Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Shenk’s vs. Bomberger’s - 2025 Michter’s Legacy Series Whiskey Showdown!
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, two whiskey distilleries are giving back to flood victims
- 0:05in Kentucky and Texas. Plus, we do a doubleheader review of the two Michter's Legacy Series releases
- 0:12from 2025, Shenk's Homestead and Bomberger's Declaration. Stay tuned.
- 0:29Hello everyone and welcome back to the Bourbon Bytes Podcast. I'm your host Clifton and this
- 0:34is the week of Thursday, August 14th, 2025. Thank you for tuning in to this week's episode.
- 0:40If you're new here, hi, welcome. Good to have you. Make sure to follow if you enjoy the show.
- 0:45Today's going to be a little bit different. I'm going to only feature a couple news stories
- 0:48because I have not just one, but two bourbons to review this week. So if you saw the title of this
- 0:56podcast and the image, you already know what we're going to be reviewing. We're going to be reviewing
- 1:00the brand new 2025 releases of Shenk's and Bomberger's from the Michter's distillery. Now,
- 1:07I previously gave an update about these releases on a podcast episode a few weeks back. It was the
- 1:13episode on July 3rd. So if you missed that, make sure to go back and tune into that to hear all
- 1:18about these releases. I'll give a little bit of a recap before we get into our review, but today's
- 1:22all going to be about tasting and comparing these two releases and seeing if they are worth the
- 1:27price, because they have gone up significantly since I last bought a pair of them. So stay tuned
- 1:33for that. But first, we have a couple news stories, both of which are actually kind of related. It's
- 1:38kind of similar how these whiskeys are related, but I did want to mention them because they are
- 1:41both for a good cause. So the first of which is coming to us from J. Mattingly 1845 Distillery.
- 1:49They are releasing a bourbon to aid local flood sufferers. So if you remember back in April of this
- 1:56year, there was a flash flood in central Kentucky, particularly affecting the Frankfort, Kentucky
- 2:01area. The Kentucky River rose to near record levels and impacted not just distilleries, but
- 2:07people, their livelihoods, you know, their homes. And this distillery is actually going to give back
- 2:14to the community. Now, fortunately, the J. Mattingly Distillery was spared from any damage due to the
- 2:19floods, but they wanted to find a way to give back to their local community. So they decided to
- 2:23a limited edition bourbon called Frankfort Rising and $30 of the sale from each bottle went back
- 2:31towards the Franklin County Community Fund to assist families affected by the April floods.
- 2:37Now, the double stave process isn't unique to this release. They've actually done it on a few
- 2:40other releases, but this one is a charred oak stave that is added after the fact to each barrel
- 2:47at just the right moment in aging to coax out extra flavor. Now, this is according to their
- 2:52press release. They say that tasting notes describe this bourbon as having a graham cracker
- 2:56note on the palate joined by toasted oak and a gentle spice from the rye with a medium to long
- 3:01finish and lingering baking spice to vanilla and nutty warmth, leaving a satisfying impression.
- 3:07All those flavor notes sound exactly like the perfect bourbon to me. Now, I've not actually
- 3:12had much from J. Mattingly. I think I may have had a sample or two, so I'm not super familiar with
- 3:17their flavor profile, but I do love a bourbon with a good cause. So this was actually coming
- 3:22out today, August 14th. This is going to be released at the distillery. It's going to be
- 3:27112 proof when it comes out. I'm not saying anything about the specific number of bottles
- 3:32here. I do know that this is a limited edition release. Their goal is to raise $10,000 from this
- 3:40bourbon. So doing some quick math because you guys know I am not the best at figuring these
- 3:47things out. It looks like it's about 333 bottles of this will be available if I'm doing the $30
- 3:53per bottle to raise at least $10,000. So there's at least 333 bottles of this based on my calculations.
- 4:00Now, looking into the Franklin County Community Fund, I like to do a little bit of research before
- 4:05I recommend giving to an organization. I actually see that this one is really involved in their
- 4:11community. And here's some facts about it. They are a permanently endowed fund at Bluegrass
- 4:16Community Foundation that provides support for civic projects and community needs for years to
- 4:21come. These contributions will go to support the organizations responding to the urgent needs in
- 4:26the community affected by these floods. They just recently awarded $50,000 to the Resource Office
- 4:32for Social Ministries to provide immediate assistance to residents impacted by the flooding.
- 4:37They also set up a multi-agency resource center for those that are affected as well. I don't know
- 4:43if I mentioned this earlier, but the bottles are $120 at retail. $30 of that is going straight to
- 4:48the community, which is incredible. So I commend them. Well done. If you guys get a chance to try
- 4:53this, let me know how it is. I mean, I think it's more of the cause than, you know, the actual whiskey
- 4:57itself, but it sounds pretty good. I'm excited to hear how it is. Now in a very similar news story,
- 5:03so this is a callback to a story I did a few weeks back. I mean, almost over a month ago now.
