Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / What Should Be In Your Board Monthly Package According to NCUA
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:07I'm here today with Todd Miller, formerly of NCUA and of my team of
- 0:11experts that help credit unions.
- 0:13Todd, how are you doing today?
- 0:15Todd Miller: I'm doing well.
- 0:15It's a beautiful fall day here in Montana.
- 0:17Things are going well.
- 0:19Treichel: That's great.
- 0:19It's humid, but I am near the ocean here in Florida.
- 0:22I'm having a good day as well.
- 0:24Today we're going to talk about a topic that we've hit.
- 0:27And we've hit with a lot of our conversations with credit unions.
- 0:31We've hit at different times in different podcasts, but it
- 0:35relates to the board package.
- 0:38And what should be in a board monthly package so that the
- 0:42board sees what they need to see?
- 0:44And oh, by the way, how will that package rise to the level of.
- 0:49Making NCUA comfortable with what's in that package.
- 0:52So you can call it the optimal board package.
- 0:55You can call it a good board package, the perfect board package, but that's
- 0:58what we're going to chat about.
- 1:00But before we do that, just in case someone's listening to this for the
- 1:03first time, if you could give a little bit of your background at NCUA before
- 1:07you started working as a consultant to help credit unions, what did
- 1:11you, what's your history at NCUA?
- 1:14Todd Miller: Certainly.
- 1:14So Mark, I spent 34 years.
- 1:16With NCOA, you can break it up into about three parts.
- 1:20The first third or so of my career, I was an examiner and a problem case officers.
- 1:24That middle third, I was a regional capital market specialist, worked
- 1:29with good credit unions and bad credit unions and everything in between.
- 1:33Actually, during that time, helped a lot of Development of policies
- 1:37of how NCUA looks at interest rate risk and looks at liquidity risk,
- 1:41did a lot of examiner training.
- 1:43Then the last third of my career, I was the director of special actions in the
- 1:46western regions, supervising problem case officers Capital market specialists,
- 1:51some regional lending specialists between that capital market specialist here
- 1:57and the director of special actions.
- 1:59You created a loss year for me where I spent a year at West core.
- 2:03And then I started my director of special actions role right
- 2:07in the middle of a recession.
- 2:09So made for some pretty interesting times.
- 2:13And I enjoyed my career with NCUA.
- 2:15It was a blast.
- 2:16I enjoyed all of it.
- 2:19The board package that we're going to talk about today, I
- 2:21conserved a lot of credit unions.
- 2:23I returned a couple to the members.
- 2:26So how board reports fit into this is near and dear to my heart.
- 2:30Treichel: Yeah.
- 2:30And from listeners conservatorship is when NCUA removes the board and serves as the
- 2:36board and the insurer and the regulator.
- 2:39And when that happens, the staff at NCUA get are basically
- 2:43running the credit union.
- 2:44They'll have a CEO, but they get very hands on in that regard.
- 2:48And so that's what Todd's referring to there.
- 2:49And by the way, there is a podcast on Conservatorships that I can
- 2:53put a link into the show notes.
- 2:55So if you're curious about Conservatorships, there's a
- 2:57whole podcast on that topic.
- 2:59All right, let's a board policy, a board package let's start
- 3:03walking through what should be in a board, a good board package.
- 3:09Todd Miller: I'm going to just give a little background and just throw out.
- 3:13We've done other podcasts here on corporate governance.
- 3:17We've done them on risk appetite statements and in those we discuss the
- 3:22nature of, this becomes a culture and part of the credit use culture and the
- 3:27board package is reflective of that.
- 3:29It's a foundation for establishing that board culture, but it reflects that.
- 3:34Or culture in corporate governance as well, at the end of the day,
- 3:39the board of directors, they're responsible for that general direction
- 3:42and control of the credit union.
- 3:45They set that strategic plan, they set those risk appetites, they're responsible
- 3:51for ensuring the credit union complies with laws and regulations in the
- 3:55board package at the end of the day.
- 3:58And at its very simplest nature.
- 4:00It's there to provide and help the Board of Directors make
- 4:06good decisions with review.
