Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Legislative Priorities in the 2024 General Assembly
Transcript
- 0:05[♪♪]
- 0:16GOOD EVENING.
- 0:16WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:18I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:18THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:19OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: THE 2024
- 0:20KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
- 0:21A TWO-YEAR BUDGET IS THE BIG
- 0:23ITEM DURING THIS 60-DAY SESSION.
- 0:25GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR HAS
- 0:26ALREADY RELEASED HIS PLAN.
- 0:28WE EXPECT TO SEE THE HOUSE
- 0:29REPUBLICAN PLAN, SOON.
- 0:31WILL THE STATE SPEND SOME OF THE
- 0:33MONEY IN THE SO-CALLED “RAINY
- 0:33DAY” FUND?
- 0:34WE’LL DISCUSS THAT, AND OTHER
- 0:36ISSUES RELATING TO EDUCATION,
- 0:37CHILD CARE, PUBLIC SAFETY, AND
- 0:38MORE.
- 0:40WE’RE JOINED IN OUR LEXINGTON
- 0:42STUDIO BY SOME OF THE LEADERS OF
- 0:43THE KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY:
- 0:46STATE SENATOR ROBERT STIVERS, A
- 0:47REPUBLICAN FROM MANCHESTER, AND
- 0:48THE SENATE PRESIDENT; STATE
- 0:51SENATOR GERALD NEAL, A
- 0:52LOUISVILLE DEMOCRAT, AND SENATE
- 0:53MINORITY FLOOR LEADER; STATE
- 0:56REPRESENTATIVE DAVID OSBORNE, A
- 0:57REPUBLICAN FROM PROSPECT, AND
- 0:59SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE; AND STATE
- 1:00REPRESENTATIVE DERRICK GRAHAM, A
- 1:02FRANKFORT DEMOCRAT, AND HOUSE
- 1:03MINORITY FLOOR LEADER.
- 1:05WE WANT TO HEAR YOUR QUESTIONS
- 1:06AND COMMENTS. YOU CAN SEND THEM
- 1:08BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER -- AT
- 1:10KYTONIGHTKET.
- 1:12SEND AN EMAIL TO
- 1:15KYTONIGHT@KET.ORG
- 1:16OR USE THE WEB FORM AT T
- 1:20KET.ORG/KYTONIGHT.
- 1:20OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:21WELCOME TO OUR GUESTS.
- 1:27HAPPY NEW YEAR.
- 1:29ALTHOUGH WE HAVE ESEEN EACH
- 1:31OTHER SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE
- 1:32NEW YEAR.
- 1:33LET'S TALK ABOUT THE BUDGET.
- 1:34WE TALKED ABOUT IT AFTER THE
- 1:37GOVERNOR GAVE HIS ADDRESS LAST
- 1:38WEEK.
- 1:38BUT WE'LL DO A DEEPER DIVE SINCE
- 1:41THE BILL HAS BEEN FILED, LEADER
- 1:44GRAHAM YOU FILED THAT LAST WEEK.
- 1:45NOW THAT YOU'VE HAD A CHANCE YOU
- 1:48PROBABLY KNOW THE MOST ABOUT IT
- 1:49WE ASSUME.
- 1:50WHAT IS YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT THE
- 1:51THINGS THAT WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT
- 1:53AFTER HE GAVE HIS STATE OF THE
- 1:55COMMONWEALTH ADDRESS?
- 1:55>> WELL, JUST TO TALK ABOUT
- 1:58EDUCATION, EDUCATION IS THE KEY
- 1:59TO AS I'VE SAID TO OPENING DOORS
- 2:02TO OPPORTUNITY.
- 2:03I THINK THAT IS IMPORTANT.
- 2:05PRE-K.
- 2:07WE ALSO ARE IN THE BUDGET THAT
- 2:11IS TALKED ABOUT OR WRITTEN IN
- 2:15THE BUDGET.
- 2:16>> Renee: IS IT STILL $172
- 2:19MILLION EACH YEAR?
- 2:20>> IN TERMS OF PROTECTING
- 2:22MEDICAID, IN TERMS OF THE
- 2:24FEDERAL SPENDING RETURNS TO THE
- 2:28PREPANDEMIC LEVELS.
- 2:31STRENGTHENING THE
- 2:31INFRASTRUCTURES ACROSS THE
- 2:32COMMONWEALTH, THE GOVERNOR
- 2:33TALKED ABOUT THAT AS WELL IN
- 2:35TERMS OF OUR HIGHWAYS
- 2:36PARTICULARLY IN THE MOUNTAIN
- 2:38PARKWAY.
- 2:39AND IN THE WESTERN KENTUCKY.
- 2:42AND INCREASING PUBLIC EMPLOYEES
- 2:44WHICH IS IMPORTANT TO ME HERE IN
- 2:47OR IN FRANKFORT STATE EMPLOYEES
- 2:49ACROSS THE STATE.
- 2:51AND COST OF LIVING INCREASE FOR
- 2:54THEM.
- 2:54ALL OF THOSE THINGS ARE WHAT THE
- 2:57GOVERNOR HAS ASKED US TO TAKE ON
- 3:00AND TO ALSO SUPPORT.
- 3:02AS A RESULT, OF HIS BUDGET, THE
- 3:06STATE OF THE COMMONWEALTH IN HIS
- 3:08SPEECH, HE HIGHLIGHTED
- 3:11COOPERATIVE SPIRIT BETWEEN HIS
- 3:14OFFICE AND KENTUCKY GENERAL
- 3:15ASSEMBLY AND I HOPE WE CAN WORK
- 3:17TOGETHER SO THAT WE CAN TAKE ON
- 3:19THE CHALLENGES THAT THIS
- 3:22COMMONWEALTH IS HAVING AS WE
- 3:23PREPARE FOR THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
- 3:25>> Renee: Mr. PRESIDENT WHEN
- 3:26WE TALKED AFTER THE GOVERNOR'S
- 3:28STATE OF THE COMMONWEALTH
- 3:29ADDRESS BOTH YOU AND THE SPEAKER
- 3:31PUT THINGS IN THREE BUCKETS THE
- 3:33THINGS WE AGREE WITH THE
- 3:34GOVERNOR ON.
- 3:35THE THINGS WE CAN BE CONVINCED
- 3:36OF AND THE THINGS WE JUST WON'T
- 3:39DO.
- 3:39I WANT IT GET MAYBE MORE WHAT
- 3:42YOU CAN BE CONVINCED OF.
- 3:43YOU SAID ON TUESDAY NIGHT,
- 3:45WEDNESDAY NIGHT THAT YOU AGREE
- 3:46WITH THE INFRASTRUCTURE THINGS,
- 3:48OF COURSE, AND THE DISASTER
- 3:50RELIEF CONTINUING RECOVERIESTS
- 3:52FOR EASTERN AND WESTERN KENTUCKY
- 3:54AFFECTED BY THE NATURAL
- 3:56DISASTERS.
- 3:57WHAT CAN BE STILL BE CONVINCED
- 3:59OF?
- 3:59>> LET'S TALK ABOUT UNIVERSAL
- 4:02PRE-K AND DAYCARE.
- 4:05I'M NOT A BIG SUPPORTER OF
- 4:07UNIVERSAL PRE-K BUT WE KNOW WE
- 4:09NEED TO STRENGTHEN OUR DAYCARE
- 4:11OPPORTUNITIES BECAUSE THAT IS A
- 4:13HUGE IMPEDIMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS
- 4:15TO GET BACK INTO THE WORKFORCE.
- 4:17SO I THINK EVERYBODY KNOWS WE
- 4:18NEED SOMETHING IN THAT REALM.
- 4:21IT'S WHAT I CALL WHAT'S IT'S
- 4:23GOING TO LOOK LIKE.
- 4:24THAT'S ONE THAT I THINK THERE'S
- 4:26POTENTIAL OF TALKING ABOUT HOW
- 4:27WE GET TO A DAYCARE MODEL.
- 4:30NOT A UNIVERSAL PRE-K AND
- 4:34THERE'S STUDIES ON THE USES AND
- 4:36BENEFITS OF EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 4:38EXPOSURE.
- 4:39SOMETIMES I THINK IT'S BETTER TO
- 4:40LET THE CHILD BE THE CHILD.
- 4:44THE INFRASTRUCTURE HOW MUCH.
- 4:45I THINK WE AGREE THAT GOOD
- 4:48WATER, GOOD SEWER, GOOD ROADS,
- 4:50IT BECOMES A MATTER OF DEGREE.
- 4:52MAYBE MORE, MAYBE LESS.
- 4:55BUT SEEING WHAT HE WANTS TO DO,
- 4:58THERE'S SOME REAL OPPORTUNITIES
- 4:59WITH THE ABILITY TO DRAWDOWN
- 5:01FEDERAL FUNDS AS WELL.
- 5:05THE OTHER I WILL TAKE A MORE
- 5:07HOLISTIC APPROACH, THE GOVERNOR
- 5:09DID A LOT OF ADVERTISING AND
- 5:10TALKED ABOUT HOW WE'VE REDUCED
- 5:12PEOPLE'S TAXES.
- 5:14THAT'S PROBABLY ONE OF THE
- 5:16THINGS MOST DISAPPOINTED WITH HE
- 5:18DOESN'T WANT TO CONTINUE THE
- 5:20MANTRA LET'S REDUCE PEOPLE'S
- 5:21TAXES.
- 5:23BECAUSE BUDGET HE HAS PROPOSED
- 5:25PROBABLY WON'T ALLOW US TO HIT
- 5:27TRIGGERS EVER TO RELIEVE THE
- 5:30BURDEN ON KENTUCKY TAXPAYERS AND
- 5:31WORKING PLACE PEOPLE.
- 5:34>> Renee: LEADER NEAL ABOUT THAT
- 5:35POINT, THE GOVERNOR TOUTED ON
- 5:37THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL ABOUT
- 5:39LOWERING KENTUCKIANS TAXES.
- 5:41BUT, YET, IN THE WJ THAT HE
- 5:43PRESENTED AS PRESIDENT STIVERS
- 5:45POINTED OUT DOESN'T MAKE ROOM
- 5:47FOR THAT.
- 5:47IS THAT DOUBLE SPEAK?
- 5:49>> NOT REALLY I THREE WHAT HE IS
- 5:51DOING IS PUT OUR OPTIONS ON THE
- 5:53TABLE.
- 5:54THEY WERE SOUND, RATIONAL THINGS
- 5:55WE NEED IN MY JUDGMENT AND I
- 5:59THINK IT'S UP TO US TO GO
- 6:00THROUGH THE PROCESS AND SEE
- 6:02WHERE WE END UP.
- 6:03YOU KNOW, WHAT STRUCK ME ABOUT
- 6:06THE BUDGET THAT HE THAT HE PUT
- 6:07ON THE TABLE WAS IT WASN'T
- 6:10EXTREME.
- 6:10IT WAS VERY FUNDAMENTAL AND
- 6:12BASIC THE THINGS WE CAN USE AND
- 6:14LAID DOWN THE FOUNDATION OF WHAT
- 6:16WE NEED TO DO IN TAKING CARE AND
- 6:18TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THE
- 6:19OPPORTUNITY WE HAVE GIVEN THE
- 6:20MONEY WE HAVE IN THE TRAJECTORY
- 6:24OF OUR ECONOMIC REALITIES IN
- 6:25KENTUCKY AT THIS TIME.
- 6:26SO I THINK ALL THOSE THINGS ARE
- 6:29DOABLE.
- 6:29BUT I AGREE.
- 6:30WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO LOOK AT
- 6:31IT AND SEE WHAT IT MEANS.
- 6:34THERE'S ISSUES WE DISDEGREE
- 6:36AGREE ON.
- 6:37UNDERNEATH WE HAVE A OPPORTUNITY
- 6:39HERE.
- 6:39AND I THINK IN MY OPINION AND I
- 6:42WOULD ENCOURAGE MY COLLEAGUES
- 6:43BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE THAT WE
- 6:45NEED TO LOOK VERY CAREFULLY HOW
- 6:47WE LAY THE FOUNDATION FOR THE
- 6:49FUTURE AND THAT'S GOING TO BE A
- 6:51DEBATE AND DISCUSSION WE CAN
- 6:53HAVE.
- 6:53>> Renee: SPEAKER OSBORNE WE ARE
- 6:54WAITING FOR THE HOUSE
- 6:56REPUBLICANS TO FILE THEIR BILL
- 6:57IN THE NEXT WEEK OR SO?
- 6:58>> I WOULD THINK WITHIN THE NEXT
- 7:01WEEK TO 10 DAYS MAYBE TWO WEEKS.
