Latest / Film And Whiskey / Oscar Nominations Reactions and American Single Malt: What to Know
Transcript
- 0:00On today's Film and Whiskey, I'm talking with our friend Daniel
- 0:03Zwayo about the Oscar nominations.
- 0:06Then we're thrown over to an old friend in Old Line Spirits to
- 0:09talk about what it means that American Single Malt is now an
- 0:13officially designated category of whiskey.
- 0:16That's all ahead on the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:39Well, hey everybody, welcome into another special bonus
- 0:42episode of Film and Whiskey. I'm Bob Book and I am flying
- 0:46solo this evening on Oscar nominations night.
- 0:50Folks, if you pay any attention to the Oscars, you know that
- 0:52this is about the second biggest day in the Oscars season.
- 0:55The nominations have been announced.
- 0:57They were delayed by about a week from the fires that are
- 1:01raging through LA, but we finally got the Oscar
- 1:04nominations. There are definitely some
- 1:06surprises. There are definitely some
- 1:07omissions. I would say I don't like using
- 1:10the word snub. And then maybe I'll get into
- 1:12that with our guest today. But we're bringing back on our
- 1:15resident Oscar critic, Indiana Pacers fan and current like 5th
- 1:20place member of our film and whiskey fantasy basketball.
- 1:24Third, Oh, third. I'm sorry, third place in
- 1:26fantasy basketball. It's our friend.
- 1:28Brad, right now? Oh, perfect.
- 1:30That's what everybody wants. It's our friend Daniel Zwayo.
- 1:33Daniel, how are you? I'm good.
- 1:35How about yourself? Sorry for the interruption.
- 1:37You're so No, no, no. I listen, I need to I need to do
- 1:40fact checking for my intros. I was going off fives and gut
- 1:42feel and it's important that we get the the records and and
- 1:47draft order straight for our fantasy basketball for next
- 1:49year. So thank you for the correction.
- 1:52Daniel's joining us this evening, A, because he's a great
- 1:55guy and I like talking to him. But B, he just wrote a piece for
- 2:00rodgerebert.com today about the Oscar nominations.
- 2:03He's been writing pieces for the last couple weeks leading up to
- 2:06the Oscars. He is our resident Oscar critic
- 2:09and he knows a lot more about this stuff than I do.
- 2:11So we're going to pick Daniel's brain a little bit.
- 2:14I guess. Let's start with this, Daniel,
- 2:16looking back on 2024 as a movie year, and I don't want to hear
- 2:21you just say the movie critic thing, which is like every year
- 2:23is a good year for movies if you know where to look.
- 2:26Was 24 a good year for movies or not?
- 2:30Yes, because every year is a good year for movies.
- 2:34It's it's 2024 was not as good of the year as 2023, which is
- 2:38the most obvious comparison because those are the last two
- 2:40years. 2023, I think legitimately had the single
- 2:44best, best picture lineup we've probably ever had, or at the
- 2:48very least the best since 1975. So it's easy to look at 2024 and
- 2:54say, well, the previous year was better.
- 2:57And yeah, that's true, but that's because the previous year
- 2:59was abnormally great. That's fair.
- 3:02That's fair. And I do think that it's a
- 3:04little bit unfair for me to be comparing it so much to 23 when
- 3:08you have films like Oppenheimer, like The Holdovers, like Anatomy
- 3:12of a Fall or Past Lives. But I just couldn't help but
- 3:15think through most of my movie viewings this year.
- 3:19Like, damn, if The Holdovers had just held out for one more year,
- 3:22it could have absolutely dominated everything this year.
- 3:26It, it feels like a year that was ripe for something to come
- 3:28along and really assert itself. And I would say pretty much
- 3:34every movie that's been in contention this year is either
- 3:37too divisive to get that consensus or the consensus
- 3:41around it has just been that it's like an 8 out of 10 and not
- 3:44anything better than that. I I just don't feel like we had
- 3:46anything breakthrough as a as an all timer movie this year.
- 3:50Well, I have a question about what you just said.
- 3:51And this could be that it's not an either or it could be a both
- 3:54things are true at once. But I wonder, are the films
- 3:58actually divisive, or have people just gotten more divisive
- 4:01in their reactions to things? Yeah, I, you know what, I think
- 4:05this year is probably a banner year for Film Twitter steering
- 4:11Award season more than maybe any other year.
- 4:14And I think my example, this is complete conjecture and
- 4:17conspiracy theory now, but when when Dune Part 2 came out early
- 4:22in the year, you know, end of February, early March, I think
- 4:24is when that movie came out. And it was just getting so much
- 4:28love and appreciation and awards prognosticator saying like it's
- 4:33going to dominate the Oscars. And then within about a month
- 4:37you started hearing, well, I wonder if The Academy Is going
- 4:40to honor this film because historically they haven't
- 4:44nominated second chapters in a trilogy and maybe they'll hold
- 4:48off. And I felt like it almost became
- 4:51a self fulfilling prophecy that enough people told Academy
- 4:55members through their various channels and podcasts and
- 4:58everything else, hey, you probably won't nominate this
- 5:01that it that it ended up not really getting any nominations.
- 5:05I'm I'm truly shocked, especially with Dune and the
- 5:07studio behind it, that it has not made more of an awards push
- 5:10this season. Yeah.
- 5:12I mean, I got Best picture and I got a handful of craft
- 5:14categories. I think it ended up with five or
- 5:15six nominations. I think a few things are
- 5:17happening there. I mean, first of all, I think
- 5:18that I apologize if I'm not remembering the timeline
- 5:23correctly, but I think that when Dune Part 2 came out, there
- 5:26wasn't a third yet. And it was like a week later
- 5:30that then they they announced the third movie.
- 5:32And so I think what may be happening there is that people
- 5:36thought it would be a major Oscar player because people
- 5:38thought it was movie 2 out of two.
- 5:41And then all of a sudden it became movie 2 out of 3.
- 5:43And so people rolled back their expectations.
- 5:45I would also say that, well, yeah, you're right that people
- 5:48were saying that in March. Anyone's saying that in March is
- 5:52just wrong because you can never say any movie is going to
- 5:55dominate the Oscars of March because we don't know what the
- 5:57contenders are going to be yet. It's like, it's like me
- 6:00predicting who's going to win the NBA title three years from
- 6:02now and I don't know who the rosters many teams are going to
- 6:04be. Right.
- 6:05Well, there is a movie that I think won the audience award
- 6:07this year at was it Sundance or it's called the.
- 6:10The life of Chuck. Yeah, that was it.
- 6:12Toronto. I saw that in Toronto.
- 6:13I really liked it. It got great reviews and it just
- 6:16got held. It never came out this year.
- 6:18I ended up we we participate in this thing thing for Vulture
- 6:21called the movies Fantasy League.
- 6:23I ended up drafting it for my team because it was a steal
- 6:26because no one knew if it was going to get released.
- 6:28But I think that just goes to show even towards the end of the
- 6:30season, you know, in September, we had no idea if somebody was
- 6:34going to pick this up and try to give it a push for Oscar season.
- 6:37Yeah. All right, Daniel, let's get
- 6:38into talking about the nominations themselves.
- 6:40So this is where I wish we had Brad present because Brad, a
- 6:44host of a movie podcast, is, I think a pretty good gauge of
- 6:49what the average person's knowledge of the field looks
- 6:52like. He doesn't go seeking out what
- 6:55are the Oscar movies for me to see this year.
- 6:57He kind of lets it come to him. And what I found increasingly
- 7:00over the last 5-6 years is that even smaller movies, which would
- 7:05have gotten some level of marketing are getting next to
- 7:08nothing now. And so people like Brad, I will
- 7:11get to January, February, and he'll say, I've never heard of
- 7:15this film before. And the only reason that I've
- 7:18heard of it is because I spent too much of my time on film
- 7:21Twitter. And so I'll have things placed
- 7:23on my radar by people in New York and LA, and they'll say,
- 7:27keep an eye out for this and it'll eventually come out.
- 7:30But as I look through this list of Best Picture nominees, I
- 7:35don't know how many of these the average person will have had any
- 7:39engagement. With.
- 7:40Yeah, I think that's true on the face of it.
- 7:42I mean, it's a correct statement to say that most people will not
- 7:47have heard of most of these movies.
- 7:49I do think that there's an element of people not making
- 7:54themselves available to hear about things anymore.
- 7:58I mean, you know, it used to be the way we heard about movies
- 8:00was because we watched TV and we would see movie trailers.
- 8:02And now we don't see movie trailers on TV anymore.
