Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 462. Is NDT (Natural Desiccated Thyroid) Making You Worse?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where we dive deep into the world of thyroid and hormones, especially for you ladies navigating perimenopause and menopause, and really for anyone struggling with hypothyroidism. I'm your host, Dr. Amy, thyroid and hormone specialist and CEO of a global telemedicine practice where we prescribe the right thyroid treatment and bioidentical hormones to all 50 states and most of Canada, helping you become that badass human that you're meant to be.
- 0:29So if you're battling weight gain and hair loss, you can't lose weight no matter what you do, your energy levels are plummeting and your libido left town, then you're in the right place and you have found your tribe. Remember, I want you to embrace every inch of that badass woman that you truly are. So if you're ready to dive in and fix things, let's get started.
- 0:51We're going to talk today about why NDT medications, specifically ARMR or NP thyroid, because those are the two NDT or natural desiccated thyroid medications available right now, why they may or may not be the best for you.
- 1:07So let's start with why they might be really awesome for you. We know in conventional medicine, so many of you are on T4 only and T4 only does not work. This is your Levo, your Synthroid, Tyrosin, Tyrosin Sol.
- 1:23And as great as it is to have some kind of thyroid hormone replacement on board, it is medical malpractice to give someone T4 only. In my opinion, this is not a documented medical malpractice lawsuit, so don't go calling your attorney. But in my opinion, T4 only is medical malpractice because it leaves you...
- 1:43in the dust, suffering with symptoms, and that's not what life is supposed to be. We're supposed to enjoy life. And if you're walking around 40 pounds overweight, gaining weight, looking sideways at a brownie, that is not the best way to live life. If you're dragging your butt through the day, you can't get off the couch, your hair is falling out, you have no sexual desire whatsoever, you're constipated, you're not pooping every day,
- 2:06You're cold all the time while everyone else is comfortable. Your joints hurt. That's no way to live life. So T4 only will do that to you. T4 only will keep you in that hypothyroid state. Unfortunately, that is standard of care. And standard of care in conventional medicine is let's test your TSH. And if TSH is above a 4.5, which is the current cutoff,
- 2:35If TSH is above a 4.5, here's some T4 medication. Here's some Levo. Here's some Synthroid. And that is the massive, massive problem in conventional medicine right now. Now, when we move over to...
- 2:48armor or NP or NDT medication, natural desiccated thyroid, the bonus of, and we'll say, hey, some T3 is better than no T3. The bonus of NDT medication then is that it does contain T4 and T3 together. Now it contains this in about an 80-20 split because natural desiccated thyroid medication is literally drying out a pig's thyroid gland.
- 3:15And we're putting it in a capsule. So when we do that, obviously, we're getting a little bit of T3 because our thyroid gland produces T4 and T3 in an 80-20 ratio, roughly, roughly. Now, this is not perfect. This is not to a T, science to a T.
- 3:36because there's only so much that we can measure as to what the thyroid gland is producing. But we have it down to about an 80-20 split. So that's what NDT medication is doing. It's mimicking our natural production. So we take the thyroid gland of a pig, we dry it out, put it in a capsule, we give it to you, and we say, here.
- 3:53This is going to mimic what your thyroid gland is supposed to be doing. If you have Hashimoto's and your thyroid gland is destroyed, it's just not producing T4 and T3 anymore, then absolutely NDT medication is going to be better than T4 only, 100% hands down. But what if you don't convert? So now I move over into the functional integrative medicine world.
- 4:20And I have said this over and over and over again, unless you are working with a thyroid expert, and even within that realm, I want you to go a little bit deeper and grill this thyroid expert that you're considering working with. I don't care if it's me or somebody else. You got to ask these questions.
- 4:40If they only do NDT, that can be a disservice to you. And many of them do. So you can't just ask the question, hey, do you treat thyroid naturally? Well, yes, we do. Do you use things other than T4 only, other than Levo and Synthroid? Oh, yes, yes, we do. Okay, do you take symptoms into account
- 5:05Like my symptoms when you're dealing with hypothyroidism and working to optimize someone. Oh yes, yes we do. Now all of those answers are absolutely correct. However, the one question that you need to ask is, do you only use natural desiccated thyroid? Do you only use armor thyroid, NP thyroid or a compounded T4 and T3? And if that answer is yes, I want you to run.
- 5:34The answer is no, no, no. We use other things. Now let's keep going. Do you use T3? Do you use lyothyronine? Do you use Cytomel? Yes or no? Do you have a cap, meaning an upper limit on how much T3 that you will prescribe? Do you ever combine T3 with natural desiccated thyroid medication?
- 6:00These are vital questions because here's the thing. If you are just put on NDT, while NDT, T4 and T3 is better than T4 only because you're getting some T3, you're getting some of that active thyroid hormone. If you don't convert T4 to T3 properly, that can be a huge issue.
