Latest / Austen Chat / Reading Between the Lines of Mansfield Park: A Visit with Patricia Matthew
Transcript
- 0:12Breckyn Wood: Hello, Janeites, and welcome to "Austen Chat," the podcast of the Jane Austen Society of North America.
- 0:18Breckyn Wood: I'm Breckyn Wood from the Georgia Region of JASNA.
- 0:20Breckyn Wood: If you're a regular listener, you may have noticed that I took a break from hosting the podcast this summer.
- 0:25Breckyn Wood: We wanted to keep the Austen conversation going though, so we invited some fellow JASNA members to step in as guest hosts.
- 0:31Breckyn Wood: Today I'm delighted to hand the microphone to Anne Fertig, Regional Coordinator for the Washington, D.C., Region of JASNA.
- 0:38Breckyn Wood: You may already be familiar with her work.
- 0:40Breckyn Wood: She's the writer and host of "Finding Jane Austen," a scripted documentary podcast about Jane Austen's life.
- 0:46Breckyn Wood: Anne has a PhD in English and comparative literature, specializing in 18th-century women's writing, and she focuses on creating digital history and new media projects for public audiences.
- 0:57Breckyn Wood: She co-founded the Jane Austen and Co.
- 0:59Breckyn Wood: web series when she was a PhD candidate at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill.
- 1:04Breckyn Wood: She now works in the museum field in Washington, D.C., as a content producer.
- 1:09Breckyn Wood: In this episode, Anne talks with Patricia Matthew about "Mansfield Park," in all its beauties and complexities, and the ways in which Jane Austen weaves social commentary into her novels.
- 1:19Breckyn Wood: Stick around to the end where Dr.
- 1:21Breckyn Wood: Matthew gives us a reading list of some of her other favorite 18th-century novels.
- 1:25Breckyn Wood: Patricia Matthew is Associate Professor of English at Montclair State University, specializing in 19th - century British literature, Regency culture, and abolitionist literature.
- 1:35Breckyn Wood: She's the editor of the Penguin Random Deluxe editions of "Pride and Prejudice" and "Northanger Abbey," released for Jane Austen's 250th birthday, as well as the forthcoming Norton Library edition of "Mansfield Park." She is currently writing a book on sugar, gender, and British abolitionist culture for Princeton University Press.
- 1:52Breckyn Wood: She co-edits the Oxford University Press series "Race in 19th - Century Literature and Culture," and her work has appeared in the journals "Women's Writing," "The Keats - Shelley Journal," and "Texas Studies in Literature and Language," as well as in "The Atlantic," "Lapham's Quarterly," "The Times Literary Supplement," and "Slate." Matthew is also the director of The Race and Regency Lab, and in 2024 was a plenary speaker at JASNA's Annual General Meeting.
- 2:18Breckyn Wood: We hope you enjoy the conversation!
- 2:21Anne Fertig: Welcome, Dr.
- 2:22Anne Fertig: Patricia Matthew, to "Austen Chat." We are so excited to have you here with us today to talk about "Mansfield Park." But before we begin, I want to ask you a question that we ask everybody on this podcast when they first come in, which is what is your Austen origin story?
- 2:37Anne Fertig: How did you first encounter Jane Austen's works?
- 2:40Patricia Matthew: Yes, well, hi Anne.
- 2:41Patricia Matthew: Thank you for having me.
- 2:43Patricia Matthew: And I think that question is interesting because I have a couple of Austen origin stories.
- 2:49Patricia Matthew: And so, the origin story of me as an Austen reader, I was— as a college student I read "Pride and Prejudice" and then wanted to read it repeatedly.
- 2:59Patricia Matthew: And so for a few years, I would read it at Christmas.
- 3:01Patricia Matthew: I don't know why I thought it was a Christmas novel.
- 3:04Patricia Matthew: I think it was a way for me to celebrate the end of the semester.
- 3:08Patricia Matthew: So, that's my original Austen story.
- 3:13Patricia Matthew: And then when I went to graduate school, one of the reasons I went was because I was so interested in her contemporaries.
- 3:20Patricia Matthew: I graduated from college very suspicious of the canon, and I thought there are other stories by other writers.
- 3:26Patricia Matthew: There must be.
- 3:28Patricia Matthew: And why do we read them?
- 3:30Patricia Matthew: Why do we read Austen and her other canonical counterparts and not them?
- 3:35Patricia Matthew: And so, I kind of drifted away from Austen for a while.
- 3:39Patricia Matthew: And so, I think the other origin story was writing my dissertation and needing a chapter—my dissertation committee insisted and said, "You cannot write a novel— a dissertation about the history of the novel and not write about Austen." And it's so silly that, you know, as a grad student, you just think you know everything.
- 3:57Patricia Matthew: And so, I conceded to write about "Sense and Sensibility," which is still, I think, my favorite Austen novel.
- 4:03Patricia Matthew: And then, finally, my students really pulled me in in a way that has stayed with me now for 23 years— their continued interest and curiosity, what they're interested in, their resistance that sort of underscores their sense that in order to be worldly and educated, they have to have read Austen.
- 4:26Patricia Matthew: Our major is designed— the English major at Montclair is designed in such a way that you can actually graduate without reading Austen.
- 4:34Patricia Matthew: And so their choice is a deliberate one.
- 4:36Patricia Matthew: Whenever she's on the syllabus, whenever I'm offering a class— any class on the novel.
- 4:42Patricia Matthew: And so, that's also in its own way a different origin story.
- 4:46Anne Fertig: I love that, especially because of this question of "why Jane Austen?"— which I think us scholars often grapple with a lot of— as you put it, why Jane Austen and why none of these other wonderful authors who are writing at the same time?
