Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Did You Agree to That?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:06So the examination has a term which is called agreed upon corrective action.
- 0:11I'm calling this podcast What is the meaning of agreed upon corrective action?
- 0:18Back when I was at NCUA.
- 0:20And I was interpreting regulations or having conversations or trying to find the
- 0:24exact precise word that I wanted to use for a communication written or otherwise,
- 0:31I would oftentimes go to dictionary.
- 0:33com, which would be a beacon.
- 0:38I would often go to dictionary.
- 0:40com, which would assist me in making sure that I fully understood
- 0:43the word that I was choosing, and which would give me further resolve
- 0:47that I had chosen the right word.
- 0:49Because sometimes what a word means forever, because you've said it,
- 0:52you've used it 30, 40, 50 years, however long you've been communicating
- 0:56with words on this planet, and so I will go there to find some clarity.
- 1:01And, when you look, go to dictionary.
- 1:03com.
- 1:05The word agree is a verb to have the same views, emotion, et cetera, harmonize
- 1:11an opinion or feeling, to give consent, assent, to live in con, in conquered or
- 1:18without contention, get along together, to come to open to come to one opinion
- 1:24or mind, come to an arrangement or understanding, arrive at a settlement.
- 1:29So that last one fits in particular as I think what NCUA means when they speak to.
- 1:35Agreed upon corrective action, and I've often said here on the podcast that
- 1:40I believe in the concept of the bell curve, and sometimes you just don't
- 1:46get the best resolution from an exam.
- 1:49Sometimes you get the perfect resolution of the exam, and it tends everything in
- 1:54life tends to fall out on a bell curve.
- 1:56Well, I got a call yesterday or excuse me recently from a person who's not
- 2:01a client, but they're just a small credit union who wanted some advice.
- 2:04They found me either here.
- 2:06On the podcast, or via LinkedIn, or via my web page, but they set up
- 2:11a calendar meeting, which you can do on my web page, by the way, and
- 2:14reached out and just wanted to have a little chat about some frustrations.
- 2:19They had on their examination.
- 2:22And so the examiner came in, the examiner was relatively quiet,
- 2:30the credit union had a good code previously, and the draft reports that
- 2:37were left had some examiner findings.
- 2:40That word read upon, and so everything worked, they had come to one opinion or
- 2:45mine, they had come to an arrangement or understanding on the examiner findings,
- 2:51and then it was crickets for a while.
- 2:53And that can happen.
- 2:54These reports have to be reviewed before I left and see way.
- 2:58We put in place or NCOA put in place a higher level of review of all exam
- 3:03reports that a supervisor had to have a review and it couldn't just come from
- 3:09the examiner and the bigger the credit union, the worse, the code, the higher.
- 3:15The level of review, however, most small credit unions could be reviewed
- 3:20by just the supervisory examiner.
- 3:22So again, the credit union had crickets silence asked where things were at
- 3:28and then dropped from the sky was.
- 3:31An email saying, here's the report.
- 3:34It's a final report and they then wanted to go and make the next steps and have
- 3:39a meeting with the board of directors.
- 3:42And the CEO was frustrated because they reached out and said, what's
- 3:48going on with the resolution?
- 3:50And oh, by the way, the camel code changed.
- 3:52As an aside, you will not find out what the camel code is until that
- 3:56higher level of supervisory review, as opposed to before, when you'd get
- 4:00a draft report, you may get a draft camel that doesn't happen anymore.
- 4:04You will just get the draft agreed upon procedures again.
- 4:06They're supposed to be agreed upon.
- 4:09If you're doing a document, a resolution, examiner findings, and
- 4:12even a letter of understanding and agreement last word in that is agreement.
- 4:16So where this situation went off the rails is that.
- 4:21The credit union had no opportunity to see a draft of any kind, the credit union had
- 4:26no opportunity to discuss that draft, the credit union had no opportunity to say,
- 4:32hey, maybe we could come up with a better solution that you might even like better.
- 4:36That'll better fit our needs.
- 4:38That didn't happen.
- 4:39And when you get to January, and you have just come off an exam that ended in
- 4:46November or December that goes into the.
- 4:49Review process at that point in time, I think sometimes what can happen
- 4:54is that there can be a complication because there's a desire to get
- 4:58the exam finalized by year end.
- 5:01So that can quote unquote, unquote counted as a completed examination because again.
- 5:09They have internal goals and requirements.
- 5:11It used to be that they had to do every federal credit union in a calendar year.
- 5:14And December was oftentimes crazy as you tried to get them all uploaded.
- 5:20And when that happens, maybe the due process that is built in for credit
- 5:25unions tends to disappear a little bit.
- 5:27And it may have happened in this situation.
- 5:29But this is, I'm just using this as one example.
- 5:31I've heard this before.
- 5:32I had this happen.
- 5:33Saw this happen when I was at NCOA, but basically the report was dropped as a
- 5:38final and I advised the credit union that it was probably changed by the
- 5:44supervisory examiner that the supervisory examiner probably said, no, we're going
- 5:49to have a document resolution here for whatever reason, not going into
- 5:53specifics of topics and things like that.
- 5:55And that that determined the camel code.
- 5:57So I provided some advice about how to best approach
- 6:01this and it's consistent with.
- 6:03What's in the examination report and oh, by the way, where does this
- 6:07term agreed upon procedure come out?
- 6:09It's about in the 4th or 5th sentence on the cover page.
