. Louise
- 13:13Rainier obviously getting the nomination for
- 13:17leading role in this. Yeah, yeah. But that just
- 13:20stuck out like a sore thumb to me, to where it
- 13:23frustrated me. We have, like, you know, a jump
- 13:26in time forward where we see the children of
- 13:30Wang and O -Lan. O -Lan. O -Lan. Thank you so
- 13:33much. We see the children of Wang and O -Lan
- 13:36grown up. Yeah. And they are Chinese individuals
- 13:39of Chinese descent. Or at least of Asian descent.
- 13:43I actually don't know for sure. You're absolutely
- 13:45right. Thank you so much. They are of Asian descent.
- 13:48And this is, again, frustrating because we're
- 13:50seeing it. And also, I forget the names of their
- 13:53sons, but the son who is an academic. And he's
- 13:57very well studied and kind of helps out a strategy
- 14:00later on involving forecasting. He's really good.
- 14:04I really liked him in this movie. How much more
- 14:08interesting is this movie if you authentically
- 14:10have Asian individuals playing those characters?
- 14:15Right. And it frustrates me because the story
- 14:18is really good. And the story is there. And I
- 14:20like the end result. But it was something that
- 14:24I couldn't get past. I totally understand that.
- 14:26And that's why I try to emphasize, at least to
- 14:31myself, I'm going back and I'm watching these
- 14:33movies with the goal of... Judging the film itself,
- 14:38the story and the things that take place in the
- 14:40movie, it is a lot of fun to look at the behind
- 14:43-the -scenes facts and everything, or it is disturbing
- 14:46to look at the behind -the -scenes facts in this
- 14:48case. But I try to view the movies based on its
- 14:52own merit. The content itself. Yes. And in that
- 14:56sense, I wish that they would have cast Chinese
- 14:59actors for this. I don't think it would have
- 15:02gotten the nomination for Best Picture or anything
- 15:04else, unfortunately, during the 1937 era, you
- 15:09know? That's one of those things where that's
- 15:12just not what was going on during the time. That
- 15:14being said, the merits of this film itself, I
- 15:17think that the acting is pretty solid. I think
- 15:20that the story is engaging. Above all else, I
- 15:23think that this movie is beautifully shot. I
- 15:26will say that the thing that you cannot knock
- 15:28this movie for is the cinematography. Yeah. Carl
- 15:31Freund got the nomination for this and well -deserved.
- 15:34This is beautiful. There are some great shots
- 15:37of him walking along the village, and it is clearly
- 15:40shot with many background actors. There is clearly
- 15:43a big set to this. Again, that's something that
- 15:48is really incredible in it. And I was frustrated
- 15:50because I was like, man, I just I really want
- 15:51to like this because look at everything around
- 15:53it. My own bias was leading me to like not feel
- 15:57that way. But it can't be denied. It is a beautiful
- 16:00looking movie. I think that is the nomination
- 16:02that I most see as justified in this. It's so
- 16:07beautiful the way that they shoot for California
- 16:09for the Chinese countryside. And it's also kind
- 16:13of like. meditative in a way yeah because we
- 16:17really have not spent much time on a farm state
- 16:20fair is probably the closest we've gotten to
- 16:22a farm yeah in the movies we've covered and that
- 16:24is more like the beginning setting and then we
- 16:27move past it in this it really is set at that
- 16:30time right and we get to see like kind of you
- 16:32know what happens when you plant this uh peach
- 16:35uh seed the peach pit into the ground what happens
- 16:39when you do that what happens when your land
- 16:42is ravaged by locusts what happens like how much
- 16:46work take does it go into raising a farm cultivating
- 16:50a farm and it's kind of meditative in that way
- 16:53where i think it gets lost a bit is when it starts
- 16:56getting into the personal play of the family
- 16:58specifically uh wang we see kind of like the
- 17:02follies later in his life but He is surviving
- 17:06through a famine. He is surviving through a drought
- 17:10where his land is not thriving and the people
- 17:13of his village need food. And how are they going
- 17:16to survive? They're going broke on this farm.
- 17:18But this is all he has had. I think there are
- 17:21interesting stories in this. And it's not like
- 17:24a terrible movie. But it was one that I had difficulty
- 17:27getting through. And I felt the runtime a good
- 17:29bit. Worth noting, this is about two hours, 18
- 17:33minutes, I think. Yeah, right around there. Maybe
- 17:3420. So it's lengthy. Not even just by terms of
- 17:39the 1937 standard. But by our standard, too.
- 17:43It's pretty unfortunate now it's a standard runtime
- 17:46for most Oscar films. But it's pretty lengthy.
- 17:49The previous films we talked about clocked in
- 17:53under two hours. captain's courageous i think
- 17:55you feel a little bit of it in that just a little
- 17:57bit most of the movies we're covering for the
- 17:58remainder of this month are about an hour and
- 18:00a half so there you go yeah we're knocking out
- 18:03the long ones first um but that's where i think
- 18:06you feel the the biggest travesty in this if
- 18:08we take aside everything we've mentioned before
- 18:10is that the runtime is really felt in this and
- 18:13it does really like in my opinion out where it's
- 18:17welcome overstay it's welcome thank you so much
- 18:19it overstays it's welcome um and i think it's
- 18:22just a bit too long But I think the end set piece
- 18:25of this is really exciting. Yes. And we'll get
- 18:29to that. But I think that is kind of like we
- 18:31talked about San Francisco last year. And we
- 18:34talked about how that is kind of a disaster film,
- 18:37even though disaster is maybe the last fifth
- 18:39of the movie. Yeah. In this sense, I think you
- 18:42can also kind of look at this as a disaster film.