- 4:08Respect to their responsibilities.
- 4:10We spent a lot of time in troubled credit unions.
- 4:13I think there's some things that come out of troubled credeans.
- 4:16And 1 of the things is they always have boards that are actually want to act
- 4:22in the best interest of the members.
- 4:23And then how do they get in trouble?
- 4:25Usually it's because the board Is misinformed about
- 4:28the credit is risk position.
- 4:29They don't know what's going on.
- 4:31In rare cases, they, their management staff misrepresented the whole
- 4:38risk of the credit into him.
- 4:39But a lot of times they're just kept in the dark and that was something that
- 4:42came up over and over in my career.
- 4:44When you get into a trouble credit, as boards were in the dark as to where
- 4:48their credit is were in terms of.
- 4:50Actual risk.
- 4:53So I think that's somewhat of an interesting thing that
- 4:56I was preparing for this.
- 4:58I thought, oh, I could Google what's in a good board report.
- 5:00I'm sure there's hundreds of web pages.
- 5:02I will tell you, here's 8 principles or here's 10 principles or whatever.
- 5:06I chose not to do that.
- 5:07I just made an own outline off of my own history here.
- 5:10Our listeners, they can go back and Google that and we'll see how much, we
- 5:13hit and how much we miss, but I'm going to try and keep it a little bit more
- 5:17simpler and a little bit more direct.
- 5:20Treichel: You got it.
- 5:20So you talked about misinformed on risk and as you're talking through that,
- 5:26I'm picturing different conversations.
- 5:29Where you've been involved with some client conversations where there's
- 5:32like a, and I'm also thinking about the concept of foreman substance, right?
- 5:37That you can have amazing data, but if it isn't handled in a proper way so that the
- 5:44board can easily find it and they have to spend, the package grows and grows,
- 5:49and it's just a data dump that's not organized well, that can create, right?
- 5:53A situation where they don't understand the risk, even though maybe you can
- 5:56hunt and peck and find all that.
- 5:58But if it's put together, it has that form, whether it's an
- 6:01executive summary on the top.
- 6:03I know you've had some conversations relative to, some large credit unions
- 6:07where you've seen some really good board packages and some covers to that.
- 6:10So when I bring that up, what should be on the front end of a
- 6:16good board package in your mind?
- 6:18Todd Miller: You bring up a lot of things there, Mark.
- 6:21And I
- 6:22Treichel: did.
- 6:22Yeah.
- 6:22So just run, I
- 6:24Todd Miller: have answers to all of those on this little piece
- 6:26of paper that's in front of me.
- 6:28All right.
- 6:28Let her rip, so a good board package, so first off NCUA, they don't have
- 6:33a lot of guidance, but they do say something about board reports and their
- 6:36exam guide, and this is the only quote I'm going to read from anything today.
- 6:40The rest of it is all just going to be me talking, you talking, but NCUA.
- 6:46They put it in writing, they say reports to directors should support the complete
- 6:50understandable and accurate information appropriate to the size and complexity
- 6:55of the credit union size and complexity.
- 6:57The credit union is an interesting statement.
- 6:59The regulators use it all the time.
- 7:01And because of that caveat.
- 7:04There is no perfect board package, credit unions are going to have a
- 7:08governance culture, a risk management culture and their board packages are
- 7:14going to reflect that, all I will say between board packages and it doesn't
- 7:19matter to the size of your credit and you're going to have quantitative
- 7:21and qualitative information in there.
- 7:24Board packages, they do have a tendency to grow over time.
- 7:29You're always fighting this balance of what does The board want and
- 7:33what does the board need to have?
- 7:36And those are difficult questions to answer.
- 7:38Every board brings with it.
- 7:40It's unique skill sets and unique background.
- 7:44So how you present information to them is going to vary across
- 7:48organizations how you order your board package and the information.
- 7:53It varies across different organizations.
- 7:57You see some organizations, they put all this compliance stuff in front
- 8:00and other places, they put it in back.
- 8:02Some people start with a financial statement.
- 8:05Other people end with a financial statement.
- 8:07At the end of the day, there's no one right answer to how you
- 8:11organize your board package.
