Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Dangers of the Lower Realms (and more!)
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the deepening, your practice podcast
- 0:03with George Haas, deepening. Your practice is recorded at the
- 0:07against this dream, Buddhist Meditation Society in Los
- 0:10Angeles. California for more information,
- 0:13visit our website at www.medicare.gov dot-org.
- 0:18That's www.a me. TT a gr, oup dot-org.
- 0:27So, welcome, everybody. This is deepening of practice,
- 0:30deepen. Your practice is intended as an
- 0:32intermediate or advanced class. And what that really means is,
- 0:35I'm not going to be offering any basic meditation, instruction.
- 0:38I expect you all ready to know them.
- 0:41That being said, if you find that I'm talking about something
- 0:43and you don't understand what I'm talking about.
- 0:46I'm happy to answer any questions.
- 0:47I'm just not going to include the basic stuff we are talking
- 0:55about Maja Cece. those Manual of inside, this is a new
- 1:00translation by The Meta vipassana society and we've been
- 1:06talking about overcoming hindrances Mojave is made a
- 1:19distinction between. A Tranquility, first Insight
- 1:32second type of the positive practice and a inside first.
- 1:39Or carnico samadhi, is the Pali word for that Konica.
- 1:46Some somebody might be translated as momentary
- 1:49concentration. In inside practice, we want to
- 2:04be able to, to investigate the nature of The Human Experience
- 2:10Through The Human Condition. To see clearly what it is.
- 2:16In order to do that, you have to have a basic level of
- 2:20concentration. The chapter that we're currently
- 2:25working on in this manual, is called purification of mind.
- 2:31And what the term purification of Mind means is that the mind
- 2:34is free of hindrances. You're probably aware of the
- 2:40list of five hindrances. Craving a version, Restless
- 2:45assist, restlessness and agitation, sloth, and torpor,
- 2:49and doubt. To say that the mind is then,
- 2:54pure is to say that those hindrances are not present in a
- 2:59traditional Tranquility, first way of practicing meditation.
- 3:03First, you established a deep level of concentration, where
- 3:07the mind is continuously free of these hindrances, And Once the
- 3:14mind is pure, you go into the positive practice.
- 3:19This is a kind of practice or an organization of practice that
- 3:23has been largely used in monastic life and we are
- 3:27householders. And so when the sad house in
- 3:33Myanmar talked about a organizing practice for
- 3:37householders householders, that would not eventually become
- 3:41monastics, they talked about it in the terms of momentary
- 3:47concentration, Brad Rather than having to generate a depth of
- 3:51concentration where the mind was pure first.
- 3:56And then moving into the passenger inside, practice they
- 4:02developed and taught a practice of momentary concentration.
- 4:07So what that means is that in the moment that you're noting
- 4:11your awareness, the mind is pure free from hindrances and that in
- 4:17the spaces in between Ween. The Mind may be caught up again
- 4:20in the hindrances and then as you string together, a series of
- 4:24noting experiences the the the What shall we call it weight of
- 4:33the concentration? Then begins to fill in the
- 4:36spaces and eventually reach a level of concentration, that's
- 4:41equivalent to the Tranquility first practice.
- 4:45So this state I thought would be a better way of householders
- 4:48practicing. And if you look at the culture
- 4:51of Buddhist Meditation in this country and certainly in the
- 4:56west, it has been very successful as as a technique.
- 5:01So it's commonly called a noting technique or a Burmese style of
- 5:06pasta of practice. so, to note, Hello.
- 5:21Noting practice. Is too.
- 5:29Know where your attention is and then to soak in and have the
- 5:34experience of the sensing process. so, you know where your
- 5:43attention is and then you soak in and have the experience the
- 5:47sensing experience, and that is I'm smiling because I haven't
- 5:54seen these two people for a while.
- 5:56One from New York, one from Hawaii.
- 6:09So, Working to rid the mind of hindrances or in the blockages
- 6:19to concentration in a carnico samadhi.
- 6:22Practice is a little bit different than in a, a sort of
- 6:28access or Jonna type practice. So obstacles to concentration in
- 6:34the methods to overcome them thoughts of past and future.
- 6:39Returning to the past, the Mind, grows restless, not thinking of
- 6:43the past, the my settles on objects in the present.
- 6:46Then the Mind does not become Restless anticipating the future
- 6:50of the Mind, becomes restless, not thinking of the future, the
- 6:53Mind settles on objects in the present, then the Mind does not
- 6:57become Restless things. That one has previously seen
- 7:03heard smelled taste tasted touched or thought about, are
- 7:07called objects of Past remembering that makes the Mind
- 7:12Restless. This is called a Restless mind.
- 7:15The past May distract one in various ways during inside
- 7:20practice one. May simply remember objects that
- 7:23one once experienced. One may think about whether or
- 7:25not ones practice was going, well one may wonder whether ones
- 7:30contemplation was effective one may wonder whether or not one's
- 7:34previous noting was distinct. One may wonder whether or not
- 7:37one experienced mind or body. ADI and so forth.
- 7:40Have you ever noticed the Mind engaged in thinking while you're
- 7:43attempting to practice? Mindfulness is a term that means
- 7:49awareness of the present moment. So each time you're in the past
- 7:52or the future, you're you've lost mindfulness and so the idea
- 7:56is to keep coming back into the experience of the present
- 7:59moment. What page are you on 78?
- 8:17A mind that anticipates our Longs for objects that have not
- 8:20yet. Come into existence is by nature
- 8:23wandering restless and unsteady this is an obstacle to incite
- 8:27concentration. Therefore one should note every
- 8:30time, the Mind grows restless and then direct the mind to
- 8:33objects in the present then the mind will no longer wander but
- 8:36it will be well focused on objects in present.
- 8:40So this is a simple instruction, you've probably heard it a
- 8:42thousand times. If the mind wanders, bring it
- 8:45back, you've heard that That's what we're talking about here.
- 8:50In order to pay attention to know that the mind has wandered,
- 8:54you have to be mindful. So, allowing this process of the
- 8:59path to the Future. Another way to think about it is
- 9:04to understand that you make a decision to to focus, your
- 9:11attention on the thought of the past or the future and you could
- 9:16easily make the same decision or simply make the same decision to
- 9:20stay on the object of meditation to settle into a concentrated
- 9:24mind. You may not notice that that's
- 9:27what you're doing because you get caught up in the content of
- 9:30thought and you're there for a while and Don't notice the
- 9:33moment that the thought arises in your attention switches from
- 9:36the object of meditation to the thought.
