Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump in Court, No Fly List & Russian Billionaire Art Fight
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm June Grosso.
- 0:13Speaker 2: Ahead.
- 0:13Speaker 1: In this hour, Donald Trump lashes out at a New
- 0:16Speaker 1: York judge a d C. Appellate Court appeared skeptical of
- 0:20Speaker 1: his presidential immunity claims. The Supreme Court takes on the
- 0:24Speaker 1: No Fly List, and a Russian billionaire sue Sotheby's over
- 0:28Speaker 1: four masterpieces.
- 0:32Speaker 3: Could a president order Seal Team six to assassinate a
- 0:35Speaker 3: political rival? That's an official act? In order to Seal
- 0:38Speaker 3: Team six, he would have to be, and.
- 0:40Speaker 4: Would speedily be, you know, impeached and convicted before.
- 0:45Speaker 3: The criminal warrant. But if you weren't, there would be
- 0:47Speaker 3: no criminal prosecution, no criminal liability for that.
- 0:50Speaker 4: What the founders were concerned about was not.
- 0:52Speaker 3: I asked you a yes, yes or no question. Could
- 0:56Speaker 3: a president who ordered Seal Team six to assassinate a
- 0:59Speaker 3: political right who was not impeached? Would he be subject
- 1:03Speaker 3: to criminal prosecution.
- 1:05Speaker 4: If he were impeached and convicted.
- 1:06Speaker 3: First and clear answer is is.
- 1:10Speaker 1: And it seemed to go downhill for Donald Trump after
- 1:14Speaker 1: that question was pressed repeatedly to his attorney by Judge
- 1:18Speaker 1: Florence Penn. At tuesday's DC Appellate Court arguments, all three
- 1:22Speaker 1: judges on the panel seemed highly skeptical of Trump's claim
- 1:26Speaker 1: that he's immune from criminal prosecution for trying to overturn
- 1:30Speaker 1: the twenty twenty election because he was president at the time.
- 1:34Speaker 1: As Trump looked on from the audience, his attorney John
- 1:38Speaker 1: Sower tried to convince the judges of the Pandora's box
- 1:41Speaker 1: of horribles if presidents don't have absolute presidential immunity, but
- 1:46Speaker 1: Assistant Special Counsel James Pearce pushed back against that claim.
- 1:51Speaker 4: The notion that criminal community for a president doesn't exist
- 1:53Speaker 4: as a shocking holding. It would authorize, for example, the
- 1:56Speaker 4: indictment of President Biden in the Western District of Texas
- 1:59Speaker 4: after he leaves off for mismanaging the border allegedly.
- 2:02Speaker 5: Never before has there been allegations that a sitting president
- 2:06Speaker 5: has with private individuals and using the levers of power,
- 2:10Speaker 5: sought to fundamentally subvert the democratic republic and the electoral system.
- 2:15Speaker 5: And frankly, if that kind of fact pattern arises again,
- 2:18Speaker 5: I think it would be awfully scary if there weren't
- 2:20Speaker 5: some sort of mechanism by which to reach that.
- 2:24Speaker 6: Criminally.
- 2:25Speaker 1: The judges also seem to completely discredit Trump's argument that
- 2:29Speaker 1: a president can only be criminally prosecuted after Congress has
- 2:34Speaker 1: voted to both impeach and convict him on similar charges.
- 2:38Speaker 1: Here's Judge Michelle Chiles.
- 2:40Speaker 7: But not everybody goes through that process, and of course
- 2:43Speaker 7: it's limited to the certain actors in that regard, but
- 2:45Speaker 7: not everybody has to go through that process. Prosecutors later
- 2:49Speaker 7: on can come into information and evidence after they've investigated
- 2:53Speaker 7: to make their determinations about what they'd like to criminally
- 2:55Speaker 7: prosecute it. So you're not always confined to whatever would
- 2:58Speaker 7: be in the impeachment judgment.
- 3:00Speaker 1: My guest is Michael Gerhard, a professor at the University
- 3:03Speaker 1: of North Carolina Law School. His new book is entitled
- 3:07Speaker 1: The Law of Presidential Impeachment. It seemed like the focus
- 3:12Speaker 1: of the argument for Trump's lawyer was that under the
- 3:16Speaker 1: Constitution's impeachment clause, a president can't be prosecuted unless he's
- 3:21Speaker 1: first impeached and convicted over the same charges. Tell me
- 3:26Speaker 1: about that argument and what you think of it.
- 3:29Speaker 8: It's really dumb, as it's not a good argument. There
- 3:32Speaker 8: are three judges in the late nineteen eighties that all
- 3:35Speaker 8: faced impeachment, and all three were actually tried criminally before
- 3:40Speaker 8: they were impeached, And they raised that argument back in
- 3:43Speaker 8: the late nineteen eighties, and courts re checked, there's no
- 3:46Speaker 8: constitutional requirement that impeachment proceed a criminal investigation. Was it
- 3:51Speaker 8: a criminal investigation proceed an impeachment? Their separate proceedings just
- 3:54Speaker 8: as simple.
- 3:55Speaker 1: So then where did they get that argument? Did they
- 3:57Speaker 1: make it up out of whole claw?