- 18:45And it's interesting what it paves way to. I
- 18:48don't think anyone hearing what we've explained
- 18:50so far about this movie would see what I think
- 18:53this kind of paves the way towards. I might actually
- 18:56have kind of a crazy swerve or zag on a double
- 19:00feature because of that. It feels a little insensitive,
- 19:03so maybe I won't do that. But we'll talk about
- 19:05it when we get to that final sequence. I'm excited
- 19:08to get there. But let's talk a little bit about
- 19:10Paul Muni. Sure, yeah, yeah. Because Paul Muni
- 19:13has a lot to do in this movie, not even just
- 19:16in the character itself. But he kind of has to
- 19:18carry the idea of family in this. Because we're
- 19:22introduced to him first and how he is to essentially
- 19:26pick up his bride. Yeah, yeah. Again, it's an
- 19:30arranged marriage. And he's kind of being chastised
- 19:34by his uncle at the beginning of this film. Walter
- 19:37Connolly. Yeah. And you're... Presented with
- 19:41Paul Muni as kind of an honorable character,
- 19:45I think, at the beginning. He's a good guy. And
- 19:48when he does go and... What's an appropriate
- 19:51way to even say? When he and Olen are... brought
- 19:55together and like he's going home with her she
- 19:58comes from a completely different lifestyle she
- 20:00was she was raised as a domestic slave not to
- 20:02her parents but to another family and she's she's
- 20:06very uh timid she's very scared and cautious
- 20:09and she thinks that this arranged marriage is
- 20:11going to be just as awful as the uh the upbringing
- 20:15she's had so i think when not only she sees this
- 20:19but we as the audience see paul muni being a
- 20:22good guy uh wang is a good generous person he
- 20:26he gives her a peach on the walk home and she's
- 20:29like what is this mine and he's like yeah you
- 20:31you get things now you you're my wife you're
- 20:35not my property um that's kind of the first look
- 20:38you get at paul muni's character and i think
- 20:40it's supposed to be good and positive and you
- 20:43use the right word their character because i
- 20:45think that's what uh olan starts or olan starts
- 20:47seeing in him yeah is that character of she's
- 20:51not just marrying a man but she's marrying this
- 20:52man And I thought this was also really impactful
- 20:56because it went both ways. Because when he gives
- 20:59her the peach and she walks behind him and watches
- 21:01him eat it, and as he eats it, he throws the
- 21:03pit out. Yeah. And he just throws the pit on
- 21:05the ground. And she stops to pick it up. And
- 21:07he recognizes this. And he sees her. And she
- 21:10picks it up. And she said, like, this can grow.
- 21:12So he sees then the sustainability. Again, not
- 21:15just this is a metaphor. It's not just the sustainability
- 21:18of the peach pit, but it's the sustainability
- 21:21of having this partnership. these two people
- 21:24and this is obviously what starts growing their
- 21:28farm is the sustainability of the two of them
- 21:31together right she has obviously i mean i don't
- 21:34want to make this comparison but you see the
- 21:36movie showing that she has the work ethic right
- 21:38yeah like she is willing to put in the work and
- 21:40fully commit to this farm and that's what they
- 21:43end up doing together yeah and it's it's probably
- 21:46out of a sense of obligation from her upbringing
- 21:49because to skip ahead a little bit When she gets
- 21:53pregnant, she's still out in the field working
- 21:54and putting in all of this hard labor. Yeah.
- 21:59And I think that's part of her character as well.
- 22:01When she gets pregnant, many times. And she never
- 22:04stops working. Never stops working. Yeah. Unfortunately,
- 22:06it sounds like we're kind of breaking down the
- 22:08Reba theme. Sing mom. Mom who works two jobs.
- 22:11Yeah. She never stops. She never stops. That's
- 22:14worth noting. She ends up having a total of four
- 22:18children. Yeah. Two boys and two girls. But tragedy
- 22:24does strike the family. Tragedy strikes the family
- 22:27when the crops are not growing the way that they
- 22:29need to, the village is running out of food,
- 22:32and they realize that when they have their fourth
- 22:36child, their daughter, that they actually aren't
- 22:38able to raise and care for this child. So I'm
- 22:44trying to find the best word for this, but they
- 22:45really do treat the child as a sacrifice. Yeah,
- 22:48the child is ultimately killed. Because they
- 22:51cannot raise them. Yeah. They cannot properly
- 22:54feed them. And it's worth mentioning that Olan
- 22:57is the one that takes care of this. We see that
- 23:00Wang is unable to even sacrifice the—is it an
- 23:06ox that they have? Yes. They have an ox that
- 23:09he has really treated as like a family member
- 23:10throughout the entire movie. And when the famine
- 23:14comes and they are unable to eat and their crops
- 23:16aren't growing, he is asked to sacrifice. I don't
- 23:21say this lightly. I do think that the Ox is one
- 23:23of the better actors in this movie. He does have
- 23:27a great moment. In this scene where he walks
- 23:29up to the Ox, the Ox is almost looking at him
- 23:32in a way of like, you don't want to do that.
- 23:34His eyes are really communicating like, hey,
- 23:37I'm not panicking. I'm just letting you know,
- 23:39you don't want to do that. And this is ultimately
- 23:42what Wayne hears from him. He's like, I can't
- 23:44do it. He's like a member of the family. I can't
- 23:46do it. And Olan says, well, then watch me do
- 23:49it. And she goes out there and has the same scene
- 23:52with the ox. And the ox continues to give that
- 23:55performance of just looking at her and being
- 23:57like, hey, look, we're newer to each other than
- 24:01me and Wang, but you don't have to do this. And
- 24:04I don't know how, but it's just really expressive
- 24:08on the ox that I thought was really impressive.
- 24:11But clearly she has this mindset of what needs
- 24:15to be done for the family needs to be done. And
- 24:17she ends up making that sacrifice in both the
- 24:20ox and their fourth child, which is tragic. And,
- 24:24you know, it's a real it's a real tone that the
- 24:27movie sets in this really depressing idea of
- 24:30what it takes to raise this family. But even
- 24:33in the face of this, they can't sell the farm.
- 24:35They can't bring themselves to sell the farm,
- 24:37even though Uncle, who is a really greedy character,
- 24:40you know, he is a man who acts out of ambition,
- 24:42a man who acts out of fear. And he's saying,
- 24:45you got to sell the farm. Because how else are
- 24:48you going to take care of your family? And they
- 24:50opt not to do that. They do want to travel to
- 24:53get different opportunities. So at this point,
- 24:56we're about halfway through the movie. Yeah.
- 24:59But the pace of this is just tragedy after tragedy
- 25:02after tragedy, which is true to the time, right?
- 25:06Sure. But this is really where the pace of the
- 25:08movie was felt for me, where you're feeling like
- 25:11there's not a lot of good happening to them.
- 25:16persevere as best as they can but it is just
- 25:19like really tragic things that are happening
- 25:21one after another the ox is one scene i mean
- 25:23obviously you cannot even compare it to the idea
- 25:26of like having a fourth child and not being able
- 25:28to take care of that right yeah so there's a
- 25:31lot of tragedy in this movie how were you feeling
- 25:33these events uh i i'm a terrible person i love
- 25:38tragedy in a movie i live for tragedy you are
- 25:42the comedy guy for sure you love a comedy thank
- 25:45you yeah i think i don't really enjoy comedies
- 25:50most of the time oh you know i am are you gonna
- 25:53be mad when i make the double feature of this
- 25:55with nirvana the band the show the movie i'll
- 25:57be very confused um but yeah you know in the
- 25:59old theatrical compares or uh i don't know the
- 26:04traditions i guess there is comedy and there
- 26:07is tragedy and i think you are a comedy Like
- 26:10you lean closer to comedy. I do love a tragedy,
- 26:12but yes, I see what you're saying. But if you
- 26:14had to stand on one side for the rest of your
- 26:17life, I think that you would stand on the comedy.