- 9:40So you want to keep maybe even thinking your way back to the
- 9:45moment that you got carried away to thought.
- 9:47So you can begin to pay it attention.
- 9:50Be mindful in that moment that the thought first arises to not
- 9:56choose to think about it, that making sense.
- 10:01Do you have a A sense of that, are you present enough in that
- 10:05moment when the thought arises that you can see it?
- 10:09Arising, if you, if you're there in that moment, as it arises,
- 10:14you're much more likely to have the opportunity to continue to
- 10:17focus on the object of meditation, rather than be drawn
- 10:21into the content of thinking. Laziness and restlessness
- 10:30shrinking or lacks the Mind grows lazy encouraging, the Mind
- 10:34laziness is overcome, then the Mind does not become Restless.
- 10:39When overactive, the Mind becomes fidgety reducing
- 10:42exertion for the genus has overcome than the Mind does not
- 10:47become Restless. Laziness and idleness often
- 10:51occur due to the mind that shrinks and is lacks when
- 10:55practice does not go smoothly when special Insight knowledge
- 10:58cannot be aroused. And when progress cannot be made
- 11:02this laziness or unwillingness to practice has an obstacle to
- 11:07inside concentration. So laziness should be removed by
- 11:10noting it closely. If this does not work, the mind
- 11:14can be encouraged in some other way.
- 11:19So one of the suggestions here, for encouraging the mind in the,
- 11:26in another way is to reflect the dangers of the lower realms. one
- 11:34of the things that's often the experience of Western
- 11:39practitioners is that when we come to, these passages of
- 11:44traditional Buddhist teaching, we tend to skip over them
- 11:48because their descriptions are so Can we use the word poetic to
- 11:56describe? I tend to come from a place of
- 12:02Buddhist atheism so I'm not wedded to a fundamental belief
- 12:08that these descriptions are an accurate representation of
- 12:11something that actually exists, but you may have a different
- 12:16view of it. If you do not practice, If you
- 12:24do not gain Liberation, if you're engaged in unskillful
- 12:28Acts that produce a negative Karma, then the likelihood is
- 12:33that you'll be reincarnated in a lower realm to contemplate.
- 12:38The nature of the lower realm is a way out of the laziness of not
- 12:43practicing. Lazy laziness is a Transit.
- 12:46A word that I think has a pejorative quality in our
- 12:51culture. We relax or any of those kinds
- 12:58of things, idleness all of these.
- 13:01But let me describe to you the nature of the lower realm of
- 13:04hell, just so you have a sense of where you're going, if you
- 13:08don't keep up your practice, A victim and Hell Realms is about
- 13:16a victim. In the hell Realms is about
- 13:18three, furlough furlongs tall, the Borden's of.
- 13:23He'll push the victim down onto the Flaming iron ground forcing
- 13:28him, or her to lie in the Supine position, then they drive Nails
- 13:32as big as palm trees into his right and left hands, right and
- 13:36left feet and waste after the back of that the victim is
- 13:40forced to lay Face down or on the side and is tortured again
- 13:45in the same way as long as his or her unsold.
- 13:49Unwholesome Karma has not yet been exhausted.
- 13:52The victim cannot die to see the Flaming iron graph.
- 13:56And here the cruel and ruthless shouts of the wardens of Hell
- 14:01provokes. Incredible Agony to be staked to
- 14:04the ground and consumed by Flames to see huge nails to be
- 14:08cruelly pierced by them causes mental.
- 14:11It'll and physical suffering that cannot be fathomed.
- 14:14Inhale there is no one who is kind or who rescues the victims
- 14:18of hell. Even though they cry for Mercy
- 14:21with cheek street with tears being separated from their
- 14:25mothers, fathers relatives, inmates intimate friends being
- 14:31completely alone, they wailed despondently as they experience
- 14:35this great suffering without relief for even a second.
- 14:40During this time, there is no chance to practice Insight
- 14:43Meditation. All right?
- 15:03So, depending on how bad your karma is, you don't die, right?
- 15:09So you can go through others, if the victim has not perished
- 15:14after the first round of torture, the warden slices or
- 15:18her body into various shapes with size as big as the roof of
- 15:21a house until blood flows. Like a river, huge Flames, leap
- 15:26up from the blood burning, the sliced parts of the body.
- 15:29Again, the victim suffers immeasurably and has no
- 15:32opportunity. To practice Insight Meditation.
- 15:41If they can escape hell, they come to the hell of the stream.
- 15:44The stream is full of bubbling liquid iron that has weeds and
- 15:49Lotus is floating in it. Whose leaves are as sharp as
- 15:52razor blades. The river bed is covered with
- 15:55sharp razor blades and the banks of the stream are also overgrown
- 15:59with grass is and reads, whose leaves are sharp as razor
- 16:02blades. If the victim happens to go to
- 16:05the stream, they fall down with a thud as they cut themselves
- 16:09from the sharp razor blades in the And then they are burned by
- 16:12the hot molten iron. Then after falling down, they
- 16:15float in the bubbling hot molten.
- 16:17I are going upstream and down as there are sharp razor blade,
- 16:21like, lat grasses and reads on the banks of the stream and
- 16:25razor, like leaves on the house, the lotuses and reads.
- 16:29Then the molten iron, the victim's body becomes torn and
- 16:33battered here, to they have no opportunity at all to practice
- 16:38Insight Meditation. It sounds Dante's Realms of hell
- 16:42that doesn't away. How are you able to escape in
- 16:47any fashion with you? Can't practice what?
- 16:56Oh, well. No, I don't think that the that
- 17:07it's practice is a metaphor in Myanmar.
- 17:10They think of this as a literal description of the lower realms
- 17:18If their mind State something. Well, whatever, no, I think that
- 17:25in Myanmar, these are descriptions of these
- 17:30descriptions describe, what most people think, literally exists.