- 7:04WE THOUGHT WE WERE GOING TO BE
- 7:05FILING IT PRIOR TO NOW, BUT AT
- 7:08THE END OF THE YEAR, THERE'S
- 7:10CHANGES IN THE PERSONNEL NUMBERS
- 7:11THE PERSONNEL CABINET MADE
- 7:14CHANGES IN SALARY NUMBERS WHICH
- 7:15HAS AN DOMINO EFFECT IN TRYING
- 7:18TO BALANCE THE NUMBERS.
- 7:19WE HAD TO GO BACK AND HAD BUDGET
- 7:22TAF RECALCULATE THOSE THINGS TO
- 7:23GET THE NUMBERS RIGHT.
- 7:26AS I'VE SAID, WE WILL FILE THE
- 7:28BUDGET WHEN IT'S READY.
- 7:30>> Renee: SO WHAT YOU ELUDED TO
- 7:32A LOT OF STATE WORKERS WHO REACH
- 7:34OUT TO ASK ABOUT WHAT COULD BE
- 7:37IN IT FOR THEM.
- 7:38THE GOVERNOR PROPOSED 6 AND 4.
- 7:406 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 25 AND ET
- 7:43CETERA.
- 7:43WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THAT?
- 7:45YOU GOT THE PERSONNEL NUMBERS
- 7:47THAT INTIMATES THAT YOU ARE
- 7:48LOOKING THE THAT?
- 7:49>> THAT HAS BEEN A GREAT PIECE
- 7:51OF INFORMATION TO HAVE.
- 7:52IT'S ONE WE'VE BEEN HOPING FOR,
- 7:54FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS.
- 7:55IT IS A MUCH MORE COMPLICATED
- 7:57ISSUE THAN JUST GIVING A SET
- 8:01PERCENTAGE INCREASE.
- 8:02WE KNOW THAT THERE IS AN
- 8:04INCREDIBLE AMOUNT OF COMPRESSION
- 8:05AND COMPACTION IN OUR STATE
- 8:08PERSONNEL CABINET AND OUR
- 8:09PERSONNEL FIGURES.
- 8:10WE NEED TO BE MORE THOUGHTFUL
- 8:12HOW WE GIVE THE RAISES.
- 8:15EVERYBODY ACKNOWLEDGES THAT WE
- 8:16NEED TO ADEQUATELY COMPENSATE
- 8:18OUR STATE EMPLOYEES.
- 8:20BUT AS PART OF THAT WE NEED TO
- 8:23MAKE ENTIRE PAY SCALE MORE
- 8:26COMPETITIVE UP AND DOWN THE
- 8:28RANKS.
- 8:28WE HAVE SO MUCH COMPACTION THE
- 8:30WAY IT'S BEEN PIECEMEALED OVER
- 8:32THE YEARS.
- 8:33THAT IS WHY THIS PERSONNEL
- 8:35REPORT WAS SO IMPORTANT TO SHOW
- 8:36US WHERE THOSE PROBLEM AREAS
- 8:38ARE.
- 8:39>> Renee: THE GOVERNOR, IF I'M
- 8:41UNDERSTANDING WHAT YOU ARE
- 8:42SAYING, ADDRESSED THAT SALARY
- 8:44COMPRESSION WHICH MEANS THOSE
- 8:45COMING IN NEWER ARE MAKING AS
- 8:47MUCH IF NOT MORE THAN THOSE WHO
- 8:49HAVE SENIORITY AND YEARS OF
- 8:51SERVICE.
- 8:51IS THAT WHAT YOU ARE TALKING
- 8:53ABOUT THAT YOU WOULD CORRECT?
- 8:55AND DOES IT ALIGN SO WHAT HE'S
- 8:57OFFERED?
- 8:58>> CORRECT.
- 8:58I DON'T KNOW THAT IT LINES UP
- 9:00WITH HIS PROPOSAL.
- 9:01BUT, YES, IT DOES CONSIDER MANY
- 9:03OF THE SAME THINGS AS FAR AS HOW
- 9:08TO REWARD LONG-TERM EMPLOYEES,
- 9:11REWARD SENIORITY, UNDERSTAND
- 9:12THAT TODAY'S HIRING ENVIRONMENT
- 9:13IS DIFFERENT IN MANY CASES THAN
- 9:16IT'S BEEN.
- 9:17WE UNDERSTAND THE COMPETITION
- 9:18FOR WORKFORCE.
- 9:19AND THAT HITS STATE EMPLOYEES AS
- 9:22MUCH AS ANY EMPLOYMENT SECTOR.
- 9:25>> Renee: CAN YOU TELL STATE
- 9:27WORKERS TONIGHT YOU GOT
- 9:28SOMETHING GOOD COMING TO YOU?
- 9:29>> I THINK IT WILL BE VERY
- 9:32THOUGHTFUL.
- 9:32I WILL NOT PUT A NUMBER ON IT AT
- 9:34THIS POINT.
- 9:36BUT I DO THINK IT IS A
- 9:38THOUGHTFUL BUDGET.
- 9:39AS WE HAVE CONTINUED TO SAY
- 9:43WE'RE PROUD OF THE BUDGET WE
- 9:46PRODUCED OVER THE LAST FOUR
- 9:48YEARS, THE LAST SIX YEARS.
- 9:49AND I THINK YOU WILL SEE A
- 9:52SIMILAR BUDGET PROCESS TO WHAT
- 9:54YOU'VE SEEN OVER THE LAST FOUR
- 9:56BUDGETS WE'VE PASSED.
- 9:58>> Renee: ANOTHER QUESTION COST
- 9:59OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT FOR
- 10:01RETIREES.
- 10:01WHAT SAY YOU ON THAT?
- 10:02>> IT IS A DIFFICULT ISSUE TO
- 10:04ADDRESS.
- 10:05I THINK EVERYBODY UNDERSTANDS
- 10:08THE PRESSURES OF INFLATION.
- 10:09THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS WE
- 10:11TALK ABOUT THE COST OF LIVING IN
- 10:17GENERALITIES.
- 10:18COST INCREASES FOR TEACHERS,
- 10:21KTRS RETIREES AND IT HAS TO BE
- 10:23LOOKED AT IN A DIFFERENT VAIN.
- 10:28KTRS RETIREES THEY PREFUND THE
- 10:31COLAS WHEN THEY PAY INTO THE
- 10:33PENSION SYSTEMS THAT IS
- 10:35CALCULATED INTO THE
- 10:35CONTRIBUTIONS.
- 10:36THE KERS COLAS ARE NOT
- 10:39CALCULATED NOT PREFUNDED.
- 10:40THEY HAVE THE ABILITY TO GET
- 10:42COST OF LIVING INCREASES IN THE
- 10:44SOCIAL SECURITY IT IS NOT APPLES
- 10:45AND APPLES BUT IT IS SOMETHING
- 10:47WE UNDERSTAND THE IMPORTANCE OF
- 10:49AND THE AMOUNT OF PRESSURE THAT
- 10:51HAS BEEN PUT ON EVERYBODY
- 10:55SPEND'S ABILITY.
- 10:55>> Renee: IF YOU WANT TO SPILL
- 10:57TEA ABOUT THINGS YOU ARE FUNDING
- 10:59GO AHEAD.
- 11:00>> I WON'T LIKELY DO THAT.
- 11:02>> Renee: I HAVE TO ASK.
- 11:03>> BUT AS HAS BEEN NOTED, YOU
- 11:07KNOW WE HAVE FOR THE ENTIRE TIME
- 11:09THAT WE'VE BEEN WRITING THE
- 11:12BUDGETS WE HAVE MADE A COMMITTED
- 11:15FOCUS ON EDUCATION.
- 11:17EVERY SINGLE YEAR.
- 11:18WE CAN CERTAINLY HAVE THE DEBATE
- 11:20AS LEADER GRAHAM AND I CERTAINLY
- 11:22HAVE OVER THE YEARS ABOUT
- 11:25WHETHER IT IS ENOUGH OR WHETHER
- 11:26IT SHOULD BE MORE.
- 11:28BUT IT IS NOT DEBATABLE THAT
- 11:30WE'VE COMMITTED RECORD FUNDING
- 11:32EVERY SINGLE YEAR TO EDUCATION.
- 11:34I WAS INTERESTING BLUEGRASS
- 11:37INSTITUTE RELEASED A STUDY TODAY
- 11:38THAT SHOWED THE EVOLUTION OF
- 11:40DOLLARSTH EDUCATION OVER THE
- 11:41LAST NOW 35 YEARS.
- 11:46AND ON INFLATION ADJUSTED
- 11:48DOLLARS THE AMOUNT OF STATE
- 11:52DOLLARS SPENT ON PER PUPIL IN
- 11:56PUBLIC EDUCATION, 1990 WAS
- 11:58$7,000 THIS IS INFLATION
- 12:00ADJUSTED IT'S NOW $17,000.
- 12:03WE'VE SPENT TWO-AND-A-HALF TIMES
- 12:04MORE IN INFLATION ADJUSTED
- 12:07DOLLARS ON EDUCATING OUR
- 12:08CHILDREN TODAY AND YET WE ALSO
- 12:10SAW AS WE KNEW WAS THE CASE,
- 12:12THAT TEACHER PAY HAS LAGGED
- 12:14BEHIND ON THAT.
- 12:15IT IS ACTUALLY LOST SOME
- 12:20INFLATION ADJUSTED DOLLARS OVER
- 12:21THAT SAME PERIOD OF TIME.
- 12:22SO WE KNOW THAT THERE IS
- 12:24ADMINISTRATIVE BLOAT.
- 12:25AND I THINK THAT THERE NEEDS TO
- 12:27BE A RESET IN THAT.
- 12:29>> Renee: AND THAT STUDY WE
- 12:31REPORTED ON ON THE 6:30 PROGRAM
- 12:33ALSO FOUND IT DIDN'T CORRELATE
- 12:35THE HIGHER FUNDING DID NOT
- 12:36CORRELATE TO BETTER STUDENT
- 12:38PERFORMANCE.
- 12:38>> CORRECT.
- 12:39>> Renee: AND I WANT TO ASK
- 12:40ABOUT THAT I WILL BEGIN WITH THE
- 12:42EDUCATOR.
- 12:43THE BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR
- 12:45PUBLIC POLICY SOLUTIONS IS A
- 12:46CONSERVATIVE LEANING THINK TANK.
- 12:49Dr. GAREN WAS THE A FOR OF THE
- 12:52REPORT EXAMINING FUNDING FOR
- 12:54K-12 EDUCATION AND THE OUTCOME
- 12:55IT IS PRODUCED AND YOU HEARD THE
- 12:58SPEAKER GIVE A GOOD SUMMARY OF
- 13:00THAT.
- 13:01WHEN YOU HEAR THOSE REPORTS WHAT
- 13:03WOULD YOU SAY THE DIRECTION FOR
- 13:05FUNDING FOR PUBLIC EDUCATION IN
- 13:06KENTUCKY SHOULD BE?
- 13:07>> FIRST OF ALL, IF YOU LOOK AT
- 13:09THE TEACHERS WHO ARE HAD IT THE
- 13:10CLASSROOM WE HAVE HAD A LOT OF
- 13:12TURNOVERS.
- 13:13TEACHERS WHO ARE LEAVING.
- 13:15WHO ARE QUALIFIED, WELL
- 13:16QUALIFIED.
- 13:17AND HAVE BEEN IN THE SYSTEM FOR
- 13:19A WHILE.
- 13:20AND BECAUSE OF MANY THINGS, PART
- 13:27BEING PAY EQUITY OR PAY HAVING
- 13:29THE IDEA OF HIGHER PAY, BUT ALSO
- 13:32THE PROBLEMS THAT WE ARE SEEING
- 13:35WITHIN THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
- 13:37A LOT OF THAT IS SOCIAL IN TERMS
- 13:39OF THE PROBLEMS THAT WE'RE
- 13:41HAVING TO DEAL WITH.
- 13:42THE PANDEMIC REALLY MADE IT EVEN
- 13:45WORSE.
- 13:46BUT, I WOULD THINK AND AS THE
- 13:48CHAIR OF THE HOUSE EDUCATION
- 13:50COMMITTEE, I KNOW THAT THAT IS A
- 13:53VERY CONSERVATIVE ORGANIZATION.
- 13:55AND THEY ARE ALSO VERY PRO
- 13:59PRIVATE PAROCHIAL SCHOOLS AND
- 14:00VOUCHERS AS WELL.
- 14:01SO WE HAVE TO TAKE THAT WITH A
- 14:04GRAIN OF SALT AS WELL.
- 14:07BUT PUBLIC EDUCATION IS WE'RE
- 14:12RESPONSIBLE FOR PUBLIC
- 14:12EDUCATION.
- 14:13THE CONSTITUTION SAYS WE HAVE TO
- 14:15PROVIDE PUBLIC EDUCATION FOR OUR
- 14:16STUDENTS.
