Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says I Cant Change
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to talk about a specific phrase today. It's not 'I don't want to change' or 'I don't agree with this.' It's 'I can't change.' And it's a phrase I hear more often from experienced employees, not new hires. Luna: Right — the employee who's been around five, ten years, and when you introduce a new process or a new tool, they just sort of shut down and say they can't do it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's different from simple resistance. Resistance you can usually negotiate or address with data. But 'I can't change' comes from a deeper place — it often signals learned helplessness. The person has convinced themselves that change isn't possible for them. Luna: Interesting. So it's not just stubbornness, it's a kind of belief about their own capabilities. Lucas: Right. And if that sounds familiar to you as a manager, you know how frustrating it can be. You present a new reporting workflow, and the senior analyst says, 'I can't learn that system, I've always done it this way.' Or you restructure a team and someone says, 'I can't work under a different lead, I've never been able to adapt.' Luna: So what do you do when you hear that? Do you push harder, or back off? Lucas: First, you have to understand the root. Let me give you a real example. I worked with a fintech company — about 300 employees — and they were migrating from a legacy CRM to Salesforce. One of their top sales analysts, a guy named Mark, had been there eight years. He knew the old system inside out. But when the migration started, he told his manager, 'I can't use Salesforce. I've tried before at my last job, and I just can't get it.' Luna: And his manager believed him? Or did she push back? Lucas: She initially believed him — she thought maybe he genuinely had a learning block. But when she observed him, she noticed something: Mark wasn't even trying. He'd open Salesforce, stare at the screen for thirty seconds, then switch back to the old system. He had already decided he couldn't do it. Luna: So he was self-confirming his own belief — a self-fulfilling prophecy. Lucas: Exactly. And this is where the manager has to shift from being a problem-solver to being a coach. Because if you take 'I can't' at face value, you either lower your expectations or you do the work for them. Neither helps. Luna: Before we go deeper, I want to acknowledge something. If this episode is resonating with you because you're dealing with a team member who says 'I can't change,' or maybe you've been that person yourself — we want this to be genuinely useful. And the way we keep these episodes free and ad-free is through listener support. If you find value in what we're doing here, you can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep doing deep dives like this one. Lucas: Yeah, and it really does make a difference. A lot of listeners have chipped in, and it allows us to spend time on these specific scenarios instead of chasing sponsors. So thank you if you've already done that. Now, back to Mark. The manager's first instinct was to say, 'Let me sit with you and show you how easy it is.' But that would have reinforced his belief that he couldn't do it alone. Luna: Instead, what did she do? Lucas: She asked a different question. She said, 'Mark, what would need to be true for you to be able to use Salesforce?' That question shifts the focus from 'I can't' to 'What conditions are missing?' And Mark thought about it and said, 'I'd need to feel like I'm not going to break anything. At my old job, I made a mistake in the CRM and lost a bunch of data, and I got blamed for it.' Luna: So there was a past trauma — a real experience that taught him that change is dangerous. Lucas: Exactly. That's the root. It wasn't about ability. It was about psychological safety. He needed assurance that mistakes during the learning process would be okay. Once the manager created a sandbox environment and told him, 'You can't break anything here, this is a test environment,' Mark started to open up. Within two weeks, he was using Salesforce for basic tasks. Luna: So the key is to uncover the story behind the 'I can't.' It's rarely about pure incapability. Lucas: Right. And there are a few common roots. One is past failure or embarrassment. Another is a fixed mindset — the person believes their abilities are static. A third is simply overwhelm — the change feels too big, so they default to 'I can't' instead of 'I don't know how yet.' Luna: How do you distinguish between them as a manager? Lucas: You ask questions. For past failure, you ask, 'Has something like this not worked for you before?' For fixed mindset, you ask, 'Do you think this is something you could learn, or do you think it's impossible?' For overwhelm, you ask, 'What part of this feels biggest to you?' The answer tells you where to focus. Luna: And then you tailor your response. For past failure, you create a safe space to try again. For fixed mindset, you share examples of people who learned similar skills later in their careers. Lucas: Exactly. And for overwhelm, you break it down into tiny steps. The small-wins approach is incredibly powerful for 'I can't' employees. You don't ask them to learn the whole new system. You ask them to do one thing — like enter a single contact record. And then you celebrate that success. Luna: That builds momentum. I've seen that work with a colleague who insisted she couldn't use a new project management tool. We started with just adding one task per day. After a week, she was adding her whole to-do list. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a specific coaching script I recommend. When someone says 'I can't change,' you say, 'I hear you. Let's assume that's true for a moment. What would it take to make that statement false?' That forces them to think about the conditions, not the limitation. Luna: So you're not arguing with them. You're inviting them to co-create a path forward. Lucas: Yes. And sometimes, after that conversation, you realize it's not about mindset at all. The person genuinely cannot change in the way you're asking — maybe the new tool requires a skill they don't have and can't reasonably develop in the timeframe. That's a role mismatch, and you need to address it honestly. Luna: When do you decide it's a role mismatch versus a mindset issue? Lucas: After you've tried coaching for a reasonable period — say, four to six weeks. If you've created safety, broken down steps, and the person still refuses to engage, it may be that the role is no longer a fit. But I'd say in my experience, 80 percent of 'I can't' cases respond to proper coaching. Luna: That's a good rule of thumb. So managers shouldn't jump to performance improvement plans too quickly. Lucas: Exactly. A PIP should come after you've exhausted coaching. And the coaching itself needs to be specific. Not 'try harder,' but 'let's practice this one specific action together.' Luna: What about the manager who hears 'I can't' and gets frustrated? I've been there — it's easy to take it personally. Lucas: It is. But you have to depersonalize it. The employee isn't saying they can't change to spite you. They're saying it because they're scared or stuck. Your job is to be the person who helps them see a different possibility. If you react with frustration, you confirm their belief that change is dangerous. Luna: So the manager's own emotional regulation is part of the solution. Lucas: Absolutely. And one more thing: sometimes the employee who says 'I can't change' is actually right in a narrow sense. They can't change overnight. They can't change without support. But they can change incrementally. Your job is to make the incremental path visible and safe. Luna: I like that reframing. Instead of 'you can change,' it's 'here's how we'll change together.' Lucas: Exactly. And when you do that, you often unlock a lot of potential. The same employee who said 'I can't' may become your biggest advocate for the new system once they feel competent. Mark ended up training other team members on Salesforce after six months. Luna: That's a great outcome. So to recap for our listeners: when you hear 'I can't change,' don't take it at face value. Ask about past experiences, break the change into tiny steps, create psychological safety, and coach with curiosity not frustration. And if after genuine effort it doesn't work, then consider a role change. Lucas: Perfect summary. And remember, your goal as a manager isn't to force change — it's to help your people discover that they are capable of more than they believe. That's the real work. Luna: Thanks for tuning in to this episode of Manager Mondays. We'll be back next week with another specific scenario to help you lead better.