- 5:02Anne Fertig: So, I know it's like a really big question, but to you, why Jane Austen?
- 5:09Patricia Matthew: I think partly it's her place in the sort of global— when I say canon, I don't necessarily mean canon the way that we use it as literary scholars.
- 5:21Patricia Matthew: I think that she's a global figure and a signal of being educated, worldly, and curious.
- 5:30Patricia Matthew: And I think she has remained popular in large part because of the adaptations.
- 5:36Patricia Matthew: I think she remains popular because you can read Austen repeatedly and find new pleasures.
- 5:44Patricia Matthew: I was talking to one of the editors I work with, and I was anxious about my own edition.
- 5:51Patricia Matthew: And I said, you know, in a really cranky way, "I mean, do we really need another edition of X?" And she said, "Well, Patricia, when's the last time we had an edition of X?" And I said, "Last month." [Laughing] We keep producing these editions of Austen.
- 6:08Patricia Matthew: I mean, I think the other thing is her books— it's such a— it's such a manageable body of work.
- 6:16Patricia Matthew: You can read the six novels every year without stretching yourself.
- 6:21Patricia Matthew: I think books are beautiful as physical objects.
- 6:26Patricia Matthew: Even as I was wrestling with writing, editing three Austen editions and thinking, "does the world need another Austen edition?" I purchased the Folio— those beautiful boxed Folio editions that they made 1200 copies or some like ridiculously small number.
- 6:42Patricia Matthew: And I thought, "Yes, not only do I need more Austen, I need this Austen in this sense." So, the books are collectible, the stories— I don't say this often, but the stories really do feel timeless.
- 6:55Patricia Matthew: I think that every generation finds Austen for themselves and they find something in her that is either fascinating or interesting or intriguing.
- 7:06Patricia Matthew: I think pop culture has invited us to consider her in new ways.
- 7:13Patricia Matthew: I think even though I have to tell everyone that "Bridgerton" is not— these are not Austen adaptations, that author is an Austen fan.
- 7:21Patricia Matthew: I think the fact that so many writers of historical romance novels cut their teeth on Austen keeps that, um, that aesthetic and that world alive for new generations of readers.
- 7:36Anne Fertig: Now you mentioned your own edition.
- 7:39Anne Fertig: Are you talking about your upcoming edition of "Mansfield Park"?
- 7:44Patricia Matthew: Well, yes, but I also— at that— in the moment, in that moment, I had seen— happily seen the publication of my Penguin Random House edition of "Pride and Prejudice," and then my Penguin Random House edition of "Northanger Abbey." And then I was also working on "Mansfield Park." And, you know, I'm— I say this— I hope the smile comes through in the audio.
- 8:10Patricia Matthew: I wrote this essay the last time we were celebrating, saying "On Teaching, but Not Loving, Jane Austen." And now, however many years later, I'm producing Austen editions.
- 8:23Patricia Matthew: I get teased a lot about it.
- 8:26Patricia Matthew: I get teased a lot by colleagues and friends and— who've known me for a long time.
- 8:32Patricia Matthew: And then there's a part of me that's like, "Well, why don't I just do them all?
- 8:35Patricia Matthew: Why don't I go ahead and do 'Persuasion'?
- 8:37Patricia Matthew: And you know, we need a good edition of 'Sanditon.'" So, I'm maybe a little bit hooked, even though I really wrestle with the work.
- 8:46Anne Fertig: What is the process of editing one of Austen's novels like?
- 8:52Patricia Matthew: So, it's terrifying.
- 8:53Patricia Matthew: It's absolutely terrifying because— and I think it's a good humility, by the way.
- 8:59Patricia Matthew: I think it's the humility that comes when you know that there have been, for more than a century, brilliant people who have taken up the task of presenting her work and doing it in a responsible way.
- 9:11Patricia Matthew: Some of them— editions— are editions that I read first as an undergraduate, then as a doctoral student, and that I teach from.
- 9:21Patricia Matthew: My Norton Critical Editions have— are really sturdy, but I've used them so much, several of them are wrapped in rubber bands because the binding— I've just used it so much.
- 9:32Patricia Matthew: And so, it's, it's a little daunting to join that community.
- 9:39Patricia Matthew: It's also— I mean, just as my— the way that I think in terms of my work as being built on the labor and brilliance of those who've come before, I want to do justice to their work.
- 9:56Patricia Matthew: And so, so that's sort of the approach.
- 9:59Patricia Matthew: It depends on the kind of editions.
- 10:01Patricia Matthew: So, Penguin Random House Deluxe Editions are meant for people who would just go into a bookstore and pick up an Austen novel.
- 10:10Patricia Matthew: So, the Penguin Deluxe editions, they're made— they're beautiful, beautiful, beautiful.
- 10:15Patricia Matthew: But it's a general introduction.
- 10:17Patricia Matthew: This is who Austen is, this is what this novel is.
- 10:20Patricia Matthew: And then they ask their editors to write short essays to highlight specific themes or characters or elements of the novels.
- 10:32Patricia Matthew: I prepared explanatory notes, and then I selected illustrations.
- 10:36Patricia Matthew: What I didn't do, which is what I think people might imagine for those, I didn't do textual editing.
- 10:43Patricia Matthew: In other words, the "Pride and Prejudice" that's in the Penguin was edited— [unintelligible] I'm gonna forget the name of the editor, but those were pre-edited.
- 10:52Patricia Matthew: So I simply provided the extra, the extra narrative material.
- 10:58Patricia Matthew: Norton was a different project.
