Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Buffett’s ‘Gravity Rule’: How Rising Rates Crash (or Lift) Your Portfolio 🚀📉
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive. Today, we're tackling something
- 0:02Warren Buffett himself apparently called the most
- 0:05important question in the world. Sounds pretty significant.
- 0:08Right. We're talking about interest
- 0:09rates. And Buffett's idea, which sounds
- 0:12simple but is, well, profound, is that they're the key factor
- 0:15in finance. Our mission really is to dig
- 0:18into why he uses that famous analogy, comparing interest
- 0:21rates to gravity. How do they actually pull on
- 0:24asset prices? We've given some great articles,
- 0:27some research, looking at his thinking and, you know, market
- 0:30history. Just trying to get a clearer
- 0:31picture for you. Yeah.
- 0:32OK, let's unpack this. Yeah, and it's fascinating
- 0:34because, like you said, it sounds almost too simple, but
- 0:37the impact is just huge. What's really interesting here
- 0:40is how deep this goes. It's not just market noise.
- 0:42It affects, well, every layer of the financial system.
- 0:46We'll go beyond the metaphor today.
- 0:47We'll look at the actual mechanics, what it means for
- 0:49real companies, the big economic forces.
- 0:52It's all tied together. OK, so that core question, why
- 0:55gravity? Buffett said.
- 0:57Interest rates are to asset prices like gravity is to the
- 1:00Apple. Love that image.
- 1:02They power everything in the economic universe.
- 1:05It really sticks with you. And he wasn't kidding.
- 1:07Remember in 2017, he said if he had to predict the market,
- 1:09forget GDP, forget elections. He just asked about interest
- 1:12rates over the next 20 years. Wow, that's a strong statement,
- 1:15especially for him. Exactly and all comes down to
- 1:18this one core idea, this formula.
- 1:20Discounted cash flow DCF. Precisely.
- 1:24DCF isn't just, you know, some academic exercise for Buffett,
- 1:27it's the absolute foundation for how he figures out what anything
- 1:30is worth. His view is the value is just
- 1:32all the cash you're going to get out between now and Judgement
- 1:34Day discounted back, Simple as that.
- 1:36In theory. OK, so think of the DCF formula,
- 1:38the cash flows, the CF on top. Those are like the future apples
- 1:41the business gives you. But the discount rate that R on
- 1:44the bottom, that's the gravity. The R OK, so unpack that.
- 1:47Why is the R the gravity? What gives it that pull?
- 1:49Well, R due isn't just pulled out of thin air, it's the
- 1:51minimum return you need to justify taking a risk.
- 1:54And it all starts with the risk free rate of return, Arnie,
- 1:58Usually we look at like long term U.S.
- 1:59Treasury bonds, the 10 year, 30 year yield, because you know,
- 2:03the US government isn't likely to default.
- 2:05That's your baseline. Right, the safest bet out there.
- 2:07Exactly. So every other investment,
- 2:09whether it's a company bond or a stock has to promise a return
- 2:12higher than that risk free rate. Otherwise why take the extra
- 2:15risk? So when that fundamental risk
- 2:17free rate moves even a little bit, it sends ripples through
- 2:20everything. It changes how you calculate the
- 2:22cost of equity. The whole valuation picture
- 2:24shifts. OK, that clicks.
- 2:26So it's not just an idea, it's literally in the math.
- 2:29Or is in the denominator, the bottom part of the fraction.
- 2:32So if R gets bigger, the final number has to get smaller.
- 2:34It just mathematically shrinks the present value.
- 2:36Inescapably. Buffett even said every time the
- 2:39risk free rate moves by one basis point, the value of every
- 2:44investment in the country changes just like that.
- 2:46It's that sensitive. And the timing matters too,
- 2:49right? That compounding effect cash you
- 2:51expect to get way out in the future gets hit much harder by
- 2:55higher rates today. Absolutely, because it's being
- 2:57discounted for more years. Which explains why those high
- 3:00flying tech stocks, the ones where all the profit is
- 3:02supposedly coming, you know, 1020 years down the road, why
- 3:05they're so incredibly jumpy when rates change.
