Latest / Comeback Files: Human strength, healing & change / Trusting Your Gut When Experts Disagree: A Letter To You | Comeback Files
Transcript
- You are standing in the middle of a room full of people shouting different truths, and for the first time, you realize your own voice is the only one that matters. It’s terrifying, isn’t it? To feel like everyone else has the map, but you’re the one who has to walk the path. I want you to take a deep breath with me right now. In through the nose, out through the mouth. Feel your shoulders drop away from your ears. We have so much noise in our lives, don’t we? Not just the literal kind—the traffic, the notifications, the chatter—but the mental clutter of other people’s certainty. We live in an age where expertise is everywhere. There is a podcast for every problem, a study for every habit, a guru for every spiritual crisis. And when we are hurting, or confused, or trying to make a big life decision, we look outward. We look for the person who knows the answer. We want them to tell us what to do so we don’t have to carry the weight of choosing. But here is the thing I’ve learned after years of sitting with women who are trying to find their way back to themselves: no expert knows your body, your history, or your soul better than you do. Even if they know more about the theory than you. Especially then. Because theory is clean. Theory doesn’t bleed. Theory doesn’t have to wake up at three in the morning with a heart racing because something feels off. Your instinct is not just a feeling; it is data. It is the sum total of every experience you have ever had, every boundary you have ever crossed, every time you said yes when you meant no, and every time you survived. It is a library inside you that most experts haven’t even opened. Let’s talk about that moment when the advice starts to clash. Maybe you went to a specialist who told you to push through the pain. Another one told you to rest. One friend said to leave your job, another said to stay and fight. The doctors, the therapists, the family members—they all love you. I believe that. They all want the best for you. But they are looking at pieces of you. They see the symptom, or the situation, or the pattern. They don’t see the whole picture. And when their voices contradict each other, the natural human reaction is to panic. We think, 'If they can’t agree, maybe I’m broken. Maybe I’m making it too complicated.' This is where the doubt creeps in. It whispers that you are being difficult, or ungrateful, or irrational. It tells you that trusting yourself is selfish. But listen to me closely: trusting yourself is not arrogance. It is the highest form of respect you can pay to your own life. When you ignore your gut to please an expert, you are not being humble. You are abandoning yourself. And you cannot heal while you are at war with your own intuition. You have to stop treating your instincts like a nuisance and start treating them like a guide. They are not trying to confuse you; they are trying to protect you. So why is it so hard? Why do we hand over the keys to our lives to people we barely trust ourselves? I think it comes down to fear. Fear of being wrong. Fear of the consequences. If I follow my gut and I’m wrong, I might lose money, or relationships, or safety. But if I follow the expert and I’m wrong, well, at least I did what was told. I can blame them. I can say, 'Well, Dr. Smith said this would work.' It spreads the responsibility. It makes the failure shared. But healing? Healing is never shared. It is deeply, intimately yours. No one can walk your path for you. No one can eat your food, sleep in your bed, or hold your hand when you are scared. We silence our voices because we were taught that compliance is good. That asking questions is rude. That women, in particular, are expected to be agreeable, to smooth things over, to make sure everyone else feels comfortable with their version of the truth. But that version of the truth often leaves you feeling small. It leaves you feeling like you are a project to be fixed rather than a person to be heard. When you choose to trust your instinct, you are stepping out of the role of the passive recipient of care and into the role of the active author of your life. It is uncomfortable. It is messy. But it is real. Remember that episode we talked about last week, 'Surviving Holiday Tension'? We spoke about keeping your peace at the dinner table when the energy is thick with unspoken judgments. You realized then that you didn’t need to argue your way to validation; you needed to anchor yourself in your own reality. This is the same muscle. It is the same practice. When experts disagree, you are essentially having a dinner table conversation with your own life. Someone says one thing, someone says another. But you are the host of that table. You decide what gets served. You decide who sits where. Healing is not a straight line. It is a spiral. You will circle back to these moments of doubt again and again. You will hear conflicting advice next month, and again next year. That is okay. The goal is not to never feel confused. The goal is to build a stronger relationship with yourself so that when the confusion hits, you don’t run away from it. You sit with it. You ask, 'What does my body feel like right now? What does my spirit whisper?' You learn to distinguish between fear—which feels tight, sharp, and frantic—and intuition—which feels steady, calm, and certain, even if it is quiet. Trust takes practice. It is a muscle that grows stronger every time you choose yourself over the crowd. So how do you actually do this? How do you tune out the noise when it is loud? Start by creating space. Silence is not empty; it is full of answers. Turn off the podcasts. Close the articles. Step away from the group chat where everyone is giving opinions. Go for a walk without your phone. Just you and the pavement. Notice what arises when there is no input. Notice what you miss when you are not busy processing other people’s thoughts. Second, check in with your body. Your mind can lie. Your mind can rationalize, justify, and twist facts to fit a narrative. But your body rarely lies. When you think about following the expert’s advice, do you feel expansion or contraction? Do you feel light or heavy? When you think about listening to your own instinct, do you feel a sense of relief, even if it is scary? Or do you feel dread? Pay attention to those physical signals. They are your compass. Also, write it down. Get the chaos out of your head and onto paper. Sometimes seeing the conflicting advice side-by-side helps you see which one resonates with your values, not just your fears. Write down what you truly want, not what you think you should want. There is a freedom in admitting that you don’t have all the answers. In fact, the experts don’t either. They have probabilities, not guarantees. They have patterns, not promises. When you accept that uncertainty is part of the journey, you stop looking for permission. You stop waiting for the all-clear signal that will never come. You give yourself permission to try, to fail, to adjust, and to try again. This is what resilience looks like. It is not stubbornness. It is flexibility. It is the ability to bend in the wind without breaking. I want you to remember that you are allowed to change your mind. You are allowed to say, 'That expert was helpful, but this feels right for me now.' You are allowed to say, 'I tried this approach, and it didn’t work. I am going to try something else.' Life is not a multiple-choice test with one correct answer. It is an open-ended essay. You get to write the story. And yes, it will be messy. Yes, there will be typos and crossed-out lines. But it will be yours. And there is a profound dignity in owning your mistakes as much as your successes. It proves that you were living, not just surviving someone else’s script. Take your time. There is no deadline for getting this right. You do not need to figure everything out today. You just need to listen to the next right step. If that step is saying no to the advice, then say no. If that step is asking for more clarity, then ask. If that step is doing nothing at all, then do nothing. Rest is not a reward you earn after you prove yourself worthy. Rest is your birthright. It is the soil from which clarity grows. So be gentle with yourself. Be patient with the process. You are doing better than you think. You are learning to trust yourself, and that is the most important relationship you will ever nurture. It’s okay to be soft here. It’s okay to be unsure. You are safe. You are held. And you are never alone in this. Thank you for letting me into your day. Thank you for trusting me with your questions. Keep listening to that quiet voice inside you. It knows the way. I’ll be here next time, ready to walk alongside you. Until then, take care of yourself. You are worth the effort. Goodnight, my friend.