- 11:01Patricia Matthew: There I went and I worked with the 1816 "Mansfield Park." We know Austen published the 1814 edition, and then she revised it in 1816.
- 11:13Patricia Matthew: It came out with a different publisher.
- 11:14Patricia Matthew: And that required— in addition to explanatory notes, I had to go through and look at— and I hesitate to call them errors— but inconsistencies.
- 11:26Patricia Matthew: Sometimes there are open quotation marks but not quote closed quotation marks.
- 11:31Patricia Matthew: Sometimes French phases— phrases— would be italicized and they wouldn't be italicized.
- 11:37Patricia Matthew: Missing words, and— there are, I— I hate to call them typos, but there are, there are mistakes and errors.
- 11:44Patricia Matthew: It's a clean draft, so there aren't a ton of them.
- 11:47Patricia Matthew: But in order to do that work— and some scholars— and Claudia Johnson comes to mind immediately, sort of discusses the 1814 and she provides information about the 1814 and the 1816 edition.
- 12:02Patricia Matthew: So, Austen changes it from 1814 to 1816, and sometimes it's the difference of a comma.
- 12:07Patricia Matthew: So, the first sentence of the 1816 edition of "Mansfield Park" and the punctuation is different than the 1814 edition.
- 12:16Patricia Matthew: And as you're reading for that— so I'm reading— you know, I don't know how many times I've read "Mansfield Park" and how many times I've taught "Mansfield Park," but I've just picked up the edition.
- 12:28Patricia Matthew: I've used Claudia Johnson's mostly.
- 12:30Patricia Matthew: Sometimes I use Penguin Classics, depending on the class.
- 12:35Patricia Matthew: But I've just sort of just picked up the edition and just assigned it.
- 12:39Patricia Matthew: Students might have different editions.
- 12:42Patricia Matthew: You know, you say you want this one, but they get the one that's the least expensive.
- 12:45Patricia Matthew: So, reading it in that way was a completely different experience.
- 12:50Patricia Matthew: Keeping track, double checking, sometimes doubting myself, sometimes seeing things a bit differently, and then, you know, circling and marking the text that Norton will go through and implement.
- 13:04Patricia Matthew: Norton, for the Library Classics, these are meant to be inexpensive classroom editions.
- 13:10Patricia Matthew: And so, I was asked to write an introduction, and I split it into an introduction and an afterword.
- 13:17Patricia Matthew: So, how can I generally introduce the novel and then put little seeds in the reader's brain that I then explore in the afterword with the hope that they'll flower, and then explanatory notes.
- 13:31Patricia Matthew: So, that's, that's that process.
- 13:34Anne Fertig: That seems so daunting.
- 13:36Anne Fertig: How do you look at the works— the texts of someone like Jane Austen, who is so revered in a way, and make that decision of what is the correct, or even what is the version we're going to go with?
- 13:50Patricia Matthew: Yeah, so I went with the 1816 because she revised it.
- 13:54Patricia Matthew: So, I feel, along with other scholars, that we can trust that that's Austen's vision of the novel that she wanted to leave behind.
- 14:03Patricia Matthew: And in some instances, it's just a missing word.
- 14:07Patricia Matthew: Sometimes the typeset is off.
- 14:11Patricia Matthew: So, I'm hardly ever in the position of feeling like I'm correcting Jane Austen .
- 14:18Patricia Matthew: .
- 14:18Patricia Matthew: .
- 14:18Patricia Matthew: right?
- 14:19Patricia Matthew: These aren't interpretive, you know, decisions.
- 14:22Patricia Matthew: But sometimes— for example, I think in one note she refers to Mrs.
- 14:29Patricia Matthew: Grant as Miss Grant.
- 14:31Patricia Matthew: And that's just a— you know, that's just a thing that happens.
- 14:35Patricia Matthew: My fear or my anxiety or my general of— is wanting to get it right and not wanting to reproduce an error that maybe should have been fixed or to fix something that isn't correct.
- 14:51Patricia Matthew: So I did my own reading of— and I read in three - ring binders— I read a print copy; I did not read it online.
- 14:58Patricia Matthew: And then I looked and consulted with other editions whenever I was concerned about something to make sure that I was reading it right— that I was, you know, that I hadn't gone too far afield.
- 15:13Patricia Matthew: But it's just, it's just this— and I think that when students read it, they'll just read it, right?
- 15:18Patricia Matthew: Maybe they won't notice that some of the closed quotations are missing or some of the punctuation is a little different.
- 15:26Patricia Matthew: But I'll know. I'll know, and I want to make sure that I get it right.
- 15:32Anne Fertig: You know, I realized as I was preparing for this conversation that "Mansfield Park" is the one that I own the most copies of in different editions.
- 15:41Anne Fertig: I actually just bought the Harvard Illustrated edition over the summer.
- 15:45Anne Fertig: I have a Broadview edition.
- 15:47Anne Fertig: I still have my Penguin from college, and it's so beat up, and it still has the sticker on it because I bought it used.
- 15:54Patricia Matthew: Used, the yellow used, right?
- 15:56Anne Fertig: Yes.
- 15:56Anne Fertig: [Laughter]
- 15:56Patricia Matthew: It's ubiquitous.
- 15:58Anne Fertig: And I can't let go of them.
- 16:00Anne Fertig: But I realize, like, with "Mansfield Park," I always— it's because, like, I always want to see somebody else's take on it.
- 16:05Anne Fertig: I always want something new and illuminated about it that I always feel like, you know, there's still so much to discover within the text of this novel.
- 16:15Anne Fertig: And "Mansfield Park" in particular seems to have this reputation of being one of Jane Austen's most complex novels.
- 16:23Anne Fertig: And some, you know, find it less accessible, maybe for that reason.
