Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / BYD Dolphin: The New Benchmark for Electric City Cars
Transcript
- 0:10OK, let's unpack this. I feel like we have been waiting
- 0:14for this specific moment for, well, for years.
- 0:19You know that feeling when you're watching a sci-fi movie?
- 0:21There's all this school tech, but it feels completely out of
- 0:24reach, like, oh, that's nice for the year 2050.
- 0:26The flying car syndrome, Yeah. Exactly the flying car syndrome.
- 0:29For the longest time, the electric vehicle conversation
- 0:32felt just like that. It was either here is a luxury
- 0:35sedan that cost as much as a small house or.
- 0:38Or here is a tiny weird concept car that you can't actually buy.
- 0:43But looking at the stack of research we have today, I think
- 0:45the script is flipped. It really has.
- 0:47We are witnessing a a pivotal moment.
- 0:50The era of the affordable, actually buyable electric City
- 0:54car isn't coming. It is parked outside.
- 0:56It's here. But here's where it gets really
- 0:58interesting, because just as the sticker prices are finally
- 1:01coming down to earth, the definition of value is getting
- 1:04completely rewritten. It turns out looking at the
- 1:07price tag is well, it's practically useless if you don't
- 1:10look at what happens after you drive off the lot.
- 1:12That is the headline for today. We're moving from a purchase
- 1:15economy to a life cycle economy. If you walk into a dealership
- 1:19and just look at the monthly payment, you are arguably
- 1:24looking at the wrong number. You have to look at the hidden
- 1:26math. So our mission for this deep
- 1:28dive is pretty clear. We're going to look past the
- 1:30glossy brochures. We are digging into the BYD
- 1:33Dolphin, a car that sources claim is redefining the
- 1:36category. But we're not just fanboying
- 1:39over 1 car, we're throwing it into the ring with some serious
- 1:42competition. Oh yeah, we're talking the MG 4,
- 1:45the Run O 5, the Kia EV3, and the Citroen EC3.
- 1:49It is a crowded field. It is, and we need to get
- 1:51technical today, but in a way that actually matters to your
- 1:54wallet. We need to talk about battery
- 1:56chemistry. Why some batteries are basically
- 1:58immortal and others, well, they aren't.
- 2:00And I want to get to the bottom of this total cost of ownership
- 2:02math because the numbers in these reports are actually kind
- 2:05of wild. But let's start with the
- 2:06challenger, the BYD dolphin. First off, the name.
- 2:10It's cute, but is it a serious machine?
- 2:13Oh, it is very serious, B. Well, A is not playing around
- 2:16here. They aren't positioning the
- 2:18dolphin as just a cheap EV. Their whole angle is
- 2:20completeness. Right.
- 2:22I saw the pricing at the base price, it's around €25,000.
- 2:25Approximately, yes, and sources suggest that with incentives in
- 2:28certain markets it can drop below 20,000.
- 2:31That is a huge psychological barrier for a lot.
- 2:34Of people 20K is huge but usually when you buy the budget
- 2:37option you expect, let's be honest, a tin can you expect
- 2:41manual windows and a radio that only plays AM.
- 2:44That's the old world. The Dolphins proposition is that
- 2:47it comes fully loaded standard. We're talking Advanced Driver
- 2:50Assistant Systems 8S and A5 Star NCIP safety rating right
- 2:56out-of-the-box. And of course the thing I can't
- 2:57stop looking at the screen, that 12.8 inch display that rotates.
- 3:02Portrait or landscape? I know, I know, some people call
- 3:04it a gimmick, but honestly I think it's kind of brilliant.
- 3:07If I'm using navigation, I want portrait mode.
- 3:09If I'm parked and waiting, I want to watch something
- 3:12landscape. It feels like they actually
- 3:13thought about it. It definitely creates a
- 3:15perception of premium value. You don't usually get at this
- 3:18price, but we have to check that against the competition because
- 3:22walking into the ring is the MG. 4 the MG 4 Now this feels like
- 3:27the cool kid at school versus the Dolphins honor student.
- 3:30That is a very, very apartment analogy.
- 3:33The MG4IS aggressively priced, it's around 20 to €23,000, so
- 3:38it's actually cheaper, but it positions itself completely
- 3:41differently. It's rear wheel drive.
- 3:43Which for anyone listening, usually translates to more fun.
