Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S5 Ep7: GRD058: Our Views on Retirement and How They've Changed
Transcript
- The Great Retirement Debate: How has Retirement Changed Over Time? Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate. I'm Jeff Levine joined as always by my friend and colleague Ed Slott. Ed, good to be back with you once again. Great to be back here on season five. Now here's an interesting item we're talking about, how retirement has been changing over time. We started with IRAs, I mean IRAs came out in nineteen seventy five was actually the first year you could have one. It was actually enacted as part of ERISA in nineteen seventy four, and it was one of the first, if not the first, maybe one of the first bills signed into law by the new President Gerald Ford. And the main thing, it was related to Labor Day after he became President when Nixon resigned. So that's why it was around Labor Day, if you're wondering. But before that, people had, oh I don't know if you know this, they're called pensions, P E N S I O N S. Not aware. Haven't seen one, don't know what it is. And you're not going to believe this, but companies would give ex employees checks for the rest of their life. It's a pretty good deal. Sign me up. Yeah, but what happened is a lot of the companies didn't meet their pension obligations and there were major problems. Anyway, the IRA was born and the story is, from books I've read, I don't know how accurate it is, Ralph Nader back then got involved and said people should have their own individual retirement account that they keep. And somebody said, that's a good name for it. And it turned out there was a guy at the IRS named Ira Cohen I think. And anyway, it became the IRA. And that was the first time people were putting money away for their own retirement. I think that is one of the ways that retirement has largely shifted is that it's become, like you've been become more responsible for more decisions That's right. In retirement. You know, when when it was a pension, you didn't have to think about what to invest in. It was sort of taken care of by the company, and whether the investments did well or not, you were entitled to your check as long as that plan remained solvent. And there wasn't much in the way of tax planning because you got your Social Security check, you got your pension check, and you paid the tax. Like, that was it. There wasn't a decision about, when do I take this money? Like, you just went to the mailbox, grabbed the check, went to the bank, and deposited it. Today, you've got to figure out what to invest in. You've got to figure out how much to put in. You've got to figure out when to take it out. You've to figure out how much to take it out. It does add a lot more burden to today's retiree than was the case thirty or forty years ago. Yeah. And retirement got more complicated. It's almost like we're going full circle and people wanna get back to pensions. I would love to get back to a pension, that would be very nice. People want to get back. There's legislation where you can do it from your four zero one ks, annuities, more interest in that. So we had the IRA over time and it built up and then came the four zero one because somebody went back to the companies in the late 70s, early 80s, and said look at this unfunded pension obligation, look at your balance sheet. How would you like to shift the risk and responsibility, mister corporation, from you to your employees? Where do I sign up for that? Yeah. Sounds like a good idea for the corporation. Right? That well, look. You could look at the chart. That's why since the nineteen eighties, you've basically seen pensions just decrease, decrease, decrease, and defined contribution plans. Last year was the year of greatest participation in the history of the country, not surprisingly so. Right, so now you had the 401s and the IRAs, and they were starting to fill up. But then it got complicated. It wasn't until years later, believe it or not, they created these accounts but they never really considered how to get the money out because people had just started then. And then in 'eighty six they wrote the first round of major regulations and they changed. But most of the money now as you say is sitting in the 401s and the IRAs. And they've gone through so many tax laws over years, over decades. But the big event, the game changer to me was one of the recent ones, the Secure Act, which changed everything. That's why I say it was a big watershed event, a game changer I said. So how does that change retirement? One of the big benefits of the IRA was something we called the stretch IRA. That long deferral of taxes for beneficiaries if you were named on the beneficiary form, designated beneficiary. You could stretch or defer taking only minimum required distributions over your life expectancy. That could have been twenty, thirty, fifty, seventy years old. Seventy years if you had a ten year old. So along came the SECURE Act effective in twenty twenty. So we already went through like fifty years history, just like that. Effective in twenty twenty, and it did away with that Secure Act and made IRAs, which were probably the number one planning vehicle for eventually after 401ks, that's where the money ended up, The number one planning vehicle for retirement, and the Secure Act change created a ten year rule for most non spouse beneficiaries, children and grandchildren, where at the end of ten years it was a one hundred, it