- 3:07Exactly. To make it really concrete,
- 3:09imagine a hypothetical company, let's call it Steady Eddie Inc
- 3:13Super reliable, throws off $100 in free cash flow every year,
- 3:17year after year. OK, now if you value Steady
- 3:19Eddie using say a 4% discount rate, maybe reflecting lower
- 3:23interest rates, it's value might work out to around $811.00.
- 3:27But what if rates rise and that discount rate jumps to 8%, Just
- 3:31a four percentage point increase.
- 3:32Suddenly, the value of that exact same $100 annual cash flow
- 3:35stream drops to about $671. Wow, that's a big hit.
- 3:38Over 17% gone. Over 17% just from that change
- 3:43in gravity, and you see the compounding effect.
- 3:45Clearly the hit to the value of year 10's cash flow is nearly
- 3:48six times bigger than the hit to year one's cash flow.
- 3:51It's not a metaphor anymore. That table, that calculation is
- 3:55the math proof of financial gravity.
- 3:57OK, that example really drives it home.
- 3:59The mechanics are clear, yeah, but let's shift gears a bit.
- 4:01Move from the models to, you know, the street level.
- 4:04Here's where it gets really interesting how this gravity
- 4:07actually effects real businesses day-to-day operations.
- 4:11Yeah, the ripple effect is massive.
- 4:13First off, it hits a company's cost of capital straight up.
- 4:16If they have loans with variable rates, boom.
- 4:18Interest payments go up immediately when rates rise.
- 4:20If they need new debt for anything, expansion,
- 4:22refinancing, it's just more expensive.
- 4:24And that pushes them to rethink their capital structure when
- 4:27rates are low. Companies love debt.
- 4:29It's cheap. When rates are high, suddenly
- 4:31issuing stock or maybe just not expanding looks more appealing.
- 4:35OK, so borrowing costs. What else?
- 4:37Big one, investment decisions. Every company has a hurdle rate
- 4:41rate, the minimum return a new project has to promise before
- 4:44they'll do it. That hurdle rate is tied to
- 4:46their overall cost of capital. Their WACC rates go up, WACC
- 4:51goes up, hurdle rate goes up. So projects that looked good
- 4:53yesterday might suddenly not make the cut today.
- 4:56You see delays, cancellations, new factories, tech upgrades,
- 4:59acquisitions, even hiring can slow down.
- 5:02Wow. And then there's the customer
- 5:03side too, I imagine. Exactly.
- 5:04It's like a double squeeze on profits.
- 5:06You've got the cost squeeze, higher interest payments, plus
- 5:09your suppliers are probably paying more too, and they pass
- 5:12that on, right? And then you have the demand
- 5:14squeeze. Higher rates mean bigger
- 5:16mortgage payments for homeowners, higher car loan
- 5:19rates, credit card interest goes up.
- 5:21Yeah, people just have less money leftover to spend, so
- 5:23sales can take a hit too. Man, that sounds tough for most
- 5:26companies. But then you hear about the
- 5:27Berkshire Hathaway anomaly. Buffett's own company,
- 5:30Berkshire, actually likes rising rates.
- 5:32How does that work? Yeah, it's pretty unique.
- 5:34It mostly comes down to their massive insurance operations and
- 5:37the float they generate. Yeah, the premiums they collect
- 5:40upfront but don't have to pay out as claims immediately.
- 5:42They get to invest that money in the meantime.
- 5:44And Buffett being Buffet, mostly puts that float plus Berkshire's
- 5:48huge cash pile into very safe short term stuff like Treasury
- 5:51bills. So when rates were near 0, that
- 5:55huge pile of money earned next to nothing.