- 14:16AND IN ORDER FOR US TO CONTINUE
- 14:19TO HAVE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND
- 14:20WE'RE DOING REALLY WELL IN OUR
- 14:23ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BRINGING
- 14:24NEW JOBS.
- 14:25THE WAY THIS COMMONWEALTH CAN
- 14:28PURSUE BRINGING MORE PEOPLE IN
- 14:31TO INVEST IN KENTUCKY IS BY
- 14:34SHOWING THAT WE'RE WILLING TO
- 14:36INVEST IN EDUCATION NO MATTER
- 14:38WHAT.
- 14:38BECAUSE EDUCATION IS THE KEY
- 14:40THAT OPENS THAT DOOR.
- 14:40I SAY THAT ALL THE TIME.
- 14:42FOR OPPORTUNITIES.
- 14:43AND SO WE CAN WORK TOGETHER AND
- 14:47WE ARE WILLING TO WORK WITH THE
- 14:51MAJORITY PARTY IN TRYING TO COME
- 14:53UP WITH IDEAS THAT WE CAN PUT
- 14:56INTO PLACE THAT ADDRESSES ALL
- 14:58THOSE ISSUES THAT PUBLIC
- 15:00EDUCATION IS DEALING WITH.
- 15:01AND SO I THINK THAT ON OUR SIDE
- 15:04AND THE GOVERNOR'S SIDE HE IS
- 15:06WANTING TO WORK BUT WE ALSO MUST
- 15:08LOOK AT THE FACT THAT TEACHERS
- 15:10ARE LEAVING FOR VARIOUS REASONS.
- 15:12AND WE NEED TO ADDRESS THAT.
- 15:15>> Renee: PRESIDENT STIVERS, TO
- 15:16BRING UP ANOTHER REPORT DONE BY
- 15:18THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR ECONOMIC
- 15:20POLICY A MORE PROGRESSIVE
- 15:23LEANING THINK TANK LOOKS AT
- 15:25ECONOMIC FACTORS AND EDUCATION
- 15:27AMONG THEM THEY REPORTED A FEW
- 15:28MONTHS BACK THAT THE WEALTH
- 15:31DISPARITY, THE FUNDING DISPARITY
- 15:33BETWEEN WEALTHIER DISTRICTS AND
- 15:35POORER DISTRICTS WAS WIDENING.
- 15:37AND THERE NEEDED TO BE SOME KIND
- 15:40OF EQUITY TO HELP BRING UP THOSE
- 15:42POORER SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
- 15:43DID YOU BUY THAT REPORT?
- 15:45AND DO YOU THINK THAT IS
- 15:46SOMETHING WORTH EXAMINING AND
- 15:48ADDRESSING IN THIS SESSION?
- 15:49>> I DON'T KNOW THAT WE CAN
- 15:50ADDRESS IT IN THIS SESSION.
- 15:51BUT I THINK IT'S GOING TO HAVE
- 15:53TO BE LOOKED AT IN FUTURE YEARS.
- 15:56AND I DON'T DISAGREE WITH THAT
- 16:01AS TO THE CONCLUSIONS.
- 16:02I THINK THAT IS ONE OF THE REAL
- 16:04CONCERNS WITH GOING OUTSIDE THE
- 16:07SEEK FORMULA AND THIS IS WHAT
- 16:08WE'VE SAID ALL ALONG GOING
- 16:11OUTSIDE THE SEEK FORMULA, TO
- 16:14APPROPRIATEIATE DIRECTLY PAY
- 16:15RAISES TO TEACHERS.
- 16:19BECAUSE I --
- 16:20>> Renee: WHICH IS WHAT THE
- 16:21GOVERNOR IS WANTING TO DO?
- 16:23>> YES.
- 16:24REPRESENTATIVE GRAHAM EVERYBODY
- 16:25AROUND HERE KNOWS AND WE AGREE
- 16:28ON THE WORKPLACE ENVIRONMENT NO
- 16:30MATTER WHERE IT IS.
- 16:31ESPECIALLY IN THE SCHOOL SYSTEM.
- 16:32AND THERE HAS TO BE A LOT OF
- 16:34THOUGHT ABOUT MAKING IT SAFE,
- 16:36OFFERING THE SERVICES.
- 16:38BUT HERE'S WHERE I THINK WE ALSO
- 16:42AGREE ON HAVING TO BE
- 16:43COMPETITIVE WITH SALARIES.
- 16:46THERE'S NO DOUBT WE'VE GOT TO BE
- 16:48COMPETITIVE WITH SALARIES.
- 16:49BUT IF YOU ARE THINKING ABOUT
- 16:52WHAT JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 16:54SCHOOLTEACHER OR GO TO THE
- 16:55WEALTHY DISTRICTS AND I DON'T
- 16:57MEAN TO PICK ON THEM, YOU TAKE
- 16:59AN OLDHAM COUNTY, AND WANT THEIR
- 17:02PAY SCALE IS VERSUS ANOTHER
- 17:05COUNTY IF YOU LIVE AN 11%
- 17:07INCREASE OUTSIDE THE SEEK
- 17:08FORMULA THAT IS GOING TO SKEW
- 17:10AND MAKE A BIGGER DIFFERENTIAL
- 17:13BECAUSE THE PAY SCALES ARE
- 17:15DIFFERENT.
- 17:15MAKING IT MORE RIGHT FOR
- 17:17LITIGATION TO SAY IT IS AN
- 17:20INEQUITABLE FUNDING SYSTEM.
- 17:21WE'VE ALWAYS SAID WE WANT
- 17:24COMPETITIVE SALARIES.
- 17:25BUT YOU'VE GOT TO SHOW US HOW TO
- 17:27DO IT INSIDE THE SEEK FORMULA SO
- 17:30WE DON'T HAVE THIS TYPE OF
- 17:31DISCUSSION.
- 17:32BECAUSE THERE ARE A LOT AND I'M
- 17:33ONE OF THEM THAT BELIEVE WE ARE
- 17:35ON THE VERGE OF HAVING A 1980
- 17:41SOMETHING CASE THAT WAS DONE BY
- 17:44BURKE COMES WAS THE LEAD COUNSEL
- 17:47SAYING IT'S INEQUITABLE.
- 17:48>> Renee: THE ROSE DECISION AND
- 17:50YOU LEADER NEAL YOU KNOW THIS
- 17:52WELL, THE KENTUCKY EDUCATION
- 17:53REFORM ACT OF 199 ON THE CASE
- 17:55REPORT SAID THAT THE GAPS NOW
- 17:57BETWEEN THE WEALTHIER AND POORER
- 17:59DISTRICTS ARE AS WIDE AS THEY
- 18:01WERE BEFORE THAT REFORM ACT IN
- 18:031990.
- 18:04SO WHEN YOU HEAR THAT AND ALSO
- 18:06WHAT PRESIDENT STIVERS WAS
- 18:07TALKING ABOUT THERE IS ANOTHER
- 18:08CONCERN THAT TEACHERS IN
- 18:11DISTRICTS THAT ARE POOR THEY ARE
- 18:12NOT BEING PAID AS MUCH SO THEY
- 18:13ARE GOING TO A FAYETTE COUNTY
- 18:15THAT IS 40 MILES DOWN THE ROAD
- 18:17OR OLDHAM COUNTY IF IT IS NOT
- 18:19TOO MUCH OF A COMMUTE.
- 18:21HOW DO YOU ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES
- 18:23AND 11% FOR ALL SCHOOL PERSONNEL
- 18:25THE RIGHT APPROACH?
- 18:26>> LET ME PUT IT THIS WAY.
- 18:29IF WE WANT TO GET TO A
- 18:31PARTICULAR OBJECTIVE WE CAN GET
- 18:32THERE.
- 18:33WE CAN SIT DOWN AND WE CAN PUT
- 18:34SOMETHING THAT IS
- 18:36CONSTITUTIONAL, THAT ACTUALLY
- 18:37SERVES THE NEEDS THAT WE HAVE.
- 18:39BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IF
- 18:40YOU LOOK AT THE NUMBERS FROM THE
- 18:42ANALYSTS THAT YOU MENTIONED, YOU
- 18:44WILL FIND THAT THEY ARE SAYING
- 18:47WE ARE ABOUT TO 2008 LEVEL IN
- 18:50TERMS OF FUNDING TEACHERS.
- 18:51THINK ABOUT THAT FOR A MOMENT.
- 18:54JEFFERSON COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 18:55THERE ARE 500 TEACHERS SHORT IN
- 18:58TERMS OF PERSONNEL.
- 18:59IF YOU LOOK AT US IN TERMS OF
- 19:01OUR SURROUNDING STATES, WE'RE
- 19:05NOT COMPETITIVE WITH RESPECT TO
- 19:06HOW THEY ARE TREATING THEIR
- 19:08TEACHERS HOW THEY ARE GOING
- 19:09FORWARD.
- 19:10AND I UNDERSTAND IT IS A TOUGH
- 19:11QUESTION.
- 19:11IT IS A TOUGH QUESTION WHENEVER
- 19:13YOU DO THIS.
- 19:13I WILL TELL YOU SOMETHING WE ARE
- 19:16IN AN UNPRECEDENTED,
- 19:18UNPRECEDENTED POSITION RIGHT NOW
- 19:20BECAUSE OF THE FUNDS THAT WE'VE
- 19:22HISTORIC FUNDS THAT WE HAVE.
- 19:24WE HAVE CAPACITY.
- 19:25BUT ALSO BECAUSE WE ALSO ARE IN
- 19:27A SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE
- 19:29ECONOMIC GROWTH AND IT PORTENDS
- 19:31TO BE GREATER GOING FORWARD.
- 19:32WE ARE IN A GOOD POSITION.
- 19:35SOMETIMES WE TEND TO BE OVERLY
- 19:38CONSERVATIVE IN OUR APPROACH TO
- 19:39THINGS AND DON'T LAY THE
- 19:41FOUNDATION FOR THE FUTURE.
- 19:41AND I THINK WE'RE GOING TO HAVE
- 19:43TO GIVE SERIOUS LOOK AT THAT.
- 19:45I THINK WE SHOULD BE CAREFUL
- 19:47ABOUT NOT TAKING ADVANTAGE OF
- 19:48THE OPPORTUNITY.
- 19:49WE'LL FIND THE MECHANISM.
- 19:51WE'LL FIND THE COMBINATION.
- 19:52WE'LL FIND THE FORMULA IF WE
- 19:54HAVE THE WILL TO GET THERE.
- 19:56>> Renee: HOW MUCH MONEY SHOULD
- 19:57BE TAKEN OUT OF THE RAINY DAY
- 20:01FUND PARTICULARLY FOR EDUCATION?
- 20:02>> ANALYSTS THEY GET TO THOSE
- 20:05NUTS AND BOLTS.
- 20:06BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS WE
- 20:07HAVE A TON OF MONEY IN RAINY DAY
- 20:10FUND AND WE SHOULD RETAIN A
- 20:12HEALTHY AMOUNT OF MONEY IN THE
- 20:15FUND.
- 20:15BUT AT THE SAME TIME WE HAVE SO
- 20:16MUCH ROOM IN THAT FUND WE HAVE
- 20:18SO MUCH IN TERMS OF NEED, WE
- 20:20HAVE SO MUCH THAT WE HAVE NOT
- 20:21ADDRESSED OVER THE YEARS, THAT
- 20:23WE ARE ACTUALLY SHOOTING
- 20:25OURSELVES IN THE FOOT IN MY
- 20:26OPINION BECAUSE WE ARE NOT
- 20:28ADDRESSING LAYINGS FOUNDATION
- 20:29WHAT WE NEED TO DO TO MEET THE
- 20:31FUTURE.
- 20:31WE HAVE TO DO THAT AND WE CAN'T
- 20:33KEEP PUTTING IT OFF.
- 20:35WE NEED TO DEAL WITH IT AND WE
- 20:36HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO IT.
- 20:37WE HAVE THE FUNDS TO DO THAT.
- 20:39THE ONLY THING WE NEED IS THE
- 20:41WILL.
- 20:41I'M SURE WE CAN GET THERE IF WE
- 20:43HAVE THE WILL.
- 20:44>> .
- 20:45>> Renee: IS THERE A WILL TO DIP
- 20:48INTO THE RAINY DAY FUND?
- 20:49>> FIRST OF ALL, OLDHAM COUNTY
- 20:51WAS BROUGHT UP TWICE HERE SO I
- 20:53FEEL LIKE I NEED TO CHIME IN ON
- 20:56BEHALF OF THE TAXPAYERS OF
- 20:58OLDHAM COUNTY WHO PAY ONE OF THE
- 21:00HIGHEST TAX RATES OF ANY SCHOOL
- 21:01TAX IN THE STATE.
