Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E029: Shaping Bitcoin Policy with Lee Bratcher
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of doctors 1974198792972000.
- 1:44And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:45It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 1:50Sell hey, I say when we sell. I've always been deeply opposed
- 1:58to crypto, Bitcoin, etcetera. You pointed out the only true
- 2:01use case for it as criminals, drug traffickers, anti money
- 2:05loaning, tax avoidance. And that is a use case because
- 2:08it is somewhat anonymous, not fully and because you can move
- 2:11money instantaneously and because it doesn't go through as
- 2:15you mentioned, all these systems have built up over many years.
- 2:17Know your customer sanctions O FAC.
- 2:20It's didn't get bypass all of that.
- 2:22I if I was the governments, I'd close it down.
- 2:26Let's close it down, gentlemen. I don't even know why we're
- 2:29doing this podcast, Jamie said. We should just close it down.
- 2:33Wrap it up. We'll just, we'll tell.
- 2:36We'll tell one of the developers to flip a switch and turn it
- 2:40off. It's that easy.
- 2:43The government can do it. You just need the government to
- 2:45do it. Crazy week.
- 2:50We're joined by Lee Bratcher from the Texas Blockchain
- 2:53Council. Very apartment timing here for
- 2:58us to have Lee on the show considering everything that's
- 2:59going on over the last week. Last week we had the Treasury
- 3:04Department write a letter of suggestions to the Senate House
- 3:10and the banking the Senate Financial and the House Banking
- 3:14Committees obviously suggesting suggesting some regulations they
- 3:18think should be pushed through on on Bitcoin and other crypto
- 3:22assets. Really honing in on validators
- 3:27which could be read as full nodes and mining pools trying to
- 3:31get them to do a lot of reporting and financial be
- 3:37considered financial institutions that would have to
- 3:39report and follow the rules of the Bank Secrecy Act.
- 3:42That was shortly followed up by this Senate Banking Committee
- 3:48meeting, this hearing yesterday with bank executives in which
- 3:51Jamie Dimon said that we should shut it down.
- 3:55And so it seems like the regulatory pressure is on
- 3:58despite the fact that we have an imminent ETF approval, which
- 4:02everybody's bullish about. But I think these regulatory
- 4:05concerns are something that we should be focusing in on and
- 4:08that is something lead that you do on a day-to-day basis.
- 4:12So before we jump into the particulars of these subjects, I
- 4:15think it would be good for the audience just to introduce
- 4:18yourself what you guys are doing at the Blockchain Council and
- 4:20why you decided to start to Blockchain Council in the first
- 4:23place. Yeah, Marty, thanks for having
- 4:26me on, guys. It's a, it's an honor to have a
- 4:29conversation. So the TBC was started about
- 4:32four years ago. I was a political science
- 4:34professor. My research area is property
- 4:37rights and I was up at the Army War College.
- 4:41I was also an Army Reserve officer at the time.
- 4:43I guess I still am in the reserves and was really studying
- 4:46how when people are secure in their property rights, they're
- 4:49less prone to be involved in Interstate conflict or civil
- 4:56wars or anything of that nature. So I I actually read the white
- 5:01paper while I was up there and thought, hey, there's such a
- 5:06thing as digital property rights.
- 5:07It can be used to secure physical property rights in the
- 5:11world, real world. And from that point on, I I was
- 5:16hooked, right? So I started to organize folks
- 5:21from a policy and regulatory perspective sort of in a
- 5:24grassroots way in 2019 and started the Texas Blockchain
- 5:28Council late in that year because I I foresaw, and it's
- 5:34always been the case I think that because of this revolution,
- 5:39this technological revolution deals with money, it was always
- 5:43going to be fraught. And the the clip that you guys
- 5:46played at the at the outset of the show with Jamie Dimon
- 5:49exemplifies that perfectly, right.
- 5:51He's, you know, JP Morgan is at at this point almost an
- 5:55extension of the federal government.
- 5:57They're tied so much at the hip. So I first saw a a big need and
- 6:02there's a lot of people out there that are builders, that
- 6:04are engineers, software engineers that are, you know,
- 6:07finance professionals that we're going to be building amazing
- 6:09products. But my skill set had to do with
- 6:13policy and politics. And so I wanted to support in
- 6:16that way by trying to clear some obstacles for adoption and just
- 6:23for for everyday companies that operate in the US And so we try
- 6:28to do that here in Texas and create model policy for the
- 6:32other 49 states. If a state like Texas passes
- 6:36legislation, other states pay attention because we're 110th of
- 6:39the US population and and the US economy.
- 6:43So we certainly support what Wyoming does, but it helps to
- 6:47have a state the size of Texas to partner with Wyoming on that
- 6:50kind of policy legislation. Yeah, it's extremely important
- 6:55that's that was a big part of our discussion last week is this
- 6:59jurisdictional arbitrage between states, Texas and Wyoming where
- 7:06probably the two most talked about states in this regard.
- 7:09And so just building on that conversation, like what power do
- 7:14you see the states having in this battle to preserve
- 7:18individuals rights to access and use Bitcoin?
- 7:22Yeah. So there's a couple things that
- 7:24we've done in the past. One is Uniform Commercial Code
- 7:27adjustments, which is essentially business law.
- 7:30And in the 87th session which was in 2021, we passed a bill
- 7:35that said that you can perfect your security interests in a
- 7:39digital asset through possession of the private keys or if it's a
- 7:43multi sig, you know the the majority of the keys.
- 7:46And so that allows people to put use, use Bitcoin and lending
- 7:49arrangements and do so. Of course you could do it before
- 7:54contractually but now it's the default status that you
- 7:56perfected your security interest in that Bitcoin as collateral
- 8:01simply through the possession of the of the keys, which is an
- 8:04important concept. We also have put some pressure
- 8:08on digital asset service providers like exchanges.
- 8:12This past session of course post FTX we drafted the first of its
- 8:16kind proof of reserves legislation that is currently in
- 8:20effect as of September 1st of this year that requires all
- 8:24digital asset service providers in order to retain their money
- 8:27transmission license they have to file quarterly reports with
- 8:31the Texas Department of Banking and the quarterly reports are
- 8:35self attestations. The annual is a third party
- 8:37attestation. Of course we all know that real
- 8:41time proof of reserves audits are the only true.
- 8:47Well I'll I'll say that differently, real time is is
- 8:50perfection of proof of reserves, right.
- 8:52So quarterly proof of reserves is not perfect, but it is a tool
- 8:55in the tool belt if you add it to traditional audit and
- 9:00assurance practices. And so you know there's some
- 9:03things that states cannot do, right?
- 9:05The states can't deem an asset a commodity or security.
- 9:08So thankfully Bitcoin's already been deemed A commodity and and
- 9:14the other thing that we can't do is affect taxation of federal
- 9:18taxation of of various assets. So you know, we can't change the
- 9:23rules around the minimus exemptions, which I think are
- 9:25very important to one day have and we can't change the capital
- 9:29gains legislation. Do you think you could have had
- 9:34as much impact? Because I feel like you'd
- 9:36probably agree there's been a lot of impact in the policy in
- 9:39Texas, but in a different state. If you started Scratch 2019 and
- 9:43do you think any other state would have been apartment to be
- 9:45able to recognize and like, what do you what do you think is the
- 9:48main difference between Texas and another state if you had to
- 9:50pick the next friendliest or culture aligned with getting
- 9:55some of these concepts? You know, I don't.
- 9:59I think it's there's a lot of luck in that, right.
- 10:01So the the Texas Blockchain Council would have been a
- 10:04failure if I tried to start a two years before or two years
- 10:07after. So timing is everything.
- 10:08We got lucky in that sense. Nearly 50% of all US Bitcoin
- 10:14mining is in Texas. That's about 20% of global hash
- 10:19rate. And so that was a huge help to
- 10:23us because the miners did and still do need a lot of
- 10:27regulatory help. And so we, we work very closely
- 10:30with the Bitcoin mining committee industry and they
- 10:33represent between 60 and 70% of total revenue for the TBC.
- 10:38So to be able to have influence, you have to have either numbers,
- 10:43money or passion, right. So Mothers Against Drunk
- 10:46Driving, they have passion and and numbers, but they don't have
- 10:49any money. You know, the defense industrial
- 10:52complex, they have money but no numbers and passion.