- 16:29Anne Fertig: Why do you think that is?
- 16:30Anne Fertig: What is it about "Mansfield Park"?
- 16:33Patricia Matthew: So, I hate to blame Fanny Price, who I feel very protective of at the end of this project.
- 16:40Patricia Matthew: I think she's— I think that there's so much going on in her head that gets lost.
- 16:48Patricia Matthew: But I do believe that she's not a heroine that we want to be.
- 16:54Patricia Matthew: Right?
- 16:55Patricia Matthew: If there's an Austen quiz— you know how for a while it's, like, which Austen heroine are you?
- 17:00Patricia Matthew: Pretty much everybody wants to be Lizzy Bennet.
- 17:03Patricia Matthew: And then after that, Elinor Dashwood, probably.
- 17:07Patricia Matthew: I'm just guessing, you know, and then I think low on that list are Catherine— is Catherine Morland.
- 17:15Patricia Matthew: I wrote an essay once about a professor who compared me to Emma Woodhouse before I had read the novel, and I was mortified when I read it, and then felt that Anne was me.
- 17:28Patricia Matthew: You know, I felt Anne.
- 17:30Patricia Matthew: I was Anne— for no good reason, by the way.
- 17:32Patricia Matthew: My father is not the head of a crumbling family.
- 17:35Patricia Matthew: He's not.
- 17:37Patricia Matthew: You know, he's not obsessed with— but he was in the military.
- 17:41Patricia Matthew: He's a retired military person, so maybe he's not Elliot's dad, maybe he's who she loves.
- 17:46Patricia Matthew: But I just think that there aren't— I think that our primary characters in terms of Fanny and Edmund— their love story is not fun, you know?
- 17:59Patricia Matthew: I mean, it's just not fun.
- 18:01Patricia Matthew: We see the shift in Darcy and Lizzy Bennet, Elizabeth Bennet.
- 18:06Patricia Matthew: We may not be rooting for them, but we see that evolve between the two of them.
- 18:13Patricia Matthew: It just sort of feels at the end that Austen just puts them together, you know.
- 18:18Patricia Matthew: And she even, I think, invites this.
- 18:20Patricia Matthew: She's like, "Listen, I'm gonna leave to other pens the details.
- 18:23Patricia Matthew: You can decide when." It's as if she understood that she's writing a courtship novel, and so she has this social contract with the reader that she has to fill.
- 18:33Patricia Matthew: And so, she has to do it, and maybe it's not so exciting.
- 18:38Patricia Matthew: Fanny is not particularly inspiring.
- 18:40Patricia Matthew: Mrs.
- 18:41Patricia Matthew: Norris is a horrible person, even though she cracks me up.
- 18:45Patricia Matthew: Lady Bertram, you know, doesn't get exercised about anything except for her, her dogs.
- 18:51Patricia Matthew: I think for many readers, the character who feels the most contemporary is probably Mary Crawford.
- 19:01Patricia Matthew: And I think in the same way that contemporary young women can identify with Lizzy Bennet and still call themselves feminists, they can identify with Mary Crawford and still call themselves feminists— except the novelist doesn't really like Mary Crawford in the same way that the novelist seems to— or our narrator seems to— like Fanny Price.
- 19:24Patricia Matthew: So, we don't have really, I think, someone to root for in the same way.
- 19:30Patricia Matthew: And the comedy isn't as present as it is in, say, "Emma." And the sentimentality— I'm just thinking out loud now, because I'm thinking of how much I love "Sense and Sensibility" and how much part of my love of "Sense and Sensibility" is being irritated with Marianne Dashwood, who I just want to shake, you know, or, like Cher in "Moonstruck," smack her and say "Snap out of it!" I just, you know— I just— I mean, in class when I teach her, I'm so genuinely exercised by how irritating she is— so much so that invariably some of my students are, like, "Goodness, Dr.
- 20:10Patricia Matthew: Matthew." They don't say "goodness." They may even say, "Damn, Dr.
- 20:13Patricia Matthew: Matthew, what did that what did she do to you?" It's rather irritating.
- 20:17Patricia Matthew: I don't think anyone in "Mansfield Park" excites those kinds of emotions.
- 20:24Patricia Matthew: And, you know, in my edition, I— you know, you go back and you look at how Austen's family reacted and responded.
- 20:32Patricia Matthew: I mean, I think even Austen's own mother wasn't crazy about Fanny Price.
- 20:37Patricia Matthew: And the novel sets on her shoulders, right?
- 20:40Patricia Matthew: By the time we pick up— I think by the time everyone picks up "Mansfield Park," they have an expectation.
- 20:46Patricia Matthew: I do not think "Mansfield Park" is anyone's first Austen novel.
- 20:50Patricia Matthew: I don't think anybody wanders into Barnes and Noble or their local independent bookseller or says, "Oh, you know what, I'm gonna read "Mansfield Park." I think they pick up "Pride and Prejudice." I think they pick up "Emma." And I mean, I just think in terms of popular culture, we haven't had the —we haven't had the definitive, iconic adaptation that cements the heroine in a way that makes us connect to her.
- 21:20Patricia Matthew: So, I think all of that is surrounding the novel.
- 21:23Patricia Matthew: And that's before you even get to the heavy subject of the slave trade.
- 21:29Patricia Matthew: I think, you know, students might find it icky that Fanny marries her cousin.
- 21:35Patricia Matthew: Henry Crawford—there's just a lot.
- 21:38Patricia Matthew: What do we do about Henry Crawford?
- 21:40Patricia Matthew: You know, the Bertram daughters are not— there just aren't a lot of likable characters.