is, that's the rule now, a one hundred percent RMD. Can you even imagine the tax bill on that even if the kids are not kids? The beneficiaries could be in their 50s or 60s. Sure, almost makes it worse because they might have their own income. They'd be in the highest earnings years. So the ten year rule, now it turned IRAs, which had great status up until the Secure Act, into probably the worst vehicle for planning for wealth transfer and estate planning. So that was the big change because now you have to look at other vehicles combined with the large IRA balances, but there's opportunities too. That's why we're talking about this. You have these over weighted, I call them over weighted large value IRAs, a million, two million, three million dollars. I call these first class problems. Yeah, first class problems. Very bourgeois problems to have, yes. But a lot of that is part tax. A lot of that is owed right back, that's why they call it tax deferred to Uncle Sam. So it's overly weighted, and you don't have as much tax risk. Some people don't have any tax risk diversification. Plus, thanks to the ABBA law, the one big beautiful bill act we have now, which extended permanently in quotes, whatever that means, the low tax rates. You have high values and low rates. And what you can do with that is look to bring these balances down because they're not as friendly, the IRAs tax wise and retirement and estate planning wise as they were in the past. Bring these balances now taking advantage of low brackets and low rates and move to things, Roth IRAs, charitable planning, even life insurance has taken the place of IRAs as a better long term planning vehicle. Yeah, it's hard to argue with that. I think I want to take us back though to go, know, instead of a Before nineteen seventy four? Well, want to take us back from fifty foot view of retirement. I wanna go like ten thousand, thirty thousand feet, really high. And then just talk about retirement in general. What does what does it mean to retire? And I think there's a huge evolution that's over the past thirty, forty years, and something we're gonna continue to see where not too long ago, retirement was an event. Right? Was a snapshot. It was a it was a picture. It was a Polaroid picture. A moment in time, if you will. Right? Where you went, you decided, okay, yesterday I worked. Tomorrow, I am not gonna do anything. Right? I'm I'm done, and it's that's that's it. It's gone. You go to your party. You got your gold watch, and they send you on your way. Today, for a lot of people, retirement is a a phased approach. In fact, there are more companies today than ever before that actually have phased retirement programs, official programs. There aren't a lot of them. I read recently about Abbott Laboratories with a official program where you could end up working fewer days. And and look, one of the reasons that they wanna do this is, and the Abbott program specifically says, one of the requirements is that you share your knowledge with the next generation. You think about a lot of people retiring. They are the ones who've worked thirty, forty, fifty years. They have that institutional knowledge that companies don't wanna lose. Well, one of the ways to do that is to instead of sending them on their way, if you will, in a moment in time, a snapshot, to make it an experience, to make retirement a phase of life where we gradually decline. In fact, you know, in my role as chief planning officer of Focus, I lead our advanced planning team, and one of the members of our team is someone who now works three days a week, was a full time advisor. Said, I don't wanna work five days a week anymore. I'd love to work part of the time. Well, we went to four days a week and now we're down to to three days a week. But that's someone who, when we have a difficult issue, we can continue to turn to and say, hey, you've got thirty plus years of experience. Help us with this. And that knowledge is right there. So I I think that is one of the big changes. And there's a lot that goes along with that. For instance, if you continue to work, even part time, that may allow you to delay required minimum distributions beyond your seventy third or seventy fifth birthday using what's called the still working exception. It might allow you, even if you don't make enough that you're saving anymore because maybe you're working a few hours, maybe you make enough so that you don't have to start drawing on your retirement assets. Or maybe you don't have to draw as much. Or maybe it allows you to delay Social Security. Like, there's a lot of benefits to continue working. And I I think it's worth pointing out here, just one more thought, and that is, like, not everyone has this luxury. Right? Not everyone can choose when they wanna retire. And one of the in some cases, one of the sad ironies of this is that in many cases, it's the people who don't need to keep working that are most able to keep working. Meaning, it's a lot of times white collar professionals who have done the best job saving, but who look, I mean, as a CPA, Ed, as a financial like, our jobs are not physically taxing. Right? We can probably do this for a really long time if we were laying bricks. Site. Yeah. It would be a lot harder to continue working, but oftentimes those individuals are the ones who haven't saved up as much, and they would benefit even more from working, but they're just not able to do so. So it's it's one of those sad ironies. But I