- 10:55So to influence policy and politics, you have to have some
- 10:58combination of those 3. And so we've got a little bit of
- 11:03all three. Of course, we don't have as much
- 11:05of any of the three as we would like, but I think the passion,
- 11:08the numbers are going to be there.
- 11:11But without, you know, membership dues from corporate
- 11:13members, it would have been really tough.
- 11:15And I think other states just didn't have the, the necessary
- 11:21backbone of companies that were there to be able to to help you
- 11:25know from that perspective, from the from the lobbying
- 11:28perspective. Yeah, it's awesome to see.
- 11:31It's a derivative of like Bitcoin success of it's all
- 11:34about incentives and in lining incentives.
- 11:36And there's a nice dance happening right now between
- 11:38politics or policy, miners and revenue.
- 11:41And ideally you get more entrenchment.
- 11:43We talked about this earlier in the week about it's kind of a
- 11:47crude analogy but you know the the whole term of you may not
- 11:49care about the war but the war cares about you.
- 11:51I've historically never cared about politics.
- 11:52But now realizing the, you know our our business is going to be
- 11:56defined by it ultimately over time and we talked about it last
- 11:59podcast about the regulatory climate, It's like you better
- 12:01care about and figure out ways that you can start to have
- 12:04exercise impact. So it's it's really recognized
- 12:07the past probably 6 to 12 months the work you guys have been
- 12:10doing and along with the summit that you hosted, it was cool to
- 12:14see it first hand. Yeah the the summit was a good
- 12:19event for us for a lot of reasons of course the
- 12:21presidential candidates that were there but you know those
- 12:25events are are very challenging to put on So it hats it goes off
- 12:28to Bitcoin magazine when they put on a a you know 20,000
- 12:32person event. Those are not easy of course.
- 12:34Ours was about 1300, so much smaller and and I should say
- 12:40just for for the people in the audience who are kind of maybe
- 12:44they're Bitcoin mining in Georgia or another state.
- 12:47The data that I just quoted was from the Miner mag.
- 12:50Of course if you look at the foundry data from from Pools,
- 12:54Texas is more like 3435% of US mining and about 16% of global.
- 12:59So it does depend on on which data you're using.
- 13:03And you know the Miner mag I found to have pretty
- 13:06comprehensive data. Foundry puts out great data too,
- 13:10but sometimes, you know some miners use different pools and
- 13:13it's hard to really get a a a accurate number.
- 13:18I think it's a good jumping off point to the discuss mining in
- 13:23Texas. Obviously post China mining ban
- 13:27in 2021, a lot of that hash rate migrated here is a large
- 13:31concentration of hash rate in the state of Texas.
- 13:34And this has been a rapid sort of development over the last two
- 13:40years particularly. And so that means that the state
- 13:43of Texas and more specifically ERCOT needs to get comfortable
- 13:47with miners, what they're doing, how they can participate and
- 13:52demand response programs. From your view, what is this
- 13:57sort of marriage of Bitcoin mining in the state of Texas?
- 13:59How's that gone over the last two years?
- 14:03Good question. It it's not gone.
- 14:08I would say that it's it's gone there's there's been seasons of
- 14:11of good and bad right. So the potential for Bitcoin
- 14:15mining to be a a load that helps to shave off the peaks and the
- 14:21and bring up the valleys of the duck curve of like our energy
- 14:24consumption patterns is really strong and it's very much real
- 14:29The and by that I mean curtailing during periods of
- 14:32high prices, high demand and being on overnight and during
- 14:36times of low demand. And there's also geographic
- 14:39component to that too. Like if you're on the opposite
- 14:41side of grid congestion, then you're you're helping to balance
- 14:46out the grid by consuming power in places that there's too much
- 14:50of it and not enough consumers of power like in West TX or
- 14:54certain parts of Central Texas. The the challenge comes with the
- 15:00speed at which Bitcoin miners can curtail.
- 15:03That's actually the biggest problem that we are facing
- 15:06within the ERCOT Large Flexible Load Task Force.
- 15:09Right now. Bitcoin miners can can curtail
- 15:12so fast that the grid, no grid anywhere in the world is built
- 15:19to really sustain that speed of curtailment.
- 15:23So we're we're trying to work with ERCOT now to figure out a
- 15:28way for for them to be able to handle that speed because once
- 15:32those protocols and and those revisions are are in place
- 15:38Bitcoin mining is essentially a tool the tool belt for ERCOT.
- 15:43The the miners are going to be, you know in SCED.
- 15:47They call it SCED. It's it's part of you know
- 15:50Ercot's ancillary services. It stands for security
- 15:53constrained economic dispatch And Ercot's going to know
- 15:57exactly the price point at which the miners were were will
- 16:01curtail and it's a little bit more complex than that.
- 16:04But the problem though is power settled at 15 minute intervals
- 16:13in ERCOT and it can be settled at 5 minute intervals if you're
- 16:17if you're in SCAD potentially right.
- 16:20So if you curtail in 2 minutes your entire load, that's 200
- 16:27megawatts coming off the grid in 2 minutes or 100 megawatts or
- 16:30whatever. If you're if you're at Rockdale,
- 16:32it's several 100 megawatts. So that's a problem for the grid
- 16:37because they have to be prepared for that, you know, for the
- 16:40frequency of the grid to lose that much load.
- 16:43You know that could be 1% of all load in Texas coming off the
- 16:46grid. In fact if all the Bitcoin
- 16:49miners came off at the same time, which is is you know
- 16:54typically they don't come off usually in the exact same minute
- 16:57but within the same maybe 5 or 15 minute window.
- 17:01That could be 3 upwards of 3% of all power on the grid coming off
- 17:06in a very short amount of time which the the grid is not built
- 17:11for. So once that gets settled
- 17:13though, then you do have this asset that that works as a
- 17:16capacitor or almost like a demand side battery.
- 17:21ERCOT doesn't like it when I use that phrase demand side battery,
- 17:24but it's a it's a it's an easy way to conceptually think about
- 17:27it. Of course it's not a battery,
- 17:28but it's more of a capacitor to use up excess energy when
- 17:32there's no demand or limited demand, and to curtail when
- 17:35there's high demand. Yeah.
- 17:38I mean, it sounds like a good problem to have in the sense
- 17:40like this is just a technological evolution of it'll
- 17:42be out on how to like stagger the curtailing.
- 17:46But I think it'd be helpful just to give a quick elevator pitch
- 17:48on like I think most people don't know that Texas has its
- 17:51own grid. And then why the efficient, like
- 17:53the market is free here when it comes to energy power and why
- 17:56miners have found a home for that.
- 17:58I think that will help, and the help contextualize what you just
- 18:01described. Yeah, that's a good point
- 18:04because it is all about incentives, right.
- 18:06As Bitcoiners we we think in terms of incentives Austrian
- 18:09economics, right. That's kind of a been a passion
- 18:13of mine for many years and sort of the Hayek vonniesis way of
- 18:18looking at things in a free market.
- 18:21So the the ERCOT market is an energy only marketplace where
- 18:26power is is bought and sold in the deregulated parts of the
- 18:29grid and you know, your consumption of power.
- 18:34If you're a wholesale power consumer, of course consumers
- 18:36are shielded from this 'cause they buy retail contracts from
- 18:41retail electric providers and you know, they don't.
- 18:44They're not really subject to they have fixed prices, which
- 18:48means we have higher prices as consumers, but we don't have the
- 18:52fluctuation or the risk of getting, you know, hit with a
- 18:56huge bill during a high price time.
- 18:59So, but Bitcoin miners want to have those lower prices.
- 19:03So they take on, you know, power purchase agreements and energy
- 19:07contracts that allow them to be flexible, allow them to save
- 19:11money by getting that absolute bottom wholesale price, which
- 19:15means they have the risk of a spot, the spot price, the LMP
- 19:20price as they call it shooting up.
- 19:23But Bitcoin miners can curtail to avoid those prices.
- 19:27So it is a real time market and the price signals that are sent
- 19:32by by the grid is actually a really amazing thing because
- 19:38prices going up is a proxy for grid stress.
- 19:41It's it's a proxy for high demand and grid stress.
- 19:44So if the prices go up to $3000 per MW hour, then it's pretty
- 19:51clear that the grid is under stress and that it would be a
- 19:53good idea to turn curtail your operations.
- 19:57Yeah, and it's been fascinating to watch pretty close up on the
- 20:01Bitcoin mining side of things, the particularly the software
- 20:05that's been built. We have Foreman Mining, one of
- 20:07their team members, Mitch, right outside the studio here.
