Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / An Order to Remove a Seawall and a Refugee Charged $1.32 Million Property Speculation Tax
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: signed for, legally speaking, a regular segment with Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers Michael Mulligan.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Some interesting stories on the agenda for this week.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: I'm just reading here the Gabriola Island Local Trust pursues a fine for failing to remove a seawall.
- 0:20Adam Stirling: What's happening here?
- 0:22Michael Mulligan: Yes, indeed, what's happening here is a legal odyssey.
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: So this case began back in 2012 and indeed it involves the Gabriola Island Local Trust and a house, in fact, on Mudge Island and for those listeners that are wondering, Mudge Island is wedged sort of between Vancouver Island and Gabriola Island.
- 0:45Michael Mulligan: Perhaps for administrative reasons, they made it subject to the zoning laws from this Gabriola Island Trust, and so the local government that island's trust passed some laws back in 2008, including one that required that no structures be built within 30 meters from the natural barrier of the sea.
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: So that's how things started, and in 2012, they determined that a family there had a seawall, which was something protecting their waterfront property from erosion, and that the seawall was closer to the sea than 30 meters, and so they told them to remove it.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: That eventually wound up in court, and the couple that owned the home argued that there was a common law right to protect your property against erosion.
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: It was a riparian right, they argued, and the judge at the original trial agreed with them and found that the island trust did not have authority to prevent them from putting up this or keeping this seawall to prevent their property from being eroded.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: Well, the litigious Gabriola Island Local Trust Committee didn't much like that outcome, and so they appealed it to the BC Court of Appeal, where they won.
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal found that, well, there may be that common law right it is something which might be relevant as a dispute between private individuals but that the provincial government has led to slave authority to override that and found that they had done so.
- 2:32Michael Mulligan: And so then, in 2021, again, the couple now ordered by the Court of Appeal removed the seawall.
- 2:40Michael Mulligan: Well, they didn't, and the case continued, and eventually the case wound up back in front of a judge in chambers in the Court of Appeal with a decision that just came out just yesterday dealing with whether there should be a contempt finding for not removing the seawall and, if so, what the penalty for that contempt should be.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: Now, a number of things had made that more challenging, and I should say that the island's trust was asking for a fairly substantial fine.
- 3:16Michael Mulligan: They wanted a fine of $7,500 and they wanted an increased fine if the seawall wasn't removed by a future date.
- 3:26Michael Mulligan: But a number of things made that more challenging, and it gives some insight into the issues that can arise when there is an order to do something that might be very hard to do Because in this case several intervening factors happened.
- 3:42Michael Mulligan: First of all, sadly, one of the two property owners, who was elderly, was diagnosed with dementia and passed away.
- 3:48Michael Mulligan: The other remaining property owner was in his late 80s and had all manner of medical conditions that were affecting him.
- 3:59Michael Mulligan: When the couple's daughter realized what was going on, she moved out from Toronto to try to help with the seawall and made various attempts to hire somebody to remove it.
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: She contacted 10 different contractors, 9 of whom said they're not interested, they're not doing it.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: A tenth showed up but their equipment was incapable of removing the seawall.
- 4:22Michael Mulligan: The daughter that got an assessment done that showed that there would be great risk of environmental harm to the foreshore and mature trees would have to be pulled out because they had grown into this very old structure, and tried to persuade the Court of Appeal that they should reconsider their decision.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: Now, first of all, on that front, there's a concept people should know about, which is a concept of a court being functious or done.
- 4:48Michael Mulligan: That means, once they've made a final order, the court can't just go back and say well, I'm going to change that, even if new information comes to light.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal found.
- 4:59Michael Mulligan: Look, despite that report, we have no authority to do anything about this.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: We've made a final order which would leave only.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: I suppose the Supreme Court of Canada was unlikely to intervene in the case of a seawall.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: The daughter, for her part, then tried with a jackhammer and sledgehammer to remove the seawall herself.
- 5:20Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately that failed, Although it was clear she tried very hard and there are apparently pictures from a bylaw officer, and she described the seawall as being two feet high and 37 feet long and she described it as being quote about as strong as the great pyramid of Giza, and so just could not get this thing out.
- 5:41Michael Mulligan: And so, back they come to court and there are multiple adjournments, sort of all these efforts to try to hire contractors.