think, again, this this shift, if you will, from retirement as a Polaroid picture to retirement as a motion picture, if you will, capturing many moments in time over months, even years in some cases, is an important trend that we keep an eye on. And the other trend you talked about, you're more responsible for your own retirement We have Social Security, which in essence is an annuity, but these are things that seem to be coming back now, other annuities, not social security. And people want to go back to getting a pension where it all started from, but they also have a fund of money. Most people have a four zero one ks or four zero three b, And as you said, they have to do all the work, the managing. I don't know how many really get involved. They use a financial advisor for the most part or do it yourself. But there's a lot on the retiree or the pre retiree, the person about to be retired, what they have to do now, as you said with the face, they have to start thinking about this in their 40s, 50s, 60s, and things are moving so fast now, we even see the younger people losing jobs with AI, the people that create it. Oh, thanks for creating it. Good bye. Yeah, people don't stay at companies anymore. You talked about thirty, forty years, my parents, that generation, they stayed at the company forever, thirty, forty, fifty years. Well when you're incentivized to stay here so you get your pension in ten years, you stay and get your pension. When you no longer need to do that, it removes one of those barriers to looking for other employment. But a message on that to younger people who tend to probably for good reasons, they jump to new jobs, they don't work thirty years at a company, they work three years and go to another company and build up stock at different companies. And they're kind of diversified that way with the company stock they have. But they should also be planning, they probably don't think about it that much, but there's a lot of what we see in the business called leakage when they leave companies and they don't know what to do with their four zero one ks, so it's only fifteen thousand. That's right, they just cash it out. Way too many people doing that. Yeah, that's a big problem because they cash out because they don't think it's enough, they pay the tax, they pay a penalty, and every job they have to start all over. So that's something that people should be aware of. If you're watching this, you may have children or grandchildren and a job in their 20s, 30s, and they're building up these jobs, but the ones that I see, and I know a few of them, where they roll into another company and to another company, and all of a sudden they're in their third or fourth job, they're still in their 30s or 40s, but now they have huge stock positions in some big companies. Not everybody, but it's something you have to think about earlier. Absolutely. And earlier, not only because you have these complicated decisions, but earlier because retirement for a lot of people is longer than it used to be. I mean, life expectancies have continued to expand. I think it was I was listening to Oh, man. Is the story about Social Security true? The auto Bismarck thing? Alright, help me out. I don't know this one. Well the story was why did they make it, the Social Security age sixty five when it started. Because somebody did a study back then down in the 40s. Yeah. Guy's name was Otto Bismarck. Yeah, I understand. And he said, make Social Security begin at sixty five because they'll all be dead by Yeah, half of people won't get Yeah, yeah. Well, mean, there's something to that, right? And that's one of the reasons that Social Security is not in as good of a fiscal shape as it was before. But to me when I look at the length of of retirement, it was in the course of human history, we went from like average life expectancy increasing over thousands of years. We increased life expectancy say like a decade. Right? From twenty to thirty or twenty five to thirty five, whatever it may be. And then over the course of the next hundred years or so, like with tens of thousands of years, humans basically didn't live much longer. Then over the course of, like, the blink of an eye, over a hundred and twenty years or so, science came in. And now, all of a sudden, we live until we're, you know, seventy five, eighty, eighty five, and, you know, some countries continue to push life expectancy out even further than that. And that also is another challenge for retirees, not only because they have more years, but medicine is able to keep us alive sometimes in not the best of health Right, it's a combination, yeah. And that's even more of an expense because now we're talking about being alive at a time when we need greater care, which can be more expensive, which means we've not only got a reserve for more years, but in some cases more expensive years. Yeah, I think of three risks when you say that. People living longer, which is a risk because they need more money to live longer. The technology keeping you alive more, that's part of that one. But also inflation, things cost more. And you may not have that same level of income coming in. And the other thing we've discussed on a few shows is the solvency of Social Security. So if you're balancing all of that, and you said on an earlier episode, I think when we were talking about the four percent rule, some of these models that financial advisors use have to assume that both spouses or at least one will live to ninety