- 17:37I think in the west we look at it and it sounds unbelievable to
- 17:41us. Preposterous maybe and so then
- 17:43we begin to try and describe it in terms of metaphors that make
- 17:47sense to us like mine States or poetic descriptions or something
- 17:51else. We claim feverishly to the
- 17:57religion of science that we all have and it says that these
- 18:02things can't possibly be true. So something else must be true.
- 18:07In some sense, it's the same kind of fixated belief.
- 18:11When I listened to the sayyed oi, give Dharma talks.
- 18:18One of my favorite stories, he tells is of a woman who wanted
- 18:23to go to the shwedagon Pagoda in downtown Yangon.
- 18:27And her children didn't want to take her because she was so old
- 18:31that she was very slow moving and they were in a hurry.
- 18:35And so they told her She couldn't go and left her at home
- 18:40and then they all piled into a taxi and the woman was so
- 18:44distraught that she began to practice Mehta and the energy of
- 18:48a meta was so strong that she flew from her house to the
- 18:52shwedagon Pagoda in downtown Yangon and got there before her
- 18:56family did. Exactly.
- 19:05But I don't think that that literally happened, but I love
- 19:07the story but the people that he was talking to did think that it
- 19:12literally happened. So how do you make sense of
- 19:16that, right? Well, I like teleportation or
- 19:23whatever, right? So, no virtuous people only at a
- 19:30time when you are a human being, can you practice Insight
- 19:34Meditation? Don't be lazy, don't be
- 19:37forgetful practice. Seriously.
- 19:39This is how to be encouraged and motivated by reflecting on the
- 19:42dangers of the lower Realms. So, Is that useful to you?
- 19:50I would think in the West for most people this the
- 19:53contemplation of the lower Realms is not going to be
- 19:56motivating you in terms of belief, in the nature of hell
- 20:01and being stuck, bring reincarnated in the Laurel and I
- 20:08wrong about that to believe literally in the lower Realms
- 20:12and are you fearful that you'll be reincarnated in one?
- 20:17So, I don't know that it's that it's one of the reasons that we
- 20:21begin to translate these things is because culturally, they
- 20:24don't work for us and so it's useful to begin to consider what
- 20:30actually does motivate you in your practice and what is it
- 20:34that you see getting out of insight practice.
- 20:37What is it? You're actually getting because
- 20:39you do come here, your do practice.
- 20:42You are interested in getting something out of the practice.
- 20:45What is it? What is it that that will will
- 20:49motivate you because as, you know, practice requires time
- 20:54energy and resources, and you have to, in some sense, really
- 20:58participate in the practice, it's not passive.
- 21:03We are a culture of distraction and passive distraction is
- 21:07probably the most popular form. We want to go somewhere and have
- 21:11something happen to us that we don't really have to participate
- 21:15in Beyond. Ring and this is not that here.
- 21:20This is not that this is actually engaging actively in
- 21:24the pursuit of something. And why do you do it?
- 21:27And then what's helpful, in terms of motivating you to do
- 21:31it. Consistently enough that you get
- 21:33the fruits of practice Inside practice leads one to
- 21:42Enlightenment through path, through ition, and navona brings
- 21:46Liberation from both suffering up from the lower Realms and the
- 21:49cycle of suffering. So the cycle of suffering is
- 21:52another way of describing reincarnation 11.
- 21:55We talked about being freed from suffering.
- 21:58What we're also saying is that you're freed from the cycle of
- 22:03rebirth that if you take birth in the human form that you
- 22:07suffer and they only way out of that is to not Take
- 22:10reincarnation. I'm but it's that.
- 22:16Something that concerns you are you desirous of being free of
- 22:20the cycle of suffering, and that's why you practice or is
- 22:24that also not going to be so useful, in terms of practice, or
- 22:28do you, as we commonly, do in the west, create a, we take the
- 22:34phrase cycle of suffering, and then we decide that it that it
- 22:37only applies to the difficulties of this life.
- 22:40So, completely changing, the definition of what was
- 22:43originally talked about. Why did you come?
- 22:50I came because I wanted to be liberated.
- 22:54I wanted to be enlightened inside, practice leads one to
- 22:58Enlightenment through path religion and Nirvana and brings
- 23:02Liberation from suffering, and both the lower Realms in the
- 23:05cycle of suffering, the benefit that it bestows are so great.
- 23:08That there is no other way that they will be realized with a
- 23:12half-hearted practice in Buddhist thought.
- 23:19Only craving the only striving that that is considered
- 23:23wholesome as the striving for enlightenment.
- 23:25But then that would mean that, you knew what it was that you
- 23:28were striving for. Because if you were striving for
- 23:31something that you thought was Enlightenment but wasn't really
- 23:34Enlightenment than it would be an unwholesome striving, so,
- 23:39When you when you came here, did you want enlightenment?
- 23:45One of the things about the Burmese style of practices that
- 23:49it's firmly entrenched in this kind of practice that
- 23:52householders can become enlightened.
- 23:54This is a basic tenant of this, this kind of Burmese practice.
- 24:01But then, do you know what that is?
- 24:03What does that mean? Really When I initially went
- 24:10down to Venice in 1992 to take my introduction to Insight
- 24:17Meditation class. The teacher went around the room
- 24:22and everybody had to declare what the reason was that they
- 24:25came to practice and I said, I wanted to be enlightened.
- 24:30I think maybe one of the great joys of being from the Midwest
- 24:33is that I'm perpetually naive. And there was a great round of
- 24:43laughter, that would be an aspiration.
- 24:46That one might have because they were teaching in a Thai Forest
- 24:50tradition, where householders don't get enlightened.
- 24:52In fact, only male, monastics can get enlightened women can
- 24:56Enlighten. So, But maybe why I came was
- 25:08that I was suffering and I and I had tried a lot of different
- 25:12things to help with the suffering and it seemed to me
- 25:16that meditation had a good reputation for relieving
- 25:20suffering and that maybe I would try that and see if it worked.
- 25:25I had been studying mostly on my own, not being very Let's just
- 25:34say earlier in my life, I had significant trust issues around
- 25:39authority figures and it was very difficult for me to take on
- 25:45a subordinate role to somebody. Also, my early life was so cruel
- 25:52that I had no tolerance for that.
