Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage the Employee Who Always Says I Forgot
Transcript
- Lucas: So you're in your weekly one-on-one with a direct report, and you ask about a deliverable that was due Tuesday. They say, 'Oh, I forgot. I'll get it to you by tomorrow.' And you think, okay, it happens. But then it happens again next week. And the week after that. Luna: Right, that moment when 'I forgot' becomes a pattern. It's one of those phrases that can really test a manager's patience. Lucas: Exactly. And it's surprisingly common. A 2024 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that 38 percent of workers admit to forgetting at least one critical task per week. That adds up — they estimate it costs companies about 7 percent in lost productivity. Luna: Seven percent. That's huge. So what's really going on? Is it a memory problem, or are they just not prioritizing? Lucas: That's the first question a manager has to answer. And the honest answer is: it depends. Sometimes it's genuine overload — they have too many things on their plate and things fall through the cracks. Sometimes it's a lack of organizational systems. And sometimes, honestly, it's a sign that the employee isn't engaged enough to care about the outcome. Luna: So how do you tell the difference without jumping to conclusions? Lucas: You ask. But you don't just ask 'why did you forget?' — that puts them on the defensive. Instead, you talk about the process. Say something like: 'Let's look at how you track your tasks. What system are you using?' If they say 'I just try to remember,' you've found the problem. Luna: That is a huge red flag. Relying on memory alone for work tasks is a recipe for failure. Lucas: Right. So the fix starts with a system. And it doesn't have to be complicated. A simple to-do list, a shared project board, a daily check-in email — whatever works for them. But the manager shouldn't just dictate the system; they should co-create it with the employee. Luna: I talked to a team lead at a mid-size tech company who dealt with this. She had one developer who constantly forgot status update submissions. She introduced what she called the 'two-minute commitment loop'. Lucas: Two-minute commitment loop — I like that. What does it involve? Luna: At the end of every meeting, the developer had to verbally restate his action items and deadlines. Then he'd immediately put them in a shared tracker while she watched — took two minutes. After a month, missed deadlines dropped by half. Lucas: That's brilliant because it creates accountability in real time. And it's not micromanaging — it's just a quick habit that reinforces commitment. Luna: Exactly. And over time, the developer internalized it. He didn't need the loop anymore. He just started doing it automatically. Lucas: So the goal isn't to manage their memory forever — it's to build a muscle. But what about the employee who continues to 'forget' even after you've put systems in place? That's when you have to consider a different root cause. Luna: Yeah, like maybe the task isn't a priority to them, or they're avoiding it because it's unpleasant. Lucas: Right. And that's a conversation about motivation, not memory. You might need to ask: 'I notice this task keeps slipping. What's your sense of why that is?' Let them open up. Sometimes they'll admit they're overwhelmed, or they don't see the value, or they need more training. Luna: So the 'I forgot' can be a cover for something else. A symptom, not the disease. Lucas: Exactly. And as a manager, you have to diagnose before you prescribe. Because if you just apply a system to a motivation problem, it won't stick. Luna: That makes me think of a study I read — when employees feel their work is meaningful, they're 3.5 times more likely to follow through on tasks. So if someone keeps forgetting, maybe they don't see why it matters. Lucas: That's a great point. And you can reconnect them to the 'why.' Show them how their task fits into the bigger project, or how it affects a customer. Sometimes a reminder of purpose is more powerful than any checklist. Luna: Okay, but what if you've tried systems, you've talked about purpose, and the forgetting persists? When do you escalate? Lucas: That's when you move to a performance improvement plan. But you frame it as support, not punishment. Say, 'We've tried a few things, and I want to help you succeed. Let's set a 30-day plan with clear expectations and checkpoints.' And you monitor closely. Luna: And if they still can't meet those expectations, then you have a different conversation — about fit. Lucas: Right. But I want to emphasize that most people don't want to forget. They want to do good work. So assume good intent first. Luna: Absolutely. And if you've been following the show for a while, you know we always try to offer actionable advice. Speaking of which, if today's episode helped you think about how to handle a chronic forgetter on your team, it might be worth a coffee to you. Lucas: Yeah, honestly, we keep this show ad-free because of listener support. If you found value in our conversation, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that really keeps us going. Luna: And it helps us avoid those mid-roll ad reads you hear on other podcasts. So thank you to everyone who already has. Lucas: Now back to managing the forgetful employee. One last technique I want to share is the concept of 'accountability partners' within the team. Pairing someone who struggles with follow-through with a teammate who is organized can work wonders. Luna: That's a great low-touch solution. The buddy system for deadlines. Lucas: Exactly. And it builds team cohesion at the same time. So to wrap up: when an employee says 'I forgot,' don't assume the worst. Help them build a system, check for motivation, and escalate thoughtfully if needed. Your team will be more reliable, and your employee will learn skills they'll use for their whole career. Luna: And they'll thank you for it — eventually. That's it for this episode of Manager Mondays. We'll see you next week.