- 5:48Michael Mulligan: The daughter try to get it out, and so they're back to.
- 5:52Michael Mulligan: Well, what should we do about this?
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: And eventually, what the court did is they did impose a fine, but a much smaller one than what the Islands Trust was asking for.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: They imposed a fine of $2,500 on the elderly, a remaining owner of the now widower of the owner of this property, and have said that well, if he doesn't get the thing removed by October, the end of October there may be an additional fine of $7,500.
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: And so it's a really interesting case because it raises these issues of contempt and practical impossibility right.
- 6:33Michael Mulligan: And the daughter is saying, look, I don't know what else I can do to get the seawall removed.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: And the court, from its perspective, is saying, look, we need to maintain the authority of the court.
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: There's been an order that this would be removed.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: We can't revisit the order, no matter what new evidence there might be, because we're a funk.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: This were finished.
- 6:53Michael Mulligan: And so the court has said you know well, presumably there's got to be some method of removing this with some degree of heavy equipment, even if it might be a great expense.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: And so that's where the matter currently sits.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: You've got the daughter with the sledgehammer.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: The elderly and firmed Whittower, who is the remaining owner of the property and contractor, is not willing to do the work, I think out of concern.
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: Either it's impossible, their equipment doesn't meet the requirements, or it's going to be hazardous or cause all kinds of other damage.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: And so that's where the case currently remains, and so we'll need to wait and see what comes of that on Mudge Island.
- 7:32Michael Mulligan: One sad possibility, of course, is that the the remaining owner of this property it sounds like his health is in pretty serious shape.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: If he passes away, then I suppose it will be back to the Gabriola Islands Local Trust Committee to decide whether they wish to start this all over again with whoever becomes the owner of the property with the very, very strong seawall somewhere on Mudge Island.
- 8:03Michael Mulligan: But it does raise a host of interesting legal issues about contempt.
- 8:07Michael Mulligan: How should that be used?
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: What penalty should be imposed when somebody doesn't comply with a very difficult to comply with order?
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: And what do we do moving forward, Because there are a number of sort of legal hard places that aren't moving right.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: The court can't change its order.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: The order is final, and you've got a circumstance where it may or may not be physically possible to get somebody to come and do this work, and so I imagine that the case is probably not over.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: There's no date set for the removal of it.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: Nobody's been found who can remove the seawall, so we'll wait and see whether the daughter continues to chip away at it or whether they find a contractor or whether the elderly father is back in court come October facing an additional fine if he doesn't manage to get the extremely well-entrenched seawall off the property.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: So that's the case from Mudge Island and claim for civil contempt.
- 9:12Adam Stirling: All right, we're going to take a quick break We'll continue with legally speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 9:18Adam Stirling: Right after this, back on the air here at CFAC's 1070 with Michael Mulligan, barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 9:24Adam Stirling: Up next on the agenda, michael, the property transfer tax being imposed on a refugee who's lived in BC since 1995.
- 9:34Adam Stirling: Set this one up for us.
- 9:36Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: So this, I think, could be an example of a seriously unintended consequence, where a person's trying to seek some remedy in court.
- 9:45Michael Mulligan: That really requires a political response.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: And the background of this is that we had, a few years ago now, this foreign buyer's tax imposed in British Columbia and it applies to properties purchased in now the Greater Victoria Capital Regional District, greater Vancouver, the Okanagan, the NIMO, various places in the province, and it was intended to deter sort of foreign speculation in property, right so the people buying property as an investment and not living here, that kind of thing.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: But the way this tax is drafted is that it imposes a 20% tax under the Property Transfer Tax Act to anyone who purchases a property in those locations or who is not either a Canadian citizen or a permanent resident.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: That's just how it's currently drafted and it had what can only be, to my mind, an unintended consequence in terms of how it impacts on somebody who's a refugee.
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: And this case, which is in the form of an application by the province to strike out a constitutional claim, was.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: The claim was brought by a man who was a refugee from Iran and he moved to Canada in 1995 and sought political asylum, which he was granted, he's lived in British Columbia since 1995.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: So this is not somebody who's some opportunistic real estate speculator.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: He's done very well living in British Columbia.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: He's obviously worked hard and he was purchasing a home in West Vancouver.
- 11:33Michael Mulligan: The home was expensive I guess every home in West Vancouver is expensive, but this one was $6.6 million and he was purchasing it in 2019.