- 5:58But as rates climb, Buffett himself has said, you know, a
- 6:01return to something like 5% rates could mean billions in
- 6:05extra pre tax earnings for Berkshire just from that cash.
- 6:09So it's a direct benefit for them, unlike most others.
- 6:11Right. And it actually highlights
- 6:13something deeper. Interest rates act as the sort
- 6:15of quality filter for the whole market.
- 6:17A quality filter? How so?
- 6:19Well, think about it. When money is super cheap, like
- 6:21in those long low rate periods, even really weak companies,
- 6:24maybe unprofitable ones, highly speculative ones, people call
- 6:27them zombie companies. They can and still borrow money
- 6:29and survive. And investors, because they
- 6:31can't get any return from safe bonds, they get desperate for
- 6:34yield and end up taking more risk, maybe funding these weaker
- 6:37players. Right chasing returns.
- 6:38But when rates go up, debt becomes a real burden.
- 6:42Suddenly only the truly strong companies, the wonderful
- 6:45companies Buffett talks about with great balance sheets, low
- 6:48debt, steady cash flow, they can handle it.
- 6:50They can often fund themselves internally.
- 6:52The high leverage, weaker companies, they struggle, maybe
- 6:55go bankrupt. So higher rates basically shake
- 6:58out the players and reward companies that were financially
- 7:01disciplined all along. Interesting.
- 7:03OK, let's zoom out even more now.
- 7:05The whole economy. How do interest rates steer the
- 7:08ship macroeconomically? Feels like the main tool central
- 7:11banks use. Oh, absolutely.
- 7:12It's the primary lever certainly for the Federal Reserve here in
- 7:15the US They use interest rates to manage their dual mandate,
- 7:18which is stable prices, basically keeping inflation
- 7:20under control and maximum employment.
- 7:22Those are their two big goals. So if they want to stimulate the
- 7:24economy, maybe boost employment, they lower rates, makes
- 7:27borrowing keeper, encourages spending and investment.
- 7:29Like hitting the gas pedal. Exactly, and if inflation is
- 7:32getting too high, they need to cool things down so they raise
- 7:34rates. Makes borrowing expensive, slows
- 7:36spending, dampens demand. That's what we saw starting in
- 7:392022 with those aggressive hikes.
- 7:41Right. And that connects directly to
- 7:42GDP, then the overall economy. Directly because rates affect
- 7:45everything from whether someone buys a house or a car to whether
- 7:48a company builds that new factory or hires more people.
- 7:51All that spending and investment adds up to GDP.
- 7:54And remember, Buffett's view is that corporate profits in
- 7:57aggregate just can't sustainably grow faster than the overall
- 8:00economy. So by influencing GDP rates,
- 8:03kind of set the speed limit for overall profit growth too.
- 8:05And what about inflation itself? We hear so much about that.
- 8:08How do rates fit in? They're totally intertwined.
- 8:11Raising rates is the Fed's main weapon against inflation, trying
- 8:14to cool demand. On the flip side, keeping rates
- 8:17too low for too long can arguably fuel inflation by
- 8:19making money too easy for investors.
- 8:22The key thing is the difference between the nominal rate, the
- 8:25headline number, and the real rate, which is the nominal rate
- 8:27minus inflation. What you actually make after
- 8:30inflation eats away at it. Precisely that real rate tells
- 8:34you about your true purchasing power.
- 8:36Buffett always understood how damaging inflation is, so his
- 8:38focus on rates is also about understanding the real return
- 8:42you can get from the safest assets, which sets the bar for
- 8:44everything else. OK.
- 8:45So if the risk free rate sets the bar, what does this mean for
- 8:51how investors actually behave? You mentioned it's kind of like
- 8:54the market's price of risk. That's a great way to put it.
- 8:56The risk free rate is what you get for taking, well, zero risk.
- 8:59So when that rate is basically 0 like it was for a long time,
- 9:03there is almost no penalty, no opportunity cost for taking on
- 9:06huge amounts of risk. Yeah, you weren't giving up much
- 9:08by not being in bonds. Exactly.