- 21:47Patricia Matthew: They're interesting, and I think they're culturally interesting, but I don't think you imagine yourself as sitting and having a conversation with them or going for a carriage ride with them the way you would with other Austen characters.
- 22:02Anne Fertig: Yeah, I think, you know, it's not necessarily a novel filled with the most likable of Austen's characters, but they're still very interesting in certain ways.
- 22:14Anne Fertig: And you yourself have given talks recently on —for JASNA groups— on social commentary, right, in "Mansfield Park." What does that— what do you mean by social commentary in the novel?
- 22:26Anne Fertig: And where do you find it?
- 22:28Patricia Matthew: Yeah, that's a— you know, I was thinking about— I love that I was thinking about that question, because I was— and I may just— this might just be a semantic distinction.
- 22:36Patricia Matthew: I think there's a difference between observation, which can feel like commentary, but just describing a world that you know, and what you choose to describe is maybe not as important as what you leave out, right?
- 22:54Patricia Matthew: This thinking silence.
- 22:55Patricia Matthew: And so I— there's sort of— there's observation, and then I think there is a kind of satirizing that Austen does.
- 23:04Patricia Matthew: And sat— you know, satire is social commentary, but I don't always know— I wouldn't always say that Austen's satirizing the clergy to make a comment on the Church of England.
- 23:19Patricia Matthew: Right?
- 23:20Patricia Matthew: I— we laugh, we laugh at a rector, we laugh at Mr.
- 23:27Patricia Matthew: Collins, but I don't know that any of us thinks that Austen is criticizing the church.
- 23:32Anne Fertig: Yeah. Good point.
- 23:32Patricia Matthew: She's criticizing [unintelligible].
- 23:33Patricia Matthew: Right.
- 23:35Patricia Matthew: But then, as she does in "Northanger Abbey," when she comes out swinging in defense of the novel, that is social commentary.
- 23:43Patricia Matthew: She just— I mean, it's just un— when I say unfiltered, I mean, she disrupts— the narrator— to defend this defense of the novel.
- 23:53Patricia Matthew: I would put that right up against Shelley's "Defense of Poetry" in defense of poetry, the "Preface to Lyrical Ballads." I mean, I just think it's such an important piece of prose that argues for genre.
- 24:08Patricia Matthew: And that feels like social commentary.
- 24:10Patricia Matthew: I want to say, and I don't want to get too far ahead of us in the conversation, but I think that her insistence that women can be rational and smart and caring and kind and not overly sentimental feels like social commentary, because so much of the writing of the time dismissed women for being overly feeling.
- 24:41Patricia Matthew: You know, I don't think you title a novel "Sense and Sensibility" without making some sort of social commentary.
- 24:47Patricia Matthew: And so, I think that that's where I see it in "Mansfield Park." I think "Mansfield Park" is as much a social commentary about the importance of the estate.
- 24:58Patricia Matthew: And I'm not obviously not the first person to see this.
- 25:03Patricia Matthew: I always think of him as Alistair.
- 25:06Patricia Matthew: He has a very important last name [Duckworth], "Jane Austen and The Improvement of the Estate" ["The Improvement of the Estate: A Study of Jane Austen's Novels"].
- 25:10Patricia Matthew: That feels like social commentary.
- 25:12Patricia Matthew: I think mentioning Repton and the conversation between Rushworth and his improvements and Fanny's resistance to the improvement— I feel that there's social commentary in there.
- 25:27Patricia Matthew: I think that Sir Thomas's regret at the end of "Mansfield Park" sort of suggests that Austen is making a— sort of commenting on how— particularly young people in the gentry— are raised.
- 25:45Patricia Matthew: It's a commentary on education.
- 25:47Patricia Matthew: And I think that's consistent across many of the books.
- 25:51Anne Fertig: That's so interesting.
- 25:52Anne Fertig: Yeah.
- 25:53Anne Fertig: Because you bring up "Northanger Abbey," and to me, the defense of that novel is so direct, it's pretty much breaking the fourth wall.
- 25:58Patricia Matthew: Yeah.
- 25:59Anne Fertig: Right? We have her speaking to us literally as the writer, as the narrator, and telling us.
- 26:06Anne Fertig: But that— it doesn't seem really to be operating in the same way in "Mansfield Park," where she's much more subtle about it.
- 26:14Patricia Matthew: Mmhmm. Yes, yes.
- 26:15Patricia Matthew: And, you know, this is a more mature novel.
- 26:18Patricia Matthew: And so, when she sits down to write this, it's not that— I mean, she always knew what a novel was, but she understood herself as a novelist in a different way, right?
- 26:27Patricia Matthew: Her other novels had done really well.
- 26:29Patricia Matthew: She must have had a process.
- 26:33Patricia Matthew: I mean, by the time— I'm gonna forget the number of years because I always do in these conversations— but by the time she sits down to write "Mansfield Park," she's been writing for a very long time.
- 26:42Patricia Matthew: She's written the juvenilia, she's written "Northanger Abbey," she's irritated that "North—, you know, in the back of her mind is "Northanger Abbey" still hasn't been published.
- 26:50Patricia Matthew: "Sense and Sensibility," "Emma," "Pride and Prejudice." I think that "Mansfield Park's" weight might be a reaction to the lightness that she worried about in "Pride and Prejudice." She said it, you know, "it wants a lecture" and she's joking, but I think "Mansfield Park" is,— I wouldn't call it a didactic novel by any means, but it is taking on heavy and weighted subjects.
- 27:14Patricia Matthew: And you're right, I think that narrator is not the same narrator in "Northanger Abbey," who happily interrupts herself to say, "Yes, novels.