- 26:20I would stand on a tragedy. Yeah, maybe. Yeah.
- 26:23Maybe. Maybe. Arrival is in my top four on Letterboxd,
- 26:26and I would not call that movie close to a tragedy.
- 26:29Roll Bounce is in my top four, and I mean, let's
- 26:31be real. We contain multitudes, is what we're
- 26:33trying to say. Yeah. But that being said, this
- 26:36is the kind of story I think that drives me.
- 26:38You know, I love stories that talk on difficult...
- 26:44journeys that characters have to take different
- 26:46scenarios that that show characters struggling
- 26:49and having to evolve and adapt to and that's
- 26:52the kind of movie that i i really enjoy we we
- 26:55mentioned too like the the stereotypes in the
- 26:59character portrayal and the acting it is left
- 27:02out of this movie thankfully for the most part
- 27:04i looked up if this movie had ever seen a remake
- 27:08That was made by like a Chinese director using
- 27:11Chinese actors. And it hasn't. It's never been
- 27:14touched. I wonder, and I'm culturally and historically
- 27:19ignorant in this, if some of these elements in
- 27:23the plot are damaging cultural stereotypes. I
- 27:28know that politics have kind of dictated how
- 27:32kids are able to be handled at different times
- 27:36in China's history. I'm not knowledgeable enough
- 27:39to really speak on any of that. But I wonder
- 27:42if that is something that is just kind of adapted
- 27:46by a white screenplay writer, you know, for this
- 27:50movie. Well, in a number, right? I mean, screenplay
- 27:52was by Talbot Jennings, Tess Schlesinger, and
- 27:57Claudine West. Yeah. So you have to imagine that
- 28:01white screenplay writers, but I'm not entirely
- 28:04sure. It's also interesting that you mentioned
- 28:06politics because politics played a big part in
- 28:08this movie. We talked about how it was filmed,
- 28:10I shouldn't say on location, but on a 500 -acre
- 28:13farm in Chatsworth, California. But what's interesting
- 28:17was that at the time of filming, the Chinese
- 28:19nationalist government was fighting a Japanese
- 28:23invasion. And there's also a battle against communist
- 28:26rebels. So you're talking about the time period
- 28:29during the movie or in real life? There's so
- 28:32much I don't know. Yeah. This was during filming,
- 28:36not when it was set. Because it was set in a
- 28:37much different time, right? Sure. But yes, they
- 28:40were battling against communist rebels. So there's
- 28:42a lot going on with the Chinese government and
- 28:45with Japan as well. So it's almost like, yeah,
- 28:49we got a lot going on here, whatever you guys
- 28:51want to do. But it was a really interesting time
- 28:54for them to film this story. Yeah. While all
- 28:57that's going on. A lot of tragedy, a lot of events.
- 29:01Yeah, for sure. What is that movie? The Girl
- 29:04with the Needle? This movie is similar to that,
- 29:08and it's just tragedy after tragedy after tragedy.
- 29:10That was... Was it a short? No, no. That was
- 29:13a feature... International film. Yeah, international.
- 29:15That was nominated, wasn't it? Yes, yeah. We
- 29:18talked about that last year, I think, you and
- 29:19I. I think I double -featured that as something,
- 29:22is why we brought it up. Man, what a... I don't
- 29:25know what happened in that double -feature in
- 29:26the first movie, but... Yeah. Eesh. It was rough.
- 29:29So, yeah, as this movie goes on, The tragedy
- 29:33with the kids strikes. The famine strikes. And
- 29:36then there is a political unrest that occurs.
- 29:41And this is kind of a turning point for the family.
- 29:46Olan is—she takes place in, like, this looting
- 29:50situation that occurs. It's like almost a siege.
- 29:53Yes. Like a riot happens at one of the palaces.
- 29:58Yeah. Which, I gotta say— That's one of the moments
- 30:01I was like, Carl Frund is doing incredible work
- 30:04here. When they break through the doors of this
- 30:08palace or village and tons and tons of extras
- 30:12are charging towards the camera, it doesn't look
- 30:16like there was any direction going on in the,
- 30:18well, you're going to run here, you're going
- 30:19to run here. People are bumping into each other
- 30:21and just. It's mass chaos. I was kind of surprised
- 30:25not to see assistant director as a nomination
- 30:27for this film. And we talk a lot about like the
- 30:30tragedies that happen on film and how they typically
- 30:32have an assistant director nomination. But I
- 30:34more so mean in this, like with all the background
- 30:36actors, it feels like there had to be multiple
- 30:39people at the hand of this wrangling. There's
- 30:42one shot specifically that I was really taken
- 30:44back by. And it's when they break, they breach
- 30:47the gates that you're talking about. And then
- 30:49there's a great hall. A large room. And the entrance
- 30:53is in the back of the shot. And you see people
- 30:55pouring in. There can't be short of, like, maybe
- 30:59300 to 500 people on screen. So many. Flooding
- 31:03this room. And it is just the scale of it is
- 31:07epic. It is large. I was very impressed by that.
- 31:11And all of this is to say that, like, you know,
- 31:14Olan survives this robbery. of all these people,
- 31:19her included, being thrusted into this room.
- 31:23Yeah, she gets trampled during the process. She
- 31:25does get trampled. But when she wakes up, she
- 31:27finds that there's like jewels, like a pouch
- 31:30of jewels in front of her that have survived,
- 31:33that no one has touched and they forgot about.
- 31:36So she grabs that as kind of her, you know, survival.
- 31:40Of I've survived this and I made it through and
- 31:43it was all for this. So my family can survive
- 31:45on these jewels and use this. And this helps
- 31:50them become wealthy. Right. They have some wealth
- 31:52to their name enough to move back home. Right.
- 31:55To the farm. And at this point, their sons are
- 31:57grown. I think their daughter is maybe. like
- 32:02preteen maybe maybe teenager you don't see much
- 32:05of her we really don't i think we see a scene
- 32:07of her like helping stir like a pot yeah that's
- 32:09about it but their sons are really where we see
- 32:12the majority of the rest of the story um kind
- 32:15of a tale of two sons in a way one being the
- 32:19academic who is off studying and the other that
- 32:22is trying to like make the best of his life living
- 32:24at home. But when they come back home, they actually
- 32:27are doing so well on the farm that you mentioned
- 32:30where Olan comes from. And it's called the Great
- 32:33House. Yes. And the Great House is coming under
- 32:36some hard times. So the Long family actually
- 32:39purchase the Great House. Yeah. And they move
- 32:43into it. So they're running that. And it's almost
- 32:45like their own little dynasty, like their own
- 32:47palace. And this is where the majority of the
- 32:51film takes place. The farm as well, but the palace
- 32:53is where we see a lot of kind of... I didn't
- 32:56feel this, but I wonder how you feel about it.
