Latest / Politics with Paul / Midterm Elections and Why They Hurt the President's Party | Politics with Paul #91
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Today we're going to talk about midterm elections and their importance and what you may
- 0:13not know about them and some historical data and what you can expect for this year.
- 0:20Presidential elections tend to get most of the attention in election commentary, and, yes,
- 0:25it's for the highest office in the land.
- 0:27But just as critical are midterm elections.
- 0:30And they're named as such because they happen halfway between presidential elections.
- 0:34And it's vital not just because it is another chance to hold our elected officials
- 0:39accountable, but it is also often used by voters to let the sitting president know what
- 0:45they think of him while not being able to actually vote on him and perhaps in the future
- 0:49her.
- 0:50Notably, midterm elections often play out very differently elections.
- 0:56Because while presidential elections tend to be more successful for the party of the
- 1:01presidential contest winner, midterms tend to be much harsher to the president's party, and
- 1:08that goes for both Democrats and Republicans.
- 1:11Now the fact that midterms are usually unkind to the president's party may be well known, but
- 1:18much less discussed are the reasons why that is the case.
- 1:21So today, we're going to talk about why midterms often play out that way, some
- 1:26noteworthy midterm results in history, what this all means for 2026, and so on.
- 1:32So let's get into it.
- 1:34First of all, why do midterms often hurt the president's party?
- 1:39Well, there are several arguments put out for why midterms are notoriously antagonistic to
- 1:46the sitting president's party.
- 1:48Some aren't that convincing while others are clear or borne out by the data.
- 1:53Though I'd two of
- 1:54them in particular at work.
- 1:56The first one is that the president is not on the ballot.
- 2:00So a lot
- 2:00of people particularly motivated to vote for the president won't come out and you see that
- 2:06in large part due to the if you compare the difference in turnout rates between the midterm
- 2:12and presidential election, midterms have a lot fewer voters showing up than presidential
- 2:18elections do.
- 2:20And you saw this in particular with Barack Obama in 2010 and 2014 and with Donald Trump
- 2:26himself in 2018.
- 2:28And sometimes you hear this referred to as the surge and decline theory where the forces that
- 2:34work for a presidential year that drove these voters out to the polls then decreased
- 2:40considerably in the midterms.
- 2:43And, also, the second factor that I'd point to is that anger and hatred are powerful tools in
- 2:50politics, and the party out of power is often more capable of harnessing that in the midterms
- 2:57because people some people will have soured on the current administration, and that's not just
- 3:02for now.
- 3:03That's for a lot of history.
- 3:05But also voters in the president's party tend to get more complacent because they've already
- 3:09quote unquote won.
- 3:11Hey, guys.
- 3:11We already took the White House.
- 3:13We have and sometimes they have the Congress or at least one chamber of Congress.
- 3:18We got it, guys.
- 3:20We have the president.
- 3:20That's what matters.
- 3:21So a lot of those people don't show up to vote.
- 3:24Being out of power though means much fewer of your policies get enacted and that tends to
- 3:29make people angry because they tend to not be heard because they're not the ones in power.
- 3:33Because when you're in power, apparently you don't have
- 3:36to really listen to people that think differently than you as much.
- 3:42You see that through a lot of history.
- 3:45And some observers also would argue that midterms also see attempts by a small but
- 3:52significant portion of the electorate looking to, quote unquote, balance the scales between
- 3:58the parties.
- 3:59So they all vote for the out of power party as a check against the president.
- 4:03Sometimes it's called a form of strategic voting.
- 4:07Now there undoubtedly are a few relative few voters doing this, but I'm I'm a bit skeptical
- 4:13of just how many of them do this balancing act.
- 4:18Though some studies from around twenty ten ish suggest that balancing was going on for at
- 4:23least a few decades up to that point, both for federal and state level elections.
- 4:28But whether balancing is still going on though, I never I haven't seen a study for that.
- 4:35I'm not saying that it doesn't exist.
- 4:37I just haven't seen it.
- 4:39But also you have to rely on people saying that, oh, yeah.
- 4:44I actually decided to vote against the party.
- 4:48Or sometimes it's it's a an assumption because, oh, well, suddenly a whole bunch of people
- 4:52voted against the president's party.
- 4:53Maybe a whole bunch of people changed their mind.
- 4:55Not necessarily.
- 4:56Some people who just didn't show up the previous time might have decided to
- 5:00come out now.
- 5:01But not everybody just votes according to their party.
- 5:05It is a it is the most common predictor of how people are going to vote, but there will be
- 5:10some people that decide, you
- 5:12know what?
- 5:13I am going to vote for the other party as a check on the president's power.
- 5:17It does happen.
- 5:18I just don't know if there's really all that many people that do it.
- 5:23But I'll have to look into that some more to see if there have been any more recent studies
- 5:28on that.
- 5:29But now let's look at the House versus the Senate when it comes to midterm elections.