- 20:11In Austin and the Commons and what they've built from a farm
- 20:14management perspective is just a a software tool that takes that
- 20:18pricing data, feeds it to the mining firmware and then has
- 20:21automatic switches that if prices reach a certain level,
- 20:24you turn off a certain amount of miners and then the prices come
- 20:28down again, you turn the back on.
- 20:30On the technological side of things, it's things are
- 20:33advancing rather quickly on the mining side, but like you said,
- 20:37the miners in ERCOT have to meet and figure out a way to do this
- 20:42so that you don't disrupt the grid too much so you're not
- 20:45doing it too, too quickly. Absolutely, yeah.
- 20:49I'll throw in a plug for Foreman and all of the other companies
- 20:53developing software for the miners.
- 20:55That is absolutely critical because for Bitcoin miners to be
- 20:59able to be in SCED in this security constrained economic
- 21:02dispatch program, they need to have a lot of granularity and
- 21:05control and so that software is is crucial.
- 21:11Yeah, Lee, I so I just drove through West TX about a month
- 21:15ago and I saw a whole bunch of flares still out there.
- 21:19And you know, I that whole long journey, many hours of of of
- 21:23seeing that you can't help but just think about how much
- 21:26potential there still is in Texas.
- 21:28And even if Texas is already the the leader in embracing Bitcoin
- 21:33mining, I'm curious if you guys have done any analysis or have
- 21:38any projections about what you think.
- 21:41So if it's if Bitcoin mining's 3% of of demand today, do you
- 21:46guys have any expectations about what's possible for for Bitcoin
- 21:50mining in Texas so or in the country in general?
- 21:56Yeah. You know Marty will know more
- 21:57about the flare side than me. I just saw a graphic that
- 22:01estimated that there's about 180 megawatts of flare gas mining
- 22:05across the US It didn't specify how much of that is in Texas,
- 22:09although we all are aware of certain sites in Texas that are
- 22:12are flare gas mining. And then we worked on House Bill
- 22:16591 this last session that clarified that you don't have to
- 22:19pay severance tax if you're selling gas for on site
- 22:23consumption at a data center. So if you if you redirect A
- 22:26flare to a generator to mine, you don't have to pay that
- 22:30severance tax. Just clarification in the tax
- 22:33code on that which was really kind of more of a signal to
- 22:36operator oil and gas operators that hey this is actually a
- 22:39really smart economic move and if it's you, but if it's the
- 22:42state, but if it's the environment, I mean it's a win,
- 22:45win, win across the board. So, but in regards to like where
- 22:50we can get on the on grid side, you know with the difficulty
- 22:55level and having coming up and difficulty just going through
- 22:59the roof, we always estimated that you know mining in Texas
- 23:03would probably cap out around 4000 megawatts which is immense.
- 23:10That's a huge amount of power and it's you know slightly
- 23:14higher than where we are now at about 2300 megawatts.
- 23:18I don't think it could go much higher than that.
- 23:21And I don't think, you know there's there's 30,000 megawatts
- 23:26of large flexible load interconnection request in the
- 23:29interconnection queue in ERCOT. The vast majority of those are,
- 23:34it's just people throwing mud against the wall to see what
- 23:37sticks, right. There's not capital for that.
- 23:39There's not, there's a lot of people that that apply for five
- 23:42different sites and it really runs that number up and it
- 23:46freaks people out. If I were at ERCOT, I'd be
- 23:48freaked out too. So getting a, getting the
- 23:52ability to clear out the interconnection queue and make
- 23:55and charging people for keeping their request in the queue is
- 24:00actually going to help us all in the long run.
- 24:01Because that means the real projects that have real capital
- 24:05will get to the the front of the line faster than just, you know,
- 24:09some landowner who's like, well, I've got a substation near my
- 24:12land, let me see if I could sell my land to a Bitcoin miner or a
- 24:15or a data center, you know, an AIGPU compute data center or
- 24:20something. So we've we've got to fix that.
- 24:22That's a huge problem that is causing major headaches across
- 24:26the state with ERCOT and with the oil and gas industry because
- 24:30Bitcoin miners are are clogging up the queue or oil and gas
- 24:34companies are clogging up the queue.
- 24:36It's it's not good for the the industry or the, you know, the
- 24:41environment. It creates a lot of noise to
- 24:45filter through. It sounds like.
- 24:47Yeah. I just overall this is it's
- 24:51funny to see how like in my head Bitcoin mining is still this
- 24:55kind of wildcatting you know find some unused energy go go
- 24:59put a shipping container full of miners there and and and you're
- 25:02in business But you know it's clear from what you're talking
- 25:07about that the bulk of it is really in this way more
- 25:10professionalized and and large scale integration with policy
- 25:15makers and and the the grid then then even I as a as a Bitcoin
- 25:21enthusiast spending all my time learning about Bitcoin I'm aware
- 25:26of I I so I guess it's really more about what Riot and
- 25:30companies like that are doing versus the shipping container
- 25:36you know capping A flare and and channeling that energy into you
- 25:40know mining Wildcat mining off grid.
- 25:43Yeah and to the off grid point Jesse to answer that I think
- 25:47what needs to happen is the maturation of the hydro cooled
- 25:51data centers especially in West TX it's simply too hot to do the
- 25:55air cooled stuff in the middle of summer.
- 25:58And those are the hydro cooled units are coming to market bit
- 26:01main as their S 21 series with a bunch of hydro cooled units in
- 26:06that they'll be releasing to market micro BT Similarly with
- 26:09their M 50s, I think they have hydro cooled units and then just
- 26:13creating the data centers that facilitate the, the racking of
- 26:17those hydro cooled units. But I think it's completely
- 26:19possible to mitigate a lot of that flare with this.
- 26:22It's just on the mining side, the infrastructure side, we need
- 26:26data centers that are able to take the heat, especially in the
- 26:30middle summer. I didn't know that was a
- 26:32limitation at all. That makes a ton of sense.
- 26:35Does that apply to other? I mean that probably applies to
- 26:37like El Salvador doing volcano mining, like are there are there
- 26:43other areas where that you know that having liquid cooled is
- 26:47gonna really help it's. Interesting.
- 26:49It's more more humid than El Salvador.
- 26:51So you can actually take that water from the air and do some
- 26:53things with it as well, I believe.
- 26:56And then and then there's different types of mining.
- 26:59We have Chris Alfano from 360 Mining.
- 27:01They're doing something pretty unique that we haven't described
- 27:03yet which is they essentially have access to natural gas
- 27:07pipelines and they're putting a mining operation behind those
- 27:11pipelines and mining Bitcoin when the price of gas is low.
- 27:14And then when the price of gas shoots up, they're able to stop
- 27:17mining and and sell that to market.
- 27:19So there's many different ways whether it's off grid flare
- 27:22mitigation, this behind the the meter sort of gas price
- 27:27arbitrage play or this on grid demand response that's out
- 27:32there. So there's many ways to
- 27:34implement mining operations in Texas, which is a beautiful
- 27:37thing. Yeah.
- 27:39And maybe taking it back to Jesse's point on like the
- 27:44professional lies nature of it and the consumer side is really
- 27:49fascinating. I think it ties in.
- 27:50There's an anecdote, I think it's with seven bill 1751 on
- 27:54this relation to the House and Senate.
- 27:56It'd be interesting, Lee to explain like that dynamic, but
- 27:59ultimately how it's counterintuitive and that the
- 28:02more miners or more Bitcoin hash rate that hits a market, how it
- 28:07can help in reducing the overall cost from the net consumer of
- 28:12electricity from the the versus like what happened in California
- 28:15effectively. I didn't really understand that
- 28:17until I think you broke it down on I think it was with Peter.
- 28:21But I think that's an important point to know that this is how
- 28:23we actually can regulate an efficient way, the use of energy
- 28:26versus it has to go somewhere at some point.
- 28:30Right, Yeah. 1751 was a targeted bill to remove Bitcoin mining
- 28:35from ancillary services likely pushed by traditional power
- 28:41users in Texas that were able to garner more that income from by
- 28:48or from selling their services to ERCOT in the day ahead
- 28:53ancillary services marketplace. And so if they could connect, if
- 28:57they could kick Bitcoin miners out of that, then they could bid
- 29:00higher because there'd be fewer bidders in the in the
- 29:02marketplace because you're bidding down and Ercot's taking
- 29:04the lowest bids. And so by having more Bitcoin
- 29:10mining and Bitcoin miners being such efficient curtailers,
- 29:15they're able to bid lower on that curve and save ERCOT money
- 29:21because ERCOT doesn't have to pay as much to procure those
- 29:24services. And the ratepayer, the the
- 29:27consumer saves money because ERCOT passes along those costs
- 29:32to everybody in their electricity bills.