- 4:00Speaker 8: I think they largely made it up. I think it's
- 4:02Speaker 8: designed in part to delay things. That's first. Secondly, and
- 4:08Speaker 8: this might be the best characterization of it, It might
- 4:11Speaker 8: be loosely based on some constitional language that seems to
- 4:15Speaker 8: leave an inference after an impeachment that officials could still
- 4:20Speaker 8: remain liable at law, But that's not a command. That's
- 4:25Speaker 8: just basically suggesting that after impeachment there could be separate
- 4:29Speaker 8: legal proceedings. I would also maybe suggest third, but I
- 4:33Speaker 8: think it's just another variation of Trump's arguments, which date
- 4:38Speaker 8: back to his presidency, that he currently no other presidents,
- 4:41Speaker 8: but he at least is above the law.
- 4:44Speaker 1: That led to some really startling hypotheticals Judge Florence Pan
- 4:49Speaker 1: asked if a president ordered Seal Team six to assassinate
- 4:53Speaker 1: a political rival, could he be criminally prosecuted? Over and
- 4:57Speaker 1: over again. She tried to press him yes or no,
- 4:59Speaker 1: Yes or no, but he didn't even make a concession there.
- 5:02Speaker 1: So we're left with the outrageous suggestion that a president
- 5:06Speaker 1: can assassinate a political rival and not face prosecution.
- 5:10Speaker 8: Well, I think that he was, in a sense arguing
- 5:12Speaker 8: from a corner, so he's already backed in, and I
- 5:15Speaker 8: think he thought maybe his best option was just to
- 5:18Speaker 8: take a hard line. But I think that question, among others,
- 5:22Speaker 8: sort of underscores the absurdity of Trump's argument.
- 5:25Speaker 1: Did you see any inkling that any of the judges
- 5:28Speaker 1: were buying that particular argument.
- 5:30Speaker 8: I did not, but that may not mean very much.
- 5:33Speaker 8: There's not always a complete overlap between what happens in
- 5:37Speaker 8: a oral argument and what comes out of an opinion.
- 5:39Speaker 8: So lawyers tend to take with a grain of salt
- 5:42Speaker 8: all the questioning in oral argument, because booris understand it
- 5:44Speaker 8: may not necessarily or predict exactly what the opinion might
- 5:47Speaker 8: look like. But I think before there was any argument buying,
- 5:51Speaker 8: other scholars who sort of study this area. Thought Trump's
- 5:55Speaker 8: arguments were probably at best, week is not absurd, and
- 5:59Speaker 8: I think that the judges least appear to have so
- 6:03Speaker 8: far taken the stimulancy of approach.
- 6:05Speaker 1: There was one thing that one or two of the
- 6:08Speaker 1: judges picked up on. Judge Karen Henderson express concern that
- 6:11Speaker 1: a ruling saying the president doesn't have immunity would lead
- 6:15Speaker 1: to politically driven prosecutions of future presidents.
- 6:18Speaker 9: How do we write an opinion that would stop the
- 6:22Speaker 9: flood dates? Your predecessors, in their ollc opinions, recognized that
- 6:29Speaker 9: criminal liability would be unavoidably political.
- 6:34Speaker 1: What side had the better of that argument?
- 6:36Speaker 8: Well, I think that question really has been answered already
- 6:40Speaker 8: by the United States Supreme Court. They answered it in
- 6:42Speaker 8: case called Trump versus Vans. And in that Supreme Court case,
- 6:45Speaker 8: the Supreme Court ruled that a president, in Trump's case,
- 6:49Speaker 8: then a sitting president may be subject to state criminal prosecution.
- 6:54Speaker 8: Trump tried to argue in that case, Oh, the president
- 6:57Speaker 8: could then be subject to all sorts of partisan crusts
- 7:00Speaker 8: and spreame. Court rejected that because the Court said they
- 7:03Speaker 8: are all sorts of safeguards against that. So it's not
- 7:06Speaker 8: really going to be a real or practical concern, because
- 7:10Speaker 8: if that's the motivation I have, we've seen federal court
- 7:13Speaker 8: fetal judges could obviously try to twist behind it, but
- 7:15Speaker 8: so could state judges, And ultimately, a state prosecution of somebody,
- 7:19Speaker 8: let's say, who used to be president, is still possibly
- 7:22Speaker 8: appealable to the United States Supreme Court, which is a
- 7:24Speaker 8: whole other safeguard that could exist. So there's no reason
- 7:27Speaker 8: to think that the possibility of a partisan prostitution means
- 7:31Speaker 8: this may never be across the teacher.
- 7:34Speaker 1: So what's your best guess of how the panel will rule?
- 7:37Speaker 1: And by the way, I want to mention that this
- 7:40Speaker 1: was an all female panel of judges, a refreshing change,
- 7:45Speaker 1: consisting of two Biden appointees and one George W. Bush appointee.
- 7:50Speaker 8: I think that the court has to be thinking, among
- 7:54Speaker 8: other things, about what kind of precedent are we going
- 7:56Speaker 8: to establish here? And if I had to guess, would
- 8:00Speaker 8: be that the Court's going to not want to establish
- 8:02Speaker 8: a precedent that makes it easier for presidents to be
- 8:05Speaker 8: above the law. The bottom line is Trump's going to
- 8:08Speaker 8: face criminal trial and you can't avoid that.
- 8:11Speaker 1: And so Trump's lawyer asks for a stay of the
- 8:14Speaker 1: opinion so that they can appeal. So if they appeal
- 8:17Speaker 1: to the full DC Circuit As for an on bank hearing,
- 8:20Speaker 1: do you think the DC Circuit would.
- 8:22Speaker 8: Take that on bank Well, I don't know the answer.