- 25:56I had, if you weren't extraordinary kind, I really
- 26:00couldn't listen to you and so it took a lot.
- 26:03Of time to find a teacher that was extraordinarily kind and
- 26:09that I felt safe enough with now admittedly, I would set up these
- 26:15very elaborate obstacle courses, testing the the teacher, and
- 26:20that most of them failed miserably.
- 26:25And that it was unfair and I see that now.
- 26:32Why did you come to you? Come to reduce your stress.
- 26:34Did you come? Because you were unhappy, do.
- 26:37Did you come because you wanted to get into the Great Game of
- 26:41Life? As we do it in our culture?
- 26:43Did you get everything you wanted in the great game of our
- 26:47culture and find that you were still unhappy?
- 26:50But why did you come The reason that this is is a useful
- 26:56investigation is because in there somewhere you'll find the
- 27:01reasons that will motivate you to continue with the practice.
- 27:07The practice is really good at eliminating stress as an issue
- 27:13and but I think also that you'll find that to Simply eliminate
- 27:17stress isn't going to be enough. It won't be enough and then
- 27:22shimmering On the horizon, we will see happiness, and the
- 27:28meditation path is often called the path to happiness.
- 27:31And, and you'll pursue that, and that you'll find that.
- 27:36Yes, it's very good at making life happy and that you can have
- 27:40that. And that it's still not enough.
- 27:44To have a meaningful life and that on the horizon shimmering
- 27:48will be freedom and you'll pursue that.
- 27:51And you'll find that that's actually fairly arduous path to
- 27:56be free. But if you can get there, you
- 27:58can be free. That it is a great freedom and
- 28:04it's enough to have a meaningful life.
- 28:08So, So, the five hindrances also overzealousness or agitation.
- 28:23Sometimes when mind becomes overzealous over energized, this
- 28:26can manifest in various ways, such as making a determination
- 28:30to effectively note every single object, however, delicate or
- 28:33subtle, it may be spending time. Checking whether or not when was
- 28:37successful in noting an object or which objects were missed or
- 28:41caught making a resolution not to miss any object.
- 28:45Ever again when one finds that one has missed an object
- 28:49reflecting on this has made the utmost. reading that one cannot
- 28:53do more than this or experiencing physical tension
- 28:57such as clenching the jaw grinding the teeth clutching the
- 29:00hands making fists have you noticed when the mind gets
- 29:05agitated Restless Lust in a version.
- 29:12Gratified. The Mind, grows lustful the
- 29:15being aware of it. Lust is overcome, then the mind
- 29:18is not become Restless, frustrated, the Mind becomes a
- 29:21verse being aware of it, or version is overcome than the
- 29:24Mind. Does not become Restless, have
- 29:27you ever noticed the mind turning to erotic thoughts, as
- 29:30you're sitting on the cushion? Apparently, it's never happened
- 29:36to anyone here. Don't long for anything, don't
- 29:48be frustrated by anything. No Liking and longing, every
- 29:52time they occur observed, frustration or disappointment
- 29:55whenever it arises, if you can come into awareness of the
- 30:00present moment, if the mind is pure of hindrances you settle
- 30:03into one pointedness. When the obstacles to
- 30:08concentration of been overcome, the aforementioned six remedies
- 30:12ones, my no longer returns to the past or anticipates the
- 30:15future. It is no longer shrinking or
- 30:18over app acting rather it is only it is only noting the
- 30:23mental and physical phenomena that arise in the moment.
- 30:34We aren't actually talking much about what it is that you're
- 30:38investigating an Insight practice here, we're really
- 30:41talking about the the necessity, the bare necessities of what's
- 30:46necessary for you to be able to push inward into the Insight
- 30:51practice momentary concentration inside.
- 30:56Practice is all about noting, so noting is to know Where your
- 31:01attention is and to soak in and and be aware of what the sensing
- 31:07experiences. So we're dividing the mental
- 31:09from the body, the Mind from the body, in that sense, the Mind
- 31:14knows what the pattern of sensing experience is and then
- 31:18the body senses it. And so we want to make a
- 31:20distinction between those two. So tonight we're going to do an
- 31:27investigation of that using shins ends.
- 31:30See hear feel technique. So the the Maja sees commentary
- 31:38is setting the stage for an investigation of the 16 stages
- 31:43of inside. The 16 stages of insight are
- 31:48descriptions of what the the inside Pursuit is that will take
- 31:53you to the path of Enlightenment.
- 31:55This is all of the, the canonical descriptions of
- 32:01practice are oriented toward taking.
- 32:04To Enlightenment in the west we have lots.
- 32:07And lots of practices that are meant to do.
- 32:09Lots and lots of different things to be relational to be
- 32:14happier. All of those different kinds of
- 32:16orientations of practice to reduce stress, but in the
- 32:21traditional Tera vaada Burmese style of practice.
- 32:25The 16 stages is the map. The first stage is to separate
- 32:33mind from body or mental from body, the knowing what it is
- 32:36from the actual sensing experience of it.
- 32:40The second stage is called conditionality, and that is to
- 32:44understand that, the present moment experience sets the stage
- 32:51for the, the experience that follow that, each moment without
- 32:57the present moment. The way that it is the moment
- 33:00after couldn't unfold the way it unfolds.
- 33:04So you begin to pay attention to this.
- 33:07This flow of experience that is defined by this.
- 33:11This moment sets the stage sets creates the possibility for the
- 33:16next moment. In in practice, you're not
- 33:22directing the mind, you're simply being present at
- 33:24witnessing whatever is happening.
- 33:27But in that witnessing, when we focus on the second stage, pay
- 33:32attention to when the Mind moves to the next sensing experience.
- 33:38So you're in one sensing experience, you know, that
- 33:41that's where it is. You soak into it and then the
- 33:43Mind moves to the next one. What is that process of the
- 33:47Mind? Choosing the next thing to focus
- 33:50on. Can you pay attention and notice
- 33:53in that process, that there's many possibilities where the
- 33:58mind could go and get it goes to a specific Place watching that
- 34:02process of selection happen. And then, the third stage is
- 34:10called the three characteristics.
- 34:14The three marks of existence. Have you heard of this?
- 34:18Not to anicca dukkha and not is not self.