- 32:58It was almost like a little corruption on Wang's
- 33:00part. Yeah, I think once he comes into some money,
- 33:03you see his character shift a little bit. And
- 33:06he's not as part of the moral high ground as
- 33:11he was, you were led to believe, at the beginning
- 33:13of the movie. Yeah, we see him kind of like leaning
- 33:16into this a little bit. And... As age continues
- 33:20to take them both, we see Wang kind of not affected
- 33:23by this too much. But Olan really is feeling
- 33:25the wear and tear of all the work that she's
- 33:28done. Bearing and raising children. Absolutely.
- 33:33Childbirth, raising those children. Prior to
- 33:36that, working on the farm. Still working on the
- 33:38farm when she was pregnant. And then obviously
- 33:40taking part in that riot and being trampled.
- 33:43That's going to take its toll on your body. And
- 33:45she's feeling ravaged by this. This kind of drives
- 33:49Wang to be pursuing other opportunities. He isn't
- 33:53really looking for other women at the time. He
- 33:55just kind of meets Lotus and is taken by her.
- 33:58Right. And it really is more of a seduction on
- 34:00her part, I think. But he is fully seduced and
- 34:03takes another wife. This is what I thought was
- 34:06interesting of the time. This isn't like an affair.
- 34:09This is like, hey, I'm going to take a second
- 34:10wife. Yeah, because he has a conversation with
- 34:13Olan about it. He's like, look, I met a woman,
- 34:15and while I'm not with her, I'm fine. But while
- 34:19I'm with her, like, that's all I want. So I think
- 34:22I'm going to take a second wife because you're
- 34:24kind of getting old. Like, he's so straightforward
- 34:26and blunt with her. And that's one of the elements
- 34:30where I'm like, is this like a cultural thing
- 34:32that I'm unfamiliar with? Or is this a stereotype
- 34:35that a white screen playwriter has then adapted
- 34:40to an American story? Yeah. I don't know. You
- 34:44said something earlier that I think is absolutely
- 34:46right for both of us, and that is just culturally
- 34:48ignorant. I'm not sure of the standards at that
- 34:54time or what was happening, so I can't say. But
- 34:57obviously this is depicted as a morally bankrupt
- 35:00decision on his part. He's abandoning his wife.
- 35:04He's looking solely for himself and not wanting
- 35:06to help her. So I think that's the way to take
- 35:08that. Is that how you took it? Where he's kind
- 35:11of abandoning his wife and what she needs and
- 35:12more looking for himself. Yeah. I mean, he's
- 35:16just reached the point where he's selfish. He's
- 35:18looking for what is going to help him. Well,
- 35:21and that selfish nature continues because we
- 35:25see that Lotus is interested in his son. And
- 35:29she takes a liking to his son, the non -academic,
- 35:32and she even seduces him. And there's an interesting
- 35:36innuendo in this of her. there's an instrument
- 35:40she plays. Yeah. Uh, it's kind of like a mandolin.
- 35:43Yeah. Oh, that's it. It's basically a mandolin,
- 35:45but she plays this instrument. And whenever you
- 35:48hear the music playing behind a door, that's
- 35:51kind of the innuendo that you're supposed to
- 35:53like insinuate with that. Right. Is that there
- 35:54is romantic, uh, intentions behind this. Right.
- 35:58We hear it with, uh, her son, his son hears it
- 36:01outside of a room and walks in and it's, uh,
- 36:04his father with, uh, Lotus. Right. And in a later
- 36:08scene, after a conversation between Lotus and
- 36:10his son, Wang walks in. And I thought this was
- 36:14actually kind of a really ingenious scene. He
- 36:18walks into the great house. And we see many caretakers,
- 36:22two to be exact, standing outside of a room,
- 36:25of Lotus's room. And they're just standing there.
- 36:29And when they see him, they don't do anything.
- 36:30They're just kind of frozen in place. And they
- 36:33know what's happening. And they've known what's
- 36:35happening. But they aren't saying anything. It's
- 36:37like Private Life of Henry VIII. Yeah. Where
- 36:39everyone's like, uh -oh. God, I can't get over
- 36:42that scene when he's like, no, it's just us.
- 36:45And then the camera cuts and there's like 30
- 36:47men standing outside of the room. Yeah. Great.
- 36:49That's exactly what happened here. A little bit.
- 36:50And you kind of see his realization when he looks
- 36:53at them of what's happening. And he walks into
- 36:56the room and nothing is really happening. But
- 36:58his son is sitting on the bed with Lotus, which
- 37:01is, you just make the assumption there. Yeah.
- 37:04And she's trying to she's on her knees begging
- 37:07for forgiveness. And ultimately, instead of blaming
- 37:09Lotus, he blames his son. Yeah. And this is another
- 37:13element of the culture, I think, that I'm like,
- 37:17well, is this itself a negative stereotype? Because
- 37:20multiple times you see him beating his son like
- 37:23brutally. beating his son uh using both hands
- 37:27and kind of slamming down on his back folding
- 37:29his fingers and then slamming his fists yeah
- 37:31the first one is earlier when his son steals
- 37:34uh some food a little bit of meat to have in
- 37:37their stew and the son admits to this well i
- 37:39stole it from an old lady which i'll be honest
- 37:42i wouldn't react like paul muni but i would be
- 37:44like i'm sorry you what yeah absolutely not he
- 37:47goes he goes pretty crazy on him when he's a
- 37:50kid but he does the same thing here Which is
- 37:53really kind of despicable, not just because he's
- 37:56beating him, but also because it's like, hey,
- 37:57man, you're two timing your wife for one. And
- 38:01yeah, maybe you told her and like it's been agreed
- 38:03upon. But also this is your son. I don't know.
- 38:07The whole thing is just like a weird relationship
- 38:10thing. It is. It was just kind of like a despicable
- 38:15thing. Yeah. It's meant to be that. Sure. For
- 38:18certain. But all this is happening while Olan
- 38:21is weak and unable to assist in any way that
- 38:25she wants to. So she feels like she's being replaced
- 38:27ultimately and, you know, understandably. But
- 38:31all of this leads to what I think is the climax
- 38:33of the movie. Yes. And I would argue is kind
- 38:35of the legacy of this movie. What I think this
- 38:38movie will be remembered for. Yeah. And that's
- 38:40where we see. Wang trying to take a little bit
- 38:43more of an accountability in his life. And we
- 38:50see that in his son, the scholar, coming in and
- 38:52kind of speaking truth to his father of, you
- 38:56have to stand up and fight. If there are locusts
- 38:58coming, and there are, Uncle has shown up to
- 39:01tell us, warn us that there are locusts coming.