- 21:02AND THEY ARE A SEEK LOSER.
- 21:05AND THE WAY IT ALL METES OUT.
- 21:06AND THE OTHER THING THAT IS
- 21:09DISPROPORTIONATE IN THE SEEK
- 21:11FORMULA AND I DISAGREE WITH
- 21:13ROBERT DOING EVERYTHING THROUGH
- 21:14THE SEEK, IS THE SEEK FORMULA
- 21:18ONLY ALLOCATES STATE DOLLARS.
- 21:20IT DOESN'T ACCOUNT FOR THE
- 21:22DISPROPORTIONATE USE OF FEDERAL
- 21:25DOLLARS TITLE IX DOLLARS THAT
- 21:29DRAMATICALLY CHANGE BUDGETS.
- 21:31THE TEACHERS IN JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 21:35ON HOLD 15 MINUTES DOWN THE ROAD
- 21:37FROM OLDHAM COUNTY ARE MAKING
- 21:4015, 20,000 MORE THAN OLDHAM
- 21:43COUNTY TEACHERS ARE BECAUSE OF
- 21:44THE ABILITY TO LEVERAGE FEDERAL
- 21:46DOLLARS I DO THINK IT'S
- 21:47APPROPRIATE IN CERTAIN CASES
- 21:49PARTICULARLY IN THE SUBURBAN
- 21:50AREAS THAT ARE FACING THAT
- 21:52CRUNCH FROM THE LARGE URBAN
- 21:54DISTRICTS GETTING A LOT OF
- 21:56DIFFERENTIAL DOLLARS.
- 21:57I DO THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE TO
- 21:59STEP OUTSIDE THE SEEK FORMULA
- 22:00FROM TIME TO TIME ESPECIALLY TO
- 22:03ADDRESS TRANSPORTATION DOLLARS
- 22:04WHICH GETS TO THE ACTUAL BOTTOM
- 22:06LINE OF INDIVIDUAL SCHOOL
- 22:08DISTRICTS.
- 22:09SO I THINK YOU'VE HEARD ME SAY
- 22:11REGARDING RAINY DAY FUND YOU
- 22:14HEARD ME SAY ALL ALONG WE ARE
- 22:16GOING TO END THIS FISCAL YEAR
- 22:18WITH MORE MONEY IN THAT FUND
- 22:19THAN WE NEED.
- 22:21SO THEREFORE I THINK WE NEED TO
- 22:23MAKE VERY, VERY THOUGHTFUL
- 22:27INVESTMENTS HISTORIC INVESTMENTS
- 22:29ONE TIME DOLLARS THEY NEED TO BE
- 22:31FOR ONE TIME ISSUES.
- 22:32>> Renee: LIKE WHAT?
- 22:34>> INFRASTRUCTURE, PAYMENT OF
- 22:38PENSION DEBT, I KNOW IT'S NOT A
- 22:42SEXY THING TO SPEND MONEY ON BUT
- 22:44WE'VE MADE INCREDIBLE PROGRESS
- 22:45IN PAYING DOWN OUR UNFUNDED
- 22:48PENSION LIABILITY OVER THE LAST
- 22:49SEVEN YEARS.
- 22:50WE ARE STILL $30 BILLION
- 22:53UNFUNDED IN OUR PENSION SYSTEMS.
- 22:55>> Renee: WHEN THE TIER ONE AND
- 22:57TIER TWO PEOPLE GO WHO IS
- 22:59CONTINUING TO PAY?
- 23:00>> IT CONTINUES TO BE THE STATE.
- 23:02WE'RE CONTINUING TO COMMIT 15%
- 23:04OF OUR GENERAL FUND TO PENSION
- 23:07SYSTEMS.
- 23:07AND THAT IS NOT AN EXCITING
- 23:10THING TO SPEND MOAN ON.
- 23:12BUT --
- 23:12MONEY ON BUT IT'S ESSENTIAL THAT
- 23:15WE CONTINUE TO PAY THAT DEBT
- 23:16DOWN.
- 23:17AND YEAR AFTER YEAR AFTER YEAR
- 23:19IF WE CONTINUE TO PAY THAT DEBT
- 23:20DOWN IT DOES FREE UP MONEY.
- 23:22IT FREES UP THAT DEBT SERVICE
- 23:24THAT WE'RE CONTINUING TO BE
- 23:27SHACKLED WITH.
- 23:28>> Renee: ALL RIGHT.
- 23:29LET'S TALK ABOUT A COUPLE
- 23:30EDUCATION ISSUES.
- 23:32SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 23:33>> PEOPLE HEAR US TALK ABOUT
- 23:36BUDGET RESERVE TRUST FUNDS AND
- 23:39RAINY DAY FUNDS AND ONE TIME
- 23:41EXPENDITURES PEOPLE NEED TO
- 23:42UNDERSTAND THIS IN THE REALM OF
- 23:44THEIR OWN DAILY LIFESTYLE.
- 23:46YOU DON'T HAVE TO REPLACE A ROOF
- 23:47EVERY YEAR.
- 23:48THAT IS WHAT YOU HAVE A SAVINGS
- 23:50ACCOUNT FOR.
- 23:52THAT IS THE EQUIVALENT OF ONE
- 23:54TIME EXPENDITURE FOR SOMETHING
- 23:54YOU HAVE IN THE SAVINGS ACCOUNT.
- 23:56WE DON'T AND YOU SHOULD NEVER
- 23:59BECAUSE ALL THE ECONOMISTS LEFT
- 24:01OR RIGHT LEANING USE ONE TIME
- 24:06DOLLARS THAT SAVINGS ACCOUNT TO
- 24:07PAY YOUR MONTHLY ELECTRIC BILL.
- 24:09THAT IS A RECURRING EXPENSE THAT
- 24:12COMES THROUGH AND YOU ARE
- 24:13BURNING YOUR SAVINGS ACCOUNT
- 24:15BECAUSE YOUR INCOME IS NOT
- 24:17SUFFICIENT.
- 24:18SO WE SHOULD NEVER USE ONE TIME
- 24:20DOLLARS TO PAY RECURRING
- 24:23EXPENSES.
- 24:24AND I DON'T DISAGREE WITH DAVID
- 24:26ON THAT.
- 24:27I'M SAYING YOU HAVE TO BE
- 24:28CAREFUL WHEN YOU GO OUTSIDE THE
- 24:29SEEK FORMULA TO START
- 24:32APPROPRIATING LARGE SUMS OF
- 24:34MONEY FOR TEACHER PAY RAISES
- 24:35BECAUSE THAT IS GOING TO SKEW
- 24:37PLACES WE CAN ARE IN THE REALMS
- 24:41OF TRANSPORTATION.
- 24:41>> AND YET, WE ARE IN A
- 24:44SITUATION NOW WHERE WE ARE
- 24:46MAKING A MAD DASH TO ZERO IN
- 24:48TERMS OF INCOME TAX PAYMENTS.
- 24:51IN OTHER WORDS, SOMEWHERE YOU
- 24:53TALK ABOUT RECURRING FUNDS AND
- 24:55BEING ABLE TO REPLACE FUNDS THAT
- 24:56IS WHERE THAT IS.
- 24:58SOMEWHERE THAT IS GOING TO HAVE
- 25:00TO BE COVERED OR ELIMINATED AND
- 25:03YOU WILL NOT DO THE THINGS.
- 25:05IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT ONE
- 25:07TIME DOLLARS FACT OF THE MATTER
- 25:08AT THE SAME TIME WE ARE IN A
- 25:12PROCESS THAT THEORETICALLY COULD
- 25:14END UP PUTTING STRICTURES ON OUR
- 25:19ABILITY TO DEAL ARE RECURRING
- 25:21FUNDS.
- 25:21THERE A CONTRADICTION HERE.
- 25:22NOT NECESSARILY THAT WOULD BE
- 25:24THE OUTCOME DEPENDS ON THE
- 25:26DECISIONS WE MAKE AND DO THE
- 25:27THINGS IN CERTAIN WAYS WE MAKE
- 25:28SURE WE CAN DEAL WITH THE
- 25:30RECURRING COSTS.
- 25:31I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD STRANGLE
- 25:33OUR CAPACITY TO ADVANCE OUR
- 25:35STATE BECAUSE WE HAVE SOME
- 25:38PHILOSOPHICAL PIECE THAT DOESN'T
- 25:40ADDRESS WHAT WE NEED TO DO TO
- 25:41MOVE INTO THE FUTURE.
- 25:43>> Renee: COUPLE OF EDUCATION
- 25:44ISSUES.
- 25:45SCHOOL CHOICE.
- 25:46SO CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT ON
- 25:47THAT.
- 25:48WOULD THAT COME FROM THE HOUSE?
- 25:50>> I'M NOT SURE WHAT CHAMBER IT
- 25:52WILL START IN.
- 25:53BOTH CHAMBERS ARE WORKING ON A
- 25:55PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT WOULD
- 25:56DO THAT.
- 25:58I THINK THERE'S SIGNIFICANT
- 25:59SUPPORT IN OUR CAUCUS CERTAINLY.
- 26:02>> Renee: IT'S BEEN A CLOSE VOTE
- 26:03IN THE PAST.
- 26:03>> IT HAS BEEN.
- 26:06AND I THINK THAT IT'S OBVIOUSLY
- 26:08IT'S NOT ONE THAT IS GOING TO
- 26:10HAVE OVERWHELMING 90-10 SUPPORT.
- 26:15BUT I DO THINK THERE ARE 60
- 26:17VOTES IN THE HOUSE TO PASS IT.
- 26:18AND I DO BELIEVE WE WILL PASS
- 26:20IT.
- 26:21>> Renee: WHAT SAY YOU Mr.
- 26:23PRESIDENT?
- 26:25SAME?
- 26:25>> IT'S VIRTUALLY THE SAME IDEA.
- 26:28>> .
- 26:30>> Renee: DO YOU CARE TO COMMENT
- 26:31ON PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL
- 26:34AMENDMENT ON SCHOOL CHOICE LET
- 26:35THE VOTERS DECIDE?
- 26:36>> LET ME SAY THIS IN.
- 26:38THE RURAL AREAS ACROSS KENTUCKY
- 26:40THE MAJOR PLYER WITHIN --
- 26:43EMPLOYER WITHIN THOSE SMALL
- 26:44COMMUNITIES ARE THE BOARDS OF
- 26:46EDUCATION.
- 26:48AND THINK ABOUT TAKING PUBLIC
- 26:51DOLLARS AND APPROPRIATING MONEY
- 26:54TO PAROCHIAL OR PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 26:56I HAVE NOTHING AGAINST PAROCHIAL
- 26:58OR PRIVATE SCHOOLS.
- 26:59THAT IS A CHOICE FOR PARENTS TO
- 27:01MAKE.
- 27:01>> Renee: AND YOU MADE THAT
- 27:02CHOICE.
- 27:02>> I MADE THAT CHOICE AND I MADE
- 27:04IT IN TERMS OF LETTING PEOPLE
- 27:06KNOW.
- 27:06BUT MY WIFE AND I WE MADE THAT
- 27:09DECISION TO PUT THEM IN A
- 27:11PRIVATE SCHOOL.
- 27:12BUT TO TURN AROUND AND GIVE
- 27:15PUBLIC DOLLARS OF WHICH THE
- 27:17TAXPAYERS HAVE PAID INTO OUR
- 27:20BUDGET AND INTO OUR REVENUE
- 27:23WOULD BE WRONG AND IT WOULD GO
- 27:25AGAINST ALL THE THINGS IN WHICH
- 27:27THE CONSTITUTION OF KENTUCKY
- 27:29ESTABLISHES THAT WE MUST HAVE
- 27:31PUBLIC EDUCATION AND IT MUST BE
- 27:35PROVIDED BY THE PUBLIC IN TERMS
- 27:37OF TAXES THAT PUT INTO OUR
- 27:42TREASURY.
- 27:42SO THAT IS THE PROBLEM THAT I
- 27:44HAVE.
- 27:45AND RENEE, IT'S OLD HISTORY
- 27:47TEACHER THE FACT OF THE MATTER
- 27:48AND I USE THIS SEVERAL TIMES,
- 27:50WHEN THE COUNTRY WAS ESTABLISHED
- 27:53AND A DEMOCRATIC PROCESS WAS PUT
- 27:54IN PLACE, THE ONE THING THAT THE
- 27:57FOUNDING FATHERS SAID WE HAVE TO
- 28:00ESTABLISH PUBLIC EDUCATION.
- 28:02IN ORDER TO PRESERVE OUR
- 28:05DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES AND TO
- 28:07ALLOW THE DEMOCRATIC SYSTEM OF
- 28:08GOVERNMENT TO OPERATE.