- 34:22Nietzsche is impermanence and dukkha is often translated as
- 34:26unsatisfactoriness. There's three levels of it.
- 34:29The first level is old age sickness and death were born in
- 34:34a human body, will grow old. It will get sick and it will die
- 34:37and there's nothing you can do about it.
- 34:39The second level is the suffering that often comes from
- 34:44getting what you want and losing it from, not getting what you.
- 34:48On tour, having to put up with things that you don't want ever
- 34:51had those experiences. And then the last one is a
- 34:55subtle ongoing constant irritation.
- 34:59That nothing is exactly the way you would have it.
- 35:02If you were actually in charge of anything, so kind of double
- 35:06edged sword, it's not the way you want it and that makes you
- 35:09realize that you're not in charge of anything in doing the
- 35:12same technique. First, we'll look at mind and
- 35:16body. The second will.
- 35:18Look at conditionality, where does the mind go?
- 35:20Why does it go where it goes? What is that inclination of
- 35:24mind? Can you see the conditions an
- 35:27example of that would be somebody coughs?
- 35:33And that brings your attention to hearing and because your mind
- 35:36is in hearing, your able to hear the subtle sound of the train as
- 35:41it goes by and you follow the sense of this.
- 35:43Sound of the training that creates an image of the train
- 35:46and the mind goes and examines the image of that, that sound
- 35:50causes to arise in the in the body.
- 35:54But it isn't the image of the present moment.
- 35:56It's an image of something that you remember, that comes with an
- 35:58emotional feeling and then the attention moves into the Body to
- 36:03touch into the experience of emotion, that the image
- 36:06generated. You follow me on that.
- 36:10So you can, in some sense, follow this thread of
- 36:12experience, one sensing experience arises, which then
- 36:16sets the possibility for the next moment to happen. and then,
- 36:21in the third stage, And tonight we're going to to investigate
- 36:31only the the self, no self, peace.
- 36:36Who's causing this to happen. Are you simply allowing your
- 36:40attention to be drawn to whatever it's drawn to or are
- 36:44you intending your attention to move from place to place who's
- 36:48hearing who's feeling? Who's seeing Or is there nobody?
- 36:53They're doing that. Then you have this experience of
- 36:57no self. The more you push into simply
- 37:00the flow of energy but the less ownership of it.
- 37:04The the the fainter the experience of self is and you
- 37:09can get into a state of just pure flowing sensing energy
- 37:13where nothing really gets fixated and there's really very
- 37:17little if any sense of self But then what happens if there's a
- 37:23strong sense of self again someone coughs and it it's
- 37:28totally irritated and that they've disrupted, your perfect
- 37:32moment of concentration. And so big, Angry self, arises
- 37:37calling out to heaven, for a lightning bolt, to eradicate,
- 37:41the coughing offender, And then that comes and goes.
- 37:46And then you notice that again, your back to this flowing sense
- 37:50of experience and that sense of big Angry self is completely
- 37:54going. Where did it go?
- 37:55If it wasn't you, the owner of the doer, the author, the
- 38:00Creator. And then in a few moments later,
- 38:06another sense of self arises the sense of compassion itself for a
- 38:10Rises very different from big Angry self.
- 38:13What was that and how long does it last before it to arise this
- 38:17of passes away? And then you come into this
- 38:20place of seeing the insubstantiality of self that
- 38:23would be the third stage of the third Insight that's useful in
- 38:29your past toward liberation. So, let's do some practice.
- 39:28So, we're just going to do some inside practice.
- 39:31I'm not going to do any concentration practice as we
- 39:35start the period of meditation. I want you to get a sense that
- 39:39you can go directly into the Karnataka samadhi.
- 39:43Practice and not do any additional Insight practice.
- 39:47I sorry, any additional concentration practice.
- 39:52But you may find it that you don't practice enough that the
- 39:55concentration comes easily and then it might make more sense
- 40:00for you to add some additional concentration development to
- 40:04your sitting practice. When we do carnico, samadhi or
- 40:13momentary Insight, momentary concentration inside practice.
- 40:17You want to hold the body still without moving it?
- 40:22There's a couple of reasons that we do this one, is that the
- 40:26body-mind will automatically adjust itself every time it
- 40:30becomes uncomfortable and in order to prevent that from
- 40:33happening, you have to be in the present moment.
- 40:36When the impulse to move arises in the mind, we don't have a
- 40:42initiation function in Consciousness.
- 40:44We have a veto function. So the unconscious process of
- 40:48the body-mind figures out that it's uncomfortable.
- 40:51That it needs to move and it at the last microsecond it sends a
- 40:58missive saying I'm about to move.
- 41:01Can we go ahead? And if you're not present and
- 41:04veto at the body, will just adjust itself.
- 41:07So this not moving reinforces present moment, awareness
- 41:12reinforces mindfulness. The second reason is that we're
- 41:18often investigating subtle sensation in the body, and the
- 41:21constant movement of the body obscure.
- 41:24So the experience of it as we were paying attention to subtle
- 41:30experience in the body of the body becomes painful and we
- 41:33move, we may not be able to find the subtle experience again and
- 41:37lose the capacity to investigate.
- 41:44So we're attempting to hold the body's still as we can and then
- 41:51the rule of thumb for moving and it's if the body becomes painful
- 41:54and the level of pain in the body is enough to distract you
- 41:58from your Technique, then adjusting the body to reduce the
- 42:02pain. So you can return to the
- 42:05technique is a good idea. But pay attention to the kind of
- 42:10movement that you make, it's often enough simply to
- 42:13straighten up a little bit or move the foot a couple of
- 42:15inches. One Direction or another rather
- 42:18than shaking the body out and moving it around each time, you
- 42:23do that, you settle in and, and have to Begin Again.
- 42:26Whereas, sometimes it's small adjustments, you can maintain
- 42:30the mindfulness. Always a good idea to do a quick
- 42:35inventory of the body's part of the settling in process.
- 42:37So, starting at the top of the head, relax the scalp, the brow,
- 42:41the eyes, The face. But the jaw goes slack, relaxing
- 42:48the tongue straighten, the spine, balancing the head.
- 42:54Relax, the shoulders. Just at the arms.