- 39:04Instead of just abandoning everything, why don't
- 39:06we try and save some of it at least? And there's
- 39:08strategy of what we can do. And his son says,
- 39:10like, if there's something that I can do to like
- 39:12fight, I'm going to do it. I'm not just going
- 39:14to give up. We're going to recruit the bugs from
- 39:16the circus and we're going to save the farm.
- 39:20If it was grasshoppers coming, I would have just
- 39:22been like, this is my bug's life double feature.
- 39:25But the locusts are on their way. So I want to
- 39:28talk about the locusts. Originally, the special
- 39:31effects team on this. were trying and just could
- 39:34not find a way to authentically create the idea
- 39:37of locusts yeah and they're like all right well
- 39:39we give up we're done it wasn't until they found
- 39:41out that there was a locust plague that was like
- 39:44or not plague but there's locusts that were coming
- 39:47about states away and they were on the way to
- 39:49a they were like we have to go film this so they
- 39:53actually traveled like different states like
- 39:54packed up everything and filmed uh these locust
- 39:57attacks to actually like interlace this now what
- 40:01i don't know there's a lot of hills and there's
- 40:04this really haunting scene where they're all
- 40:06standing at the bottom of the hill looking up
- 40:08and at the top of the hill you can see almost
- 40:10like clouds like waves of locusts coming in uh
- 40:14there's also really up close shots of the locusts
- 40:17that almost look like a monster movie yes and
- 40:20i i want to talk about this i i don't fully know
- 40:23what shots were used that they filmed at the
- 40:26actual locusts like you know eating I'm not sure
- 40:30if that was like the waves and then they just
- 40:32kind of put that over the shots of the California
- 40:35farmland or the location shots. I'm not sure.
- 40:39But either way, they did practically capture
- 40:42locusts for the film. And what I thought was
- 40:45really interesting was the effect of this ends
- 40:47up looking like a B -side monster movie. Yeah.
- 40:51Because there's shots of the locusts where their
- 40:54eyes are pretty much the only thing on camera.
- 40:58And they're laying onto crops and eating it and
- 41:01attacking it. And you see a flood of black covering
- 41:06the farms. And it keeps growing. And it's really
- 41:10dread -inducing. And again, I just can't talk
- 41:13about how big these bugs look when they arrive
- 41:16on site. They're massive. This really did make
- 41:19me wonder, I wonder how much of this movie lent
- 41:21itself to like the 1950s, 1960s, like, you know,
- 41:26attack of the 50 foot woman. Sure. Ants. Ants.
- 41:30Them. Them is what I'm thinking of. Thank you.
- 41:32So large bugs attacking. And obviously it doesn't
- 41:36look very good then. But at this point, like
- 41:38it looks really like scary. Yeah. Well, I mean,
- 41:41this might be an element of, oh, look, people.
- 41:45react to this in the theaters they see the bugs
- 41:46and they're like oh those creepy crawlies so
- 41:48maybe that did at least spark in the horror genre
- 41:52like maybe we do creature features well i'm sure
- 41:55you know what is it 1941 cat people uh oh i forget
- 42:02the exact year but it is in 40s for some reason
- 42:04it's either 40 41 or 43 i don't know why yeah
- 42:07three is standing out to me but okay there's
- 42:09no bugs in that though There's not, but I'm saying
- 42:11that once RKO gets its first horror movie and
- 42:14horror starts popping off that way, I wonder
- 42:17if they're looking back to seeing the things
- 42:18that worked well in scenes like this. Sure. Not
- 42:21just in The Good Earth, but scenes like this.
- 42:23Like, well, that was kind of effective. I wonder
- 42:25if we can do something with that. Yeah. It's
- 42:27interesting. I'm not saying by any means this
- 42:29movie birthed that concept. But I wonder if including
- 42:34something like this on screen starts introducing
- 42:37to people like, oh, I felt really unsafe in that
- 42:40scene. I mean, if anything, we can look even
- 42:42further back at King Kong, of course. But, you
- 42:46know, every little piece is probably a stepping
- 42:49stone towards what we get in the 50s and things
- 42:51like that. 100%. I do want to say, when the locusts
- 42:55first come over the hill as the just dark cloud,
- 42:59that shot is... One of the most effective shots
- 43:02we've seen on the podcast so far. I agree. Where
- 43:05this impending doom feels like you feel the weight
- 43:10of it. And I was so astounded by that. Carl Froon,
- 43:16I can't imagine that that was a practical shot.
- 43:19They had to have done something in the camera
- 43:22or afterward, like overlaid something. Like,
- 43:32I think that they really shot, like, the people
- 43:34standing at the bottom of the hill looking up.
- 43:36And I think they did really film locust waves.
- 43:39Right. And then they probably just, like, overlapped
- 43:41it. Because notice it's kind of, like, in the
- 43:43sky. Yeah, yeah. And not really going over, like,
- 43:45the hills. It's so weird, though, because I don't
- 43:48think I've ever seen modern footage of locusts
- 43:50flying in real life. So I'm like, you guys could
- 43:53have just put this out and you would have been
- 43:55nominated for Best Picture. Like, the locust
- 43:57swarm? Yeah. Without overlaying it over anything.
- 43:59And I'd still be like, this is crazy. So, you
- 44:02know, I told you off pod that one of the films
- 44:06that I initially wanted to double feature this
- 44:08with was Minari. Yes. Because I thought Minari
- 44:10was, while also casting actors of Asian descent,
- 44:15that we did see like a good bit of the farming
- 44:19aspect and what farming means to like, not just
- 44:21the individual, but the family. Right. And the
- 44:23legacy of farming and what you're willing to
- 44:25do for your family. I thought that that would
- 44:28be a fantastic double feature for this. The reason
- 44:30I bring it up now, imagine if Minari just happens
- 44:34to feature one of the most breathtaking monster
- 44:37sequences at the end of it. Yeah. And that is
- 44:40the good earth. That is how, I want to say jarring,
- 44:44but it does feel like the climax of this movie,
- 44:47and it does feel like it belongs in it, where
- 44:49not only do we have this scene of we have to
- 44:51protect our farm, we then have maybe 20 minutes.
- 44:55of them attacking the locusts, trying to smoke
- 44:58them out, affect them with fire, and then as
- 45:01they land, you're trying to pour water over them
- 45:04and drown them. And then when that doesn't work,
- 45:06let's step on them. Let's grab all the tools
- 45:08that we have and try to kill them on the ground.