- 3:46Exactly. It pushes you through corners
- 3:48rather than pulling you. It has a sportier setup.
- 3:51It appeals to the driver, who has a strict budget but still
- 3:54wants to smile. So we have the sensible tech
- 3:56dolphin versus the fun on a budget MG 4.
- 4:00Where do the others fit in the Renault 5 and Kia EV3?
- 4:04Well, the Renault 5 is playing the nostalgia card perfectly.
- 4:07It's stylish, retro, sits around 28,000.
- 4:09It's a fashion statement. The Kia EV3, however, is a big
- 4:13step up. You're looking at around
- 4:14€35,000. That's a €10,000 jump from the
- 4:17dolphin. Why the premium?
- 4:18Range Pure and simple, the Kia offers a massive 560 kilometers.
- 4:24The dolphin is at about 4:27. So if you have severe range
- 4:28anxiety, you pay the Kia tax for Peace of Mind.
- 4:31OK, so the landscape is set, but let's go back to the dolphin,
- 4:33because the sources keep pointing to one specific thing
- 4:36as its secret sauce, and it isn't the rotating screen, it's
- 4:40the battery. This is the most critical part
- 4:42of this deep dive. If you take nothing else away
- 4:44today, you need to understand the difference between NMC and
- 4:46LFP. OK, lay it on us.
- 4:48Explain it like I'm 5, no jargon.
- 4:51Deal Most E VS You see the Kia, the Renault, the Citroen use
- 4:55what's called NMC batteries. Nickel, manganese, cobalt.
- 4:58Think of NMC as the Sprinters. They're high performance, very
- 5:02energy dense. That's how Kia gets that big
- 5:04range without the car weighing 3 tons.
- 5:06OK, so NMC is the athlete, lightweight, high energy.
- 5:08Correct, but the Dolphin uses LFP, Lithium Iron phosphate
- 5:11specifically BY DS Blade Battery.
- 5:14LFP is the workhorse. It's historically been a bit
- 5:17heavier for the same amount of energy.
- 5:19So why would BYD use the heavier, bulkier tech?
- 5:22That sounds like a downgrade. Two massive reasons, safety and
- 5:25longevity. The sources are incredibly clear
- 5:28on this. LFP chemistry is much more
- 5:31stable. The blade battery has acclaimed
- 5:330 fire risk. You can puncture it, crush it,
- 5:37it's extremely difficult to make it catch fire.
- 5:39I saw that video about the nail penetration test.
- 5:41It was intense. But safety is one of those
- 5:43things you hope you never need. What about the day-to-day?
- 5:46Longevity. This is where the economics get
- 5:48fascinating. An NMC battery like in the Kia
- 5:52or Renault is typically rated for about 1000 to maybe 1500
- 5:56charge cycles. OK, 1500 cycles, that sounds
- 5:59decent. It's fine, it'll last the life
- 6:01of a normal car, but the Dolphins LFP battery it is rated
- 6:05for over 3000 cycles. Whoa, that's double.
- 6:09It's more than double, and if you do the math, 3000 cycles
- 6:11times the range that translates to approximately 1,000,000
- 6:14kilometers of driving. 1,000,000 kilometers that is.
- 6:17That's ridiculous. The seats will have
- 6:18disintegrated, the door handles will fall off.
- 6:20The car will almost certainly fall apart around the battery,
- 6:24but think about what that means for value with the Dolphin, the
- 6:26engine. The battery is the most durable
- 6:29part of the entire vehicle. There's another practical angle
- 6:32I read about. You know how with my phone and
- 6:34with most EVs everyone says don't charge to 100%?
- 6:37Right, the famous 80% rule. It's standard advice for NMC
- 6:41batteries to prolong their life. But the sources say that doesn't
- 6:44apply to the dolphin. Correct, LFP batteries actually
- 6:48prefer hitting 100% to calibrate so you can plug it in every
- 6:51night, charge it to full, and not worry about degradation.
- 6:55That is a huge psychological win because if I buy a car with 400
- 6:59kilometers range, but I'm only supposed to use 80% of it, I
- 7:02really only have 320 kilometers. Exactly, with the dolphin you
- 7:05get the whole buffet every day. No guilt.
- 7:08Now we should mention the MG4 also uses an LFP battery in its
- 7:12standard version. So it has the same benefits.