- 27:23Patricia Matthew: I'm doing X, Y, and Z." Calls herself Catherine's biographer at some point, right?
- 27:30Patricia Matthew: I think the narrator in "Mansfield Park" is always present, but a little more restrained— much more restrained than in "Northanger Abbey." But still there, you know.
- 27:43Patricia Matthew: She's still, she's still— when she comes in and says, "You know, I don't want to dwell on tales— on misery, and then dwells on it.
- 27:52Patricia Matthew: You just— you just "Come on already, we're ready to wrap this up.
- 27:57Patricia Matthew: We know how it's gonna end by now." But she just understands herself as part of a tradition of storytellers.
- 28:06Anne Fertig: You mentioned earlier this idea of silence in the novels.
- 28:11Anne Fertig: How do we read silence?
- 28:14Anne Fertig: Like how— especially in a novel like "Mansfield Park," but also any of the others, what do you do with what's unsaid?
- 28:23Patricia Matthew: That's a great way to say that question.
- 28:25Patricia Matthew: I am— because I was thinking sort of topically.
- 28:28Patricia Matthew: So, Austen, by and large, for example, is silent about servants.
- 28:32Patricia Matthew: With very few exceptions, right.
- 28:35Patricia Matthew: We don't think about that.
- 28:37Patricia Matthew: She doesn't mete out punishment in the way that she quote, unquote is supposed to.
- 28:45Patricia Matthew: So, I think Marianne Dashwood, by all accounts— I think in another novel, probably, if in the hands of another novelist, might have died.
- 28:55Anne Fertig: Right.
- 28:56Patricia Matthew: But she doesn't.
- 28:56Patricia Matthew: Right.
- 28:57Patricia Matthew: She loses her blush, but she still marries a man who's wealthy enough to give her exactly the life that she wants.
- 29:05Patricia Matthew: I think there is a way that Austen is not particularly interested in punishing characters for not adhering to even her— what we might think of as her ideals.
- 29:18Patricia Matthew: So, Lydia Bennet is— certainly doesn't have the life she wants.
- 29:22Patricia Matthew: She's away from her family.
- 29:24Patricia Matthew: She sort of is excommunicated to the north when the south is this beautiful aesthetic place.
- 29:31Patricia Matthew: But I think that we're invited to think about her more sympathetically.
- 29:36Patricia Matthew: So, the criticism of Lydia is silent in a certain way.
- 29:41Patricia Matthew: I think even in explaining that she's her mother's favorite, Austen leaves a lot to the readers.
- 29:48Patricia Matthew: In "Mansfield Park,"— and I talked about this with JASNA, and I think it made its way— I have, I've— I sent in all the materials that are in copy edits; I'm not quite remembering everything.
- 29:58Patricia Matthew: But I was particularly interested in the silence in the landscape at the ha - ha— that moment where the land doesn't announce itself until you're right at the edge of it.
- 30:09Patricia Matthew: And so, for people who might not remember, that's that architectural element that is designed to separate the land and cordon it off without disturbing the vista.
- 30:21Patricia Matthew: So, you don't see a ha-ha— you don't know it's there; it's like a ditch— until you're right on it.
- 30:27Patricia Matthew: In fact, ha-ha is what— that's supposed to capture your— "Oh, it's there." It can be dangerous.
- 30:32Patricia Matthew: And in "Mansfield Park," when Fanny Price says "You'll slip into the ha-ha," right?
- 30:38Patricia Matthew: That's a, that's a— this land is silent in what it might— how it might be a danger to Maria Bertram.
- 30:48Patricia Matthew: So it's not telling, but the reader understands— and especially Austen's readers would have understood what a ha-ha is.
- 30:56Patricia Matthew: And of course, you know, I think about the silence of the Bertrams.
- 31:01Patricia Matthew: I'm —Austen doesn't do this in her novels, but I said it would be very convenient for us if Austen had had an anti-slavery teapot on the table, or if Lady Bertram was knitting an anti-slavery pillowcase— we know that women did this.
- 31:19Patricia Matthew: So the silence is not just in that moment that everyone points to when there's silence when Fanny brings up the slave trade.
- 31:27Patricia Matthew: The silence about it exists throughout the novel.
- 31:30Patricia Matthew: Even though when Mrs.
- 31:33Patricia Matthew: Norris mentions the Antiguan property, the plantation, it's one of the times when Lady Bertram is actually the least silent.
- 31:42Patricia Matthew: She says, pretty forcefully, "It's fine.
- 31:45Patricia Matthew: He's got that well in hand." And for a woman who doesn't seem to care about much of anything, to just sort of be— " exercised" is too strong a word.
- 31:56Patricia Matthew: But she actually does stand up to her sister in that moment and says, "We have talked about it.
- 32:03Patricia Matthew: My husband and I have talked about it." And then, you know, goes back to being herself.
- 32:08Patricia Matthew: And so, that distinction between silent and speech— that's between silence and speech.
- 32:15Patricia Matthew: I'll just say one more thing.
- 32:17Patricia Matthew: When Mary Crawford is trying to pull Fanny Price into her brother, and she says, "I have, you know, I've been, I've been silent, but I haven't been blind." I don't know if I've got that quote direct.
- 32:33Patricia Matthew: But she says, "You know, I may not have said anything, but I've seen it." And when her uncle is asking her why she doesn't want to be with Mary— Henry Crawford, she doesn't know how to speak to him, but the narrator shows us what's happening in her brain.
- 32:47Patricia Matthew: Her brain is really loud.
- 32:49Patricia Matthew: She's sifting through all of the implications of what it would mean to explain why she doesn't trust Crawford because she doesn't want to accidentally reveal that her cousins have behaved imprudently.