- 5:08It was the Garrison Brothers Guadalupe release, which was, you know, unfortunately timed around
- 5:14the timing of the flooding of the Guadalupe River. But they actually, you know, took that moment and
- 5:20made it into a positive thing by starting the Garrison Brothers Distillery's Guadalupe Relief
- 5:26Day. They raised $100,000 for Texas flood relief through bourbon sales and community support.
- 5:33So another example of a bourbon distillery making a huge impact. They pledged $50 from every bottle
- 5:40of cast rent Guadalupe single barrel that was sold alongside with profits from the whiskey
- 5:46shack and gift shop merchandise to the cause. So it was actually on July 12th was the day that they
- 5:51called the relief day where all this kind of came in. They raised an initial $50,000, which was
- 5:57matched dollar for dollar by Happy State Bank in Fredericksburg. So it brought their total
- 6:02contribution to $100,000. And those funds were delivered to the Community Foundation of the
- 6:08Texas Hill Country's Kerr County Flood Relief Fund. That is a big long name, but it's definitely
- 6:16dedicated strictly for the relief of that flooding. Similar to how, you know, Kentucky
- 6:21was affected by the flooding in April, Texas was just devastated by those floods. So Garrison
- 6:26Brothers did team up and set up an online donation page back on July 7th, and it got its first $10,000
- 6:32in donation matched by private donors. So you can actually still donate to this cause if it's
- 6:37something that you want to give back to that community. It's going to be active until October
- 6:421st, the donation link on their website. So definitely go check that out. And just looking
- 6:46at the page, I'm seeing a lot of donations from not only individuals, but small businesses in the
- 6:50area. So always love seeing communities support each other and build each other up, especially
- 6:55after, you know, devastation hits the area. So I just want to say huge shout out to those folks
- 7:00for offering an opportunity to give back to the communities that make them who they are and
- 7:06offering a significant portion of your proceeds to a good cause. I think that's really important,
- 7:11you know, not that like 1% match thing that a lot of things do, you know, not to say that's anything,
- 7:15you know, not worth mentioning. I appreciate it more than nothing, but seeing that much per bottle
- 7:20be given back is really special. So cheers to those two. All right. Well, like I said, this week
- 7:25is not going to be very news focused because we have two reviews to get to on this week's portion
- 7:30of Byte Sized Reviews. All right. Well, first up of the 2025 Legacy Series from Michter's Distillery.
- 7:46Like I said, I covered the announcement of these releases on a podcast a few weeks ago,
- 7:50but now I'm excited that I had a chance to buy them. They popped up on K&L Wine and Spirits website.
- 7:57I did pay full retail price for these, maybe a little bit more. I think combined it was around
- 8:02$300. So the suggested retail on the Shenk's is $110 and the suggested retail on the Bomberger's
- 8:09is $120. So I paid, you know, maybe 20% more, but I was willing to do it because I knew that
- 8:16I wanted to get my hands on these releases. So yeah, we're going to start with the Shenk's,
- 8:20which is the lower cost of the releases. Now, we don't know too much about this. Like I said,
- 8:24I'm going to, you know, recap the press release just very, very quickly. Now for the 2025 Shenk's
- 8:30release, what makes it special is because some of the whiskey was finished in French oak toasted,
- 8:35but not charred barrels. And these are crafted from wood grown in the Vosges forest. Yes,
- 8:41I love the pronunciation of that because it's not spelled like that at all. It's spelled V-O-S-G-E-S.
- 8:46But the goal of it was to help accentuate the character of the rye in the whiskey. Now,
- 8:51another thing that makes this interesting, especially from the Michter's lineup is this
- 8:54is a Kentucky sour mash whiskey, which as a reminder means they use a portion of the spent
- 8:59mash from the previous batch that was going and they use it to start the fermentation on the next.
- 9:05Now with the Shenk's, we do not get an age statement here on the bottle. We just see that it's small
- 9:11batch. It is, you know, 91.2 proof. So 45.6% ABV. Very little information on the bottle as well.
- 9:19It's more of like one of those, you know, if you know, you know, it's a special release. I think
- 9:22the first time I had a Shenk's and Bomberger's was probably back in 2018, 2019. I'd have to go look
- 9:28on my channel, but it's been more than five years since I've last had one of these. So I had to,
- 9:33you know, see what it's all about and see if it's worth that $110. Let's go to give the Shenk's
- 9:37Homestead a nose. Oh, yes. Okay. Yeah, I like that a lot. I mean, I've always said that I've
- 9:45loved the whiskey coming out of Michter's. I think they have a very solid flavor profile that
- 9:49kind of is consistent across their entire lineup. Guess they are a little pricier than some other
- 9:53releases, even like the standard Michter's bourbon or American whiskey, but they're one that I
- 9:57happily recommend to folks, especially if you're trying to get into, you know, more higher end
- 10:02whiskey. I think Michter's is always a place to go. Now, do I say jump straight to Shanks Homestead?