- 29:34So you know there's a lot of data that's needed that we'll
- 29:39we'll go into. You know there's three
- 29:41different, there's three different components here as to
- 29:43how Bitcoin miners affect the price of energy.
- 29:45One is this day ahead market that we just described and we
- 29:50know pretty sure we're we're actually fairly confident that
- 29:53Bitcoin miners drive the price down because of the the 1751
- 29:58wouldn't have existed had we not been so efficient at driving the
- 30:02price down in that market. The other is the simple demand,
- 30:06the demand and and supply equation, right.
- 30:09Bitcoin miners add demand and therefore they should
- 30:12necessarily increase price. So at the aggregate level, if
- 30:16you take nothing else on a simple demand supply, supply and
- 30:20demand curve, Bitcoin miners increase the price of
- 30:23electricity for consumers. So there's one positive and one
- 30:26negative and the third piece, which I think is a positive.
- 30:30And there, this is the part that we really need a lot of data on
- 30:33is Bitcoin miners are not consuming energy at the top of
- 30:39price pressure. So by being off at the highest
- 30:43points price points, we are actually lowering prices for
- 30:48consumers during certain periods.
- 30:50So by being there and consuming power, we're creating incentives
- 30:55for new generation. But then by turning off and not
- 30:59adding to price pressure when prices start to get high, you
- 31:03know those are the that's why it's a super complex.
- 31:05You know, you can't just say that Bitcoin mining increases
- 31:08prices or decreases prices. It's very nuanced.
- 31:13And so the jury's still out on on what it does for that.
- 31:15We do know that it's good for liability and good for smoothing
- 31:19out the energy consumption patterns of the grid.
- 31:23That's 100% verifiable and provable.
- 31:27But certainly we want to make sure that we're doing that in a
- 31:31in an effective way. So did that answer the question,
- 31:34Michael? I'm not sure if I really got at
- 31:36it. Yeah, I think the last part was
- 31:38just the overnight. I think the touching on when
- 31:41things go negative and that somebody has to consume that and
- 31:43that's where like Bitcoin miners can come in at 3:00 AM to be
- 31:46able to support. Yeah, that's the reason why you
- 31:50don't see new fossil fuel generation in really hardly
- 31:54anywhere. It's 'cause there's a $3030 per
- 31:57MW hour subsidy on renewables, and fossil fuel generators
- 32:02can't. They're losing money overnight,
- 32:05so they have to compete with a $30 MW subsidy for renewables
- 32:10and they also have to deal with negative prices overnight, which
- 32:15is a killer for them. One of the things I remember
- 32:19about and learning about the grid just a little bit is that
- 32:24the grid is really designed. Any grid is designed for a few
- 32:27hot days in August and you know that you've got these peaker
- 32:31plants that only come on for a tiny fraction of the time.
- 32:35Have you seen that you know Bitcoin mining and and this
- 32:39demand response capability has reduced the need for incremental
- 32:45peaker plants. Is that something that's flowing
- 32:48through to like the the CapEx requirements for you know the
- 32:52grid going forward it? It absolutely is.
- 32:56I mean we, it's hard to know necessarily.
- 33:00Hey, this peaker plant is getting less, It's being turned
- 33:05on less because of Bitcoin mining.
- 33:07That's really a difficult thing. But it is pretty clear that
- 33:11Bitcoin miners are competing with peaker plants at those
- 33:17those high prices, right? So peaker plants are are going
- 33:22to come on a couple of days in August, probably a few days in
- 33:25the winter. And Bitcoin miners are sort of
- 33:29lessening the need for that and therefore sort of competing in
- 33:34the marketplace against peaker plants.
- 33:37Whereas they're from the supply side, Bitcoin mining is from the
- 33:39demand side. Thanks for tuning in to The last
- 33:43trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 33:45want to dive deeper, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com where
- 33:50you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 33:53analytics, including our recently published white paper,
- 33:57Bitcoin's Full Potential Valuation, and our new tool, the
- 34:01On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 34:06On the subject of the $30 per MW subsidy that wind and solar get,
- 34:11you think this could lead to some systemic fragility due to
- 34:16disruption in free market operations.
- 34:18That's the one thing I worry about is the over the the focus
- 34:23on building out more wind and solar capacity that yes, at some
- 34:29points in the middle of the night it may drive prices
- 34:31negative. But if we have a situation like
- 34:34the winter storms that we've had in recent years become more
- 34:38normalized, like yes at times those prices are negative but
- 34:43the generation isn't always reliable when it gets cold out
- 34:46the the clouds are covering the sun and sometimes the the wind
- 34:50turbines can freeze up. So like that's a big problem I
- 34:54could see arising on the horizon.
- 34:57There's just this over focus on wind and solar generation at the
- 35:03detriment to more reliable generation in the form of
- 35:07nuclear, natural gas, coal, whatever it may be.
- 35:09And if the market is being manipulated in a way that is
- 35:13making those operations uneconomical, you could see a
- 35:16lot of these be decommissioned 'cause they can't keep the
- 35:19lights on due to these subsidies.
- 35:22Absolutely. There's really that's that.
- 35:25You hit the nail on the head. There's only three ways to get
- 35:27out of the situation. One is you remove the federal
- 35:30subsidies on wind and solar. That's probably not going to
- 35:33happen. Two is you subsidized reliable
- 35:40generation through chief financing or other things which
- 35:45Texas did in the last legislative session, provided
- 35:48some low interest financing for reliable generation to be built.
- 35:55And the third is you match you, you you bring in more flexible
- 36:01load, right. So the only those are the really
- 36:05the only three ways to to get out of the situation that we
- 36:08find ourselves in the Texas grid is overly saturated with with
- 36:12renewables when in solar. And I think the the two
- 36:18mechanisms that we're going to have to use is more flexible
- 36:21load that's green hydrogen, you know hydrogen electrolyzers,
- 36:25they're very flexible Bitcoin mining data centers and and
- 36:29other forms of industrial consumers that are flexible.
- 36:32And perhaps even aggregating consumer demand through like the
- 36:36Google, you know Nest products or other products that actually
- 36:39provide passes on some savings for consumers that are willing
- 36:42to change their energy consumption habits based upon
- 36:45the market. Maybe you get a notification on
- 36:48your phone like, hey, you'll save $3 today if you, you know,
- 36:52turn your electricity down by one or two degrees or something
- 36:55or your thermostat down. So yeah, leaning on those last
- 36:59two I think are the way we get out of this, but we're in a bad
- 37:02spot and it is a function of federal subsidies, Absolutely
- 37:09well-intentioned to be sure. But you know, that's the the
- 37:13road to hell is paved with good intention.
- 37:14So. Yeah, this is something I've
- 37:18been pining on for for some time, screaming into the abyss
- 37:22sometimes it seems, but I'm very happy to see that we're on the
- 37:26same page. Here we have.
- 37:29It's insane. In my mind, I just wrote a piece
- 37:33in the Bitcoin Times, their energy edition.
- 37:35I really dove into this. We have a perfect case study in
- 37:37Germany. They did this over the first two
- 37:39decades of the century and the results have been abysmal for
- 37:43them. And it just is extremely
- 37:45disconcerting as somebody lives in Texas to see Texas making
- 37:49similar mistakes. But I do have hopes that clear
- 37:54minds can prevail and people can recognize what's happening.
- 37:57We just need more people talking about it.
- 38:00Well, I think, I think that that keys on exactly what you're
- 38:03doing, Leah, like be curious on you're talking about intentions
- 38:06and motivations and incentives. It's like across the aisle you
- 38:10got you know Warren Vivek, RFK like what?
- 38:17What gives? I know you you shared a little
- 38:19thoughts but just like curious on their angles of like their in
- 38:23their stances to Bitcoin to digital assets and as recent as
- 38:27the clip this morning with like the you know banking JPMC and
- 38:31rat poison squared ask like what's your what what have you
- 38:35seen. I know, I think there was a
- 38:37letter that was written to you or part you were part in it,
- 38:39about Texas and our colleague. What have you seen in the
- 38:42motivations and intentions across, you know, politics in
- 38:45Texas and the US? Yeah, I'll start with Elizabeth
- 38:49Warren. I mean I think she's obviously
- 38:52the one that we see the most out there with her anti crypto army
- 38:56and you know she's got a, she's obviously brilliant, right.