- 8:05So realistically, you know, how are people finding out about new
- 8:08movies? If if you don't ever expose
- 8:11yourself to something with commercials, then what do you
- 8:15realistically expect to have? Where do you, how do you expect
- 8:17to encounter movie trailers? And if you don't go to movies
- 8:22because you don't know what's out, then you all start seeing
- 8:24trailers in front of other movies.
- 8:26Yeah. So do you still think that at
- 8:28the root of it, this is an issue with consumers and the way we
- 8:32consume things more than it is an advertiser issue and the way
- 8:36that they're targeting people? Well, I think part of what
- 8:40you're talking about is the sort of relationship between the
- 8:44Oscars and box office. And traditionally when something
- 8:49gets nominated for a lot of Oscars, it gets a huge box
- 8:52office boost. So a lot of films want to be in
- 8:56theaters when the Oscar nominations happen.
- 9:00The problem is that if every film wants that, then they're
- 9:03all directly competing against each other and none of them can
- 9:06make it. And then you leave September,
- 9:08October, November to vacant. So some movies open September,
- 9:15October, November. Other movies wait till January
- 9:19when nominations happen. As the sort of art film world
- 9:27keeps getting further and further removed from just the
- 9:29general theatrical zeitgeist, and as audiences keep wanting to
- 9:33watch kind of nothing but franchise movies, it becomes a
- 9:37lot harder. And, you know, so then you'll
- 9:39have films that that deliberately wait to open for
- 9:42Oscar nominations, like September 5 or Nickel Boys.
- 9:46And then they don't get the nominations that they thought
- 9:48they would, or only a few of them, which that means they
- 9:51won't make the money they thought they would.
- 9:54And it becomes a vicious cycle. Yeah, Yep.
- 9:57I think it's mostly about consumers.
- 9:58I also think it's just part of modern life.
- 10:00I mean, so you and I are in a basketball league.
- 10:02We're both huge basketball fans. One of the biggest conversation
- 10:05topics about the NBA the last few years is why are the ratings
- 10:08so far down? Why, you know, what's what's
- 10:10wrong? Why aren't people enjoying the
- 10:11NBA? And, you know, I listened to, I
- 10:16listened to the Six Trophies podcast with Shay Serrano and
- 10:18Jason Concepcion. I was listening to a new episode
- 10:20earlier today and they put it specifically, it's like the
- 10:24razor down for Basil because the razor down for everything.
- 10:27Because in 1994 there were seven things on TV and now there are
- 10:313000 things on TV, 4 million things on YouTube, everyone has
- 10:35Spotify, everyone has 10 streaming services.
- 10:39It's like what? What do you realistically expect
- 10:42in a different reality when there are 7 things to watch for
- 10:457,000,000 Things to watch? Yeah, I think that's fair.
- 10:48And I'm not trying to to be the hot take guy, but I've been
- 10:51thinking a lot about this crop of Oscar nominees, especially
- 10:55compared to last year's, where I felt like they did a good job of
- 10:57capturing both really populist movies and also movies that
- 11:01built word of mouth throughout Oscar season.
- 11:04I'm hoping that's what we get this year.
- 11:06But it it seems like the Oscars are always teetering on the
- 11:09brink of like complete implosion.
- 11:12And 2024 looks to be a crop of movies that may not help their
- 11:16case a lot when it comes to viewership and awareness.
- 11:20So I want to just let me name the best picture nominees for
- 11:24this year. You've got Anora the Brutalist,
- 11:28a complete unknown, Conclave, Dune Part 2, Amelia Perez, I'm
- 11:35still here, Nickel Boys, The Substance and Wicked.
- 11:41Now, I would say that roughly half of these have broken
- 11:46through enough in the zeitgeist in the mainstream that people
- 11:49will have at least heard of them, right?
- 11:51Like a complete unknown conclave dune.
- 11:54I would say the substance, it's such a big hit now and wicked
- 11:57for sure. The other five are, I think,
- 12:00trying to make their case. Some of these are definitely a
- 12:03surprise. And I'll I'll kind of let you go
- 12:05ahead and tease your article today.
- 12:07What were the biggest surprises, both in terms of what made it
- 12:10and what didn't make it in this Best Picture crop?
- 12:12Best Picture went pretty expectedly.
- 12:17I got 8 of 10 right. I think most people got 8 of 10
- 12:20right. The two surprises were I'm Still
- 12:23Here in Nickel Boys. The two movies that I think
- 12:26people most commonly predicted to be in those spots were a real
- 12:30pain in Sing Sing, with a few people also thinking September 5
- 12:34would make it. I'd say the I'd say it's
- 12:37somewhat surprising the real pain isn't there.
- 12:39But I didn't think it was a sure thing because there were only
- 12:41two other categories that it was really expected to be a major
- 12:43player in, which were original screenplay and Supporting Actor,
- 12:46both of which it did get nominated for.
- 12:48But often when a film is only really going to be a factor in
- 12:51two other categories, it's hard to say the Best Picture support
- 12:55is truly there. I think from year to year and
- 12:57with this new Academy make up that we have, it's it's both
- 13:01exciting and it's super frustrating because you can't
- 13:04really pigeonhole movies the way he used to be able to write.
- 13:08Like I loved a real pain. It was one of my favorite movies
- 13:11of the year. And I really thought that based
- 13:14on the kind of vibes it was giving off and the audience
- 13:17reactions I saw in person when I saw the film, I was like, oh,
- 13:20this is the holdovers for this year.
- 13:23It this is going to slot right into that holdover spot and
- 13:26really make a play. And you know, they gave it the
- 13:29big September push. So I thought that it was in
- 13:31prime position for a traditional Oscar campaign, and that just
- 13:35apparently didn't work. Whether it was the movie itself
- 13:38or the sort of traditional way it was being pushed, it really
- 13:42never caught on with Oscar voters.
- 13:45And I think as I look through this list of 10 movies, you
- 13:48know, I'm, I'm trying to kind of parse out like, oh, you know,
- 13:51this is this year's Killers of the Flower Moon or this is this
- 13:54year's Oppenheimer. And it's both a good and a bad
- 13:58thing that nothing really seems to be mapping 1 to one in terms
- 14:01of what would make it in in prior years.
- 14:04Yeah. And you know, something you said
- 14:06about, you know, the Academy has grown and it's certainly artier
- 14:12and certainly more international than it used to be.
- 14:14It's a double edged sword because, you know, certainly
- 14:17that is manifesting the results. But in the old Oscar years,
- 14:22people used to complain every year about how many things got
- 14:26in that were just that seemed like pure Oscar bait.
- 14:29I mean, some movies that come to mind are like The Reader in Cold
- 14:33Mountain and Extremely Loud and Incredibly close.
- 14:37And movies like that don't get Best Picture nominations
- 14:39anymore. But that's a good thing, because
- 14:41when they did, people complain every year like who?
- 14:43Who wants those movies? And so now it's movies that
- 14:47certainly has smaller audiences, but at least somebody does
- 14:50actually want them, even if that's a smaller number of
- 14:52people. Well, I think that's a perfect
- 14:54segue into talking about perhaps the biggest lightning rod of
- 14:56this Oscars race, and that is Emilia Perez.
- 14:59Yeah, that's the exception. I'm not sure who does want that.
- 15:02So folks, if if you've not heard of Emilia Perez, it's a Netflix
- 15:05film. It is perhaps best known because
- 15:07of who's in it and that is specifically Selena Gomez in a
- 15:11supporting role. She of $1 billion in make up
- 15:14money now. So it's it's a very politically
- 15:19charged and I don't know hot button topic movie that no one
- 15:26seems to like because it certainly would seem to check
- 15:30the what what would be considered traditional liberal
- 15:33boxes of Hollywood. And yet the audience for whom it
- 15:36is apparently being made has pretty much wholesale rejected
- 15:40it as having really regressive ideologies.
- 15:43And then obviously anyone on the opposite side of the political
- 15:46spectrum from this movie is already not going to like it.
- 15:49It got mixed to negative reviews from most critics, and yet it
- 15:53has pretty much dominated award season.
- 15:56Daniel, is it just? Because of the international
- 15:59make up of the Academy. Now because this movie seemed to
- 16:01do well at the Globes too. But I don't think anyone could
- 16:05have seen this getting 13 Oscar nominations.
- 16:08Well, so a slight correction there that really shocks me.
- 16:12When I was researching a piece I was writing the other day, I
- 16:15looked up the Metacritic score of Amelia Perez, which I
- 16:19expected to be really low. And it turns out the Metacritic
- 16:22score is 71, which is actually pretty high.
- 16:26And I confess I don't understand it because every critic I've
- 16:29actually seen or listened to speak about the film has not
- 16:32liked it. So I don't know where that 71
- 16:36score comes from, but I, I believe it's accurate.
- 16:40I mean, I, you know, it's not like I think anyone is
- 16:42nefariously manipulating scores over at the Metacritic.