- 11:45Michael Mulligan: Now, I should say that the man did apply to become a permanent resident.
- 11:50Michael Mulligan: According to the facts in the case, he applied on more than one occasion, and on the last occasion he applied was in 2017.
- 11:59Michael Mulligan: But anyone who, uh, I guess his uh had experience trying to get their passport renewed and realize how quickly the federal government operates on these sort of matters, uh and so, even though he applied uh to become a permanent resident yet again in 2017, that process didn't get completed until 2022.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: Uh, it's hard to believe, but that's how long it took.
- 12:24Michael Mulligan: Uh and so what it meant is that the man received a tax bill of $1.32 million, wow, uh, on the theory that he was somehow a property speculator.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: Uh, on the basis that he was a foreign buyer, right, despite the fact that he's lived here since 1995.
- 12:42Michael Mulligan: Yeah, uh and so the man brought uh this uh application trying to make constitutional claims on the basis that either he was um discriminated against on a analogous ground to some grounds that are uh discrimination is prohibited against in section 15 of the charter and also a section seven uh argument under the charter, trying to find some basis to avoid having to pay $1.32 million.
- 13:12Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the claim the province or the lawyers for the province were almost successfully getting this all just struck out as being a hopeless effort.
- 13:23Michael Mulligan: Uh, the court did say, well, there's some sort of glimmer of hope if there's an amendment on one of the arguments, and so gave the man some additional time to amend the claim to continue with the constitutional argument.
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: But the case is also an example of how, you know, the court is not there to determine whether policy is good or not.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: Right, judges aren't there to decide.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: Do I like this law, or is this sensible, or should it be this?
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: Uh, there are, of course, some constraints constitutional constraints, uh, but the policy decision is a political one, right, and really, what this case calls out for and hopefully somebody's listening, um, is that when, if we, if we conclude that the foreign buyer stacks is a good idea, uh, politically, and the idea there being to discourage uh sort of speculative investments in real estate, it cannot be that that policy was intended to impose a 20% tax on uh long term refugees who are trying to buy a home.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that just cannot be what this was intended to do.
- 14:35Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: And so hopefully somebody is not somebody at the political level is thinking about this right, because when the case sort of marches along in court, the entire analysis by everyone involved the judge, the lawyers on both sides is a legal analysis.
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: Right Is sort of is this constitutionally permissible?
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: What are the limits of section seven, the section, you know, 15 of the charter?
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: Uh, is this kind of a tax prohibited on constitutional grounds, which is all fine and it's good we have that system in place, but none of that is answering that just big fairness question.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: Is this right?
- 15:13Michael Mulligan: Is this really what was intended by this piece of legislation?
- 15:17Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so it wouldn't take much, it seems to me, to make a change to this piece of legislation in a way that would completely maintain its purpose.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: Right, to avoid people who are using, you know, real estate as some sort of a speculative investment opportunity well, not unintentionally taxing long-term refugees, and so you can easily imagine how that could be fixed.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: You know, add to the description of who's exempt to it refugees, or even refugees who have resided in British Columbia for pick some period of time.
- 15:57Michael Mulligan: How many years would you like the person living here before?
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: It's absolutely apparent that the person who fled death in Iran is not here to speculate in a house they're trying to buy, and so hopefully somebody's listening or somebody reviews this and makes a change to the legislation to fix the problem, and hopefully they do it retroactively, because we're not trying to impose a 20% tax on refugees trying to buy a home, and that really needs to be fixed and it seems unlikely that's going to get fixed in a legal argument.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: That's a political argument and so hopefully somebody's listening and does something about it.
- 16:39Adam Stirling: Yeah, it's sort of a bizarre situation that I would have never thought of, but obviously there's going to be some sort of a means test involved with the refugee application process, because the person having no means or similar to no means, I would suspect, is one of the criteria for coming here in the first place.
- 16:53Adam Stirling: So why do it twice?
- 16:55Michael Mulligan: Yeah, I mean this man.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: The background here is that he was a political, a sort of political asylum, and he described himself and this was part of the argument as stateless, effectively, because his evidence was if he went back to Iran he'd be killed, and he had applied on more than one occasion, to having been here as a refugee for many years, to become a permanent resident the third time in 2017.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: And just, it took years for that to get processed.
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: Now, aptly, as of last year, it's processed.