- 42:59Hang down. Arranging the hands,
- 43:00comfortably. If you're sitting in a chair,
- 43:06plant your feet. So you have a good solid base
- 43:08and if you're sitting on a bench or cushion arrange, the legs of
- 43:11they'll be comfortable for the period of sitting.
- 43:15Just let the breath go in and out as it will no effort to
- 43:18control it. If you know how to do the
- 43:25flexible noting see hear feel strategy, go ahead and begin and
- 43:30I'll give some instructions. so typically the possibly
- 43:34meditation is done eyes closed but one of the reasons that you
- 43:39might do that differently as if you find that you're falling
- 43:41asleep and want to add energy to the meditation and then opening
- 43:46the eyes, often accomplishes this We're going to divide
- 43:52visual experience from auditory experience from felt experience
- 43:57in the body as the three domains.
- 44:00This is a little different than you might have in a traditional
- 44:04Burmese style of noting in a Burmese style of noting is
- 44:08simply let your attention be drawn to whatever is interesting
- 44:10and then you generate a label for that name for that.
- 44:16That intends to engage a part of the mind that creates a lot of
- 44:21experience of self. And so using the see hear feel
- 44:25of method where these categories are predefined is helpful in
- 44:33being able to experience insight into self and no self.
- 44:37So that's why we're doing it this way.
- 44:42If your eyes are open, in your attention is drawn to exterior,
- 44:45Right space. If your eyes are closed and your
- 44:49attention is drawn to the experience of visual thinking,
- 44:54for most people that happens on a screen, centered at the eyes
- 44:58in front of or slightly behind the eyes.
- 45:01A blank screen. Most people experience it as a
- 45:05Darkness or a modulating grayscale.
- 45:09Some people describe it as a lightness.
- 45:13So a blank screen center to the eyes and then imagery associated
- 45:16with thinking arises there. You may also notice there's a
- 45:21visual aspect of the body's current position.
- 45:23It's called proprioceptive sand English.
- 45:27How you know how the body is positioned in visual thinking?
- 45:32some people reported dark center with a glowy edge of most people
- 45:35report that the Mind rapidly scans through the body and then
- 45:39creates an image of how its positioned There's also the
- 45:44aspect of visual thinking, which is the body's location, in its
- 45:47current environment. So, most people report, a view
- 45:50looking straight out from the face. although some people do
- 45:56report being outside of the body, looking at it, There is
- 46:02the image reaction to local sensation in the body.
- 46:06So you feel pressure in the body and often there's a visual
- 46:10experience. Accompanying it and then there's
- 46:13the visual aspect of reaction texture sound.
- 46:17So maybe you hear the sound of my voice and see an image of the
- 46:20in the front of the room. Any of those experiences were
- 46:26going to note them, that is to say know that our attention is
- 46:30in a visual experience, we're going to soak into the sensing
- 46:34of that experience and then we're going to generate in
- 46:37auditory thinking space. The label.
- 46:39See the purpose of labeling is to reinforce concentration if
- 46:46your attention is drawn to an aspect of auditory experience,
- 46:51Either exterior sound or internal.
- 46:54Auditory thinking the Clear Talk of the Mind, the words, whose
- 46:57meaning you can understand. For most people that's inside
- 47:04the head between the ears as soft area.
- 47:07Not a pinpoint. Although some people do report
- 47:11hearing auditory thinking and exterior sound at the opening of
- 47:15the ears. If your attention is drawn to an
- 47:19aspect of visual of auditory experience, you're going to note
- 47:23that know that that's where your attention is soaked into the
- 47:28sensing experience. You're going to generate the
- 47:32single word label here in auditory thinking space.
- 47:35No need to label the labeling. If your attention is drawn to
- 47:41the body, the felt sense of the body could be the effects of
- 47:47gravity of temperature of respiration, circulation of the
- 47:54efforting to hold the posture or it could be emotional content in
- 47:57the body. Any of those are going to note
- 48:00it know that that's where your attention is.
- 48:04So can have the sensing experience and you're going to
- 48:07generate the label feel in order to rethinking space If more than
- 48:15one sensing experiences active at the same time, just choose
- 48:19one to focus on and I'll do a little out loud.
- 48:28Feel. Feel.
- 48:34See. Feel.
- 48:42Here. Here.
- 48:50Feel. You get the idea.
- 49:24In this segment of the meditation, this evening, the
- 49:27Insight that we're exploring, is the knowing what it is as
- 49:31different from the sensing experience.
- 49:35So, pay attention to that. Feeling into the sensing
- 49:40experience. And then watching the Mind
- 49:44recognize that pattern of sensing and know what it is,
- 49:48associate conditioning to it. Were you able to concentrate?
- 50:38Are you able to tease apart knowing what it is from the
- 50:41sensing experience, huh? Were you able to follow the
- 50:56conditionality one sensing experience leading into another
- 51:03more about that one? You're in, let's say you're in
- 51:09see space. And the mind is just hanging out
- 51:13there, you're not doing anything to change it and then all of a
- 51:17sudden moves him to feel space. What is that process of the of
- 51:23that shifting into the next experience?
- 51:30Can you pay attention? You do have a sense of where the
- 51:33mind is going to go before it ends up there.
- 51:37Do you say that part of the process of assembly that in
- 51:43order to process any shift in sensation, you have to use like
- 51:53your thought and thus, I would then the Peter.
- 51:58So, so you'd have a narrative as to where the the mind was going.
- 52:05Yeah. I was like here so I'm with
- 52:10dreaded just try to ignore that part, right?
- 52:16I would say that that's the experience of this stage of
- 52:20sitting, but it's not required. That that you have a thought
- 52:25watching. It may be in some, in that
- 52:28moment, to sense of self was created to watch the process of
- 52:32the Mind. That you could get into a place
- 52:35of flow, where you're simply knowing where the mind is going
- 52:41to go. This is the melody, a narrative.
- 52:51Or is it just a process that doesn't have nearly involved if
- 52:55you keep it clip, 21, word, it doesn't tend to bloom into a
- 53:00narrative, but it can easily Bloom into a narrative of so,
- 53:15The sensing, but then the creation of the word created, a
- 53:25sense of self doing it. and then, Maybe investigate if you
- 53:33don't create the label, if you're just noting.