- 33:03Patricia Matthew: Even though if she had said so, that might have been a warning to everyone about what was forthcoming between Henry Crawford and Maria Bertram.
- 33:14Anne Fertig: So, as you know, there's been a lot of research recently by Devoney Looser, amongst others, about the abolitionist ties of the Austen family themselves— notably the Austen brothers.
- 33:27Anne Fertig: Is this something that you see strongly emerging in a novel like "Mansfield Park" or any of the others?
- 33:34Anne Fertig: Or is it something that you think is more couched in those silences?
- 33:40Patricia Matthew: So here's what I wrote.
- 33:43Patricia Matthew: I'm not quoting it directly.
- 33:45Patricia Matthew: I think we want to see Austen as an abolitionist because that aligns with our admiration.
- 33:50Patricia Matthew: But to be an abolitionist and to use that term is a— it's an actual— it suggests something concrete.
- 33:58Patricia Matthew: Right?
- 33:59Patricia Matthew: It was a movement, and people adhered to abolitionist thought, or they were slavery's apologist, or they were ameliorist, right?
- 34:08Patricia Matthew: Let's fix the institution of slavery, not end it.
- 34:12Patricia Matthew: And I don't see in the novel a clear abolitionist stance.
- 34:18Patricia Matthew: I think the— I think the novel is sympathetic to the plight of enslaved people.
- 34:25Patricia Matthew: I think the reference to Cowper and the ref— and the fact that Austen reads Clarkson— I think it's all there.
- 34:32Patricia Matthew: And I think Austen was sympathetic.
- 34:33Patricia Matthew: But here's the thing: even when Austen's a social commentator— just what you said, it's couched very carefully.
- 34:39Patricia Matthew: She's not a Wollstonecraft, right?
- 34:42Patricia Matthew: She's not an Edgeworth, right?
- 34:44Patricia Matthew: She's not, she— even when she's speaking for women's rights, she's not doing it from a pulpit.
- 34:49Patricia Matthew: She's not doing it standing on some sort of pedestal waving an equity banner.
- 34:54Patricia Matthew: That's just not who she is as a writer.
- 34:56Patricia Matthew: And so, it's not just that she doesn't write that way about the slave trade.
- 35:00Patricia Matthew: She doesn't write that way— even her social commentary, with the exception of defending the novel as a genre, right?
- 35:07Patricia Matthew: I don't think she— I don't see her as coming up and standing up and shouting anything.
- 35:13Patricia Matthew: In fact, the thing that sometimes irritates me about contemporary adaptations of Austen is that they want the story to be more aggressively political than I think Austen is in any of her writing.
- 35:27Patricia Matthew: It's definitely there.
- 35:29Patricia Matthew: It's definitely there.
- 35:30Patricia Matthew: And I think it's —I think it's fair to look at her and not to equate— I don't think Fanny is an abolitionist.
- 35:39Patricia Matthew: I think Fanny is an institutionalist.
- 35:41Patricia Matthew: I think whatever her uncle wants, she wants.
- 35:43Patricia Matthew: Whatever the church wants, she wants.
- 35:46Patricia Matthew: You know, I don't, I don't think that Fanny is an abolitionist.
- 35:49Patricia Matthew: And she's— and we can't, we can't forgive her for not being knowledgeable about it, because she asks questions.
- 35:59Patricia Matthew: She's "I'd love to hear my uncle talk about it." We don't know what he describes to her, right?
- 36:06Anne Fertig: Right.
- 36:06Patricia Matthew: My book project spends a lot of time thinking about the representations of slavery, of the slave trade that circulated in England, which is very— in so many ways, papers over the horror of it.
- 36:21Patricia Matthew: At the same time, you know, Mansfield rules on the Zong case.
- 36:26Patricia Matthew: So— and the circulation of the "Brookes" image, the slave ship that shows how enslaved people were stacked.
- 36:36Patricia Matthew: So that's circulating.
- 36:38Patricia Matthew: And we don't know if— Austen doesn't mention it.
- 36:42Patricia Matthew: But the fact that Fanny doesn't come out swinging against abolition doesn't mean that her creator, Jane Austen, is not sympathetic to the slave trade.
- 36:50Patricia Matthew: And I think we want a— I think we want a clearer statement because it's such an uncomfortable business.
- 36:57Patricia Matthew: It's such an uncomfortable— it's a nasty business.
- 36:59Patricia Matthew: It's such an uncomfortable thing for people to think about in a world that they want to imagine where people are walking around in costumes and, you know, gloves and, like, where cos people— I don't do it—people cosplay that world, and they want to separate it from the engine that made it possible, which was the slave trade.
- 37:25Anne Fertig: That's a fantastic answer.
- 37:27Anne Fertig: And I think, you know, as you talked a lot about this idea of social commentary and the various forms of it, you know, we often do consider "Mansfield Park" to be the most politically charged of Austen's novels.
- 37:40Anne Fertig: And maybe that's just because we are reading what we want to be reading into it.
- 37:45Anne Fertig: Do you find, though, any similar strands of that in the other novels?
- 37:51Patricia Matthew: I think you've hit on it.
- 37:53Patricia Matthew: And thank you.
- 37:54Patricia Matthew: I'm glad that my answer made sense.
- 37:55Patricia Matthew: And I want to just say here on this podcast, it's evolved in dialogue with members of JASNA and Austen and Co.
- 38:04Patricia Matthew: The res— not just Devoney's research, but the research— at my JASNA talk at the AGM, I had a slide up of 30 years of talking about this topic.