- 8:25Speaker 8: I'm not sure why the full DC Circuit needs to
- 8:27Speaker 8: hear this. I think that's another move by Trump's lawyers
- 8:30Speaker 8: to delay everything, sort of to throw a lot of
- 8:33Speaker 8: legal process and the proceedings against him as a way
- 8:36Speaker 8: to kind of delay them in the hopes I suppose
- 8:39Speaker 8: that Trump will win the presidency and pardon themselves, or
- 8:41Speaker 8: that one of his accolltes wi win the presidency and
- 8:44Speaker 8: pardon him. But the courts, I think, are aware of
- 8:46Speaker 8: the possibility that they're being used here, and generally speaking,
- 8:49Speaker 8: courts don't like to be used in that manner.
- 8:51Speaker 1: Everyone assumes that this is going to be appealed to
- 8:54Speaker 1: the Supreme Court no matter what happens, and a lot
- 8:57Speaker 1: of legal experts are predicting that the Court will take
- 9:00Speaker 1: the case. But is that necessarily true.
- 9:04Speaker 8: No. Let's say, for example, this current panel concludes that
- 9:08Speaker 8: none of Trump's arguments are credible, and the court rejects
- 9:11Speaker 8: all of them. The spin Court could simply reject and
- 9:14Speaker 8: the appeal based in part on the justices considering there's
- 9:18Speaker 8: no real issue here and we have to decide because
- 9:22Speaker 8: what the panel would have concluded is consistent with whatever
- 9:26Speaker 8: courts have said before. So there's no compelling reason why
- 9:30Speaker 8: the US needs to intervenient at this point. The other
- 9:32Speaker 8: thing I might just raise at this point is to
- 9:35Speaker 8: just make note of the fact that Trump is still
- 9:38Speaker 8: trying to argue that as a former president he has
- 9:42Speaker 8: some kind of special community. The sitting president may not
- 9:45Speaker 8: be immune. It's a criminal process that was decided by
- 9:48Speaker 8: the US spin Court. When Trump is president, it's Trump
- 9:50Speaker 8: versus Advanced. So these are quite long reaches. Donald Trump
- 9:55Speaker 8: is making claiming for a former president immunity that, by
- 9:59Speaker 8: the way, no sitting president has ever had, and that
- 10:02Speaker 8: just increases the odds. I think that course will reject his.
- 10:05Speaker 1: Claim, and the decision from this panel could come at
- 10:08Speaker 1: any time. Thanks so much for your insights, Michael. That's
- 10:12Speaker 1: Professor Michael Gerhard of the University of North Carolina Law School.
- 10:16Speaker 1: Coming up next. Trump also made an appearance this week
- 10:19Speaker 1: at his New York civil fraud trial, where he lashed
- 10:22Speaker 1: out at the judge. I'm June Grosso and this is Bloomberg.
- 10:26Speaker 10: Well, see my legal issues, every one of them. Everyone
- 10:29Speaker 10: civil and the criminal ones are all set up by
- 10:32Speaker 10: Joe Biden, Trooker, Joe Biden.
- 10:34Speaker 1: Donald Trump even blames the civil cases against him on
- 10:38Speaker 1: President Joe Biden. And at the finale of New York's
- 10:41Speaker 1: three hundred and seventy million dollar civil fraud trial against Trump,
- 10:46Speaker 1: a trial in which his business empire is at stake,
- 10:49Speaker 1: the former president repeated his list of grievances and lashed
- 10:53Speaker 1: out at the judge. Joining me is Bloomberg Legal reporter
- 10:56Speaker 1: Patricia Hurtado, who was in the courtroom. Pat Trump was
- 10:59Speaker 1: not supposed to speak the closing arguments on Thursday. What
- 11:02Speaker 1: happened to change that?
- 11:03Speaker 11: Email exchanges began last week between the court, the AG,
- 11:09Speaker 11: and Trump's lawyers suggesting that Trump wanted to speak, and
- 11:14Speaker 11: number one, the age's office is flipping out that there's
- 11:16Speaker 11: no precedent for a descendant to help deliver their own
- 11:19Speaker 11: closing argument and that's not proper. And then the judge
- 11:23Speaker 11: was saying, is your client willing to follow the rules
- 11:26Speaker 11: which are no political speeches? Basically sick to the fact
- 11:30Speaker 11: and the evidence that you're arguing, and the judge gave
- 11:33Speaker 11: a multiple deadline, and at one point the judge is saying,
- 11:37Speaker 11: you've got to drop dead deadline. You have to tell
- 11:39Speaker 11: me if he's going to speak on Thursday. And then
- 11:42Speaker 11: shrub lawyer says that Mwania's mother passed away, so he'd
- 11:45Speaker 11: like to postpone everything till the twenty ninth of January,
- 11:49Speaker 11: and the judge is like, no, you can't, and then
- 11:52Speaker 11: shrub lawyer says, basically, very unfair your honor to do this,
- 11:56Speaker 11: not allowing President Trump, who's been wrongfully demean and by
- 12:00Speaker 11: an out of control, politically motivated Attorney general, to speak
- 12:04Speaker 11: of the things that must be spouting about. The judge said,
- 12:07Speaker 11: I want to base it again, take it or leave
- 12:09Speaker 11: it now. I never you have until news seven minutes
- 12:11Speaker 11: from now. I will not grant any further extensions. And
- 12:15Speaker 11: that last sentence, I will not grant any further atensions
- 12:18Speaker 11: is all in caps. And then the judge messages that, hey,
- 12:21Speaker 11: it's twelve twelve. Now I've never heard from you. So
- 12:24Speaker 11: I assume that your client will not agree to the
- 12:27Speaker 11: reasonable lawful limits that.
- 12:29Speaker 12: I have imposed as a precondition to giving the closing statement.