- 7:14Mostly it's safe, it's durable, but the source is rated cycle
- 7:18life at around 2000 cycles. Still excellent but the Dolphins
- 7:213000 plus figures technically industry leading.
- 7:24OK so the dolphin has this heavy immortal battery.
- 7:27Does that make it a slug to drive?
- 7:29You would think so, but no. The electric motor saves it.
- 7:32It has 204 horsepower. It does zero to 100 kilometers
- 7:36an hour in seven seconds. 7 seconds is not slow.
- 7:39That's faster than most gas cars people are driving.
- 7:41It's plenty fast for merging onto a highway.
- 7:43It's not a sports car, but it's certainly not a golf cart.
- 7:46But here's the gotcha we have to talk about the trade off.
- 7:49Yeah, because reading the charging specs, it seems like
- 7:51the dolphin stumbles a bit on a road trip.
- 7:54This is its Achilles heel, and this is where the MG 4 plays its
- 7:58ace card. If you look at DC fast charging
- 8:00at a highway rest stop, the Dolphin is capped at 88
- 8:04kilowatts. Which is not great.
- 8:05It's on the lower end. The MG Four, however, offers up
- 8:08to 140 kilowatts. OK, so translate that.
- 8:12I'm on a road trip, I stop for coffee.
- 8:14What's the difference? It's significant.
- 8:16In the MG 4, you might be back on the road in 25 minutes.
- 8:19In the Dolphin you're looking at maybe 40 minutes, maybe more.
- 8:22If you're a road warrior doing long trips all the time, the
- 8:25MG4IS objectively the better tool.
- 8:28So the MG4 charges faster, but the dolphin counters this with
- 8:32efficiency, right? The tortoise and the hare.
- 8:34Precisely, the dolphin is incredibly efficient.
- 8:37It consumes about 15.9 kilowatt hours per 100 kilometers.
- 8:41The MG4IS thirstier between 16 and 18.
- 8:45So the dolphin charge is slower, but it needs less electricity to
- 8:48go the same distance. Which saves you money every
- 8:51single time you drive. And that leads us perfectly into
- 8:54the part of the notes that I found most eye opening, The
- 8:57Hidden Economics. This is the part I love because
- 9:00we always hear EVs are cheaper to maintain but nobody ever
- 9:04breaks it down. It's just physics.
- 9:05Let's start with the brakes in your gas car.
- 9:08Every time you stop, you press the pedal pads clamp onto rotors
- 9:12and you're grinding money into dust, right?
- 9:15And I pay a few 100 bucks to replace them every couple of
- 9:17years. In an EV like the Dolphin, when
- 9:19you lift your foot off the accelerator, the motor reverses.
- 9:22It becomes a generator. It slows the car down by
- 9:24recharging the battery. That's regenerative braking.
- 9:27So I'm not actually using the physical brakes.
- 9:29Much, hardly ever. Only for the last few meters or
- 9:32in an emergency. The sources estimate that on the
- 9:35dolphin the brake pads can last over 100,000 kilometers.
- 9:38Wow. So instead of changing them
- 9:40every 40, Ki might change them once.
- 9:42Maybe once in the car's entire life.
- 9:44The annual cost is tiny, in fact.
- 9:47The problem is they can rust from lack of use.
- 9:49Rust from not using them enough. That is a very specific problem
- 9:53to have. But then we have the EV tax
- 9:55because we get hammered on tires.
- 9:57Yes, this is the dark side. Batteries are heavy.
- 10:00The dolphin is carrying around 200 to 300 kilos of extra
- 10:03weight, plus electric motors deliver instant torque that push
- 10:07you feel. So heavy car plus instant torque
- 10:09equals. Shredded rubber.
- 10:11You were just grinding those tires into the pavement.
- 10:14What kind of lifespan are we talking?
- 10:16On a gas car, you might get 50 or 60,000 kilometers.
- 10:19On an EV, you're looking at changing them every 25 to
- 10:2235,000. Ouch.
- 10:24And a set for the dolphin cost what, 5 to 800 euros?
- 10:27In that ballpark, yeah. So you have to mentally balance
- 10:29the books. I'm saving on gas and brakes but
- 10:31I need to budget for tires. So does it balance out?
- 10:35The sources did the math for 10 years and 150,000 kilometers.
- 10:38This is the showdown. Who wins?