- 45:11Just start beating them. And there are, when
- 45:13I say waves, I don't just mean the actual literal
- 45:15wave of the locusts flying in, but there are
- 45:18hordes of... locust bodies that we see of them
- 45:21slamming on the ground, hitting them with shovels,
- 45:24with rakes, stepping on them, digging them into
- 45:26these moats. It is a large production. It's brutal,
- 45:30too. It is brutal. And it is horrifying, which
- 45:34makes their win even more satisfying. But it
- 45:37is just, I say this lovingly, so out of place.
- 45:39It is the ultimate tragedy for them to overcome,
- 45:42and they do. And ultimately, they're finding
- 45:45their way through it, but this is the only thing
- 45:47that they face head on, that they handle. And
- 45:49this is when I think we really see Wang's character,
- 45:52like, actually evolve. He listened to his son.
- 45:55He took the advice of his, like, you know, someone
- 45:57that he saw below him before that. And this is
- 46:00when things change for him. And he wants to be
- 46:02fully involved in his marriage. And he wants
- 46:04to be, like, fully accepting of his sons. And
- 46:07the next thing that we see is his son's wedding.
- 46:10Like, he is married, and they are celebrating.
- 46:12But there's tragedy that comes in this, too.
- 46:15Do you want to speak to that at all? kind of
- 46:20succumb to the exhaustion that she's dealt with
- 46:22her entire life and she realizes that she will
- 46:25be passing soon at the wedding at the wedding
- 46:28yeah and this is this is such a devastating loss
- 46:33for this family because she has been the one
- 46:35person who has always been there to step up and
- 46:38do what is necessary from the from the moment
- 46:40she was introduced to wang and that life on the
- 46:44farm she has been the one who does not complain
- 46:48about going out to work she is the one cooking
- 46:50the meals not only for wang but also for uncle
- 46:52and all of the friends she is raising the kids
- 46:56she was the one to bear and obviously birth the
- 46:59children and work out in the fields while she
- 47:02was pregnant and she was present during the the
- 47:05raid where she found the jewels that brought
- 47:08her family out of poverty and gave them back
- 47:11their farm and this is kind of one of those too
- 47:14little too late elements from wang where you
- 47:18know he's kind of always taken a back seat as
- 47:21as a caregiver role and and just kind of like
- 47:25an element of the family and now he's stepped
- 47:30up he's done his part during this locust invasion
- 47:32he's given up his uh second marriage his infatuation
- 47:37with lotus and he's there to be available to
- 47:41his family and to his wife. But now she's dying.
- 47:44And it's too little too late. Ultimately, though,
- 47:49when she does pass, you have this final piece
- 47:53where he goes out onto the farm and approaches
- 47:58a peach tree. And this is the tree that has grown
- 48:02from the pit that Wang planted, or O -Lan planted,
- 48:06during their first day back. when they were married.
- 48:11And he has this final line where he says, Olan,
- 48:14you are the earth. Yeah, I think this was the
- 48:19best possible ending for this movie, was him
- 48:23going to the tree that has grown from the pit
- 48:26that she planted and realizing what she has given
- 48:30him. She was the ultimate cultivator in their
- 48:33relationship. And it really was like him kind
- 48:36of coming full circle. to the life that he lived
- 48:39on the farm, and then watching what has grown
- 48:41from it is literally what's behind him in the
- 48:44wedding, is the fruits of her labor, quite literally.
- 48:48And I thought this was the perfect ending for
- 48:50this movie. I thought it was really well written.
- 48:53Do you know if this was adapted from anything?
- 48:56I didn't find anything in my research. I think
- 48:58there was a Broadway play is what it was. Okay,
- 49:00got it. Oh, I'm so sorry. I lied. You have it?
- 49:03Yeah. It's based on a novel by Pearl S. Buck.
- 49:06There you go. So that makes a little bit more
- 49:08sense. It did feel very literary, right? Yeah.
- 49:11It felt very much like a novel. Yeah. So I was
- 49:14going to commend the screenplay writers. Oh,
- 49:16yeah. There you go. So ultimately, a movie that's
- 49:20kind of, excuse this term, plagued by some controversy.
- 49:25Sure. Right? That's very easy to look at now.
- 49:27At the time, not controversy. At the time, we
- 49:31were seeing this happen more often. This was
- 49:33a pretty successful movie. For MGM. Obviously
- 49:36did well for Paul Muni. When it comes to Louise
- 49:39Rainier. Yeah. What was the result of her nomination?
- 49:44She did take home the Best Actress award for
- 49:48this. And I feel like if you're going to award
- 49:49any kind of acting in this movie, it has to be
- 49:53Louise Rainier. This is her movie. This is her
- 49:56story. Olan is the, she's the hero in this movie.
- 50:02Yeah, I would say driving force. Yeah. I think
- 50:05that that's what I like so much about this movie.
- 50:08Obviously, like you said, it has its controversies
- 50:11with the casting choices, with some of the stereotypes
- 50:14in the culture even that I have said I am unfamiliar
- 50:19with, whether or not they're damaging or not.
- 50:23But this is the story of a mother of a hardworking...
- 50:28just dedicated mother who will do everything
- 50:31and anything to her family, including sacrificing
- 50:33the love received from her husband so that he
- 50:38can continue to be happy in his life. Like she
- 50:40sacrifices everything and she is always the one
- 50:44to step up and do what is difficult. And when
- 50:46I say difficult, I mean the hardest thing a mother
- 50:48can do and should never have to do. So like this
- 50:52is the story of Olan. And that's why I'm so curious
- 50:56if this will ever receive, Another adaptation
- 51:00in the future, but done by a Chinese director
- 51:04and Chinese stars. Because I think it's a great
- 51:07story. It is. But I also think that the time
- 51:11has kind of passed for something like this to
- 51:13happen. Not to adapt this movie, but to adapt
- 51:16it the way that I see it. This to me feels like
- 51:19a... William Wyler, Cecil B. DeMille, like this
- 51:23has to be like an epic of like the 1950s. And
- 51:26that's how I would have wanted to see Good Earth,
- 51:29because I would have wanted to see the same kind
- 51:31of care taken in, or sorry, care given into the
- 51:35riot scene, like in the palace. I'd want to see
- 51:39like hundreds and hundreds of background actors
- 51:41flooding the scene. And I just don't see that
- 51:44happening these days with a like authentically
- 51:47Asian cast. I don't know. I would love to. Don't
- 51:51get me wrong. But I think realistically, I don't
- 51:53see that happening. Even if a director in China
- 51:56were to decide to do this, like a true international
- 51:58film. Oh, oh, oh. Yeah. I'm not looking for anything
- 52:02here in Hollywood. Give me someone who is capable
- 52:06of telling the story properly. I would love to
- 52:08see it. Hey, what's up? You know what's funny?