- 8:14Talk about some of the qualitative and quantitative stuff.
- 8:17A short, Version of it in the way I always assessed it Is and this is
- 8:23todd miller's personal view of what a board package looks like To me board
- 8:28reports should reflect management's responsibility to demonstrate compliance
- 8:32with business plan board policy Risk appetite standards of the credit union
- 8:38Treichel: say that one more
- 8:39Todd Miller: time So they should reflect management's responsibility to demonstrate
- 8:45to their board compliance with business Or policy and risk appetite standards.
- 8:52And those are all things the boards put in place.
- 8:54They create that business plan business strategy.
- 8:57They set all the policies.
- 8:59The board is responsible for setting that risk appetite to me.
- 9:03Board report should demonstrate management's compliance with those items.
- 9:09Treichel: As you say that, I think of a couple of conversations we've
- 9:12had with credit unions over time where a credit union strategic plan
- 9:15said A, B, and C, and then what they did was B, Q, and R, and there was
- 9:21no pivot in those board documents.
- 9:24And so NCUA Criticized and those credit unions pretty harshly
- 9:28because they didn't really do management really didn't do that.
- 9:31And the board didn't ask to see that in those situations.
- 9:36Todd Miller: It's fine if the credit union does that, but somewhere there
- 9:39in your qualitative board reporting and discussions, there has to be okay.
- 9:43Today's business.
- 9:45This plan ABC is not working.
- 9:47Here's why.
- 9:48And here's an opportunity to pivot and accomplish board goals by doing X, Y, Z.
- 9:54And here's the opportunity and risks entailed with that.
- 9:58Like I said, there's no right way to do it, but that's one of the things that
- 10:04comes out, in your qualitative reports, and we'll talk about qualitative reports.
- 10:09They need to be clear, concise, provide context, but.
- 10:14At the big level, your CEO, CFO, lending people, whatever the case
- 10:18may be, they should be providing explanations for deviations from plans.
- 10:23Why are we not able to do what we thought we were going to do?
- 10:28But, we're in an election year.
- 10:29Things are going to change.
- 10:30We just went through a cycle where we went through COVID and We have
- 10:35these massive increases in interest rates, which no one can predict.
- 10:38You respond to those by laying out, in your board reports and
- 10:42your CEO, let's go discuss.
- 10:44The world has changed.
- 10:46Our risks and opportunities are different.
- 10:48We have to pivot.
- 10:49Here's how we're going to do it and make that a discussion at the board level.
- 10:55Also, you lay that kind of stuff out in your qualitative reports.
- 10:59I'm getting ahead of myself because you ask questions that get us to the end.
- 11:05Treichel: Get back.
- 11:05Get back to your agenda.
- 11:06We've got qualitative.
- 11:08We've got quantitative.
- 11:09This is the next thing that we do is walk through 1 of those or what?
- 11:13Todd Miller: Let's go through the quantitative reports first, because
- 11:16these are numbers, and I will just say this, you break quantitative reports
- 11:22down into, I break them down into a number of categories, and I think
- 11:27you'll find in the literature, this is probably the same, even though I didn't
- 11:30look it up, you have key performance indicators, how are we doing financially.
- 11:34And how are we doing against our budgets and our strategic plans?
- 11:38You have key risk indicators, NCOA throws out a whole historical, key
- 11:43ratios and historical ratios on their financial performance report.
- 11:47A lot of those are key risk indicators, key performance indicators.
- 11:51You have financial reports and then you have budget.
- 11:54In a strategic plan updates, I think there's a couple things that, in a good
- 11:59performing credit, and you're going to see is there's going to be a lot of
- 12:01consistency in these quantitative reports.
- 12:05They're going to tell you where you've been where you're at.
- 12:11And give you some indication of where you think you're going.
- 12:14And I think that's important with boards, especially because they're
- 12:18not there in the criterion every day.
- 12:21They need some measures to show where they've been, where
- 12:24they're at, where you're going.
- 12:26I think those pieces are in there.
- 12:29Now, the quantitative reports.
- 12:30This is very interesting.
- 12:31I like dashboard type level reports.