- 16:45I, I believe that score is mathematically correct.
- 16:49I just don't understand who those people are.
- 16:51And are they like, in hiding or are they in critical witness
- 16:54protection because they don't want to admit to liking Amelia
- 16:58Perez? Yeah, I don't know, man, but it
- 17:01definitely seems to be in pole position here.
- 17:03Nothing's really challenging it right now in terms of sheer
- 17:07numbers of nominations. The next highest nomination
- 17:10getters are Wicked and the Brutalist tied for ten
- 17:13nominations. Well, and so sorry, one one last
- 17:16thing about Emilio Perez we should talk about.
- 17:18You know, so you mentioned how a lot of people that the movie
- 17:20seems to be 4 don't seem to like the movie.
- 17:23And that's true, but there's the difference between so it's a
- 17:27movie in Spanish and takes place in Mexico, but it was made by
- 17:31Europeans. A lot of the pushback we're
- 17:35seeing on the movie comes from people of Latino descent, but I
- 17:41think a lot of the support for the movie is coming from the
- 17:43Europeans in the Academy. That's like the European
- 17:47aesthetic of the film. Yeah, well, I think I've also
- 17:50seen a ton of pushback from the transgender community on this
- 17:53movie as well. And I I, if I can try to map it
- 17:56to another recent nominee, I think this is really kind of
- 17:59filling the the void of the triangle of sadness.
- 18:03How the hell did this movie get in the best picture race?
- 18:06And again, it it's a, this movie is certainly not a satire, but
- 18:10it has the cheekiness of a European made film about issues
- 18:14of it, you know, Triangle of Sadness, it's issues of class
- 18:17and race. This movie, it's issues of
- 18:20gender and race. And I think that it's definitely
- 18:23performing better with non American critics than it has
- 18:28with anyone I've seen in America.
- 18:30Yeah, I mean, the way I've sort of explained Amelia Perez to
- 18:34people is it feels to me like Baz Luhrmann cosplay.
- 18:38And. I don't like Baz Luhrmann.
- 18:40I haven't really liked any Baz Luhrmann films.
- 18:43So it makes sense that Emilia Perez also isn't working for me.
- 18:46But most Baz Luhrmann films do really well at the Oscars.
- 18:49I mean, a few years ago Elvis got it a lot of nominations and
- 18:53I did not think Elvis was a good movie.
- 18:54But, you know, there's there's obvious precedent that there are
- 18:59people in awards bodies that like Baz Luhrmann films.
- 19:03And so it makes sense that they also like Amelia Perez.
- 19:06Well, since you've now outed yourself as a Bazelerman
- 19:08detractor, I'm going to go out on a limb here and I'm going to
- 19:11say something that is probably going to get me drawn and
- 19:13quartered in film criticism circles.
- 19:17The brutalist did not do it for me, man.
- 19:19I went to see it last week and I was so incredibly pumped after
- 19:23that first half. And I I will join the chorus of
- 19:25people who just say the second-half landed with a real
- 19:28thud. I thought the epilogue that was
- 19:30tacked on at the end was really ham handed and just did not work
- 19:36for me. Overall it felt like an exercise
- 19:39in Letterbox to Bros making a movie that captures the form of
- 19:45films that they love without the real substance underneath it.
- 19:48I'm curious to hear what you thought of the Brutalist because
- 19:51it seems like this is now A2 horse race between Emilia Perez
- 19:54and the Brutalist. Yeah, so.
- 19:56Well, so first of all, I'm going to disagree with the last thing
- 19:58you said. I think there are other films
- 20:00very much in the best picture race and I wouldn't even say
- 20:02that those are the top 2, but we can get to that later.
- 20:05The Brutalist I saw in Toronto, I've been meaning to see it
- 20:08again. So I've still only seen it the
- 20:10one time, which was, you know, four months ago now.
- 20:14I mostly agree with you that the ending didn't work.
- 20:17I would say I would be a little more generous and say it's 3/4
- 20:21of a great movie than just half a great movie.
- 20:23I even thought. That the first half of the
- 20:25second-half of the movie was really great.
- 20:27The third quarter if you will. I agree the ending did not work,
- 20:32but man, it's such a big swing and the first half and even the
- 20:391st 3/4 I think are so good and so just inspiring for the way a
- 20:47big swing should make you feel when you're watching it that you
- 20:50sort of forgiven anything. I mean, you know, I, I was
- 20:53listening to Sean Fennessy and Adam Naman talk about it on the
- 20:57best picture. And what Adam Naman said was
- 20:59that it's the, the Brady Corbett is the only person out there
- 21:05even trying to make a Francis Ford Coppola movie.
- 21:07And I thought that was a that was a great way to phrase it.
- 21:10But like you, you watch it and you see the same ambition that
- 21:14you see in things like The Godfather and Citizen Kane and
- 21:16There Will Be Blood. And that's not to say that it
- 21:19lands as perfectly as any of those movies, but man, that
- 21:22ambition goes a goes a long way to how you feel about it.
- 21:25Yeah, for sure. And I don't want to be overly
- 21:27negative about the movie, but I, I feel like there is a crop of
- 21:30young film makers that are coming up now who have been
- 21:33equally raised on film history and Instagram.
- 21:38And so, you know, you say, hey, I made my movie in Vista Vision
- 21:42as if that lends credence to the film itself.
- 21:45And I really appreciated some of the imagery in the movie, but it
- 21:48felt like a big exercise in worshipping at the altar of film
- 21:53without the actual religious. This experience of having a good
- 21:56movie presented to you, at times you know it, it really felt kind
- 22:00of hollow to me. Yeah, I think in a way, watching
- 22:02The Brutalist is almost experiencing the art form of
- 22:08movies conceptually more than it is experiencing a singular
- 22:11movie. Yeah.
- 22:12I mean, even watching the trailer for The Brutalist, you
- 22:15just sort of feel like you're in the presence of something that
- 22:18is going for it. Yeah.
- 22:20And you know, people have talked for years about the A 24
- 22:23aesthetic and I don't always buy into that stuff, but this might
- 22:26be the most a 24 movie of all time.
- 22:28Like it is, it is marketed as an experience from A 24 and I think
- 22:34it really does appeal to that sort of, again, I'll say the
- 22:37phrase like the letterbox to bro who wants to experience a
- 22:42Francis Ford Coppola movie. And it just did not quite hit
- 22:46that height for me. Yeah, I I do want to see it
- 22:48again because the ending really didn't work for me the first
- 22:52time I saw it. But now that I will go in with
- 22:55different expectations, I'm curious how it will land for me.
- 22:58All right. If there's two movies that I
- 22:59think for me are kind of the dark horses in this race, or at
- 23:02least contenders in this race, I think Enora is still hanging
- 23:06around. Enora was the front runner back
- 23:09in October. It really seems to have fallen
- 23:11off and taken the back seat. I'll be interested to see what
- 23:14the campaign does from here and call it the traditionalist in
- 23:17me, but I still think that Conclave might have a punch to
- 23:21land. It is by.
- 23:23Far, I think the crowd pleaser of the bunch, if the boomers
- 23:26that are still represented in the Academy have anything to
- 23:29say. It just feels like a good old
- 23:32fashioned. Lots of dialogue, lots of
- 23:35scenery chewing. The problem with that is that
- 23:39Edward Berger didn't get a director nomination to back it
- 23:41up. So I'm curious to hear you said
- 23:43that there are other movies in this list that you think could
- 23:46challenge what is still on the radar for you?
- 23:48Yeah. So if you want to go sort of
- 23:51inside baseball with how the breast, with how the best
- 23:53picture ballot works, of the 10 best picture nominees, it seems
- 23:57pretty clear that there are six of them that like really have a
- 24:01lot of support and four that don't have as much support.
- 24:03The six that really have a lot of support are Inora, the
- 24:07Brutalist Conclave, a Complete Unknown, Wicked and Amelia
- 24:11Perez. I would separate those six into
- 24:13two groups. The Brutalist, Amelia Perez and
- 24:17Wicked are the three that I don't think can win.
- 24:20Best Picture, Anora Conclave and A Complete Unknown are the three
- 24:25that I think can. And I would expect the Best
- 24:26picture winner to be one of those three.
- 24:29And the way I would describe the difference is the way the Best
- 24:32Picture preferential ballot works is, you know, so there are
- 24:3710 films and voters rank all 10. And then there are elimination
- 24:40cycles. For a film to survive and
- 24:44actually win Best Picture, two things need to happen.
- 24:46First, it needs to have a lot of first place votes.
- 24:49You can't survive the early eliminations without having a
- 24:51lot of first place votes. That's how we know something
- 24:53like Nickel Boys or I'm Still Here are not going to win Best
- 24:55Picture because they're not going to have enough first place
- 24:57votes to survive the early eliminations.