- 12:32Speaker 12: Because you know, we all know the rules parties not
- 12:35Speaker 12: to us to be speaking in court. So from lawyers,
- 12:38Speaker 12: three of them gave closing statements and they finished, and
- 12:43Speaker 12: then one of his main lawyers, Chris Ki, turned to
- 12:47Speaker 12: the judge and says, I know you said that my
- 12:49Speaker 12: client couldn't speak, but now could he speek?
- 12:53Speaker 11: He'd like to speak. And the judge was like, well,
- 12:55Speaker 11: will he abide by the rules? I will he promise
- 12:59Speaker 11: to do that? Mister Trump, do you promise to do that?
- 13:02Speaker 11: And then Trump didn't even answer him, just launches into
- 13:06Speaker 11: yao and buy by the ground rules, and he just
- 13:09Speaker 11: starts speechifying, and it's going on and on and on,
- 13:13Speaker 11: and he spoke for about six minutes in a diatribe
- 13:15Speaker 11: against the age, against everyone that was infare to him,
- 13:19Speaker 11: about the judge.
- 13:20Speaker 1: And we should point out that the judge is the
- 13:23Speaker 1: one that's going to be deciding this case. There is
- 13:26Speaker 1: no jury. Yet he's been attacking the judge.
- 13:29Speaker 11: He accused the judge of not paying any attention. He said,
- 13:32Speaker 11: the judge never listens for more than a minute anyway,
- 13:35Speaker 11: And so he said things like seve days and lens
- 13:38Speaker 11: and years and millions of pages. They found nothing and
- 13:42Speaker 11: for what I borrowed money from the bank, much smaller
- 13:45Speaker 11: than's three hundred and seventy million. And then that's when
- 13:47Speaker 11: the judge interrupted and he goes just one more minute,
- 13:51Speaker 11: and then he goes, you can't listen for more than
- 13:53Speaker 11: one minute. They should pay me for what I've gone through.
- 13:57Speaker 11: And then the judge says, okay, thank you very much.
- 14:00Speaker 12: Can you please control your clients.
- 14:02Speaker 1: The New York Age claims that Trump inflated his assets
- 14:06Speaker 1: for more than a decade to get better terms on
- 14:08Speaker 1: hundreds of millions of dollars in loans. How did Trump's
- 14:12Speaker 1: attorneys defend against that in the closing arguments?
- 14:15Speaker 11: It's a whole witch hunt, is this. It's the thing improper.
- 14:18Speaker 11: If anyone made any mistakes, it's all masars fall. It
- 14:22Speaker 11: was always mistakes were made, but they're not important and material.
- 14:27Speaker 12: No one was.
- 14:27Speaker 11: Harmed, the banks weren't harmed, stuff like that. You know,
- 14:31Speaker 11: it's been the same exact thing this whole time.
- 14:35Speaker 1: And the judge says he'll aim to deliver a verdict
- 14:37Speaker 1: before January thirty first, Thanks so much, Patty. That's Patricia
- 14:42Speaker 1: her Toado, Bloomberg legal reporter. Trump used his two court
- 14:45Speaker 1: appearances this week to rail against the six cases against him,
- 14:49Speaker 1: to civil cases and for criminal cases, and he wasted
- 14:53Speaker 1: no time on Tuesday spreading the word that Fulton County
- 14:57Speaker 1: Prosecutor Fanny Willis has been accused of miss conduct in
- 15:00Speaker 1: the Georgia election interference case.
- 15:03Speaker 10: They say she's in far more criminal liability than any
- 15:06Speaker 10: of the people she's looking at. So I think that
- 15:09Speaker 10: when you look at what happened where they pay a
- 15:12Speaker 10: lawyer with absolutely no experience seven hundred thousand dollars who
- 15:15Speaker 10: happens to be her lover or her boyfriend, and then
- 15:19Speaker 10: they go on trips and vacations together, for expensive vacations together.
- 15:23Speaker 10: And the reason they paid him so much because he
- 15:25Speaker 10: was after me.
- 15:27Speaker 1: Trump, of course embellished and distorted the allegations, which come
- 15:31Speaker 1: from a court filing in the case. One of his
- 15:33Speaker 1: co defendants, Michael Roman, a former Trump campaign official, claims
- 15:37Speaker 1: that Willis improperly hired her romantic partner to lead the
- 15:41Speaker 1: Rico case and benefited financially from his appointment. The filing
- 15:46Speaker 1: does not offer any direct evidence to back up those claims,
- 15:50Speaker 1: and Willis has not yet responded to the allegations. Joining
- 15:53Speaker 1: me Is Michael Moore of Moore Hall, the former US
- 15:56Speaker 1: Attorney for the Middle District of Georgia. Michael, how damaging
- 15:59Speaker 1: are the these allegations that Willis hired her romantic partner
- 16:04Speaker 1: Nathan Wade to be the special prosecutor in the case
- 16:08Speaker 1: and benefited when he took her on several trips to California,
- 16:11Speaker 1: Florida and the Caribbean.
- 16:13Speaker 13: Well, without question, I think it's tragic for the case.
- 16:16Speaker 13: And I don't mean that it means that legally that
- 16:18Speaker 13: I think that the allegation raised in mister Oman's motion
- 16:21Speaker 13: are sufficient to have the case dismissed, but it's just
- 16:24Speaker 13: an unforced error on the DA's part if they're true.
- 16:28Speaker 13: I don't know if they're true or not, but it
- 16:30Speaker 13: would be hard to imagine a lawyer filing that kind
- 16:32Speaker 13: of nuclear motion without having some proof in their back pocket.