- 5:34Now midterms are unkind to the president's party regardless of whether you're looking at
- 5:39it through the lens of
- 5:40the US house or the US senate.
- 5:42But how
- 5:45unsuccessful the sitting president's party is can look much different in the house versus the
- 5:52senate Because only a third of the US senate is up for election, and the whole house is up for
- 5:59election every time.
- 6:00Because remember, US senators have six year terms.
- 6:03So one time, they'll be during a presidential election, and then the next time they're up for
- 6:09election, it's gonna be during a midterm, and it's gonna go back to president, midterm,
- 6:13president, midterm for that same specific seat.
- 6:16So each also, the senate is a much smaller chamber than the house is.
- 6:21So each seat in the senate is mathematically more consequential than a seat in the house.
- 6:27And policy wise, senators have a lot more power, and they also represent a whole state as
- 6:32opposed to for most US house representatives.
- 6:35They represent a fraction of their state unless you live in one of those states that only has
- 6:40one US house representative.
- 6:43And so the number of seats held by the president's party in the senate can vary
- 6:49considerably depending on what seats are up for election.
- 6:52So if a republican president is in office at the time, there may just happen to not be as
- 6:59many republican seats up in that election, or maybe there are a lot more that are up for that
- 7:05election.
- 7:05Remember, it's it's because that those six year terms, it can look much different depending on
- 7:12whether it's a presidential year or a midterm year and when that seat just happens to be up.
- 7:18Now does the party or the president's party fare worse in the house or the senate?
- 7:24That depends on how you look at the information.
- 7:28But since 1934, the president's party in the US house has had a net loss in seats in 20 of
- 7:35those midterms while it had gains in only three of them.
- 7:39That was under FDR in 1934, Bill Clinton in 1998, and George w Bush in 2002.
- 7:46And there was an average loss of 11% of seats that that president's party held in those
- 7:55elections.
- 7:56For the US senate since 1934, the president's party had a net loss in seats in 15 midterms
- 8:04while it had gains in seven of them, and they lost an average of about 15% of seats in the US
- 8:12senate that they held.
- 8:13Remember, there are far fewer seats that are up for election in the US senate than there are in
- 8:17the US house.
- 8:18So those senate seats are mathematically much more consequential.
- 8:24So the parties the president's party in the US house has had more elections with a net loss in
- 8:31seats than for the senate, but the senate averages more losses as a percentage of seats
- 8:37that they held compared to the house.
- 8:40So it kinda depends on how exactly you look at it.
- 8:43And because there are more seats in the house, the number of house seats that are lost lost
- 8:48can look can be more stark than if you're looking at it through the lens of the Senate.
- 8:56But for more specific instances in US history, because there are quite a few noteworthy
- 9:04midterm results and a few of
- 9:06them are because they happen to buck the trend of the president's party not doing well.
- 9:13But we're
- 9:14gonna focus more on the times where the sitting president's party lost seats because that is a
- 9:19lot more common.
- 9:20And so the biggest democratic loss in midterm history was back in 1894 where Democrats lost
- 9:29116 seats in the house, which was the biggest loss for a party in the midterm ever, and they
- 9:36lost five seats in the senate.
- 9:38Though this is when The US Senate was still chosen by state legislatures.
- 9:42That wasn't until another about twenty years later that that was changed so that we directly
- 9:48elected US senators.
- 9:50And at the time, president Grover Cleveland, a democrat who was the first president to win
- 9:57nonconsecutive terms in office until Donald Trump just did it back in 2024.
- 10:02He returned to the White House in 1892.
- 10:05He had actually won the popular vote in the previous presidential election.
- 10:09He just
- 10:09didn't win the electoral vote.
- 10:11But during that term,
- 10:13there was a severe depression.
- 10:14There was a railroad strike, obviously, back when railroads were a lot more economically
- 10:20important, and a giant swath of jobless workers went to DC to demand relief.
- 10:28And, obviously, the party in power was blamed there, which in this case was Democrats, and it
- 10:33was the president.
- 10:35And so Democrats lost massively.
- 10:38But then on the flip side, the biggest Republican loss in a midterm ever was back in
- 10:431874, so twenty years before that Democratic loss, where Republicans lost 96 seats in the
- 10:50house and nine in the senate.
- 10:52And this was following financial panic and concerns over post civil war governance during
- 10:58the Reconstruction era.
- 10:59And one of these fronts, if you will, where that you saw this was there was internal strife
- 11:06within the Republican party, excuse me, about how to deal with the Democratic South.
- 11:11Some were more not conciliatory, but some of them were more like we should ease them back
- 11:17into the union.
- 11:20And if they reaffirm their allegiance to the country, we won't be as harsh on them while
- 11:27other Republicans said, no.
- 11:29We have to deal with them harshly.
- 11:30They were the ones who started this war.
- 11:32We need to basically tell them what's what.
- 11:35And so a lot of that internal strife led to a much less cohesive Republican party.
- 11:42So Democrats were able to take advantage of that.