five. Yeah, in many cases. The four percent rule was based on a thirty year life expectancy. So if you think, well, I'm gonna retire at, you know, sixty five, that only gets you to ninety five. If you live to a hundred, that's five more years. So that four percent rule wouldn't work in that scenario. And of course, as I I I'm prone to say or often, the four percent rule is a very bad name. It's not a rule. It's a guideline, a starting post. Right. You know, something to think about. But the idea here simply being the longer you live, the lower your starting distribution needs to be from your retirement account if you want a high degree of confidence of not running out of money during your lifetime. And that is the big change. Retirement, as you said, became a phase, but it became a big phase. Some people are retired longer than their working years. That never happened before. So that needs to be planned for. I talked about earlier when I said bringing these large IRA balances down while rates are low, taking advantage of low brackets while they're here, Roth conversions can help. Any time you can have an account growing income tax free, there's obviously no tax, so Roth conversion money will last longer because it's never eroded by future or current taxes. Or even life insurance. I'm talking about permanent life insurance may be a way to take some of that IRA money down and build up in a permanent cash value policy with long term care riders, and build up cash value that you could tap if you needed tax free. Yep, yep. And we continue this line of thinking of people living longer, but this trend only happening really more in recent history. We're now at a point where we have more data, more information. For a long time, we didn't have people living in large masses until late eighties, nineties, etcetera. We're now many of today's retirees have experienced this with their parents. And that was often the first time. If we think about you know, those today who are in their seventies or eighties, their parents probably didn't live into their late eighties or nineties. That wasn't as common back then. Today, many of, you know, today's retirees or those just approaching retirement or maybe those who are in already for ten or fifteen years, they've been through things with their parents. They have seen their parents have health events in retirement. They have seen, you know, in some cases parents not put aside enough money and outlive their savings. And so there's more awareness today. And even with the the health of seniors, we know a lot more about the importance of social interaction than we did in years past. The importance of staying active in retirement. You know, these were things where, again, we talk about the difference in today's retirement versus years past. You know, in the past, it was like, you're retired. You're done. Like, you can sure. Go fill your time with whatever it is. But today, there's a there's a renewed importance to retire to something and not from something. Right. To be able to to think of it as the next stage of your life, but to continue learning and growing and doing things. And many retirees are now taking up hobbies that they wish they would have had time for when they were in their 30s, 40s and 50s, but they were just busy with work and a family at that time. And now they have pickleball. Now they have pickleball. Everybody has pickleball, yes. Right, right. You see it everywhere. Every tennis court in town is a pickleball court now. But you brought up something that's even more interesting, that planning for your own retirement, but as you're sixty or seventy, you may be taking care of an aging parent. And that is almost like preparing for double retirements. It can, it's very difficult for those individuals. In some sense, it can be very challenging while you're going through it. In another sense, it can be like a trial run to see what you want for your own retirement and what you don't want for your own retirement. You can learn a lot from that. Indeed. But it has changed from where we started where people literally had no retirement accounts other than the pensions. Now they're coming back to the pensions, but they have bigger balances and they can prepare better to what's going to come in the future. Yeah. And part of preparing is arming yourself with knowledge. And look, we said right from the start that one of the biggest differences between retirement in the past and retirement today is today, you are responsible for a lot more of the decisions you make. And so if you're gonna make those decisions, you wanna do it with education and knowledge behind you. And that's what we're here to provide. Education and knowledge on both sides of an issue so that you can make better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes. And Ed, that's our mission here at the Great Retirement Debate, to help more of you reach better outcomes in your retirement. So thanks so much for joining us on this episode of the Great Retirement Debate. We'll see you all real soon. Jeffrey Levine is chief planning officer at Focus Partners. This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice. Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information, which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice. Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. The topic discussed and corresponding arguments are those of the speakers and may not accurately reflect those of focused partners.