- 16:36Speaker 13: While I don't think again that it gives a legal defense,
- 16:40Speaker 13: it just makes the optics terrible and it gives the
- 16:44Speaker 13: already plentiful critics of the prosecution in the case, it
- 16:50Speaker 13: just gives them something else to grab hold to, and
- 16:52Speaker 13: as a prosecute don't want to do that.
- 16:54Speaker 1: Is there anything wrong with Willis having a romantic relationshiphip
- 17:00Speaker 1: with the special prosecutor working.
- 17:02Speaker 13: For her, Well, it can be. I mean, I think
- 17:05Speaker 13: there are always concerns, you know, when you have that,
- 17:07Speaker 13: because of potential problems with sexual harassment and workplace problems.
- 17:12Speaker 13: And I imagine it is violative of probably some ethical
- 17:15Speaker 13: divisions for the office. Is it illegal in his face? None,
- 17:18Speaker 13: you know, in their private life is their private life.
- 17:20Speaker 13: So I don't know that that really is the basis
- 17:23Speaker 13: of the attack. It's more of a you know, was
- 17:26Speaker 13: this appointment made and is this prosecution itself now being
- 17:30Speaker 13: used as a way to generate funds that somehow flow
- 17:34Speaker 13: back to the benefit of the District Attorney herself. And
- 17:37Speaker 13: I think that's the basis of their motion.
- 17:39Speaker 1: And this isn't the first time that Willis has faced
- 17:41Speaker 1: public scrutiny, including an Atlanta judge criticizing her in July
- 17:46Speaker 1: of twenty twenty two for hosting a fundraiser for a
- 17:50Speaker 1: Democratic candidate running against one of the potential targets of
- 17:54Speaker 1: the investigation.
- 17:56Speaker 13: You know, we've talked about this at some length, that
- 17:58Speaker 13: the question of whether or not an elected thee should
- 18:00Speaker 13: even be prosecuting a case like this, and so just
- 18:03Speaker 13: if you compare the difference what we've seen in Jack
- 18:05Speaker 13: Smith a special counsel, versus what we're seeing in the
- 18:08Speaker 13: fulls and DA's job, and that is you've got an
- 18:10Speaker 13: elected officials. She's moving around making media appearances, walking on
- 18:13Speaker 13: red carpets and openings and glamour things and all this,
- 18:16Speaker 13: and you've got Jack Smith bus that who's in a
- 18:18Speaker 13: cave somewhere with his minions doing his work, you know,
- 18:22Speaker 13: and he's not coming out and making public statements and
- 18:24Speaker 13: put himself out for public scrutiny. And so while the
- 18:27Speaker 13: DA may argue, well, some of this I need to
- 18:29Speaker 13: do as part of my job because I have to
- 18:32Speaker 13: be re elected, that seems to weigh against the value
- 18:35Speaker 13: of having elected DA involved in a case like this,
- 18:38Speaker 13: and it causes the case to be somewhat tainted from
- 18:41Speaker 13: an optics point of view. And I think the same
- 18:43Speaker 13: is true even in the appointment of staff, as we've seen.
- 18:46Speaker 13: If the allegations in this motion that had been raised
- 18:49Speaker 13: are accurate, and mister Wade has never prosecuted a felony case,
- 18:52Speaker 13: and so you have to be asking yourself why would
- 18:55Speaker 13: this be happening as opposed to having a career prosecutor
- 18:58Speaker 13: who's well versed and well experienced and felony prosecution. Then
- 19:02Speaker 13: the concerns about how much he's being paid, why is
- 19:05Speaker 13: he being paid that, how was he selected? You know,
- 19:08Speaker 13: all these things start to then come together, and so
- 19:11Speaker 13: while it doesn't make the case unprosecutable, it makes her
- 19:16Speaker 13: job much much harder as a prosecutor to do something
- 19:19Speaker 13: and make decisions that the public can continue to have confidency.
- 19:23Speaker 1: We'll wait to see what she says in her answering papers.
- 19:25Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Michael. That's Michael Moore of Moore Hall
- 19:29Speaker 1: coming up, Getting off the No fly List. I'm June
- 19:32Speaker 1: Grass and you're listening to Bloomberg. This week, the Supreme
- 19:36Speaker 1: Court justice has faced a quandary over the government's secretive
- 19:40Speaker 1: no fly list. The justices sought to balance security and
- 19:44Speaker 1: fairness in the case of a US citizen who sued
- 19:47Speaker 1: the government for violating his constitutional rights when it put
- 19:51Speaker 1: him on the no fly list, but the government took
- 19:53Speaker 1: him off the list eight years ago, and says the
- 19:56Speaker 1: case is moot or no longer a live controversy. Jonas
- 20:00Speaker 1: Figre says he doesn't know why he was put on
- 20:03Speaker 1: the list. In the first place, and what kinds of
- 20:05Speaker 1: activities risk getting him put on the list again. Both
- 20:09Speaker 1: liberal and conservative justices press the Assistant US Solicitor General
- 20:15Speaker 1: so Panjoshi on the black box that the no fly
- 20:18Speaker 1: list is. Here are Justices Sonya Sotmayor and Clarence Thomas.
- 20:23Speaker 14: Well Ken, Sir, and tell you that they're not going
- 20:27Speaker 14: to engage in a terrorist activity if they don't know
- 20:31Speaker 14: what terrorist activity it is that you claim they.
- 20:34Speaker 6: Did, but we know nothing. How would he know a
- 20:39Speaker 6: year from now if he is on the list with
- 20:42Speaker 6: the same procedures or different procedures or different facts, when
- 20:46Speaker 6: he doesn't know why he was on the list in
- 20:48Speaker 6: the first instance.