- 12:34And the challenge for any criterion is how do you summarize these things
- 12:38without providing too much detail?
- 12:41You give a board too much detail and it causes a couple problems.
- 12:46One thing, you lose your directors because they can't interpret the information.
- 12:50And the other thing, if you give them too much detail, it really invites
- 12:53boards to start micromanaging little numbers and that's not their role.
- 13:00So board level reports, they need to be summary type of data.
- 13:06I like the dashboard things.
- 13:09I think it's important in accrediting that your board reporting these numbers
- 13:13are reported in a consistent format, regardless of where they come from.
- 13:17If you're still.
- 13:18CFO is giving you refinance reports, and he highlights
- 13:22variances with red, yellow, green.
- 13:25You should expect to see the same thing from the lending.
- 13:27You shouldn't see lending reports that use blue, magenta, and purple.
- 13:33There needs to be some consistency to that throughout the organization, because
- 13:37it's how you build credibility, trust, and it makes it easier for your board
- 13:40members to understand data given to them.
- 13:43It used to drive me nuts when I would go into a credit union and say, Okay
- 13:47here's the financial trends here.
- 13:49And, they go the oldest information on the left, newest information on the right.
- 13:54But then you pick up another report on the next page, and it goes the other way.
- 13:57It's just like that just adds confusion to things.
- 14:00Let's Keep this whole process consistent, and there should actually
- 14:06be some conscious thought put into that within an organization of
- 14:10how we're going to organize data.
- 14:12Now, along with a qualitative report like that, like I said, I like dashboards
- 14:18sometimes credit unions do need detailed information, but, at the end of the
- 14:22day, There should be qualitative reports that go with these dashboards.
- 14:27So I wouldn't be should be telling the board, hey, everything's fine.
- 14:30Let's go on the way.
- 14:32We expect.
- 14:32Wait, wait, we have variances here.
- 14:34This is not going the way we expect.
- 14:36Here's why.
- 14:36Here's what we're going to do about it.
- 14:39Sometimes you just need to explain to the board.
- 14:41Here's the 2 or 3 key pieces of information on this dashboard.
- 14:45This is what you need to be looking at have any questions.
- 14:48I also think, 1 of the things I said, I talked about.
- 14:51Where we've been, where are we, where do we want to be?
- 14:54I do think it's also important that credit unions have dashboards
- 14:57that compare themselves to their peers, too, where are our peers at?
- 15:02Where are our competitors at?
- 15:04Almost everyone does that in terms of setting loan and share rates, but you
- 15:09should benchmark your key performance and risk indicators against your peers.
- 15:13Occasionally, too it helps that the board set that strategic direction.
- 15:18But I think the con System formatting is available.
- 15:22If a board member wants to dig into raw data, fine, make it available to them.
- 15:27But I don't think it has to be, in the reports every month, and I do think it's
- 15:31important to that boards and especially on these qualitative reports from
- 15:36executives, they tell board members.
- 15:39What's important?
- 15:40What's not in here?
- 15:41I'll give a couple of examples.
- 15:43That happened in real life about this.
- 15:45Most board reports, they don't have cost accounting.
- 15:48Cost information, that's a daily thing.
- 15:51It doesn't need to be in there.
- 15:52But, as in a travel carding with them, they had 52 branches,
- 15:5539 of them were losing money.
- 15:58I think maybe you should tell your board that's maybe something they
- 16:01need to know, and then contrast that with a carding at the same time.
- 16:05That's 2 states away within their strategic plan.
- 16:09They laid out, okay, we have multiple branches, we have small, medium,
- 16:12large ones, we expect them to make profitability within, within a year.
- 16:1518 months when the open on 20 on the small and medium ones, 24 months on the big one.
- 16:21I have a policy.
- 16:22If we have a branch that's losing money over a 12 month period, we're
- 16:26going to have a plan to fix it within.
- 16:2812 months or we're going to close that branch or it doesn't have to deal with it.
- 16:31Expectations are laid out.
- 16:33Here's what we're going to do.