- 24:58They're going to be the first films eliminated from the
- 25:00process. But once the early eliminations
- 25:04happen and we start getting deeper onto people's ballots,
- 25:081st place votes don't matter as much.
- 25:10Anymore. At that point, what most matters
- 25:12is being last on the fewest number of ballots.
- 25:17So movies like the Brutalist and Amelia Perez and Wicked
- 25:21obviously have a lot of fans they have.
- 25:24They will get enough first place votes to survive those early
- 25:26eliminations. But I also think they have a lot
- 25:30of detractors and they will be at the bottom of too many
- 25:34ballots to ultimately win. Which is why I think either a
- 25:38Nora Conclave or a complete unknown will be the winner.
- 25:41Because those are the movies where two things are true.
- 25:44One, they're going to have enough first place votes to get
- 25:47through the early eliminations. And two, they won't be at the
- 25:51bottom of very many ballots. The one thing that's true those
- 25:543 movies is no one really hates them.
- 25:56I mean, look, it's 2025 and the Internet exists so there are
- 26:00obviously people that hate them. But generally speaking, in a
- 26:04voting body of 10,000 people, those are the three films that
- 26:07don't really have many haters. So I think that the best picture
- 26:10will come from one of those 3. Now there is a lot of time for
- 26:14politicking and for campaigning over the next, what, six weeks
- 26:17until we get to the Oscars. If you had to put money down
- 26:20today on one of those three, what do you think is A currently
- 26:26your pick for that, and B what do you think is actually going
- 26:29to withstand the next six weeks of campaigning to come out on
- 26:32top? Man, Conclave seems like the
- 26:37safest bet purely because it's the one that I almost can't
- 26:40imagine what the backlash is going to be like.
- 26:43Inora, you're going to get backlash about like, is it the
- 26:47male gaze? There's already been the
- 26:49intimacy coordinator backlash and a complete unknown.
- 26:53You're going to get the backlash like is it Oscar bait?
- 26:55Are music biopics good? Do they like are they terrible?
- 26:59Is this like Bohemian Rhapsody all over again?
- 27:01And look, I hated Bohemian Rhapsody and I love complete
- 27:03unknown. So I don't think movies are
- 27:04comparable, but there will be takes that they are comparable.
- 27:09Conclave is the one where like, I just kind of don't see what
- 27:12people are going to attack it from in in in a way it's, you
- 27:16know, maybe the most boring is not the right word because I
- 27:19think conclave is a really good movie.
- 27:21It's it's probably the least challenging of the best comedies
- 27:26other than, you know, Wicked, which isn't really trying to be
- 27:28challenging, but that can work in it's favor.
- 27:31Do you think we still live in a world where you need a Best
- 27:34Director nomination to back up your Best Picture nomination to
- 27:37have a real shot? Yes and no.
- 27:40I think that over the course of a decade, you probably have nine
- 27:45years where the Best Picture winner also gets a Best Director
- 27:47nomination. But there are exceptions in as
- 27:52long as it happens rarely, not getting a best director
- 27:56nomination can be actually a boon for a movie.
- 27:58I mean, we, we saw this happen with Argo in 2012 where there
- 28:01was such outcry that Ben Affleck didn't get a nomination that it
- 28:05made people like the film even more.
- 28:06And look, I, I love Argo. I think I'm even going to be on
- 28:08a podcast with you talking about Argos.
- 28:11But you have to acknowledge that a part of Argo's journey to the
- 28:16best picture microphone at the end of that Oscar night, but
- 28:20part of that journey was Ben Affleck not getting a direction.
- 28:22And that played directly into the campaign and the way people
- 28:25felt about the movie. Yeah, for sure.
- 28:27And particularly with Edward Berger and Conclave, I think
- 28:30it's really interesting that, you know, so he also directed
- 28:33All Quiet on the Western Front two years ago.
- 28:35He did not get a best best director nomination for that one
- 28:37either. And All Quiet on the Western
- 28:40Front and Conclave, together, those two movies got 17 Oscar
- 28:44nominations, and he didn't get a director nomination for either
- 28:471. So that speaks to that will
- 28:50speak to a feeling that this guy has not gotten his due and that
- 28:53could help the movie. Yeah, I mean, he and Denis
- 28:56Villeneuve can be hanging out in the Losers Club on Oscar night
- 29:00because once again, Denis not nominated for a Dune film, which
- 29:03is it was expected. It still shocks me.
- 29:07Like I I just don't really know what the guy has to do with his
- 29:11gigantic tentpole movie to earn himself some Oscar love.
- 29:16That's beside the point because I think we both agreed Dune is
- 29:18absolutely out of the running here.
- 29:20Daniel, before I let you go, what I appreciated about your
- 29:23article was you also don't use this word snub.
- 29:26I don't like talking about snubs when it comes to the Oscars
- 29:28because it implies some sort of objective collective truth and
- 29:33that someone was ignored instead of just there being a pool of
- 29:36really good people to choose from with.
- 29:38With that said, what are some films or performances or
- 29:43whatever what have you that you wish you could have seen listed
- 29:47here today? Yeah, I agree with you that I
- 29:49don't like the word snub because snub implies an agenda that I
- 29:52don't think is what's happening with 99% of Oscar emissions now.
- 29:57Every once in a while there is something I think is a genuine
- 30:00snub. The best example I think is last
- 30:02year when the French film A Taste of Things was left out of
- 30:05the best International Film Race.
- 30:07I think that was a genuine snub that I think people deliberately
- 30:10didn't vote for it because they were so outraged that France
- 30:12chose that movie instead of Anatomy of a Fall.
- 30:14So it was a real sort of screw this movie kind of movement.
- 30:17That is a case where I think the word snub is fair to use.
- 30:20But for the most part it's, you know, I mean, like we said, the
- 30:23the Academy has 10,000 members and you got 10,000 people voting
- 30:30on their taste and it's like. If if.
- 30:35It's going to be weird. You know they're going to be
- 30:36weird results. The results won't make sense a
- 30:39lot of the time. But to say snub implies that you
- 30:42think people sort of like had this hidden agenda, which I
- 30:46think is almost never what's happening.
- 30:48In some ways, I think the best case to use the word snub isn't
- 30:53when people watch something and didn't like it, but rather when
- 30:58the evidence sort of suggests that people didn't watch a movie
- 31:00at all. So, you know, answer your
- 31:03question, what I really wish would have been there to me, the
- 31:07best active performance of 2024 in either weed or supporting any
- 31:12gender. Just by far and away what I
- 31:15thought it was the performance of the year was Marian Jean
- 31:17Baptiste in the British film Hard Truths.
- 31:21I just saw it last night and that the movie didn't land for
- 31:24me as well as it did with others, but the performance
- 31:26absolutely did. Yeah.
- 31:27And so she one best actress from every major critics group in the
- 31:33country, New York Film Critics, Los Angeles, Chicago, National
- 31:37Society of Film Critics, they all gave her best actress.
- 31:40I don't think that Academy members watched that movie and
- 31:46disagreed about her performance. I think they just didn't watch
- 31:49the movie. And that's a different problem.
- 31:53It's in some ways a more depressing problem.
- 31:58I have, if anyone, I will spare it from you in this podcast.
- 32:02But I have gone on rants online that I think the reason voters
- 32:05aren't watching that movie is because it is a movie about
- 32:08black women. And I think for voting bodies
- 32:13that are largely white male, you can convince white men to watch
- 32:18movies about black men. You can convince white men to
- 32:21watch movies about white women. I think it's hard to convince
- 32:24white men to watch movies about black women.
- 32:26It feels too distanced from their experience and I think a
- 32:30lot of the most surprising Oscar omissions in the recent years,
- 32:33whether it be Daniel Dedweiler for till two years ago, whether
- 32:38it be the Woman King getting 0 nominations, whether it be Hard
- 32:41Truths today, whether it be Daniel Dedweiler in The Piano
- 32:44Lesson today. I think there's a real
- 32:46commonality of stories about black women being ignored.
- 32:50And again, I just, I don't think it's because voters are watching
- 32:53movies and thinking they're good.
- 32:55I think it's that voters just feel overwhelmed by their two
- 32:59watch stacks and the movies that end up falling out of the
- 33:04rotation are the movies about black women.
- 33:07That's a good point. Yeah.
- 33:08I mean, I think that my pick for her, for who I would have in the
- 33:11best actress lineup is someone who didn't even make a dent in
- 33:15awards season. But it was my favorite
- 33:17performance of the year just because it was so kind of
- 33:19deliciously scene chewing. And that was Zendaya in
- 33:23Challengers. I thought that she absolutely
- 33:25knocked it out of the park in that movie.