- 28:10BECAUSE WE CAN EDUCATE PEOPLE TO
- 28:13KNOW HOW A GOVERNMENT IT IS A
- 28:18DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC GOVERNMENT
- 28:19WORKS.
- 28:20AND IT ALLOWS PEOPLE TO NOT ONLY
- 28:23LEARN, BUT ALSO TO THRIVE IN AN
- 28:26ECONOMIC SYSTEM THAT WE'VE
- 28:28CREATED.
- 28:29>> Renee: LEADER NEAL?
- 28:30>> I THINK IF YOU MAKE A POLICY
- 28:32DECISION TO TAKE TAXPAYER MONEY
- 28:35AND DIVERT THAT TO THE SO-CALLED
- 28:38CHOICE SYSTEMS THEN YOU ARE
- 28:41DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY
- 28:43COMPROMISING YOUR ABILITY TO
- 28:44DEAL WITH THE NEEDS OF THE
- 28:45PUBLIC SYSTEM WHICH WE ARE
- 28:47CONSTITUTIONALLY BOUND TO DEAL
- 28:49WITH.
- 28:50SO I THINK YOU KNOW, I AGREE
- 28:52WITH LEADER GRAHAM THAT IF
- 28:55PARENTS WANT THEIR KIDS TO GO TO
- 28:57VARIOUS OTHER SCHOOLS THAT'S
- 28:59FINE I HAVE NO PROBLEMS WITH
- 29:00THAT.
- 29:00BUT WE SHOULD NEVER, NEVER,
- 29:03COMPROMISE THE NEEDS OF A PUBLIC
- 29:06EDUCATION SYSTEM.
- 29:06AND I THINK THAT GOING INTO THIS
- 29:09DIRECTION NECESSARILY AND
- 29:10ABSOLUTELY TAKES AWAY FROM OUR
- 29:13CAPACITY TO DO SO.
- 29:16>> Renee: MAKE A HARD PIVOT TO
- 29:17TALK ABOUT THINGS HAPPENING
- 29:20TOMORROW.
- 29:21WE'LL START WITH THE LEADER ONE
- 29:23OF THE OTHER LEADERS IN THE
- 29:26SENATE, SENATOR YATDS WHO IS
- 29:28YOUR MINORITY WHIP IS GOING TO
- 29:29FILE OR HAS FILED OR WILL BY THE
- 29:31TIME THIS PRESSER HAPPENS
- 29:33TOMORROW MORNING, A BILL TO
- 29:35CREATE LIMITED EXCEPTIONS TO
- 29:37KENTUCKY'S TRIGGER LAW FOR
- 29:38SURVIVORS OF RAPE AND INCEST AND
- 29:41NONVIABLE PREGNANCIES AND HEALTH
- 29:43OF A PREGNANT WOMAN.
- 29:45YOUR TAKE ON THE NECESSITY OF
- 29:48DOING THIS NOW AND NOT WAITING?
- 29:49>> WELL, YOU KNOW, I HAVE A MORE
- 29:54FUNDAMENTAL POSITION ON THAT.
- 29:56AND MY POSITION ON THAT IS THAT
- 30:00A STATE GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT BE
- 30:02DIRECTING A WOMAN HOW SHE
- 30:05CONTROLS HER BODY AND HER HEALTH
- 30:07CHOICES WITH RESPECT TO THAT.
- 30:08I KNOW IT IS A COMPLEX ISSUE.
- 30:10BUT I DON'T THINK THE STATE
- 30:12SHOULD BE DOING THAT SORT OF
- 30:13THING.
- 30:14THAT IS BETWEEN A WOMAN, HER
- 30:16DOCTOR AND HER GOD.
- 30:17YOU KNOW, WHEN THE STATE COMES
- 30:19IN AND BEGINS TO MANDATE HOW AN
- 30:22INDIVIDUAL IS TO HANDLE THEIR
- 30:23CHOICES IN LIFE AS IT RELATES TO
- 30:25THEIR HEALTH, AS IT RELATES TO
- 30:27THE THINGS THAT ARE PERSON
- 30:30PERSONAL TO THEM WE'RE
- 30:34OVERREACHING.
- 30:34>> Renee: PRESIDENT STIVERS IF I
- 30:36REMEMBER CORRECTLY YOU ARE
- 30:37QUOTED AS BEING OPEN TO THIS
- 30:40DISCUSSION?
- 30:41HOW DO YOU FEEL BECAUSE THIS
- 30:42COULD COME BEFORE A COMMITTEE
- 30:44MAYBE IF IT IS ASSIGNED TO ONE.
- 30:46AND BE ACTED ON IN THE SENATE?
- 30:47>> IT WILL BE ASSIGNED TO A
- 30:49COMMITTEE.
- 30:51LET'S START WITH ONE PREMISE I
- 30:54WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERYBODY
- 30:56UNDERSTANDS.
- 30:57ALWAYS SAID THERE'S NO
- 30:58EXCEPTIONS IN THE LAW.
- 30:59THERE IS.
- 31:00ALWAYS HAS BEEN.
- 31:01>> Renee: FOR THE LIFE OF THE
- 31:03MOTHER.
- 31:03>> SO WHEN PEOPLE WALKOUT AND
- 31:05SAY THERE'S NO EXCEPTIONS THAT
- 31:07IS BLATANTLY WRONG.
- 31:09NOW, HERE'S WHERE I THINK
- 31:12PROBABLY 97% OF THE POPULATION
- 31:13WOULD AGREE.
- 31:17LATE TERM ABORTIONS.
- 31:18A VIABLE CHILD THAT IF TAKEN
- 31:21FROM THE WOMB AT
- 31:23SEVEN-AND-A-HALF, EIGHT MONTHS
- 31:24COULD LIVE, LATE TERM ABORTION.
- 31:27I HEARD A YOUNG LADY TESTIFY SHE
- 31:30DID THIS BECAUSE OF ECONOMICS.
- 31:31I DON'T THINK PEOPLE AGREE WITH
- 31:34THAT.
- 31:35WHERE IT BECOMES TOUGH IS WHEN
- 31:36YOU START MOVING BACK IN-BETWEEN
- 31:39THOSE POINTS IN TIME.
- 31:42ABOUT VIABILITY, HEALTH OF THE
- 31:45MOTHER, WHY THE MOTHER IS
- 31:47PREGNANT AND I SAY THAT LOOK,
- 31:49EVERYONE OF US AROUND HERE
- 31:52UNDERSTAND THE TRAUMA DON'T
- 31:56UNDERSTAND WE KNOW THAT THERE
- 31:57WILL BE TRAUMA WHERE THERE IS AN
- 32:00ACT OF INCEST OR RAPE.
- 32:02THAT'S TOUGH.
- 32:03THAT'S WHERE IT GETS HARD TO
- 32:06DECIDE WHEN YOU THEN HAVE A
- 32:07WOMAN AND I DON'T THINK ANYBODY
- 32:09WOULD DISAGREE WITH THIS, THE
- 32:11WRAP AROUND SERVICES FOR THIS
- 32:14WOMAN WHATEVER HER DECISION IS,
- 32:16WE SHOULD MAKE SURE SHE HAS AND
- 32:18ANYBODY WHO PERPETRATES THAT
- 32:20TYPE OF ACT ON A WOMAN SHOULD BE
- 32:24SWIFTLY PUNISHED AND HARSHLY
- 32:27PUNISHED.
- 32:28BUT IT'S REALLY TOUGH WHEN YOU
- 32:29GET TO THAT VIABILITY OF A
- 32:32CHILD.
- 32:33AT WHAT POINT?
- 32:36VERSUS THAT BALANCE OF A WOMAN
- 32:38WHO IS NOT EVEN IN A RAPE OR
- 32:40INCEST SCENARIO.
- 32:42THEN IT GETS TOUGHER WHEN YOU
- 32:45HAVE THAT.
- 32:45DO YOU UNDERSTAND?
- 32:47AND AGAIN, UNDERSTAND YOU ARE
- 32:50TALKING TO FOUR MALES HERE.
- 32:51WE CAN'T COMPREHEND.
- 32:54WE CAN ONLY EMPATHIZE.
- 32:56BUT THAT BECOMES A VERY
- 32:58DIFFICULT CHOICE FOR REPUBLICANS
- 33:00AND DEMOCRATS IN EITHER CHAMBER.
- 33:02AND SO THERE IS A LOT OF
- 33:04DISCUSSION.
- 33:04I DO NOT KNOW WHAT THE OUTCOME
- 33:06WILL BE.
- 33:08>> Renee: SPEAKER OSBORNE?
- 33:09>> WE DO CONTINUE TO HAVE
- 33:11CONSIDERABLE DEBATE OVER IT.
- 33:12IT COMES UP FREQUENTLY IN OUR
- 33:15CAUCUS DISCUSSIONS.
- 33:17>> Renee: THE WHIP HAD FILED
- 33:19THIS MEASURE SIMILAR MEASURE.
- 33:21>> SO IT IS AN ONGOING
- 33:23DISCUSSION.
- 33:24WE'VE YET TO REACH CONSENSUS ON
- 33:28WHAT WE'RE CAPABLE OF DOING AS A
- 33:31CAUCUS MOVING FORWARD.
- 33:32BUT WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
- 33:33HAVE THE CONVERSATIONS.
- 33:36I'M WITH ROBERT I'M NOT SURE
- 33:37WHERE WE WILL END UP ON IT.
- 33:39>> Renee: THERE IS ANOTHER BILL
- 33:40TO CONSIDER FROM YOUR SENATE
- 33:43JUDICIARY CHAIRMAN WHITNEY
- 33:45WESTERFIELD THE SENATE BILL 34
- 33:48THE ALPHA ACT THAT WOULD ALLOW
- 33:50FOR REQUIRE PREGNANCY SUPPORTS
- 33:51WHEN IT COMES TO CHILDCARE AND
- 33:53TUITION ASSISTANCE HOUSING
- 33:55ASSISTANCE TO DO WHAT YOU
- 33:56MENTIONED.
- 33:57SO HOW DOES YOUR CAUCUS FEEL
- 33:59ABOUT THAT MEASURE?
- 34:00>> I HAVEN'T SEEN SENATE BILL 34
- 34:02SO I'M NOT SURE ABOUT THE
- 34:03DETAILS.
- 34:04IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT WRAP
- 34:05AROUND SERVICES FOR THAT YOUNG
- 34:08WOMAN AND MAYBE OLDER WOMAN, BUT
- 34:10THE WOMAN, THOSE SERVICES NEED
- 34:13TO BE PROVIDED AND ASSISTANCE.
- 34:16THIS IS A TOUGH TIME.
- 34:17>> Renee: IT IS A HALF A MILLION
- 34:19PRICE DAK 551 MILLION.
- 34:22>> THAT IS NOT HALF A MILLION.
- 34:24>> HALF A BILLION.
- 34:25THOSE NUMBERS ARE SO HIGH I
- 34:28CAN'T SAY IT RIGHT.
- 34:29HALF A BILLION DOLLARS OVER THE
- 34:31NEXT TWO YEARS.
- 34:31>> THE SERVICES IN THE QUANTIFY
- 34:34INDICATION OF THE NUMBERS I HAVE
- 34:35NOT SEEN.
- 34:36DIDN'T KNOW HE WAS GOING TO FILE
- 34:38IT.
- 34:38I HAVE NOT READ THROUGH IT.
- 34:40>> Renee: HE MENTIONED THAT THE
- 34:43BILL REQUEST FORM WHEN IT CAME
- 34:44OUT LIKE IN THE FALL WE ASKED
- 34:47THE GUBERNATORIAL CANDIDATES DO
- 34:48YOU CHAIR TO CHIME IN ON THIS
- 34:52ABOUT SUPPORTING PREGNANCY
- 34:53SUPPORTS WE'LL CALL IT FOR
- 34:55SHORT.
- 34:55IS THIS SOMETHING THAT THE
- 34:57DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS AND THE HOUSE
- 34:58COULD GET BEHIND?
- 34:58>> I KNOW THIS.
- 35:01OUR CAUCUS IS VERY STRONG IN
- 35:02TERMS OF A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO HAVE
- 35:06ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE.
- 35:07AND THAT IS WHAT IT COMES DOWN
- 35:09TO, PHYSICAL AS WELL AS MENTAL
- 35:12HEALTHCARE.
- 35:13AS A FATHER OF TWO DAUGHTERS, I
- 35:16WANT MY YOUNG LADIES TO BE ABLE
- 35:17TO MAKE DECISIONS ON THEIR OWN
- 35:20ABOUT THEIR HEALTHCARE, BUT ALSO
- 35:23ABOUT WHAT DECISIONS THEY WANT
- 35:24TO MAKE WHEN IT COMES TO THEIR
- 35:26BODIES.