- 11:45And, also, Democrats were just regaining power in the South again and building it back up
- 11:50until they retained their prewar you could even argue that they became even stronger after the
- 11:59civil war in the South after Reconstruction, and then you saw the institution of Jim Crow
- 12:06laws.
- 12:07And then so Democrats then in 1874 took advantage of that.
- 12:13But other monumental swings in midterm elections include nine eight 1938, 1994, and
- 12:202010 for Democrats.
- 12:221938 was a backlash to some of the new deal policies under FDR.
- 12:28Some people felt that he was overstepping his balance.
- 12:31Obviously, some people did not think that.
- 12:341994 was sort of that buildup of Republicans starting to gain some steam in the South
- 12:41partially because of what we saw starting in the nineteen sixties, what a lot of people
- 12:46called a great sorting out as the parties became a lot more distinct where Republicans
- 12:52became more and more conservative, Democrats became more and more liberal, and a lot of
- 12:58those staunch Democrats in the
- 12:59South felt that the party was leaving them and then they were eventually drifting over to the
- 13:06Republican party.
- 13:07And so the Republicans made those gains in the South that now seem very, you know, you know,
- 13:15what's
- 13:15the big deal?
- 13:16Of course, Republicans are very strong in the South.
- 13:19Back at that time, that was something that was completely unheard of.
- 13:23And so that was during the time of Bill Clinton, and so Republicans took power in 1994.
- 13:31And that's kind of ushered in not really ushered in, but it it finally really set the
- 13:37stage for this level of hyperpolarization that we see today, which was really building up
- 13:42since the nineteen sixties.
- 13:44And then in 2010, democrats lost a lot of seats as well in large part because of this tea party
- 13:51wave in the Republican party and not just at
- 13:55the federal level, but Republicans also took control of a lot
- 14:00of state legislatures as well.
- 14:02And even now, Republicans tend to have the advantage in state level governments.
- 14:08And then on the republican side, the some other monumental swings that went against them, those
- 14:14were those previous ones were for democrats, but others that went against the republican
- 14:18party were 1958 during Eisenhower's tenure, Even though a lot
- 14:25of people loved they liked Ike, they
- 14:28did not feel quite as much the same way about his party.
- 14:321974, they suffered significant losses under Ford.
- 14:37A lot of it in response to Richard Nixon and the Watergate scandal, and then in 2018 for
- 14:45Donald Trump.
- 14:46And so perhaps we'll see another swing against Donald Trump in this election cycle.
- 14:52We'll talk more about that later.
- 14:55But in general, indicators of what will happen in midterm elections.
- 14:59What what do what do we use to indicate what will happen in midterm elections or at least
- 15:04predict?
- 15:05Obviously, history is a prominent guide for that, but what else can give us an indication
- 15:11of how a midterm is going to go?
- 15:14And there's a lot of different factors that different people use to make their arguments,
- 15:20but using any data point by itself and alone, that's not necessarily going to be predictive.
- 15:26In fact,
- 15:27you're to be, you're likely going
- 15:30to be led astray if you only use one specific thing and more on that's on these specific
- 15:38factors.
- 15:38But let's talk about those right now.
- 15:41First of all, let's talk about the generic congressional poll or generic congressional
- 15:46ballot.
- 15:47This is a polling question where people are asked without names, simply, would you vote for
- 15:53a republican or a democrat in
- 15:55congress today?
- 15:58So doesn't matter who is on the ballot.
- 16:02Just would
- 16:02you vote democrat or would you vote republican?
- 16:04And so this is useful for general sentiments towards the parties, and partisan
- 16:09identification is still the strongest predictor of how someone will vote, but some people will
- 16:15still like their specific congressperson, that incumbency advantage, which we'll also get into
- 16:21shortly.
- 16:22But you have to be careful with using the generic congressional poll.
- 16:26Yes.
- 16:26It's very useful for finding the sentiment against these parties in general, but these
- 16:33polls tend to pull from people across multiple congressional districts and states.
- 16:40So you're pulling people from a bunch of different election scenarios, or maybe you're
- 16:45just happening, even if you're doing it random sampling, you might just happen to be pulling a
- 16:50bunch of people from a very staunch Republican district or a very staunch Democratic district.
- 16:56And also the fact that we can only vote on the house member who represents our district or a
- 17:01senate member who represents our state.
- 17:04So just because there's a certain percentage of people that would vote for a democrat or a
- 17:12certain percentage of people vote for a republican, that doesn't mean it's gonna neatly
- 17:16apply across the board.
- 17:17Generic congressional poll is not a clean one to one application of how the next congress
- 17:22will look.
- 17:22So if Democrats are polling at 52% in a generic congressional poll, that doesn't mean they're
- 17:28gonna win 52% of the seats in the house because it depends on where those people are being
- 17:34pulled from.
- 17:35Maybe you just happen to have more democrats from a smaller cluster of democratic districts
- 17:40or might be doing that for the Party.