- 39:01She's a brilliant elected official you know attorney.
- 39:07The problem that I've seen with her is that her staff she quite
- 39:12influential because her staff populates a lot of the executive
- 39:16agencies. So she's got a lot of former
- 39:19staffers that are in the White House, in the administration, in
- 39:22key positions. And she's able to set some of
- 39:26the narratives for other more centrist Democrats that are more
- 39:31interested in level headed policy and and job creation and
- 39:36you know economic development than they are with with virtue
- 39:38signaling and things like that. And and I do think that, you
- 39:44know, she has benefited. She looks for areas that align
- 39:51with her sort of world view where she can become the, the
- 39:56biggest mouthpiece for that, you know for or against that thing,
- 40:01right. So if there had already been
- 40:05somebody who was the anti Bitcoin mining or anti digital
- 40:08asset senator, then she probably would have found some other.
- 40:15You know, thing to to latch onto.
- 40:17So she's she's got some she's winning political capital with
- 40:21certain groups. Although I think she's
- 40:24miscalculated here or maybe hasn't looked at the same
- 40:27polling data that I've looked at.
- 40:30She thinks there's a a winning issue here politically and
- 40:33there. It's also possible I've not
- 40:35looked at her donor you know open open records donor reports
- 40:40of who's donating to her. But I'm fairly sure since she's
- 40:43on Senate Banking that the, you know, the big systemically
- 40:48important banks and and and those companies in that orbit
- 40:53are highly important to her fundraising.
- 40:56So, you know, it's almost like Jamie Dimon was tripping over
- 41:00her, over himself to agree with her in that hearing.
- 41:04And I think those are the three primary reasons why she is the
- 41:09way that she is. She's she's she's incredibly
- 41:11smart and I think we shouldn't underestimate her.
- 41:16Chief Karen of the Nation, Elizabeth Warren, But I I think
- 41:22with that in mind, let's paint an optimistic future.
- 41:26So like with her posturing in mind, how would how do you think
- 41:31is the best way to counter that? What narrative should Bitcoiners
- 41:35in the industry be running with to paint an optimistic future of
- 41:38an America that Braces embraces Bitcoin?
- 41:42Yeah, the the easiest issue that I think we're going to find is
- 41:46the Bitcoin being the antithesis to a central bank digital
- 41:49currency. That issue pulls extremely well
- 41:53in our favor, right. So and we know that it is, but
- 41:56most people don't yet connect that in their minds as two sides
- 41:59of, you know, the opposite sides of the coin.
- 42:02So she, she has been tacitly supportive of a central bank
- 42:08digital currency, which is not surprising because it gives more
- 42:11control, more granular control to the government and I think
- 42:15allows the government to surveil transactions more efficiently,
- 42:19Right, Michael, we were talking about very early in the show
- 42:22that part of the reason why, you know you have these travel rural
- 42:25dollar restrictions and that that dollar amount has been
- 42:29lower recently. You know we're around $600.00
- 42:31where there's there's reporting on.
- 42:35It's very cumbersome for these different agencies to sift
- 42:39through all of that data. I mean there's the the the
- 42:42amount of transactions is is enormous especially when you to
- 42:45the low dollar transactions absolutely mind boggling how
- 42:50they could sort through that data.
- 42:52If that was on a blockchain and on a centrally controlled
- 42:56blockchain you know sort of a ACBDC if you will.
- 43:00It would be a lot easier for them to sift through look for
- 43:03patterns understand you know people's habits than it is
- 43:07today. And that's certainly
- 43:12disheartening and scary for for those of us that believe in
- 43:15liberty and freedom And so that's our easiest target right
- 43:18is to is to paint anybody who's anti Bitcoin as pro CBDC and
- 43:24Elizabeth Warren already wants to be pro CBC that's fine.
- 43:26That is that issue polls really bad pulls like 95% and to you
- 43:34know negative favorability with Republicans and and even close
- 43:38to 60% negative favorability with Democrats.
- 43:41So no chance for that issue. That's that's really where we
- 43:46want to hang our hat in, in the near term.
- 43:49In the long term, providing more data points around Bitcoin
- 43:53mining and its environmental potential to to, you know, soak
- 43:57up methane at landfills, to soak up flared gas, to soak up excess
- 44:01energy, to, to balance grids. You know, that's I think very
- 44:06clear to all of us. But until there are academics
- 44:11that are willing to set aside, you know, their, you know, the
- 44:15narrative, the media narrative and actually do some, some, you
- 44:19know, robust studies, we're going to have a hard time
- 44:24convincing Elizabeth Warren of that.
- 44:25I think so. I I think the low hanging fruit
- 44:28is the CBDC issue and the freedom issue.
- 44:31Yeah, I think that's a a very important like idea in in the
- 44:34circles we we discuss things and it's like it's already like a
- 44:37foregone conclusion that we're already surveilled.
- 44:40It's like the government can barely send the Stimi checks and
- 44:42how to do public private partnerships like how can they
- 44:44actually with the $600.00 that you referenced in the 10,000
- 44:47like aggregate that info it's still disparate and the second
- 44:49you put it on like a wholesale blockchain that just instantly
- 44:53you're just turned off. Like Marty says one thing and
- 44:55then his his bank account is is done before he can end the pod.
- 44:59Like that's the kind of like Orwellian thing and the the sad
- 45:02part is I think it happens. It's just like if we can delay
- 45:04it as long as possible to get, you know, kind of awareness and
- 45:08all the things associated with Bitcoin is the is the game.
- 45:11Yeah, it's the CBDC conversation's really
- 45:13interesting 'cause you see a divergent of opinions at, well,
- 45:18Federal Reserve isn't technically federal, but you see
- 45:20Jerome Powell and other Federal Reserve Board members saying, I
- 45:23don't, we don't think ACBDC is worthwhile or something that we
- 45:27would want to implement. And then you have the Elizabeth
- 45:29Warrens of the world really pushing it.
- 45:31So there's not even real continuity in CBDC narrative at
- 45:35that level? It's it's funny because that's
- 45:38the, I was just having a discussion with a firm overseas
- 45:41that's quasi doing you see like bit go has go network upper loop
- 45:45where they do these consortiums within the digital asset like
- 45:49provider and they do net settlement and they want to do
- 45:52their own quasi like private you know currency.
- 45:55But this is what effectively at least the thesis is what
- 45:57happened. A signature.
- 45:58Because nobody talks about like SVB had their deal, Silvergate
- 46:01had their deal, but that was duration risk with the
- 46:03treasuries. Nobody talks about like they
- 46:05just like shot signature in the back at the end of on A.
- 46:08Sunday night. On a Sunday night in the, the
- 46:11comment I think thought in the the understanding is that they
- 46:13were developing the send network and that this was this like
- 46:15competitor between these banks to like net out over you know 24
- 46:19hours, seven days a week. And so it's coming.
- 46:22It's just like to Marty's point, I think there's their private
- 46:24public partnership and then from a like federal level and they're
- 46:27still trying to like cut out the banks, you know and they're like
- 46:31wait. And so that's I think that
- 46:33infighting is actually helpful in our direction of like it just
- 46:36delays all of this is important. Yeah, our our natural allies in
- 46:42this fight are going to be regional banks.
- 46:46You know the systemically important banks are going to
- 46:48side with the the Fed and the federal government no matter
- 46:51what. But regional banks are getting
- 46:55screwed right now, right. So they're having to offer 4%
- 46:59interest on deposits whereas Bank of America and JP Morgan
- 47:03can offer point 1%. I mean you just can't run a
- 47:06business with that unfair finger on the scale.
- 47:11And so and also regional banks are are you know I think they're
- 47:16against central bank digital, they're certainly against fed to
- 47:19consumer like a retail CBDC 100% talk to people at various
- 47:24banking industry associations, they are against that.
- 47:29I think they are probably indifferent to intermediated
- 47:34CBDC that's just just fed to banks sort of like intrabank
- 47:39CBDC. We certainly still oppose that.