- 20:49Speaker 15: Yeah, so that's the key. He does know why he's
- 20:52Speaker 15: on the list. He was told that he was put
- 20:55Speaker 15: on the list because he posed a threat of engaging
- 20:58Speaker 15: in or conducting a violent active terror and was operationally
- 21:01Speaker 15: capable of doing so.
- 21:02Speaker 1: Justice Neil Gorsich was one of the justices who appeared
- 21:06Speaker 1: most sympathetic to do process concerns in the case.
- 21:10Speaker 16: Now, the government may very well have had good reasons.
- 21:13Speaker 16: I don't for a second mean disgust otherwise, but an American
- 21:17Speaker 16: citizen normally has a right to what's been called every
- 21:20Speaker 16: man's evidence against him. That's due process, that's a pillar
- 21:26Speaker 16: of our democracy. And here the government says, no, you
- 21:32Speaker 16: don't get that evidence.
- 21:33Speaker 1: Joining me is Hinna Shamsi, director of the acl USED
- 21:37Speaker 1: National Security Project. The ACLU filed an amikas brief in
- 21:41Speaker 1: the case. So start out by telling us what happened
- 21:46Speaker 1: to Jonas kra Well UIs.
- 21:48Speaker 2: Icra is a US citizen who discovered that he was
- 21:52Speaker 2: on the no fly list in twenty ten, and he
- 21:55Speaker 2: then filed a lawsuit saying that the government wrongly based
- 22:00Speaker 2: him on the list in violation of his constitutionally protected
- 22:04Speaker 2: right to travel, and that the procedures that the government
- 22:08Speaker 2: used to place him on the list violated fundamental due process.
- 22:12Speaker 2: So the case moved forward, and the government then removed
- 22:17Speaker 2: him from the list in twenty sixteen, and since then
- 22:21Speaker 2: it is argued that his lawsuit could not go forward
- 22:24Speaker 2: because it was moot there was no live case or
- 22:28Speaker 2: controversy to be adjudicated. Mister Fra then appealed from a
- 22:32Speaker 2: district court judgment in the government's favor, and the Ninth
- 22:36Speaker 2: Circuit Court of Appeals twice issued decisions in mister Fickra's
- 22:41Speaker 2: favor rejecting the government's attempts to end the case, and
- 22:45Speaker 2: that's when the government appealed to the Supreme Court, and
- 22:48Speaker 2: that's the argument that the court heard.
- 22:51Speaker 1: Does the government, the FBI in this case, frequently refuse
- 22:55Speaker 1: to tell people exactly why they've been put on the
- 22:58Speaker 1: no fly list or why they've been taken off the
- 23:01Speaker 1: no flylist?
- 23:02Speaker 2: Absolutely, you know, and this is one of our fundamental
- 23:07Speaker 2: problems with the no flylist and why we've been working
- 23:10Speaker 2: on litigating these issues for about twenty years, which is
- 23:14Speaker 2: that the no fly list program essentially operates in a
- 23:17Speaker 2: black box of executive branch discretion and secrecy. The government
- 23:23Speaker 2: refuses usually to tell people the full reasons and most
- 23:29Speaker 2: often any reason for placing people on the no fly list.
- 23:34Speaker 2: And so for decades, we and other rights groups have
- 23:38Speaker 2: documented the secrecy unfairness of this program and it's devastating
- 23:45Speaker 2: consequences for people's lives, Yet it remains a black box.
- 23:49Speaker 2: Let me be more specific, Americans who are on the
- 23:52Speaker 2: no fly list and most often left in the dark
- 23:55Speaker 2: about why they've been placed on the list. They're not
- 23:58Speaker 2: given any meaningful explanation when they are removed if they
- 24:03Speaker 2: are removed, or any guarantee against being wrongfully placed on
- 24:08Speaker 2: the list in the future. And the issue before the
- 24:12Speaker 2: court was whether mister Sikra's case could go forward after
- 24:17Speaker 2: he had been removed.
- 24:20Speaker 1: Does Pikre know why he was put on the list?
- 24:23Speaker 2: He does not have the reasons, all the reasons that
- 24:26Speaker 2: he was put on the list.
- 24:27Speaker 15: You know.
- 24:27Speaker 2: In the argument that took place on Monday, the government
- 24:31Speaker 2: repeatedly said, well, we've provided a reason, you know, we've
- 24:35Speaker 2: explained the criteria for placement on the no fly list
- 24:40Speaker 2: that was applied to him. But here's the problem. What
- 24:43Speaker 2: that means is that the government has disclosed what standard
- 24:47Speaker 2: it uses to place people on the no fly list,
- 24:50Speaker 2: and we can talk about why that standard is vague
- 24:52Speaker 2: and broad and deeply problematic, but it hasn't disclosed the
- 24:57Speaker 2: reasons that it thinks mister Sikra satisfied that standard. So
- 25:03Speaker 2: mister Figray doesn't know what he's alleged to have done
- 25:07Speaker 2: wrong in the first place, and how he can, as
- 25:11Speaker 2: he argued to the court, you know, know what to
- 25:14Speaker 2: do in order not to be placed on the no
- 25:16Speaker 2: fly list again in the future.
- 25:18Speaker 1: It seemed as if several of the justices cross ideological lines,
- 25:22Speaker 1: were sympathetic. Tokra, Justice Sonya Sotomayor said, how can someone
- 25:28Speaker 1: tell you that they're not going to engage in a
- 25:30Speaker 1: terrorist activity if they don't know what terrorist activity you
- 25:33Speaker 1: claim they did? So catch twenty two?