- 17:43Even if you're doing it random sampling and you're it's a really good poll, you still have
- 17:48to be careful with how those where you're exactly you're getting those people from.
- 17:54And also just the general idea of, you know, that's what people are saying they'd vote for,
- 17:59but are they necessarily actually gonna turn out to vote?
- 18:03They might be really energized right now, but are they going to
- 18:06be energized later?
- 18:08And it's
- 18:08also harder to apply generic congressional polls to the US Senate since not every senate
- 18:14seat is up.
- 18:14And a lot of times the election conditions for a senate seat are much different than a
- 18:20district because you're representing a whole state versus a specific district.
- 18:24And you're also having a lot more people voting on a senate seat compared to a house seat, not
- 18:29just because typically there are more people being represented by that senator versus a
- 18:35house member.
- 18:37People also tend to care about the senate a bit more than they do for the house representative.
- 18:44So there's gonna
- 18:45be more people voting on the senate anyways.
- 18:48But when combined with some of these other factors, generic congressional ballots can help
- 18:54us predict what's gonna happen in the midterm.
- 18:56And speaking of those other factors, we also have presidential approval rating.
- 19:01So you've seen them before.
- 19:04You ask people, do do they approve of the way that the president is handling his job?
- 19:10Yes or no?
- 19:11Or it'll be a similar question to that.
- 19:15With how nationalized elections have become, that which is to say that more elections are
- 19:21placed in the context of what is happening nationally instead of locally, and that's not
- 19:25just for congress.
- 19:26You're seeing that for governor.
- 19:27You're seeing that state legislatures.
- 19:29You're even seeing it for local level races where it's a litmus test of, do you like the
- 19:33current president?
- 19:34Do you support the current president?
- 19:37Which invites a lot of problems on its own, but that's that's a discussion for a different
- 19:43topic.
- 19:44And so the approval or disapproval of the president can have a tremendous impact on
- 19:52congressional voting because it's in that context of, oh, wait.
- 19:57This guy, this lady, she's
- 19:59in the she's this she he or she are the same party as the president.
- 20:03I like the president.
- 20:04I'm gonna vote for them.
- 20:05Oh, they're in the same party as the president.
- 20:07I don't like him.
- 20:08I'm not gonna vote for this person.
- 20:11You're seeing a lot more of that kind of thought process amongst voters because of this
- 20:17nationalization of elections and especially because members of congress have more staunchly
- 20:24hitched their wagon to or against the president's party as the years go on.
- 20:30But it can still run to the same problems that the generic congressional polling can because
- 20:35you might be taking public opinion from a or you are taking public opinion from across a
- 20:40bunch of districts and states.
- 20:42So it doesn't neatly conform to the percentages of how congress will shake out.
- 20:47So it you know, just because 45% of people approve of the job that the president is doing,
- 20:54doesn't mean that the president's party is going to win 45% of the seats.
- 20:59It really just depends on how those voters are divvied up across districts.
- 21:06Another factor that people use to indicate how a midterm election will play out is they'll
- 21:12point to the special elections since the last presidential election.
- 21:16And these are often treated as bellwethers to signal what's going to come in the midterm
- 21:23election.
- 21:24And I'm not typically a fan of that.
- 21:27Now, such special elections do tend to go more against the sitting president and that could be
- 21:32a signal of turbulence for the president's party.
- 21:34But I and I've talked about this before.
- 21:37I am I get kind of annoyed when I hear people treat individual special elections as
- 21:44bellwethers of what's going to come like this one seat in, I don't know, North Carolina or
- 21:49this one seat in Nevada is going to indicate what's going to happen.
- 21:55That alone is going to be an indication of what's going to happen in the midterm for the
- 22:00president.
- 22:00No.
- 22:00That's a it's a very most the majority vast majority of these elections are for districts.
- 22:06So these districts are a lot more localized.
- 22:08Their effects are more contained.
- 22:10So it's difficult, if not impossible, to extrapolate for the rest of the country.
- 22:15And, also, most places will not have any sort of special election between the presidential
- 22:21election and the midterm election.
- 22:23So you aren't getting the sentiments of the whole country.
- 22:27So, admittedly, I get very annoyed by hearing special elections being, oh, is this is this a
- 22:33bellwether?
- 22:34No.
- 22:34It's not.
- 22:35And now if you take these special elections together, now that might give you a bit more of
- 22:41a sense of what's going to happen, but you still have a lot of places that are not having
- 22:46special elections.
- 22:48So there's sometimes an overreliance on those to indicate this is what's gonna clearly happen
- 22:55in the midterm.
- 22:55And also, it's partly sensationalization to to to draw more engagement from people so that,
- 23:03you know, you've you've got people's interest peaked in what's going on in politics.
- 23:08So admittedly, not a fan of that factor, but I'm not gonna say that it's not useful because
- 23:16it can be when it's used in tandem with multiple other factors like economic factors.