- 47:43It's not as Orwellian, but it's it's certainly a a step in the
- 47:46wrong direction. But we have some natural allies
- 47:50in regional banks, you know to fight against the CBDC and and I
- 47:55think you got also natural allies in sort of the liberty
- 47:58movement writ large that maybe doesn't understand Bitcoin,
- 48:01right. So as I mentioned earlier, some
- 48:04of the survey data, 48% of Texans under the age of 29 own
- 48:11digital assets. Only 6% of people over the age
- 48:15of 65 own them. And the favorability numbers are
- 48:19very similar, right? Young people are highly
- 48:22favorable. You know, a net plus 10 positive
- 48:26positive favorability score for Bitcoin across the board, but
- 48:29that's like net 30 for young people and actually net negative
- 48:34for for old people. So if we have this issue that
- 48:37all old people understand and I say that very, that's crass.
- 48:41I should say people of older generations or whatever as a
- 48:45nicer way to say that. But people in in older
- 48:47generations, they they get liberty and they know they're
- 48:52against CBD CS. So that's really the narrative
- 48:54that I think we should push on. I think those numbers are funny
- 48:58because the other side of it that doesn't hold Bitcoin is
- 49:01whatever the Texas bill or what was going on this past year
- 49:05about the gold backed currency and that the other side hasn't
- 49:09gone far enough on Bitcoin. But there's just this underlying
- 49:12understanding that something's very broken with the money and
- 49:16it's like they just, it's just we're still kind of like that's
- 49:18where we focus on the pawn and the education is because it's
- 49:21helping people see that it already exists.
- 49:24Yeah, I wanted to ask you guys about that.
- 49:26So we we took a neutral stance on the gold backed stable coin
- 49:30that was potentially going to go in Texas.
- 49:32It ended up not making it through both, both chambers.
- 49:36But what are what are your else thoughts on the gold backed
- 49:38stable coin? I mean it.
- 49:40It's sort of like an interesting wrench to throw into things
- 49:45better than a. Solano backed one.
- 49:48Yeah, exactly. Yeah, of of of all the assets
- 49:50you could pick to back something with, it's probably the second
- 49:54best asset possible. But, but then it it still just
- 50:00doesn't in my opinion solve for the the root problem of you
- 50:04know, when you're linking a a digital currency to anything
- 50:10then there's a problem because you you then there's a surface
- 50:13area for attack, for corruption, for accounting error, anything
- 50:19like that where you know if you if you have gold in a vault and
- 50:22you're saying, OK, there's there's so many units of gold
- 50:25here. And then we're going to issue
- 50:27digital currencies that are going to, you know, represent
- 50:30the units in the vault. There's all sorts of problems
- 50:33that can arise from that link from physical to digital.
- 50:37And that's, that's the beauty of what Bitcoin solves is that
- 50:40there is no link from physical to digital.
- 50:43It's purely digital and so. There is a link.
- 50:47Well, OK. So there's a link in the
- 50:49economic cost of creation of that digital unit, but you don't
- 50:54have the, the, the connection of physical asset to digital asset.
- 51:01You have pure digital asset. Energy.
- 51:05Energy is the only place where the physical and digital really
- 51:08connect. From Bitcoin I.
- 51:10Personally, I personally think it's great.
- 51:12I think it moves and this is partially probably Jesse will
- 51:14want to talk on and I think we should like the Overton Window
- 51:16when we talk about politics, but Overton window and this
- 51:19understanding of like what actually backs your unit.
- 51:22And we, we had this discussion last week with Joel from 2 Ocean
- 51:25about you know these kind of free banking style CBD, not CB,
- 51:29CS, free banking style dollars and like what backs them and
- 51:32ultimately like having a sovereign state like Wyoming
- 51:34back the dollars. But then you'll start seeing
- 51:36different people back that currency maybe it's two 3% goes
- 51:40into Bitcoin 4% what you just described believe is like well
- 51:44it's backed by gold and theoretically gold will
- 51:46appreciate compared to the dollar.
- 51:48And so that will actually increase the purchasing power
- 51:50again theoretically in this setup of that.
- 51:53And so at least it starts that question and then if it's backed
- 51:55by the Texas sovereign government and you can always
- 51:57get that you know peg back, I could see it at least having a
- 52:00like it starts to move the discussion, we all know where
- 52:02it'll it ends. It's very similar to like the
- 52:05the Russian and geopolitical stance that we're starting to
- 52:08see or you know coordination of economic activity around
- 52:13settling oil for other forms of currency or what is it backed
- 52:17by. So I think it's in my opinion
- 52:18it's a net positive and just having those discussions, but I
- 52:21think end of the day we all kind of know where things trend
- 52:23towards. Yeah.
- 52:25I'd I'd agree with that. I I think that I think that what
- 52:28we're seeing with the BRICS nations trying to maneuver to
- 52:33find a way to establish a new like reserve currency standard
- 52:39that will be commodity based rather than U.S.
- 52:41Treasury based that you know that's the way the world is
- 52:45moving in and and so having like a a, a gold backed currency in
- 52:52Texas makes a lot of sense for like throwing your hat in the
- 52:56ring in in terms of options out there.
- 53:00But yeah, I agree with Michael. I think it is a stepping stone
- 53:03towards what will eventually be that preferred because because
- 53:09of that that inherent link that remains when you have any kind
- 53:14of physical asset represented in the digital space rather you
- 53:19know and and and you know in in that sense you still have the
- 53:236102 problem with gold. There's a vault that holds the
- 53:29gold and the and the government can say, you know, we're
- 53:33changing the rules, we're taking that that, that gold.
- 53:37And that is the beauty of what Bitcoin makes so much more
- 53:41difficult because where is that Bitcoin being held?
- 53:46It's everywhere and it's nowhere at once.
- 53:51I I personally love gold. It kind of pains me.
- 53:53I like, listen to, I know Marty's now this strong stance,
- 53:57but yeah, it's like Matt and they they'll call it a shit
- 53:59coin. And it's like, it's like, it's
- 54:01like I like. Gold too.
- 54:02It's like our, but it's our best friend.
- 54:03Like from a pure like, how do we explain Bitcoin?
- 54:06It's like this thing has existed for thousands of years.
- 54:08It's obviously not as scarce as Bitcoin, but it has the same
- 54:11properties that you can start to build a mental model of how the
- 54:14world was constructed and can go there And to dismiss it as that,
- 54:18it's like, OK, we know where it goes, but we still have like
- 54:20years and years, if not decades to do that transition.
- 54:23And if we can align with that, it's like an easy way to say
- 54:25this is digital gold, then everything else is like whatever
- 54:28it is, copper, aluminum. But it's not money I think is
- 54:32the right mental model to like start sharing with our our
- 54:34boomer friends and folks that are.
- 54:36It's too far to go directly into Bitcoin, at least whole whole
- 54:39hog like we have. I don't appreciate the
- 54:41assumption that I'm not aligned. I I've said it many times
- 54:45before, gold bugs are our friends.
- 54:46We're philosophically aligned. We need to be welcoming the gold
- 54:50bugs and putting up with some of their derogatory comments on
- 54:53Bitcoin. Say, hey, you know, you don't
- 54:55get it, but we're more aligned than you know.
- 54:59I'm just trying to set in your mind for for for Matt so when he
- 55:02when he calls them shit corners it's the the gold the gold bugs
- 55:06as shit corners or gold's a shit coin I think just give them a
- 55:10little and. And I, you know, we we end up in
- 55:13these slightly tribal positions, but I think, I think gold, gold
- 55:18enthusiasts and Bitcoin enthusiasts actually are free
- 55:22market money enthusiasts. That's that's really what we are
- 55:26at the end of the day. We like, we like that there are
- 55:30assets that are better to hold as money and that the free
- 55:33market through time and you know proving out the properties of
- 55:37these different assets can can gravitate towards certain assets
- 55:42being better for money. And that is the entire history
- 55:45of gold winning out over all any other form of physical commodity
- 55:49money over 70,000 years of going from from seashells in cave
- 55:54sites 70,000 years ago to to gold becoming the global
- 55:59standard. And and Bitcoin is just a part
- 56:01of that competition now. It's just a new entrant into
- 56:04free market money. And I happen to think that it
- 56:07will win out because it has superior properties to gold.
- 56:10It's it's gold perfected in many ways.
- 56:14But at at the end of the day we we're aligned that free market
- 56:21money and commodity money makes sense.
- 56:25Yeah. On that note, I'm sure you saw I
- 56:30was on my laptop earlier because I was looking for this chart.