- 33:27And it was it was a challenging role.
- 33:29She had to age from basically, I think like 17 up to mid 30s.
- 33:33And, and the absolute command that she had at the center of
- 33:36that movie, I think she's she has a presence, a screen
- 33:41presence that exceeds her, both her experience and her years on
- 33:45screen. It made me really excited for
- 33:48what's to come with Zendaya. Yeah, and I really liked
- 33:51Challengers. And you know, so Mary Angelina
- 33:55Baptiste was the the omission today that I was the saddest
- 34:00about. The one that I was the most
- 34:02purely shocked about was the Challengers didn't get nominated
- 34:04for either score or original song, both which were by Trent
- 34:08Reznor and Atticus Ross, both of which were outstanding.
- 34:11It won best original score at the Golden Globes, which I would
- 34:14have thought would at least sew it up for a nomination.
- 34:19Yeah, but that didn't happen. That was, I think, the biggest
- 34:22pure surprise of the morning. Well, if we're talking about
- 34:24film Twitter stuff, I thought that it might sneak into
- 34:26cinematography as well. There's some really inventive
- 34:29camera work there. Well, and same with editing, the
- 34:31way they, the way they assemble the tennis matches.
- 34:33Yeah, I mean it. It got blanked and I was really
- 34:35surprised. Daniel, I want to thank you for
- 34:37jumping on with us talking about the Oscars.
- 34:39You've gotten me re excited about the Oscars after a day
- 34:42looking at a list of movies that I frankly didn't love this year.
- 34:46So tell us a little bit more about what you're writing.
- 34:48Where can we find you to get more excited about this Oscar
- 34:51season? So like you said, I, I wrote,
- 34:54wrote two pieces for Roger Ebert's this week. 1 was
- 34:57predictions of how the nominations would go.
- 34:59And then there was a piece today about what wasn't there and, and
- 35:03why and sort of how it happened that way.
- 35:07I will be doing Oscar predictions for Roger Ebert's
- 35:10the week before the show. Other than that, I'm not sure
- 35:14yet, but we'll see. You can find Daniel on Twitter
- 35:17at Third Man Movies. Are you?
- 35:19Are you? Have you made the switch to Blue
- 35:20Sky yet? Yes, I was just going to say I'm
- 35:21also at Blue Sky at the same address.
- 35:23Third man movies third spelled out THIRD.
- 35:26Daniel Zwio, thank you so much for joining us today.
- 35:29Thank you, Bob. I appreciate it.
- 35:30Always fun to talk to you. All right, we're joined once
- 35:39again by Mark McLaughlin from Old Blind Spirits.
- 35:43Mark, it's been like a year and a half since we had you on the
- 35:45show. How's it going, man?
- 35:47Hey, glad to be back. Things are going pretty well.
- 35:50You know, had a 2024 was kind of a wild ride and mostly in good
- 35:53ways and churning away 2025. So you know, things are moving
- 35:57in the right direction. We're good.
- 35:58How are you? We're doing great, man.
- 36:00I was. I was saying that it's good to
- 36:02actually see your face for the first time.
- 36:04We're chatting over Zoom. I don't know what happened last
- 36:06time, but you you were reminding us that I think you were like at
- 36:10home in your bed or something the last time we talked.
- 36:12So you know, at least now you've got like the the zip up old line
- 36:16vest on. You look like a professional.
- 36:18That's right. That's right.
- 36:19Yeah, yeah, yeah. And the and the listeners can
- 36:20take the, the, you know, the, the bedroom thing however they
- 36:22want, you know. It was an interesting
- 36:25conversation to say, at least. It it just confirmed for me how
- 36:29sultry the sound of my voice must be, Brad.
- 36:31That's that's what it is. Moving on from that, I.
- 36:36Mean listen. Hey, so we've been going back
- 36:38through some of our past episodes, Brad.
- 36:40We've been updating a lot on the our film and whiskey website and
- 36:43we've been adding a lot of our old whiskey reviews as blog
- 36:46posts. And we've actually seen a lot of
- 36:48traffic on the site from some of these blog posts.
- 36:50And I just updated the last time we had old wine on the show, we
- 36:55reviewed 3 of their whiskeys. So we did their bottled and
- 36:58bond. We did their Madera cask finish
- 37:01and their Port cask finish. Now, in addition to those three,
- 37:04we also had a a separate episode with Mark just kind of talking
- 37:08about the history of the brand where we called out their Navy
- 37:11strength 114 proof American single malt.
- 37:15And dare I say, Brad, it might be my favorite American single
- 37:20malt on the market right now. Dude it is bonkers how delicious
- 37:25old line spirits 114 is. That Navy strength just kicks
- 37:30ass man. I'm also like curious.
- 37:32So like Navy strength is 114 where?
- 37:35Where would you put like army strength whiskey?
- 37:37Oh man, well under 100. OK, that's what I figured.
- 37:40Yeah, that's like the whiskey that you can sell outside the
- 37:44liquor store 'cause they've proved it down to like 48 proof.
- 37:47Does that mean that like marine strength is just like really
- 37:51stupid? But it's like 148 proof like.
- 37:54Yeah, it's kind of like. Way too much to handle.
- 37:56Yeah. It's just very volatile, you
- 37:58know? Yeah.
- 38:01So Mark is back to join us once again.
- 38:03He's brought along 4 different spirits for us to sample as we
- 38:06talk. But what we really brought him
- 38:08in for was this new development in the TTB world.
- 38:11Folks, we really don't get into the legality behind our products
- 38:14very often, but there's been a. Feeling we should.
- 38:17I feel like we should though, Bob, that that's what everybody
- 38:19is looking for. Like what is the legal world
- 38:22behind spirits? I think we just try to cover it
- 38:25with the blanket statement like this is legal.
- 38:27Trust me, you know, that's kind of what we we typically do here.
- 38:32But but the TTB recently designated American single malt
- 38:36as an official category in the world of spirits.
- 38:39And this has been something that's been brewing for a long
- 38:41time. There's been a lot of lobbying
- 38:43going on to get it recognized as an official category.
- 38:46Now, what does that mean for the average consumer, Brad?
- 38:49I don't know. You don't know.
- 38:50We just know that we're still drinking delicious whiskey.
- 38:52And so we've brought Mark along to kind of fill us in as average
- 38:57Joe's on what this means for us, for our wallets, for the shelves
- 39:01and the selection that we might see, but also what it looks like
- 39:04for a producer of American single malt.
- 39:07So Mark, we're going to be kind of tapping into your expertise
- 39:10today, man. Yeah, well, hey, no, happy to be
- 39:13here. And I mean, do you want to jump
- 39:15right in to to what you queued up there?
- 39:17I mean, yeah. All right.
- 39:19Well, so the yeah, the category recognition has been, that's
- 39:23been something like you said that that's been in the works
- 39:25for years. And one of the most interesting
- 39:28things about that, in my opinion, is that it's we as a
- 39:31category of producers, American single malt, we were, we were
- 39:34all producing this thing we called American single malt
- 39:37whiskey. And we were all adhering to a
- 39:39set of a definition that we all agreed to as a group of
- 39:41producers, but it didn't really exist, right?
- 39:43We were, we were very, very broadly under the government
- 39:47rules called an American malt whiskey, which had a pretty wide
- 39:50range of definition. And then so we were all acting
- 39:53as if this existed and encouraging and pushing the
- 39:57government to place a, a definition around it.
- 40:00And you know, one perspective on that, which was originally my
- 40:03perspective, was why would we encourage the government to come
- 40:05in? And place any sort of, you know,
- 40:08definition on something that is right now we have more
- 40:10flexibility. Why encourage the oversight?
- 40:13And where I was convinced that I was wrong and I think I was
- 40:16wrong is that, you know, the government eventually was going
- 40:18to do this anyway. Probably not in 2024 without the
- 40:20big push, but eventually as the category grows that we're going
- 40:23to do it. And who knows, without our input
- 40:25what the definition would have been.
- 40:26Somebody, you know, well meaning but not really well versed in
- 40:30ASM might have just, you know, put forth some definition that
- 40:33really, really kind of screwed us.
- 40:34So you. Mean you can't trust politics
- 40:36politicians to like put categories on things they don't
- 40:39really understand. You know, you'd be shocked, you
- 40:41know, you know, it's, it's, it's wild.
- 40:45The, so we, you know, we, we proposed this and as a, as a
- 40:48group, like I said, we all got on the same, same page and, and
- 40:51then it worked. It took longer than we expected,
- 40:53but it worked. And then So what that means for
- 40:56consumers in the near term, I don't think it means much more
- 41:00than an added layer of not respectability.
- 41:04What's the word I'm looking for? Just an added layer of of this
- 41:07is a real thing? This is officially.