- 6:12So there's a standard cover page that comes with every examination and
- 6:16in the, you've seen it every time.
- 6:18You may skip over it.
- 6:19You've seen so many times, but what does this report cover?
- 6:22The last sentence of that category is this report documents, yeah.
- 6:26Our conclusions and agreed upon corrective actions, if warranted,
- 6:31again, agreed upon corrective actions.
- 6:34If you don't get a opportunity to see something before it is called final, then.
- 6:43It's not an agreed upon corrective action.
- 6:46Now, how can NCUA rectify this and what will they probably do?
- 6:51They'll say, yeah, when we meet with you and your board of directors, if your
- 6:55camel code requires that they meet with the board of directors, we can take a
- 6:59look at it and we will consider at that point making a change now, sometimes
- 7:05they will, sometimes they won't.
- 7:07Generally speaking, the higher up the, the higher up the chain of
- 7:10command it went, the more difficult it would be to get some changes made.
- 7:14And if you've got well seasoned examiners and well seasoned supervisory examiners,
- 7:20you might be able to achieve that.
- 7:22As a matter of fact, recently I had a credit union client that was
- 7:27trying to do some negotiation on some language and I could tell by what
- 7:31they'd already received that it had probably gone up to the highest levels.
- 7:35That it could have based on their camel code and based on their asset size
- 7:40that therefore it was a final report.
- 7:42I encouraged them to push back to get the facts straight because there was a
- 7:46factual item that needed to be cleared up.
- 7:48But I told them other than the facts, if there were other opinions that
- 7:51you were trying to get in there and influence them on the language.
- 7:55That it may be more difficult now that they already had their
- 7:58camel codes and things like that.
- 8:00Now, in that instance, that credit union was successful and
- 8:04again, you got to play to win.
- 8:05So they were able to get into a to make changes to the
- 8:07report that better portrayed.
- 8:10What had actually happened at the credit union.
- 8:12And again, NCOA wants to get there, but there are situations sometimes where they
- 8:17run out of time and that's not an excuse.
- 8:19It's just the reality.
- 8:20Only so much water will go down and drain at one point in time.
- 8:23And when you get to the end of the year, there can tend to be a scramble, but that
- 8:27doesn't mean you don't have your rights.
- 8:29So if you find yourself in this.
- 8:32I would push back.
- 8:33I would push back to the examiner.
- 8:35I would push back if that doesn't work to the supervisory examiner, and you can
- 8:39already always raise it to a high level.
- 8:42This informal level of appeal is outlined on the 2nd page of the examination report
- 8:48and says have an immediate dialogue.
- 8:50Well, if it's thrust upon you as final, it's hard to have an immediate dialogue.
- 8:55And unfortunately, the desire to have a higher level of review.
- 9:01Of examination reports, which will take will which creates some consistency.
- 9:05So it's a good thing.
- 9:06It's good intent, but that sometimes makes it harder to have that immediate
- 9:11dialogue, especially when drops it from the sky at the last minute and then says
- 9:16it's final and then starts asking if they can meet with your board of directors.
- 9:19Again, it comes down to, as always, things come down to people and I would
- 9:24encourage you if you find yourself in this situation to, Decide if it's something
- 9:29that is worth pushing to get the best proper language in there, but at least
- 9:33as a courtesy, they should acknowledge the fact that it was never agreed upon
- 9:37and have at least one dialogue where you have the opportunity to do that.
- 9:40That's only right.
- 9:41And if it was raised to ultimately higher level, the examiner and supervisory
- 9:46examiner would be embarrassed in this in this situation, which is another
- 9:50reason they are likely to have some conversations with you in this regard.
- 9:54Again, it's.
- 9:56I've said here, I've said on LinkedIn that oftentimes credit unions have to
- 10:02decide if they are going to go along to get along, that every time NCUA makes a
- 10:08request or makes a demand, you have to decide if it's something that you think
- 10:13is a great idea, a mediocre idea, or a bad idea, but in any event, they should, and
- 10:18are required to, give you an opportunity To agree upon it now push come to shove if
- 10:24it's material enough safety and soundness, they're not going to cave, but they are
- 10:27going to give you and they should give you that opportunity to be heard that
- 10:30opportunity to influence the language so that you can make it consistent
- 10:34with something that meets the needs of NCUA from a safety and soundness and or
- 10:39regulatory perspective, but also meets the needs of you and your credit union.
- 10:44And more importantly, your members.
- 10:46All right, that's it for today.
- 10:48Again, 1st page of the examination report says that the report includes
- 10:53agreed upon corrective actions.
- 10:55Make sure you agree.
- 10:56Make sure you use finesse.
- 10:58Use all your people skills to get language that makes sense for you,
- 11:04your credit union and your members.
- 11:06Lastly, if you like this podcast, please share it with a friend, and
- 11:11if you're a casual listener, I would appreciate it if you would subscribe,
- 11:16and then you will automatically get down to downloaded to your favorite
- 11:19app every episodes, which come out at least once, sometimes twice a week.
- 11:24And you could tell by the title, if it's something that might be worthwhile
- 11:29for you listening to in any event, I thank you for listening today.
- 11:32And this is Mark Treychel.
- 11:34Signing off with flying colors.
- 11:43Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 11:47your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 11:51of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 11:55If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions,
- 11:58check out our services at markteichl.
- 12:00com.