- 10:40Let's. Look at the totals combining
- 10:42electricity and maintenance. The Renault 5 / 10 years is
- 10:45estimated at €11,800. OK 11.8 K and the budget racer,
- 10:51the MG 4. The MG 4 is slightly higher at
- 10:54€12,000, mostly due to its higher energy consumption and
- 10:59the dolphin. The BYD Dolphin comes in at
- 11:01€10,500. So that's a €1500 saving over
- 11:05the MG 4. It represents roughly a 20 to
- 11:0830% saving on maintenance plus the efficiency.
- 11:11It all adds up. That is significant, €1500 is a
- 11:15family vacation. It's not a rounding error.
- 11:17Exactly. And remember that calculation
- 11:19includes the stability of that LFP battery.
- 11:21You're far less likely to face a catastrophic battery failure out
- 11:25of warranty. That's an insurance policy that
- 11:27isn't even factored into that number.
- 11:29So we look at the price, the tack, the charging, the math.
- 11:32I feel like we can categorize these cars now.
- 11:34If a listener asks which one should I buy, what's the answer?
- 11:38It depends entirely on who they are.
- 11:40If you are the sensible buyer, a parent, a commuter, someone who
- 11:43drives a car until the wheels fall off the BYD, Dolphin is the
- 11:47winner, hands down. It's the adult in the room.
- 11:49It is. That's total cost of ownership,
- 11:52safest battery, and it's spacious.
- 11:54It has a 345 liter trunk junk. It's the rational economic
- 11:58choice. But what if I don't want to be
- 12:00rational? What if I want to have fun?
- 12:01Then you go for the MG4 if you're a driver's choice buyer
- 12:05or you're on a tight budget right now, the MG 4 is super
- 12:08compelling. Rear wheel drive, faster
- 12:11charging, lower sticker price. And the Kia EV3.
- 12:15That is the premium choice. You are paying that extra 10
- 12:17grand for one thing. Peace of Mind on range.
- 12:21If you absolutely need to drive 500 kilometers without stopping,
- 12:24you buy the Kia. So to synthesize all this, it
- 12:27feels like the market has really split.
- 12:29It's no longer just buy an EV or don't now it's do you want to
- 12:33buy for fun, which is the MG4, or do you want to buy for
- 12:37forever, which is the dolphin? Buy for forever is a fascinating
- 12:40concept. The Dolphin is essentially a
- 12:42long term investment on wheels. That LFP tech changes the car
- 12:46from a consumable good into a durable asset.
- 12:49That leads me to a thought I can't shake.
- 12:51If this battery is rated for 1,000,000 kilometers and the
- 12:53average person drives what, 15,000 a year, that battery
- 12:56theoretically lasts 60 years. The car is going to be a pile of
- 13:00rust, but the battery will still be fresh.
- 13:02It's a very real possibility we might see a future where the car
- 13:05body is scrapped but the battery is pulled out and used for home
- 13:08energy storage. It completely changes the used
- 13:11car market. In 10 years, a used dolphin with
- 13:14150,000 kilometers might actually be worth more than we
- 13:17expect because it's core component is barely broken in.
- 13:20It forces us to rethink depreciation.
- 13:23If the engine never dies, does the car ever really lose its
- 13:27value in the same way? It's a profound question.
- 13:30A wild thought, The car might actually outlive your need for
- 13:33it. Indeed, a whole new world for
- 13:36automotive economics. You know, before we sign off, we
- 13:38have a special note for this deep dive.
- 13:40We usually end with the big question, but today we want to
- 13:43take a second to talk directly to you.
- 13:45Yes, you listening right now, whether you have headphones in
- 13:49or you're stuck in traffic or maybe walking the dog.
- 13:52We know your time is valuable. There's an endless ocean of
- 13:55content out there, and the fact that you chose to spend these
- 13:58past, what, 15 or 16 minutes with us diving into battery
- 14:01chemistry, it genuinely means a lot.
- 14:04It really does. We do this because we love it,
- 14:06But it only matters because you're curious enough to listen.
- 14:09So thank you for trusting us to guide you through all this EV
- 14:12tech. We hope we made it clear and
- 14:14useful for you. We couldn't do this without your
- 14:16curiosity. We'll catch you on the next deep
- 14:18dive. Drive safe everyone.
- 14:20Goodbye and thank you.