- 23:23Now it's a bit simplistic, but there is some truth to the
- 23:26old saying, it's the economy.
- 23:27Economic factors are going to have a major impact on what people or how people vote.
- 23:35Probably not as
- 23:35much as the party identification is going to, but it's still going to have a pretty impactful
- 23:43effect.
- 23:44And sometimes it may draw people to vote against the party that they typically identify
- 23:49with.
- 23:50And you also see many voters, what we call retrospective voters, will vote against the
- 23:56party in power if their pocketbook is not doing well.
- 23:59And then some people might do it if they perceive that their group that they identify
- 24:05with, whether it's a geographic group or a racial group or a a group in an industry like
- 24:12their specific career sphere, if they perceive that that whole industry is not doing well,
- 24:19that may influence their votes as well.
- 24:21But it's not just about whether they the economy is doing well by more objective, for
- 24:28lack of a better term, standards, but whether certain voters think it is doing well because
- 24:33these perceptions are going to vary for people.
- 24:36I can talk to two different people right now and they can have very similar it can be a
- 24:42similar social class.
- 24:43They can be a similar job, and some of them are and one is going to think that the economy is
- 24:48terrible and one is gonna think that the economy is doing well.
- 24:50One could have a more positive view while the other one has a more negative view even though
- 24:54they have otherwise very similar characteristics.
- 24:58And some of that is going to be driven by party.
- 25:01A lot of people, if their party's in power, they will perceive the economy as doing better
- 25:07than maybe it is.
- 25:09And then some people who identify with the party that's not the president's may perceive
- 25:14the economy as doing worse than it actually is.
- 25:17Both sides can be biased in that regard.
- 25:20But another factor that a lot
- 25:23of people use to try to predict how a midterm election is going to shake out in general is
- 25:29you look at the incumbents who are retiring from office.
- 25:32Now it's easy to rag on politicians for being out of touch with citizens,
- 25:37and to some extent, that is justified and maybe sometimes we overblow it.
- 25:43Admittedly, I can
- 25:44do that too.
- 25:46But politicians often know when the winds of elections are really against them.
- 25:52And sometimes, maybe even often, they respond by just simply retiring, especially if they're
- 25:58in the US senate because the only higher office in that in that case would be for president.
- 26:04But if they really think that elections are not gonna go their way, they may just say, screw
- 26:10it.
- 26:10I'm not even gonna run for reelection.
- 26:11I'm just going to call it a career.
- 26:15Now it's not always the sitting president's party in midterms that does it.
- 26:19There are both Democrats and Republicans this year that are retiring, but you often see more
- 26:25of them decide to retire in midterms and you tend to see it in the sitting president's party
- 26:31because midterms tend to go against the sitting president's party.
- 26:34Now sometimes they instead to decide they decide to run for a different office that they
- 26:41think they have a better chance at.
- 26:42But for this context, I'm just talking about the retirements because of the indication of a
- 26:49bellwether or not the bellwether, excuse indication of what might happen in midterms
- 26:56overall.
- 26:56So you can look at these retirements because people may just say it's not worth it.
- 27:01I'm gonna lose anyways, or it's almost definite that I'm I'm gonna lose and so they won't even
- 27:06try.
- 27:07And you also have to account for the incumbency factor.
- 27:11The incumbency advantage is very well documented and sitting office holders in
- 27:16Congress often win upwards of 85%, 90% of the time.
- 27:21But if those incumbents are retiring, then
- 27:23that incumbency advantage is gone.
- 27:25They might not a lot of
- 27:28times, they won't think that that incumbency advantage is going to help them this time.
- 27:32Now some of them are just older and and and or tired of the job of congress, but a lot of
- 27:39times it is because the winds of the election are going against them.
- 27:44So they may think that the incumbency advantage is not going to save them this time, and the
- 27:49generic sentiments towards Democrats or Republicans like you see in these generic
- 27:53congressional ballots may become more pronounced in how impactful they are on those
- 27:59elections because now it's an open seat.
- 28:00There's not a Republican or a Democrat holding it because that person is retiring.
- 28:05And in the past decade or so, you we've tended to see more incumbents retiring in midterm
- 28:10years than they were in presidential or midterm years.
- 28:15And then one last factor I'll I'll highlight that a lot
- 28:21of people use to get an indication of how a midterm is going to go for the sitting
- 28:25president's party.
- 28:26By no means is this an exhaustive list, but some people look at what's called the policy
- 28:32mood measure, the or the Stimson measure.
- 28:34This is named after political scientist James A.
- 28:37Stimson, who has been publishing these statistics for decades now, so he's still going
- 28:41at it.
- 28:42And it tracks short term and midterm variations in whether the population wants more or less
- 28:49government action on various issues.
- 28:52So if there's higher scores, it means people have a more liberal sentiment and they want
- 28:57more active government.
- 28:58If there are lower scores, it means it's more conservative and they want less active
- 29:03government.
- 29:03The higher and lower scores don't have any meaning on their own.