- 9:10So it pushes investors out on the risk curve into stocks, into
- 9:13junk bonds, maybe crypto, whatever, just desperately
- 9:16searching for any kind of return.
- 9:17And that can inflate bubbles. Buffett's warned about this
- 9:19repeatedly. But the opposite happens when
- 9:21rates are high. Right.
- 9:22If you can get say, 5% risk free from a Treasury bond, suddenly
- 9:26safety looks pretty good. Investors then look at the stock
- 9:29market and say, OK, if I can get 5% guaranteed, I need a much
- 9:33higher potential return from stocks to make that extra risk
- 9:36worthwhile. So they demand more, which
- 9:38pushes stock prices down. Or at least puts pressure on
- 9:40them. Yeah.
- 9:41So essentially, the level of interest rates dictates the
- 9:43market's general mood is at risk on.
- 9:46Let's speculate or risk off. Let's play it safe.
- 9:48It governs where the money flows.
- 9:50OK, this makes sense conceptually, but you mentioned
- 9:52Buffett laid out historical proof.
- 9:54That 1999 Fortune article sounds key.
- 9:56He looked at 2 specific periods. He did.
- 9:58It's a classic piece. He analyzed 2 back-to-back 17
- 10:02year periods that were almost perfectly symmetrical in length,
- 10:04but wildly different in outcome. The first period, let's call it
- 10:07the Great Stagnation, ran from 1964 to 1981.
- 10:11Seventeen years. Get this.
- 10:13Over that time, the US economy, measured by GNP grew an
- 10:16incredible 373%. Almost quintupled.
- 10:19Wow. So stocks must have soared,
- 10:20right? Think but the Dow Jones
- 10:23Industrial Average. It basically went nowhere.
- 10:24Started at 874, ended at 87517 years for a 0.0% annualized
- 10:30return. Flat.
- 10:31That's insane. And economy quintuple stocks do
- 10:33nothing. How?
- 10:34Buffett's explanation? Gravity.
- 10:36Specifically the tripling of the gravitational pull of interest
- 10:39rates. Remember, this was the era
- 10:41ending with Paul Volcker at the Fed jacking rates up to kill
- 10:43inflation. Long term bond yields went from
- 10:45around 4% / 15%. That massive increase in the
- 10:49discount rate just crushed asset value.
- 10:51Plus, he noted, corporate profits as a slice of the whole
- 10:54economic pie were also relatively low then.
- 10:56So booming economy yes, but sky high rates kept stock valuations
- 11:01completely grounded. OK, so that's period one.
- 11:03Then the mirror image happened right after.
- 11:04Exactly the next 17 years, the bull market bonanza from 1982 to
- 11:081999. Now during this period, GNP
- 11:11growth was actually slower. It less than tripled, not as
- 11:13impressive as the first period. Economically, the market
- 11:15exploded. The Dow went from that same 875
- 11:18starting point to over 9181, more than a tenfold increase.
- 11:22That's a 15.3% return compounded annually.
- 11:25So slower economy but massively better stock returns.
- 11:29What was the difference? Gravity again, but working the
- 11:32other way. Interest rates started their
- 11:34long historic decline from that 15% peak down to around 6% by
- 11:38the end of 99. The gravitational pull lessened
- 11:40dramatically. That combined with corporate
- 11:43profits climbing back up as a share of GDP just lit a fire
- 11:47under the market. And then you had that
- 11:48psychological element he mentioned.
- 11:50The I can't miss the party feeling pushing things even
- 11:52higher. The contrast between those 217
- 11:55year blocks is just stark. It's the historical proof.
- 11:58So the truly fascinating thing here?
- 12:00The deeper truth maybe is that what really drives your long
- 12:03term investment returns isn't always just how much the economy
- 12:06grows. It's something else.
- 12:07That's the punchline. The primary driver over long
- 12:10periods isn't necessarily fundamental growth.