- 35:29AND SO I'VE ALWAYS BEEN
- 35:34PRO-CHOICE.
- 35:35BECAUSE OF THE FACTORS THAT GO
- 35:36WITH IT.
- 35:37EVERYONE HAS A DIFFERENT STORY
- 35:38IN TERMS OF WHY THEY MAKE THAT
- 35:43DECISION.
- 35:43BUT WHAT REALLY BOTHERS ME IS
- 35:45THAT IT IS AND I DON'T WANT TO
- 35:47GO DOWN THIS PATH BUT IT IS SO
- 35:49IRONIC THAT THE PARTY THAT IS
- 35:51ALWAYS TALKED ABOUT LESS
- 35:53GOVERNMENT IS INVADING ON THE
- 35:55RIGHTS OF INDIVIDUALS DEALING
- 35:57WITH THEIR INDIVIDUAL PROBLEMS
- 36:00OR INDIVIDUAL SITUATION IN WHICH
- 36:02THEY HAVE PUT THEMSELVES IN.
- 36:04I'VE NEVER UNDERSTOOD THAT.
- 36:05HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT YOU ARE FOR
- 36:08PEOPLE TO HAVE THE RIGHTS TO
- 36:09MAKE DECISIONS ON YOUR OWN.
- 36:11THEY USE THAT IN TERMS OF THE
- 36:13GUN LOBBY HAS ALWAYS USED THAT
- 36:16TERMINOLOGY WHEN IT COMES TO
- 36:17GUNS.
- 36:18BUT, YET, THEY DON'T RESPECT A
- 36:20WOMAN'S RIGHT TO DECIDE ABOUT
- 36:23HER HEALTHCARE.
- 36:23>> Renee: I WILL GIVE YOU ALL AN
- 36:25OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND TO THAT.
- 36:26I WILL ASK A POLITICAL QUESTION
- 36:27ABOUT IT.
- 36:28THE POLITICAL CALCULUS OF NOT
- 36:30ACTING ON IT IN AN ELECTION YEAR
- 36:33WHEN YOUR MEMBERS ARE UP SOME OF
- 36:35WHOM ARE NOT RETURNING BUT THE
- 36:37CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT NUMBER
- 36:38TWO PROPOSED WAS SOUNDLY
- 36:41REJECTED.
- 36:41PEOPLE WOULD SAY THAT GOVERNOR
- 36:42BESHEAR PART OF HIS VICTORY
- 36:45COMES FROM HADLEY DUVAL FEATURED
- 36:48IN THAT AD TALKING ABOUT BEING
- 36:51RAPED BY A GRANDPARENT AT AN
- 36:54EARLY, EARLY PRETEEN AGE.
- 36:57IS IT A LOSING ISSUE FOR
- 36:59REPUBLICANS?
- 37:00>> WELL, DEPENDS HOW YOU DEFINE
- 37:02LOSING.
- 37:04TO THIS AND I RESPOND TO
- 37:07REPRESENTATIVE GRAHAM, WHEN YOU
- 37:09KNOW THAT AT 8 MONTHS THIS CHILD
- 37:15CAN LIVE AND IS VIABLE OUTSIDE
- 37:17THE WOMB, I REALLY HAVE A HARD
- 37:21TIME SAYING THAT THE PUBLIC IN
- 37:25GENERAL DOESN'T THINK THAT THE
- 37:28LEGISLATURE OR LEGISLATIVE BODY
- 37:29SHOULD BE ABLE TO SPEAK FOR WHAT
- 37:32IS A VIABLE, LIVING BEING.
- 37:38AND SO I CAN THINK OF MY
- 37:40DAUGHTERS OR MY SONS THAT IF IT
- 37:43GOT TO THAT POINT, I'D SAY HAVE
- 37:45THE CHILD I'LL RAISE IT.
- 37:48THAT'S ME.
- 37:51AS TO THE POLITICS, THIS IS A
- 37:54DEEP PERSONAL ISSUE ON EITHER
- 37:55SIDE OF THE ISSUE.
- 37:56SO I'M NOT GOING TO BE
- 37:58JUDGMENTAL.
- 37:59THIS IS GOING TO HAVE TO COME
- 38:00DOWN TO YOUR PERSONAL
- 38:03CONVICTIONS.
- 38:03AND IT'S NOT A POLITICAL
- 38:05CALCULUS.
- 38:06IF YOU WANT TO MAKE IT A
- 38:09POLITICAL CALCULUS, ELECTIONS
- 38:10ARE WON ON MULTIPLE ISSUES NOT A
- 38:13SINGLE ISSUE.
- 38:14DOES IT HURT YOU?
- 38:16DEPENDING ON THE AREA YOU ARE
- 38:16IN.
- 38:18DEPENDING ON THE TYPE OF
- 38:18CAMPAIGN YOU ARE RUNNING.
- 38:20SOME PEOPLE THOUGHT IT HURT THE
- 38:22REPUBLICAN NOMINEE MORE THAN HE
- 38:25FLIP-FLOPPED ON THE ISSUE.
- 38:27SO THE ISSUE IS IN THIS
- 38:30SITUATION VERY PERSONAL TO EACH
- 38:32AND EVERY PERSON AND I'M NOT
- 38:34GOING TO TELL THEM.
- 38:35YOU HAVE TO LOOK INSIDE YOUR
- 38:37HEART AND YOUR SOUL AND MAKE A
- 38:38DECISION WHAT YOU THINK YOU NEED
- 38:39TO DO AND I WILL NOT BE
- 38:41JUDGMENTAL NO MATTER WHAT THE
- 38:43DECISION IS.
- 38:43>> AND YET, THE STATE, IS DOING
- 38:46JUST THAT.
- 38:47THEY ARE MAKING A CALCULATION,
- 38:50THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT WHAT I
- 38:51THINK SHOULD BE DONE AS OPPOSED
- 38:52TO THE INDIVIDUAL WHO HAS THE
- 38:56BODY.
- 38:56I THINK IT DOES GET DICEY WHEN
- 38:59YOU GET TO THE QUESTION OF
- 39:01VIABILITY.
- 39:01THERE IS NO QUESTION ABOUT THAT.
- 39:03BUT WHAT IS THAT POINT?
- 39:07WHO KNOWS.
- 39:07WHERE SHOULD THAT POINT BE?
- 39:09AT SOME POINT, AT SOME POINT
- 39:11IT'S NOT RATIONAL AND NOT
- 39:13APPROPRIATE FOR THE STATE TO
- 39:16TELL SOMEONE TO COMPROMISE THEIR
- 39:19HEALTH FOR INSTANCE BECAUSE
- 39:20SOMEONE ELSE OUTSIDE THE STATE
- 39:22SAYS THIS IS HOW YOU ARE GOING
- 39:23TO DO THIS.
- 39:24NOW, WHERE DO YOU FIND THE
- 39:26DIVIDING POINT HERE?
- 39:27AND IT'S PROBLEMATIC.
- 39:30SO YOU KNOW, I GUESS IT'S EASY
- 39:32FOR ME TO SIT HERE AND SAY WELL,
- 39:35THE STATE SHOULDN'T BE INVOLVED.
- 39:37BUT AT SOME POINT THE STATE
- 39:38SHOULD NOT BE INVOLVED AT LEAST
- 39:40IN TERMS OF THAT ARGUMENT.
- 39:41AND IT GIVES ME MAJOR CONCERN
- 39:43WITH RESPECT TO THAT.
- 39:44IF YOU ASK ME PERSONALLY WHERE I
- 39:46STAND ON THAT?
- 39:47I HAVE ALL KINDS OF RESERVATIONS
- 39:49ABOUT THIS QUESTION WHEN YOU GET
- 39:51TO THE QUESTION OF VIABILITY.
- 39:53I'M HESITATING PERSONALLY
- 39:55MYSELF.
- 39:55BUT HERE IS THE STATE.
- 39:57A COLLECTIVE GROUP OF PEOPLE
- 39:58MAKING SOME JUDGMENTS AND IF YOU
- 40:00LOOK AROUND THE VARIOUS STATES
- 40:01IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
- 40:02THEY ARE GOING FROM ZERO TO
- 40:04WHATEVER THE NUMBER IS.
- 40:07SO THIS IS A TOUGH QUESTION.
- 40:09GRANT TED.
- 40:09BUT I THINK IT'S ONE THAT WE
- 40:11SHOULD BE VERY SLOW TO EXTENDING
- 40:13CONTROL OVER A PERSON'S DECISION
- 40:15MAKING OVER THEIR HEALTH AND
- 40:17OVER THEIR BODY.
- 40:18>> Renee: WE'LL SEE IFER IN
- 40:21YATES PROPOSED BILL ACTUALLY
- 40:24DEFINES VIABILITY.
- 40:26THERE WOULD HAVE TO BE
- 40:27DEFINITIONS, RIGHT?
- 40:28SO WE'LL SEE IF THAT HAPPENS
- 40:30ONCE IT'S FILED.
- 40:31>> WE HAVE A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS
- 40:33A TOUGH PIVOT FROM WHAT WE WERE
- 40:34TALKING ABOUT.
- 40:35LET ME GO BACK TO THIS QUESTION
- 40:37ABOUT THE ABORTION PILL.
- 40:39THIS IS FROM JIM M. ASKING ABOUT
- 40:42THE ABORTION BILL.
- 40:43SO I THINK WE'VE DISCUSSED THAT
- 40:45WE'LL MOVE ON AND GO BACK TO THE
- 40:49HAZARDOUS TIER 3 EMPLOYEES
- 40:50QUESTION FROM BOIL COUNTY.
- 40:54ASK SENATOR STIVERS WHERE THEY
- 40:56STAND ON CONVERTING HAZARDOUS
- 40:58TIER 3 STATE EMPLOYEES TO
- 41:02HAZARDOUS TIER 2 STATE
- 41:03EMPLOYEES?
- 41:03>> THERE'S ONGOING DISCUSSION
- 41:07ABOUT THE COST AND BENEFITS OF
- 41:10THAT PPOB IS DOING AN ANALYSIS
- 41:13TO SEE WHAT THE IMPACT.
- 41:15>> Renee: THE PUBLIC PENSION
- 41:17OVERSIGHT BOARD.
- 41:18>> JIM ANY HICK AND TJ JOHNSON
- 41:22CHAIR THOSE THAT COMMITTEE FOR
- 41:24US.
- 41:24I DON'T THINK THERE IS AN
- 41:27ABSOLUTE REJECTION OF THE IDEA.
- 41:29BUT THERE'S ALSO A CONSTANT
- 41:32AWARENESS OF THE STRIDES WE HAVE
- 41:33MADE IN PAYING DOWN OUR PENSION
- 41:35LIABILITIES OVER THE LAST SEVEN
- 41:37YEARS.
- 41:37SO EVERYTHING WE DO THAT IMPACTS
- 41:40THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY, AFFECTS
- 41:45THE ACTUARIAL ANALYSIS OF OUR
- 41:48PENSION SYSTEMS WE LOOK AT IT
- 41:49WITH A WARY EYE.
- 41:51>> Renee: SO THE GOVERNOR
- 41:53PROPOSED I WILL PUT THIS INTO
- 41:56THE LANGUAGE PEOPLE WILL YOU
- 41:57HAD, THE GOVERNOR PROPOSED FOR
- 41:59STATE POLICE TO BE RETURNED BACK
- 42:00TO THE DEFINED BENEFIT PLAN
- 42:03INSTEAD OF THE DEFINED
- 42:05CONTRIBUTION THAT IS WHAT THAT
- 42:08MEANS?
- 42:08>> SENATOR NEAL TALKED ABOUT
- 42:10BEING RESPONSIBLE AND HOW WE'VE
- 42:12BEEN RESPONSIBLE AND ALL THIS
- 42:14MAYBE IT WAS REPRESENTATIVE
- 42:15DWRAM, I CAN'T REMEMBER.
- 42:16THAT IS WHERE YOU HAVE TO BE
- 42:18RESPONSIBLE WHAT YOUR
- 42:19CONTRIBUTIONS ARE AND WHAT
- 42:20SPEAKER OSBORNE SAYS, BECAUSE
- 42:22THEREFORE MANY, MANY YEARS
- 42:23PEOPLE DIDN'T LOOK AT ACTUARIAL
- 42:27SOUNDNESS.
- 42:27AND WHAT THE IMPACT WAS AND I
- 42:32GAVE PAUL PATTEN CREDIT FOR THE
- 42:34FORD PLANT BECAUSE THAT WAS
- 42:36THERE.