- 25:36Speaker 2: It is a real catch twenty two And it was
- 25:40Speaker 2: a concern. You know, the discretion as well as the secrecy,
- 25:44Speaker 2: is something that the justices, and I think a lot
- 25:47Speaker 2: of the justices across the spectrum were troubled by or
- 25:51Speaker 2: expressed concern about, because, as often happens, courts as well
- 25:56Speaker 2: as the people who are impacted by the placement, are
- 26:00Speaker 2: in the dark in this black box of a program.
- 26:03Speaker 1: Just As Elena Kagan suggested that the government should be
- 26:07Speaker 1: required to go before a judge in private to explain
- 26:11Speaker 1: why someone had been placed on the no fly list,
- 26:14Speaker 1: why they've been removed from the list, and why they
- 26:17Speaker 1: would not be returned to the list, and Justice course
- 26:20Speaker 1: it seemed to agree with that. Is that a possible
- 26:23Speaker 1: solution here?
- 26:24Speaker 2: Well, you know, I want to start with what Justice
- 26:26Speaker 2: Gorsicic said, which is that normally, in our legal system,
- 26:32Speaker 2: we have a right to know what evidence the government
- 26:35Speaker 2: has against us, and that's due process. So one of
- 26:38Speaker 2: the alternatives proposed during the argument in court was that
- 26:43Speaker 2: the government could provide its reasons to a judge in camera,
- 26:49Speaker 2: meaning you know, in continued secrecy, for the judge to
- 26:53Speaker 2: make a determination. And that would certainly be better than
- 26:57Speaker 2: what exists now or what mister was facing, which is
- 27:01Speaker 2: not being able to have any kind of meaningful guarantee
- 27:07Speaker 2: that the government would not place him on the list
- 27:10Speaker 2: wrongly again in the future. I think we should still
- 27:14Speaker 2: pause and think about what that might mean though, that
- 27:17Speaker 2: the government tells a judge. But if your person who
- 27:22Speaker 2: has been left in the dark about why you've been
- 27:26Speaker 2: placed on the list in the first place, why you've
- 27:28Speaker 2: been denied as some of my clients have the right
- 27:31Speaker 2: to travel to be with their loved ones on their
- 27:35Speaker 2: sick beds, to attend funerals or weddings or graduations, you know,
- 27:40Speaker 2: surely more is required to the person impacted themselves. But
- 27:45Speaker 2: let's see how the court rules, and what.
- 27:47Speaker 1: About the government's position that there's not an open controversy here.
- 27:52Speaker 2: The FBI's position was that they have told mister Fikra
- 27:58Speaker 2: that he would not be placed on the list again
- 28:02Speaker 2: quote based on currently available information, and that that is
- 28:07Speaker 2: enough to end his case. And what mister Fickra was
- 28:10Speaker 2: arguing was that that isn't enough. That when the government
- 28:14Speaker 2: acts as it did here, which is that it voluntarily
- 28:18Speaker 2: takes someone off the list, the case is not moved
- 28:23Speaker 2: because the standard the government has to meet is to
- 28:26Speaker 2: make it absolutely clear that the allegedly wrongful behavior won't
- 28:31Speaker 2: happen again. And mister Fickra argued that the government hasn't
- 28:36Speaker 2: repudiated its decision to put him on the list, and
- 28:39Speaker 2: it remained free to return him to the list for
- 28:42Speaker 2: the same reasons and using the same procedures that mister
- 28:45Speaker 2: Fickray alleged were unlawful. So, in essence, mister Fickray was
- 28:50Speaker 2: asking for his case to go forward so he could
- 28:53Speaker 2: have his day in court.
- 28:54Speaker 1: And what do you think the justices might do here?
- 28:57Speaker 2: Well, I think what leaves me cautiously of mystic about
- 29:00Speaker 2: the argument is that most of the justices understood that
- 29:06Speaker 2: a system in which a person does not know the
- 29:10Speaker 2: government's reasons for placing them on their list or taking
- 29:13Speaker 2: them off, it that there's not really a guarantee here
- 29:16Speaker 2: against the kind of bromfo conduct that is being challenged occurring.
- 29:21Speaker 1: Thanks for being on the show. That's Hinnashamsi of the
- 29:23Speaker 1: ACLU coming up. A Russian billionaire take Southeby's to court
- 29:27Speaker 1: over four masterpieces. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 29:33Speaker 15: So, ladies and gentlemen, we moved to the Leonardo da Vinci,
- 29:36Speaker 15: the Sabato Mundy.
- 29:37Speaker 1: The masterpiece by Leonardo of Cristis Savior previous in the
- 29:40Speaker 1: collections of three Kings of England, and in that auction,
- 29:44Speaker 1: billionaire Russian oligarch Dmitri Rybalovlev resold Salvador Mundy for more
- 29:50Speaker 1: than triple the amount he paid for it. Now that
- 29:53Speaker 1: painting and masterpieces by Modigliani, Klimt, and mcgreet are the
- 29:58Speaker 1: subject of Rybalovlev's suit against Southeby's. He claims the auction
- 30:02Speaker 1: house helped a Swiss art dealer dupe him out of
- 30:05Speaker 1: more than two hundred and thirty million dollars when the
- 30:08Speaker 1: dealer bought artworks through Southeby's and then turned around and
- 30:11Speaker 1: sold them to dry Ballovlev at markups worth tens of
- 30:15Speaker 1: millions of dollars. Sotheby's denies any wrongdoing. Joining me is
- 30:19Speaker 1: Bloomberg Legal reporter Chrys do Mesh, who's covering the trial. Chris,
- 30:23Speaker 1: this case offers a glimpse into the opaque art world.