- 52:12The cat probably was saying the same thing. I'd
- 52:13love to see it. I would love to see a... a full
- 52:17scale production of this done. And I didn't even
- 52:20think about it being done solely like within
- 52:22like the, the Chinese studio. So that's a great
- 52:25call. Like that is probably something that could
- 52:28happen. I'd love to see it because I do think
- 52:30that this story is at its core, very relatable.
- 52:34I also just love kind of like taking a a step
- 52:37back and looking at like farming life. And that's
- 52:39what a good bit of this is. Yeah. I think it
- 52:42gets a little melodramatic at times with the
- 52:44Lotus aspect. And it's hard to kind of like find
- 52:47the decisions that Wayne makes redeemable, but
- 52:51that, but the final sequence of the locust attack
- 52:54makes things so much more exciting. And I think
- 52:58if you cut out that part with Lotus and everything,
- 53:00cause that makes it again, it's very. of him
- 53:04walking in and the intention is that his son
- 53:07has been sleeping with his second wife. Yeah.
- 53:10There's a difficult aspect to that. Again, if
- 53:13that's true to culture during the time period,
- 53:17then leave it in there because I think it just
- 53:19adds another element of Olan having to deal with
- 53:23all of these crazy scenarios going on in her
- 53:25life. Totally. And it just makes her stronger
- 53:28and stronger as a character. Yeah, I think that's
- 53:31right. I would love to see it. I would just obviously
- 53:33love to see a Chinese production behind it. Yeah.
- 53:38Yeah, totally. So let's get into ratings then.
- 53:41I think I'm about to get some angry emails, possibly,
- 53:46based on this one. Well, you know what? We'll
- 53:47see, won't we? We'll see. Why don't you lead?
- 53:51Or do you want me to lead? Let's have you lead.
- 53:54Uh -oh. I'm not going to scroll down, because
- 53:56if I scroll down, I'll see your rating. I want
- 53:57to hear it in real time. Okay. I have this listed
- 54:00at two stars. Two stars. This was not for me.
- 54:03Again, I do recognize it. It's probably a little
- 54:06bit higher, maybe two and a half. It is real
- 54:09tough for me to look past what has been done
- 54:12here. Now, you said it expertly at the top of
- 54:15the episode. This was what they were doing at
- 54:17the time. And what we have to do is rate the
- 54:20movie on its own merits. And the first thing
- 54:23I will call out is when I see any kind of stereotypes
- 54:25being played, any kind of harmful depictions
- 54:29done on these people. And that's not really done
- 54:32here. There's not a lot of that at all. So accents,
- 54:36depictions of their character, nothing negative
- 54:40to that. So I commend the movie for that. Where
- 54:43I think it frustrates me is seeing the hundreds
- 54:46and hundreds of extras, background workers that
- 54:49are used that are of Asian descent. Right. And
- 54:53that tells me this can be done. We just decided
- 54:56that for the movie to make as much money as possible,
- 54:59we can't have these leads being in that role.
- 55:03And I'm sorry, we can't have these individuals
- 55:05playing the leads. We need Paul Muni, Louis Rainier
- 55:08and sorry, Louis Rainier and Walter Connolly.
- 55:12Right. To play them. And that. sits weird with
- 55:15me i think this movie has a real pace issue when
- 55:18it comes to that third act but it does i mean
- 55:21i think the lasting impact of this movie will
- 55:23be that uh sequence with the locusts sure the
- 55:26cinematography specifically of the movie that
- 55:29carries into that sequence so i i agree with
- 55:32you the cinematography is the thing that i think
- 55:34stands out the most to me in this but um maybe
- 55:36i'm closer to two and a half stars but two is
- 55:38my initial thought gotcha um i think that's totally
- 55:42fair and respect Respectable. Carl Frunn's cinematography
- 55:46is so incredible in this. Very good. That the
- 55:49locust blew me away the way that was presented.
- 55:52You know what else did? The wind. Yeah, that
- 55:55helped. That did help. But like the droning sound
- 55:57as they come over the hill too. I was just like,
- 56:00wow. This sound design was actually really effective
- 56:02too. Yeah, I'm surprised. But maybe because it
- 56:05was such a small portion of the movie. That being
- 56:08said, I think that this movie is beautiful. It's
- 56:11probably... Maybe top 15 most beautifully shot
- 56:16movies that we've covered. Okay. I think the
- 56:18acting is solid. I think that Louise Rainier
- 56:21deserved the win from what I can tell. We'll
- 56:25see, you know, when we watch more of these movies.
- 56:28But she really is incredible in this movie. All
- 56:31that being said, I gave this three and a half
- 56:33stars. Okay. I actually really like this. That's
- 56:35exactly what I gave Captain's Courageous. Yes.
- 56:38So I, you know. I feel like there's some controversy
- 56:41there, but this movie worked for me. There's
- 56:45nothing wrong with it working for you. Yeah.
- 56:47I think what is wrong, if you're like, I think
- 56:49Paul Muni should have been Wang Lung, that's
- 56:52a little controversial. Right. But no, I think
- 56:55that's a totally respectable rating. I see the
- 56:58vision for you on that. I will say with Louise
- 57:01Rainier, I don't know if she was just tired of
- 57:03filming, but she sold tired so well. And, you
- 57:07know, Obviously, the makeup itself is controversial
- 57:11because you do have it applied to change the
- 57:13race of these actors. Yes, hair especially. But
- 57:16Louise Rainier, they do an incredible job of
- 57:19aging her as the movie goes on. Specifically,
- 57:22like around her eyes, there's a lot of bags that
- 57:24are applied to sell that, you know, tired, worn
- 57:27out feeling. Yeah, it's pretty impressive, that
- 57:31part of the makeup. Yeah, this is kind of like
- 57:34an alternate universe thing where it's like,
- 57:36man, this could have been great. This could have
- 57:39been fantastic. One of the films that we talk
- 57:41about the most with the Oscars, if done in a
- 57:44different universe. And that's just the way I
- 57:46see it. It's also whenever you look at movies
- 57:48like this, it is going to be kind of up to viewer
- 57:52discretion of how you feel about something like
- 57:55this. Can you get past that? Is it a moral thing
- 57:57that you can look past? Is there a world where
- 58:00this movie is great despite that truth? I think
- 58:03that's an interesting conversation. I don't think
- 58:05there's a right or a wrong. Let me take that
- 58:08back. I don't think that there's a right or a
- 58:10wrong opinion to be had on a movie just because
- 58:13of that. I think that you can feel a certain
- 58:15way and that's totally justified. You can also
- 58:18feel that way about the movie itself and the
- 58:20emotion that it makes you feel. And I think that's
- 58:22totally justified too. So it's an interesting
- 58:25thing. And I think it's a difficult conversation
- 58:28for us to have on a pod like this because you
- 58:30and I are both very progressive. You and I are
- 58:33both very much a believer that everyone should
- 58:35have the same rights as everyone else. And that's
- 58:37not always, especially on historical pod, going
- 58:40to be the case that we've seen here. Right. So
- 58:42it's a difficult time. But I think it was a movie
- 58:46that had some really lasting impact. And I'm
- 58:49excited to see where that takes it. I agree.