- 12:12It's the change in valuation. It's the price the multiple
- 12:15investors are willing to pay for $1.00 of earnings.
- 12:17And that multiple is fundamentally anchored to
- 12:19interest rates, right? So, period 1, Great economy, but
- 12:24rates soared. Valuation multiples collapsed. 0
- 12:27Return for stock investors. Period two OK economy, but rates
- 12:31plunged, valuation multiples expanded massively.
- 12:34Spectacular returns. So the lesson is, a great
- 12:37economy doesn't automatically mean great stock returns, and a
- 12:40SOSO economy doesn't mean bad returns either.
- 12:42Exactly. Over the long haul, that
- 12:44gravitational pull of interest rates, how it changes the
- 12:47valuation people put on things, is often a more powerful force
- 12:50for your investment results than the underlying economic growth
- 12:53itself. That's a really powerful take
- 12:55away. OK, but you know, life isn't
- 12:57always that neat. The long term is clear, but
- 12:59short term things get messy. What about times when rates go
- 13:02up but stocks also go up? Or vice versa when that simple
- 13:05inverse relationship seems to breakdown.
- 13:07Yeah, that's a crucial point. The short term is definitely
- 13:09noisier and the the key thing there is why rates are changing.
- 13:12The context matters hugely. You can see rising rates and
- 13:14rising stocks happening together.
- 13:16Typically, that's when rates are going up because the economy is
- 13:18strong and the market expects even better earnings ahead.
- 13:22Optimism outweighs the higher discount rate, maybe.
- 13:24For a while, potentially higher expected profits, the numerator
- 13:28in the DCF can sometimes overpower the higher discount
- 13:31rate in the denominator. We saw phases like that in the
- 13:3350s and 60s. OK.
- 13:34But the opposite scenario is more common lately.
- 13:37It often feels that way. You usually see rising rates and
- 13:40falling stocks when rates are being hiked specifically to
- 13:42fight high inflation, like the Fed's been doing, or if there
- 13:45are worries about government debt or fiscal stability.
- 13:48That's like a double whammy for stocks.
- 13:51The discount rate goes up and people start worrying that the
- 13:53rate hikes themselves will slow the economy, so future earnings
- 13:56expectations might fall too. Got it.
- 13:59And the timing of these cycles is tricky too, like the first
- 14:02rate hike doesn't instantly kill the market.
- 14:04Not necessarily, no. History suggests it's not an
- 14:06automatic trigger for a bear market or recession.
- 14:08One study, I think from Northwestern Mutual looked at
- 14:11the last five rate hike cycles and found it took on average
- 14:14over 4 years from the first hike to the start of a recession.
- 14:17Four years. Yeah, the market can often climb
- 14:20for quite a while after the hikes begin.
- 14:22But conversely, rate cuts aren't always bullish either.
- 14:25Sometimes they're a sign of panic.
- 14:26Like the Fed cutting rates because things are already bad.
- 14:28Exactly. Think about the cuts during the
- 14:312001.com crash or the 2008 financial crisis.
- 14:35The Fed was easing policy aggressively, but markets were
- 14:38still falling hard because earnings were collapsing and
- 14:40fear was rampant. The lower discount rate couldn't
- 14:43overcome the sheer economic damage.
- 14:45That context is everything. And this ties into those
- 14:48valuation multiples like the price to earnings ratio, the PE.
- 14:51Absolutely. There's generally a strong
- 14:53inverse link. Lower rates tend to justify
- 14:56higher PE ratios. Why?
- 14:582 main reasons. One, mathematically, a lower
- 15:01discount rate makes future earnings worth more today.
- 15:03Two, practically, if bonds are paying next to nothing, they're
- 15:06not much competition for stocks. Investors are willing to pay
- 15:09more for potential stock growth when the safe alternative offers
- 15:12so little. Historically, P ES tend to be
- 15:15higher when Treasury yields are low.