- 17:28Michael Mulligan: He's a permanent resident in Canada and hopefully he'll become a citizen in Canada, right, obviously a hardworking and successful person we're lucky to have here, but we need to get this legislation fixed so we're not unintentionally punishing people like this man.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: That just cannot be what was intended by that tax.
- 17:49Adam Stirling: Absolutely Next story a new trial ordered following a conviction for criminal contempt to deal with the issue of a quote officially induced error.
- 17:57Adam Stirling: Lots of stuff there.
- 17:59Michael Mulligan: There's a whole bunch packed into that.
- 18:01Michael Mulligan: Yes, so this particular case was a Indigenous man who was convicted of criminal contempt for allegedly violating an injunction not to block the construction of the Trans Mountain Pipeline, and that goes for back in 2019.
- 18:20Michael Mulligan: Now the issue what the issue there is that criminal contempt includes an element of men's rage, like the person must be intentionally doing something wrong.
- 18:32Michael Mulligan: That's kind of what the criminal law, in virtually every respect, is concerned with, right, that's, you know, we're concerned with people doing things intentionally wrong, not tripping and falling into others or, you know, doing something by mistake, right?
- 18:45Michael Mulligan: That's sort of what we're concerned with before we start punishing people and putting them in prison.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: Yeah, and so this man.
- 18:53Michael Mulligan: His evidence at his trial was that he was a serving as a elder, he was a watchman.
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: That he was.
- 19:04Michael Mulligan: He was 70 years old, by the way, and he says he was attending where this protest was going on, to engage in a pipe ceremony to keep the peace.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: And, significantly, he says that he spoke to the police to ask them about that and his evidence was that, based on previous conversations with the police, he understood that he had permission to conduct this type of ceremony and because of those conversations.
- 19:36Michael Mulligan: As far as he knew on that day, he wasn't violating anything.
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: That was his evidence.
- 19:39Michael Mulligan: Now he was nonetheless convicted, which is what resulted in this appeal to the court of appeal.
- 19:46Michael Mulligan: And the legal issue on the appeal was what you identified, which is that concept of officially induced error.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: So what is that?
- 19:54Michael Mulligan: Well, the concept of an officially induced error it has six elements, so there's a lot here to unpack.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: But it has to be an error of law or mixed fact.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: In law.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: It must be that the accused considered the legal consequences of their action and then got advice from an appropriate official, right?
- 20:12Michael Mulligan: You couldn't get advice from the postman that you're okay to show up at the blockade or something, right, that's probably not going to work.
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: But the advice was reasonable, right?
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: So if you had some obviously wacko advice, that's not going to apply.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: That the advice was erroneous and that the person relied upon the erroneous advice and the concept there, right?
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: The court analogized to that concept that we've talked about before of entrapment, where a person does the physical elements of something but because they were entrapped into doing it, it would be unfair or unjust to convict them of it.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: And so here the man's evidence amounted to look, I spoke to the police about whether I was allowed to conduct this ceremony, and so, with that, would the police be an appropriate official?
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: Probably right.
- 21:07Michael Mulligan: Was that advice reasonable?
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: Probably right.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: There's nothing obviously bizarre about that advice.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: Was it wrong?
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: Possibly right.
- 21:17Michael Mulligan: And did the person rely on it?
- 21:19Michael Mulligan: Well, that was his evidence that he relied on it, and, interestingly, there was video evidence of what the man had done at the ceremony, and his evidence about what he was doing corresponded with what was on video and showed that the man initially was not with the group of protestors that he was doing this ceremony.
- 21:39Michael Mulligan: He moved after a period of time to where these protesters were conducted the ceremony locked hands in a circle and then was leaving, and so there was scope for what he was arguing to be consistent with the evidence there.
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: Right, and so the court of appeal has ordered a new trial on the basis that a judge should consider his evidence in terms of whether it met that test for being officially induced error and whether he should properly have been convicted.
- 22:10Michael Mulligan: So that's what officially induced error is, and we will await the new trial to see what happens with the 70 year old indigenous man who conducted this ceremony at the protest.
- 22:21Adam Stirling: All right, legally speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 22:25Adam Stirling: A pleasure, Michael.
- 22:25Adam Stirling: Learn something new every week Until next week.
- 22:27Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 22:28Adam Stirling: Have a great day, All right, you too.