- 30:28Speaker 17: It's interesting. This is the art world and it's kind
- 30:31Speaker 17: of inherently secret just in the way it operates. Maybe
- 30:35Speaker 17: some of our listeners might see the parallels to say,
- 30:38Speaker 17: bond trading and things like that, where there's no extential
- 30:41Speaker 17: exchange that you can look up the prices of a
- 30:43Speaker 17: Picasso or a da Vinci. You know, it undergoes evaluation
- 30:46Speaker 17: process by auction houses like Southeby's and by private actors,
- 30:50Speaker 17: and often some of the participants don't really want to
- 30:53Speaker 17: have their identities out there at any point in the process.
- 30:57Speaker 17: They just want to sell the work. So therefore it
- 30:59Speaker 17: can lead to the kind of opaque market where you
- 31:01Speaker 17: don't really know what the true value of a work
- 31:04Speaker 17: is until you know, somebody buys it. I mean, that's
- 31:07Speaker 17: really the true value of it, and somebody is willing
- 31:09Speaker 17: to pay a certain amount of money for the work,
- 31:12Speaker 17: and that has led, you know, through the years. I mean,
- 31:14Speaker 17: there's certainly other cases where collectors have felt that they
- 31:18Speaker 17: were misled by dealers as to you know, how much
- 31:21Speaker 17: they paid for something like that. But this case is
- 31:24Speaker 17: really at the high end of the art market. And
- 31:27Speaker 17: I mean we're talking about a Da Vinci that was
- 31:29Speaker 17: the most expensive artwork ever sold. And needless to say,
- 31:33Speaker 17: you don't often see Russian billionaires on the stand in
- 31:37Speaker 17: federal court in New York. So that alone makes it
- 31:40Speaker 17: a fascinating case. And to kind of have just the
- 31:43Speaker 17: art world laid bare for an audience in federal court.
- 31:47Speaker 1: So tell us what Rybalavlev's claim is.
- 31:52Speaker 17: So he claims, and he's claimed all along, that this
- 31:54Speaker 17: was a massive fraud poisted on him by Bouvier, who
- 31:58Speaker 17: is his art dealer for many many year Wan who
- 32:00Speaker 17: was arrested in twenty fifteen as he was going to
- 32:04Speaker 17: the billionaire's apartment in Monaco, thinking he was completing a
- 32:07Speaker 17: deal for a Mark Rothko and instead he was arrested.
- 32:10Speaker 17: And it's been almost a decade of various legal maneuvers.
- 32:14Speaker 17: The dealer and Rybalavled have settled late last year so
- 32:18Speaker 17: that he's no longer involved in the case. But essentially
- 32:21Speaker 17: he alleges that the auction house helped the dealer kind
- 32:23Speaker 17: of mislead him into these deals by providing documents supported
- 32:26Speaker 17: the valuations that he claims were excessive and allowed the
- 32:30Speaker 17: dealer to pocket, you know, more than a billion dollars
- 32:33Speaker 17: in improper payment that he wasn't aware of being paid. Essentially,
- 32:36Speaker 17: he says, you know that he would just buy these
- 32:37Speaker 17: things in private, pretend he was negotiating with the sellers,
- 32:41Speaker 17: and then just sell it to him while making up
- 32:43Speaker 17: a whole line of talks about acquiring the painting.
- 32:45Speaker 1: It seems like it's odd for the jury to see
- 32:49Speaker 1: him suing Southeby's when the man who is at the
- 32:53Speaker 1: heart of this is.
- 32:54Speaker 17: Not in the courtroom for sure. And that's what Southeby's
- 32:57Speaker 17: is hanging its hat on here. They say, you know this,
- 33:00Speaker 17: here's a billionaire, and this is a guy who does
- 33:03Speaker 17: regularly large transactions bys a lot of art, owns the
- 33:07Speaker 17: Monaco soccer team, and should have done his own due
- 33:10Speaker 17: diligence rather than relying on the statements of an art
- 33:13Speaker 17: dealer who one could easily suspect might have a different interest.
- 33:18Speaker 1: And Bouvier's lawyer's point to the fact that Rybalavlev did
- 33:22Speaker 1: not win the legal actions he brought against Boovia in
- 33:27Speaker 1: jurisdictions around the world, and also federal prosecutors were looking
- 33:31Speaker 1: into Boovia and dropped the case.
- 33:33Speaker 17: Yes, the prosecutors here in the Southern District of New York.
- 33:36Speaker 17: It spent more than a year building a case against
- 33:38Speaker 17: the dealer. But then after Rybalavlev sold the Da Vinci
- 33:42Speaker 17: work for the record amount four hundred and fifty million,
- 33:45Speaker 17: more than triple what he pays if they dropped the probe,
- 33:47Speaker 17: saying that there was no real way that they could
- 33:50Speaker 17: prove criminality.
- 33:51Speaker 1: It sounds like it'll be a fascinating case. Thanks so much, Chris.
- 33:55Speaker 1: That's Bloomberg Legal reporter Chrys do Mesh, and that's it
- 33:58Speaker 1: for this edition of the Bloomberg Glaw podcast. Remember you
- 34:01Speaker 1: can always get the latest legal news by subscribing and
- 34:04Speaker 1: listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 34:08Speaker 1: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso
- 34:12Speaker 1: and this is Bloomberg