- 15:16Which brings us back to that psychological thing Buffett
- 15:18mentioned. The I can't miss the party
- 15:20factor. What happens in those really
- 15:23long bull markets, often fueled by low rates, is that investors
- 15:26can kind of lose their minds a bit.
- 15:29They forget fundamentals and just chase whatever's going up.
- 15:31Momentum takes over and you end up with PE multiples that, as
- 15:35Buffett said, are completely detached from any reasonable
- 15:38valuation framework. Bubbles basically so.
- 15:41Pulling it all together, it's not just the level of rates, but
- 15:43the speed and the reason they're changing that hits the market
- 15:47short term. That seems to be the more
- 15:48nuanced view, yeah. A slow, predictable series of
- 15:51small hikes when the economy's strong, the market might digest
- 15:54that OK. A sudden, unexpected monster
- 15:56hike that can cause panic. Same with cuts.
- 15:58A small cut to fine tune a decent economy might be seen as
- 16:01positive. Big emergency cuts when things
- 16:04are clearly falling apart? That's usually bearish because
- 16:06it confirms everyone's worst fears.
- 16:08You really need the whole story. OK, this has been incredibly
- 16:11insightful, a real deep dive into this gravity concept.
- 16:14So to wrap this up for everyone listening, the big take away
- 16:18from Buffett isn't really about trying to predict rate moves or
- 16:21time the market right. It's deeper than.
- 16:23That exactly. It's about understanding.
- 16:25Understanding this fundamental force that, as he says, powers
- 16:28everything. So for you, the listener, what
- 16:31are the practical ways this understanding helps?
- 16:33How can you use this in your own investing?
- 16:35I think there are three core benefits.
- 16:37First, it helped you calculate a reasonable intrinsic value.
- 16:40It anchors your discount rate thinking instead of just
- 16:43guessing, you start with the real world risk free rate.
- 16:47It helps you stay grounded and avoid overpaying, especially
- 16:49when markets get frothy. Makes sense What?
- 16:51Else second, it helps you assess relative attractiveness.
- 16:54That risk free rate is your baseline, your ultimate
- 16:57opportunity cost. You can look at a stock,
- 16:59estimate its potential return, and compare it directly to the
- 17:02guaranteed return you can get from a safe bond.
- 17:04Is the extra risk worth it? Rates tell you that.
- 17:06OK. Valuation and comparison.
- 17:08OK. And the third. 3rd, it helps you
- 17:10understand the operating environment for the businesses
- 17:12themselves. Are rising rates creating
- 17:15headwinds for companies you own or are looking at?
- 17:18Are falling rates providing A tailwind?
- 17:20It adds another layer to your analysis of the business itself.
- 17:23So even though rates go up and down, the core benefit way of
- 17:26thinking, finding great companies, pay fair prices, know
- 17:30what you own, demand a margin of safety, that stuff doesn't
- 17:33change. Not at all.
- 17:34Those principles are timeless. Understanding interest rates,
- 17:37understanding this purest expression of the opportunity
- 17:39cost of capital just gives you the essential framework, the
- 17:42context to apply those principles rationally and with
- 17:45discipline no matter what the market or the economy is doing.
- 17:48That's really the key to long term success, acting rationally
- 17:50within that framework. Fantastic summary, really.
- 17:53Powerful stuff. So here's a final thought for
- 17:55you to Mull over as you see interest rates.
- 17:58Move. Think about that.
- 17:59Quality filter idea? How might that continue to
- 18:02reshape different industries, maybe even the businesses you
- 18:04deal with everyday? What does that?
- 18:06Filtering imply. We really hope this deep dive
- 18:09give you a valuable new lens to view the financial.
- 18:11World through. Thanks so much for joining us
- 18:13today as we unpack Warren Buffett's law of financial
- 18:15gravity. Definitely take some time to
- 18:17reflect on these ideas and how they connect to what you see
- 18:19happening out there. Until next time on the Deep
- 18:21Dive.