- 58:52Totally agree, and I'm looking forward to the
- 58:54international film category being introduced
- 58:57eventually so that we see these stories told
- 58:59by the individuals who I think have a better
- 59:02understanding of how to tell these stories. Right,
- 59:06and let me wrap this up the only way that I know
- 59:09how. We are men who have beards. You have a beard
- 59:12right now. Yeah. Let me ask you this. At what
- 59:15point, and I'm kind of pointing at Walter Connolly
- 59:17in this movie, at what point do you think you
- 59:20have to shave? Probably today. It's getting pretty
- 59:24long. Yours is pretty close -knit. It's on your
- 59:27face. It's not hanging off too much. Walter Connelly
- 59:29in this is sporting a, I might be exaggerating
- 59:32a little bit, three -foot beard that can't consist
- 59:35of more than 20 hairs. It's a little Fu Manchu.
- 59:39It's pretty bad. Yeah. It's pretty bad. It's
- 59:42pretty rough. And I think if you're going to
- 59:43take any kind of racial context in this movie
- 59:47and condemn it for that, you could do it to the
- 59:49beard. Yeah, I agree with that. So going into
- 59:52our double features to wrap this up. Yes. I went
- 59:55with a story of a mother who is willing to step
- 59:59up and do everything in her power to protect
- 1:00:01her family. And I went with the John Krasinski
- 1:00:04film, A Quiet Place. Damn it, that's good. Damn.
- 1:00:10Great pick. Yeah. And it takes place on a farm.
- 1:00:13It does. It does. Yeah. And monsters attack the
- 1:00:16farm. Do you think it was a farm before? Or did
- 1:00:18they make it a farm because of? There's no way
- 1:00:21they went out there and they planted all of that
- 1:00:22corn while monsters were attacking. It had to
- 1:00:26have been. It was a farm before. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:00:28Okay. You're right. And then they just drive
- 1:00:30into town. Okay. That's what it is. Well, they
- 1:00:32walk into town. Yep. I meant before. I'm thinking
- 1:00:36of quite always day one. Yeah. Yeah. I got you.
- 1:00:39When they like would drive in it. It doesn't
- 1:00:40matter. I don't even know if that was their farm
- 1:00:42though. I think they may have. It wasn't day
- 1:00:44one. It was part two. Part two is the sequence
- 1:00:46where she's driving backwards in the car and
- 1:00:48everything. Because it showed the beginning of
- 1:00:50the invasion. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I see what
- 1:00:53you're saying. Any other thoughts? I think that
- 1:00:57franchise is great. I agree. I love it. I thought
- 1:01:00day one was surprisingly heartfelt. Yeah. I think
- 1:01:04that's my least favorite of the franchise, but
- 1:01:06I do still enjoy it quite a bit. It's told outside
- 1:01:08of the story of A Quiet Place, so that makes
- 1:01:10sense. I hope that they expand more on that franchise.
- 1:01:12they are filming uh part three right now oh i
- 1:01:15love that yeah wonderful uh rise of krasinski
- 1:01:17i think is what it's called oh finally um that's
- 1:01:23so dumb okay my double feature uh i went a little
- 1:01:26unconventional i originally wanted to do minari
- 1:01:29because i thought that that was a movie that
- 1:01:30did pay respects to the culture while also talking
- 1:01:33about a family of uh farm uh a family with farm
- 1:01:37history and like raised on a farm. Yeah. And
- 1:01:40also the difficulty of like traveling and what
- 1:01:42you need to do to keep the family and the business
- 1:01:44alive. With that said, I wanted to also acknowledge
- 1:01:49the idea of what you can do with that farm. And
- 1:01:52I decided to pick a movie in which they grew
- 1:01:55so much corn that they actually made back the
- 1:01:58production, the cost of production for their
- 1:02:01movie by selling the corn that they grew. In
- 1:02:04the movie. And this is Christopher Nolan's 2014
- 1:02:07Interstellar. This is a movie that is also about
- 1:02:12farmers and their children and the lengths that
- 1:02:15they'll go to to save them. A bit different.
- 1:02:18But I thought that the idea of like the full
- 1:02:21scale of farming and what you can do with that
- 1:02:23was masterfully done on Nolan's part. And I wanted
- 1:02:27to kind of pay a little tribute to that without
- 1:02:29being too cheeky. So Interstellar is my pick.
- 1:02:32Very cool. Very cool. Love that a majority of
- 1:02:36that movie does not take place on the good earth.
- 1:02:39But, boy, is it about the good earth. Yeah. I
- 1:02:41actually have no idea. I've never seen that movie.
- 1:02:43Oh, well, then you have no idea that it doesn't
- 1:02:45take place on earth. No, I just imagine that
- 1:02:48something called Interstellar. At the very least,
- 1:02:50maybe he's looking at the good earth. But I guess
- 1:02:53we'll see. It is about farmers. Perfect. And
- 1:02:57how love is quantifiable. Oh, just like Space
- 1:03:00Time Continuum. We're not sponsored. I can't
- 1:03:03do it again. But yes, we are farmers. I heard
- 1:03:06that, though. J .K. Simmons approved. But yes,
- 1:03:08that is The Good Earth. Let us know what you
- 1:03:10thought of the movie. Shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 1:03:13at gmail .com. And if you would like to support
- 1:03:17the podcast, you can check out patreon .com slash
- 1:03:19outaopodcast. Early episodes, bonus episodes,
- 1:03:24Horror of the Overlooked, our side podcast where
- 1:03:27we talk about the movies, the horror movies that
- 1:03:29were missed. Nope. Overlooked. Bye. The Academy
- 1:03:33Awards. And, yeah, next episode we will be talking
- 1:03:38about the life of Emil Zola. I have no idea what
- 1:03:42that movie is about. What if it's an MCU prequel?
- 1:03:46Oh, you think so? About Zola. That would be cool.
- 1:03:48I don't think his name was Emil. I don't think
- 1:03:50so either. Nor do I think it's going to be Toby
- 1:03:53Jones? Toby Jones. Toby Jones. Oh, that guy.
- 1:03:58Yeah. I was thinking of you. Man, if he has any
- 1:04:00legacy in Hollywood, it's going to be, oh, that
- 1:04:02guy. Yeah, yeah. But yes, stay tuned for that
- 1:04:06episode. I think that's going to wrap us up here.
- 1:04:09As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 1:04:12you at the movies.