- 10:06We'll find out. We'll see if this is worth, you know, a splurge buy if you are new to it.
- 10:11But yeah, on the nose, the Shenk's is sweet. It's caramel. It's got a little bit of like a roasted
- 10:18nuttiness, I think, on the nose. And for only being 91.2 proof, I mean, that's a lot of character
- 10:23coming off of just the nose alone. The more I know, the more it goes in kind of the direction
- 10:26of graham cracker. But it has a bit of like a, you know, this is a weird example, but kind of
- 10:31an egg tart dessert. It kind of has that like, I don't know how you would describe it. It's not
- 10:36like a sour note, but it's something that kind of has that like egginess on the nose, if that makes
- 10:40sense. It's kind of like blending savory and sweet together. And that's a that's the thing that I
- 10:45really like about a lot of bourbon. So I'm hopeful that the palette is going to be just as interesting
- 10:50as this nose is. So let's go and try this 2025 Legacy Series from Michter's Shenk's Homestead
- 10:56Sour Mash Whiskey. Cheers. Hmm. Interesting. It definitely doesn't go, you know, it's funny,
- 11:06I said on the nose, it doesn't have char, which, like I said, it's not a charred barrel. That's
- 11:11what makes it unique and what makes it an American whiskey. But I see the same thing here. It's got
- 11:16kind of like a roasty characteristic to it. Not smoky at all. Not necessarily like any of those,
- 11:21like, you know, strong wood notes that I would get on, like, let's say a bourbon. But this one
- 11:25just has a little bit of like a like you kind of are roasting some, like I said, almonds or
- 11:30peanuts or something in that territory. It does coat the palate, but it's with an interesting
- 11:35sweetness and like a little bit of like a coffee note. You can't really tell much age on this
- 11:39whiskey because you're not getting that element. I usually can tell, you know, how old a bourbon is
- 11:42based on how much of that older oak note I'm getting. But this one, it almost feels like
- 11:47I don't want to say devoid of it because that's the kind of is doing a disservice. But there's not a
- 11:52oaky backbone that I typically see in a bourbon. That's really unique. I think it is a really good
- 11:58whiskey. You know, for my palate, I do look for more of those oaky, bold notes. You know,
- 12:04it's not even a diss on the proof. I just think, you know, this is definitely a lighter, more
- 12:08delicate whiskey that I'm typically used to drinking, especially at that price point.
- 12:12I don't want to sound like, you know, a snob, but when I'm paying over $100 for a bourbon,
- 12:16I would like at least one, an age statement or two, a cask strength release. I just think
- 12:21$110 is a bit high for this release or it's higher than I would be willing to pay for it.
- 12:25But I did, and I'll enjoy it. I just don't think I enjoy it that much more than the
- 12:29Michter's Toasted Sour Mash whiskey they did. What was that? Was that a couple of years ago?
- 12:35It was like their special release. It was like the Toasted Barrel release. Retail on it was only like
- 12:38$60. I think that the second batch of it was a bit higher, but this is definitely in that realm.
- 12:43It's not, it doesn't feel like a special edition release in the way that I expect Shenk's to be.
- 12:47But we'll see. Maybe it's just the Shenk's. Maybe the Bomberger's Declaration release this year
- 12:52will be the one that blows me away. So we're going to go ahead and move on to that portion
- 12:56of this doubleheader byte-sized review. Now the Bomberger's Declaration from 2025 comes in at 108
- 13:04proof. This one is also a small batch, but it is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. So once again,
- 13:10they use the chinkapin barrels that they have done in previous releases, and they claim that
- 13:15wood science and maturation are key to the character of Bomberger's Declaration.
- 13:20Michter's Master of Maturation, Andrea Wilson, said that she's happy with the result.
- 13:24We used a spectrum of different barrels constructed from wood, naturally seasoned outdoors,
- 13:29in varying cases for 18 months to three years to four years to five years, thus changing the
- 13:35chemistry of the oak's contributions during aging. The result is a bold and multi-dimensional
- 13:40experience to savor and enjoy. Now like the Shenk's, we do not get an age statement on the whiskey
- 13:46itself. We're talking about just the seasoning of the casks being up to five years old. So we don't
- 13:51know. It is a straight bourbon whiskey, so we at least know the minimum age is at least four years
- 13:56old. But as with the Shenk's, I'd really like to know how old this whiskey is, especially when
- 14:00I'm paying top dollar for it. Let's go ahead and get the Bomberger's Declaration poured.