- 6:19So if all this thyroid expert integrative functional person does is increase your natural desiccated thyroid dose. So let's put you on armor. Then let's increase that armor. Oh, you're not feeling better. Let's increase it again. Let's take it up again. And you're not converting your T4 into T3 or you're pushing up your reverse T3.
- 6:39And if you need to deep dive in that, we have other episodes on reverse T3. We can certainly link those in the show notes. But if you are pushing up your reverse T3, essentially pushing your body into survival mode, that is going to backfire on you. And you're going to be as hypo as you were or could be on T4 only.
- 6:58Because that little bit, that 20% T3 that you're getting in that natural desiccated thyroid medication is not enough to push your reverse T3 down, is not enough to support your thyroid T3, free T3 levels. And all of that T4 is just pushing to reverse and pushing you deeper and deeper into hypothyroidism.
- 7:19The other component to just think about when we are talking about NDT is the fact that it is derived from a porcine thyroid gland. So it's identical to our thyroid gland.
- 7:32Now, let's break down autoimmunity. Let's break down Hashimoto's. And before I do this breakdown, I am going to say this is not the case with everyone. Many thyroid patients are on Armour and on NP thyroid, and they're doing just fine. And if you're one of them, congratulations. It's awesome. I'm glad to see you in optimization land. So if you are truly optimized, your symptoms are minimal to none.
- 8:00If you are not truly optimized, then you're going to have issues. And it might be the NDT. It might be too much T4. So maybe you're doing okay on that NDT and you just need a little bit of T3 added in because we want to change that ratio. We don't want you at 80-20. We want you at 60-40. Okay.
- 8:2350-50, 40-60 with more T3 on board. Or it could be that your body sees that natural desiccated thyroid medication, follow me here, as your thyroid gland. And since your Hashimoto soldiers are set up to attack your thyroid gland because they think it's a bad guy,
- 8:46They're going to launch an attack whenever you take NDT medication. It's possible. Now, remember what I said. This is not in every single case. So I do not want you to think that just because you are on NDT medication that, oh, my gosh, I must not be doing well because when I take it.
- 9:07My soldiers are launching an attack on my thyroid. That's not always the case, but it could be the case. So that is why I am giving you some food for thought that if you are not optimized on NDT, you need to think outside the box and be working with someone who knows what they're doing so that we can get you optimized.
- 9:29Now, the other kind of roadblock that I see that I mentioned earlier in the list of questions to grill any integrative functional thyroid expert, hormone expert on when it comes to your thyroid is the T3 component. So NDT in and of itself, not bad. It's not a bad thing. How your body deals with it, we need to look at that. Does it cause an autoimmune attack? Does it cause an autoimmune flare? Do you get worse when you take it? Let's dig deeper.
- 9:59And maybe we just have to add in some T3 and change that ratio. Now, when I said the question to ask about a cap on T3, here's what I mean. If you're working with a functional integrative blah, blah, blah practitioner that says, oh, yes, I will use T3. And then they only give you five, maybe 10 micrograms of T3. And they go, well, you know, any more than that.
- 10:24you'll have a heart attack or you'll start losing bone. Oh, that TSH that's suppressed. Yeah, that's not good. That's not good. So yes, I have a cap on how much T3 I can give you because we don't want that TSH suppressed. I have a whole other podcast on suppressed TSH. Literally, I think I have what the hell in the title of the podcast. And I believe it is called Functional Medicine Doctors Freaking Out Over Low TSH, WTH.
- 10:54Because to me, those functional practitioners should not be using the term functional and they should just go back to their conventional training.
- 11:03Anyone who thinks that low TSH is bad or will cause AFib or bone loss needs their license revoked or they need to stop touching people's thyroid and leave it to the people that know what they're doing. So many of them will have this cap in their mind of how much T3 they can actually give you. And that's it. So it doesn't matter if you're like me and you need 75 micrograms twice a day, you're getting 10. 10.
- 11:32It doesn't matter if you're like many of my patients who do fantastic on 25, 30, 35, 40, 50 micrograms of T3 twice a day, who are optimal on 15 micrograms twice a day. It is nuanced. It is personalized. And we cannot have a cap on how much T3 we give you because only you and your body knows your body's going to tell us how much T3 you actually need to move into optimization land.
- 11:59So that is another issue that I have with practitioners putting a cap on how much T3 they will prescribe because that can leave you as hypo as working with a conventional doctor, except you paid the functional one a couple grand and you're still hypo and you still have symptoms.
- 12:18NDT medication is fantastic. It literally was the first thyroid medication we had. Did you know that? The very first thyroid hormone treatment we had was natural desiccated thyroid, dried out thyroid from a pig.