- 42:36AND ALSO DURING PAUL PATTEN
- 42:40ADMINISTRATION THEN BUDGET
- 42:41DIRECTOR RAMSEY SAID WE DON'T
- 42:43NEED TO MAKE A COUPLE YEAR
- 42:45CONTRIBUTIONS THAT WAS A
- 42:47CATASTROPHIC MISTAKE.
- 42:48BECAUSE YOU NOT ONLY LOSE YOUR
- 42:52CONTRIBUTION, YOU LOSE 30 YEARS
- 42:54OF ACTUARIAL COMPOUNDING TO PAY
- 42:57FUTURE YEAR OBLIGATIONS.
- 42:58ANYTHING YOU DO WILL RIPPLE NOT
- 43:01JUST THIS YEAR BUT IT WILL
- 43:03RIPPLE FOR 30 YEARS OUT.
- 43:04SO YOU HAVE TO BE AWARE OF THAT,
- 43:07ESPECIALLY WHEN WE HAVE SUCH AN
- 43:08UNFUNDED LIABILITY.
- 43:09NOT SAYING WE CAN'T, NOT SAYING
- 43:11WE CAN.
- 43:12BUT YOU HAVE TO DO THE ANALYSIS
- 43:13FIRST.
- 43:15>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENT ON
- 43:16THAT BEFORE WE TALK ABOUT PUBLIC
- 43:18SAFETY?
- 43:18THIS IS A BIG ISSUE ON A LOT OF
- 43:20PEOPLE'S MINDS PARTICULARLY
- 43:22THOSE WHO LIVE IN MORE URBAN
- 43:24AREAS IT'S HAPPENING ALL OVER
- 43:25THE STATE AND THE NATION.
- 43:27PUBLIC SAFETY PLAN UNVEILED BY
- 43:28HOUSE REPUBLICANS BACK IN THE
- 43:30FALL WHICH SEEMS LIKE A YEAR AGO
- 43:31NOW.
- 43:32AND IT HAD SEVERAL COMPONENTS TO
- 43:34IT AND WE'VE TALKED ABOUT
- 43:35WHETHER OR NOT I THINK IT WAS
- 43:37SUSAN MILES WHO SAID IT MAY NOT
- 43:39BE ONE BIG BILL IT COULD BE
- 43:41BROKEN DOWN INTO PARTS.
- 43:42THERE WAS A WIRE STANING
- 43:44PROVISION THAT GOTTEN PUSHBACK.
- 43:46WHERE DOES THAT STAND AND WHERE
- 43:47DO YOU SEE IT GOING?
- 43:48>> IT'S GOING TO BE A PRIORITY
- 43:50FOR THE HOUSE AND TO YOUR POINT,
- 43:53RENEE, CRIME IS SOMETHING THAT
- 43:55IMPACTS EVERY CITIZEN OF THE
- 43:57COMMONWEALTH IN EVERY AREA OF
- 43:58THE COMMONWEALTH.
- 43:59IT'S MORE PRONOUNCED IN SOME
- 44:01AREAS THAN OTHERS.
- 44:02BUT PUBLIC SAFETY IS SOMETHING
- 44:04THAT EVERYBODY VALUES AND
- 44:06CHERISHES AND SOMETHING WE NEED
- 44:07TO MAKE SURE THAT WE DO
- 44:09EVERYTHING AS A GOVERNMENT
- 44:11TALKING ABOUT GOVERNMENT
- 44:12RESPONSIBILITIES ONE OF OUR
- 44:13BIGGEST RESPONSIBILITIES IS MAKE
- 44:15SURE OUR CITIZENS ARE SAFE.
- 44:17THE SAFER KENTUCKY ACT AS IT'S
- 44:20BEEN COINED IS THOUGHT WELL
- 44:22THOUGHT OUT BILL.
- 44:23IT'S BEEN DONE IN A BIPARTISAN
- 44:28BASIS.
- 44:30CONSIDERABLE INPUT FROM LOCAL
- 44:31MAYOR'S OFFICE FROM THE POLICE
- 44:34DEPARTMENTS, FROM THE F.B.I.,
- 44:36GENERAL COLEMAN HAS BEEN
- 44:37INVOLVED IN THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
- 44:39I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHAT IT'S
- 44:41GOING TO LOOK LIKE WHEN IT'S ALL
- 44:43DONE.
- 44:43AS OF RIGHT NOW THERE ARE 16
- 44:46DIFFERENT COMPONENTS IN IT THE
- 44:48WIRETAPPING PROVISION HAS BEEN
- 44:49PULLED OUT.
- 44:51BECAUSE IT WAS CONTROVERSIAL.
- 44:52AND THERE'S OTHER ISSUES THAT
- 44:55IT'S HARD TO GET CONSENSUS
- 44:57AROUND BUT I THINK IT'S
- 44:58IMPORTANT TO HAVE CONVERSATIONS.
- 45:00BUT I DO THINK IT WILL BE A
- 45:03PRIORITY FOR US.
- 45:04THE BILL IS GOING TO BE FILED
- 45:07TOMORROW, I BELIEVE MAYBE FILED
- 45:08TODAY.
- 45:11AND JERRY BAUMAN IS THE LEAD
- 45:13SPONSOR ON IT DOING A GREAT JOB
- 45:16OF BRINGING PEOPLE TOGETHER ON A
- 45:17SENSITIVE ISSUE.
- 45:19>> Renee: LEADER NEAL YOU ARE
- 45:20FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY SO YOU
- 45:21KNOW THIS WELL.
- 45:23IS IT AN OVERSIMPLIFIED
- 45:26NARRATIVE THAT VIOLENT CRIME IS
- 45:28OUT OF CONTROL?
- 45:29FIRST RESPOND TO THAT AND IF
- 45:30YOU'VE SEEN THE HOUSE REPUBLICAN
- 45:31PLAN DO YOU THINK IT'S IN STEP
- 45:33FOR WHAT SHOULD BE DONE TO
- 45:35ADDRESS THOSE CONCERNS?
- 45:36>> WELL, I THINK WHATEVER IS
- 45:38DONE SHOULD BE DATA-DRIVEN.
- 45:42IF THE OBJECTIVE IS LAID OUT
- 45:45CLEARLY AND IT BRINGS YOU THE
- 45:48RESULTS THAT ARE CALCULATED TO
- 45:50MAKE A BETTER SOCIETY, UPLIFT
- 45:52PEOPLE AND MAKES SENSE IT'S
- 45:54FINE.
- 45:55BUT WHEN YOU GOT A BILL THAT
- 45:56SAYS YOU DO THREE STRIKES AND OF
- 45:59VIOLENT CRIMES AND WHATEVER THE
- 46:00DEAL IS AND YOU END UP WITH THE
- 46:03DEATH PENALTY OR SOMETHING OF
- 46:04THIS NATURE, I TRY TO FIGURE OUT
- 46:06HOW DOES THAT MAKE IT SAFER?
- 46:08>> THE THREE STRIKES DOES NOT DO
- 46:14THE DEATH PENALTY.
- 46:15>> YOU HAVE A DEATH PENALTY
- 46:16PROVISION IS THAT NOT IN THAT
- 46:18BILL?
- 46:19>> THERE IS A DEATH PENALTY
- 46:20PROVISION BUT IT DOESN'T HAVE
- 46:21ANYTHING TO DO WITH THE THREE
- 46:23STRIKES.
- 46:23THE THREE STRIKES AGAINST
- 46:25VIOLENT OFFENSES IT SAYS THAT
- 46:27YOU DON'T GET TO PAROLE OUT IF
- 46:30YOU'VE GOT THREE VIOLENT
- 46:32OFFENSES.
- 46:32>> IF YOU HAVE A DEATH PENALTY
- 46:34PROVISION IN THE BILL, THE FACT
- 46:36THAT YOU HAVE THAT MAY MAKE
- 46:38SOMEONE FEEL GOOD, AND SOMEONE
- 46:40MAY SAY THAT IS JUSTICE.
- 46:42BUT IT HAS CONSEQUENCES.
- 46:43FOR INSTANCE SOME YEARS AGO WE
- 46:45WERE DEALING WITH THIS QUESTION
- 46:46WHETHER YOU INCARCERATE SOMEONE
- 46:49OR PUT THEM ON DEATH ROW THAT IT
- 46:51COSTS MORE TO PUT THEM ON DEATH
- 46:53ROW AND EVENTUALLY THAT IS
- 46:54SOMETHING YOU DON'T GET THE
- 46:56RESULT THE SAFETY PART OF THAT
- 46:58IS REMOVE THE PERSON FROM
- 46:59SOCIETY.
- 47:00WHY EVEN GO THERE?
- 47:01MY POINT IS IS THAT THERE ARE
- 47:04PROVISIONS IN THE BILL THAT I
- 47:05DON'T AGREE WITH.
- 47:06THERE ARE OTHER PARTS I DO AGREE
- 47:08WITH I COULD LOOK AT.
- 47:09BUT I THINK WE OUGHT TO TAKE
- 47:11SOME OF THE PARTS OUT.
- 47:12I HAVE TO SCRUTINIZE IT
- 47:14CAREFULLY.
- 47:15>> Renee: PRESIDENT STIVERS YOUR
- 47:16THOUGHTS?
- 47:17AND DOES THE SENATE REPUBLICANS
- 47:20HAVE NOT RIVAL PUBLIC SAFETY
- 47:22BILL DO YOU HAVE YOUR OWN SET OF
- 47:24IDEAS HOW TO ADDRESS VIOLENT
- 47:26CRIME?
- 47:26>> YOU SEE SOME OF THE BILLS
- 47:28FILED BY VARIOUS PEOPLE, NO
- 47:31MATTER WHAT PARTY YOU ARE IN,
- 47:33THERE ARE DIFFERING OPINIONS.
- 47:40WIRETAP, THE WIRETAP IS
- 47:41SUCCESSFUL NOW.
- 47:43YOU GOT TO GO TO FEDERAL COURT
- 47:44AND REQUEST IT.
- 47:46SO IT'S UNDER TITLE 3.
- 47:49I DEALT WITH IT BECAUSE I DID A
- 47:52LOT OF FEDERAL CRIMINAL DEFENSE.
- 47:53YOU HAVE TO HAVE A LOT OF
- 47:55SERIOUS HOOPS TO JUMP THROUGH
- 47:56BEFORE YOU CAN GET THAT.
- 47:58I'M NOT OPPOSED TO WIRETAP.
- 48:01SOME OF THE REPUBLICAN PARTY
- 48:02ARE.
- 48:03BUT THAT IS ONE OF THE MOST
- 48:05USEFUL TOOLS IN GETTING REALLY
- 48:07AT THE ORGANIZED CRIME BE IT
- 48:12GANG OR SYNDICATED,
- 48:15RACKETEERING, THAT'S WHERE TO ME
- 48:17IS A REAL PROBLEM.
- 48:19THE OTHER THING I WANT TO SAY
- 48:21ABOUT CRIME BILLS, YOU KNOW, A
- 48:24STATUTE IS BLACK AND WHITE.
- 48:25IT IS WHAT IT IS.
- 48:27AND IF YOU SEE SOMEBODY IN THE
- 48:30CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM, THEY
- 48:32EITHER DID OR THEY DIDN'T DO IT.
- 48:35THERE'S MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES
- 48:36BUT WHAT WE NEED TO LOOK AT,
- 48:39THAT'S JUST A MANIFESTATION OF
- 48:41THE UNDERLYING PROBLEM.
- 48:43TO SAY THAT WE DISAGREE ON
- 48:46HAVING QUALITY EDUCATION, I
- 48:48DON'T THINK ANYBODY AROUND THIS
- 48:49TABLE THINKS WE SHOULDN'T HAVE
- 48:51QUALITY EDUCATION IT'S WHAT IT
- 48:52SHOULD BE.
- 48:53THAT IS AN UNDERLYING PROBLEM IN
- 48:55A LOT OF CIRCUMSTANCES AND WHY
- 48:57SOMEBODY SHOWS UP IN THE
- 48:59CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM.
- 49:01SAME THING WITH MENTAL HEALTH
- 49:03ISSUES.
- 49:04BIGGER ISSUE MAYBE OVERALL IS
- 49:09DRUGS.
- 49:09DRUGS ARE AN ISSUE.
- 49:10LET'S STOP DRUGS COMING INTO THE
- 49:14SYSTEM.
- 49:14BECAUSE THEN YOU HAVE THAT TYPE
- 49:17OF MANIFESTATION OF A PROBLEM
- 49:18AND WINDS UP BEING A PUBLIC
- 49:21SOCIETAL PROBLEM.
- 49:22>> Renee: ARE WE GOING TO SEE A
- 49:23PROPOSAL FROM THE SENATE ABOUT
- 49:25MENTAL HEALTH SUPPORTS?
- 49:26ARE YOU MAKING THE CASE TO HELP
- 49:28BUOY UP THAT SYSTEM?