- 53:36So just the knowing and the soaking in whether that same
- 53:39thing happens, the label is really there to boost your
- 53:44concentration, so it's late in the evening in the middle of the
- 53:48week. So maybe we're tired and our
- 53:52concentration doesn't form well enough.
- 53:54And so using the labeling is a kind of turbo boost for
- 53:58concentration, but if you're concentrated well enough, you
- 54:01don't need Label is really funny.
- 54:05I thought I was concentrating. So strong that head was this
- 54:10thing like it was Mara and all of a sudden all the stuff was
- 54:14hitting me as I did a little quick meta to you know because
- 54:20it really was too intense. That's kind of cool just having
- 54:24that all happen. Good, morrow.
- 54:28We're starting a punk band, just so, you know, cold.
- 54:30The whores of Mara gonna have three backup singers.
- 54:43The daughter of Mara the daughters of bar,
- 54:59Yeah. I for one always picture bar and
- 55:03drag. I don't know about you until
- 55:08now. And what about the investigation
- 55:13around self and no self. How did that feel?
- 55:16Do you have a? I was noticing that I had a
- 55:21strong identification with the knowingness and that's it.
- 55:24It's it was as if I were watching from awareness function
- 55:29of self and then I would lose track of that all together, and
- 55:32we'll just be in the selfie experience, and then that would
- 55:35pass, and I would be back to awareness watching.
- 55:45What do you think about the idea of insight practice being
- 55:48organized around? These particular exploration?
- 55:54Does that make sense to you in terms of a way of organizing
- 55:57practice? The second. it just simply
- 56:21didn't notice well, The process of D identifying and clarifying.
- 56:30What what happens often is that the sense of self arises and
- 56:35we're aware of it in a identified with it and then it
- 56:38begins to pass away and we step back into awareness and that
- 56:42acts as a bridge, we then identify orb, you awareness
- 56:47itself with a sense of identity and then when the next sense of
- 56:51self arises, we jump back into the experience of self and That
- 56:56process creates this perception that the self is ongoing.
- 57:02If you pay attention and separate awareness from the
- 57:06consciousness of self, then you see that the sense of self
- 57:11arises and passes and awareness is just the neutral Observer
- 57:16watching it. So it's a clarification that
- 57:19awareness is not actually the activity of self.
- 57:23But the thing that knows that the activity of self is present.
- 57:39If you're more aware that separateness, then our that I is
- 57:45there. Some idea that then you're able
- 57:47to There's very little suffering
- 58:01and awareness. There's a lot of suffering in
- 58:04the experience of self. So if you can really the idea is
- 58:09this figure-ground reversal where you step out of these
- 58:12identifications with self as the central agent of your activity
- 58:17into awareness. Then you inhabit this place a
- 58:21very little suffering as opposed to being confined to these
- 58:26repeated arisings of self that are often pressure cookers of
- 58:29suffer. You notice a sense of self
- 58:33arise, big Angry self, you realize that it's, it's in
- 58:38material and that it doesn't need defense and you just allow
- 58:41it to come and go and awareness is watching that, which is
- 58:44totally neutral, no suffering. You manifested sense of
- 58:48self-consciousness and you step back into awareness and let it
- 58:53fall away. And then re manifest another
- 58:55sense of self that has more agency and in some sense that
- 59:00makes him Better at being engaged in the world.
- 59:11He actually could do that. You'd have more of a consistent
- 59:15self. We're well, consistently aware
- 59:21and then the self experience is would come and go.
- 59:33Resilient spacious kind of person, right?
- 59:40Do you ever identify strongly with a sense of self and suffer
- 59:43horribly? I did this a jealous identified
- 59:49with a person who had lost something.
- 59:52I'm a always so painful and I watched myself forming around
- 59:56that and then I was aware of it and I intentionally stopped good
- 1:00:04for a moment. So the idea of course is not to
- 1:00:08eradicate the Excel, things experience, you need it, and you
- 1:00:11need to be brilliant if you needed to be efficient and good
- 1:00:15at it. But we don't want to get trapped
- 1:00:18in it. If you want to be able to come
- 1:00:20and go from the experience of self without clinging without
- 1:00:24fixating unnecessarily longer than you need to.
- 1:00:39Decisions in the next steps. You take our responses to this
- 1:00:45self, right? I'm so if you're taking
- 1:00:48somebody. Yeah right.
- 1:00:51Or like you're disappointed in yourself and you get upset like
- 1:00:54so then you act on it but if you have that awareness and what is
- 1:01:01it but this decision, is there a place make awareness?
- 1:01:06That can make decisions. Well awareness, does that
- 1:01:09actually probably make decisions that knows and the sense of self
- 1:01:12doesn't make decisions either. It's the unconscious process of
- 1:01:16the body minded that makes decisions.
- 1:01:19Unconscious part of the bottom line makes decisions.
- 1:01:23Yeah, Consciousness does not know, does not do any of that,
- 1:01:28it simply knows that that's what's happening.
- 1:01:33So the body-mind makes it takes in the data.
- 1:01:38Is it understands it formulates a decision and then at the last
- 1:01:43possible second it sends a bulletin to the conscious mind
- 1:01:46which is we're about to do this is just a good idea and if
- 1:01:52you're mindful you can hit the veto button, then it flashes.
- 1:01:56If it's a bad idea, And then the body-mind will reformulate
- 1:02:01another way of being and it'll send up the next bulletin.
- 1:02:05We're about to do this. Is this a good idea?
- 1:02:07Nobody's in the booth to hit the veto button, you just do it,
- 1:02:13that could be coming out of a condition to just look at.
- 1:02:16We totally coming out of it. The sense of angry self.
- 1:02:20The, the Miss understanding that angry self is substantial and
- 1:02:24needs. Vigorous defense.
- 1:02:27And if nobody's mindful the plan of vigorous defense has to beat
- 1:02:32the crap out of somebody, you just go beat the crap out of
- 1:02:35them. That's what happens.
- 1:02:39Or you yell at them or you say something unkind or hurtful, so
- 1:02:44there's no inherent wisdom and body-mind a database of this
- 1:02:50pattern of experience happens. We've done these different
- 1:02:54responses in the past, we've gotten these different outcomes
- 1:02:57in the past, we kind of would like to have that kind of
- 1:02:59outcome, so we'll take that action.