- 41:10Legitimacy. Legitimacy is a word I couldn't
- 41:12find. You know, this is the first
- 41:14category of whiskey that the US government has recognized in
- 41:16like 52 years. That's a pretty big deal, we
- 41:18think now. I think what you're going to see
- 41:19is what that gives us as producers is now we have a, you
- 41:23know, every business wants clarity.
- 41:24You know, you always hear about that.
- 41:26You know, when there's going to be changes to taxes or something
- 41:28like that, whether they're good or bad changes to businesses,
- 41:30they, they just want to know so they can plan and grow.
- 41:32So we know, we know what this category now officially looks
- 41:35like and we you can grow from there, which is great.
- 41:37So you know, will you see American single malt whiskey
- 41:40categories in your local liquor store?
- 41:43Maybe, maybe not. I think you will eventually.
- 41:46But in the near term, I think it's just that little, that
- 41:48little tailwind boost of like, hey, we're, you know, we're
- 41:51taking ourselves seriously and so is the government and so are
- 41:53the consumers. Well, and it seems like it would
- 41:55also trickle down into things like a San Francisco spirits
- 42:00competition, right where now you have a formalized category of
- 42:04American single malt that you can win, you know, best in show
- 42:08in and, and things like that. So it seems like it just expands
- 42:12the world and at the end of the day, like it gives the whiskey
- 42:15consumer more things to enjoy. And, and I think that's like the
- 42:20beautiful element of giving it that designation is like now I
- 42:26get like I as a consumer, get to become an expert in something
- 42:29that's brand new and it like that's really fun.
- 42:32Yeah, I agree. I couldn't agree more.
- 42:34And then, you know, the beauty of the definition, the way it
- 42:36was, the way it has become official in my opinion, is that,
- 42:40you know what we didn't want to do when you look at the
- 42:42definition of single malt Scotch or the definition of bourbon or
- 42:45rye whiskey here in America, those definitions make all the
- 42:48sense in the world, right? And, and they and they are
- 42:50pretty tightly defined. And that makes sense when you're
- 42:52a category that's been around for hundreds of years, right?
- 42:54You want to enshrine that so that newcomers don't, you know,
- 42:59do something with the category of bourbon that you don't, you
- 43:01know, that that the the industry and the consumers don't want,
- 43:04right? You know, just, I mean, wacky,
- 43:05call it a bourbon and it hurts the name of bourbon.
- 43:07You know, American Singer Mall is in a different position.
- 43:09We're just starting out. So we want to have a wide enough
- 43:13aperture, if you will, or a wide enough list of options on what
- 43:16we can do with our whiskey that allows us to do something
- 43:18different than Scotch, different than bourbon, but but also have
- 43:23guardrails on so it doesn't get too crazy.
- 43:25So that's really, I think what was done.
- 43:27And a good example of that is, you know, bourbon, as you guys
- 43:29well know, has to be aged in a virgin oak cask, as does
- 43:32American rye whiskey, old line or excuse me, American single
- 43:35malt can be aged in a virgin oak barrel or a used barrel.
- 43:38It doesn't really matter. It, it doesn't matter at all.
- 43:40It's, it's, it's allowed. And that's wonderful because you
- 43:42have certain places like, you know, Virginia Distilling
- 43:45Company, they make one for whiskey down in Virginia and
- 43:47they take a little bit more of an old world approach and old
- 43:49line takes more of a new world virgin oak aging.
- 43:51We can both do that and be in the same category.
- 43:54And I think what you're going to see is, you know, as the, you
- 43:58know, up until now, I think that rum has probably had the widest
- 44:01breadth of flavors in any category.
- 44:03When you look at very, very funky rums from like Martinique
- 44:06to very, very sweet rums from, you know, Puerto Rico or or
- 44:09sometimes the Dominican Republic, places like that, rum
- 44:12is just such a wide open category, which is great.
- 44:14I think American Singapore is going to revival that for the
- 44:16amount of the breadth of flavors that you can get from a category
- 44:19because the definition was left, you know, a little bit more
- 44:22open. I think it's a good segue into
- 44:24talking about the spirits that you sent us to try today.
- 44:27And first of all, thank you for that.
- 44:29Any package that I received that has four different kinds of
- 44:31alcohol in it is always greatly appreciated.
- 44:34Let's go. But like I said, I think we've
- 44:36tried four different spirits from you guys already.
- 44:38We have four more today. Three of them are American
- 44:41single malt. One of them is a rum, which I
- 44:43know excites Brad because when he's not drinking whiskey, he's
- 44:47a rum guy. So, Brad, you're welcome.
- 44:50Thank you. Thank you very much.
- 44:51Mark is my new favorite distiller.
- 44:54Yeah. So I think we should go ahead
- 44:56and dive into this flagship American single mall.
- 44:59This is 95 proof. And I guess my first question
- 45:02mark is like, explain to me the difference between your flagship
- 45:0595 and your bottled and bond, which is at 100.
- 45:08You know, aside from just the fact of, you know, aging or
- 45:11proof point, like is there any sort of different make up to
- 45:15anything here? Or is are we just trying to find
- 45:18a more approachable proof point for the 95?
- 45:21That's a great question. So yeah, there are kind of
- 45:23noteworthy differences. So the we have, we produce our
- 45:26whiskey in two locations. As you guys may remember, we
- 45:28have the distillery that I'm sitting in now where we have a
- 45:30300 gallon pot still and we work with Middle W spirits in
- 45:34Columbus, OH and we use their much, much larger column still
- 45:37and pot still for the stuff we produce out there.
- 45:40So we produce in two locations since we're talking about the
- 45:43category definition or we're talking about that.
- 45:46Now it's important to note that we don't marry any barrels from
- 45:49Ohio with any barrels from Baltimore that would run afoul
- 45:51of the definition. But as long as those barrels,
- 45:53you know, stay Baltimore barrels stay with Baltimore barrels as
- 45:56far as you know, blending and consumption and Ohio barrels
- 45:59stay with Ohio barrels, then we're compliant.
- 46:02So because of for a number of reasons.
- 46:04So the whiskey here is coming off a completely different
- 46:06still. It's double pot stilled
- 46:09distilled. And we also age in here in
- 46:12Maryland. Most of the stuff we produce we
- 46:14put into actually 30 gallon barrels and everything else we
- 46:17do in Ohio, which is, you know, higher volume is goes into 53
- 46:21gallon ASPs. So and that came about by
- 46:24accident. We were phasing our way from
- 46:27small barrels up to the larger barrels as a lot of distilleries
- 46:30do. And once we hit the 30s, we just
- 46:32loved the character and we didn't want to let that go
- 46:35completely. We didn't want to just pass
- 46:36through that that size towards 50 threes.
- 46:39We didn't want to let that go. So what we do here in Maryland
- 46:42mostly goes into 30s. And so that the bottle in the
- 46:44Bond was distilled here and are still meets all the requirements
- 46:48bottle in the Bond and it was aged in a 30 gallon barrel #4
- 46:52char, whereas what we're drinking at the 95 was aged in a
- 46:5653 gallon ASB from for a blend. And it's a blend of four to 8
- 47:01year old, which is also important because those, those
- 47:03profiles between 4:00 and 8:00 are dramatically different.
- 47:05And it's it's amazing how they kind of play together.
- 47:08One of the things that we mentioned on the last episode
- 47:10with you guys was and, and forgive me for the kind of
- 47:14crudeness of this comparison, but Brad, I love the Bourbony
- 47:17character that's brought forth in their single mold.
- 47:20I think it's a fantastic gateway from bourbon drinkers into a new
- 47:24category. And I think it is that virgin
- 47:26oak that you guys use. It really does impart that sort
- 47:29of Bourbony sweetness. Brad, we're going to give just
- 47:31general impressions of these because we want to respect
- 47:34Mark's time, but also we will give full reviews of all four of
- 47:37these products on our website. So go to filmwhiskey.com and you
- 47:40can find all these reviews. What immediately jumps out to me
- 47:44on the nose here, Brad, on this flagship, we have a tea that we
- 47:47drink when we're all sick in my house and there are sick people
- 47:50in my house. And it's a lemon, lemon ginger
- 47:53tea. There is there is lemon and
- 47:55there is ginger on this and it is super bright.
- 47:58And I am absolutely in love with this nose man.
- 48:01Yeah, it absolutely has some floralness to it that I really,
- 48:06really love. And yet, like you said, there's
- 48:08enough of that bourbon influence, not bourbon
- 48:12influence, enough of that cask influence that man, like it has
- 48:17a little bit of vanilla and a little bit of caramel and enough
- 48:20to to blend it all together. And then you drink it.