- 16:34It's a different
- 16:36Treichel: those 2 examples you gave him, putting my old head on and you could see
- 16:41in your 1st example, all those branches losing money and not having the data.
- 16:45You could see a pretty rough exam wrapped around that and maybe we're
- 16:49examiners will point that out.
- 16:50And the other 1, you can see where that.
- 16:53It not only helps the board understand it, it helps the relationship with NCOA
- 16:57and helps NCOA get in there and get out quick because they can, they, you
- 17:02the management team and the board has put together a package that is succinct
- 17:07yet provides the right information.
- 17:09And then the other thing, when I'm thinking about dashboard, it reminded me
- 17:13of a Confucius quote, which is, it's a simple task to make something complex.
- 17:20And it's a complex task to make something simple, right?
- 17:23How do you.
- 17:25The work behind building that dashboard can be very complex can
- 17:30be very challenging but it provides a simple summary that someone can
- 17:34take and make decisions on and.
- 17:37Meet their regulatory needs, meet their needs of understanding the
- 17:41credit union because, because it was artfully put together to.
- 17:46To tell the appropriate narrative of what the board needs to understand.
- 17:51Todd Miller: Yeah.
- 17:51And, you mentioned complex made simple and, probably the biggest area
- 17:57with respect to that is credit risk reports, you have a very complex thing.
- 18:01And this is the biggest risk in any credit out there.
- 18:04If they fail, it can.
- 18:06Was to be credit risk or liquidity risk and if they have liquidity
- 18:09risk that causes a failure It's almost always because of poor
- 18:12asset quality at the bottom side.
- 18:14So it all comes down to this credit risk is it?
- 18:17most significant risk in any credit union.
- 18:20And, credit unions are involved in all kinds of different types of lending.
- 18:25You have your consumer lending.
- 18:26You might even indirect lending.
- 18:28You might have participation loans.
- 18:30You have various types of residential real estate lending.
- 18:32You have all these different types of commercial lending, and they all require
- 18:37different types of reporting structures.
- 18:39And, how do you lay down What's important for a board, and how do you get them in a
- 18:46succinct one or two pages in each of those areas to understand where credit risk is?
- 18:51It's a very challenging issue.
- 18:53A lot of credit unions, they use a company called Encino to
- 18:57monitor their consumer loans.
- 18:59You can break that thing down to where there's hundreds of pages, but there's
- 19:02also ways to break it down very easy in two or three pages to here's where
- 19:07our credit risk scores have migrated.
- 19:09And here's where our LTVs have migrated.
- 19:11Here's what this looks like when we combine LTVs with credit risk scores
- 19:16and how that changes over time.
- 19:18It can be done in two or three pages.
- 19:20Just, but there's a lot of hours of work behind it to get it there.
- 19:25So the board doesn't get bogged down, but they still have a clear picture of
- 19:28what's going on with that portfolio.
- 19:31You'll see this with clients, all people that have business loan portfolios, you're
- 19:35making large loans, quite often, two or three large loans, you lose them in a
- 19:39year and it's a years of profitability.
- 19:42Out the door right there.
- 19:44You will always see the examiners and the regulations harping on what
- 19:48type of business loan reporters have to end up in the board package.
- 19:53And sometimes you think it's on onerous board members sometimes might think it's
- 19:58onerous, but they're important pieces that the board has to look at and understand.
- 20:04You get another piece of this nowadays where credit unions, almost all of them
- 20:09have fairly complex committee structures.
- 20:11That manage different areas of the operation.
- 20:14You have IT steering committees, you have ALCO committees, you might have a risk
- 20:18committee, you might have a business loan committee, you might have a regular loan
- 20:23committee how much of that information makes its way to the board and you're
- 20:27going to do that in summary or detailed information, it becomes a challenge.
- 20:32You do have to figure out a way to get all these committee type
- 20:35reports information to the board and.
- 20:37You don't have to spend a lot of time on them.
- 20:40If things are going according to plan, the board should really try and keep
- 20:44their eyes focused on strategic direction.
- 20:48That's opportunities and threats.
- 20:50If things are going well, they don't need to spend time on that.
- 20:53They need to spend time on where do we need to go?
- 20:55And how do we get there?