- 56:32I didn't find the exact chart I want it, but bringing it back to
- 56:35the regional banks as our greatest allies, because I think
- 56:37it's important to dive into this because we need as many allies
- 56:40as possible. And so here's the chart of
- 56:43deposits and as you can see, deposits are flat lined as
- 56:48people have been dumping their cash in some money market funds.
- 56:51And there's another chart out there that I couldn't find.
- 56:54But it shows the divergent of deposits at the systemically
- 56:56important banks versus the regional banks.
- 56:58It's completely divergent. Money is flooding out of the
- 57:01regional banks. And so to that point, how do we
- 57:06become allies? How, how could the Bitcoin
- 57:07industry help these regional banks?
- 57:09We had Ron DeSantis mentioned earlier this year, I believe
- 57:14that if the federal government were to crack down on the
- 57:18ability for industry players within the cryptocurrency
- 57:21landscape to get bank accounts, Florida and their state
- 57:24chartered banks would step in and provide those banking
- 57:27services. Lee, in your mind, we think we
- 57:30need more states like Florida or Texas to embolden their state
- 57:35chartered banks and then their regional banks to support the
- 57:38industry. I think that's a great step and
- 57:43absolutely we work with the Texas Department of Banking on
- 57:47those topics and as being Texas, our Texas Department Banking
- 57:51Chairman and that department is very cognizant of their role as
- 57:56a leader. You know Chairman Cooper is on F
- 57:59sock and the president's working group and he is very, I guess I
- 58:07don't want to put words in his mouth but in his actions he's
- 58:10demonstrated A willingness to stand up for state banking
- 58:15regulation and the rights of state banks as set forth in in
- 58:20various, you know, federal statute and and constitutionally
- 58:24as well. So a natural ally for us.
- 58:28I I think we should, this is going to be tough, but I think
- 58:31we should actually begin dialogues with state banking
- 58:36associations, banking associations at the federal
- 58:40level and banking associations at various state levels.
- 58:44Now that might be a culture shock for us and for them, but
- 58:50we're natural allies and if we could create some sort of
- 58:52platform, some areas that we agree, you know that that makes
- 58:57huge waves in in Washington DC and state capitals around the
- 59:00country. If Bitcoin and bitcoiners and
- 59:04trade associations representing the digital asset industry are
- 59:08now allying with, you know, your local, your statewide or even
- 59:12federal, nationwide regional banking associations or
- 59:17independent banking associations.
- 59:21Getting that done, though, I don't know that that takes.
- 59:25That's probably something that we could do if we all put our
- 59:27minds together and get got on a bunch of zoom calls and and met
- 59:31with the the right people. But it's a it's a Herculean
- 59:34effort, to be sure. If you're representative of
- 59:38State Chartered Bank or one of these state banking regulators
- 59:43listening to the show, reach out.
- 59:44We should have a conversation. We should, yeah, no, we could.
- 59:49We could probably link in LinkedIn, stock them, get their
- 59:51emails using Zoom Info, and just say, hey, we need to we need to
- 59:55get organized here. Yeah.
- 59:59You, you, you. Talked about it about the like
- 1:00:04press for the summit and getting like local.
- 1:00:08I think this kind of ties into it.
- 1:00:09It's like the regional banks. So you know they're kind of like
- 1:00:11the the heart and soul of America when it comes to like
- 1:00:13agricultural loans and mechanical loans and things
- 1:00:16associated with that. And then the constituents in
- 1:00:19these small markets being able to see the presence and then
- 1:00:21vote. Love to hear kind of like your
- 1:00:23thoughts on the just the grassroots is a slower burn and
- 1:00:27it's it's something Marty talks about a lot of like the small
- 1:00:30towns like you have to have the local you can only start from
- 1:00:33like your armed distance whether it's like your personal family
- 1:00:36group, peers, network, professional group, your town
- 1:00:39and that starts to like grow and bubble up.
- 1:00:41And it sounds like you have that approach.
- 1:00:43Lee, be curious like your thoughts on that and what others
- 1:00:46can do in other markets. Because the idea is this
- 1:00:47playbook can be can be done anywhere right in the US or
- 1:00:50internationally from being able to effect political change or at
- 1:00:54least uncovering some of the things that historically people
- 1:00:58haven't seen clearly, that the money's fundamentally broken and
- 1:01:01and there's ways that can be fixed and it just takes somebody
- 1:01:04taking action. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:08All politics is local, as the old adage goes.
- 1:01:10So I think that's absolutely right.
- 1:01:14And there are other trade associations in other states.
- 1:01:19About 40 of the 50 states have trade associations, and I chair
- 1:01:23a a steering committee for that entity.
- 1:01:26It's a loose federation. It's not really an entity per
- 1:01:29SE. It's a federation of state
- 1:01:30associations. And we are working to build
- 1:01:35grassroots networks of people that will go out and block walk
- 1:01:39and call their representatives. And you know, because it's one
- 1:01:42thing to get a bunch of people like Anons on Twitter to rail
- 1:01:47against Elizabeth Warren or to, you know, put put pressure on in
- 1:01:52that way, that's good, that's helpful.
- 1:01:54But we also need to have the people that are that person's
- 1:01:58constituents that that live in that district, that electric
- 1:02:02elected officials district that can call up and say hey I live
- 1:02:05in your district and you know that's that's more impactful
- 1:02:08than a retweet or a like is 150 constituents calling a
- 1:02:14representative's office is a is a far bigger wake up sign for
- 1:02:19them than you know a tweet that gets 10,000 or even a million
- 1:02:23likes and retweets. They they get kind of rattled a
- 1:02:27little bit more when constituents start calling or go
- 1:02:31visiting you know visiting their offices.
- 1:02:32And so you know we put together playbooks around block walking
- 1:02:36and how to you know if if you get out there for an elected
- 1:02:39official's campaign and you know that they're supportive of the
- 1:02:43industry and you block walk for them, they won't forget that
- 1:02:47because very, you know a lot of people go out and vote but very
- 1:02:49people will go out and block walk on behalf of an elected
- 1:02:52official. So we do that every time
- 1:02:54elections come around and try to get our members to block walk
- 1:02:57for our allies. You know it's it's a.
- 1:03:01It's a good practice to to to get in for sure it's block.
- 1:03:06Walk. Is that like a like a cousin of
- 1:03:08like tar and feathering? Or what is?
- 1:03:10It. Sorry that that just means like
- 1:03:13going around and knocking on doors and saying hey you live in
- 1:03:16senator you know XY ZS district we think you should vote for to
- 1:03:21re elect them because we're we've been very impressed with
- 1:03:25how they've you know voted or whatever.
- 1:03:27Like, it's basically just going around supporting them, talking
- 1:03:32to their voters on behalf of them because they can't
- 1:03:35physically walk around and talk to every voter before elections.
- 1:03:40Yeah, I think everybody forgets how much power we have.
- 1:03:43Like from a local perspective, I think about like COVID and all
- 1:03:45the people even in California, like sheriffs are like, no,
- 1:03:48we're not going to do that. Like you have to go to work with
- 1:03:50these individuals. You have to see them every day.
- 1:03:51Like that's the thing that people feel the pressure when
- 1:03:54you're able to see physical humans and you're like, oh, I
- 1:03:56have like a recourse for my actions versus it just be
- 1:03:59ephemeral. And so, like, oh, some some
- 1:04:01number on a ballot. That's funny to that point,
- 1:04:04Michael, Like these pockets exist in every state.
- 1:04:07Everybody likes to basically paint each state with a red or
- 1:04:11blue brush, but there are certainly purple areas and blue
- 1:04:15States and red areas and blue states.
- 1:04:16When I escaped New York for COVID, we went to Cape May
- 1:04:19County, New Jersey. NJ is considered one of the the
- 1:04:23bluest states out there, but the county we were in did not put up
- 1:04:26with a lot of the BS and the lockdown mandates and stuff like
- 1:04:30that. So these pockets do exist.
- 1:04:31It's just emboldening these people.
- 1:04:32And that's something I've been saying a lot recently on a bunch
- 1:04:35of podcasts. My my own podcast and other
- 1:04:37podcasts is it needs to be an instilling of confidence in to
- 1:04:43the silent majority that is afraid to speak up like you said
- 1:04:47Lee. I think people would be
- 1:04:48surprised how far their voice carries if they actually use it
- 1:04:53by calling their their local official or showing up, yeah.