- 49:29WHEN IT COMES TO ACCESS FOR
- 49:34PSYCHIATRY SERVICES THEY ARE
- 49:35NONEXISTENT IN THE STATE YET WE
- 49:36TALK ABOUT HOW WE CAN HARDEN OUR
- 49:39SCHOOLS BUT SOME SAY WE NEED TO
- 49:41HEARTEN OUR SCHOOLS AS WELL.
- 49:42>> THERE IS A LOT OF DISCUSSION
- 49:44HOW WE PUT MONIES INTO THE
- 49:45MENTAL HEALTH AREAS IN ALL
- 49:48FACETS NOT JUST SCHOOLS.
- 49:51>> Renee: AND ARE YOU HAVING THE
- 49:52DISCUSSIONS NOW AND WE COULD SEE
- 49:54SOME RESOURCES FINANCES GO
- 49:56TOWARD THAT?
- 49:56>> I THINK IT VIRTUALLY EVERY
- 49:59CAUCUS IS TALKING ABOUT AND THE
- 50:01GOVERNOR HAS TALKED ABOUT HOW WE
- 50:03GET HELP IN THE MENTAL HEALTH
- 50:05AREA.
- 50:06>> Renee: RIGHT.
- 50:07IF WE GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL I
- 50:08DON'T REMEMBER THE BILL NUMBER
- 50:10OF THIS SCHOOL SAFETY ACT BY THE
- 50:13LATE JOHN CARNEY AND MAX WISE.
- 50:16>> SENATE BILL ONE AND HOUSE
- 50:18BILL ONE.
- 50:18>> THANK YOU.
- 50:19THERE WAS A CALL FOR SOME MENTAL
- 50:22HEALTH SUPPORTS AND WAS A
- 50:25COUNSELOR FOR EVERY 250 KIDS AND
- 50:27WE'RE LAGGING BEHIND THERE AND
- 50:28MAYBE NEED MORE THAN THAT RATIO
- 50:31BECAUSE THAT WAS FIVE YEARS AGO.
- 50:32>> IT WAS ONE OF THE REASONS
- 50:35THAT WE REREINSTITUTED THE
- 50:37SCHOOL SAFETY TASK FORCE THIS
- 50:39YEAR.
- 50:40WHEN WE GOT WE PUT THAT TASK
- 50:42FORCE BACK TOGETHER TO
- 50:44REEVALUATE THOSE THINGS.
- 50:46THERE WERE CERTAINLY IT WAS A
- 50:47GOOD BIPARTISAN BILL WHEN WE
- 50:48PASSED IT.
- 50:49BUT THERE WERE THINGS WE
- 50:51COULDN'T GET CONSENSUS AROUND
- 50:53AND WE COULDN'T AFFORD IN THE
- 50:56BUDGET.
- 50:56THERE WAS THINGS THAT WORKED AND
- 50:58THINGS THAT DIDN'T WORK.
- 51:00I THINK HAVING THAT CONVERSATION
- 51:02BACK LOOKING BACK AT WHAT WE'VE
- 51:04DONE OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS,
- 51:06THE PROGRESS WE'VE MADE AND THE
- 51:07PLACES WE'VE FALLEN SHORT WE
- 51:09HAVE INCREDIBLE WORKFORCE
- 51:12SHORTAGES IN CHILD PSYCHOLOGY
- 51:14AND MULTIPLE LEVELS BOTH AT THE
- 51:17CABINET IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS, AND
- 51:20CONTINUE TO TRY TO FIND WAYS TO
- 51:25BUILD WORKFORCE IN THOSE AREAS.
- 51:26BECAUSE I THINK WE ALL KNOW THAT
- 51:28IT'S THERE AND WE DO HAVE
- 51:32FUNDING TO PUT BEHIND THINGS
- 51:34THAT MAY MAKE SIGNIFICANT
- 51:35IMPACTS IN THOSE AREAS.
- 51:37>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENTS YOU
- 51:38HAVE ON THAT?
- 51:38>> OTHER THAN THE FACT OF HAVING
- 51:40TAUGHT SCHOOL FOR 27 YEARS AND
- 51:43DEALING WITH STUDENTS WHO WERE
- 51:46HAVING A DIFFICULT TIME IN THE
- 51:49SCHOOL DISTRICT IN TERMS OF
- 51:52THEIR PROBLEMS THAT THEY WERE
- 51:53HAVING A LOT OF THAT WAS MENTAL
- 51:56ILLNESS.
- 51:56A LOT OF THAT WAS COMING FROM A
- 52:00VERY DIFFICULT FAMILY LIFESTYLE.
- 52:02AND IF WE CAN GET MORE PEOPLE
- 52:05MORE COUNSELORS IN THE SCHOOLS
- 52:08FROM K-12, IN TERMS OF DEALING
- 52:11WITH THAT, AND BRINGING PEOPLE
- 52:14IN WHO WILL WORK WITH THESE
- 52:16STUDENTS TO TRY TO GET THEM TO
- 52:18MOVE IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION, I
- 52:20THINK THAT'S WHERE THE
- 52:22INVESTMENT SHOULD BE.
- 52:23BECAUSE A LOT OF THIS STARTS
- 52:25WHILE THEY ARE IN THE PUBLIC
- 52:27SCHOOL SYSTEM OR IN THE SCHOOL
- 52:28SYSTEM.
- 52:29BECAUSE IT CAN BE KIDS WHO ARE
- 52:33COMING FROM PRIVATE AND
- 52:34PAROCHIAL SCHOOLS AS WELL.
- 52:35WE KNOW THAT MENTAL ILLNESS IS
- 52:38ON THE RISE THROUGHOUT OUR
- 52:40SCHOOL SYSTEMS AS WELL AS WITHIN
- 52:42OUR COMMUNITY AS WELL.
- 52:43BUT I THINK THAT'S ONE WAY THAT
- 52:45WE COULD INVEST IN HELPING THOSE
- 52:47KIDS WHO ARE GOING DOWN THE
- 52:49WRONG PATH AND BRINGING THEM IN
- 52:51AND GETTING GIVING THEM WHAT
- 52:53THEY PROBABLY NEED IN TERMS OF
- 52:56COUNSELING.
- 52:57AS WELL AS TRYING TO INCORPORATE
- 53:00THEM TO TRANSITION INTO TO DO
- 53:02WHAT IS RIGHT AND KNOW WHAT IS
- 53:04RIGHT FROM WRONG.
- 53:06>> Renee: AND THE THREE MINUTES
- 53:07WE HAVE REMAINING ALMOST I WANT
- 53:08TO TALK ABOUT MEDICAL MARIJUANA.
- 53:11SO THIS BECOMES IN 2025 DOCTORS
- 53:15CAN LEGALLY PRESCRIBE MEDICAL
- 53:16CANNABIS TO PATIENTS WITH THE
- 53:18SEVEN QUALIFYING CONDITIONS AND
- 53:19WE HEARD FROM GOVERNOR BESHEAR
- 53:21THAT HE WANTS TO EXPAND THAT
- 53:23LIST TO 21, TO INCLUDE AILMENTS
- 53:25LIKE PARKINSON'S DISEASE, SICKLE
- 53:31CELL, AND ARTHRITIS, ANY
- 53:34APPETITE FOR THAT?
- 53:37>> FOR ME?
- 53:39>> Renee: FROM YOU?
- 53:40>> I DON'T VOTE FOR THE BILL IN
- 53:43THE FIRST PLACE NEVER MIND
- 53:44EXPANDING IT.
- 53:45>> RESEARCH SHOWS THAT SOME OF
- 53:49THOSE THAT YOU TALKED ABOUT THAT
- 53:50IS A WAY IN TERMS OF ADDRESSING
- 53:53SOME OF THOSE ISSUES THAT YOU'VE
- 53:56ASKED US ABOUT IN TERMS OF
- 53:58MARIJUANA.
- 53:58SO I THINK WE SHOULD GO WITH THE
- 54:00RESEARCH.
- 54:01THOSE WHO HAVE RESEARCHED AND
- 54:03PROVIDED US WITH INFORMATION
- 54:05THAT SAID THIS DOES PROVIDE SOME
- 54:06HELP TO THOSE WHO ARE SUFFERING
- 54:08FROM ALL OF THOSE ISSUES THAT
- 54:11YOU JUST TALKED ABOUT WE NEED TO
- 54:13FOLLOW WHAT THE MEDICAL PEOPLE
- 54:16ARE SEEING CAN HELP THOSE WHO
- 54:18NEED THAT HELP.
- 54:20>> Renee: WE'RE WAITING FOR THE
- 54:21U.K. STUDY THAT THE END OF THE
- 54:24ONE-YEAR CYCLE OR CLOSE TO IT.
- 54:25>> $2 MILLION APPROPRIATED FOR
- 54:28THE UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY WHO
- 54:29HAS BEEN PICKED OUT BY THE NIH
- 54:33NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF HEALTH TO
- 54:34DO OTHER STUDIES ON OPIOID ABUSE
- 54:35TO COME WITH A LIST.
- 54:37SO I THINK YOU NEED TO SEE THAT
- 54:39LIST.
- 54:40I WASN'T SUPPORTIVE OF THE BILL
- 54:42BECAUSE ALL THE TYPES OF
- 54:44PROLONGED EXPOSURE AND USE AND
- 54:46YOU CAN SEE ALL THE STUDIES
- 54:48COMING OUT HOW ADVERSE IT CAN BE
- 54:49TO YOUR HEALTH AND YOUR MENTAL
- 54:52HEALTH.
- 54:52I HAVE NO APPETITE.
- 54:54DIDN'T A YEAR AGO AND DON'T HAVE
- 54:55IT TODAY.
- 54:56>> Mr. SPEAKER?
- 54:57>> I DID VOTE FOR IT.
- 54:59AS DID THE VAST MAJORITY OF THE
- 55:04HOUSE.
- 55:04BUT I THINK BEFORE WE TALK ABOUT
- 55:06EXPANDING THE CONDITIONS, WE
- 55:08KNEW WHEN WE PASSED THAT BILL IT
- 55:10WAS ACKNOWLEDGED ON THE HOUSE
- 55:12FLOOR AND THE SENATE FLOOR,
- 55:13STEVE WAS THE SPONSOR,
- 55:15ACKNOWLEDGED THERE'S HUGE
- 55:18ADMINISTRATIVE HOLES IN THE BILL
- 55:19THAT WAS PASSED.
- 55:20ONE REASON IT DELAYED
- 55:21IMPLEMENTATION.
- 55:22BEFORE WE START TALKING ABOUT
- 55:26DRAMATIC EXPANSION, LET'S TALK
- 55:27ABOUT FIXING THE ADMINISTRATIVE
- 55:28HOLES THAT WE KNOW EXIST
- 55:30ALREADY.
- 55:31AND THEN I AGREE WITH DEREK.
- 55:34LET'S LET SCIENCE TELL US LIKE
- 55:37WHAT SHOULD AND SHOULDN'T BE
- 55:38INCLUDED.
- 55:39AND I THINK WE CAN MAKE SOME
- 55:41REASONABLE DECISIONS ALONG THAT
- 55:42WAY.
- 55:43BUT I'M MORE INTERESTED IN
- 55:46GETTING THE VERSION THAT WAS
- 55:48PASSED IN AN APPROPRIATE FORM
- 55:50THAT THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH CAN
- 55:53ADMINISTER IT JUST FOR THE
- 55:55LIMITED NUMBER OF CONDITIONS
- 55:57THAT WE'VE IDENTIFIED.
- 55:58>> AND THE ESTIMATE I DID VOTE
- 56:00FOR IT.
- 56:00I THOUGHT IT WAS A MAJOR STEP
- 56:02FORWARD AND I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT
- 56:04WITH RESPECT TO THAT.
- 56:05I THINK WE SHOULD FOLLOW THE
- 56:07RESEARCH AND THIS IS A DOOR
- 56:09OPENER FOR MANY PEOPLE WHO
- 56:11OTHERWISE WOULD NOT HAVE RELIEF
- 56:14FROM THERMALDIES MEDICAL
- 56:15MALADIES SO I THINK IT IS A GOOD
- 56:17THING.
- 56:17WE ARE DOING IT CAREFULLY GOING
- 56:19FORWARD CAREFULLY IT'S IMPORTANT
- 56:20TO DO IT THAT WAY.
- 56:21>> WE'LL GET TO THE CHILD TO
- 56:24FAMILY PAID LEAVE AND OTHER
- 56:28ISSUES.
- 56:28THANK YOU FOR WATCHING I I'LL
- 56:30SEE YOU TOMORROW NIGHT ON
- 56:31KENTUCKY EDITION.
- 56:33TAKE GOOD CARE.