- 20:56And so it becomes a big challenge.
- 20:59But at the end of the day, all those committee stuff used.
- 21:03It needs to be available to them.
- 21:05Today, that's easier than ever.
- 21:07There's lots of software platforms out there.
- 21:09A lot of people create their own software platforms where board
- 21:12members can sign in and look at it.
- 21:14I remember the old days before there was that way.
- 21:17I had 1 of the largest credit unions in the U.
- 21:19S.
- 21:19in my district.
- 21:20I think they were the only credit and used every line on the call report.
- 21:24Other board packets came in a binder to me each month.
- 21:26One of these cardboard bifolds, I don't know, it was probably
- 21:30250 pages, but, they had.
- 21:32Five or six keys, those and all kinds of joint ventures.
- 21:35And it was very interesting.
- 21:37And, I sat down with this chief operating officer that creating one of the exams.
- 21:42It's there's all this stuff.
- 21:43Get in here.
- 21:44I said 90 percent of his examiners told us to put it there.
- 21:47We don't look at it.
- 21:49But you find things that, okay, this was a regulation requirement, 10 years
- 21:54ago, and it got thrown in the board packet and it never got taken out.
- 21:57The other thing that, credit unions need to do and board members and CEOs
- 22:01need to do this probably once a year or every other year, they really need to
- 22:06go back and assess their own packages.
- 22:08What are we looking at?
- 22:10Do we really need to see this?
- 22:12Is this important?
- 22:13Does it have to be in there?
- 22:15A lot of those things you do put in there, or if you've got subsidiaries
- 22:18and stuff, you might only talk about it once a year and a lot of it goes through
- 22:22a consent agenda I have found, in that one party, and I was just talking about
- 22:27I said, do board members ever even.
- 22:29Look at this stuff or understand what's going on.
- 22:31And I was there for an exam one time, and they just had a regular board meeting.
- 22:35And, the CEO invited me to come to a regular board meeting.
- 22:39Okay.
- 22:40That board meeting was very interesting.
- 22:42Those board members did read all that stuff.
- 22:43They did have questions on it.
- 22:45They did understand all of it.
- 22:47I was very impressed.
- 22:49So qualitative reports.
- 22:51Like I said, you need to have, executives need to summarize and
- 22:55address in a qualitative written form.
- 22:58Format, all these qualitative reports, and then I need to layer on top of that.
- 23:03Hey, what's going on in the world?
- 23:05That's increasing our risk.
- 23:07What's opportunities that?
- 23:08Hey, we didn't think about them when we did our strategic plan 2 years ago.
- 23:12But here's something that we can do now that benefits our members.
- 23:15It will be profitable.
- 23:17Do we.
- 23:18I want to go down this path.
- 23:20Here's risk and rewards of this type of thing.
- 23:23So it's really important that especially those qualitative reports, they
- 23:27address those risk reward things.
- 23:29It's an important that they address deviations from plans.
- 23:33We have a risk appetite.
- 23:34We have a business plan here.
- 23:35We have a strategic plan.
- 23:38Things aren't going according to plan.
- 23:40Those are the things the CEO, the CFO, your lending executives,
- 23:44they need to address those issues in their qualitative reports.
- 23:49Where are we having deviations from expectations?
- 23:52And the sooner you bring those things up, the easier it is for everyone to
- 23:57address them and pivot if necessary.
- 24:02Treichel: Can you think of the example of that use of qualitative where you
- 24:06had all these branches that didn't.
- 24:08That weren't making money.
- 24:09And then this other one where they were tracking it really well.
- 24:12Can you think of any anecdotal qualitative things that you've seen
- 24:18that were done either particularly well or particularly poorly?
- 24:23Nothing might come to mind but any examples like that, that, that come
- 24:26to mind when I throw that out there,
- 24:28Todd Miller: the poorly done ones, there's lots of examples of those,
- 24:32especially with lending areas.
- 24:34Is where, you throw raw data at the credit union or, especially business portfolios.
- 24:40We're, we don't really disclose our risk migration or we'll even lay it out.
- 24:45Here's our business portfolio.