- 29:06It's not like higher is better, lower is better.
- 29:08It's just a spatial way to describe how much one way or another the general public is about
- 29:15a particular policy.
- 29:18Though using this to predict midterm results depends partly on how voters perceive these
- 29:23candidates' positions on these issues, and some candidates will purposely purposely obfuscate
- 29:30certain aspects of their positions or their policies that they think that it's not gonna
- 29:35play well with their voter base, but it's still something they strongly believe in.
- 29:38And also a lot of voters don't think ideologically or they focus on only one or a
- 29:44few specific policies and not all of those policies in the Stimson measure.
- 29:48A lot of people don't necessarily think in conservative or liberal terms.
- 29:52They might think about the specific policies, which is related, but not exactly the same, but
- 29:59they don't necessarily see things as conservative or liberal.
- 30:02So if the mood is more liberal, they won't necessarily be like, oh, okay.
- 30:05I'm voting for the liberal person.
- 30:07Or if it's a more conservative mood, they won't necessarily go, okay.
- 30:10I'm voting for the conservative person.
- 30:11They don't necessarily think in those terms, and a lot of these people aren't using the
- 30:15Stimpson measure to decide how they should vote.
- 30:19But it can still be a useful way to to determine which way the wind blows in terms of
- 30:25which party is going to benefit.
- 30:27But, again, one measure alone is not necessarily that informative.
- 30:31But if you use a bunch of these factors or all of them, it starts to give you a clearer idea
- 30:37of what you could expect overall from a midterm.
- 30:40And you see some political scientists and observers, they'll use a comprehensive measure
- 30:46that says, okay, on these 10 points, these 12 points, these 14 points, which party is
- 30:51benefiting from this?
- 30:52Or which president and if it's a presidential election, they'll say which presidential
- 30:56candidate is benefiting this.
- 30:58And then they'll use that to determine like, oh, if if the sitting president's party is
- 31:03losing on seven of these measures, they're going
- 31:06to lose the midterm, that sort of thing.
- 31:09So you can find a few of those.
- 31:10I'm forgetting what some of these specific ones are off the top of my head, but you do see some
- 31:16political scientists and observers and commentators use these kinds of measures, these
- 31:23comprehensive measures to try to determine whether a midterm is gonna go not necessarily
- 31:29whether a midterm is gonna go against the sitting president's party, but how much it's
- 31:33going to go against the sitting president's party.
- 31:35Because remember, it's a midterm.
- 31:37Chances are it's not gonna work out well for the
- 31:39sitting president's party.
- 31:41But now let's bring this to this year's elections.
- 31:46What are some of the potential biggest influences and impacts on the twenty twenty six
- 31:52midterm elections?
- 31:54Well, in pretty
- 31:56much every election, political party identification is generally the strongest
- 32:00indicator of how people are going to vote.
- 32:02And second place isn't all that close.
- 32:04Second place is maybe economic factors, generally speaking.
- 32:07And it can vary depending on the contest in question.
- 32:10You might find one US house race where the party identification factor isn't all that
- 32:15important or it's not nearly as important as it is for a lot of other places.
- 32:20And it's more economic factors.
- 32:22Again, every race has its own contexts, its own things to deal with.
- 32:29But at the end of the day, most Republicans will vote Republican, and most Democrats will
- 32:33vote Democrat.
- 32:34And you can be even very annoyed with your own party.
- 32:37A Democrat can have a lot of grievances with other Democrats.
- 32:40A Republican can have a lot of grievances with other Republicans, but still a lot of times the
- 32:46we can't let the other side win mentality will prevail.
- 32:50A lot of times, it will prevail.
- 32:53And some people will just think of it in the terms of what's the lesser of two evils kind of
- 33:00deal.
- 33:00But apart from that, lots of things can change in the time until an election, even when
- 33:05there's four or five, six months to go.
- 33:07Even two or three months, one month, there can be a sudden change.
- 33:12And we there's often an assumption that more people pay close attention to politics than is
- 33:18actually the case.
- 33:19A lot of people don't start really paying attention until there's like one, two, three
- 33:23months out.
- 33:25And even for the people who are paying close attention, there could be changes in key issues
- 33:29or in their own personal lives that influence how they vote.
- 33:34They might not make a different choice for their vote, but something in their personal
- 33:40lives or in their thought processes that might change, that makes them less motivated to even
- 33:46go out to vote.
- 33:47So their vote might not change, but whether they whether they actually go vote might
- 33:51change.
- 33:53And people may be energized to go out to vote now, but will they keep that energy up months
- 33:58later?
- 34:00A lot of people won't.
- 34:01So that's why you always have to be careful looking at when you when you ask sometimes
- 34:06polls will ask people, you know, how excited are you to go vote?
- 34:10How motivated are you to go vote?
- 34:12How much are
- 34:12you looking forward to go vote?
- 34:14If you do that too far out and you hold on to that that sentiment too much,
- 34:20people might burn out before the election's actually upon us.