- 1:04:58And especially if they can use it in a coordinated way too.
- 1:05:01If they can get a network or a community of people, you know,
- 1:05:06in our case it's like minded people who who are freedom
- 1:05:08advocates and and believe in free market based, commodity
- 1:05:13based money as Jesse put it to to start making calls.
- 1:05:18That's pretty powerful. Well, you can.
- 1:05:20Can you touch on some of the existing politicians in their
- 1:05:24stances are getting Bitcoin? Like, there's two parts to this
- 1:05:27it feels like, and maybe I'm wrong, but like Senator Cruz
- 1:05:29maybe understands Bitcoin probably the best.
- 1:05:32But then you reference and I can't remember the names but
- 1:05:34there's a guy in South Texas I think Cuellar and then another
- 1:05:37one that I hadn't heard from before and I haven't even had a
- 1:05:40chance to look him up. But I thought it'd be good to
- 1:05:41reach out and potentially hear their stances and like what's
- 1:05:44driving the interest of like the these alignment because it's not
- 1:05:48they wouldn't do it for gold. My assumption is it's like it's
- 1:05:51not gold. There's something of with the
- 1:05:52the pulling the demographics and all the things associated would
- 1:05:55be curious like your take there? Yeah, so people like Senator
- 1:05:59Cruz, they get it at a philosophical level like down to
- 1:06:02the, you know, you guys have heard his remarks on on Bitcoin
- 1:06:06representative Cuellar down in South Texas.
- 1:06:09I don't know, I don't think he's read the Bitcoin standard or and
- 1:06:13I don't think he really has had time to give much thought to the
- 1:06:17philosophical piece of it. But what he does understand is
- 1:06:21that it's bringing jobs to his district in in the form of
- 1:06:24Bitcoin mining. And he also understands the
- 1:06:28polling data because his district skews younger and skews
- 1:06:32Hispanic at the at that geography of Texas.
- 1:06:36He understands that his constituents are more likely to
- 1:06:40like it than older white people. And so he sees jobs and he sees
- 1:06:46polling data and then you've got people like Vivek and RFK,
- 1:06:49right? So they have philosophical
- 1:06:51alignments with portions of Bitcoin like Vivek is very much
- 1:06:56aligned with like sort of the the concerns around money
- 1:06:59printing and debasement of Fiat currencies and the way that
- 1:07:05Bitcoin counters that, right. So he's got a a strong, some
- 1:07:09some strong talking points on that and he unveiled his, you
- 1:07:12know, 3 comprehensive policy at the summit.
- 1:07:16He had three policy points and self custody was one of them,
- 1:07:19which I thought was great. And then RFK is a big privacy
- 1:07:23advocate has been for decades and so and and sort of has a a
- 1:07:29weariness or or or leeriness if you know if you will of big
- 1:07:34government and government overreach and surveillance.
- 1:07:38And so that is that Bitcoin has certainly struck a nerve with
- 1:07:44him and you know, I think I think he that's probably, if if
- 1:07:48we were to ask him would be his, his most, I guess favorite
- 1:07:55property of Bitcoin, if you will.
- 1:07:58Yeah, I I can't help but think about how, you know, how far
- 1:08:03we've come in in terms of reaching politicians.
- 1:08:07And and you did a great job there of of highlighting how for
- 1:08:11different politicians Bitcoin speaks to them for different
- 1:08:14reasons. You know, whether that's just
- 1:08:16because it's jobs in their district for Bitcoin miners or
- 1:08:19because of privacy. But as Bitcoin keeps doing its
- 1:08:23thing and and keeps making its way through the adoption curve
- 1:08:27of of just individuals turning to this asset because it's a
- 1:08:32it's a savings technology and and you know in a time with high
- 1:08:36inflation in the dollar and that reaches politicians too and and
- 1:08:42so it not only reaches the you know, the politicians but their
- 1:08:45their the electorate. And this whole process is is
- 1:08:48running in parallel together, you know, as we all make our way
- 1:08:53through the adoption curve of Bitcoin as a society.
- 1:08:57And it it strikes me as as so important what you guys are
- 1:09:00doing of of trying to find ways to to in in some ways hold off
- 1:09:08draconian reactions to Bitcoin at the political level long
- 1:09:14enough for this organic process of people discovering Bitcoin
- 1:09:18and and recognizing the benefits that it brings to them for their
- 1:09:22particular needs, whatever those may be.
- 1:09:24Because there are so many different advantages of Bitcoin,
- 1:09:28You know, these efforts help to provide that air cover for long
- 1:09:33enough for that organic process to play out until we reach that
- 1:09:36intransigent, intransigent, minority tipping point where,
- 1:09:41you know, there there's enough of a of a hardcore advocate base
- 1:09:48for this asset that it becomes pretty impossible to, you know,
- 1:09:53make it illegal. And so I I I can't help but feel
- 1:09:57like we're in this window of time where we we need to survive
- 1:10:01and and help gain little wins in the political process long
- 1:10:07enough for the mechanics of Bitcoin to inevitably play out
- 1:10:11in the adoption curve to to defend Bitcoin in its own right.
- 1:10:17Couldn't agree more or. You just have to wait till they
- 1:10:20wait till they age out. But we got like 25 years.
- 1:10:22I was looking at the delta between Warren and Feinstein and
- 1:10:25it's it's literally she she lived to 99.
- 1:10:28So we got a we got a good. We got a good way to go.
- 1:10:31I'll keep my comments to myself and with that in mind, we we
- 1:10:35want to be respectful of your time.
- 1:10:36I know you have something here in a few minutes, so before we
- 1:10:40wrap it up, is there anything we didn't cover that you think we
- 1:10:42should mention? I think the last thing that I'd
- 1:10:47say is, you know, part of the reason why Texas has had such a,
- 1:10:52you know, has been considered a leader in this industry is the
- 1:10:55energy of bitcoiners and and freedom advocates in Texas.
- 1:11:02And so it really doesn't happen without a culture that's
- 1:11:06predisposed to that. And so I I think the work that
- 1:11:09you guys do and that many others do to continue to spread that
- 1:11:14message is vitally important. So I really appreciate that.
- 1:11:17And that helps us in the advocacy efforts because we have
- 1:11:20strong grassroots to reach back into.
- 1:11:24Yeah. I would say my big thing was to
- 1:11:27shout out to the I don't know if you've completely changed the
- 1:11:31name. Is it officially every year now,
- 1:11:32the North American Blockchain Summit?
- 1:11:34Or is it? Yeah, 'cause I know it's the
- 1:11:36Texas. Yeah, we it's been the Texas
- 1:11:40Summit the last couple years and we did we did change the name to
- 1:11:43the North American Blockchain Summit this year and and moving.
- 1:11:46Forward and we've gone to a lot of conferences.
- 1:11:50Personally, I thought from a professional standpoint it was
- 1:11:53the best that I've been to from we're starting to see the
- 1:11:55maturation of the industry from the people that put on a suit
- 1:11:59and that are producing like high value across the world frankly.
- 1:12:02But there was predominantly in the North America and and it's
- 1:12:07growing and it showed like that. You know ideally I love Fort
- 1:12:10Worth, we'll save that debate for another day, Fort Worth and
- 1:12:12Dallas. But like the fact that people
- 1:12:14could fly in it was a great place.
- 1:12:15So hats off for doing that and ideally we, you know we'll we'll
- 1:12:19definitely be participating next year.
- 1:12:21Yeah, next year. And that if anybody's looking to
- 1:12:23come to Texas for something like that, it was a great networking
- 1:12:25event. Much appreciated.
- 1:12:29For Texans hour and 10 minute podcast, I think we did a good
- 1:12:33job guys. Lee, thank you so much for
- 1:12:37joining us. Can't wait to have you on again.
- 1:12:40There's definitely. A.
- 1:12:42Lot happening in the market in the next few years.
- 1:12:44I'm sure we'll have many things to catch up on at some point,
- 1:12:47Absolutely we'll. Have to do it in person.
- 1:12:49It's a little bit of a it's kind of messed up.
- 1:12:51We're all in Texas and I know Lee has a nice podcast studio up
- 1:12:55in in the Fort Worth Dallas area.
- 1:12:57So next time we're all up there, we'll we'll get together live.
- 1:13:01Maybe. We have one here in Austin, too.
- 1:13:03I'm sitting in it. You can use this place.
- 1:13:07All right. That's all we got today.
- 1:13:09We'll see you guys next week.