- 48:24And for me, it immediately goes into that really beautiful multi
- 48:28experience that I want out of any single mom from anywhere.
- 48:32Yeah, Brad, I'm going to let you kind of dictate which is the
- 48:35next one that we drink. Do you want to jump immediately
- 48:38to the Navy proof, which we've already said is is freaking
- 48:41dope? I always want to jump to the
- 48:43Navy proof, Bob. I think it'd be good to jump
- 48:45into the the Pedro Jimenez Sherry cask finish, which I've
- 48:51already drank. Oh my God.
- 48:56Yeah, one of the things I love about their experimentation
- 48:58process at Old Wide is how many different finishes they're
- 49:02producing. So like I said, we've tried the
- 49:04Port Cask and the Madera Cask already.
- 49:07We're trying to Sherry cast today and I'm looking at their
- 49:09website and I thought, you know, we've we have to be tapping out
- 49:12on all of their their line, their portfolio at this point.
- 49:16Oh no, Brad, we've got a cognac cask finish, Maple syrup cask,
- 49:20muscatel, armagnac soturn and rum cask finish that we can
- 49:25still work through. So, Mark, you're invited back
- 49:28perpetually anytime you. Can count me in?
- 49:32I'll wear my welcome anytime. Mark, tell me about the the PX
- 49:36finish. Like, what was it about this
- 49:38specific line that made you go, oh, we need to turn this into
- 49:42something, something we're doing?
- 49:45You know, so it's, it's been a kind of a long evolution and
- 49:47I'll try to keep it as brief as I can.
- 49:49But when we started out our, our finishing process, you know, I
- 49:52think we first put whiskey in the finishing barrel back in
- 49:552016, maybe. So right around the beginning of
- 49:57when we were, we're kind of getting going.
- 49:59We went with Ola Rosso Sherry, which we love.
- 50:03And that was the first one we did.
- 50:04It just seemed like kind of a, for us, an obvious first move,
- 50:07very commonly used style of barrel.
- 50:10And really we figured there was very little risk to doing it.
- 50:13Let's just see what, you know, what happens.
- 50:14And we love the result. Somebody kind of opened up our
- 50:16aperture and decided that, you know, there's a fine line, I
- 50:20think as a distillery where, you know, putting out new and
- 50:23different products, but also not coming across as like you're all
- 50:26over the map, right. So we made it a deliberate
- 50:30choice to kind of open up that aperture and order a couple
- 50:32barrels here, a couple barrels there to try out new things,
- 50:35test them out, see what people thought, see what we thought,
- 50:39see what was, you know, financially, you know, with a
- 50:41marketable product. And then now we're kind of
- 50:44narrowing it down again and we're taking the ones that we
- 50:47think are the biggest winners and making them slowly, surely
- 50:51into, you know, ongoing, ongoing releases.
- 50:54So the Sherry finish, you know, we did Ola Rosso, which we love.
- 50:58We still do love and at one point, you know, after having
- 51:01done the the port casks and that that kind of fruit bomb
- 51:05characteristic of those port casks gave us some a little bit
- 51:08more interest. And like, well, PX Sherry can be
- 51:10a little more fruity, a little sweeter than Olaroso.
- 51:12So it's not nearly as big and bold necessarily as one of those
- 51:15ports, but it's kind of a step in that direction.
- 51:17So we ordered some. We absolutely loved it.
- 51:20We actually have more coming in soon, more barrels.
- 51:23So yeah, it was just a a way of just taking that that known
- 51:26factor of Olarosso and just nudging it in a different
- 51:29direction. And we were thrilled with the
- 51:30result. And actually, if I can share
- 51:34without going on too long, we actually also took a chance with
- 51:36these barrels to do an level of experimentation that we hadn't
- 51:39done before. Is these barrels come to us
- 51:41sealed with a little bit of liquid in them, a little of the
- 51:43wine and it's there's an inner gas in there, argon or something
- 51:46I believe that keeps it stable. And then you have a choice.
- 51:49You can empty that or you can keep it in.
- 51:51And we had four barrels for this release and we one, we kept the
- 51:55wine in there, which was maybe a liter out of a like 60 gallon
- 51:58barrels. So very, very minimal.
- 52:00You know, one, we Ted emptied everything out and then the
- 52:02other two were like 1/3 and 2/3. And it was fun just to kind of
- 52:05see, you know, every time we do one of these finishes, not only
- 52:08does it work, but what can we learn from this that we can then
- 52:10apply to the next thing when it's Madeira or whatever.
- 52:12So and we actually found that the one with no with all the
- 52:17wine emptied was actually our favorite.
- 52:19Here's here's something I'm going to be bold.
- 52:21We just drank a few weeks ago, a month or two ago, the Bushmills
- 52:2730 and Bushmills 29, which are both PX finishes.
- 52:32If you can't get your hands on Bushmills 29, which is thousands
- 52:37of dollars, I think that this is like the perfect substitute.
- 52:42Oh man. Like tell me I'm tell me I'm
- 52:44wrong, Bob. Here's the thing, dude.
- 52:46Like so we've tried three different cask finishes now.
- 52:49And when you already respect like the the baseline product
- 52:53that is being finished in something else, then you're kind
- 52:56of willing to go on a more experimental route, right?
- 52:59Like I'm looking at our old scores.
- 53:01I fell in love with the Madera finish.
- 53:03I gave it a 45 out of 50. It was one of the highest scores
- 53:05I've ever given on this podcast. You were not a fan of the Madera
- 53:09finish. But we both know that apparently
- 53:12that's just a thing with the Madera.
- 53:14That's not a thing with this baseline distillate here.
- 53:17So I I love that you guys are willing to introduce people to
- 53:21like, hey, this is what old line looks like Now come with me as
- 53:25we try finishing it in all these different casks.
- 53:28I think that this one here the the PX finish.
- 53:31It's crazy to go from the flagship to this because like
- 53:34the the biggest thing I noticed was the difference in viscosity.
- 53:38Like this just had a much more syrupy mouthfeel to it.
- 53:41I don't know, Brad, if I would say that it tops the Madeira
- 53:44finish for me, but it's like right there, man, This is a damn
- 53:48good finished whiskey. Yeah, and it's the, oh, I if
- 53:53you, if you haven't gotten into PX finishes, this might not
- 53:56always sound great, but it's the pruning this of it that like is
- 54:01so freaking good. And I know prunes are not the
- 54:05favored thing, you know, fruit of the stone fruits, but man, oh
- 54:10man, it leaves you with such a richness of flavor.
- 54:15I like, like truly I, I, I hope I'm not overstepping.
- 54:19Normally we never compare whiskies when we're talking to a
- 54:22distiller to another company. I truly think that this is worth
- 54:26way more money than you're charging for it.
- 54:28The price The price on this PX finished is incredible.
- 54:33Well, I appreciate that. And you know, we, we, we make a
- 54:35very conscious effort to keep our pricing as we, we, even
- 54:40though we're a single malt whiskey, so many of our early
- 54:42adopters are bourbon drinkers. And, you know, they even
- 54:46granted, you know, bourbon prices have gone out to lunch in
- 54:48the past few years, but they're starting to come back down.
- 54:51But the, you know, we, we thought like, you know, I like
- 54:54to spend, you know, 45 to 65 bucks is my sweet spot on a
- 54:59bottle of whiskey. I mean, sometimes above,
- 55:01obviously there's certain things below that you can find some
- 55:03great deals below that. That's kind of like, you know,
- 55:04generally speaking, where a lot of what I buy is and I'm like,
- 55:07and I think for bourbon drinkers, a lot of the brands,
- 55:10the big brands vacated the consumer and moved up market
- 55:13because demand and left that. So we're like, you know what,
- 55:15like our margin and our margins are way lower than a a big
- 55:18bourbon producer. AR grain is more expensive than
- 55:20B we're tiny, but you know, we're going to put it there and
- 55:23we're going to that's what we think it should be.
- 55:24And yes, as we get some things that are a little bit more rare,
- 55:29maybe we'll go up for certain things.
- 55:30But really that sweet spot is if we feel that's, that's kind of
- 55:32where we want to shop. And I'd, I'd much rather sell it
- 55:35there and have you say, wow, what a deal I got and make a few
- 55:39extra bucks. You know, to me, that's better
- 55:41in the long run for everybody. Yeah, I mean, I mean, at the end
- 55:44of the day, like finish is an important part of any whiskey
- 55:46tasting experience. And like when I walk away from
- 55:50drinking a bottle of whiskey and go man, I only paid X amount of
- 55:55dollars for that. Like that is the best finish any
- 55:58distiller can leave on a on a consumer's financial palette.
- 56:03Like, wait. Yeah, absolutely right.
- 56:05Yeah. You want people to.