- 24:47Here's the totals risk ratings, call it 1 through 8 bad, good to bad.
- 24:52We have the.
- 24:53Some are seven or eight here that are potential losses.
- 24:56But what you don't say within that is wait, two of these are the
- 25:00largest loans in the credit union.
- 25:02They're not just an average loan balance.
- 25:04These are ones that can hurt us materially.
- 25:06And you don't share that information with the board, material risks like that,
- 25:10you need to just throw it out for them.
- 25:13And, the.
- 25:15The well run credit and those qualitative reports, they're going
- 25:18to be looking forward towards opportunities all the time.
- 25:23You have this new emerging AI issue.
- 25:25What does that mean for us?
- 25:27And we've seen credit games that, and this is both good or bad, they play
- 25:31with within the Bitcoin and the crypto currencies and how do we provide services
- 25:36and say, keeping for our members and we've seen examples of credit games
- 25:39that have structured this extremely well and others that have dived into
- 25:43it without really thinking through all the implications and they, Been heavily
- 25:48criticized by their examiners for doing so four or five years ago, before I
- 25:52retired, you'd see a lot of that with the whole marijuana banking issue, right?
- 25:58You got Freddie Ian's that dove into it.
- 26:00They did a lot of homework.
- 26:02They did an extremely good job with it.
- 26:04Other credit unions dove into it without doing their homework.
- 26:09And, then you get an exam report and the board doesn't even realize, Oh, wait we
- 26:13had 300 marijuana bank and clients here.
- 26:17And we've got a fine from FinCEN because we didn't, handle our SAR.
- 26:22Appropriately, and I've seen examples of that in real life to the boards.
- 26:25Just get surprised.
- 26:26Hey, we get a fine from Vincent for not doing something.
- 26:30And, we didn't even know we were involved in that 1.
- 26:32And a business,
- 26:34Treichel: That's that's what they call a red flag.
- 26:35Definitely.
- 26:37Todd Miller: Yeah more of the examples of the way we're, we've not really summarized
- 26:43for our directors, those significant risks, we bury them away in detail.
- 26:50And that's where the qualitative reports need to come out is,
- 26:54let's not bury things in details.
- 26:57Another example of that 1 time.
- 27:00And a member complained about their CD not renewing at the right weight, and
- 27:06they appealed it to a branch manager.
- 27:08Branch manager said, no, they appealed it to the board management, told the
- 27:12board, hey, we did the right thing board upheld their branch managers
- 27:16decision, how to renew the certificates.
- 27:19That member pulled out 4 million and I had to go borrow that
- 27:23entire amount from the corporate.
- 27:25No one told the board that this member is appealing a thing here
- 27:28over 200, but no one bothered to tell the board that member had 4 million
- 27:32in that 200 million credit union.
- 27:36Yeah, it's like maybe the board would have made a little different decision
- 27:39if they had the whole story here behind this appeal that came to them.
- 27:44Treichel: Yeah, that's a great example.
- 27:46I had a similar example.
- 27:48I read it in a USA Today back when USA Today was printed.
- 27:53It's a guy came in and was disheveled into the bank and wanted to get
- 27:56the parking validated and they wouldn't do it and brought it all
- 27:59the way up to the vice president.
- 28:01But no one had the idea to look at.
- 28:04And he even said, I'm going to close my account.
- 28:05They go, sure.
- 28:06Okay let me go do that.
- 28:07And that's when the light, the lights went on.
- 28:09They saw, that that it was the biggest depositor in that particular bank.
- 28:12So great point.
- 28:14Great point.
- 28:14Beyond qualitative what else what else do you have on that on your sheet of topics?
- 28:20Todd's topics on board packages.
- 28:22Todd Miller: I said, there's no, no correct answer to this.
- 28:25I do think.
- 28:26It's important that, you keep your reporting consistent.
- 28:30Let's figure out what works.
- 28:31Let's keep this consistent.
- 28:33Let's not be changing it all the time.
- 28:35I think board calendars and board agendas are important.
- 28:38Different boards will look at how you go through this
- 28:42agenda in different directions.