- 38:15Patricia Matthew: And so, it's just a topic that people have considered in myriad ways, published in "Persuasions", which is such a phenomenal gift to the public— that scholarly, careful thinking from a range of readers.
- 38:30Patricia Matthew: I've been in dialogue; I've benefited so much from that work.
- 38:33Patricia Matthew: I don't know that she is or not, but I think we are keenly tuned into this subject.
- 38:40Patricia Matthew: I think we are just so focused on it from various perspectives.
- 38:48Patricia Matthew: If you're a person of color in the literary societies of Austen, you are unique.
- 38:56Patricia Matthew: You're one of a small percentage.
- 38:58Patricia Matthew: And it has to feel strange there.
- 39:03Patricia Matthew: It is a world that's dominated by white women with deep investments in a particular version of Austen.
- 39:10Patricia Matthew: I'm always— but also, and I say this, I'm not just being politic— also deeply curious about history.
- 39:18Patricia Matthew: Right?
- 39:18Patricia Matthew: Deeply want— they really want to understand.
- 39:21Patricia Matthew: And so that balance of understanding it and then leaving the fantasy of Austen untouched, that's a kind of tightrope.
- 39:28Patricia Matthew: I was sort of shocked at a meeting when someone came up to me and they were disagreeing with what I had presented in my talk.
- 39:39Patricia Matthew: And unlike at an academic conference where they would have asked me a question that I could have then answered, I was on my way to get a scone.
- 39:46Patricia Matthew: And they said— and I didn't know— they had the benefit of knowing me, and I didn't know them, and I didn't want to, you know, I didn't want to sort of whip out my scholarly stick and spank them.
- 39:59Patricia Matthew: But I was aware that it's in the air, this sort of question.
- 40:04Patricia Matthew: And I have to be very careful about the invitations I accept, because sometimes people want me to come and tell them a certain story about Austen that I don't believe.
- 40:14Patricia Matthew: And they want to believe it so much, so as part of it, and I don't— I just—I just as an intellectual, as a scholar, as a black woman, that's not work that I want to do.
- 40:26Anne Fertig: Right.
- 40:27Patricia Matthew: But even if I'm sympathetic to people wanting to have that.
- 40:30Patricia Matthew: So it's a long answer to your question about her commentary.
- 40:32Patricia Matthew: I don't know that it's more pronounced.
- 40:34Patricia Matthew: I just think that we pay attention to it in very different ways.
- 40:38Patricia Matthew: And I think where we are open to queerness in Austen, people are very— get very uncomfortable because thinking about slavery is thinking about racism, and that's an indictment of the reader and the text.
- 40:50Patricia Matthew: And so people are holding on to two things.
- 40:52Patricia Matthew: I don't know if I said that well, but I think they're holding on to two things at once: their sense of Austen and their sense of themselves as someone who likes a good person whose literature they absolutely adore.
- 41:04Anne Fertig: Yeah, I think that sounds absolutely correct.
- 41:07Anne Fertig: And first of all, thank you for talking about your experiences.
- 41:10Anne Fertig: And I think for so many people, Austen is so important to them that, you know, sometimes challenging Austen or— can feel like a challenge.
- 41:21Anne Fertig: So absolutely 100%.
- 41:23Anne Fertig: So, we're at the end of our time, but I do want to ask you one more question.
- 41:28Anne Fertig: You mentioned before your essay that you wrote many years ago about how you feel there's so many other authors that don't get the same attention as Austen.
- 41:39Anne Fertig: Finish this off.
- 41:40Anne Fertig: Who do we read next?
- 41:42Anne Fertig: For somebody who's read Austen and wants to move on to somebody 18th- and 19th-century, who would you recommend?
- 41:49Patricia Matthew: Well, she's having a resurgence.
- 41:51Patricia Matthew: I would say Maria Edgeworth.
- 41:53Anne Fertig: That's my answer too.
- 41:56Patricia Matthew: Yeah, Maria Edgeworth.
- 41:57Patricia Matthew: I think Susan Ferrier is not nearly as great a novelist as Austen, but I think her trilogy— Susan Ferrier is really great to read.
- 42:07Patricia Matthew: Who else would I— I'm now paying attention to anti-slavery poetry.
- 42:12Patricia Matthew: And so I'm really interested in this collection of poetry edited by Mary Rawson.
- 42:18Patricia Matthew: I always think we need to go back to "Evelina" and go back to Burney.
- 42:22Patricia Matthew: And then, of course, as I mentioned way before we started talking, we need new— we need as many editions of "The Woman of Colour: A Tale," as we have of— maybe we don't need as many as we have of "Pride and Prejudice," but we— Lyndon Dominique has done an amazing, phenomenal— that is a phenomenal, just critically urgent edition.
- 42:43Patricia Matthew: I think we should have more editions for exactly the reason you said you have multiple editions of "Mansfield Park," right?
- 42:49Patricia Matthew: We want other editors with other things to say, even as we deeply respect Lyndon Dominique's work.
- 42:56Anne Fertig: That is a fantastic reading list.
- 42:58Anne Fertig: Thank you again.
- 42:59Anne Fertig: Thank you for joining us today, and thank you for the fantastic conversation.
- 43:05Breckyn Wood: Dearest listeners, I am pleased to announce that Austen Chat now has over 200 five-star reviews on Apple Podcasts.
- 43:13Breckyn Wood: Thank you so much for your support.
- 43:15Breckyn Wood: If you haven't yet given us a rating, please consider leaving a five-star review on Apple Podcasts so that more Janeites can find us and join our Austen - loving community.
- 43:25Breckyn Wood: Again, thank you.
- 43:26Breckyn Wood: I remain yours respectfully, Breckyn Wood.