- 34:25But will a single issue be what drives a midterms?
- 34:30Probably not.
- 34:31One issue might have outsized importance and might be the biggest issue, but you can almost
- 34:37never boil down election to, oh, it's because of policy views on this issue.
- 34:42A lot of times in commentary and analysis, people will say, well,
- 34:47this election was won because of this specific thing.
- 34:51No.
- 34:51It's pretty much never like that.
- 34:54That might be the biggest reason why an election happened that way, but there's a whole
- 34:59bunch of different factors at play that influence the election outcome.
- 35:03So one issue may have outsized importance, but it's never gonna be one specific issue that
- 35:09totally dictates what happens, especially not across a ton of contests, excuse me, for an
- 35:15overall midterm review.
- 35:17And some contests will care about certain issues more than others will.
- 35:23Some districts may care about immigration more than others do, or they may care about health
- 35:28care more than other places do, or the unemployment rate they'll care about more than
- 35:35in other places because some places will have a higher unemployment rate than others.
- 35:38And whatever the salient issue is at the moment, that could be supplanted by a different
- 35:44one layer.
- 35:44And while some voters may be very upset with their party about how they have handled one
- 35:49particular policy, is that necessarily going to lead them
- 35:52to vote a different way?
- 35:54Probably not because they're still thinking about a lot
- 35:58of other policies that they may agree with their party on.
- 36:02But if they're angry enough, pissed off enough about the issue at hand, they might just sit at
- 36:09home instead.
- 36:10So they might not go, you know what?
- 36:11I'm a democrat.
- 36:12I'm gonna vote republican.
- 36:13I'm a republican.
- 36:13I'm gonna vote democrat.
- 36:14No.
- 36:14They may just say, I'm just not gonna go.
- 36:16Or they may avoid a specific election like a specific US senator or US house member, and
- 36:25maybe they'll vote on other things instead.
- 36:28But that being said, what are some of the issues that could make a major impact in the
- 36:35twenty twenty six midterms.
- 36:37Obviously, redistricting is going to be impactful, but in what exact way?
- 36:44Because, yes, gerrymandering maps by both Democrats and Republicans in their respective
- 36:49states are going to make more of their seats almost impervious to the opposing party or for
- 36:55the opposing party.
- 36:57But are the redistricting wars themselves going to influence people to vote a different way?
- 37:04Are Republicans gonna go, you know what?
- 37:06I really don't like what we've been doing with redistricting.
- 37:08I'm gonna vote Democrat.
- 37:10Or are Democrats gonna look at what their party has done with the redistricting and say, you
- 37:14know what?
- 37:15I'm gonna vote Republican.
- 37:16This is unacceptable.
- 37:17That's highly doubtful that
- 37:21either party is going to have a lot of their voters vote against their party for
- 37:25gerrymandering, especially since both parties are engaging in it.
- 37:28So it makes it easy to start engaging in what aboutism.
- 37:33Well, they're doing it.
- 37:34So you know what?
- 37:34That's not as big
- 37:36of a deal as if we do it.
- 37:37Or, you know, you can feel like
- 37:42your conscience is safe because you're saying, well, they both sides are doing it, so I'm
- 37:47still just gonna stick with my party.
- 37:49You know, my feelings about the current redistricting controversy going on and how both
- 37:56parties are engaging in gerrymandering, and I quite frankly don't care for any of the excuses
- 38:01made by either party there, but I don't think it's gonna necessarily change a lot of people's
- 38:06minds.
- 38:07But it's going to obviously make some districts safer for both Democrats and Republicans.
- 38:15But what about the Iran War?
- 38:17Obviously, it's very important right now.
- 38:19As of the time of this episode, the war has been going on for a month, month and a half.
- 38:25But is this war going to last long enough to be part of the wider voting public's conscience?
- 38:30Remember, there's a lot of voters that are not paying attention to politics right now, or they
- 38:34are they do have an idea of what's going on, but are they gonna completely forget about it
- 38:39when it comes to election time?
- 38:42Well, if gas prices continue to stay high and the prices of other goods are driven higher
- 38:47because of the higher cost to transport goods, that could hit Donald Trump and Republicans
- 38:53harder.
- 38:53Now, yes, presidents, both Democrat and Republican, are treated as if they set gas
- 38:58prices when they don't or that they have a much more direct impact on gas prices than they
- 39:04actually do, but they still do have policies that can have a direct or indirect impact.
- 39:09Now whether those policies are overall good or bad, I'm not getting into that.
- 39:14That's for you to decide.
- 39:15But however rightly or wrongly, presidents are often blamed for gas prices, and people think
- 39:23that presidents specifically set the gas prices, which they don't.
- 39:27And if they did, I think they would set the gas prices much lower more often than they actually
- 39:33do.
- 39:34But there's also the fact that The US is also engaged in yet another war, and it may be held
- 39:39against Donald Trump after calling for no more wars and not getting as involved in other
- 39:46countries affairs while he was on the campaign trail.