- 1:03:03I feel like what, especially when I was when I'm doing on a
- 1:03:06practice sometimes on retreat. I'm just I'll do something I'm
- 1:03:13doing it before I even knew that, if that I have had that
- 1:03:17idea, number one time, I was teaching yoga retreat and
- 1:03:21sitting a lot, and I picked up a block and I brought it to this
- 1:03:25woman. We needed it.
- 1:03:27And I knew that she needed it, but I was literally carrying it
- 1:03:30over there for her before I even had the thought it was such a
- 1:03:33cool. It was like, it made me think of
- 1:03:35what they talk about. Wisdom function like that.
- 1:03:40Deep kind of not self or Spirit. Knowing we just act from that
- 1:03:48open place. Also, there's tended.
- 1:03:52The conscious mind is a half a second behind.
- 1:03:55What's really happening. So that your most things you
- 1:04:00don't even know about it till they've already happened
- 1:04:02consciously. So, if you can step out of that
- 1:04:08all together, it just be in that spontaneity of the flowing
- 1:04:12experience of the body mind. That actually, it's It's often
- 1:04:20wiser? Yeah, but that's but if you look
- 1:04:24at it in terms of just sort of brute processing, the body mind
- 1:04:29is processing 11 million bits per second.
- 1:04:32The conscious mind is processing 16, which one do you think is
- 1:04:36likely to come up with a better answer?
- 1:04:42So if you can step totally out of self and just act, I'm a
- 1:04:47photographer and I would photograph of the four by five
- 1:04:54it takes about 30 minutes to set the camera up to take a picture.
- 1:05:00And if I could get totally into the Zone with no self, I
- 1:05:05wouldn't even really be aware of what pictures I'd taken.
- 1:05:09And that actually was the thing that gave me the most pleasure
- 1:05:12because I would get home too and develop the film in the dark
- 1:05:16room and then I would have to investigate the - deceive what
- 1:05:19did it was? Actually I was taking a picture
- 1:05:21of and that was really sort of an exciting way to work because
- 1:05:27when I got totally in Consciousness, the pictures
- 1:05:32didn't have that life that they had.
- 1:05:35When I just worked from that place of I'm not known if that
- 1:05:41makes sense. He said metaphor.
- 1:05:46We have run out of time. Thank you for coming.
- 1:05:50I will be away on Retreat for the next two weeks.
- 1:05:53So we'll have some of the 80s teachers coming in, so I'm not
- 1:05:59sure what the curriculum will be. but then the second week of
- 1:06:06January I'll be back and we'll continue with the Maha see This
- 1:06:14is deepen your practice. So I'm always advocating ways
- 1:06:16for you to deepen your practice and Retreat practices useful for
- 1:06:20that. I have a retreat that starting
- 1:06:24on Monday up at La Casa de Maria in Santa Barbara, there are
- 1:06:29still places available in it if you want to come to it.
- 1:06:32It's an 11 Knight Retreats or the first five night of the
- 1:06:35first five days of the retreat will be meta and this the second
- 1:06:40six days of the Treat will be the pasta.
- 1:06:43Not. So, one of the things about a
- 1:06:47mint of a positive Retreat, as you go, very deeply into the
- 1:06:49metric practice, which brings you into a very kind place with
- 1:06:53yourself, and then you can move from that, kind place of self
- 1:06:57into the inside investigations and it tends to be much smoother
- 1:07:03rather than often the opposite experience can be challenging.
- 1:07:09I've been doing this now for a year and it really He is a great
- 1:07:12way to practice. It's also a meaningful Life
- 1:07:16retreat which means that it's a that it's a relational
- 1:07:19mindfulness Retreat. So in addition to the metin and
- 1:07:23the vu+ focused on examining how your conditioning has affected
- 1:07:30the way that you view yourself, and the way that you view other
- 1:07:33people through the lens of John bowlby's attachment Theory.
- 1:07:39So I find that That's very useful in terms of
- 1:07:43understanding, how your conditioning has affected the
- 1:07:46way that you engage in relationships.
- 1:07:50There's still space is open. I think there are I'm not
- 1:07:55exactly sure. But last Friday they were.
- 1:08:06Joanna Harper and Mary stand. Cabbage are doing a retreat in
- 1:08:10January for women, only in Joshua Tree, our week-long were
- 1:08:13treated Cheryl scene and Dave Smith are doing a New Year's
- 1:08:19intention setting Retreat up at in Malibu so those are the next
- 1:08:24Retreats that are available. I'm also an Ardent supporter of
- 1:08:29meditation centers because I know that the vipassana practice
- 1:08:33often becomes challenging, and it's useful to have people who
- 1:08:36will support you in your practice, where better to meet
- 1:08:40somebody who's practicing meditation, then at a meditation
- 1:08:44center, if you don't have a meditation center to come to,
- 1:08:49where the hell are you going to meet somebody who's practicing
- 1:08:51meditation, right? I work with people all over the
- 1:08:54country and one of the reasons that they often work with me is
- 1:08:58because they don't have access to any place to go.
- 1:09:01They don't have access to a song and it makes the practice much
- 1:09:05harder. I know that you may think that
- 1:09:08we've been here forever and will continue to be here forever.
- 1:09:11But I can assure you that the finances of a meditation center
- 1:09:14always precarious. And we really do rely on you to
- 1:09:19contribute to the lights and the doors being open.
- 1:09:23Every time you come, we've kind of crunch the numbers and $15 is
- 1:09:29are what we think is a good amount.
- 1:09:32But you are practicing generosity for yourself is a way
- 1:09:36of opening the heart. And if you're well resource, $15
- 1:09:41may not mean much to you, in which case you need to practice
- 1:09:44at a level that does have meaning if $15 means enough to
- 1:09:47you, then practice it, that level of, it's too much practice
- 1:09:51at the level that you're comfortable with.
- 1:09:53But also understand that we as a community, are delighted to
- 1:09:57provide the space for you to come to practice.
- 1:09:59If you're not resource, if you would also be.
- 1:10:02So kind as to put the chairs back in the cushions the way
- 1:10:05that's also appreciated will see you soon.