- 56:07Yeah. That that you nailed it.
- 56:08Like the purchase should be good from beginning to end and after,
- 56:10you know, just like, hey, I want another bottle of X.
- 56:12That was a good deal. And I was pleased, you know.
- 56:16Well guys, let's jump into. This Navy Strength and then
- 56:17Brad, I think what we'll do is we will review the rum as a
- 56:21bonus review on the website and we'll keep this totally whiskey
- 56:24centric. We haven't actually given a full
- 56:27review of Navy strength aside from just saying it is awesome.
- 56:31And I think. If you're a listener of this
- 56:33podcast like that should be enough for you to go get it at
- 56:36this point. We've reviewed a lot of whiskeys
- 56:38on this podcast, and I'm telling you, this is an awesome whiskey.
- 56:42But Brad, as we dive into the 114, let's just give a few notes
- 56:46here. What are you picking up on this
- 56:47one on the nose? Man, I, I mean, it's, it's got
- 56:50the maltiness that's all there. I think that what hits me,
- 56:55there's like a rich vanilla bomb for me that just it's, there's a
- 57:05depth to it that you don't often find on other single malts.
- 57:09Yeah, we talk all the time about how if you go to Scotland and
- 57:13you're sampling whiskeys at distilleries, it's really easy
- 57:17to find cast strength or quote UN quote foolproof Scotch in
- 57:21Scotland. You can't really get high proof
- 57:23Scotch in America. And so AI think that this single
- 57:27malt is scratching my itch for high proof single malt.
- 57:32But it combines for me the best of like American craft whiskey.
- 57:36It has that just like American craft note that we get
- 57:40sometimes, Brad, you know what I'm talking about.
- 57:41There's like a a distinct herbal note we get on craft whiskey,
- 57:47but it's coupled with that incredible maltiness that we
- 57:50love in our single malts. And it's like the perfect
- 57:52marriage of those two. And I mean, to Mark's point,
- 57:56it's 55 bucks like you like there's nothing on the market
- 58:00that is competing with this right now.
- 58:02It's like insane value and insane quality married together.
- 58:07Yeah, yeah, Truly, if you can get your hands on their Navy
- 58:11strength, it will be one of the best bottles you have on your
- 58:15shelf at any given time. I I man, you guys keep talking.
- 58:20I love it. This is This is.
- 58:22How we're trying to coax you back.
- 58:24Keep. Sending us finishes and stuff.
- 58:26Done, done, man. I'm I'm a I'm a I'm a I'm a
- 58:28sucker for it. The no well, I, I guys, I can't
- 58:31thank you enough for those comments.
- 58:32And I, it's, we love this Navy strength.
- 58:34And you know, where we, we originally, we call it our blue
- 58:37label because it's a blue label. And the blue label used to be a
- 58:41cast strength, which ranges from 1:23 to 1:26 or so.
- 58:45And we certainly didn't want to vacate the cast strength, but we
- 58:48wanted to actually make our cast strength program a single barrel
- 58:50program. So we decided, Archie, I
- 58:53decided, you know, a year or two or three ago, whatever it was
- 58:55that well, you know, we love our cast strength, but he and I were
- 58:58almost always putting a drop of water in it or an ice cube just
- 59:01to kind of bring it down a little bit.
- 59:02Like we're probably drinking this thing in the mid one teens
- 59:04anyway. You know, that's what we love
- 59:06that. We just think it shines at that
- 59:08kind of 1-14 ish range. And then also, you know, we're
- 59:11Navy guys and no one's really doing Navy strength whiskey.
- 59:14There's a few 1 fourteens out there like, you know, old
- 59:15granddad, but they don't name label it as Navy strength.
- 59:19So all those reasons like, hey, this just seems like a slam
- 59:21dunk. And then now we've opened up our
- 59:23our we call our black label, which is our single barrel cast
- 59:26strength. So not only like store picks,
- 59:28but also we'll do like we're releasing a Mark founder pick
- 59:30here like next week. I think this 114 has been such a
- 59:34big win for us. And one thing that has changed
- 59:36since we last spoke is I'll shamelessly plug that we can
- 59:39actually ship to like 41 states now.
- 59:42That's. Awesome man.
- 59:43Website if anybody is listening and wants to pick up any of the
- 59:45bottles and we have free shipping on three or more
- 59:47bottles. So, so yeah, if people are
- 59:50interested in grabbing it, you can go right to our website and
- 59:53it basically is fulfilled via third party in Washington, DC.
- 59:56But that's been really, really great for us that people can,
- 59:59you know, experience what you got, you know, basically
- 1:00:01experience what you're tasting if they want to taste
- 1:00:03themselves. Well, Mark, we can't say enough
- 1:00:05good things about you or the brand.
- 1:00:06Thank you so much for joining us.
- 1:00:08Before you go, I want you to just give like your 32nd
- 1:00:11elevator pitch to bring it back to the category for people who
- 1:00:15are listening to the podcast who really only drink bourbon, maybe
- 1:00:19dip their toe in rye once in a while.
- 1:00:22Single malts. It's a, it's a step, man.
- 1:00:24It, it really is a leap of faith for a lot of people because
- 1:00:27they're just not used to the category.
- 1:00:29Psych us up a little bit. Convince us why should we be
- 1:00:32trying American single malt? Absolutely.
- 1:00:35So I, I dearly love the categories of bourbon, rye,
- 1:00:39single malt, Scotch, you know, blended, I love them all right.
- 1:00:42And they all bring different things to the party.
- 1:00:44One thing I've noticed in the past, you know, especially 10
- 1:00:46years that bourbon has taken on such a massive outsized role in
- 1:00:50the market where as much as I love bourbon, there's a lot of
- 1:00:53people who only drink bourbon. And I think they don't realize
- 1:00:56that there's so many, the things that they love about that
- 1:00:58bourbon can be found in other categories and often in ways
- 1:01:01that they never could have really imagined.
- 1:01:03So for us, you know, we're not trying to displace any category.
- 1:01:07It'd be silly if we never could if we wanted to, But for
- 1:01:09American Singapore, I think most of us look at it as, you know,
- 1:01:12for if you guys have your seven or eight, you know, kind of go
- 1:01:15TOS you, you reach for pretty often.
- 1:01:17We want to be one of those. We want an American Singapore to
- 1:01:20be in that rotation. Because I think that the, the
- 1:01:23flavors, if you look at like AI think of like a, a blending
- 1:01:26board for like a DJ or something, like all the flavors
- 1:01:29for the most part are going to be very similar or the same as
- 1:01:31what you deliver in a bourbon. It's just they're different
- 1:01:34levels, right? So you can get those and you
- 1:01:36know, we just offer something that other categories can't.
- 1:01:39And I think it's, you know, go to your local, you know, whiskey
- 1:01:43bar and you know, it's hey, pay, pay 8 bucks, 10 bucks, 15 bucks
- 1:01:46to try something new. If you like it, go to the store
- 1:01:48and buy it. And that goes for the whole
- 1:01:50category, you know, old line, others.
- 1:01:51There's amazing American single malts out there.
- 1:01:53And I'm excited that people are are starting to really see
- 1:01:56what's out there and available at a great value in many cases.
- 1:01:59Yeah, and Mark, like you would be a regular on our podcast
- 1:02:03because Bob and I say that all the time, Like just try things
- 1:02:06like that. There are so many whiskeys.
- 1:02:08Like go to your whiskey bar, give it a shot.
- 1:02:10You know, it's there for a reason.
- 1:02:12Use it to try new things, have new experiences.
- 1:02:15And I, I can guarantee you if you try old line spirits, it
- 1:02:20will not be a waste of your money.
- 1:02:22You will have an awesome experience and it will be well
- 1:02:25worth your time. Brad, I learned a fun fact
- 1:02:27today. I don't I did not know this
- 1:02:29until today. There are currently more
- 1:02:33distilleries producing single malt in America than in
- 1:02:37Scotland. So if you.
- 1:02:39Truly suck at Scotland. I was going.
- 1:02:41To say, if you truly believe in American exceptionalism, if you
- 1:02:44really think that we're #1 then you need to be trying some
- 1:02:47American single. Malt.
- 1:02:49Guys, this has. Been Mark McLaughlin from Old
- 1:02:51Line Spirits. Mark, it's great to catch up
- 1:02:53with you. Congratulations on the entire
- 1:02:55portfolio. Congratulations on the TTB
- 1:02:58designation and come back and join us soon man.
- 1:03:00Hey you guys, thanks for having me.
- 1:03:02It's always a pleasure and thank you all so much.
- 1:03:04I'm here, whatever you need, let me know.
- 1:03:05We'll be back on Tuesday with another regularly scheduled
- 1:03:08episode, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:03:11I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.