- 39:48I'm not saying, you know, my specific opinion on him, but that is going to be a lot of the
- 39:54calculus for a lot of voters as they say.
- 39:57Well, you said you weren't going to get involved in these things.
- 39:59So people may hold out against the party.
- 40:03Now if the Iran war resolves itself soon and it's not as much of
- 40:07a problem and prices start going down, it may fade out of the conscience of a lot of voters.
- 40:14Certainly, the more engaged and highly partisan and ideological voters on both the Republican
- 40:20and Democratic sides, they're not gonna forget their vote was already set in stone.
- 40:25There was nothing that was going to change their opinion anyways.
- 40:29And then lastly, immigration because that is a key issue right now, of course, and it's likely
- 40:35going to continue to be a key issue as it has been for most, if not all, of Donald Trump's
- 40:40second term.
- 40:41It was one of the highlights of his platform or one of the things that he highlighted on his
- 40:45platform.
- 40:46And a lot of the pushback over such policies such as the response to the Minnesota protests
- 40:53or putting immigrants in camps in other countries like El Salvador or in The US such as
- 40:59in Florida, Those are probably not going away anytime soon because those policies are
- 41:05probably going to continue to be relevant come election time.
- 41:10Now how much does that swing an election towards or against Democrats or towards or
- 41:18against Republicans?
- 41:20It's hard
- 41:20to say right now because we still have got many months before voting even starts, but I would
- 41:27assume that that is going to be another key issue for Donald Trump and the Republican
- 41:34party.
- 41:35But there was also some support for Donald Trump based on his immigration stances on the
- 41:39campaign trail.
- 41:40So how much of that will still be around in this midterm?
- 41:42But, of course, support for a president on any of their issues, on any of their stances before
- 41:49they get a chance to implement the policies can always shift when those policies actually
- 41:55happen because when a politician says is going to happen versus what actually does happen,
- 42:01there can be a lot of disparity in that regard.
- 42:04Whether they, you know, went back on a promise or just something just happened to work out
- 42:08differently or there was an unintended consequence, There's all sorts of things that
- 42:12can change.
- 42:14So, obviously, there's still gonna be a lot of people that are still staunchly for Donald
- 42:18Trump because of those policy views, and there's still gonna be some people that are
- 42:22staunchly against them because of those policy views and those policy effects.
- 42:26But, again, a lot of
- 42:28those people were already set in stone whether or not they
- 42:32were gonna vote for Donald Trump, and they'll be set in stone whether or not
- 42:35they vote for his party.
- 42:39But at the end of
- 42:40the day, though, it is a safe bet to assume that the sitting president's party is not going
- 42:45to have a fun midterm because you just have to look at history and all the reasons why people
- 42:50do it, whether it's because they're, quote, unquote, balancing a midterm against the
- 42:56president so that, you know, whichever party the president is, they're just gonna vote for
- 43:01the opposite party.
- 43:02Or if it's just simply because the president's not on the ballot this time or, you know, the
- 43:11out party is angrier and more hateful this time, and it's both parties.
- 43:16Let's not act like it's one party or the other.
- 43:19Both parties engage in it, And so any one of those things can have a particularly potent
- 43:26effect on this year's elections.
- 43:28Now how much how many seats would be lost by Republicans?
- 43:33You also have to account for the fact that Republicans in the US house had a very thin
- 43:38margin.
- 43:39So even just losing a few seats can totally swing the majority in the favor of Democrats.
- 43:46And I'm I'm forgetting exactly how many seats that are up in the senate are held by
- 43:51Republicans right now.
- 43:53I'd have to look that up again.
- 43:54But part of that's part of the calculus too.
- 43:57How many Republican seats in the US senate are up for election?
- 44:01Now there might they might still have a net loss in seats, but will they lose enough to
- 44:06lose the US senate?
- 44:08That's one of
- 44:08the big questions.
- 44:09But in any case, midterms in this case, Donald Trump is a Republican.
- 44:16Republicans control congress, and midterm history suggests that at least one of
- 44:22those chambers is going to become democratic.
- 44:27If it's just one, it's almost definitely going to be the US house.
- 44:31They might win the US senate as well.
- 44:33But in any case, republicans should brace themselves.
- 44:38And so that is going to do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 44:44As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 44:46Please like, comment, share, and subscribe for the podcast wherever you get them on YouTube,
- 44:52on Spotify, on Apple Podcasts.
- 44:53Hopefully, expand this to other podcast platforms in the near future.
- 45:00My links to the show notes, Facebook page, Paul Raider author and speaker, LinkedIn profile,
- 45:04medium.com profile, my five day educational email course about how we can all more
- 45:09effectively mitigate polarization toxicity, my website, Paul Raider dot org, my email,
- 45:15PaulRaiderwrites@gmail.com, my book on Amazon about independence in elections, and believe
- 45:23that's all of them.
- 45:24So thank you
- 45:25so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.