- 28:44I've seen places where agenda 1 is our agenda, Compliance report, that's the
- 28:49first thing we're going to look at, are we in with all our risk appetites, other
- 28:52places that's 3rd or 4th down the agenda.
- 28:55Their 1st agenda item is, here's our financial performance this month and
- 29:00here's the CEO's report and here's the CFO's report and somewhere in there.
- 29:05They eventually get to these compliance reports.
- 29:07But the important thing is you create a consistent.
- 29:11Way to whole approach your board meetings and your board packages.
- 29:15That builds trust with your board.
- 29:17There's an art involved in this because, like I said, you have to balance what the
- 29:21board needs to know with what they want to know, and based on their backgrounds, they
- 29:25want to know more and there's always this fine line between giving them appropriate
- 29:34data versus giving them too much.
- 29:37And like I said, you have to be very careful about.
- 29:41Overwhelming your board with detailed data that they don't need because it
- 29:46just creates a situation where they don't understand what your risk profile is, or
- 29:52it invites them to dig into micromanaging stuff that they don't need to micromanage
- 29:58and that can create a world of problem.
- 30:02In and of itself, if the board starts micromanaging daily operations.
- 30:08Treichel: Great point.
- 30:08Great point.
- 30:10This is this has been as always enjoyable talking through some more stories.
- 30:15And I think this is another great episode that credit unions can listen to, to
- 30:22improve their corporate governance, improve their relationship with N.
- 30:25C.
- 30:25U.
- 30:25A.
- 30:26Any questions I should have asked you that I didn't ask on this topic?
- 30:31Todd Miller: No, but maybe I can summarize things, in just a couple short points.
- 30:36And like I said, there's a lot of art and a lot of detail that goes into this.
- 30:40But at the end of the day, you're trying to accomplish a couple things.
- 30:44Is with good board reporting, you want to present data that helps
- 30:48board members make good decisions.
- 30:51There's a lot that goes into that, but at the end of the day, that's what you're
- 30:54trying to accomplish is present data that helps board members make good decisions
- 30:58and you want to give them a clear understanding of your current situation
- 31:03and you want to keep their focus.
- 31:05It's on future actions.
- 31:08Where do we need to go going forward?
- 31:10And that's the challenge.
- 31:11And sometimes I wonder how did you accomplish that as an executive
- 31:14director when you had changes at the N.
- 31:17C.
- 31:17U.
- 31:17A.
- 31:17board level?
- 31:18I have a feeling there was changes made, each time you got new directors and
- 31:22new directions there, but maybe not.
- 31:24Maybe you guys were very consistent about things.
- 31:26Treichel: We were able to keep some things on track, but as I said, every time
- 31:30the board chair changed, it was, purple became yellow and yellow became purple.
- 31:34And a board comes in, like you said, what does a board want to know?
- 31:37And what does a board need to know?
- 31:38They come in.
- 31:40Every person is the journey that they've taken through time and what they've seen,
- 31:44what they've been exposed to, what they've seen elsewhere, what their particular
- 31:47interest is that what That plays a role on it, whether it's the board or a
- 31:53teacher's credit union board, which is going to, have a certain, if they're all
- 31:57teachers, they were trained in one way.
- 31:59If they're all farmers, they're trained in a different way.
- 32:02I remember 1 of 1 of my favorite.
- 32:04Learning experiences when I was a new examiner was a
- 32:07credit union in a farming area.
- 32:10And the credit committee was all farmers and the board was all farmers.
- 32:14And I learned more about farming in that one week than I ever have
- 32:17in any point in time in my life.
- 32:19And I got a comfort level, but they were asking for particular things just
- 32:23because of the journey that they've taken.
- 32:24Todd, that was a great summary.
- 32:26I think that's going to be the sound that the sound bite from this one
- 32:29is what you just summarized there.
- 32:31As always, I appreciate your thoughts on these important credit union topics.
- 32:38Thanks for your time.
- 32:39Yep.
- 32:39Thanks for your time, Todd and listeners.
- 32:41I want to thank you as always.
- 32:43Thank you for listening.
- 32:44This hope you'll listen again soon.
- 32:46Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.