- 12:35And then big pharma came in, Synthory took over. And then all of a sudden, all of these studies on T4 only and T4 monotherapy being just fine to optimize someone's thyroid. And NDT got pushed to the side.
- 12:51Now, though NDT is fantastic and it's better than T4 only, it might not be the perfect solution and treatment for you. Or maybe you need it combined with some T3. Or maybe you don't need it at all and you just need T4 and T3. Or maybe you need T3 only. We don't know because the thyroid is nuanced.
- 13:14But the purpose of this show and this message is to tell you, please do not just go with a practitioner and think that you are going to be optimized just putting all of this natural desiccated thyroid in your body. It might. It might not. You might cause a thyroid storm. Your soldiers might see that medication as an invader and launch an attack. You might push up your reverse T3.
- 13:39You need to have an open mind and get really dialed in and nuanced with your thyroid hormone replacement treatment, because there's a variety of different combinations that we can do. So whenever I am asked, what's your favorite thyroid medication?
- 13:54I say the one that's going to work for you, in the dose that's going to work for you, in the combination that's going to work for you. And we don't know until we try and then we test and we ask you, how do you feel? And we put that all together to really detail out the perfect treatment. So if you are working with someone, you're on NDT and you're just not feeling your best,
- 14:20Ask those questions. See what they say. Maybe fire them and get a new doctor if you don't like their answers or if their answers don't line up with exactly what we talked about today. Now, one last small little component I will leave you with regarding NDT medication. Some people actually react to the fillers in NDT. I get the statement a lot. I want to do thyroid treatment, but I want to be...
- 14:49All natural. Now, NDT does have the word natural in the beginning. So that really throws a lot of people off. But the bottom line is it is a pharmaceutical company that makes it. And short of getting your thyroid medication compounded with T4 and T3, there is no way you are going to avoid fillers.
- 15:11In any of them. But I want to put your mind at ease. It's only a small percentage of the hypothyroid population that are really hypersensitive to fillers. So when we are talking about Armour or NP thyroid, there are fillers in there. They are both made by a pharmaceutical company.
- 15:32So it's not necessarily that the term natural, you know, we always think natural versus synthetic. Well, in the world of hormones, natural bioidentical hormones, a lot better than synthetic, progestins, fake, equine, estrogen, that do more harm than good. Yes, in that hormone world, natural versus synthetic, actually those terms have a place and a meaning. In the world of thyroid,
- 16:00We can't just hyper-focus on the word natural because it doesn't necessarily mean that it's all natural. You're still getting fillers in there.
- 16:11So this is where you have to expand your horizons when it comes to thyroid treatment. I actually call T4, so the levosynthroid tyrosine, T3, the cytomol, lyothyronine. I call those both biosynths, biologically identical yet synthetic in nature because they're in that synthetic category because they're in the synthetic category because they are made in a lab to be identical.
- 16:36identical to the T3 and T4 that your body makes, but we're not taking it from an animal. Biosynth. These biosynth thyroid replacement meds are a beautiful thing.
- 16:49The only way you're going to be T3 only if you need it is with a biosynth, linothyronine, cytomel. The only way that we are going to change ratios, even if we're using NDT med is by adding in T3, the biosynth.
- 17:07I want you to get out of that mindset. If you're in this mindset, I want to break it right now. That natural desiccated thyroid medication is the only way to go. And that it must be natural because it has natural in the title.
- 17:23That's like saying everything that's labeled gluten-free is gluten-free. It isn't. In case that was just a bomb dropped on you. Truth bomb. It's not. Just like everything organic is not 100% organic. And I can go into all kinds of arguments to make you see that, but I'll just leave it at that. Natural desiccated thyroid medication is not 100% natural. It contains fillers and your body may or may not like it.
- 17:53Maybe your body likes it, just needs some T3 added into it. Maybe you need to change altogether. The purpose is to open your mind to the possibilities.
- 18:02that are out there to get you into optimization land. And I don't want you pigeonholed with your own thinking. And I don't want you pigeonholed with the propaganda that so many alternative integrative functional practitioners are pushing because it might not be right for you. When it comes to the thyroid, it's very, very nuanced. You'd be working with someone like myself and my team. Shameless plug, absolutely. Because I've seen it.
- 18:32I've seen it too many times. I've had too many patients come into the practice who have dropped thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars on really big name thyroid experts, functional practitioners, because they had that term functional medicine in their title. And they didn't ask the questions when it came to their thyroid. I want you to be armed with knowledge, all the knowledge that I can possibly give you
- 19:00I want you to be armed with that so you make the right decision and you don't waste another day feeling like garbage. Keep an open mind with thyroid treatment and know that it is very, very nuanced.