- 14:05Oh on the nose already I can tell that this is much more of what I'm familiar with. I was going
- 14:11to say it's much older, but that's just because I'm getting that oak influence that I didn't get
- 14:15on the Shenk's. So I can't necessarily judge that because that is an American whiskey versus a
- 14:19bourbon. But I will say for me and my palate, I am drawn toward the nose of the Bomberger's
- 14:24myself. It is dark, it's rich, it's got a bit of cinnamon and some baking spices. It's kind of
- 14:29reminded me very much of like a fall whiskey. There's almost a bit of an earthiness that kind
- 14:32reminds me of like a, I don't want to say a tree, like that's kind of weird, but it kind of does
- 14:38remind me of like the smell of autumn, you know, like the leaves falling on the ground. Yeah,
- 14:42very different direction than the Shinx and it's definitely more what I'm looking for. So by the
- 14:47way, I think I mentioned this, but if I forgot, this is 108 proof versus the 91.2 proof of the
- 14:52Shenk's. So we're jumping up quite a bit. I'll stop nosing it. Let's go ahead and give a taste to the
- 14:572025 Bomberger's Declaration. Cheers. Ooh. Okay. Yes. That is a really good bourbon. Oh wow. It
- 15:08has almost a bit of bitterness on the back end, but like bitter in a good way, like a bitter dark
- 15:13chocolate. Yeah. I have a good feeling that that bitter and those darker flavors are coming from
- 15:17that seasoning of the wood. You know, I think drier wood tends to lead to a bit more of the
- 15:23bitter, you know, darker notes. Younger wood, I think is more of the kind of sour notes. Sometimes
- 15:29I get on a whiskey. I always say it has like a young wood note. That's usually what I'm referring
- 15:32to. It has a bit of like a tartness to it. This doesn't have that at all. It's very, very dry,
- 15:36very rich. And even though I said, you know, this doesn't have an age statement based on palette
- 15:40alone, I would guess there's a lot of older whiskey that went into this. Would I like them
- 15:44to have revealed that? Absolutely. Do they need to sell it? No, it's going to sell out no matter
- 15:48what. It's done it every year since I got it last time. It rarely sits on the shelves unless
- 15:53it's overpriced. Man, that is really good. That's right up my alley. It's that darker oak. It kind
- 15:58of reminds me of what I like about some Russell's Reserve picks. They kind of have some of the
- 16:03similar baking spices notes in there as well, combined with that older age. I think those are
- 16:08nine years old, if I remember correctly. So it's definitely in that realm of flavor profile. If I
- 16:12had to guess, you know, age, like I said, I would say like eight or nine, but man, that is a
- 16:17fantastic bourbon. This will definitely make it into a contender for my top 10 whiskeys of the
- 16:23year. So if you see these two on the shelves and you can't decide between the two and like, let's
- 16:28say you can only get one, even if the Shenk's is a little bit cheaper, the Bomberger's to me is a
- 16:32significantly better buy for your buck. If you do like a bolder, darker, richer oakier whiskey
- 16:39experience. But if you prefer the sweeter, the lighter, you don't want that much oak influence,
- 16:43but you want that burst of flavor and especially at a lower proof Shenk's Homestead is a great buy
- 16:49as well. I just think for me personally, I would probably skip that moving forward. And I would
- 16:53just get the Bomberger's because the Bomberger's hits every note that I want a good bourbon to be
- 16:58other than, you know, not being that available and not having an age statement. Those are my
- 17:02two things that would knock it down from if I were to give it a score that would knock it down a bit.
- 17:06But yeah, both good releases for what they are. I'm curious to hear what you guys think. Have you
- 17:12had this year's release from 2025 or have you had other releases of Bomberger's and Shenk's?
- 17:17Let me know. Leave a comment on the either the YouTube video of this podcast or leave a comment
- 17:21on our Discord server, which by the way, you guys can find at BourbonBytes.com. Everyone's welcome.
- 17:26But if you are a Byte Club member, which is our membership program, you get access to some
- 17:30exclusive rooms like our VIP lounge, our monthly movie night, our private tasting lounge for those
- 17:36at the higher tiers and much, much more. But we'd love to have you over on BourbonBytes.com. You can
- 17:41find the merch. You can find the discord, all that fun stuff there. But all right. I think that
- 17:45does it for this week's episode. I know it's a little bit different than my normal format, but I
- 17:49did want to make sure I squeezed in both of those reviews since I previously mentioned both of these
- 17:53on the podcast. Now that I have a chance to try them, I wanted to follow up with the review here
- 17:57on the podcast. So thank you for listening. Make sure to follow me again on your favorite platform.
- 18:02I post a new episode every Thursday. And until next time, this has been Bourbon Bytes, whiskey
- 18:08reviews with a gaming twist. Cheers. I'll talk to you guys next episode.